El Salvador: Woman faces retrial after baby died in toilet birth
16 July 2019
A woman in El Salvador whose baby was found dead in the toilet where she gave birth is facing a retrial on charges of homicide. Evelyn Beatriz Hernandez Cruz, 21, was originally sentenced to 30 years in prison in 2017 but was released following an appeal. She says she did not know she was pregnant and lost consciousness during the birth. Initially accused of abortion, she was eventually found guilty of homicide. Abortion is illegal in El Salvador and those found guilty face between two and eight years in jail. But in many cases, including the one against Ms Hernandez, the charge is changed to one of aggravated homicide, which carries a minimum sentence of 30 years. Evelyn Hernandez says she experienced severe stomach pains and bleeding while at her home in rural El Salvador on 6 April 2016. She went to the toilet, located in an outhouse, where she fainted. Her mother took her to a hospital, where doctors found she had given birth. She was arrested after the body of her baby was found in the toilet's septic tank. Ms Hernandez, who was 18 at the time, says she had been raped by a gang member but that she had no idea that she was pregnant. She said she had confused the symptoms of pregnancy with stomach ache because she had experienced intermittent bleeding, which she thought was her menstrual period. "If I'd known I was pregnant I would have awaited [the birth] with pride and joy," she has said in the past. She also said that while she had "felt something come loose" inside her, she did not hear a baby cry out and did not realise she was giving birth. Ms Hernandez was charged with aggravated homicide in 2017. Prosecutors said that she had hidden her pregnancy and not sought antenatal care and while they said they could not establish whether the baby was alive at birth, they argued that Ms Hernandez had committed murder. The judge ruled that Ms Hernandez knew she was pregnant and found her guilty of aggravated homicide. She was sentenced to 30 years in prison in July 2017. Ms Hernandez lawyers appealed against the judge's decision. The defence lawyers said that forensic test showed that the baby had died of meconium aspiration, inhaling his own early stool. This can happen while the baby is still in the uterus, during delivery or immediately after birth. The lawyers said that the test proved that Ms Hernandez had not tried to abort the baby but that it had died of natural causes. "There is no crime," defence lawyer Bertha Maria Deleon said. However, her conviction was confirmed by another court in October 2017 so her lawyers took their appeal to the country's supreme court. In February 2019, the supreme court annulled the 2017 conviction citing absence of evidence and ordered a retrial with a new judge. Ms Hernandez was released from jail pending the retrial. Ms Hernandez's lawyers say prosecutors on Monday changed the charges levelled against her from aggravated homicide to manslaughter. Going into the trial on Monday, Ms Hernandez said she was innocent and that she had trust "in God and my lawyers". Rights organisations in El Salvador says there are still at least 20 other women in jail under the country's strict abortion laws. Over the last decade, campaigners have managed to free around 30 through evidence reviews. A retrial verdict in Ms Hernandez's favour would give those still in jail hope their convictions could also be overturned. The retrial comes just six weeks after new President Nayib Bukele took office and women's groups are hoping he could usher in a more lenient stance on the issue.
Evelyn Hernandez says she experienced severe stomach pains and bleeding while at her home in rural El Salvador on 6 April 2016. She went to the toilet, located in an outhouse, where she fainted. Her mother took her to a hospital, where doctors found she had given birth. She was arrested after the body of her baby was found in the toilet's septic tank. Ms Hernandez, who was 18 at the time, says she had been raped by a gang member but that she had no idea that she was pregnant. She said she had confused the symptoms of pregnancy with stomach ache because she had experienced intermittent bleeding, which she thought was her menstrual period. "If I'd known I was pregnant I would have awaited [the birth] with pride and joy," she has said in the past. She also said that while she had "felt something come loose" inside her, she did not hear a baby cry out and did not realise she was giving birth.
6634_0
What happened?
Ms Hernandez was charged with aggravated homicide in 2017. Prosecutors said that she had hidden her pregnancy and not sought antenatal care and while they said they could not establish whether the baby was alive at birth, they argued that Ms Hernandez had committed murder. The judge ruled that Ms Hernandez knew she was pregnant and found her guilty of aggravated homicide. She was sentenced to 30 years in prison in July 2017.
6634_1
What were the charges?
Ms Hernandez lawyers appealed against the judge's decision. The defence lawyers said that forensic test showed that the baby had died of meconium aspiration, inhaling his own early stool. This can happen while the baby is still in the uterus, during delivery or immediately after birth. The lawyers said that the test proved that Ms Hernandez had not tried to abort the baby but that it had died of natural causes. "There is no crime," defence lawyer Bertha Maria Deleon said. However, her conviction was confirmed by another court in October 2017 so her lawyers took their appeal to the country's supreme court. In February 2019, the supreme court annulled the 2017 conviction citing absence of evidence and ordered a retrial with a new judge. Ms Hernandez was released from jail pending the retrial.
6634_2
Why is there a retrial?
Ms Hernandez's lawyers say prosecutors on Monday changed the charges levelled against her from aggravated homicide to manslaughter. Going into the trial on Monday, Ms Hernandez said she was innocent and that she had trust "in God and my lawyers".
6634_3
What is the latest?
Rights organisations in El Salvador says there are still at least 20 other women in jail under the country's strict abortion laws. Over the last decade, campaigners have managed to free around 30 through evidence reviews. A retrial verdict in Ms Hernandez's favour would give those still in jail hope their convictions could also be overturned. The retrial comes just six weeks after new President Nayib Bukele took office and women's groups are hoping he could usher in a more lenient stance on the issue.
6634_4
Why is the case significant?