The British Press; or, Morning Literary Advertiser. — London, England, 1825-05-27 00:00:00

, question _ Vffillmaithisell home& at Ms t:boner or Coventry. (A laugh.) The Moe of Casesetne poised the Emancipation Bill on the ground of ha befog essential to the happiness and tranquillity of the opowery t and the House of Lords had on the other hand rejected a as oppoeed to the well-being of the kingdom, because the Moue' sf Lords could not continue to exclude six millions of their fillow-subjects from the State, unless they conceived it necessity 'faits stability. To come then to the point, and granting the Ca entire Claims inconsistent with the well-being and security of the coqntry : to ascertain that fact it was incumbent on the House to , t the best information ; it was also incumbent on them to strengthen thdr am, and show by the best evidence and authority that they were tight in the course. pursued by the ii. SS'hat eyi . • I to have recourse to? None certainly was entitled to weight and consideration than that . over to, govern Ireland in the most difficult tirnes--nonc coed be more valuable than that of Lord ' been an eye-witness or the proceedings in that !re best qualified to talk of their civil &sten. origin and consequences. How was it that Lord -ens en opinion which would have weight with `which he was so disriuguished a Member ? aim (Mr. S. Rice) have you not the vote of bard therefore his opinion, what more can yon desire? 'hat he wanted not alone the evidence of Lord . Lord Lieutenant of Ireland ; that Nobleman ' years in that country, during which residence '• himself acquainted with every thing connected • called far the despatches, as the recorded evi_ l i Representative. lie (Mr. like) might be "'• that these opinions have been given on the , it were not demonstrable from reason that .. once give up his motion. Sir (said the cannot go from the school of the child to the I , 'd matt; but the Catholic question forces itself on .) How is it passible then that Lord %Venal aad not sent his opinion on it f I call on the in favour of the Catholic Bill to support my as soppordng the principle on which their own votes were The on. ndemen opposite might say, examine the bean theraortnittee; he(Mr. R.) was sure that Vile the Howe. of Lords to permit the examination, s the mune Hon.Oentlemen, that such course inconvenience.; he therefore adopted the of maringint the correspondence. After' observations,. the Honourable Member said that advanced timeshare in opposition to theestholic - weight, would prove the propriety of reenacting It was said that Catholics were not loyal sub. se not to be trusted. If ao they had already re- There wawa feeling In Ireland not only of bit ternms For recent disappointments, but a foreboding that the day of *ape fur the Uatholica, if ir had not already passed away, would soon set. The House was told to apprehend no danger from -Catholic disappointment and Catholi: disturbance. They were sold that the Catholics were peaceable, and therefore no danger was to be apprehended frost their violence. Such language came with - who opposed their claims. %Vhat did this v, - that If under disappointment and Catholics, how much more safely might gratitude after conceding to them their rust Neese for Somersetshire says. " Do what dean." If so, bow can he be warranted respects so much? The Catholics woot praise, as little as did the Agricultural Ass*. Hon. Baronet end Mr. Webb Hill, who the O'Oorman of that Society, receive the Londonderry, when he told them that the were quiet and "peaceable 4 they spurned enlogiuns when they foucd that he toss reit- interests. (Isuchter.) " On Wedges. another day you ailed me dog." Is ISt, 3 receive the praise of the is. Ilareard. Catholics would take the advice fif a lim iest prayer to them was, that they *there s—Sat. that they, at every risk, and ander up the strongest union among their own united in their exertions for the common seesejl principle should be to do every , so merit, deserve, and &Noire Protestant The streets wet they outing in in their se this water, and they out are long resell ' dub wishes. (fear, hear.) Let the people re be but unsanseas, and when that tints He____ not refuse to accede to their prayer. (Chew Mambas, wbosegeopertp end Uri WEN 041101111bMi fat spectre esteemed them the power which they held at present. The power he wished to see see established was the power of the law, and if they desired to see that power of the law restored to its just influence, and to take away the control of certain—he would not call them agitators, but 'ceders of the Catholic body, they could ngt do it more effectually than by taking away those grievances, and that perpetual ground of complaint. Ile was sure that the succeeding generation would view with astonishment—he might say contempt—the arguments which had been urged against the Catholic claims in these days, and that they would hardly believe they had, upon that question, seemed to be deprived of all the benefit of time and circumstances,' and fallen back to a state of thinking and action only worthy of the middle ages. (Hear, hear.) It would hardly be credited that they had, at variance with ever/ principle of sound policy, left it in the power of any foreign Minister to trouble the peace of the country, instead of following that wise, enlightened, and liberal policy which distinguished the other proceedings of the day, and which, in that case, would have tended so strongly to preserve the power and pre eminence of the country This country had established a continental society for the purpose of diffusing its principles amongst the peo. pie of the neighbouring nations. 'What would they think to see a similar institution in France, to disseminate opinions amongst the Irish ? And with what feelings could they look upon& system of po. hey which had left Ireland at the mercy of foreign intrigues, and taught its people to look with distrust at the proceedings of the Le. that of the country ? Now, with a view to support the vote of that House upon the subject of the Catholic question, by the sen timents of Lnrd ASellesley—to rebuke and censure that Noble Person, if, with a strong opinion upon the justice of the Catholic claims, he had not pronounced an opinion at all —if he has pto. flounced an opinion to ascertain what that opinion Vas, lie thought that M ouse was bound to support his motion for t h e production of the papers alluded to. They had a precedent far such n measure. Papers had been produced to justify the application of coercive proceedings against the Irish people. and were they not likewise to be pradueed when the effect war likely to be productive of concilia tion and tranquillity ? Papers had been produced to the House of Lords, and he thought that precedeot was sufficient to justify the present motion. He hoped the House of Commons would not refuse its consent to a proceeding which would put it in possession of the evidence of the Chief Magistrate of Ireland, and thereby justify not only the vote they had given, but also give the means of a renewed effort to do justice to the people of Ireland. The Hon. Oendeman concluded by moving—Chat an humble Adams he presented-to IW Majesty, praying he would be pleased to fieOlim that there be laid before that House copies of all letters or dew patches from the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland respecting the origin and nature of the religious animosities prerailing in that country, and the means pointed out for allaying those disturbances, and confirming the prosperity and security of the empire. Sir T. LETHIIRIDGE denied that he had ever entertained or exrressed any opinions hostile so a feeling of the loyalty of the purple of Ireland. He was not able to follow the Hon. Alember through his speech, but he thought the motion wait one of oonal.. derable difficulty, and that it could not be well resisted by that portion of his Majesty's Ministers who had favoured the Catholic cluhns. He thought the Hon. Member for Limerick had gone out et the line of his duty when be charged the people of England with making a clamour upon that question. They expressed their true opinion—that expression was stronger than lie ever rennin be:cd—stronger. than at had ever been, although it was late—and he was convinced it would be impossible for the Honourable ' Member for Limerick, or any other Honourable Member, to 'bring forward a proposition upon the subject of the Catholic Claims, which would not meet with the strong disapprobation of the people of England. He would he deceiving himself and those for whom he felt o much interest, if he entertained any other opinion. The lgonotirahle Member then observed, that if the hopes of the Catholic Body had been raised, they were not raised by those who whiled things to remain as they were, and who had repeatedly expressed that wish ; and concluded by arguing, that I as there had been no disturbances after the putting down of the Catholic Association, there could not be a jot apprehension of those dangers which were used to terrify the people of this country now. Mr. 001ILHURN thought it very natur4:4lnet as the How. Member for Limerick Itsd not an opportunity of delivering his • timents upon the Catholic Question on other tea, he take the opportunity of putting the HMSO opinions now ; but lie considered that it himjAfr. Goulburn) who had already eta= lion, to follow the Hon. Gentleman (the Mambo Cyr ehrough the whole of his argument'. That lion. Gentsosok argued the question as if it was purely Irish, while hetet looked opal it al involvinga great constitutional q sinner eureened with the inmate of the &OM •-""1 ,- ling extensive and the best information upon the mite of Ireland. Be sides, the House should bear in mind, that after they had been for two Sessions of Parliament consulting all classes of men—from Peers and persons holding high offices in Courts of Justice—Aoni the richest Prelate, of die Established Church down to poor Pre lates, and from Priests of the Roman Catholic Church—front all classes of persons in short, bounding their inquiry only by not ex amining those the examination of whom would be likely to lead them not into information but ignorance—after so general an inves tigation, it would not be courteous to the Marquis %Pellesley to reject his testimony on the state of Ireland. At any time lie would be glad to avail himself of the infornistion of a person so capable, from his experience and wisdom, of udging rightly of the condi. tion of Ireland ; but stow that inquiry was the order of the day, he was particularly desirous of deriving information from one who, bound by duty to know the condition of Ireland, and connected with that country by birth, anti he believed too by an affection for it, from his commanding station. would obtain—he would not say acqsiiescecce in his views wish the people of this country—but at least would challenge the most minute attention. (Hear, hear.) It was not satisfactory to the House to say that we knew the opi nions of the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland by his proxy in the House of Lords. That was not sufficient. They had an instance in an other place of a Noble Person speaking one way and voting another. It might be—though he did not expect it—that the Noble Marquis who was at the head of his 'Majesty's Government in Ireland, might write one way and vote another. However. to prevent the possibility of mistake, it was right that the Noble Lord should be judged by his own declarations; that his opinions should be, as it were, reflected in their trite mirror. It was there fore his opinion that, for this purpose, his despatches should be Lid before the House. He was the more desirous also that the opinions of the Marquis IVeliesiey should appear after the speech of the Prime Minister, which assumed so decided • tone as to =cunt to a declaration that, neither now or at any future time, eboteld the claim which the Roman Catholics so earnestly sought for be conceded to them. (Hear, hear.) He was sorry to hear that such an opinion had been expressed. For-his own part, he bud been as long opposed to the concession of these claims, as long as he could conscientiously oppose them. As long as he bad any tenable !ground to occupy he maintained it, and did not abandon It instil he saw the nakedness of the land, and was sincerely convinced et the hollowness of the cause. (Loud cries of " Hear, hear.") In the late discussions there was not a reason or a pretext of swoon advanced, he thoogbt., fee the easainued denial of theirclainiai k wee in deference to the weight of reason and argument on the other side that he supported those laws. What a great temptation was given to the Roman Catholics of Ireland to keep the peace by the Lie decision in another place. It was saying to the people of Ire land, " Be peaceful as you cap be, contribute your funds to the egigencies of the State to the utmost extent of your means ; be your *ion founded alike in justice, policy, and expediency, it matters e el, both now and for ever you and the constitution must be tliws is each other. (Cheers.) This was making their exclusion =.; it opened no prospect of a wise policy to promote the of Ireland, and - " Sery'd only to discover sights of woe, Regions of sorrow, doleful shades, where peace And rest can never dwell--hope never comes, That comes to all."—(Cheers.) As to the two measures which accompanied the Bill for the Eman cipation of the Roman Catholics, he had supported them on Re. scent of their tendency to make the passing of the measure accept able to all parties. The opinions of the Honourable Secretary of State for the Home Department, and of other Members of his Ma jeaty's Government on the question, however conscientious they may be., he the more regretted, as they entailed upon Ireland the sontinosnee of a system, Inconsistent, unintelligible, and calculated ter retard the improvement and mar the happiness of that country. A ' peremeresee in this system, however attached Ministers may be to their respective opinions, was taking liberties with their duties as etweesnim eras making • plaything of a great nation and a mighty maws. ( Hear, hear.) The danger to the Church, and the apprehension of the draseveration of the two countries, had been fully disproved by the evidence of Mr. Blake, who said that if such a danger or apprehension enuid be entertained, he would not wish for the passing oldie measure. Rut was there not danger to Ire appre hended from not passing this measure? Sappoae the people of Ire land unanimous, or seorly44, in the necessity of carrying this mea sure; suppose that seventy-five Members nut of one hundred Re preeentatima of that country to have voted for the second reading of the Rill; supposing that of the rensaining twenty-fire some were absent, and four or five were English Members foe Irish places, yet with this feeling for she measure, general and dtepthrourds-- -- the country, was tide natio representation .of iis 1.- .41 the rimier withheld back into .should be carried in and 4 passing therefore, Ai irritation approved of the -•d by apport always Ireland. Friend that exasperate created by lion. that that he •e ob , ap , must inoon for At supported Name view ammo t Doyle. repreaented reland, had ha birnsel f to faul t only Ivoeste of justice ender.. is these attention • charge • first . that charge expect He . tell- Ake up fresL ? By that the at all former recorded , grounds for producing such despatches, though they existed ; and, because communications of a confidential nature might takd between the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland and his Majesty's • ten, which it would be highly inexpedient to submit to public its spection. (Hear, hear.) Mr. BROWNLOW explained, He by no means meant to accuse the Right lion. Secretary of the Home Department of in- consistency; on the contrary, he regretted his too great uniformity of opinion. (Hear. hear.) He had not spoken of an individual, bat of a system ;—(Cheers)--and he would say, that there was an inconsistency in that system, from the difference of opinion that prevailed amongst Ministers with regard to the Catholic Question, which marred any plan of permanent improvement in Ireland, and checked the general prosperity of the empire. (Loud cries of " Hear, hear.") Lord J. RUSSELL, after expressing an opinion, that he under stood the Hon. Member fur Armagh in the sense in which he ex plained himself, said, that although change of opinion was some- times attended with suspicion. yet when such a change had taken place as that of the lion. Member for Armagh, where personal sacrifices were made, and obloquy incurred, the change could only be attributed to honest and sincere conviction. A Ministry strong in opposition to the measure would be better, not perhaps for the Catholics, but certainly for the empire, than a divided Cabinet, like the present. (Hear. hear.) Lord lingrall had informed him on one occasion, that Mr. Pitt, in 1804, told him (Lord Fingal') that he was desirous of carrying this measure, but owing to the prejudices f the King the subject could not he mentioned to him ; and as the then administration were prosecuting with energy t he war with France, he could not hazard the existence of that administra tion by urging the Catholic Question. This was an arrogant, yet it was • consistent reason, but no such reason could now he urged, as there was no subject of so great importance to interfere with the passing of this vitally important measure. If we were obliged to go to war, what tremendous dangers might ensue to us from the unhappy state of Ireland. Supposing that the present conduct of the Government, their vacillating behaviour, should bring on an insurrection in Ireland. how would the Mink 'era stand with the country, and how would they stand also with the Throne? Should they be asked the cause, they would be obliges! to confess that it was because they had not conciliated Ire land : upon which his Majesty might say, " Why did you not tell me this ? you are sworn to advise me according to the best of your cunning and ability, and yet on tissa great and important question you have been silent, and have never once given me a word of ad... vice." He hoped that if such a crisis should arrive, his Mojealtes responsible advisers might be able to account for their extraordi nary conduct in this instance, but he owned it was such as would ever excite his wonder and astonishment. This being the lust op portunity which he should have of speaking on the subject this Session, he thought it to be his duty to state the impression which had been made on his mind by the result of the measure intended for the relief of the Irish Catholic; that impression, he would re peat, was, that this country was not safe, and that the tranquillity of Ireland was more than ever endangered by the rejection of that measure. Bush being his conscientious opinion, he felt hawed( bound to declare it. Sir W. MAXWELL spoke on the question, but he was uuscly unintelligible in the gallery. Colonel BAGWELL perfectly concurred in the motion of lib Honourable Member for Limerick. He hoped he should not be nut of order in noticing what had taken place in the other Hoeft of Parliameat, but he could not help lamenting the situation himself and the other Honourable Members for Ireland who wee' about to return to that country. Ile thought that a certain nom high in the bovernment of the country—he meant the Primal& nister--ought, when he disposed of the question it: the manual. had done, to have tuensioned some remedy for allaying the turbo. lent and feverish state in which Ireland would naturally be theme_ by the rejection of that measure. (Hear, hear, hear) Another Noble and Learned Lord had used language of a very extrsordiesay nature, and which perhaps at some future period he would be called upon to answer for. Lord L. GOWER said, that during the many debates SWAIM taken place on the subject of Catholic Emancipation, be hell geese' occasion only presumed to o ff er his opinion upon it, borilless he thought it would be better to leave the field to those who ewer, letter able to speak to its merits than himself. On the proem , trahm, however, he could not resist making one or two obennto..! line with regard to the motion of the Hon. Member for listarkk. certainly felt extreme reluctance in opposing that modes. 'duty in Parliament had been, and would for the future be, disestegi ea one sole object, that of Catholic Emancipation (hear, IV rand if he thaw& that in refusing his vote to his klajtatfa warnmeat hathwald be able to promote that measure, he ebswid ant' Whim a(l enact what he plight to do. Bat it had bees mil a, ...... "1111111111 . 1 1 11 .11111WIIINIPPROP IPPIII MIPP 11 . 11.11.11111/101.1111.1P M 111111 " 11111111.111"9"111.111.4 7 104 " 1/111"P"."9111 . 0/1" ‘ , _ . _. :.. , . •, .. -* ..• - . • . • . . - . . e e . _ ..... - • le -, o . .•' ... .-. . )Ibet..- - - -4 1 ;?' , _ • '... , I 1 ...., 1 1 11 ~ . ::.. ttrrlsl,4ltlNs• ~. . • . • . . . . . . ,_ ... _ .. • . be ' k and rust no Et i .l:: " INI * 41".1.1.e5ee11 • . 6( =lre the ro " t*fal 4l4 ast el et bj"' ma"' f r ( t ;othz "6" ll. 4t * t iii. k I mr;pa ' rt of the. 11.1.914 agakl it he dva as ise lill eseerwi ft." ilieltry,:geoefr. it t ls ori ld a bc wh b r i t j le t right people, k7 wl t s i s:Z u p " ° pil l = what estat l' t last to be ems is athe it gors ox e whit wen not ebb le et UK far Members of the Commons were two to ow its vont. and angtending eh the • 0 Ilhill English. 'foe Hots . Gentle. were within the grave( their legitimate ambition,and were with!' 4: le Petrie were Polied he litDa Ws the peopealen la& et. 0. • 9" ,of the streognit from them, and they from the h' heat bort were Sun beck I 'ding -.-""' . se taw, hear-) ll* *waist "wowed the - tiet a g i nit ''''"'"r p C ''. 4 1 6 - . _ then , the people the depths of deppaer. Meru, tsar.) t was certain Ft should A. ''„lt ilh " . ' anew efwearesurrer. shed* he sibie SO veentriest of the country contrived (by a majority E4lWritost ___,. M e they n o r he only borne in mind, that thin measure mast be ultimately carried '' • "'""*- 'as gold an ewe.- as lON be teeniest') to exclude the Catholics, an idea wool be ralIM *a & I. ' ' . ''''' n ' e It to . es ••• - • Wert their ' ings when eff(ct, mit had been already carried triumphantly by reason tt . - - ....„.... e 4111161114101 11111 ifilibilill k Oten ed. kappa of the Vitae wool4llloll4llooort 10 Mein the tomirmiegml es hp. ' • they were open that ques- argument. (Hear, hens.) It was better, therefore, that the paste their rights. Ruch a ftilfig would in the end make therollfilk — feleg — deriaTditieet be lir lo attribute that clamour, if of the measure should be immediate, and it was painful, thereto Or " n"" 4-- eft let ikeNLIABLET, British COnneedsirt, and kuir to kas thematic if theft tiegreoluiesk eliglaillitlhaila we% to s.isea imisairtions feeling, The Hon. to see the old career of exclusion purled, and fresh irritat: .... ix ib ete .1• -•.: " mak be efehingegl the med. oferhhil be. With reseed ett the ay of "No Popery," and the bane artifices_ by. peor ts the ein the Jew Bill, and created, at a time so favourable to concession. Ile approved of I •, inon g the Oh gluir um raspy which it Ssetwitheshosid wilorely.lef dilltellaillgeoglosis Oltdt Ant tidy mhos pituarit in support manner is which the motion tomight had been brought forward . line efiallt imi I C U% old gist heir tad genaillellee No ffengry." would else he the fiat eis lane "No otelliasementheL kilpensuelt ' beerourr, herr no value; his honourable F ri end. It came recommended to his Rupp we ,-• 4. 41, +• 6 , see m ab - sr rreefberey Ogle libgeilbetiecite Xing" le thiteemieleanner. (Heir, bear.) He Whirr scale a Ilettbeikerm hew* a *abate wpm my sisbjew is tire Home, nor by . the unwearied activity and useful patriotism winch he alwi we" et se -se. del blill4oll 4to Oadtplies pica of conduct which he. was MN must be madirill Or by wow emr• a ortaimer of peddler) gpmemed tang Which extracts evinced in any subject connected with the interest of beim 4.- " ..a ' Media ideal liteOr t. lbw in that Here mer error to Cathode amseeinlas. An might mothiedwet Athlete untahl rat Wiser upon the question (Hear, hear.) . her thit twin it 'ere -111. Ind hn'e printer, eared isibeet, well known fees bug moseessed aberstsee hiessfria pa stapsteas rem' be, thereferw, vow no reason j Mr. PEEL agreed fully in one observation of his lion. Fria . - helletefitet old ireet hi ld i r di ef Ilm he in suer for etelliks, pegibitei asivenL copies of a RS= Algothey- Wiwi Warr *few thateejellible at eJr PIM seine . 70 I ( Mr. S. Rice) who brought forward this measure, namely, tl •- . ''' wee 1:p horn thil elf grinudon - peer wbe darer. in ardor pince. to Miele he man , rib !afore@ es she ogecties of weether NB vesting every topic ought to be avoided which was calculated to exuper, Ask peg. ag gm perm mar kl eraursit. (Werr i er. a ) oratuirerle of the Inn allialamilige, dimmer. wallas dm heel ' gemusebt 1 *Abed Wet, berm. brairie only the feelin g . of disappointment which must naturally be created .......„........., he t & „. 6 , so * me m f a l og o web, loom a g ih a ma s Qom ' s' ma as , „biiimeimiimge. Isom rim gaNii, whoa sere emerriem th e . rejection of the claims of the Roman Catholics. Ilia lit ... PP 1 0 " 7"'n"'"" ilidirairo b w = b i , k r ai s ii a t& a a se amm a a ago im a m aa psal m s Wes reseene pik.;. _____la i ma m is megiagregea,"greee imil been a cession Manama Friend not only recommended the propriety of abstaining from tl •se en tom fromki& sa d Aim Istkanis. Vats mos la th e Peerage, impb •IM maj o s . some, I eery mcgaibumitrie remrentationa (hear, line of remark, but he must also do him tho justice to say, that • seeellide One era UN sot hilifefiffe tee him to forelleno, diem re mid Acne, of that speech , sad the est& thish) sod such was sly, in his emotion, to operate had observed the precepts he had enjoined. lie tbould hope to e .am figs ommi mr'mpregub, hi_ suflermen is dere pmeembreg% be mentarrmi it, to thin . (Hear, hear.) Though chunera es a orarnirig r who mesh' merle with Wigton subjects serve the rule his lion. Friend had laid down, net should any a m on d do yam m brim is wad gag earmessep simile te eirg pm. were eullale, so we the bmiguage of the President, . • la was .when there woomeeell dangeos hewed of the imoneeety did shich peal, however provcking, 'educe him to depart from it. He ne jar -" a ft a s si gsphash at 'gee egarmsereint of Os igimarn. generally tea he orinsidered se expressing the mature sentiments of had eased mock inwitement. Ti' Mee. Member bed roved for take leave to express somewhat of surprise at the charge of Met apseif /WINO *se thee Os thief litgret of loestedlet--the the People," ilkdadoe which many instances might be cited; hem dime peelers, upon three grew* s the first was, shat their pee_ sistency being preferred against him by the Hon. Member for I was ssa ogee *gibe ft meg gm eigemag magi be hem, many he wash( seism the Jew Bill. in turning over the debates duals, would soothe the feelinged She people of imbed. He wet magi', the more particularly as that lion. Meatier had euppor ?ids—Aar whim war ea errepil the escalade of begs on this Bill he found all the arguments now used against the Ch. minified that it would not ham. that earl, and that eut the eon. him until within the feet six weeks ; he had taken the same vi sides 4 the House. as will se re ef pos. The tholic claims. (A laugh, nod hear, hear.) One of the Petitions teary it would keep alive ass Novi feelings which may have ,of it hitherto as he (Mr. P. did, and Low called him to &cm - a mmo' ems aammegeg A i' age flurego._mgelry from Lando" against it mid, that naturalising the Jews would he .ariers hem the bee excitmore. T he Hen. - Gentleman had main. ' for nut becoming as he h-d done--a convert of Doctor Loy a l *glum mb o s a g mom • .. d gigs, aka w g 1i $ ilie'di ae !rest dishonour to " not the Protestant but the Christian Church," eared shut they should nem *we mere with more readiness ' (Hear, hear, anti a laugh.) The Hon. 31ember, who represere bu l l, 4 ,,1bb IbMabba, Machos, shu t bum gassy Ile ggpel. anise Why this was worse than the Catholics—next " that it would en- Weft they were to do. gestiihr Wow they were In be the fore- one of the most respectable and influential counties in Ireland, li • ass.emo mapegages big ter eameg, se mem lona, egisidff, mime danger our happy Constitution, Church and State" (cheers and senses of evil , .• but did th ane*. Messibseeleollat that the papers all along been a strenuous supporter of that cause, which he n goo game gbir gramma y (lose, hem) /Aegis" ro r the laughter) ; and further, " thst it would be prejudicial to trade to be alluded to had not bees geigegiagi.ellaig vas nmeitin upon the told 'inn (31r. P.) wee a hollow cause, and one untenable in art *or Wear the mum, sod Mei . arr err him what admit the Jews Into Lendon." He did not know what the lament subject had been negatired,aed the cam sbeariessel. The next good meat. He (lie. P.) blamed not the motives of the lion. Mem! • her bear ado for Now. (Hear, berm) If there had been a Chsneellor of the Exchequer thought, but certain it was that the lion. Gentleman proposed tarifa...6 the inducing the Lords —nay, lie admired his sincerity—but after what had already hi g g s e e.". ...se di.' enerseadon b a d been mesh e d, former ones did not think it prejudicial to admit the Jews to change their opinions by the prerbeeir of the sentiment, of pened to himself. the Hon. Member should rot believe himself oboe so ago so ni a ebarge of ire • trey ? into Landon , or den so Downing-street. (Hear, and a laugh.) Marquis Wellesley. This was the Meerge he had ever heard of be infallible. (Ilear.) Nor should he be foremost in finding fa E . t jegetioad owe 111111..1ed0. ssppnsefs g eho cedes* Agee, A Gentleman, the Meerther I believe for Northamptonshire. takes the Members of one House of Parliament taking it upon them to with others, because the genie light had not broken in upon th. Bill of whir reerldwit to yit weigh le o f another and a'different view of the question, and here he would re- produce the means of changing the opinions of 'die other : but that had broken in upon himnelf. (Hear, hear, hear )It was of with mbeimegue ermarie gf Immo Wei mind the House that they had been told of some dark, unknown, even admitting that the opinueos of that House might be influenced last SealiQn that the lion. Member had been the chosen advocate sag en. ageetten gge 016.111=liteggeg , raw% undefined evils, which were to arise as consequences aby Lord Wellesley, he (31r. Cloulburn) contended that they were the Orangemen of Ireland, and had presented petitions front tl vi:i ' Wild him the nem, Aga age& their consent to Catholic Emancipation ; what those evils were he already in possession of that Nobleman's sentiments, and that he body—which he (lie. p.) was glad to find no longer existent iligerf se Ole pies. meg a Mod orated could not exactly comprehend, but he thought that whatever they had declared by his vote that hie feelings to the Catholic body re. praying for inquiry into the cases of Orangemen requiring just on al red ill• . use le, for might be, they would fin d in their parallel the fears of the 1100. maioed unaltered. The Honourable Gentleman contended too that to be done them. lie (31r. P.) had no small difficulty In end. Gl* . bMg feed lehodinf *Ono dir • the denger. llemberhe wes now quoting, whoargued that if aeenersinaturalies- these papers would form a substitute for the examination of the Touring to induce the _Honourable Gentleman to waive th seeddkespepleseqspinnedlegfepannoMetedanliese Redid not wish non of the Jews took place, they would finally strip the inbalsitauts Lord Lieutenant. If he thought such examination necessary, he inquinee which he was so anxiously priming on the anent • fielull* air; bet illrigll4 samusgre th e mess Ohrtual and oleo of this country of all th e ir p r operty, swallow u p all their estates, should beteg forward a distinct proposition on the subject, although of the Howie. As to want of uniformity, it was the last clue wir ' it ars. - Ile rebid on that assembly AS Only the and take possession of all the power of the kingdom. (Hear.) He he confessed he would like to hear the arguments by which Hon. to which on this question he was subect, for from his i • imigrour if set the gauger Mel,. Though the Bill for now came to another Member, the Representative of the City of Gentlemen wouhl support a proposition for bringing before their coming Into Parliament he had taken the same view of it t sapplailiali It brrithi Parliament Into collision with every Ca. London. That person took a more deep and theological view of Committees • person so high in office as the Lord Lieutenant of he now did ; and he must take leave to add, that the cha umiak ibeeiribeli mom distinguished member, Lord Fingal!, down the subject. He threw overboard all considerations of political pre. Ireland. Conceiving, therefore, that the Honourable Member for had come iinm a quarter front which he had least reason to cap to Ur tAsres men who paid Id. per month—though _passed in dominance , and at once roundly asserted that as th e Jews of that Lime r i c k h a d n o t s t ate d any grounds for hie Median , and that he it. Ile world now revert to the discussion of that question. the. iestand against the strongest feelings of the Catholics, day were the offering of those who crucified our Saviour, they had brought it forward more for the purpose of giving opinions had had frequent and fitter opportunities than the present for i therp eithaltted to it not only with good will, but with pleasure ; laboured under a curse, and were not fit to be naturalized in a upon the Catholic question than to obtain what he proposed, and Pressing hie opinions upon it—it was one to the discussion of wh {he - y apnea not to evade the law, and not merely obeyed it, but Christian State. just as those who now °pease the concessions to thinking too that even if the Honourable Member did suppose such he always came with pain : he had been from the commeneetne gave to is an enlarged construction, and it ceased to exist even as the Catholi , s argue, thetas those Catholics are the descendants of the a measure would be beneficial, that it would rather increase than and continued to he opposed to the admission of Roman Cathol a deliberate awnthly. By their conduct they showed themselves persona who kindled the fires of Smithfield, they ought not to be en- diminish any irritation, he would give a decided opposition to the to political power; but although he differed with some of his C deserving well of the house. They were bound alone to obey the trusted with political power. (Hear, hear.) In his opinion there production of those papers the Honourable Member required. leagues as to the propriety of granting thine claims, he could say lance of the refute—why then did they go farther ? by, was mine as much absurdity in the one argument as the Other. Sir J. NEWPORT could not treat so lightly the feelings of say, and he would appeal to the chief and most powerful of the beetle* they Wete full of hope—they were buoyed up (Hear.) • They had some wit and humour, too, in the proceedings six millions of people. It was essentially necessary that the b ri o,. vocates of those claims for the correctness of the assertion, that t with expectation ; they knew that an inquiry was now going on, upon the , new question . He would take the liberty to read • few of lature should be made acquainted whit the opinions of the highly difference did not in an y degree prevent him from acting with th which was calculated to elicit the truth ; they freely tendered them. them to the House, and perhaps they would throw a little livelinees gifted person who had filled foe so many years the office of Chief who entertained opposite opinions--nor did it tend. to withh 'mime as ilttnemes, for the purpose of unveiling the whole truth ; into a subject which had been hitherto dull. Ina Hebrew Journal, Magistrate of Iriland, and he could not repeat it too often, section front any Catholic the benefit of any existing law, or the full 1 Yhpy felt that if the information acquired were but acted on, the an it was called, published at that time, there appeared the follow- plished, with the assistance of the Catholic body, the difficult task far enjoyment of every right and fair proportion of the advents, ' reffsdie Association must cease to exist of itself, and that any ing paragraphs:—" :—" Received since Our kit, one mail from Jett'. of tranquillising that fearfully disturbed country. Ile (Sir John to which Its was at present entithd. (Hear, hear, from Mr. Plu Aron on their part was therefore unnecessary . Catholics were ex- saki'''. Last Friday twenty - one Jewish children were circum- Newport) did riot wish to go, as an Honourable Gentleman oppo. kett.) He would now pass to the consideration of the despatch arnined before the n'ommitteet not a single individual of that per. cited in the usual manner." Olean and a laugh.) Tim reports of site had observed,— fora copy of which his Hon. Friend (31r. Rice) had moved ;of i eloasim, who occupied a place in their deliberations, or guided their the risinee of Christians in bales are altogether without founds. . Per ignes . existence of which despatches, however, his lion. Fribod seen eeensals, who was not only examined by-their friends, but under- tion." (Hear, hear.) This was the manner cat which the people Suppositos eineri doloto. to have no other evidence than was contained in the record e west the operation of that most powerful engine for eliciting the were roused upon the subject of the naturalization of the Jews, and lie wished to preserve peace and tranquillity in Irelmd ; and he newspaper. 'Much reference had been made to what had happet tenth, cross-examination, by persons interested in confounding the if a clamour cculti be thins excited upon such a question, he thought thought it above all important that they should be in possession in another place—even what had passed in the Committee; anon - wheete.e. They had before them bk. O'Connell, to give an ac. that it might be conceded now, it was disgraceful only to the of the Noble elarquis's opinions upon the best means of effecting House was irregularly . introduced into the discussion. Even count of every transaction in his political life. They had before authors of it, and not to be taken in any case as evidence of the that object. He complained of the ringing of belle which had mode of putting questions by a Noble Friend of his (Lord Liv them too, Dr. Pnyle, to be questioned on every topic connected truth, and reason of objections to any national measure. But be attended the celebration of the late victory over the Catholics, an pool) wan introduced, and it was said that he should not have pi *hi the Catholic Church and its discipline in Ireland. The Ca- thought he could point out the cause of the clamour against act of folly which had done more towards pulling down the }ninon certain question to one of the witnesses before the Committee. if theties looked forward with strong anticipation of success. They the Jew Bill, and the clamour against Catholic Emancipation. lished Church than all the concessions they could ever make to the did no: intend fo accede to the passing of the question. It i found that their cause was gaining ground in the Commons House. At the same note Lord Chatham,, in the debates upon that Roman Catholics. Ile complained also of the conduct of that quite impossible fur aperson who was not present, and was therefi [hey found that in Ireland it was gaining ground. (Hear, hear.) Bill (the Jew Bill) o b serve d, t h a t h e w a s fully convinced reli- Right Rev. Prelate who had argued in another place upon a unacquainted with the course of an examination, to say what qu They felt too that, notwithstanding what might be said of yeti. gion had nothing to do with the nuestion, but that the old high speech delivered at the Catholic Board, without having made him. tion it was fitting should be put, and what should not. Lear dons to the contrary, that amongst the best-educated and higher church principles were beginniog to lay bold of the people. (Hear.) self acquainted with the rittuinstances attendant upon the delivery this subject, he would argue the question before the House on I classes io England, the cause of emancipation was gaining ground. So he said of the question of Catholic Emancipation. Religion of that speech, and with the fact that it was the only one that had Parliamentary grounds. Previously, however, he would say to Not an individual in Ireland connected with the Catholics—not a hard nothing to do with it, bitt the old high church love of aluDa. ever been twice noticed by the Catholic 'Body after its delivery, and his honour as a gentleman, that no personal consideration as to Peotextant who did not entertain a reasonable hope and,expectation poly and exclusion aas brought to bear against it, and the people by them twice distinctly /reprobated. If the Right Reverend Prelate situation, or to his opinions on the Catholic question actuated I , • that the Catholics would be placed at die close of [he Session in were made to believe that it was connected with religion, but those did not know that fact, he was wrong to argue upon a speech, until on the present occasion. There were two Bills before the Ho betel circumstances than at its commencement; nor were these who bad recourse 10 such tricks knew that religion had no more he was quite clear it had been acknowledged by the Catholic this Session, one for the suppression of the Catholic Associate - hopes at all diminished by' the opposition given by the opponents to do with the question than the regulation of weights and rues- Body • if he did know it, he was guilty, in his opinion, of a the other the Roman Catholic Relief Bill; whilst chimer of th of the measure to it in that House. They met it fairly on prin. sures, or the pendulum. In die Harley Papers there were letters very disingenuous artifice, in making use of it as are presentation Bills was before the House, there might be some ground he dole, still in a conciliatory tone, a, men entertaining conscientious upon the same Jew Bill, upon which the clamour raised at the time of the feeling of that Body towards the Protestant church. lowed for moving for these despatches. His lion. Fitted, due feeling, (Cheers.) This the Catholics observed; instead of exciting sea attributed to a motive of influencing the elections next year. The rejection of. the measure now assumed a more painful shape the propels of one of these measures through die I louse, had git *airy feelings, it made them regret that so much talent and sha- (Loud cries of " Hear hear.") plow much influence the idea of than it did on any former occasion, wrought up as the hopes and notice of a similar motion ; but en the day that motion i nee *ere opposed to them. (Hear, bear, hear.) Such a en approaching election had upon the decision of the Catholic wishes of Ireland were lately to the reception of the measure. to have conic on, a sufficient nuntber of Members did elketunstanee was likely to make the rejection less dangerous Q i i ) testion, he could not say . (Hearn Another letter tneationed a After all that had been said, it Was a grievous result to find that attend to nuke a House. lie did not renew that motion aft if it had been rejected ; but what has been the consequence ? liberal Bishop of Norwich, foe it seems there was one in those all was but delesion. Ile remembered the cry of 1780 and 1807, wards during their progress ; but now that another of these 13 A Bill for emancipating the Catholics had been that Session, for the days, and if he WAS half so good a man as the present as to the cry of' the danger the reception of this measure would be to was before the House, what was the ground alleged fur produci edondtitne, placed in the hands of the Lord Chancellor, and, can. Bishop : he was well entitled to the praise bestowed upon hint. the Chur c h. The q u e st i on was n o t one o f re li gion b u t o f mono . them P It was said that Lord Wellesley recommended cert ever circumstances, too,*Tor which there existed no precedent. It That Bishop had given his support to the Jew Bill, and on Ida poly, and the ground of the ascendancy of the Established Heti. measures, or that if he did not recommend them, he ought to was sent up supported by those who before opposed the Claims, re:urn to his diocese lie wet insulted by the populace ; the buys of gion was but a repetition and continuance of Clint same delusion censured. These despatches. supposing diem to exist, were g wig backed also by a greater mans of Protestant feeling than was Ipswich even called after him if be came to circumcise Chest, which had been invariably resorted to by the opponents of this celled for with a view of converting the House of Lords. So t ever, on any former occasion, called into action. The Bill then, and placards were exhibited, stating that the Bishop was to confirm measure. (ileac, hear.) the ascertaining whether Lord 11'ellesley deserved to be censor attended by all these favourable circumstances, was rejected by the the Christians one day, and the Jews the next. lie would now Mr.CURTEIS said belied often opposed further concession to the and a hope of converting the !louse of Lords, were the avowed t Odom of Lords. He did no: wish to comment on the House of leave the question of the clamour on the Jew Bill, hoping he Catholics, and he had every reason to be satisfied with his conduct. jests sought to be attained by the present motion. These were, Lord.; if he did snit would be improper, and he moo, of course, had convinced the House how little dependence was to be placed He had been often entrusted witb petitions by his constituents; he submitted, eery unsatisfactory grounds for acceding to the Ares be called to order if he stated that the House of Lords placed the upon such expressions of public opinion in matters connected with was glad to knnw teat his opinions on this subject corresponded motion. If these certain despatchn (he would rather call th Oorrisnons in • most disgraceful station, if he said that they chord. religion. If one of the objections to die granting of Catholic titian- with theirs, and he. felt dist he discharged his duty whilst he re- " uncertain") were produced relating to Orange ludms mei r Bleed Its yetseeedings as nonsense and trash in the. teginntng, and cipation was the indisposition to grant any political power to the presented due feelings and sentiments of those who sent him to gions animosities, would they not, he would ask, ten d to rake worse at the cloth' (Cries of •• Hear, hear.") He did not wish to leaders of the Catholic body, he would ask whether any political Parliament. the ashes of almost extinguished religious feud, and create fresh wee harsh terms; it was sufficient for inn to say that the two power which could be granted them, would be equal to that they bin. BROWNLEOW said, that his Hon. Friend (Mr. Rice), at ritstion one subj ect on which too much already prevailed ? Houses were at issue on a partizukr question, and that no less a at present enjoyed, and which the rejection of the BiU the other the commencement of his speech, observed that those who sup. what he hail sai d he (lid not mean to convey an impression that tagation than one which involved the peace aid tranquillity of night had continued to a gr e ater extent than ever. It was the ported the Roman Catholic Bill would act inconsistently if they Opinion. of Lord Wellesley on the Catholic Question were at Ireland. Were they then to say, we shall adopt the opinions of the grievances of the Catholic body which gave the power to Mr. did not support him in his present motion. He (Mr. Browalow) changed from what they appeared to be by his speech on a fort House of Lords ? Rothe' let them say, we shall pursue a con. O'Connell and 31e. Shell, and other leaders of that l>ody. Ile did would free himself from any imputation of inconsistency on that occasion in the House of Lords, and by his more recently recur dilatory course. The present was not an ordinary difference-- not mean to 'mink disrespectfully of those gentlemen ; they knew account by supporting it. ((leer, hear.) There were good grounds vote. Bet ire would oppose the present motion for these two t est like a dif f erence on the Silk Bill ; the questloct was not whether he respected and esteemed them ; but he did not wish to give them in his opinion tar acceding to it, in the propriety of having the most sons principally, that no Parliamentary grounds had been acs everwutildreele be made at Allanehnuor or f!nri,ntrs. (A leech.' The the power which they held at Present. The Power he wished to see extensive and the best information uoun the state of Ireland. Be. for producing such despatches. though they existed : and. secom donee then ought they u etrenger--none meet end tif the individual sent ovi turd arduous times--none Wellesley, who had beet eenntry, and therefore he iesta, both of their ogle Wellesley could express the House of Lord., of t jt may be said to him (11 ellesley, and therefore Ma would reply, that hi Weltealey, bat of the Lc had been now four years he must have made hint Stith it ; he therefore call 'deface of the 'Cog's R atked how do you know Catholic Question ? If they were, he should at , . Membest we sauna placeof druid On notice. 02billcs4 • am Vim whim • • Lora beam* rceel to aik ould be ordained by t nse great public mitigated tour* Male further observatic the reasons advanced else of sodded to any weight, the Pena' I &vs. It w Imes--that the, were not calved too much. There et bad grace from those who pa& e amount to ? Why, - smogs they could treat the ( they confide in them for gratt clams ? The Hon. Mamba you cvi you wont disturb the Is reftroug those whom ha re take such tat.gusge as praise, ,aciation, of which the Hon. 'Were the ('Connell and the Iproines of the late Lord Lot ...agricultural population wen With indignation at his cub ,logislating against their ini !.day you spat on me, another wanner, will the Catholics re . Ire (Mr. Rice) hoped the Ca ; • sere friend 4 for his earnest -serenely to two principles i— e:l circumstances, keep up body ; that they remain eat cause. (Cheers.) The sea tailor within their power so r eooperation. (Cheers.) Tit favour, let them outlet Oft ti 4a safety the harbour of thole Q Ireland—let all classes be tome that House could not le leis blab iteesbas. whose.] = . . „ ....... . ' Noble Lord in Joh ! illessell), that there . was ugly a s isms br which Catho licanapation could beebtatned„ re was by division of the °moment : a secession of that pan of his Ma. jetty's :Ministers who supported the roe from the .Councils of the King. Rat he (Lord L. • that named of . 01006,01 such being likely to be the result d a nature, the en! that would ensue from it would be is Emancips. tion itself ; end feeling thus he justified in apt wlthdrawing Itis support from his MejseljObiloptenunait on th-. present acestaffr • and therefore if the Ileitinjbauld come to s division he diva. however reluctantly, oppeseliffilesation. Tile CHANCELLOR of the EXCALQUEffinhsened, that if he thought the production of the flame retered Ise by the Hie. Member for Limerick would tend to the' object whi c h that lion. Gentleman had hi view, herg inis tffilmitedler e the Ex chequer) should not have the lees; olejeetie to ithdr being imme diately produced. The objesterhich dish Illen thinhoten stated he had In calling fur these parse teas time entree die dissatisfac , tion in Ireland, which might haree bees esetted b'y a recent decision in Parliament. The Hon. aehdesnan declared it to be his opinion that the producthin of the dowernents in question would have that effect ; but after the best camlideration which he (the Chancellor of the Exchequer) could give the subject, he confessed he did not see how that effect was to be produced by the production of the dom. molts, even supposing they . contained every sentiment which the Hon. Member for Limerick imagined them to do. It was natural to believe that in the correspondence whi c h th e G overnment had had with the Noble Alarquis at the head of the Irish Government, regarding the state of that unfortunate country.-- for unfortunate he could not help calling her (hear, hear, hear)-- it um natural to believe that in that were correspondence there was much matter, the publicity of which would he calculated to_prudaht quite an opposite effect to that anticipated by the Hon. Member, and upon that ground alone he should oppose their production. be was bound, in justice to his Hon. Friend, to say that, upon a q ues t tion of so much interest and importance, he had stated his case and opened his question in a manner calculated to produce the very effect he so much desired, and that the production of the papers would only increase that agitation, and produce that result whi c h his Hon'. Friend was most anxious to avoid. With regard to the discussion on the main question, he did not, at the periods of its debates, feel himself called upon to trouble the House with any remarks, because he thought it quite unnecessary to do so. The question did not requite any new advocacy—or rather, it bad a better advocacy than those could give it who had on forma occasions supported the question, for it had the advocacy of nubby who had hitherto opposed it. But although he had not addressed the House, yet be did sot show in a doubtful manner what were his sentimenta on the question. Not only had he made them apparent by the rot a which he gave on the principal question, but by those lie had aloe given on the tso other accompanying me:murex. He gave those votes certainly with great reluctance, and not without considerable doubt and hesitation; but he gave those votes, nevertheless, because he believed by doing so lie should be rendering the main and im portant question a greater degree of support than he otherwiseshouM do. A Noble Lord (Lord John Russell) had said, that although he could not conceive by what reasoning it was that those of his Mates. ty's Ministers who supported this measure could reconcile it to their minds to follow the course they did with regard to it, yet he would do them the justice to say that he believed they acted in the Iran. net they did from a conscientious sense astute. In the forme.' Session, he (the Chancellor of the Exchequers had expressed his letedosents with regard to the situation of the Gove rn ment as to thi s rtlar question ; and those sentiments be still retained. But . now say, that if lie thought by resigning his situation be should_ be furthering the cause of Catholic emancipation, Ile would do so immediately. (Hear, hear.) Ile did not say thi s f or the purpose of effect. He made the declaration of this sentiment to relieve his own conscience. (Hear, hear.) But as he did nut see that such a step on his part would have this effect, he could not conceive that he was bound to resign his situation, especially when it appeared that the country was satisfied with the present Government, and that its interests would not be promoted if that Government were to be broken up. With respect to the fate of the measure in the other House, he far one could not see, notwithstanding the result, that there was any reason for the friends of Catholic Emancipation to despair. lie found, in the first place, that most remarkable circumstan ce, namely, that among the Representatives of Ireland there was a very large increase of /tim bers who considered that the carrying of this measure, so far from being dangerous to Ireland, was essential to its continuance as • pant of thus empire. He found also that there were many who h this country had hitherto been adverse to the question, were now its supporters; and although it was true that in the other House of Parliament there was a very different opinion entertained them what there was in this, yet even there he observed some Nib ble Lords bad felt it their duty to me in favour of the men. sure, which in former Sessions they had strenuously opposed. It did not therefore appear to him that the failure of it this Ses. sion rendered the question so hopeless as it might be the interest of some persons to represent it, or as many of its friends sere too in. dined despondingly to consider it. As the motion before the House had been sufficiently MEC by his Right Ilonourable Friend (the Secretary for the Hume Department,) he should not enter into his reasons for opposing it more than he had already done ; but be could not avoid stating what he had to the House, because be certainly felt anxious to vindicate himself and those with shorn he acted who were favourable to the Catholic Question, from the insinuation, that the conduct which they conceived themselves justified in pursuing resulted from one inclination—to remain in office. Lord GRAVES noticed certain remarks which had fallen from as Hon . Gentleman (COl. it - . ... . .. Bagwell we believe) in reference to the speech of a Noble Marquis, and he spoke in vindication of that Noble and Gallant Officet's conduct on the recent debate in the other House of Parliament. The Noble Marquis never spoke of turning his sword against the Irish ; lie made use of a technical ex pression (a laugh), and he meant it in a civil point of view. ()loch laughter.) He (Lord Graves) thought himself bound to vindicate the conduct of the Noble Marquis, and to resist the insinuation that bad been made against his character. Colonel BAGWELL (as we understood) explained. lie. BROUGHAM and Mr. GALWAY (we believe) rose at the same instant. Mr. Brougham being loudly called for, he ob served, that if the House had not made the call, he certainly should have given way to the Honourable Gentleman. He was afraid he was about to do what was very contrary to the fashion of the night l for he intended to enter a little into the subject matter or the motion now before the House. The Right Honourable Gentleman (Mr. Peel) had offered various arguments against the documents being granted. In the first place he said, why should they go back an far? it was a vague motion. If that was the sincereobjection of the Right Hon. Gentleman to the measure, he (Mr. Brougham) was sure that he could tell bow to remedy the defect; but it the Right lion. Sectetsry would do it, be (Mr. Brougham), with the permission of his Hon. Friend (Mr. S. Rite), would, by the simple introduction of the words, " within the last 24 or 12 months." The next objection was that the pa pen were unnecessary, and that it was inexpedient to produce them, as their production might work harm to the country. This objec tion might be answered by inserting into the motion the words —" in so far as the same can be produced, without de Tiniest to the public interest. Then came an objection which was of a very strange and singular description. The Right Honourabill Gentleman asked—" How do you know that there is such a paper in existence ?" Why, if he (Mr. Brougham) did not • know it before, he knew it now, because if there had not been any such pa pet the Right Hon. Gentleman would have said so. But as to the argument that there was no necessi.y for the production of the papers, there he and the Right Hon. Secretary were quite at issue. It had been said that the noble and excellent individual at the head of the government of Ireland had advised certain coercive measure' to be adopted towards that country. Now what he (Mr. B.) wished to know was, how this advice was given, in what way that noble perses had qualified it, and what were the facts which he assigned for suet measures ? These were important particulars to be ascertained; for such a recommendation, it was fair to presume. was attended with certain quatifications. How had this Session berm ? Had the House forgot it was recommended by the Comm sad the; nothing else ha d been done except following that reessomeodation, that they should adopt some measure respectiag the Catholic Asso ciation. And how had the steps which were taken in pursuance of that recommendation justified ? It was grounded on the ex perience and observation of the Noble Lord at the head of the Irish Government, and the result of that observation and experience alone was. that a new arm of power bad been given to the Govern tnent of that country. If any man ever had reason to complain, it was that great and Noble Lord who now governed Ireland. Under his sway that country might have been great and happy but lie was disabled from rendering it so by one man pulling one way, and another another. if this country stood compromised in its conduct, how stood that venerable nobleman, the Vicegerent of Ireland? That Noble Lord had recommended coercioi, but it was coupled, es he (Mr. B.) understood, with advice for conciliation. The Govern ment had given coercion because the Lord Lieutenant had recom mend it; but they had withheld conciliation. (Hear.) Was it not fair :hen that his - lion. Friend (Mr. S. Rice) should ask, in justice to the Noble Marquis, for the correspondence, to see whether that Noblemen had recommended and advised such a measure as was neither harsh nor ungracious in its tendency ? But it was deoi•4 because it would be perceived, that his Majesty's Government had make a false estimate of what the times required, and had only auk °bloke of that which went to coerce ; but had rejected by the 1•11111 i of the other House of Parliament that which would bare eseeiliated. He had heard that this Catholic question had been us. happily opposed by certain persons whose names it was contrary to the rules of the House to mention. He had no right to break in upon that etiquette (fur it was nothing else), which prevented the Men.. ben of this House to allude to any thing that had occurred else where, although the fact was well known, that there was not a arlour or a commas smoking-room in all England, Wales, and reland, where the people might not safely, and without hearing I ally thing about a breach of privilege, discuss any one speech of any one Noble Peer, in any we night, on any one question. and out hear any thfisg more after it than before. But he had heard that a speecii was made by a very high personage nese the throne, which had been circulated throughout Ireland in fine printed cha racters, by Mr. Benbow, he believed, who was the greatest libeller is the three kingdoms. This person had printed and circulated a speech that never was, nor ever could bespoken by that royal person age. lie dare say the Attorney G eneral had already filed a aion inlonnation against this Benbow, because any thing more sandal • ous—more outrageous to that Illustrious person, could not be made ' than to make him say that he was determined he would not, nem he came to the throne, govern, according to the Constitution —but that scandalous, false, and calumnious libel made the Boke of York say that whicb King James 11. never dreamt of, mat least never whispered in favour of the Catholics; that he intended to govern the Protestants in a spirit of opposition to the Catholics. vrkb Now 40 the expression of the Marquis of Anglesey, h (Ni. 8.1 wwilekved that it was very harmless. The Noble Marlin Inge rale% „Pat SI inexpert at tanking speeches as be (31r . which Catholic; Col. tiz yI Omar. • *dr lb " r. 1% .s=- *IN imissue. •eeloasisa 14 suck ea •M nit it mirage of •+Mrad te .kmo beim - _ • . . Iplos of Irel ' 'Wogs would s what it had Adz millions when that ct ilbe of ju Mimosa iry dame Aboilaritolic trim bon but. a *Ora great a ;dad no. n =Olt iog b u . skim a. Sot (goblet existe Some ()Mier irricetted hit -solotod to be Oka Chancel Brougi Wee Right ow, from soniliang it. vim the c Lupo., the t Alen batwing ridge the °pi es this ques tun. bad &angel paw. and theme chola; 'question W a s! lie sent lim fr( atveincute o meting, azu Measurable dell was not I. but opinion. • The King, * cipation ; be SIM 11111131, in se Is respec h mild not stricken in „which his fal present King says tinclent scruples. ( I support it. terms times, areee.: The perhaps, rem Mr. Secret; Learned Oen by him a nature. (lie ply, and a, u It was Pali.r Mr. BKOI line of ''''''' that no SCTU pl would prove Ymanotpatiot Rohm of Pi was different stemptlve. bu the Heir Pres this part of t I nion in the C 7 that the worst liver. The was the Itight potlant quest Then there a, that when one the Irish Cat '. Xection ; are &user, stan, most useful I compromise s thought woul them, sooner portant ?new victuals emit( stand would it *dr duty 'bey felt it r Cbassge the a Erasing co would awn cor Awe the a *Sold tell th, hsg such a sta try would TO member of th he need not t. ,the support viduals Dlembers of question had could be form the AVest of I bridge) and a Home Depart so short a ti excluded fret made a %mild ham quitting huelearir.g t kr a short tin' Mt re the triu kmour on the 'be reasons at ettsminton whi that the preset saved. Whe • despair for 4re mr_Yen her recital steadily, sold set dept lOW teeeld vet Mr. It. M, pinnent hotio , inewid injure Illissioni fay! agolmt mg the lilimed for a SD Adds wit waid io; indu Mr. PLUN j oat down, to tlwr Borland sent motion. llactber for 1. advert's_ hr not ilia Catholic q •At la saw plac4 *eat i and a awl Was so Inimentoi the au ann. and le Ada °byte. 'Wham dip a. • elei question m at ia ßßOU LUN aseemiss P Friar Pleitseta ss i: yeeelp. BMW ‘llO On OW great E . nal Pr" I II ~ -~