The Statesman. — London, England, 1810-07-21 00:00:00

' 4 ' . : s ' •, LAW IN7'ISLLIGENCEt. • • T. ._ -....11.••••- COURT OF KING'S BENCH, Jut.y 40. sittings before Lord ELLEN BOROUGH ) and a Special Jury at Westminster. THE XING AGAINST IFINNERTY. The ll..fendant. having withdrawn his plea of o' Nut Guilty," and thereby alloiving judgment to go by default, the cause did not proceed; • ' THE RING 0. JOUN GALE JONES. s Mr. ABBOT havioropened the pruccctlibg, in this case, 1 . ... The A/TOMMY GENERAL stated the tircsent Proyeguticus. ;to have been instituted ;for Markt 6 : 4 6( 17 41oull Andinslicitmse libel' s :. pabaske44y. , .ihe. Dcfeinfaitt against Lord Castlereagh:, It ,would . . be the ditty' of the Jury to say, if tilt: Defendant ' - 'had • not Published the• papers • in tuisecrioe, 'anti' ' • lige% it ‘t Wild be for .them to say, if then* - were mot libels. The Defendant, It vrotild appear, Was he (;enductor of a ,certain ' Society, a Debating, . i ocety —of which he should say' nothing' tletogt:', •totyite its character, etcept in so far as th4prep . • 4eist libels were in questiOn. The first li(sol'ivas - • Funtained in the following placard: . , . • • . .*lt. FINNEILTy ANL) LORD CASTLEREAGH:— WM(IBH FORUM. No. &f, BEDFORD.SIREET, , • VOYKII•Vq‘VitIMN; MONDAY, JAN. 49 k 11310. . QussTion—" Ought my Lord Ciptlereagb's coaduot tq. wattllt Mt. romertv. during the late Expedition to Walche pen. lobe approvid no 4 sal u t ar y m eas u r e of precaution in • preserve oilier and discipline amon g his Majesty's forces, or .por.tob iled as a flagrant iufringement upon the liberty of a Brim,. subject, and a coward:, aei of oppression against I sis ianossnl indioidu4l7" . Tile 4Olemeol of Mr. Finnerty's treatment by 'Loa Ciwdeo ireagh. as it appeared in 'As Moraing Chronicle• of toesdax, Ibe ?,Jd.hislspn, hat been read with the most lively emotiinw, lluid has eXcLed ai.iversol astonishment And alarm.. 1111..1.19- J/sr', hal ap,mded to “ the 41 Joel sense,i4erality and justice" of Fie British Nat•on, to Bite their decided simian rig t h e puniest. Yo far as the British Vomit) eau lend its aid towards pearand pr‘alaiming that opinion, sieiti . a:r . nis appeal par that or any olAsrpersocuted or ttsfencilas olitsvidunf sea . il iofs Of acad.. ta pain! If the goals Lord Castlereagh chit ' ',fluter suifiCient confidence la ;finis ias jai" a pnblicnnsc e sel f gt free shit inifspeadentEnglisiemen, hems% rest assired that Le snot' jinselpirpiny.., Tlicre I. Diablo & fur Ishiclstlre Ma 4 paltersdr thii•listittution more ardently long than an op . p a ce, kin 4ii . tristirp 'and Ms lesioniv face.' to pee, and heat- t ag t e em rev/mate lb.ir . cheractir arol.evidavi • iilareroreerorgratiaati inswitel Conntry. • ' ' 7 i :'rtio.jorywoulti vinterve 'that this article' *Mr prekteOu t a s p t reviotts publicetion, which, in the igidletat*) Was:stated ta 7 be ii gross libel. .That, this was 'an, he. (the .43tornepOeneral) . could Maintaitrwithbut ear,d contradiction s the.. libel. ler, Mr. finniriy, Milling been 'tried fork his very, Affraiiiido hit‘lag,withdrairn . hii :pi* DE not C1 . i5fn. 1 14 4 1, 4 ,14, thus *4404 jadtatant•to go. agaiitse hien i thereby . ccinfesibeg the crime, with which Ire 'wU Charged.* It was unnecessary, for Ilia phis Attortiey-,Getterai), however, to build 100101 mi such a defence. He held the publici tivii in Ritestiou- • in. bie liantl, on it - waitift, boas . 056 a ry , fat 111 s. Loraillitip ;and ~(Itos ij urt. (poly -to - reed it,: Gillett that it **tit libe,l ' idtlitlaa..lo. deist thOttitoltlikirUs#Wifarqietrici it . . ii th e . .vbjec4•Asatter a liebiiti t o - if ta l spiiiiii. Vita Wei Our rEpedition, Woe 'boot to sail to :VVolohrreo; 4 overg!rimscreeel*. i inkcia:miOn tbat•efieoliestio. named "iniu to *accompanY 'the.. ._ • tiedition,..afia tTigy 44ru'iliaf informed - 1 4 that it mes 'tient; thiiiiiii: lei n netty 'sli ould so attend tfietik": peditlon.., The order to this affect was issued' It's Perim2Lfigo late to be enceeted,grevious do Abseil. 14. /run e lse atriited at:WalclicAll. ) ,.4stl,retrs Mr , 1 0 . Was 'orddrefibmWtlsbllgh he Jerneittelltivre. the grime? pail tortht ' iliac Our ,armies irertiln the* wortm • - lii *Nee teltet - 'kefOised ti hti.llPiii slimly 410 4', that 'telovew On order intact froth Lord Castlercegh,ot.gh um .Nctiat at i#4s:firectbY it •exisresied a doubt it spy. of 11 yi, NI pj eati's liviteit;hiinieteli iei'd eaubdrdeetdit,'bist -be was • poeildents•iiP: the - measuitS tirdcieded tihal - *Lbrii Cluthirtmkelti It must hare lieelt owing IC tine or . • ether `of 'heap two reitsonst z tithettliat Ite.did.. not , ' Irish Mi. 1 7 . •to be an obsatireff.4:what wile going ou st Walcheren,tbecause itttrild•nothear a public tliiiciosure, or from a desire orailitingstnai ille gal pur e nee to the conduct of Mr. Finoefit: At so, what. could he too puhlto opiniotkof hit (Lord Casilerealiti's) sew of liberality and justicp I, ilk lial beep the Stittli of his life to dedervellichsited, of .• Lira Castlereagh,' and he had • ittaitter:ltis . tilljts.t.; bat to ..remaio longer silent' uhtler the oh luiuses.esat r.pon bias would beculpabie lidilfario vice. Lord Castlereagh hated him heettotehait44 loinred hie, 'Pip letter of Mr. tinnertl-4413. wefitt 'on Wrists?! the Ouse or a *ilia In • IrClisid . pf :die inane a Orr, who was "aid to have been eucetuti under ,the Gut ernment of Lord ' Castlea re a gli s , orleila was lie innocence apperent ; 'there bYlinktlying that Lord Castlereagh hed,beett guilty. .of • ittOrdert; •that fur a treadle on. This subject, which appearridanisolrish"Papet called The Press, 11., (Einetrey) arms triedtind ordered 46 salTel lin.' priokaawm , ,i Opt on.the departure of Earl - Cam den, be 111 S ushered ; to: ba , . liberated, but ilia this beueiitlent•Whit ib his firoar.wirs rendered of non, • . Peet' bi trelarerferenetOrLitrd Castlereagh • It • Was nut toe the Attorney-Opneral this day 'to state bur far thigl,pubAbation:.toink.or "was• tioC• tree. ; but s it ti,negikr.r . Nrjese t ifsk.,stste . to yoa, that • 'attlsittigh them& acts are . jossetkted. to .4ril 4.,;aitte. • seargb,,tioe order lok reitioti.ng•Nli. Pigner . 4 train' Niachereit'clitlnot originate with I.4l...Ciatfereaghs. . • but with Whew. • Lord,Ccuitlereagh tsdnuAtrow... ledse of the (mg:spud hp hear4l,of. it its, astik, and . after-. a report, sande that theordor.Aelliatten in.; ciectdal, and . Mr. FioneFty a ilad beep Isadert ttp at Web:hes ci s ' • aNkets (as las lifslati..to , ilol ..aasif. a similar ogler to Lord 'Cheating.: . awake. -.. :Sup s teitb respect. t 4 ail the Priagedinkt wb,i cs k - Air es ititca sp . have. -taloa ; place ..in.,.., 1 ritimm• tner " took iilace in the year 1797, before i f ottliCoittle,- reiigh was 9 , ...eretary Or ztictui . they tualt'place•un dctl:Lorti Pulhira. : Whatever tasted upon- the subject of Mr. Orr, passed between toy Loki Itel . baut and 'the • then 1,0 pi • Liebien'abt sorlbilaad, Lord Caulikii, si alt which it•irti‘ Castlereighhad • nothing to do. It is butitisitcrifioneder‘' to ski. . Gurci•n•hilit tir lief.sno:r to state, that no Case ever • under Went a ploret.tribus - and attentive considers,- tioit t4ll that orgr. Wr . u.•Orr; and se fer,frose ben% .true was. it, that the recomierederion to MeicY %! . .. 19 ' 61 1 1)1)4ft0 by Lord Yelverten, who tried it.; that when f i ord yelvertcuspatosed.sentenc4- tiro!i Mr. Orr, he • Catitiinnuf hie' against erne taining any hopciof ainitigeti b n of that sentence: an a hen di,: Frit'e %yes , Oerred to LorillOreeten as sgch cods al asyi &ac t by. thc Gutesataaat .-, • . • this or that country, where so for mercy, Lord Yelrertoo perfectly satisfied with the verdli eisiced of the prisoner's god-, - port of . .LOrd Yciverton the prisoner was moat. ed. " I state this, Gentlemen, from a reference 'I have hhd to Artherititite:"publiC documents, andc‘therefore l . I know it to - be true." • The :Learneti , Lorli, and 'the ; lury, would observe the authority whic'h these Gentlemen •Of the British Forum claimed to themselves. They put Lord Castlereagh on trial, and they eintimoned him to attend for that purpose before the - andlefiCe et the British;Forum. They, peremptorily summon ed • him..sts attend • informing him, at Oa same ,time, that he shoehorn fair play. In the tetonilt ~.pu lilliation, by . the Present Defendant, - cin , this:l "itrbjeet, the libel was of a still'efore intlamiuttory; nature: •Thefoliowinvesat 'the placard . ; i , - . • i .It 114.0 U Rl4 ED D.ll BA ' FOR T- I Ol t A O Fj i 7 U. .T.LERlAG—Bittrisit UM, Ne. 1 .• .4 ' I F flt li-ST it E ET, 'COY kIiTGARIMIN, WA : ...a. , . • . 'uitttoN—..'buit4 toy toil C4ttr;eatii4' eeogice tit-. :worsts Mt. Finn s ea/4ering Ike date Ezpointioti to Walehe ren, to he *pro! ni a salutary measure of preasutian to '' pteserve order discipline ansongshis• Majesty's forces. or reprobated as a flagrant infringrosent voggl i beftlig JP. IBritish subject, and eowardlraetof so spunk,* , immrept individuatV , • • . 14ist . MalstloW Wotwithslawling .thawieqkand Images& attempts to sit& the disekstAil oil he present important *Me. ; • Coil, by teasiag deneiLeuut .defacing the bills,-. a Crowded A ssembly (amvug whom were several Noblemen mkt .Meat• ben' of the Souse of Coosinolt) attended, 'intake a very jateresting debate, the Opener was about to reply; whew is Gentle than intimately . and personally coareeillemitered the reora.ead kering- pledged .blinivif to attend on the,pest even ing, and either von the debate or take a part' inOe Mears Woo, the QuestuseNlialr with the cogent of 'large = to y, adjourned. Several important and latraordinary tl_ Will be made in the Morse of the mem, anti laid Castle reagh or Ala .detherents are peremptorily seeseseeeet to attend and prevent, if passible, his character from biker consigned to overtosting iltasayasidiellsgriom;, , Xatereatworit rapt:rites the exeention of Wm. Orr, in Itataados gas* TNE AnmEN MIA. TION OT Till NONLE laioi l datheirkilsiookrtati4 Mabee= , kid before Aim praiti A g Al f fiusoceocsoant road Psis Mr. Fianerfir litter. amid excitei in the audfshoesbdik ess.-0-- Allffilt aid disetiot: , Earl# sitasslan.ce .ir tossuestly : It bein g an a4jperned Qui:slice, any &miasma eta rooky S. release the debitte.• • • Then followed a thirripubliestioo--4 .. . Last Illooday,, alto two evening's discussion, a carded sr legibly utoninmUsly derided; chaff gi Lord Cast le reagh 's coe d-um towards Mr..; Vionertg,pught tote. peitrobated, as, al*. grant infringement upon the liberty of a Stitlsh subject . ii mikvartll l actqf oppression against ass lanoreet indivi . In consequence oak. Fi noecty bet eg detained at the Hews 'of Commits, he tug list to attend tilt it late In the evening,- when, to the uni versaj• witiMactims. of a most resat:oBlde !Lodi epee,be entered the room and delivered a most animate. statement of the proceedliqjsat.Whicheren, sad that:l)4Am of Lord Castlereagh. It it onneeemary st) add,. AM Mr. F. expe: Mewed th e' mold battering aud unequivocal pici‘ofeof pabliia p- Lp robation, while on the ooatrary Note /mad iesmissid -- 'n leis Lordship's defence. Thus has been furnished a at and striking iastance of the folly aed •inatility• of site% at least in this country, to oppress asl bear down =inn iudividual ; by this dismission' virtue end indenendeace received tbeiriottandadequate retinal , while pqde an ragtime bkve WA humbtesitti thedast ! The Man rs age aheartfelt satisfaction. in thus anormuseiag WA dnelsioa, feel cqnsgiriestbey hartdom tbelecialyi, _ , :. 1 WheiesveMi.Leid Caitlereagh acid: ills letilleigittes thus saiiiiiiciet! to **id s- , -Why, $$ (11& •--- • Of (he 1101Sisb Potedi . P.. The statement till .0( '.4allv j efli, las/W:o' 1)• - Calchltited in *rot vid 4sgitst. 4 : _...':. z _•-• • • • , ! _ Ai Tikiil44 4. tiamby,Gioiral, coucii ved, pliceatf ed atrocity ill' Om libels whiff he . bia igii"Colo', The kpracarus were, with tii3 greetest sOulnialo isoas,- - . peorteti - atreverr corner of Ms 400 E, k tlti.bn)(6bleg Or Altai cOikrif be,.leffaistitts, , 14.0,4,C4F-tillresiiso Wes , guilty of: aii: •utideb t . chargsa : 4ll, Mr,....fiiilierty's.letter .Iniptsto4' that he had leen ammorted to.attand et. the . of th4 - 111a&b totem ; !hid there vadat/ones tvielOittnt'ithebenti' 3 l#olcftir 41144 off 4 ,t 1 Mai Wasijticei • : bie - . : ideri6hi ir • and lao 'mod heac,stip . ... neuter: Ilto, 4 nesust,' charges. AA 0, - , 1 44, 440 14 iivi* Ilia, *Out& f indignation et thi a urotak fsred to •thet:ctiitit; Mir tti ilia' ev .- altri, 1nP01t.:144 . ..1iii . Lozaskip ` l ,6titt CD ttu . tbeigsli., threielpetblOk_tkors . Anse grossly - ta 3 k .''flf. itlPtitO. i lk* 4 X9l,ooolist 11,014,5 , . .try• uainiiast . piley, theeemtmice not lying :them. He concluded ~ bY') stallog,4lailhe 7 *amt had irpresied a deli* Ito hiviLititto.k. stAih kit bpteasixl.,:i gip - Lordship, kw coahl Orgrm hint, „re; in Illtriltdalketis .: . . .•- '. ' Mr. Jews', Counsei foe . the Ilefen n\ •njitted, thee iiiiilving liiiiifie v rkitt4' ' ~ , y aiitioartd- 0461 - 0104 43:40, , 4 Aw ir riciment.. ~... •• ; ~, : 7 p,,: .- - ..:, •7,,,•';1-...;, , ..,4 ; ,• : rd•o44prosepiwitifill f 41,1c4110,41,, p f etoftrie,. -At.,4.40,.4 ocbl E arse4.4444(r , if it .wasiss Oisieffoosta4) ii i irai.fect*ik t0 id ;, ..,....1.. /..,;i. 1. :vs ,; ! . ;.4,.. r .. ~-; :- , - a Mr. leisitsVift*WEVlVl'VoiliVK i. ii.. jhet on. tho:Sfth ofillwy, - 14014. , ...andirrist thereto '. Lord C, e* . *h• hsd Iporgs , , ,oo4t r Principal' seCre4 es Of. Stiiii). ....;.4.4,44, , • . JAG beiw,' p 'leis-. stkted; Oa hit , etwykyati Itir . titelfiteeet 'hit btOdn'eia - t4 . lt ..1.0. 4 0, for :*4ll4.,Arthr* . siootbs. , :,/., .4, sent 10 'the - witaiirtlii mil"; tilith vOtts AT • - . print. The %toe .. h.q.sit.: 44 itipsdinViiieint ahem). to,,Aohn,,:und , .also .the. Otatomairipti! free whence • limy rerg„grip4o4,kgMetk i jitgi Jet° irinted Vy - Me wituese 'foe clie Parmidiugs. that the MariilscrfiSt et ensiii - Witiln'ilititlitfir't4antAi hind:writing, - alli'estapethe.44l4 • '"'ltierl4 Forsuro," and :slushier arlieh.wisiF ailosvOCtd.. stead .frote the: former SiettbjeteNlilia, Anbjec,t to • theincieaseeitigrating wi l ac tro 4s. eiprk,prigiad of thillist ind l ist of tea l . 400.0100 oFO - • 001 zo • intermediate one'Bo. -- :' l ',.. '''.' ' • • .. , ~. • , •- n .,. The' - Poblicetten * sit lir; FintartjetiLetteej Tjurchrouials, of I theissil—ef Jinni/ last, 4,gs ' °lll4'elt. --- • • - .'-:. ak 41061 . • • :. ..-? • -:- 1.-11 . .. • Jo b "' j9 6 # 6 .5.4, 5 14 1 913E4vi1ik.441- ,11 0 - it i a stick is,p, and otiservtlial, - dtit Istaatilise plicards 'fur the BritiSh - FOrutni Int . t . 147,1*.paid - fur his libour by the Piescit Delentisisto : .!: 1 ! . .. Tho . A Tleitngx,,Gensuat . haAag,:ilosed his cue, .1 . ,, . .., ..... ,_ „.. . _ . 1 ..: 1 . ~ ..... Mr. ?ins' Wdiesied the - Jury on ate plitt - to4 the - Defendaiit. - Thit the Jury - Web t - iiil4 Vi;.` tertsio any idea that- tie felt a particular affection -or was otherwise inlerested-its any erscomrmoh id grie for the Defeasiau( r he..thought it but :pro. ; per io state, that he did not stood towards the Defendant its the relation of ebrothet, 4i. of any . .other neatednnection..lll4 Eleftlndinebelonged to AiddleseiOni.(the beamed Couusel)vaas a native . , * (q. Cailnarthegshirc, in, Wales, : Thor. Defendant hqweres, 119,15 4 5ett, .4 :fi t ;: lip• • t ek:AlttiV t , :tie at `k . . . I :AN. ~.:. .. of that description he should at. reckon as his brother. It was on the Defendant had come to him, ' him to undertake his defence top4t ire felt eatresaely embarrassed bow op pro. The Defendant he knew to bp a map of . atreok. dinary abilities in the public Lie In which he acted,, and he knew him also to be adirraild With eviiry. domestic and private virtue, though not pos.' sensed of fortitude enough to withstand the at r tacks of the designing. It was, therefore, with extreme Viluctawap7that ;with his slender &bill. ties,.. and still more slender practice, be under tn took the defence, ,of seek a man.—When,, the Defendant calk:44'W the Learned Counsel,' he informed him that hp tied been advised. to with.. draw his plea. The Merced Counsel risked the j Dofeedeet if he felt coaggiotts of gent ? ,kle told Alai he. did not,' and the Learned Conosel- idtised ;him, that,with each a feeling it.would be improper, ! in him t6tplitati guilty.. there was any error int this,:be.hopodit- Wight heisttributed, is it Justly neght,:to Mtn, and; ot to Air Client. The .114. tialt,Forum was. a place whdre subjects were , 4404 iillmeggend,' sot one Wbere , lieror orimproper con. , diet woo attributed -:to: Any man without fldridhittuultigilow,fer, it : might be so attributed jolting. • , castieriagh, therseforo, in hankie . ..Ma costdect%•4o ijectod .to .e.acidaktioq br discomfit:ow •a br British' Foram was not 11,re eißOsed tothailr.ol l •l l igllF-.*oo, IMMO praise And apptihtttidq ft .. It was feng..ney.thing la the kondac.t. of Lord Prultio,- religh t. which,, is language of the adveatise s meat, •Ilmitakid to have occObnesf o'f.stonisholeat and Oki* ;" it was the statement of Mr. Floper. ty,, teitiAli was clearly oeant . to hire excited these ken* ;It was said that this &hate ot the Fennel»-wks something like Lord-A:as tkweagfiie To this he could not agape ; It was 3. ,jo." deed, 1k: trial oR skill in argument, and at such. 10004 tioeld Wol k if*Atteessnry, that par lio ll . *it' 149 - Ifig4tiOisrlojitceived-4liorn: mente:•Of.piat-Odiettlinetlfftlels;',' Pad: coodeted them' to their &tire ibtherehad jocte. ad Attorney iGentAttil - 10n1 . 1 *d' Iraikeute, elet+.ittlo9.ll:l444*/40141 1 4feligiCANO;fettcn• that might be slid- to,be a trial ; •hut here there Was no snob, tbitsp orl -s—,ll was also Complained: , that the people-wne. ?bets oaid'to ilave been outraged and inssltedi.'• Lord Castlereagh,' if. was 'to be observed, ire. not the most fortunateinan world-as (hi Dee: - ' . Cl l l ooll ,l l .P l ibw irfg 1 .rat ent • - ', ' .11gig ..4ggiLirliWit. 6 -. ‘. " s 1 •. loe•litdibiet,` 6 J,tßit y stitit t itittiVi *ii Sikick. natfai*wily cortte4 ilgthett ini§';'tiiiiiNg. , agisglingleginesahrillin ,Aitaiiifikia;stsi?stalort " 4141116,11/1- giltrlitek, :11te.ord.O.Issiiit : myth ..' i i iiiit.it;4444 rtiiii4 liftWrArliiptipA . % ' o 4 l -"C • '. ~m 4i ii.ijin to t ' . 14iiiiiilirt•A4 tlrgr, WiftlealmonY tbsti*k i A Ai. • Apg a r our libaredirt INtilikk'fir arilw° l4 soithin itkiiikillittkiiii . teffieln, • its libeiti etic al!tys rewsaln incep--, ,: 41flisioctl i shis ' GnSitt- - ;Mew ortipillititi to itakos./. ~thetir yarkqe7..103.. - caidifft•ar. iteltlittitid; wee d'titez . lisltiergol.l)f thq . Admit ,hilitilsoi ,, . 7 olrfitiVerion;*ito•fladt been u i l tY: I f II °40 441 t 4 0114) ; 1 4 601*i'l taard4 eireag - a • fdpatted. ,wilty ; 1 .-the priisentr . -7 ant 'why CO 400 U. Clr gi 0 AU kl t;:fie„enr,,,t ‘ ed,.t ' fnre, - -thifshe'Stiry siotthtnot stiffer'. this guilt. of him who had acknowledged .iii Chine, to fall 'on the Defendant,- -wan tai atsconstious • of . any Lora, Ur.stripsocsinsli. , 4-p, Gentleinen of the' Jury.: Th,ta is an ititlictiesnt.. %Sint, the Defend. *ant, John Gale Jones,_ and it *irres that before the time Of•tlut printing a certain 1i114,, jotrd gas, 1 tisrettsh had been ono of the prineinirSe4tsiatical .4d. State.of his Majesty.; aint4 • Geu ttetriaiy there is anothe!Nlegatiun, that there had' been,• on the : 14d Jn a ' scan,dslous and seditious libel it!' the for ma !okr a cfnerrning Lord . C4tfe:. reset; - - pats/lobed in a certain 'Newspaper Oiled:, 7'he Mongol, Dirichlet., • That alleptiou in. yokes, list of all, ski fact,- and ncstAbn' cos. was such a has bee n producea n tublished on `. Finnerty, texed to it.- _ alleged t, -.. a elmedalot. --id malicious libel. That certainly. is, a material allegation. Th e whole scope of.illat which has been read in detail ,to you frees The Morning Chronicle, does impute to Lord Castlereagh the purpose of persecuting and oppressing this man, summing it up in the last paragraph that he had made use of his Minis. terial power to. gratify prejudice, to invite the persecution of his person, and to fix an imputation upon his character; and the whole of the statement which is contained in the letter, goat° maintain that, . which :in the summing up of the libel is stated to be lite motive for Lord Castle reag h' s conduct. Gentlemen, there certainly can be so. Ahiqg more' libellous, than to impute to a man is a high public Office a gross abuse of his public tune. cow, to degrade and injure an individoal. The question,, therefore, upon. this part of the ea se being, .witathee this, letter has properly applied to it the •descriptlng.,.pf a•scaodalons .and malicious thel ibe 1 . 4ke terms, b i e ßt i p i e ll; it maintained se if..o ipui h idbtb. libels thatad ii csr v it; e edtr r orn t vi;en those trgbeiltcuygit elirelletioary step, font is not the publication of tei t in his mha. l o i s b ti.v el olver fi; te w Ictt :i iis c o h it t ci ll ittli e " D ithi e ue fe lpt( o h d rreet ae .i t pit Os ind the contents of theta that your atten. 0910,19 qt, by particularly !heave , inasmuch as it Is in - (Impact of them only (reference being made to °thes' matter" merely,for expliitation) that he stands h4fote"yqit te.day. ~ The 'publications in question rsio,.threa in weather ; the question is, , whether o.theix `are 'of. a. libellous lettere, and whether tilt.fleseilpOn Which is " &POO to the% by this ..: : ... . - -t. in k ietmetit 'is Justly, applicable to them • I Will read throes.: and cm:intent effort 1144 n as I read thee, Tim first begins the,," Ought my Lord Code. ' 4 kstaghia.eandtkct 'toward' Mr. Finnerty during the Ip k te rowetfitroo te" - Walcheren to be approved as a Salittitry, Malmo of precaution, to preserve order • atitt,difttisio among his Majest33 forces, ails/. grubefed of At flagrant infriogemeat . - upon the li. i betty of al3titish . Subject,. 4014.eowerdly act of oppression igabist a. inincentiedlVi4bal 1" 'New, Gentlemen, .ia q,, t 9 e . bOrne . in a country *hello people - balre 04; s pit tn 4 .10 or , .oh om oter, Alt it 'lltinirei! -'- to put in this elterroht "4 , TIF 194 '.diecoesitia' of all quea guiltier& base otipoemoloa—whether he has iqtippei flee — and (ohms ; tbjeqt *debate by a pct.. - m ope shilling • ti" ~. ,01 0 0 , 0 of assembly Wiwee'L, .• - 01:11dbate ? le•-it 'bat . IpZvi ble t ireistfill ''' li , . . ''.P..! 248 .• •./badtei thWhas au 1 - irti..• . , 1900010iit Pot erelosiet4ef,"4ll6a it laiiii.le ligft...fik IR —44ittlithig 14. . ,tcllttatitiitt's Ittordiiit, ho . slpoAvigtis'elliasii - fi:* . Ara. . Vttiliiic4foirik4 been guilty sty to yak to child, I led sheutd make that „itbelissembfed careless Pirbsert together:for the ale": of *hcarieg that die. isklefed as more ca. the peace of mind More mischiev ous to to the feelinejetithe ling only in liwine ; I mpel( In , the solemn ;tfwactiOns, bound:l46e Tby of di!ty-s the ,eostaidee t his as in _l . p nisi Gentlevee ) ttatemen t t :qr , hir. riiiper, Aliteagit, u it appeared '.ltf7 e titiagr . the ;3d a Ifsdletibetrlittly wet viral iffotiObiatet trod ' to'llietittliticetioo of terviireeTfireiiik which s•likvi. PiaWieft)ol Bp . ibmility, aitt/ justice."( their detidotepinion British' Ponta can .collecting, mad ,procialithar - --,put; set that of anj ws ledlildwil.,bliall a. tt (Male ellegation, icy ere tending their . . . 4', .I** peeutiated dad defillceledi individikal, and jt.iiiiiiis 46iditb . iiipt - 7-411e":rbolet icePe .and on! sect. , alleks*tetratir that it- meaai•lo impute thee rittisedittOblitLoid Cistimagirt Ilia] it goes . 43•444 4, ,j1rItlinigentte . t oril Cestlereegh can master * ~.1 6 . 2 1 1_I catifiatilbeld" venture into,* public estrov. .:01. n -r igit ivee ptit i oktio nti independent : ...thic E he ng i l s is a hia i Lti r .: o l . o - That qi --konikotio o koalpitira public assembly of free and litdependattltdeisltitea." He may rest assored, t ' , that- hVilvilt.liVe'l'airPlay."..-Now see bow 04 s lirol*.htle•othiite to the ear le - kept, ' ." • There ill . : -iteithing foe twhicit ahe Mattageta of this Institee . • .ticirt mato *deafly tong, than an 'opportunity of "Theeting-14 . E.Ordship and his adherents face to Ate, end . heiring - them - . vindicate ',their character , till 44 . 14117 it_...be01re an:. outraged and insulted' • wtrintry. l ",' tiseettlemen, 'ls that a fair hist; to tell his trittlithip that there Ii in outt!Wil Sod in t! seated toiletry, - Which the oilltext *Sheila must vane.. ‘atttifell -uhtl . kneiatco ;by biro; and to • i4y; 'lie' wit livt'Olit fair vial by your com ing before Ilfersi: irhai'lest -. have outraged and insultettillt 6 ii,. - `1 think ? fropOisihle to state any .thing to 3 hei It. lifel If 'this - ii '. not: • . Then, Gentle. 'men, .veil6oatif'tti:thi'aiititied . ulalicitiou. 'That • •begieatly!itiitlttglife Twatitia as before,, with the wird" , ihrefixi4F, l t 4 rho .. 44 • bird Castlereagh :" MO iblir*viittcectil, l a' . Esif 'Monday, itetwith stiediertlie,ittelitilidinallielet attempts to stifle the disciesiotiet fif 'Ali 1)&161 important ouesti 'a ' by tearing 46tvas and il: fading the . hi115. , 1,-.Mes n .' oga kooli 4 ogie iitteol v is, Gentlemen, if any or •-. . : .... . THEEAESMJ 4 9T o applicidan:ii, *do. *emery MIS stated Ididseg twilit'. 'o4 4 d. to r Tdict, and fully etrif- ni4ht that It, and upon that re : quested of U LT. ia-the world-•a lial•C d ic-'oo.lWlilir.,- if- the 'Dee. ihafiltkAtkiefrt,any matt** 1 g ild vie Au fondant tisk hatitCo • JO seWseste ih his -7o; tiro WWII titttbilod i tor . flu! 'memorable rum it one alitillag i o,pletric• o Ili net di* i ill 9! o4 fr r l i f el kh.g. r. a i I n __ ! ,_____,_ : ll6l4lol attempting, aa - Mei nt AttoroopOmirit‘tabliddr ds4. , :tesi,..AWk.. strictly -twid.a. 0 04,41, 1 0 •°` uvP"MiT feei l ice hi.ve hOntioralvie r Mitacte . etas tikilti''Se4lltrlK seat AlotbAlirgi4Rt., 7:? 1 ,. 0 #90 1 41 4 4 i ;ILIC and fir- o f a s luf f * 7a !.,.. I L.. . . jOACI4,O4t 4it that tinter '41114140e subject- 0i: t rs on3Z ilinit; tl - 14, ' •.► - ' i l ;;; '. 77 L 1111 A ea*S o l/ 1 ! ..**i&litchre.. to :Nitta° .. ' ThOt the MAO •' ' tido setsse et t l e S it aid*O-htro *Mb: tae.reeinchior iepose F .. . i4JOSSUOI their frOlittiealler . jacklatej atitlega. .41 1 e4elhwknieh,51,9 4 , ittr A tifl:: l (tribunal toliddlVeotileti •• • puppets( . the g* ".I.ll,o.lll4l..o4iftLiwynauff I p , h dia. aim .teritinifir4; '.., :44:4104 • ... ' ' ..'t bsit the. oat lo tpc,4"AZts t..of a. rilf,4 od P! flacagds ii• getiliblilif-,C. 161 1 . ..i5fer, 1 ",.. i , rel_ 4 ,•!' RO" ka,'"l'irat .it t o i k 1 1 1.! Ai n sefrp: , • . , saner 4.witilAkilatk:follit;Millilklly Po Atilegi...reou 5?.r...110 . ! . keowar s y .t . p ~, 1 If g 44 .-Virliti - tedicitc4, l o4-4104014 1 404 , are!g..°T 0 "4.74rtr, ._.", i 1 : o Mt seat iii a ' . iniatinv-Vnid. thik im. ~___ _ .... !recorcet,,,i. . tt!PP9r ,f - j 2 .4 Mona. toretka,te Defr o ltrt.lsatlikti i sW it r . Pie afteptiOttlif -.your prtfirts.eWel g ° o iiiblik4 4 * " -errik ' ,* PeciiniY• B4. .i 4o 4 6 6iir Vl* knat . a. nil's; . .: 16ihi ::ii,;#44, - 10feeleeft-= .41 64 4,1 01 kk,.VeittglY 4 kb , t ' amtltattees, bar* litiftsi*.*ltttl'' 41*.A.iija. cpllo..eMrdritaii4Oolly,4i . frel iberefi zi4 4 4004 Akill Castlereagti•Wiklif t eV . liialwoor • of. a base disregerd . of. fmwdati e !Mimed ediiiiik,ind 4tot to havtratired .. .0 :;; . : friend,.oraisy.other ptiir . .„ l Al übowliPt isged lies against tEe Ititatr of' i 'VW • * •-•"' . . Am:tatter of Aisoirido*fiallilift the '4'0110., lb, two pettier. 34ertattiectioit • :. ; ' ,' . pe0p1e;w16041(44146 iq'rlia thy 4.ary reaghi seemed to; , letvd. .old old, ~ :1%; 111,b"ii :purpntaligof ofiltOlditle '01 1 : O let thdif :Why• did they aut. ve 10,1b)ile" 81/11 •:, %410 • 100-;!..0W any. *dog be cent WU.J'USP -settle-diem 1. or, • whyk:Atick Ahoy. Wolt4ii - . ,-:11/1 . )minickastire -deatractiieof itlyilvd* enemies, .but is , friends,: } toi Wal , 4. ' , theinsariduallo held au Ili rs 01*ili -like Mk Qiillot and SahhoPsitclife, t.' :,,,, e public, lbeenore irritatiag to the, awl" instead. of* windmills,: lioviAlidy.'SJ •• 1 7. . )adividurdloilteld up I Tiki lailliet, 'lllagnei,lSlVittinge: eiy! '61441410...-TW I 41 .OK first • . iib, I feel -my' ill', 0 ,Ila • ibll4 AtAlOget w varly diffeiwatir . )4nii 7„: di : -tipoirotant Easel licao 4stin xing, Defend.. Alteresst -dales; and in etatii litlp i l '#0 , 1 4 .. - , .1 `Dash ;' I . 4ok• . haw tlikcitio and 0 . Weseeof the' -libll, dnf the Mike a :" '. .. pioweiz.jo,stfte- to publication, I t l / 4 1 .Cialelk . '.vefitid 04. author, : era witeennuf tti Oil/ --- highlrodemaions publication, wild aoi eased - part tot Or 61140: :110741iiisioArt it:gealiiiti) am. "The stafaull ri •.. ' -4 ':•-• wit 0 4 0 04144 iiit,./igicitit.to.fitdifet.••• • •dot jy'ritsatineat toy Lord Castiere Erti 'W . Iltet iitieh Forma, tbe . Attoreey ? Elkae4 41110, In „the. Moraine Chronicle, of M.r.tiag, treated. fr , *ith • ndliiite*ag goodinitir g and ' t r.• testaati:. ha& been: read with th rCriteth kir . iere he should' sl 4 raepailatabliis.fti ;gel/egg* timid, :Mot hal etzcited universe '.., . . bleak. hoiseany. OrsaViihiitt - li4iokirds' .14k,kki alaraillading all aloof to rot., was bein rtmarlitel* , - -,itrhile•Oilbei ' itcal Mr. Floc** in -the ,Months •v i lio Mt riiiii; Ae il is *Ay* - Ali Di* '4: sly. has been rent so rte s .—whir P,' the ' rig . ria4o -,iltad i pealed to the gond soeie libere Mi . 4 ' °leak* n: - Mai %Ida' lie - lif ,Ow flriGsh• Natioa,; to give tb ; .- - • .-, • t; Eaves :ir.4 l. she tret,i4sibbWßAlKA4: , l;iiistf -11 0;, oftile subject. *Se tar as the Iviprinioek 141y1.(WOW iskiefaiOlitlvierlidii . OP fte intlEkf its Kid towards .callectim Ifft,Attelie . fri - ani . other part otilialroWliff: 11O•erfoyelt Oct Unti4pinian, wither hie frappes i t : 1••-eq. 1 .I*.Atilaytt, 1PV011 448 2010. 44.41619 4 0 W-5..; gthar.peeeeeplad et de fe n c ele s s ;.6. 140 . b eeir ,,, A .„, Mk t *: reisq - •iiiseitioklogii*amitil vet:..iie - ritadajq sdfil....-Is not rCi t hilli,!: Otreni.ixt , .* - -Wiiieh the wodattiollolifilAtiltet ttwit- this person to whew the' . , - 4. - Il t f.;. : 74,0: , 4. .4 P:,:, • t „ .. t lways be st a Woo pllrxtypilacit, Altat there I only last le pittolisio.d. 9 th e ,Paper. That and re. p by the Printer of thaPaper, who r.day.— parr, which he stales to hoe been pu preCe4; . thak,(l4, containing a latter signed P. extra/K.. Then has that lettee the quality Anne] se said,. It is alleged to be a madalous and malii , 11 . - 1 d. 111 • ei