addressing leakage in the eu ets border adjustment or output based allocation the eu ets has been criticised for threatening the competitiveness of european industry and generating carbon leakage i e increasing foreign greenhouse gas emissions two main options have been put forward to tackle these concerns border adjustments and output based allocation i e allocation of free allowances in proportion to current production we compare various configurations of these two options as well as a scenario with full auctioning and no border adjustment against this background we develop a model of the main sectors covered by the eu ets electricity steel cement and aluminium we conclude that the most efficient way to tackle leakage is auctioning with border adjustment which generally induces a negative leakage a spillover this holds even if the border adjustment does not include indirect emissions if it is based on eu rather than foreign specific emissions or for some values of the parameters if it covers only imports another relatively efficient policy is to combine auctioning in the electricity sector and output based allocation in exposed industries especially if free allowances are given both for direct and indirect emissions i e those generated by the generation of the electricity consumed although output based allocation is generally less effective than border adjustment to tackle leakage it is more effective to mitigate production losses in the sectors affected by the ets which may ease climate policy adoption c 2011 elsevier b v all rights reserved

sequential formation of coalitions in games with externalities and fixed payoff division this paper analyzes a sequential game of coalition formation when the division of the coalitional surplus is fixed and the payoffs are defined relative to the whole coalition structure gains from cooperation are represented by a valuation which maps coalition structures into payoff vectors i show that any core stable coalition structure can be attained as a stationary perfect equilibrium of the game if stationary perfect equilibria may fail to exist in general games a simple condition is provided under which they exist in symmetric games furthermore symmetric stationary perfect equilibria of symmetric games generate a coalition structure which is generically unique up to a permutation of the players a general method for the characterization of equilibria in symmetric games is proposed and applied to the formation of cartels in oligopolies and coalitions in symmetric majority games journal of economic literatureclassification numbers c78 c71 1996 academic press inc

preferential trading arrangements as strategic positioning abstract we analyze a three country model of trade negotiations in which countries can form bilateral free trade areas bilateral customs unions or a trilateral preferential trading arrangement and can continue negotiating after reaching an agreement in contrast to the literature on multilateral bargaining the set of agreements can form a nonpartitional network while in contrast to the network literature players can reach multilateral agreements patient enough countries only reach bilateral agreements if insiders gain more than outsiders which allows them to manipulate the status quo in subsequent negotiations however a hub and spoke pattern may then emerge and insiders then dissipate the advantages of strategic positioning we also use variants on the model to explain why a us commitment not to bargain bilaterally sustained progress at gatt negotiations and the rarity of open access preferential trading arrangements

global valuation of ecosystem services application to the pantanal da nhecolandia brazil in costanza et al s famous nature paper costanza r d arge r de groot r farber s grasso m hannon b et al the value of the world s ecosystem services and natural capital nature 15 387 253 260 a value for the world s ecosystem services is posited as a point of departure for further discussion these calculations were re estimated and qualitatively assessed in application to the pantanal sub region nhecolandia the original study was re estimated to evaluate the sensitivity of the original study to more detailed and accurate data and to better understand the potential for the people of the pantanal to benefit from environmental stewardship refocusing the analysis to the regional watershed level using locally derived data provided an opportunity to explore appropriate local policy alternatives and recognize regional biophysical heterogeneity which is largely impractical at the global hemispheric or perhaps national scale a value of more than us 15 5 billion or us 5 million per resident was derived an annual per hectare value of approximately 1 2 of costanza et al s calculations more biophysically diverse but largely drier regional conditions indicated by our data explain this discrepancy water supply and disturbance regulation contribute close to 2 3 of the total calculated value waste treatment cultural value and water regulation each contribute substantially 6 9 to the total nutrient cycling recreation and habitat values play more minor roles 1 5 3 in the total valuation the concepts of imperfect substitutes and comparative advantage are applied within the broad category of natural capital in order to evaluate the potential of alternative economic development strategies for the region 2000 elsevier science b v all rights reserved

cooperative management of groundwater resources in the presence of environmental externalities this paper investigates how cooperation among users can achieve a better management of groundwater in the presence of environmental externalities cooperation allows users to internalize the damages caused by their activities and reduce extractions the paper develops a game theoretical framework to assess the value of cooperation in an aquifer that is divided into three sub aquifers that are being overly exploited two types of externalities are modeled first water extractions in each sub aquifer impact water levels in neighboring sub aquifers extraction externality second the three sub aquifers are also connected to an ecosystem and thus decisions in each sub aquifer affect the health of the ecosystem environmental externality a cooperative game theory model is applied the model empirically shows how the uncontrolled extractions in each sub aquifer affects neighboring groundwater users but also cause severe impacts to the linked ecosystem the model is tested empirically in one of the most important aquifers in spain the eastern la mancha aquifer the results illustrate how both extraction and environmental externalities interact in affecting the likelihood of cooperation among the users the paper estimates the value of cooperation and its stability with and without the environmental externality

china s carbon emissions trading overview challenges and future because china has emerged as the largest greenhouse gas ghg emitter in total annual emissions to accelerate the pace of ghg emission reduction in china is important to the success of global efforts in addressing climate change carbon trading is a market mechanism and key instrument in the mitigation of climate change this paper explores the policy process and development state to date of china s carbon trade market to understand the emergence and development of that market and to understand what barriers are hampering china s carbon trade market development to achieve this goal this paper introduces and analyzes china s status in the international market examines the factors driving carbon market launching by the chinese government and traces the development of mandatory carbon emission trading and voluntary emission trading it is argued that china s carbon trading market is confronted with challenges such as the absence of a functional carbon trading market inaccuracy of the quota allocation an imperfect trading mechanism and lagging legislation at the present stage shortcomings such as having no real time carbon price and dominated spot transactions differentiate china s trade market substantially from a functional system a quick market integration of china s carbon market appears remote it is suggested that specific measures be taken to promote the development of the chinese carbon trading market

endogenous free trade agreements and the multilateral trading system i evaluate in this paper the impact of free trade areas ftas on the world trading system i use an oligopolistic political economy model where the external tariffs of fta members as well as the decision to form ftas are endogenously determined in this context i show that ftas are primarily beneficial to the multilateral trading system this conclusion is based first upon the finding that ftas induce their member governments to lower their external tariffs and to do so deeply enough to enhance trade even between fta members and non members while this ensures gains for the latter in general fta members may not gain i show however that governments will endorse only welfare improving arrangements in spite of their political motivations as a result fta members benefit from ratified arrangements as well finally i find that ftas by reducing the role of special interests criteria in governments trade regime decisions also tend to enhance support for further liberalization at the multilateral level

import price elasticities reconsidering the evidence recent economic geography and trade empirical studies based on monopolistic competition suggest high levels of trade price elasticities between 3 and 1 1 however price elasticity estimations in trade equations using unit values as price proxies usually lead to lower values of around unity we show that those inconclusive results may be due to some misspecification in these equations as well as measurement errors in prices when suit able instrumental variables are used within a panel of industrialized countries we obtain high price elasticities the majority ranging from i to 13 the highest estimates correspond to industries producing homogeneous goods jel classification c2 c3 and f 1

origins and development of the eu ets the successful creation of the european union emissions trading scheme eu ets was not inevitable countries such as canada and japan which might be thought to have a less complex and more cohesive cultural and institutional context failed to do so europe succeeded for a number of reasons with a single market for the economy the logic of a single market for environment is inexorable the european commission which had failed in its earlier efforts to introduce a carbon energy tax made the case for trading with great skill and persistence on the basis of qualified majority voting which meant no country had a veto the uk and denmark initiated their own national schemes and there was a serious risk of balkanising the market with up to 27 different schemes with the losses of scale and scope this would entail meeting the union s kyoto commitments required a substantive pan european response and eu ets was the most credible and effective way of doing so the european parliament and environmental non governmental organisations played a constructive role pushing for more auctioning of allowances and less of them allocated centrally free allocation managed by member states ms was a necessary condition to achieve the support needed so they failed to achieve these objectives in the initial phase but they characterize the commission s proposals post 2012

energy conservation more effective with rebound policy this article sketches the problem of indirect energy use effects also known as rebound of energy conservation there is widespread support for energy conservation especially when it is voluntary as this seems a cheap way to realize environmental and energy climate goals however this overlooks the phenomenon of rebound the topic of energy rebound has mainly attracted attention from energy analysts but has been surprisingly neglected in environmental economics even though economists generally are concerned with indirect or economy wide impacts of technical change and policies this paper presents definitions and interpretations of energy and environmental rebound as well as four fundamental reasons for the existence of the rebound phenomenon it further offers the most complete list of rebound pathways or mechanisms available in the literature in addition it discusses empirical estimates of rebound and addresses the implications of uncertainties and difficulties in assessing rebound suggestions are offered for strategies and public policies to contain rebound it is advised that rebound evaluation is an essential part of environmental policy and project assessments as opposed to earlier studies this paper stresses the relevance of the distinction between energy conservation resulting from autonomous demand changes and from efficiency improvements in technology equipment in addition it argues that rebound is especially relevant for developing countries

alternative designs for tariffs on embodied carbon a global cost effectiveness analysis in the absence of effective world wide cooperation to curb global warming import tariffs on embodied carbon have been proposed as a potential supplement to unilateral emissions pricing we consider alternative designs for such tariffs and analyze their effects on global welfare within a multi region multi sector computable general equilibrium cge model of global trade and energy our analysis suggests that the most cost efficient policy could be region specific tariffs on all products based on direct plus electricity emissions in the end however the potential cost savings through carbon tariffs must be weighed against the administrative costs as well as legal issues and political considerations

the value of trade agreements in the presence of political pressures an argument often heard in favor of trade agreements is that by committing to free trade a government can credibly distance itself from domestic lobbies but several existing models of endogenous protection suggest that governments have no interest in foreclosing interest group pressures since governments derive rents from the political process we develop a small country model in which factors are sector specific in the short run but mobile in the long run we show that in this setting a government may be worse off in the political equilibrium than under commitment to free trade and hence it may value a trade agreement

is the wto passe the wto has delivered policy outcomes that are very different from those likely to emerge out of the recent wave of preferential trade agreements ptas should economists see this as an efficient institutional hand off where the wto has carried trade liberalization as far as it can manage and is now passing the baton to ptas to finish the job this paper surveys a growing economics literature on international trade agreements and argues on this basis that the wto is not passe rather and subject to some caveats this survey of research to date suggests that the wto warrants strong support while a more cautious view of ptas seems appropriate

a modified ghg intensity indicator toward a sustainable global economy based on a carbon border tax and emissions trading abstract it will be difficult to gain the agreement of all the actors on any proposal for climate change management if universality and fairness are not considered in this work a universal measure of emissions to be applied at the international level is proposed based on a modification of the greenhouse gas intensity ghg int measure it is hoped that the generality and low administrative cost of this measure which we call the modified greenhouse gas intensity measure mghg int will eliminate any need to classify nations the core of the mghg int is what we call the ihdi adjusted gross domestic product idhigdp based on the inequality adjusted human development index ihdi the idhigdp makes it possible to propose universal measures such as mghg int we also propose a carbon border tax applicable at national borders based on mghg int and idhigdp this carbon tax is supported by a proposed global emissions trading system ets the proposed carbon tax is analyzed in a short term scenario where it is shown that it can result in a significant reduction in global emissions while keeping the economy growing at a positive rate in addition to annual ghg emissions cumulative ghg emissions over two decades are considered with almost the same results

efficient climate policy with internationally mobile firms a major concern in the design of an incomplete climate agreement is thatfirms that use fossil fuels intensively may respond to emission regulationsby relocating their plants from cooperating to non cooperating countries this paper analyses how the cooperating countries might deal with the issueof firm delocation through emission taxes trade provisions and alocalisation subsidy to mobile firms it is shown that firms should not beinduced to stay in the cooperating countries by lowering emission taxesbelow the pigouvian tax rate incentives to stay should be given partlythrough trade provisions and partly through a localisation subsidy a secondbest solution without localisation subsidies is also discussed in thatcase the efficient emission tax is lower than the pigouvian tax rate finally the paper discusses the implications of the first best and thesecond best policy regimes for the pattern of firm localisation

border adjustments supplementing nationally determined carbon pricing as agreed on in the paris agreement each country determines its own contribution to combat climate change on a voluntary basis there is no mechanism to force a country to comply with its own nationally determined contributions this bottom up approach builds on unilateral actions and yields a kind of carbon pricing which is not necessarily identical across countries as a consequence these nationally determined climate policies have drawbacks in terms of carbon leakage and loss of competitiveness for firms producing in high carbon price countries to reduce these negative effects border adjustments bas may be appropriate subsequent to more stringent environmental regulation we model a three stage game involving carbon price competition in the first stage the introduction of bas in the second stage and oligopolistic competition between firms in the third stage strategic trade theory suggests that the qualitative results about the optimal ba policy may vary with the underlying type of competition namely bertrand and cournot competition however our results are similar for both types of competition we conclude that bas are suitable for supporting a more stringent environmental policy moreover we find that anticipation of the implementation of bas in the second stage yields higher average carbon prices in the first stage since high carbon price countries increase their carbon prices whereas the other countries partially offset

international and sectoral variation in industrial energy prices 1995 2015 energy price rises for industry are a major political concern access to cheap energy is often considered a key factor for the competitiveness of industry to enable international comparisons and to foster further empirical research on the impacts of energy price or tax differentials on a wide range of outcomes such as international trade and investment patterns we construct sector level energy prices for 12 industrial sectors in 48 countries for the period 1995 to 2015 our prices are constructed as weighted averages of fuel specific prices by fuel consumption we provide guidelines for the use of our energy price data which is made available for download as well as a set of stylized facts on major trends and variations and illustrative applications

role of embodied energy in the european manufacturing industry application to short term impacts of a carbon tax abstract role of energy in the manufacturing industry is a major concern for energy and environmental policy design issues like energy prices security of supply and carbon mitigation are often connected to the industry and its competitiveness this paper examines the role and consequences of embodied energy in the european industry to this end a multi regional input output analysis including 59 industrial sectors for all european union countries and 17 more aggregated industries for other regions of the world is developed other segments of the economy are not included this base is combined with energy consumption carbon emission as well as bilateral trade data for every sector in all included countries our main result is that embodied energy in manufactured products imports represents a significant aspect of the energy situation in european industries with quantities close to the direct energy consumption these flows can further be broken down for detailed analysis at the sector level thanks to the number of distinct industries included results demonstrate that an important part of embodied energy inside european products is not concerned with domestic energy price changes in addition a european wide carbon tax would induce an unbalanced burden on industries and countries

european emission trading scheme and competitiveness a case study on the iron and steel industry abstract we quantify the impact of the european emission trading scheme ets on the two dimensions of competitiveness production and profitability for the iron and steel industry among those covered by the scheme this sector is one of the most exposed since it is both highly co 2 intensive and relatively open to international trade we also examine the robustness of these results to various assumptions marginal abatement cost curve trade and demand elasticities as well as pass through rates and updating of allocation rules of which the latter two are scarcely debated we conclude that for this sector competitiveness losses are small we prove this conclusion to be robust hence arguments against tightening the environmental stringency of the ets in phase ii are not justified on grounds of competitiveness loss our systematic sensitivity analysis allows us to identify the important assumptions for each output variable it turns out that pass through rates and updating rules are significant despite being often implicit and least debated in existing analyses

exploring the effect of cap and trade mechanism on firm s production planning and emission reduction strategy abstract cap and trade mechanism has a significant effect on firm s production and operation decisions and carbon emissions this study develops a mathematical model to examine the effect of cap and trade mechanism on firm s production planning and emission reduction strategy based on the model the firm s critical production planning decisions such as the optimal production quantity optimal allowance selling price and the maximum profit under the cap and trade mechanism are derived firstly then based on the cost benefit analysis the conditions under which the firm makes the optimal emission reduction strategy between buying carbon allowance from the carbon trading market and conducting low carbon processing are identified the result suggests that when the low carbon processing cost is greater than the potential opportunity benefit the firm is inclined to purchase carbon allowance from the carbon trading market and vice versa finally a numerical analysis is conducted to investigate the effects of relevant factors such as carbon quotas carbon emission rate low carbon processing cost and transaction cost on firm s production and operation decisions the results indicate that under the cap and trade mechanism the transaction cost has a positive effect on allowance selling price the firm s optimal production quantity and maximum profit is positively related to carbon quotas while negatively related to carbon emission rate and low carbon processing cost this research contributes to enrich related literature and knowledge with regard to carbon emissions reduction at the firm level and highlight the critical importance of cap and trade mechanism in reducing carbon emissions

can tariffs be used to enforce paris climate commitments we evaluate the potential of border carbon adjustments bcas and strategic tariffs to compel noncompliant countries to meet emission reduction targets pledged under the paris climate agreement our analysis employs a numerical economy wide model with energy sector detail and given recent actions by the us administration considers bcas on us exports we find that when the us does not restrict emissions and faces bcas on its exports us welfare losses are smaller than when the us meets its paris commitments hence bcas are preferable for the us and cannot be used to enforce paris climate commitments the use of strategic tariffs on the contrary would result in a trade war and a larger welfare decrease in us welfare than when it meets its paris commitments strategic tariffs also decrease welfare in countries that meet their paris pledges accordingly strategic tariffs which are much higher than bca rates can be used to enforce paris climate commitments if compliant countries are willing to incur welfare losses to punish non compliant countries

unilateral climate policy and competitiveness economic implications of differential emission pricing unilateral emission reduction commitments raise concerns on international competitiveness and emission leakage that result in preferential regulatory treatment of domestic energy intensive and trade exposed industries our analysis illustrates the potential pitfalls of climate policy design which narrowly focuses on competitiveness concerns about energy intensive and trade exposed eite branches the sector specific gains of preferential regulation in favour of these branches must be traded off against the additional burden imposed on other industries beyond burden shifting between industries differential emission pricing bears the risk for substantial excess cost in emission reduction as policy concedes too low carbon prices to eite industries and thereby foregoes relatively cheap abatement options in these sectors from the perspective of global cost effectiveness we find that differential emission pricing of eite industries hardly reduces emission leakage since the latter is driven through robust international energy market responses to emission constraints as a consequence the scope for efficiency compared to uniform pricing is very limited only towards stringent emission reduction targets will a moderate price differentiation achieve sufficient gains from leakage reduction to offset the losses of diverging marginal abatement cost

border carbon adjustments addressing emissions embodied in trade approximately one fourth of global emissions are embodied in international trade and a significant portion flows from non carbon priced to carbon priced economies border carbon adjustments bcas figure prominently as instruments to address concerns arising from unilateral climate policy estimating the volume of emissions that could be potentially taxed under a bca scheme has received little attention until now this paper examines how a number of issues involved in the implementation of bcas can affect their ability to cover emissions embodied in trade and thus address carbon leakage these issues range from ensuring compliance with trade provisions and assumptions on the carbon intensity of imports to determining which countries are included and whether intermediate and final demand are considered here we show that the volume of co2 captured by a scheme that involved all annex b countries could be significantly reduced due to these issues particularly by trade provisions such as the principle of best available technology bat as a consequence the tariff burdens faced by non annex b parties could dwindle considerably these findings have important policy implications as they question the effectiveness and practicalities of bcas to reduce carbon leakage and alleviate competitiveness concerns adding further arguments against their implementation

disaggregated economic impact analysis incorporating ecological and social trade offs and techno institutional context a case from the western ghats of india economic valuation of ecosystem benefits and their aggregation in a benefit cost analysis bca framework is the norm in mainstream environmental economics but valuation and bca have also attracted criticisms internal criticisms point to the absence of alternative scenarios in valuation overlooking of ecological trade offs and dis services and inattention to context others criticize aggregation across diverse stakeholders and the problem of non monetizable benefits and dismiss bca as fatally flawed they suggest approaches such as deliberative decision making and multi criteria analysis we propose a middle path that uses the strengths of economic analysis for decision support while avoiding the pitfalls we disaggregate economic impacts by stakeholder groups link ecosystem changes to benefits as well as dis benefits and examine how socio technological context shapes the magnitude of economic impact we illustrate this approach by studying the impact of creating the biligiri rangaswamy temple wildlife sanctuary in the western ghats forests of southern india our analysis shows that while some stakeholders are net beneficiaries others are net losers changes in forest rights irrigation technologies and ecosystem dynamics influence the magnitude of benefits and sometimes convert gainers into losers such disaggregated analysis can provide useful information for deliberative decision making and important academic insights on how economic value is generated

a numerical investigation of the potential for negative emissions leakage leakage of greenhouse gas emissions increased emissions in unconstrained regions due to regulations in other regions undermines the effectiveness of sub global climate regulations reduces incentives for unilateral climate initiatives and can result in distortionary trade measures winchester 2012 these concerns are expressed in measures to reduce leakage included in the eu emissions trading scheme and draft legislation in the united states the now defunct waxman markey bill two sources of leakage include changes in fossil fuel prices and trade flows carbone helm and rutherford 2009 leakage via fossilfuel price effects occurs when reduced energy demand in constrained regions decreases fuel prices and increases fuel use in unconstrained regions trade changes contribute to leakage when production increases in unconstrained regions as a result of increased exports to and reduced imports from constrained regions

asymmetric industrial energy prices and international trade this paper measures the response of bilateral trade flows to differences in industrial energy prices across countries using a panel for the period 1996 2011 including 42 countries 62 sectors and covering 60 of global merchandise trade we estimate the short run effects of sector level energy price asymmetry on trade we find that changes in relative energy prices have a statistically significant but very small impact on imports on average a 10 increase in the energy price difference between two country sectors increases imports by 0 2 the impact is larger for energy intensive sectors even in these sectors however the magnitude of the effect is such that changes in energy price differences across time explain less than 0 01 of the variation in trade flows simulations based on our model predict that a 40 65 tco2 price of carbon in the eu ets would increase europe s imports from the rest of the world by less than 0 05 and decrease exports by 0 2

cost effective unilateral climate policy design size matters given the bleak prospects for a global agreement on mitigating climate change pressure for unilateral abatement is increasing a major challenge is emissions leakage border carbon adjustments and output based allocation of emissions allowances can increase effectiveness of unilateral action but introduce distortions of their own we assess antileakage measures as a function of abatement coalition size we first develop a partial equilibrium analytical framework to see how these instruments affect emissions within and outside the coalition we then employ a computable general equilibrium model of international trade and energy use to assess the strategies as the coalition grows we find that full border adjustments rank first in global cost effectiveness followed by import tariffs and output based rebates the differences across measures and their overall appeal decline as the abatement coalition grows in terms of cost the coalition countries prefer border carbon adjustments countries outside the coalition prefer output based rebates

production costs of the chemical industry in the eu and other countries ammonia methanol and light olefins abstract our study compares chemical production costs in the european union eu and other countries in order to understand whether these costs are higher in the case of europe than in other countries our analysis focuses on ammonia methanol and light olefins ethylene and propylene as all of them are considered chemical compounds produced in large scale the countries selected for comparison are usa russia ukraine and saudi arabia since they have high shares of extra eu28 trade and or the global installed capacity of the selected products a bottom up approach based on information at facility level has been followed including 116 29 122 and 224 facilities producing ammonia methanol ethylene and propylene respectively taking into consideration the complex differences in technologies and co products between operators costs are broken down to six components 1 feedstock 2 credits due to co products 3 electricity 4 thermal energy 5 other materials chemicals catalysts etc and 6 labour and other costs salaries overheads etc our findings suggest that it is not easy to reach a common conclusion about the whole chemical industry overall costs compare more favourably among countries than initially thought in the case of processes producing co products but maybe less favourably when processes are without co products the european industry has lower production costs than the industries in the other countries in the case of ethylene and propylene but higher in the case of ammonia and methanol feedstock costs play the most important role in the total production costs of all four products but the presence of credits due to by products could change the behaviour of the total costs

carbon allowance auction design of china s emissions trading scheme a multi agent based approach in this paper a multi agent based ets simulation model is proposed for carbon allowance auction design in china in the proposed model two main agents i e the government the ets implementer and the firms in different sectors the ets targets are considered under the ets policy all agents make various decisions individually according to their own goals and interact with each other through three main markets the commodity market the primary carbon auction market and the secondary carbon trading market different popular auction designs are introduced into the ets formulation to offer helpful insights into china s ets design 1 generally the ets would lead to positive effects on china s carbon mitigation and energy structure improvement but a negative impact on economy 2 as for auction forms the uniform price design is relatively moderate while the discriminative price design is quite aggressive in both economic damage and emissions reduction 3 as for carbon price the uniform price auction might generate a slightly higher market clearing price than the discriminative price auction and the prices under two auction rules fluctuate about rmb 40 per metric ton 4 as for carbon cap the total allowances in the carbon auction market should be carefully set to well balance economic growth and mitigation effect

is there a case for carbon based border tax adjustment an applied general equilibrium analysis concern that unilateral greenhouse gas ghg emission reductions could foster carbon leakage and undermine the international competitiveness of domestic industry has led to growing calls for carbon based border tax adjustments btas this article uses a global general equilibrium model to assess the economic effects of btas and comes to three main conclusions first btas can reduce carbon leakage if the coalition of countries taking action to reduce ghg emissions is small because in this case leakage while typically small mainly occurs through international trade competitiveness losses rather than through declines in world fossil fuel prices second even though the economic effects of btas vary somewhat depending on how they are implemented their welfare impact is typically small and slightly negative at the world level third and perhaps more strikingly btas do not necessarily curb the output losses incurred by the domestic energy intensive industries eiis they are intended to protect in the

border tax adjustments in the climate policy context co2 versus broad based ghg emission targeting abstract using a multi region multi sector computable general equilibrium cge model this paper compares the efficiency distributional and emission leakage effects of border tax adjustments btas as part of unilateral climate policies that are based on carbon dioxide co2 only versus those based on all greenhouse gases ghgs simulation results suggest that the broad based ghg policies in general have lower efficiency costs and result in less re distributive effects btas bring modest efficiency gains with adverse distributional consequences the distributional impacts are smaller under broad based ghg policies compared to that based on co2 only however these are due to a wider variety of abatement options under multi gas policies rather than the btas per se the main difference between the two policies is distributional effects first co2 only based policies have worse impacts on fossil fuel exporters such as russia and relatively better outcomes for oil importers such as india and china compared to that of multi gas policies particularly when it involves large global emission reduction second sectoral coverage under btas also influences the differential outcomes for example brazil is worse impacted under ghg based policies if agriculture is brought under btas as two third of its emissions are non co2 based and agriculture is the primary source of these emissions

parcelling virtual carbon in the pollution haven hypothesis the methodology proposed in this paper allows us to parcel the pollution haven hypothesis phh into a bi regional input output framework to analyse whether the specialisation of countries in different stages of production and or in final goods trading generates an increase or a decrease in global emissions as a consequence of international trade we apply the model to the spain china trade relationship as it existed in 2005 finding a phh of 29 667 ktco2 if this trade had not existed so each country had met its demand for intermediate and final goods global emissions would have been reduced by these 29 667 ktco2 of this phh 43 5 corresponds to imports of final goods 32 4 is related to imports of intermediate goods for the last stage of production the remainder 24 1 is caused by global value chains gvc between the countries only 3229 ktco2 of phh emissions are linked to domestic emissions from the sector in which the imports are produced the rest is explained by domestic linkages or successive rounds of domestic production which supports the existence of an indirect phh together with a trade growth in the last years the fall of trade barriers would have implied a transformation of global production chains that have boosted global emissions

the steel industry a mathematical model under environmental regulations abstract in this work a spatial equilibrium problem is formulated for analyzing the impact of the application of the eu ets on the steel industry that has historically seen europe as one of its major producers the developed model allows us to simultaneously represent the interactions of several market players to endogenously determine output and steel prices and to analyze the investment in the carbon capture and storage ccs technology in addition the proposed model supports the evaluation of the co2 emission costs on the basis of directive 2009 29 ec the 20 20 20 targets and the energy roadmap 2050 in this light two main processes for steelmaking have to be considered integrated mills bof and electric arc furnace eaf in minimills

what about coal interactions between climate policies and the global steam coal market until 2030 because of economic growth and a strong increase in global energy demand the demand for fossil fuels and therefore also greenhouse gas emissions are increasing although climate policy should lead to the opposite effect the coal market is of special relevance as coal is available in many countries and often the first choice to meet energy demand in this paper we assess possible interactions between climate policies and the global steam coal market possible market adjustments between demand regions through market effects are investigated with a numerical model of the global steam coal market the coalmod world model this equilibrium model computes future trade flows infrastructure investments and prices until 2030 we investigate three specific designs of climate policy a unilateral european climate policy an indonesian export limiting policy and a fast roll out of carbon capture and storage ccs in the broader context of climate policy and market constraints we find that market adjustment effects in the coal market can have significant positive and negative impacts on the effectiveness of climate policies

third country effects of regional trade agreements does regionalism negatively impact non members to answer this question we examine the effect of regional trade agreements rtas on imports from non members and the tariffs that they face using data from six rtas in latin america and europe we do not find evidence that implementation of the regional agreements is associated with trade diversion from third countries to regional members using detailed industry data on preference margins and most favoured nation mfn tariffs for three trade agreements in latin america over 12 years we find that greater preference margins do not significantly reduce imports from third countries we also look at the effect of preferences on external tariffs we find evidence that preferential tariff reduction tends to precede the reduction of external mfn tariffs in a given sector offering evidence of tariff complementarity overall the results suggest that regionalism does not significantly harm non members

abatement and allocation in the pilot phase of the eu ets we use historical industrial emissions data to assess the level of abatement and over allocation that took place across european countries during the pilot phase 2005 2007 of the european union emission trading scheme using a dynamic panel data model we estimate the counter factual business as usual emissions scenario for eu member states comparing this baseline to allocated and verified emissions we find that both over allocation and abatement occurred along with under allocation and emissions inflation over the three trading years of the pilot phase we find over allocation of approximately 280 million euas and total abatement of 247 mt co2 however we calculate that emissions inflation of approximately 73 mt co2 also occurred possibly due to uncertainty about future policy design features

do south south preferential trade agreements undermine the prospects for multilateral free trade due to trade diversion there has been concerns expressed over the proliferation of preferential trade agreements ptas between south countries in this paper we compare welfare across the various forms of bilateral free trade agreements ftas and customs unions cus and examine their implications for the stability of multilateral free trade while north north ptas tend to yield higher welfare we fi nd certain cases where south south agreements are more likely to lead to global free trade than north north or north south agreements but other cases where multilateral cooperation over free trade is the least likely under south south agreements we also examine how the expansion of existing agreements or the combination of separate agreements affects the potential for free trade

managers investors and crises mutual fund strategies in emerging markets the authors address the trading strategies of mutual funds in emerging markets the data set they develop permits analyses of these strategies at the level of individual portfolios a methodologically novel feature of their analysis they disentangle the behavior of fund managers from that of investors for both managers and investors they strongly reject the null hypothesis of no momentum trading funds momentum trading is positive they systematically buy winners and sell losers contemporaneous momentum trading buying current winners and selling current losers is stronger during crises and stronger for fund investors than for fund managers lagged momentum trading buying past winners and selling past losers is stronger during noncrises and stronger for fund managers investors also engage in contagion trading selling assets from one country when asset prices fall in another these findings are based on data about mutual funds that represent only 10 percent of the market capitalization in the countries considered were it a larger share of the market finding counterparties for their trades the investors who buy when they sell and sell when they buy would be difficult and the premise that funds respond to contemporaneous returns rather than causing them would become tenuous

a literature based multi criteria evaluation of the eu ets abstract this article reviews the existing literature on the european union emission trading scheme eu ets focusing on empirical ex post research since the end of the first period 2007 the literature is presented through a multi criteria evaluation concerning environmental effectiveness despite over allocation during the first period abatement is estimated between 2 5 and 5 trade driven carbon leakage was not observed even if long term economic models predict divergent leakage estimates for certain at risk sectors the abatement target was likely to be below an economically efficient level but was reached in a fairly cost effective way even if free allocation gave rise to several distortional effects equity concerns were manifold and constitute a major drawback to the policy finally institutional feasibility can be considered positive in that the eu ets passed the european legislative process unlike the previously proposed eu wide carbon tax

brown backstops versus the green paradox abstract anticipated climate policies are ineffective when fossil fuel owners respond by shifting supply intertemporally the green paradox this mechanism relies crucially on the exhaustibility of fossil fuels we analyze the effect of anticipated climate policies on emissions in a simple model with two fossil fuels one scarce and dirty e g oil the other abundant and dirtier e g coal we derive conditions for a green orthodox anticipated climate policies may reduce current emissions the model can also be used to analyze spatial carbon leakage calibrations suggest that intertemporal carbon leakage from 0 to 8 is a relatively minor concern

should the wto require free trade agreements to eliminate internal tariffs abstract in a three country model of endogenous free trade agreements ftas we study the effects of requiring fta members to eliminate tariffs on one another as is essentially stipulated under current wto rules we explain why in the absence of such a requirement ftas members impose positive tariffs on each other even when maximizing their joint welfare we show that requiring fta members to eliminate internal tariffs induces them to lower their external tariffs such external trade liberalization by fta members undermines the prospects of global free trade since it reduces the non member s incentive to enter into trade agreements with them

unilateral co2 reductions and carbon leakage the consequences of international trade in oil and basic materials a recursively dynamic general equilibrium model featuring six world regions with trade in energy and non energy goods is used to simulate the period from 1990 through 2100 in 10 year intervals the simulations explore the effect of unilateral action by the oecd to curb global co2 emissions unilateral cuts create incentives for free riding by non participating regions so that global emissions are reduced by less than the amount that the oecd cuts back its regional emissions carbon leakage occurs through two channels first basic materials production increases in unconstrained regions resulting in increased carbon intensity of gdp second reductions in oecd oil imports cause the world oil price to fall leading to an increased energy intensity in the non participant regions in this paper we use a general equilibrium model to assess the extent to which these two mechanisms reduce the effectiveness of oecd reductions in curbing global co2 concentrations

can an emission trading scheme promote the withdrawal of outdated capacity in energy intensive sectors a case study on china s iron and steel industry abstract outdated capacity and substantial potential for energy conservation are the two main features of energy intensive sectors in developing countries such countries also seek to implement market based options to further control domestic carbon emissions as well as to promote the withdrawal of outdated capacity and upgrade production level this paper presents a quantitative assessment of the emission trading scheme ets for china s iron and steel industry the diverse array of normal and outdated capacities was modeled in a two country three good partial equilibrium model simulation results show that the abatement potential can be underestimated if the energy saving effects that result from emission abatement are not considered in the scenario analysis we demonstrated that the free allocation of allowances can cause a competitiveness distortion among domestic normal and outdated capacities given the government s intention to promote outdated capacity withdrawal and production level upgrading an output based allocation approach is strongly suggested for china s iron and steel sector

optimizing cooperative carbon emission reduction among enterprises with non equivalent relationships subject to carbon taxation abstract getting enterprises to reduce carbon emissions cooperatively is an effective way of sharing the burden of carbon taxation it is easier for core enterprises to promote cooperation because of their dominant positions in the supply chain the main goal of this paper is to provide a potential method for the core enterprise to organize this cooperation successfully we explore how core enterprises should allocate their reduction investments and coordinate the selection of technology upgrade strategies so as to maximize their profits without disrupting the profits of cooperating enterprises for a supply chain where there are non equivalent relationships between enterprises the main hypotheses are that each enterprise only produces one product and each production process in each enterprise can only select one production technology and the intermediate products are mainly traded among cooperative enterprises a model based on independent carbon emission reduction model i is first constructed and used to analyze each enterprises basic information when they reduce carbon emission without cooperation considering total costs profits and so on then based on this information a model including cooperation is proposed model ii in model ii the enterprises are divided into core and cooperative enterprises and both capital and technical cooperation are considered a multi agent system is presented to simulate the negotiations between the enterprises and is then used to solve model ii finally a numerical example is considered to examine the feasibility of the proposed model the results indicate that a cooperative carbon emission reduction strategy has more advantages than the independent carbon emission reduction approach a notable advantage is that it can further rationalize the emission reduction structure of the supply chain through rational allocation of reduction investments and thus further restores profits

international trade in carbon emission rights and basic materials general equilibrium calculations for 2020 restrictions on co emissions affect international trade and the pattern of comparative advantage this paper based on calculations with a static general equilibrium model suggests that international trade in carbon rights is a substitute for trade in energy intensive goods and thus international trading in carbon rights reduces sectoral effects of emission reductions in our model we surprisingly find that free riding by non signatory countries may not render unilateral action ineffective if the oecd unilaterally cuts global emissions by 5 per cent from 1990 levels by the year 2020 emissions by non oecd regions increase but offset less than 15 per cent of this cutback moreover carbon taxes depress international oil prices and create incentives for increased tradc in natural gas

can bilateral trade agreements help induce free trade there has been growing debate about whether bilateral trade agreements are damaging multilateral efforts to eliminate barriers to international trade this paper develops a model in which trading blocs always charge optimal tariffs and make trade agreements based on strategic considerations we ask a very simple question does the fact that trading blocs can form bilateral trade agreements make free trade less likely to occur the answer is that it depends on the size distribution of the trading blocs if there is one large trading bloc along with some smaller ones then bilateral trade agreements allow the smaller trading blocs to coalesce and block the monopoly power of large trading blocs in this case bilateral trade agreements facilitate the attainment of free trade not allowing customs unions leads to more not less protection if trading blocs are of roughly equivalent size then bilateral trade agreements allow groups of trading blocs to more effectively monopolize world trade in which case they may make free trade less likely these results suggest that a policy that inhibits the formation of trading blocs may be harmful we also compute the welfare effects of trade agreements to get some idea of how empirically important these issues are

capital market response to emission rights returns evidence from the european power sector prior studies on the distributional effects of the european union s emission trading scheme eu ets have so far only relied on supply and demand data empirical evidence from capital markets has been missing we address this gap and measure the ets s economic consequences using the expectations of investors towards the regulatory impact on firm value employing a multifactor model we show that returns on common stock of the largest affected industry power generation are positively correlated with rising prices for emission rights this implies that the market predicts that firms are not only able to pass on their share of the regulatory burden to customers but even achieve windfall profits by overcompensating for the costs

a model of carbon price interactions with macroeconomic and energy dynamics abstract this paper develops a model of carbon pricing by considering two fundamental drivers of european union allowances economic activity and energy prices on the one hand economic activity is proxied by aggregated industrial production in the eu 27 as it provides the best performance in a preliminary forecasting exercise vs other indicators on the other hand brent natural gas and coal prices are selected as being the main carbon price drivers as highlighted by previous literature the interactions between the macroeconomic and energy spheres are captured in a markov switching var model with two states that is able to reproduce the boom bust business cycle hamilton 1989 first industrial production is found to impact positively negatively the carbon market during periods of economic expansion recession thereby confirming the existence of a link between the macroeconomy and the price of carbon second the brent price is confirmed to be the leader in price formation among energy markets bachmeier and griffin 2006 as it impacts other variables through the structure of the markov switching model taken together these results uncover new interactions between the recently created eu emissions market and the pre existing macroeconomic energy environment

the size of trading blocs market power and world welfare effects abstract we construct an n country n commodity trade model to analyze the implications of bloc size for nash equilibrium tariffs and welfare the relationship between the absolute size of symmetric trading blocs and their market power is ambiguous and we illustrate how this relationship varies with model parameters in contrast sufficiently large increases in the relative size of a bloc enhance its relative market power and cause the welfare of its country members to rise above the free trade level we establish the existence of an optimal bloc size and study the dependence of optimal size on the parameters of the model

the impact of border carbon adjustments under alternative producer responses border carbon adjustments bcas have been proposed to address leakage and competitiveness concerns in traditional assessments firms regard bcas as output taxes rather than implicit emissions taxes using a stylized energy economic model we analyze the impact of bcas for alternative producer responses when firms view bcas as an implicit emissions tax the outcome depends on whether or not firms can differentiate production across destination markets if firms are able to produce a lowemissions variety for regions imposing bcas results are similar to when firms regard bcas as an output tax if firms produce a single variety for all markets bcas result in larger leakage reductions than in standard approaches we also find that bcas are less effective at addressing competitive concerns in scenarios that result in larger leakage reductions jel codes f18 q54

eu emission allowances and the stock market evidence from the electricity industry this paper constitutes to our best knowledge the first econometric analysis on stock market effects of the eu emission trading scheme eu ets our results suggest that eu emission allowance eua price developments matter to the stock performance of electricity firms eua price changes and stock returns of the most important european electricity corporations are shown to be positively related this effect does not work asymmetrically so that stock markets do not seem to react differently to eua appreciations in comparison to depreciations the carbon market effect is shown to be both time and country specific it is particularly strong for the period of eua market shock in early 2006 and differs with respect to the countries where the electricity corporations analysed are headquartered stock market reactions to eua volatility could not be shown

border adjustment for european emissions trading competitiveness and carbon leakage unilateral or sub global policies to combat climate change are potentially sensitive to free riding and carbon leakage one way of dealing with carbon leakage and competitiveness is the imposition of border adjustment measures for competing imports for example in the form of the obligation to importers of goods to purchase and surrender emissions allowances to the authorities when importing in this paper we explore some implications of border adjustment measures in the eu ets for sectors that might be subject to carbon leakage we examine the implications of two variants of these measures on the competitiveness of these sectors and on the global environment with the help of a multi sector multi region computable general equilibrium cge model of the global economy our calculations suggest that border adjustment might reduce the sectoral rate of leakage of the iron and steel industry rather forcefully but that the reduction would be less for the mineral products sector including cement the reduction of the overall or macro rate of leakage would be modest so from an environmental point of view border tax adjustments would not be a very effective policy measure but might mainly be justified by considerations of sectoral competitiveness

economic and environmental impact analysis of carbon tariffs on chinese exports as an alternative measure for the proposal of border tax adjustments btas advocated by the countries that seek to abate co2 emissions hereafter referred to as abating countries export carbon tax ect voluntarily conducted by the developing countries has been widely discussed in recent years this paper uses the multi regional and multi commodity computable general equilibrium cge model and the gtap8 1 database to investigate the economic and environmental effects of carbon tariffs on chinese exports the following three policy scenarios are considered 1 the abating countries implement cap and trade emission programs without btas 2 the unilaterally abating countries levy import tariffs and export subsidies on non abating countries and 3 the abating countries implement unilateral climate policies combined with ect imposed by china the ect policy of china is evaluated with a carbon price set at 17 us t co2 results illustrate that the ect voluntarily implemented by china is ineffective in reducing its domestic co2 emissions moreover ect merely has a minor impact on global emissions finally the competitiveness of china s energy intensive and trade exposed eite industries suffers substantial losses if export tariffs are imposed however china s gains in terms of welfare and gross domestic product gdp would be slightly improved if an ect policy is implemented compared to the scenario where china is subjected to btas levied by the abating coalition in the light of the tradeoff between tariff revenue for welfare and competiveness losses of the eite industries it is therefore difficult to conclude that carbon tariff on chinese exports is an alternative policy to btas

is the gatt wto s article xxiv bad the gatt wto article xxiv prevents a customs union cu from raising its common external tariff in this paper we compare cu formation with and without this article xxiv constraint we show in a multi country oligopoly model that for a given cu structure article xxiv improves world welfare by lowering trade barriers however we also show that article xxiv has a composition effect on cu formation it affects the endogenous choice of cus by encouraging more symmetric cus article xxiv causes more trade to be subject to trade barriers as a result article xxiv may be bad for world welfare 2012 elsevier b v

carbon markets 15 years after kyoto lessons learned new challenges abstract carbon markets are substantial and they are expanding there are many lessons from market experiences over the past eight years there should be fewer free allowances better management of market sensitive information and a recognition that trading systems require adjustments that have consequences for market participants and market confidence moreover the emerging market architecture features separate emissions trading systems serving distinct jurisdictions and a variety of other types of policies exist alongside the carbon markets this situation is in sharp contrast to the top down integrated global trading architecture envisioned 15 years ago by the designers of the kyoto protocol and raises a suite of new questions in this new architecture jurisdictions with emissions trading have to decide how whether and when to link with one another stakeholders and policymakers must confront how to measure the comparability of efforts among markets as well as relative to a variety of other polic

comparing policies to combat emissions leakage border carbon adjustments versus rebates we explore conditions determining which anti leakage policies might be more effective complements to domestic greenhouse gas emissions regulation we consider four policies that could be combined with unilateral emissions pricing to counter effects on international competitiveness a border charge on imports a border rebate for exports full border adjustment and domestic output based rebating each option faces different potential legal hurdles in international trade law each also has different economic impacts while all can support competitiveness none is necessarily effective at reducing global emissions nor is it possible to rank order the options effectiveness depends on the relative emissions rates elasticities of substitution and consumption volumes we illustrate these results with simulations for the energy intensive sectors of three different economies the united states canada and europe although most controversial full border adjustment is usually most effective but output based rebating for key manufacturing sectors can achieve many of the gains

to what extent are eu steel companies susceptible to competitive loss due to climate policy abstract in recognition of their competitive vulnerability a set of special rules have been devised for managing sectors such as iron and steel within the eu ets under these rules the eu steel sector has received free allocations in excess of their compliance needs to now and will continue to receive some free allowances up to 2020 however perceptions of the sector s competitive vulnerability have been largely based on inherently hypothetical analyses which rely heavily on counterfactual scenarios and abatement cost estimates often provided by firms themselves this paper explores how the three largest steel firms in the eu acerlormittal corus and thyssenkrupp have sought to strategically exaggerate their vulnerability to carbon pricing to the effect of an inefficient policy outcome we conduct a qualitative assessment of two of the key narratives underpinning the competitive vulnerability argument of eu steel companies lack of abatement opportunities and inability to pass through cost increases based on interviews case studies and publicly available data we find that these arguments provide only partial and weak justifications for competitive loss and preferential treatment under the eu ets the strategy however remains successful due to information asymmetry and the peculiar political economy of eu climate regulation

the effects of border crossing frequencies associated with carbon footprints on border carbon adjustments abstract the fragmentation of production across national boundaries has become an important feature of the world economy this present paper adopts the viewpoint that not only the size and composition of carbon footprints are relevant but also the border crossing frequency associated with these carbon footprints which is defined as the number of borders a product crosses in a supply chain this process will affect the spatial accounting of the carbon emissions produced to support the economic activity the calculation of border crossing frequencies of carbon footprint is accomplished by decomposing the leontief inverse matrix derived from the world input output database we find that the aggregated average border crossing frequencies of carbon footprints show an increasing tendency which is influenced by the economic crisis obviously the policy application focuses on the united states which we assume to levy carbon tariffs on foreign emissions embodied in imports we find that the indirect carbon tariff on emissions embodied in international trade take a significant share the border carbon adjustments are mainly targeted at emissions generated in china which also pays the greatest share of the tariff burden the implication of carbon tariffs faces the problem of multiple taxation

optimal environmental border adjustments under the general agreement on tariffs and trade a country choosing to adopt border carbon adjustments based on embodied emissions is motivated by both environmental and strategic incentives we argue that the strategic component is inconsistent with commitments under the general agreement on tariffs and trade gatt we extend the theory of border adjustments to neutralize the strategic incentive and consider the remaining environmental incentive in a simplified structure the theory supports border adjustments on carbon content that are below the domestic carbon price because price signals sent through border adjustments inadvertently encourage consumption of emissions intensive goods in unregulated regions the theoretic intuition is supported in our applied numeric simulations countries imposing border adjustments at the domestic carbon price will be extracting rents from unregulated regions at the expense of efficient environmental policy and consistency with international trade law

chinese companies awareness and perceptions of the emissions trading scheme ets evidence from a national survey in china abstract china announced the launch of a national emissions trading scheme ets in 2017 however companies appear show little enthusiasm for participation in the ets in china this paper identifies the factors affecting companies awareness and perceptions of ets by conducting a national survey based on an online questionnaire from may to november 2015 in seven carbon trading pilots the results indicate that companies attitudes towards the ets are positively influenced by government regulations and policy public relations management and estimated economic benefit of these public relations management is the decisive factor and estimated economic benefit is confirmed to be a relatively weak predictor a company s environmental and energy strategy exerts insignificant effects on its preference for the ets although the sampled companies are very willing to save energy and reduce emissions there exists an inverted u shape relationship between a company s level of mitigation technologies and its attitudes towards the ets the carbon price fails to stimulate companies to upgrade mitigation technologies the majority of companies treat participation in the ets only as a means of improving ties with governments as well as of earning a good social reputation rather than as a cost effective mechanism to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions

how carbon offsetting scheme impacts the duopoly output in production and abatement analysis in the context of carbon cap and trade abstract in the context of addressing climate change the carbon emission trading scheme has become one of the main measures adopted by many countries and regions to achieve emission reduction goals noticing this current lack of research based on a duopoly model this paper quantitatively explores the impact of carbon offsetting scheme on both emission trading participants profits and industry s output by drawing on advanced experience of carbon offsetting scheme from developed countries such as us switzerland and eu and thus provides a perspective for government to design optimal aggregate standard for carbon cap and trade results show a negative correlation between enterprises carbon intensity and their equilibrium output in the product market and indicate a threshold for the relative magnitude of the duopoly enterprises carbon intensity above which their absolute output will differ dramatically the incorporation of carbon offsetting scheme into a non offset quota trading scheme will reduce its equilibrium carbon price thereby mitigate its negative impact on industry s total output in the product market by an either linear or quadratic form depending on the design for the proportion ceiling of offsetting quota

tariff bindings and the dynamic formation of preferential trade agreements abstract we show that multilateral tariff binding liberalization substantially impacts the nature and extent of preferential trade agreement pta formation first it shapes the nature of forces constraining expansion of free trade agreements ftas the constraining force is a free riding incentive of fta non members under relatively high bindings but an exclusion incentive of fta members under relatively low bindings second multilateral tariff binding liberalization shapes the role played by ptas in the attainment of global free trade initially tariff binding liberalization leads to custom union cu formation in equilibrium but in a way that undermines the pursuit of global free trade however further tariff binding liberalization leads to fta formation in equilibrium and in a way that facilitates the attainment of global free trade our theoretical analysis also has implications regarding recent empirical discussions over the relative merits of ftas versus cus

sustaining the emerging carbon trading industry development a business ecosystem approach of carbon traders abstract this paper explores how carbon traders nurture the business ecosystem to sustain the emerging carbon trading industry development we collected primary data from a multinational carbon trader and its ecosystem partners in china through the construction of interviews and documentary the research findings show the carbon trading industry has experienced four stage evolution with different driving forces the carbon trader attracted and organized ecosystem partners to facilitate the cdm project owners to create carbon credits and trade them a systematic business ecosystems approach through the lens of context cooperation and configuration initiated by carbon traders has facilitated the industry development our findings also implicate to industrial practitioners and policymakers for sustaining the emerging industry development at both the current and the post kyoto protocol periods

impacts of climate policy on the competitiveness of canadian industry how big and how to mitigate competitiveness concerns have been at the forefront of climate policy debates in canada particularly as a result of its high energy intensity and significant exposure to international markets this paper uses a dynamic computable general equilibrium model to assess the likely impacts on sectoral competitiveness that would accompany efforts to meet greenhouse gas mitigation targets that have been set by the canadian government additionally it evaluates several design mechanisms that could be used to reduce the negative competiveness impacts associated with adoption of domestic climate policies the analysis suggests that several sectors would likely face significant competiveness challenges under a reference scenario in which permits are given to emitters in lump sum however it finds that competiveness impacts can be minimized by using output based recycling of permits or by using border tax adjustments

product level embodied carbon flows in bilateral trade as increasingly complex modelling approaches to quantifying embodied carbon in trade have become popular the lack of disaggregation has been identified as a key weakness this paper quantifies embodied carbon in bilateral trade at the product level this is done using the material balance approach by collecting product carbon intensity factors from multiple data sources and combining with bilateral trade data in physical quantities the dataset covers trades between 195 countries for 1080 products in 2006 the detailed mapping of trade embodied carbon provides detailed insights into the nature of the flows that were previously masked or under reported for example it finds that the lion s share of global trade embodied emissions are concentrated in a relatively small number of product categories of traded goods suggesting that focusing mitigation efforts and trade measures on these products would be an effective strategy to address potential carbon leakage and to decarbonise international supply chains the results also highlight that embodied carbon is focused in regional trade thus regional harmonisation of climate mitigation policy will be effective in mitigating leakage

a look inwards carbon tariffs versus internal improvements in emissions trading systems abstract subglobal climate policies will be the norm for some years to come however several options exist for improving the efficiency of domestic emissions regulation a prominent but contentious policy option for improving the external efficiency is the implementation of carbon tariffs on non regulating regions this is thought to reduce carbon leakage and increase domestic production albeit at the cost of non regulating countries in contrast internal efficiency improvements can be more collaborative in type among others they include extending and linking of domestic emissions trading systems this study compares the relative economic impacts of those policy options if annex i countries would follow one or the other the study uses a computable general equilibrium model of the global world economy and develops a set of emissions trading and carbon tariff scenarios with various degrees of sectoral and regional coverage for a globally effective annex i emissions reduction target of 20 the results indicate that linking annex i countries domestic emissions trading systems and expanding their sectoral coverage could yield greater global welfare improvements than implementing carbon tariffs on energy intensive goods imported from non annex i countries while non annex i countries would be significantly better off without facing carbon tariffs on their exports annex i countries could gain from either policy the relative gains from linking and extending the sectoral coverage of domestic emissions trading systems are greater for early policy implementation within a large annex i coalition of climate regulating countries while late implementation within a small coalition would yield greater relative welfare gains from imposing carbon tariffs the results suggest that in addition to the political benefits there exists an economic rationale for substituting the external efficiency improvements associated with implementing carbon tariffs with internal ones associated with extending annex i countries emissions trading systems

downstream regulation of co2 emissions in california s electricity sector this paper examines the implications of alternative forms of cap and trade regulations on the california electricity market specific focus is given to the implementation of a downstream form of regulation known as the first deliverer policy under this policy importers i e first deliverers of electricity into california are responsible for the emissions associated with the power plants from which the power originated even if those plants are physically located outside of california we find that absent strict non economic barriers to changing import patterns such policies are extremely vulnerable to reshuffling of import resources the net impact implies that the first deliverer policies will be only marginally more effective than a conventional source based regulation

regionalism in a multilateral world recent regional initiatives have been addressed from a vinerian perspective of trade creation and trade diversion this is true of both policy oriented economists who tend to be critical of the initiatives and theorists who have added dynamic and gametheoretic elements to the vinerian structure this paper describes the stylized facts of much recent regional integration and develops an alternative model the analysis suggests that regional integration far from threatening multilateral liberalism may in fact be a direct consequence of the success of past multilateralism and an added guarantee for its survival

multilateral stability and efficiency of trade agreements a network formation approach we study the endogenous network formation of bilateral and multilateral trade agreements by means of hypergraphs and introduce the equilibrium concept of multilateral stability we consider multi country settings with a firm in each country that produces a homogeneous good and competes as a cournot oligopolist in each market under endogenous tariffs we find that the existence of a multilateral trade agreement is always necessary for the stability of the trading system and that the formation of preferential trade agreements is always necessary for achieving global free trade we also find that global free trade is efficient but not necessarily the only multilaterally stable trade equilibrium when countries are symmetric heterogeneous in terms of market size we derive conditions under which such a conflict between overall welfare efficiency and stability occurs

the role of stocks and shocks concepts in the debate over price versus quantity recent literature showed that the choice between a price or quantity control depends in part on the dynamic structure of cost uncertainty temporary shocks to abatement cost favors the use of a price control while permanent shocks favor a quantity control unfortunately the importance of this assumption to the optimal choice has not yet received wide attention among economists we analyze the regulatory sproblem in an alternative setting and reproduce these results our contribution is the simplicity of the model and the accessibility of the results which reinforce the critical role played by the assumed structure of uncertainty

a strategic and welfare theoretic analysis of free trade areas abstract we construct a three country model to determine how the formation of free trade areas ftas affects optimal tariffs and welfare we find that at constant rest of the world row tariffs the adoption of internal free trade induces union members to reduce their external tariffs below the kemp wan j int econom 6 1976 95 97 level and causes row s terms of trade to improve and its welfare to rise when row also behaves optimally its policy response to the formation of the fta is to raise tariffs generally fta members prefer to liberalize internal trade partially and find regional integration appealing only if their collective size is sufficiently large we also demonstrate how ftas may undermine the attainment of global free trade

dynamic formation of preferential trade agreements the role of flexibility in practice free trade agreements ftas vastly outnumber customs unions cus nevertheless the literature traditionally views cus as optimal for members because cu members coordinate external tariffs i show that a dynamic fta flexibility benefit can help explain the prevalence of ftas individual fta members have the flexibility to form their own future ftas whereas cu members must jointly engage in future cu formation i show how the relative prevalence of ftas versus cus depends on the structure of market size asymmetry across countries and use these predictions to shed some light on fta versus cu formation in europe and south america formation dynamique d accords commerciaux preferentiels le role de la flexibilite en pratique les accords de libre echange ale sont plus nombreux que les unions douanieres ud neanmoins la litterature specialisee percoit traditionnellement que les ud sont optimales pour les membres parce qu ils peuvent coordonner leurs tarifs externes on montre qu une flexibilite dynamique de l ale peut aider a expliquer la prevalence des ale les membres des ale ont la flexibilite de former leurs propres ale dans l avenir alors que les membres des ud s engagent conjointement pour la formation des ud futures on montre comment la prevalence des ale versus les ud depend de la structure de l asymetrie de la taille entre les pays et on utilise ces previsions pour eclairer les choix entre la formation de ale et de ud en europe et en amerique du sud

external trade diversion exclusion incentives and the nature of preferential trade agreements in a game of endogenous trade agreements between three countries we show that while the pursuit of customs unions cus prevents global free trade from emerging as a coalition proof nash equilibrium the pursuit of free trade agreements ftas does not this result reflects the relatively flexible nature of ftas whereas each fta member can independently undertake further trade liberalization with respect to the non member cu members must do so as a group due to their common external tariff by diverting members exports away from the non member both types of trade agreements induce the non member to voluntarily lower its import tariffs

negotiating free trade we develop a dynamic bargaining model in which a leading country endogenously decides whether to sequentially negotiate free trade agreements with subsets of countries or engage in simultaneous multilateral bargaining with all countries at once we show how the structure of coalition externalities shapes the choice between sequential and multilateral bargaining and we identify circumstances in which the grand coalition is the equilibrium outcome leading to worldwide free trade a model of international trade is then used to illustrate equilibrium outcomes and how they depend on the structure of trade and protection global free trade is not achieved when the political economy motive for protection is sufficiently large furthermore the model generates both building bloc and stumbling bloc effects of preferential trade agreements in particular we describe an equilibrium in which global free trade is attained only when preferential trade agreements are permitted to form a building bloc effect and an equilibrium in which global free trade is attained only when preferential trade agreements are forbidden a stumbling bloc effect the analysis identifies conditions under which each of these outcomes emerges

value of recreational fishing in the brazilian pantanal a travel cost analysis using count data models abstract recreational fishing value of the brazilian pantanal is measured using travel cost method tcm we compare non linear poisson and negative binomial count data models to estimate recreational fishing trip demands the count data and truncated models are used primarily to account for non negative integer and truncation properties of recreational fishing trips as suggested by the recreation valuation literature the results reveal that non linear and truncated count data models perform relatively well in our study the economic values of recreational fishing in terms of consumer surplus cs are derived using non linear and truncated models we estimate the cs values from 540 54 to 869 57 per trip resulting in the total social welfare estimate range from 35 to 56 million the study demonstrates a relatively high value of recreational fishing in the pantanal in comparison to similar studies conducted in other parts of the world the findings of this study would be important for resource management decisions in the pantanal and could serve as a reference in valuing similar resources in other ecosystems around the world

the customs union issue why do we observe so few of them the number of preferential trade agreements has greatly increased over the past two decades yet most existing bilateral arrangements take the form of free trade areas and less than ten percent can be considered to be fully edged customs unions this paper develops a political economy model of trade policy under imperfect competition to provide a positive explanation for the prevalence of free trade areas in a three country setting a representative from each prospective member is elected to determine the tarifis to be applied on imported goods under a customs union the necessity to coordinate tarifis leads voters to strategically delegate power to more protectionist representatives contrary to most of the existing literature we show that strategic delegation may imply that free trade areas increase welfare compared to customs unions moreover the model also indicates that free trade areas are more likely to be politically viable than customs unions