Star. — London, England, 1823-02-21 00:00:00

i . - industry, and research, rather than its accuracy. The' appointment of the Committee, however, was still a precedent in point. A Committee had also been ap pointed on the motion ()Ibis Hon. Friend, the Mem ber for Shrewsbury, for ascertaining what Members of that House held places under, or derived emolu ment from the. rown ; and the motion itself had been • made by the recommendation of the Chair.— The Committee, for which be should move, would !rave :the Means of ascertaining, .froth the different *dinning odcers, all the particulars required ; and athotigb there would, donbtlesi, be greet difficulty in getting a Return perfectly accurate, the Committee could gain its object ; for a general Tteturn .made with JOleriible accuracy would be sufficient. ;The House would remember, that when the Committee of Education was appointed, they wrote for infotma- • tipn to the Clergyrnen of every parish in the kingdom; that they obtained many answers, some satisfactory, and others not; that from some they obtained no re turns at all ; but still they were enabled, by the in formation they actually did obtain, to compile a most valuahle. document, commonly' called 4 , the Educa- ! tion Digest." The information which he should wan: would be very material ; and lie bad no doubt it might: be gained by the same means and in the same manner. 'He had heard, however, that what he now asked. would tiiit be granted by the opposers of Par liamentary Reform. He thought those opposers al ways took higher ground. He thought they had always said, We admit your facts, but we contend the House iu its present state works well." Would tkey now, at a time when all Public Institutions and Constitutions in general were so minutely scrutinized, would they conceal from the Public who were their Coriatituents? To refuse this motion would be to abandon the ground they - had previously taken. Not only would their opposition be an abandonment of that ground, but it would little avail them ; for the Returns for which be called were already before the *mid, though not in so correct a form as he wished. :They were stated in books extensively circulated, and Omer -4y relied upon. These facts were known, and others were divulged not less hurtful than the former bi the - reputation of the House. It-was well known, for instance, that at a recent Borough Meeting in Cornwall, a letter had been read to the Corporation, from a Noble- Peer, then the Patron of the Borough, declining to be 'such patron any longer ; and report added, - that he bad so declined, because he was so diigusted at the numerous applications which had been made for his patronage by the voters of. the Borough. When 'this letter had been read to the Corporation, one of its-Mei:niers, a Member,'too, of that flouse( gear, hear)—rose and isropased drat it iilitsuld be .orferedio,anot4ic Noble Lord, a Whitler also of the Upper HOuse—(Hear, 'bear) ;-and iiith regard•to - this infer, it seas'to be &served, that the last-mentioned noble Lord 'had iso property or elan mid= within 1C) miles of the Borough t so that the - argument about the fair influence of property and edenection Wm the ground,. and there was no pos. • Ole doubt' . that the, transfer Of patronage was to be fora plain, sUbstintial; valuable consideration. All thitairas notorious; smd f its notoriety could not but confirm the seepicions of the People, respecting the constitution of that House. He feared that what was proposed 14.. one side of the House, was generally opposed by the other. But yet, he submitted to the char 'information besought was necessary, in Order:that they might come to a fair consideration .13ftheijirestion of Reform. Whatever might be the opposition made to his motion, or what its result, he was convinced he should have the vote of every un prejudiced man; and that, if the motion were to be riveted, the country would be satisfied that die House was afraid to have its own constitution knoivn to the Pubiie. The IsToblicLord concluded by moving—. 44 That a Select Comniiitee be appointed to inquire into the iriihrof Voting on dm Election of Members to serve in Parlia. saiitt-for Cities and Dorouglu, and the number of persons Leer eia!ng that right." • -•-•`Mr. Secretary 41414641 G said, he was sure the :Viable Lord -would adMit 'that he (Mr. Canning) had ,tenet only tilfornned hi* that lie should • oppose the 'minion, litit that lie itad also stated the grounds of his intendfc i Opposition. He should not enter into • .1 - oAer question which was connected with this - .tuition, but, should coitemt himself to the merits of itre'tpecifleiliOtitin *fie knew, however, it would lie*felt• by the Pnblie, anilthis must he acknowledged by the noble I:ord,. that, if this motion were carried, it would be, thought that the general question of Re . Itirnkliad'imade considerable progress, .and that the 'oppolition hitherto:made to it had in a great measure r lieeu -withdrawn. 1-le believed that in one, he was sure that iu the other of these suppositions they would • be mistaken. ..He should, however, guard himself against drawing any. inference as to the possible con aeqbences of the motion; and, as he before obServed, should meet it on its own grounds. So meeting it, . he bad not the feast hesitation to say that the motion involved the most arbitrary and tyrannical principles. Many of the points to which the examination of the proposed. Committee would be directed, had already been ascertairied and decided by the House. The . right of -voting upon contested elections Stood re corded upon the journals. As to these, therefore, the proposed . inquiry was unnecessary, because the Jour nal themselves could be referred to at Once: But, as to those Boroughs, the right of which was not . 'io aseertained,• many. of theta were held by_ Charter; and were these prarteis to be exposed to eilleha tiod, and conscqpently, perhaps, to forfeitire?'Stids a proposition had, never, he believed, Veen that Haase since the reign of Jinies the SeCOnd. ' - jt • vitilla be a s 'great . er r stretch'of poem? in the Waist to call for such an.esaluipatiOn„ as it would be in there to calf for. stn eikaitliatibotif tire itlb'fleis'ofèststes ( —;-:( is ekeei set 2velie troi4irox..eiltb;d. # 3 , Miiiis. • pi iv'ateYiMits were finitided • upon :chlrterki, fear rnstmek acid 'Mani *them' Mir* "Tor the ; to - rot*Atkails, t o ookblepootio ; soireeattorney irbistid.noisttc -ile!ii... Wit ;tilteli•spirli at NuirY, to the 'rights OF indirr2riVlillOfirtibiiii? • . . • i t ilril()KgßElSSEltt, Said, did hot s prOpOiac the - 04 . irtii(ifift % r Charters. , • 'gr'*rtkOrr. OAI4II'II.NA 'laid, it • certiihtly ; 40 'stated - 40iiite.of iltiotkow given by the Noble :turd; . :ilitc;ltikhritan, - S&tietary - here 'referred to • the fierce 440%40011a 'Charters.") -He world • - , :thealateit• as, e - Nab' le .turd'e motion-nbw He did not propose the exignination of Charters-- Then how was the object of the motion to be 0b... • • . tanned? --(Hear, hoar.),-trOlt virp,.nat alp*: Lord had AdMitted he did isot.elpectTerfeet racy ; but. how . was any information ..to be obtained: beyond That popular floating knowledge -la' which the Noble Lord had alluded?. Be (Mr. Canning) con tended, that no more accurate information could be obtained without the eximinaflon of Charters.; and • the sort of popular knowledge in question was never contested by the opposers of Parliamentary Reform. If it had ever been.disputed, then, indeed, the Noble . Lord would havea right to call for accurate infor mation. This species of knowledge was never, to his recollection, denied, in the course of the Many de. bates which had taken place on . this subjeCt, long be fore the Noble Lord had taken it under his pi-titre tion. He (Mr. Canning) never remembered the fact, that Boroughs, containing very few voters, sent Mem ' ben to Parliament, to have been denied in the speech 'Of any one Member who opposed Parliamentary Re form. For his own part, he had always set out in his argument, upon the very admission of this fact. He always, for instance, conceded the fict, that two voters only sent Members for OltlsSirum: No point was ever made upon the supposed denial of this, or such a fact. No obstacle was thrown in its way.— . - His opposition to Parliamentary Reform was, that the House of Commons, with all these acknowledged imperfections, was adequate to the performance of all- its Constitutional duties ; and that he, and those who thought with Wm, dreaded change more than they desired improvement. lie should not now go into the argument, whether he was right or wrong. All that he said was, that there never Mad been any disposition to dispute the assertion upon which the necessity of a Reform in Parliament was advocated. In short, all was admitted in the way of fact, which the Noble Lord desired for the benefit of his argu ment. And, after all, he observed the motion of the Noble Lord was imperfect ; for he did not call for the number of voters in the different counties. This could be ascertained without much difficulty, particularly in the Irish counties, to all of which the Registry Laws applied. But with respect to the number of voters in cities and boroughs, he would ask the Noble Lord, ,by 'what scale be would proceed? If he intended to go by the elections which had taken place last Session Jibe did, the return as to all the places at which there had been no contest must be nil. And even_ in those-at which there bad been con tests, the return would tie inaccutate, unless the poll ing had proceeded to the exhaustion of all the voters. In Liverpool, for example, the electors, at the election before last, were polled to a considerablesiumber ; but at the last election he believed not more than two hundred bad been polled. With this doubt, 'there fore,and this uncertainty, a popular estimate would be,quite sufficient fisil'a popular argument. That es- Onsets was Conceded to the Noble Lord by his oppo nents, .so 6.44 his own view, the returns he wanted.were spite unnecessary. The object of some was to cutoff dieseieccant parts of our Constitu tion; but that of the Noble d was to retain them, notwithstanding their deiradatiOn. No man ever had been, or ever woufd be so absurd as to found his case upon an argument in favour of close boroughs. It was admitted dint they were small and limited, both as regarded the functions they were destined to perform and the share they had in representation. All this was admitted, and whatever force the' admis.siois could give to the - Noble Lord's:4lti*mM, he had no wish to deprive hiin it. Lie did not think he would gain anything . fromit ; he thmight great prejudice would be a rrayed against it were the House to: sanction such a cause. When fi rst the Noblk Lord gave notice of his m ot ion, he had applied him self *to consider how far it would be 'practicable to pricure die information he desired, without the in strumentality .of the evils. he had pointed nut. But he had failed in his endeavour to devise the means. To a Committee, therefore, for such purposes lie ob jected. First, for the reason he had mentioned, that the effect of it Must be to bring the charters of the Boroughs into question.before such a 'tribunal ; and next, because he was convinced it would bring on the question as to that title, considerably more than the Noble Lord, in his candour, had assured them hean ticipated, but not more than his judgment must int form him it would be pushed. He wished 'to agoid the prejudice which must be raised on the one hand, and on the other, he could see no possible *ay of ar riving at the complete information desired by the Noble Lord. His other reason .was, that whatever benefit the Noble Lord could derive from the full completion of his hopes from the motion iis'already in his possession, as far as admiSsion or concession could give it'to hiM. In declining to-give Slip port to the Noble Lord's motion, he assured him he did it without the smallest feeling of hostility:, 'and, without a desire to throw any impediment in the; way of the motion he was about to bring forward oni the main question. He would be ready to meet it, When it came, with perfect candour. It touched, he apprehended, no feeling-or passion that could find a place in that House; at least so he felt it.: Ideienuld meet it with temper; Wirt; for the preasit a ' Be muiti .oppoie the motion beforethelkuse, asbeing, for_the Noble Lord's • Mitpc4es,;enneitiesarY—(l-rear, bay). Mr. A BERCROMB,lf•nssured , the :flight Hon. GentlemanoppositetblnCimnine, that after listening 'With great attention to *bat he had said, he could `,discover. only. ` fv q`.grourids'i non Viliith'he 'opposed the motion of his Noble Frlend.; one oferhich existed only. in the inn egination of the Right' Honourable Gentleman, and the Other waifotinded Only upon an es,aggeration,,or,. he d father an ninten tonal inistepresennuion ofbis NOble ftiesici f . In pre , ceeding toexamine them, he would pat esitirelyout of , t;be; question the Bight flenourible Gontlertian's views _Whit .030erbr:the'tood of his • Noble Friend. His RobleFriendilesired certain in-[ formation, for. Which -he moved. and with all tiefe-1 vence,he Inuit beg leave tosay,:th otitis Noble Frien ds seas.rnastlikely.tobe the best judger of bow far that information would- serve .him ornot, sought- it for his own purposes, and no doubt wouldknowhow to deal with it. The 'Bight. klentrurable uientlenian supposed that the whole world teas ripe and ready,in-T -the event of-the motion -being curried,. and 'the .in-1 quirt* instituted, to-expect& sweeping Reform. Then, . -if .so:slight a cheynutaiieb werecapahle.tif governing the public opinion. upon this sabject,the public mind must be deeply impressed with-an idea. of :the netts-4 sky of some such thatigtvaiad that it was the assay - at House.to pas:gnome such. measpos. ...r . Dritmoitld knot be better to take experience as a guide it place ,of the imagination the Right honourable Gentle. i • • . . ,ealas already a precelent 'to gist t " 7 eiNeetion of the title dyed . But 4se , triti:anti 4;44 ~.vin- t ht case Ai :bis klenouvable Ft iend 1 0 1 .4entiertrin saes he has got a • precedent : and tine l e. ..erberefeir Lanark , Did any one suppole that , . qt- mu was, did that precedent hpply? The ninti cause he4llAd•got the same information relative to the i.fierf Scotch electors had, he believed. been called feeehOldesi of Sentland i. that that, sweeping Iteerirm for in in the-case of Ireland. and the call wit, easily ettpected by the Right Honourable Gentleman was a I answered, for the freeholders werere, t i,,ere ( l. Bak :bit the 'nearer , ?•,( Hear, hear).—He had. seen no i.was this done through. the med . ea 0f,,,a. Comrni symptoms of the public alarm foretold in such eland if not, how did the prec ,nt apply? Int • • juncture of circherstaoces, arid if, it hed not Lame i s departed from the means for merly pursued Tor fro a person of the Hight Itoneurable tienifemans I same professed object, how co uld they preveat -till rank and station, he should say It was a mere chimeta. inference that some 'stake .views actuated them ?..,.. The question•was, whether the mode of seeking this 'Wean Addeli 051 , if no lean - view information was of a Parliamentary nature or not? Noble Letd, how.caine jt.tlaat ; in none A. and here. was a case in point—a . precedent . which, rel . :A*s.9e the subject or ltec tu n s - „bid is, with all his acuteness, the Right Honourable Gentle- matter,' until "the Tion.,,Wemb'ee !. tlt! man had not ventured to allude Co. The motion then Creeveykgeve him ille . ,bint ? " fli at 04 Was useful in its nature, and ,proper in. ite,fotte r . right by a eirptionot thie,leira to 'prejl Useful, to enable them to comparethechaegeswhleli cutsionon-the.que4l2l4.4,l44'or*L Let had taken place in population with the „aurehauged. , h e met fairly, and npilieceight infix a s state, of the elective franchise ; and &Mier, by the ens manner. On the ginutill,Lthererore, ._ precedent which lie had quoted.. And eigethey, - to not wish*, prejudice the greas question OTrt-.....,, forego this merely because the Right Flononeabte military Reform, he 60950 tie motion. Gentleman admitted what he found it difficult to . Lord J. 11.USSELI. Wished to know,, whetter-% Oily ?—( Hear, hear).---The fact was ; 'the 'Ri ght Was to understand the Tiiiht HOnourable Secifiritettit Honourable Gentleman. had a fearful eye on the Ilth thatif he moved fer a Return he would not oppose Of March, and, he felt that this information if Ob- If so, he would give up the motimelor a Cottieniti l ie: tained would make a deep impression on.the minds Mr. Secretary I'E4 *Mild be teedy to meet ar of many persons, And assist his Noble Friend's Mo- otipn the. Rasle s Lord might think,proper to niake. _ tion eventually. And so far he could agree with But i he cou ld not allow, himself to be drawn in to him, inasmuch as there was a great feeling in the pledgehierielZherei:ehand which course he would take. minds of a vast portion of this country as to the Mr., OAM/a having, been aHuded to as the per.. . necessityOf Reform. Bat because the imagination son Who originally suggested the motion before t,. of the Right Honourable Gentleman was alarmed at fleuse, would brief!) , repeat the grounds upon whiel the approaching 11th of March, the House was not he had suggested it. He bad stated to the HouseN, to be deprived of what it had a just right ,so expect. that the population had increased from five millions Then as to the second ground of objection to the mo- to eleven millions within a given period, but thic tion, which, as he said, was founded in exaggeration while the population was so increasing, the mono of his Noble Friend's views, the fact was, that his poly of the elective franchise remained exactly where Motion had nothing at all to do with the Charters:— it bad first been, and the : number of electors not But. theßight Hon.Geutleman supposed that his Noble much increased. With airiew, therefore, to ascot.. Friend was to be assisted by some astute persons, for taro and expose the exact ratio in which the two had the 'purpose of picking holes in them all. It was not proceeded, as i egarded each other, he. pr o v osed that so, but merely to ascertain what constituted the -that course sh,.uld be taken which ha . been adopted right of voting in the different boroughs ; and that by his Noble Friend. The Right 1-1(1,6 Gentleman this would be a most useful, and was a most neces- opposite (Mr. Canning) said, he was ready to admit sary inquiry, could not be denied, when so few Officers that the Members were, as he stated they were, and really knew distinctly what did constitute that right, thereupon wished to put a stop to the motion. This which they were every day called upon to decide.— was the first time that such language had beenheld Beyond this it was the object of the motion to ascer- by the Minister of the Crown to that House. Ho taro the number:of freemen in each place. It might be never had in view the calling of the Charters in ques true that, in a large place like Liverpool, to which, no Lion, and he considered the House bad a right to the doubt, the mind of the Right Hon. Gentleman natu- information. In former times, there was'an Act One rally recurred, it would be hard to make this return; hibiting every man from voting who was not actually but in all such cases the greatest number that .had a resident in the Borough.; and at one time there ever voted at an election would he deemed a suffi. was. an attempt made to repeal that Act, in the reign dent answer. He thought he bad made it out clear of Queen Elizabeth, hut it tailed, the . dill not getting that his Noble Friend was entitled to his, motion— beyond the. Committee. It would be well to contrast (Hear, hear).—And why the Right Hon. Gentleman the language of that period with the practice of . the should deny this motion he could .not understand, present times. The Honourable Meuher then reid unless it were that he thought it would make for an extract from the speech of some Hon. Member that question of which he was the known advocate in a former Parliament, which. recited.—" That a and champion—Wear, hear).—For his part he cared Duke of the realm wrote to a certain Borough, salr. little whether it was carried or not, when regarding ing, that there was something to come on shortly Ile it in that point of view; because he was satisfied that Parliament, upon which lie was to summon ail his more good would accrue to the cause of Reform by friends; and that as he considered them among ,t his the refusal than if it were, agreed to—(Hear).—For friends, he sent them four name = , begging they what would be the construction of every plain ra. would elect two out of them to return to IPAI imment. tional mind upon such conduct? Would not such -,-They answered the Duke in all humbleness, that a mind naturelly ask this question—" What can in- they .were prohibited by law from doing that \Oriels duce the HOuse of COmmons to refuse This informa. he desired of them, and many others answered in'the• dour—rear, hear).—Such, lie- contended, would same way; by the law, saying that liberty, was a loss bete e'chet of it—and what 'would be the plain ra- of liberty, if left to act as they pleased in such mat done' answer to that question? It would be this— ters, without being limited by lair." The Speaker " Nothing, but that they are afraid of the disclosure r also observed, " that it were a pity but all. DOWIII had —(hear, hear).—That was the light, and the' only answered in the same way, for then tiaery had . not light in which the refusal would he'regarCled by the been,so robbed as they were." The Act which proliis Public at large. . And then he put it .to the Right bited non-residents from voting bad existed rip to Hon. Gentleman whether he would not hasten that the 14th of the htte King, and it was a pity it had crisis which it was the object of his opposition to ever been repealed. They should then not see as f(ie)f retard or prevent ?—(Host, hear).—Then Would he did now ; every day, not Peers merely wr i t i ng to Bo not give that impulse to the public mind which he roughs, but Peer and purchaser going down togeiher. dreaded—that .mind being already prepared; and They would not now see Cornwall an open maihex viewing with different feelings, in a different Wie r for such purchasers as the philosophical Member for and occupying itself with a greater earnestness now Bodmin could tell them it was; nor would it now-ar than it had eeer before done,. with the daily ed. days be a topic of political conve rsat i on , as to w h a t vapcing . eause . of Aefostn....(M or, hedr).. . , . sums had been laid out in an investment. of freemen .-.• Mr. Secretary.. PEEL seid. that notwiffisitunfing , With regard to the question before the House, the the speech of the Hen. and Learned Gentleman who Right 'Honourable Gentleman opposite (Mr. Ceti- Iticl i ist iota town, he intended to resist the motion nirsg)- told- them he had turned the matter in bis tOiore th i ellouse upon precisely the same'grOpecls mind, and thought the appointment o f a C omm i ttee as th osiurged by his Right Hon. Friend, (Mr. Can. would not be available—and this was the only mi ning) and he was prepared to contend that the Atm surer that was to be made to it. The excellent speech land Learned Gentle Man had not succeeded fn weak- of his Honourable and Learned Friend (Mr. Aber- Autjug the foie, of those grounds—(Weir-onm the , cronsby), in favour of the notice, could not fail .to .Opposition.) First of all, the Hon. and ,Leerned strike every one who heard it as unanswerable,: and Genttenian set tut:with the inference that his bight lie hoped it would* prove so. - Hon. Friend was afraid of thedistlotetesthat would Lord MILTON said he rose Merely 'for the pate ' result , from the appointment of the Cotumittee. liow pose of ascertaining on what grounds the motion of was it possible to draw such an inference when his -his 'Noble Friend was to be resisted.' it was ditficidt first avowal Was, that he conceded all that could be to reconcile the objections of the Right Hon. Meas. inked on that score ? . .(1-fene, hear.) Could he then ber for, Harwich (Mr. Canning) with the bejections le afraid Of discloinres, when he himself admitted of the Right Hon. Member for the• University of Oi. their full Weight ? The Hon. and Learned Gentle- ford (Mr. Peel). The fi rst defene e d hi s . opposit io n stand/ en sai d he 'would begin by throwing aside all on the - broad ground that such things were as diey the arguments of his Right Hon. Friend(Mr. Can- should be. The other Right Hon. Gentleman re nitig) in favour of'the .views of the Noble Lord- - , sisted, by asking was it prudent to exeose thedefee (Lord J. Itunell).hensidering that ,the mover - Must dire state of representation in .13orouglis? : Wbal he be the best judge of his - own intentions and interests. .(Lord Milton) Wished was, thatthey who voted on Why this was Is if a Motion made by an Honourable the motion would ask themselves whether . they Member in . that Rouse, became that Member's pri- grennded their dissent on the broad ground of. tie Me property,-,and as if it was not competent to ,Right'llon.,Secretary (Mr. Canning), or on the ex the* Houseto discuss the object and tendency of every . pressed apprehensions , as to imprudence, of the Right itiotiOn—(Near ; hear.) - Admitting. this right, was it Hon. Member for the U niversity ef Oifoid ?" Or, trot a fairnse of it to affirm, that the views of the • hear). The Right Hon. Memberlor IfarWic was -1/ Mover would riot be assisted by the motion he had willing to give further information if he could dee* framed, as the , information requited by-it ceeld not the means; the Right Htiii.',Meitiber for the'POO be correctlY Otkiined ?:- Was it Prudent - to ezpose,the sity of Oxford's oppositiOn was riot to the muner pit, L ectsofthe 4epresentatroe. 7 -(1-1e9; from the op. to the information - , (Hear,. heer). • According, to roadie . a.) .He (Mr. Peel). argued 'aiietkivring to the him, you might do-the tame. eke; in Scotland Ist, ''trews of the .NOlsle Lora,' and he - itifet, that if.fris the Boroughs in Scotland, is,inlEtiglao to ti1f . 0411,"" ,ibject.%vere to sheW the paucity 'of -Members upon holders, but iu Euglandit would Per impitidiow.,:* which Representation rested ,.- then , as regarded hiSs appeared - to hint (Lord Milion)•tlsiteshelsisotiqapf object, he could only draw from it-an illegitimate his Noble Friend wasjlefectisfe,inaiii*Uriklkiiiti inletenet. •if his real object were . merely to put a .itself to electors and vopulation, 'Without% Maud . ~single qhestion to the o ffi cers who were to - appear 'that on' which all . atlmitted •repreiet ilf before the • Committee, why not put that question founded—he *meant the direct taxation:4;4d by Wits ilie . 'Comenittee?—(flear, hear.) If so, why Towns andtorporatiOns. . ,_ ~ -. , . „.,- fellow.uphiemotion by a call for persone, papers, . .. Nl'. PRELEin exPlarlln. l : 6 4 said tho lo 4i:Sikiii r Wat and record'? How could he offer to limit the power, h bi e s tait ": in she ,,,.. l s dt g i : th t e he int aj l e : t in io e t rit itof a x .. t merv b9 11 . 06 661 ,4 4 ", :iiis er iv ' 7i i j ow 4° 1 1 4 . 14 or check the researches - of the CorriMitiee?. Might form , he net-be permitted s e have just alarms at seeing et any de ficiency *their. coseitiatiop.....- jale " 6lll .. j6.. ,.. 1F5. Committee for euclepurposes invested with ' unlimi t ed . ..,,n'lgir -.I L I. v.iiel v lrr. The Bowe then divniad on, Lomta's!. mums., 4 • powifie? -He .agreed .with his flight Hon..liriend, ,- . 41" • - - ~ po Noel - - Ili - that the same vigilance and jealousy ought to silent . ; ,,,,„1, 1 , ,htejerity ..,.t , . ,-I . • Pe; ,t • ..;..4:48 .-.. this species of right, as guarded Private property , • : Nr.. W. Win moved coat th'i'reki,kiiii-,; ‘ ,.o ) „,ee t p, e where nothing but litigation could justify the pre- a . lierera at thi s_____kniczni, trenitahrary tart to, toss; ef-dso ~? j a bil"ac his Po d s A he ndectti : Ap i *.fix light it )06 :Odic* alf.lifrt ,t that 4973 i i 7e, Mr* Lion ^AA coil; 71 ) i i :A