wheat from chaff meta analysis as quantitative literature review abstract this paper presents and develops a quantitative method of literature reviewing and evaluating empirical research meta regression analysis or mra economics is theory driven yet we must learn empirically if economics is to advance mra offers a more objective statistical method to summarize our empirical knowledge and to explain the wide study to study variation in economic research mra is used to assess the evidence for ricardian equivalence and its findings are contrasted to those of conventional narrative review furthermore mra establishes a platform from which to distinguish genuine empirical effect from the exploitable specification error that infests applied econometrics

a positive effect of human capital on growth abstract recent studies have found that economic growth appears to be unrelated to increases in educational attainment in this note i show that there is a correlation in one dataset but it is typically hidden by unrepresentative observations

endogenous lifetime and economic growth abstract endogenous mortality is introduced in a two period overlapping generations model probability of surviving from the first period to the next depends upon health capital that is augmented through public investment high mortality societies do not grow fast since shorter lifespans discourage savings development traps are possible productivity differences across nations result in persistent differences in capital output ratios and relatively larger gaps in income and mortality high mortality also reduces returns on education where risks are undiversifiable when human capital drives economic growth countries differing in health capital do not converge to similar living standards threshold effects may also result

wealth distribution in life cycle economies abstract this paper compares the age wealth distribution produced in life cycle economies to the corresponding distribution in the us economy the idea is to calibrate the model economies to match features of the us earnings distribution and then examine the wealth distribution implications of the model economies the findings are that the calibrated model economies with earnings and lifetime uncertainty can replicate measures of both aggregate wealth and transfer wealth in the us furthermore the model economies produce the us wealth gini and a significant fraction of the wealth inequality within age groups however the model economies produce less than half the fraction of wealth held by the top 1 percent of us households

both institutions and policies matter but differently for different income groups of countries determinants of long run economic growth revisited summary this paper revisits the recent debate on the determinants of long run economic growth with the simple idea that different factors matter at different country groups classified by income levels this paper improves on the methodology by conducting not only cross section estimations but also fixed effects panel and system gmm estimations the results suggest that new policy variables such as technology and tertiary education as well as institutions matter as the determinants of long run economic growth in addition this paper finds that while secondary education and institution turn out to be important for lower income countries an emphasis on technology and higher education appears to be effective in generating growth for the upper middle and high income countries but not for the lower middle and low income countries

the use and abuse of meta analysis in environmental and natural resource economics an assessment motivated by the 2006 report of a work group appointed by the environmental protection agency epa this paper examines the present state of meta analysis in environmental economics and offers recommendations for its future use to this end we summarize and assess 140 meta analyses from 125 published and unpublished studies covering 17 topical categories in environmental and resource economics first we provide several generic meta analysis models as reference points and discuss major estimation issues five econometric issues are identified as part of a complete analysis 1 sample selection criteria 2 basic data summary 3 primary data heterogeneity 4 heteroskedasticity and 5 non independence of multiple observations from primary studies second a tabular summary is presented for the 140 meta analyses with respect to estimation methods third a narrative summary is presented for 19 meta analyses including the three value of statistical life studies examined by the epa work group and one analysis from each of 16 other categories fourth we offer a set of best practice guidelines for future meta analyses in this and other areas of economics last the paper comments on the use of meta analytic methods for benefit transfers of environmental values

prospective analysis of technological innovation systems identifying technological and organizational development options for biogas in switzerland abstract in this article we put forward a concept for the identification and analysis of future development options of technological innovation systems the key element of our approach the so called variation analysis is a methodology to identify coherent socio technical and organizational variants within a specific innovation field consistent combinations of these two dimensions may be interpreted as nuclei for alternative future developments of innovation systems the method may be used in discursive foresight processes to inform strategy formulation of firms or policy makers who see a utility in furthering the innovation field the paper has a focus on developing the theoretical background and the analytical structure of the methodology empirically we illustrate the method for the innovation system of biomass digestion in switzerland

the costs of missing the millennium development goal on gender equity abstract at the millennium summit the world community pledged to promote gender equality and chose as a specific target the achievement of gender equity in primary and secondary education by the year 2005 in every country of the world based on the findings from a growing empirical literature that suggests that gender equity in education promotes economic growth reduced fertility child mortality and undernutrition we estimate what the costs in terms of growth and forgone fertility mortality and undernutrition reduction will be for the 45 countries that are on current projections unlikely to meet the target our estimates suggest that by 2005 the countries that are off track are likely to suffer 0 1 0 3 percentage points lower per capita growth rates as a result will have 0 1 0 4 more children per woman and by 2015 an average of 15 per 1 000 higher rates of under five mortality and 2 5 percentage points higher prevalence of underweight children under five sensitivity analyses suggest that the results are quite robust to using different specifications and approaches to estimating these losses

communities matter institutional preconditions for community renewable energy abstract energy transitions are high on political agendas from a practical viewpoint community approaches are deemed essential in order to transition from a predominantly centralized energy supply to a decentralized one and to exploit the potential of renewable energies in this paper i discuss how the emergence of community based energy projects can be analyzed from an institutional perspective in this context a community is treated as an individual institutional order that shapes decisions i examine how community structures the implementation of biogas cooperatives in the autonomous province of south tyrol in northern italy my findings suggest that community spirit a cooperative tradition and the norms of locality and responsibility are central drivers behind the emergence and constitution of biogas cooperatives not only do these institutional features of community influence the decision concerning which farmers are in or out but also plant location and scale i argue that community is a necessary analytical category for understanding community energy

an empirical model of labor supply in a life cycle setting this paper formulates and estimates a structural intertemporal model of labor supply using theoretical characterizations derived from an economic model of lifetime behavior a two step empirical analysis yields estimates of intertemporal and uncompensated substitution effects which provide the information needed to predict the response of hours of work to life cycle wage growth and shifts in the lifetime wage path

structural transformation and the deterioration of european labor market outcomes this paper examines hours worked in continental europe and the united states from 1956 to 2003 the empirical work establishes two results first hours worked in europe decline by almost 45 percent compared to the united states over this period second this decline is almost entirely accounted for by the fact that europe develops a much smaller market service sector than the united states a simple model of time allocation is used to understand these patterns i find that relative increases in taxes and technological catch up can account for most of the differences between the european and american time allocations over this period

institutional dynamics and technology legitimacy a framework and a case study on biogas technology legitimacy is central for both novel and established technologies to mobilize the resources necessary for growth and survival a loss of legitimacy in turn can have detrimental effects for an industry in this paper we study the rise and fall of technology legitimacy of agricultural biogas in germany over a period of more than 20 years 1990 2012 the field witnessed impressive growth and professionalization for many years and has become one of the key technologies in germany s energy transition in recent years however it has been confronted with major criticism which finally resulted in a substantial cut back of public and political support the aim of our study is twofold in empirical terms we will explain the technology s loss of legitimacy despite its compliance with original policy objectives growth and maturation in theoretical terms we work toward a more general framework to understand technology legitimacy and to explain the institutional dynamics of technological innovation systems

are micro and macro labor supply elasticities consistent a review of evidence on the intensive and extensive margins we evaluate whether state of the art macro models featuring indivisible labor are consistent with modern quasi experimental micro evidence by synthesizing evidence on both the intensive and extensive margins we find that micro estimates are consistent with macro estimates of the steady state hicksian elasticities relevant for cross country comparisons on both the extensive and intensive margins however micro estimates of intertemporal substitution frisch elasticities are an order of magnitude smaller than the values needed to explain business cycle fluctuations in aggregate hours by preferences the key puzzle to be resolved is why micro and macro estimates of the frisch extensive margin elasticity are so different

the effects of market structure on industry growth rivalrous non excludable capital abstract we analyze imperfect competition in dynamic environments where firms use rivalrous but non excludable industry specific capital that is provided exogenously capital depreciation depends on utilization so firms influence the evolution of the capital equipment through more or less intensive supply in the final goods market strategic incentives stem from i a dynamic externality arising due to the non excludability of the capital stock leading firms to compete for its use rivalry and ii a market externality leading to the classic cournot type supply competition comparing alternative market structures we isolate the effect of these externalities on strategies and industry growth

does schooling cause growth a number of economists find that growth and schooling are highly correlated across countries a model is examined in which the ability to build on the human capital of one s elders plays an important role in linking growth to schooling the model is calibrated to quantify the strength of the effect of schooling on growth by using evidence from the labor literature on mincerian returns to education the upshot is that the impact of schooling on growth explains less than one third of the empirical cross country relationship the ability of reverse causality to explain this empirical relationship is also investigated

towards a micro founded theory of aggregate labour supply we build a heterogeneous agents life cycle model that captures a large number of salient features of individual male labour supply over the life cycle by education both along the intensive and extensive margins the model provides an aggregation theory of individual labour supply firmly grounded on individual level micro evidence and is used to study the aggregate labour supply responses to changes in the economic environment we find that the aggregate labour supply elasticity to a transitory wage shock is 1 75 with the extensive margin accounting for 62 of the response furthermore we find that the aggregate labour supply elasticity to a permanent compensated wage change is 0 44

beyond publication bias abstract this review considers several meta regression and graphical methods that can differentiate genuine empirical effect from publication bias publication selection exists when editors reviewers or researchers have a preference for statistically significant results because all areas of empirical research are susceptible to publication selection any average or tally of significant insignificant studies is likely to be biased and potentially misleading meta regression analysis can see through the murk of random sampling error and selected misspecification bias to identify the underlying statistical structures that characterize genuine empirical effect meta significance testing and precision effect testing pet are offered as a means to identify empirical effect beyond publication bias and are applied to four areas of empirical economics research minimum wage effects union productivity effects price elasticities and tests of the natural rate hypothesis

the market failure and the systemic failure rationales in technological innovation systems abstract in this paper we analyse the conceptual relationship between the market failure rationale and the systemic failure rationale as justifications for policy intervention within an innovation systems is analytical framework current policy analyses in the is literature are characterised by two contrasting theoretical positions regarding the way in which both rationales are conceptually interrelated in one strand of the literature the market failure rationale is considered as a valid although insufficient justification for policy intervention that therefore needs to be complemented by the arguments put forward by the systemic failure rationale this perspective implicitly presents the systemic failure framework as a more general approach than the market failure perspective on the other hand a number of is policy contributions explicitly reject the market failure approach and consider it a flawed argument for government intervention in this theoretical view the systemic failure approach is thus proposed as a more appropriate alternative innovation policy rationale despite their relevance as the theoretical bases that currently underpin actual innovation policy design an analysis of the robustness and conceptual coherence of these contrasting perspectives has not been provided so far in this work we set the analytical steps we deem required for this analysis and investigate under which premises the relationship between the market failure and the system failure rationales proposed by these two policy perspectives is valid from a theoretical point of view

analyzing the functional dynamics of technological innovation systems a scheme of analysis various researchers and policy analysts have made empirical studies of innovation systems in order to understand their current structure and trace their dynamics however policy makers often experience difficulties in extracting practical guidelines from studies of this kind in this paper we operationalize our previous work on a functional approach to analyzing innovation system dynamics into a practical scheme of analysis for policy makers the scheme is based on previous literature and our own experience in developing and applying functional thinking it can be used by policy makers not only to identify the key policy issues but also to set policy goals

income inequality in the united states 1913 1998 this paper presents new homogeneous series on top shares of income and wages from 1913 to 1998 in the united states using individual tax returns data top income and wages shares display a u shaped pattern over the century our series suggest that the large shocks that capital owners experienced during the great depression and world war ii have had a permanent effect on top capital incomes we argue that steep progressive income and estate taxation may have prevented large fortunes from fully recovering from these shocks top wage shares were flat before world war ii dropped precipitously during the war and did not start to recover before the late 1960s but are now higher than before world war ii as a result the working rich have replaced the rentiers at the top of the income distribution

the social outcomes of education and feedbacks on growth in africa most of the effects of education included in the complete model presented here are shown to be consistent with those found in the mainstream of the research on each outcome using microeconomic data this however is a first effort to estimate net education effects more comprehensively beyond just growth and health effects on other key measures of development in africa and also a new view of indirect feedbacks on economic growth and of externalities after developing the conceptual framework the regression estimates are presented together with a discussion of the net direct and indirect effects of education on each outcome these are shown to improve infant mortality increase longevity strengthen civic institutions and democratisation increase political stability and increase investment in physical capital which in turn have positive delayed feedback effects on the economic growth process the effects also lower fertility rates and population growth rates but the latter occurs only after long dela

human capital and growth abstract this paper describes a growth model with the property that human capital accumulation can account for all observed growth the model is shown to be consistent with evidence on individual productivities as measured by census earnings data the central hypothesis is that we learn more when we interact with more productive people

labor supply in the past present and future a balanced growth perspective the absence of a trend in hours worked in the postwar united states is an exception across countries and historically hours fall steadily by a little below 0 5 per year are steadily falling hou

education and economic growth a meta regression analysis summary this paper surveys the literature which examines the effect of education on economic growth specifically we apply meta regression analysis to 57 studies with 989 estimates and show that there is substantial publication selection bias toward a positive impact of education on growth once we account for this the genuine growth effect of education is not homogeneous across studies but varies according to several factors specifically it is attributed to differences in education measurement and study characteristics mainly model specification as well as type of data used and the quality of research outlets where studies are published e g academic journals vs working papers

the returns to education in thailand a pseudo panel approach summary this study employs the pseudo panel approach for estimating returns to education in thailand while treating the endogeneity bias common to estimates from data on individuals pseudo panel data are constructed from repeated cross sections of thailand s national labor force surveys of workers born during 1946 67 estimates show a downward bias of the returns to education in least squares regressions with individual data a result confirmed with instrumental variable estimation the overall rate of return is between 14 and 16 females have higher returns than males and workers in urban areas have higher returns than those in rural areas

voting over redistribution in the meltzer richard model under interdependent labor inputs abstract this paper extends the median voter result of meltzer and richard 1981 to the case where a labor economy has any constant returns to scale production function under quasilinear preferences with constant wage elasticity average productivities of the different labor inputs depend on their relative abundance in the economy agents are heterogeneous due to their labor type and given type due to their relative efficiency they vote over income tax rates which in turn dictate the level of redistribution the paper shows that preferences over tax rates are single peaked and hence the median voter theorem applies this framework connects the scarcity of inputs to the most preferred tax rates

are all economic facts greatly exaggerated theory competition and selectivity there is growing concern and mounting evidence of selectivity in empirical economics most empirical economic literatures have a truncated distribution of results the aim of this paper is to explore the link between publication selectivity and theory contests this link is confirmed through the analysis of 87 distinct empirical economics literatures involving more than three and a half thousand separate empirical studies using objective measures of both selectivity and contests our meta meta analysis shows that publication selection is widespread but not universal it distorts scientific inference with potentially adverse effects on policy making but competition and debate between rival theories reduces this selectivity and thereby improves economic inference

a complexity approach to innovation networks the case of the aircraft industry 1909 1997 successful innovation depends on complementary competencies in networks of producers users and governmental bodies the effects of complementarities within innovation networks are modeled using kauffman s nk model from the model the hypothesis is derived that producers users and governments self organize in specialized innovation networks producers of particular technologies increasingly focus on particular user markets in particular countries data on 863 aircraft models 1909 1997 show these strong specialization patterns in the post war period policy implications are indicated emphasizing the recent rise in transnational collaborations which can be understood as a means of escaping historical specialization patterns

output growth the real wage and employment fluctuations this paper is an attempt to contribute to the integration of business cycle analysis with long term growth a real business cycle model with endogenous growth is developed and estimated with u s data in the present framework wage movements do not have to be transitory to generate fluctuations in labor effort the reduced form is a constrained bivariate output hours or real wage hours vector autoregressive process the bivariate setup provides a useful framework for analyzing the persistence of output fluctuations given that the theory implies that hours of work contain information about future output movement copyright 1991 by american economic association

wealth varying intertemporal elasticities of substitution evidence from panel and aggregate data abstract this paper constructs and estimates a model of consumer preferences in which the intertemporal elasticity of substitution ies of consumption expenditure rises with the level of wealth the purpose of this paper is to measure the effect that systematic variation in the ies of poor and rich consumers has on the ies of aggregate consumption expenditure we find economically significant differences in the ies of poor and rich consumers in indian panel data on the consumption of individual households we also find economically significant differences in the ies measured in aggregate time series data for the u s and india

prospects for expanded utilization of biogas in germany the prospects for expanded utilization of biogas systems in german was analysed by identifying the operational and policy factors affecting the complete chain of processes from implementation process for biogas plants through to biogas production and utilization it was found that the renewable energies act eeg and energy tax reliefs provide bases for the support of expanded utilization upgrading of biogas to natural gas quality for utilization in the transportation sector was arguably the most promising technology that could support rapid utilization expansion sustainable deployment of biogas systems in light of the unstable feedstock prices and availability and the need for subsidy free operation in the long term requires enhancement of feedstock flexibility and quality characteristics to maximise gas yield and optimisation of the anaerobic digestion process management assessment of energy balance and potential environmental impacts of the integrated process chain provides a holistic assessment of sustainability the results also support the development and foster of policies and framework for development of biogas as environmentally friendly energy resource among a mix of renewable energy sources hence compete favourably with fossil fuels to enhance the prospects for expanded utilization

human capital and economic growth tests based on the international evaluation of educational achievement abstract using the secondary school science achievement scores obtained by the international association for the evaluation of educational achievement this paper provides more direct tests than others on the effect of human capital on economic growth bearing important implications for theory and olicy

income and wealth heterogeneity in the macroeconomy how do movements in the distribution of income and wealth affect the macroeconomy we analyze this question using a calibrated version of the stochastic growth model with partially uninsurable idiosyncratic risk and movements in aggregate productivity our main finding is that in the stationary stochastic equilibrium the behavior of the macroeconomic aggregates can be almost perfectly described using only the mean of the wealth distribution this result is robust to substantial changes in both parameter values and model specification our benchmark model whose only difference from the representative agent framework is the existence of uninsurable idiosyncratic risk displays far less cross sectional dispersion and skewness in wealth than u s data however an extension that relies on a small amount of heterogeneity in thrift does succeed in replicating the key features of the wealth data furthermore this extension features aggregate time series that depart significantly from permanent income behavior

determinants of horizontal spillovers from fdi evidence from a large meta analysis summary the voluminous empirical research on horizontal productivity spillovers from foreign investors to domestic firms has yielded mixed results in this paper we collect 1 205 estimates of spillovers and examine which factors influence spillover magnitude our results suggest that horizontal spillovers are on average zero but that their sign and magnitude depend systematically on the characteristics of the domestic economy and foreign investors foreign investors who form joint ventures with domestic firms and who come from countries with a modest technology edge create the largest benefits for the domestic economy

consumption and labor supply with partial insurance an analytical framework we develop a model with partial insurance against idiosyncratic wage shocks to quantify risk sharing closed form solutions are obtained for equilibrium allocations and for moments of the joint distribution of consumption hours and wages we prove identification and demonstrate how labor supply data are informative about risk sharing the model estimated with us data over the period 1967 2006 implies that i 39 percent of permanent wage shocks pass through to consumption ii the share of wage risk insured increased until the early 1980s and iii preference heterogeneity is important in accounting for observed dispersion in consumption and hours jel e21 e23 e31 e52

comparing the innovation effects of support schemes for renewable electricity technologies a function of innovation approach abstract the aim of this paper is to provide a comparative assessment of the innovation effects of instruments which support the diffusion of renewable electricity technologies with a functions oriented technological innovation system perspective the paper provides a link between two major streams of the literature the functions of innovation systems and the literature on renewable electricity support schemes we show that when a functional perspective is adopted feed in tariffs are likely to be superior to other policy instruments quotas with tradable green certificates and tendering although they still need to be complemented with other instruments most importantly direct r d support furthermore those innovation effects are affected by the specific design elements of the instruments chosen

the laffer curve revisited abstract laffer curves for the us the eu 14 and individual european countries are compared using a neoclassical growth model featuring constant frisch elasticity cfe preferences new tax rate data is provided the us can maximally increase tax revenues by 30 with labor taxes and 6 with capital taxes we obtain 8 and 1 for the eu 14 there 54 of a labor tax cut and 79 of a capital tax cut are self financing the consumption tax laffer curve does not peak endogenous growth and human capital accumulation affect the results quantitatively household heterogeneity may not be important while transition matters greatly

a new database on human capital stock in developing and industrial countries sources methodology and results abstract the paper describes the techniques and data adopted for the construction of a new series of estimates of the stock of education in 85 countries over 28 years 1960 1987 the series are built from enrollment data using the perpetual inventory method adjusted for mortality estimates are corrected for grade repetition among school goers and country specific drop out rates for primary and secondary students enrollment data series used start as far back as 1930 for most countries and even earlier for others this reduces the need for backward extrapolation of enrollments to provide the initial estimates of the investment inventory

higher education and economic growth in africa abstract this paper uses panel data over the 1960 2000 period a modified neoclassical growth equation and a dynamic panel estimator to investigate the effect of higher education human capital on economic growth in african countries we find that all levels of education human capital including higher education human capital have positive and statistically significant effect on the growth rate of per capita income in african counties our result differs from those of earlier research that find no significant relationship between higher education human capital and income growth we estimate the growth elasticity of higher education human capital to be about 0 09 an estimate that is twice as large as the growth impact of physical capital investment while this is likely to be an overestimate of the growth impact of higher education it is robust to different specifications and points to the need for african countries to effectively use higher education human capital in growth policies

innovation system strengths and weaknesses in progressing sustainable technology the case of swedish biorefinery development based on the combination of economic challenges and uncertain policy conditions in the united states european union and elsewhere the development of advanced biorefineries has progressed slower than anticipated this has delayed the transition to a more sustainable and less carbon intensive economy in this article we adopt the technological innovation system tis approach to analyze advanced biorefinery development in sweden a front runner country in current development the analysis highlights a number of system strengths e g long term research funding significant research infrastructure strong actor networks that have contributed to developing the swedish tis but also important system weaknesses e g weak coordination among ministries lack of industrial absorptive capacity unclear roles inhibiting it the article highlights a combination of four policy measures that build on the system strengths to address the system weaknesses a the implementation of a deployment policy for creating domestic niche markets b improved policy timing and more structured coordination among different governmental agencies c the provision of stronger incentives for mature industries to invest in rd and d improved organization and financing of existing research infrastructure in addition to the empirical contribution the article contributes with novel insights into the tis framework by highlighting the dynamics between system strengths and weaknesses and suggests that system strengths should be better emphasized in future tis studies

the returns to education macroeconomics we offer an extensive summary and a critical discussion of the empirical literature on the impact of human capital on macro economic performance with a particular focus on uk policy we also highlight methodological issues and make recommendations for future research priorities taking the studies as a whole the evidence that human capital increases productivity is compelling though still largely divided on whether the stock of education affects the long run level or growth rate of gdp a one year increase in average education is found to raise the level of output per capita by between three and six percent according to augmented neo classical specifications while leading to an over one percentage point faster growth according to estimates from the new growth theories still over the short run planning horizon four years the empirical estimates of the change in gdp are of similar orders of magnitude in the two approaches the impact of increases at different levels of education appear to depend on the level of a country s development with tertiary education being the most important for growth in oecd countries education is found to yield additional indirect benefits to growth more preliminary evidence seems to indicate that type quality and efficiency of education matter for growth too

evolutionary approaches for sustainable innovation policies from niche to paradigm fostering technological innovation is considered as an important element of policies towards sustainable development in the past 10 years evolutionary policy approaches have been increasingly advocated for several reasons they seem well equipped to underpin sustainable innovation policies they focus on dynamics of change and their drivers they allow for a substantive perspective on technologies beyond mere input output relations taking into account trajectories and different characteristics of innovation and they are able to describe circumstances under which established technologies might persist even when they are to some extent inferior to their new competitors lock in however the policy effectiveness of evolutionary approaches in cases in which radical or systemic changes are involved is not yet proven in this paper we assess the theoretical rationale instrumental aspects and the coping with policy constraints of three evolutionary policy approaches which have also been used in empirical studies strategic niche management transition management and time strategies each approach has its strengths and specific problems and all three have to be further developed and tested out but they hold promise for contributing to non incremental change with economic and environmental benefits by shaping processes of variation selection and retention with the outcomes feeding back into policy they may also be used in other areas in which innovation direction is important for instance health care or food