Manalal Prabhudayal vs Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd

The present appeals arise out of an order dated January 21, 2004 passed by the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in ARBA No. 20 of 2003 and an order dated August 3, 2004 passed in Review Petition No. 11 of 2004. By the said orders, the High Court partly allowed the appeal filed by the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. - respondent herein and reduced the rate of interest from 12 per cent per annum to 6 per cent per annum with effect from September 19, 1995, that is, from the date of the award passed by the arbitrator till the date of deposit of amount in the court. (A review petition, being R.P. No. 11 of 2004 filed by the appellant was also dismissed by the High Court on August 3, 2004).

The facts relevant for the purpose are that the appellant herein is a partnership firm and is having its shop in Bhubaneswar. It was insured with respondent-Insurance Company. Insurance policy was taken by the appellant in the year 1991 which was continued from time to time. The insurance coverage was to the tune of Rs.1,50,000/- (rupees one lakh fifty thousand only). It was the case of the appellant that due to communal riots in Bhubaneswar in March, 1991, the shop of the appellant-firm was ransacked, looted and was razed to the ground. The total pecuniary loss sustained by the appellant was to the extent of Rs. 4,00,000/- (rupees four lakhs only). Since, however, the liability of the Insurance Company was limited to Rs. 1,50,000/- (rupees one lakh fifty thousand only), the appellant lodged a claim of Rs. 1,93,075.00 (rupees one lakh ninety three thousand and seventy five only) on the basis of the amount insured at the rate of 12 per cent per annum. The Insurance Company instead of allowing the claim lodged by the appellant offered an amount of Rs. 50,425/- (rupees fifty thousand four hundred and twenty five only) since, according to the Insurance Company, as per the survey-report received by the Company, the loss was to that extent. As the appellant was not satisfied and the claim could not be settled, it invoked arbitration clause by issuing a notice for appointment of an arbitrator. An arbitrator was appointed who passed an award in Arbitration Case No. 1 of 1998 on June 13, 1999 allowing the claim of the appellant with interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum. The Insurance Company was directed to pay to the appellant a sum of rupees one lakh fifty thousand "with interest @ 12 per cent per annum from the date of claim till payment". In other words, the arbitrator granted interest to the appellant @ 12 per cent per annum all throughout, that is, pre-reference period, pendente lite and after the award till the date of payment.

Proceedings had been initiated for making award a rule of the court by moving the court of Civil Judge, Senior Division, Bhubaneswar. It was registered as O.S. No. 543 of 1999. The Insurance Company also filed Misc. Case No. 279 of 2002 for setting aside the award. After hearing the parties, the Civil Judge, (Senior Division), Bhubaneswar vide order dated October 9, 2002 'decreed' the suit in favour of the appellant herein. The award dated June 13, 1999 in Arbitration Case No. 1 of 1998 was made rule of the court and the respondent-Insurance Company was directed to pay the awarded amount to the appellant within three months from the date of the order.

For the foregoing reasons, the appeals filed by the appellant-firm deserve to be allowed and are accordingly allowed. The order passed by the High Court reducing the rate of interest from September 19, 1995 till the award and till the amount is paid/deposited in the court from 12 per cent to 6 per cent per annum is set aside and the order passed by the arbitrator in the award granting interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum all throughout, that is, for pre-reference period, pendente lite and post award period is upheld. In the facts and circumstances of the case, no costs.