endogenous growth convexity of damage and climate risk how nordhaus framework supports deep cuts in carbon emissions to slow or not to slow nordhaus 1991 was the first economic appraisal of greenhouse gas emissions abatement and founded a large literature on a topic of worldwide importance we offer our assessment of the original article and trace its legacy in particular nordhaus s later series of dice models from this work many have drawn the conclusion that an efficient global emissions abatement policy comprises modest and modestly increasing controls we use dice itself to provide an initial illustration that if the analysis is extended to take more strongly into account three essential elements of the climate problem the endogeneity of growth the convexity of damage and climate risk optimal policy comprises strong controls

electric power sector reform liberalization models and electric power prices in developing countries an empirical analysis using international panel data this study aims to clarify whether the effects of electric power sector reforms should be different either across regions or between developing and developed countries an empirical model was analyzed to observe the impact of electric power prices on the selection of a liberalization model in the power sector this was achieved by the use of an ordered response fixed effect and a random effect model an instrument variable technique was also used to estimate the impact of the liberalization model on the electric power price this technique addressed the problems of simultaneity bias between the electric power price and the liberalization models selected these econometric models were designed using panel data from 78 countries in four regions developed countries asian developing countries the former soviet union and eastern europe and latin america for the period from 1985 to 2003 the research findings suggest that higher electricity prices are one of the driving forces for governments to adopt liberalization models however the development of liberalization models in the power sector does not necessarily reduce electricity prices in fact contrary to expectations there was a tendency for the price to rise in every market modeled

determining discount rates for the evaluation of natural assets in land use planning an application of the equivalency principle one of the most pressing issues when making decisions over long term environmental problems is deciding on an appropriate discount rate this can be a highly technical discussion while some argue in favour of market rates which usually tend to be high others support the use of near zero rates to ensure that both current and future generations are properly accounted for this paper presents an alternative approach to determining the discount rate for environmental assets in the case of land use planning the equivalency principle ep based on the normative proposition that the social value of protected natural land should be at least the same as the market price of an adjacent land with similar environmental characteristics that has been granted permission for development the paper first provides a theoretical overview of the approach followed by an application of the ep at the land plot level across 11 european countries based on the ep pure rates of social time preference that would equate natural and development land values within each administrative unit have been calculated the findings show that the application of the ep usually results in discount rates that are lower than market rates and that are geographically differentiated this implies discount rates that account for preferences of the society where the land or natural resource is located with results ranging between 0 and 11 with an average rate of 1 across study sites

the effect of power distribution privatization on electricity prices in turkey has liberalization served the purpose various electricity reforms have been adopted by a number of countries within the last 2 decades turkey as one of those countries has restructured its electricity market and intensively privatized the distribution companies as one of the main targets of the liberalization efforts in the sector was announced to be reduced consumer prices it is a matter of interest to look at the related developments after privatizations hence this study attempts to explore the impact of power distribution privatization in turkey on the national end user electricity prices results of the analysis suggest that privatization of electricity distribution companies has not yielded the expected retail price declines within the first 4 years of the program whereas wholesale tariffs exhibit a reduction in the rate of 10 retail tariffs show an increase of 5 9 within the period in question besides the unstable patterns of the two tariffs imply that the market is not yet ready for the automatic pricing mechanism planned to be implemented based on a cost reflective methodology therefore results indicate that the factors behind the unsatisfactory outcomes of the program should be explored in order for the privatization efforts in the turkish electricity distribution market to serve the purpose

investment security of supply and sustainability in the aftermath of three decades of power sector reform the last three decades have witnessed many electricity industry reform processes in more than half of the countries in the world the reforms have aimed inter alia at encouraging private investments in electricity infrastructure enhancing security of electricity supply and making power industry operate in line with the requirements of the sustainable development using an original panel dataset from 55 developed and developing countries covering the period from 1975 to 2010 this study aims at finding out to what extent these objectives have been materialized so far econometric models are used to identify the effects of electricity market liberalization on these variables the research findings suggest that the progress toward the electricity market reform is associated with a decline in private investments in the electricity industries of developing countries higher levels of self sufficiency in electricity supply and lower co2 emissions from electricity generation

welfare specifications and optimal control of climate change an application of fund the sensitivity of the optimal control of carbon dioxide emissions to the specification of the social welfare function is systematically explored using the fund model increasing risk aversion emphasises climate change damages relative to emission reduction costs but at the same time increases the discount rate of consumption without international co operation the discount rate effect dominates so that optimal control decreases with increasing risk aversion with international co operation optimal control first increases then decreases with increasing risk aversion since climate change falls heaviest on the poor optimal control increases with increasing inequity aversion full fledged intergenerational welfare functions on the one hand emphasise climate change damages but on the other hand place more weight on current poorer generations in fund the two tendencies almost cancel

assessing the determinants of household electricity prices in the eu a system gmm panel data approach abstract a meaningful portion of the consumer basket of european households and companies is embodied by electricity as well as gas or refined petroleum products as energy products are essential inputs of nearly all final goods and services whichever change of energy prices has a direct impact of the general price level in this context the main purpose of this study is to assess the main drivers of household electricity prices in the european union eu throughout a period of deep sector transformation relying on eurostat data not only we analyze the long term progress of household electricity prices across the eu but also we provide empirical evidence on their determinants while confronting the results with the eu energy policy path for this purpose a firsthand approach is herein developed based on a dynamic model with panel data through gmm proposal method by blundell and bond 1998 4 with the windermeijer 2005 41 correction the data analysis provides grounds for a relation between the variable of household electricity prices with variables related to sector liberalization renewable energy sources which support the eu policy to boost liberalization this study offers evidence that the sector liberalization is accompanied by a decreasing trend in prices which is consistent with the european commission s objectives to liberalize

valuing the future recent advances in social discounting the perplexing issue of discounting prescriptive economics requires that unless there are very good reasons to the contrary economic policy should be based on the principle that individuals preferences should count indeed the entire body of welfare economics centres round the formal identity of the statement x prefers a to b and the statement x has higher welfare in a rather than b this combination of a seemingly innocuous and democratic value judgement preferences should count and a formal definition about the meaning of welfare improvement involves many complications the entire history of policy analysis focuses on those complications whose preferences should count over what time period what constitutes a legitimate attenuation of the basic value judgement one of the problem areas concerns timediscounting the process whereby society places a lower value on a future gain or loss than on the same gain or loss occurring now the rationale for time discounting follows logically from the basic value judgement of welfare economics if people s preferences count and if people prefer now to the future those preferences must be integrated into social policy formulation time discounting is thus universal in economic analysis but it remains as it always has controversial the controversy has a parallel in another form of discounting spatial discounting when translated into economic terms the ethical principle

who should abate carbon emission we review the optimal pattern of carbon emission abatements across countries in a simple multi country world we model explicitly with the model in chichilnisky 4 the fact that the atmosphere is a public good within this framework we establish conditions for it to be necessary for optimality that the marginal cost of abatement be the same in all countries these condition are quite restrictive and amount to either ignoring distributional issues between countries or operating within a framework within which lump sum transfers can be made between countries these results have implications for the use of tradeable emission permits which as normally advocated will lead to the equalization of marginal abatement costs across countries the observation that the atmosphere is a public good implies that we may need to look at a lindahl equilibrium rather than a walrasian equilibrium in tradeable permits

changing patterns of uk poverty 1997 2004 it has been noted that the failure to meet the target set by the government for reducing the head count ratio of child poverty in britain is partly due to the success of government policy in generating economic growth apart from ignoring the argument that absolute poverty is not a meaningful idea this apology for the failure of government to meet poverty targets also misses wider problems embedded in recent trends in the household income distribution for example inequality measures sensitive to the distribution of income amongst the poor suggest that the experience of those who remained poor may have worsened

the aggregation of climate change damages a welfare theoretic approach the economic value of environmental goods is commonly determined using the concepts of willingness to pay wtp or willingness to accept wta however the wtp wta observed in different countries or between individuals will differ according to socio economic characteristics in particular income this notion of differentiated values for otherwise identical goods say a given reduction in mortality risk has been criticized as unethical most recently in the context of the social cost chapter of the ipcc second assessment report these critics argue that being a function of income wtp wta estimates reflect the unfairness in the current income distribution and for equity reasons uniform per unit values should therefore be applied across individuals and countries this paper analyses the role of equity in the aggregation of climate change damage estimates using basic tools of welfare economics it shows one way of how wtp wta estimates can be corrected in aggregation if the underlying income distribution is considered unfair it proposes that in the aggregation process individual estimates be weighted with an equity factor derived from the social welfare and utility functions equity weighting can significantly increase aggregate global damage figures although some specifications of weighting functions also imply reduced estimates the paper also shows that while the postulate of uniform per unit values is compatible with a wide range of reasonable utility and welfare specifications there are also cases where the common value notion is not compatible with defensible welfare concepts

how reliable are microsimulation results an analysis of the role of sampling error in a u k tax benefit model abstract we assess the statistical reliability of microsimulation models in two ways by comparing simulated outcomes with survey actuals and by calculating asymptotic confidence intervals for a variety of summary measures the confidence intervals we derive take account of re weighting for differential survey response and also the effects of imposing revenue neutrality they are calculated for a version of one of the most widely used u k tax benefit simulation models the results suggest that baseline simulations are reasonably accurate but that some widely used measures of the effects of policy changes may be very imprecise estimates of population effects

the effects of electricity reforms on productivity and efficiency of china s fossil fired power plants an empirical analysis abstract this paper investigates the effects of electricity reforms on productivity and efficiency of china s generation plants based on the third industrial census data and the first economic census data partial factor productivity pfp analysis indicates that the productivity improvements in labor and capital inputs associated with the reforms are approximately 26 and 45 respectively the effect of the reforms on fuel expense is weakly significant but there is evidence of significant productivity improvement in fuel usage further total factor productivity tfp analysis shows that the efficiency gain from the reforms is still significant when the substitution effect of labor and capital inputs are considered though the magnitude is much lower than that of the pfp analysis the effect of the reforms on technical efficiency becomes weakly significant when fuel expense is further included in tfp analysis but a significant positive effect is expected if fuel input is measured in physical quantity

policy reform shadow prices and market prices how should public projects and policy reforms be assessed when market prices give misleading signals revenues and costs at market prices then give distorted measures of social gains and losses and our appraisal should use social opportunity costs or shadow prices we show how shadow prices may be integrated into an analysis of policy reform demonstrate the critical dependence of these prices on government policy and analyse their relations with market prices the model allows for a wide range of sources of impairment of price signals we also discuss key issues in the analysis of price reform and privatisation

broken dreams unmet expectations of investors in the philippine electricity restructuring and privatization abstract over the last three decades privatization and restructuring of electricity sectors has been a hot topic the expectation was that prices would fall due to increased competition and that generators would become more innovative and efficient however the enthusiasm for deregulation wavered after events such as the debacle in california the fall of enron and the setbacks of ontario in the philippines comprehensive legislation was passed in 2001 but the implementation has been rather slow and controversial this paper looked at the allegation of politicizing power rates and found a logical alternative to the perceived conspiracy angle based on market data it is highly probable that depressed market rates was a result of coping mechanisms of new players trying to adjust to the restructured industry

discounting and distributional considerations in the context of global warming the economics of global warming is reviewed with special emphasis on how the cost depends on the discount rate and on how costs in poor and rich regions are aggregated into a global cost estimate both of these factors depend on the assumptions made concerning the underlying utility and welfare functions it is common to aggregate welfare gains and losses across generations and countries as if the utility of money were constant but it is not if we assume that a e co2 equivalent dlubling implies costs equal to 1 5 of the income in both high and low income countries a pure rate of time preference equal to zero and a utility function which is logarithmic in income then the marginal cost of co2 emissions is estimated at 260 590 usd ton c for a time horizon in the range 300 1000 years an estimate which is large enough to justify significant reductions of co2 emissions on purely economic grounds the estimate is approximately 50 100 times larger than the estimate made by nordhaus in his dice model and the difference is almost completely due to the choice of discount rate and the weight given to the costs in the developing world as well as a more accurate model of the carbon cycle finally the sensitivity of the marginal cost estimate with respect to several parameters is analyzed

the social cost of carbon and its policy implications the shadow price or social cost of carbon is an important indicator of the global incremental damage done by emitting greenhouse gases today cost benefit analysis would set the optimal amount of greenhouse gas emission reduction at the point where this social cost just equals the incremental cost of controlling emissions the higher the value for the social cost of carbon the more control is warranted this comparison assumes that cost benefit analysis is the correct way of determining climate change policy and many believe this is not the case because of the very long term irreversible and potentially catastrophic nature of global warming but in the short run at least a comparison of cost and benefits is required and in any event all decisions imply costs and benefits but what is the right figure for the social cost of carbon this paper reviews the uk government s assessment of the cost and concludes that it has been set far too high because of a misreading of the integrated assessment models used to balance costs and benefits moreover adoption of the uk government s shadow price would have formidable implications for energy policy in the uk and for policies on afforestation copyright 2003 oxford university press

zero discounting can compensate future generations for climate damage abstract in cost benefit analysis of climate policy there are two main approaches to discounting each with implications conflicting with our moral intuitions thus discounted utilitarianism implies that we hardly need to protect future generations against climate change while classical utilitarianism implies that we should reduce our consumption across the board to benefit future generations the insolubility of the debate derives from the fact that both classical and discounted utilitarianism permit only a single discount rate for all consequences occurring in the same future year while our intuitions clearly do distinguish between consequences depending on whether we cause adverse effects on other people s interests and violate their rights most people share the moral intuition that we ought to refrain from harming others and ought to compensate them if we were unable to prevent harm to regain a reflective equilibrium between such deontological intuitions and economic theory there is a need to accept different discount rates for different situations a zero consumption discount rate in the case of cost benefit analysis of measures to prevent wrongful harm to future generations and standard discounting in all other cases applying a zero consumption discount rate means that future generations are automatically largely compensated for climate damage that remains unmitigated

reducing child poverty in britain an assessment of government policy 1997 2001 the reduction and eventual elimination of child poverty has become one of the central objectives of the new labour government in britain measures to achieve this by changing taxes and benefits and promoting paid work are described their effects are assessed using a micro simulation model the policy changes will achieve a significant reduction in child poverty but it will remain in 2001 substantially higher than in 1979 and much higher than in most european nations

impact of reform and privatization on consumers a case study of power sector reform in orissa india abstract orissa is the first state in india to have undergone reform in the power sector with the government withdrawing its control the model of this reform is known as the wb orissa model the goal of this paper is to examine the impact of this reform on consumers of electricity which has been measured using multiple regression models the variables represent the parameters that consumers are most interested in and the regression coefficients represent the weights of the corresponding variables the data were collected using a survey methodology the impact of reform was found to be mixed some groups of consumers saw benefits while others felt a negative impact a focus group study was conducted to identify the variables of interest to consumers of electricity the model was used to estimate consumer benefit and was validated using primary data and structural equation modeling the study revealed beneficial aspects of reform and areas with no benefits

preferences in the future environmental economics has been much occupied with the discount rate which is the value of future costs and benefits relative to present costsor benefits but at least as important is the question of whatshould be discounted that is what the value of those future environmentalbenefits is to future generations this paper analyzes the role for futurepreferences and discusses the state of knowledge i argue that theappropriate discount rate is the market one and that the real problemis determining future willingness to pay this approach makes clearerthe connection between discounting and the valuation debate this paper focuses on two features that have been prominent in that debate existence value and reference dependence i argue that thereis a vital connection between the two constructs and that this link yieldsimportant implications for future willingness to pay

social criteria for evaluating population change abstract many applications of economic analysis require social evaluations of alternatives involving different numbers of people in this paper we use the tools of social choice theory to provide an axiomatic formulation of this problem it yields a class of social criteria called critical level generalized utilitarianism this class and its implications are compared with other criteria and are found to yield intuitively appealing results

intertemporal population ethics critical level utilitarian principles this paper considers the problem of social evaluation in a model where population size individual lifetime utilities lengths of life and birth dates vary across states in an intertemporal framework we investigate principles for social evaluation that allow history to matter to some extent using an axiom called independence of the utilities of the dead we provide a characterization of critical level generalized utilitarian rules as a by product of our analysis we show that social discounting is ruled out in an intertemporal welfarist environment a simple population planning example is also discussed

the damage costs of climate change towards a dynamic representation economic assessments of climate change impacts are commonly presented as the effect of a climate change associated with a doubling of the atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide on the current economy this paper is an attempt to express impact as a function of both climate change and socio economic change with regard to climate change issues discussed are level versus rate of change speed of adaptation speed of restoration and value adjustment and symmetry with regard to socio economic change agriculture migration and the valuation of intangible losses are addressed uncertainty and higher order impacts are treated briefly it is qualitatively argued and quantitatively illustrated that these issues matter a great deal for the damage profile over the next century a damage model based on my best guesses is presented in the appendix

do people care about future generations derived preferences from happiness data the main approaches for computing very long term discount rates revealed and stated preferences have limitations we overcome previous shortcomings using derived preferences i e we retrieve information on very long term time preferences from happiness data and people s expectations about the living conditions of future generations we account for possible endogeneity between expectations about the future and current well being using 2sls we find that negative positive expectations about future generations have a very large negative positive impact on subjective well being this finding suggests that the very long term discount rate is lower than implied by most traditional economic analyses

the impact of power market reforms on electricity price cost margins and cross subsidy levels a cross country panel data analysis abstract one of the main expectations from power market reform has been a reduction in both price cost margins and cross subsidy levels between industrial and residential consumers this paper focuses on this issue by looking at the impact of the electricity industry reforms on residential and industrial electricity price cost margins and their effect on cross subsidy levels between consumer groups using panel data for 63 developed and developing countries covering the period 1982 2009 empirical models are developed and analyzed the research findings suggest that there is no uniform pattern for the impact of reform process as a whole on price cost margins and cross subsidy levels each individual reform step has different impact on price cost margins and cross subsidy levels for each consumer and country group our findings imply that reform steps have different impacts in different countries which supports the idea reform prescription for a specific country cannot easily and successfully be transferred to another one so transferring the formal and economic structure of a successful power market in a developed country to developing countries is not a sufficient condition for good economic performance of the electricity industries in developing countries furthermore the study suggests that power consumption income level and country specific features constitute other important determinants of electricity price cost margins and cross subsidy levels

the stern review a deconstruction using a simple model designed for transparency but nonetheless calibrated to support the much quoted damage estimates of the stern review of the economics of climate change we demonstrate significant sensitivity of those results to assumptions about the pure rate of time preference the time horizon and the rates of risk and equity aversion used to compute certainty and equity equivalent annuities most importantly we demonstrate enormous sensitivity to presumed constant regional vulnerability and underlying assumptions about adaptive capacity manipulation of any of these parameters one at a time across reasonable ranges can diminish damage estimates by as much as 84 or in the case of extending the time horizon with the review s low discount rate increase damage estimates by 900 we also confirm the usual result that limiting atmospheric concentrations to specific benchmarks above 400 ppm cannot eliminate all damages nonetheless we applaud the stern review author team for reconfirming that the climate problem can be approached productively as an economic problem whose solutions can be explored with the tools of decision analysis 2008 elsevier ltd all rights reserved

did residential electricity rates fall after retail competition a dynamic panel analysis abstract a key selling point for the restructuring of electricity markets was the promise of lower prices there is not much consensus in earlier studies on the effects of electricity deregulation in the u s particularly for residential customers part of the reason for not finding a consistent link with deregulation and lower prices was that the removal of transitional price caps led to higher prices in addition the timing of the removal of price caps coincided with rising fuel prices which were passed on to consumers in a competitive market using a dynamic panel model we analyze the effect of participation rates fuel costs market size a rate cap and switch to competition for 16 states and the district of columbia we find that an increase in participation rates price controls a larger market and high shares of hydro in electricity generation lower retail prices while increases in natural gas and coal prices increase rates we also find that retail competition makes the market more efficient by lowering the markup of retail prices over wholesale costs the effects of a competitive retail electricity market are mixed across states but generally appear to lower prices in states with high participation rates

designing climate mitigation policy this us paper provides an exhaustive review of critical issues in the design of climate mitigation policy by pulling together key findings and controversies from diverse literatures on mitigation costs damage valuation policy instrument choice technological innovation and international climate policy the authors begin with the broadest issue of how high assessments suggest the near and medium term price on greenhouse gases would need to be both under cost effective stabilization of global climate and under net benefit maximization or pigouvian emissions pricing the remainder of the paper focuses on the appropriate scope of regulation issues in policy instrument choice complementary technology policy and international policy architectures

right for the right reasons four authors of the stern review on the economics of climate change and dennis anderson who provided advice and background papers for the review make a final rejoinder on the debate about the review that has occupied recent issues of this journal they respond to comments in the present issue by carter et al by henderson and by tol and yohe carter et al continue to argue against a growing body of scientific evidence and a growing consensus on that same evidence the source of their critique is first a distinctly partisan and increasingly untenable position on the broad range of available scientific evidence and second a mistrust of the international consensus building exercise centred on the intergovernmental panel on climate change henderson is also largely preoccupied with the latter procedural issues tol and yohe focus on economic arguments their critique is rather narrower in focus and concerns the way in which abatement costs were calculated in the supporting work carried out by dennis anderson it rests on basic confusions and misconceptions many of which were explained in previous contributions however readers of world economics might be more interested in a broader reflection how would the stern team following the debate of the last eight months assess the approach policies and arguments set out in the review their view is that their analyses and policy proposals and the arguments in support are sound and have stood up well to scrutiny in other words they were right and for the right reasons central to many critiques of the review is a fundamental misunderstanding of the role of formal highly aggregated economic modelling nevertheless the stern team have argued strongly and in their view convincingly that even within the confines of formal economic modelling the concerns raised by a small group of commentators do not overturn their basic conclusion that the cost of action is much less than the cost of inaction the critics here fall short by failing to simultaneously afford the necessary importance to issues of risk and ethics

human capital tangible wealth and the intangible capital residual since income is the return on wealth the total wealth of any given country should be on the order of 20 times its gdp instead the average observed ratio from the balance sheet accounts of the system of national accounts sna is a factor of 2 6 to 6 6 depending on whether natural resource stocks are included in the balance sheet the clear implication is that the sna wealth accounts are incomplete with the most obvious omission being human capital estimating the value of human capital using the lifetime income approach for a sample of thirteen mostly high income countries yields a mean share of human capital in total wealth of 62 four times the value of produced capital and 15 times the value of natural capital but for selected high income countries in the sample there is still an average of 25 of total wealth which is unaccounted it is neither produced nor natural nor human capital this residual intangible wealth is arguably the stock equivalent of total factor productivity the value of assets such as institutional quality and social capital which augment the capacity of produced natural and human capital to support a stream of consumption into the future

the impact of regulatory quality and corruption on residential electricity prices in the context of electricity market reforms abstract the european electricity markets have been undergoing significant regulatory reforms since the introduction of the first liberalisation directive in 1996 theory predicts that liberalisation promotes cost efficient production and competition and hence leads to lower prices the goal of this paper is to assess the impact of regulatory quality and non compliance with the law on electricity prices in the context of electricity market reforms we address problems of endogeneity by using the blundell blond system gmm estimator and find that vertical integration and market concentration lower end user prices all else equal moreover improving regulatory quality and reducing corruption both have a negative impact on prices when holding other factors constant the intensity of the reforms has limited impact on electricity prices when these reforms are introduced in an institutional environment characterised by high levels of corruption and low quality regulation

deregulation vertical unbundling and the performance of china s large coal fired power plants article i nfo in 2003 china s integrated electricity utility the state power corporation spc was unbundled and dism antled into five generation groups and two grid companies in an effort to increase competition and improve ef ficiency in this paper we study the impact of this deregulation reform on the operational efficiency for a balanced panel of 34 large power plants for the period 1997 2010 we find that on average these power plants have converged to the technological frontier over the sample period controlling for substantial heterogeneity in the technical profile we also find that the unbundling reform has boosted productivity of china s large thermal power plants however the presumably differential impacts of the reform on the previously spc managed power plants and the independent power producers in our sample are insignificant

the stern review and the costs of climate change mitigation responding to the dual critique and the tol and yohe paper in the previous issue of world economics professor anderson counters a number of assertions made in those papers including the claims that the stern review is alarmist or scaremongering biased in its estimates and was not reviewed by peers he points to a number of areas where the authors either got it wrong or seriously misrepresented the review

a review of the stern review on the economics of climate change the stern review calls for immediate decisive action to stabilize greenhouse gases because the benefits of strong early action on climate change outweighs the costs the economic analysis supporting this conclusion consists mostly of two basic strands the first strand is a formal aggregative model that relies for its conclusions primari ly upon imposing a very low discount rate concerning this discount rate aspect i am skeptical of the review s formal analysis but this essay points out that we are actual ly a lot less sure about what interest rate should be used for discounting climate change than is commonly acknowledged the review s second basic strand is a more intuitive argument that it might be very important to avoid possibly large uncertain ties that are difficult to quantify concerning this uncertainty aspect i argue that it might be recast into sound analytical reasoning that might justify some of the review s conclusions the basic issue here is that spending money to slow global warming should perhaps not be conceptualized primarily as being about consump tion smoothing as much as being about how much insurance to buy to offset the small change of a ruinous catastrophe that is difficult to compensate by ordinary savings

what is wrong with the west european economies tol and yohe point out that in their reply vol 8 no 1 to tol and yohe s review vol 7 no 4 the stern team demonstrates the fragility of the numerical findings of the cost benefit analysis in the stern review at the same time the stern team puts less weight on cost benefit analysis as a guide to policy making on climate change tol and yohe show that the stern review allows several mutually contradictory interpretations of the model that underlies the cost estimates and argue that each interpretation implies that stern s cost estimates have a severe downward bias

the behavioural economics of climate change this paper attempts to bring some central insights from behavioural economics into the economics of climate change in particular it discusses i implications of prospect theory the equity premium puzzle and time inconsistent preferences in the choice of discount rate used in climate change cost assessments and ii the implications of various kinds of social preferences for the outcome of climate negotiations several reasons are presented for why it appears advisable to choose a substantially lower social discount rate than the average return on investments it also seems likely that taking social preferences into account increases the possibilities of obtaining international agreements compared to the standard model however there are also effects going in the opposite direction and the importance of sanctions is emphasized

the environmental paradox in generation how south america is gradually becoming more dependent on thermal generation there has been an increasing focus on global warming emission of green house gases ghg and the problems this might create in this article we review the trend in sustainable and renewable electricity generation in south america where the generation portfolio increasingly depends on thermal generation in particular gas south america is a region that has relatively low emissions but the current development is not desirable in environmental terms we analyze the underlying reasons for this development which is related to security of supply deregulation and the cost of renewable energy we review and discuss the policies to promote renewables in the region we analyze the potential advantages and drawbacks of different types of market interventions such as direct subsidies that create potentially strong market distortions more sophisticated market interventions that might be less intrusive but not necessarily as effective as e g firm energy markets we also review market based solutions such as the clean market mechanism and its potential and the use of renewable electricity in non interconnected zones which might be one of the most economically attractive applications of renewables however without a stronger and more aggressive intervention from the governments in the region it is unlikely that the increase in thermal generation can be stopped

evaluating projects and assessing sustainable development in imperfect economies we are interested in three related questions 1 how should accounting prices be estimated 2 how should we evaluate policy change in an imperfect economy 3 how can we check whether intergenerational well being will be sustained along a projected economic programme we do not presume that the economy is convex nor do we assume that the government optimizes on behalf of its citizens we show that the same set of accounting prices should be used both for policy evaluation and for assessing whether or not intergenerational welfare along a given economic path will be sustained we also show that a comprehensive measure of wealth computed in terms of the accounting prices can be used as an index for problems 2 and 3 above the remainder of the paper is concerned with rules for estimating the accounting prices of several specific environmental natural resources transacted in a few well known economic institutions

inequality and poverty in united states the effects of rising dispersion of men s earnings and changing family behaviour using semiparametric density estimation techniques we analyse the effect of rising dispersion of men s earnings and related changes in family behaviour on increasing inequality in the distribution of family income in the united states for the period 1969 1989 the growing dispersion of men s earnings and changing family structure can account for most of the rise in family income inequality by contrast the increase in labour force participation by women offset this trend inequality grew at a slower rate in the 1990s than in earlier decades largely because of stabilization in the relative earnings of men from low income families

how to spend it resource wealth and the distribution of resource rents natural resource revenues differ from other government revenues both in their time profile and in their political and legal status they are volatile and exhaustible and belong to all citizens of the country in which they are located this paper discusses the theory of natural resource revenues and examines expenditure practices in a range of resource rich countries it considers both the distributional impact and the efficiency of expenditure policies focusing on the extent to which they succeed in providing all citizens with their share of the benefits due to natural resources

weight factors in cost benefit analysis of climate change equity considerations may justify the use of weight factors when estimating the costs of climate change this paper reviews different weight factors that have been used in the climate economics literature based on a simple model it is shown that although the different weight factors imply substantially different cost damage estimates they actually yield the same optimal emission reductions this paradox is explained by the fact that some of the approaches require that also the abatement costs are weighted and this offsets the effect of the diverging cost damage estimates the model is then used to analyse the importance weighting may have on the overall cost benefit analysis at present when most of the global emissions of fossil co2 originate from the industrialised countries the global optimal emissions are considerably lower if costs are weighted however the more the emissions in developing countries grow the less important becomes the introduction of weight factors in cost benefit analysis of climate change for the global emission reductions in the model developed here on a regional level the introduction of weight factors continues to play an important role implying substantially lower emissions in the rich region and slightly higher in the poor

a new global deal on climate change a global target of stabilizing greenhouse gas concentrations at between 450 and 550 parts per million carbon dioxide equivalent ppm co2e has proven robust to recent developments in the science and economics of climate change retrospective analysis of the stern review 2007 suggests that the risks were underestimated indicating a stabilization target closer to 450 ppm co2e climate policy at the international level is now moving rapidly towards agreeing an emissions pathway and distributing responsibilities between countries a feasible framework can be constructed in which each country takes on its own responsibilities and targets based on a shared understanding of the risks and the need for action and collaboration on climate change the global deal should contain six key features i a pathway to achieve the world target of 50 per cent reductions by 2050 where rich countries contribute at least 75 per cent of the reductions ii global emissions trading to reduce costs iii reform of the clean development mechanism to scale up emission reductions on a sectoral or benchmark level iv scaling up of rd v an agreement on deforestation and vi adaptation finance

discount rate and the social cost of carbon dioxide a korean forecast this paper is to forecast the korean long term social discount rate of carbon dioxide sdrc and the social cost of carbon dioxide scc it is estimated using the ramsey function savings behavior

political pricing of electricity can it go with universal service provision abstract political parties in india are known to use electricity prices as a tool to secure a win in the democratic election process this article examines the setting of electricity prices from a political economy perspective citizens differ in their willingness to pay for electricity and the consumer surplus and electoral uncertainty seem to influence their choices while exercising their franchise to win political parties must receive a majority of votes and a party in power may try to achieve this by choosing to ignore a consumer group either by charging a price higher than their willingness to pay or by choosing to satisfy them by charging a lower price two theoretical models are proposed the first model computes the possible prices when common perfectly correlated electoral shocks are anticipated while the second model computes the possible prices for independent and identically distributed electoral shocks we test these models with available data on willingness to pay and electricity price for agricultural domestic and industrial consumers in an indian state by generating prices that would be charged to each of these types of consumers to maximize the chances of re election actual prices seem to confirm the second model more than the first

justifying precautionary policies incommensurability and uncertainty abstract when decisions are taken in conditions of keynesian or knightian uncertainty and when there is a threat of serious or irreversible environmental damage the precautionary principle is often recommended to guide decision making however the precautionary principle has been widely criticised in response to these criticisms a qualitative version of the precautionary principle is developed which draws its normative content from a blend of formal decision theory and political philosophy it is argued that precautionary action can be justified by some flexible combination of uncertainty and incommensurability the greater the uncertainty the less incommensurability is required to justify precautionary action and vice versa throughout the paper the arguments are explored using the example of climate change decision problems

effects of regulatory reforms in the electricity supply industry on electricity prices in developing countries electric power sector reforms in the electricity supply industry have had an impact on industrial and household prices in developing countries in latin america the former soviet union and eastern europe using original panel data for 83 countries during the period from 1985 to 2002 we examine how each policy instrument of the reform measures influenced electricity prices for countries in the above regions we found that variables such as entry of independent power producers ipp unbundling of generation and transmission establishment of a regulatory agency and the introduction of a wholesale spot market have had a variety of impacts on electricity prices some of which were not always consistent with expected results the research findings suggest that neither unbundling nor introduction of a wholesale pool market on their own necessarily reduces the electric power price in fact contrary to expectations there was a tendency for the price to rise however coexistent with an independent regulator unbundling may work to reduce electricity prices privatization and the introduction of foreign ipp and retail competition lower electricity prices in some regions but not all

spite and development in a wide variety of settings spiteful preferences would constitute an obstacle to cooperation trade and thus economic development this paper shows that spiteful preferences the desire to reduce another s material payoff for the mere purpose of increasing one s relative payoff are surprisingly widespread in experiments conducted in one of the least developed regions in india uttar pradesh in a one shot trust game the authors find that a large majority of subjects punish cooperative behavior although such punishment clearly increases inequality and decreases the payoffs of both subjects in experiments to study coordination and to measure social preferences the findings reveal empirical patterns suggesting that the willingness to reduce another s material payoff either for the sake of achieving more equality or for the sake of being ahead is stronger among individuals belonging to high castes than among those belonging to low castes because extreme social hierarchies are typically accompanied by a culture that stresses status seeking it is plausible that the observed social preference patterns are at least partly shaped by this culture thus an exciting question for future research is the extent to which different institutions and cultures produce preferences that are conducive or detrimental to economic development

the impact of climate change on the balanced growth equivalent an application of fund the stern review added balanced growth equivalents bge to the economic climate change research agenda we first propose rigorous definitions of the bge for multiple regions and under uncertainty we show that the change in the bge is independent of the assumed scenario of per capita income for comparable welfare economic assumptions as the stern review we calculate lower changes in bge between a business as usual scenario and one without climate impacts with the model fund than the stern review found with the model page we find that mitigation policies give even lower changes in bge and argue that those policy choices should be the focus of the research effort rather than total damage estimates according to our results the current carbon tax should be below 55 tc sensitivity analyses show that the stern review chose parameters that imply high impact estimates however for regionally disaggregated welfare functions we find changes in bge that are significantly higher than the results from the stern review both for total damage as for policy analysis with regional disaggregation and high risk aversion we observe fat tails and with that very high welfare losses

ethics of the discount rate in the stern review on the economics of climate change any comparison of the costs and benefits of climate change is dominated by the chosen discount rate but although the stern review emphasises the ethical nature of the parameters entering into its choice of a relatively low discount rate its discussion of the pure time preference parameter is unbalanced in particular no consideration is given to the role of agent relative ethics which i has a wellestablished philosophical pedigree going back to david hume ii is likely to correspond closely to world wide public attitudes towards intergenerational welfare and iii would entail discounting a unit of welfare accruing to future generations compared to an equal unit accruing to people alive today at a positive rate the authors also discuss the other ethical parameter upon which the discount rate depends namely the elasticity of marginal utility with respect to consumption in the conventional model this simultaneously reflects different aspects of inequality aversion as well as risk aversion which complicates its interpretation finally they discuss the divergence between market rates of discount and the low rate chosen in the review and the limitations on the one hand on the normative significance of market rates as well as the danger on the other hand of relying on rates chosen by elites or philosopher kings

a 100 year review of electricity policy in ireland 1916 2015 abstract over the past century ireland s electricity sector has undergone a significant transformation this paper documents the nation s struggle to build an electricity system to improve security of electricity supply through portfolio diversification and to promote indigenous energy sources this was a challenge for an electrically isolated island with little natural resources the paper also identifies the ineffective policy decisions that left ireland exposed to the 1970s energy crises the crises did however provide a clear impetus for focusing irish energy policy going forward the successful deployment and integration of large scale wind power was due to strong national and supranational policy decisions in 2015 ireland had the third highest wind energy share of national electricity demand 22 8 of all iea wind member countries the paper also traces ireland s transition through market reform regional fragmentation and looks onwards to the eu internal market for electricity in essence this paper provides a holistic view of the implications of various policy decisions on the electricity sector along with the stresses of external factors on the electricity market and should be useful for policy makers elsewhere faced with similar decisions

a review of the stern review on the economics of climate change how much and how fast should we react to the threat of global warming the stern review argues that the damages from climate change are large and that nations should undertake sharp and immediate reductions in greenhouse gas emissions an examination of the review s radical revision of the economics of climate change finds however that it depends decisively on the assumption of a near zero time discount rate combined with a specific utility function the review s unambiguous conclusions about the need for extreme immediate action will not survive the substitution of assumptions that are consistent with today s marketplace real interest rates and savings rates

the damage costs of climate change toward more comprehensive calculations it is argued that estimating the damage costs of a certain benchmark climate change is not sufficient what is needed are cost functions and confidence intervals although these are contained in the integrated models and their technical manuals this paper brings them into the open in order to stimulate discussion after briefly reviewing the benchmark climate change damage costs region specific cost functions are presented which distinguish tangible from intangible losses and the losses due to a changing climate from those due to a changed climate furthermore cost functions are assumed to be quadratic as an approximation of the unknown but presumably convex functions results from the damage module of the integrated climate economy model fund are presented next uncertainties are incorporated and expected damages are calculated it is shown that because of convex loss functions and right skewed uncertain ties the risk premium is substantial calling for more action than analysis based on best guess estimates the final section explores some needs for further scientific research

distributional impacts of climate change mitigation in indian electricity the influence of governance abstract studies that examine the distributional impacts of climate change mitigation policies often neglect the influence of institutions that implement these policies this study examines the short term consumption side distributional impacts of expanding low carbon electric supply in the state of maharashtra india with a focus on the influence of regulatory discretion in pricing households welfare impacts from economy wide electricity price shocks are simulated against a baseline that is calibrated to actual household economic and electricity service conditions including actual electricity budgets block tier prices and supply rationing industrial price impacts are propagated to households using a leontief input output analysis regulatory pricing decisions are evaluated based on social welfare metrics for economic efficiency and income inequality the analysis reveals new linkages between climate change mitigation electricity policy and income distribution low income households can be shielded from mitigation impacts without losses in aggregate welfare to the extent that regulators can recover mitigation costs through industrial price increases regulators flexibility to distribute costs across households is constrained by industrial customers migration off the grid reduced supply interruptions to the rural poor from the resulting demand contraction are a potential co benefit of mitigation distributional impacts therefore depend on other electricity policies that are driven by the political economy of the sector

on modeling and interpreting the economics of catastrophic climate change with climate change as prototype example this paper analyzes the implications of structural uncertainty for the economics of low probability high impact catastrophes even when updated by bayesian learning uncertain structural parameters induce a critical tail fattening of posterior predictive distributions such fattened tails have strong im plications for situations like climate change where a catastrophe is theoretically possible because prior knowledge cannot place sufficiently narrow bounds on overall damages this paper shows that the economic consequences of fat tailed structural uncertainty along with unsureness about high temperature damages can readily outweigh the effects of discounting in climate change policy analysis

social discounting under uncertainty a cross country comparison recent research suggests that social cost benefit analysis should be conducted with a declining discount rate for instance newell and pizer discounting the distant future how much do uncertain rates increase valuations j environ econ manage 46 2003 52 71 show that the us certainty equivalent discount rate declines through time using a simple autoregressive model of us interest rates this paper extends that line of research estimating both autoregressive and regime switching models of real interest rates to determine certainty equivalent discount rates in australia canada germany and the uk it is found that the regime switching model is a better model of past interest rate behavior for all four countries this model tends to produce a more rapid decline in certainty equivalent discount rates the paper provides applications to the economics of climate change and nuclear power

endogenous discounting and climate policy under risk of abrupt climate change the occurrence hazard is added to the social discount rate as a result the social discount rate 1 increases and 2 turns endogenous to the global warming policy the second effect bears profound policy implications that are magnified by economic growth in particular we find that greenhouse gases ghg emission should be terminated at a finite time so that the ensuing occurrence risk will vanish in the long run due to the public bad nature of the catastrophic risk the second effect is ignored in a competitive allocation and unregulated economic growth will give rise to excessive emissions in the long term the ghg emission paths under the optimal and competitive growth regimes lie at the extreme ends of the range of feasible emissions