natural resources and sub national economic performance does sub national democracy matter abstract the differentiation in the impact of resources on economic growth is often explained by the specifics of institutional factors the aim of this paper is to investigate how sub national political differences influence the effect of natural resources on economic growth using a dataset of russian regions this paper demonstrates that sub national democratization influences the growth effects of resources and considers possible mechanisms for this influence the paper finds that in russia natural resources are only capable of promoting growth in the regions with non democratic political systems that at the same time have an efficient and non corrupt bureaucracy

foreign ownership and corporate income taxation an empirical evaluation abstract foreign ownership allows countries to effectively export part of their corporate tax burden hence countries with high foreign ownership are expected to impose relatively high corporate taxes the findings of this paper suggest that there indeed is an economically significant positive relationship between foreign ownership and tax burdens in europe already significant foreign ownership levels in europe offer an explanation for the absence of a race to the bottom in corporate tax levels

profit shifting and investment effects the implications of zero taxable profits abstract recent empirical research documents a tendency of multinational enterprise affiliates to bunch around zero reported profit we set up a theoretical model of multinational firm behavior in which we allow for corner solutions in the choice of the optimal transfer price due to insufficient profits or losses of affiliates such constraints in the choice of the transfer price induce bunching and generate investment effects in the low tax as well as the high tax country in equilibrium affiliates might overinvest and the investment effects generate a tendency for too high profit taxes the analysis provides a micro foundation for the investment effects that result from transfer pricing the finding stands in contrast to the existing literature where transfer pricing choices are unconstrained

tax asymmetries the cost of capital and investment some evidence from united kingdom panel data a measure of the cost of capital is developed that incorporates the dynamic effects of tax changes and tax asymmetries estimates of the cost of capital are made using an unbalanced panel of 1987 u k quoted companies over the period 1971 to 1984 there is wide cross sectional variation in the cost of capital the measure is used in estimating an equation where this cross sectional variation is found to be a significant determinant of the level of company investment copyright 1989 by royal economic society

local institutions audit quality and corporate scandals of us listed foreign firms using data on shareholder initiated class action lawsuits in the us i investigate the corporate scandals of us listed foreign firms the shareholders of scandal firms suffer considerable loss in both the short term and the long term i document that firms domiciled in countries with weak institutions are more likely to be embroiled in corporate scandals but such a relation can be moderated by the presence of big 4 auditors investors automatically adjust for undiscovered misconduct when valuing the stocks of non scandal firms i e the spillover effect investors rely on the audit quality to form their expectations about the severity of undiscovered misconduct and thus impose less negative spillovers on firms with big 4 auditors especially when the firms are from countries with weak institutions taken together my results suggest that listing on us exchanges does not fully compensate for weak local institutions voluntarily bonding to a more stringent audit process has an incremental effect on protecting shareholder interests and enhances the confidence of investors in firms financial integrity

the significance of tax law asymmetries an empirical investigation this study uses tax return data for u s nonfinancial corporations for the period 1971 1982 to estimate the importance of restrictions on the ability of firms to use tax credits and to obtain refunds for tax losses our results suggest that the incidence of such unused tax benefits increased substantially during the early 1980s though we do not find these increases attributable to increased investment incentives during that period we present estimates of the marginal tax rate on interest payments which take into account unused tax benefits and emphasize the importance of distinguishing current tax payments from marginal tax rates in estimating the incentive to invest

the metabolic transition of a planned economy material flows in the ussr and the russian federation 1900 to 2010 abstract the study of long term historical trends in material flows has gained some prominence in ecological economics since the first studies for austria and the united kingdom were published as part of a special section in 2002 this research expands the existing knowledgebase by presenting material flows for the russian federation and its predecessor states employing a standard accounting framework the study of material flows for the russian federation provides an interesting and unique case of a planned economy and its transition to a market based form of economic organization we show that in spite of considerable differences in the physical economy the ussr developed material use patterns similar to that of western industrialized economies lower levels of consumption were more than outweighed by inefficient production the transition towards a market economy drove rapid improvements in resource productivity but also growth in metabolic rates the results indicate that the transition to an industrial metabolic profile proceeds largely irrespective of economic and political conditions an improved understanding of the evolution of socio economic systems and the material flows that fuel them is increasingly relevant for designing new systems of production and consumption and facilitating a transition towards a more sustainable industrial metabolism

explaining differences in public sector efficiency evidence from russia s regions summary using the case of russia s regions this paper extends the literature on public sector efficiency in three directions an attempt to better understand differences in public sector efficiency through the study of subnational governments in one country the first examination of public sector efficiency of subnational governments in emerging markets and the first study of public sector efficiency in russia three types of scores of public sector performance and efficiency indicate substantial differences across regions an econometric examination suggests that they are largely explained by per capita income the share of federal transfers in subnational government revenue quality of governance and democratic control and the level of spending

fiscal policy and regional output volatility evidence from russia eller m fidrmuc j and fungac ova z fiscal policy and regional output volatility evidence from russia regional studies this paper investigates the relationship between fiscal policy and output volatility in russian regions between 2000 and 2009 accounting for endogeneity between output volatility and fiscal developments by using system generalized method of moments gmm estimation techniques the results indicate that discretionary fiscal policy contributes to output volatility and induces macroeconomic instability at the regional level in russia this corroborates previous studies using cross country data to reduce business cycle fluctuations it would be necessary to curtail procyclical fiscal activism at the regional level e g via fiscal rules and sound institutions of fiscal federalism

income and democracy existing studies establish a strong cross country correlation between income and democracy but do not control for factors that simultaneously affect both variables we show that controlling for such factors by including country fixed effects removes the statistical association between income per capita and vari ous measures of democracy we present instrumental variables estimates that also show no causal effect of income on democracy the cross country corre lation between income and democracy reflects a positive correlation between changes in income and democracy over the past 500 years this pattern is con sistent with the idea that societies embarked on divergent political economic development paths at certain critical junctures jel d7 e 1

growth in post soviet russia a tale of two transitions abstract in the early stages of post soviet russia s economic transition small scale entrepreneurial activity appeared to be a strong engine of growth moreover striking regional variations in initial conditions and adopted policy reforms appeared useful in accounting statistically for observed regional variations in entrepreneurial activity here we investigate whether these relationships have persisted as russia s transition has continued to evolve and find that they have not we then document that the emergence of bank issued credit virtually non existent outside of moscow prior to 2000 has been an important engine of growth since 2000 thus to date russia s post soviet development appears as a tale of two distinct transition paths

can foreign firms bond themselves effectively by renting u s securities laws abstract the study tests the functional convergence hypothesis which states that foreign firms can leapfrog their countries weak legal institutions by listing equities in new york and agreeing to follow u s securities law evidence shows that the sec and minority shareholders have not effectively enforced the law against cross listed foreign firms detailed evidence from mexico further shows that while some insiders exploited this weak legal enforcement with impunity others that issued a cross listing and passed through an economic downturn with a clean reputation went on to receive privileged long term access to outside finance as compared with legal bonding reputational bonding better explains the success of cross listings

risky local tax bases risk pooling vs rent capture abstract when a jurisdiction s land or other fixed resources are owned by non residents its residents have an incentive to capture the non residents rents by imposing confiscatory taxes when different jurisdictions are subject to less than perfectly correlated risks such taxes destroy the benefits of risk pooling that cross ownership of property otherwise permits if jurisdictions must use property taxes i e taxes on both immobile land and mobile capital instead of taxes on land alone they will compete for mobile capital by keeping tax rates low if capital is sufficiently substitutable for immobile factors tax rates will be low enough to achieve greater effective diversification of risks and higher welfare

patterns of transition from plan to market patterns of transition from plan to market martha de melo cevdet denizer and alan gelb hungary s bankruptcy experience 1992 1993 cheryl w gray sabine schlorke and miklos szanyi why and when do governments initiate public enterprise reform jose edgardo campos and hadi salehi esfahani roads land use and deforestation a spatial model applied to belize kenneth m chomitz and david a gray industrial centralization in indonesia j vernon henderson and ari kuncoro guidlines on searching for a dalton improving tax reform an illustration with data from indonesia shlomo yitzhaki and jeffrey d lewis a new data set measuring income inequality klaus deininger and lyn squire

tax competition when firms choose their organizational form should tax loopholes for multinationals be closed we analyze a sequential game between two symmetric countries when firms can invest in a multinational structure that confers tax savings governments are able to commit to long run tax discrimination policies before firms decisions are made and before statutory capital tax rates are chosen non cooperatively whether a coordinated reduction in the tax preferences granted to mobile firms is beneficial or harmful for the competing countries depends critically on the elasticity with which the firms organizational structure responds to tax discrimination incentives a model extension with countries of different size shows that small countries are likely to grant more tax preferences than larger ones along with having lower effective tax rates

the invisible hand and the grabbing hand evidence from a survey of 105 shop owners in moscow and warsaw shows that the reliance on private protection as well as the burden of regulation and corruption are much greater in moscow the evidence suggests that the invisible hand model of government better fits the warsaw local government and the grabbing hand model is more appropriate for moscow the evidence implies that the singular focus on the speed of economic reforms to understand the success of transition is misplaced and that the quality of government may be as essential this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

capital income and profit taxation with foreign ownership of firms abstract this paper establishes optimal rules for capital income and profits taxation in the open economy with or without foreign ownership of domestic firms we show that if there are constraints on the feasibility of profits taxation both saving and investment taxes generally enter the optimal tax package if instead profits can be fully taxed then source based investment taxes vanish if domestic firms are in part owned by foreigners then source based investment taxes can be used to shift income away from these to domestic citizens and they may even be used to finance lump sum transfers to domestic residents

in praise of tax havens international tax planning and foreign direct investment abstract the multinationalization of corporate investment in recent years has given rise to a number of international tax avoidance schemes that may be eroding tax revenues in industrialized countries but which may also reduce tax burdens on mobile capital and so facilitate investment both the welfare effects of and the optimal response to international tax planning are therefore ambiguous evaluating these factors in a simple general equilibrium model we find that citizens of high tax countries benefit from some tax planning paradoxically if tax rates are not too high an increase in tax planning activity causes a rise in optimal corporate tax rates and a decline in multinational investment thus fears of a race to the bottom in corporate tax rates may be misplaced

taxation of mobile factors as insurance under uncertainty this paper considers the effects of the taxation of mobile factors i e capital under uncertainty the wages earned by residents of a jurisdiction are uncertain due to random shocks since the uncertain wages in a jurisdiction depend on the amount of mobile capital employed in the jurisdiction and since taxation alters the quantity of capital employed taxation affects the riskiness of uncertain wages in particular the taxation of capital moderates the fluctuation of uncertain wages thereby providing insurance for this reason jurisdictions use distortionary capital taxation even if lump sum taxation is available in addition this insurance effect counteracts the tendency toward too low tax rates on capital arising from tax competition and possibly improves the efficiency of tax competition

a tale of two reforms i identify the absence of well functioning product markets in transition economies as a sufficient condition under which big bang reduces output initially while a chinese style reform increases output big bang dismantles central planning or centralized organization of production permitting monopolistic and vertically interdependent enterprises to pursue their own monopoly profits by restricting output and inter firm trade to the detriment of the economy as a whole the chinese reform by maintaining central planning but allowing enterprises to produce for the emerging product markets after they have fulfilled their output quotas under planning gives enterprises incentives to expand output beyond planned targets

the transition to a market economy pitfalls of partial reform we present a theory of a partial economic reform of a planned economy similar to the one that took place in russia since 1988 and in china earlier in such a reform some markets are liberalized in the sense that producers can sell output to whomever they want including private firms at free prices but at the same time must sell to state firms at state prices we show that such a reform can result in a substantial diversion of subsidized inputs away from state firms and toward private firms even when state firms value these inputs more the result may be a reduction of total output the simple analysis sheds light on many consequences of the soviet reform such as breakdown of coordination of production increased state policing of delivery quotas prohibitions of trading cooperatives and opposition to privatization the model also explains why partial reform failed in russia but worked in china

reform without losers an interpretation of china s dual track approach to transition this paper develops a simple model to analyze the dual track approach to market liberalization as a mechanism for implementing efficient pareto improving economic reform that is reform achieving efficiency without creating losers the approach based on the continued enforcement of the existing plan while simultaneously liberalizing the market can be understood as a method for making implicit lump sum transfers to compensate potential losers of the reform the model highlights the critical roles of enforcement of the plan for achieving pareto improvement and full liberalization of the market track for achieving efficiency we examine how the dual track approach has worked in product and labor market liberalization in china

policy reform and growth in post soviet russia in pursuit of its transition from a command to a market economy russia has witnessed enormous regional differences in economic growth rates moreover the implementation of economic reforms has also differed markedly across regions we analyze whether regional differences in reform policies can account for regional differences in growth rates and conclude that to a considerable degree they can most notably we find that regional differences in price liberalization policies exhibit a positive direct correspondence with growth we also find that regional differences in large scale privatization exhibit a positive correspondence with the regional formation of new legal enterprises which in turn exhibits a strong positive correspondence with growth

property rights and finance which is the tighter constraint on private sector investment weak property rights or limited access to external finance from a survey of new firms in post communist countries we find that weak property rights discourage firms from reinvesting their profits even when bank loans are available where property rights are relatively strong firms reinvest their profits where they are relatively weak entrepreneurs do not want to invest from retained earnings

economic reform and comparative advantage in agriculture in the newly independent states in this paper i examine whether the newly independent states nis of the former soviet union fsu could have a comparative advantage in agriculture after successful economic reform the analysis has two steps first using empirical estimates i examine comparative production costs of the fsu s main imported goods in the 1980s second i discuss how reform could change the goods relative productivity and costs thereby altering the structure of profitable agricultural trade analysis and estimates are for the aggregate fsu vis a vis the world market

cross border loss offset can fuel tax competition following recent court rulings cross border loss compensation for multinational firms has become a major policy issue in europe this paper analyzes the effects of introducing a coordinated cross border tax relief in a setting where multinational firms choose the size of a risky investment and host countries non cooperatively choose tax rates we show that coordinated cross border loss compensation may intensify tax competition when following current international practice the parent firm s home country bases the tax rebate for a loss making subsidiary on its own tax rate in equilibrium tax revenue losses may thus be even higher than is implied by the direct effect of the reform in contrast tax competition is mitigated when the home country bases its loss relief on the tax rate in the subsidiary s host country

persistence of power elites and institutions we construct a model to study the implications of changes in political insti tutions for economic institutions a change in political institutions alters the distribution of de jure political power but creates incentives for investments in de facto political power to partially or even fully offset change in de jure power the model can imply a pattern of captured democracy whereby a democratic regime may survive but choose economic institutions favoring an elite the model provides conditions under which economic or policy outcomes will be invariant to changes in political institutions and economic institutions them selves will persist over time jel d02 d72 the domination of an organized minority over the unor ganized majority is inevitable the power of any minority is irresistible as against each single individual in the majority who stands alone before the totality of the organized minor ity at the same time the minority is organized for the very reason that it is a minority

executive overconfidence and the slippery slope to financial misreporting abstract a detailed analysis of 49 firms subject to aaers suggests that approximately one quarter of the misstatements meet the legal standards of intent in the remaining three quarters the initial misstatement reflects an optimistic bias that is not necessarily intentional because of the bias however in subsequent periods these firms are more likely to be in a position in which they are compelled to intentionally misstate earnings overconfident executives are more likely to exhibit an optimistic bias and thus are more likely to start down a slippery slope of growing intentional misstatements evidence from a high tech sample and a larger and more general sample support the overconfidence explanation for this path to misstatements and aaers

investment incentives and corporate tax asymmetries abstract recent facts on the importance of corporate losses motivate more careful study of the impact of tax incentives for investment on firms that lose money i model firm investment decisions in a setting featuring financing constraints and carrybacks and carryforwards of operating losses i estimate investment responses to tax incentives allowing effects to vary with cash flows and taxable status results suggest that asymmetries in the corporate tax code could have made recent bonus depreciation tax incentives at most 4 less effective than they would have been if all firms were fully taxable cash flows have more important effects on the impact of tax incentives recent declines in cash flows would predict a 24 decrease in the effectiveness of bonus depreciation results thus suggest that tax incentives have the smallest impact on investment exactly when they are most likely to be put in place during downturns in economic activity when cash flows are low

the dynamic effects of tax law asymmetries under the laws of most countries a distinction is made between gains and losses by businesses losses that must be carried forward are subjept to two penalties a loss of interest and expiration previous examinations have focused on the higher expected tax payments such a tax system without full loss offset imposes on risky projects this paper presents a dynamic analysis of the impact of taxation on investment when gains and losses are treated asymmetrically the results demonstrate how firm characteristics and the timing of taxes can influence behaviour under current u s tax law a distinction is made between gains and losses by businesses for corporations gains are taxed at what is essentially a flat rate of 46 while losses do not necessarily qualify for a refund at the same rate to obtain an immediate refund the taxpayer must have had taxable income during the three previous years in excess of the current loss any losses that cannot be carried back in this fashion must be carried forward subject to two implicit penalties such loss carryforwards earn no interest and they expire after fifteen years similar provisions apply in other countries hence businesses investing in risky projects for which the probability of having to carry losses forward is positive can expect to pay higher taxes than they would under a system with full loss offset i e the immediate refund of taxes for losses incurred many corporations

new evidence of regional income divergence in post reform russia this article investigates regional income convergence in russia during 2000 2008 we test the hypothesis in which income divergence across regions of the country should give place to income convergence as the country moves toward free market economy with strong market institutions the study contributes to the existing literature by using the exponential smooth autoregressive augmented dickey fuller adf unit root test in a panel setup a novel econometric technique which encompasses cross sectional dependence results show strong evidence of on going regional income divergence in post reform period

tax revenue losses through cross border loss offset an insurmountable hurdle for formula apportionment abstract this paper analyzes the relevance of firm losses for tax revenues and welfare when switching from separate accounting to a system of tax base consolidation with formula apportionment we find that a system change unambiguously decreases tax revenues in the short run in which neither firms nor governments can adjust their behavior due to the cross border loss offset inherent in formula apportionment in the medium run in which only firms can adjust their strategies tax revenues are still lower under formula apportionment if the probability of incurring losses or the costs of profit shifting are sufficiently small however in the long run where firms and governments can adjust their behavior a switch from separate accounting to formula apportionment is beneficial under the aforementioned conditions furthermore we show that a higher weight on input shares in the apportionment formula may mitigate tax competition and thus increase tax revenues because contrary to output factors input factors provide a backstop against a shortfall of tax revenues due to loss making subsidiaries

do countries compete over corporate tax rates this paper tests whether oecd countries compete with each other over corporate taxes in order to attract investment we develop two models with firm mobility countries compete only over the statutory tax rate or the effective average tax rate while with capital mobility countries compete only over the effective marginal tax rate we estimate the parameters of reaction functions using data from 21 countries between 1983 99 we find evidence that countries compete over all three measures but particularly over the statutory tax rate and the effective average tax rate this is consistent with a belief amongst governments that location choices by multinational firms are discrete we also find evidence of concave reaction functions consistent with the model outlined in the paper

the physical economy of the european union cross country comparison and determinants of material consumption abstract in this paper we investigate what determines observed differences in economy wide material use among the eu 15 member states the empirical basis for our analysis is an extended and revised material flow data set for each of the eu 15 countries in time series from 1970 to 2001 this data set comprises consistent data for domestic extraction imports and exports as well as for derived material flow indicators broken down by 12 types of materials we compare the level and composition of domestic material consumption dmc in the eu 15 member states and identify determinants of the observed differences across the european union member states overall dmc per capita varies by a factor of three ranging between 12 tonnes per capita in italy and the united kingdom and 37 tonnes per capita in finland this variability of dmc in the eu 15 is in a similar order of magnitude as the variability of gdp per capita or total primary energy supply per capita linear correlation analysis reveals that national income and final energy consumption relate to material use but cannot fully account for the observed differences in material consumption by breaking down overall material flow indicators into 12 categories of materials and analysing their use patterns in detail we identified a number of factors socio economic and natural that influence the level and composition of economy wide material use many of these factors are specific for certain types of materials others are more general and quite some driving factors counteract each other regarding the direction of their influence concluding we summarize the most important driving factors for domestic material consumption stressing population density as largely neglected but important explanatory variable for material use patterns discuss issues of environmental significance aggregation and the use of different denominators in material flow accounting and suggest a re interpretation of dmc

industrial profitability and trade among the former soviet republics the break up of the soviet union claudia senik leygonie and gordon hughes this article looks at profitability and trade in the republics of the former soviet union looking at individual industries republic by republic there emerges a picture of some highly profitable sectors along with others with negative value added the most profitable industries mostly associated with oil and gas extraction are the least protected the least intensive in labour and already the most developed the least efficient industries include food processing and light industry and are the most protected ones trade patterns both within the former soviet union and with the rest of the world are unrelated to comparative advantage consequently sizable gains from trade are potentially available and the relevant industries are identified when the single trade balance constraint is replaced by constraints at the republic level it is clear that russia stands to benefit from not having to cover with its surpluses the deficits of the other republics russia again along with kazakhstan and ukraine should benefit from a shift to market based terms of trade

comparative dis advantage in russian agriculture the economic reform that began in russia in the early 1990s has spurred major changes in the structure and volume of the country s agricultural production and trade this paper examines whether russia has a comparative advantage in agricultural outputs compared to agricultural inputs and whether it has a comparative advantage in bulk crops versus meat the paper also investigates whether the changes in russia s agricultural production and trade during transition have been consistent with the country s agricultural comparative advantage as indicated by the empirical results

corporation tax finance and the cost of capital this paper examines the influence of corporate tax exhaustion on the firm s financial and investment decisions a dynamic programming model is used to establish effective marginal tax rates in the presence of a tax system that permits the carry forward of losses to future periods the paper demonstrates that internal optimal financial structures may result which do not require the imposition of external constraints the cost of capital is highly sensitive to the current taxable earnings of the firm and the implications of this for such tax transfer activities as leasing are discussed

tax competition with imperfectly mobile capital abstract this paper considers interjurisdictional tax competition in a two period model with imperfectly mobile capital in the first period capital is perfectly mobile in the second period however capital cannot move perfectly because of transactions costs once employed in a jurisdiction in the first period this imperfect mobility of capital may lead to the overprovision rather than the underprovision of public goods in the second period and may make jurisdictions compete more aggressively for capital in the first period

the provision of local public goods and factors in the presence of firm and household mobility abstract this paper studies the efficiency properties of allocations when firms and households are mobile and when local governments provide local public goods and local public factors the analysis differentiates between immobile land owners and perfectly mobile workers and concludes that an efficient allocation is obtained if there is no outflow of land rents to absentee owners if rents flow out only local public goods are supplied in accordance with the samuelson rule the provision of local public factors is inefficiently low however and jurisdictions tax mobile firms and mobile households inefficiently high in order to restrict the outflow of rents an optimal intervention scheme is derived in this case we also analyze the distortions that result when the non availability of local head taxes makes it impossible to internalize crowding costs

bank privatization finance and growth abstract this paper examines whether privatizing state owned banks improves finance and economic growth to do so we exploit regional banking variations in russia induced by the idiosyncratic creation of specialized banks in the last years of the soviet union 1988 91 that were subsequently privatized starting in 1999 private banks including surviving spetsbanks emerged as an important source of external finance for private firms and households we document that the regional concentration of spetsbanks in the early years of the russian federation is orthogonal to economic fundamentals that are related to growth after the emergence of bank finance results indicate that while privatized banking increased lending significantly it did not increase economic growth however privatization did increase growth when banks retained fewer political connections and when regional property rights were better protected highlighting the importance of both factors

to steal or not to steal firm attributes legal environment and valuation data on corporate governance and disclosure practices reveal wide within country variation that decreases with the strength of investors legal protection a simple model identifies three firm attributes related to that variation investment opportunities external financing and ownership structure using firm level governance and transparency data from 27 countries we find that all three firm attributes are related to the quality of governance and disclosure practices and firms with higher governance and transparency rankings are valued higher in stock markets all relations are stronger in less investor friendly countries demonstrating that firms adapt to poor legal environments to establish efficient governance practices

on the implications of introducing cross border loss offset in the european union abstract this article investigates a tax competition model where countries compete for capital and profits of multinational enterprises mnes through statutory tax rates and cross border loss offset provisions which allow a transfer of foreign subsidiaries losses to the parent company a joint implementation of full cross border loss relief is welfare maximizing because it ensures production efficiency and no profit shifting in equilibrium local governments choose zero level of the loss relief in a noncooperative equilibrium if only capital is mobile and relax the loss offset when mnes engage in profit shifting therefore allowing multinationals to undertake international tax planning activities may be welfare improving in our model

the great divide and beyond financial architecture in transition a growing and deepening divide has opened up between transition countries where economic development has taken off and those caught in a vicious cycle of institutional backwardness and macroeconomic instability this great divide is visible in almost every measure of economic performance gdp growth investment government finances growth in inequality general institutional infrastructure and increasingly in measures of financial development strategies for financial development have differed dramatically across countries and over time offering interesting opportunities to study the links between real and financial sector development