Instruction: Given a question and its related document, determine if the question is answerable by analyzing the information in the document. Output yes if the document addresses the question, or no otherwise.

Input:
Question: My husband has a woodworking shop in our garage which is under our living quarters would this alarm work or would we have false alarms all the time?
Document: I swapped out my old ion alarms for the photoelectric ones based on a newspaper article that claimed the ion type gave too many false alarms (ie cooking in kitchen) and the ion type were not as senstive as the photoelectric types in that by the time an ion type alarm finally went off, a real fire would be well-underway.I find now - from actual usage - that the photoelectric generates MANY MORE false alarms than the older ion type (probably because it's more sensitive).
I have had a prior design for 10 years. I replaced the old smoke detectors with these and they work fine. No false alarms for me.
These work very well, for a span of time. Then they kinda go bonkers and alarm for no reason! They are not the only Hardwire Smoke Alarm w/battery backup that behave this way. We have tried a few! Yes, we replace the batteries for the 'battery backup' bi-annually and they still seem to have this NEED to freak out after about 5 - 6 years! We thought we could use them without the battery, but then they simply alarm all the time!
The new ring WILL fit under the two screws. It's a tight fit, but it does work. Before you start you might want to check and be sure what type of screw is holding the existing ring in place. I got on the ladder expecting a Phillips screw. It was a square.The alarms seem to work fine. We haven't had any false alarms. If you do have false alarms it's my understanding that power issues can cause that, especially at night.
We replaced our old BRK smoke detectors with these after our old ones would alarm for no reason in the middle of the night. It was very annoying. The house was installed with them 8 years before, but I guess smoke detectors don't work efficiently that long. I didn't want to replace them with the same brand, but learned that I had to. We have had the new ones installed for about a month (My hubby easily installed them.) and we have had no problems.
I do not write many reviews but these were so bad and took so much of my time that I thought I had a responsibility to make sure others do not live through the false alarm beeb hell.I have no issue with Amazon. Ordering, delivery all went well as usual. The problems began once I had installed the 6 units in my house. I was replacing units that were 10 years old but for the most part gave me no problems.
I bought 4 of this product to install in my home.They seemed to work fine, but every few days, each of them would chirp 3 times. It isn't 3 full alarm tones indicating a fire, just chirps, but its enough to wake you. I talked to the BRK/First Alert customer service agent after the first one did this and he couldn't even tell me what the 3 chirps signal meant!
All I had to do was replace the trim ring as the plug was exactly the same. I can't imagine the wire harness being hard to replace either if you do your own home electrical work.So I installed the alarms and that was that until it was time for the real thing (more or less). I had some pasta boil over on the stove and the burner caught on fire. It wasn't major, maybe 6 to 8 inch flames, but a fire nonetheless.
Do not buy unless you like being awoken while you're sleeping for false alarms. Huge waste of time and money. Buy another brand like Kidde.
I bought this unit to replace my existing BRK ionization detectors. So far so good. No false alarms, no alarms in the middle of the night. I guess we'll just have to see how they hold up with time.
Answer: yes