Star. — London, England, 1828-12-15 00:00:00

Tr I i. .- --.-~- r - thought it tight stud sufficient to look into the school of Cline and Cooper fora surgeon to supply the vacancy in the hospital. But he was the nephew of Sir Astley Cooper. You will see by and bye what the libeller says on that subject. Your do not know it set unless you have read the newspapers. He has attempted to. prove that ohich he has had the audacity to allege, that it was ssetely through the insttumentslitrof Sir Astley Cooper that Mr. Branshy Cooper was put into that situation, without regard to his merits. Has he proved that? He has proved the very reverse. You will doubtless remember Mr. Harrison's evidence, upon which 1 say nothing, for soy, time is not yet come to comment on th at. I have stated the history of Mr. B. Cooper, and the pro gress that has made him one of the Surgeons of Guy's Hospital, which has made him subject of pity to some; but he disdains all pity ; he appeals to this Court for its interposition, to protect him from the malice of this Editor, and the enmity with which he has at tempted to surround him. It is now time, Gentlemen, you should know who the defendant is. I know no. thing myself of Mr. Wakely, nor should I have known him except for the occurrences of yesterday. I could only then note the extreme ignorance and folly which he possessed. But I am authorised, Gentlemen, now to say, that he is as ignorant of his own professon as he is of good taste. I speak of him only from yes. terday, for I never beard of any of his operations. He is known, however, I believe, to the public exclusively for publishing the Lancet, which he tells you he estab lished. In doing that, it was for the purpose of pub lishing lectures, avowing that he does it for the purpose of committing plunder on the property of others, for the purpose of assisting himself. What, tientlemen, are we then to hear it said that if Mr. Cline or Sir Astley Cooper, or any other eminent surgeon, should compile a course of lectures, and deliver them to the pupils of his own class at the Hospital, who pay him for attendance, and remunerate him for those labours , that a particul ar paper shall rob him of all advantage, and, without.his leave, make them public, so as to give to all the pupils in the kingdom who desire to study this art, all the advantages this Gentleman thought he bad himself established? That he shall injure him and . rob him, and gain tea times more than he does himself, who has been at all the labour of compiling such lectures, end which would make it unnecessary for them to at. tend, because all the advantages del ived from the atten tion of the pupil to those lectures may be gained by .reading this work? These contributions to the Lam* make it worth 5 or ` OOOl. per !mum. The Editor has himself avowed. that it is a eibrk founded on rob bery and plunder. and that he receives contributions (rum pupils at the hospital, Whom he calls men of honour ; men who are iuducsd to betray their honour, .and who, by making contributions, furnish that which ought never to come out but by consent of the ,lecturera theipselves. But lie does not stop here._ He goes a step further, and I. am glad that I am ado dressing Gentlemen of edocatios, and only wish suety person to judge sightly of. this ; I ask whethes, what' any man had taken great pains so get these Wetmore. _which he had intended to publish himself, what he wool* have endu ed if a pupil, Who had Wee allowed toralet important notes, was to furnish them to a Gentian's' who. meant afterwards to commit them to press?... C•n any man suffer suss aisle as rhialto be mule of his work.? Suppose you had a written , communication. what would you say if the person whom you had in trusted with the key, of. youe cabinet had made extracts from it, and sent it to the Lancet ? Would ya u not think that man one of the basest of his kind ?-. And would you allow him to enter your doors again? And yet these art the contributors, these are the means by which he rolls in his carriage and laughs at the patties. I bare then, upon his own word, to say, that his work is a sort of binary raven, which lives by plunder, and holds up its head by the injoi y which it ina Ilia: on othe i rs. Now, Gentlemen, what is it be has don" to Mr. B' ansby Cooper ? In order that I Indy exploit that, j must by and bye submit to yaa r l am bound urge through a process certainly new tome; bat don't believe that Mr. Lambert, whatever he may. think of his own powers, or the pupil of sit months, or the demon strator of Mr. Slee's schooli some of whom are so longer pupils; don't believe that you have from them any information whatever upon it. The defendant has called but two witnesses who deserve the least credit. One is Mr. Alderman Partridge, who is a surgeon, and the other is a surpon, end also a dealer in potatoes--(A.laugh). ' , should have thought that when I came to observe upon Mr. Alderman Par ttidge's evidence, which I shall do without his petiole sicn, that I should have thought better of bins. if there had not been something in him that induced me to think he knew something of the defendant. I should have felt a great deal more had I. not thought that ' Gentleman had had the benefit of some others prom's assistance in vuttiog his questions, who might have prevented him from.displaying hisignorance. No doubt the editor and. Mr. P. will improve together.; and de pend upon is, whatever praise shall be due from. the. Loacet to Mr. Partridge, he villa have it ; bait he. must. allow me to state, that it willnot.be asy probe whichthe prole sion sill lone at, Doming fromsuch.a publication , a critical wto of this tostotehich mites& gs eataltal pasonal ibalds y with its repotts ofcasesof serge'', Ria bald y of this dercr ipt ion will no doutst havesonseareight pith the minds of the.tule,sr, but with pe'ple.of learn. ing and of honour it tending it mote contemptible.— Every man who contributes to•thattwosic is celebrated in it ; every one who does not is abused, trod he will get cut down Ity . the Lancet —by. the Lamberts. tbeWaisely s, and the youngpupilso astcFtliee will Is/lifted-spin it in aepetiosity of the pupils cif Mr. Cooper. Mr. Travers, and all the others who ate men of. tacit enlightened feelings. Gentlemen,. their is. a certain ptivilege which l'eloogt to this bleb profession; it is. safari thing, that is better felt than explained; and the man , that do e s not, feel it will Tit t be capable of. appse ciating. the arguments I address to your. In the or- , dinars , traffic of life, called commerce,. there is , a. );lain courseof dealing. of, sitsphrintegeitys that masks the line betweeo honesty.aud the meaning of it is well andersteod by every man. But in tbe.practice..ef a• lihersl profession there is a. certain feeling. of. helmet which becomes a Gentleman, and which a: Gentleman only can feel ; which renders it um sordid, bet which Fives it a character. which belongs to such a pralesaiosa— aa et t sin dignitya-aseatainpliiia whicbmakes aanaolikeli that profit is a.vcondary object.toblers.--that fame an+ reparation, apd means,of are. its greatest.re commendations—turd that everything elseis snoods& r . , Itother in the par fission at. the law, or the profession eqoally.honourahle. send, perhaps,. (wally useful, or muse so—that principle is alebaaedo-thot principle: is destroyed, it a man finds .that it depends.upos.whethea. tag makes coocessions or to to the editor. of. Owl:amt.+ lthe Ude. that it peed'. upon whether he maims mete). coot ri & bations—t ha t he should coos t the Nether, to smite that Nine wbsib.bilitre was acquired by honouse , xosten i t a ao a nd fair MOW, it introduces into the. sWtAr.s.!•sew of degtadatios. thee dispossesses halZs sod laally4lestsois it. Wbutsl4l youitoritay of the different situations of Surgeons—if • at this mo ment any of the persons in that honourable situation were to tell you that all their reputation was acqiiitbd by such means—ell the esteem of the public may be knocked down, and a man. if he has the misfortune to cffend Mr. Wakely, the Editor, or sonic centre 'botor to the Lancet, although a matt miy have that tight feeling, and those refined sentiments which would fit him for the honourable profession of a surgeon, yet still, having offended this prom, he is to be held forward to the public as unworthy of the situation which he holds? What, if in the law, as in every place where persons use employed in doing that which enables them to publish their peculiar efforts —if they were not to allow that lair competition in a Court of Justice to determine who is the Advocate which the public should employ; but that it should be given beforehand by suppression and false tepresenta don, would not that de troy the honour of the Bar? and would it not tend to degrade still more that ho nourable profession, if among themselves tersons were to be found capable of making replrts t f their own?— Such a thing cannot be found in the profession to which I belong. But it has an example in the profession of which we are treating to-day; for you have Mr. Lam bert, who is said to be a surgeon, getting his eight guineas a month; and depend upon it, Mr. Lambert's lame will depend much more upon the fime he gets in that publication, than he will get from any other honourable member of that profession. Such a coarse it is that degrades a profession—such a course it is, that, from my very heart and soul, I wish such a profession could not be so tainted.— I return now to the immediate subject of the operation which Mr. Cooper has performed. He is now, 1 believe, at the age of 34 or 35; he has performed many opera tions for the stone—many at Guy's Hospital ; his suc cessful operations have not been reported—l do not mean to say that with respect to others of greater expe rience, or who have peibrmed greater numbers of such an operation—l do not mean to contend for an instant that he is greater than them, but 1 speak of Mr. Bransby Cooper, who, from his experience, has performed many of the operations most difficult and complicated—this operation of the stone especially. Now, I shall endea vour to state to yvu this case particularly; but you are not to understand that 1 am giving you a lec ture, or stating more of the anatomy of the case than the course of this proceeding makes it necessary I shoold be aware of. Gentlemen, there was a time when this unhappy. operation was attended with almost certain loss of life. The improved surgery of modertxtimes has much improved the consequences of this disaster, so that the number of those who die, in comparison with those who are saved, is very few to what it formerly was. I believe it is generally considered now that the Dumber dying isabout two in fitteen—that is one to wren and a half. Formerly _they very rarely escaped. Atone time the numbers were as one to four or five, now it is one to seven and a half. This disorder some times attacks infants, end in that feral it is ‘. most easily desk with. Many persons are of that iender age that she stone may be retracted almost to a certainty with bet hazard. With others the danger increases ; but I. believe that Mr. Bransby Cooper has performed the Apperation on perhaps one of the oldest men that eves suffered it—a person whose age was eighty seven. The operation is never performed on an adult till he himself feels that the pain he suffers, or the ap rreheosion of the loss of - life, is greater than the risk of the operation. Every man must kids* of that by his siva feelings; these is something in the apparatus:more teirtble than in the operation' itself—something that operates on the "Wad against being the subject of it ; and it is nothing but the extreme pain, or the apprehen sion of the loss of life, or under the hopes of being re lieved it, that gives a party courage to submit to it. You easy suppose, therefore, that no surgeon was ever called upon to operate unless under extremity, where the patient says, 4 .1 cannot live, I s must die un der it; the urgency is so great that I call upon you for instanl? relief. All judgment is at an end—you must perfotat the operation,- or I must. die." What course is left but to perform the operation ? Now be it understood that , the particular practice of different surgeons in some slight degtee varies; but they are all employed for the same end.. It is not any province here to dmoribe and remark upon the merits of the different schools. You have Wed that the French, hardly use any of the instruments that we do; we use the instruments that we think best, and those which *recalculated-to:give the least pain and uneasi ness-to the patient. The first operation, however, is to ascertain the existence of the done. This is done by in troducing through the Urethra a . sound—. 4 small rod of steel; this ihtroduced through the tender passage finds its way tato the bladder ; then by turning it about a little, if it encounters a hard substance, striking it. with the' instrument, the operator heats the sound of it. and ascertains the-existence of stone. Mat bring . done, then comes the operation. For the purpose• of the operation when I state to you the practice,. you will understand me as stating it' abject to any errors that may be corrected by and tela—the patient• is- tied down in the simplest manner, 'an incision then made in the perinsuns between the sittotuns. and anti.. The finger is introdeced into the bladder, and it.very often happens that where it is.the stoweis thrown oat in a moment without any other instrument.. In- children, the parts you are to operate upon do .not lie• far from the surface, and are easily reached by the finger. Improportion as the per- - son- becomes adult, the parts - swell, sod therefore it is netes4a, y,par dada, ly in adults; that bob mutants should' be had recourse to. No man shooldeverattempt to' attend• an operation- of. this' kind without haring a number ofinstrunseets with him.. He would be most• iwesumptuoutif be did. Theeye of the operator does M. to'see in what. situation the stone is placed' it is all touch and feel—consequently a variety of in. ptroments Meat be necessary; and every man' who at• tends as a surgeon knows-that he is bound to have all the inurement' that ale used in the school of surgery ,''which be has been taught. The first operation is then to iotrodnee again into tl urethra this -sensed or staff. Mr. Ban a most eminent surgeon of the-Hospital, has Oeen himself.theinventor of the staff. He considers it: highly , useful. Somme it, 101111 410 not ; that is mere' matter of etioioa. What heoalls'his staff is *straight' 'ick, net curved, with apolini The urethra is a long. canals-which passes throve, what is called the prostate. gLied, before it entere.the bladier. In the restate gland it has a communication with other pans of ani mal life which V- need-not allude to: Bet it isepnred into' the • Mudd.... On pausing the gaff, you pear. pate the opening into the prostate 'gland, and- it is inserted. into..the bladder. The staff has a curve in it atthich isspiacedlio.frons, and-between the legs of the pawns , a ed 4bruSe of the cesveisethat when- the opts fatOf imroduees his' knife it ;Ouches the point of the curve; . when the point of :the basks iathe stall be then knows;he is iathe true. direction of the urethra-ether Nether., can getthet predate glatnl. tot briagielp the.. its* faairerd, aail.alsesiat its pinkie& a bake be seefilne tbr , WANT. k Japed 3eleieß 41001 went on to explain the mode of operring at some length.. If tile forceps cannot find the stone, then the s'onnd is introduced through the openi ig. and it is a common practice. if the stone 'cannot be felt, to try sounds of dilly/at forms. The stone May be enfolded in 1 1 e Masan., or so suspended that it may be extremely difficult to get at it. Then the operator has reef nese to thilireoop, which is an instrument like a tea spoon in Atra shape. With this an exertion h made to touch stone, and thereby cause it to fall, so that it may be got at by the foiceps ; now it sometibus happens that there ate cases in which the most XlOlllll operator is baffled m his exertions to reach the stone,' or to find fit the position of it, and whete the cause why its si u ition cculd not be ascertained has been only di-covered upon a pose reorient esamination. A tu•geon may be convinced thai the stone may be lodged somewhere, but still in a position where he can not reach it by ordinary means. In that case othel means must he resorted to, and a second incision may become necessity. This is the usual ci use of the opera; don; but I will come now to the riperation in question; which was performed by Mr. Branshy Cooper. The man had been sent up firm a oar ls's in Sussex. blow there were eminent surgeons at 11:14111 on, and it was these fore only fair to assusie that the case was ode of great difficulty, or the parish would not have gone to the ex pense of sending him to Londisn to be operated upon: Hoiever, he was sent to the Hospital, and Mr. Bransby Cooper saw him. Although he was a stbut man, with a hectic complexion, Mr. Bransby Cover ascertained that his kidneys were in I uisordered state, and that it, was necessary to postpone the operation onfil this dis order was ab teed. It was accordingly postponed, until the agony he sureied rendered the operation no longer proper to be delayed, until in sh wt it most be performed or the patient must die. Mr. Cooper made an incision, and these was an immediate lbw of urine—not a gush— tor under such circumstances no gush could ever take place. owing to the collapsing s f the parts. He then in serted his finger, butcould only reach the prostategland, and could not reach the bladder. This he spoke of at the time. Feeling, however, by his finger in the prostate gland, that the wound was in the right direction, he put the forceps in to see if he had reached the bladder. This was most easily to be ascertained by the forceps, for the forceps being shaped like a pair e.f scissors, could easily be expanded within the. bladder ; and it the stone was in the ordinary situation, would easily lay hold of it; but the forceps could not be expanded in a solid substance like the prostate gland. Ali. Cooper, however, could not find the stone, from its r xtraordinary situation. The first idea was, that the previous indications were falla cious, and that there was no stone at lei, and Mr. Cooper felt very anxious. as any perstronaight naturally be under such circumstances. He then had the option to carry his instraments all loons the bladder. to feel fur the .tore,which would have required fence to make a secoirsi incision; he chose the latter, and calling for Sir Astley Cooper kt,ife, lie enlarged the wound. and then again tried the forcepi, but without success:— He then thought he would y with the sound if indeed 'there was a stone, and then, upon withdrawing the sound, the curved point of that instrument stiuck the SWIM This proved that the stone lay, as it were, upon. the upper part of the pubes, and accordingly it became necessary to resort to the bent f eceps, which, by me :ins of its curvature, might touch the stone and bring it down. The bent forceps, however, could not touch the stone, and what then was to be done? The only mode was to make a wound 10 the prostate gland, large enough for the forceps to be introduced through it. Mr. Cooper then used the gorget, but not the blunt gorget. It was false to say that he had usedlhe blunt gorget; he used the setting gorget, which is like a prolonged scoop, and which has two advantages—first, that of making the wound sufficiently large ; and. secondly, the advantage of nor being able to make it too large, for it cannot make A wound beyond a specific sire. According to all the rules of science, the cutting gorge will make a wound large enough to admit the straight forceps,whicb, while the abdomen is pressed down, w ill catch the 'tea This was the course adopted, and it succeeded. It is perfectly true that Mr. Cooper did say that he could not imagine what was the difficulty of the case, but when he had di.covered the difficulty, he had used the most skilt ul and the most prompt means of overcoming it. The stone was flat and lay, as it mete, upon the shelf of the pubes. There was no pro trading end for the forceps to lay hold of ; therefore the form of the stone and its position fully accounted for its not bait caught by the forceps. What passed sib sequently ? That which always takes place alter such an operation, and which is due to science to be cart led into effect—a post mortem examination and presrreation of the parts. In the course of the operation Mr. ,Callaway had himself (and Mr. Callaway was admitted to be a man of skill) thrust his finger into the wound, to see if he could reach the bladder, but he could not do so. It was an utter falsehood to say that any force was used. He would call Mr. Callaway, who would tell them that it was a most gross and calumnious exagge ration to say'that any force was used. On opening the body, a Gentleman. who went to witness it for curiosity, put his- finger into the wound, and could not reach the bladder, owing to the depth of the peril sum. Dr. Hodgskin had not said that the perineum was not deep, but he bad said it was not deep in proportion to the size of the man. The wound in the bladder precisely corresponded with the external wound, except so far as a small slip of no importance in the prostate gland hid not hit the very spot of the original wound. There was Cellular membrane between the bladder and the rectums, which was very easily broken; but no breach had taken place, and it was perfectly sound. The kidneys were diseased, and that alone might have contributed to the man'sdeath without theoperation having been per formed at all. Mr. Hodgikin made an observation that this membianesrai easily licerable. and yet it was perfectly sound: As'sbon as Mr. Hodgskin turned his back, Lam bert took up the part, and exclaimed to these is an open ing brtwten the bladder and the rectum." upon which Mr. Hodgskin, who is a Quaker. immediately replied, " if tittle be an Opening, friend, it is thyself has made it," and he had made it. Mr. Kay would prove, and so would Mr. Hodgskin, that there was no opening when they had examined the parts immediately before. He should move to them the stupid ignorance of Lansbeit, for if be had sense, he would know- that if the opening was made by the forceps, it would have been traceable by the retrain:aced blood. But this was not the case ; there was no eitsavasated blood. I now come to Mr. Longboat, the contributor to the Lancet, at eight guineas pre Month. Mr. Lambert sweets-that. he knows mote of his profession. than Mr. Bransby Cooper. Ho MAN a communicatibn to the Lancet; Ylr.Wakely is a wit, amp Mr. Lansfsett partakes a little of thae•etwerta;ning se covnplishmeut. 66 My uncle's knife" was a portiere of Mr.Laimberes wit, and he had thrown the whole og.. currence into at dramatic shape. This it was, " My uncles knife; and half t dote* other instruments.. rod 0161 , 0111 i examination—On Tuesday layt an .per. slow took' plate by Mt. IL Cooper, and tbashwert used Mi. Kars Icalfaatia cutting tolo,, M unclesioilik Tog" *es slid tin Wdftdar staples go 'might be exp.ecte4, the nianAlied.'" Now, what think you of the taste iWa man wis es ' such an operation, and who had thus then thrown a description• of it into a I know nut, if the choice were given Should choose to be the inventor of gross and false as it is, or the reporter and yet eapabie of throwing it into nth a k After reading the libel. and commenting passages, the Learnt d Gentierrian said • was now :is Court. The libeller m. avowing, " I did publish all this arid som and substance of the charge is true an unskilful man, and most .unfit to Gay's Hospital." The last defence of to the foto*ing effect I am Editor in which I publish reports of the eases the public hospitals." fly the bye (said not know how Guy's Hospital can be , lic one, as it is not, nor ever was supported tribution. It did nt t &but its doors ag; went there for the purpose of science, anxious to exclude such as obtruded order that viey might invent and diver The Editor went on to say, " my t me in the usual course the report cf this tical ientarks, and I, as in duty b. und, bclieving it to be true, and not knowing —So if the Editor of the Liheei got whom he gives eight guineas a month ever infamou., be is in duty bound to world. Bad as that libel was, and has, motives which gave it biith, the defendant duced a single witness who did not entitle to a verdict. All the witnesses in succession beyond the possibility of climbt the false!! because the pleas on the recold were those defendant mast *tali or fall—those pleas pretended to have su . .porters ;e.ch witness not esiablish the truth of the charge,for the other. The fit si;and most competent pet in the witness box was the ,author of the that mars was Lambert; it was admitted upon two occasions differences with M. was suspected of contributing to the , turned out he was sec, iving eight guine his contributions, and mote according of matter supplied. At a dinner at he gave offence to the company, and Mr. Cooper and others to leave the were made to extract that fact from Lambert examination; at length' he said he - on finding his presence disagreeable Upon another occasion, a short time port which was the subject of the pre then suspected, but not then known, Lancet; it appeared he had used tin word invented by Mr. Wakely to desip inrge-ns, to make them ridiculous, and more popular. Mr. Cooper was offended soon. When questioned upon this point ".Lcertainly did not mean to give offence Did you not (I asked him') on your you would wa•ch an opportunity revenge? " I cannot swear that I did of warm temper; I cannot swear t I remember being called on for an be did watch his opportunity of des:ri Ili Went to the min* who gave him thing which no surgeon who has the lions to respectability would think of my honour,"says he to Wakely, “ it however, lops off some put of the libel , itiambert puts his finger iu between the rectum, and then says Mr. C. had forced that direction ; a statement which, unless tact beyond what could be supposed, have invented for the purpose of destroyinj Cation of an individual towards whom vowed vengeance. In the whole tout sional experience (continued the Learned I never saw a libel, the malice of whit tined? admitted. Wake!, comes for avows hitutelf—he throws the shield over must now pay the consequences. Don' t, *as any reason itrwhat he said yesterd, you that lie would sincerely regret the charge,should it tern cut to be untrue. ruin the fame and family of an innocent Gentleman, and then get off by. such No; he has made common Caine with it he be base, fake, and infamous, you defendant) are more so; you were nut levulence, you are a deliberate trafficker slander. It gives you fuar or five a-year, and law, reason, and feeling.. ought to be punished for so venal and base a man nha never offended you. No oilier reaps profit from this slander ; and the and the more popular the object of than more likely is it to procure an extended . The Newspapers, too, wire the precursors lumity ; they told those who were not that something was to be found in the the Lancet too shocking for ordinary forsooth, are to be the judge between the explanation which Mr. Cooper may you ; and you have the impudence, afro 'charge, to call on him for a further explanai some further remarks of this nature, Sir Je that the only res;.ectable witness pc:domed fondant was Mr. Partridge—he was, ' Learned Counsel could hear, a respect he possessed, as it was to be hoped he justice and of good feeling, lie %soul lesson now offered to him—never ag, of the skill and knowledge of any man, without first giving the opportL What difficulties might have presented la any ors ation which might at fir Mr. Partridge to have bees unskilfL The Learned Counsel said that he would case to go abroad even with the verdict it it could at the same time be said that obtained merely by some defect evidence. He would not consent to ouch terms. For the sake of the character he felt himself bound to produce as witnesses of that character some of the highest - men in the profession, and among die relative of his ever to be lamented mwel Romilly. After citing several a less aggravated libel the most exemi had been given, Sir James Scariest call' to mark their sense I f the serious inj, client by the libel which the defendant fished. He conjured them not to O a triumph to the defendant, or to bold to the scorn and contempt of the • who: they might conceive to be a but which malevolence and baseness a worn of triumph. 111 beside JAMBI had metaled, Hr. F. I mbers et the Lola. in Witch the alined tbs publication of which woe admitted t. Noa, Ce, wbo had wit . e l described i t , a . bee a dramatic CO en ate, %het; at such a cali f% dpe ter of it, if sehi ith ty i s ft at tut !Ida% on st .„, war that the ro:tee n.t them, • * bet d it is tit le hie he be a sr pct, if the iii, t o et by for of th e IP no es which „toe, be d Sit J atik*i.. considered 4 ", we tied by publi c Tit igainst those • floc t, although it pat id themselves, !minute calve sat ',palter bout Ca ihis case, with ( bee and, published i t. sioi Ito the colony. felt foam a per Pl 4 a fitsehood, h e ", nbl o publish it tog a , Mt base as were a t brio Want did net a 4 Sei intitle the plain; tar session estahii b. 6I it hood of the lid, tail hat by wtich d ie Si. ,leas cadet not h eels mess did motetti al r each contradictor per son to be ple ct 4 ma the libel hini. 4 4, It ,fitted that he k art Mr. Cosper. lk me e Lasted. It no, the ine4a a month Is t rag to the quantity int t Guy's 11. .• tea I was ordered the -le room. Ulm obi Lambert opal% the remembered dm apl he left the tam r i are before the se. Via resent trial, hes% pat ,tobe a spy to tie bet I,e term " Bai, " l i t i designate hospit4 the , and his woik tit h lll rded at the egad. if I Dint Lambert ail , Op meta >1 r. Coops: sot our oath say, the atti of having yea ,the iid ;lam a •* aft r that I said a; tCb n apology." To, Dies raying Mr.C• the in eight guine scat re slsghtest if accepting. “ is true.' Wa el before he' the bladder amide bet reed the foie:ere ON finless he was sm. the I, he must bawd hog straying the repo. 1,14 . 1 om he had before arse of my picks; ea twarned CoUnsel) I '4 hich was more aer as irward, and boldly bet rer Lembertogklbe hai 't suppose that there tit dap to you. He told he insertion of the e. What I would he I ar, eat and respectable is a whining 'scow? his reporter ; and, a uu (tattlitlß ti , the rat ot actuated by ma. • 0 4ficker in lies sae thousand r outset g. decline that )ce base an attack ups titer person but yed le mote respectable al that slander is; the ided circalation.— cursors of this ca. )t professional men. 01 he neat number d ' 1 r publication: Yos. n your own lies and nay wish to give re to after insetting the zalanation.—Alter • Sir J. Semitic said Ire:domed by t':e des It from all that the ' ectable man, and f• he did, that .ensell mild profit by the pin to judge tastily other protessiunal tunity of explaining theinselves to hie first view appear 11 tinily pei formed.— rould not allow this lief for the plamtif. that that verdict era in the defend o to take a verdict oa 'erecter of his cheat. witnesses in support . st and most emote • there Dr. Roe► aced friend, Sir Se- cases, in which foe . exemplary damage.' :ailed upon theJurf 1 injury aimed at hi . lent had that pub' • t v ii ne e ic d , o .a pP t b l en aPo y i : vei r g t a li t u iti di l d. d . q t: . 1 a P. rectocn pert , 0141 ,bled libel was coatleee. I by tbe Waldo& w'