Iowa caucus: Chaos at key vote as results delayed
4 February 2020
Results from voting in Iowa, the first round in the contest to pick a Democratic candidate to face President Donald Trump, have been plunged into chaos by apparent technology issues. The state's Democratic party said the holdup was a "reporting issue", adding that it expected to "have numbers to report later today [Tuesday]". On Monday, voters flocked to more than 1,600 schools, libraries and churches. Despite the absence of results, several candidates are claiming victory. Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders spoke of winning in Iowa's caucuses, citing internal campaign data that placed him ahead of Pete Buttigieg, the former mayor of South Bend, Indiana. Earlier, Mr Buttigieg told supporters that "by all indications" his campaign was "going to New Hampshire victorious".  He is referring to the forthcoming vote to select candidates in that state on 11 February. Mr Trump tweeted that it was an "unmitigated disaster", adding "the only person that can claim a very big victory in Iowa last night is 'Trump'." The vote in Iowa was a caucus - which involves people attending a meeting before voting on a candidate, perhaps via a head count or a show of hands. Voters in primaries - like the vote in New Hampshire - can just turn up at a polling booth and vote in secret. Iowa Democratic Party (IDP) spokeswoman Mandy McClure said officials had found "inconsistencies in the reporting of three sets of results" that was simply a "reporting issue" rather than a hack or intrusion. She denied an app created to allow reporting of results had gone down. "The underlying data and paper trail is sound and will simply take time to further report the results." The local party chairman Troy Price later said : "We are validating every piece of data we have against our paper trail. "That system is taking longer than expected, but it's in place to ensure we are eventually able to report results with full confidence." Rules on reporting were changed for this year, with Iowa Democrats required to report three numbers to party headquarters, rather than just the final delegate totals. Ms McClure's statement was flatly contradicted by party officials at county level, who blamed technology issues for the delay. They said the app created for caucus organisers to report their results had malfunctioned, leaving precinct captains to call state party headquarters, whose phone lines swiftly became jammed. Elesha Gayman, the Democratic chairwoman of Scott county, Iowa's third largest, said many officials were having issues reporting results and had been left hanging on hold. Dallas County chairman Bryce Smith also said the app had crashed, a view echoed by Nate Gruber, the Democratic vice-chairman of Black Hawk county, a part of the state with the largest concentration of African Americans. "It doesn't really work," he said, adding: "No-one can reach the state party to report." Calls to the Iowa Democratic Party hotline late on Monday had the same recorded message: "All of our operators are currently busy." The Democratic Party establishment spent the past few days hand-wringing over what they might view as a doomsday scenario where Bernie Sanders posted a solid win in the Iowa caucuses. It turns out they're heading towards an outcome much worse than that. Three years after having their party servers hacked by Russians in an attempt to disrupt the 2016 election, a "quality control issue" derailed the reporting of the Iowa results. It's not a good look for the Democratic Party - or for American democracy. It will be a snafu that launches 1,000 conspiracy theories and leaves a race that might have received some clarity after a year of campaigning a muddled mess as the primary season gets underway. The candidates are vying to win the opening contest of the 2020 White House campaign and become the Democratic nominee who will challenge Mr Trump, a Republican, in the 3 November election. Largely white, rural, sparsely populated Iowa awards just 41 of the 1,991 delegates needed to clinch the party nomination under America's quirky political system. But the Hawkeye state can offer crucial momentum - the last four Democratic nominees have all won the Iowa caucuses. The front-runners among the 11 remaining contenders are Senator Sanders and former US Vice-President Joe Biden. Pete Buttigieg, the former mayor of South Bend, Indiana, Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren and Minnesota Senator Amy Klobuchar also blitzed the state. Amid the delay, party officials held a call with the rival campaigns. Lawyers for the Biden campaign wrote a letter to the Iowa Democratic Party to register concern about the "considerable flaws" and "acute failures" in the reporting system. "The app that was intended to relay Caucus results to the Party failed; the Party's back-up telephonic reporting system likewise has failed," said the letter. A source in Mr Buttigieg's campaign told Reuters news agency the delay was "definitely going to de-legitimise whoever wins". Mr Trump's campaign gloated over the debacle. Trump 2020 manager Brad Parscale said Democrats were "stewing in a caucus mess of their own creation with the sloppiest train wreck in history", adding that it would be "natural for people to doubt the fairness of the process". But Republicans have had their own problems in Iowa previously. In 2012, Mitt Romney was declared the winner of the caucuses only for the party to say two weeks later that Rick Santorum had actually won. The president's eldest son, Donald Trump Jr, tweeted that the Democratic results chaos was all a "fix". However, there was no indication that it had been caused by anything other than human or technical error. Republicans also held Iowa caucuses on Monday and, as predicted, Mr Trump - who enjoys around 90% support in his party - squashed his two little-known challengers. The race will next move on to the other three early-voting states of New Hampshire next week, then Nevada and South Carolina later in February. On Super Tuesday, 3 March, 15 states and territories will vote. The field will be whittled down until a final nominee is crowned at the party convention in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, in July.
Iowa Democratic Party (IDP) spokeswoman Mandy McClure said officials had found "inconsistencies in the reporting of three sets of results" that was simply a "reporting issue" rather than a hack or intrusion. She denied an app created to allow reporting of results had gone down. "The underlying data and paper trail is sound and will simply take time to further report the results." The local party chairman Troy Price later said : "We are validating every piece of data we have against our paper trail. "That system is taking longer than expected, but it's in place to ensure we are eventually able to report results with full confidence." Rules on reporting were changed for this year, with Iowa Democrats required to report three numbers to party headquarters, rather than just the final delegate totals.
9499_0
What are the organisers saying about the Iowa situation?
Ms McClure's statement was flatly contradicted by party officials at county level, who blamed technology issues for the delay. They said the app created for caucus organisers to report their results had malfunctioned, leaving precinct captains to call state party headquarters, whose phone lines swiftly became jammed. Elesha Gayman, the Democratic chairwoman of Scott county, Iowa's third largest, said many officials were having issues reporting results and had been left hanging on hold. Dallas County chairman Bryce Smith also said the app had crashed, a view echoed by Nate Gruber, the Democratic vice-chairman of Black Hawk county, a part of the state with the largest concentration of African Americans. "It doesn't really work," he said, adding: "No-one can reach the state party to report." Calls to the Iowa Democratic Party hotline late on Monday had the same recorded message: "All of our operators are currently busy."
9499_1
Did the app crash?
The candidates are vying to win the opening contest of the 2020 White House campaign and become the Democratic nominee who will challenge Mr Trump, a Republican, in the 3 November election. Largely white, rural, sparsely populated Iowa awards just 41 of the 1,991 delegates needed to clinch the party nomination under America's quirky political system. But the Hawkeye state can offer crucial momentum - the last four Democratic nominees have all won the Iowa caucuses. The front-runners among the 11 remaining contenders are Senator Sanders and former US Vice-President Joe Biden. Pete Buttigieg, the former mayor of South Bend, Indiana, Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren and Minnesota Senator Amy Klobuchar also blitzed the state.
9499_2
What's at stake?
Amid the delay, party officials held a call with the rival campaigns. Lawyers for the Biden campaign wrote a letter to the Iowa Democratic Party to register concern about the "considerable flaws" and "acute failures" in the reporting system. "The app that was intended to relay Caucus results to the Party failed; the Party's back-up telephonic reporting system likewise has failed," said the letter. A source in Mr Buttigieg's campaign told Reuters news agency the delay was "definitely going to de-legitimise whoever wins".
9499_3
How did the campaigns respond?
Mr Trump's campaign gloated over the debacle. Trump 2020 manager Brad Parscale said Democrats were "stewing in a caucus mess of their own creation with the sloppiest train wreck in history", adding that it would be "natural for people to doubt the fairness of the process". But Republicans have had their own problems in Iowa previously. In 2012, Mitt Romney was declared the winner of the caucuses only for the party to say two weeks later that Rick Santorum had actually won. The president's eldest son, Donald Trump Jr, tweeted that the Democratic results chaos was all a "fix". However, there was no indication that it had been caused by anything other than human or technical error. Republicans also held Iowa caucuses on Monday and, as predicted, Mr Trump - who enjoys around 90% support in his party - squashed his two little-known challengers.
9499_4
How did the Trump campaign respond?
The race will next move on to the other three early-voting states of New Hampshire next week, then Nevada and South Carolina later in February. On Super Tuesday, 3 March, 15 states and territories will vote. The field will be whittled down until a final nominee is crowned at the party convention in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, in July.
9499_5
What comes next?