Star. — London, England, 1810-05-18 00:00:00

FARLmmENTARr TROC4,BDIAW, HOUSE OE LORDS, THURSD4T.MM 17. In the Committee of Privileges on the Roxburgh Parer, the Lord Advocate of Scotland was heard on hebalf of the Crown. The Entbenlement B:11, the Exchequer BUM 'funding Bill, the Hawkers' and Pedlars' Bill, the Mali Stag e Coaches Bill, the Malt Intercourse Bill. and several other Bill, were brought up wily , upon by Mr. Lushington, Mr. Davenport, Mr. Blatliburn, Sir I. G. , the douse disposed power Cotterell, Mr. Moore, and other Members, an s d read sires tigiler The Etribezzlemvt Bill was ordered to be printed. . alleviate those burthens by mean s of t h e strictest eco- The Scots and Irish Judges Salaries Augmented= Bill - sees, nomy. To•sliew the necessity of these measures, it on the motion of Lord Viscount MELVILII:,read a thin, time ' was only necessary to observe, that there were now and passed. • • - three Offices, one of theM held by a Noble Lord op. The earl of DONOUGFIMORE postponed his motion - eels-It - , tive to the Catholics till Tuesday next, fur waiei; day the Lorc4 . posite, and the otherstwo . of the Tellerships of the were ordered to be summoned. i Exchequer, producing together, if he was rightly in - Lord Viscount MELVILLE fixed his motion relative to the formed, no less than £75,000 a year, and which hay conveyance of troops in Ships of War for Monday, for which day log been granted in reversion, could not be regulated the Lords were ordered to be sumnioncd. tin these grants expired. He admitte d the truth of Earl GREY postponed his motion till Friday , t he ist of June, for which day the LcrJs were ordered to be summoned.. what the Noble Viscount had stated with respect to REVERSION BILL. the Committee of Finance of the House of Commons, Earl C R.OSVENOR, on moving thessecnnd lea- and trusted that what bad been said wo u ld hav e t he ding of the Reversion Bill, observed t ha t he could + effect of contributing to quicken the labours of that not help feeling considerable anxiety upon this sub- Committee, and induce them to forward their plan ject, as he felt that if the bill was rejected Much dis- with more expedition. No man could be more cer satisfaction would be excited amongst the well-affec- • tarn than he was of the truth of what the Noble Vis. ted, and that a handle would be given to• those not. count had stated, that the benevolent views of his well affected, which they might use for mischievous Majesty were always ready to support any measure purposes. He would not repeat the arguments .which for alleviating the burthens of the people ; and he had been before urged upon this topic, buf he vhtilds" most deeply' lamented that his Majesty was now in not help observing that, however little it. might be that state as to render it doubtful whether the wants said this bill would effect, in point of economy, still .: or. wishes of his people could come home to his feel that it was necessary to pass it, in order to shee a legs. This, however, was a subject upon which he disposition to ceconornize the resources of the coup- ' touched tremblingly ; but it was one which demand try. It should a!so be recollected, with respect to ed the serious consideration of their Lordships. He economy, that if a saving in offices comparatively couldnot but lament that his Majesty should have been small, amounting only to £lOO,OOO, had been made I advised, in providing for a branch of his family, who at the commencement of his Majesty's reign, it.wnuld I had unhappily met wit!: misfortunes, and there being h ive amounted by this time, at compound interest, to : a fund applicable to the purpose, rather than make £20,000,000. He could not but consider the power the provision from that fund, to 'add to the burthens , of granting Reversions as a dreadful engine of clan- i on the people. He could not but lament, that, in the destine corruption, and many of their Lordships were I exercise of the power of granting sinecures for life, probably not aware of the manner in which it opera- I instead of making them the rewards of services, an ted, extending itself, as it did to almost all offices, and 1 occasion rather appeared to have been sought of vex exercised in the silent chambers and secret recesses of I ing and teasing the people. He admitted, with re the Treasury, where, by a stroke of the pen, tens and j spec: to the present Bill, that it was utterly incon hundreds of Reversions were granted to increase the I sistent with the Constitution that the power of grant influence of Ministers. He admitted that some I ing Offices in Reversion should be transferred to the clauses in the bill might require alteration, but that l Houses of Parliament by means of address to the coiild be done in the Committee. Crown, and thou g ht it more liable to abuse than the ' The LORD CHANCELLOR observed, that this power as now exercised by the Crown. Still, how. Bill was wholly different from those bills on the same ever, he thought this objection, and the others urged I subject, which'had formerly been before the House, by the Noble and Learned Lord, might be obviated and in principle was highly objectionable. The oh- in the Committee. ject of the present bill was not to abolish the power of Lord Viscount SIDMOUTH was of opinion, that granting offices in reversion, and far joint lives, with it might be adviseable to abolish the power of grant benefit of survivorship, but to alter the mode of gran- ing some Office; in Reversion, but contended that a Ling them, and that in a manner the most objection- great delusion had gone forth with respect to this . able that could be conceived. It was enacted by this measure ; there was much exaggeration on one side, bill• that the Crown should not have the power of and clamour on the other ; but the fact was, that the granting these offices, except in pursuance olan Ad- measure would take away nothing from the preroga -Iress from both or . either House of Parliament, that , tin of the Crown, nor in the least diminish the bur was to say, that the Parliament were to take away 1 thens on the people. He had hoped that it was in from the Crown the power of granting these offices, i contemplation to specify in a Bill of this description, and to transfer it to themselves—a mode the most ! the Offices the power of gianting which in aversion inconsistent with the usage, the practice, and the spirit ;it was proposed to abolish ; but from the nature of of the Constitution. His Lordship pointed out other : the present Bill, he was convinced, it was impossible clauses in the bill a s . involving great absurdities. As ;to amend it so as to answer any useful purpose. to any discontent existing in the public mind, he I The Earl of LIVERPOOL entirely concur - 1A in thought the only proper way for thatnouse to act opinion with his Noble and Learned Friend on the was to endeavour to do their duty without being in- Woolsack, with reference to the present Ell. -As fluenced by any popular clamour. Those who for- to the burthens of the people, he admitted, they w,:re merly directed all their efforts to overthrOw the Mo- I treat ; but it should also be considered, that the opu- Botchy, now finding that unsuccessful, turned those Ilence, the wealth, the commerce, and the means if efforts against the Privileges of the ( House of Corn- the, cottutry, and 'that the burthen now compared • mot-, with a pretended veneration for the Throne, *A the meatus of the country was not so great as that but still having the same object in - view, the destruc-iin the reign Or King William, compared with the tion of the Constitution ;; and he was certain their 'then resnurces'o f the country. Lordships must be convinced ,` that the Privileges The tad ofCARYSFORT thought it impossible which the House of Commons held for the benefit of that the objections to the present bill could be reme the people, were essential to die Constitution, and that died in a Committee. • if the House of Commons, with its privileges and Lord REDESDALE was of a similar opinion, powers, were,to be swept aWay, neither their Lord- arid thought the best mode of tenting open those n- ships' House nor the Monarchy could long exist. As gulations with respect to any offices, which it might 1 to the preseathill, - his objections were decidedly to its be deemed expedient to carry into effect, would be to principle, and could not be removed in a-Committee. enact, that no future grant of any office in reversion What .he'avished was, that the whole subject should I or for joint lives with benefit of survivorship, should be before - the House, thht they might know what Ibe allowed to stand in the way of any regulation of offices k was proposed' to abolish and what to logo- : such office. 'late; in 'order that this investigation might not be I The question was put for the second reading of the. fettered by any new grants in Reversion, he thought I bill, which was negatived. the best mode would be to pass a biltfor suspending The LORD CHANCELLOR moved that the for a limited time the power of granting Offices in bill be rejected, which was ordered. geversion. • Adjourned at half past nine o'clock till to-morrow Loid Viscount MELVILLE agreed with the No- , (this day). ble and Learned Lord in his opinions relative to the i . • present Bill ; and observed as to the supposition, that HOUSE OF COMMONS. the pas•ing of it would please the people ; that the The Hawkers and Pedlars Bill was read a third time and passed. House of Commons had repeatedly passed a Bill Mr. WriIARTON moved for a new writ for St. Germains, in u on this sub i the room of Mr. Yorke, who since his election had accepted the pject, hut it seemed to be very slow in operating to please the people. The fact was, that I place of First Lord of the Admiralty. Mr. W HA RTONbrought in a Bill far Consolidating the Du- the object of • the Bill was not understood by the pen- ! ties on Customs, in t h e Isle of M ann. Read a first, and ordered pie ; and as to 'airy 'saving to arise from it, it would ! to ta. read a second time to-morrow. be so trifling as to be scarcely worth mentioning. A ; A Petition was presented to the House from the Catholics of the County of Gahv . ay, praying relief. i Hell :way 1% ater-Works B ill great 'delusion had gone abroad upon this subject, it iht was read a third dine, and seemed to be supposed that by agreeing to a measure • r .,,,,,i, of this desCription, the Offices themselves would be : Mr. Wt ARTON brought in a Bill for permitting the Expos.- aboli ahed whereas, in truth the . power of granting , tation of Foreien ::::lt from certain ports in the United Kingdom, i , i toNrrunchind. riaa a fi rst time and ordered to be read a diem itl a certain mode would alone be affected. he i wiL e i( Aou.t rro could not conceive any thing - ovel unconstitutional I s e cond Mr aa e . lia v‘ :s . : n 1 800 I ' l.E rose pursuant to notice to than the clause in the ITIVICnt Bill authorising the i move for leave to bring in a Bill to repeal so much of an Act of .Granting oil:dates in ReWertlon only upon the ad- ; the Bth and 9th of William 111. as related to the Lodging of Pau tress of both or either Hi.iase' of Parliament. The ' PiTt,hirrivesOreven.' C oac hes Bill was read a third time and p assed . Houses might differ ; one Kona night have one fa- i hir e . GRE I N ta fEL, in the absence of an Honourable Fri end P of . voured person to recommend'fdr &Grant in *Lever- i his (Mr. Manning), postponed the consideration of the Report of sion, and the other House another; what was to be ,• the Marine Insurance Committee till Tuesday. I N 'l: l l3e u Su , r F st i ey.w . . G 1 I. E •n y era ß l's Bill was rea d d a third time and passed. the consequence then ? scete they to go to the King'i Rino o l l u . s t c o n h is ta . : f sers ley n e o to ffi b c ri es nt s itiiitea Courts It to s Palace and struggltNat the doors for admission , to try i Regulate the F ees ant ' which should get in first ? Upon former discussions ,cf Law In Ireland. The Bill was brought in, read. a first, and o f this subject, the speech of his Majesty at the open- i ordered to be read a second time oil Monday next. .ing of the Parliament had been referred to, and he ! Sir PATRICK 'MURRAY presented certain papers lately . ttred to lie n the tast e. Would mo ved for, relative o o t th: l Diguruances in tine 'M Madras Army.— was certain that the benevolent views of his Majesty O rdered Would be always ready to give effect to any measure Ale. DUNDAS gave notice of a motion for to-morrow, for a 'which c( uld alleviate the burdens on his people.. But Bill for regulating EolistnitTnt into the Service of the East-India , Company, and also for Regulating Courts Martial in the same what had the Committee of Finance of the House of Service. Commons done after three years investigation ? This A Message from the Lords announced their assent to the Scots single measure was the whle result of their labours. • Jud g es Salary Bill, .',cc. &c. Let their Lordships have before them the whole plan , Mr. WHARTON presented an Estimate of the Domestic Ex pence of the Royal Naval Asylum for one year. Laid. =the Ex of economy which was proposed , and then the y woul d table. Mr. POSTER brought In a Bill for the Encouragement of the g be able to ive it a due consideration--then they d C e n Liquor in Ireland. Read a first, and or would be enabled to understand what r e g ulations in d to be read a second time to-morrow. Consumption of Malt offices it was proposed to enact. With this view, he . Mr. PF.RCEVAL moved for leave to bring in a Bill to n - thought it might be advisable to postpone the second late the Office of Registrar of the Court of Admiralty. Leave g iven. iv reading of this 'Bill for three weeks, in order to learn ; Tile LORD ADVOCATE of SCOTLAND moved the secon d from the Commons, in the mean rime, the i;:tture of the ' patht g of the Highland Roads Bill. To be conunitted g a-morrow. flan wh'ch the Committee of Finance had agreed upon. ; Mr. 1 USHINGTON brought up the Report cf the Committee g o il puy conteoded, that the real practical of Ways and ?vim,- Resolutions APIS le, aa4 Bilk ordered. moved tie dird Friend. (Mr. on this sub• other hustbess A) wished that the present. EXCHEQUER rather thought altered '• intention, and in. to. Use Droirs of , the Minkstry till another occasion. Mr. CALCRAFF did not understand that he his any smelt intention. • Mr. SHERIDAN stated, that ate Honourable Gentleman had just come down with him from the Bullion Committee, and he supposed he would he here immediately. The CHANCELLOR of the EXCHEQUER upon this agreed to withdraw the motion, but Burling that Mr. Tierney had gams away, he presisted. Mr. CALCRAFT said, that his Honourable Friend had only left the House a short time after sitting a great part of the day at the Bullion Committee—thinking he might do so as be under stood that another subject was to have come on first which would have occupied some time. He (Mr. Calcraft) could not allow this matter to pass without expressing an opinion— , ( allu ding 13 ::1:s t i:: tention to divide the Howe.) The House then divided--For the third reading 51—Against it 22—Majority 29. deny the aelbent required ; but then he refused to grant it time to consider, whether part of the fund might not be applied to the purposes of this Bin) —k was known that his Majesty had on on oc. casion given a million out of this fund towards th e public service, and it was to be presumed from this paternal attention to his people, that he would a m refuse any sums that could be spared fair their relief , if he were properly advised. He had given sums to several members of his family out of this fund, s 2 doubt upon such exigency that if he had not this fu L a he would have been under the necessity of applvine to that House, and this too from those paternal feel ings which his Majesty possessed as well as others.,.. But here came the tact, that 5e25,000 had been gra f ,. I,tednut of this sum to Sit Home Popham, amd aim . [ they stint towards bringing home a Governer from k distant settlement. Fie asked whether it was wise, whether it was candid and affectionate towards h . , !Maigsty, to advise him to overbsok this fund, and ap ply to his subjects at once at a moment when th 4 1-Chancellor of the Exchequer,- by the measute wh ic h he proposed last night, conft4sed the difficulty G e ending new sources of taxation, and when some 4G had been..in:his confidence, whose knowledge cf de . subject was unquestionable, and who of Late had laid i ' the foundation of a strong claim to the con fi dence and approbation of the country, bad urg e d the ik., cessity .of retrenchment ? When. .the Right Hes, . GentleMan.had resorted tothe surplttia. th e c onk ,. . lidate k i kund, td furnish the Ways aud.lifeaus of the , year, a measure, which to • say the leint of it, h e thought erroneous, was it spewing a proper regard .to the dignity of tie Crown? Was it dutiful and affectionate to his : Mi . tieSit'iri advise hits ,to cotr.e upon his suhjecti Tot . th is- ir OW a- year, whesk hi m . self had a fund ontiesifiitit' to r:i.f . it ? He hoped that what his lino: NentriMr. Lambe) had !said, would, sink ifeeoininte hearts of the Membe rs o f that House. All that was wanted was a delay till the state of the Admiralty Fund could be ascertained, and with that view lie moved that die debate be ad, I, journed till this day se'nnight. ".-: 1 The CHANCELLOR of the EXCHEQUER contended. that it was much more properand credi, . table, in the first instance, to grant this annuity cu t 'I of the Consolidated Fund. If, upon examination, it should appear that the Admiralty Fund could bear a sum equal to the purchase of the annuity, it blight be paid out of the Droits into the Consolidatedfundi. , But he maintained, that the two subjects were not at I all connected.with each other. The grant of the an. inuity ought to be independent of the consideration of i ' . the state of the Droits of Admiralty. The House divided, and the 'timber* were--For the original motion, 65—For the Amendment, 37 Majottty 28.—The Bill was accordingly passed, and ordered to the Lords. When strangers were admitted. Mr. H. MARTIN was speaking upon the ques tion, that the Bill be pissed. He stated, that con sidering the situation of the country when 200 millions had been added to the capital of the National Debt. between 1794 and 1808; it was important to consider whether this annuity might not be supplied oat of the Droits ef the Admiralty, for nobody denied that iz 'ought to be granted in some way or other: • From the papers on the table it appeared that the Droits of the Admiralty were fully competent to answer this demand. It appeared that there were from four to five millions which had not been applied to public purposes. After the large addition which had been made to the Royal privy purse, it was hardly fair to load the Consolidated Fund with this additional bur then, when there existed other means of meeting the demand. He also adverted to the 41 per cents. which had been left at the disposal of the Sovereign, and had yielded £172,000. The CHANCELLOR of the EXCHEQUER remarked, that the Honourable and Learned Gentle man did not advert to the fact, that two-thirds of the Droits were granted to the captors, all to he de ducted from the sum which he had stated. The fact was, that no more had been left at the disposal of the Crown than from one to two millions. The observa tions which had been made in other respects could not be borne out by the napers on the table. Mr. CREEVEY . dini:t.l that it was the uniform practice to give two thirds to the captors ; there had been a departure from the rule in the case of the Spa nish prizes. But what appeared particularly objec tionable was, that the Crown should have the dispo sal of such enormous sums, without being subject to be called upon by Parliament for an account of, its application. Lord MILTON observed, that the Right Honou rable Gentleman himself appeared to have admitted the other night, that there were sufficient Droits to purchase this annuity, though now he seemed to be of a contrary opinion. 'The CHANCELLOR of the EXCHEQUER ad mitted that there was a sum of £70,000 which would probably purchase this annuity, unaccounted for, but that was a different thing from admitting . that there were about five millions in the same situation. Mr. WILLIAM SMITH said it was different— ' but the question now was, whether the House should stop the pr ogress of the Bill till the account of Droits could be examined and discussed ; or pass the Bill now, and discuss afterwards whether the annuity might not be charged upon this fund ? After the conte.sion that there were £70,000 in the hands of the Registrar—the point, as far as the reason of the thing went, was decided. He agreed in the mons trous nature - of the circumstance, that the Crc wn should have the disposal within a few years of eight .millions of money independent of Parliament. There had been a question, whether the Crown could accept of a vcluntary loan, &c. but the absolute command of i this sum was monstrous. All this had ari , en from i the change of things in this coun:ry, to which we liadJ not been always careful, to aceornniodate our institu dens. While the King paid his Army and Navy out of his own possessions, it was fair that he should have the disposal of whatever was captured ; but when the country paid nineteen millions for a Navy, and about as much for an Army, was it equitable that the Crown should have the proceeds of captures with out account ? Anbther objection to it was, that it was a bounty upon injustice. The nation would be ashamed of improper captures from foes or friends,but a Minister of the day might not scruple to procure large sums in this way. He adverted to the capture i of the Spanish frigates, the greatest blot upon the AdmiUstration of a Right Honourable Gentleman, now no more. Such temptations ought not to be kit , upon any Ministers. He hoped the Droits of the; Admiralty would, at no distant peri!)d, be regulated by an Act of Parliament , but in the mean time, it was their duty to ascertain whether the present an., nuity might not be supplied from them before they agreed further to load t h e Consolidated Fund. Mr. LAMBE observed, that. it was proper that. this annuity should be granted ; but he could not help remarkLig the very different manner in which a 1 request from the Crown was received in that House, • from that in which the wishes of that House were at r tended to by the assertors of undue prerogative. The House had been ready to vote sums called for upon occasions similar to the present in the most muniti. ' cent manner ; but when the Reversion Bill :Went to the Lords, a Bill which had been considered of grea ter importance than it really was, and which the pub lic were willing to have taken for more than it was ' worth, it was well known what a vexatious opposition it met with. Mr. WHITBREAD, as his Hon. Friend had not yet come (which was not extraordinary after having , sat all day at the Bullion Co mm i ttee ) begged leave to say a few words. He would propose that the de . bate be adjourned for k few dos, that they.might . have an opportunity fund, out of - • paid. Nobody 1. be found necessary ' ted Fund, the not object. , 6reem to the Ministers, the Crown it - - delay I The • Upon our re-admission we found, Mr. WHITBREAD observing, upon a Bill which he had jun brought in to explain and amend the Act , for the remittal of the Poor, so far as relates to the regulation of WOrkhouses. The Honourable Gentleman took occasion to state, that by the nest Sessions, he should endeavour to prepare some arrangemects with respect to the poor, which be hoped would meet a more fa• •ourable reception from the House than °some Conner proposi tions of his upon the same subject had experienced.. The Bill was read a first, and ordered to be rude second time on TTgai neat. Ordered, on the motion of Mr. FOSTER, that the House should to-morrow resolve imo a Committee for the purpou of considering the propriety of erecting certain Light Houses tiroo the Coast of Ireland. I . Mr. R. WARD presented a petition from the Governess al Greenwich Hospital, praying leave to present aput/ser petits, which being received, was read. We understood it to relate to the cmastructiou of certain building, in the neighbourhood of Greenwich Hnisital. Orderodta he ma tbe-table. Mr. TIERNEY gave notice of his intentiiin to mace apes de first open day for an Address to his Majesty, praylig ler SP count of the amount of the Limits of.tho Admiralty a view to ascertain whether Hsu . amount would • provide for the Annuity which she House had vot o' Brunswick. Mr. MARTIN put a question to the Chancellor of the itch,- quer across the table, with respect to the Registrar of lbs Aduii• ratty, winch the latter answered. But both spoke in sojow I tone, that no one could distinctly understand them. Mr. I'IERNEY stated, that as the till for appropriating. tie surplu. produce of the Stamp Duties, would; he undenitodd , read a second :ime on Tut sday, he should then take occasios tx make some Lbsetvatiotis tipoh the subject ; and also niove for Cie appointment of a Committee to inquire into LW pneral.state the Cuselidated Fund. FINANCE nrsoivriovs. The House then went into a Committee on M. Martin's Financial Resolutions. On the Resolution being read for the Abolkion of Sinecures, Mr. BANKES rose to move an Amendment 1. , this Resolution, which in substance was as follow: •' Not to abolish entirely Sinecure Places, but to cre ate from such as should be iii future abolished a fund to enable his Maje,ty to reward public services."—' He considered that it was absolutely necessary that the Crown should have the means of rewarding:lts. civil servants for active and important services. Thn was the only way by which the country could bop! to have the benefit of the services of many men great talents, who would certainly not be sufficiently remunerated by the mete emoluments of their offices. It must he recollected that several of those men gave up professions which would he more lucrative to them, in order to devote their time to the public set. vice, He never was of opinion that servicvs.of this nature should' go unrewarded : but he disapproved cs sinecures, which were in factleldom :TOW* , thine purposes. He thouAlit that at the pres ent tithe Par. liament should she* tirrountry that their welt Posed to tempers* reecirm of existingaboses. i t believed that there was a time, and that tint very Ia . r back, when such meas ure as the Reversion li : u would have given considerable satisfaction to the pub lic. He was, however, aware that this time had now in a great measure goneliy, and that the f)oblic was not now directed to irnall objects, but tOimPor' cri cant objects, endangeri the frame of our constito! Lion ; nevertheless, what he thought reasonable and right to do some years ago "he should still in and he thought that Parliament tell ht, clop'' persevere ing the Reversion Bill, do a good deal to skew mg sound and good part of the community, dillt were disposed to meet their wishes in the i isloPerr refnetisAii , - As sinecures now stood, sfr the is.- - Woods Cl' • item** Wore the Uses volsewhedier tbet power or DUKE 07 11717071171C1e1l AWlll l l7lt . • granting Orypes ill Ravenioa should continue W exist Tie CHANCELLOR of the ExcH i asi or net iffe adntitted that the abolition of the ?War par o n D u k e of Bropswickl i i: nnvitf 'i WOUldlirOd9 o 3 6 4 1 .. ) hnaledj, win* an d vit i n i rl '- • boa bissid te wake a prapeekOat . but a Viral)/ Illairlig ; )tilt ,boWever trifling in , Idostoming tee hopresslon diet pH* • the sum that NataUiti he. ttitiopTe)y =wed, .still it wis qess armee no tatare ea he (Mr. Ca ' of imiortante with Teem:lie ltb the bothara that now eetwokkra_ebeshwdd b e at up for the present, The CHANCELLOR. of the EXCHEQUER rl 1 tallitaltraY pressed upon din P e° P le • and t ° 3/leW 414 that the Honourable Gentleman had altered his hum the Nouse was disposed to do all ill !heir power to tended to defer the diseassion of the Question as {tat journed for a few dais, that they. might , reform of grievances. As sinecure' ir-- -- , 1 )portunity of inq u i r i ng i nto the state 0E the, stead of being consi4era the honearable siivaras t j of which, if possible, this sum ought to be great public service tlity seemed to *B, abswed , . 1 ! . ody objected to the annuity, andif it shonld carry amif .. 4 P2. 0 k;. '' Nisi otlpi held hin ion 6 ieoessary to have recotirso to The.consoliriti- ~ s tp, a 4 4 ,calA ws, l ,l ;, : '. 'uteiti ill et: el-14 1914 ,1 i the last room* pl" ilic,OßTlVr t he hooka .. society { . I r k . .i j. i 'to &Ara ;thirst 0, , t‘ , But he wonl4 . putik.ftllinrid, ..taivp- .44 5 1 0 4. 41 4r*5. ')iiil• $. ' 'lf teitiatltsiviio,. 1 ~ . , , 'br rev.) t tlttligiiirhicb, la.' •l• i, , !..Mimistersr w. - 4 -.- - 04 . t f 6 'ell to he giToo ;94 v vio Nta teki•iti , _ , 1 , . w i r it 4o4.loeJJ, us" ~,theyi t tfotiLirtgreetroThili 'bossed . irif t ;o„44, pa ¢, „ ~v A „ L m A k Right 4op. i aeMan ißid;ll 'did not moving hie A ad i t '' --- ,-- . '' atelt en ~