pollution without subsidy what is the environmental performance index overlooking abstract agriculture is heavily subsidized in most organization for economic cooperation and development oecd countries and environmental externalities can occur due to pollution caused by protectionist policies this study examines the structure of agricultural protection in oecd countries from a chronological and comparative perspective in addition the policy environment interaction is scrutinized to better explain the environmental implications of agricultural policies in the era of globalization this paper critically evaluates the environmental performance index and recommends that this index includes polluting inputs in future calculations

environmental policy in the european union fostering the development of pollution havens abstract a pollution haven occurs when dirty industries from developed nations relocate to developing nations in order to avoid strict environmental standards or developed nations imports of dirty industries expand replacing domestic production the purpose of this study is to determine whether the european union eu has increased its imports of dirty goods from poorer less democratic countries during a period of more stringent environmental standards previous empirical studies such as those by levinson and taylor levinson a and taylor m s in press unmasking the pollution haven effect international economic review ederington levinson and minier ederington j levinson a and minier j 2005 footloose and pollution free review of economics and statistics 87 92 99 kahn and yoshino 2004 and ederington and minier ederington j and minier j 2003 is environmental policy a secondary trade barrier an empirical analysis canadian journal of economics 36 137 54 find evidence that united states imports are responsive to changes in environmental stringency but the effects of eu policy have not been examined as thoroughly our study follows kahn kahn m e 2003 the geography of us pollution intensive trade evidence from 1958 to 1994 regional science and urban economics 33 383 400 and examines the impact of industry energy intensity and toxicity measured by an energy index and a toxic release inventory tri index on imports into the eu at the 2 digit industry level from 1970 to 1999 we use the signing of the maastricht treaty to signify a period of more uniform and stringent community wide environmental standards 1993 1999 and identify the level of per capita gdp within an eu trading partner we find an increased amount of eu energy intensive trade with poorer countries during the period with more stringent eu environmental standards this result is not robust however when poorer countries are defined by oecd membership and geographic region we do not find an increased amount of eu toxic intensive trade with poorer countries although there is some evidence of increased eu imports of toxic goods from poorer oecd and non eu european countries for our full sample of trading partners in all regions the evidence supports the phh for eu energy intensive trade but not for toxic intensive trade results for regional trade analysis are less clear

the policy preferences of the us federal reserve in this paper we model and explain us macroeconomic outcomes subject to the discipline that monetary policy is set optimally exploiting the restrictions that come from optimal policymaking we estimate the parameters in the federal reserve s policy objective function together with the parameters in its optimization constraints for the period following volcker s appointment as chairman we estimate the implicit inflation target to be around 1 4 and show that policymakers assigned a significant weight to interest rate smoothing we show that the estimated optimal policy provides a good description of us data for the 1980s and 1990s

price stability vs output stability tales of federal reserve administrations abstract this study disentangles policy parameters from those describing private sector behavior by simultaneously estimating an empirical model for inflation and output along with a loss function for the last three federal reserve administrations three important results emerge first the federal reserve appears to put more emphasis on price stability than output stability when the entire sample is considered second and more importantly the loss function parameters exhibit structural break at the time paul volcker was appointed chairman the accommodative characteristics of monetary policy were replaced with a more active policy towards controlling inflation finally interest rate smoothing is found to be an important feature of the monetary policymaking process for all three administrations

questioning the empirical basis of the environmental kuznets curve for co2 new evidence from a panel stationarity test robust to multiple breaks and cross dependence abstract this paper investigates the time series properties of per capita co2 emissions and per capita gdp levels for a sample of 86 countries over the period 1960 2000 for that purpose we employ a state of the art panel stationarity test which incorporates multiple shifts in level and slope thereby controlling for cross sectional dependence through bootstrap methods our analysis renders clear cut evidence that per capita gdp levels are nonstationary for the world as a whole while per capita co2 is found to be regime wise trend stationary the analysis of country groups shows that for africa and asia per capita co2 is best described as nonstationary while per capita gdp appears stationary around a broken trend in addition we find evidence of regime wise trend stationarity in both variables for the country groups consisting of america europe and oceania the results of our analysis carry important implications for the statistical modelling of the environmental kuznets curve for co2 since the differing order of integration in both variables for the world as a whole and for africa and asia calls into question the validity of panel cointegration techniques which assume that both variables are nonstationary and cointegrated with one another cointegration techniques would not be appropriate either for the case of america europe and oceania which are characterised by per capita gdp and co2 emissions being stationary around a broken trend similar conclusions are reached when we analyse country groups based on levels of development failure to properly characterise the time series properties of the data by not controlling for an unknown number of structural breaks and for cross sectional dependence could be responsible for the fragility and lack of robustness surrounding the estimation of environmental kuznets curves

pollution haven hypothesis revisited a comparison of the brics and mint countries based on vecm approach abstract the aim of this study is to investigate the existence of pollution haven hypothesis phh and test the casual relationship between inward foreign direct investment fdi and environmental pollutions as well as other potential influencing factors of environmental performance to this end a panel vector error correction model vecm and panel co integration test is conducted for two country groups the brics i e brazil russia india china and south africa and the mint i e mexico indonesia nigeria and turkey during 1982 2014 empirical results illustrate a bidirectional and positive causality between fdi inflows and gdp per capita for both groups implying a virtuous circle of fdi growth nexus more importantly both the brics and mint countries illustrate bidirectional and negative causality between fdi inflows and environmental pressures i e per capita energy consumption for brics and per capita carbon emissions for mint such findings indicate the pollution haven hypothesis does not stand in this case in addition it is also found that the opening degree of trade can be promoted by fdi inflows which has rarely been deeply analyzed in prior studies concluding remarks and policy suggestions are proposed in the last section

declining volatility in the u s automobile industry dramatic changes in the volatility of output occurred in the u s auto industry in the early 1980s namely output volatility declined the covariance of inventory investment and sales grew more negative and adjustments to production schedules which in earlier decades stemmed primarily from plants hiring and laying off workers were more often accomplished with changes in average hours per worker after the mid 1980s using a linear quadratic inventory model with intensive and extensive labor adjustments we show how all of these changes could have stemmed from one underlying factor a decline in the persistence of motor vehicle sales jel g31 l25 l62 m11

linking namea and input output for consumption vs production perspective analyses evidence on emission efficiency and aggregation biases using the italian and spanish environmental accounts we integrate input output and namea tables for spain and italy in 1995 2000 and 2005 in order to address the hot policy issue of sustainable consumption and production a comparison of production and consumption perspectives may have relevant policy implications we deal with the domestic technology assumption and primarily the aggregation bias that may result when calculating indirect emission using different sector aggregations in the analyses e g 16 30 50 extended input output analysis provides analyses of the emissions embodied in domestic consumption and domestic production by considering the structure of intermediate inputs and environmental efficiency in each production sector our empirical findings show that different sectoral aggregation significantly biases the amount of emissions for the consumption perspective though differently in the two countries italy surprisingly show consumption production ratios around or lower than one but in line with some major work at eu level our results thus suggest that special attention must be paid when interpreting the ee ioa of country estimated amounts of embodied emissions both in domestic final demand and those directly associated with the production sectors when the sectoral aggregation level has a low definition as considered in some recent similar studies

is environmental policy a secondary trade barrier an empirical analysis should international trade agreements be extended to include negotiations over environmental policy the answer depends on whether countries distort levels of environmental regulations as a secondary means of providing protection to domestic industries our results suggest that they do previous studies of this relationship have treated the level of environmental regulation as exogenous and found a negligible correlation between environmental regulation and trade flows in contrast we find that when the level of environmental regulation is modelled as an endogenous variable its estimated effect on trade flows is significantly higher than previously reported jel classification fl f14 f18 est ce que la politique environnementale est une barriere commerciale secondaire une analyse empirique est ce que les accords commerciaux internationaux doivent etre etendus pour couvrir la politique environnementale la reponse depend du degre de distorsion que les pays introduisent dans leur politique environnementale pour proteger leurs industries nationales nos resultats suggerent que cet impact est important des etudes anterieures de cette relation ont traite la politique environnementale comme exogene et ont montre qu il existe une co relation negligeable entre politique envir onnementale et flux commerciaux au contraire nous revelons que quand la politique environnementale est consideree comme variable endoge ne son effet sur les flux com merciaux est plus eleve de maniere significative que ce qu on a note anterieurement

testing for indeterminacy an application to u s monetary policy reply this paper considers a prototypical new keynesian model in which the equilibrium is undetermined if monetary policy is passive the likelihood based estimation of dynamic equilibrium models is extended to allow for indeterminacies and sunspot fluctuations we construct posterior weights for the determinacy and indeterminacy region of the parameter space and estimates for the propagation of fundamental and sunspot shocks according to the estimated model u s monetary policy post 1982 is consistent with determinacy whereas the pre volcker policy is not we find that before 1979 indeterminacy substantially altered the propagation of shocks

estimation of a forward looking monetary policy rule a time varying parameter model using ex post data abstract in this paper we consider estimation of a time varying parameter model for a forward looking monetary policy rule by employing ex post data a heckman type 1976 the common structure of statistical models of truncation sample selection and limited dependent variables and a simple estimator for such models annals of economic and social measurement 5 475 492 two step procedure is employed in order to deal with endogeneity in the regressors this allows us to econometrically take into account changing degrees of uncertainty associated with the fed s forecasts of future inflation and gdp gap when estimating the model even though such uncertainty does not enter the model directly we achieve efficiency in estimation by employing the standardized prediction errors for inflation and gdp gap as bias correction terms in the second step regression we note that no other empirical literature on monetary policy deals with this important issue our empirical results also reveal new aspects not found in the literature previously that is the history of the fed s conduct of monetary policy since the early 1970s can in general be divided into three subperiods the 1970s the 1980s and the 1990s the conventional division of the sample into pre volcker and volcker greenspan periods could mislead the empirical assessment of monetary policy

reexamining the empirical evidence for an environmental kuznets curve this paper uses an updated and revised panel data set on ambient air pollution in cities worldwide to examine the robustness of the evidence for the existence of an inverted u shaped relationship between national income and pollution we test the sensitivity of the pollution income relationship to functional forms to additional covariates and to changes in the nations cities and years sampled we find that the results are highly sensitive to these changes and conclude that there is little empirical support for an inverted u shaped relationship between several important air pollutants and national income in these data

misplaced childhood when recession children grow up as central bankers abstract we examine how much an early i e childhood experience of recession influences the behavior of central bankers we develop a model of decision making by a committee whose leader and members exhibit recession aversion due to their personal experience the model reveals that recession aversion could lead to a reluctance of the policymaker to increase policy rates in a panel multinomial logit model for nine major central banks analyzed over the period 1999 2015 we find that growing up in a recession influences monetary policy making central bankers early personal experiences of recessions shape their policy reactions increasing the willingness to cut policy rates with policy relevant magnitudes the results are robust to alternative behavioral hypotheses accounting for a number of control variables or sample variation

econometric policy evaluation and inverse control the traditional approach to monetary policy evaluation entails a first step in which structural parameters are estimated and a second in which the performance of alternative policy rules is studied this paper combines the two steps of the traditional approach into one by estimating a structural model subject to the restriction that the central bank chooses the policy rule that minimizes expected loss the structure is a forward looking new keynesian model in which equilibrium values of output and inflation depend on expectations of future values of those variables analysis of u s data between 1965 and 2001 support the hypotheses that the sample contains two policy regimes that the fed placed far greater weight on stabilizing inflation after 1980 and that improvements in policy were available in both regimes the unified approach also sharpens estimates of structural parameters

consumption based carbon emissions and trade nexus evidence from nine oil exporting countries abstract the relationship between international trade and carbon emissions has been studied extensively nonetheless consumption based carbon emissions which is adjusted for international trade have not been studied this study is an attempt to address the gap by using consumption based carbon emissions which is adjusted for trade in case of oil exporting countries the effect of international trade is analyzed by treating exports and imports separately from 1990 to 2018 the long run impact of all variables i e exports imports and gross domestic product gdp is higher than the short run coefficients the empirical evidence both in the long run and short run confirms the negative effect of exports on consumption based carbon emissions furthermore gross domestic product gdp and imports have a positive and statistically significant impact on consumption based carbon emissions both in the short run and long run policies related to consumption based carbon emissions and international trade shall realize the effect of government policies to absorb it fully by taking approximately two years

the environmental kuznets curve ekc theory part a concept causes and the co2 emissions case abstract the main purpose of this study is to capture the main features of the environmental kuznets curve ekc concept according to the ekc theory the process of economic growth is expected eventually to limit the environmental degradation created in the early stages of development the ekc concept leads many researchers from the early 1990s to assume that each economy should focus on its growth and any environmental problems will be eventually eliminated by the process of economic growth several studies attempt to test empirically the ekc hypothesis using data on many countries and examining various types of environmental degradation while other studies examine the underlying factors that may drive such a relationship this article reviews the evolution of the ekc concept and the possible causes of an ekc pattern like the distribution of income the international trade pollution haven hypothesis structural changes technical progress and improvements in energy efficiency institutions and governance and consumer preferences as co2 emissions are a pollutant with global effects several studies deal with the possible ekc pattern for co2 emissions and these studies are discussed separately the various critiques on the ekc concept are reviewed in the second article of this work

footloose and pollution free in numerous studies economists have found little empirical evidence that environmental regulations affect trade flows in this paper we propose and test several common explanations for why the effect of environmental regulations on trade may be difficult to detect we demonstrate that whereas most trade occurs among industrialized economies environmental regulations have stronger effects on trade between industrialized and developing economies we find that for most industries pollution abatement costs are a small component of total costs and are unrelated to trade flows in addition we show that those industries with the largest pollution abatement costs also happen to be the least geographically mobile or footloose after accounting for these distinctions we measure a significant effect of pollution abatement costs on imports from developing countries and in pollution intensive footloose industries

changes in federal reserve preferences abstract using a model of optimizing central bank behavior i estimate the dynamic behavior of preferences which are captured by the relative weight put on stabilizing inflation versus minimizing the output gap unlike previous work i let this parameter vary continuously over time there is a drastic but steady rise in the weight on inflation around the appointment of paul volcker however i find variation in preferences throughout the sample period the results suggest that preference changes have been more complex than typically assumed in the literature the estimated preference series is used to perform counterfactual experiments and to construct a new measure of monetary shocks

the conditional stock market response to banks distressed asset sales on cds availability this paper analyzes the stock market feedback on bank announcements of non performing loan npl sales conditional on whether credit default swaps cds are traded on the vendor bank s debt or not

monetary policy rules based on real time data this paper examines the magnitude of informational problems associated with the implementation and interpretation of simple monetary policy rules using taylor s rule as an example i demonstrate that real time policy recommendations differ considerably from those obtained with ex post revised data further estimated policy reaction functions based on ex post revised data provide misleading descriptions of historical policy and obscure the behavior suggested by information available to the federal reserve in real time these results indicate that reliance on the information actually available to policy makers in real time is essential for the analysis of monetary policy rules

economic growth and environmental degradation the environmental kuznets curve and sustainable development abstract in this paper we critically examine the concept of the environmental kuznets curve ekc it proposes that there is an inverted u shape relation between environmental degradation and income per capita so that eventually growth reduces the environmental impact of economic activity the concept is dependent on a model of the economy in which there is no feedback from the quality of the environment to production possibilities and in which trade has a neutral effect on environmental degradation the actual violation of these assumptions gives rise to fundamental problems in estimating the parameters of an ekc the paper identifies other econometric problems with estimates of the ekc and reviews a number of empirical studies the inference from some such ekc estimates that further development will reduce environmental degradation is dependent on the assumption that world per capita income is normally distributed when in fact median income is far below mean income we carry out simulations combining ekc estimates from the literature with world bank forecasts for economic growth for individual countries aggregating over countries to derive the global impact within the horizon of the bank s forecast 2025 global emissions of so 2 continue to increase forest loss stabilizes before the end of the period but tropical deforestation continues at a constant rate throughout the period

the environmental kuznets curve and sustainability a panel data analysis abstract in recent years sustainability has represented one of the most important policy goals explored in the environmental kuznets curve ekc literature but related hypotheses performance measures and results continue to present a challenge the present paper contributes to this ongoing literature by studying two different ekc specifications for 10 middle east and north african mena countries over the period 1990 2010 using panel data methods for the first specification namely ekc we show that there is an inverted u shape relationship between environmental degradation and income while for the second specification namely modified ekc mekc we show that there is an inverted u shape relationship between sustainability and human development hd the relationships are shaped by other factors such as energy trade manufacture added value and the role of law more interestingly findings from the estimation show that ekc hypothesis hd and sustainability are crucial to build effective environmental policies

transboundary effects of environmental policy markets and emission leakages abstract one of many explanations for environmental kuznets curves for rich countries can be that dirty production is relocated to economies with laxer abatement regimes if this is caused by national abatement policies environmental stresses are transferred to other countries further the economic costs of national abatement policies can be shared with foreigners to some extent both through a lower demand for imports and losses of market shares for foreign competitors that produce cleaner products we quantify effects internally and abroad of a growth induced unilateral carbon tax policy in a rich open economy we find that the environmental benefits fall and the economic costs rise when a global rather than a national perspective is employed

the environmental kuznets curve for pm2 5 pollution in beijing tianjin hebei region of china a spatial panel data approach abstract the purpose of this study is to exam the existence of environmental kuznets curve ekc of pm2 5 pollution in the beijing tianjin hebei bth region of china as one of the most important economic growth poles in china bth region has long been suffering from air pollution especially pm2 5 pollution thus in this study we utilized satellite observations of pm2 5 pollution and panel data of 13 cities in bth region from 1998 to 2016 to investigate the relationship between economic growth and pm2 5 pollution after verifying the spatial effect of pm2 5 pollution by spatial statistical analysis the spatial econometric model spatial durbin model sdm was chosen over the non spatial model in the examination of ekc the results showed that 1 the relationship between economic growth and pm2 5 pollution presented a significant inverted u shaped pattern though bth region is still in the upward section there is a hope that it will cross the point and enter the downward section in the future 2 the turning points of ekc would happen later with spatial effect considered compared to the result of non spatial model 3 the turning point of ekc would not happen until the region enter the post industrial economy stage moreover though some of the cities in bth region have entered post industrial stage none of them has cross the turning point of ekc results of this study indicate a promising future in the control of pm2 5 pollution as well as provide suggestions to put more emphasis on regional cooperative governance in air pollution control for the policy makers

the missing pollution haven effect this paper examines the effect of recent increases inhazardous waste disposal taxes on employment growth inindustries that generate hazardous waste mostexisting literature has found that interjurisdictionaldifferences in environmental stringency havenegligible measurable economic consequences commonexplanations for this lack of effect include claimsthat 1 measures of environmental stringency arepoorly quantified 2 compliance costs are modest 3 variation in compliance costs among jurisdictionsis small and 4 cross section data are insufficientto explore the consequences of increasingly stringentstandards this paper addresses these four concernsby quantifying hazardous waste disposal taxes demonstrating that they are large and varied acrossjurisdictions in the united states and showing thatthey have had a significant effect on hazardous wasteshipping among states the paper then uses a panel ofstate and county level data to show that despite thesefindings state hazardous waste disposal taxes do notimpose large employment losses on industries thatgenerate waste

bad luck bad policy and learning a markov switching approach to understanding postwar u s macroeconomic dynamics abstract this paper evaluates the role of monetary policy in understanding the u s post war macroeconomic fluctuations we construct a medium size dsge model in which the central bank through a real time learning process can make mistakes in estimating key elasticities between macroeconomic aggregates and the central banks objectives may change over time the model also features time varying volatilities of non policy shocks we find that misperceptions of the persistence of inflation and the slope of the phillips curve could affect optimal monetary policy decision making therefore their accurate prediction is key for achieving successful monetary policy outcomes in addition we argue that the monetary policy shift geared toward inflation stabilization in the late 1970s changed the composition of output making the marginal efficiency of investment shock that proxies for the functioning of the financial sector the most important contributor to the business cycle

trade the pollution haven hypothesis and the environmental kuznets curve examining the linkages abstract this paper examines the extent to which the ekc inverted u relationship can be explained by trade and specifically the migration or displacement of dirty industries from the developed regions to the developing regions the pollution haven hypothesis phh using detailed data on north south trade flows for pollution intensive products the evidence for the phh is assessed emissions of 10 air and water pollutants are then estimated controlling for trade openness structural change and dirty north south trade flows evidence of pollution haven effects is found although such effects do not appear to be widespread and appear to be relatively small compared to the roles played other explanatory variables

changes in the federal reserve s inflation target causes and consequences this paper estimates a new keynesian model to draw inferences about the behavior of the federal reserve s unobserved inflation target the results indicate that the target rose from 1 1 4 percent in 1959 to over 8 percent in the mid to late 1970s before falling back below 2 1 2 percent in 2004 the results also provide some support for the hypothesis that over the entire postwar period federal reserve policy has systematically translated short run price pressures set off by supply side shocks into more persistent movements in inflation itself although considerable uncertainty remains about the true source of shifts in the inflation target jel e31 e32 e52

inferring monetary policy objectives with a partially observed state accounting for the uncertainty inherent in real time perceptions of the state of the economy is believed to be critical for the analysis of historical monetary policy we investigate this claim through the lens of a small scale new keynesian model with optimal discretionary policy and partial information about the state the model is estimated using maximum likelihood on us data over the volcker greenspan bernanke regime a comparison of our estimates to those from a version of the model with complete information reveals that under partial information i the federal reserve demonstrates a significant concern for stabilizing fluctuations in the output gap and ii the discrepancy between optimal and observed policy behavior is smaller

estimating central bank preferences under commitment and discretion this paper explains u s macroeconomic outcomes with an empirical new keynesian model in which monetary policy minimizes the central bank s loss function the presence of expectations in the model forms a well known distinction between two modes of optimization termed commitment and discretion the model is estimated separately under each policy using maximum likelihood over the volcker greenspan bernanke period comparisons of fit reveal that the data favor the specification with discretionary policy estimates of the loss function weights point to an excessive concern for interest rate smoothing in the commitment model but a more balanced concern relative to inflation and output stability in the discretionary model

economic growth trade and energy implications for the environmental kuznets curve abstract the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis asserts that pollution follows an inverted u path with respect to economic growth the ekc has been explained in terms of structural changes in the composition of economic output and increased environmental regulation at higher income levels while some authors have incorporated the impact of trade policy orientation on the ekc the impact of the actual movement between countries of goods that embody pollution has not been considered this paper attempts to econometrically quantify the effect using pooled cross country and time series data the ekc hypothesis is examined with respect to commercial energy consumption the source of many serious environmental problems it was found that while both industrializing and industrialized countries have added to their energy requirements by exporting manufactured goods the growth has been substantially higher in the former at the same time industrialized countries have been able to reduce their energy requirements by importing manufactured goods exports of manufactured goods by industrialized countries has thus been an important factor in generating the upward sloping portion of the ekc and imports by industrialized countries have contributed to the downward slope

revealing the preferences of the us federal reserve we use bayesian methods to estimate changes in us post war monetary policy in the smets and wouters model we perform the estimations by allowing for a break in monetary policy at the time of volcker s appointment as chairman this enables us to capture changes in the monetary policy regime introduced by volcker during the volcker greenspan period we find support for the assumption that monetary policy in the volcker greenspan period performed optimally under commitment our estimation strategy allows us to estimate the preferences of the us federal reserve in the volcker greenspan period where the main objective of policy appears to be inflation followed by interest rate stabilization output growth and interest rate smoothing we find that the great moderation of output growth is explained by a combination of two factors the decrease in the volatility of the structural shocks and the improved monetary policy conduct inflation stabilization however is mainly due to the change in monetary policy that took place at the beginning of volcker s mandate copyright 2010 john wiley sons ltd

regime switches agents beliefs and post world war ii u s macroeconomic dynamics the evolution of inflation and output over the last 50 years is examined through the lens of a micro founded model that allows for changes in the behavior of the federal reserve and in the volatility of structural shocks agents are aware of the possibility of regime changes and their beliefs have an impact on the law of motion underlying the macroeconomy the results support the view that there were regime switches in the conduct of monetary policy however the behavior of the federal reserve is identified by repeated fluctuations between a hawk and a dove regime instead of by the traditional pre and post volcker structure counterfactual simulations show that if agents had anticipated the appointment of an extremely conservative chairman inflation would not have reached the peaks of the late 70s and the inflation output trade off would have been less severe these beliefs counterfactuals are new in the literature finally the paper provides a bayesian algorithm to handle the technical difficulties that arise in a rational expectations model with markov switching regimes

environmental regulation whose self interests are being protected special interest can explain why environmental policy limits economic activity in areas where air quality is above minumum standards locational competition among region helped create a policy that raised factor mobility cost from slower to faster growing regions analysis of votes shows greater support for this policy was received from northern urban constituencies and the greatest opposition came from the south and the west pollution abatement costs per unit of output are higher in areas with higher not lower air quality

dirty industries patterns of change in industrial countries this article concerns itself with the environmental role of heavily polluting industries since 1970 analysing its development in 11 basic industries as well as electricity production and road transport in 32 industrial countries it argues for a green industrial policy demonstrating that other mitigations of environmental pressure in industrial countries end of pipe treatment relocation to the third world structural change in the industrial sector and even environmentally oriented modernization have so far been unable to solve the problems of dirty industries although some approaches have shown some promise

optimal interest rate smoothing this paper considers the desirability of the observed tendency of central banks to adjust interest rates only gradually in response to changes in economic conditions it shows in the context of a simple model of optimizing private sector behaviour that assignment of an interest rate smoothing objective to the central bank may be desirable even when reduction of the magnitude of interest rate changes is not a social objective in itself this is because a response of policy to irrelevant lagged variables may be desirable owing to the way it steers private sector expectations of future policy

international trade and shared environmental responsibility by sector an application to the spanish economy abstract the aim of this paper is to define a shared responsibility criterion for analysing the impact of international trade on co 2 emissions applied to sectors with the approach proposed it is possible for sectors in a country to account for only a part of the emissions associated with exported and imported goods the agents considered as responsible for pollution are sectors two fold as producers and suppliers of intermediate inputs and final demand accounting for direct emissions linked to production and as consumers of intermediate inputs required for production accounting for direct and indirect emissions linked to consumption of inputs and the countries and foreign sectors that trade with these industries the responsibility of emissions is shared by all the participants along the global product chain depending on the value added of each step the criterion is applied to the spanish economy for the period 2000 to 2005 and proves useful for determining what economic policies may be suitable for mitigating anthropogenic impact on the environment and for including all the agents of the supply chain in the development of sustainable supply chain management

eu emission allowances and the stock market evidence from the electricity industry this paper constitutes to our best knowledge the first econometric analysis on stock market effects of the eu emission trading scheme eu ets our results suggest that eu emission allowance eua price developments matter to the stock performance of electricity firms eua price changes and stock returns of the most important european electricity corporations are shown to be positively related this effect does not work asymmetrically so that stock markets do not seem to react differently to eua appreciations in comparison to depreciations the carbon market effect is shown to be both time and country specific it is particularly strong for the period of eua market shock in early 2006 and differs with respect to the countries where the electricity corporations analysed are headquartered stock market reactions to eua volatility could not be shown

has monetary policy become more effective we investigate the implications of changes in the structure of the u s economy for monetary policy effectiveness estimating a vector autoregression over the pre and post 1980 periods we provide evidence of a reduced effect of monetary policy shocks in the latter period we estimate a structural model that replicates well the economy s response in both periods and perform counterfactual experiments to determine the source of the change in the monetary transmission mechanism and in the economy s volatility we find that by responding more strongly to inflation expectations monetary policy has stabilized the economy more effectively in the post 1980 period

nimby taxes matter the case of state hazardous waste disposal taxes this paper links the theoretical and empirical literatures on interjurisdictional tax and regulatory competition focusing on the case of state hazardous waste disposal taxes it begins by demonstrating that local environmental taxes can be inefficient and that the inefficiency depends on the tax elasticity of polluters responses the paper then uses panel data from the toxics release inventory to estimate the magnitude of the tax elasticities and to demonstrate the empirical relevance of the theoretical inefficiency of local taxes 1999 elsevier science s a all rights reserved

from inflation to more inflation disinflation and low inflation volume 2 of a history of the federal reserve forthcoming covers the years of inflation and disinflation followed by a return to relatively low inflation it addresses four questions why did inflation start why did it continue for 15 or more years from 1965 to about 1982 why did it end why did it not return as we look back to the 1950s and 1960s two of the many changes in the federal reserve system affecting inflation deserve comment first in the 1950s the goal was price stability and zero reported inflation not inflation of about 2 percent the 1959 1960 disinflation brought reported consumer price index cpi inflation measured as a 12 month moving average to less than 1 percent from march through august 1959 this measure again was below 1 percent through most of 1961 and it did not reach 2 percent until early 1966 properly measured and adjusted for biases in the price index the true price level probably declined modestly during this period this period of deflation was also a period of sustained economic growth it and several periods of deflation discussed in volume 1 of a history of the federal reserve 2003 show no evidence of the liquidity trap that absorbed much recent attention in the united states and japan a second major change is the role of economists and economic research at the federal reserve board and in the federal reserve banks in the 1950s the board had no economists as members and there were few economists as

term structure evidence on interest rate smoothing and monetary policy inertia abstract numerous studies have used quarterly data to estimate monetary policy rules or reaction functions that appear to exhibit a very slow partial adjustment of the policy interest rate the conventional wisdom asserts that this gradual adjustment reflects a policy inertia or interest rate smoothing behavior by central banks however such quarterly monetary policy inertia would imply a large amount of forecastable variation in interest rates at horizons of more than 3 months which is contradicted by evidence from the term structure of interest rates the illusion of monetary policy inertia evident in the estimated policy rules likely reflects the persistent shocks that central banks face

energy costs in germany and europe an assessment based on a total real unit energy cost accounting framework abstract affordable energy is one of the objectives of the eu s energy policy this goal has been challenged by many factors influencing energy prices and costs such as developments in global energy markets the eu ets and the promotion of renewables analysing energy costs prices times quantity instead of prices has the advantage of accounting for quantity adjustments however it does not allow for monitoring the burden that energy costs pose on firms for this purpose both the european commission and the energy expert commission of the german government recommend using real unit energy costs defined as energy costs as a fraction of value added we develop an input output based real unit energy cost accounting framework and study the trends in germany and the eu between 1995 and 2011 we find that many of the discovered developments are not adequately represented in the political debate especially with regard to indirect costs via energy embodied in intermediate inputs which are more difficult to assess indirect energy costs are on the rise are larger than direct costs in many industries are increasingly imported and amplify the asymmetric impacts of legal exceptions available to energy intensive industries

monetary regime switches and central bank preferences monetary policy objectives and targets are not necessarily constant over time the regime switching literature has typically analyzed and interpreted changes in policymakers behavior through simple interest rate rules this paper analyzes policy regime switches by explicitly modeling policymakers behavior and objectives we show that changes in the parameters of simple rules do not necessarily correspond to changes in policymakers preferences in fact capturing and interpreting regime changes in preferences through interest rate rules can lead to misleading results

has u s monetary policy changed evidence from drifting coefficients and real time data despite the large amount of empirical research on monetary policy rules there is surprisingly little consensus on the nature or even the existence of changes in the conduct of u s monetary policy three issues appear central to this disagreement 1 the specific type of changes in the policy coefficients 2 the treatment of heteroskedasticity and 3 the real time nature of the data used this paper addresses these issues in the context of forwardlooking taylor rules with drifting coefficients the estimation is based on real time data and accounts for the presence of heteroskedasticity in the policy shock the findings suggest important but gradual changes in the rule coefficients not adequately captured by the usual split sample estimation in contrast to orphanides 2002 2003 i find that the fed s response to the real time forecast of inflation was weak in the second half of the 1970s perhaps not satisfying taylor s principle as suggested by clarida gali and gertler 2000 however the response to inflation was strong before 1973 and gradually regained strength from the early 1980s onward moreover as in orphanides 2003 the fed s response to real activity fell substantially and lastingly during the 1970s

regime switching and monetary policy measurement this paper applies regime switching methods to the problem of measuring monetary policy policy preferences and structural factors are specified parametrically as independent markov processes interaction between the structural and preference parameters in the policy rule serves to identify the two processes the estimates uncover policy episodes that are initiated by switches to dove regimes shown to granger cause both nber recessions and the romer dates these episodes imply real effects of monetary policy that are smaller than those found in previous studies

complexity and bank risk during the financial crisis abstract we construct a novel dataset to measure banks complexity and relate it to banks riskiness the sample covers stock listed euro area banks from 2007 to 2014 bank stability is significantly affected by complexity whereas the direction of the effect differs across complexity measures

air pollution and dirty industries how and why does the composition of manufacturing output change with economic development this paper examines the impact on air pollution ofchanges in the composition of manufacturing output indeveloped and developing countries pollutionemissions from manufacturing output are estimated ina manner which holds constant the effect of technologyand regulations allowing the impact of compositional changes alone on pollution to beestimated the paper has three main findings 1 theinverted u estimated between per capita income and thepollution intensity of gdp arises due to both thecomposition of manufacturing becoming cleaner and theshare of manufacturing output in gdp falling compositional changes alone are not responsible forthe inverted u between per capita income and percapita emissions 2 changes to the composition ofmanufacturing output are consistent with the pollutionhaven hypothesis however there is clear evidence thatrising per capita incomes are associated with afalling income elasticity of demand for dirty products this fact may explain the compositionalchanges that occur with development 3 in additionto the income elasticity effect the analysis suggeststhat land prices and to a lesser extent the prices oflabour and capital determine the proportion of dirtyindustry within a country s manufacturing sector

credit default swaps and the empty creditor problem the empty creditor problem arises when a debtholder has obtained insurance against default but otherwise retains control rights in and outside bankruptcy we analyze this problem from an ex ante and ex post perspective in a formal model of debt with limited commitment by comparing contracting outcomes with and without insurance through credit default swaps cds we show that cds and the empty creditors they give rise to have important ex ante commitment benefits by strengthening creditors bargaining power they raise the debtor s pledgeable income and help reduce the incidence of strategic default however we also show that lenders will over insure in equilibrium giving rise to an inefficiently high incidence of costly bankruptcy we discuss a number of remedies that have been proposed to overcome the inefficiency resulting from excess insurance jel g30 g32 g33 one of the most significant changes in the debtor creditor relationship in the

politics and the fed in the standard economic model of policy choice choices are made by analyzing the social welfare implications to find welfare optimizing policy choices in this paper i argue that in a democratic government and perhaps elsewhere policy choices emerge from a political process people vote the voting process chooses elected representatives with their appointees the representatives make policy choices the appropriate model for policy analysis is a political economy model this conclusion is reinforced by my fifteen years of studying the history of the federal reserve 1 from the start that study reflected the influence of james buchanan and many others who followed him by analyzing policy choices made by individuals or committees motivated by considerations other than optimal welfare some of my prior work with alex cukierman and scott richard is fully in that tradition meltzer cukierman and richard 1991 consider recent federal reserve policy the federal reserve has more than doubled the size of its balance sheet it has more than 1 trillion of excess reserves and more than 1 trillion of long term relatively illiquid mortgage backed securities no central bank in a developed country ever had so much long term debt in 1932 a much less informed federal reserve board refused a request from congress to support the mortgage market congress responded by creating the home loan banks a fiscal solution the current board undertook the fiscal operations this is a political decision who would claim it is optimal policy in the late 1970s congress gave the federal reserve a dual mandate except for the years of moderation it has acted lexicographically from 1979 to 1982 it pursued disinflation letting unemployment rise to 10 8 percent before 1979 it concentrated on 1

were there regime switches in u s monetary policy working paper 2004 14 june 2004 abstract a multivariate model identifying monetary policy and allowing for simultaneity and regime switching in coefficients and variances is confronted with u s data since 1959 the best fit is with a model that allows time variation in structural disturbance variances only among models that also allow for changes in equation coefficients the best fit is for a model that allows coefficients to change only in the monetary policy rule that model allows switching among three main regimes and one rarely and briefly occurring regime the three main regimes correspond roughly to periods when most observers believe that monetary policy actually differed and the differences in policy behavior are substantively interesting though statistically ill determined the estimates imply monetary targeting was central in the early 80s but was also important sporadically in the 70s the changes in regime were essential neither to the rise in inflation in the 70s nor to its decline in the 80s jel classification e52 e47 c53 key words counterfactuals lucas critique policy rule monetary targeting simultaneity volatility model comparison i the debate over monetary policy change in an influential paper clarida gali and gertler 2000 cgg presented evidence that us monetary policy changed between the 1970 s and the 1980 s indeed that in the 70 s it was drastically worse they found that the policy rule apparently followed in the 70 s was one that when embedded in most stochastic general equilibrium models would imply non uniqueness of the equilibrium and hence vulnerability of the economy to sunspot fluctuations of arbitrarily large size their estimated policy rule for the later period on the other hand eliminated this indeterminacy these results are a possible explanation of the volatile and rising inflation of the 70 s and of its subsequent decline the cgg analysis has two important weaknesses one is that it fails to account for stochastic volatility us macroeconomic variables and particularly the federal funds rate have gone through periods of tranquility and of agitation with forecast error variances varying greatly from period to period ignoring such variation does not lead to inconsistent estimates of model parameters when the forecasting equations themselves are constant but it strongly biases toward a finding of changed parameters tests of the stability of the forecasting equations the other weakness is that the cgg analysis rests on powerful and implausible identifying assumptions they require that we accept that the response of the monetary authority to expected future inflation and output does not depend on the recent history of inflation money growth or output it is hard to understand why this should be so especially in the 70 s when monetarism was a prominent theme in policy debates congress was requiring reports from the fed of projected time paths of monetary aggregates and financial markets were reacting sensitively to weekly money supply numbers the requirement for existence and uniqueness of equilibrium in dynamic models is that the monetary policy rule show a more than unit response of interest rates to the sum of the logs of all nominal variables that appear on the right hand side of the reaction function if we force a particular measure of expected future inflation to proxy for all the nominal variables that actually appear independently in the reaction function we are bound to get distorted conclusions on the one hand because expected future inflation will be a noisy measure of the full set of nominal influences on policy we might get downward bias in our estimates from the usual errorsin variables effect on the other hand to the extent that expected future inflation like most expected future values shows less variation than current nominal variables we could find a mistaken scaling up of coefficients

the importance of being systemically important financial institutions abstract we investigate whether financial markets reacted to the regulatory changes implied by the publication of the list of systemically important financial institutions sifi and the new rules designed to address the too big to fail problem of systemic banks by applying event study methodology to a sample of 70 of the world s largest banks we assess whether the stock prices of sifis reacted significantly and differently from those of other large banks not deemed to be systemically important following the release of information regarding the methodology used to identify sifis and their new capital requirements the disclosure of the first list of 29 sifis and the publication of the updated list of 28 sifis overall we determine that financial markets did not univocally react to the new regulation regarding sifis however markets discriminated between high and low capitalized banks and they correctly estimated the probable effects of the additional capital requirements

a further inquiry into the pollution haven hypothesis and the environmental kuznets curve abstract empirical research on the relationship between economic growth and its impact on the environment often tests the environmental kuznets curve ekc a hypothesis that rising national output leads to increases in pollution emissions until an economy reaches a certain size and decreases thereafter this paper addresses a branch of ekc literature focused on the role international trade plays in shaping this relationship in particular we test the pollution haven hypothesis which posits that emission reductions observed in developed nations are partly the result of shifting dirty production to developing nations with lax environmental standards we estimate ekcs for seven oft studied pollutants and find little evidence that pollution havens play a significant role in shaping the ekc we also find that confidence intervals around ekc turning points are very wide often including values well above the range of the data this leads us to be skeptical of the optimistic view that economic growth naturally leads to improvements in environmental quality

jurisdiction shopping and foreign location choice the role of market and nonmarket experience in the european solar energy industry several countries provide policy support to specific sectors in order to facilitate industry transitions while industry support policies stimulate the growth of their target sectors little is known about how such policies engender heterogeneous international strategies in this article we investigate how industry support policies influence foreign location choices we argue that firms engage in jurisdiction shopping choosing to invest in countries with more generous policy support but that this tendency varies markedly across firms specifically we suggest that firms nonmarket experience exacerbates the effect of policy support on location choice whereas market experience has less of an impact further we propose that some firms view generous policies more skeptically than others depending on the nature of their nonmarket experience we test and find support for our predictions using a longitudinal dataset of foreign investments of firms entering the solar energy industry in the european union our findings indicate that supportive policies stimulate the energy transition attracting in particular foreign entrants diversifying into renewables or having more policy experience at the same time they suggest that adverse policy changes in one country affect how firms assess policies in other countries highlighting the need for policy coordination at a supranational level

why inflation rose and fell policy makers beliefs and u s postwar stabilization policy this paper provides an explanation for the run up of u s inflation in the 1960s and 1970s and the sharp disinflation in the early 1980s which standard macroeconomic models have difficulties in addressing i present a model in which rational policymakers learn about the behavior of the economy in real time and set stabilization policy optimally conditional on their current beliefs the steady state associated with the self confirming equilibrium of the model is characterized by low inflation however prolonged episodes of high inflation ending with rapid disinflations can occur when policymakers underestimate both the natural rate of unemployment and the persistence of inflation in the phillips curve i estimate the model using likelihood methods the estimation results show that the model accounts remarkably well for the evolution of policymakers beliefs stabilization policy and the postwar behavior of inflation and unemployment in the united states

the significance of sell off profitability in explaining the market reaction to divestiture announcements abstract previous research on asset sales has emphasized the divestment motivation and the use of the proceeds from the sale as determinants of selling firm value gains in contrast this paper explores the extent to which the relevant information necessary to evaluate sell offs is embodied in the profitability of the sale i e the price received by the seller over the value in use of the divested assets where the latter is a function of past operating earnings and book value our empirical results show that sell off profitability is substantially more significant in explaining the market reaction to divestiture announcements than the previous literature has suggested we provide strong evidence of a positive relation between selling firm abnormal returns during sell off announcements and profit on the sale which remains significant after controlling for the motivation behind the sell off the use of the proceeds from the sale and the presence of agency costs of managerial discretion we conclude that sell off profitability explains a major portion of selling firm abnormal returns and is one of the most significant determinants of the market reaction to divestiture announcements

the effect of state and local taxes on economic growth a time series cross section approach results based on pooled time series and cross section data are presented which indicate that state and local tax increases significantly retard economic growth when the revenue is used to fund transfer payments however when the revenue is used instead to finance improved public services such as education highways and public health and safety the favorable impact on location and production decisions provided by the enhanced services may more than counterbalance the disincentive effects of the associated taxes these findings underscore the importance of considering the incentives provided by a state s expenditures as well as by its taxes i n the past several years a number of states have implemented limitations on taxes or expenditures while others have raised tax rates in response to the revenue shortfalls of the early 1980s although much of the ongoing debate over state fiscal structures revolves around expressed preferences over tax expenditure combinations per se the question of how state and local taxes may affect economic growth is often central to the discussion nonetheless the empirical evidence remains sparse previous studies can be divided into two broad categories assessments of the magnitudes of tax costs and statistical analyses of the relationship between tax rates and growth cost studies have tended to minimize the role of taxes in business location decisions either because state and local taxes are a relatively small component of total costs for most businesses or because interstate tax differences are small relative to other cost differences between states although these results suggest that the role played by taxes is a minor one describing how large the tax disparities may be is not the same as ascertaining their economic effect of the statistical studies many including bloom 1955 thompson and mattila 1959 and carlton 1979 1983 find no relationship between taxes and growth however kleine 1977 grieson 1980 and generally grieson et al 1977 report negative correlations romans and subrahmanyam 1979 find growth to be negatively related to the fraction of revenues devoted to transfer payments and a variable which they claim measures personal tax progressivity but positively related to business taxes with the exception of carlton who estimates models of the birth and size of firms within metropolitan areas and the grieson et al 1977 and grieson 1980 studies which consider taxes in new york city and philadelphia these authors use data from a single cross section of states more recently newman 1983 and plaut and pluta 1983 both use cross sectional data from two time periods the former finding negative effects of corporate tax rates and the latter yielding mixed results in this study we utilize a time series from 1965 through 1979 of cross sections of 48 states exploiting the richness of this data set we are able to allow for otherwise unexplained differences between states which could be expected to bias results based on a single cross section moreover this much larger sample provides the statistical power necessary to disentangle the separate effects of different categories of taxes public expenditures and transfer payments a distinguishing feature of this paper is that we explicitly recognize the government budget constraint linking these fiscal variables and the deficit or surplus in addition we have taken account of the effects of labor force characteristics by including variables for wage rates unionization and population density our results indicate that tax increases significantly retard economic growth when the revenue is used to fund transfer payments as a result programs of income redistribution are more effectively undertaken at the federal than at the state and local level on the other hand when the revenue is received for publication april 30 1984 revision accepted for publication january 22 1985 university of california davis i am indebted to the institute of governmental affairs at the university of california davis for financial support to adrienne kandel for invaluable research assistance and to two referees for their helpful comments 1 see williams 1967 morgan and brownlee 1974 vasquez and deseve 1977 and the advisory commission on intergovernmental relations 1981 see also due 1961 for a survey of the early literature including a discussion of the findings and limitations of survey results on this topic 574 1 copyright 1985 this content downloaded from 157 55 39 35 on mon 29 aug 2016 04 45 38 utc all use subject to http about jstor org terms state and local taxes and economic growth 575 used instead to finance enhanced public services such as highways education and public health and safety the favorable impact on location and production decisions provided by the improved services may more than counterbalance the disincentive effects of the concomitant taxes these findings underscore the importance of considering the incentives provided by a state s expenditures as well as by its taxes we begin by sketching a model which provides the basis for the analysis and discussing appropriate estimation techniques then in section ii we describe the data used and our hypotheses the econometric results are presented in section iii followed by brief concluding remarks in the final

modelling the impact of environmental regulations on bilateral trade flows oecd 1990 1996 since the early seventies an increasing attention has been paid to the impact environmental polict nmight have on foreign trade one of the most important issues is whether countries with relatively strict environmental regulations tend to experience a deterioration of international competitiveness and thus a fall in exports and a rise in imports of the pollution intensive commodities or on the other hand benefit from the improvement in environmentally more sensitive industries so far most empirical studies have concluded that the proportion of environmental costs to the total production costs is still so marginal that environmental policies have hardly any effect on comparative advantage patterns and thus on foreign trade one of the few exceptions is van beers and van den bergh 1997 who found that stricter regulations have some negative impact on bilateral trade flows between oecd countries the aim of this paper is to show that tyhis outcome is partly due to model mis specification the analysis id based on a triple indexed model and on its variants it is found that as soon as both the importing and exporting country specific effects are taken into consideration the relationship between stricter regulations and foreign trade becomes statistically insignificant this suggests that environmental costs do not have a real impact neither negative nor positive on foreign trade

is there an environmental kuznets curve for sulfur abstract most existing estimates of the environmental kuznets curve ekc for sulfur which use samples of mainly high income countries indicate a maximum emissions turning point at middle to lower high income levels of gdp per capita we use a larger and more globally representative sample than previous sulfur ekc studies we find that sulfur emissions per capita are a monotonic function of income per capita when we use a global sample and an inverted u shape function of income when we use a sample of high income countries a model estimated in first differences results in a monotonic ekc when estimated with both high income and global samples reductions in emissions are time related rather than income related

macroeconomic stability and the preferences of the fed a formal analysis 1961 98 the rate of inflation in the u s has declined from an average of 4 5 in the period 1960 79 to an average of 3 6 in 1980 98 between those two periods the standard deviations of inflation and the output gap have also declined these facts can be attributed to the interaction of three possible factors a shift in central bank preferences a reduction in the variability of aggregate supply shocks and a more efficient conduct of monetary policy in this paper we identify the relative roles of these factors our framework is based on the estimation of a small structural macro model for the u s economy jointly with the first order conditions which solve the intertemporal optimization problem faced by the fed overall our results indicate that the policy preferences of the fed and in particular the implicit inflation target have changed drastically with the advent of the volcker greenspan era in addition we find that the variance of supply shocks has been lower and monetary policy has been conducted more efficiently during this period

shocks and government beliefs the rise and fall of american inflation working paper 2004 22 september 2004 abstract the authors use a bayesian markov chain monte carlo algorithm to estimate a model that allows temporary gaps between a true expectational phillips curve and the monetary authority s approximating nonexpectational phillips curve a dynamic programming problem implies that the monetary authority s inflation target evolves as its estimated phillips curve moves the authors estimates attribute the rise and fall of post world war ii inflation in the united states to an intricate interaction between the monetary authority s beliefs and economic shocks shocks in the 1970s altered the monetary authority s estimates and made it misperceive the tradeoff between inflation and unemployment that misperception caused sharp rise in inflation in the 1970s the authors estimates indicate that policy makers updated their beliefs continuously by the 1980s policy makers beliefs about the phillips curve had changed enough to account for fed chairman paul volcker s conquest of u s inflation in the early 1980s jel classification e3 e5 key words updating beliefs policy evaluation self confirming equilibrium nash inflation ramsey outcomes i introduction today many statesmen and macroeconomists believe that inflation can largely be determined by a government monetary authority then why did the federal reserve board preside over high us inflation during the late 1960s and the 1970s and why under paul volcker did it rapidly bring inflation down during the early 1980s this paper answers these questions by estimating a model that features a particular process that makes a procession of economic shocks induce the monetary authority to alter its model of inflation unemployment dynamics the phillips curve at each date t the monetary authority updates its beliefs about the phillips curve and then recomputes a first period action recommended by a phelps problem a discounted dynamic programming problem that minimizes the expected value of a discounted quadratic loss function of inflation and unemployment 1 the monetary authority pursues the same objectives at each date using the same structural model with only its estimates of that model changing over time 2 this model of the systematic part of inflation puts the monetary authority s beliefs about the phillips curve front and center 3 we assume that the monetary authority s model of the phillips curve deviates in two subtle but important ways from what it would be in a rational expectations model e g kydland and prescott 1977 the first deviation is that while the true phillips curve is like kydland and prescott s we assume that the monetary authority omits the public s expected rate of inflation from its phillips curve by itself this omission need not prevent the outcomes of our model from coinciding with those of kydland and prescott s nor need it imply that the government s model is wrong in a way that could be detected from even an infinite sample whether the monetary authority s model is wrong in a statistically detectable way depends on how we allow the monetary authority to reestimate the parameters of its model in particular if the monetary authority were to believe that the coefficients of its phillips curve are constant over time then its estimates would converge to ones that support a self confirming equilibrium sce after convergence its estimated phillips curve would correctly describe occurrences along the sce path for inflation and unemployment such an after convergence version of our model has little hope of explaining the rise and fall of us inflation that model would have inflation fluctuating randomly around a constant sce level that coincides with kydland and prescott s time consistent suboptimal i e excessive level 4 this outcome motivates our second subtle deviation from a rational expectations equilibrium