self selection and the efficiency of tournaments when exogenously imposed rank order tournaments have incentive properties but their overall efficiency is reduced by a high variance in performance bull schotter and weigelt 1987 however since the efficiency of performance related pay is attributable both to its incentive effect and to its selection effect among employees lazear 2000 it is important to investigate the ex ante sorting effect of tournaments this paper reports results from an experiment analyzing whether allowing subjects to self select into different payment schemes helps in reducing the variability of performance in tournaments we show that when the subjects choose to enter a tournament the average effort is higher and the between subject variance is substantially lower than when the same payment scheme is imposed sorting is efficiency enhancing since it increases the homogeneity of the contestants we suggest that the flexibility of the labor market is an important condition for a higher efficiency of relative performance pay

heterogeneity tournaments and hierarchies tournament contracts are characterized that simultaneously elicit first best efficient effort levels and self selection of risk neutral heterogeneous workers into ability specific contracts comparisons across self selected ability types are shown to be sometimes necessary to attain efficiency rationales are explored for not commonly observing such contracts in hierarchical organizations

contests as selection mechanisms the impact of risk aversion abstract we investigate how individual risk preferences affect the likelihood of selecting the more able contestant within a two player tullock contest our theoretical model yields two main predictions first an increase in the risk aversion of a player worsens her odds unless she already has a sufficiently large advantage second if the prize money is sufficiently large a less able but less risk averse contestant can achieve an equal or even higher probability of winning than a more able but more risk averse opponent in a laboratory experiment we confirm both the non monotonic impact and the compensating effect of risk aversion on winning probabilities our results suggest a novel explanation for the gender gap and the optimality of limited monetary incentives in selection contests

learning from coarse information biased contests and career profiles an organization s promotion decision between two workers is modelled as a problem of boundedly rational learning about ability the decision maker can bias noisy rank order contests sequentially thereby changing the information they convey the optimal final period bias favours the leader reinforcing his likely ability advantage when optimally biased rank order information is a sufficient statistic for cardinal information the leader is favoured in every period in other environments bias in early periods may i favour the early loser ii be optimal even when the workers are equally rated and iii reduce the favoured worker s promotion chances this paper presents a model of boundedly rational learning by an organization the aims are to represent in a simple form the costs of gathering processing or transmitting information and to analyse their implications for the procedures selected to handle information as well as for the decisions actually made like other recent work on the internal organization of firms this work explores to what extent organizational structure and behaviour as well as organizational performance can be explained by adaptation to the costs associated with information in the learning model we formulate the decision maker not only selects a rule specifying what action to take as a function of his observations but also chooses sequentially the information partitions generating those observations this general problem is interpreted in the context of an organization which needs to make an important promotion decision and which attempts to maximize the value of the information generated during the observation periods that precede the decision one of the motivations for this analysis was the finding by organizational sociologists that earnings and promotions in the later stages of a worker s career are strongly correlated with earnings and promotions in the early stages kanter 1977 rosenbaum 1984 later success is positively associated with early success even when one controls for the effect of observable characteristics likely to affect performance such as education one obvious source of this correlation is differences in ability that persist over time and that are not captured by the observable covariates in this paper we focus on differences in ability which are initially unobservable by organizations and their workers as well as by researchers we present a simple model of an organization trying to learn about differences in ability and show

is the market biased against risky r d this article analyzes the riskiness of the r d strategies chosen by firms engaged in a winner takes all patent race in contradiction to dasgupta and stiglitz 1980 we show that when the distribution of invention times is symmetric the market equilibrium cannot be safer and may be riskier than is socially optimal we identify the economic reason for the emergence but only if there are few competitors

modifying variability and correlations in winner take all contests we consider contests with a fixed proportion of winners based on relative performance special attention is paid to winner take all contests which we define as contests with relatively few winners receiving relatively large awards but we consider the full range of values of the proportion of winners if a contestant has the opportunity to modify the distribution of her performance what strategy is advantageous when the proportion of winners is less than one half a riskier performance distribution is preferred when this proportion is greater than one half it is better to choose a less risky distribution using a multinormal model we consider modifications in the variability of the distribution and in correlations with the performance of other contestants increasing variability and decreasing correlations lead to improved chances of winning when the proportion of winners is less than one half and the opposite directions should be taken for proportions greater than one half thus it is better to take chances and to attempt to distance oneself from the other contestants i e to break away from the herd when there are few winners a more conservative herding strategy makes sense when there are many winners our analytical and numerical results indicate that the probability of winning can change substantially as variability and or correlations are modified furthermore in a game theoretic setting in which all contestants can make modifications choosing a riskier less risky performance distribution when the proportion of winners is low high is the dominant best response strategy we briefly consider some practical issues related to the recommended strategies and some possible extensions

search duplication in research and design spaces exploring the role of local competition a lack of sufficient diversification in research strategies has been identified as an important problem for delegated research we show that this problem can be solved by local competition such as bribery lobbying rent seeking competition at the patent office among players who apply the same search strategies or develop the same design such competition can restore full efficiency in the non cooperative equilibrium local competition interacts with the choice of whether to cluster or diversify and rather than adding a further inefficiency to the existing ones it eliminates inefficiency the results are robust and hold under simultaneous search strategy choices as well as for sequential choices

managerial incentives on the near linearity of optimal compensation contracts are examined when outcomes depend on managers choices as well as efforts as the cost of effort shrinks relative to payoffs the optimal contract converges to a linear payoff if the control space of the agent has full dimensionality but not otherwise thus when the agent can trade expected return for greater correlation with other returns it is better to ignore relative performance when the cost of effort is small when the choices include all fair gambles and hedges the linear schedule is no more expensive than any other schedule that induces effort unfair gambles are examined as well

the selection efficiency of tournaments abstract we discuss tournaments in terms of their efficiency as probabilistic mechanisms that select high quality alternatives players in a noisy environment we characterize the selection efficiency of three such mechanisms contests binary elimination tournaments and round robin tournaments depending on the shape of the distribution of players quality the number of players and noise level the results have implications as to how and under what circumstances the efficiency of tournament based selection can be manipulated

the simple economics of research portfolios this article identifies biases in market portfolios of parallel research projects arising from the noncongruence of social goals and private aspirations occasioned by those circumstances where the market rewards only the winner and where the winner is awarded the entire social surplus it is shown that under risk neutrality this noncongruence implies that t he market encourages the development of too many discoveries too lar ge a spread in the distribution of the quality of discoveries and an excessive occurrence of multiple discoveries copyright 1987 by royal economic society

solar electricity development and policy support in ghana abstract limited fossil resources the continuous increment in fuel prices and severe environmental problems require new sustainable electricity generation options which utilize renewable energies solar photovoltaic generation is a proven renewable energy technology and has the potential to become cost effective in the future for it produces electricity from the solar radiation in ghana the electricity demand is rapidly increasing at a rate of 10 annually in the attempt to change the conventional energy intensive economical development and its negative impact on the environment the government has begun to support the development of the solar photovoltaic technology strongly in this paper the state of solar photovoltaic the challenges facing the industry the potential of the technology the policies and strategies to promote development of the technology have been presented

on the evolution of attitudes towards risk in winner take all games abstract a long standing conjecture is that winner take all games such as patent races lead to the survival of risk takers and the extinction of risk averters in many species a winner take all game determines the males right to reproduce and the same argument suggests that males will evolve to be risk takers psychological and sociological evidence buttresses the argument that males are more risk taking than females using an evolutionary model of preference formation we investigate to what extent evolution leads to risk taking in winner take all environments journal of economic literature classification numbers c7 d8

of tournaments and temptations an analysis of managerial incentives in the mutual fund industry we test the hypothesis that when their compensation is linked to relative performance managers of investment portfolios likely to end up as losers will manipulate fund risk differently than those managing portfolios likely to be winners an empirical investigation of the performance of 334 growth oriented mutual funds during 1976 to 1991 demonstrates that mid year losers tend to increase fund volatility in the latter part of an annual assessment period to a greater extent than mid year winners furthermore we show that this effect became stronger as industry growth and investor awareness of fund performance increased over time

the dynamics of portfolio management contracts we consider the multiperiod relationship between a client and a portfolio manager and the resulting problem of motivating a manager of unknown ability to acquire valuable information we explore the contractual forms and the optimal retention policy of the client and find that the optimal initial set of contracts features a smaller performance based fee component paid to the manager than in a first best contract and the contract choice elicits only partial information about the manager as a result ex post performance measurement is critical to future recontracting in general managers are retained only if the returns on their portfolio exceed the benchmark by an appropriate amount article published by oxford university press on behalf of the society for financial studies in its journal the review of financial studies

myopic risk taking in tournaments abstract there is a common notion that incentive schemes in the financial industry trigger myopia and risk taking in some sense this contrasts with the concept of myopic loss aversion mla which implies that myopia mitigates risk taking a number of experimental studies support the mla hypothesis by showing that people take less risk the more frequently their investments are evaluated in this paper we show experimentally that if subjects are exposed to tournament incentives the standard mla effect disappears rather there is a tendency towards more risk taking the more frequently investments are evaluated

auctionin entry into tournaments a research tournament model with heterogeneous contestants is presented for a large class of contests the optimal number of competitors is two this insight makes designing the tournament easier and highlights the importance of selecting highly qualified contestants while customary uniform price and discriminatory price auctions are intuitively appealing mechanisms for solving this adverse selection problem in practice they generally will not be efficient mechanism for selecting contestants instead we propose an alternative auction format that is equally simple to implement and efficiently selects the most qualified contestants to compete regardless of the form of contestant heterogeneity

biased contests for symmetric players in a biased contest one of the players has an advantage in the winner determination process we characterize a novel class of biased contest success functions pertaining to such contests and provide necessary and sufficient conditions for zero bias to be a critical point of arbitrary objectives satisfying certain symmetry restrictions we however challenge the common wisdom that unbiased contests are always optimal when contestants are symmetric ex ante or even ex post we show that contests with arbitrary favorites i e biased contests of symmetric players can be optimal in terms of various objectives such as expected aggregate effort the probability to reveal the stronger player as the winner or expected effort of the winner

work incentives hierarchy and internal labor markets this paper argues that contracts with payment based on a ranking of employee performance can provide performance incentives even under asymmetric information that prevents payment based on individual performance only being enforceable such contracts also fit with five features of labor markets that have aroused considerable interest 1 hierarchical wage structures 2 internal promotion 3 wage rates that rise with seniority and experience more than productivity 4 the variance of earnings increasing with experience and 5 wage rates attached to jobs rather than individuals with differentials set by administrative procedures rather than by reference to external market wages

household welfare and the pricing of cocoa and coffee in cote d ivoire lessons from the living standards surveys cocoa and coffee are the most important crops in cote d ivoire until recently the difference between world and administered producer prices provided an important source of government revenue as a result of a continued decline of world prices of both crops however the ivoirien government was forced to cut producer prices in half because 40 percent of ivoirien households grow either cocoa or coffee this cut can be expected to have a considerable impact on the welfare level of these households the authors use the 1985 living standards measurement survey to estimate the welfare effects of producer price changes for ivoirien households permitting an evaluation of the probable consequences of the recent price cut using nonparametric econometric techniques they find that although many households will suffer losses of income the cuts will not have adverse distributional effects cocoa and coffee farmers are scattered throughout the income distribution but most are concentrated in the middle

rigging the lobbying process an application of the all pay auction textabstractin a world where a politician can explicitly auction off a prize to the high bidder the standard auction literature can be used to analyse political behavior the justice system however precludes politicians from explicitly selling the prize to the highest bidder thus politicians cannot let it become public knowledge that they are in the business of selling political favors an institution has emerged in political markets to overcome this constraint which are termed as lobbying lobbyists make implicit payments to the politician through campaign contributions if these up front payments were rebated to those failing to receive the prize it would be clear that the politician was selling favors this article has examined an interesting principle arising in all pay auctions this principle states that a politician wishing to maximize political rents may find it in his best interest to exclude certain lobbyists from participating in the lobbying process particularly lobbyists valuing most the political prize

rent risk and replication preference adaptation in winner take all markets abstract we study the evolution of an economy where agents who are heterogeneous with respect to risk attitudes can either earn a certain income or enter a risky rent seeking contest we assume that agents behave rationally given their preferences but that the population distribution of preferences evolves over time in response to material payoffs we show that in particular initial distributions with full support converge to stationary states where all types are still present although rents are perfectly dissipated in material terms at a steady state efficiency is greater than if everybody had been risk neutral since risk lovers specialize in rent seeking

learning to lend for off grid solar power policy lessons from world bank loans to india indonesia and sri lanka abstract the world bank has sought to advance the diffusion of solar photovoltaic pv technology for off grid applications in the developing world as these systems are fundamentally different to centralised power stations and conventional rural electrification the world bank has been learning how best to lend for such technology this study seeks to highlight the lessons learnt from the world bank s first loans for off grid pv to india indonesia and sri lanka it uses lifetime cost analysis to justify continued intervention in this sector and it draws on theories of innovation diffusion to guide analysis and ultimately policy recommendations because of the special role of entrepreneurial start up companies in the rural pv sector the paper also uses a company cash flow model to demonstrate the efficacy of various supply side policies finally the study concludes with a checklist of policy lessons and a consideration of the role of the international finance corporation in this sector

how tournament incentives affect asset markets a comparison between winner take all tournaments and elimination contests abstract we investigate the impact of investment managers tournament incentives on investment strategies and market efficiency distinguishing between winner take all tournaments wta where a minority wins and elimination contests ec where a majority wins theoretically we show that investment managers play heterogeneous strategies in wta and homogeneous strategies in ec and markets are more prone to mispricing in wta than in ec experimentally we find that investment managers play more heterogeneous strategies in wta than in ec but this does not trigger significant differences in prices moreover prices in wta and ec do not differ significantly from markets composed of linearly incentivized subjects

tournament rewards and risk taking this article considers a lazear rosen tournament model where agents can influence both the spread of their output distribution risk taking and its mean the unique equilibrium induces excessive risk taking and a low level of effort by modifying the tournament to give the highest prize to the agent with the most moderate output a low level of risk taking and high level of effort can be sustained as an equilibrium the first result can be useful to understand the relative performance evaluation puzzle of executive compensation and the second result can be useful to understand puzzling workplace norms promoting mediocrity

contests with stochastic abilities we consider the properties of perfectly discriminating contests in which players abilities are stochastic but become common knowledge before efforts are expended players whose expected ability is lower than that of their rivals may still earn a positive expected payoff from participating in the contest which may explain why they participate we also show that an increase in the dispersion of a player s own ability generally benefits this player it may benefit or harm his rival but cannot benefit the rival more than it benefits himself we also explore the role of stochastic ability for sequential contests with the same opponent multibattle contests and with varying opponents elimination tournaments and show that it reduces the strong discouragement effects and holdup problems that may otherwise emerge in such games high own ability dispersion selects such players into the contest and favors them in elimination contests jel d72 d74 i introduction manytournamentsarecharacterizedbymultiple rounds with or without the elimination of some candidates in earlier stages of the process of determining a final winner in the political context electionprocessesthatdetermineparty leadersorpoliticalleadersmoregenerallyconsist ofmultipleconteststages intheracefortheu s presidency severalcompetitionstagesgradually narrowdownthenumberofcompetitors 1 inter

comparative statics of contests and rent seeking games this paper develops the comparative statics properties of a contest encountered in patent races and rent seeking games the author shows that symmetric equilibrium expenditure and profit per player decrease with the number of competitors and the discount rate but increase with the value of the prize a fundamental lemma established in the paper shows that a stability condition usually imposed on the model is automatically satisfied the author identifies a class of likelihood or hazard rate functions for which aggregate expenditure increases with the number of competitors and total profits converge to zero copyright 1997 by economics department of the university of pennsylvania and the osaka university institute of social and economic research association

psychological pressure in competitive environments evidence from a randomized natural experiment much like cognitive abilities emotional skills can have major eects on performance and economic outcomes this paper studies the behavior of professional subjects involved in a dynamic competition in their own natural environment the setting is a penalty shoot out in soccer where two teams compete in a tournament framework taking turns in a sequence of ve penalty kicks each as the kicking order is determined by the random outcome of a coin ip the treatment and control

risk taking in selection contests abstract we study contests where the strategic variable is the degree of risk taking rather than the amount of effort the selection efficiency of such contests is examined we show that the selection efficiency of a contest may be improved by limiting the competition in two ways by having a small number of contestants and by restricting contestant quality

photovoltaic technology markets economics and rural development abstract photovoltaic pv electricity has been widely supported as a remote energy source for developing countries in response the production and shipment of pv modules in developed nations has steadily increased through the past decade often marketed through the auspices of technology transfer and financed by international development aid this paper investigates the motives economics and development implications of pvs in rural electrification drawing on field research in the dominican republic the implications of subsidizing a pv market rather than investing in further pv research and development are explored

cognitive performance in competitive environments evidence from a natural experiment competitive situations that involve cognitive performance are widespread in labor markets schools and organizations including test taking competition for promotion in firms and others this paper studies cognitive performance in a high stakes competitive environment the analysis takes advantage of a natural experiment that randomly allocates different emotional states across professional subjects competing in a cognitive task the setting is a chess match where two players play an even number of chess games against each other alternating the color of the pieces white pieces confer an advantage for winning a chess game and who starts the match with these pieces is randomly decided the theoretical analysis shows that in this setting there is no rational reason why winning frequencies should be better than 50 50 in favor of the player drawing the white pieces in the first game yet we find that observed frequencies are about 60 40 differences in performance are also stronger when the competing subjects are more similar in cognitive skills we conclude that the evidence is consistent with the hypothesis that psychological elements affect cognitive performance in the face of experience competition and high stakes

digging for golden carrots an analysis of research tournaments contracting for research is often infeasible because research inputs are unobservable and research outcomes cannot be verified by a court sponsoring a research tournament can resolve these problems a model is presented in which contestants compete to find the innovation of highest value to the tournament sponsor the winner receives a prespecified prize the tournament game has a unique subgame perfect equilibrium free entry is not optimal because equilibrium effort by each researcher decreases in the number of contestants an optimally designed research tournament balances the probability of overshooting the first best quality level against the probability of falling short copyright 1995 by american economic association