compensation and rewards for environmental services cres and efficient design of contracts in developing countries behavioral insights from a natural field experiment the use of economic incentives for biodiversity mostly compensation and reward for environmental services including payment for es has been widely supported in the past decades and became the main innovative policy tools for biodiversity conservation worldwide these policy tools are often based on the insight that rational actors perfectly weigh the costs and benefits of adopting certain behaviors and well crafted economic incentives and disincentives will lead to socially desirable development scenarios this rationalist mode of thought has provided interesting insights and results but it also misestimates the context by which real individuals come to decisions and the multitude of factors influencing development sequences in this study our goal is to examine how these policies can take advantage of some unintended behavioral reactions that might in return impact either positively or negatively general policy performances we test the effect of income s origin low effort based money vs high effort based money on spending decisions necessity vs superior goods and subsequent pro social preferences future pro environmental behavior within madagascar rural areas using a natural field experiment our results show that money obtained under low effort leads to different consumption patterns than money obtained under high efforts superior goods are more salient in the case of low effort money in parallel money obtained under low effort leads to subsequent higher pro social behavior compensation and rewards policies for ecosystem services may mobilize knowledge on behavioral biases to improve their design and foster positive spillovers on their development goals

intensive and extensive margins of exports what can india learn from china we decompose india s export performance in manufactured products during 2000 15 into changes at the intensive and extensive margins india s performance along different margins is compared and contrasted with that of china the results show that while china outperforms india at both the margins the gap is particularly wide at the intensive margin decomposition of intensive margin along quantity and price margins shows that chinese products are generally sold cheaper than indian products higher price margin however has not translated into high intensive margin for india due to its abysmally low quantity margin we examine different explanations for china s superior performance relative to india along different margins using a gravity model our results suggest that china s exchange rate policy was not the prime reason for its export success neither do we find that fdi inflows were significant in explaining the export performance gap between them the results show that china s export relationship bias towards high income partner countries holds the key in understanding its superior performance this bias is a natural consequence of china s high degree of specialization in labor intensive activities india by contrast due to an idiosyncratic pattern of specialisation has failed to exploit its export potential in high income countries

optimization of india s power sector strategies using weight restricted stochastic data envelopment analysis abstract india s power sector has a significant impact on the country s development and climate change mitigation efforts optimization of energy planning is therefore key to achieving the overall planning goals the hierarchical multi objective policy optimization is a policy centric multi level bottom up iterative approach designed from a developing country perspective utilizing the optimality principle of dynamic programming it is applied to the indian power sector by grouping the strategies into three portfolios namely power generation mix demand side efficiency group and supply side efficiency group each portfolio is optimized taking into account the objectives of cost minimization and comprehensive risk and barrier reduction the portfolios are further combined and optimized at a higher level with respect to higher level objectives namely economic growth energy equity energy security and climate sustainability this paper focuses on the second level optimization utilizing data envelopment analysis dea both the deterministic and stochastic variations have been analysed and the results compared in respect of unrestricted as well as restricted weight models the analysis shows that weight restricted stochastic dea model is most appropriate for efficiency optimization of power sector strategies the methodology can be effectively used for energy planning in developing countries

the evolution of institutions in india and its relationship with economic growth this paper examines the evolution in a few public institutions over time in india it presents three types of evidence on institutional outcomes such as losses in power generation backlogs in disposal of court cases on perceptions based measures of governance some going back to the 1960s and finally on customs administration and whether it has been more effective at detecting evasion over time all the evidence suggests that institutional quality has not improved over time it then addresses the two way relationship between growth and institutions in terms of two apparent paradoxes the first is why growth has turned around so dramatically in india despite the relatively limited nature of reforms especially compared with other countries the second paradox is why despite nearly 30 years of rapid growth institutions have not improved the paper offers some explanations that might help explain these paradoxes

india trade policy review the review of india s trade policy by the wto the third of its kind is in three parts the report by the wto secretariat a statement by the government of india and minutes of the discussion of the report by the trade policy review board the review provides detailed information not only on india s trade and foreign investment policies but also an analytical review of india s export and economic performance the review notes that india has made considerable progress with the liberalisation of its trade and investment regime but it has a long way to go if it were to achieve a growth rate of eight to nine per cent the stated objective of the policy makers this paper drawing upon the material in the report analyses india s growth prospects and endorses the broad conclusions of the report

international search behavior of business group affiliated firms scope of institutional changes and intragroup heterogeneity this paper investigates whether and when affiliation to business groups enables or constrains firms international search behavior during institutional transitions we theorize that given the unique structure and complex form of business group organizations the search behavior of affiliated firms is influenced by the degree of misalignment in outlook at the group and affiliate levels of management we identify the scope of institutional changes business group attributes and affiliate characteristics as sources of such misalignment the results from panel data on 298 firms from the indian pharmaceutical industry for the 1992 2007 period show that the constraining effects of business group affiliation are observed only when institutional changes are specific to the affiliates industry and not when broad institutional changes affect the business group as a whole moreover we observe heterogeneity in the search behavior of group affiliated firms first the degree of misalignment is greater in the case of affiliates belonging to older business groups and those that are more distant in terms of age and industry since the group s founding second by contrast and suggesting an alignment in outlook we find that affiliated firms that occupy a prominent position within a group or industry are able to bargain for and receive attention and support from the business group to undertake international search our findings have implications for research on the role of business groups in a changing institutional context and for the strategic adaptation of firms embedded in complex organizational and institutional settings

payments for pioneers revisiting the role of external rewards for sustainable innovation under heterogeneous motivations abstract acknowledging the diversity of preferences goals and motivations of individuals is key to promote the effectiveness of incentive based conservation interventions this paper analyses the heterogeneity of motivations to adopt silvopastoral practices a social ecological innovation for soil conservation and carbon emission reduction we use q methodology to identify smallholders views with regard to these practices in a community in the forest frontier in chiapas mexico the analysis uncovers three main perspectives self sufficient pioneers environmentally conscious followers and payment dependent conservatives we discuss these perspectives around three topics smallholders predisposition to adopt silvopastoral practices their views about needing external payments to sustain their livelihood and the diffusion of innovative sustainable practices we relate these perspectives with livelihood characteristics and with observed adoption levels under a pilot programme to promote silvopasture our findings suggest that incentives other than payments may be more appropriate for those more likely to adopt and that payments could encourage rent seeking strategies and not necessarily promote permanent behavioural change we suggest ways for designing more effective and adaptive environmental conservation programmes to foster adoption and continuation of social ecological innovations

determinants of conservation among the rural poor a charitable contribution experiment this paper examines how conservation decisions are affected by environmental degradation donations to an environmental ngo and participation in actual conservation activities capture individual preferences for environmental conservation environmental degradation is measured both through survey based data on experiences of deforestation and environmental shocks and through indices of deforestation constructed with gis data the results show that being exposed to environmental degradation is correlated both with higher donations and conservation behavior the relationship between conservation choices and individual social preferences is also explored experimental measures of individual altruism and inequality aversion and survey measures of trust time preferences and civic engagement are correlated with donations and real world conservation decisions respectively these findings show the role of environmental awareness in fostering environmental conservation even in very poor settings they also highlight the potential of experiments which closely mirror real world decisions to generate conclusions generalizable to individual behavior outside the laboratory

privatisation the market for corporate control and capital flight from russia the estimates of the amount of capital flight vary widely ranging from a low of 30 billion toa high of 300 billion 1privatization the market for corporate control and capital flight from russiaronald w introbedepartment of economics university of w estern ontario1 introductionwhile the data are ambiguous and estimates vary considerably there seems to be a generalconsensus that some perhaps a substantial amount

the diverging patterns of profitability investment and growth of china and india during 1980 2003 summary this paper documents the diverging patterns of capital accumulation profit rates investment rates capital productivity and technological progress of china and india between 1980 and 2003 the two asian economies have followed very different growth patterns and today they face different challenges india s is how to accelerate growth while china s policy makers debate between the need to maintain a high growth rate to generate employment and the imperative to reduce it to cool the economy india must address impediments to investment china must deal with the question of whether investment can continue being the main source of growth

why has china succeeded and why it will continue to do so the key factor underlying china s fast development during the last 50 years is its ability to master and accumulate new and more complex capabilities reflected in the increase in diversification and sophistication of its export basket this accumulation was policy induced and not the result of the market and began before 1979 during the last 50 years china has acquired revealed comparative advantage in the export of both labour intensive products following its factor abundance and sophisticated products although the latter does not mean that there was leapfrogging china is exceptionally well positioned especially taking into account its income per capita to continue learning and gaining revealed comparative advantage in the export of more sophisticated products given adequate policies carefully thought out and implemented reforms and skilful management of constraints and risks china has the potential to continue thriving this does not mean however that high growth will continue indefinitely

co2 emissions from household consumption in india between 1993 94 and 2006 07 a decomposition analysis abstract co 2 emission from anthropogenic activities is one of the major causes of global warming india being an agriculture dependent country global warming would mean monsoon instability and consequent food scarcity natural disasters and economic concerns however with proper policy interventions co 2 emissions can be controlled input output analysis has been used to estimate direct and indirect co 2 emissions by households for 1993 94 1998 99 2003 04 and 2006 07 complete decomposition analysis of the changes in co 2 emissions between 1993 94 and 2006 07 has been done to identify the causes into pollution energy intensity structure activity and population effects according to broad household consumption categories results indicate that activity structure and population effects are the main causes of increase in co 2 emission from household fuel consumption to identify the causes at the sectoral level a second decomposition has been done for changes between 2003 04 and 2006 07 to identify the causes in the next stage finally alternative energy policy options have been examined for each consumption category to reduce emissions combined strategies of technology upgradation fuel switching and market management in order to reduce co 2 emissions for sectors like batteries other non electrical machinery construction and electronic equipments including television for which all the effects are positive need to be adopted

china s macroeconomic performance and management during transition since reforms started in 1978 china has combined rapid growth with moderate price stability this paper analyzes china s macroeconomic performance over the past fifteen years with special attention to factors responsible both for the pace of economic expansion and the periodic fluctuations regarding the former the author identifies four sources of stimuli administrative decentralization high levels of fixed capital investment the elastic supply and quality of the labor force and the increasing volume of savings supplemented in recent years by a large inflow of foreign direct investment future growth with stability calls for controlling and implementing banking and fiscal reform

common fallacies in the debate on the transition to a market economy fallacies and other lessons leszek balcerowicz words and the concepts they express exert a powerful influence on political debate and policy decisions in transition economies in this introductory essay the principal architect of the first radical reform programme in europe after the fall of the berlin wall develops a lexicon of common fallacies in the political debate and introduces many of the main themes of the volume one common fallacy is that of country specificity ukraine is different what worked or did not work elsewhere is not relevant here some countries may indeed have specific economic problems viz the huge military industrial sector in ukraine but economic theory is clear about which policies are best for basic problems macroeconomic stabilization as the appropriate response to hyperinflation price liberalization and liberalization of supply are the prescribed therapy for massive shortages etc so there are useful lessons to be learned from prior experience by the same token erroneous interpretation of those experiences can give credence to mistaken policy arguments for example the argument that whatever has been done before in the west must be right is itself clearly wrong similarly balcerowicz argues that china s success does not prove the universal merits of gradualism the agricultural reforms of the late 1970s in china were in practice surprisingly radical the essay identifies many other pitfalls in reasoning about transition experience several having to do with the failure to apply ceteris paribus reasoning for example the fall in output in 1991 in all the countries connected with the former soviet union including finland was caused in large part by the collapse of their trade with the union and certainly not exclusively by the policies they followed there are numerous other examples

enterprise reform and corporate governance in russia a quantitative survey the objective of this paper is to verify the range and depth of the study on corporate governance in russia through a comprehensive survey of 202 research works with regard to the internal structure of russian corporations a great deal of research has been conducted in a relatively short time since the collapse of the soviet union by many highly motivated researchers who have provided insightful perspectives these achievements however place too much emphasis on the empirical analysis of the interrelation between ownership structure and corporate restructuring leaving some critical themes open for further discussion as the 21st century begins a well balanced research base should be established in this field in order to identify the reality of russian corporations from a multifaceted perspective

the formation of risk sharing networks this paper examines the formation of risk sharing networks in the rural philippines we find that geographic proximity possibly correlated with kinship is a major determinant of mutual insurance links among villagers age and wealth differences also play an important role in contrast income correlation and differences in occupation are not determinants of network links reported network links have a strong effect on subsequent gifts and loans gifts between network partners are found to respond to shocks and to differences in health status from this we conclude that intra village mutual insurance links are largely determined by social and geographical proximity and are only weakly the result of purposeful diversification of income risk the paper also makes a methodological contribution to the estimation of dyadic models

rural urban disparities in india and china abstract this paper compares rural urban disparities in china and india in light of differences in the following indicators income and consumption deposit to credit ratios and agricultural and industrial productivity access to such public services as health are also considered reasons for disparities are sought in government policies affecting agricultural terms of trade credit and rural to urban migration the paper concludes that the chinese economy during the mao zedong period was much more egalitarian than the indian but the case is less clearcut for the deng xiaoping period

india and china contrasts in economic liberalization abstract it is argued that in both india and china despite some important differences 1 a similar cultural and political imperatives led to similar systems of dirigisme and economic outcomes with the chinese growth higher than the indian because of higher investment 2 b crises engendered by their dirigiste regimes impelled reform 3 c their attempts to replace the plan by the market have striking similarities but 4 d ultimately because of continuing atavistic attitudes to toward trade and commerce the reforms remain insecure

are there cultural effects on saving some cross sectional evidence why are there such large differences in saving rates across countries conventional economic analyses have not been successful in explaining international saving differences so economists have sometimes suggested that national saving differences may be explained by cultural differences this paper tests the hypothesis that cultural factors influence saving by comparing saving patterns of immigrants to canada from different cultures using data from the canadian survey of family expenditures we find no evidence of cultural effects on saving

economic reforms in india since 1991 has gradualism worked opinions on the causes of india s growth deceleration vary world economic growth was slower in the second half of the 1990s and that would have had some dampening effect but india s dependence on the world economy is not large enough for this to account for the slowdown critics of liberalization have blamed the slowdown on the effect of trade policy reforms on domestic industry however the opposite view is that the slowdown is due not to the effects of reforms but rather to the failure to implement the reforms effectively this in turn is often attributed to india s gradualist approach to reform which has meant a frustratingly slow pace of implementation however even a gradualist pace should be able to achieve significant policy changes over ten years this paper examines india s experience with gradualist reforms from this perspective

economic experiments for collective action in the kyrgyz republic lessons for payments for ecosystem services pes abstract payments for ecosystem service pes schemes have become increasingly popular in attempting to promote ecological stewardship and conservation behaviour through provisioning of economic incentives often as market inspired transactions the scholarship and empirical application of pes schemes has tended to focus on contract design and conditionality of payments rather than more fundamentally examining whether incentives do indeed influence behaviour in desired ways in this paper a set of incentive framed treatments are introduced to existing collective action institutions promoting common pool resource management in order to explore the effects of incentive provision on the propensity to participate in the maintenance of collectively owned irrigation canals the experiments take place in the kyrgyz republic characterized by the historic transition of nomadic collective traditions subsequent soviet rule to advances towards democracy market integration and the first pes pilot in the country in the incentive treatments provided we reveal the close interplay between the framing of incentives the influence of village leaders mobilizing collective activity and social norms of reciprocity trust and enforcement in mobilizing collective work each framed case study exhibits a unique configuration of individual motivations group norms and other regarding rationalities providing critical insight into this new frontier of pes implementation

technical and structural change and the fall in the manufacturing output capital ratio in mexico 1990 2015 the article studies the fall in the manufacturing output capital oc ratio in mexico in the post trade liberalisation period 1990 2015 from a classical perspective a pattern of falling oc ratio rising labour productivity and greater capital intensity can be interpreted as a case of marx biased technical change a within between industry decomposition shows however that in mexico the fall in the average oc ratio reflects not only within industry technical change but also structural change in the form of a change in the composition of the capital stock towards industries with low or declining oc ratios econometric estimations moreover show that within industry technical change was not related to the initial level or change in domestic labour costs as in the dominant interpretation of the sources of marx biased technical change but was driven instead by mexico s industrial integration with the usa within industry technical change and convergence to us oc ratios dominated in an early phase but were replaced by structural change and divergence in a later phase following the china shock of the early 2000s irrespective of the source of change in the average oc ratio though both within industry technical change in the early phase and structural change in the late one tended to reduce the average profit rate in the mexican manufacturing sector

growth efficiency and convergence in china s state and collective industry in china as in the soviet union and eastern europe economic reform initiatives seek to increase productivity by introducing elements of market oriented policies and institutions into an economy formerly dominated by state planning efforts to evaluate the impact of reform of chinese industry have focused on the measurement of productivity change in state enterprises this study expands the prior framework of analysis in several directions our investigation of productivity trends is not limited to state enterprises but includes quantitative comparisons with china s fast growing collective industries which contributed 36 of overall industrial output in 1988 1 unlike previous studies our analysis works with gross rather than net output this permits us to investigate changes in the productivity of intermediate inputs which occupy a large portion of total costs in chinese industry as well as labor and capital to do this we develop a quasi frontier estimation procedure which seems appropriate for comparisons of total factor productivity based on chinese industrial data finally we offer a quantitative perspective on the extent to which reform efforts have moved industrial resource allocation toward patterns expected of a market system the analysis confirms our previous finding based on a restricted framework employing only labor fixed capital and net output that multifactor productivity in state industry has risen substantially during

socio ecological explanations for crowding out effects from economic field experiments in southern africa abstract economic and psychological literature mentions three conditions under which the crowding out effect of pro social behaviour is likely to occur and to crowd out citizens moral obligations to behave co operatively i use a framed field experiment on joint extraction from a common pool resource cpr where the crowding out effect has already been reported before in combination with the trust game carried out in farming communities of namibia and south africa to replicate these conditions the research design and the cross cultural setting enable to explicitly control for these effects the results of the experiments support that the crowding out effect depends on the nature of the external intervention controlling vs supportive external intervention the degree of participants self determination high vs low self determination in the group a society s norms of trust and reciprocity high vs low trust within the society the results imply that outside regulations aiming to conserve natural resources risk worsening the situation when neglecting democratic legitimization as well as local community norms

analyzing historical and regional patterns of technical change from a classical marxian perspective abstract this paper analyzes whether technical change follows the labor saving capital using marx biased pattern this form of technical innovation underlies marx s explanation of the falling rate of profit long term data for industrialized societies reveal such pattern punctuated by a phase in which both inputs present an increase in productivity regional data from the penn world table supplemented by our standardized net capital stock estimate reveals that most of the world regions have followed the marx biased technical change over the period 1964 1990 however the non marx biased pattern appears in some world regions in the 1980s

infrastructure provision and macroeconomic performance this paper studies the differences between private and government provision of infrastructure capital utilization decisions and their differential role in determining market prices for capital goods under the two regimes of infrastructure provision serve as a critical transmission mechanism for fiscal policy a subsidy to private providers of infrastructure is preferable to direct government provision irrespective of how the subsidy or expenditure is financed the case for private provision is much stronger in economies characterized by high levels of congestion the choice between private and government provision also has a crucial effect on the design of optimal fiscal policy 2011 elsevier b v all rights reserved

collectivization and china s agricultural crisis in 1959 1961 the agricultural crisis in china in 1959 61 after the initial success of the collectivization movement resulted in 30 million extra deaths in this paper a game theory hypothesis proposes the main cause of this catastrophe i argue that because of the difficulty in supervising agricultural work the success of an agricultural collective depends on a self enforcing contract in which each one promises to discipline oneself a self enforcing contract however can be sustained only in a repeated game in the fall of 1958 the right to withdraw from a collective was deprived the nature of the collectivization was thus changed from a repeated game to a one time game as a result the self enforcing contract could not be sustained and agricultural productivity collapsed the empirical evidence is consistent with this hypothesis

motivation crowding in environmental protection evidence from an artefactual field experiment abstract this paper examines how motivation crowding and social image affect environmental conservation decisions an artefactual field experiment conducted in bolivia is used to reproduce the trade off between individual and social benefits in natural resource use and test the effect of non monetary and non regulatory incentives on pro social behavior for environmental conservation the results show the presence of a social norm prescribing positive contribution towards environmental protection and that external incentives have heterogeneous effects on pro social behavior depending on how they influence reputation and self image the experimental results differ from those of analogous experiments conducted in the laboratory and are instead consistent with those from field experiments on common pool resource management this fact suggests caution in generalizing conclusions reached in the laboratory to different settings and populations

the management of common property resources collective action as an alternative to privatisation or state regulation can locally based collective action be a viable way to manage common property resources many writers on collective action and common property are sweepingly pessimistic about the ability of the people who face problems of common property to organize sustainable patterns of use for themselves this paper shows with reference to prisoners dilemma garett hardin s tragedy of the commons and mancur olson s logic of collective action that the analytical basis for this pessimism is weak in many situations of village based common property resource use there can thus be no general presumption that the collective action route to common property resource management will fail any more than there can be a general presumption that it will work the paper suggests a number of general factors to do with the characteristics of the resources the user group and group state relations on which chances of success depend

rural industrialization in china and india role of policies and institutions summary the dynamic rural nonfarm sector in china has been a major contributor to the country s remarkable growth while in india the growth in output and employment in this sector has been rather stagnant this paper argues that the observed patterns in the rural nonfarm development are the results of institutional differences between the two countries especially in their political systems ownership structure and credit institutions a review of the strengths and weaknesses of the rural nonfarm economy in china and india highlights the potentials and challenges of growth in the sector

total factor productivity change in china s farming sector 1952 1989 a crucial problem in economic development is choosing institutions that are relatively efficient in resource allocation and conducive to growth however institutional innovations usually take time and it is often difficult to isolate these effects from the effects of noninstitutional factors modern china is one of the few exceptions it offers a rich experience in dramatic institutional changes after 1949 a smallholder system was experimented with immediately after the land reform this was quickly followed by various forms of collectivization since 1979 the household responsibility system hrs has gradually replaced the commune system thus china provides a unique opportunity for a comparative study of these different rural institutions in terms of the total factor productivity index tfpi this index measures the change in output relative to the change in inputs the examination of the tfpi also has policy implications the apparent plateau in grain production and the slow growth in other crop production from 1985 to 1989 constitute a sharp contrast to the period 1979 84 which witnessed rapid growth in both grain and economic crop production in china public ownership is favored by orthodox ideology and noneconomic factors often play an important role in economic life 2 in facing slower growth in crop production whether the hrs should or should not be the long term rural institution has become a sensitive question again and has kindled a heated debate within china in this study i will examine the performance of the successive rural institutions in china in terms of changes in the tfpi over the period 1952 89 using 1989 as the final year of my study the most important finding of this study is that the hrs showed a clear advan

china s economic growth 1978 2025 what we know today about china s economic growth tomorrow summary this paper examines china s future growth prospects and the potential drivers of future growth using two approaches it first asks in how far china s recent economic development matches standard growth patterns identified in development economics and trade theory second gdp is decomposed into income components which in turn are explained for the reform period by the quantity and quality of labor future gdp can then be re composed from future labor data available today overall china s economic growth is likely to continue at current rates through 2015 before it gradually slows such a growth has numerous implications

spite and development in a wide variety of settings spiteful preferences would constitute an obstacle to cooperation trade and thus economic development this paper shows that spiteful preferences the desire to reduce another s material payoff for the mere purpose of increasing one s relative payoff are surprisingly widespread in experiments conducted in one of the least developed regions in india uttar pradesh in a one shot trust game the authors find that a large majority of subjects punish cooperative behavior although such punishment clearly increases inequality and decreases the payoffs of both subjects in experiments to study coordination and to measure social preferences the findings reveal empirical patterns suggesting that the willingness to reduce another s material payoff either for the sake of achieving more equality or for the sake of being ahead is stronger among individuals belonging to high castes than among those belonging to low castes because extreme social hierarchies are typically accompanied by a culture that stresses status seeking it is plausible that the observed social preference patterns are at least partly shaped by this culture thus an exciting question for future research is the extent to which different institutions and cultures produce preferences that are conducive or detrimental to economic development

the political economy of economic liberalization two of the major policy problems facing governments of developing countries in the 1 980s have been unsustainable external and internal disequilibria and implementation of politically feasible stabilization cum liberalization programs which become necessary to correct these imbalances this article discusses these crises and subsequent policy reform the analysis suggests that balance of payments and fiscal deficits are frequently the result of use of an incorrect accounting system in a fixed exchange rate economy and of public sector expansion beyond its economically feasible size that governments usually seek to liberalize their economies during a crisis to regain control when the growth of the transfer state has led to generalized tax resistance avoidance or evasion that reduction of the government role will be required to alleviate these crises that sharp departures from past policies rather than gradual reform may be politically necessary and that contrary to the current technocratic opinion on this matter the sequencing of a consistent and credible package of reforms which will most effectively reduce the costs of adjustment is initial liberalization of domestic capital markets simultaneous with cuts in the fiscal deficit followed by floating the exchange rate and then commodity market liberalization with the growing importance of internal monetary fund imf stabilization and world bank structural adjustment programs there has been concern about the proper sequencing of the standard stabilization cum liberalization measures contained in these packages in particular there is grave concern at the very mixed and in some cases disastrous effects of liberalization attempts on incomes and employment in the southern cone of latin america in the late 1970s and early 1 980s much of the existing discussion of the order of liberalization is conducted within the traditional technocratic framework which seeks to determine the welfare cost minimizing deployment of policies in the standard stabilization and 1 this assumes a benevolent and well informed government maximizing a social welfare function

completing china s move to the market beginning in late 1978 by luck as much as design china arrived at a strategy for market oriented economic reform that combined substantial reform with rapid growth in gdp and exports the sequencing of reform began with the easy to reform sectors agriculture and foreign trade and then took up the more difficult task of reforming the large state owned enterprises with respect to agriculture small scale industry and foreign investment china found ways of introducing meaningful property rights into the increasingly marketized system a partially unreformed financial system and inadequate autonomy of large state enterprises accounts however for the current stop go nature of chinese development