Understanding Deep Architectures using a Recursive Convolutional Network
Authors: David Eigen, Jason Rolfe, Rob Fergus, Yann LeCun
ICLR 2014

Abstract: Convolutional neural network models have recently been shown to achieve excellent performance on challenging recognition benchmarks. However, like many deep models, there is little guidance on how the architecture of the model should be selected. Important hyper-parameters such as the degree of parameter sharing, number of layers, units per layer, and overall number of parameters must be selected manually through trial-and-error. To address this, we introduce a novel type of recursive neural network that is convolutional in nature. Its similarity to standard convolutional models allows us to tease apart the important architectural factors that influence performance. We find that for a given parameter budget, deeper models are preferred over shallow ones, and models with more parameters are preferred to those with fewer. Surprisingly and perhaps counterintuitively, we find that performance is independent of the number of units, so long as the network depth and number of parameters is held constant. This suggests that, computational efficiency considerations aside, parameter sharing within deep networks may not be so beneficial as previously supposed.


Peer review:
[Review]:
We would like to thank all the reviewers and readers for their comments and concerns.  In response, we have made many significant revisions, including a new abstract and discussion, and new plots including training error for each experiment.  We have responded to each of your comments above in separate replies.

The new version is now available on arxiv.