estimation using contingent valuation data from a dichotomous choice with follow up questionnaire a comment abstract cameron and quiggin j environ econom management27 218 234 1994 provide evidence against the use of the standard interval data model and in favor of the more general bivariate probit model an apparent miscalculation in the estimation process overstates the poor performance of the interval data model for the application reported by cameron and quiggin when the miscalculation is corrected the data reported by cameron and quiggin provide results consistent with alberini s j environ econom mangement29 169 180 1995 finding that interval data models provide robust estimates of mean willingness to pay from dichotomous choice with follow up contingent valuation questions

statistical efficiency of double bounded dichotomous choice contingent valuation the statistical efficiency of conventional dichotomous choice contingent valuation surveys can be improved by asking each respondent a second dichotomous choice question which depends on the response to the first question if the first response is yes the second bid is some amount greater than the first bid while if the first response is no the second bid is some amount smaller this double bounded approach is shown to be asymptotically more efficient than the conventional singlebounded approach using data from a survey of californians regarding their willingness to pay for wetlands in the san joaquin valley we show that in a finite sample the gain in efficiency can be very substantial

regulating stock externalities under uncertainty abstract using a simple analytical model incorporating benefits of a stock costs of adjusting the stock and uncertainty in costs we uncover several important principles governing the choice of price based policies e g taxes relative to quantity based policies e g tradable permits for controlling stock externalities as in weitzman rev econom stud 41 4 1974 477 the relative slopes of the marginal benefits and costs of controlling the externality continue to be critical determinants of the efficiency of prices relative to quantities with flatter marginal benefits and steeper marginal costs favoring prices but some important adjustments for dynamic effects are necessary including correlation of cost shocks across time discounting stock decay and the rate of benefits growth applied to the problem of greenhouse gases and climate change we find that a price based instrument generates several times the expected net benefits of a quantity instrument

optimal mix of emissions taxes and cap and trade abstract in practice different emitters of a particular pollutant are sometimes subjected to different control mechanisms this paper focuses on the situation where a part of the economy is regulated by a cap and trade program while the rest is subjected to an emissions tax using an extended version of weitzman s prices vs quantities model m l weitzman prices vs quantities revi econ stud 41 1974 477 491 we analyze the conditions under which this is superior from an efficiency point of view to subjecting the whole economy to either of these control mechanisms the paper addresses a crucial trade off between two sources of efficiency loss one due to cost effectiveness issues and another due to emissions volume this trade off determines the optimal size of each sector it is shown that the size of the taxed sector at an optimum increases with the relative steepness of the aggregate marginal abatement cost function

estimation using contingent valuation data from a dichotomous choice with follow up questionnaire reply abstract our original article proposed that the two yes no willingness to pay wtp responses produced by this survey format should be viewed as a pair of jointly distributed correlated discrete random variables the comparison model the conventional approach to estimation using these types of data contained a programming error correction alters the results from the comparison model but our original claim that estimation by conventional methods can produce misleading inferences if ours is the appropriate specification still stands this is especially true if negative wtp is precluded when e wtp is calculated

do reminders of substitutes and budget constraints influence contingent valuation estimates a test is performed of the recommendation by the noaa panel on contingent valuation that respondents be reminded about other substitute resources and their budget constraint prior to answering the willingness to pay wtp question the context for this experiment is a cvm study of the benefits from reducing fire hazards to old growth forests in oregon the test was performed using two mail surveys that were otherwise identical except for the inclusion of reminder statements prior to the wtp question the dichotomous choice logit equations were not statistically different between versions and the mean wtp results were identical

status effects public goods provision and excess burden abstract most studies of the optimal provision of public goods or the excess burden from taxation assume that individual utility is independent of other individuals consumption this paper investigates public good provision and excess burden in a model that allows for interdependence in consumption in the form of status relative consumption effects in the presence of such effects consumption and labor taxes no longer are pure distortionary taxes but have a corrective tax element that addresses an externality from consumption as a result the marginal excess burden of consumption taxes is lower than in the absence of status effects and will be negative if the consumption tax rate is below the pigouvian rate correspondingly when consumption or labor tax rates are below the pigouvian rate the second best level of public goods provision is above the first best level contrary to findings from models without status effects for plausible functional forms and parameters relating to status effects the marginal excess burden from existing u s labor taxes is substantially lower than in most prior studies and is negative in some cases

prices versus quantities in a second best setting the choice between taxes and tradable permits has been independently analysed by two distinct research traditions the first proceeds from weitzman s partial equilibrium sto chastic model and concludes that a tax should be preferred if the marginal abatement cost curve is steeper than the marginal environmental benefit curve the second utilises deter ministic general equilibrium models with pre existing distortionary taxes it concludes that non revenue raising instruments e g grandfathered tradable permits are costlier than rev enue raising ones e g a tax on every unit of pollution or auctioned permits to build a bridge between these two traditions we introduce in weitzman s model a positive cost of public funds due to pre existing distortionary taxes the tax admits a greater comparative advantage over the permits as compared to weitzman s classical result then we assume that the regulated industry blocks any proposal that poses it too high an expected burden this may require a transfer to firms in the form of freely allocated permits or lump sum tax rebate it turns out that if this acceptability constraint is binding then the comparative advantage of taxes over permits is still reinforced quantitatively even if the marginal benefit function is 50 more steeply sloped than the marginal cost function the price instrument should be preferred we also compare the expected net benefit of these two instruments to a contingent instrument which leads to the ex post optimum the superiority of the contingent instrument over the quantity one is higher than in first best

interval estimates of non market resource values from referendum contingent valuation surveys contingent valuation methods cvm have attracted considerable attention in recent years as researchers have begun to resort to survey methods to elicit individual values for non market goods such as environmental resources or public goods cummings brookshire and schulze 1986 and mitchell and carson 1989 offer comprehensive assessments of these methods cvm survey questions come in a variety of forms one format which has proven to be popular is called the discrete choice or take it or leave it referendum or closedended question originally implemented in the literature by bishop and heberlein 1979 since respondents find it very difficult to identify precisely their true point value of access to some resource or public good open ended valuation questions can be unreliable or can discourage response in contrast most people are familiar with being confronted by a posted price for a good and with deciding whether or not they would buy at that price this is the strategy behind discrete choice cvm questions a different hypothetical price is offered to each respondent and by their yes no response to the question of whether they would be willing to pay this price the researcher gains information about their true underlying point value one persistent difficulty with the econometric techniques that are currently used most widely to analyze referendum contingent valuation data is the absence of confidence intervals for the ultimate value estimates early empirical applications approximate mean valuations using a truncated mean based on a logit model with the upper limit being the highest bid value in the sample unfortunately the variance of this estimated mean cannot easily be recovered from the numerical integration procedure commonly used to calculate the

complying with the kyoto protocol under uncertainty taxes or tradable permits the kyoto protocol allocates tradable emission allowances aaus to developed countries but they are free to choose a set of policy instruments to comply with these targets we compare two different policy instruments a tax and purely domestic tradable permits for the european union the us and japan information on abatement costs and international permit price is imperfect and stems from nine global economic models for a country party to the protocol the benefit of emission reduction is that it can sell more or has to buy less aaus we show that in this context permits entail a slightly lower expected cost than a tax for the us and japan whereas both instruments yield an almost equal outcome for europe applying weitzman s framework prices vs quantities res 1974 in this context we show the importance of the positive correlation between costs and benefits technology shocks that lead to low abatement costs in one country generally lead to low abatement costs in other countries too thereby leading to a low international permit price in the true up period

correlated uncertainty and policy instrument choice abstract for two decades environmental economists have generally maintained that benefit uncertainty is irrelevant for choosing between price and quantity instruments but that cost uncertainty matters with the identity of the efficient instrument depending upon the relative slopes of the marginal benefit and cost functions but in the presence of simultaneous correlated uncertainty such policy instrument recommendations may be inappropriate with plausible values of relevant parameters the conventional identification of a price instrument will be reversed to favor instead a quantity instrument the opposite reversal from the choice of a quantity instrument to a price instrument seems less likely to occur

optimal intensity targets for greenhouse gas emissions trading under uncertainty uncertainty is an obstacle for commitments under cap and trade schemes for emission permits we assess how well intensity targets where each country s permit allocation is indexed to its future realized gdp can cope with uncertainties in international greenhouse emissions trading we present some empirical foundations for intensity targets and derive a simple rule for the optimal degree of indexation to gdp using an 18 region simulation model of a cooperative global cap and trade treaty in 2020 under multiple uncertainties and endogenous commitments we show that optimal intensity targets could reduce the cost of uncertainty and achieve significant increases in global abatement the optimal degree of indexation to gdp would vary greatly between countries including super indexation in some advanced countries and partial indexation for most developing countries standard intensity targets with one to one indexation would also improve the overall outcome but to a lesser degree and not in all individual cases although target indexation is no magic wand for a future global climate treaty gains from reduced cost uncertainty and the potential for more stringent environmental commitments could justify the increased complexity and other potential downsides of intensity targets

a new paradigm for valuing non market goods using referendum data maximum likelihood estimation by censored logistic regression abstract this paper challenges the w m hanemann amer j agr econom 66 332 341 1984 and c sellar j p chavas and j r stoll j environ econom management 13 382 390 1986 utilizations of logit models to estimate the value of non market resources from referendum survey data these data are more informative than conventional choice data the random utility interpretation of logit models is therefore too restrictive bypassing the utility function entirely it will be shown that parameters and standard errors for utility theoretic inverse hicksian demand functions can be extracted directly and much more simply estimated demand functions need not be limited to those corresponding to the linear in parameters utility difference specifications which can be handled by packaged logit programs

what experimental protocol influence disparities between actual and hypothetical stated values preferences elicited in hypothetical settings have recently come underscrutiny causing estimates from the contingent valuation method to bechallenged due to perceived hypothetical bias given that the receivedliterature derives value estimates using heterogeneous experimentaltechniques understanding the effects of important design parameters onthe magnitude of hypothetical bias is invaluable in this paper we addressthis issue statistically by using a meta analysis to examine data from 29experimental studies our empirical findings suggest that on averagesubjects overstate their preferences by a factor of about 3 in hypotheticalsettings and that the degree of over revelation is influenced by thedistinction between willingness to pay and willingness to accept publicversus private goods and several elicitation methods

do hypothetical and actual marginal willingness to pay differ in choice experiments application to the valuation of the environment abstract in this paper we test the validity of choice experiments with donations for environmental projects in particular we test whether or not there are differences in preferences between a hypothetical and an actual choice experiment our experiments indicate no differences in addition internal tests of validity indicate transitive and stable preferences in both experiments although there are some indications of possible learning effects during the experiment

combining price and quantity controls to mitigate global climate change abstract uncertainty about compliance costs causes otherwise equivalent price and quantity controls to behave differently and leads to divergent welfare consequences although most of the debate on global climate change policy has focused on quantity controls due to their political appeal this paper argues that price controls are more efficient simulations based on a stochastic computable general equilibrium model indicate that the expected welfare gain from the optimal price policy is five times higher than the expected gain from the optimal quantity policy an alternative hybrid policy combines both the political appeal of quantity controls with the efficiency of prices using an initial distribution of tradeable permits to set a quantitative target but allowing additional permits to be purchased at a fixed trigger price even sub optimal hybrid policies offer dramatic efficiency improvements over otherwise standard quantity controls for example a 50 trigger price per ton of carbon converts the 3 trillion expected loss associated with a simple 1990 emission target to a 150 billion gain these results suggest that a hybrid policy is an attractive alternative to either a pure price or quantity system

tax versus trading and efficient revenue recycling as issues for greenhouse gas abatement abstract we give empirical welfare results for global greenhouse gas emission abatement using the first multi party model to include both tax versus trading under uncertainties and revenue recycling including multiple independent parties greatly reduces the welfare advantage of an emissions tax over emissions permit trading in handling abatement cost uncertainties from that shown by existing single party literature but a previously ignored and much bigger advantage of a tax from better handling uncertainties in business as usual emissions greatly boosts the overall tax versus trading advantage yet the degree to which each mechanism is used to raise and recycle revenue efficiently by lowering distortionary taxes rather than recycle revenue as lump sums or not raise revenue by giving tax thresholds or free permits may in turn dominate any tax versus trading advantage choosing the best greenhouse abatement mechanism should thus consider the issues of tax versus trading and efficient revenue recycling together

the effect of knowledge on the disparity between hypothetical and real willingness to pay the use of a contingent valuation cv method is controversial among economists because it is based on hypothetical rather than real economic choices this paper reports the results of an experiment designed to elicit the real and the hypothetical willingness to pay wtp for a private good the effect of different settings of knowledge direct and indirect of the good on subjects valuation behaviour are investigated the findings show that i a direct knowledge of the good reduces the observed disparity between hypothetical and real wtp and that ii different settings of knowledge generate different perceptions of the characteristics of the good

effects of cheap talk on consumer willingness to pay for golden rice a large body of literature suggests willingness to pay is overstated in hypothetical valuation questions as compared to when actual payment is required recently cheap talk has been proposed to eliminate the potential bias in hypothetical valuation questions cheap talk refers to process of explaining hypothetical bias to individuals prior to asking a valuation question this study explores the effect of cheap talk in a mass mail survey using a conventional value elicitation technique results indicate that cheap talk was effective at reducing willingness to pay for most survey participants however consistent with previous research cheap talk did not reduce willingness to pay for knowledgeable consumers

emission taxes and tradable permits a comparison of views on long run efficiency we compare three different views on the long runefficiencies of emission taxes which includethresholds inframarginalexemptions and of tradeable emission permitswhere some permits areinitially free the differences are caused bydifferent assumptions aboutwhether thresholds and free permits should besubsidies given only to firmsthat produce or full property rights treatingtax thresholds as well asfree permits as property rights would departfrom the conventional view but would allow greater flexibility in makingeconomic instruments bothefficient and acceptable such flexibilitycould be very important inachieving efficient control of greenhouse gasemissions

consumers industrialists and the political economy of green taxation co2 taxation in oecd abstract economists have traditionally suggested that politicians should simply impose a uniform tax on harmful emissions as the first best solution prescribes however a detailed analysis of the actual design of green taxes in the oecd reveals that they are differentiated and far from this first best optimal design public choice theory suggests that an important reason that industry as a group in contrast to households is capable of lobbying against green taxation the paper presents empirical findings on co2 taxation within the oecd countries which confirm this theoretical prediction taxes are not uniform and households pay a tax rate which is six times higher than that paid by the industry on average even when tax revenue is fully refunded to industry the potential losers energy intensive firms will lobby harder against it than the potential winners labor intensive firms due to small group advantages the norwegian case confirms these arguments finally it is suggested that a co2 tax may perhaps successfully be applied to households because they tend to be badly organized as such a mix of green taxes in relation to non organized interests and grandfathered permit markets in relation to organized interests should be considered in the search for cost effective and politically feasible instruments

taxes and quotas for a stock pollutant with multiplicative uncertainty we compare taxes and quotas when firms and the regulator have asymmetric information about the slope of firms abatement costs damages are caused by a stock pollutant we calibrate the model using cost and damage estimates of greenhouse gasses taxes dominate quotas as with additive uncertainty this model with multiplicative uncertainty allows us to compare expected stock levels under the two policies and to investigate the importance of stock size and the magnitude of uncertainty on the policy ranking

the role of economics in climate change policy many policy problems have frustratingly long histories of inefficient regulation that can be difficult or impossible to reverse even where large efficiency gains might be had from doing so climate change is an exception however because little real action has been undertaken to date it presents an unusual opportunity for an efficient economic policy to be employed right from the beginning however the opportunity could easily be lost ongoing negotiations conducted under the auspices of the united nations framework convention on climate change have so far produced the kyoto protocol a deeply flawed agreement that manages to be both economically inefficient and politically impractical in this article we examine the key economic characteristics of climate change and argue that economic theory provides good guidance on the design of an efficient and politically realistic policy because climate change involves vast uncertainties and has potentially enormous distributional effects neither of the standard market based environmental policy instruments is a viable approach a tradable permit system would be inefficient and an emissions tax would be politically unrealistic however a hybrid policy combining the best features of the two would be an efficient and practical approach we then compare our hybrid proposal to the kyoto protocol and argue that it overcomes the protocol s shortcomings

efficient estimation methods for closed ended contingent valuation surveys closed ended contingent valuation surveys can be very useful in the evaluation of nonmarket resources respondents merely state whether they would accept or reject a hypothetical threshold amount either as payment for giving up access to the resource or as a fee for its use the authors develop a maximum likelihood procedure which exploits the variation in the threshold values to allow direct and separate point estimates of regression like slope coefficients and error standard deviations without truncation bias their illustration uses data from a survey of recreational fisherman to examine factors which influence individuals willingness to pay copyright 1987 by mit press

transitional restricted linkage between emissions trading schemes linkages between emissions trading systems are deemed an important element of the future climate policy landscape they are however difficult to agree and remain few and far between temporary restrictions on permit trading have potential to facilitate and gradually approach unrestricted full linkage we compare the relative merits of several link restrictions in this respect namely quantitative transfer limits border taxes on transfers exchange and discount rates and unilateral linkage to this end we develop a simple model to have a unifying framework which in conjunction with lessons we draw from real world experiences serves as a basis for a broader policy oriented discussion while quantitative restrictions seem to be the natural route to full linkage they can lead to uncertain distributional effects and weaken price signals these aspects are mitigated under a border permit tax but this policy seems harder to implement exchange rates have potential to adjust for programmes stringencies and raise ambition over time but can be challenging to select as experience corroborates unilateral linkage can be a convenient approach

evaluating the validity of the dichotomous choice question format in contingent valuation hypothetical and actual cash willingness to pay wtp for an art print were elicited with dichotomous choice and open ended question formats comparing hypothetical and actual dichotomous choice responses using both a likelihood ratio test and the method of convolutions suggests we reject equality at the 0 05 but not the 0 01 level hypothetical wtp was roughly two times actual wtp with the dichotomous choice format there were no significant differences between the open ended and dichotomous choice question formats when both were used to estimate hypothetical wtp or both used to estimate actual wtp

investigations concerning the dynamics of consumer behavior in uncertain environments this paper reports the results of several experiments investigating dynamic consumer behavior when consumers know their incomes and prices but are uncertain about their preferences we find that they typically adopt a two step approach to locating optimal consumption bundles initially a grid search method is employed this is followed by a gradient search method an interesting phenomenon observed in many of our experiments is a tendency to consume a bundle well away from the optimum immediately after the optimum is located the effects of income and price changes are also studied

referendum models and economic values theoretical intuitive and practical bounds on willingness to pay innovations in the estimation of referendum type contingent valuation models have led to willingness to pay wtp measures inconsistent with consumer preferences and unbounded from above or below we propose a set of criteria which guarantee a bounded measure of wtp the criteria reject the traditional random utility model with unrestricted error terms in favor of the random wtp model with bounds on wtp once wtp is bounded by zero and income the form of the distribution is less consequential a new model for wtp is developed based on the beta distribution and is compared to previously estimated models

are hypothetical referenda incentive compatible a comment in a recent article in this journal cummings al 1997 offer experimental evidence rejecting the hypothesis that a hypothetical referendum is an incentive compatible mechanism for obtaining the social value of or willingness to pay for changes in the allocation of environmental goods and services while cautions in offering a blanket rejection of hypothetical referenda as a means of measuring economic values on the basis of their findings the authors do suggest that at least in experimental settings respondents appear to behave differently when real money is changing hands wheather hypothetical situations adequately mimic real market situations has been debated in the contigent valuation literature since its inception see cummings brookshire and schulze 1986 cummings et al s finding of incentive incompatibility appears to offer strong evidence for the critics of hypothetical referenda