Star. — London, England, 1811-05-31 00:00:00

/ / m.itc W Lie a Pl " 011 Vost 1..)11 Da tees AP Co ped 23, obi WI Et; urn Fa an ti t; f he made it, h e was engaged in. another concern, for the Appropriation Act was Duke of Boltun, that the House of Loyd: .wcu'dyearly sent for thei wherein IW must acquiee a muc h i larger fortune than concurrence ; hut if they altered one iota of it, the Bill thus be rendered useless. The Duke, however, did he now d eman ded . —( Near, haar.) not bring the subject before that House, and the Civil I was immediately thrown our.—ln all the precedents . List was made good by the Commons alone. In the Mr. BAN KES rose and said, that he concurred in adduced, the Lords made no complaint of the Corr most of the sentiments expressed by the Hon. Gentle- rnons infringing on their authority. The €3090 salary time ef George I. and of George 11. there were also 1 man who made the motion, because he thought lie which Mr. Palmer received, WAS given under an oreer numerous examples of such a power being exercised gone too far in asserting the rights and pri- of Council, without the authorityof either House ;and by that House. In 1758 the House of Cemmons, I had not i vilege of the House.—( Hear, hear.) —Great as those bad the present Ministry beenfriendly to hi m,he would without any co mmunication, actuated solely by pub privileges, however, were, it was necessary to keep have received the per centage in the same manner. It lac principles, addressed the King to augment the sa.l them within the limits prescribed them by the Con- was ridiculous to pretenddrat there were no precedents larks of the Judges, the Mouse of Iserts never inter posing, though theoretically sp eakin g they may.— stitution . He admitted the precedents which had in point, when those of the debts of Lord Chetharn I been referred to by his Hon. Friend, but he would and Mr. Pitt were before them, which were dischar. This originated with the House of Commons, and by I ask, whether the other House, on several occasions, ged under the authority of that House of Parliameco them was made good. In the present reign, there were also numerous instances of the exercise of the , had not exercised a similar authority without any which now reinsed to pay £54,000 m the man who complaint from the Commons ? He should not as- had produced so many millions. The answer in clues. same power. In all public monuments they de present motion, because he did net think tion,he contended, was without precedent. He would not only upon the grant, but also upon the merits ; sent to the of the individual. In the present reign , two signal I the word n su ffi ciency" applicable to the subject.— shew nnmerous instances of Addresses of that House, His Majesty" Ministers, in the exercise of their du- which were always answered either in the afFamativc, examples occur, in which there was no ieterference I ! ti es , were no less bound to watch over the ri g hts and or it was stated that the Address would he taken into on the part of the Lords , n o concurrence asked, no interests of the Crown, as well as the House over its consideration. In 1766 or 1767, an Address from the opinion given by them, though in one case a protest own rights and privileges, and he bel ieved the advice House of Commons was presented to the Crown, re. was signe d . hy the Lord Chancellor a nd the Arch to the Prince Regent to have been given ender that commending the increase of the Navy, to which the bishop ot York of that day. He alluded, he said, to im press i o n.—(Hear, hear.) — Knowing , a s the y must, answer was, that the subject would be taken into wo e . the case ot Lord Chatham, whose services he thought the determination of the other branch of the Legisla- sideration. But on no occasion couldthe recollect err .could not be too highly rewarded. In this case the term could Ministers have ad vised an y other than a instance of an answer like the present. In all instances was contested in the Lord s, June 2,1778, and se qualified Answer to the Addr ess of the House of where the House of Commons had said, that with se veral Peers argued against it. The House of Corn. mons, however, efterwas ds addre ssed Commons ? He thought t he Lords should p ossess specs to money matters they would become good to:- the Crown for a public funeral, and the right of checking improv ident grants of the public the same, his hleje9ty had al* eys replied , that hewould m onument to Lord Chatham, a money, which were sometimes made in that House, give directions accordingly. They were not or. this the payment of his debts. In a still later instance, more especially at present, when the public bur:hens occasion, to take into consideratioh what had passed upon the death of Mr. Pitt a monument-was voted, were so heavy on all classes of society, although lie between that House and the Lords. There were cases and the payment of his debts ; in neither of these cases admitted Mr. Palmer's public services had been ex- us ual i the Lords and they mitsht differ, and the were the Lords consulted, and in no way did they tremely useful. express their concurrence in the payment of Mr. Pitt's I mode nt proceeding was to' have a confereect Mr. LAMBE said, be had given all the attention !on the subject of difference. The Lords might con. debts. The sum of £49,000 was included in the ' Ain his power to the speeches which he had heard; since them that the y were in the wrong, or they pp roriation Act, and none of the sub j ects men- but he did not think the pre c e dents alluded to were might be brought over to their opini on ; but it was toned. The Loads , too, had desired the C rown to I exactly in point with the subject before them. He not for the Crown to say that we (the House of issue money for certain services, one of which was was satisfied with Mi. Palmer's services, and sorry Commons) were in the wrong; nor was it for the HOUSE OF COMMONS. the printing of their Journals. There were at present that he WAS not present when the remuneration was I Minister to say to the Crown that the House of learned persons employed by that House to investi- The East Country Dock Bill was read a third time and passed. ; voted him ; but he wished to avoid a discussion like I Commons were in the wrong, and to shut the Lord COCHRANE gave notice that lie would move, on this gate certain claims, who must be paid in that man the present, because it was the most likely of any to i Royal ear against their Address—(Hear, hear, hear.) s a y se'nnight . " That there be laid before the House a grapy of net. He knew not, theoretically speaking, why the excite that which was bad—he meant a party spirit, ,If such an Address as that they had presented to the the Table of 'Fees of Office hung up in the Aelm-ralty Court of Lords could not originate money bills, as a was only Malta; Copies ot the Correspondence between the Judge ot the of which they should be entirely divested. It was ; Prince Regent was always to receive such an answer by use that this was coat med to the Commons.— Admiralty Court at Gibraltar, and the Judge of the Admirahy , the undoubted duty of the Representatives of the 1 1 from the Crown, there would then be an immediate Court at Mal a, oat the subject of the condemnation of Prizes.- Nothing could be less desirable tb:m any altercation People to protect their rights and privileges entire; , end to all good understanding between the Crown a nd also Ce', bof a.Correspondence relative to the formation of betwixt the two Houses ; and at resent there was not the Offices of Judge and Proctor of the Court of Admiralty at the faintest trace of any dieputed point betwixt them. but with great respect for the Hon. Mover of the and the Commons. The Crown had said, if I ad ate, a. and the duties to be performed by the persons filling those , motion, had he really felt the subject as he represent- I vance the money, Where is it to come from ? This . . Ihe whole was betwixt the Crown and the Commons. o.tuations. ed, he thought he should not let one day pass over I was not .conformable to the usual practice. There laurel NULTON postponed his Motion respecting the appoint- The Crown says, it will not give effect to the vote of • . without calling the attention ot the House to it, and - never had been an instance in which the House had nem ot his Royal Highliess the Duke of York, to the Office of the House of Commons till Pat liament provide the give his most strenuous opposition to every bill whose voted money, and not afterwards made it good. It Con' iu elite, till next Thursday. means, language never before used in any answer to ' A m eo.age from the Lords, announciog their concurrence to object was to impose a burthen on the country, was to be presumed, from the vote of the House itself, an Address of that House—( Hear, Hear.) But the the Canada Rum bi ll , the Isle of Man Sheen 8.11, the cache - till redressed. He (Mr. Lambe) apprehended, that that the money woad accordingly be made forth, Oiler F.ills' Bills for £6,000,000, and i'i,.:GO C.Co ; and the Die- Crown thanks the House of C . I coons , sets not Par although money bills could not originate in the House coming. The Lords were certainly a branch of the O il Indemnity Bill, without a ny amendment- liament, when they tender mo..ey bills. With what of Lords, yet that they had the power of rejecting any I Legislature, and more nearly attached to the Crown 'lee Irish Lunatic nil was rtad a first, and ordered to be read grace does the Regent come when he asks sepplies a second tit= to morrow. • • for the army end navy? lie calls for millions and that passed that House. He observed, that the vote than the Commons; but if they should prove at any Mr. SWAN moved ter the printing of the Evidence of the of the Lords, respecting the foreign soldiers, in the time unreasonable, the Houseof Commons had wars Shoreham Road LIB to he po-tponed tid : hurbday next. ' hundreds of millions, :tad to dispose of them when reign of King William, was very anomalous, but very weapons in their own hands which enabled them to It was opposed by Mr. C. • iont,ss, Mr. P. Mooa t, and Mr. raised, every shilling of which is Applied by the Corn ust, and therefore the concurrence of the other House meet them. They were the great depositaries of the CaLcsarr, and sunorted by Sir JAWS Gil AMA M alid Mr. G. mons, and the Commons only ; and when we call . .1 VA a SITTA HT ; aftet which the Hall:it divide, when there ap- was reasonably to be expected. Future Parliaments, public purse, and by this means only emit! they cute upon him to advance a teilliiig sum, he say s, " I doubt i eared—For Mr. 3wati's motion 57--Aganist 36--Majority 21. , under these circumstances, ought to be very cautious stitutionally oppose orresistthe more power fulboinches you, you will be tette to your word.— (Hear. hear.) 14 AN UFACT UltlL:tS' PET:TIONS. n •g e. o . t imitating such a precedent. Ile wasof opinion, that of the Legislature. It was a new thing to say that Mr. BLACKBURN presented a Petition twin the Mantifac. I vvili not till Parliament provide zhe f e r,Osee- n ( ;it the last Address was improper, the practice should die Commons might not make good the sumsrhey had surer& of the town of IVi4uobeiner and its vicinity, praying ior a I Chancellor of the Exchequer here smiled )—tt . 1. un. be, for the future, abandoned. consideration o f the distresses under which thsy laboured, and t detstand (said ir. Whitbreee sLlte smile of the !tightpromised. Would the Minister, either in the House of relief front them. It was not his intention, he observed, to move i Honourable -en te, tleman ;he ti . usts to his skill in Par-1 Mr. WILLIAM WYNNE said, he had always Lords or in that House, say that the could not make any thing farther than that the Fetttion should he upon the table,' ~ opposed the claims of . Mr Palmer; but as the . House good the sum ? with respect to the concurrence of the i eetnentary tactics, to the friends whom his influence : but on some future day, he would move that it be referred to a had come to Resolutions upon them, he felt it his House of Lords, be contended that in such cases it may assemble, and his eloquence m ay convince. Any Coautettee. Sir R. 1-EBLF. earntstly called epos the House to acrtde to Member might ask his friends to come down, for Le duty, as an individual Member, to support them, for was not necessary. Ihe House of Commons had been the prayer ot the Petition. 'l lie richer pail or the people a Eng- . did not speak of u ndue influence. Last Session, the the same rea s on that he supported the vote of corn always in the habit of communicating with the Crown, land bad catered loto a subs:ription tor the Relief of the Pot tu- • eta enan Ird token the grant to Mr. Right Hon. G 1 . e . mitment last Session, although he was . against it in and had repeatedly voted sums by address withont the F acile, and he hoped they would lend an equal suppoi - t to their so de sated . the fi rst instance. He thought, however, that an Ad- concurrence of the other House. Were the House of unfortunate Countrynien. Palmer out of the Apprepriation Act, dress for money was not so eligible a mode as if it had Commons robe setified with that answer on the patio. gave 1115 hearty support to the Petition, the intention of the House. He would appeal to the ' Camel STANLEY : originated in a Committee of Supply, when more op- the Crown, their own Journals, fromtbat day, would as he telt convinced, from enquiry, that the c o mplaints were 1 House whether any gitts.. , ,tion had undergone a more well fcunded. full discussion, or was mei e powerfully opposed. IT _ po . nullities of discussion were admitted. He had date their degradation and dcrwnfalL (Hear, bears) if The CIiANCEIUOR of theIiNCHEQUER wi,hed the House n . itherto thought . a vote of that House sufficient males- we say we shall vote away no monde , unless the Lords to be put ia possession of the Petmon, and also made acquainted i was a contest haween the hliiiistee of the Crown and rity f or the issuing of money from the Exchequer. arc likely to approve of it, from that moment our pd with the titian of it, before there IV:la a day fixed for a Cljta ' a private man, in which the latter was ultimately, mattes ;. iN.C4IISC, IN cl e tnere ph postb;lity of reisevh , g the suf. 1 and, as he c onceivet n iustly triumphant. The Hoese Sir JOHN ANSTRUTHER observed, that the vileges are gone; from that moment it would be in terers eetol to the extent of their Veneto, the ordaing of had long since acknowledged the claims of Mr. Pal- qeestion was not betwixt the Government and the vain to hold Committees of Stspply. They ought a Committee nught create false hopes in the Manufacturers of but the Minister had contrived to deprive him FY souse, but merely whether the grant should have rather to have joint Committees with the House of success, and they might murmur when it was nr,t complied with. : met" ; been issued immediately. or whether Ministers should Lords, and make the disposal of the Supply a coMMOk He could not c onsent to gist hopes u here relief could not be given. of remuneration at the close of the session, when many 'I he Petition was then re;.d and ordered to remain on the table. Membets bad left town. ' This proceeding was justly have paused before they advised an answer until the , right. The great question was, if the House shrue... NIY. BLACKBURN presented a similar Petition from threw- lon Mattut..cttaes of Bolton rese n t vicinity, which was also read deprecate d . by 7it had been usual to grant money upon an Address forego an the privileges they had hitherto claimed, termed it an appeal from Philip sober to Philip drunk. and ordered to lie 0:1 the table. And the Gentleman who preseted them notified his intention Mr. Palmer next applied to a Court of Law, where which had its origin in a Commi tee of Supply for and been admitted to possess. H:s Royal Heir of bringing forward a motion reilectit:g them appeal on %Vol- be presumed he should obtain redress ; but altlmugh small sums, and afterwards gradually increased. He had been entrapped (Hear, hear) by the advice im ;motley lieu. , . .no exertion on his Own part, or that of his Cou rse was surprised to hear a complaint made because tht posed on him. Why s hould they go out of their Vll KING'S ILLNESS. • wanting, the Minister, by ev ery ove obstacle in his object ot the Address had me been immediately com. to creete a difference between the Crown a nd tee Mr. WHITBREAD stated, that in a y partly of what avand ta kin e advantage of objection, succeed_ plied with, when there were so many precedents to Commons ? His Royal Highness had been entrap. bad that day come to hi, ki.ossledge, it W - at mit his intuition tci w- , .ei . in defeeting his chtims. He hoped he should cotton the contrary. In the reign of Queen Anne, the House ged by bad advice, and he trusted, would know haw have brought before the House that day his motion tor provid- Cd ing for the supply ot the 1 7 .xecutive in the event of the King's that night be told that the further discussion would of Commons voted a sum of money in the same man- to appreciate it in future. incapacity by illness at any future period; but had be not been lead that House into a dispute with the House of ner, to repeir the fortifications of Portsmouth and Cha- The CHANCELLOR of the EXCHEQUER In possession of the information lie then was ,Ma he should Pot Lords— (Hear, hear.) .He was sure it would not ; thane, but was that immediately done ? No, the an- said, that he could not help adverting to the diffecnt Lave vressed his motion that evenine, as thes another sub- swer expressed her Majesty's satisfaction that a subject tone in which the Hon. Gentleman had spoken this which be was about to bring before the which he appre. but even if it should, lie did not know any right ilte:n t ed would occupy their aitention the rest of the night. Ihe which a.Minister possessed to oppose the sense of the .of so much importance had attracted their considers - night, and on a former night, on this subject. It was other questioo, however, respecting the Regency, he hoped to be Houseenpon a lu ll consideration ;end discussion of tion, and that she should order the estimates of the then stated, that it was an unconstitutional act, and a able to bring au some day in the mitt week, Friday, if possible. i the oestton. Should a dispute unfortunatel I expence to be prepared and laid before them. It was breach of the privileges of the House. A more ma. eitivierce. - certain that even now the Lordsmight reject the claims Berate tone had been now adopted, and a tone more y, tow.; ever, arise, it would be the duty of the House of Mr. WHITBREAD moved, that the Answer of Commons to fight its own battles, and not submit to of Mr. Palmer ; what blame could then attach to Mis- conformable to what he then endeavoured to shoo the Prince Regent to the Address of the Meuse on . the totelege of the Right lion. Gentleman -(Hear misters, for pausing till they should know the decision that there never was an argument more unjust or na the subject of Mr. Palmer's claim, be tiow read, which hear.) He should not then trouble-them ariv longer', ,of the two Houses- (Hear, hear.) Had they acted founded. Now they did not go so far as to say the being read accordingly , 11 the as he was not swats of any objection that could be i , , otherwise he should think them highly censurable. it was a breach of the privileges of the House. The Mr. WHITBREAD observed, that from a Mr. 1 LERMA observed, that the Right Hon. question ot its being a breach of privilege must arise . made to his motion. He concluded by moving— ! information be had bee able to acquire, tholigh il. , . 1 Gentleman opposite appeared to rely his defence more from the usual practice. He admitted that the Heise i e 1 La! whoever lead advised his Royal lilgliness the Pr'rce ' miler addressee had often been made by that House, : the knows strength of his numbers than his do- had often voted matey by Address, but it did recd Regent to doulit the stithchncy or the se ill ot the Holt of Gom ur n no answer like die pie sent had ever been returned to ' men ,„ - nuke good money eve wai et ques:ed by et e ddress to quence. (ef laugh.) As he had noticed on former therefore follow that the Address of the House was any address. He intended nothing in the slightest ' l re yaw. to John Palmer, l;, q, wag guilty of breaking that south occasions, a majority were 'ready to vote with him, equal to a command. The Crown hid a right to eener and understirdi:legy,waliliachwnhai:dhltilttiv.g.sausliscifstteidtelthetigwhecesiti Liu: wit hout Demi; avoure wt o 1 Sovere ign tcetom l i he .. r , . degree disrespectful to tire Prince Regent ; as the :red •• . • . . .' ' f d'h ne argument to justify pause and to think before acceding to the object Crown was ale , eys supposed to act by the advice of p o or an - any Address. Surely there was not a man in we its Ministers, so also must the Regent, end for 'the an- . !ant, because it involved the interest of a meritorious House would say that the Address of the Cowmen Mr. TIER NEY supported the motion. swer returned, they afnite must be regerded as Repoli. ; individual, as well as an increased revenue of upwards was imperative on the Crown (Hear, i.ear.) -He `it' bible. He had thought the power ot originating all Colonel PALMER stated his astonishment at the opposition which he understood would still be made of a mil li on and a half yearly. He could admit no not deny the authority or right of the Moose to money grants h a d belonged to the House of Cont- PP the t e n of his relative for having mate. objection that had yet been urged against the men- up to the Crown with an. Address, but still it in mons, and from that principle many salutary Wks 1 really incr eased an important breach of the revenue. sine, because he was confident that Mr. Palmer was Destined with the Crown, as a right not less indie the only individual in the Kingdom who had perform- i putable, to give its sanction or not—(Hem hear.) had been laid down, of meet importence to the sub-He had himself seen letter from the Right cots of this country. Taking up the affeir ma d e th i a H on. ed so important a service to his Country, and remained Were the Address of flte House imperial% e, si el. Gentletnee opposite to ,a Gentleman who was also a Revolution, numetous Addresses had beets to s heen n, no i n , 1 Member, .. and to whom he WS deeply indebted fie hitherto unrewarded. (Heart! he ar !) He could dis. votes might be extended to millions as well i Isis exertions in supp ort of Mr. Palmer's claims. la cover no informality in their proceedings, because limited to thousands. They who odd that the so [lse Crown respecting, el money,they were strictly according to the practice of the ' swer in question was a breach of privilege and a stance where such an Address had been made, had ' I that letter the Rig . Hon . Gentleman stated, that • H o use ' nt the Commons ever failed us make good their grants. should the House consent to receive the report, he . for more than a century. It was an injustice tion of the Constitution, ought to recollect, t: st 1 The Crown had always relied upon the hlouse of I ' should not make further opposition to it, and then cfose to Mr. Palmer to say that it was a party question, was constitutionally in the power of the Criem te rt • because it was known that a large poi lion of the ma- • fuse assent to Bi l ls Commons to provideehe means for raising such sums re . Ihe1 he must undergo some difficulty in convincing die of money as public eitiencies might i egtolv. jority who divided in h . favour - has welt the partictiln• —(Hear, hear.) T he first question to be cor.• - - House of the propriety or consistency - of hi • s ' • • • married for the present Ministers to w lvise tee . Regent - i trienos of the Ministers, who certeinlv did not solicit was, if tbe answer to the Address Was coneitutosa. duct. When the house of Peers, on a fainter °Lea- I any support in his behalf. On the contrary, when if the advice g iv e n tha b t y lv : d lin e i v s e ter n s w w " a e s d b ::: : • " 7 to se ed an uneracious Answer, e his• implied that . sloe, rejected Mr. Peliner's claims, he was advised to i to make a fresh application to the House of Commons, the Right Honourable Gentleman foued the sense of . next, if there was any thrng in the m anner of ci.e the House either wanted the power or the will Commons against him, he took care to defeat answer that violated the privileges of ma • ke good their Address. The answer . belongs h ex d . to give e ff ect to their own Resolutions, which he did • t h e clusivele to the Mieister, by. whom the Regent Wa • its effect In the other House, where the influence of With e respect to the first, as he had already obserbete bh.e motion he made teen so ill advised. In the fi rst year of leing a ... the . other ay, ut hefound i Government was known to be more consid • treble. the Crown must have a right to accede or n ot to • • would a a sum ben., an addiesS Was voted that he p y • h imself in no better situation than when lie was re . , Under such circumstances, he considered it an ex- Address. The Crown had a rignt to do so wild' re• i fused redress in a Court of Law , ,where the Judgetratelv of donative, to Isis foreign troops . _ , I treme hardship on Mr. P 1 a mer not to receive one specs to any Address from the Houses Set' ', I the House e- of money by waywould not permit the action to proceed, beceuse Mr. I : %ol •3 In the time of (peen Anne, in the case of the Duke , sixpence of iir4 croo 1 o 'l 1 :at was voted him. He defied He should like to bear it stated, that the iso‘ i mer would not prove that his improvements were an of Marlborough, in the case of the fifty n . ew churches r. , . y . Member to produce a precedent ot a man in his not the same right here as in the case of bAi . SL ,( • ivil ` tended for the bene fi t of the nominal defendant. He con.t 11. that were order' to be built, in the case ot the C / situation(Hear! . that h . fth ' services of his father ' s er s were a nature which voted I 'l.! List, the whole -passed between the Q . ueen and the eught not to pas s unrewarded, and stated, that his money, it was termed monstrous and daring , such statement had been attempted, ror 'n l, - ' ,- (oc- Ca.n.mons. to this last case of the Civilisist, it be- . because the Lords had •an equal right to grant It. HOnourable Gentleman thought pmper to hhe con r t act with Mr P i tt . was not so beneficial to him as , .tthjeCt WAS-noticed If their Lordships did 'ln te . i;" possess ' it, they were undoubted- high ground to stand on-41102w bar.) 'lth• apprehended? because, at the timef die letesee'd . le, a very &seed class ol men front time - immemorial, acceding to an Address of an y 0134.9 t ' PORLIAMENTART PROCEEDINGS. HOUSE OF LORDS, MAY SD. Their Lordships met at about Itaif-past two o'clock,in a Cout ure of 'Privileges, on the Banbary apd Roxlifirgh Peerages ; ten alter Many learned observations from the Lord Chancellor, ,ord Erskine, the Earl of Lauderdalb, and Earl Stanhop d e, and their it ,ppvariog that the Judges, who had been called on weliver. tinting on certain questions relative to . the Banbury case, were fully prepared to antwerthe further consideratioo, was post two to the second day atter the recta.'. The Roxburgh cause, at the suggestion or Lind LAUDER tAI.E, was deferred to next Thursday. Lord XYLL:IiOIz.D reported the Answer of his Royal High ness the Prince Repeats to the lasi Address from their Lordships appeals, ) 5 4- he Earl of LIVERPOOL. presented a Report of the Select :ommittee, appoirntd to consider the most convenient and ex peditious fray of transactiog the judicial business of the House. 'Ede Resolutions, five in number, were severally put. The sonic , /3, and 4th, were obje cted to b y Earl Stanhope, but after .i s ervations from Earls Gr e y , Lauderdale, suidLiverpool, they Jere all weed to. On the Notion orLord REDESDAI.E, the Insolvent Debtors Lill was ordered to be read the third *tune to-nwrrow. Their 4ordships, o'd the motion of Lord REDESDALE, were ordcied to be sfuntnoned to-morrow, tor the Report on Mr. trey's Estate Bill. 'lie Revenue Laws Bill, .with a few verbal amendments pro ,:osed by Lord REMSDALE, went through a Committee. 1 lie Irish Servants' Embezzlement Lill was returned from the Commons, with the agreement of that 'House-to their Lordships' amendments. Several Private Bills were also brought up : The Dublin Harbour Improvement, the Custom-ht dine Offteere Wine an Spirit Du ties, the Beef and Pork Exportation, the . Superannuation, and the home-made Chocolate kzporaciou Bilk sven,t into a Committee. - Mr. Ford, from the Victualling Board, Mr. Kingston, from ti e Bast-India Compani, and Mr. Meta, from the Board of Con front. presented Papers, which were laid on the Table. Adjourruni tall to-morrow. i C 4: e Ill+ re reinarliaole, tto ..... some Gentlemen IN bi ii Ii