Star. — London, England, 1803-05-05 00:00:00

t'ARLiA friEN TAR r PRuCE EDI4vGS. HOUSE OF LORDS, WEDNESDAY. MAY 4. I ord lit.reford and tiny ai:lScle took :he oa•ht and their feat=• Or• tic iecond of the Edinburgh Rntd Bill, a Peti tion av,i , pr,fcrited againa it front feveral prrfons in the neigh buurhoo,l of th.it place. The Bin race of the Town of Nottingham was br.)ii,;h , op from the Conunoris by Mr. Hawkins Browne, and read a fire tin.e. MARKI-lAM'c DIVORCE BILL• The Hotifi: having refulved Well into a Committee on this Lord Ave ICLAND core, purruant to the notice he had given nu a lornier day, to oppofe that dank in it by which Mrs. Markli.,ni was allowed to enjoy all the property the polTeffed beitire her in.irriage. If that alae meant any thing at all, it went to do a th.ii;z w hich bad never before obtained the fanc tion of Parhain.nt, and would eltablith a ninit dangerous pre cedent. It ini,;h: bean at of great liberality on the part of ,Mr. Markham, to content to give up fo much prop,:rty 1 but it was pot tit :ha; the Houle fliould encourage a thing that migt-t prove dangerous to the public morals. He believed that a doubt could net remain in the breaft of any man, but that the cafe of fairithani was totally free front colnulion if, however, the oueltion had been deuhtful, the ad:Milton of fuch a clank as this mull state a %reit gro?ndtd fulpicion, that collufion had exi:ied. &fides, it was not prop r that a wontan, who bad offended in the manner the had, lhould be placed in the fame lit nation with regard to property, as when the had concluded Lerf,lf in a virtuous manner. While be was fpraking on this iihjeta he mull oblerve, with a contiderable degree of fatisfae tion, that the great attention paid of late years by that Houle to cafes of this hind, bad gone a great way to improve the pub hc morals; and that f..tisfadlion mull be (till greater, when the morals of this country were compared to thole of France.— During the lift year, the number of divorces in Paris alone amount( d to no !els than one thoufand ; and in our whole Unit ed Kingdom, there was only ON( in the courfe of one year. His L a rdthip ;:;en concluded with moving the rejection of the chore. Lord ALVA NI. rs could not confent to the rejedtion of the chute, until he w•2S affurcd,by the Noble Lord, that tome com petent proviion v..oulci be made for the unfortunate woman who was the obj eel of it. For, however criminal her condudt might have been, it was not proper or jutt that the ihould be cart up on the world de.tit ire of the means of fupport, particularly fo after having brought a eonfiderable property to her hulband. Lord A UCK LAND replied, that no loch thing was intended. Mr.. Markham woad certainly have a competent provifion ; and front the knowledge he had of her connedtions, he knew (he would enjoy property,indtpendent of that mentioned in the prefent Bill. The LORD CIIANCELLOII faid, he agreed with his Noble and I.earned Friend, that a female convidied of adultery ought not to be forced to a life of proftitution for want of fume mainte nance, but at the fame time, notwithltanding his Noble and Learned Friend's humane fuggeftion, It mutt be remembered, that a Lady, who, after having brought her hufband a nume rous offspring, was eonvidted of adultery, was not entitled to expedt extraordinary lenity at the hands of the Legiflature. In the prefent cafe it was not poi:able to imagine that there was the fmalleft collufion, but it appeared that, front the parties being over anxious, honourably and undeniably, to avoid the imputation of collufion, they bad fallen upon the introduction of a claufe, which, in ordinary cafes, would have induced the greateft furpleion that collufion was at the bottom of the whole proceeding; for what could lend a !Ironer colour to a pre fumption, that it was a bargain between a hufband and wife, and that the former laid to the latter, " if you will agree to come into my eroporal of a divorce, I'll leave you as I found you, in •c:1 pothilion of all your fortune, and all other advan tages that nizy have accrurd to you fince your marriage." 'll he latter part of the clank, which tended, " that the (hall and may bold all goods, chattels, perfonal, and effeets whatfoever, that the (hall at any time hereafter became kind of by defcent, gifts. porehare or otherwife," was a matter of mere furplufage, and wholly unneeeffiry, as every body knew, that, after a Le giflative Divorce a viner'a matrimaxii,whatevcr came to her was her own. The preceding part of the claufe was altogether molt objationable, and would net be allow, d to Wand, as it would form a dangerous precedent for the future. His Lordthip ex ?read in common with his Noble Friend, who moved that the claufe be omitted, his gratification that the great and fcrupulous attention which their Lorcithips had paid to Divorce Bills, of late had confiderably tended to decreafe their number, and by holding greeter di/bet:ldes to the palling fuch Bills, bad fervsd tc feeure and promote the morals of the people. Before be fat dow - n, his Loran') laid, he concurred entirely with his Noble I riend (Lord Auckland), that if the Lady Rood in nerd of proviiion. the regular mode was for her to petition the Houle for that purport, and therefore, it would be right to allow time foe her doing Cu, if the thought proper, by poftponing the fur ther fitting of the Comniittee fur a few days. On the motion being put, the clank w^s omitted. When the Preane-le came to be conliotred, the 1.0110 Cow N- Ca L toy faid• a claufe of it teemed, from want of accurate at tention, to have efeaped, which ought not to Rand, and that referred to the baft.:nlizing the lezitimatc ilfise of the marriage, which was againit all form, and contrary to the known law of the land. lie thrre: . .,re moved, for the better coulideration of that matter. that the further fitting be adj3urnsd to Monday •ext..-Ordered.ss.Adjourned. HOUSE OF COMMONS. Mr. S reit writ took the Chair at the ufuala.aur; and Come private buliuefs having been done, A M. ffage from the Lo ds announced their Lordfhip's af km to a Bill for preventing vexatious averts, and to feveral private Bills. Mr. Wie.K IT asr moved, that there be laid be the Heufe a copy of the Evidence taken by the Commitßimer, of Ac counts on the Dublin Paving and Strect•repairing Committee. Lord !AVM's Go wee moved the Order of the Day on the further cunfidcration of the Report of the Committee on Coun ty Briigei. When the Refolutinns were agreed to, and a 8.11 ordered to be brought in accordingly. The confider Lion of the Stirling Elation Petition was poll , pored till Tusfday the 23i1 of Aurult. Leave was riven for the Fait India Company to lay before the Houle an Aeeount of the Produce of their Q2ick Stock. Mr. Flowaao, a•ter fume ohfervations, moved that the Do. tw.ch Road Bill be re-committed. The motion was orrofrd by Mr. Hu R IT, Sir ROSIER'S - &IX T•Ps. Sir LAWIENCL PAtIoNS, and Mr. DICEISIS, and fup porte.l by Mr. STU a rtr s and Sir Vs' st. Or A It Y. Stran:,crc were or:eied to withdraw, when a divifion took place—Fur the Re-cui.anitment, 44—Againli it, 92---.Maju rity, 32. The Ittlo:utioo was then agreed to, and a Bill ordered ae. corJui‘ly. NAVY AIIItSFS. Sir 14E0410' MILOMAY ride to call the attention oldie I tonic to t li l.jeei upon which, both within that Flouk• :CI I thtnlighollt the country, much cu rii.rity and folicitude had been excited : he alluded to the proceedings of the Committee appointed to enquire into the alledgcd Attics in the Naval ger vice, which were (laced by his Majeily's Mitullers to he of the molt flagitious and ctiortmus nature. Butt it was rather cxtramdinary, that this Commit tce had been appointed now frost months ; though they had been proceeding from that time to this cn their enquit y ; though the nature of the int/el t...zation for witch they were appointed was of the moll urgent nano ; and although they were (tria lv enjoined by the I inufe to report the refults of their enquiry from time to time, yet no report whatever had yet been made, notwitlidanding the anxiety of the ruhlic mind, and notwithilanding the chat acler , ur many perfons,:llwa?; heretofore cont . :dere:l as if high lc:pet/ability, remained as in a (Lice nt tielinquerr y, although, as he onderflood, no proof whatever LAJ ct.rne out to fultilantiate the charges again:! thu.te charaf.ers ; in onc Rance cfpccirlly : A :•:r. Taylor, wit° bad hetn charged with delinquency in his central. So far from his delinquency being proved, or his difmilial julified by the inve(hgation, that he was reinitated in his contra& S:r Henry argued at tome length on the neceility of an immediate report from the Committee, in order to the fatisfaetion of the Houle and the Country ; and he concluded by moving, "That the laid Commiffroners do report forthwith." Sir CHAR LFS POLE fail, he had the honour of being one of the Commiffioners on the fubjed of Navy Abufes, and he fhould be happy to give the' Hon. Baronet and the Honk every fatisfattion in his power on this fubjed. He could ail - tire the Houfe, that from the fiat hour the Commiffioners fat in January Tall, to the prefcnt, the Cosnmiffioners of that Board had unremittingly fat for feven hours each day, in the moft fedulous attention to the bu finds committed to their invefligation ; they had, indeed, a molt arduous talk to perform : they had been able as yct to get through but four of the fubjeds referred to their enquiry : the proceedings were voluminous, and it was necefrary to have fair copies tranfcribed to lay before the Houfe. This was in operation, and one of thefe Reports was nearly finithed, and the other three would alfo be fpeedily read, fo as to lay the whole before the' Houle in a few days. He regretted that the time of the Houfe fhould be taken up with fuch quef tions ; and had he been in the Houfe when the Hon. Baronet firft made hismotion, he fhould have given the information he now gave. Captain MARKHAM laid, he knew nothing of the proceedings of the Commillioners ; but he thought the Hon. Baronet had made many allufions which, in his opinion, would have been better kept back ; he neither thought it decent nor proper that the Report fhould have been touched upon. He did' not think that the Block contrad was a good one from the beginning ; but the proper opportunity for difeuffing the matter would be when his own opinion came to be oppofed to the other fide of the quellion : he would not enter into the propriety of the expedient now ; he fhould only Rate, that the Lords of the Admiralty, judging the contract detrimental, they employed a very ingenious me chanic, who fet up a machine in the yard at Ply mouth, for making blocks; and upon a comparifon of his blocks with thofe furnifhed by Mr. Taylor, the former were every way fuperior, both in work manfhip and value. With refped to the equip ments of the Navy, he Aimed the Houfe, with much warmth, that the imputations thrown upon the Admiralty, on that account, were equally ma levolent and unfounded, and highly injurious to the country. For, taking a comparative view of the flare of our Naval equipments at this moment, and the period of 1792, three months previous to the commencement of hoftilities, our force at this day would be found molt conliderably fuperior indeed. We had now in Britifh harbours a force competent to cope with fleets greatly fuperior to any which France and her Allies, even in the bell days of her navy, had ever commenced with us a maritime contelt—a force which, were it to put to fca to-morrow, would have nothing to contend with but fifhing.boats. The CHANCELLOR of the EICHEQZIER." Sir, I fully agree with my Hon. Friend who has jolt fpoken, that the imputations which have been thrown out againft the Board of Admiralty, and the equipments under their direction, not only do molt unjultly affect that Hon. Board, but are alfo, heavy imputations upon the country in general, I and tend to deprefs the public fpirit ; and if fuch imputations are thrown out, which ferve only to depreciate our ftrength, refources, and efficiency at home, it has a tendency to mifchievous effects abroad. I oblerved with regret the particularity with which my Hon. Friend alluded to the fpeech of the Hon. Baronet. All that the Hon. Baronet alluded to, was to the points which were objects of enquiry. Until the report be made (and I think the Houfe is fatisfied, by the declaration of ano ther Hon. Friend of mine behind me, Sir Charles Pole, that there will be no want of diligence in bringing forward all the information required), I du feel, that in the nature of the motion itfell there is a good dial of that which may be ftyled rtbuke to the Commiffinners. It excited a fulpi ; cion that there had been much unneceffisry delay on their parts ; but the Houle has been allured, and, I unit, latisfadorily, that not a moment's delay or intermiffion has unneceffarily occurred; ' that one report is nearly ready to bring forward, and three others will be ready in a day or two.— , In my opinion, the imputation of neglect has not bee, a hidden thought. The Hon. Baronet has thrown out fume fuggeflinns, indicating that the Board of Admiralty has, at prefect, fearcely the means of adequate defence for the public fervice. I do not at all like fuch fufpicions thrown out againft perfons in their highly refponlible lions, without authentic grounds. I never laid there would be fifty fail of the litre ready for fca by any particular day. It would have been mad nels to have fo aflerted. What I laid was, that fifty (hips of the line might be equipped for fervice within one month, from the commencement of emergency ; but I exprefsly difclairn having laid any thing of that on which it was impatiible to form any accurate calculation; namely, of the! precife time at kith] which the ilia complement of men for Inch a fleet could be completed. It may be very poffible to calculate cus the period within which a certain number Of may be got ready for lea, yet it is irnputlible to calculate that which depends on continoencies, fuel: as the procurathas of men fur thole flsips. 'We calasot know the nuns• hot of mercantile (hips which may be in our ports when an emergency may occur, ti om which !hips A great portion of thole men mull be had. It is, , however, of fume importance for the Houfe to I know, that fifty fail nt the lm: may be got ready in all other rcfpeds than their full complement of men, within one month from the commencement of emergency. I will not at :I.:s moment (late the prccilc number of (hips of war now in Britilh ports, but this I will Alert, that it is greatly be yond the number which appeared, to my oblerva. tion, Rated L:7 the public prints. It is greatly beynr!.: ou. tun o _t any former p.aiod, within any timilar ehlanceolthe expellation br probability of 'llollH:tits, and is loch as usait 1:4; gratifiing to I every friend to his country. I can fpecify, not from my own authority, from one more authentic, that there are thirtyfiven fail of the hue now in the ports of this country ready for fea, and aetu ally in commiflion, betides thole on foreign Ra tions ; and I beg Gentlemen may not infer, that becaufe the whole of thofe (hips may not be now completely manned, that hands are not therefore procurable. It mull be confidered, that in every cafe, the proceedings of the of the Admi ralty are meafured by the emergency of circurn. fiances. They have, in fart, abflained from taking any Rep by which the commerce of the country might be embarraffed, until occafion becomes ine vitable. They have not impreffed from protec tions ; they have not retorted to thofe meafures which, followed to their extent, would fpeedily in fore the requifite complement of men. Let us r.:colletl, what is the number of our fleets on fo reign Ration ; let us remember, that we have not on the prefent, as on former preparations for de fence, made our commencement with ten, twelve, or fifteen fail of the line, but withifiy fail of the line, adually in commillion : not with ten, twelve, or fourteen thoufand feamen, as formerly, but with _fifty thoqfand : and that, therefore, it is not quite fo eafy nor fo neceffary, to increafe upon our number of either, in the latter or in theforrner cafe. Upon the whole, Sir, I have been anxious to cor red errors, and to let myfelf right; and, I muff fay, there is no period to which I look forward with greater anxiety, than that day when I (hall have an opportunity of meeting enquiry—when I (hall have an opportunity of doing juflice to the conduit of his Majeßy's Government, and to my. fell, amongft others, as a Member of it. I look forward to that day with more fatisfaCtion than can poffibly defcribe, when public duty (hall per mit me to make a communication, upon which it is propofed to found an enquiry into the (late of the nation. That day (hall be accelerated, on my part, as much as my public duty can poffibly ad mit ; and I truft the refult will be fatisfaftory to the moll zealous hopes and expetlations of the bell friends of the country. I (hall, therefore, Sir, in (lead of giving my negative to the motion of the Hon. Baronet, move, 4 , That you proceed to the other Orders of the Day." Mr. CANNING, in a fpeech of confiderable length. vindicated the motion of the Hon. Baronet, his Friend, and the motives which induced him to it, and the right which he had, as a Member of Par liament, to information upon a fubjett on which , there had been fo much hurry, on the part of his Majefty's Minifters, to precipitate enquiry, left guilt fhould fly from jutlice ; that the Bill was hurried through the Houfe, lie would not fay with unconllitutional, but certainly with moll unufual celerity ; nor were even the Chriflmas holidays allowed to pats over,before it was paired into a law. Minifters then allured the Houfe the country was in profound peace—that now was the time for re dation in our eflabliffiment—retrenchments and economy : now the time for inveßigating abufes which had crept into our naval departments dur ing an arduous war of ten years, for deteEting frauds, and punithing delinquency and peculation. Four months had patted over in fedulous enquiry, without any report from the Commillioners, or any proof adduced of the guilt of the principal perfons aecufed. Did any refult go to prove the guilt, or extenfive peculation alleged had exifted? Was it a proof of the peculation charged againft Mr. Taylor, that Co far from being conviCted and punifhed, he was reinflated in his contra& ? His Hon. Friend, therefore, in demanding this report, afked only fur the information to which, as a Mem ber of Parliament, he was intitled ; to which, he was prompted by the feelings of a Gentleman and a Friend, anxious for the vindication of thofe friends who had fuffered the groffeft imputation without any proof being adduced, fo far as he could learn, to fußain them. With refpeet to the propriety of enquiring into any abufes which might have crept into the Iyflem of his Majeßy's dock yards, in the courfe of a long and arduous war, he had no objeCtion to every reafonable enquiry, with a view to correCtion. If an officer, or an ar tificer was over-paid, he had no objeftion to re trenchment ; but it was of the molt material and important difference, whether this was to be done at a time of profound peace, when no mitchief could refult from the reform, or at the eve of a war, when fuch meafures would ferve but to irri tate ufeful artificers, and drive them from the public fervice, without any means of fupplying their places. Such aeconomy mull be infinitely more mifchievuus, than any degree of extrava gance it could he direCted to retrench. It hap pened, he laid, in this, as in many other cafes, that thole who wittiest to ((ippon the fame argu ments, contradifted each other upon the fame topics. Such was now the cafe between the Right Hon. Gentleman on the floor (the Chancellor of the Exchequer) and his Hon. Friend behind him (Capt. Markham) ; but before he proceeded to call the attention of the Houle to the point he meant to allude to, be would move that his Majelly's late Meltage'to both Houfes be row read—(it was read accordingly).—.. Here, then, (laid the Hon. Member) is the flatten contradittion between two of the molt leading authorities, on a moll impor tant tubjeft. His Islajefty's Metfage tells this Houfe that an important Treaty is pending between this Country and the Government of France, the refult of which cannot yet be known ; and that formi dable equipments are carrying forward in all the ports of France and Holland, againft which it it neceilary to be prepared for any refult. The pub lic farce is immediately encrealed ; formidable ar maments in our arterials, and equipments in nui fleets, are immediately let on toot ; the countr y is thrown into apprehenfion andalarm; public ere lit into ennfulion ; and r,ow that we ate told that a formidable fleet is ready to put to fea, we hear, for the &II time, and from a Lord of the Admiralty too, that this fleet may be oppofed, net by formi dable equipments from the ports of France and Holland, for it now teems that there are no fuel things in thole ports, but it has nothing to refl. , but a f i rer of fining kair \Vas this, he wnol, alk, the ground of all our alarms and apprelien lions \l 'as this the proof of intelligence on the part cl Mir.ifiers, which induced them to cools tile apprelienfions of the Country? ft was an ir, Rance, however, and the true one in his mind, u, account why communication fo often promifed wa; fo long delayed. Mr. Fox laid, he (hould sot long trefpafs on the patience of the Houfe, but he could not fuffer it to depart without obferving, that he did not exaely coincide in opinion with either of the Hon. Get, tlemen who had fpoken in this debate, and who, h e thought, had treated the Hon. Baronet with more feverity than any thing that had fallen from 1 1 ; : , was entitled to. The Houfe would recoiled th.rt no inquiry had been moved, and therefore no im putation could poftibly attach to the intentions („ thofe who were defirous to obtain information, than that of a defire to know how a bulinefs:olthi ; importance, which the Hon. Baronet's Motion al. luded to, had been condueed. It was very na. tural to with that every matter of moment lhould be before the Houfc, and no one more ariently defired it than he did; for his own past, It: convinced of the general good intention, corm:eel with ability to corral abufes, and he lincerely hoped the noble Lord at the heed of the Admiral ty, and thole with whom he abed, would not Cul fer themfelves to be intimidated by an infutreeh.n of jobbers who were ever ready to let up the huc and cry again ft thofe who would bring their mal. praeices to light, and that they would boldly and determinedly look with the molt fcrutinizing eye into the abufes which have crept into the naval dt partrnent, and which, if left uncorrected, might be attended with the molt fatal confequences tv the belt and dearth interelts of the Country. He was by no,means a friend to ftrong powers, but if ever ftrong powers ought to be given, he though; it Ihould be agtainft thofe abufes which prevail in fo important a department as that of the Admi ralty, and which, according to all accounts he had heard, (for he was not prefent when the Bill was introduced) called fo loudly for reform. With re fpett to the armament, this was not the time to difcufs it, and his only reafon for riling at the prc. fent moment, was to exprefs the thorough confi dence he repofed in the Admiralty, at the head of which prefided a noble Lord, whole ardour in the caufe of his country could not be exceeded. Capt. Ma a KHA 55, in explanation, laid, that when he (poke of the fuperiority of this country over the enemy in fitting out a fleet, he did not mean to fpeak contemptuoufly ; but he thought he had a right to fpeak with exultation on fuch a fubjeet, and he was very confident their exertions in that department could by no means be compared to out 's. Sir HENRY MI LEM AY Paid, the Chancellor of the Exchequer had made ufe of words, as coming from him, which he did not ufe ; he did not recoiled having called the Gentlemen, compofing the Board of Admiralty, parfimonious charaCters. The CHANCELLOR of the ETCH ca affirred the Hon. Baronet that he did pot mean to mifre• prefent or initiate what had fallen from him, but that he undertlood him to fay, 'that the Admi ralty had ufed " a parfimonious and ill-timed (economy." Mr. LEICESTER Paid, he was lorry that the Corn • miffioners have not been able to give the Houle the refult of their inquiry refpeaing the abides in h:c Majelly's Navy, before this time ; but hesould afrure the Hon. Baronet that the Report fhould be l aid before the Houle as early as potlible. Sir H. MI LDM AY then withdrew his motion. The LORD ADVOCATE for Scotland moved for leave to bring In a Bill to inereafe the income of Sehoolmallen in Scotland. On leave being granted, his Lordibip moved, tbat the Houfc do go into a Committee on the Paid Bill to-morrow morning; which was agreed to. The CHANCELLOR of the EXCHICV ea propofe that Coming Gordon, Efq. be added to the Conimiaa appointed to confider the Bill relative to the Hidilands of Scotland. IRISH LAW COURTS SILL. Mr. LEE moved the Order of the Day for the ennficteration of the Mill Law Courts Bill. He faid, there was a queftion of very confiderable im portance relative to the MN Law Courts before the Houle ; and as it had been now three years under deliberation, he was anxious it fhould be brought to a conclufion. It was of the greateft confequence to Ireland ; the objet of it was to put Ireland, with regard to its Law Courts, pre cifely on the fame footing as England : the confe queace of the meafure would be to leffen the ex pence of (ultras. A meafure of fo much impo;- tancs. he trulted, would not meet with any ob jcetion. The principal meafure in the Bill was to enforce the more fpeedy appearance of defendants to procefs. The only mode known to our ancef tors of compelling an appearance, was to arreft the body of the defendant ; or if he could not be found, to flue a fecond wrir to dtftrain his goods to compel his appearance. For two or three cen turies this continued to be the praelice, but in the reign of King George I. an Al of Parliament palled, by which it was enadted, that if a defen dant did not appear in eight days after the fervice of procefs, the plaintiff might enter an appearance for him, and file a declaration againit him, the fame as if lie had appeared himfelf. The reafon was, becaufe the party having difobeyed the writ was guilty of a contempt. All he wanted was to extend that law to Ireland, and thereby give the fuitors the fame facility in that country as in this. The reafon a fimilar Alt had not pallid in Ireland was, the people of that country not hav ing had a Parliament fo attentive to their interefts had the fame laws which glverned this country been extended to them, a vall deal of thofe incon veniences which had taken place would have been avoided. It was true, a meafure had been adopt ed for altering part of the law of Ireland, but it had not gone the length of the Statute of George I. The confequence of that meafure had been, that all the bulinefs had run into the Court of Exche quer. a Court which, of all others, ought not to have a cemmnn lawjoirifdietion, for there were only two days in the week appropriated to the difpatch of common law bulinefs, to which, in the Courts of King's Bench, and Common Pleas, every day in the week was In appropriated. The effeet of this was, that all the bulinefs having got into the .:ours of Exchequer, the quantity was fo great. and the fuitors found themfelves In entangled in delay, that the mifchief was as bad as before the law had been altered. The Hon. Member adverted to the eonthiEt of the different Judges of the 'Line; to nd, t L , d 9n the :r it to to /1y 1 Geri. hodie Mort: n 11;:a t that so ;ru- ms 1 ation, dtha; on al. 'y ca. houla gently 1 le was neeel cerely miral- ot etSic.n e hue c - 1 ly and ig eye val Lle- might ices to He but if ought - , ail in kdmi- e had 11 was ith re- me to 1,1 in L to th lal It f4l