South Africa initiation schools suspended after circumcision deaths
20 December 2019
The South African authorities have suspended several initiation schools where boys have died in recent weeks taking part in circumcision ceremonies. The country's religious and cultural commission said the schools in different areas of the Eastern Cape would be suspended for a year. It called for the arrest of those responsible for at least 20 deaths. The initiation into manhood involves spending weeks in mountainous areas in harsh conditions. Every year, tens of thousands of initiates aged between 15 and 17 spend time in seclusion in the bush where they are taught about how to be upstanding men in society. But exactly what happens there is kept a secret. Ukwaluka, or traditional initiation, is seen as a necessary part of the passage from boyhood to manhood by some of the country's largest ethnic groups, including the Xhosa and Ndebele. For many who practise the ritual, the homecoming is a time of celebration, where a feast is prepared for the family and community to enjoy. It is a celebration of the young men's safe return and more importantly their new adult status. But sometimes things go terribly wrong, with some initiates dying or left disfigured from a botched circumcision. Hundreds of boys were taken to hospital last year where they were treated for penile amputation, septic wounds and dehydration. South Africa's circumcision season typically falls during two periods, in June and in December. This is when most boys are home from school and have time to complete the rituals, which can last up to a month. When young Xhosa boys are aged between 15 and 17, their families prepare to take them to an initiation school - where they will be under the care of an "ingcibi", a traditional surgeon, and an "ikhankatha", a traditional nurse. - More than 400 boys have died from botched circumcisions in South Africa since 2012 - South Africa's initiations seasons are in June (winter) and December (summer) - Tens of thousands of young boys undergo male circumcision in the bush, carried out by traditional surgeons - More than 100 boys were rescued from unregistered school in June this year - Dehydration, malnutrition and wounds going septic are the leading causes of deaths of initiates Source: Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs The surgeon performs the circumcision, while the traditional nurse looks after treating the wound as well as the initiate's daily needs, including food. The practice itself is steeped in secrecy. So secretive in fact that the boys are not allowed to speak about what happens while there. Women are not allowed to go near a circumcision school as this is believed to be a bad omen. Some have complained that it is this secrecy that has got in the way of addressing the challenges and criticisms of what happens when the boys are away from home. Circumcision is steeped in tradition that has been passed down through many generations. It offers a profound cultural connection with the past. And while some have described it as an outdated and increasingly dangerous tradition, the right to practise one's culture is protected by South Africa's constitution. Most of the deaths have been as a result of dehydration and wounds going septic, pointing to a lack of proper care and ill-treatment of initiates at the schools. Many of those who have died were attending initiation schools which had not been registered with the authorities. These schools are on the rise because initiation has become a lucrative exercise with the surgeons and nurses being paid for their work. There is also a problem that some underage children, who may not be able to cope, go through the ritual without their parents' approval. In June, more than 100 boys were rescued from unregistered schools in the Eastern Cape province. "We are seeing the mushrooming of these illegal initiation schools, where individuals are inviting people to send their boys at an exorbitant fee. That's why we are saying it's now the commercialisation of the practice which is against tradition," local government spokesperson Mamkeli Ngam was quoted by News24 as saying. The ingcibi now need to be registered before being allowed to carry out circumcisions. The government is also now paying for medics to visit the registered schools to check on the well-being of the boys. It is harder to check up on the unregistered schools, because of their illicit nature. Government-funded health centres now also perform circumcisions as an alternative to the traditional route, but cultural purists see this as a Westernisation of their custom. Traditionally, initiation has been a private matters, usually arranged by the boy's father or a male elder within the family. The role of the elder would be to find a reputable surgeon in the village with a proven track record. So any greater involvement of the state may not be welcome. Traditional circumcision remains a contentious issue in South Africa even within the communities that practise it. While there are no easy answers, many agree that young boys should not be dying simply for wanting to be recognised as a man.
Every year, tens of thousands of initiates aged between 15 and 17 spend time in seclusion in the bush where they are taught about how to be upstanding men in society. But exactly what happens there is kept a secret. Ukwaluka, or traditional initiation, is seen as a necessary part of the passage from boyhood to manhood by some of the country's largest ethnic groups, including the Xhosa and Ndebele. For many who practise the ritual, the homecoming is a time of celebration, where a feast is prepared for the family and community to enjoy. It is a celebration of the young men's safe return and more importantly their new adult status. But sometimes things go terribly wrong, with some initiates dying or left disfigured from a botched circumcision. Hundreds of boys were taken to hospital last year where they were treated for penile amputation, septic wounds and dehydration.
1651_0
Why do people get circumcised?
South Africa's circumcision season typically falls during two periods, in June and in December. This is when most boys are home from school and have time to complete the rituals, which can last up to a month. When young Xhosa boys are aged between 15 and 17, their families prepare to take them to an initiation school - where they will be under the care of an "ingcibi", a traditional surgeon, and an "ikhankatha", a traditional nurse.
1651_1
Why is there a 'circumcision season' and what happens?
Circumcision is steeped in tradition that has been passed down through many generations. It offers a profound cultural connection with the past. And while some have described it as an outdated and increasingly dangerous tradition, the right to practise one's culture is protected by South Africa's constitution.
1651_2
If children are dying why not just outlaw the practice?
Most of the deaths have been as a result of dehydration and wounds going septic, pointing to a lack of proper care and ill-treatment of initiates at the schools. Many of those who have died were attending initiation schools which had not been registered with the authorities. These schools are on the rise because initiation has become a lucrative exercise with the surgeons and nurses being paid for their work. There is also a problem that some underage children, who may not be able to cope, go through the ritual without their parents' approval. In June, more than 100 boys were rescued from unregistered schools in the Eastern Cape province. "We are seeing the mushrooming of these illegal initiation schools, where individuals are inviting people to send their boys at an exorbitant fee. That's why we are saying it's now the commercialisation of the practice which is against tradition," local government spokesperson Mamkeli Ngam was quoted by News24 as saying. The ingcibi now need to be registered before being allowed to carry out circumcisions. The government is also now paying for medics to visit the registered schools to check on the well-being of the boys. It is harder to check up on the unregistered schools, because of their illicit nature.
1651_3
But what is causing the deaths?
Government-funded health centres now also perform circumcisions as an alternative to the traditional route, but cultural purists see this as a Westernisation of their custom. Traditionally, initiation has been a private matters, usually arranged by the boy's father or a male elder within the family. The role of the elder would be to find a reputable surgeon in the village with a proven track record. So any greater involvement of the state may not be welcome. Traditional circumcision remains a contentious issue in South Africa even within the communities that practise it. While there are no easy answers, many agree that young boys should not be dying simply for wanting to be recognised as a man.
1651_4
Should the government take over the circumcisions?