deciding between competition and collusion we develop an approach to identify and test for bid rigging in procurement auctions first we introduce a general auction model with asymmetric bidders second we study the problem of identie cation in our model we state a set of conditions that are both necessary and sufe cient for a distribution of bids to be generated by a model with competitive bidding third we discuss how to elicit a prior distribution over a e rm s structural cost parameters from industry experts given this prior distri bution we use bayes s theorem to compare competitive and collusive models of industry equilibrium finally we apply our methodology to a data set of bidding by construction e rms in the midwest the techniques we propose are not computationally demanding use e exible functional forms and can be programmed using most standard statistical packages

declining values and the afternoon effect evidence from art auctions we study the order of sale in art auctions the final bid relative to the auctioneer s estimated price declines throughout the course of an auction a theoretical model shows that in an auction ordered by declining valuation even in the presence of risk neutral strategic bidders the price received relative to the estimate for later items in an auction should be less than the price relative to the estimate for earlier items furthermore ordering heterogeneous items by value maximizes revenue for the auctioneer

optimal nonparametric estimation of first price auctions this paper proposes a general approach and a computationally convenient estimation procedure for the structural analysis of auctioni data considering first price sealed bid auction models within the independent private value paradigm we show that the underlying distribution of bidders private values is identified from observed bids and the number of actual bidders without any parametric assumptions using the theoiy of minimax we establish the best rate of uniform convergence at which the latent density of private values can be estimated nonparametrically from available data we then propose a two step kernel based estimator that converges at the optimal rate

dynamic conjectural variations in a lanchester oligopoly an approach based on dynamic conjectural variations is advanced for developing dynamic advertising strategies in a lanchester oligopoly differential game the approach allows competitors to anticipate rival reactions to market share state variables and maintains the computational advantage of open loop nash equilibrium strategies in an empirical application to the ready to eat cereal industry it is shown that advertising strategies based on dynamic conjectural variations can better explain the advertising of the cereal competitors than can open loop advertising strategies

subcontracting and the survival of plants in the road construction industry a panel quantile regression analysis this paper investigates how subcontracting parts of contracted work shapes entrants success and survival we find that newly developed quantile regression approaches can be adapted to study survival of firms competing for government contracts in road construction the method is applied on a data set that includes patterns of firm entry exit and auction related information we find an apparent increase in the business life of firms who subcontract out part of their projects in texas these subcontracting effects appear to be more pronounced for firms with few or no options outside the industry and among firms who contract out part of their work to disadvantaged business enterprises

a non expected utility model and its application in practical auctions this article presents a non expected utility decision model which is nonlinear in the winning probabilities the model not only explicitly expresses bidders attitudes to risk but also addresses t

equilibrium in auctions with entry the authors model entry incentives in auctions with risk neutral bidders and characterize a symmetric equilibrium in which the number of entrants is stochastic the presence of too many potential bidders raises coordination costs that detract from welfare the authors show that the seller and society can benefit from policies that reduce market thickness i e the relative abundance of buyers their analysis extends well known revenue equivalence and ranking theorems but also demonstrates that variations in the auction environment affect optimal policies e g reservation prices in ways not anticipated by models that ignore entry copyright 1994 by american economic association

closed loop advertising strategies in a duopoly using the lanchester model to describe the dynamics of the market where two firms compete for customers by advertising we solve the problem of determining an optimal advertising strategy for maximum discounted profits we develop both open and closed loop strategies and explain the relationship between them using a new mathematical approach we prove that our closed loop solution is a global nash equilibrium the closed loop strategy is time variant and depends linearly on the actual market share the time variant coefficient incorporates the discount factor its computation requires the solution of a backward differential equation and a set of two nonlinear differential equations for an initial value problem the closed loop advertising expenditures are proportional to the open loop advertising expenditures and to the square of the competitor s actual market share this provides a very practical adaptive control rule that allows the manager to adjust the actual advertising expenditure and to deviate f

dynamic promotional budgeting and media allocation this paper address the managerial problem of promotional budgeting and media allocation in a dynamic competitive framework we develop an extended lanchester model that is able to analyze multi instrument promotion in an oligopoly the competitors each with a different initial position as well as economic value of the market share and communication effectiveness adopt the strategy of maximizing their net present value of discounted profits taking the other players actions into account the resulting differential game is solved using a novel method providing both the open loop strategy and the closed loop strategy for each firm we prove that our solution is a global nash equilibrium we develop a simple formula that when applied to an open loop strategy readily generates a feedback strategy we also show that for both open and closed loop strategies the proportion of the budget allocated to each instrument is invariant with time and depends only on instrument effectiveness we illustrate the results and provide several managerial rules and discuss their application in practice finally we show that our model favorably compares with other model in the literature in explaining actual data

partnerships and double auctions with interdependent valuations in a symmetric independent private values setting a sealed bid double auction dissolves a partnership efficiently this well known result remains valid in a model with interdependent valuations however if common values components are large agents might prefer not to participate in a double auction therefore a simple extention of the rules of double auctions is suggested that ensures participation even though these modified double auctions are not incentive efficient they still realize gains from trade and can be implemented without knowledge about the specifications of the model

takeover contests toeholds and deterrence we consider a setting in which two potential buyers one with a prior toehold and one without compete in a takeover modeled as an ascending auction with participating costs the toeholder is more aggressive during the takeover process because she is also a seller of her own shares the non toeholder anticipates this extra aggressiveness of the toeholder thus he is deterred from participating unless he has a high valuation for the target company this leads to large inefficiency losses for many configurations expected target returns are first increasing then decreasing in the size of the toehold

auction guarantees for works of art abstract this paper addresses the question of whether auction guarantees change the bidding environment and whether they cause a change in price once the value of an item is taken into account we analyze both the cases of third party guarantees and in house guarantees we use two datasets one of christie s and sotheby s contemporary and impressionist evening sales from january 2010 to february 2012 and another larger dataset consisting of all items auctioned at christie s from 2001 to may 2011 while more expensive items are more likely to have guarantees we find little empirical evidence to suggest an effect on price from the guarantee itself once the value of the item is taken into account

does the sun shine on art prices this paper examines how variation in mood influences subjective risk and hence auction prices for art in london during the period 1990 2007 the private value of an object is closely related to taste and mood which is proxied for by the variation in weather using a unique data set that includes presale estimates for paintings sold through sotheby s and christie s auction houses as well as weather data for london from the british atmospheric data centre we find that the lower part of the price distribution is populated with paintings with a relative high private value whereas in the upper part prices are driven primarily by the common value characteristics our findings have important implications for collectors and investors in the art market

a decision support framework for evaluating revenue performance in sequential purchase contexts abstract this paper studies the product ordering problem in sequential purchase contexts where sellers aim to maximize their revenue faced with budget constrained buyers we propose a multi layered decision support framework that combines empirical data with simulation optimization and econometric methods to address this problem our framework allows sellers to i compare revenue performances of limited information sequencing strategies ii quantify benchmark revenue levels that can be achieved via the optimal sequence based on detailed buyer information iii determine the costs of limited information and strategic buyers to the seller and iv identify the moderators of sequencing strategy performance we illustrate our framework through two applications in a business to business used car auction setting contrary to previous studies reporting practitioners tendency to sequence items from the lowest value to the highest our results suggest that the best performing limited information sequencing strategy depends on buyers bidding behavior we also find that the revenue difference between the optimal sequence and a limited information sequencing strategy can be substantial our results show that a significant portion of this revenue difference is associated with the seller s limited information on buyers budgets and product valuations our applications also provide various sensitivity analyses and develop new propositions on the moderators of the relationship between the seller s revenue and sequencing strategies

asymmetric price benefits auctions abstract this paper studies the performance of two auction procedures for allocating the assets of a dissolving partnership when partners valuations for the assets are independent and asymmetrically distributed with one partner reputed to be more interested in the assets to be divided we provide results on existence and uniqueness of the equilibrium induced by these auctions comparative statics are developed especially the differences between relative efficiency and revenue from the two auctions journal of economic literature classification numbers c72 d39 d44 d52 d74 d82

initial shareholdings and overbidding in takeover contests within the context of takeovers this paper shows that in private value auctions the optimal individually rational strategy for a bidder with partial ownership of the item is to overbid i e to bid more than his valuation this strategy however can lead to i an inefficient outcome and ii the winning bidder making a net loss further the overbidding result implies that the presence of a large shareholder increases the bid premium in single bidder takeovers at the expense of reducing the probability of the takeover actually occurring

sequential auctions of heterogeneous objects abstract we consider sequential second price auctions in which heterogeneous objects are sold to bidders with unit demand and a single dimensional type we show that a symmetric increasing equilibrium exists if objects are ordered in terms of dispersiveness of value distributions equilibrium price declines when objects are equivalent on average and additional conditions hold

catalogue vs order of sale effects in sequential auctions theory and evidence from a rare book sale we examine bidding in a rare book sequential auction that has features of a natural experiment lots were arranged in alphabetical order the reserve set non strategically and half the bids placed by mail in bidders we distinguish between the effects induced by the print order of the catalogue from those by the sequential nature of the sale we document the existence of distinct catalogue effects on prices number of bids and price variability and determine their causes we demonstrate that these catalogue effects also influence floor bidder behaviour we derive a theoretical model that generates key aspects of floor bidder behaviour copyright 2004 royal economic society

can affirmative action be cost effective an experimental examination of price preference auctions one of the most controversial questions facing our economy and society in recent years is the question of affirmative action the debate centers around an issue of minority representation in which the rights of the majority are depicted as being compromised by affirmative action programs set up to increase the welfare of minorities implicit in this discussion is the assumption that all affirmative action programs must be cost increasing this result it is claimed follows trivially from economic theory since any interference into the competitive process which prevents the most capable from being chosen must be wasteful and costly in this paper we challenge this claim with experimental results demonstrating that pricepreference auctions in which high cost minority firms are given preferential treatment in the awarding of contracts in such a way that it is possible for these firms to win a contract but not have submitted the lowest bid can be programs that both enhance minority representation and are cost effective in that they decrease the cost of government procurement in the theoretical literature on asymmetric auctions eric maskin and john riley 1995 and the optimal auction literature roger myerson 1981 it has been shown that in asymmetric auctions in which firms draw their costs from

how auctions work for wine and art interview auctioneers and even to buy a little wine in the meantime i have also had the opportunity with john abowd 1988 to observe and collect data on the auction sale of impressionist and contemporary paintings this paper reports on some of the empirical regularities that i and others have observed in the actual operation of the auction markets for these items in view of the rich and diverse array of theoretical literature on auctions it seems high time economists began to spell out precisely what facts it is meant to explain 2

advertising competition in a dynamic oligopoly with multiple brands a model is developed that allows the derivation of feedback nash equilibrium advertising strategies for oligopolistic competitors the model is an extension of a modified vidale wolfe model that incorporates multiple brands per competitor the resulting expressions of feedback advertising strategies are combined with those for sales dynamics in an empirical model that is applied to the carbonated soft drink market which involves three primary competitors and five primary brands the research provides the following contributions a modification of the vidale wolfe model is extended to allow dynamic analysis of an oligopoly in which the competitors each offer multiple brands the model extension permits the derivation of a feedback nash equilibrium the determination of a feedback nash equilibrium enhances empirical analysis by allowing an expanded empirical model that includes the explicit modeling of endogenous advertising along with demand relationships

retailers and consumers in sequential auctions of collectibles we analyse an independent private value model where heterogeneous bidders compete for objects sold in sequential second price auctions in this heterogeneous game bidders may have differently distributed valuations and some have multi unit demand with decreasing marginal values retailers others have a specific single unit demand consumers by examining equilibrium bidding strategies and price sequences we show that the presence of consumers leads to more aggressive bidding from the retailers on average and heterogeneous bidders is a plausible explanation of the price decline effect the study of the expected revenue of the seller confirms the interest of auctioneers in inviting different types of bidders nous analysons un modele a valeurs privees independantes dans lequel des encherisseurs heterogenes sont en concurrence pour des objets vendus lors d encheres sequentielles au second prix dans ce jeu heterogene les encherisseurs tirent leurs evaluations de distributions qui peuvent differer et certains les revendeurs ont des demandes multi unitaires avec des evaluations marginales decroissantes alors que les autres les consommateurs ont une demande individuelle specifique l examen des strategies d equilibre et des sequences de prix montrent que la presence de consommateurs conduit en moyenne a des encheres plus agressives de la part des revendeurs et que la presence d encherisseurs heterogenes constitue une explication plausible a la decroissance des prix l etude de l esperance du revenu du vendeur confirme l interet des commissaires priseurs a inviter differentes categories d acheteurs

entry and competition effects in first price auctions theory and evidence from procurement auctions motivated by several interesting features of the highway mowing auction data from the texas department of transportation tdot we study three competing procurement auction models with endogenous entry our entry and bidding models provide several interesting implications for the first time we show that even within an independent private value paradigm as the number of potential bidders increases bidders equilibrium bidding behaviour can become less aggressive and the expected procurement cost may rise because the entry effect is always positive and may dominate the negative competition effect we then develop structural models of entry and bidding corresponding to the three models under consideration controlling for unobserved auction heterogeneity and use the recently developed semi parametric bayesian estimation method to analyse the data we select the model that best fits the data and use the corresponding structural estimates to quantify the entry effect and the competition effect with regard to the individual bids and the procurement cost copyright 2009 wiley blackwell

design competition through multidimensional auctions this article studies design competition in government procurement by developing a model of two dimensional auctions wherefirms bid on both price and quality and bids are evaluated by a scoring rule designed by a buyer three auction schemes first score second score and second preferred offer are introduced and related to actual practices if the buyer can commit to a scoring rule in his best interest the resulting optimal scoring rule underrewards quality relative to the buyer s utility function and implements the optimal outcome for the buyer underfirst and second score auctions absent the commitment power the onlyfeasible scoring rule is the buyer s utility function under which 1 all three schemes yield the same expected utility to the buyer and 2 first and second score auctions induce the first best level of quality which turns out to be excessive from the buyer s point of view

endogenous participation in charity auctions abstract data from a recent field experiment suggests that differences in participation rates are responsible for much of the variations in charity auction revenues across formats we provide a theoretical framework for the analysis of this and other related results the model illustrates the limits of previous results that assume full participation and introduces some new considerations to the choice of auction mechanism it also implies however that the data cannot be explained in terms of participation costs alone there must exist mechanism specific obstacles to participation

a model of advertising competition using a dynamic model of advertising rivalry between competitors in a duopoly the author obtains analytical results for the case of pure market share rivalry in a mature market a more general mod

how not to raise money we show that standard winner pay auctions are inept fund raising mechanisms because of the positive externality bidders forgo if they top another s high bid revenues are suppressed as a result and remain finite even when bidders value a dollar donated the same as a dollar kept this problem does not occur in lotteries and all pay auctions where bidders pay irrespective of whether they win we introduce a general class of all pay auctions rank their revenues and illustrate how they dominate lotteries and winner pay formats the optimal fund raising mechanism is an all pay auction augmented with an entry fee and reserve price

auctions with endogenous quantity this article studies auctions in which several sellers compete for the right to sell to a market characterized by a negatively sloped demand curve in this environment the quantity traded becomes endogenous this effect leads to three results concerning the outcomes of open versus first price sealed bid auctions first an open auction yields a higher expected price than does sealed bidding second and more important the open auction captures less of the potential gains from trade than does the sealed bid auction third for broad classes of demand curves the efficiency gains from switching to sealed bids from an open auction accrue to both sellers and the buyer so that all concerned parties would agree to the change a direct application of the theory is to procurement the heavy use of sealed bidding in procurement is seen as rational in light of these results auction models with endogenous quantity could be an alternative to price setting oligopoly models for the study of price formation in general for the latter impose strong information requirements on agents and yield only equilibrium price vectors not equilibrium processes for determining prices

government procurement and international trade abstract we model the bidding for a government contract in which there is imperfect competition each bidder is better informed about his own costs than either his rival bidders or the government and the distribution of the domestic firms costs differs from the distribution of foreign firms costs because of comparative advantage effects we find that the government minimizes its expected procurement cost by operating a price preference policy not necessarily purchasing from the lowest bidder

the collateral value of fine art in this paper we examine the effect of implicit seller reserves on the estimation of value at risk based on historical asset sales data we direct our examination toward how and whether fine art might prove an appropriate form of loan collateral for banks and other financial institutions using a data set of french impressionist paintings brought to auction from 1985 to 2001 we control for the effect of works that are bought in house to construct a distribution of potential sale values that corrects for sample selection bias it turns out that the downside risk surrounding deviations of auction prices from expert presale estimates depends critically on how buy ins are incorporated if downside risk is assessed solely on historical experience with successful auction sales the data appear to support loan to value ratios between 50 and a 100 larger than loan to value ratios that countenance the existence of seller reserves the auction process however is quantifiable and can reveal the necessary risk information required for loan consideration

secret reserve prices in a bidding model with a re sale option this paper presents an auction model in which the seller may choose not to sell in spite of receiving a bid above the announced reserve price such behavior is seen frequently in auctions yet would be suboptimal within most existing models here the seller uses resale to signal information about the object s value that could not be easily communicated via a reserve price announcement the model predicts that bids for reauctioned objects increase relative to initial bids and that on average prices of both reauctioned items and those sold at initial auction rise as delay in reauctioning increases copyright 1997 by american economic association

auctions and the price of art the value of most important works of art is established by public auction either directly by an actual sale or indirectly by reference to other sales how the auction system works is thus a critical determinant of how the public s preferences are translated into the evaluation of artistic work the auction system is central in the determination of the incentives for artistic work and the efficiency of the auction system is a key determinant of the cost of creating and distributing works of art this paper contains a review of the burgeoning new research of the last decade that has been designed to shed light on how the art auction system actually works what it indicates about price formation and how well it performs we begin our discussion in section 2 with a short description of the mechanics of the auction system and then organize the remainder of our discussion around two major topics the first topic concerns how auction prices can be used to determine and compare overall price movements within the art market and other markets and the second topic concerns how the auction mechanism influences prices we

auctions with price proportional benefits to bidders after some auctions including amish estate sales and buyer rings knockout auctions each bidder receives a share of the revenue generated by the auction we show that in the symmetric case equilibrium bids in both first price sealed bid auctions and oral auctions increase as each bidder s share increases in the case of independent signals oral auctions result in higher expected equilibrium prices than do first price sealed bid auctions journal of economic literature classification number d44

bid preference programs and participation in highway procurement auctions we use data from highway procurement auctions subject to california s small business preference program to study the effect of bid preferences on auction outcomes our analysis is based on an estimated model of firms bidding and participation decisions which allows us to evaluate the effects of current and alternative policy designs we show that incorporating participation responses significantly alters the assessment of preferential treatment policies

vested interest and biased price estimates evidence from an auction market this study employs a new data set from art auctions to examine the relationship between auctioneer presale price estimates and the long term performance of artworks we find that the price estimates for expensive paintings have a consistent upward bias over a long period of 30 years high estimates at the time of purchase are associated with adverse subsequent abnormal returns moreover the estimation error for individual paintings tends to persist over time these results are consistent with the view that auction house price estimates are affected by agency problems and that

differential game models of advertising competition abstract differential game methodology combines two attractive features that are critical to the study of advertising competition dynamics and multi competitor decision making a focused review of two decades of differential game modeling of advertising competition indicates that insights gained to date while valuable are of a limited nature and research in the area needs to extend beyond present limits four recent studies are offered as examples of possible directions to follow in continued research

private information and altruism in bidding roscas this article studies how altruism improves allocations in a private information environment where strategic behaviour reduces economic welfare a theoretical analysis establishes that in an environment characterised by uncertainty and private information outcomes of auctions in rotating savings and credit associations roscas are more efficient when bidders preferences are altruistic rather than selfish a semi parametric structural estimation technique for rosca auctions is presented a parametric structural estimation identifies interactions between group characteristics and bidder altruism it is found that effective leadership and intra group diversity are associated with a greater extent of bidder altruism and thus more efficient intra rosca allocations

on the strategic choice between capital and labor mobility abstract this paper analyzes the strategies of two governments when choosing between capital and labor mobility for each type of factor mobility the nash equilibria under both income taxes and quotas on factor flows are derived from each country s point of view an income tax dominates a quota the paper also shows that in a strategic environment ramaswami s result that a country prefers the restricted inflow of a scarce factor to the restricted outflow of an abundant factor continues to hold for some initial factor endowments but the opposite result may obtain for other factor endowments

guarantees in auctions the auction house as negotiator and managerial decision maker the multimillion dollar price guarantees that an auction house can offer for paintings have already had a large impact on auction house profits and place new demands on the auctioneer s decision making and negotiating skills yet auctioneers have not been studied as independent entities and decision makers to create a price guarantee the auction house and the seller must negotiate both the guarantee amount and the extra commission the seller pays if the auction price exceeds the guarantee we present a normative model of negotiations and find the frontier of guarantee and commission that is the nash bargaining solution we also determine the optimal reserve that the auctioneer should place on guaranteed property we find that guarantees decrease the auction house s expected revenue compared to a conventional auction but do allow it to attract business which might otherwise be lost guarantees benefit sellers increasing the expected value and lowering the variance of their auction revenue the auctioneer s optimal strategy depends not only on the distribution of the artwork s auction price but also the price it will bring if it fails to sell at auction in the latter case the auction house must pay the seller the guarantee and then sell the artwork which it now owns in a private secondary market where buyers regard the property as damaged goods and lower their offers although all points on the frontier produce equal expected revenue several frequently used decision making rules suggest that both parties may prefer a guarantee arrangement where the seller pays no additional commission and the guarantee has the lowest value on the frontier

anchoring effects evidence from art auctions in order to separate anchoring where an irrelevant message has an effect on the outcome from rational learning where past prices are not irrelevant because they may be used to estimate unobservable quality we use the following strategy we first develop a hedonic prediction of price for both the current sale e g the 2006 sale and the previous sale these hedonic predic tions are based on observable characteristics of each painting and an index of overall prices we then regress actual sale price on our hedonic prediction on the difference between the actual price in the previous sale and our hedonic prediction this expression tests for anchoring and on the difference between the actual price in the previous sale and our hedonic prediction of price in the previous sale this expression controls for unobservable characteristics the test for anchor ing is the extent to which the actual price in the previous sale affects the current sale price we can identify anchoring from other effects because the demand for art which is captured by the average overall price index changes over time whereas the unobservable component of qual ity is assumed to remain constant between auctions this allows us to control for unobserved quality characteristics as long as something drastic has not happened between sales such as a painting has been deemed a fake which is a very rare occurrence the assumption of constant quality is a realistic one

a note on feedback sequential equilibria in a lanchester model with empirical application we study in this paper dynamic equilibrium advertising strategies in a duopoly with asymmetric information structure and sequential play the advertising model of lanchester is used in a game where the relevant solution concept is feedback stackelberg equilibrium which is subgame perfect an algorithm is devised for the computation of this equilibrium and numerical results are reported and discussed using a data set from the cola market we obtain the resulting advertising strategies and provide a comparison with closed loop and open loop nash equilibria

asymmetry in first price auctions with affiliated private values collusion and heterogeneity across firms may introduce asymmetry in bidding games a major difficulty in asymmetric auctions is that the bayesian nash equilibrium strategies are solutions of an intractable system of differential equations we propose a simple method for estimating asymmetric first price auctions with affiliated private values considering two types of bidders we show that these differential equations can be rewritten using the observed bid distribution we establish the identification of the model characterize its theoretical restrictions and propose a two step non parametric estimation procedure for estimating the private value distributions an empirical analysis of joint bidding in ocs auctions is provided copyright 2003 john wiley sons ltd

optimal auctions with asymmetric financial externalities abstract this paper studies optimal auction design with asymmetric linear financial externalities among bidders when the matrix that relates bidders payoffs to their payments is nonsingular the payment related component in the design objective must equal a unique linear combination of its counterparts in bidder s payoffs if all multipliers of the linear combination are nonnegative a modified myerson procedure is discovered for deriving the optimal design if any multiplier is negative an arbitrarily high value can be achieved for design objective by setting proper fixed transfers to bidders when the matrix is singular the unbounded optimum result typically prevails we applied our method to auctions with cross shareholdings and charity auctions for revenue maximizing and efficient designs

small business set asides in procurement auctions an empirical analysis as part of public procurement many governments adopt small business programs to pro vide contract opportunities for businesses often with preferences for firms operated by mem bers of groups designated as disadvantaged the redistribution arising from such programs however can introduce significant added costs to government procurement budgets in this paper the extent to which small business set asides increase government procurement costs is examined the estimates employ data on japanese public construction projects where approximately half of the procurement budget is set aside for small and medium enterprises smes applying a positive relationship between profitability and firm size obtained by the non parametric estimation of asymmetric first price auctions with affiliated private values a counterfactual simulation is undertaken to demonstrate that approximately 40 percent of smes would exit the procurement market if set asides were to be removed surprisingly the resulting lack of competition would increase government procurement costs more than it would offset the production cost inefficiency

costly auction entry royalty payments and the optimality of asymmetric designs abstract we analyze optimal auction mechanisms when bidders base costly entry decisions on their valuations and bidders pay with a fixed royalty rate plus cash with sufficient valuation uncertainty relative to entry costs the optimal mechanism features asymmetry so that bidders enter with strictly positive but different ex ante probabilities when bidders are ex ante identical higher royalty rates which tie payments more closely to bidder valuations increase the optimal degree of asymmetry in auction design further raising revenues when bidders differ ex ante in entry costs the seller favors the low cost entrant whereas when bidders have different valuation distributions the seller favors the weaker bidder if entry costs are low but not if they are high higher royalty rates cause the seller to favor the weaker bidder by less and the strong bidder by more

identification and estimation of auction models with unobserved heterogeneity in many procurement auctions the bidders unobserved costs depend both on a common shock and on idiosyncratic private information assuming a multiplicative structure i derive sufficient conditions under which the model is identified and propose a non parametric estimation procedure that results in uniformly consistent estimators of the cost components distributions the estimation procedure is applied to data from michigan highway procurement auctions private information is estimated to account for 34 of the variation in bidders costs it is shown that accounting for unobserved auction heterogeneity has important implications for the evaluation of the distribution of rents efficiency and optimal auction design

the many player advertising game this study extends the time variant closed loop strategy of fruchter and kalish 1997 to the n player advertising game we demonstrate that solving an n player game using 2 players results in overadvertising

silent auctions in the field and in the laboratory we analyze data from hundreds of auctions from three field silent auction sessions we focus on the descriptive statistics and on a parametric model of jump bidding we then report data from six laboratory sessions of silent auctions as a controlled environment this allows us to evaluate the auctions in ways not available within the field the laboratory experiments capture essential features of the field sessions and thus comprise a credible laboratory testbed for further examination of institutional perturbations in the silent auction jel d44 h41

an oligopoly model of dynamic advertising competition abstract an oligopoly model is presented that allows the determination of feedback nash equilibrium advertising strategies for an oligopoly analyses of symmetric and asymmetric oligopolies with the model show that unit contribution and advertising effectiveness have positive effects on a competitor s own advertising and steady state sales while discount rate and decay rate have negative effects an asymmetric analysis further shows that unit contribution and advertising effectiveness affect positively and discount rate and decay rate negatively a competitor s rivals advertising but have effects in opposite directions regarding rivals steady state sales the symmetric and asymmetric analyses also show that steady state sales per competitor decline with the number of competitors in the oligopoly while total oligopoly steady state sales increase the model is applied empirically to the triopolistic competition involving anheuser busch sabmiller and molson coors in the beer industry

empirical analysis of closed loop duopoly advertising strategies closed loop perfect equilibria in a lanchester duopoly differential game of advertising competition are used as the basis for empirical investigation two systems of simultaneous nonlinear equations are formed one from a general lanchester model and one from a constrained model two empirical applications are conducted in one involving coca cola and pepsi cola a formal statistical testing procedure is used to detect whether closed loop equilibrium advertising strategies are used by the competitors rather than open loop strategies in the second application involving anheuser busch and miller the general model is estimated results indicate that closed loop equilibria better explain dynamic advertising competition than do open loop equilibria also closed loop equilibrium advertising strategies implied by model estimates show that competitive advertising levels may or may not be monotonic in market share

nonparametric estimation of asymmetric first price auctions a simplified approach abstract we present an approach to nonparametric estimation of pseudo values in asymmetric affiliated private values apv models for first price auctions that eliminates the curse of dimensionality we show that pseudo values can be estimated by using two dimensional functions of bids for apv models regardless of the form of asymmetry

an empirical investigation of advertising strategies in a dynamic duopoly the equilibrium profit maximizing advertising policies of firms operating in a dynamic duopoly are derived by linking in a single framework the econometric estimation of the market response function and the technique of differential games that characterizes dynamic competitive behavior we use the lanchester model of combat to represent the system dynamics that capture the competitive shifts due to investments in advertising by the two market rivals we determine the equilibrium advertising levels using both closed and open loop policies we also compare these equilibrium advertising policies for each firm to those obtained using an optimal control theory formulation wherein the advertising spending levels of the rival are assumed to be known the empirical results obtained by analyzing the advertising rivalry between coke and pepsi for the period 1968 1981 under the above three alternative spending policies provide some interesting insights into the nature of competition between these two market rivals a significant contribution of this paper is to extend the existing literature on advertising competition by integrating theoretical and empirical analyses

charitable motives and bidding in charity auctions research on bidding in auctions has generally relied on the assumption of self interested bidders this work relaxes that assumption in the context of charity auctions because understanding charitable motives has important implications for auction design and charities fundraising strategies this study investigates bidders specific types of charitable motives and the strength of these motives we carry out three controlled field experiments consisting of real life auctions conducted on a local internet auction site we use a novel design in which we simultaneously run charity and noncharity auctions for identical products and vary the percentage donated to charity results show that auctions with proceeds donated to charity lead to significantly higher selling prices a result due to a higher bidding by bidders with charitable motives rather than to increased bidder entry we also find that increased prices only occur when the charitable donation is a percentage of the auction revenue and that a fixed charitable donation associated with each auction has no effect on prices furthermore we find that prices are increasing in the percentage donated to charity we find considerable support for a model of voluntary shill like bidding where charitable bidders try to increase proceeds in charity auctions we also find that auctions with 25 of revenue donated to charity had higher net revenue than noncharity auctions hence companies may be able to use charity auctions as part of a corporate social responsibility strategy and at the same time increase profitability even though they donate part of the proceeds to charity

an empirical study on the lanchester model of combat for competitive advertising decisions this paper presents an empirical study on the lanchester model of combat for competitive advertising decisions three issues are evaluated i the specification of the market share response model ii the effect of inflation on the estimation of the response model and iii the performance of competitive strategies it is shown that a the square root function that is used in previous studies is often inappropriate to characterize the market share response model b market share variations are more responsive to current advertising expenditures c closed loop nash equilibrium strategies are better competitive advertising strategies for firms to maximize profits than open loop nash equilibrium strategies and d finally general perfect equilibria nash equilibrium strategies developed by case are usually not good competitive advertising strategies for firms to maximize profits

rotating savings and credit associations when participants are risk averse we model rotating savings and credit associations roscas among risk averse participants who experience privately observed income shocks a random rosca is not advantageous whereas a bidding rosca is if temporal risk aversion is less pronounced than static risk aversion the payoff scheme of a bidding rosca facilitates risk sharing in the presence of information asymmetries the risk sharing performance of a simple arrangement where a group of homogenous individuals runs several bidding roscas simultaneously is as good as that of a linear risk sharing contract and is more enforceable because it carries a fixed rather than a variable contribution

the potentials of a reverse auction in allocating subsidies for cost effective roof top photovoltaic system deployment abstract photovoltaic pv has developed to one of the most promising technologies for renewable electricity generation the austrian government currently provides subsidies for roof top pv systems through a constant administratively determined feed in tariff or an investment co funding in both subsidy schemes applications are approved on a first come first served basis there are concerns about i the selection of suitable roofs for pv systems and ii allocating subsidies among applicants to deploy roof top pv systems cost effectively thus we analyze the potentials of a simple discriminative first price reverse auction application scheme applicants define individually the required level of subsidy and those with the lowest request for subsidies are selected in an ex post analysis we evaluate the potentials of such a scheme in increasing power output and saving public spending for the federal state of vorarlberg in austria results indicate a potential increase of cumulated produced electricity between 15 and 18 in comparison to the current policy in addition a reverse auction based system would lead to savings of public spending per kwh between 20 and 41

charity auctions with multiple goods bidding behavior and revenue abstract in a charity auction with multiple goods we show that the highest losing bid uniform price auction revenue dominates its lowest winning bid counterpart only in the highest losing bid uniform price auction is bidding independent of the number of goods and players and revenue increasing in the number of goods

markov perfect equilibrium advertising strategies of lanchester duopoly model a technical note we propose a numerical approach to compute stationary markov perfect nash equilibrium advertising strategies of the lanchester model the algorithm can be implemented using a standard mathematical package and importantly it does not require that the players discount their future earnings at a zero rate an assumption that has been made in the literature

recent developments in dynamic advertising research a variety of continuous time differential functions have been developed to investigate dynamic advertising problems in business and economics fields since major dynamic models appearing before 1995 have been reviewed by a few survey papers we provide a comprehensive review of the dynamic advertising models published after 1995 which are classified into six categories i nerlove arrow model and its extensions ii vidale wolfe model and its extensions iii lanchester model and its extensions iv the diffusion models v dynamic advertising competition models with other attributes and vi empirical studies for dynamic advertising problems for each category we first briefly summarize major relevant before 1995 models and then discuss major after 1995 models in details we find that the dynamic models reviewed in this paper have been extensively used to analyze various advertising problems in the monopoly duopoly oligopoly and supply chain systems our review reveals that the diffusion models have not been used to analyze advertising problems in supply chain operations which may be a research direction in the future moreover we learn from our review that very few publications regarding dynamic advertising problems have considered the supply chain competition we also find that very few researchers have used the diffusion model to investigate the dynamic advertising problems with product quality as a decision variable and the pricing decision has not been incorporated into any extant lanchester model the paper ends with a summary of our review and suggestions on possible research directions in the future

are bid preferences benign the effect of small business subsidies in highway procurement auctions abstract bid preferences in procurement auctions allow firms from an identifiable group an advantage in bidding against unfavored firms while economic efficiency is expected to fall as a result of bid preferences government procurement costs may either increase or decrease depending on the competitive response of favored and unfavored firms this paper uses data from california auctions for road construction contracts where small businesses receive a 5 percent bid preference in auctions for projects using only state funds and no preferential treatment on projects using federal aid i show that while firms bidding behavior matches theoretical predictions procurement costs are 3 8 percent higher on auctions using preferences the higher procurement cost in preference auctions is attributed to reduced participation by lower cost large firms structural estimates of latent firm costs are then used to evaluate how efficiency and the division of surplus between firms and the government are impacted by bid preferences firm profits are 3 1 percent lower under bid preferences however this is overwhelmed by the efficiency loss due to reduced large firm participation the efficiency loss conditional on firm participation is estimated to represent around 0 1 percent of overall procurement costs including the adverse effect of preferences on the participation of large firms increases the estimated efficiency loss to 3 6 percent which represents 27 cents for each additional dollar awarded to small businesses through the program counterfactual simulations indicate that if participation were instead inelastic to bid preferences the 5 percent bid preference would be close to the optimal level

high bids and broke winners abstract this paper analyzes auctions where budget constrained bidders have options to declare bankruptcy it predicts a bidding equilibrium that changes discontinuously in a borrowing rate available to bidders when the borrowing rate is above a threshold high budget bidders win and the likelihood of bankruptcy is low when the borrowing rate is below the threshold the winner is the most budget constrained bidder and is most likely to declare bankruptcy this result explains the high bids and broke winners anomaly in the c block fcc spectrum auction based on its equilibrium analysis the paper proves that a seller can profit from offering to finance the highest bidder at a below market interest rate even with default risk journal of economic literature classification numbers d44 d45 d82 g33 l96

collusive practices in repeated english auctions experimental evidence on bidding rings the repeated meeting of buyers at english auctions where multiple units are sold is a common occurrence the art auctions at sotheby s christie s and other prestigious auction houses are attended by a regular group of institutional buyers more mundanely the same taxicab buyers meet at vehicle auctions for used police cars jon p nelson 1995 commission order buyers attend the same livestock and agricultural commodity auctions these buyers may be agents for multiple meat processors u s department of agriculture grain inspection packers and stockyards administration 2001 the 1946 american tobacco antitrust case american tobacco co et al v united states 328 u s 781 1946 is a well known account of how buyers of tobacco operated to hold down the price of auctioned leaf tobacco at various sites buyers for the big three cigarette manufacturers had developed facilitating practices that helped them purchase raw tobacco at relatively low prices these buyers voluntarily restricted themselves to attend the same auctions buyers were aware of the amount of leaf and the tobacco grades available at auction sites they had instructions from the cigarette makers on the highest bid prices they could pay and communication among these buyers seemed evident from a coordinated practice of buying low grade tobacco that was not used by the makers in the sale of livestock cattle producers have claimed that packer buyers act to hold down cattle prices at the auction site there are a few large processors who give their agents buy orders these orders along with further communication between the processor and agent instruct the agent on the number of cattle to purchase during a given week and provide a schedule of prices they can pay for varying types of cattle some agents represent more than one processor or packer and therefore have multiple buy orders agents repeatedly meet each other at regional cattle auctions they may not be the only buyers but they are the largest purchasers of slaughter cattle brought to market and at most auction sites have substantial monopsony power this paper documents the impacts of several practices that may facilitate low sale prices when multiple units are sold at repeated english auctions laboratory english auction markets are created the number of symmetric buyers attending the auction is either six or two with total demand in these two environments held constant the six buyer market is intended to represent a relatively competitive environment while auctions with two buyers represent rivalry with substantial monopsony power held by each agent we use these two market environments to study how selected treatments or facilitating influences affect the behavior of buying agents the six buyer market generally is viewed as a control for comparison to the dominant twobuyer environment but very collusive behavior may be observed in the six buyer auctions depending upon market practices phillips department of economics and finance university of wyoming p o box 3985 laramie wy 82071 e mail owenphil uwyo edu menkhaus department of agricultural and applied economics university of wyoming p o box 3354 laramie wy 82071 e mail menkhaus uwyo edu coatney u s department of agriculture grain inspection packers and stockyards administration competition branch aurora co 80011 e mail kalyn t coatney usda gov this work has been supported by the u s department of agriculture under grant numbers usdagipsnc5418 and usdag00354009126 the findings and conclusions expressed in this paper are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the funding agency 1 these are regional auctions houses where slaughter cattle primarily cull cows and fed steers and heifers and feeder cattle are sold cull cows are animals taken out of a herd and slaughtered because of age inability to produce calves or reduced milk production concerns regarding slaughter cow possessors sharing common purchasing agents have been raised in assessment of the cattle and hog industries calendar year 2000 u s department of agriculture grain inspection packers and stockyards administration june 2001

quality improvement and goodwill accumulation in a dynamic duopoly abstract this paper analyzes optimal advertising and quality improvement decisions by duopolist firms competing in a dynamic setting an extended version of the lanchester model is formulated where conformance quality and goodwill are both involved in competition for market share each competitor s new customer attraction rate depends on its own goodwill while the disloyalty rate for current customers is influenced by the proportion of defective items the search for a non cooperative solution by qualitative as well as numerical means leads to definition of the optimal path for advertising and improvement efforts for each competitor examined under a wide range of configurations

erratumauction guarantees for works of art this paper addresses the question of whether auction guarantees change the bidding environment and whether they cause a change in price once the value of an item is taken into account we analyze both the cases of third party guarantees and in house guarantees we use two datasets one of christie s and sotheby s contemporary and impressionist evening sales from january 2010 to february 2012 and another larger dataset consisting of all items auctioned at christie s from 2001 to may 2011 while more expensive items are more likely to have guarantees we find little empirical evidence to suggest an effect on price from the guarantee itself once the value of the item is taken into account