France strike: Rail misery as three-month action tests Macron
3 April 2018
France's rail network has been severely disrupted, as a wave of strikes against President Emmanuel Macron's labour reforms gets under way. The start of the strike has been dubbed "Black Tuesday", but the action will spread over three months, affecting two days in every five. Staff at state railway SNCF are leading the strike, but the energy and waste collection sectors are also affected. The unrest presents Mr Macron's biggest challenge since his election last May. The unions say some of the plans to overhaul the heavily indebted SNCF would pave the way for its privatisation. But Prime Minister Edouard Philippe denied this, saying the proposals aim to change the status quo that was "no longer tenable". In parliament, he added: "If the strikers are to be respected, the millions of French people who want to go to work, because they have no choice, because they want to go to work, must also be respected." SNCF warned that major disruptions were expected on Wednesday. With the four main rail unions observing the strike, services have been severely curtailed. Some 77% of SNCF drivers were believed to be on strike. The company said 34% of its staff overall were striking. Only one in eight high-speed TGVs is scheduled to run while only one in five regional trains is operating. Commuter lines into Paris have also been slashed and bus services have been hugely overcrowded. Some stations were crammed for the few trains available, others were deserted. The website that measures car traffic around the capital recorded about 420km (260 miles) of jams at rush hour. International services are more sketchily affected. Eurostar has 75% of trains running and the Thalys services to Belgium, the Netherlands and Germany are almost normal, but there are no services to Spain, Switzerland or Italy. Employees of Air France, who are demanding a 6% pay rise, are into the fourth day of industrial action. The airline is operating 75% of its flights. Travellers across Europe suffered more disruption as up to 15,000 flights across the continent were facing delays due to a technical problem. Eurocontrol, which runs the EU's air traffic system, said the fault in the system had been identified and that moves were under way to return the situation to normal. Unions have also called out all rubbish collectors, to push for the creation of a national collection service and better retirement options. Workers blockaded some waste treatment plants. Energy sector unions have also called strikes to demand, among other things, an end to the liberalisation of the energy markets and a review of deregulation. Thousands of students are also reportedly taking part in the strikes, in opposition to the toughening up of university entry regulations. Analysis by the BBC's Hugh Schofield in Paris There are three reasons why President Macron feels relatively optimistic about the rail strike. First, unlike in the last massive (and successful) general strike in 1995, this time there can have been no mistaking the government's intention to reform. Neither the public nor SNCF staff can pretend the planned changes come out of the blue. They are clearly part of the broad reform agenda for which Mr Macron was elected. Second, there is far less automatic sympathy for the SNCF than there used to be. The level of rail services has declined sharply, especially for commuters, who are as a result more open to calls for reform. Third, new options have opened up for commuters. There is home-working; car-pooling; expanded coach services. This should make it easier for workers to get round the inconvenience. All that said, these will be tense weeks for the government. Nerves are going to fray. People will get angry. Daily life will not be easy. In these circumstances, plans can go badly awry. A wrong move and public opinion could easily shift back behind the strikers. SNCF workers enjoy generous conditions, including automatic annual pay rises, early retirement, 28 days of paid annual leave and protection from dismissal. Their close relatives are also entitled to free rail tickets. The Macron government wants to phase out the special SNCF contracts, proposing to put new hires on contracts like those that apply elsewhere in industry. The aim is to open up the state railways to competition from 2023, in line with EU requirements. SNCF has EUR46.6bn ($57.5bn; PS40bn) of debt. The rail unions also feel their action goes beyond rail workers' conditions and marks a major test of union clout. Just over 11% of the French workforce is unionised - one of the lowest levels in the EU - but the unions traditionally punch above their weight, economically and politically. "We're defending the French public service, not just rail workers," said Emmanuel Grondein, head of union Sud Rail. Mr Macron's Republic On The Move party also feels the strike has wider connotations. "We need to rid this country of its strike culture," spokesman Gabriel Attal said. Opposition to Mr Macron's agenda was shown on 22 March, when tens of thousands of teachers, nurses and other workers joined rail staff on strike. The BBC's Lucy Williamson in Paris says many union members see Mr Macron as the man who wants to break the power of the unions. But strikes in September failed to stop Mr Macron passing laws that make it easier for firms to hire and fire, and the majority of the public are opposed to industrial action this time. The usual mix of support, anger, disappointment, humour and resignation. This one purports to show a Paris-Lille train and asks whether commuters are also on strike: This one carries a mock CV, suggesting railway workers are serial strikers (grevistes): While this offers wholehearted support:
With the four main rail unions observing the strike, services have been severely curtailed. Some 77% of SNCF drivers were believed to be on strike. The company said 34% of its staff overall were striking. Only one in eight high-speed TGVs is scheduled to run while only one in five regional trains is operating.
2158_0
How is the strike taking hold?
Analysis by the BBC's Hugh Schofield in Paris There are three reasons why President Macron feels relatively optimistic about the rail strike. First, unlike in the last massive (and successful) general strike in 1995, this time there can have been no mistaking the government's intention to reform. Neither the public nor SNCF staff can pretend the planned changes come out of the blue. They are clearly part of the broad reform agenda for which Mr Macron was elected. Second, there is far less automatic sympathy for the SNCF than there used to be. The level of rail services has declined sharply, especially for commuters, who are as a result more open to calls for reform. Third, new options have opened up for commuters. There is home-working; car-pooling; expanded coach services. This should make it easier for workers to get round the inconvenience. All that said, these will be tense weeks for the government. Nerves are going to fray. People will get angry. Daily life will not be easy. In these circumstances, plans can go badly awry. A wrong move and public opinion could easily shift back behind the strikers.
2158_1
Can Macron face down the strikers?
SNCF workers enjoy generous conditions, including automatic annual pay rises, early retirement, 28 days of paid annual leave and protection from dismissal. Their close relatives are also entitled to free rail tickets. The Macron government wants to phase out the special SNCF contracts, proposing to put new hires on contracts like those that apply elsewhere in industry. The aim is to open up the state railways to competition from 2023, in line with EU requirements. SNCF has EUR46.6bn ($57.5bn; PS40bn) of debt. The rail unions also feel their action goes beyond rail workers' conditions and marks a major test of union clout. Just over 11% of the French workforce is unionised - one of the lowest levels in the EU - but the unions traditionally punch above their weight, economically and politically. "We're defending the French public service, not just rail workers," said Emmanuel Grondein, head of union Sud Rail. Mr Macron's Republic On The Move party also feels the strike has wider connotations. "We need to rid this country of its strike culture," spokesman Gabriel Attal said. Opposition to Mr Macron's agenda was shown on 22 March, when tens of thousands of teachers, nurses and other workers joined rail staff on strike. The BBC's Lucy Williamson in Paris says many union members see Mr Macron as the man who wants to break the power of the unions. But strikes in September failed to stop Mr Macron passing laws that make it easier for firms to hire and fire, and the majority of the public are opposed to industrial action this time.
2158_2
What is the strike about?
The usual mix of support, anger, disappointment, humour and resignation. This one purports to show a Paris-Lille train and asks whether commuters are also on strike: This one carries a mock CV, suggesting railway workers are serial strikers (grevistes): While this offers wholehearted support:
2158_3
How have passengers been reacting?