markets for pollution control when firms are noncompliant the problem of noncompliance and enforcement in transferable discharge permit tdp markets has not received much attention this paper examines the consequences of noncompliance for a tdp market given fairly general assumptions about the characteristics of the enforcement policy in place the analysis reveals that when firms are noncompliant tdp markets retain their efficiency property only under some fairly stringent conditions the effect of noncompliance on the equilibrium permit price raises some important questions about the ability of a tdp market to achieve and remain in equilibrium when firms are noncompliant

understanding heterogeneous preferences in random utility models a latent class approach a finite mixture approach toconditional logit models is developed in whichlatent classes are used to promoteunderstanding of systematic heterogeneity the model is applied to wilderness recreationin which a branded choice experiment involvingchoice of one park from a demand system wasadministered to a sample of recreationists the basis of membership in the classes orsegments in the sample involved attitudinalmeasures of motivations for taking a trip aswell as their stated preferences overwilderness park attributes the econometricanalysis suggested that four classes of peopleexist in the sample using the model toexamine welfare measures of some hypotheticalpolicy changes identified markedly differentwelfare effects than the standard singlesegment model and provided insight into thedifferential impact of alternative policies

controlling for observed and unobserved site characteristics in rum models of recreation demand hatch act and state of iowa the iowa department of natural resources and the u s environmental protection agency s science to achieve results star program grant r830818

individual transferable quota markets under illegal fishing the use of individual transferable quotas in fisheries has been considered an opportunity to achieve a given total allowable catch with a maximum social benefit one of the assumptions used in obtaining that result is that the system is in perfect compliance the presence of violations and the need for enforcement of tradable property rights systems in fisheries has not received much attention in the literature the incidents of non compliance however may affect the performance of transferable property rights based fisheries in unexplored ways in this paper we adapt previous literature on enforcing emissions trading programs to analyze a positive model of fisherman behavior that operates under a perfectly competitive individual transferable quota system while recognizing the opportunities for violations of quota holdings given incomplete enforcement considering a poorly enforced individual transferable quota system we are able to obtain a number of implications for the current and future equilibrium of the quota market the time paths of the fishery and the proper design of a policy rule on total allowable catch tac

handling unobserved site characteristics in random utility models of recreation demand abstract this paper presents a new random utility model of recreation demand that addresses the unobserved characteristics of recreation sites most random utility recreation demand models implicitly assume that all relevant site characteristics are observed by the researcher or allow for the possibility of unobserved characteristics in a restrictive manner unlike traditional approaches the proposed model avoids the bias unobserved site characteristics can cause in welfare estimates and the travel cost parameter monte carlo simulations motivate the proposed model by showing that it provides more efficient parameter estimates in contrast existing methods yield less efficient estimates and biased standard errors that overstate precision an empirical application to recreational fishing in wisconsin illustrates the potential importance of this modeling innovation in this application controlling for unobserved characteristics is important for a range of model specifications

modeling recreation site choice do hypothetical choices reflect actual behavior we examine the ability of revealed preference rp site specific stated preference sp transferred sp and joint rp sp models to predict aggregate and individual recreation site choice in a holdout sample for two statistical comparisons the rp model provided the most accurate predictions of individual choices however the transferred sp model applied directly or estimated jointly with the rp data performed best in three aggregate and one individual prediction test these findings suggest that data from well designed and conducted sp surveys from one site can be combined with site specific rp data from another site to generate improved models of recreation site choice an objective of many economic studies is to construct models of choice behavior these models form the basis for welfare mea surement the models can also be used to make predictions of choice behavior that can inform policy makers of the proba ble results of changes in economic fac tors resource

on optimal audit mechanisms for environmental taxes abstract we consider the auditing problem of an environmental enforcement agency with fixed audit resources how to decide which firms to audit after having observed the firms taxable emissions reports the goal of the agency is to implement the socially efficient emissions level the audit mechanism is the agency s sole choice variable while other variables such as the tax rate on emissions and the fine for non compliance are determined by other governmental actors the fines and budget of the agency are constrained in such a way that the common random audit mechanism fails to implement socially efficient emissions assuming perfect information among the firms we derive an optimal audit mechanism capable of implementing the socially efficient emissions level the optimal audit mechanism creates a contest exploiting the strategic interdependencies between the firms where the probability of winning not being audited for each firm depends on costly efforts their taxable emissions reports

profits from violating controls on the use of a polluting input profits from violating the quota charge and permit market systems are compared the results indicate that for a given permit price the violation profits of the charge and permit market systems are the same and exceed the profits from violating a quota system if the optimal use of inputs in a compliant market is lower than the quota it is also shown that under a permit market system the occurrence of violation decreases the equilibrium price of permits this implies that the profits from violating a permit market are lower than violation profits of a charge system

a repeated nested logit model of atlantic salmon fishing participation and site choice for atlantic salmon fishing are modeled in the context of a repeated three level nested logit model consumer s surplus measures are derived for different levels of species availability in the penobscot river the most important salmon river in new england for comparison six other travel cost models are estimated these include restrictive cases of the nested logit model a partial demand model and two single site demand models comparisons across these models indicate the importance of modeling the participation decision including income effects and of adopting a nested logit structure rather than a single level logit structure

combining contingent valuation and travel cost data for the valuation of non market goods the travel cost method tcm has long been used to infer the economic value of nonmarket resources and public goods more recently contingent valuation cvm survey methods have gained popularity for eliciting these values here cvm survey responses are combined with tcm data on actual market behavior to estimate jointly both the parameters of the underlying utility function and its corresponding ordinary demand function this is a prototypical empirical example of a new modeling strategy variants of which should prove useful in many applications especially where reliance on a single valuation method is undesirable

responsible production policies with substitution and carbon emissions trading abstract this paper considers a production model involving a manufacturer that uses two different technologies the green technology and the standard technology the green product produced by the green technology can be used as a substitute for the traditional product produced by the standard technology but not vice versa three models are considered the first model concerns with product substitution only and serves as a benchmark model for the next two models the carbon emission allowance model and the carbon emission trading model the second model extends the product substitution model by imposing an upper limit on the total carbon emission allowance for each firm the third model extends the second model to cater for carbon emission trading for the carbon emission allowance model analytical result shows that the optimal production quantity of any product depends on both its total carbon emission allowance quota and its unit carbon emission profit and the effect of substitution improves the service level the expected profit of the manufacturer and the green of product mix for the carbon emission trading model analytical result shows that whenever the production quantity of any product is optimal the marginal profit of production i e the additional profit obtained by producing an extra item should be equal to the unit price of carbon emission trading within the market moreover the optimal policy of either model reduces the total amount of carbon emission thus producing less pollution to the environment lastly the optimal profits obtained by using the carbon emission trading model are larger than the corresponding optimal profits obtained by using the carbon emission allowance model

response to embodied energy and emergy analyses of a concentrating solar power csp system 2012 while emergy analysis i e emergy synthesis environmental accounting was developed in the early 1980s by h t odum building upon his seminal work outlining the energy basis for man and nature the method is still developing some very important aspects of the method such as the global baseline for renewable emergy and how the emergy yield ratio eyr a critical index for implicating the contribution of a process to society is to be calculated are still under debate in the scientific community this makes it all the more critical that when an emergy analysis is done all methodology is laid bare and justified unfortunately zhang et al 2012 energy policy 42 pp 232 238 is deficient in doing so in the response below i lay out the problems i observed in the paper and propose a revision to their analysis i should note that no issues were found with the embodied energy portion of the analysis and the inconsistencies with accepted methodology were likely due to an unfamiliarity with the emergy method

a latent segmentation approach to a kuhn tucker model an application to recreation demand abstract in this paper we extend the latent segmentation approach to the kuhn tucker kt model the proposed approach models heterogeneity in preferences for recreational behavior using a utility theoretical framework to simultaneously model participation and site selection decisions estimation of the latent segmentation kt model with standard maximum likelihood techniques is numerically difficult because of the large number of parameters in the segment membership functions and the utility function for each latent segment to address this problem we propose the expectation maximization em algorithm to estimate the model in the empirical section we implement the em latent segmentation kt approach to analyze a southern california beach recreation data set our empirical analysis suggests that three groups exist in the sample using the model to analyze two hypothetical beach management policy scenarios illustrates different welfare impacts across groups

remediation and self reporting in optimal law enforcement abstract many environmental laws encourage firms to self report their violations to government regulators rather than subject themselves to probabilistic enforcement this paper studies self reporting enforcement regimes when there are ex post benefits of remediation or clean up remediation benefits are shown to impart two advantages to the use of self reporting beyond those identified elsewhere firstly whereas non reporting firms only engage in costly clean up when they are caught by an enforcement authority self reporting firms always engage in efficient remediation secondly with self reporting the government can costlessly impose stiffer non reporter penalties that reduce the government enforcement effort required to achieve a given level of violation deterrence

incomplete enforcement with endogenous regulatory choice abstract this paper extends the economic literature on the incomplete enforcement of social regulation by incorporating regulatory choice in an institutional environment of limited regulatory resources and powers we show how regulatory decisions determine the structure of incentives faced by regulated firms our results indicate that the expense of monitoring relative to the regulator s power to levy penalties helps to explain the differences between compliance and deterrence enforcement styles we find that in most circumstances firms with higher abatement costs will receive a larger share of regulatory resources and thus face higher penalties than firms with lower costs

the regulatory choice of noncompliance in emissions trading programs this paper addresses the following question to achieve a fixed aggregate emissions target cost effectively should emissions trading programs be designed and implemented to achieve full compliance or does allowing a certain amount of noncompliance reduce the costs of reaching the emissions target the total costs of achieving the target consist of aggregate abatement costs monitoring costs and the expected costs of collecting penalties from noncompliant firms under common assumptions i show that allowing noncompliance is cost effective only if violations are enforced with an increasing marginal penalty however one can design a policy that induces full compliance with a constant marginal penalty that meets the aggregate emissions target with lower expected costs this last result does not depend on setting an arbitrarily high constant marginal penalty in fact the marginal penalty need not be higher than the equilibrium marginal penalty under the policy with the increasing marginal penalty and can actually be lower finally tying the marginal penalty directly to the permit price allows the policy objective to be achieved without any knowledge of firms abatement costs

combining revealed and stated preferences consistency tests and their interpretations this article models the recreation demand for iowa wetlands combining survey data on both actual usage patterns i e revealed preferences rps and anticipated changes to those patterns under hypothetical increases in trip costs i e stated preferences sps we formulate and test specific hypotheses concerning potential sources of bias in each approach and discuss what can be learned about the validity of the models from such tests

enforcement costs and the optimal magnitude and probability of fines whenever the government uses fines to control harmful activities it incurs certain costs in connection with the enforcement process this article will show how these costs affect the optimal magnitude of fines and the optimal degree of enforcement effort that is the optimal probability of detection of those who commit harmful acts we will distinguish between two types of enforcement costs fixed enforcement costs are costs that do not depend on the number of individuals who commit harmful acts these costs would include for example the expenses borne by a pollution control agency in testing water quality in a lake variable enforcement costs are costs that do depend on the number of individuals who commit harmful acts such as the costs of prosecuting and penalizing polluters in our basic model we assume that the fixed enforcement costs are the costs of maintaining the probability of detection at a certain level and that the variable enforcement costs are the costs of fining individuals the main conclusions of this article may be summarized as follows the optimalfine equals the harm properly inflatedfor the chance of not being detected plus the variable enforcement cost of imposing the fine if the fine is of this magnitude the expected fine will equal the harm caused by the harmful act plus the expected increase in enforcement costs occasioned by it for instance suppose that the probability of detecting a

design of sustainable supply chains under the emission trading scheme increase in environmental concerns together with legislations are forcing industries to take a fresh look at the impact of their supply chain operations on the environment this paper introduces a mixed integer linear programming based framework for sustainable supply chain design that considers life cycle assessment lca principles in addition to the traditional material balance constraints at each node in the supply chain indeed the framework distinguishes between solid and liquid wastes as well as gaseous emissions due to various production processes and transportation systems the framework is used to evaluate the tradeoffs between economic and environmental objectives under various cost and operating strategies in the aluminum industry the results suggest that current legislation and emission trading schemes ets must be strengthened and harmonized at the global level in order to drive a meaningful environmental strategy moreover the model demonstrates that efficient carbon management strategies will help decision makers to achieve sustainability objectives in a cost effective manner

improving environmental valuation estimates through consistent use of revealed and stated preference information abstract environmental valuation data from stated and revealed preference methods are integrated into a unified model of preferences for environmental quality improvement that identifies the use and nonuse components of the total value estimate this articulates clearly what parts of the total value estimate come from each type of data and permits tests of whether estimated preferences satisfy weak complementarity between the environmental good of interest and related private goods the statistical advantages of using more information for the valuation problem are exploited while retaining flexibility to identify value estimates from any individual method of analysis

combining revealed preference data with stated preference data a latent class approach a substantial literature exists combining data from revealed preference rp and stated preference sp sources aimed either at testing for the convergent validity of the two approaches used in nonmarket valuation or as a means of drawing on their relative strengths to improve the ultimate estimates of value in doing so it is assumed that convergence of the two elicitation approaches is an all or nothing proposition i e the rp and sp data are either consistent with each other or they are not the purpose of this paper is to propose an alternative framework that allows for possible divergence among individuals in terms the consistency between their rp and sp responses in particular we suggest the use of a latent class approach to segment the population into two groups the first group has rp and sp responses that are internally consistent while the remaining group exhibits some form of inconsistent preferences an em algorithm is employed in an empirical application that draws on the alberta and saskatchewan moose hunting data sets used in earlier combined rp and sp exercises the empirical results suggest that somewhere between one third and one half the sample exhibits consistent preferences we also examine differences in welfare estimates drawn from the two classes

efficient environmental policy with imperfect compliance discussions of efficient environmental policytend to recommend taxes rather than quotas ongrounds of efficiency a uniform tax willequalize marginal abatement cost betweenpolluters when polluters actions are imperfectly observable the distinction betweentaxes and quotas becomes less clear taxes maybe evaded by underreporting of emissions whilequota violations will not always be discovered this paper explores the conditions under whichthe efficiency properties of taxes continue tohold even when evasion is possible and theextent to which the fine for quota violationsplays the same role as a tax on emissions withsimilar efficiency properties

revealing additional dimensions of preference heterogeneity in a latent class mixed multinomial logit model latent class models offer an alternative perspective to the popular mixed logit form replacing the continuous distribution with a discrete distribution in which preference heterogeneity is captured by membership of distinct classes of utility description within each class preference homogeneity is usually assumed although interactions with observed contextual effects are permissible a natural extension of the fixed parameter latent class model is a random parameter latent class model which allows for another layer of preference heterogeneity within each class this article sets out the random parameter latent class model and illustrates its applications using a stated choice data set on alternative freight distribution attribute packages pivoted around a recent trip in australia

emergy based ecological footprint analysis for a mega city the dynamic changes of shanghai abstract to move towards sustainable urban development interactions between economic and ecological systems should be further investigated due to their coupled relations in this study we propose an emergy based ecological footprint eef analysis framework shanghai was selected as a case study city to see its dynamic changes from 2007 to 2016 the results show that shanghai had a large ecological deficit an extremely high ecological footprint intensity and a poor coordination relationship between its ecological system and its economic system indicating a great ecological challenge that it is facing the uneven distribution of its emergy ecological footprint is mainly due to the large share of fossil fuels land type but with the city s great efforts the overall ecological pressure has been reduced and the coordination relationship has also been improved while the local economy is still booming pearson correlation analysis further indicates that the city s policy on developing tertiary industry has resulted in a positive effect on improving the coordinating relationship the ratio between the output value of heavy industry and gross industrial output value has the most negative correlation with the coordinating relationship finally policy recommendations are raised by considering the local realities these recommendations can also provide valuable insights to other megacities with similar challenges

noncompliant firms in transferable discharge permit markets some extensions abstract this paper extends the results of previous research on transferable discharge permit tdp markets with noncompliant firms to make a specific comparison between standards and tdp systems when regulatory authorities are unable to achieve full compliance particular attention is given to the importance of the shape of the penalty function facing noncompliant firms the analysis indicates that under plausible penalty functions tdp markets may allow more pollution or a higher fraction of regulated firms out of compliance these results highlight the importance of implementation in the success of pollution control strategies relying on tdp markets

emergy evaluation of the sustainability of chinese steel production during 1998 2004 abstract this paper deals with the application of emergy analysis to the sustainability of chinese steel production in 1998 2004 emissions impacts were quantified using emergy synthesis and other methods dilution method disability adjusted life years daly method and ecological cumulative exergy consumption ecec method the results show that its sustainability is very low and declining in this period emissions obviously reduce the sustainability although their impacts are generally decreasing and the main reasons lie in its low nonrenewable resources and energies efficiencies finally the related suggestions were put forward for improving its comprehensive performance

perceptions versus objective measures of environmental quality in combined revealed and stated preference models of environmental valuation abstract this study examines perceptions and objective attribute measures in discrete choice models of recreation site choice behavior these forms of attribute measurement are examined in individual and combined revealed preference stated preference models our results suggest that the model based on perceptions slightly outperforms the models based on objective attribute measures however issues such as the definition of the choice set and the measurement of welfare present significant challenges when using perceptions data

combining revealed and stated preference data to estimate the nonmarket value of ecological services an assessment of the state of the science this paper reviews the marketing transportation and environmental economics literature on the joint estimation of revealed preference rp and stated preference sp data the rp and sp approaches are first described with a focus on the strengths and weaknesses of each recognizing these strengths and weaknesses the potential gains from combining data are described a classification system for combined data that emphasizes the type of data combination and the econometric models used is proposed a methodological review of the literature is pursued based on this classification system examples from the environmental economics literature are highlighted a discussion of the advantages and disadvantages of each type of jointly estimated model is then presented suggestions for future research in particular opportunities for application of these models to environmental quality valuation are presented

combining price and quantity controls to mitigate global climate change abstract uncertainty about compliance costs causes otherwise equivalent price and quantity controls to behave differently and leads to divergent welfare consequences although most of the debate on global climate change policy has focused on quantity controls due to their political appeal this paper argues that price controls are more efficient simulations based on a stochastic computable general equilibrium model indicate that the expected welfare gain from the optimal price policy is five times higher than the expected gain from the optimal quantity policy an alternative hybrid policy combines both the political appeal of quantity controls with the efficiency of prices using an initial distribution of tradeable permits to set a quantitative target but allowing additional permits to be purchased at a fixed trigger price even sub optimal hybrid policies offer dramatic efficiency improvements over otherwise standard quantity controls for example a 50 trigger price per ton of carbon converts the 3 trillion expected loss associated with a simple 1990 emission target to a 150 billion gain these results suggest that a hybrid policy is an attractive alternative to either a pure price or quantity system

further results on permit markets with market power and cheating abstract this paper examines a market for pollution permits in which one firm has market power and one or more firms is noncompliant i show that the firm with market power may choose to hold more permits than it needs effectively retiring permits from the market i also show that some noncompliance may be socially desirable because it can mitigate the distortion caused by market power similarly some degree of market power may be socially desirable because it can in turn mitigate the distortion caused by noncompliance

influence of sewage treatment on china s energy consumption and economy and its performances abstract the sewage treatment industry may affect china s energy saving and economic growth related goals to some degree this study investigated influence of sewage treatment on china s energy consumption and economic growth and its performances from 2008 to 2013 we adopted a set of indicator system based on energy emergy and money to depict these interactions including energy use per unit emission reduction euer cost per unit emission reduction cuer environmental benefit per unit investment ebui ratio of energy consumption from sewage treatment to national total energy consumption rest ratio of cost of sewage treatment to the gross domestic product rcsg structural coordination degree of sewage treatment scds and scale harmony degree of sewage treatment shds here emergy was used to quantify the environmental impact of water pollutants the study results show that energy efficiency of sewage treatment keeps relatively stable the economic cost of sewage treatment increases obviously the environmental performance of sewage treatment investment slightly rises and the sewage treatment has an increasing impact on the energy consumption and economic growth of this country as far as the relationships between different indicators or factors are concerned the structure of china s sewage treatment industry worsens obviously due to rising energy consumption and economic cost meanwhile the relationship between economic cost and energy consumption for sewage treatment domestic water consumption and discharged sewage s impact seriously deteriorated finally some corresponding issues are discussed and the related policy implications are put forward

enforcement and price controls in emissions trading this paper examines how enforcement affects the structure and performance of emissions trading programs with price controls under uncertainty about firms abatement costs the analysis highlights how an enforcement strategy can cause abatement cost risk to be transmitted to enforcement costs via the price of permits when this occurs accommodating the effect of abatement cost risk with an optimal policy results in higher expected emissions and lower expected permit price than their second best optimal values however it is possible to design an enforcement strategy that shields enforcement costs from abatement cost risk by tying sanctions directly to permit prices this enforcement strategy stabilizes enforcement effort the optimal permit supply and price controls are independent of enforcement costs and the policy produces the second best optimal outcome

an emergy evaluation of complexity information and technology towards maximum power and zero emissions abstract this paper mostly deals with the role of energy matter and information flows within both environmental and human dominated systems sustainable growth and development of both kinds of systems require optimum use of available resources for maximum power output as suggested by lotka s maximum power principle lotka aj contribution to the energetics of evolution in proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america vol 8 1922 p 147 50 lotka aj natural selection as a physical principle in proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america vol 8 1922 p 151 5 recently restated by odum odum ht maximum power and efficiency a rebuttal ecol model 1983 20 71 82 odum ht environmental accounting emergy and environmental decision making n y john wiley sons 1996 as maximum em power principle within the framework of his emergy synthesis approach in times of declining resources this principle translates into increased efficiency and optimum use of any kind of waste and co products ecosystems and any self organizing systems always apply this strategy and their selection evolution mechanisms are based on their ability of growing on any untapped resource available in order to do so they increase the number of components and patterns for resource degradation in order to optimize the resource throughput and power output such a strategy also applies to human dominated economic systems where the ability of dealing with co products and wastes by means of appropriate designs as well as reuse and recycling processes may lead to zero emission patterns increased complexity optimal resource throughput minimization of emissions resource exchange among system s components and be the key for successful and sustainable development in this paper life cycle assessment and emergy synthesis approaches are suggested as joint tools for qualitative and quantitative evaluation of progresses towards industrial symbiosis and more sustainable production and consumption patterns within a zero emission framework

combining discrete and continuous representations of preference heterogeneity a latent class approach unobserved preference heterogeneity has been widely recognized as a critical issue not only for modelling choice behaviour but also for policy analysis this paper examines alternative approaches for incorporating heterogeneity in recreational demand we apply a hybrid model combining discrete and continuous heterogeneity representations of tastes to capture the defining features of both the latent class and the random parameter logit specifications this model allows for the joint estimation of discrete segments and within segment heterogeneity providing a richer interpretation of preference heterogeneity a database of recreational trips to forest sites in mallorca has been used to compare the empirical performance of this hybrid approach with common specifications such as the conditional logit the random parameter logit and the latent class model

self reporting of pollution and the firm s behavior under imperfectly enforceable regulations abstract motivated by the nature of u s laws a model is developed for a firm that maximizes expected profit and faces imperfectly enforceable pollution standards with imperfectly enforceable reporting requirements some previous models of imperfectly enforceable standards and taxes are special cases of this general mode when the fine for violating the pollution standard is linear in excess pollution the form will equate the marginal cost of control to the marginal fine rate and thus actual pollution will be insensitive to enforcement parameters related to under reporting the more complex comparative statics that exist when the fine is non linear are analyzed and comparisons with other models are made

on indirect tax evasion abstract this paper examines some aspects of the decision to evade indirect taxes in the context of a monopolistic firm in particular the degree of interdependence between the tax shifting and the tax evasion decisions is analyzed both in the case of a fixed and of a variable probability of being detected it is shown that in the first case the shifting and evasion decisions are separable while in the second case this is no longer true in this latter case a rule according to which the probability decreases with larger declarations can be said to be an efficient one the conditions for a firm s becoming a completely submerged one are derived and finally direct and indirect tax evasion are compared it is shown that for decreasing risk aversion an indirect tax is evaded as a percentage less than a profit tax of equal yield

self reporting and the design of policies for regulating stochastic pollution abstract existing environmental regulations frequently require firms to self report their compliance status to regulatory agencies using a principal agent framework i derive and compare incentive compatible regulatory policies with and without self reporting i find the firm needs to be audited less often when self reporting is required but punished more often the sign and magnitude of the gains from self reporting depend on the relative size of audit and sanction costs the accuracy of the regulator s monitoring technology and the desired level of abatement effort

prices versus quantities with incomplete enforcement abstract i study whether incomplete enforcement of a regulation has any impact on the choice between price e g taxes and quantity e g tradeable quotas instruments results indicate that a second best design accounting for incomplete enforcement can be implemented equally well with either instrument as long as the benefit and cost curves are known with certainty if these curves are uncertain to the regulator however the quantity instrument performs relatively better than the price instrument the reason is that the effective amount of control under the quantity instrument is no longer fixed which makes this instrument come closer to a non linear instrument

marketable permits market power and cheating abstract in this paper we present a model of a noncompliant firm operating in a marketable pollution permit market in the main result of the paper we show how compliance is related to the initial distribution of permits a firm with market power will cheat less the larger its endowment of permits is from a fixed stock of permits the competitive fringe however will cheat more as its endowment of permits is reduced generating an ambiguous global impact on cheating

enforcement costs and the choice of policy instruments for controlling pollution i introduction when evaluating policy instruments for controlling pollution analysts generally agree that economic incentives are superior to direct controls in terms of minimizing abatement costs however when it comes to minimizing enforcement costs there is no such agreement some analysts such as freeman et al 1973 and anderson et al 1977 argue that economic incentives would be much easier to enforce than direct controls while others such as drayton 1978 argue that they would be virtually unenforceable the debate typically centers on technical difficulties in continuously monitoring emissions and to a lesser extent on political and legal issues related to the assessment of penalties 1 an issue that has not been examined is whether there are economic reasons for enforcement costs to vary across policy instruments although there is now a sizable economic literature on the problem of noncompliance with pollution control policies there have been no attempts to formally compare enforcement costs across policy instruments 2 accordingly the purpose of this note is to examine whether there are economic grounds for arguing that enforcement costs would be lower for economic incentives than direct controls 3 the policy instruments compared are marketable permits or emissions taxes and uniform standards the instruments are compared in a setting where the penalty schedule is previously specified by some judicial or legislative body and the regulator s enforcement policy is limited to the choice of audit frequency the analysis is based on the premise that for any policy instrument that targets emissions the regulator will have to periodically monitor emissions and assess penalties for noncompliance the relevant question then is whether less frequent monitoring would be required to ensure compliance with economic incentives casual analysis suggests this should be the case economic incentives minimize aggregate abatement costs and lower abatement costs imply lower costs to firms of complying this should imply in turn that less stringent enforcement is needed to achieve compliance this argument although intuitively appealing is flawed using a simple model of pollution control with costly enforcement i show that enforcement costs narrowly defined may be higher for economic incentives for purposes of exposition the result is established in a setting where the regulator ensures each firm is fully compliant however as shown in the appendix the result generalizes to the more realistic setting where firms are partially compliant ii the model consider a group of n risk neutral firms emitting a single pollutant for simplicity the damages from the pollutant are assumed to depend only on total emissions each firm s abatement costs are given by a strictly convex function c sub i x sub i that is decreasing in emissions x sub i the firm s maximum emissions level is denoted mathematical expression omitted and is defined by mathematical expression omitted with probability p sub i a regulator audits each firm and measures its emissions if the regulator finds the firm s actual emissions x sub i exceed its allowed emissions s sub i the firm is assessed a fine of f x sub i s sub i as is common in the literature on enforcement i assume the fine schedule is previously specified e g by a legislative body 4 thus the regulator can choose the probability with which it audits firms but not the fine it assesses for noncompliance i assume the fine schedule is such that both the total fine and marginal fine are increasing in the violation size x sub i s sub i f prime is greater than 0 and f prime prime is grater than 0 because the regulator is assumed to ensure full compliance no violations occur and no fines are collected therefore enforcement costs consist solely of auditing or monitoring costs to simplify the analysis the cost of conducting an audit a is assumed to be the same across firms

environmental policy instruments technology adoption incentives with imperfect compliance we study the incentives to adopt advanced abatement technologies in the presence of imperfect compliance interestingly incentives under emission taxes and pollution abatement subsidies are the same that in the perfect compliance scenario however under emission standards imperfect compliance can increase firms incentives to invest whereas under an emission permit mechanism investment incentives decrease only if widespread non compliance induces a reduction in the permit price our results are valid for fairly general characteristics of the monitoring and enforcement strategies commonly found in both theoretical and empirical applications

using angler characteristics and attitudinal data to identify environmental preference classes a latent class model a latent class model of environmental preference groups is developed and estimated with only the answers to a set of attitudinal questions economists do not typically use this type of data in estimation group membership is latent unobserved the intent is to identify and characterize heterogeneity in the preferences for environmental amenities in terms of a small number of preference groups the application is to preferences over the fishing characteristics of green bay anglers answered a number of attitudinal questions including the importance of boat fees species catch rates and fish consumption advisories on site choice the results suggest that green bay anglers separate into a small number of distinct classes with varying preferences and willingness to pay for a pcb free green bay the probability that an angler belongs to each class is estimated as function of observable characteristics of the individual estimation is with the expectation maximization e m algorithm a technique new to environmental economics that can be used to do maximum likelihood estimation with incomplete information as explained a latent class model estimated with attitudinal data can be melded with a latent class choice model

a joint latent class model combining likert scale preference statements with choice data to harvest preference heterogeneity in addition to choice questions revealed and stated choices preference surveys typically include other questions that provide information about preferences preference statement data include questions on the importance of different attributes of a good or the extent of agreement with a particular statement the intent of this paper is to model and jointly estimate preference heterogeneity using stated preference choice data and preference statement data the starting point for this analysis is the belief that the individual has preferences and both his her choices and preference statements are manifestations of those preferences our modeling contribution is linking the choice data and preference statement data in a latent class framework estimation is straightforward using the e m algorithm even though our model has hundreds of preference parameters our estimates demonstrate that 1 within a preference class the importance anglers associate with different green bay site characteristics is in accordance with their responses to the preference statements 2 estimated across class utility parameters for fishing green bay are affected by the preference statement data 3 estimated across class preference statement response probabilities are affected by the inclusion of the choice data and 4 both data sets influence the number of classes and the probability of belonging to a class as a function of the individual s type

identifying demand parameters in the presence of unobservables a combined revealed and stated preference approach we develop a combined revealed and stated preference approach to identify discrete choice demand parameters in the presence of unobserved determinants of choice our approach overcomes difficulties associated with small choice sets multicollinearity and endogeneity that arise with revealed preference approaches to illustrate our framework we revisit two canadian moose hunting datasets our empirical results suggest the potential gains from fusing revealed and stated preference data but they also suggest its limitations when the data generating processes for the data sources differ

emission taxes versus other environmental policies in the environmental policy of most countries various forms of quotas and direct regulation are more important than environmental taxes this paper addresses four arguments which are often given against the use of emission taxes the three arguments related to information asymmetries and non convexities are valid in the sense that they point to complications in the use of environmental taxes the fourth argument is related to the employment effects of different types of environmental policies in economies with unemployment although this argument is frequently used by politicians the analysis provides no justification for it on the contrary in the model used employment is higher with environmental taxes than with nonrevenue raising environmental policies

optimal pollution standards and non compliance in a dynamic framework in this paper we present a stackelberg differential game to study the dynamic interaction between a polluting firm and a regulator who sets pollution limits overtime at each time the firm settles emissions taking into account the fine for non compliance with the pollution limit and balances current costs of investments in a capital stock which allows for future emission reductions we derive two main results first we show that the optimal pollution limit decreases as the capital stock increases while both emissions and the level of non compliance decrease second we find that offering fine discounts in exchange for firm s capital investment is socially desirable we numerically obtain the optimal value of such discount which crucially depends on the severity of the fine in the limiting scenario with a very large severity of the fine the optimal discount implies that no penalties are levied since the firm shows adequate adaptation progress through capital investment

willingness to pay for quality improvements should revealed and stated preference data be combined abstract in this article we propose theoretically consistent welfare measurement of use and nonuse values for an improvement in environmental quality with revealed and stated preference data an analytical model based on the comparative static analysis of the variation function that describes the relationship between recreation demand and dichotomous choice contingent valuation models is estimated our results show that revealed and stated data should not be combined under the same assumed preference structure unless the two decisions imply the same change in behavior induced by the quality change in addition our results indicate scope effects in willingness to pay measures estimated with stated preference data

the cost effective choice of policy instruments to cap aggregate emissions with costly enforcement we study the cost effectiveness of inducing compliance in a program that caps aggregate emissions of a given pollutant from a set of heterogeneous firms based on emissions standards and the relative cost effectiveness of such a program with respect to an optimally designed program based on tradable discharge permits our analysis considers abatement monitoring and sanctioning costs as well as perfect and imperfect information on the part of the regulator with regard to the polluters abatement costs under perfect information we find that a the total cost effective design of a program based on standards is one in which the standards are firm specific and perfectly enforced and b the total cost of an optimally designed program based on standards is lower than the total cost of an optimally designed transferable emission permits system except under special conditions this is true when it is optimum to induce perfect compliance and when it is not under imperfect information nevertheless it is only by implementing a system of tradable permits and perfectly enforcing it with a constant marginal penalty tied to the price of the permits that the regulator can surmount the informational problem and at the same time minimize the total cost of the program with certainty

a difficulty with the travel cost method instead of observable prices of recreational visits travel cost method tcm re searchers are obliged to substitute researcher assigned visitation cost estimates i argue that visitation costs are inherently subjective but are ordinally measurable so long as the cost in creases with distance travelled it follows that traditional tcm yields only ordinally measur able welfare estimates the household produc tion function formulation of tcm resolves this problem only by imposing severe and un testable analytical restrictions tcm cannot serve as a stand alone technique for estimating recreation benefits rather it must be calibrated using information generated with fundamentally different methods jel q26

convergent validity of revealed and stated recreation behavior with quality change a comparison of multiple and single site demands we consider the convergent validity of several demand models using beach recreation data two models employ multiple site data a count data demand system model and the kuhn tucker demand system model we explore the role of existing variation in beach width in explaining trip choices and analyze a hypothetical 100 foot increase in beach width we compare these models to a single equation model where we jointly estimate revealed and stated preference trip data and focus on a hypothetical scenario considering a 100 foot increase in beach width in each case we develop estimates of the change in beach visits and the welfare impacts from the increase in width the trip change estimates from two of the three models are similar and convergent valid though the willingness to pay estimates differ in magnitude

using taxes to deter illegal fishing in itq systems we study the effects of different tax schemes used in fisheries management in combination with an individual transferable quota system we focus on the effects of taxes on equilibrium quota prices and on violations under the assumption that enforcement to induce compliance is imperfect and costly the use of taxes is motivated by the regulator s need to recover costs for enforcement activities we propose the use of a tax on the price of the processed products based on its impact on violations and the information that is required to implement it we also show that this tax has a double pay off for enforcement because it reduces the demand for illegal fishing and increases revenue for enforcement activities without producing a deadweight loss in the quota market we present an application of our model to the case of the red shrimp fishery in chile in our simulation example a tax of 7 on the price of fish exports could sufficiently reduce harvest demand and generate enough funding to completely eliminate quota violations which in the absence of taxes can be more than 100 of the total allowable catch at the same time this tax could increase the equilibrium quota price by 19

comparing environmental policy instruments in the presence of imperfect compliance a case study in this paper we aim to include rule making implementation monitoring and enforcement costs into the cost comparison of policy instruments we use a simple partial equilibrium model and apply it to the textile industry the model includes discrete abatement functions and costly monitoring and enforcement the case study uses individual firm data to simulate the differences in abatement costs and compliance decisions between firms we compare combinations of regulatory instruments emission taxes emission standards and technology standards and enforcement instruments criminal fines civil fines and transaction offers we show that the inclusion of information monitoring and enforcement costs indeed alters the relative cost efficiency of the different instruments

non compliance and the quota price in an itq fishery this paper examines the effects of non compliance on quota demands and the equilibrium quota price in an itq fishery i show that whereas lower quota prices are implied unambiguously by expected penalties which are a function of the absolute violation size the expectation of penalties based upon relative violations of quota demands can under certain conditions produce higher quota prices than in a compliant quota market if there are both compliant and non compliant firms in the fishery the result would then be a shift in quota demand from compliant to non compliant firms rather than the reverse the findings are generally applicable to quota markets in other industries including pollution permit markets

the inclusion of economic and environmental factors in the ecological cumulative exergy consumption analysis of industrial processes abstract resource economic and environmental impacts are three major factors in the evaluation of industrial processes all of them might imply certain contributions of ecosystems services a comprehensive accounting of these factors is critical to sustainability assessment of industrial activities at the ecological scale ecological cumulative exergy consumption ecec analysis is a promising approach to address these issues however the current knowledge on ecec is incomplete especially in economic investment and environmental impact in this paper ecec analysis is extended to quantify purchased resources and pollutant emissions of industrial production accordingly an extended ecec framework is proposed integrating the resource economic and environmental factors furthermore for better understanding of sustainability a concept of ecological life cycle cost elcc is put forward revealing the relationship between the ecec and traditional economic evaluation finally a case study of china s raw coal production is used to illustrate the features of these proposed frameworks the ecec and elcc analyses indicate the great ecological influence of raw coal which has been underestimated by the traditional assessment approaches

to comply or not to comply pollution standard setting under costly monitoring and sanctioning in this paper we characterize optimal regulatory policies composed of a pollution standard a probability of inspection and a fine for non compliance in a context where both monitoring and sanctioning are socially costly and the penalty may include gravity and non gravity components at the regulator s discretion under given penalties the optimal policy entails compliance with the standard as long as a quite intuitive condition is met non compliant policies may include standards even below the pollution levels that minimize the sum of abatement costs and external damages interestingly the appropriate structure of the penalty under non compliance is highly progressive while the best possible shape of the fine under compliance is linear if the regulator is entitled to choose the structure of the fine linear penalties are socially preferred and the optimal policy induces compliance

enforcing transferable permit systems in the presence of market power we derive an enforcement strategy for a transferable permit system in the presence of market power that achieves complete compliance in a cost effective manner we show that the presence of a firm with market influence makes designing an enforcement strategy more difficult than enforcing a perfectly competitive system we also re consider hahn s 1984 suggestion that a firm with market influence should be allocated permits so that it chooses to not participate in the permit market when enforcement and its costs are taken into account hahn s suggestion does not hold except in a very special case the presence of market power will limit the extent to which transferable emissions permit systems can fulfill their theoretical promises hahn 1984 was the first to show that permit trading in the presence of market power cannot be expected to result in a distribution of emissions that minimizes aggregate abatement costs furthermore the distribution of emissions will never be completely independent of the initial allocation of permits modeling a transferable permit system in which one firm has market power while the rest are perfect competitors a dominant firm competitive fringe model hahn demonstrated that aggregate abatement costs are minimized only when the dominant firm is allocated exactly the number of permits it will choose to hold in equilibrium simply aggregate abatement costs are minimized only when a firm that can manipulate the permit price does not because it chooses to not trade permits like most of the theoretical literature on transferable permit systems hahn ignored the fact that compliance in a permit system must be enforced recognizing this important omission van egteren and weber 1996 extended hahn s work to

sustainability analysis of a society based on exergy studies a case study of the island of samso denmark abstract the danish island samso has since 1997 initiated a process through which the island should reach a state where it would be able to supply its own energy such a situation was reached since 2005 after having established 21 windmills and the island is now a net exporter of electricity to the danish power network at the same time the buildings in the more habituated areas were connected to 4 district heating plants which generate heat from combustion of straw in some cases combined with supplementary inputs from photo thermal devices meanwhile certain activities on the island such as running the ferries cars factories and heating in more distant areas are still dependent on significant input of fossil fuels the inhabitants have recently stated a wish to move on towards being independent of fossil fuels in 2030 and carbon neutral during the next decades as a consequence the idea came up to develop a method for the sustainability analysis of a society which would assist in governing the transitional process in the direction of increasing sustainability therefore a framework has been developed based on the concept exergy that may reveal where large consumptions are taking places such areas are likely to be sensible targets for action or at least increased attention basic methods have been developed that allows to account for infrastructure transfers inputs and outputs and consumption in terms of exergy and taking into account whether the exergy storages or flows can be considered to be renewable or not the framework has been developed for six societal sectors the energy sector the public sector the private households the agricultural sector the industry commerce and trade sector and nature nature is here considered an activity that provides the society with an exergy that may also be of value to our societies often referred to as ecosystem services based on the estimated amount of infrastructure and transfers inputs and outputs a number of sustainability indicators have been developed that may be monitored over time and which may serve to indicate whether potential measures undertaken also lead the society in the right direction an attempt to evaluate the potential importance of wastes has also been carried out as in organic waste could play an important role in acquiring the amount of bio diesel required to run the ferries in the future the results demonstrate that the already existing overhead in production of electricity leaves the island with many options and a great opportunity to be independent of fossil fuels in near future in fact it might well be that socio economical perspectives will turn out to be the more severe obstacles in the transition process adjacent to this work a carbon model has also been set up to reveal the consequence of proposed measures and strategies to the carbon budget of the island jorgensen and nielsen 2014