Instruction: Answer the given question by extracting information from the supporting document.

Input:
Question: Do the lids screw on tightly without the shaker? Or is the shaker needed for the lid to close?
Document: I ordered these bottles to use for my dried herbs. They're perfect--not too big, but big enough so I can store a lot of herbs. The different size shaker caps are very handy and fit tightly.I don't really care that they didn't come with labels; I just write on the lid or bottle itself with a permanent marker, or a sticky label (that I already have).I'm especially happy that they're made in USA.
These jars arrived well packaged and neat. They fit my spices great and are the perfect regular sized spice jars with nice little shaker hole lid thingys, and white screw on plastic caps. I love that they are made is the USA which was what made my final decision to buy these. I would recommend them for anyone who is looking for very functional nice sized spice jars. Oh, and my husband accidentally dropped one on the kitchen floor the other day and it didn't even crack!
When I ordered this I was expecting that the case would contain 16 pcs, which in today's parlance usually means that each jar would consist of a lid and jar, with a few shaker tops thrown in. You get sixteen jars and lids here, and an assortment of large and small hole shaker tops. This was well worth the price.
The mouth is wide enough to add spices and sprinkles without using a funnel, unless your hands are shaky. The two sizes of holes in the shaker tops are suitable for anything from seasoning salt to cupcake sprinkles. If you're going to wash these before using (I always do), plan to do it by hand and separate the shaker tops from the lids before dropping them into the soapy dishwater.
I discovered that the red McCormick spice lids that have the flip top shaker lid fit just perfect on these spice jars. So now for my salt and pepper that need measuring and a shaker I have the best of both worlds-- a red McCormick flip top lid. I can unscrew the lid for measuring OR flip the lid for the shaker. I am really pleased and happy with this purchase and recommend this item.
Also, the red plastic McCormick flip-top shaker lids fit these jars, as well as the blue Great Value brand. There is also a yellow flip-top shaker lid that fits, but I do not know the brand.Lastly, be sure to check the prices! When I purchased these, it was cheaper to buy 3 of the 16 count boxes with super saver shipping than it was to purchase the 48 count.
I needed more spice jars and found these. Products are exactly as expected. Arrived on time and without any difficulty or follow-up.Preprinted labels are good but blank labels are useless as ink will not dry on them and they smear.
I really like these bottles! I needed something new for my cabinets after 30+ years of McCormick, Spice Islands and Schilling bottles of varying sizes and shapes tumbling out whenever I needed the seasoning at the bottom or back of the stacks. These are obviously well made, first-quality items, with clear glass, white lids and opaque shaker tops with two sizes (24 each)of holes.
I've always wanted one. I use a lot of different spice, and storage in a drawer became problematic because they shifted out of order, wasting time hunting for what I needed. With the carousel they are out of the drawer,up on the counter and at my fingertips, without taking up a lot of precious counter space. It is well made, heavy enough so it won't tip over, and attractive. What more could I ask for?
I've taken to buying spices in bulk, since the food store I go to now has a whole bulk section (also, it's way cheaper that way). I needed a place to store the spices that I didn't already have jars for (i.e. anything that didn't come standard with the spice rack I got gifted with at my wedding). These are, well...glass jars with tops. It would be hard to screw them up.
Answer: The lid screws on the same tightness with or without the shaker component.