EU fishing rules: Did the UK throw away a million tonnes of fish?
11 February 2020
Claim: UK fishermen were "throwing back a million tonnes of fish dead" every year because of the EU's Common Fisheries Policy (CFP), according to Conservative MP Owen Paterson. Reality Check verdict: No one has ever come up with a credible figure of one million tonnes for UK fishermen alone. It's true that UK fishermen were required by EU rules in the past to throw back unwanted or undersized fish - although exactly how much is not known. The EU started reversing these rules in 2016 and by 2019 vessels weren't allowed to throw back any fish subject to quotas. There's some evidence discarding is still happening, though, despite the rule change. The Conservative MP and former Environment Secretary Owen Paterson told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that Brexit would allow the UK to become "an independent maritime nation" and "stop the complete horrors" of the EU's Common Fisheries Policy (CFP). He said, under CFP rules, UK fishermen were "throwing back a million tonnes of fish dead as pollution every year". * The UK remains part of the Common Fisheries Policy - which sets the rules on how EU members fish - until the end of the transition period, at the end of this year. The system that will replace it is still up for negotiation. Until relatively recently, EU member states - including the UK - were required to throw some fish back into the water. This controversial practice was known as "discarding" and involved returning unwanted catches back to sea (dead or alive) because they were too small or because the crew had exceeded their quota - the amount of fish they were allowed to catch. There is no single accepted figure for this. A 2005 study estimated that 500,000 to 800,000 tonnes of fish were discarded in the North Sea each year, but it did not attribute this to any one country. In 2008, a report from the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) put the figure for the North Sea at one million tonnes. Again it did not single out the UK. This was calculated by subtracting kilos of fish sold from kilos of fish caught. In 2010, University of Exeter scientists put the figure at 267,000 tonnes of fish discarded in the North Sea in 2010 - and said this figure had declined from about 500,000 tonnes in 1990. A House of Lords report published in 2019 said that in 2013 an estimated 1.7 million tonnes of fish and "other marine animals" were being thrown back into the sea each year across European waters - again not specifically by UK fishermen. The National Federation of Fishermen's Organisations (NFFO) told us they did not recognise the one million tonnes figure quoted by Mr Paterson and did not believe an estimate of discarded fish could be reached. From January 2015 onwards, the EU started reversing its policy on discarding. It introduced a "landing obligation" on fishermen to keep the fish they caught. This first applied to "pelagic" species of fish (including mackerel and herring) before being extended from 2016 to bottom-dwelling fish (including cod, haddock and plaice). By January 2019, vessels weren't allowed to discard any species of fish for which quotas were used to limit the numbers caught. We spoke to Mr Paterson. He said he was referring to the situation under the old rules but added that he "knew the discard ban was not going to work". While he believed the one million figure to be a widely recognised estimate, he acknowledged that "the reality is, we don't know". The discard ban has "proven challenging to implement", according to Louisa Casson, oceans campaigner at Greenpeace UK. "There are many proposed solutions, including observers and CCTV on boats, but none of these are in place across the entire UK fishing fleet," she said. And there is some evidence vessels are still discarding fish, including video and photographic evidence of illegal discards happening off the coast of Scotland gathered by campaign groups Our Fish and Open Seas. A House of Lords report on the landing obligation policy, published in February 2019, said: "Little attempt appears to have been made to enforce the landing obligation's requirements thus far, allowing the discarding of fish to continue." The NFFO said that while the ban was working well for some types of fishing, for others there were "fundamental difficulties caused by the design of the legislation" which required a "fundamental overhaul". *UPDATE 14 February: After the publication of this piece Owen Paterson contacted us to say that when he said "we'll be able to implement modern techniques and conservation and stop the complete horrors of the CFP where we were throwing back a million tonnes of fish dead as pollution every year as discards" the "we" in the latter part of the quote was a reference to the EU rather than the UK. Read more from Reality Check Send us your questions Follow us on Twitter
Until relatively recently, EU member states - including the UK - were required to throw some fish back into the water. This controversial practice was known as "discarding" and involved returning unwanted catches back to sea (dead or alive) because they were too small or because the crew had exceeded their quota - the amount of fish they were allowed to catch.
9469_0
So what do the rules say?
There is no single accepted figure for this. A 2005 study estimated that 500,000 to 800,000 tonnes of fish were discarded in the North Sea each year, but it did not attribute this to any one country. In 2008, a report from the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) put the figure for the North Sea at one million tonnes. Again it did not single out the UK. This was calculated by subtracting kilos of fish sold from kilos of fish caught. In 2010, University of Exeter scientists put the figure at 267,000 tonnes of fish discarded in the North Sea in 2010 - and said this figure had declined from about 500,000 tonnes in 1990. A House of Lords report published in 2019 said that in 2013 an estimated 1.7 million tonnes of fish and "other marine animals" were being thrown back into the sea each year across European waters - again not specifically by UK fishermen. The National Federation of Fishermen's Organisations (NFFO) told us they did not recognise the one million tonnes figure quoted by Mr Paterson and did not believe an estimate of discarded fish could be reached.
9469_1
How many fish were discarded?
The discard ban has "proven challenging to implement", according to Louisa Casson, oceans campaigner at Greenpeace UK. "There are many proposed solutions, including observers and CCTV on boats, but none of these are in place across the entire UK fishing fleet," she said. And there is some evidence vessels are still discarding fish, including video and photographic evidence of illegal discards happening off the coast of Scotland gathered by campaign groups Our Fish and Open Seas. A House of Lords report on the landing obligation policy, published in February 2019, said: "Little attempt appears to have been made to enforce the landing obligation's requirements thus far, allowing the discarding of fish to continue." The NFFO said that while the ban was working well for some types of fishing, for others there were "fundamental difficulties caused by the design of the legislation" which required a "fundamental overhaul". *UPDATE 14 February: After the publication of this piece Owen Paterson contacted us to say that when he said "we'll be able to implement modern techniques and conservation and stop the complete horrors of the CFP where we were throwing back a million tonnes of fish dead as pollution every year as discards" the "we" in the latter part of the quote was a reference to the EU rather than the UK.
9469_2
Is discarding still happening?