Issue: load_from_disk in DatasetsDict/Dataset not working with PyArrowHDFS wrapper implementing fsspec.spec.AbstractFileSystem
State: closed
Labels: name: bug

## Describe the bug
Passing a PyArrowHDFS implementation of fsspec.spec.AbstractFileSystem (in the `fs` param required by `load_from_disk` methods in `DatasetDict` (in datasets_dict.py) and `Dataset` (in arrow_dataset.py) results in an error when calling the download method in the `fs` parameter.


## Steps to reproduce the bug

The documentation for the `fs` parameter states:

```
fs (:class:`~filesystems.S3FileSystem` or ``fsspec.spec.AbstractFileSystem``, optional, default ``None``):
                Instance of the remote filesystem used to download the files from.
```

`PyArrowHDFS` from [fsspec](https://filesystem-spec.readthedocs.io/en/latest/_modules/fsspec/implementations/hdfs.html) implements `fsspec.spec.AbstractFileSystem`. However, when using it as shown below, I get an error.

```python
from fsspec.implementations.hdfs import PyArrowHDFS
...
transformed_corpus_path = "/user/my_user/clickbait/transformed_ds/"
fs = PyArrowHDFS(host, port, user, kerb_ticket=kerb_ticket)
dss = DatasetDict.load_from_disk(transformed_corpus_path, fs, True)
```

## Expected results

Previous to load from disk, I have managed to successfully store in HDFS the data and meta-information of a DatasetDict by doing:
```python
transformed_corpus_path = "/user/my_user/clickbait/transformed_ds/"
fs = PyArrowHDFS(host, port, user, kerb_ticket=kerb_ticket)
my_datasets.save_to_disk(transformed_corpus_path, fs=fs)
```

As I have 3 datasets in the DatasetDict named `my_datasets`, the previous Python code creates the following contents in HDFS:

```sh
$ hadoop fs -ls "/user/my_user/clickbait/transformed_ds/"
Found 4 items
-rw-------   3 my_user users         43 2021-10-19 03:08 /user/my_user/clickbait/transformed_ds/dataset_dict.json
drwx------   - my_user users          0 2021-10-19 03:08 /user/my_user/clickbait/transformed_ds/test
drwx------   - my_user users          0 2021-10-19 03:08 /user/my_user/clickbait/transformed_ds/train
drwx------   - my_user users          0 2021-10-19 03:08 /user/my_user/clickbait/transformed_ds/validation
```

I would expect to recover on `dss` the Arrow-backed datasets I previously saved in HDFS calling the `save_to_disk` method on the `DatasetDict` object when invoking `DatasetDict.load_from_disk(...)` as described above. 

## Actual results

However, when trying to recover the saved datasets, I get this error:

```
...
  File "/home/fperez/dev/neuromancer/neuromancer/corpus.py", line 186, in load_transformed_corpus_from_disk
    dss = DatasetDict.load_from_disk(transformed_corpus_path, fs, True)
  File "/home/fperez/anaconda3/envs/neuromancer/lib/python3.9/site-packages/datasets/dataset_dict.py", line 748, in load_from_disk
    dataset_dict[k] = Dataset.load_from_disk(dataset_dict_split_path, fs, keep_in_memory=keep_in_memory)
  File "/home/fperez/anaconda3/envs/neuromancer/lib/python3.9/site-packages/datasets/arrow_dataset.py", line 1048, in load_from_disk
    fs.download(src_dataset_path, dataset_path.as_posix(), recursive=True)
  File "pyarrow/_hdfsio.pyx", line 438, in pyarrow._hdfsio.HadoopFileSystem.download
TypeError: download() got an unexpected keyword argument 'recursive'
```

Examining the [signature of the download method in pyarrow 5.0.0](https://github.com/apache/arrow/blob/54d2bd89c99df72fa091b025452f85dd5d88e3cf/python/pyarrow/_hdfsio.pyx#L438) we can see that there's no download parameter:

```python
    def download(self, path, stream, buffer_size=None):
        with self.open(path, 'rb') as f:
            f.download(stream, buffer_size=buffer_size)
```

## Environment info
- `datasets` version: 1.13.3
- Platform: Linux-3.10.0-1160.15.2.el7.x86_64-x86_64-with-glibc2.33
- Python version: 3.9.7
- PyArrow version: 5.0.0


Hi ! Can you try again with pyarrow 6.0.0 ? I think it includes some changes regarding filesystems compatibility with fsspec.

Hi @lhoestq! I ended up using `fsspec.implementations.arrow.HadoopFileSystem` which doesn't have the problem I described with pyarrow 5.0.0.

I'll try again with `PyArrowHDFS` once I update arrow to 6.0.0.

Thanks!