primary commodity prices and the oecd economic performance abstract the relationship linking primary commodity prices to the oecd economic performance is analyzed by explicitly accounting for the presence of a two way causality the macroeconomic model is built on a relatively small number of equations which represent the interplay of five markets primary commodity financial oecd labour oecd and ldc product market the difference between primary commodity and manufactured good price formation is emphasized quantitative results are provided on the basis of historical estimations and dynamic simulations

rethinking the global food crisis the role of trade shocks although fundamental factors were clearly responsible for shifting the world to a higher food price equilibrium in the years leading up the 2008 food crisis there is little doubt that when food prices peaked in june of 2008 they soared well above the new equilibrium price numerous arguments have been proposed to explain overshooting including financial speculation depreciation of the united states us dollar low interest rates and reductions in grain stocks however observations that international rice prices surged in response to export restrictions by india and vietnam suggested that trade related factors could be an important basis for overshooting especially given the very tangible link between export volumes and export prices in this paper we revisit the trade story by closely examining monthly data from thailand the largest exporter of rice and the united states the largest exporter of wheat and maize and the third largest exporter of soybeans in all cases except soybeans we find that large surges in export volumes preceded the price surges the presence of these large demand surges together with back of the envelope estimates of their price impacts suggests that trade events played a much larger and more pervasive role than previously thought

from the classical economists to empiricists a review of the terms of trade controversy contrary to the classical position the works of prebisch and singer in the middle of the last century launched the controversial hypothesis of a long term decline in the terms of trade of primary products vis a vis manufactured goods and a corresponding decline in the terms of trade of developing countries vis a vis advanced ones the present study traces the origin and evolution of the hypothesis and reviews the related statistical debate it also reviews the theoretical support for the prebisch singer hypothesis it is an exercise in the history of economic thought to trace how the controversies surrounding the terms of trade have evolved over time specifically noting that with the development of the field of econometrics the central thesis of the argument got lost somewhere in the realm of hi tech statistical debates

the continuing commodity crisis of developing countries abstract since the early 1980s the dominant feature of the international commodity markets has been a sharp downtrend in prices though short term instability has also remained excessively high for many commodities international policy should therefore be focused on supply management to raise depressed levels of commodity prices the problem of short term commodity price instability is best tackled by a series of international buffer stocks rather than by hedging on the financial markets a technique which has serious limitations for exporters in developing countries

the singer prebisch hypothesis a statistical evaluation the statistical objections raised against the singer prebisch thesis regarding the secular decline in the terms of trade of primary products in relation to manufactures do not have as sound a basis as is generally supposed they have on a priori grounds the projection of that historical experience into the post war years as made by h w singer and r prebisch also holds good until the oil crisis years of the 1970s it would hold true up to 1983 if oil and opec are exc luded as a special case with the decline in the terms of trade of primary products the trading terms of the developing region vis a vis the developed one also deteriorated in view of increasing manufacture exports by the developing region it is doubtful how far the two terms of trade indexes will move in the same direction copyright 1986 by oxford university press

a model of military spending and economic growth this paper investigates a model of militaryconflict between two regimes in which eachmay initiate combat in order to confiscateresources from the other conflict or thepotential for same results in wastefulmilitary spending which lowers growth foreach regime equilibrium military spendingis determined in a one shot game analysisof the one shot game is followed by a studyof the prospects for an equilibrium inwhich regimes lower military spending anddo not engage in combat in repeated play in this latter case military spending willbe decreased to a level just sufficient todeter deviations from the no combatequilibrium this minimum level increases and growth decreases with the internalpolitical instability of each regime moreover an exogenous increase in thedefensive capability of each regime mayeither increase or decrease growth depending upon the initial level ofmilitary spending and growth

probability and timing of succession or closure in family firms a switching regression analysis of farm households in germany in a two step econometric approach that corrects for selectivity bias we analyse the determinants of the probability of succession and the timing of succession or closure in a unique sample of 233 north german family farms we set up the succession decision as an intertemporal optimization problem the empirical results show that larger and more profitable farms which are specialized in dairy production are significantly more likely to have an intra family successor we find that a nonagricultural education of the current manager or the successor delay succession when the family decided to stop farming operations nonagricultural education of the owner delays closure of the farm closure occurs earlier if the manager is able to lease out the land in the process of retirement although farm households react to incentives originating from tax and pension regulations many important determinants of succession are beyond the control of policymakers

the effects of volatility in the terms of trade on output growth new evidence abstract this paper examines the empirical evidence for the hypothesis that there is a negative relationship between terms of trade volatility and output growth it finds a statistically significant link between income terms of trade volatility and lower growth rates when the degree of volatility in the income terms of trade is decomposed into its components fluctuations in real exports are of a magnitude similar to those in the relative price of tradables similarly the volatility in the net barter terms of trade is equally affected by variations in the price of exports and of imports any policies aimed at stabilizing the terms of trade or any of its components need to take account of this

the returns to schooling a selectivity bias approach with a continuous choice variable the essence of selection bias is that we do not observe nonoptimal choices this applies whether the choice variable is discrete or continuous this paper extends the selection bias methodology to the case where the choice variable is continuous and the choice set is ordered the leading practical application of this analysis is the schooling choice problem schooling is treated as a continuous choice variable and selectivity corrected rates of return are estimated the findings suggest selectivity is of considerable importance and support the comparative advantage hypothesis of willis and rosen 18

long run prices of primary commodities and oil prices acutely volatile movements in primary commodity prices have drawn considerable interest from empirical researchers exports of these commodities account for the bulk of export earnings of developing countries the traditional demand based framework was unable to explain the marked deterioration in these prices during the 1980s this paper tries to ascertain the role played by real oil prices in explaining the extremely volatile movements in real prices of primary commodities by taking into account oil price shocks over the period 1973 1996 using monthly data real primary commodity prices and real oil prices are cointegrated additionally the error in the cointegrating relation stimulates real commodity price adjustment not real oil price adjustment

developing countries terms of trade in manufactures 1967 87 a note terms of trade relating only to manufactured exports and imports are calculated for a sample of 37 industrialised and developing countries over the 1967 to 1987 period it is found that the terms of trade movements were significantly more favourable for higher income countries this result highlights the importance of export diversification as part of a development strategy

is everything neutral in his well known analysis of the national debt robert barro introduced the notion of a dynastic family this notion has since become a standard research tool particularly in the areas of public finance and macroeconomics in this paper we critique the assumptions on which the dynastic model is predicated and argue that this framework is not a suitable abstraction in contexts in which the objective is to analyze the effects of public policies we reach this conclusion by formally considering a world in which each generation consists of a large number of distinct individuals as opposed to one representative individual we point out that family linkages form complex networks in which each individual may belong to many dynastic groupings the resulting proliferation of linkages between families gives rise to a host of neutrality results including the irrelevance of all public redistributions distortionary taxes and prices since these results are not at all descriptive of the real world we conclude

manufactured exports of developing countries and their terms of trade since 1965 a comment abstract the results of sarkar and singer 1991 on the trends in the relative unit values of the manufactured exports of developing countries are sensitive to the choice of end year and to fluctuations in the unit values of us exports relative to those of the rest of the world the relative unit values of us exports are highly correlated with movements in the us real exchange rate and there is some evidence to suggest that sarkar and singer s findings primarily reflect changes in the real exchange rates of developing countries

crime confiscation and frowth for and against leviathan this paper presents a dynamic general equilibrium model ofrent seeking in which the payoffs and the choices between productiveand non productive activity are endogenous the economy has the potential for endogenous growth but when agents can choose between confiscation and productive investment growth is no longer possible

on the comovement of commodity prices we present strong evidence against the excess comovement hypothesis that the prices of commodities move together beyond what can be explained by fundamentals prior studies employ broad macroeconomic indicators to explain common price movements and potentially correlated fundamentals are not controlled for we use inventory and harvest data to fit a partial equilibrium model that more effectively captures the variation in individual prices the model explains the majority of the comovements among commodities with high price correlation and all of the comovements among those with marginal price correlation common movements in supply factors appear to play an important role in the observed comovements in commodity prices

earnings functions beyond human capital taking a short run view of the labour market where individuals with given levels of education have to be matched with jobs differing in level of complexity and difficulty wages are related to education and job levels in a sample of some 13 000 observations controlling for age experience and sex a model emphasizing both sides of the allocation process is favoured over the simple human capital view that ignores allocation once education is taken care of it is claimed that the long run human capital model can fruitfully be expanded with this short run allocation structure the empirical results measure the differences in earnings for individuals with given education working at different job levels and shows them to be substantial the relevance of adding job levels to the explanatory variables is illustrated with the case of female earnings discrimination and with differences in age earnings profiles between general and vocational education

the impact of uncertainty shocks on the volatility of commodity prices in this paper we empirically examine the impact of uncertainty shocks on the volatility of commodity prices using several alternative measures of economic uncertainty for the u s we estimate their effects on commodity price volatility through var analysis we find that the latent uncertainty shocks have the most significant impact on commodity price volatility when compared to observable measures of economic uncertainty in specific our results show that the unobservable economic uncertainty measures of jurado et al 2015 have a significant and long lasting positive effect on the volatility of commodity prices our findings indicate that a positive shock in unobservable macroeconomic and financial uncertainty leads to a persistent increase in the volatility of the broad commodity market index and of individual commodity prices with the macroeconomic effect being more significant finally we show that the impact is stronger in energy commodities compared to agricultural and metals markets

iniquidade educacional no brasil uma avaliacao com dados do pisa 2000 this paper assesses the extent of educational inequality and inequity in brazil using data obtained from the international study pisa 2000 prepared by the oecd we provide some descriptive indices of inequality as well as a measure of inequity understood as inequality of educational opportunities based on a simple inferential analysis most indicators show that the levels of educational inequality and inequity in brazil are very high

modelling market fundamentals a model of the aluminium market the standard approach to modelling primary commodity markets under rational expectations is to relate the commodity price to the production and consumption surprises i e the innovations on the equations using the world aluminium market we show how this approach can be modified so that both the price and stock can be written in terms of one or more market fundamentals which reflect the supply demand balance on the market this approach allows joint estimation of production consumption stock demand and price equations subject to cross equation restrictions it may be seen as a formalization of the approach adopted by metals industry analysts

north south terms of trade and growth a macroeconomic framework on kaldorian lines abstract in the presidential address to the royal economic society 1976 nicholas kaldor presented an informal model of the world economy on this kaldorian line this paper presents a north south growth model it has been observed that there is no relationship between the monopoly power of the northern capitalists and the north south terms of trade technical progress in the south has a declining impact on the southern terms of trade while technical progress in the north does not have a similar impact on the northern terms of trade furthermore this model shows that the south as a whole cannot speed up its long term growth rate through export promotion rather it faces a terms of trade loss

finite lifetimes and growth abstract in this paper we study the long run growth property of overlapping generations models it is shown that in one sector models with convex technologies the asymptotic growth rate must be zero this results because the young do not have sufficient income to purchase a large capital stock thus a policy of income redistribution to the young can generate growth even if financed by income taxation additionaly it is shown that two sector models and one sector models with nonconvex technologies are consistent with growth

agriculture s terms of trade issues and implications the article addresses 1 the issue of what agricultural commodity prices should be compared to if we are concerned with the welfare of agriculturalists 2 the general absence of product quality adjustment when analysis is undertaken comparing agricultural to manufactured goods prices 3 the extent to which energy prices are or will be the driver of both manufactured and agricultural prices and 4 the importance of considering agriculture s terms of trade tot against the service sector since the service sector is typically the largest in the economy it reflects on the basic question of whether the widespread perception that agriculture s tot secularly decline is correct

earnings functions testing for the demand side abstract to analyze labor market phenomena one may simultaneously grade workers by education and jobs by level of difficulty and complexity human capital theory predicts earnings based on only worker quality thurow s version of a segmented labor market theory predicts that only the job level is relevant and the assignment theory predicts that both variables are relevant using three different data sets for the netherlands testing demonstrates convincingly the superiority of the assignment theory

cointegration how short is the long run abstract when testing for cointegration and faced with short sample periods it is common for researchers to turn to more frequently sampled observations that is to move from annual to quarterly or monthly data in order to increase the number of observations we argue that such a gain in the degrees of freedom is more apparent than real essentially cointegration is a long run concept and hence requires long spans of data to give tests for cointegration much power rather than merely large numbers of observations using monte carlo simulations we demonstrate this for four popular tests for cointegration

manufactured exports of developing countries and their terms of trade since 1965 abstract during the last 40 years since the prebisch singer terms of trade deterioration hypothesis was first proposed the commodity composition of exports of developing countries has undergone a major change in the direction of dominance of manufactures in their nonfuel exports with strong growth in the volume of their manufactured exports but this did not allow developing countries to escape unequal exchange relations with the industrial countries their barter terms of trade in manufactures showed signs of weakness rather than improvement and clearly failed to reflect the respective productivity trends leading to deterioration in factoral terms of trade

long run commodity prices economic growth and interest rates 17th century to the present day a significant proportion of the trade basket of many developing countries is comprised of primary commodities this implies relative price movements in commodities may have important consequences for economic growth and poverty reduction taking a long run perspective we examine the historical relation between a new aggregate index of commodity prices economic activity and interest rates initial empirical tests show that commodity prices present a downward trend with breaks over the entire industrial age providing clear support for the prebisch singer hypothesis it would also appear that this trend has declined at a faster rate since the 1870s conversely several gdp series such as world chile china uk and us trend upwards with breaks such trending behaviour in both commodity prices and economic activity suggests a latent common factor like technological innovation to assess the relationships between economic series we apply a stationary var vector autoregression to model movements around trends strikingly there is evidence that commodity prices granger cause income and interest rates whilst interest rates granger cause commodity prices from these results and the related impulse response function analysis the historical perspective provides some useful information for contemporary policy makers for example loose monetary policy has tended to support higher commodity prices more over commodity price movements have an asymmetric country effect on economic activity periods of falling commodity prices will support gdp growth for com modity importers like the us but depress growth for commodity exporters such as chile

anatomy of a crisis the causes and consequences of surging food prices although the potential causes and consequences of recent rising international food prices have attracted widespread attention many existing appraisals are superficial and or piecemeal this article attempts to provide a more comprehensive review of these issues based on the best and most recent research as well as on fresh theoretical and empirical analysis we first analyze the causes of the current crisis by considering how well standard explanations hold up against relevant economic theory and important stylized facts some explanations turn out to hold up much better than others especially rising oil prices the depreciation of the u s dollar biofuels demand and some commodity specific explanations we then provide an appraisal of the likely macro and microeconomic impacts of the crisis on developing countries we observe a large gap between macro and micro factors which when identifying the most vulnerable countries often point in different directions we conclude with a brief discussion of what ought to be learned from this crisis

conflict and rent seeking success functions ratio vs difference models of relative success the rent seeking competitions studied by economists fall within a much broader category of conflict interactions that also includes military combats election campaigns industrial disputes lawsuits and sibling rivalries in the rent seeking literature each party s success pi which can be interpreted either as the probability of victory or as the proportion of the prize won has usually been taken to be a function of the ratio of the respective resource commitments alternatively however pi may instead be a function of the difference between the parties commitments to the contest the contest success function csf for the difference from is a logistic curve in which as is consistent with military experience increasing returns apply up to an inflection point at equal resource commitments a crucial flaw of the traditional ratio model is that neither onesided submission nor two sided peace between the parties can ever occur as a cournot equilibrium in contrast both of these outcomes are entirely consistent with a model in which success is a function of the difference between the parties resource commitments

on the effects of world stock market and oil price shocks on food prices an empirical investigation based on tvp var models with stochastic volatility abstract transmission of price shocks from one market to another one has long been investigated in the economic literature however studies have namely dealt with the relationship between financial and energy markets with the recent changes in market conditions investors policy makers and interest groups are giving special attention to food market this paper aims at analyzing shock transmission between international food energy and financial markets and to provide some insights into the volatility behavior during the past years and discuss its implications for portfolio management to do this we present a new time varying parameter var tvp var model with stochastic volatility approach which provides extreme flexibility with a parsimonious specification we resort also to a generalized vector autoregressive framework in which forecast error variance decompositions are invariant to the variable ordering for the assessment of total and directional volatility spillovers our main findings suggest that volatility spillovers increase considerably during crisis and namely after mid 2008 when stock markets become net transmitter of volatility shocks while crude oil becomes a net receiver shocks to crude oil or msci markets have immediate and short term impacts on food markets which are emphasized during the financial crisis period moreover we show that augmenting a diversified portfolio of food commodities with crude oil or stocks significantly increases its risk adjusted performance

an empirical study of re enrolement behaviour for male high school dropouts to understand further the behaviour of high school dropouts during their periods away from school this paper studied empirically the decisions of male dropouts on whether to return to school we applied the bivariate probit multinomial logit and waiting time models to analyse this issue the estimation results from all three models indicate that the armed forces qualification test score age experience of using drugs local labour market situation and the duration of the period out of school had significant effects on a male dropout s return decision family background variables contrary to what we expected had little effect on this decision

a roller coaster ride an empirical investigation of the main drivers of the international wheat price over the last decade commodity prices have registered substantial booms and busts marked by extreme volatility wheat in particular one of the main nonoil commodities has registered a roller coaster in price levels which seems to be inconsistent with supply and demand fundamentals to acutely investigate the drivers of wheat prices and quantify their impact a vector error correction model vecm has been used the exogenous variables have been distinguished into four groups market specific factors broad macroeconomic determinants speculative components and weather variables the quadriangulation of the determinants will enable us to better understand the movements in wheat price and identify the specific role of each component the results show that a mix of factors are contributing to wheat price movements including speculation global demand and real effective exchange rate

debt crisis of the less developed countries and the transfer debate once again in the perspective of substantial amount of net transfers from the debtor less developed countries ldcs to the creditor developed countries dcs in the recent debt crisis years there is a renewed debate that started in the context of german reparation payments after the first world war on the question of transfer burden of debt the present study assembles some evidence to show that the ldcs in general expanded their export volumes and faced losses in their export unit values in the process of their debt repayments many ldcs faced this transfer burden of debt irrespective of whether their export drive was in the field of primary products or manufactures thus the keynesian analysis for german transfer problems seems to be relevant in the context of the present experience of the ldcs for some debtor countries the insoluble transfer problem mentioned by keynes exists as they are facing fisher s paradox the more the debtors pay the more they owe

dynamic persistence of primary commodity prices this article examines the persistence of shocks to international commodity prices from 1900 to 2008 using the updated grilli yang index the main innovation of this study is that it determines whether commodity prices are characterized by multiple changes in persistence specifically bootstrap methods are used to estimate persistence and the associated half life shocks are calculated we find that the persistence of shocks can vary widely depending on the individual commodity and the time period the results suggest that policy makers need to exercise caution when introducing measures to cushion the effect of shocks to world commodity prices

a factor model for co movements of commodity prices abstract we fit a factor model to two monthly panels of deflated prices of energy metals and agricultural commodities prices consistently display a tendency to revert towards the factor though the speed of reversion to the factor is slow using both in and out of sample metrics we compare the factor model to that of a no change model and to two simple models that tie changes in commodity prices to percentage change in either global industrial production or the u s dollar the factor model does relatively well at long 12 month horizons in terms of commodities the factor model s performance is best for energy prices worst for metals with agricultural prices falling in between

non graduation and the earnings function an inquiry on self selection abstract we model schooling careers in the dutch educational systems including the decision to drop out as a discrete sequential choice in which expected earnings play an important role selectivity biasd from correlation between the errors in the decision function and the earnings function appears empirically relevant and we correct for it by applying a proper maximum likelihood estimation procedure the results indicate that drop outs behave differently from graduates in the decision functions on schooling careers expected earnings based on estimated earnings functions in mid career are never significant yet the educational choices appear ex post consistent with choices according to comparative earnings advantage

southern primary exports technological change and uneven development a two region model is developed to examine the implications of trade and capital flows between the north which produces a good which is used for consumption and investment purposes in both the north and the south and the south which produces a good which is used as a consumption good in the south and as a primary intermediate good in the north the main purpose of the paper is to analyse the implications of technological change in the north which reduces its dependence on the imported intermediate good special attention is focused on north south terms of trade movements and on the possibility of international uneven development

extended stay at university an application of multinomial logit and duration models in brazil few studies have been devoted to proving the existence of and evaluating the internal inefficiencies of state universities such work however is highly important because state higher learning is free and a great amount of resources is involved in its maintenance the objective of this study is to develop empirical models to permit an evaluation of the factors related to the decision to complete or abandon the course and to verify whether the duration of the connection to the university is also related to the same factors among the results obtained the most important is that the prolonged stay at a state university favours students whose families could afford their schooling

the long run behavior of the relative price of primary commodities statistical evidence and policy implications abstract this paper is concerned with both the statistical and policy issues surrounding the long run behavior of the ratio of primary commodities prices to those of manufactured goods seen as a measure of the barter terms of trade between primary producers and the producers of manufacturers the statistical evidence reported is found to offer support for the secular deterioration hypothesis the policy implications of this finding for less developed countries are explored

price behaviour in the us sweetener market a cointegration approach the sweetener market in the united states is complicated because of the substitution possibilities between high fructose corn syrup hfcs and sugar this study focuses on the relationship between raw sugar prices and the prices for high fructose corn syrup sugar and hfcs are imperfect substitutes for several industrial uses sugar can be used for all industrial uses but hfcs has limited uses this study uses cointegration analysis to examine the relationship between sugar and hfcs prices as well as the relationship between raw and refined sugar prices over time the results indicate that sugar and hfcs prices move together for the 1983 1996 period however after this time period hfcs prices no longer follow sugar prices

do multinationals deteriorate developing countries export prices the impact of fdi on net barter terms of trade this paper explores the economic relationship between foreign direct investment fdi to developing countries and the export prices of the latter measured by terms of trade it is rst shown that economic theory suggests such a relationship for various reasons but is inconclusive about the direction of the eect to address this open issue empirically i analyze data on more than 50 developing countries throughout the period 1980 2008 using robust dynamic panel data methods the results show that fdi had an economically relevant and statistically signicant positive impact on developing countries net barter terms of trade a higher level of education in the developing country fosters this eect

whither the terms of trade an elaboration of the prebisch singer hypothesis movements in the prices of primary products and manufactured goods are analysed using a model that introduces differences in wage and price determination between primary production and manufacturing wages and prices in primary production are treated as competitively determined while prices and wages in manufacturing are determined by mark up pricing and union employer bargaining respectively the objective is to capture the influence of structural differences between manufacturing and primary production on the terms of trade between industrialised and developing worlds as discussed in the seminal contributions to the development literature by raul prebisch and hans singer the model is estimated using price and wage data from the post world war ii period support is found for the prebisch singer hypothesis however our estimates suggest that during periods of particularly rapid manufac turing growth there have been intervals of net improvement in the terms of trade of primary producers

market reforms and commodity price volatility the case of east african coffee market the goal of this paper is to examine the impact of commodity market reforms on producer price volatility using evidence from the east african coffee market the results based on time varying volatility models and key summary statistics show that coffee market reforms in the east african community eac are associated with changes in producer price volatility and volatility persistence at both country and regional levels however reforms were not the only cause of changes in price volatility the study further shows that reforms had different effects on prices volatilities of arabica and robusta varieties of coffee grown in individual eac countries these findings have wider implication for commodity market reforms and producer price stabilisation policies in the eac and coffee producing countries in sub sahara africa

the impact of exchange rates and developing country debt on commodity prices a major feature of the international economy over the past decade has been the swings in the value of the us dollar the dollar fell to a historically low level in the late i970s but rose sharply over the period i982 4 by the beginning of i985 the dollar was generally considered to be over valued by between 2o and 40 since i985 there has been a depreciation of over one third these wide fluctuations in the value of the dollar have had implications for all major traded goods this paper focuses on the effects of changes in the value of the dollar on primary commodity prices and possible interactions between ldc indebtedness and these effects a rise fall in the value of the dollar must be expected to result in a fall rise in dollar commodity prices ridler and yandle i972 proposed a simple comparative static single commodity model to analyse the effects of exchange rate changes on the price of an individual primary commodity they showed that the commodity price change would be given by the change in an appropriately weighted exchange rate index write the price of commodityj as

the demand for and return to education when education outcomes are uncertain this article treats education as a sequential choice that is made under uncertainty a simple model is used to explore the effects of ability high school preparation preferences for schooling the borrowing rate and ex post payoffs to college on the probability of various post secondary college outcomes and the ex ante return to starting college the model motivates an empirical method of accounting for uncertainty about educational outcomes and for nonlinearity in the relationship between years of education and earnings when estimating the expected return to the first year of college

the prebisch singer hypothesis a reappraisal independent of stationarity hypotheses time series behaviour of the relative price of primary commodities raul prebisch i950 and hans singer i950 believed that the long term trend of primary commodity prices was negative the latter in an interesting discussion of the above quandary pp 482 3 viewed rises in primary commodity prices as purely temporary sources of surplus that offered short lived opportunities to increase industrial investment these opportunities were missed by private investors who instead increased primary sector investment in such circumstances because all private activity tends to be governed by the price