is there a turning point in the relationship between income and energy use and or carbon emissions abstract we analyze the effect of fuel mix model specification and the level of development on the presence and size of a turning point in the relationship between income and energy use and or carbon emissions the results indicate that fuel mix the specification for income and the level of economic development affect conclusions about whether there is a turning point in the relationship between economic activity and energy use and carbon emissions including fuel shares generally reduces the size of a turning point that is estimated from a panel that includes observations from both oecd and non oecd nations but this result varies according to the level of development for oecd nations there is limited support for a turning point in the relationship between income and per capita energy use and or carbon emissions for non oecd nations there is no turning point in the relationship between income and either energy use or carbon emissions instead the relationship is positive together the results indicate that forecasters and policy makers should not depend on a turning point in the relationship between income and energy use or carbon emissions to reduce either

rethinking ecosystem services to better address and navigate cultural values ecosystem service approaches have become a prominent basis for planning and management cultural services and non use values are included in all major typologies and present some of the most compelling reasons for conserving ecosystems though many barriers exist to their explicit characterization the values that conform least well to economic assumptions variously lumped together with as cultural services have proven elusive in part because valuation is complicated by the properties of intangibility and incommensurability which has in turn led to their exclusion from economic valuation we argue that the effectiveness of the ecosystem services framework in decision making is thwarted by i conflation of services values and benefits and ii failure to appropriately treat diverse kinds of values we address this challenge by 1 distinguishing eight dimensions of values which have implications for appropriate valuation and decision making 2 demonstrating the interconnected nature of benefits and services and so the ubiquity of intangible values 3 discussing the implications of these propositions for ecosystem services research and 4 outlining briefly a research agenda to enable decision making that is ecologically appropriate and socially just because many ecosystem services co produce cultural benefits full characterization of services must address non material values through methods from diverse social sciences

environmental regulation capital output and energy efficiency in china an empirical research based on integrated energy prices abstract how to improve environmental quality and achieve high quality development of economy have become important challenges for china in the new era based on the klems framework this paper analyzes the relationship between environmental regulation factor substitution and energy saving effect by using panel structure vector autoregression model and panel data of china industry from 2004 to 2014 the following conclusions are drawn 1 china s environmental regulation can promote the substitution of capital to energy however benefit of this substitution in the long run is greater than that in the short run 2 only in the long run can china s environmental regulations have significant energy saving effect technological innovation is the main reason for the improvement of energy saving effect of environmental regulation 3 china s environmental regulation will not significantly improve the structure of capital which makes the economic benefits low finally the paper discusses the possible ways to improve china s environmental regulation from the aspects of forming a scientific environmental supervision system improving energy pricing mechanism and capital structure

environmental regulation and competitiveness empirical evidence on the porter hypothesis from european manufacturing sectors abstract this paper investigates the weak and strong versions of porter hypothesis ph focusing on the manufacturing sectors of 17 european countries between 1997 and 2009 the hypothesis that well crafted and well enforced regulation would benefit both the environment and the firm was originally proposed by porter 1991 and porter and van der linde 1995 to date the literature has analyzed the impact of environmental regulation on innovation and on productivity mostly in separate analyses and focusing on the usa the few existing contributions on europe study the effect of environmental regulation either on green innovation or on performance indicators such as exports we instead look at overall innovation and productivity impacts first focusing on overall innovative activity allows us to account for potential opportunity costs of induced innovations second productivity impacts are arguably the most relevant indicators for the strong ph as a proxy of environmental policy stringency we use pollution abatement and control expenditures pace one of the few sectoral level indicators available we remedy upon its main drawback namely potential endogeneity by adopting an instrumental variable estimation approach we find evidence of a positive impact of environmental regulation on the output of innovation activity as proxied by patents thus providing support in favor of the weak ph this result is in line with most of the literature on the other front we find no evidence in favor of the strong ph as productivity appears to be unaffected by the degree of pollution control and abatement efforts

schumpeterian innovation and entrepreneurs in capitalism a case study of the u s biotechnology industry abstract this paper uses the theoretical framework developed by joseph schumpeter to examine the first ten years of the u s biotechnology industry the role of the entrepreneur scientist inventor manager and capitalist are distinguished there is a discussion of the obstacles the small firms have had to overcome to create a new economic space in the marketplace it is argued that the earlier schumpeter of the theory of economic development and business cycles emphasizing the role of small firms more accurately describes the u s biotechnology industry in 1985 than schumpeter s later work capitalism socialism and democracy which postulated that the large established firms have preempted the role of small firms in innovation a discussion of the role of large established firms and the small entrepreneurial firms presents the tensions inherent in the cooperative arrangements between these two types of business enterprises the role of small biotechnology firms in reducing these innovations to practice and in their ability to continue to grow demonstrates that the independent entrepreneur recognized by the early schumpeter has been very active in the biotechnology industry

do competitively acquired funds induce universities to increase productivity abstract this paper analyzes the impact of private and public third party funds on the productivity of swiss university departments and public research institutions estimating a production function assuming that labor inputs produce master students and scientific publications reveals a positive effect of public third party funding on productivity but not for private funds however once we include technology transfer as an additional output the coefficient for public third party funding turns insignificant while private funding becomes significant indicating that the disciplining effect of public donors focuses on publications while private donors foster technology transfer we employ three alternative approaches to tackle endogeneity and find qualitatively robust results

farm productivity and rural poverty in india armed with new data we return to an old question from the pages of this journal to what extent do india s rural poor share in agricultural growth combining data from 24 household sample surveys spanning 35 years with other sources we estimate a model of the joint determination of consumption poverty measures agricultural wages and food prices we find that higher farm productivity brought both absolute and relative gains to poor rural households a large share of the gains was via wages and prices though these effects took time the benefits to the poor were not confined to those near the poverty line

the informal sector in developed and less developed countries a literature survey the main goal of this study is two fold 1 to provide ageneral overview of the contributions to the literature on theinformal sector with a special focus on the public choiceapproach and 2 to compare these contributions across twoinstitutionally different types of countries developed andless developed developing and transition countries thepaper focuses on the criteria used to define the informalsector the relationship between the formal and informaleconomy tax evasion and public choice analysis it isstressed throughout this paper that the distinction betweenthe two types of countries is of key importance

china s uneven progress against poverty while the incidence of extreme poverty in china fell dramatically over 1980 2001 progress was uneven over time and across provinces rural areas accounted for the bulk of the gains to the poor though migration to urban areas helped the pattern of growth mattered rural economic growth was far more important to national poverty reduction than urban economic growth agriculture played a far more important role than the secondary or tertiary sources of gross domestic product gdp rising inequality within the rural sector greatly slowed poverty reduction provinces starting with relatively high inequality saw slower progress against poverty due both to lower growth and a lower growth elasticity of poverty reduction taxation of farmers and inflation hurt the poor external trade had little short term impact

natural resource economics and conservation contributions of agricultural economics and agricultural economists research by agricultural economists on natural resources has been distinguished by an interdisciplinary emphasis and a dynamic perspective it has recognized technological and institutional constraints has been oriented toward solving concrete resource management and policy problems and has emphasized empirical and quantitative analysis agricultural economists have introduced methods for evaluating natural resource conservation efforts for predicting adoption of resource conservation technologies and for designing efficient and sustainable resource management policies they have identified ways of improving land management and preventing land degradation proposed reforms of institutions governing water allocation and water quality and introduced policies for balancing environmental and efficiency considerations in the management of pests biodiversity and livestock diseases their research has had substantial impacts on the formulation of resource conservation policies

self selecting agri environmental policieswith an application to the don watershed we consider a model of regulation for nonpoint source water pollution through non linear taxation subsidization of agricultural production farmers are heterogenous along two dimensions their ability to transform inputs into final production and the available area they possess asymmetric information and participation of farmers to the regulation scheme put constraints on the optimal policy that we characterize we show that a positive relationship between size of land and ability may exacerbate adverse selection effects we calibrate the model using data on a french watershed and we simulate the optimal second best policy and characterize the allocation of the abatement effort among the producers

counting and multidimensional poverty measurement this paper proposes a new methodology for multidimensional poverty measurement consisting of an identification method k that extends the traditional intersection and union approaches and a class of poverty measures m our identification step employs two forms of cutoff one within each dimension to determine whether a person is deprived in that dimension and a second across dimensions that identifies the poor by counting the dimensions in which a person is deprived the aggregation step employs the fgt measures appropriately adjusted to account for multidimensionality the axioms are presented as joint restrictions on identification and the measures and the methodology satisfies a range of desirable properties including decomposability the identification method is particularly well suited for use with ordinal data as is the first of our measures the adjusted headcount ratio we present some dominance results and an interpretation of the adjusted headcount ratio as a measure of unfreedom examples from the us and indonesia illustrate our methodology

toward a new conception of the environment competitiveness relationship accepting a fixed trade off between environmental regulation and competitiveness unnecessarily raises costs and slows down environmental progress studies finding high environmental compliance costs have traditionally focused on static cost impacts ignoring any offsetting productivity benefits from innovation they typically overestimated compliance costs neglected innovation offsets and disregarded the affected industry s initial competitiveness rather than simply adding to cost properly crafted environmental standards can trigger innovation offsets allowing companies to improve their resource productivity shifting the debate from pollution control to pollution prevention was a step forward it is now necessary to make the next step and focus on resource productivity

the myth of the biotech revolution an assessment of technological clinical and organisational change abstract this paper argues that despite being widely promoted by academics and consultants the empirical evidence does not support the existence of a biotech revolution nor does the data support the widely held expectations that biotechnology is having a revolutionary impact on healthcare or economic development the revolutionary model is therefore a misleading basis for policy making as it over estimates the speed and extent of any changes in productivity or the quality of therapeutics instead the evidence suggests biotechnology is following a well established incremental pattern of technological change and creative accumulation that builds upon rather than disrupts previous drug development heuristics

the developing world is poorer than we thought but no less successful in the fight against poverty a new data set on national poverty lines is combined with new price data and almost 700 household surveys to estimate absolute poverty measures for the developing world we find that 25 of the population lived in poverty in 2005 as judged by what poverty typically means in the world s poorest countries this is higher than past estimates substantial overall progress is still indicated the corresponding poverty rate was 52 in 1981 but progress was very uneven across regions the trends over time and regional profile are robust to various changes in methodology though precise counts are more sensitive

empirical observations on new public management to increase efficiency in public research boon or bane abstract new public management npm was the catch phrase of the reforms in the public research and higher education sector for the last decades the postulated effect of the npm reforms is increased efficiency in governmental resource spending on the public higher education and research institutions though backed by theoretical considerations this hypothesis has hardly been tested empirically using a unique dataset of german research units this paper deals with the influence that npm mechanisms have on research performance controlling for different university mission it can be shown that both greater internal hierarchy especially strong presidents as well as greater operative flexibility for the researchers themselves increase research performance some of the variables including the presence of research councils have a positive effect on research efficiency under some definitions of research output on the other hand the introduction of resource accounting systems has a negative impact all in all we conclude that the public science sector reforms implemented in most of the western economies were heading into the right direction by providing greater performance incentives and increasing allocative efficiency in resource spending also we provide some ideas of how npm may be combined in order to construct a sensible governance system we conclude that the mechanisms should be selected based on the mission of the university

towards integrated social ecological sustainability indicators exploring the contribution and gaps in existing global data sustainable development goals sdgs which recognise the interconnections between social economic and ecological systems have ignited new interest in indicators able to integrate trends in and

the energy gdp relationship in developing countries empirical evidence and stability tests abstract the elasticity of energy consumption with respect to gdp is an important element in projecting energy needs in economic development this study uses cross section and pooled cross section time series data to find that the elasticity of energy consumption with respect to gdp in developing countries is in the neighbourhood of 1 35 and significantly above one over the period covered 1970 to 1976 the relationships appear to have remained stable there are significant differences between areas of the world but the differences in the elasticities between different continents are not large

economic prescriptions for environmental problems how the patient followed the doctor s orders o ne of the dangers with ivory tower theorizing is that it is easy to lose sight of the actual set of problems which need to be solved and the range of potential solutions as one who frequently engages in this exercise i can attest to this fact in my view this loss of sight has become increasingly evident in the theoretical structure underlying environmental economics which often emphasizes elegance at the expense of realism in this paper i will argue that both normative and positive theorizing could greatly benefit from a careful examination of the results of recent innovative approaches to environmental management the particular set of policies examined here involves two tools which have received widespread support from the economics community marketable permits and emission charges pigou 1932 dales 1968 kneese and schultze 1975 both tools represent ways to induce businesses to search for lower cost methods of achieving environmental standards they stand in stark contrast to the predominant command and control approach in which a regulator specifies the technology a firm must use to comply with regulations under highly restrictive conditions it can be shown that both of the economic approaches share the desirable feature that any gains in environmental quality will be obtained at the lowest possible cost baumol and oates 1975 until the 1960s these tools only existed on blackboards and in academic journals as products of the fertile imaginations of academics however some countries have recently begun to explore using these tools as part of a broader strategy for managing environmental problems

measuring sustainable development some empirical evidence for france from eight alternative indicators abstract this paper presents results from a time series analysis of eight measures of development and or sustainability for france the measures chosen are green national net product genuine savings ecological footprint indicator of sustainable economic welfare genuine progress indicator pollution sensitive human development indicator sustainable human development indicator and french dashboard on sustainable development a theoretical description of each index highlights their advantages and drawbacks underlining the fact that no indicator is perfect and no one can give an exhaustive view of sustainable development therefore the analysis of various indicators is necessary to evaluate sustainable development with accuracy empirical results of measures of well being show that french development was improving between 1990 and 2000 concerning sustainability indicators support different conclusions it seems that french development was weakly sustainable but unsustainable in the strong sense over the period examined

growth elasticity of poverty direct estimates from recent data using recent poverty data for developing countries elasticity of 2 poverty headcount with respect to the growth of gross domestic product gdp per capita is directly calculated for the 1990s and the 2000s the global estimate is around 0 84 which is much smaller in absolute magnitude than what some highly influential studies have reported or used for the poverty dense south asia region the elasticity is of the order of 0 22 which is a dramatic contrast from the previous estimates for india where the number of poor people is by far the largest of any country and where the poverty rate is higher than even in sub saharan africa ssa the elasticity is of the order of 0 13 which is an even bigger contrast from earlier studies policymakers and researchers are urged to keep these estimates in mind while judging the likely effect of income growth on poverty and to discount poverty reduction claims based on higher elasticity estimates that have been reported or used in many influential studies i

the contribution of university research to the technological innovation of the german economy societal auto dynamic and political guidance abstract in recent years a growing interest of firms in the transfer of technologically usable results from university research can be observed in the f r g in the first part of the paper a short account of available empirical evidence for this is given in the second part a general theoretical model is developed which tries to explain the intensification of transfer activities as the result of a specific auto dynamical causality connecting firms and universities in the third part the role of political guidance as a catalyzing force for this societal auto dynamic is discussed

buying big into biotech scale financing and the industrial dynamics of uk biotech 1980 2009 this article explores how the uk s biotech firms have evolved in response to their financial environment as investors expectations about the potential of biotech have changed funding options have opened up and closed down leading firms to develop new business models and routes of technology development after a favorable period new constraints on stock market funding have forced uk biotech firms to compress their life cycles constraining their ability to generate the late stage drug candidates sought by large pharmaceutical firms these changes are analyzed within a neo chandlerian framework in the context of a selection environment where rather than firms of varying inefficiencies being selected by an efficient market we find entrepreneurs submitting themselves to an inefficient investment selection process at the intersection of industries attempting to achieve their own scale economies the article highlights the importance of the scale of investment at the firm and industry level and suggests that decline in the size of the industry can have adverse consequences for investment and firm performance in this setting

limitations in evaluating environmental and agricultural policy coordination benefits agricultural policy has traditionally been concerned with the maintenance and stability of farm income and the provision of a stable food supply at low relative prices the food security act of 1985 was the first farm legislation to directly tie farm income and environmental concerns through the conservation reserve program conservation compliance sodbuster and swampbuster provisions the coordination of conservation and farm income policies contributed to commodity supply control by reducing the availability of arable land and it promoted environmental quality by removing some highly erodible land and wetlands from crop production a number of new environmental and food safety initiatives are also being enacted outside the agricultural policy process the most significant piece of legislation is the water quality act of 1987 designed to control

induced innovation and energy prices this paper uses u s patent data from 1970 to 1994 to study the impact of energy prices on energy efficient innovations theories of technological change have focused both on demand side factors which spur innovative activity by increasing the value of new innovations and supply side factors such as scientific advancements that make new innovations possible data on demand side factors are easily obtained but data on supply side factors that influence innovation are not readily available this paper uses patent citations as a measure of the usefulness of the existing base of scientific knowledge citations to previous patents are used to construct productivity estimates which measure the usefulness of the existing stock of knowledge to inventors in a given energy field for any given year these estimates are then combined with data on demand side factors to estimate a model of induced innovation in energy technologies the results indicate that both energy prices and the supply of knowledge have strongly significant positive effects on innovation the paper concludes with a discussion of the implication of this work for environmental policy

uncoordinated agricultural and environmental policy making an application to irrigated agriculture in the west agriculture and the environment are linked by a mutual reliance on scarce resources and prevalent market distortions in this paper we examine the efficiency costs of policies that correct distortions in one sector while ignoring those in another the dual distortions of an environmental externality and water subsidies are studied in the context of irrigated agriculture in california the welfare costs associated with independent action by either a water agency or an environmental authority when that policy maker attempts to correct the respective market distortion without consideration of the distortion in the other market are estimated policies to correct the two distortions are found to be complementary under these conditions the independent correction of either distortion improves welfare by at least 118 per acre in most cases the simultaneous adoption of various second best policies further reduces welfare losses associated with these distortions

venture capital high technology and regional development florida r l and kenney m 1988 venture capital high technology and regional development reg studies 22 33 48 this paper explores the role of venture capital in technological innovation and regional development both aggregate data and a unique firm level data base are employed to determine the location of major centres of venture capital flows of venture capital investments and patterns of investment syndication or coinvestment among venture capital firms three major centres of venture capital are identified california san francisco silicon valley new york and new england massachusetts connecticut as well as three minor venture capital centres illinois chicago texas and minnesota venture capital firms are found to cluster in areas with high concentrations of financial institutions and those with high concentrations of technology intensive enterprises venture capital firms which are based in financial centres are typically export oriented while those in technology centres tend t

venture capital and the birth of the local area networking industry abstract venture capital has played an important role in funding the development of a number of us high technology industries economists and business scholars utilizing models based in traditional economics have studied venture capital from the perspective of investment decision making these models provide significant insights and yet they do not explain the actual operation of venture capital this case study of the creation of lan industry utilizes a synthesis of the dominant design and social constructionist perspectives to create a more nuanced explanation of how the practice of venture capitalists operates to create firms and industries

literature survey on the relationships between energy environment and economic growth abstract the aim of this study is to exhibit an exhaustive survey which is related to the great flight of the literature of energy environment growth nexus at the individual and regional scale studies covering the period from 1978 to 2014 the survey takes into consideration the sample country region etc periods covering econometric strategies and conclusions our survey is based on the causality direction among i the energy use variables electricity nuclear renewable and non renewable and output growth ii between economic growth and environment and between the three variables at the same time globally these surveys provide paradoxical and not conclusive results which energy consumption can boost economic growth through the productivity enhancement and it can boost also the environmental damages through the enhancement of pollutant emissions our survey sheds more the lights on the energy environment growth literature by giving an extensive listing 1978 2014 of these causal linkages among the energy use variables environment and economic growth for both individual and collective cases there is a unanimous consensus about the importance of dealing with such dynamic relationship which is seems to be a cornerstone element in setting any ambition strategies energy ecological and economics

dollar a day revisited the article presents the first major update of the international 1 a day poverty line proposed in world development report 1990 poverty for measuring absolute poverty by the standards of the world s poorest countries in a new and more representative data set of national poverty lines a marked economic gradient emerges only when consumption per person is above about 2 00 a day at 2005 purchasing power parity below this the average poverty line is 1 25 which is proposed as the new international poverty line the article tests the robustness of this line to alternative estimation methods and explains how it differs from the old 1 a day line

facts and fads in academic research management the effect of management practices on research productivity in australia abstract as a response to competitive market forces and governmental steering policies australian universities have strengthened considerably their internal research management in the last two decades this paper examines empirically the effect of management on academic research productivity the results suggest that management practices indeed seem to have some positive effect on research productivity and the effect is consistent in the earlier 1995 2000 and later 2001 2007 time period universities with a more intensive management approach not only have higher absolute level of research productivity but they demonstrate also faster growth in productivity an omitted variable bias and robustness of the results to the choice of the output measure are under a particular attention and call for some caution in interpreting the results

a principal agent approach to a self administered organization with an elected principal we consider a self administered organization characterized by a principal elected by the agents of the organization conditions are established under which self administration leads to either stronger or weaker incentives in comparison to an organization which only pursues exogenous objectives while the output of the organization is controlled by the effort of the agents and by nature the pay off of the principal also includes rents from office generally two different contractual regimes can be observed either a hard regime with strong incentives and low fixed payments or a soft regime with weak incentives and high fixed payments

the evolving role of agriculture in poverty reduction an empirical perspective abstract the role of agriculture in development remains much debated this paper takes an empirical perspective and focuses on poverty as opposed to growth alone the contribution of a sector to poverty reduction is shown to depend on its own growth performance its indirect impact on growth in other sectors the extent to which poor people participate in the sector and the size of the sector in the overall economy bringing together these different effects using cross country econometric evidence indicates that agriculture is significantly more effective in reducing poverty among the poorest of the poor as reflected in the 1 day squared poverty gap it is also up to 3 2 times better at reducing 1 day headcount poverty in low income and resource rich countries including those in sub saharan africa at least when societies are not fundamentally unequal however when it comes to the better off poor reflected in the 2 day measure non agriculture has the edge these results are driven by the much larger participation of poorer households in growth from agriculture and the lower poverty reducing effect of non agriculture in the presence of extractive industries

dual market structures and the likelihood of repeated ties evidence from pharmaceutical biotechnology this paper analyses the role of repeated ties in the high tech pharmaceutical biotechnology industry a sector that is characterized by a strong dual market structure our most important finding is that previous ties in pairs of large pharmaceutical companies and small biotechnology firms have a negative effect on their subsequent partnering an explanation for this result is found in the context of understanding the specifics of large small coalitions in a high tech dual market structure unlike what is known about repeated ties in many other industries this high tech dual market structure indicates that r d partnerships between a small number of very large companies and a large group of dependent small firms are not characterized by mutual dependence similarity or equality

uniform and non uniform second best input taxes we investigate second best input based taxes foragricultural nonpoint pollution control when marketprices are endogenous and production isheterogeneous theoretically we derive the optimalforms of taxes which take account of heterogeneity non uniform taxes and a tax which does not auniform tax empirically we use a multi factor market equilibrium simulation model to determineoptimal tax rates and associated equity effects particularly differences in landowner gains lossesacross a heterogeneous region when market prices areendogenous second best tax policies result inpecuniary externalities that affect existingenvironmental externalities in particular thepecuniary externalities amplify the effect of producerheterogeneity on determination of sub regionaldifferences in tax rates and returns to land particularly for the uniform policy with endogenousprices the uniform tax rate is considerably higherthan any of the non uniform rates and ironically thenon uniform taxes result in less dispersion oflandowner gains across sub regions than the uniformtax

a theory of the early growth of the firm economic enterprise consists in the matching of resources and opportunities to create value growth processes of the new enterprise are here explored in a systems model inspired by penrose a sequence of phases in the early life of the firm reflects growth processes and problems solutions giving rise to new problems firms must access mobilize and deploy resources before they can generate resources for growth subsequent phases in which growth reinforcement and growth reversal forces content are not universal but are set in motion in an important minority of firms the major job creators beyond the early phases critical problems facing the firm are more diverse the growth of the firm is related to the building of the competence needed to respond to changing industrial opportunities copyright 1998 by oxford university press

measuring environmental policy stringency approaches validity and impact on environmental innovation and energy efficiency abstract solid tests of the impact of environmental and energy policy on important economic outcomes such as innovation productivity competitiveness and energy and carbon efficiency are impaired by the lack of appropriate empirical proxies for the commitment to and stringency of environmental policy we contribute to the literature by 1 computing different indicators of environmental policy stringency 2 testing to what extent they convey similar insights through a statistical comparison exercise and 3 showing the implications of using one or the other indicator in two illustrative empirical applications focused on environmental innovation and energy efficiency we conclude by highlighting the implications of our analysis for empirical research focusing on the evaluation of policy impacts and highlight fruitful future research avenues

a literature survey on energy growth nexus abstract this paper provides a survey of the recent progress in the literature of energy consumption economic growth and electricity consumption economic growth causality nexus the survey highlights that most empirical studies focus on either testing the role of energy electricity in stimulating economic growth or examining the direction of causality between these two variables although the positive role of energy on growth has become a stylized fact there are some methodological reservations about the results from these empirical studies a general observation from these studies is that the literature produced conflicting results and there is no consensus neither on the existence nor on the direction of causality between energy consumption electricity consumption and economic growth as a policy implication to avoid from conflicting and unreliable results the authors may use the autoregressive distributed lags bounds test two regime threshold co integration models panel data approach and multivariate models including new variables such as real gross fixed capital formation labor force carbon dioxide emissions population exchange rates interest rates etc thus the authors should focus more on the new approaches and perspectives rather than by employing usual methods based on a set of common variables for different countries and different intervals of time