spectrum auction designs and revenue variations this study examines a sample of 93 national 3g spectrum auctions for the period 2000 2011 to identify the sources of substantial revenue variations an implied reduced form econometric model that recognises the censored nature of the sample relates per capita winning bid per mhz per million populations values to regulator determined auction design characteristics auction competitiveness mobile wireless market conditions and spectrum package attributes identified from tender documents the analysis reveals that among other factors all auction design characteristics independently impact on realized 3g spectrum auction revenues

intergenerational income group mobility and differential fertility one question development economists are especially interested in but so far left unanswered is how would the societal income distribution be affected by introducing a family planning program to reduce the reproduction rate of the poor which is usually high in developing countries the purpose of this paper is to search for analytical answers to this question we are able to make definite comparisons about some class of inequality measures of the steady state societal income distributions and these comparisons provide strong theoretical support in favor of the above mentioned family planning program excerpt

the distribution of wealth measurement and models abstract analysts debating the consequences of a policy change for the wealth distribution may come to different conclusions because of different views about how the distribution should be defined and measured or about the processes determining the distribution the aim of this survey is to provide an analytical framework within which such conflicts may be assessed the first part of the paper discusses conceptual issues in the definition of wealth and compares methods of deriving estimates of wealth distribution the second and larger part of the paper surveys lifecycle and intergenerational models of the distribution of wealth including a discussion of the role played by inheritance the presentation is largely theoretical indeed one of the paper s conclusions is that empirical modelling of the wealth distribution is under developed at least for the purposes of addressing many topical policy issues

testing symmetry and proportionality in ppp a panel data approach purchasing power parity ppp is a proposition equating the nominal exchange rate to the ratio of the domestic to foreign price levels this article employs bayesian panel data methods to test for ppp in particular the implied symmetry and proportionality conditions using a dataset of all the organization for economic cooperation and development member countries in the post bretton woods era i do not find support for symmetry and proportionality in ppp over time and across countries

trying to explain home bias in equities and consumption investors hold a substantially larger proportion of their wealth portfolios in domestic assets than standard portfolio theory would suggest a phenomenon called equity home bias in the absence of this bias investors would optimally diversify domestic output risk using foreign equities therefore consumption growth rates would tend to co move across countries even when output growth rates do not empirically however consumption growth rates tend to have a lower correlation across countries than do output growth rates a phenomenon i call consumption home bias in this paper i discuss these two biases and their potential relationship as suggested by the literature

self enforcing exchange among generations implications for consumption and mobility abstract a three generation olg model with one directional altruism and two directional intra family transfers is presented adults invest in their children s education and make transfers to their elderly parents however due to lack of altruism adults with high earnings do not share consumption equally with their elderly parents but spend a larger share of their earnings on own consumption and on their children s education this allows the model to be consistent with three empirical observations that are difficult to reconcile with traditional altruistic frameworks of intergenerational social interactions and mobility i consumption is not perfectly shared between members of an extended family ii consumption is not equally persistent over the lifecycle as across generations and iii the intergenerational persistence of earnings is particularly high at the top end of the earnings distribution

decomposing intergenerational income elasticity the gender differentiated contribution of capital transmission in rural philippines summary using longitudinal data from rural philippines we decompose intergenerational income elasticity ige into five distinct pathways intergenerational transmissions of health education land and spouse education capital plus residual correlation in productivity intergenerational human capital transmissions from mothers are stronger than those from fathers maternal education is the parental capital most strongly associated with ige while naive ige estimates are indistinguishable for sons and daughters the pathways that generate these results differ strikingly for sons ige is entirely explained by parent to child capital transmission by contrast strong income correlation exists between daughters and parents even after controlling for parent and child capital endowments

second price common value auctions under multidimensional uncertainty the literature has demonstrated that second price common value auctions are sensitive to the presence of asymmetries among bidders in a two bidder model bikhchandani 1988 reputation in repeated second price auctions j econ theory 46 97 119 has shown that if it is common knowledge that one bidder has a disadvantage compared to her opponent that bidder almost surely never wins the auction employing a similar two bidder model this paper shows that this result does not carry over when one allows for two sided uncertainty in such case in every equilibrium the disadvantaged type bidder needs to win the auction with strictly positive probability we then solve for the equilibria in two cases one with two types and another with a continuum of types and we show that they converge to the symmetric equilibria of the corresponding symmetric auctions we thus reestablish a lost linkage in the analysis of common value and almost common value auctions

distributional effects of public education in an economy with public pensions we study how the allocation of government expenditures between two major outlays education and pay as you go social security affects human capital distribution in an economy with heterogeneous agents we consider an overlapping generations economy where the government maintains both programs and allocates tax revenues to finance them in our model human capital is one of the factors of production it is itself produced as a combined result of public inputs and private inputs parents decisions to invest time and material resources in education of their children are motivated by altruism heterogeneous in its strength across the population which leads to heterogeneity of incomes we investigate the effect of an increase in public funding for education on the human capital distribution we show that in this framework contrary to some earlier results increased spending on public education may lead to higher inequality our results depend crucially on the interaction of education funding with the social security budget and on the elasticity of substitution in the learning technology

the economics of poverty traps and persistent poverty an asset based approach abstract longitudinal data on household living standards open the way to a deeper analysis of the nature and extent of poverty while a number of studies have exploited this type of data to distinguish transitory from more chronic forms of income or expenditure poverty this paper develops an asset based approach to poverty analysis that makes it possible to distinguish deep rooted persistent structural poverty from poverty that passes naturally with time due to systemic growth processes drawing on the economic theory of poverty traps and bifurcated accumulation strategies this paper briefly discusses some feasible estimation strategies for empirically identifying poverty traps and long term persistent structural poverty as well as relevant extensions of the popular foster greer thorbecke class of poverty measures the paper closes with reflections on how asset based poverty can be used to underwrite the design of persistent poverty reduction strategies

educational inequality and intergenerational mobility in latin america a new database abstract the causes and consequences of the intergenerational persistence of inequality are a topic of great interest among various fields in economics however until now issues of data availability have restricted a broader and cross national perspective on the topic based on rich sets of harmonized household survey data we contribute to filling this gap by computing time series for several indexes of relative and absolute intergenerational education mobility for 18 latin american countries over 50 years and making them publicly available we find that intergenerational mobility is on average rising in latin america this pattern seems to be driven by the high upward mobility of children from low educated families at the same time there is substantial immobility at the top of the distribution significant cross country differences are observed and are associated with income inequality poverty economic growth public educational expenditures and assortative mating

four invalid propositions about equality efficiency and integenerational transfers through schooling four propositions that have been advanced on the basis of verbal intuition are considered they are given precise interpretation in a formal model and then disproved the propositions concern intergenerational transfers through schooling in particular they concern equality efficiency conflicts net benefit calculations and the role of genetic transmission

the relative impact of inheritance and other factors on economic inequality an empirically grounded micro simulation of saving with bequests related negatively either in total to average children s income or separately to individual children s incomes is constructed for a single generation in a steady growth economy behavioral parameters are set so that predicted bequests to the next generation are consistent with both the scale and assignment of inheritances taken from a real world source for the simulation generation the relative impact of inheritance and other factors on different aspects of economic inequality is assessed while inheritance is a major cause of wealth inequality its influence on annual income and lifetime resources is small and in the latter case ambiguous inheritance perpetuates and may intensify inequalities arising originally from other causes in that sense it is a secondary cause of inequality but that is not of course to say that it is of secondary importance the extent of its influence on distribution remains an open question which cannot be decided merely by theoretical reasoning but requires in addition something in the nature of a quantitative analysis of the relevant facts wedgwood 1929 pp 60 61

like grand parent like child multigenerational mobility across the eu abstract this study shows that the multigenerational transmission of inequality in most of the 28 eu countries is higher than what a parent to child paradigm would suggest while a strand of the literature claims that this is due to a direct grandparental effect economic historian gregory clark argues that multigenerational mobility follows a markovian process in his view not only are previous estimates severely attenuated by an errors in variables problem but persistence is also constant across time and space using a unique retrospective survey containing information on three generations of european citizens we provide suggestive evidence against such a universal law of mobility while estimates based on measurement error models show that persistence is indeed as strong as clark suggests there are cross country differences furthermore for a few eu countries we cannot reject the hypothesis of a direct grandparental effect overall there is no single data generating process to describe multigenerational persistence that fits all eu countries 2

home bias in equity portfolios inflation hedging and international capital market equilibrium we test whether the home bias in equity portfolios is caused by investors trying to hedge inflation risk the empirical evidence is consistent with this motive only if investors have very high levels of risk tolerance and equity returns are negatively correlated with domestic inflation we then develop a model of international portfolio choice and equity market equilibrium that integrates inflation risk and deadweight costs using this model we estimate the levels of costs required to generate the observed home bias in portfolios consistent with different levels of risk aversion for a level of risk aversion consistent with standard estimates of the domestic equity market risk premium these costs are about a few percent per annum greater than observable costs such as withholding taxes thus the home bias cannot be explained by either inflation hedging or direct observable costs of international investment unless investors have very low levels of risk aversion article published by oxford university press on behalf of the society for financial studies in its journal the review of financial studies

do auctions and forced divestitures increase competition evidence for retail gasoline markets to foster competition governments can intervene by auctioning licenses to operate or by imposing divestitures the dutch government has done exactly that organizing auctions to redistribute tenancy rights for highway gasoline stations and imposing divestitures of such stations on the four major companies we evaluate this policy experiment and find that the auctioning of licenses without an obligation to divest has no discernible effect on prices an obligation to divest lowers prices by 1 3 2 3 at divested sites moreover prices decrease by 0 9 1 2 at sites nearby this suggests that the observed price decreases are at least partly due to competitive spillovers

dynamic asset allocation when bequests are luxury goods abstract luxury bequests impart systematic effects of age to an investor s optimal allocation the expected percentage allocation to equities rises throughout retirement when bequests are luxuries the marginal utility of bequests declines more slowly than the marginal utility of consumption this is essentially lower risk aversion as a retiree approaches death her expected remaining lifetime utility is increasingly composed of bequest utility and thus generates progressively lower risk aversion a retiree responds by increasingly favoring the higher return risky asset compared to standard preferences luxury bequests elevate a retiree s average exposure to the risky asset but the difference is small in early retirement

markov perfect equilibria in altruistic growth economies with production uncertainty this paper concerns the existence of markov perfect equilibria in altruistic growth economies previous work on deterministic models has established existence only under extremely restrictive conditions we show that the introduction of production uncertainly yields an existence theorem for aggregative infinite horizon models with very general forms of altruism journal of economic literature classification numbers

pride and prejudice using ethnic sounding names and inter ethnic marriages to identify labour market discrimination labour markets discriminate against workers with particular ethnic sounding names we use non random sorting into interethnic marriage and salient differences between sephardic and ashkenazi surnames to evaluate the causal impact of sephardic affiliation on wages using the 1995 israeli census we estimate the effect of a sephardic sounding surname on wages we first compare the wages of israeli jewish males born to sephardic fathers and ashkenazi mothers sa who are more likely to carry a sephardic surname with the wages of israeli jewish males born to ashkenazi fathers and sephardic mothers as we find that israeli labor markets discriminate based on perceived ethnicity sa workers earn significantly less than their as counterparts we then exploit the custom of women to adopt their husbands surnames to disentangle actual ethnicity from the ethnicity perceived by the market consistent with ethnic discrimination based on surnames we find that it is father in law s ethnicity rather than father s ethnicity that shapes female wage rates finally we find that labor markets discriminate based on surname only when those names provide additional information about ethnicity when ethnicity can be discerned from skin tone surnames do not provide additional explanatory power with respect to wages

wealth inequality and intergenerational links previous work has had difficulty generating household saving behaviour that makes the distribution of wealth much more concentrated than that of labour earnings and that makes the richest households hold onto large amounts of wealth even during very old age i construct a quantitative general equilibrium overlapping generations model in which parents and children are linked by accidental and voluntary bequests and by earnings ability i show that voluntary bequests can explain the emergence of large estates while accidental bequests alone cannot and that adding earnings persistence within families increases wealth concentration even more i also show that the introduction of a bequest motive generates lifetime savings profiles more consistent with the data

bequest and wealth accumulation are some pieces of the puzzle missing the lively debate between laurence j kotlikoff and franco modigliani presented in the spring 1988 issue of this journal concerns an old question what is the main motivation for saving and therefore for the accumulation of wealth more specifically what are the respective contributions to aggregate wealth of 1 saving for retirement also known as hump saving 2 precautionary savings and unintended bequests due to uncertainty about the length of life and 3 planned bequests of course other wealth holding motives are possible but let us follow kotlikoff and modigliani in setting them aside for now if modigliani s life cycle hypothesis is to be viewed as a close to approximation of reality then the bulk of existing wealth should have resulted from some combination of hump and precautionary saving our comment on this dispute attempts to advance two issues first the controversy involves an enormous gap between empirical estimates of the share of inherited wealth in total accumulation even though the estimates are often based on the same data we hope to clarify why the estimates vary so widely second the kotlikoff modigliani dispute is presented as an american issue with little extension abroad we will present some results from other countries that bear on the controversy some of the estimates from kotlikofi s paper originated in a 1981 paper he wrote with lawrence summers which is why we sometimes refer to his position as the kotlikoff summers argument in this comment the problem of conceptualizing the contribution of bequest to aggregate savings can be summarized with a thought experiment assume all bequests were confiscated

when equal opportunity is not enough training costs and intergenerational inequality this paper develops an individual optimization model with persistent intergenerational immobility its key feature is that training costs are negatively correlated with family background leading to differences in privately optimal training levels across population groups heterogeneity of innate abilities is shown to reduce but not eliminate the importance of family backgrounds conversely wage thresholds which result from indivisibilities in the production or training functions or noncompetitive elements in the economy such as segmented labor markets increase the scope for inequality in the steady state

the reality of stock market jumps diversification abstract we propose a non parametric procedure for estimating systemic co jumps and independent idiosyncratic jumps for 35 stock markets and study news associated with these jumps as reported in factiva and bloomberg from 1988 to 2014 our results suggest that it is important to distinguish between systemic co jumps and idiosyncratic jumps we find both types of jumps have important implications for home bias investors while idiosyncratic jumps have economically significant impact on portfolio weights for emerging markets our news analysis suggests systemic jumps are typically caused by currency crises sectoral failure liquidity issues and deteriorating economic climate while idiosyncratic jumps are usually caused by political unrest currency instability and large firm effects on small economies in fact many of the idiosyncratic jumps share the same origin although different stock markets experienced the impact differently at different times

estimation of short run and long run elasticities of energy demand from panel data using shrinkage estimators this article discusses the problem of obtaining short run and long run elasticities of energy demand for each of 49 states in the united states using data for 21 years estimation using the time series data by each state gave several wrong signs for the coefficients estimation using pooled data was not valid because the hypothesis of homogeneity of the coefficients was rejected shrinkage estimators gave more reasonable results the article presents in a unified framework the classical empirical bayes and bayes approaches for deriving these estimators

on the effects of barriers to international investment a simple model is presented in which it is costly for domestic investors to hold foreign assets the implications of the model for the composition of optimal portfolios at home and abroad are derived it is shown that all foreign assets with a beta larger than some beta plot on either one of two security market lines some foreign assets with a beta smaller than are not held by domestic investors even if their expected return is increased slightly while it is obviously not true that asset markets are completely segmented between countries there is evidence of barriers to international investment although reality seems to lie in that grey area between complete segmentation and no segmentation at all most international asset pricing models are concerned with the extreme case of no barriers to international investment no effort seems to have been made to study the effect on portfolio choice of such barriers which make it costly to hold foreign securities as opposed to domestic securities but which do not in general render international diversification so onerous that investors avoid foreign securities completely casual empiricism suggests that models without barriers to international investment should be suspect those models cannot explain why it appears that in every country investors on average hold more domestic securities than would be required if they held the world market portfolio 2 this paper constructs a model of international asset pricing in which there is a cost associated with holding either long or short risky foreign securities for the sake of simplicity in most of the paper we assume that while domestic investors face barriers to international investment foreign investors face no such barriers it turns out that nothing significant is lost with such an assumption the main conclusions of this paper for the case in which foreign investors face no barriers to international investment are 1 in the presence of barriers to international investment some risky foreign

capital income taxation wealth distribution and borrowing constraints the theorem of zero taxation of capital income is reexamined and is shown to hinge critically on the assumptions of a long horizon and perfect markets for the inter temporal allocation of resources the theorem does not hold when borrowing constraints prevent individuals from insuring against idiosyncratic shocks and have a precautionary motive for savings structural assumptions are made such that with no taxation aggregate savings are socially excessive in the long run i e the rate of return is smaller than the discount rate sufficient conditions for a pareto efficient taxation or subsidization of capital in the long run depend on the correlation between individuals consumption and savings a subsidy may be efficient when individuals incomes follow a predictable pattern of life cycles with no negative bequest 2001 elsevier science b v all rights reserved

job information networks neighborhood effects and inequality this paper explores the theoretical and empirical literature to examine the use by different social groups of informal sources of information provided by friends relatives and acquaintances during job search and its consequences for the job market it also addresses the role of network structure and size the resource endowments of contacts and nature of the links between contacts to explain differences in the effects of job information networks in doing so the paper also turns to the sociology literature on job information networks and provides an economic perspective on such sociological concepts as strong versus weak ties inbreeding distance from structural holes etc the paper distinguishes between models of exogenous job information networks that is where individuals obtain job related information through a given social structure and endogenous job information networks which are social networks that result from individuals uncoordinated actions the paper pays special attention to such issues as physical and social proximity and sharing of information and discusses them in the context of the recent social interactions and neighborhood effects literature finally the paper outlines a model that integrates job information networks where interactions occur in business cycle frequencies with the dynamics of human capital formation which include the joint effects of parental community and neighborhood human capital and are set in life cycle frequencies for the purpose of organizing suggestions for future research and examining earned income inequality

distribution and growth in models of imperfect capital markets abstract a full analysis of the distribution of income should include both the inequality in income between different generations of the same family what is usually called intergenerational ocial mobility and the inequality in income between different families in the same generation becker tomes 1979 p 1154

foreign direct investment the human dimension this paper argues that fdi is plagued by information asymmetries and moral hazard problems which can be ameliorated by face to face interaction an equilibrium model of fdi indicates that better ability to discriminate among alternative projects in a foreign country through personal contact will increase foreign investment into that country and spur more investment back from that country we examine the relationship between fdi and three proxies for personal interaction distance language and travel we find strong evidence supporting the importance of the human dimension in fdi particularly that associated with travel the direction of influence appears to be of travel on fdi rather than fdi on travel

the economics of poverty traps and persistent poverty empirical and policy implications the moral and economic imperatives to intervene in poverty traps motivate the identification of poverty traps and their structural causes so as to inform the design of appropriate policy responses however empirical identification remains challenging because of poverty traps complexity after reviewing mechanisms that can generate poverty traps we focus on one multiple financial market failures emphasising its heretofore underappreciated testable implications including specific behaviours that are rational only in the presence of a poverty trap we therefore recommend tests for these behaviours rather than more econometrically challenged efforts to directly test for poverty traps in estimated asset dynamics

economic interpretations of intergenerational correlations science itself for example see galton s 1869 study of the eminence of relatives or his 1889 analysis of the heights of parents and children but extensive use of economic theory to interpret these correlations is much more recent using basic economic concepts such as supply demand investment incentives missing markets and so on theorists hope to explain how and why status is correlated across generations economic theory might provide a unified treatment of a variety of socioeconomic indicators such as earnings income occupation or wealth or it might predict how taxes subsidies and economic regulation affect intergenerational mobility and the operation of markets however while the subject matter earnings consumption wealth occupa tion is clearly interesting to economists it could nonetheless be the case that beyond basic questions of measurement economic theory has not improved our understanding of intergenerational mobility goldberger 1989 is quite explicit in this contention by emphasizing the distinction between genes and environment and by using statistical theory as its main analytical tool the paper by samuel bowles and herbert gintis in this issue implicitly concurs with goldberger we take this challenge very seriously what characterizes an economic approach to mobility while biologists and bowles and gintis distinguish endowments and investments by their source genetic versus environmental factors one focus of economic theorists is motiva

on five hot issues on wealth distribution throughout the last twenty years a lot of attention has been devoted by economists to the accumulation and distribution of wealth it appears clearly that we are now quite rich in hypotheses and models but still very poor in data this brief paper will focus on five hot issues on the distribution of wealth 1 is wealth inequality mainly due to income differences 2 what is the quantitative importance of inheritance on wealth accumulation and inequality 3 is equal sharing an egalitarian rule 4 do consumers segmentation or assets distinction help understanding wealth distribution 5 is there a long term increase or decrease of the strikingly similar degree of wealth inequality among industrialized countries

model misspecification and underdiversification in this paper we study intertemporal portfolio choice when an investor accounts explicitly for model misspecification we develop a framework that allows for ambiguity about not just the joint distribution of returns for all stocks in the portfolio but also for different levels of ambiguity for the marginal distribution of returns for any subset of these stocks we find that when the overall ambiguity about the joint distribution of returns is high then small differences in ambiguity for the marginal return distribution will result in a portfolio that is significantly underdiversified relative to the standard mean variance portfolio

the effects of compulsory schooling on growth income distribution and welfare abstract in this paper we consider an olg model with productive capital and human capital affecting the quality of labor in each generation parents invest in their children s education but disregard its external effect on the aggregate production function government intervention in providing compulsory schooling increases economic growth along the equilibrium path while the intragenerational income distribution becomes more equal also in the long run the majority of individuals in each generation are better off due to compulsory schooling

talent growth and income distribution a model with heterogeneous individuals and bequests between generations is constructed to analyze income distribution and educational choice the introduction of an imperfection in the credit market is shown to influence the allocation of talent both ability and bequest are of relevance in deciding whether or not to invest in education with learning by doing between generations the allocation of talent affects not only the level of production but also the growth rate copyright 1993 by the editors of the scandinavian journal of economics

the intergenerational transmission of employers we find that about 40 of a cohort of young canadian men have been employed at some time with an employer for which their father also worked and 6 9 have the same employer in adulthood the intergenerational transmission of employers is positively related to paternal earnings particularly at the very top of the earnings distribution and to the presence of self employment income and the number of employers with which the father has had direct contact it has an important influence on nonlinear patterns in the intergenerational elasticity of earnings

intergenerational earnings mobility inequality and growth abstract we examine a model in which per capita income inequality intergenerational mobility and returns to education are all determined endogenously individuals earn wages depending on their ability which is a random variable they purchase an education with transfers received from their parents and are subject to liquidity constraints in the model multiple steady state equilibria are possible countries with identical tastes and technologies can reach differing rates of mobility inequality and per capita income equilibria with higher levels of output also have lower inequality higher mobility and more efficient distribution of education

a theory of intergenerational mobility we study the link between market forces cross sectional inequality and intergenerational mobility emphasizing complementarities in the production of human capital we show that wealthy parents i

the desegregating effect of school tracking this paper makes the following point detracking schools that is preventing them from allocating students to classes according to their ability may lead to an increase in income residential segregation it does so in a simple model where households care about the school peer group of their children if ability and income are positively correlated tracking implies that some high income households face the choice of either living in the areas where most of the other high income households live and having their child assigned to the low track or instead living in lower income neighbourhoods where their child would be in the high track under mild conditions tracking leads to an equilibrium with partial income desegregation where perfect income segregation would be the only stable outcome without tracking

the impact of intergenerational transfers on household wealth inequality in japan and the united states our paper sheds light on the implications of intergenerational transfers for wealth inequality by examining whether or not individuals who receive intergenerational transfers from their parents are more likely to leave bequests to their children than those who do not using microdata for japan and the united states the estimation results show that the receipt of intergenerational transfers from parents and or parents in law increases the likelihood of individuals leaving bequests to their children in both japan and the united states which in turn is likely to contribute to the persistence or widening of wealth disparities however such a tendency is found to be stronger among less better off households in both countries and this may help alleviate the disequalising effect of intergenerational transfers on the distribution of wealth at least to some extent

inheritance and wealth inequality evidence from population registers we use new population wide register data on inheritances and wealth in sweden to estimate the causal impact of inheritances on wealth inequality we find that inheritances reduce relative wealth inequality e g the gini coefficient falls by 5 10 percent but that absolute dispersion increases examining different parts of the wealth distribution we find that the top decile s wealth share decreases substantially whereas the wealth share of the bottom half increases from a negative to a positive share in essence wealthier heirs inherit larger amounts but less wealthy heirs inherit more relative to their pre inheritance wealth we also find that post inheritance behavioral adjustments mitigate the equalizing effect of inheritances because less wealthy heirs consume larger shares of their inheritances moreover we find that the swedish inheritance tax reduced the equalizing inheritance effect but that the redistribution of tax revenues could reverse this result finally we show that inheritances increase wealth mobility

confidence in the familiar an international perspective one striking feature of intemrnational portfolio investment is the extent to which equity portfolios are concentrated in the domestic equity market of the investor the home bias puzzle i examine the role of investors perception of foreign investment risk on their portfolio choices the expected retumrns and risk of foreign investment are specified through an asset pricing model with the home portfolio being the benchmark asset pastor s 2000 domestic capm the model serves as a reference point around which investors can center their prior beliefs i focus on investors prior beliefs that are consistent with the literature on confidence in the familiar foreign equities in terms of both expected returns and risk being viewed less favorably than domestic equities these prior beliefs are then combined with the data on g7 equities and the revised beliefs are used to obtain the global optimal asset allocation to hold predominantly domestic equities each g7 investor has to believe that the risk of foreign investment is several times higher than the actual risk the home bias is more of a puzzle for a u s investor during the 1970s specifying investors prior beliefs around the world capm does not help resolve the puzzle

the cost of equality unequal bequests and tax avoidance abstract for altruistic parents desiring to bequeath their wealth to their children estate taxes can be costly in utility terms the most straightforward way to reduce the tax burden is through inter vivos transfers taking full advantage of potential tax free giving often requires that parents differentiate between children in the amounts transferred this unequal giving contrasts sharply with the presumed desire to make equal bequests this paper examines the extent to which wealthy parents take advantage of tax free giving and whether the desire to spend down an estate is sufficient to induce unequal giving i find that while wealthy parents do appear to make early bequests they rarely do so to the extent permitted by law and thus forego a substantial amount of tax savings

gary becker s contributions to economics from his first published work gary becker has consistently strived to extend the domain of economic analysis his interest is in social science broadly defined and he is convinced that economic theory in its established neoclassical form provides the best set of tools for analysing social science questions when he finds an interesting problem on the borderland of what is conventionally thought of as economics and that is where he is looking for his problems he is not worried that he is trespassing on the traditional grounds of sociologists political scientists lawyers anthropologists or biologists on the contrary he clearly delights in showing how economic theory can be brought to bear on such problems he is of course not alone in trying to extend the borders of economics many other scholars have contributed to the movement which some have characterized as economic imperialism becker is one of the most outstanding of the imperialists this review of his work is organized in accordance with the main topics on which becker has worked chronologically his work on the economics of discrimination which grew out of his doctoral dissertation comes first next in order come his fundamental contributions to human capital theory he was also one of the founders of the so called new theory of consumption which is no longer so new and he has made important contributions to the economic study of crime and punishment and to the economics of political decision making some of his most original work is in the economics of the family where he provides economic explanations of such questions as marriage divorce and procreation after the topic by topic review of becker s contributions i will try to provide a more general evaluation of his work and to characterize it more fully in terms of research traditions and methodological attitudes

the distribution of wealth and welfare in the presence of incomplete annuity markets this paper examines the implications of the absence of complete annuity markets on the distribution of wealth and welfare of agents whose saving decisions are obtained under uncertainty regarding the length of their life the absence of annuities is shown to yield a unique nondegenerate intragenerational distribution of wealth which is fully characterized this characterization is then used to evaluate the pareto desirability of an annuity system alternative welfare criteria that can be used when the proposed change has differential impacts on the initial state of subsequent generations are considered

education technologies wages and technological progress abstract we analyze the worker s incentives to acquire skills under technological progress when the costs of education are endogenous and depend on the wage distribution we show that the agent s intergenerational elasticity of substitution plays then a relevant role in determining how incentives and the long run wage distribution react to technological progress moreover whenever poverty traps of unskilled workers exist higher rates of technological progress can even decrease the incentives of low skill workers to acquire skills we also analyze the effects of educational subsidies in contrast with previous analytical findings we obtain that subsidies always decrease the long run skill premium finally we study the efficiency of the resulting competitive equilibria

intergenerational persistence of earnings the role of early and college education recent empirical evidence from the united states indicates a high degree of persistence in earnings across generations designing effective public policies to increase social mobility requires identifying and measuring the major sources of persistence and inequality in earnings we provide a quantitative model of intergenerational human capital transmission that focuses on three sources innate ability early education and college education we find that approximately one half of the intergenerational correlation in earnings is accounted for by parental investment in education in particular early education we show that these results have important implications for education policy

simulating the transmission of wealth inequality via bequests abstract this paper develops calibrates and simulates a dynamic 88 period olg model to study the intergenerational transmission of u s wealth inequality via bequests the model features marriage realistic fertility patterns random death assortative mating based on skills heterogeneous skill endowments heterogeneous rates of return skill inheritability progressive income taxation and resource annuitization via social security all bequests arise from imperfect annuitization nonetheless the model generates a realistic ratio of aggregate wealth to aggregate labor income a realistic bequest flow relative to the stock of wealth and a realistic wealth distribution at retirement skill differences assortative mating social security and the time preference are the primary determinants of wealth inequality bequests do propagate wealth inequality but only in the presence of social security which disproportionately disinherits the lifetime poor intergenerational wealth immobility also considered here is primarily determined by the inheritance of skills from one s parents and the magnification of the impact of this inheritance by marital sorting

tax and education policy in a heterogeneous agent economy what levels of redistribution maximize growth and efficiency this paper studies the effects of progressive income taxes and education finance in a dynamic heterogeneous agent economy such redistributive policies entail distortions to labor supply and savings but also serve as partial substitutes for missing credit and insurance markets the resulting tradeoffs for growth and efficiency are explored both theoretically and quantitatively in a model that yields complete analytical solutions progressive education finance always leads to higher income growth than taxes and transfers but at the cost of lower insurance overall efficiency is assessed using a new measure that properly reflects aggregate resources and idiosyncratic risks but unlike a standard social welfare function does not reward equality per se simulations using empirical parameter estimates show that the efficiency costs and benefits of redistribution are generally of the same order of magnitude resulting in plausible values for the optimal rates aggregate income and aggregate welfare provide only crude lower and upper bounds around the true efficiency tradeoff

voting education and the great gatsby curve abstract high inequality goes hand in hand with low intergenerational earnings mobility across countries little is known about why the us is characterized by high inequality and low mobility while the opposite tends to hold for scandinavian countries in an overlapping generations model calibrated to the us education policies are endogenized via probabilistic voting by exploiting cross country variation in the bias in voter turnout towards the educated and elderly the model replicates the negative relation between inequality and public education expenditures and accounts for more than a quarter of the variation in inequality and mobility for the us i find that compulsory voting could foster mobility whereas inequality would be hardly affected

intergenerational transfers production and income distribution abstract we consider an overlapping generations economy where the aggregative production process uses physical capital and human capital intergenerational transfers from parents to their children are motivated by altruism we distinguish between two types of transfers investment of parents in the education of their offspring and capital transfer the gift bequest motive we show that the intensity of each type of altruism and hence the composition of the two types of transfers affect significantly the equilibrium output and the intragenerational income distributions comparing competitive equilibria from the same initial distributions of capital transfers and human capital we derive a the economy with the higher education inclined altruism attains lower output and more equal intragenerational income distributions if either the production function s elasticity of substitution is not large or the altruism is weak b for more bequest inclined altruism the effects are usually reversed c under public provision of education higher bequest inclined altruism results in lower output and less equal distribution of income in all dates

the sampling error in estimates of mean variance efficient portfolio weights this paper presents an exact finite sample statistical procedure for testing hypotheses about the weights of mean variance efficient portfolios the estimation and inference procedures on efficient portfolio weights are performed in the same way as for the coefficients in an ols regression ols t and f statistics can be used for tests on efficient weights and when returns are multivariate normal these statistics have exact t and f distributions in a finite sample using 20 years of data on 11 country stock indexes we find that the sampling error in estimates of the weights of a global efficient portfolio is large

why did the equity home bias fall during the financial panic of 2008 investors tend to put most of their wealth in local stocks theories of portfolio choice and uncertainty aversion jointly predict that this home bias should increase during a financial crisis yet using a sample of 45 countries i document that the equity home bias fell during the financial panic of 2008 exploiting bilateral stock holdings i find that investors actively increased their home bias but large valuation changes subsumed these trades across countries the change in home bias is consistent with partial portfolio rebalancing and increased information asymmetries during the crisis

long run growth and human capital this paper analyzes long term growth in a closed economy with human as well as physical capital the human capital corresponds to general education private utility maximization determines each child s schooling costs of educating a given individual are convex although self sustaining growth is not possible steady states with per capita output growing faster than the underlying rate of technological progress do emerge and the magnitude of some comparative static results is increased section 3 attempts to pin down the degree of growth rate amplification implied in practice concluding with estimates of 30 50 percent

awarding telecom licences the recent european experience this paper analyses the procedures used by different european countries for awarding spectrum licences to potential operators of third generation 3g mobile telephone networks we contrast market based methods such as auctions with bureaucratic methods such as beauty contests they have been used for decisions about two major questions 1 how many licences should be awarded and how much spectrum should each licence give access to 2 which companies should receive which licences and how much should they pay for their licences most countries used a bureaucratic process to answer the first question however germany austria and greece were different and constructed auctions in which the number and size of licences were determined by the auction itself as for the second question there was much variation between countries and both auctions and beauty contests were popular methods we have four main findings first the bureaucratic procedure used by most countries to answer the first question led to companies concealing relevant information from the authorities second while firms may have tried to manipulate the procedures used in germany austria and greece to deter entry to their markets they were surprisingly unsuccessful in this third the traditional economic criticisms of beauty contests seem to apply to some but not to all those that were conducted finally the bidding strategies adopted by the telecom companies were often more complex than those predicted by economic theory

introduction to development theory abstractthisarticle introduces the symposium on economic development theory 2007 elsevier inc all rights reserved jel classi cation o11 o12keywords development economics development economics a subject that studies institutions growth inequality and povertyin the developing world is a large lively and exciting area of research the objective of thissymposium is to put together some contributions in economic theory with a distinct focus ondevelopment questions much of early development economics as typi ed in the work of paul rosenstein rodan arthurlewis ragnarnurkse tiborscitovsky allynyoung gunnarmyrdal harveyleibenstein alberthirschman amartyasenandothers wastheoretical thoughnotnecessarilyinthesenseofformalmodel building theseauthorsallfelttheneedtobringnewconceptsintoeconomictheory ideas that would capture the essential features of underdevelopment and provide explanationsof the development process existing economic theory with its focus on competitive markets depersonalized exchange steady technical progress and balanced growth simply did not seemrightwhenmatchedwiththegroundrealitiesofunderdevelopment fragmented imperfect orjustplain missing markets highly personalized transactions in credit insurance or agrarian tenancy ambiguousornonexistentpropertyrights andwidespreadevidenceofpovertytrapsandhistoricallock ins a fair bit of modern economic theory was born in some of these early development writings young s article 40 on increasing returns was perhaps the rst systematic study of noncon vexities in economic growth rosenstein rodan s celebrated paper 32 on post war interven tion in europe provided a conceptual foundation for modern thinking on coordination failures

the family inheritance and the intergenerational transmission of inequality unequal inheritance of material wealth is commonly considered a major cause of inequality in consumption however theoretical models of the intergenerational transmission of inequality by becker blinder and ishikawa imply that unequal inheritance may either increase or reduce consumption inequality differences in inherited wealth resulting from unequal parental incomes increase inequality in recipients consumption however unequal bequests caused by differences among families in the endowed ability of children or the costs of producing human capital are equalizing empirical results confirm these predictions the inheritance received by children is inversely related to both children s income and parental education thus bequests are compensatory in that ceteris paribus low income children inherit more than their advantaged contemporaries

international portfolio diversification with estimation risk international portfolio diversification has long been advocated as a way of enhancing average returns while reducing portfolio risk for the investor who considers diversifying into foreign securities this proposition however relies on the assumption that the required inputs to the classical mean variance analysis are known with certainty typically expected returns variances and covariances are simply replaced by their ex post sample values and the optimal portfolio is derived without mentioning the uncertainty inherent in these parameter values but the rational investor should take this uncertainty into account when forming expectations and probably will consider estimators that are less subject to estimation error than the classical sample mean this paper investigates alternative estimators of expected returns and their implications for the alleged gains from diversification an important observation is the crucial influence that errors in estimating expected returns have on portfolio analysis a closer examiprevious studies of international portfolio diversification have relied on ex post meanvariance analysis without considering the problem of estimation risk typically past averages are substituted for expected returns and no allowance is made for the uncertainty inherent in these parameter values first i demonstrate the shortcomings of such an approach and second i investigate another method of estimating expected returns initially proposed by stein by shrinking the sample averages toward a common mean i find that the out of sample performance of the optimal portfolio is substantially increased one of the implications of this method is that the classical conclusions vastly overestimate the possible gains in average returns instead benefits from diversification are more likely to accrue from a reduction in risk this paper draws on part of my dissertation at the university of chicago i am grateful to arnold zellner michael mussa george constantinides and especially john bilson for useful discussions and comments numerous improvements were also suggested by the referee this research received the generous financial support of the college interuniversitaire d etudes doctorales dans les sciences du management

the distribution of wealth with uncertain income it is well known that an uncertain income stream will induce individuals to save if they are forward looking in this paper we investigate the consequences of such saving on the distribution of wealth among households the inquiry is motivated by the fact that both the dispersion of the us wealth distribution and the variance of transitory income have increased in the recent past surprisingly we find that an increase in earnings uncertainty is more likely to decrease than increase the inequality in wealth holdings

the determinants of price in 3g spectrum auctions this article examined the empirical relationship between prices paid for national 3g wireless licenses when spectrums were sold by auction the reduced form modelling approach was based on the prem

how not to run auctions the european 3g telecom auctions abstract there were enormous differences in the revenues from the european third generation 3g or umts mobile phone license auctions from 20 euros per capita in switzerland to 650 euros per capita in the uk though the values of the licenses sold were similar poor auction designs in some countries facilitated collusion between firms and failed to attract entrants the sequencing of the auctions was also crucial we discuss the auctions in the uk netherlands germany italy austria switzerland belgium greece and denmark

savings and wealth in models with altruistic bequests during recent years much attention has been given to the role of bequests in explaining various aspects of economic behavior for example authors have studied the impact of bequests on physical wealth accumulation laurence kotlikoff and lawrence summers 1981 the interest elasticity of savings owen evans 1983 tax reform laurence seidman 1984 and the distribution of wealth alan blinder 1976a more recently economists have begun to distinguish between human and physical bequests gary becker and nigel tomes 1986 acknowledging the presence of bequest in human form is important in analyzing each of the issues mentioned above outlays on children affect the shape of the family s labor supply and expenditure profiles upon which the level of aggregate savings crucially depends if these outlays are interest sensitive substitutes for physical bequests they will also influence the interest elasticity of savings in the area of tax reform the neutrality of the consumption tax depends on the ability of the government to identify human capital bequests from general consumption raymond batina 1987 if this is not possible the portfolio choice of investment in human versus physical capital may be distorted at the margin finally the unequal transmission of wealth across generations may be explained by the lack of physical bequests and the inefficiently low levels of human bequests made by wealthconstrained households becker and tomes 1986 to distinguish clearly the behavior of constrained households from unconstrained households who make sizeable physical bequests both types of bequests must be recognized this paper introduces a model that makes explicit examination of these issues possible it extends lord s 1989 multiperiod model of life cycle savings and adult human capital investment by adding altruistically motivated human and physical bequests 2 the model is calibrated using microeconomic data on earnings time and goods expenditures on children s human capital and physical bequests we then use the model to examine the contribution of bequests to wealth accumulation and the level of savings this topic is the source of an important but yet unresolved debate between franco modigliani 1988 and kotlikoff 1988 kotlikoff maintains that u s wealth accumulation is primarily the consequence of bequests as opposed to life cycle savings for retirement one type of evidence cited by kotlikoff comes from simulation results demonstrating the failure of realistically calibrated life cycle models to generate sufficiently high saving rates and wealth income ratios alan auerbach and kotlikoff 1987 we show however that if a pure life cycle

stochastic wealth dynamics and risk management among a poor population we use herd history data collected among pastoralists in southern ethiopia to study stochastic wealth dynamics among a poor population although covariate rainfall shocks plainly matter household specific factors including own herd size account for most observed variability in wealth dynamics we find no support for the tragedy of the commons hypothesis past studies may have conflated costly self insurance with stocking rate externalities biophysical shocks move households between multiple dynamic wealth equilibria the lowest suggesting a poverty trap according to nonconvex path dynamics these findings have broad implications for development and relief strategies among a poor population vulnerable to climatic shocks a vast economic literature on risk management rests explicitly or implicitly on the classic friedmanite permanent income hypothesis studies of portfolio management consumption smoothing social insurance and the like all depend on the canonical assumption that stochastic income realisations are drawn from a stationary income distribution leading to consumption smoothing off a stable asset base the possibility of asset accumulation connects this literature to the immense literature on the theory and empirics of economic growth

a theory of trickle down growth and development this paper develops a model of growth and income inequalities in the presence of imperfect capital markets and it analyses the trickle down effect of capital accumulation moral hazard with limited wealth constraints on the part of the borrowers is the source of both capital market imperfections and the emergence of persistent income inequalities three main conclusions are obtained from this model first when the rate of capital accumulation is sufficiently high the economy converges to a unique invariant wealth distribution second even though the trickle down mechanism can lead to a unique steady state distribution under laissez faire there is room for government intervention in particular redistribution of wealth from rich lenders to poor and middle class borrowers improves the production efficiency of the economy both because it brings about greater equality of opportunity and also because it accelerates the trickle down process third the process of capital accumulation initially has the effect of widening inequalities but in later stages it reduces them in other words this model can generate a kuznets curve

regional agricultural endowments and shifts of poverty trap equilibria evidence from ethiopian panel data we examine changes in patterns of equilibria over time and across regions applied to the ethiopia rural household survey we revisit incidence of multiple equilibria using new nonparametric techniques and examine single equilibria that remain stagnant below the poverty line using quantile regressions we identify differences across the income distribution we introduce the empirical analysis of sequences of equilibria we identify a single equilibrium in 1994 1999 but find a second higher equilibrium emerging in 1999 2004 evidencing a shift from unimodal toward a bimodal asset distribution the most deprived region exhibits a low level stagnant equilibrium despite significant rural income growth nationwide

risks and rewards gary becker s contributions to economics gary becker is one of the most original and influential economists of our age his originality lies in extending the frontiers of economics and broadening the range of important social science problems that are amenable to economic analysis he has gone against the grain of establishment thinking in the economics profession invariably choosing to work on problems that were considered beyond the boundaries of modem economics yet this work made close contact with many of the great economists of the past and many of the concepts he invented and developed are now widely if not routinely used in modem economics several of the approaches to problems he pioneered have evolved into fields and specialities in their own right that becker has had an immense intellectual impact and influence in the economics profession is supported empirically by the voluminous citations to his work over the years and in other ways obviously citation counts have well known difficulties and cannot prove anything by themselves but if used in conjunction with more fundamental evidence they do have the virtue of being quantifiable marshall medoff s 1989 1 recent citation study is one of the best available because citations are weighted by the importance of the journals in which articles appear among non nobel prize economists working in u s universities under 65 years of age becker ranks first in total citations over the 1971 85 period to which medoff s study refers and he is first by a very wide margin though the study is limited to economists in the united states it is clear that becker would rank at or very close to the top of any worldwide list furthermore becker s work is virtually all substantive economic analysis hardly any of it is devoted to the development of methodological tools or to surveys both of which gamer citations more easily and many concepts

early and late human capital investments borrowing constraints and the family we develop a dynastic human capital investment framework to study the importance of family borrowing constraints and uninsured labor market risk as well as the process of intergenerational ability

regulator flexibility and the administrative allocation licensing of 3g spectrum globally most nations assign radio spectrum to provide 3g mobile services during the period 1999 2007 while there is consensus among most economists that auctions are the preferred assignment mechanism the assignment mode is split more or less equally in terms of the number of licences issued between administrative allocations and auctions with auction procedures tending to raise more revenue for governments cartelier 2003 the question that naturally arises is why are administrative allocations so popular a method to assign spectrum mcmillan 1995 conjectures that administrative allocations provide additional flexibility accordingly this study examines the performance of 3g assignments in terms of an econometric analysis of a unique sample of national 3g spectrum administrative allocations these outcomes are modelled as depending on spectrum package attributes and post award network deployment requirements

sorting and long run inequality many social commentators have raised concerns over the possibility that increased sorting in society may lead to greater inequality to investigate this we construct a dynamic model of intergenerational education acquisition fertility and marital sorting and parameterize the steady state to match several basic empirical endings we end that increased sorting will signiecantly increase income inequality four factors are important to our endings a negative correlation between fertility and education a decreasing marginal effect of parental education on children s years of education wages that are sensitive to the relative supply of skilled workers and borrowing constraints that affect educational attainment for some low income households

license auctions when winning bids are financed through debt we study an auction where two licenses to operate on a new market are sold and winning bidders finance their bids on the debt market higher bids imply higher debts which affects product market competition when debt induces firms to compete more aggressively retail prices are lower than in a model without debt as are auction revenues when debt induces firms to compete less aggressively retail prices are higher than in a model without debt and the effect on auction revenues is ambiguous net firm profits are always higher than in a model without debt due to endogenous credit rationing

intergenerational transfers and the accumulation of wealth h t ouseholds acquire wealth from two sources they save out of income they have earned and they receive transfers from other people the first method of wealth accumulation goes under the name of life cycle saving in which people save during their working lives and dissave after retirement the second involves either an inter vivos transfer that is a transfer between living people or a bequest a transfer that occurs at the death of the donor while inter vivos transfers and bequests will arise in dynastic models where preferences include a taste for the well being of one s descendents few empirical life cycle models reflect these concerns indeed a sharp debate has arisen over the ability of the simple life cycle model to explain observed wealth accumulation understanding the relative sizes of these sources of wealth accumulation affects a variety of issues for example the effects of government debt social insurance public transfer programs estate taxes and incentives for charitable giving depend to some extent on the magnitude and nature of private saving and transfers of wealth analyses of the inequality of wealth may depend on whether most of wealth is earned or received as transfers appropriate policies for encouraging private saving may look rather different depending on whether most saving is to be consumed later in life or passed along to the next generation finally evidence on transfer patterns relates to more fundamental

wage structure as implicit insurance on human capital in developed versus underdeveloped countries abstract this paper explores the role of wage structure as implicit insurance on human capital it illustrates how smaller wage differentials in the developed world can be welfare enhancing by acting as implicit insurance while larger wage differentials in underdeveloped countries make investments in human capital riskier in other words with smaller wage differentials the students in a developed country are insured against poor educational outcomes through the existence of well paid alternative employments which are not present in the economy of a less developed country this result arises as multiple equilibria in a general equilibrium model when there are no insurance markets for human capital

direct foreign ownership institutional investors and firm characteristics in this paper we characterize foreign ownership using a dataset of ownership and attributes of swedish rms the analysis reveals that foreigners show a preference for large rms rms paying low dividends and rms with large cash positions on their balance sheets when we further analyze the preference for large rms we nd that market liquidity and presence in international markets measured through export sales or listings on other exchanges seem to characterize foreign holdings better than rm size alone foreigners also tend to underweight rms with a dominant owner importantly we demonstrate that most of the features associated with foreign ownership are driven by the fact that foreign investors typically are mutual funds or other institutional investors hence we identify an institutional investor bias rather than a foreign investor bias finally using ownership data on a country level we conclude that the results are particularly strong among u s investors who comprise the largest institutions among foreign investors 2001 elsevier science s a all rights reserved jel classixcation g1 g15

wealth distribution and optimal inheritance taxation in life cycle economies with intergenerational transfers we introduce intergenerational transfers into a general equilihrium life cycle model in order to explain observed levels of wealth heterogeneity in our overlapping generations model heterogenous agents face uncertain lifetime and leave both accidental and voluntary bequests to their cinldren furthermore agents face stochastic employment opportunities the model is calibrated with regard to the characteristics of the us economy our resuits indicate that hequests onl account for a sniall proportion of ohserved wealth heterogeneitv the introduction of an inheritance tax increases both welfare are measured by the average value of the newborn and equality of the wealth distribution preliminary versions of this paper have been presented at conference on intergenerational transfers taxes and the distribution of wealth in uppsala 1999 and the econoinetric societv european meetirig in santiago dc compostela 1999 we would like to thank michael kaganovieli john laitner james smith frank stafford and carl cristian von weizsacker for comments on earlier versions of the paper all remaining errors are ours

the political economy of intergenerational income mobility the intergenerational elasticity of income is considered one of the best measures of the degree to which a society gives equal opportunity to its members while much research has been devoted to measuring this reduced form parameter less is known about its underlying structural determinants using a model with exogenous talent endowments endogenous parental investment in children and endogenous redistributive institutions we identify the structural parameters that govern the intergenerational elasticity of income the model clarifies how the interaction between private and collective decisions determines the equilibrium level of social mobility two societies with similar economic and biological fundamentals may have vastly different degrees of intergenerational mobility depending on their political institutions we offer empirical evidence in line with the predictions of the model we conclude that international comparisons of intergenerational elasticity of income are not particularly informative about fairness without taking into account differences in politico economic institutions jel e24 j62 j68 p16