The National Register. — London, England, 1819-05-09 00:00:00

LOCIIERtf SYSTENI. We Lave Iteird, anti is *some degree hove envat . ..l in the conflict of opiosioia which dais oitbjeci LAw 1.11 . 4. I.llt molting Ito% tronstiOred vslitt . O. ill Ihr Irn•i ele2t re. hi% ohnitra Ilse conclusions to vehieh ver verse Int. XinatW led. Ou the contr.try, wr Intwl found slims.• of the Lrst is‘lorint d sultileisms to lir its collie cotosidrawe wills skor 11W 11. . . The Cuiroplaid. has been prai.e.i " by the ha. of %%hull." a is wid. '• a rape( pUmiii.lti of Ile• hands ',rem. to he set-weir —sem., not is arena - ed. We alFi W. With- Wit fear ut cuutraisictioty that au merit rt►rrl is or rail b. er tired. B. ILI. wait is Cll.ll rte,..ed and confined. stud its I toper mot tier motion thereby iujnre 1, hot the flagesit may nt vet theict.s be en tendeJ the Ley. in Lb? tutp.t as d po.itinnv• To the ntAster rho reromalendr it, it in duubilr.e 4 very pin . . tif.ible piece of 4114 l lain( iy, hid to the arhoiar, it taisuist by a 'rat piall4/6114C plas el', 11 14 41 11441 wile•.. 11411 mito.l erJOINtbIY A lei r anti careful voi.itiosi of the hand is a.•uretly not to be given by 1444 . 414 the 1411%1 isa lift Antek.. Logiet's agrertion ig. ili.tt "Li' pupils rfllrell d em the flirt i .I.liments of to It. most (Ist& ult aed :Ostrom. combinations." It is:Certainly nether santertu mite f.r a man r.ifeaeina to teach the most difficult end ahstrn-e pin ta of the science of hartnotry. lint Ise himself AlloosJd hose chew's hi. practical in more, or at le.ist hi* neglect, of ItelflV Of the ari4 and simplest rules of har monic prozression The sio/dtioris of these rules 1.1 Crt . (ettfrirturiately for this profound theorist) contained is the Irimoris for the piano-bate whirl; he c posed and published. ( Seer Lessons id, !fah, and 3 ;d of toli , or's Se vat!). and they certainly form a most leLieidors ilda•ti a- Cum of the depth, the aremaev and Ilse wslite of his lansicol kna.cledtr, These blun ders, of which the nano ' t)r., in mosteal composition scissild hose been uslismed, Ifft4t . lsudlt puhUt•d out 1., the professor 0 e sans tams'. 41 grottJetuest is London. mid were curl ected in kliffsllllll . ll I c•lition• at his soil. These are Dow, therefore, to be foetid only in the cdiehmes pri.erpm. Hut admitting for a single souinent the romperessey of Mr. Loki. r, Atom it therefose f illow that all his disciples ale competent to instruct diem pupils iu "the MUM •bsl ruar , Collll4lll4lilltilt of liar ((((( ny t" C3ll a owl teach Ilwt %WI) he himself slues not nude' stand; orate we vi suppose NM it LOtglefi.lll tearher e4ll to " D little tit" lie •ble to aeluire au t,uparl t event of sitosje.ll bouwird%e arLicb Melt 411 lie 11 . 1X!Ieft 1.114 . 111 iIAW . spent :hem liter to arriving at? Absurdity mill impossibility ate 1.14.1.1.cL1 npou the sexy foe, of such is sum; lw*- •eer, rainy our admission in Mr. Lociel's forum ati.l for• tiler, and let its emsrple to all the toasters of 11i4 arltuul the. 'pusscs•tou of 1110 prolutinttest musical kilo% led„;e. Can t!us knowledge—is it a I:hist the avulse of peoth.lity, 'that it c..in be impel ted to hourclitt4-schuul misses of town .3 to 12 years They may be made, patrut like, to answer questions, and eunoult to memory, as elttily as their petite roldt, the number of slats and sharps in the .c smelliest Le's; they may obtain .11 soperficial stilettos ing asf the seirtire of harmony. just enough to enable them to prate shout dominatits.llloll.slontitinnts,inversiuns, ',aspen .l,,ns, limier, and so on. Let .bsynrol this they ate uo mole able to learn Mau Mr..Logtee is aide to leach. We %erre di first rails prised, In writing roneerning 'AI I*. 1.01:11 r, by %that combisiation of ideas or lIASOCIAIiOII4, the prof( emus of Laputa shatild have pre4:lllrd them eel v.:3 to Ilia •tippos ices. Our recollection of lbeir WA. vied and siiiimi:tr labonts WAS not sufficiently visid to arroisitt foi it. Bat on naming to Ali. Gmlisei's nese' ip• Lou;1 of that far lamed seat of ad, tier, the prototype Or our modern professor appeared, and doubtless sisagested to his panegyrist the mention of Lat.inta. . 1 This tholes nor,' as", Gill'atee, •' an in a very large MOM, with torts points Olises slug use to look earnestly at of tune, lie said, perhaps I might tawnier in are employed in a project fur improving sprees/Wive knollited,re by pi artiest aud mechanical operations. 11.11 the %%mid wool ti soon be vausiiieed of its at•Clialcest, for a noire tAdttetl thought lies er entered any other brad. -Vt t y one ktor sr how labour ions ttie usual method is of atininilig to science, whereas by his contrivance. iise whirl peron, at a reasonable charge, nirly %lite books is Philosophy, Poetry, Mathematics, sic. without nay assistance from getibis." Here, rertailits„ we hose Air. Logirr, alaiost Lr proptia itc•contt. Ft's!, the large theta the pupils around tiim," (and %shy out a) a, well as IV) then " the franc." Besides, the objects of the two professors tire au very similar—Mr. Lenier (see Lis Companicat to the rititaplast) tell% iis that he has disco. -rod ••• A tatillOti of m.siating the icumer to oreoissioe.lt -the end ,:sroposed by thivaiia of arewhanhat cuntricauce, M atta. s to titiatteatipted." His rival of Laspista 0 as " eityluyed 4,1 a prujert fur improvititt speculative know leales• by pi ac rurarasicrit °proteins." Again—by this pa <vet '• Its; most iguotaut person ni) suite !looks in l'asslaavo laAy, Port•v. Mathemartic•„" and Mr. Donaldson. it 1$441(1 . 0610 at Glasgow, affirms that " pupils of fe'vezer: capacity cud ordinary lisdarstry fumy feel themselves e•-pituie of 0511511411144 Cartelli, Handel, Haydn, Moz art, and mri.." N vr, after this, see hope nu 011 e, and espe• < Miay ru Lugar/mu. will treat Air. G•t!tive aecousit as a ,i•kt, Itai t guttl it as the limiest usual platir it '<satin of a Ur fact. lila to quit the profeuter of birth,. and descend to v!ileo and Neu tun. What paas,ible au.slogy cats be traced 1t...tr./reit the discoveries of these talstlawuptiess, and that 04 . 'Air. '<ogler—Malt sect et ha< lie unveiled in the seicatee of n. ; what ,I incipla• los lie dweuvered ? Tim utmost t. at lie pretends 10 14 a 114 w method of teaching. But et ere rat:vatting Alr. Lower to a level W7ll NeN theist would still 'militin a slip, dilierettee between their syn. la-Its—tire our being tlenunisto ably rival. and the other as r i e niainstta'aly scrim; We insert the lever or an Amateur, in fnvonr of this heranve we wish Mr. I..ogier *aid Isis pontoon. to I.l<r fsi:l and fair play. Unr knowledge of the sub ject of music will be arpreciated our reader., Levi it would have heels nutter inure to the purpose. if st,e Amateur (as he calls himself ) had lt-sleben to %1114.4 t helms asserted, boils so reaps et of our •• gad Alt. Lo4lei's La.owledie of autism. IT- on.l N.....(a< r Ore yea y natal/5.4"5t at our apl , l ) in. 10 the 1.114 la. 44 . 11.4.4414. no ibut Dr. THE NATIONAL REGISTER. tauter' stud Dr. Woolens A. Crtl their 'hotel y 'loony i nsu lird wi t copol to be to .61.41; hie we did loose thew rad M.. Laver" toe .I‘7•—•%r poured Ithe lu be ow.. We .4411 out lettoe the unprejwiierd 1111.1 di.h.tcrsetrillli lites.oth letirr. it is Hu ott‘arl—it dnr,. sleet iistru.l to trill to a isioglr itojevtiou %loch we 1.-1 s it nor dilly so its.ske to the sy.tcui. *r ere out convinced of it...upcsior edicary ; it may hove obtained (*IAN& we musts it.. ) • 11. r applobiti ,, li toti loatromigr of the first nnblhtY rod gentry alt helmet." We hare the best re.- cows for thulkstig that in Dulslio, its well at es Liverpool, it is slow in • rapid deviator, aud Ilist we .hall court tinsel° record its peiveglble lool•*rellent. Li 1u by 1'1.11(610w to .sr the Jim it eaters which are Toasts es the mippursers id' Mr. loutier. Ynay who air D... Esurs. mad Ms. Wit kiss. god Ali. Wigley, and the suaiirily of thesis Loudest peril:onus e Otis se-..lets will nol tail to uti.er.r thevuire• 'docent) will' which the point 'lnputs• bete rest abd Mr. Lover is 4.0..5.e...1 14..1 setitlvieso. He lakes fur grauted ihrunehout the inaniir•l octal decided %uperiorily at 54,0:5, god l'ed•ons 151)011 the. acudtimptiou as if as *err act llipUled o' igionative and prep slice-" will out allow at to ter itsis quite so ilea ly and having tom slslyd p fully ar.r legions for the opl ne gave. we shall Way, Ms. Logieu end sydriss lu the stow Ind Seise lest ut er.peruruce. We hair tau rod in viva but Div adrauveterist of a science to which we are ktruogly attached, aud it tt cau br wade lu appear that this beaence EAU oe louse tol.y, IY. wet etreelll.illy Igui4l/l by its. Iv.* se .taus, we 10111181 in to hear true elle gigure to Mr. Lower. TO THE EDITOR. leave %ern tour oh . • lions 0* Mr. Locier's ',potent, and ain >slrptisrd al the 4Cr.niuny which Imo Lades them. 4. it 'fin.' dele.it the put pnon it nos memo Iu .11. 61 11. If • 1 4 , 11 a 1111; 111 I,li proklig 3 nu hove but kill. knuasledge of ninety. I o:u•r, at leatd. 11.u.l that }on boot liven Al 3. 011111,10 4, the cello, oi yoecjemlice., poisons ; I ',bawds t it ploper, 168068A1' the mention' of )11111 J 0 ,11044 ,1 10 Mal e 5.111115 .or 41(.51144.1x I rhstirr to Nle. Logirr, nisei h.. Sydena of Mt... al lindrieetion. for i aon perids/drd pfn •will ogler milli mie that Utility r• peenlioi tilts are not gosh. iiinverial," winch lead meta. lhirargh Igisosanre ur preja• titer, In soi•typresent liar 1111.WPI or lite voice 'Airier of iluolo alas are rug sled in Siluelifyiug the great wet k of ettoe.tt son. In Ibr year llfli, Mr. Login - , *home talents, no a cony power and perbis wen, *err well ►uuuu and Inglil% apple rioted by the tin.' ruft esional vh.teifietel l t in the I:ingnotn, coanneiteedi leaching in 1)51 the thew') and it. other ut Music on anew nod . t simple plan !ban that int whisis they had pert imoiy been laugh', and he organ his upro+- lioas at WI unly.tarce of Ju.lt Ilse elnithet. of his unit ttie4ado. In a few months afterwards. he gate a public exami nation ol bis pupils, at %Inch arse pre:seat bison! of 114 twat musicians, and many of the first characters cat that lime le-idestt its the capital of Ileland The ifillfrove melds of Mr. Lamer %sere roused,' ell so great and obvious by the pee-mi. ;stearin, as immediately to prorate for his plan of tuition the •pilfllll4ll.lll il.u11 , •11 , 111gC of lilt: first notsile , y and a..itity cal that ;met of the [foiled It hied A a shoat, bait by no Hit - 1111s lukruauu , uppusition Ou the part of the pissfeasion its Dauirif, mime the most el special hie teacher. sit that city. acid *tier pat ts of be hind, adopted Al.. Lusties'a syatem ; and eta reputation Laving leached ISt nano, Pears/el veil *1 the pro. feivaiosi atellosey vertu 10 1)1111111. 41111 11111.11 pal hi• method of mats nettiou, lot the piiii.e.se ofinteusliseing it in the lostism of their pupils. It sa pretty geuelallv knotsal, t..at Ihr gloater pail. if not oil , of these gentlemen acre ha full employ mem as tracheas at the lime Mr. Logiet's system was made poitslie ; Mat they taari , l:ed scarf rat I abed moles ; weer abscut many a tcl.a nom their tsars) busies paid usia ifflooat lu jilt. Logier for ials.sfiettog teem, aim Mete pet:saps taut it& tier in talent or iisteglity to thuve tvl.o ily•pist 1641 gentleaamu am{ Ms els trim The sneers* and faun , of the new method of tuition, at length named lilt, 1.1 riul - c.m.isi ill the capital, and Mr. Wel.he. a gentleman as 'smell respected fur the paadrlsce *llll rautiula %lurk had prey 1111 l sly eliaraeteriaed his cosidnet, as lee was vainest for his profeasiumel re solved to Dohlio. for Me pin pow cat' ;oersatiall) risiirisig into tile Minns miss this news system had tu pun lot 1 1 4 1 / 1 1 1 14 11 1 . Tlit ac- n il of Cain joisrucy nate, that after it sr at mid ilive•lii1411011 01 * its merits, Alt. Welt be adopted it, awl opals lilt tetuso to Lutiouit, announced his intention of optima; aes A ;Athol for leaching tail the Logesinit plan. The grit lanes) Who taught upon the old plan were 110 W selillU.ly A 141111141 al she-David you, Ili tor nil is'aira /k, laud bei/.111, naturally ellungit, to animist to slop tier pi-o gees' cat itinovation, hate '• their milt was in elauget." A comainati ~,,, powerful in punit of Hainhees, iuelading souse 111.11Vii111 341 cfnifesmmtly men of talent, was fuelled I. stem the central cat upiuiuu by the authority of their unmet, Several exontinatition of Mows. Loßier and ‘Velibe's riicitc, to articii lior in. wnel s or Ile Society, rod other iirtift.viion el men Weit lb Vii d, axle micro in London. :florae wore rolluteeil by some Alt sriiii•iiintr iu the sicovapees and pamphlets fur and adaiii•t Ilia neva cy.teni. 'l6l. most important fact is, that all this bickering had the cirri of making the Logeriapi plait Ileum kinswii in a ' f g w• steels than the utmost egotist of its fi Undo caul( base accompli.lied in 3 cars. Mr. Logier's plan bat already been adopted by s eor the moat reaper table teachers in most tit the !principal town. ill Britain. It 14 patroiti , ed by 1.0/1W u( lita• first character. Coe rack and talents iu the kingdom. The Logerian Academics ale, in Cart, al 1144 monint fully amt tided, iu spite of the misrepresentations and falsthunds V• 111111 Wive lii every possible Slid' , r ',ten circulated to its prejudice. Some of the pupils have • been tan :lot on nails plans—their !misfits have had anyie °ppm tuenties, and are quite capable of judicial; J bur totalitarians e merits. ilany of the minuets and Imam goal J 1,10% of the young lames taught at perstsit ma the ian pl in, base brew the pupil. of Unstick, Cledienti, Crimes., owl other eminent tineacians, Rbu have appeared in ILagiaad bur the last half century the public will, 'tress, 1701 uo diS i eloled to Wink it a plobault ciftwa- MAY D. ',lmre that prelim)* an trualified. and baring I.nrit powerful motives fur making a nittsity. Na alt he b i w yy b y quackery" aud tb*Mril." ' t he Is mil its, that flume di v• pvi%ons. err to.. well issf..infrd on the .„1,j.,.. and 111.10 highly gitte.l ant. P.lne.sti..n and intrilert, not 10 d r t e et the •' ignorntire" an.; dr.pi.r the `• impudence.• WWl+ could bate ilirtate.l smelt an attack. I ihne purposely ascended saying any thing with regard to the tontrarative sit. or' She old and new methods of inindeal inition, and bare confined myself to the bi.in f y ~f this new specks or ()mirk. ." But with ...geed In the minty sit s a%aieiti, *heir ail• not a f1•%6 illhairt•St4- 1611161. of it,. has lug Masud) ptiolueed a beimitile change io the „tons of it. upponeog. I the iritrsilartion of slates, the teaching in ela..es, nod the g.ei. ter an•iety they have re really idiewii to rumbinr line Herm y with the pcietire , ore pretty deri•ive proof% that this slew .y.tetti will not pros e oarless to the rising gesso Mims ; besides, I A m %.111 that those who heath stectieding to it have no olikciion whatever to pot the que•ii 0000 to its impelio.its over the () id idsn,l o H.r hot uf ear/468km by a rOlapiledthl. I send yon the name. of those prore.sots Si .0 at ptesert teach Lower's system, polity* this dos morn, may have some &et ita inducing Miters in then lot ore Isteisinatiolo on Ibis subject, to MAIM iIIOIIIIIIVPII le !IMO Letter (plaint. d with facts, before they an derided', estuleinn plan of instruction. Ur any attritv at imp, veniew, I am, Sit, )0111., .tie. AN AblAgEl.3l. . 0 ,, AN Amateur can hardly suppose we Cali lied roam fur hit 6.1 uf Poutessors.— ED. LAW INTELLIGENCE. SATURDAT, May I. NIAS T. ADAM SON AND Orfila& This was an action tried before Mr. Justice Park. at Clielins foid, when a verdict was entered for the plaintiff for SIT/. Mr. Nolan now applied for a new trial, on the grounds of a mis-direction of the J udge in point aim/. The plaintiff was an uncertificated bank: ups t the &lonian's wee. an auctioneer and his assistants. The action was .or a trespass committed by them in entering and seizing some furniture on the plaintiff's premises. it was &Lied at the trial, that, previous to his banks uptey. the plaintiff hail soli his house to his brother, who, however. subse- Tient to that event taking pl a ce. a ga i n admit ted him into pus session, and the assignees agreed to let him have his furniture for tont this suns was accordingly paid by a Mr. Collinson. T.re assignees. however, having afterwards occasion to sinpect town thing inipmper, directed the ilekw•ants to enter and shstrain for rent *hey did enter, and took possession;• but the plaintiff, by stratagem got them out. After e.-.rtti they rand, a re-entry by force. aad this was the trespass complained of. It appeared that the furniture was worth 3471.„ a. Is sold for that sum now. Although Mr. Collinson, who paid the 1001. for the harken, might pethapa have maintained an action, the learned counsel submitted Neu had no interest in the property: but even allow ing he had, another and very important question arose upon this transaction, t'ait was. bow tar an uncertificated bankrupt could maintain an action against his assiooes, alai were the rod de feaulants in this action. Toe Court /owned a rule to show cause. WIDNTIDAT. MAT 5. TIII EARL OF DARWLET This nine mug Mr. Blieh approlret t,•.mt • i n COI" . queilee of the °War made by 11114 LOIAIOIIiI.II, use &- article . . exhibited agaist.t hum. Mr. Wwrrett. In. cotiorei, said, that he held ice hie hand an affidavit whirls hod been with • view to induct their Lin Irm.eu the lul buil. It sav the afiLievit of Mr. aid it tt 1 forth iluit mince he was in eititoily, under the weir:nit of Lord Elienho lough, upon riuUlar art .ries exhibited by the noble Earl, his 10,lieur had hero 1111101 dilllllll4lloll. The wbnst .4 his Properly now ronaistcd oldie soon or CDol.in e,vill; of the ►nne 0 . 11,0031. which hr cap.red to receive from the judg ment et the Court of Clidneety in lit - loud, but it hieb Judgment lied not been !et inistintiour ed; and ut lit tam of 4.001 , 1. der to ltim as ueurtyee.c of rrtt.iu lit opts !yr in that vonsitel. Ile itidrbisd b. brut rill tutu; ;And under first. cii vsilliquglt•t u.i• COt in a eitifition to find %trinity tin bar emu wlimb Olen . Lord • *hips had been piramani In •wind, naisitly , 6,0051. fur hien re le, And two mercies iu $.OOOl. coda. 4earlett, on the Mime suit.. bald, that t h e herlth of Mr. Blies had ante, ell rmtnid,table injos) anio n ; hu lag ingot ihil iiiiii ill. t , .ruutr since that tune 114(1 been le. Mired, end a' was ersary that he should either depo.•tt mom.) in the hands cif his bad. air give them iii.e:reption tido secui ity, ha hoped that the Cuurt would lint insist titian such trims as must render his isuprisoutueht perpe• lust. Mr. Gurney, as connael for the Earl of Darnley, said, he load a very ainpleasaut duty to both as it re gat Jed Iris wink florid and himself. But the conduct of Mr. !Biala hail been such, that the Court,he apprehended, would feel Ilirsiororrs bound 10 lomat upon ample set u. lily 44 111 P loitz4PfirditUfl of the peace. It no. a 5141 ia.- portaut comidirtai ion fur their blidial pa, that Mr. at the time when he was tinder recognizance its keeping the peace, had committed sugar of these ..ggraeating aria which ttie noble Lord had 'nue, ralithiied against him. alr. Moak had followed the Loll of D .ruby to Italy, to France, and to England; sad at present, Ilia Lorib.hip could never leave his humor without &thug Mr. Mich at his licels. G was evident, therefore, that the lite of hits Lordship could nut be sate, unless this gentleman were in rosiliiminesit, or that he were readmitted from making any attack u such penalties as he *wild uut choose to If he could wit find hail %about depwittog moue, in their or giving Owns such security as Ilia counsel had meolittnedi the emit would i 0000 uediately understand the Impiemion which his condnet hail made on these oho Vert best acquainted with him. Thee Lord ChicfJustier, after having consulted his bro thers, said, that as this aresteman ass now bylisre the Court, and as no sureties weir offered, and it appearing that tile security given hrfame Lord Ellenhorungli NUS net gliafieltlll to restrain him from a Wrack of the peeve, the Quilt could nut discharge theis duty to the applieant and to the public within't committing hint. It 111.1.eamd 14141 11116 grntlrttsan Nalo 11111 pitvical to say what secuiity Ite wild give tut boom if, out Mir ellet hr i mild hod fee Lis g rot beliabioisi. .he Court did nut a 1•15 that he should he teamed to hock tel AS moat plodine a per petual istoprieuilibent; hut, at the Mime uute, llicy were tietind to take care that he was placed stu k r such .control as should preclude kia frogs exercising any Tioleare 150