effects of energy price rise on investment firm level evidence from indian manufacturing sector this paper analyses the effects of the rising prices of energy products on the investment of a large panel of manufacturing firms in india during 1993 2013 the prime motivation behind this study is the absence of an empirical study into this research issue exclusively on indian economy the empirical results obtained by estimating an error correction model ecm using generalized method of moments gmm show that energy price rise has negative effect on the investment of firms in the manufacturing sector the negative effect is transmitted to the firm s investment through both demand side and supply side factors the transmission also depends upon factors such as the energy intensity of production the results also show that the sales growth investment relationship becomes weak in the face of the rising prices of the energy which could be due to the cautious approach to investment adopted by the firms therefore it calls for the attention of the policy makers to evolve a comprehensive energy policy to ensure continuous supply of energy at affordable prices to the manufacturers

tax policy uncertainty and corporate investment abstract the anticipatory effects of a corporate tax reform of the tax cut cum base broadening variety are analyzed in a dynamic stochastic adjustment model of firm behavior focusing on the case where the firm is uncertain both about the timing and the contents of the expected reform the value of the firm is solved prior to and after the reform the existence of investment spurts prior to the implementation of the tax reform is established rigorous results are derived under constant returns and the effects of diminishing returns are explained the expectation of a future tax cut causes the firm to accelerate optimal investment while the expectation of a reduction in the tax base the rate of fiscal depreciation has the opposite effect for a firm which updates information timing uncertainty interacts with the expectation effect moreover increased timing uncertainty may accelerate or decelerate investment as an optimal response to an expected tax cut futhermore for reasonable assumptions it is shown that a rate cut cum base broadening tax reform of the type implemented in several oecd countries in the 1980s and 1990s cannot be revenue neutral

corporate taxation and capital accumulation evidence from sectoral panel data for 14 oecd countries abstract we present new empirical evidence that sector level capital output ratios are strongly influenced by corporate tax incentives as summarised by the tax component of a standard user cost of capital measure we use sectoral panel data for the usa japan australia and eleven eu countries over the period 1982 2007 our panel combines internationally consistent data on capital stocks value added and relative prices from the eu klems database with corporate tax measures from the oxford university centre for business taxation our results for equipment investment are particularly robust and strikingly consistent with the basic economic theory of corporate investment

the demand for physician services evidence from a natural experiment this study exploits a natural experiment in belgium to estimate the effect of copayment increases on the demand for physician services it shows how a differences in differences dd estimator of the price effects can be decomposed into effects induced by the common average proportional price increase income effects and by the change in relative prices substitution effects the price elasticity of a uniform proportional price increase is relatively small 0 13 for men and 0 03 for women substitution effects are large especially for women but imprecisely estimated despite the substantial price increases the efficiency gain of the reform if any is modest

fixed costs of adjustment coordination and industry investment we test whether smooth industry level investment dynamics result from explicit aggregation of asynchronous and possibly lumpy firm level investment we compare the deviations of optimal from actual firm behavior across industries categorized by their ratios of idiosyncratic uncertainty to the sum of idiosyncratic and aggregate uncertainty the deviations are represented by the residuals of a cointegrating regression that is derived from the firm s first order condition under no adjustment costs in support of models with asynchronous firm decisions we find a significant negative relationship across industries between idiosyncratic uncertainty and the persistence of these residuals

decomposition of moral hazard this study seeks to simulate the portion of moral hazard that is due to the income transfer contained in the coinsurance price reduction healthcare spending of uninsured individuals from the meps with a priority health condition is compared with the predicted counterfactual spending of those same individuals if they were insured with either 1 a conventional policy that paid off with a coinsurance rate or 2 a contingent claims policy that paid off by a lump sum payment upon becoming ill the lump sum payment is set to be equal to the insurer s predicted spending under the coinsurance policy the proportion of moral hazard that is efficient is calculated as the proportion of total moral hazard that is generated by this lump sum payment we find that the efficient proportion of moral hazard varies from disease to disease but is the highest for those with diabetes and cancer

intertemporal production and intertemporal substitution in output supply and input demand abstractthis article presents an intertemporal model of production with multiple inputs to investigate substitution opportunities facing firms over time the firm s intertemporal profit maximization problem is characterized with the familiar cost function and various intertemporal substitution elasticities are delineated for output supply and input demand the absence of intertemporal substitution in production can imply production smoothing and allowance for intertemporal substitution in labour demand reinforces the prediction of the real business cycle model for aggregate us manufacturing we find substantial substitution in output supply and labour demand over time due to intertemporal changes in output price and wage rates

supply side and demand side cost sharing in deregulated social health insurance which is more effective abstract microeconomic theory predicts that if patients are fully insured and providers are paid fee for service utilization of medical services exceeds the efficient level moral hazard effect in switzerland both demand side and supply side cost sharing have been introduced to mitigate this problem analyzing a panel dataset of about 160 000 adults we find both types of cost sharing to be effective in curtailing the use of medical services however when moral hazard mitigation is traded off against risk selection the minimum deductible supply side cost sharing option ranks first followed by the medium deductible demand side alternative making the supply side option somewhat more effective

factor demand models with nonlinear short run fluctuations abstract this paper considers asymmetric costs of adjustment that propagate nonlinear shortrun fluctuations in stochastic factor demand systems the model endogenously generates asymmetric cyclical demand for capital and labour between peaks and troughs of the business cycle the empirical analysis of the model is based on quarterly time series data of the dutch manufacturing sector for the period 1971 i 1984 iv and annual time series data of the u k manufacturing sector for the period 1955 1986 i find important differences of adjustment speed of capital and labour inputs between expansionary and contractionary phases of the business cycle

capital tax reform and the real economy the effects of the 2003 dividend tax cut this paper tests whether the 2003 dividend tax cut one of the largest reforms ever to a us capital tax rate stimulated corporate investment and increased labor earnings using a quasi experimental design and us corporate tax returns from years 1996 2008 i estimate that the tax cut caused zero change in corporate investment and employee compensation economically the statistical precision challenges leading estimates of the cost of capital elasticity of investment or undermines models in which dividend tax reforms affect the cost of capital either way it may be difficult to implement an alternative dividend tax cut that has substantially larger near term effects jel c72 c78 c91

unfunded liabilities and uncertain fiscal financing we develop a rational expectations framework to study the consequences of alternative means to resolve the unfunded liabilities problem the projected exponential growth in federal social security medicare and medicaid spending with no known plan for financing the transfers resolution requires specifying a probability distribution for how and when monetary and fiscal policies will change as the economy evolves through the 21st century beliefs based on that distribution determine the existence of and the nature of equilibrium we consider policies that in expectation combine reaching a fiscal limit some distorting taxation modest inflation and some reneging on the government s promised transfers in the equilibrium inflation targeting monetary policy and debt targeting tax policy cannot anchor expectations on those target variables expectational effects are always present but need not have large impacts on inflation and interest rates in the short and medium runs in the economy s stationary distribution the capital stock may grow or shrink and substantial probability falls on little or no reneging

is demand for polluting goods manageable an econometric study of car ownership and use in mexico abstract our motivation for estimating a demand system for gasoline and cars is its strategic relevance to policy objectives such as pollution control if demand is responsive to pricing demand reductions for polluting goods will provide an important share of the pollution reductions otherwise cleaner technologies will have to do most of the job we estimate a model of gasoline demand and car ownership in mexico using a panel of annual observations by state key features that we introduce include instrumental variables on differenced data and the treatment of possible dynamics measurement errors in the data and unobserved individual state characteristics we use tests of serial correlation in the a residuals to model the dynamics properly the resulting demand system is quite responsive to pricing even in the short term 0 6 for the own price elasticity of gasoline but we emphasize a medium to long term perspective of 5 10 years as most relevant for policy five to ten year elasticity estimates are in the range of 1 25 to 1 13 applying these elasticity estimates to data on pollution control options for the vehicle fleet in mexico city the costs of reaching a target for pollution reductions would be 45 more expensive if one were not willing to use a demand management instrument such a gasoline tax in the control program

tax policy and heterogeneous investment behavior abstract we estimate the effect of temporary tax incentives on equipment investment using shifts in accelerated depreciation analyzing data for over 120 000 firms we present three findings first

oil prices inflation and interest rates in a structural cointegrated var model for the g 7 countries sharp increases in the price of oil are generally seen as a major contributor to business cycle asymmetries moreover the very recent highs registered in the world oil market are causing concern about possible slowdowns in the economic performance of the most developed countries in this paper a structural cointegrated var model has been considered for the g 7 countries in order to study the direct effects of oil price shocks on output and prices and the reaction of monetary variables to external shocks our results can be summarized as follows i a stationary money demand as suggested by the classic theory of money can be identified for most countries ii according to the estimated coefficients of the structural part of the model for all countries except japan and u k the null hypothesis of an influence of oil prices on the inflation rate cannot be rejected inflation rate shocks are transmitted to the real economy by increasing interest rates iii impulse response analysis suggests for most countries the existence of an instantaneous temporary effect of oil price innovations on prices iv impulse response functions indicate different monetary policy reactions to inflationary and growth shocks v the simulation exercises directed to estimate the total impact of the 1990 oil price shock indicate that for some countries u s a significant part of the effects of the oil price shock is due to the monetary policy reaction function for other countries canada france and italy however the total impact is offset at least in part by an easing of monetary conditions

assessing energy price induced improvements in efficiency of capital in oecd manufacturing industries to assess how capital stocks adapt to energy price changes it is necessary to account for the impacts on different vintages of capital and to account separately for price induced and autonomous improvements in the energy efficiency of capital stock the results of econometric analysis for five manufacturing industries in 19 oecd countries between 1990 and 2005 indicate that higher energy prices resulted in smaller energy use due to both improved energy efficiency of capital stock and reduced demand for the energy input the investment response to energy prices varied considerably across manufacturing industries being more significant in energy intensive sectors the results of policy simulations indicate that a carbon tax can deliver significant reductions in energy consumption in the medium run with modest declines in energy using capital stock

public investment and industry incentives in life science research life science research has shifted rapidly from the public to the private sector raising questions about government s remaining role we shed light on the issue by employing a dynamic investment response model to examine the public s impact on industry life science research effort and success we find that government expenditures in both basic biological research and agricultural and medical science create substantial spillovers for private firms the spillovers are unfortunately partly nullified by government competition for scarce research inputs yet even after accounting for such competition public investment has been strongly complementary to private investment indeed opportunities created through public research are the principal source of growth in industry life sciences copyright 2007 oxford university press

an examination of the equilibrium specification and structure of production for canadian telecommunications multiple output models of canadian telecommunications production are estimated under different production equilibria a specification test is conducted between the short and long run equilibrium models and the long run equilibrium is rejected in order to capture the nature of the disequilibrium a dynamic cost of adjustment model is estimated for bell canada there are significant adjustment costs and it is estimated that for 1 00 of marginal capital costs the carrier must incur an additional cost of 0 30 to install the new capital into the production process

investment ramifications of distortionary tax subsidies abstract this paper examines the investment effects of tax subsidies for which some assets and not others are eligible distortionary tax subsidies concentrate investments in tax favored assets thereby reducing the expected pre tax profitability of investment and reducing payoffs to bondholders in the event of default anticipation of asset substitution encourages lenders to require covenants in debt contracts which only imperfectly address asset substitution and distort investment the result is that borrowing is made more expensive which in turn discourages investment borrowing rates can react so strongly that aggregate investment may rise very little or even fall in response to higher tax subsidies debt issued by u s firms in risk of default after the 2002 introduction of bonus depreciation for u s equipment investment contained many more covenants than in other periods a pattern that reversed when bonus depreciation was discontinued after 2004 furthermore firms at risk of default borrowed less and were more apt to lease capital than were other firms during the bonus depreciation period

a dynamic analysis of interfuel substitution in u s industrial energy demand using data for 1960 92 to analyze interfuel substitution in the u s industrial sector a dynamic linear logit model is shown to provide superior global properties than a comparable dynamic translog model confirming earlier static results by t j considine 1989 the linear logit model provides a direct unbiased estimate of the rate of dynamic adjustment indicating a median response lag of less than two years excluding fuels used for nonenergy purposes yields larger estimates of the price elasticities for coal and oil and indicates generally greater potential for interfuel substitution than when using aggregate data

determination of employment with wage and price speculation the purpose of this paper is to investigate whether aggregate fluctuations in employment may be explained within a market clearing framework as intertemporal substitution in labor supply and demand an intertemporal substitution model for the firm is derived this model is estimated with a lucas rapping type supply equation empirical results with finnish data lend support to the intertemporal substitution model particularly concerning the demand function specification on the other hand the results for the supply equation are somewhat mixed being rather sensitive to the dynamic specification

the general equilibrium costs and impacts of oil price shocks in newfoundland and labrador abstract the 2014 2015 dramatic drop in world oil prices had devastating impacts on a global scale we analyse economic costs and impacts of a negative oil price shock following the 2014 2015 decrease in oil prices on the provincial economy of newfoundland and labrador canada we use a dynamic computable general equilibrium model to estimate a drop in oil prices by inputting the estimated effect as a direct impact to royalties which are the land input in the oil and gas sector of the provincial economy we provide sensitivity to account for the duration and magnitude of the shock as well as the timing of recovery our results suggest that a shock in the price of oil will have its most significant impact on gdp in the initial years over the first five years the reduction in gdp due to this shock would be roughly 2 1 of gdp in our most realistic shock scenario but could be much higher in other scenarios considered a sharp drop in gdp over the first five years will be mitigated somewhat in the long run as the growth in oil prices rises however negative long run impacts to gdp persist due to the oil price shock in 2014 2015 and will worsen if there is a prolonged shock

estimating the tradeoff between risk protection and moral hazard with a nonlinear budget set model of health insurance insurance induces a tradeoff between the welfare gains from risk protection and the welfare losses from moral hazard empirical work traditionally estimates each side of the tradeoff separately potentially yielding mutually inconsistent results i develop a nonlinear budget set model of health insurance that allows for both simultaneously nonlinearities in the budget set arise from deductibles coinsurance rates and stoplosses that alter moral hazard as well as risk protection i illustrate the properties of my model by estimating it using data on employer sponsored health insurance from a large firm

the intertemporal dimension of neoclassical production theory abstract the aim of this survey paper is to provide a guide to the literature on optimal dynamic factor demands to the non specialist reader interested in applied work we start with the distinction between variable and quasi fixed factors of production and use these to characterize the firm s temporary equilibrium we then review the optimal intertemporal behaviour of the firm using the notion of adjustment costs as a means to solve the firm s optimization problem this process gives rise to a system of interrelated dynamic factor demands in a flexible accelerator format theoretical difficulties and empirical limitations of this model are discussed this fact leads us to review the theory of intertemporal duality we next analyze the issue of expectations in this class of dynamic models a section reviewing the empirical work on dynamic factor demands follows after which we offer some concluding remarks

quasi fixed inputs in u s and japanese manufacturing a generalized leontief restricted cost function approach in this paper a generalized leontief variable cost function is develope d which permits analytical derivation of steady state levels of quasi fixed inputs and capacity output and does not require specification of a numeraire input this framework is then used to evaluate the fa ctor demand patterns of japanese and u s manufacturing based on bot h one quasi fixed capital input and two quasi fixed capital and la bor input specifications and both static and dynamic optimization t he findings provide evidence of considerable flexibility of demand re sponses in japan which may have contributed to japan s relatively st rong economic performance in the volatile 1970s copyright 1988 by mit press

dynamic factor demand equations in u s and canadian agriculture abstract this research provides one of the first empirical estimates of a data based dynamic factor demand model for american and canadian agriculture models such as these deserve more widespread use in the empirical analysis of agriculture these models have the advantage that they do not impose inappropriate dynamics on the data rather they permit the data to select the appropriate dynamics we use a model originally developed by anderson and blundell this model is a general first order dynamic model which contains as testable hypothesis several simpler models this model permits us to estimate the long run agricultural production structure as a subset of the dynamic parameter estimates we will test this long run structure for symmetry homotheticity and neutral technical change the estimated models may be used to test for three alternative dynamic structures in the limit dynamics may not be needed and we can test for the static long run equilibrium model two intermediate cases are the autoregressive and the partial adjustment models which are simpler than the general model but still include dynamics our results suggest that the long run equilibrium model is unsatisfactory in both countries a dynamic model is needed in both countries the two more restricted dynamic models are rejected the general dynamic model is required in canada the long run equilibrium structure is homothetic with neutral technical change in the united states homotheticity is also accepted but neutral technical change is rejected

recursive factor of production interrelations and endogenous cycling a multivariate linear rational expectations equilibrium version of the lucas prescott investment model is developed to study the behavior of factors of productions with recursive interrelations the connection between these interrelations and endogenous cycling is established in a testable way maximum likelihood estimates using annual postwar aggregate u s manufacturing data provide strong evidence of capital labor interrelations that induce a labor overshooting type of endogenous cycling this raises questions for the methodology of current real business cycle models which rule out the possibility of such interrelations copyright 1991 by economics department of the university of pennsylvania and the osaka university institute of social and economic research association

rebound directed technological change and aggregate demand for energy abstract we analyse the long run role of energy in aggregate production the factor share of energy has been remarkably constant despite the relative decline in the price of energy we analyse possible explanations for this observation ruling out the idea that endogenous directed technological change has led to a failure of energy augmenting technology to keep pace with labour augmenting technology instead we propose a model in which a combination of income and substitution effects has driven both shifts in consumption patterns towards existing energy intensive goods and the emergence of new such goods

health insurance tradeoffs revisited abstract in two recent papers journal of health economics 18 2 141 152 journal of health economics 18 6 811 824 nyman raised some questions about the welfare calculations and conclusions in our earlier paper manning and marquis health insurance the tradeoff between risk pooling and moral hazard vol 15 1996 this note discusses the erroneous criticisms in his papers first although we estimated a marshallian demand curve our calculations are based on compensating variations that incorporate the gains from risk pooling second our estimates of second best insurance plans indicate that some cost sharing is optimal in contradiction to his assertion that our results raise questions about the desirability of insurance coverage the comment also deals with other issues raised by nyman

expectations and factor demand this paper develops and estimates a model of interrelated factor demand with rational expectations in the presence of internal adjustment costs invariant technological parameters are distinguished from the firm s adjustment parameters which change when the exogenous processes faced by the firm change the capital demand equation is derived by solving the euler equations which stem from minimization of the present value of costs future exogenous variables are supplied from solutions of arima equations the model is tested on postwar quarterly data for u s manufacturing a regime change in the process for energy prices is simulated as is a temporary suspension of the investment tax credit

real flexibility and financial structure an empirical analysis i examine the empirical relation between real flexibility and financial structure i test whether real flexibility increases debt capacity by lowering default risk and making assets more marketable or decreases debt capacity by facilitating risk shifting and asset substitution i measure real flexibility as the sensitivity of marginal production and investment decisions to variations in the economic environment i find that financial leverage is negatively related to production flexibility but positively related to investment flexibility this split in results suggests that although asset substitution facilitated by investment flexibility can be prevented contractually risk shifting facilitated by production flexibility is intractable copyright 2003 oxford university press

factor substitution in u s manufacturing does plant size matter we use micro data for 10 412 u s manufacturing plants to estimate the degrees of factor substitution by industry and by plant size we find that 1 capital labor energy and materials are substitutes in production and 2 the degrees of substitution among inputs are quite similar across plant sizes in a majority of industries two important implications of these findings are that 1 small plants are typically as flexible as large plants in factor substitution consequently economic policies such energy conservation policies that result in rising energy prices would not cause negative effects on either large or small u s manufacturing plants and 2 since energy and capital are found to be substitutes the 1973 energy crisis is unlikely to be a significant factor contributing to the post 1973 productivity slowdown

the value of medicaid interpreting results from the oregon health insurance experiment we develop frameworks for welfare analysis of medicaid and apply them to the oregon health insurance experiment across different approaches we estimate low income uninsured adults willingness to

insurance induced moral hazard a dynamic model of within year medical care decision making under uncertainty health insurance may lead individuals to overconsume medical care many studies explore this moral hazard using models that aggregate medical care decisions up to the annual level using employer employee matched data from the medical expenditure panel survey meps i estimate moral hazard using a dynamic model of within year medical care consumption that allows for endogenous health transitions variation in medical care prices and individual uncertainty within a health insurance year i then estimate moral hazard under a second set of conditions that are consistent with the assumptions of most annual decision making models the within year decision making model produces a moral hazard estimate that is 19 2 larger than the alternative model i highlight the importance of controlling for within year dynamics in a model of medical care consumption using a counterfactual policy simulation that implements the individual mandate provision of the 2010 patient protection and aordable care act i nd that full implementation of the policy decreases the percentage of uninsured individuals in the population being analyzed from 11 8 to 6 0 furthermore when all uninsured individuals are forced into coverage their predicted annual medical care expenditure increases by 45 5

aggregate health care expenditures and national income is health care a luxury good it is well known that a strong relationship exists between national expenditures on health care and national income this has been used to suggest that health care is a luxury good and that factors such as the type of health care delivery system in a country are of little importance in determining expenditure levels this paper argues that these implications rely upon the application of microeconomic analysis to macroeconomic data and that this is not appropriate as well as raising questions about the inferences drawn from previous studies new empirical evidence is presented which casts some doubts on previous findings international comparisons are based on purchasing power parity rather than exchange rate conversions underlining the importance of prices as well as quantities in the relationship and leading to the conclusion that the aggregate data show health care to be if anything a necessity rather than a luxury good

energy price energy efficiency and capital productivity empirical investigations and policy implications abstract the immediate effect of carbon pricing policy is to raise energy costs which in turn reduces energy consumption either through induced capital under utilization or investments in new energy efficient capital the latter mechanism which implies improvements in energy efficiency is realized in the long run while the former which has implications for capital productivity tends to occur in the short run we employ panel vector autoregressions as well as co integration and error correction techniques to identify these short and long run relationships including their differences across canadian industries

dynamic factor demand systems and the adjustment speed towards equilibrium most models of factor demand can be grouped into two categories the first is static models which consistently account for substitution among several factors without imposing a priori restrictions on the production structure such models utilize flexible functional forms to represent the underlying technology however they impose strict restrictions on the dynamic behaviour of the technology in that either full or partial static equilibrium is assumed studies in this group providing a rationale for modelling some input factors as fixed in the short run include brown and christensen 1980 and kulatilaka 1985 a partly dynamic approach was suggested by pindyck and rotemberg 1983 who explicitly model the adjustment costs of some factors however the underlying production technology is still regarded as static the second category consists of dynamic models that incorporate cost of capital stock adjustments such models often apply a single factor and typically impose ad hoc assumptions in both categories the researcher selects the inputs which are not regarded as completely variable mostly on the basis of a priori assumptions in this paper we will focus on implications of a dynamic modelling of factor demand systems it is clear that a firm will adjust to price changes only when it is profitable to do so accordingly the cost of adjustment may serve as a rationale for why different factors may adjust towards equilibrium at different speeds hence when we are able to model the adjustment speed of the different factors we are also able to parametrically test for the

investment tax incentives prices and the supply of capital goods using data on the prices of capital goods this paper shows that much of the benefit of investment tax incentives does not go to investing firms but rather to capital suppliers through higher prices the reduction in the cost of capital from a 10 percent investment tax credit increases equipment prices 3 5 7 0 percent this lasts several years and is largest for assets with large order backlogs low import competition or with a large fraction of buyers able to use investment subsidies capital goods workers wages rise too instrumental variables estimates of the short run supply elasticity are around 1 and can explain the traditionally small estimates of investment demand elasticities in absolute value the demand elasticity implied here exceeds 1

the risk and duration of catastrophic health care expenditures the authors measure the time series property of catastrophic medical costs facing the elderly using information on medical deductions from a panel of tax returns during the period of analysis 1968 73 taxpayers could deduct medical expenses above 3 percent of income they correct for the resulting censoring bias using multivariate tobit estimated with a variant of the smoothed simulated maximum likelihood method the estimated coefficients imply a 1 00 increase in out of pocket medical spending is associated with 2 65 in future out of pocket spending copyright 1994 by mit press

the economics of moral hazard revisited pauly s 1968 pauly m 1968 the economics of moral hazard comment american economic review 58 531 537 analysis of the welfare loss from insurance assumes that medical care consumption is not determined by income but recent studies suggest it is this study argues that 1 pauly s analysis overstates the welfare loss because it includes the effect of income on consumption 2 the relevant income effect is derived from income transfer from the healthy to the ill that occur when the probability of illness is less than 1 and 3 the welfare loss can be considered the transaction cost of insurance

inflation tax rules and investment some econometric evidence this paper presents econometric evidence on the effect of tax incentives on business investment in the united states in the period from 1953 through1978 the analysis emphasizes that the interaction of inflation and existing tax rules has contributed substantially to the decline of business investment since the late 1960 s because the investment process is far too complex for any simple econometric model to be convincing i have estimated three quite different models of investment behavior the strength of the empirical evidence rests on the fact that all three specifications support the same conclusion more generally the analysis and evidence show that theoretical models of macroeconomic equilibrium should specify explicitly the role of distortionary taxes especially taxes on capital income the failure to include such tax rules can have dramatic and misleading effects on the qualitative as well as the quantitative properties of macroeconomic theories this paper was presented as the fisher shultz lecture at the fourth world congress of the econometric society 29 august 1980 in aix en province this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

short and long term equilibria relationships between first and third generation dynamic factor demand models abstract first generation dynamic models of input demands are theoretically inferior to third generation models yet their simplicity makes them attractive for estimation purposes moreover first generation models can be shown to be generically related to third generation models and under certain assumptions input demand expressions in a third generation model collapse to those of the first generation seemingly offering a short cut for estimation however empirical comparisons suggest that first generation specifications do not afford a reasonable approximation to input functions embedded in more complex third generation models furthermore the reduced form coefficients do not permit identification of third generation model structures

liberalisation consumption heterogeneity and the dynamics of energy prices in this study the methodology var and the cointegration analysis are used to examine the dynamic interaction among the energy prices of the competitor energy sources in a liberalised market data from the uk market were applied and models for the residential and industrial sectors were developed our results indicate the existence of long run relationships between the energy prices before and after the liberalisation implying the possibility of substitution among the different forms of energy however the results appear to be also largely influenced by external variables not included in the models that may be reducing the importance of the energy prices over their own evolution and offsetting the basic substitution relationships the general results of the impulse response functions both for the residential and industrial sectors present low statistical significance which seems to be due to the still slow rate of adjustment of the energy market to price changes along with the immaturity of the liberalisation process taking into consideration the results some routes for future research are pointed out namely the need to include in the analysis variables which would proxy the general state of the economy

structural models of dynamic factor demands with nonstatic expectations an empirical assessment of alternative expectations specifications until recently little literature existed on incorporation of nonstatic price and output expectations into empirically implementable factor demand models for example the vast literature on flexible functional forms is almost completely characterized by static expectations on prices and output as well as instantaneous adjustment to desired levels of demand more recent studies have incorporated increasingly complex theoretical and econometric structures the literature along the lines of fuss 1976 and berndt fuss and waverman 1979 bfw incorporates endogenous determination of dynamic adjustment structure but retains a static expectations assumption on the other hand most current rational expectations models following the lead of thomas sargent and robert lucas make very restrictive simplifying assumptions on the deterministic economic structure in order rigorously to specify the complex stochastic structure implied by the rational expectations assumption a thrid category of model represented by pindyck and rotemberg 1983 relies on an instrumental variable approach to ensure error orthogonality and hence consistency with the rational expectations assumption this procedure allows for a more complete structural specification but does not explicitly incorporate an expectations process this paper represents a step toward a synthesis of the structural and stochastic approaches to dynamic input demand modeling with emphasis on both theoretical foundations and empirical tractability in this approach approximations to rational expectations and certainty equivalence are used explicitly to incorporate anticipatory behavior of firms into the structural model of dynamic factor demands theoretically this is accomplished without sacrificing rich economic structure a structural factor demand model is developed which includes both stock relationships and expectations formation based on an explicit dynamic optimization framework empirically the focus is on avoiding complex stochastic structures that are of little use to most empirical researchers all of the expectational models are empirically straightforward to implement and yet incorporate the important theoretical and empirical structure required for detailed analysis of short and long run behavior two issues must be addressed to formalize and implement the model the

the own wage elasticity of labor demand a meta regression analysis firms labor demand responses to wage changes are of key interest in empirical research and policy analysis however despite extensive research estimates of labor demand elasticities remain subject to considerable heterogeneity in this paper we conduct a comprehensive meta regression analysis to re assess the empirical literature on labor demand elasticities building on 942 elasticity estimates from 105 different studies we identify sources of variation in the absolute value of this elasticity heterogeneity due to the theoretical and empirical specification of the labor demand model different datasets used or sectors and countries considered explains more than 80 of the variation in the estimates we further find substantial evidence for the presence of publication selection bias as estimates of the own wage elasticity of labor demand are upwardly inflated

cost specification and firm behaviour in a hotelling model of resource extraction in applied resource economics much attention has been focused on the ability of the hotelling model to explain observed firm behavior in this paper a preliminary specification search is performed to determine the appropriate cost function parameterization for the firms in the sample before proceeding to the estimation of the euler equation once a cost function specification is chosen the corresponding euler equation is estimated via the generalization method of moments gmm which allows for better estimates of the euler equations than in previous studies even with the preliminary specification search and the use of gmm estimation the behavior of the panel of fourteen canadian copper mining firms in the data set examined does not seem to be consistent with the basic hotelling model used

interrelated factor demands for manufacturing a dynamic translog cost function approach abstract in this paper we report the results of estimating a joint model for labour capital and energy using the transcendental logarithmic cost function of christensen jorgenson and lau 1973 this allows us to determine both the own price and cross elasticities of substitution between labour capital and energy we combine a model of factor shares with a dynamic adjustment process for each factor we also impose on the cross equation restrictions necessary to provide additivity homogeneity and symmetry since the covariance matrix in systems of share relationships is singular we follow the suggestions of anderson and blundell 1982 and employ a mullivariate error corrrection model the results suggest that additivity symmetry and homogeneity restrictions do hold and that there are short run increasing returns to scale

an econometric analysis of fluctuations in aggregate labor supply and demand the paper contains a simple equilibrium model of the labor market the supply function allows for intertemporal substitution in response to real wage fluctuations and the demand function allows for adjustment costs on employment the supply and demand functions both solve quadratic partial adjustment problems driven by rational expectations about future real wages the market equilibrium also solves a partial adjustment problem driven by rational expectations about future preference and technology shocks two related issues are emphasized the identification of dynamic labor supply and demand functions and the theoretical interpretation of serial correlation in employment and real wages when the supply and demand shocks are assumed to be ar 1 processes which are not causally related the model delivers a simple structure for the equilibrium process for employment and real wages which is a restricted var 2 this simple structure facilitates the interpretation of summary statistics on the time series properties of observed employment and real wage series the supply and demand functions can both be locally identified using only employment and real wage data an illustrative application is presented using u s manufacturing data for the period 1948 1971

an adjustment cost model of long term employment in japan summary a dynamic factor demand model is presented which pays special attention to the prevalence of a longterm employment relationship in japan the model is based on the representation of technology by a variable cost function with adjustment costs for employment and capital stock where the variable cost consists of the sum of overtime costs and materials costs with employment being quasi fixed and scheduled hours institutionally regulated short run adjustments are mostly made by overtime hours application to a time series data on the japanese electrical machinery industry indicates quasi fixity of capital and employment and reproduces short run overshooting of overtime hours to compensate for the sluggish adjustment of employment

capacity utilization and depreciation in use in this paper the effect capacity utilization has on the depreciation of capital goods is studied starting from a quadratic approximation to a normalized short run cost function expressions for the optimal rate of capacity utilization the demands for labour and energy and for investment are obtained investment is a function of past capital stock expected future capital stock expected future relative prices and expected future depreciation rates expectations are modelled via instruments the model is tested using us total manufacturing quarterly data depreciation dependent upon usage is found to be both statistically and economically significant

optimal health insurance for multiple goods and time periods we examine the efficiency based arguments for second best optimal health insurance with multiple treatment goods and multiple time periods correlated shocks across health care goods and over time interact with complementarity and substitutability to affect optimal cost sharing health care goods that are substitutes or have positively correlated demand shocks should have lower optimal patient cost sharing positive serial correlations of demand shocks and uncompensated losses that are positively correlated with covered health services also reduce optimal cost sharing our results rationalize covering pharmaceuticals and outpatient spending more fully than is implied by static one good or one period models

reprint of the pros and cons of sick pay schemes testing for contagious presenteeism and noncontagious absenteeism behavior abstract this paper provides an analytical framework and uses data from the u s and germany to test for the existence of contagious presenteeism and negative externalities in sick leave insurance the first part exploits high frequency google flu data and the staggered implementation of u s sick pay mandates to show using a reduced form framework that population level influenza like disease rates decrease after employees gain access to paid sick leave next a simple theoretical framework provides evidence on the underlying behavioral labor supply mechanisms the model theoretically decomposes overall labor supply adjustments moral hazard into contagious presenteeism and noncontagious absenteeism behavior and derives testable conditions the last part illustrates how to implement the model exploiting a german sick pay reform and administrative industry level data on certified sick leave by diagnosis the empirical test finds that the labor supply elasticity for contagious diseases is significantly smaller than for noncontagious diseases under the identifying assumptions of the model this finding provides additional indirect evidence for the existence of contagious presenteeism

inventories employment and hours abstract this paper develops a model that integrates inventory and labor decisions we extend a model of inventory behavior to include a detailed specification of the role of labor input in the production process distinguishing between employment hours and effort per worker we estimate jointly the euler equations for inventories and employment a labor compensation schedule and an hours requirement function with the cross equation restrictions imposed the econometric results shed light on several important topics including the shape of the marginal cost of output the role of labor hoarding as an explanation of pro cyclical productivity and the persistence of inventory stocks

dynamic factor demands and the effects of energy price shocks a dynamic model is used to understand how sharp changes in energy prices affect investment behavior employment and energy use the authors discuss the theory behind their model selection model specifications estimation methods and data list parameter estimates and elasticities for the selected model and describe the simulations they conclude that 1 the data strongly reject the hypothesis of constant returns to scale within their specification of aggregate production 2 the data indicate adjustment costs on labor are small and 3 their results help reconcile some of the conflicting estimates of energy demand elasticities appearing in recent literature 23 references 3 figures 3 tables

technical efficiency and u s manufacturing productivity growth this paper establishes that new inputs increase technical efficiency levels for u s manufacturing over the period 1950 1998 intermediate inputs exhibited higher rates of efficiency growth than labor and capital efficiency adjusted productivity growth annually averaged 0 4 percentage points above measured growth the gap between efficiency adjusted and measured productivity growth arises from aggregating inputs using observed and not efficiency adjusted cost share weights in the calculation of measured growth specifically the decline in efficiency adjusted material cost shares compared to the measured shares coupled with the comparatively high material input growth rate was the main source of the productivity gap

the pros and cons of sick pay schemes testing for contagious presenteeism and noncontagious absenteeism behavior abstract this paper provides an analytical framework and uses data from the u s and germany to test for the existence of contagious presenteeism and negative externalities in sick leave insurance the first part exploits high frequency google flu data and the staggered implementation of u s sick pay mandates to show using a reduced form framework that population level influenza like disease rates decrease after employees gain access to paid sick leave next a simple theoretical framework provides evidence on the underlying behavioral labor supply mechanisms the model theoretically decomposes overall labor supply adjustments moral hazard into contagious presenteeism and noncontagious absenteeism behavior and derives testable conditions the last part illustrates how to implement the model exploiting a german sick pay reform and administrative industry level data on certified sick leave by diagnosis the empirical test finds that the labor supply elasticity for contagious diseases is significantly smaller than for noncontagious diseases under the identifying assumptions of the model this finding provides additional indirect evidence for the existence of contagious presenteeism

dynamic factor demands and market structure under rational expectations some estimates for the italian manufacturing system this paper deals with a dynamic model of the behaviour of firms under rational expectations the adjustment cost framework is followed to describe production technologies the objective of firms is to maximize the stream of future profits under rational expectation first order conditions for the optimum are derived with respect to input demands and one output supply the output market structure is modelled in order to test price taking behaviour the adjustment costs of quasi fixed inputs are internal and interrelated the model is estimated for the italian manufacturing system with encouraging results

an alternative framework for evaluating welfare losses in the health care market a recurring theme in the health economics literature is that excess health insurance reduces society s welfare this proposition is considered to be a truism by most health economists feldman and morrisey 1990 report that two thirds of american and canadian health economists surveyed agree with the statement that the level and type of health insurance held by most u s families generate substantial welfare loss due to over consumption of medical services consequently most research in the area has attempted to identify the exact dollar value of this welfare loss in this note i will try to show that the traditional method of calculating welfare losses from excess health insurance is severely flawed because it is based on assumptions about consumer behavior that are not supported by the available empirical evidence furthermore the methodology masks other potentially greater societal welfare losses that are likely to exist in the health care sector and blinds us from seeking the most effective public policy remedies this note suggests an alternative framework for considering welfare losses based on researchers evaluations of medical necessity

consistent tariffs with dynamic supply response abstract this paper models a large importer of a competitively produced good for which there are nonlinear adjustment costs in production if producers have rational expectations and the importer is unable to make a credible commitment regarding future tariffs market power may be disadvantageous this is more likely to occur when the difference between short and long run elasticities of supply are large this result depends on the particular subgame perfect equilibrium that is chosen if producers were capable of strategic behavior other equilibria which rely on trigger strategies would be reasonable and market power could no longer be disadvantageous

dynamic factor demands under rational expectations we model the industrial demands for structures equipment and blue and white collar labor in a manner consistent with rational expectations and stochastic dynamic optimization in the presence of adjustment costs but allowing generality of functional form we represent the technology by a translog input requirement function that specifies the amount of blue collar labor needed to produce an output level given quantities of three quasi fixed factors nonproduction workers equipment and structures a complete description of the production structure is obtained by simultaneously estimating the input requirement function and three stochastic euler equations we find adjustment costs are small in total but large on the margin and differ considerably across factors

health insurance the tradeoff between risk pooling and moral hazard choosing optimal health insurance coverage involves a trade off between the gain from risk reduction and the deadweight loss from moral hazard this paper examines this trade off empirically by estimating both the demand for health insurance and the demand for health services it relies on data from a randomized controlled trial of cost sharing s effects on the use of health services and on the health status for a general non elderly population

tax reform and adjustment costs the impact on investment and market value this paper provides an effective tax rate measure that is valid in the presence of adjustment costs and anticipated tax changes and a measure of the impact of tax changes on market value that may be decomposed into the effects on discounted pure profits and normal returns to capital changes in the value of capital may in turn be decomposed further into changes in the marginal value of new capital and changes in the relative value of new and existing capital these new measures are used to evaluate tax changes similar to those introduced by the recent u s tax reform copyright 1989 by economics department of the university of pennsylvania and the osaka university institute of social and economic research association

taxation corporate financial policy and the cost of capital the cost of capital plays an important role in the allocation of resources among competing uses in a decentralized market system the purpose of this paper is to organize and present what is known and what is hypothesized about the effects of taxation on the incentive to invest via the cost of capital taking full account of important issues that arise independently from the question of taxation included in the analysis is a discussion of empirical findings about the interaction of inflation and taxation in influencing the incentive to invest and a treatment of taxation and uncertainty this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

assessing a disaggregated energy input using confidence intervals around translog elasticity estimates the role of energy in the production of manufacturing output has been debated extensively in the literature particularly its relationship with capital and labor in an attempt to provide some clarification in this debate a two step methodology was used first under the assumption of a five factor production function specification we distinguished between electric and non electric energy and assessed each component s relationship with capital and labor second we calculated both the allen and price elasticities and constructed 95 confidence intervals around these values our approach led to the following conclusions that the disaggregation of the energy input into electric and non electric energy is justified that capital and electric energy and capital and non electric energy are substitutes while labor and electric energy and labor and non electric energy are complements in production and that capital and energy are substitutes while labor and energy are complements

investment tax incentives and frequent tax reforms despite the frequency of tax changes and their potential importance to investors almost all of the analysis of tax based investment incentives assumes investors never anticipate any tax changes we depart from this approach by analyzing the historical pattern of u s corporate investment incentives over the period 1953 86 incorporating the feature of investor awareness that the tax code may change our analysis incorporates a predictive equation for future tax variables into a model of optimal investment subject to adjustment costs and uncertainty we find that expectations of future tax changes significantly affect the incentive to invest only if adjustment costs are low in this case the incentive to invest in 1986 was strong as investors are estimated to have anticipated the coming reduction in investment incentives this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

tax policy and business fixed investment in the united states abstract this paper derives and estimates models of nonresidential investment behavior in which current and future tax conditions directly affect the incentive to invest the estimates suggest that taxes have played an independent role in affecting postwar u s investment behavior particularly for investment in machinery and equipment in addition the paper develops a method for assessing the impact of tax policy on the volatility of investment when such policy is endogenous illustrative calculations using this technique based on the paper s empirical estimates suggest that tax policy has not served to stabilize investment in equipment or nonresidential structures during the sample period

monetary policy response to oil price shocks how should monetary authorities react to an oil price shock this paper shows that in a noncompetitive economy policies that perfectly stabilize prices entail large welfare costs hence explaining the reluctance of policymakers to enforce them the policy trade off is nontrivial because oil energy is an input to both production and consumption as welfare maximizing policies are hard to implement and communicate i derive a simple interest rate rule that depends only on observables but mimics the optimal plan in all dimensions the optimal rule is hard on core inflation but accommodates oil price changes

energy transition under irreversibility a two sector approach in this paper we analyze the optimal energy transition of a two sector economy energy and final goods with exhaustible oil reserves a renewable source of energy and a pollution threat the latter corresponds to a pollution threshold above which a part of the capital is lost following flooding for instance we show that the optimal energy transition path may correspond to a corner regime in which the economy starts using both resources then crosses the pollution threshold and therefore loses a part of its capital at the end the sole adoption of the renewable energy is optimal only in the long run this result is in line with the asymptotic energy transition arguments stating that the transition to clean energy may happen only in the long run we also show that economy reduces the use of energy resource as long as the productivity of capital and energy services is high therefore public policies should promote investments in energy innovation that targets productive sector home appliances and buildings and helps to save both money and energy we extend the present model to allow for additional investment in energy saving technologies our main results show that this additional investment favours the energy transition in the sense that it increases the time within which the economy may experience the catastrophe and the welfare of the society for policy implications economic instruments such as taxes on dirty energy subsidies on clean energy or incentives for energy saving technologies need to be implemented in order to promote the energy transition this is particularly important for developing countries that mostly rely on polluting energy resources and are the most vulnerable to climate change but those economic instruments should be carefully designed in line with the asymptotic energy transition result

mobility costs frictional unemployment and efficiency with imperfect job information flows it is plausible that the distribution of job offerings becomes more attractive when there are more vacancies and more unemployed with word of mouth communication this condition is derived given this condition steady state equilibrium is not efficient with welfare increased by the introduction of unemployment compensation even though all agents are risk neutral in this way workers become more selective in the jobs they accept

a model of the natural rate of unemployment since the publication of edmund phelps volume the new macroeconomics has treated the labor market as a dynamic process of rational search by unemployed workers for available vacancies wages are viewed as at least potentially flexible though free contracting between workers and firms may lead to fixed wages in the short run imperfect information is a crucial element of the theory for it implies both a need for contracting and a need for rational search rather than simple market clearing in each period a positive rate of frictional unemployment may exist in equilibrium denoted as the natural rate this unemployment is due to the frictions in the search process and imperfections in information rather than to any deficiency in aggregate demand milton friedman defined the natural rate as the level that would be ground out by the walrasian system of general equilibrium equations provided there is embedded in them the actual structural characteristics of the labor and commodity markets including market imperfections stochastic variability in demands and supplies the cost of gathering information about job vacancies and labor availabilities the costs of mobility and so on p 8 this paper reexamines the micro foundations of the natural rate in a model of labor market equilibrium in which turnover flows and imperfect information are explicitly considered workers may quit their current jobs to enter the unemployment pool in order to search among available vacancies for a more preferred position firms economize on turnover by an appropriate wage policy

financial structure production and productivity evidence from the u s food manufacturing industry this study integrates production and financing to examine the impacts of financial structure change on the production profitability and productivity growth in the u s food manufacturing industry empirical results show that during the period covered by this study agency cost associated with increased debt use by this industry negatively affected its output growth input demand profitability and overall productivity growth dividend payment positively contributed to the production and performance of this industry via signaling benefit however the negative effects of increased debt use by this industry far outweighed the positive contribution of dividend payment the u s food industry achieved a 0 9 average annual productivity growth which came primarily from technological progress and capital adjustment the rapid increase in debt use by this industry was responsible for slowing down the pace of productivity growth via its negative contribution to the total factor productivity growth capital expansion was the principal driver of output growth and profitability in this industry

user cost elasticity of capital revisited researchers still lack consensus about the size of the user cost elasticity of capital the divergence in prior estimates may have arisen because one of the two strands of research has neglected cointegration among capital its user costs and sales using german firm level panel data i show that estimating a distributed lag model prevalent in prior literature leads to low estimates of the user cost elasticity properly accounting for cointegration in an error correction model yields a much larger point estimate of the price elasticity of capital close to 1 non random sample attrition is found to be relatively unimportant

human capital and voluntary unemployment there are numerous complementary arguments which partially explain the natural rate of unemployment salop 1979 and shapiro and stiglitz 1984 have shown that some equilibrium unemployment can be involuntary mortensen 1970 and diamond 1981 explain equilibrium unemployment of the voluntary search type the purpose of this paper is to add to the understanding of voluntary unemployment by examining human capital accumulation the basic idea is a simple one each worker is assumed to enter the labor force with an initial endowment of human capital each worker s endowment is conformable to a particular industry and is of lesser productive value elsewhere if the worker gains employment in the industry where his capital is conformable he adds to it by learning by doing if he is unemployed or works elsewhere the initial human capital endowment depreciates if the depreciation rate is greater when the individual is employed in an alternative non conformable industry than when he is unemployed then periods of voluntary unemployment may arise from intertemporal expected utility maximization an islands type parable might be useful in explaining how these circumstances can arise consider industries and their labor pools to be separated as if on islands on joining the labor force individual workers first go to the island where their human capital is conformable if an individual gains employment he acquires more human capital by learning by doing if he is unemployed but remains on the island he receives full information about any technological or organizational changes in the production process furthermore interaction with his fellow islanders constantly reaffirms his knowledge and understanding of the production process if the individual shifts to another island to work he receives imperfect information about the industry where his human capital is conformable hence his human capital will depreciate at a faster rate whilst these arguments may describe a phenomenon which is contemporaneously unimportant in a full intertemporal context they may be substantial even a small quantity of human capital retained today can have significant implications over a lifetime

temporary investment tax incentives theory with evidence from bonus depreciation even modest reductions in the after tax cost of capital purchases provide strong incentives for increased investment indeed for tax subsidies that are temporary and for capital goods that are very long lived the incentive to invest when the after tax price is temporarily low is essentially infinite firms that would have purchased new capital equipment in the future instead make their purchases during the period of the subsidy for tax increases the effects are the opposite firms that would have normally invested now delay until the tax rate returns to normal we present a model of the equilibrium effects of temporary investment tax incentives the model reveals a simple relationship between the shadow price of investment goods and the size of a temporary investment tax incentive specifically for sufficiently long lived capital goods goods with very low rates of economic depreciation and for sufficiently short lived investment tax subsidies the shadow value of capital should be nearly unchanged and thus the pre tax shadow price of capital goods should fully reflect the magnitude of the tax subsidy this result holds regardless of the elasticity of investment supply and regardless of the underlying demand for capital instead it relies only on the firm s ability to arbitrage predictable movements in the after tax price of long lived capital over time two conclusions immediately follow first observ ing price increases following a temporary tax incentive is not evidence that investment supply is relatively inelastic a temporary investment tax subsidy can substantially affect investment even if it bids up the price of investment sharply second because economic theory dictates that the shadow price of investment moves one for one with a temporary tax subsidy the elasticity of supply can be inferred from quantity data alone recent changes in us tax law allow us to use the model and its implications to estimate struc tural parameters that govern the supply of investment the 2002 and 2003 tax bills provided temporarily accelerated tax depreciation called bonus depreciation for certain types of qualified capital goods under the 2002 bill firms could immediately deduct 30 percent of investment purchases and then depreciate the remaining 70 percent under standard depreciation schedules

optimal health insurance for prevention and treatment this paper reexamines the efficiency based arguments for optimal health insurance extending the classic analysis to consider optimal coverage for prevention and treatment separately our paper considers the tradeoff between individuals risk reduction on the one hand and both ex ante and ex post moral hazard on the other we demonstrate that it is always desirable to offer at least some insurance coverage for preventive care if individual consumers ignore the impact of their preventive care on the health premium using a utility based framework we reconfirm the conventional tradeoff between risk avoidance by risk sharing and moral hazard for insuring treatment goods uncompensated losses that reduce effective income provide a new efficiency based argument for more generous insurance coverage for prevention and treatment of health conditions the optimal coinsurance rates for prevention and for treatment are not identical