Irish general election: Sinn Féin tops first preference poll
10 February 2020
Sinn Fein president Mary Lou McDonald has described the Irish general election as "something of a revolution in the ballot box". Counting is continuing and the first results have come in, with Sinn Fein winning the most first preference votes. With all first preferences counted, it has 24.5% compared to 22.2% for Fianna Fail and 20.9% for Fine Gael. No one party will win enough seats for an outright majority. Before the election, both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail ruled out forming a government with Sinn Fein, citing its tax policies and IRA past as deterrents. On Sunday evening taoiseach (Irish PM) and Fine Gael leader Leo Varadkar said it would be "challenging" to form a government. Fianna Fail leader Micheal Martin did not rule out working with Sinn Fein, but said "significant incompatibilities" still existed. Polling in the election closed at 22:00 local time on Saturday. Ballot boxes from across the 39 constituencies were opened at 09:00 on Sunday. Many counts have finished for the night and will resume at 10:00 on Monday, but some are continuing. Sinn Fein ran 42 candidates across the 39 multi-seat constituencies, about half that of both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail, which will have a knock-on effect on the number of seats it can secure in the 160-seat Dail (Irish parliament) where 80 seats are needed for a majority. Once the final number of seats for each party is known, leaders will try to form a coalition government in order to avoid another general election. Before the election both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail said they would not enter coalition with Sinn Fein. Arriving at the RDS count centre in Dublin on Sunday afternoon, Sinn Fein leader Mary Lou McDonald said she was exploring options to see if it would be possible to form a government without either Fine Gael or Fianna Fail. Fine Gael leader Leo Varadkar said his party has consistently ruled out forming a coalition with Sinn Fein "in large part because of their policies in relation to crime, tax and the way the economy and society should be run and also our deep concerns about their democratic structures. "We don't believe a coalition between Sinn Fein and Fine Gael is a viable option," he said. He said a "forced marriage would not result in a good government." Fianna Fail leader Micheal Martin did not rule out working with Sinn Fein, but said "significant incompatibilities" still existed. He said reports suggested that his party "would be the largest". He added that he was a "democrat" and respected the vote of the people. Following the last election in 2016 Sinn Fein had 23 seats in the Dail (Irish parliament). There are 160 seats up for election this time around, and Sinn Fein is set to dramatically increase how many it holds after it won the most first preference votes. Ms McDonald said this election was about "change". She topped the poll in her four-seat Dublin Central constituency. "The frustration people have felt for a long time with the two-party system, whereby Fine Gael and Fianna Fail handed the baton of power between each other - that's now over," she said. "We now have a very substantial mandate." She said she was exploring options to see to see if it was possible to form a government without Fine Gael and Fianna Fail. By Chris Page, BBC News Ireland Correspondent Sunday evening is seeing a cascade of results from across the country. Many early victories have gone to Sinn Fein - with no part of the country looking untouched by the party's surge. While the general picture is becoming clear - the final numbers will be determined by the process of numerical preferences trickling down through the various stages of the counts. Sinn Fein surpluses will be very much in play here - as the party was only running one candidate in many constituencies, the destination of the transfers from the successful runners is set to have an impact on what other parties take the seats. The latest seat projection by University College Dublin, for RTE, puts Fianna Fail as the largest party on 45 seats - with Sinn Fein on 37 and Fine Gael on 36. Plenty of counting is still to come. Fine Gael has been in government since 2011, firstly with the Labour Party and then with independents and with a confidence and supply deal with Fianna Fail. It looks set to lose seats for the second election in a row, but that does not necessarily rule it out of forming another government. Its share of first precence votes dropped from 25.5% at the last election to 20.9%. Party leader Leo Varadkar reiterated that he did not want to enter into government with Sinn Fein and said Ms McDonald had not been in contact with him. The taoiseach said he was "not really" disappointed that he did not top the poll in his own constituency. He did get an increase in his votes compared to the last election. He added it was now clear there was now a "three-party system". Fianna Fail has been in government for more years than anyone else since Ireland became independent, but it has not been the ruling party since 2011. Earlier on Sunday Micheal Martin said reports suggested his party "would be the largest" but that it was early days. He said there was a lot of "volatility", adding people who could not get elected in the local elections had been successful in this one. He said the most important thing when forming a government was "compatibility in the programme for government" and that formation of a government was going to be very difficult. Mr Martin added he was a "democrat" and respected the will of the people. Despite previously saying he would not govern with Sinn Fein he has now not ruled that out. The Green Party is also set to increase the number of seats it holds. Green leader Eamon Ryan, who was elected on the first count for Dublin Bay South, said his party would play its part in talks to form a government. Ruth Coppinger from the left wing alliance Solidarity-People Before Profit lost her seat. Labour Party leader Brendan Howlin said it had not been a good day for his party as it had been squeezed by Sinn Fein. The party's former leader Joan Burton lost her seat in Dublin West. She was first elected to the Dail in 1992. The Social Democrats co-leader Catherine Murphy said it was "historic," saying there had been a "seismic shift". She said she knew there was a wind in the Sinn Fein sail. The Green Party secured 7.1% of first preference votes, followed by Labour (4.4%), Social Democrats (2.9%), Solidarity-People Before Profit (2.6%). Aontu (1.9%) independents (12.2%) and others (1.3%) accounted for the rest. An exit poll - commissioned jointly by Irish national broadcasters RTE and TG4, as well as The Irish Times and University College Dublin suggested a move toward Sinn Fein among younger voters, with the party receiving the largest number of first preference votes among 18-24 years olds (31.8%). The majority of voters over the age of 65 appear to have given their first preference to Fine Gael or Fianna Fail. Ireland's elections are carried out under the proportional representation (PR) voting system, using the single transferable vote (STV). Voters wrote "1" opposite their first choice candidate, "2" opposite their second choice, "3" opposite their third choice and so on. This means that the picture presented when the first preference votes are counted does not completely reflect the final outcome. Newly elected TDs will gather on 20 February . The ceann comhairle, or speaker, is automatically re-elected. In most situations, the speaker does not vote, so a government will need 80 TDs to hold a majority.
Once the final number of seats for each party is known, leaders will try to form a coalition government in order to avoid another general election. Before the election both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail said they would not enter coalition with Sinn Fein. Arriving at the RDS count centre in Dublin on Sunday afternoon, Sinn Fein leader Mary Lou McDonald said she was exploring options to see if it would be possible to form a government without either Fine Gael or Fianna Fail. Fine Gael leader Leo Varadkar said his party has consistently ruled out forming a coalition with Sinn Fein "in large part because of their policies in relation to crime, tax and the way the economy and society should be run and also our deep concerns about their democratic structures. "We don't believe a coalition between Sinn Fein and Fine Gael is a viable option," he said. He said a "forced marriage would not result in a good government." Fianna Fail leader Micheal Martin did not rule out working with Sinn Fein, but said "significant incompatibilities" still existed. He said reports suggested that his party "would be the largest". He added that he was a "democrat" and respected the vote of the people.
337_0
What kind of government could be formed?
Following the last election in 2016 Sinn Fein had 23 seats in the Dail (Irish parliament). There are 160 seats up for election this time around, and Sinn Fein is set to dramatically increase how many it holds after it won the most first preference votes. Ms McDonald said this election was about "change". She topped the poll in her four-seat Dublin Central constituency. "The frustration people have felt for a long time with the two-party system, whereby Fine Gael and Fianna Fail handed the baton of power between each other - that's now over," she said. "We now have a very substantial mandate." She said she was exploring options to see to see if it was possible to form a government without Fine Gael and Fianna Fail.
337_1
What could Sinn Fein's surge mean for the overall result?
Fine Gael has been in government since 2011, firstly with the Labour Party and then with independents and with a confidence and supply deal with Fianna Fail. It looks set to lose seats for the second election in a row, but that does not necessarily rule it out of forming another government. Its share of first precence votes dropped from 25.5% at the last election to 20.9%. Party leader Leo Varadkar reiterated that he did not want to enter into government with Sinn Fein and said Ms McDonald had not been in contact with him. The taoiseach said he was "not really" disappointed that he did not top the poll in his own constituency. He did get an increase in his votes compared to the last election. He added it was now clear there was now a "three-party system".
337_2
How is Fine Gael performing?
Fianna Fail has been in government for more years than anyone else since Ireland became independent, but it has not been the ruling party since 2011. Earlier on Sunday Micheal Martin said reports suggested his party "would be the largest" but that it was early days. He said there was a lot of "volatility", adding people who could not get elected in the local elections had been successful in this one. He said the most important thing when forming a government was "compatibility in the programme for government" and that formation of a government was going to be very difficult. Mr Martin added he was a "democrat" and respected the will of the people. Despite previously saying he would not govern with Sinn Fein he has now not ruled that out.
337_3
Will Fianna Fail return to government?
The Green Party is also set to increase the number of seats it holds. Green leader Eamon Ryan, who was elected on the first count for Dublin Bay South, said his party would play its part in talks to form a government. Ruth Coppinger from the left wing alliance Solidarity-People Before Profit lost her seat. Labour Party leader Brendan Howlin said it had not been a good day for his party as it had been squeezed by Sinn Fein. The party's former leader Joan Burton lost her seat in Dublin West. She was first elected to the Dail in 1992. The Social Democrats co-leader Catherine Murphy said it was "historic," saying there had been a "seismic shift". She said she knew there was a wind in the Sinn Fein sail. The Green Party secured 7.1% of first preference votes, followed by Labour (4.4%), Social Democrats (2.9%), Solidarity-People Before Profit (2.6%). Aontu (1.9%) independents (12.2%) and others (1.3%) accounted for the rest. An exit poll - commissioned jointly by Irish national broadcasters RTE and TG4, as well as The Irish Times and University College Dublin suggested a move toward Sinn Fein among younger voters, with the party receiving the largest number of first preference votes among 18-24 years olds (31.8%). The majority of voters over the age of 65 appear to have given their first preference to Fine Gael or Fianna Fail.
337_4
What about the smaller parties?
Ireland's elections are carried out under the proportional representation (PR) voting system, using the single transferable vote (STV). Voters wrote "1" opposite their first choice candidate, "2" opposite their second choice, "3" opposite their third choice and so on. This means that the picture presented when the first preference votes are counted does not completely reflect the final outcome.
337_5
What voting system does the Republic of Ireland use?
Newly elected TDs will gather on 20 February . The ceann comhairle, or speaker, is automatically re-elected. In most situations, the speaker does not vote, so a government will need 80 TDs to hold a majority.
337_6
What happens next?