wind power in the danish liberalised power market policy measures price impact and investor incentives wind power has a strong position at the danish electricity market mainly caused by high feed in tariffs in the 1990s investments in new wind power installations on land however have declined dramatically after the danish electricity market was liberalised in 1999 first the paper describes how policy measures directed towards wind power have been redesigned to match the liberalised market then we estimate the impact of the redesigned tariffs on the electricity prices finally we assess whether the new tariffs make an incentive to invest in wind power the paper concludes that the new tariffs not by itself make evidence for the actual danish recession in new wind power installations after the electricity reform the main causes could include a combination of problems in spatial planning high risk aversion of new wind turbine investors and perhaps more favourable support schemes in other countries

market price behavior of wholesale electricity products texas abstract applying a regression based approach to a newly developed sample of over 60 000 hourly observations for 01 01 2011 12 30 2017 we answer the question what moves the day ahead market dam prices for energy and ancillary services as and the real time market rtm price for energy in the electric reliability council of texas ercot our answer comprises the following findings that capture the interdependence of ercot s energy and as products 1 the dam energy price increases with the day ahead forecasts of natural gas price system load and as requirements but declines with nuclear and wind generation s forecasts 2 the as prices increase with the dam energy price and the as procurement forecasts but decline with the as offer forecasts and 3 the rtm energy price increases with the dam energy price but diverges from the dam energy price due to forecasting errors related to the dam energy price s fundamental drivers these findings imply that texas can reduce the prices for day ahead energy day ahead as and real time energy via wind generation development and demand side management further texas can improve its electricity trading efficiency by improving ercot s forecast accuracy to narrow the rtm energy price s divergence from the dam energy price

high penetration wind generation impacts on spot prices in the australian national electricity market this paper explores wind power integration issues for the south australian sa region of the australian national electricity market nem by assessing the interaction of regional wind generation electricity demand and spot prices over 2 recent years of market operation sa s wind energy penetration has recently surpassed 20 and it has only a limited interconnection with other regions of the nem as such it represents an interesting example of high wind penetration in a gross wholesale pool market electricity industry our findings suggest that while electricity demand continues to have the greatest influence on spot prices in sa wind generation levels have become a significant secondary influence and there is an inverse relationship between wind generation and price no clear relationship between wind generation and demand has been identified although some periods of extremely high demand may coincide with lower wind generation periods of high wind output are associated with generally lower market prices and also appear to contribute to extreme negative price events the results highlight the importance of electricity market and renewable policy design in facilitating economically efficient high wind penetrations

the impact of wind generation on wholesale electricity prices in the hydro rich pacific northwest extant literature documents that wind generation can reduce wholesale electricity market prices by displacing conventional generation but how large is the wholesale price effect of wind generation in an electricity market dominated by hydroelectric generation we explore this question by analyzing the impact of wind generation on wholesale electricity prices in the pacific northwest region of the united states this hydro rich system tends to be energy limited rather than capacity constrained with its marginal generation during the hydro runoff season often a hydro unit instead of a natural gas fired unit we find that increased wind generation reduces wholesale market prices by a small but statistically significant amount while a hydro rich system can integrate wind generation at a lower cost than a thermal dominated region the direct economic benefits to end users from greater investment in wind power may be negligible

impacts of variable renewable energy on wholesale markets and generating assets in the united states a review of expectations and evidence abstract we synthesize available literature data and analysis on the degree to which growth in variable renewable energy vre has impacted or might in the future impact bulk power system assets pricing and costs in the united states most studies of future scenarios indicate that vre reduces wholesale energy prices and capacity factors of thermal generators traditional baseload generators are more exposed to these changing market conditions than low capital cost and more flexible intermediate and peak load generators from analysis of historical data we find that vre is already influencing the bulk power market through changes in temporal and geographic patterns areas with higher levels of vre the most significant observed impacts have concentrated in areas with significant vre and or nuclear generation along with limited transmission with negative pricing also often occurring during periods with lower system wide load so far however vre has had a relatively modest impact on historical average annual wholesale prices across entire market regions at least in comparison to other drivers the reduction of natural gas prices is the primary contributor to the decline in wholesale prices since 2008 similarly vre impacts on thermal plant retirements have been limited and there is little relationship between the location of recent retirements and vre penetration levels although impacts on wholesale prices have been modest so far impacts of vre on the electricity market will be more significant under higher vre penetrations

a framework to evaluate security of supply in the electricity sector security of electricity supply soes has become a major concern for regulators and policymakers over the last decade however most work focusses either more generally on energy security or on a single fuel we develop a comprehensive but flexible framework to assess the soes for a single jurisdiction taking into the account the specificities of electricity this framework has two aims i provide a snapshot of the situation to understand current weaknesses and determine what actions are required ii capture the evolution over time to evaluate progress and identify potential problems before they materialise the framework based on an extensive literature review consists of twelve dimensions that are critical for soes we develop metrics that capture the state and evolution of each dimension this framework is intended to be a management information tool for all stakeholders aimed at organising data and structuring its analysis to enable monitoring the evolution of the soes while also functioning as an early warning system by flagging potential future problems

electricity market price and nuclear power plant shutdown evidence from california abstract japan s fukushima nuclear disaster triggered by the march 11 2011 earthquake has led to calls for shutting down existing nuclear plants to maintain resource adequacy for a grid s reliable operation one option is to expand conventional generation whose marginal unit is typically fueled by natural gas two timely and relevant questions thus arise for a deregulated wholesale electricity market 1 what is the likely price increase due to a nuclear plant shutdown and 2 what can be done to mitigate the price increase to answer these questions we perform a regression analysis of a large sample of hourly real time electricity market price data from the california independent system operator caiso for the 33 month sample period of april 2010 december 2012 our analysis indicates that the 2013 shutdown of the state s san onofre plant raised the caiso real time hourly market prices by 6 mwh to 9 mwh and that the price increases could have been offset by a combination of demand reduction increasing solar generation and increasing wind generation

simulating the impact of wind production on locational marginal prices this paper analyzes the impact of wind production on the locational marginal prices of a fully competitive pool based electricity market wind productions are modeled as negative loads and characterized by historical data records the analysis pertains to the structural relationship between wind production and locational marginal prices and disregards the collateral effect of strategic offering the study presented allows a statistical characterization of locational marginal prices as a function of the statistical data of the wind plants and the structure of the considered electric energy system

large scale wind power integration and wholesale electricity trading benefits estimation via an ex post approach abstract the integration of large scale wind power has brought about a series of challenges to the power industry but at the same time a number of benefits are being realized among those the ability of wind power to cause a decline in the electricity market prices has been recognized in quantifying this effect some models used in recent years are based on simulations of the market supply side and the price clearing process the accuracy of the estimates depend on the quality of the input data the veracity of the adopted scenarios and the rigorousness of the solution technique in this work a series of econometric techniques based on actual ex post wind power and electricity price data are implemented for the estimation of the impact of region wide wind power integration on the local electricity market clearing prices and the trading savings that stem from this effect the model is applied to the case of spain where the estimated savings are compared against actual credit and bonus expenses to ratepayers the implications and extent of these results for current and future renewable energy policy making are discussed

merit order effects of renewable energy and price divergence in california s day ahead and real time electricity markets abstract we answer two policy questions 1 what are the estimated merit order effects of renewable energy in the california independent system operator s caiso s day ahead market dam and real time market rtm and 2 what causes the hourly dam and rtm prices to systematically diverge the first question is timely and relevant because if the merit order effect estimates are small california s renewable energy development is of limited help in cutting electricity consumers bills but also has a lesser adverse impact on the state s investment incentive for natural gas fired generation the second question is related to the efficient market hypothesis under which the hourly rtm and dam prices tend to converge using a sample of about 21 000 hourly observations of caiso market prices and their fundamental drivers during 12 12 2012 04 30 2015 we document statistically significant estimates p value 0 01 for the dam and rtm merit order effects this finding lends support to california s adopted procurement process to provide sufficient investment incentives for natural gas fired generation we document that the rtm dam price divergence partly depends on the casio s day ahead forecast errors for system loads and renewable energy this finding suggests that improving the performance of the caiso s day ahead forecasts can enhance trading efficiency in california s dam and rtm electricity markets

on the sign of the investment uncertainty relationship understanding the effects of uncertainty over any decision variable has fascinated economists for a long time risk aversion and incomplete markets are likely to make the investment uncertainty relationship negative e g roger craine 1989 joseph zeira 1989 what happens in the absence of risk aversion and incomplete markets is however ambiguous richard hartman 1972 and andrew b abel 1983 1984 1985 found that in the presence of symmetric convex costs of adjustment mean preserving increases in price uncertainty raise investment of a competitive firm as long as the profit function is convex in prices on the other hand the recent literature on irreversible investment e g robert s pindyck 1988 giuseppe bertola 1988 has shown that increases in uncertainty lower investment all these results have been derived under either risk neutrality or complete markets intuition suggests that the explanation for such a difference lies with the asymmetric nature of adjustment costs in the irreversible investment case as compared with the symmetry of the adjustment cost mechanisms proposed by abel and hartman although this intuition is confirmed in this paper asymmetric adjustment costs are shown not to be sufficient to explain why the results differ in fact a more hidden but at least as important difference between these two literatures is that the former assumes perfect competition and constant returns to scale whereas the latter assumes either imperfect competition or decreasing returns to scale or both 2 the purpose of this paper is to highlight the role of the decreasing marginal return to capital assumption due to either imperfect competition or decreasing returns to scale or both in determining the effects of adjustment cost asymmetries on the sign of the response of investment to changes in uncertainty under risk neutrality for this the paper develops a simple model with a cost of adjustment mechanism general enough to consider both symmetric convexity and irreversibility as special cases one of the most important findings is the lack of robustness of the negative relationship between investment and uncertainty under asymmetric adjustment costs3 to changes in the degree of competition in fact when firms are nearly competitive the conclusion of hartman and of abel holds no matter how asymmetric adjustment costs are studying adjustment cost mechanisms has a central role in understanding the dynamics of investment and its business cycle implications but conclusive results about the sign of the instantaneous relationship between uncertainty and investment should not be department of economics columbia university new york ny 10027 i am grateful to giuseppe bertola prajit dutta glen hubbard anil kashyap richard lyons and the referees for their useful comments 1the financial literature on investment has considered risk aversion through a premium in the discount rate determined by the capm capital asset pricing model intertemporal capm or consumption capm however often this discount rate is left unchanged when studying the response of investment to uncertainty changes e g pindyck 1988 pp 974 5 thereby omitting the effect of changes in uncertainty on investment due to risk aversion and incomplete markets 2in the typical version of the irreversible investment problem there is no cost of upward adjustments thus imperfect competition and or decreasing returns to scale are required to bound the size of the firm 3in this paper asymmetric adjustment cost refers to the case in which it is more expensive to adjust downward than upward certainly the opposite case is a trivial extension of the case studied in this paper

the merit order effect a detailed analysis of the price effect of renewable electricity generation on spot market prices in germany the german feed in support of electricity generation from renewable energy sources has led to high growth rates of the supported technologies critics state that the costs for consumers are too high an important aspect to be considered in the discussion is the price effect created by renewable electricity generation this paper seeks to analyse the impact of privileged renewable electricity generation on the electricity market in germany the central aspect to be analysed is the impact of renewable electricity generation on spot market prices the results generated by an agent based simulation platform indicate that the financial volume of the price reduction is considerable in the short run this gives rise to a distributional effect which creates savings for the demand side by reducing generator profits in the case of the year 2006 the volume of the merit order effect exceeds the volume of the net support payments for renewable electricity generation which have to be paid by consumers

japan s energy security predicament post fukushima if energy security is defined as the availability of energy at all times in various forms in sufficient quantities and at affordable prices without unacceptable or irreversible impact on the economy and the environment japan is facing an energy security predicament for a country that was already uneasy about energy security the march 11 2011 earthquake and tsunami which caused a nuclear catastrophe in tepco s fukushima daiichi nuclear power plant turned this unease into outright anxiety with the temporary and or permanent closure of many nuclear reactors japan has had to replace lost power tokyo has had no choice but to secure additional fossil fuels a strategy that has negatively affected japan s economy due to rising fuel costs the increase in japan s fossil fuel consumption has also caused a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions and affected tokyo s commitment to kyoto targets this paper analyzes the consequences of the 2011 nuclear disaster for japan s energy security recognizing that japan s future energy policy choices are constrained and path dependent the paper outlines energy policy recommendations for japan s government

an ex post analysis of the effect of renewables and cogeneration on spanish electricity prices abstract growing concerns about climate change and energy dependence are driving specific policies to support renewable or more efficient energy sources such as cogeneration in many regions particularly in the production of electricity these policies have a non negligible cost and therefore a careful assessment of their impacts seems necessary in particular one of the most debated impacts is their effect on electricity prices for which there have been some ex ante studies but few ex post studies this article presents a full ex post empirical analysis by looking at use of technologies and hourly electricity prices for 2005 2009 in spain to study the effects that the introduction of renewable electricity and cogeneration has had on wholesale electricity prices it is particularly interesting to perform this study in spain where an active system of public support to renewables and cogeneration has led to a considerable expansion of these energy sources and electricity pricing is at the center of intense debate the paper reports that a marginal increase of 1 gwh of electricity production using renewables and cogeneration is associated with a reduction of almost 2 per mwh in electricity prices around 4 of the average price for the analyzed period

what drives renewable energy development abstract this viewpoint reviews renewable energy development in 14 markets that differ in market structure restructured vs not restructured use of feed in tariff fit yes vs no transmission planning anticipatory vs reactive and transmission interconnection cost allocated to a renewable generator high vs low we find that market restructuring is not a primary driver of renewable energy development renewable generation has the highest percent of total installed capacity in markets that use a fit employ anticipatory transmission planning and have loads or end users paying for most if not all of the transmission interconnection costs in contrast renewable developers have been less successful in markets that do not use a fit employ reactive transmission planning and have generators paying for most if not all of the transmission interconnection costs while these policies can lead to higher penetration of renewable energy in the short run their high cost to ratepayers can threaten the economic sustainability of renewable energy in the long run

impacts of day ahead versus real time market prices on wholesale electricity demand in texas abstract the somewhat recent nodal market structure in texas impacts wholesale day ahead market dam and real time market rtm prices however comparative insights on consumer responses to both these prices have not received attention this paper attempts to fill this void by developing a system wide demand response model to better understand price elasticities under dam and rtm pricing these insights may also assist grid operators to develop improved short term forecasts of electricity demand using a large dataset from the electric reliability council of texas and a hierarchical bayesian population model we offer new insights on how dam and rtm pricing shapes demand for electricity and the related consequences for maintaining a reliable electricity market

interim bribery in auctions abstract bidders can bribe the auctioneer before they bid with the auctioneer lowering the winner s bid if the winner paid the bribe in equilibrium bidders employ a cutoff strategy and corruption affects neither efficiency nor the bidders expected payoffs

wind power and electricity prices at the pjm market increased deployment of wind power generation is changing the landscape of power supply around the world when integrated with electricity markets wind power is also widely known to influence the prices cleared at the market this paper examines the effect of wind power generation on the day ahead market prices in the pjm electricity market using robust econometric models and statistical inference results show that the quantified expected benefits to wholesale market participants may be substantial despite the relatively low wind power penetration levels still observed within the pjm jurisdiction relative to other markets the quantified unitary benefits outweigh by a great margin the renewable energy credits given to qualifying wind farms across the market when benefits outweigh the costs incurred to generate them welfare is accrued to this end benefit allocation mechanisms are proposed which may contribute to the continued development of wind power on the roadmap to a cleaner power industry of the future

texas s operating reserve demand curve s generation investment incentive abstract faced with reserve margin projections well below the adopted target of 13 75 of the system peak forecast the public utility commission of texas on 01 17 2019 ordered the state s grid operator the electric reliability council of texas to right shift the operating reserve demand curve ordc to increase generators revenue from energy sales in ercot s real time market rtm using a large sample of 15 min data for the backcast period of 01 01 2015 through 12 31 2018 we calculate the ordc shift s impact on rtm prices and investment incentives for natural gas fired generation ngfg had the ordc shift been in effect in the backcast period the resulting rtm price increases in 2018 could suffice to justify ngfg investment though not in the prior years of 2015 2016 and 2017 while the actual ordc shift occurred on 03 01 2019 had a large impact on rtm prices in the ensuing six month period of march august 2019 texas s planned renewable generation is expected to erode ngfg s operating profit thus diminishing the ordc s investment incentive over time hence texas s energy only market design will likely need further refinements to solve the missing money problem of inadequate ngfg investment incentive

indexation and the effect of inflation uncertainty on real gnp this article examines the combined effects of inflation uncertainty and indexation on the growth rate of real gross national product gn p the evidence suggests that greater indexation partially reduces t he adverse effect of inflation uncertainty on real gnp growth over time it also indicates that in contrast to earlier findings regarding th e effect of inflation uncertainty on employment the overall effect of inflation uncertainty on real gnp growth may be permanent a preliminary assessment of whether the discrepancy is the result of in flation uncertainty permanently affecting the growth rate of the capi tal stock is inconclusive copyright 1988 by the university of chicago

evaluating options for the future energy mix of japan after the fukushima nuclear crisis the fukushima nuclear accident in march 2011 has increased social and political reluctance to embrace nuclear power in japan and elsewhere the japanese government has thus been considering four possible future energy mixes including a nuclear free pathway and three others with 10 35 nuclear supply coupled with a larger proportion of renewable energy and fossil fuels to replace nuclear here we use multi criteria decision making analysis mcdma to assess the potential negative economic levelised cost of electricity and energy security environmental greenhouse gas emissions land transformation water consumption heated water discharge air pollution radioactive waste and solid waste and social safety issues impacts of the four proposed pathways to determine which scenario most holistically minimises adverse future outcomes the nuclear free pathway has the highest overall potential for adverse outcomes score 2 49 out of 3 and the 35 nuclear power supply option yielding the lowest negative impact score 0 74 without weightings despite some sensitivity to the choice of criterion weights our analyses demonstrate clearly that from an empirical perspective a nuclear free pathway for japan is the worst option to pursue we recommend that mcdma methodology we used for japan can be applied to other countries to evaluate future electricity generation scenarios

germany s nuclear power plant closures and the integration of electricity markets in europe this paper examines the potential implications of national policies that lead to a sudden increase of wind power in the electricity mix for interconnected european electricity markets more specifically it examines market integration before and after the closures of eight nuclear power plants that occurred within a period of a few months in germany during 2011 the short and long run interrelationships of daily electricity spot prices from november 2009 to october 2012 in apx endex belpex epex de epex fr nordpool omel and swissix and wind power in the german system are analysed two mgarch multivariate generalized autoregressive conditional heteroscedasticity models with dynamic correlations are used to assess spot market behaviour in the short run and a fractional cointegration analysis is conducted to investigate changes in the long run behaviour of electricity spot prices results show positive time varying correlations between spot prices in markets with substantial shared interconnector capacity a negative association between wind power penetration in germany and electricity spot prices in the german and neighbouring markets and for most markets a decreasing speed in mean reversion

on the real effects of inflation and inflation uncertainty in mexico we estimate an augmented multivariate garch m model of inflation and output growth for mexico at business cycle frequencies the main findings are 1 inflation uncertainty has a negative and significant effect on growth 2 once the effect of inflation uncertainty is accounted for lagged inflation does not have a direct negative effect on output growth 3 however as predicted by friedman and ball higher average inflation raises inflation uncertainty and the overall net effect of average inflation on output growth in mexico is negative that is average inflation is harmful to mexican growth due to its impact on inflation uncertainty 4 the mexican presidential election cycle significantly raises inflation uncertainty both during the year of the election and the year following the election which has correspondingly negative effects on output growth

does california s co2 price affect wholesale electricity prices in the western u s a abstract using a sample of daily market data we quantify the effect of california s co 2 cap and trade program on the wholesale electricity prices of four interconnected market hubs in the western u s a north of path 15 np15 and south of path 15 sp15 in california mid columbia mid c in the pacific northwest and palo verde pv in the desert southwest a 1 metric ton increase in california s co 2 price is estimated to have increased the electricity prices by 0 41 mwh p value p value p value 0 0056 for mid c and 0 15 mwh p value 0 0925 for pv these estimates reflect a the np15 and sp15 sellers pricing behavior of fully including the co 2 price in their intra state transactions b the mid c price s 100 pass through of the co 2 price in the pacific northwest s hydro export to california and c the statutory obligation of paying the co 2 emissions cost by california s buyers of the electricity imported from the desert southwest the policy implication is that internalization of co 2 s externality in the western u s a requires a cap and trade program with a regional scope that encompasses all four hubs thereby remedying the california program s limited geographic coverage which introduces distortions in neighboring markets

comparing the costs of intermittent and dispatchable electricity generating technologies economic evaluations of alternative electric generating technologies typically rely on comparisons between their expected life cycle production costs per unit of electricity supplied the standard life cycle cost metric utilized is the levelized cost per mwh supplied this paper demonstrates that this metric is inappropriate for comparing intermittent generating technologies like wind and solar with dispatchable generating technologies like nuclear gas combined cycle and coal levelized cost comparisons are a misleading metric for comparing intermittent and dispatchable generating technologies because they fail to take into account differences in the production profiles of intermittent and dispatchable generating technologies and the associated large variations in the market value of the electricity they supply levelized cost comparisons overvalue intermittent generating technologies compared to dispatchable base load generating technologies they also overvalue wind generating technologies compared to solar generating technologies integrating differences in production profiles the associated variations in the market value of the electricity supplied and life cycle costs associated with different generating technologies is necessary to provide meaningful comparisons between them this market based framework also has implications for the appropriate design of procurement auctions created to implement renewable energy procurement mandates the efficient structure of production tax credits for renewable energy and the evaluation of the additional costs of integrating intermittent generation into electric power networks