willingness to pay for quality improvements comparative statics and interpretation of contingent valuation results this paper extends variation function theory by examining the effects of changes in prices quality and income on willingness to pay for quality change comparative static effects are found for both on site users and nonusers of the resource these results are used to interpret contingent valuation empirical models for example the substitution and complementary relationships between trips to natural resource sites can be identified this paper also suggests tests for comparison of contingent valuation with recreation demand models and other tests of validity

multivariate count data regression models with individual panel data from an on site sample the purpose of this paper is to consider the problem of controlling for on site sampling in the context of a system or panel of demand equations specifically in the context of recreation demand we are concerned with the situation in which survey respondents are asked to provide information not only about the actual trips to a specific site observed behavior but also their anticipated trips either under current conditions or given price and quality changes a multivariate poisson log normal mpln model and a seemingly unrelated negative binomial sunb model are used to jointly model the observed and contingent behavior data and to correct for on site sampling

models for referendum data the structure of discrete choice models for contingent valuation abstract in 1979 bishop and heberlein introduced an appealing variant of the contingent valuation method which required only yes or no responses hanemann developed a utility theoretic interpretation of the yes no responses which has helped popularize the approach recently cameron has offered another interpretation also utility theoretic which she argues is more general than the hanemann random utility model this paper compares the deterministic models suggested by hanemann and cameron showing them to be dual to each other it shows that correct specification of either function must exclude endogenous variables such as quantity demanded it also demonstrates that using utility theoretic models allows one to compare travel cost models and contigent valuation models on the basis of their implied behavior not on the unobservable surplus or variation measure

combining intended demand and yes no responses in the estimation of contingent valuation models abstract the contingent valuation method cvm has limitations arising from the lack of a direct link between estimated willingness to pay and consumer behavior regarding the use of the good being evaluated to estimate the total value of a resource under a capacity constraint information on intended use is introduced as an integral part of the cvm this combined approach allows use and non use values to be distinguished for a sample of users and non users the econometric specification is applied to estimate the benefits of reducing water pollution on beaches located near an important metropolitan area of south america

public goods as characteristics of non market commodities in benefit cost analysis it is useful to model public goods as the quality of privately consumed nonmarketed goods this strategy is often pursued in valuing environmental amenities the theoretical foundations of this model have not been fully developed in this paper comparative statics results are derived for quality changes of nonmarket goods the results reveal some common misconceptions about welfare measurement of quality changes conditions are presented for a quality induced change in the marshallian consumer surplus of the nonmarket good to approximate the true compensated welfare measure the conditions are equally necessary for obtaining exact welfare measures copyright 1993 by royal economic society

what are households willing to pay for improved water access results from a meta analysis abstract although several factors contribute to low rates of access to improved water and sanitation in the developing world it is especially important to understand and measure household demand for these services one valuable source of information regarding demand is the growing empirical literature that has applied stated preference methods to estimate households willingness to pay wtp because it is difficult to generalize and support planning based on this scattered literature we conduct a meta analysis to take stock of the worldwide sample of household wtp for improved drinking water services using 171 wtp estimates drawn from 60 studies we first describe this sample and then examine the potential factors that explain variation in wtp estimates our results suggest that households are willing to pay between approximately 3 and 30 per month for improvements in water access specifically in line with economic theory and intuition wtp is sensitive to scope the magnitude of improvement in drinking water services as well as household income and stated preference elicitation method we demonstrate how our results can be used to predict household level wtp for selected improvements in drinking water access in regions with low coverage and find that private benefits exceed the cost of provision

handling unobserved site characteristics in random utility models of recreation demand abstract this paper presents a new random utility model of recreation demand that addresses the unobserved characteristics of recreation sites most random utility recreation demand models implicitly assume that all relevant site characteristics are observed by the researcher or allow for the possibility of unobserved characteristics in a restrictive manner unlike traditional approaches the proposed model avoids the bias unobserved site characteristics can cause in welfare estimates and the travel cost parameter monte carlo simulations motivate the proposed model by showing that it provides more efficient parameter estimates in contrast existing methods yield less efficient estimates and biased standard errors that overstate precision an empirical application to recreational fishing in wisconsin illustrates the potential importance of this modeling innovation in this application controlling for unobserved characteristics is important for a range of model specifications

fair share siting noxious facilities as a risk distribution game under nontransferable utility abstract the search for equitable solutions to the siting of noxious facilities has long been an unresolved problem theoretically and politically common prescriptions often involve compensating host communities in this article we address the case when compensation is not an option or when we are unable to translate risk into a common measure of utility we propose a new analytic for finding equity based fair share distributions of risk which translates directly to mixed siting strategies in order to do this we employ a new general solution concept for n person bargaining games under nontransferable utility we discuss conditions under which the existence of such solutions can be proven last we illustrate the solution concept with application to the lancer project a controversial municipal incinerator originally proposed for east los angeles comparing results obtained with the ntu shapley value with the actual proposal finally we point out that solutions will involve risk elimination not just redistribution per se but we need both and to talk of one without the other is at times unjust at times ineffectual and often both

testing the validity of contingent behavior trip responses while a number of validity tests exist for contingent valuation data to date there are very few literature examples for contingent behavior cb data the objective of this study is to test the validity of cb trip data for different levels of rock climbing access using data from surveys implemented before and after a policy restricting recreational access was imposed results from generalized negative binomial and seemingly unrelated poisson regression models show significant sensitivity to scope and suggest that cb data may be a valuable supplement to revealed preference data when policy proposals are outside the range of historical conditions copyright 2002 oxford university press

improving willingness to pay estimates for quality improvements through joint estimation with quality perceptions willingness to pay for quality change may depend on heterogeneous perceived quality levels contingent valuation studies should include measures of quality perceptions as covariates in the willingness to pay model in order to avoid omitted variable bias variation in quality perceptions across respondents leads to a potential endogeneity of quality perceptions i address the potential for endogeneity bias using an instrumental variables approach in which a measure of quality perceptions is included as a determinant of willingness to pay and is simultaneously determined by various exogenous factors the willingness to pay model is estimated jointly with quality perceptions allowing for correlation of the error terms using data on willingness to pay for water quality improvements in the neuse river in north carolina i reject exogeneity of perceived quality correcting for endogeneity improves the measurement of willingness to pay by differentiating willingness to pay among respondents with heterogeneous quality perceptions

budget constrained frontier measures of fiscal equality and efficiency in schooling equality and efficiency are key issues in educational reform here the authors analyze the efficiency and equality consequences of various school finance reforms using a cost indirect output distance function this function readily models multiple output production under conditions of budgetary constraint and provides a natural measure of performance that is closely related to farrell type measures of efficiency the analysis suggests that despite school district inefficiency finance reforms can affect student achievement however any potential gains in output from redistribution are dwarfed by the potential gains from increased efficiency more strikingly the analysis demonstrates that budgetary reforms designed to equalize expenditures could actually increase the inequality of student achievement

the use and abuse of meta analysis in environmental and natural resource economics an assessment motivated by the 2006 report of a work group appointed by the environmental protection agency epa this paper examines the present state of meta analysis in environmental economics and offers recommendations for its future use to this end we summarize and assess 140 meta analyses from 125 published and unpublished studies covering 17 topical categories in environmental and resource economics first we provide several generic meta analysis models as reference points and discuss major estimation issues five econometric issues are identified as part of a complete analysis 1 sample selection criteria 2 basic data summary 3 primary data heterogeneity 4 heteroskedasticity and 5 non independence of multiple observations from primary studies second a tabular summary is presented for the 140 meta analyses with respect to estimation methods third a narrative summary is presented for 19 meta analyses including the three value of statistical life studies examined by the epa work group and one analysis from each of 16 other categories fourth we offer a set of best practice guidelines for future meta analyses in this and other areas of economics last the paper comments on the use of meta analytic methods for benefit transfers of environmental values

modeling recreation site choice do hypothetical choices reflect actual behavior we examine the ability of revealed preference rp site specific stated preference sp transferred sp and joint rp sp models to predict aggregate and individual recreation site choice in a holdout sample for two statistical comparisons the rp model provided the most accurate predictions of individual choices however the transferred sp model applied directly or estimated jointly with the rp data performed best in three aggregate and one individual prediction test these findings suggest that data from well designed and conducted sp surveys from one site can be combined with site specific rp data from another site to generate improved models of recreation site choice an objective of many economic studies is to construct models of choice behavior these models form the basis for welfare mea surement the models can also be used to make predictions of choice behavior that can inform policy makers of the proba ble results of changes in economic fac tors resource

revealing preferences for leisure time from stated preference data when consumer choice is constrained by time as well as money willingness to pay can be defined with respect to either numeraire the two measures can be related formally within a utility consistent model of choice subject to two constraints furthermore when information is collected on both the respondent s marginal value of time can be identified a system of willingness to pay time and money and the marginal value of leisure time is estimated jointly in an application to california whalewatching and whale stock enhancement the empirical approach can be applied with only minor additions to survey techniques for nonmarket valuation

estimating the demand for a new technology bt cotton and insecticide policies this article examines the potential demand for bt cotton in the southeast from information gathered in the first year of commercialization we combine revealed preference rp data on adoption of bt cotton varieties with stated preference sp data on willingness to adopt to estimate demand using a double bounded maximum likelihood procedure using estimated demand equations we simulate the costs of reducing conventional insecticide applications through subsidization of bt cotton results indicate that reducing cotton insecticide applications by 40 in the southeast would require a 21 acre subsidy with total annual program costs between 53 million and 60 million

combining contingent valuation and travel cost data for the valuation of non market goods the travel cost method tcm has long been used to infer the economic value of nonmarket resources and public goods more recently contingent valuation cvm survey methods have gained popularity for eliciting these values here cvm survey responses are combined with tcm data on actual market behavior to estimate jointly both the parameters of the underlying utility function and its corresponding ordinary demand function this is a prototypical empirical example of a new modeling strategy variants of which should prove useful in many applications especially where reliance on a single valuation method is undesirable

policy evaluation with combined actual and contingent response data the city of marietta georgia experimentally switched from flat fee financing to volume based pricing for its trash services in january 1994 both before and during the experiment detailed data on individuals observed responses to the actual introduction and contingent behavioral responses to a hypothetical introduction of volume based pricing were collected this study applies these data and investigates the methodology of collecting contingent behavior data and their use in policy analysis in particular this study empirically evaluates the effect of experience with the policy on responses to contingent behavior questions and tests for potential bias in the contingent behavior data

toward equitable and sustainable rural water supplies a contingent valuation study in brazil because many rural people are poor it is usually assumed that rural water supplies must be financed by government agencies it is now widely recognized however that many rural people can and will pay for improved water supplies and that sustaining and extending services depends on mobilizing this willingness to pay this article describes a study of willingness to pay for water in brazil the study shows that surveys of actual and hypothetical water use practices can provide policy relevant information on willingness to pay which is shown to vary according to household socioeconomic characteristics and the characteristics of the existing and new supplies of water in rural brazil tariffs for yard taps can be increased substantially before significant numbers of housebolds would choose not to connect to an improved system whereas provision of free water at public taps can protect the poor without jeopardizing the financial viability of the scheme billions of people in developing countries face daily problems in obtaining water for drinking cooking bathing and washing more than 1 500 million people 30 percent of the world s population are estimated to be without access to uncontaminated water and an unknown but large proportion have to spend hours daily to collect water briscoe and de ferranti 1988 churchill 1987 because the adverse consequences for productivity health and quality

choosing and sharing implementing a project like a nationwide nuclear waste disposal which benefits all involved agents but brings major costs only to the host is often problematic in practice revelation issues and redistributional concerns are significant obstacles to achieving stable agreements we address these issues by proposing the first mechanism to implement the efficient site the host with the lowest cost and share the exact cost while retaining total control over realized transfers our mechanism is simple and in the vein of the well known divide and choose procedure the unique nash equilibrium outcome of our mechanism coincides with truthtelling is budget balanced individually rational and immune to coalitional deviations more generally our mechanism can also handle the symmetric case of positive local externalities e g olympic games and even more complex situations where the usefulness of the project regardless of its location is not unanimous

noxious facilities environmental damages and efficient randomized siting this paper considers the efficient siting of a noxious facility that causes environmental damages for example increased pollution in the host community the analysis shows that there can be multiple efficient locations without transfers and that an efficient location need not have the smallest wta or wtp in general there exist randomized outcomes that are ex ante efficient and that pareto dominate efficient outcomes the analysis also shows that a community s most preferred lottery never provides full insurance under some conditions lotteries with no host compensation are pareto superior to those with compensation

victim compensation revisited abstract the siting of an efficient noxious facility may decrease social welfare if people care about horizontal equity the facility decreases the relative attractiveness of the host city decreasing land rent in the host city and increasing land rent elsewhere victim compensation which promotes horizontal equity at the expense of efficiency will increase social welfare if a the demand for land is relatively inelastic b the demand for the output of the noxious facility is relatively elastic and c the preferences for horizontal equity are relatively strong

combining revealed and stated preference methods to value environmental amenities at residential locations this paper combines an established revealed preference method discrete choice he donic analysis and a relatively new stated refer ence method choice based conjoint analysis in order to estimate more accurately the aesthetic benefits generated by the presence and quality of environmental amenities associated with residen tial locations it applies the combined approach to the housing market of fairfield connecticut which contains several environmental amenities and is experiencing an improvement in the quality of its coastal wetlands due to active restoration efforts jel q26

household biomass energy choice and its policy implications on improving rural livelihoods in sichuan china abstract it is widely known that a switch from traditional biomass energy to modern clean safe and efficient energy could improve local rural livelihoods by enhancing the access to high quality energy and reducing the negative impacts of traditional biomass energy on health environment and living standards hence in this paper we used alternative specific conditional logit model asclm to examine the rural household energy choice behaviors in sichuan province of china from the perspective of revealed and stated preferences the results show that the fuel switching in our study region is not a simple unidirectional process from traditional biomass energy to modern fuels as incomes improve household energy choice behaviors could be not only affected by energy specific characteristics such as fuel price smoky level and safety risk but also influenced by household specific factors such as income level age and educational level of the decision maker household demographic structure number of people frequently eating at home distance to the nearest biomass collecting spot and household location suggesting that government should attach more importance to simultaneously improve energy quality control energy price and enhance household socio economic status

evaluating the productive performance of uk universities as cost constrained revenue maximizers an empirical analysis the study presents an empirical analysis of the relative revenue efficiency of uk universities in providing teaching and research with government policies pressurizing the largely public funded universities to secure efficiency in both input usage and output revenue university producers are modelled as cost constrained revenue maximizers taking explicit account of the quality of research output the methodology uses linear programming techniques to construct nonparametric cost indirect production frontiers and to compute revenue efficiency relative to these frontiers revenue efficiency is then decomposed into its output allocative and technical components further analysis investigates the sources of allocative and technical inefficiencies

willingness to pay for improved water service in manaus amazonas brazil the 1 5 million residents of the city of manaus form the epicenter for economic activity and development in the amazon basin the current water treatment facilities were built when there were a mere 100 000 people living here the fifteen fold increase in population has made access to water a major public health concern families that can afford to buy bottled water do and those that can not are susceptible to water borne disease and illness at an ever increasing rate in order to determine how much citizens are willing to pay for universal access to water service in the home the university of amazonas center for environmental sciences has conducted a survey of over 1600 residents collecting information on current water needs health concerns household socioeconomic characteristics and from a contingent valuation cv experiment how much they would pay for access to improve water service in the home this paper makes use of the 1479 observations from four elicitation formats 1 open ended 2 open ended with a bpre qualifyingq statement 3 descending bid dichotomous choice and 4 ascending bid dichotomous choice results suggest that residents are willing to pay wtp more than r 12 us 6 12 per month

is meta analysis a noah s ark for non market valuation this paper describes meta analytical methods as they have been applied to non market valuation research these studies have been used to review and synthesize literature and more recently in benefit transfer this second use imposes a higher standard on the consistency in economic concepts being summarized and in the resources included in a meta analysis to meet this need the paper proposes and illustrates a structural framework using a generalized method of moments estimator to estimate the parameters of a preference function with the benefits estimates usually encountered in meta analytic summaries

the five percent rule for improved water service can households afford more abstract results of household willingness to pay surveys in five small moroccan cities reveal that respondents would pay 7 to 10 of total household expenditures for individual water connections and subsequent commodity charges despite already having reliable and free standpost service the study also illustrates that relatively low cost rapid and reliable survey techniques to learn about water demand characteristics are possible and therefore should routinely be incorporated into the planning for all developing country water projects

combining revealed and stated preferences consistency tests and their interpretations this article models the recreation demand for iowa wetlands combining survey data on both actual usage patterns i e revealed preferences rps and anticipated changes to those patterns under hypothetical increases in trip costs i e stated preferences sps we formulate and test specific hypotheses concerning potential sources of bias in each approach and discuss what can be learned about the validity of the models from such tests

choice and temporal welfare impacts incorporating history into discrete choice models abstract static cross sectional discrete choice models are often employed to calculate welfare measures in environmental valuation these measures will be biased if the underlying preference function includes temporally related attributes and lagged dependent variables nevertheless static models continue to dominate the literature in this paper we provide an approach to estimating discrete choice models that includes consideration of prior behavior and past attribute perceptions and allows for testing consistency with random utility maximization in a time series context we apply this model to the case of recreational fishing site choice and participation comparing our time series approach to static versions we find that the time series model provides a richer behavioral characterization of site choice we also find significant differences between cross section and time series welfare measures the time series model raises several concerns about the specification of the policy impact and the subsequent welfare measurement that are not apparent in the static case

property rights protest and the siting of hazardous waste facilities ture since that time no major hwf has been sited anywhere in the united states the epa had anticipated that local opposition would make finding these sites an exceptionally difficult task their pessimism was well founded and if anything understated according to the hazardous waste counsultant s latest state by state review the outlook for siting hwfs in the future is even more bleak than in the past due in large part to what they term a worsening of the emotional atmosphere surrounding siting efforts this failure to site any new hwf has come about in spite of assurances by government and company officials that new facilities built according to the present standards would pose negligible risks to the local residents attempts have been made to break the deadlock by instituting extensive public participation procedures establishing state siting boards with the power to overrule local decision makers and requiring facility owners to compensate local governments for safety services the latter provided in this paper we argue that the ambiguous nature of the present property rights governing the siting of hwfs is an important cause of the stalemate we offer a new approach to siting which recognizes the de facto property rights assumed by local communities we propose a political market via a referendum

improving environmental valuation estimates through consistent use of revealed and stated preference information abstract environmental valuation data from stated and revealed preference methods are integrated into a unified model of preferences for environmental quality improvement that identifies the use and nonuse components of the total value estimate this articulates clearly what parts of the total value estimate come from each type of data and permits tests of whether estimated preferences satisfy weak complementarity between the environmental good of interest and related private goods the statistical advantages of using more information for the valuation problem are exploited while retaining flexibility to identify value estimates from any individual method of analysis

what experimental protocol influence disparities between actual and hypothetical stated values preferences elicited in hypothetical settings have recently come underscrutiny causing estimates from the contingent valuation method to bechallenged due to perceived hypothetical bias given that the receivedliterature derives value estimates using heterogeneous experimentaltechniques understanding the effects of important design parameters onthe magnitude of hypothetical bias is invaluable in this paper we addressthis issue statistically by using a meta analysis to examine data from 29experimental studies our empirical findings suggest that on averagesubjects overstate their preferences by a factor of about 3 in hypotheticalsettings and that the degree of over revelation is influenced by thedistinction between willingness to pay and willingness to accept publicversus private goods and several elicitation methods

anticipating the consequences of school reform a new use of dea we use dea type linear programming techniques to simulate a basic component of educational reform eliminating restrictions on the allocation of school personnel our technique allows us to identify potential output gains or equivalently potential cost savings from reform we can also identify which personnel groups are likely to gain and lose under this reform when we apply our model to a sample of texas school districts we find evidence that the educational establishment has substantial economic rents to protect from school reform and that the primary beneficiaries of reform are likely to be affluent school districts with few minority students the technique which relies on the relationship between the direct and indirect distance functions can be easily generalized to measure the potential gains from removing other input restrictions such as union work rules environmental regulations or deed restrictions

the two stage hedonic wage approach a methodology for the valuation of environmental amenities abstract this paper extends the hedonic wage model to a two stage model in which willingness to pay may be estimated for specific amenities in concert with supply relationships which may be estimated independent of the hedonic model these willingness to pay functions allow for the computation of the value of changes in the level of the amenity the technique has several important advantages over other valuation techniques including less stringent data requirements and fewer econometric problems such as intractable identification problems and truncation biases the model is applied to freshwater fishing and benefits associated with changes in fishing quality are estimated both generically and through specific water quality improvements

construct validity of averting cost measures of environmental benefits construct validity is concerned with the consistency of empirical measures with theoretical relationships this paper reviews and extends the theoretical relationship between averting costs and willingness to pay measures of these two theoretical constructs with empirical averting costs savings and contingent valuation from one population are used to establish construct validity of the averting cost technique used empirical results indicate that the contingent valuation and averting costs measures have a low correlation although low correlation is consistent with the construct validity of averting costs measures these results indicate that inferences from averting cost measures are quite limited

a comparison of welfare estimates from four models for linking seasonal recreational trips to multinomial logit models of site choice we compare four methods of linking a site choice random utility model to a seasonal trip model the four approaches are those proposed by morey et al 1993 am j agric econom 75 578 592 hausman et al 1995 j public econom 56 1 30 parsons and kealy 1995 j environ econom management29 357 367 and feather et al 1995 j environ econom management29 214 227 we estimate the alternative models using a common data set and calculate a change in welfare for two policy scenarios across the models we find that there is little practical difference between the approaches of morey et al and hausman et al they are nearly the same mathematically and the welfare estimates in our empirical example are quite close the approaches of parsons and kealy and feather et al generated welfare estimates that were substantially different from the previous two approaches as well as from each other they also generated results that reveal the inconsistencies between their site choice and season trip models

specification tests for mixed demand systems with an emphasis on combining contingent valuation and revealed data abstract in a world characterized by r unrationed goods i e market goods and n r rationed goods such as most environmental goods necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of an underlying rational preference structure are derived based on a system of mixed demand functions with complete information with incomplete information the case of a partial demand system is addressed and a test for separability is proposed the implications for testing rationality in a world characterized by combined rp and sp individual data are examined for data consistency testable conditions are derived

perceptions versus objective measures of environmental quality in combined revealed and stated preference models of environmental valuation abstract this study examines perceptions and objective attribute measures in discrete choice models of recreation site choice behavior these forms of attribute measurement are examined in individual and combined revealed preference stated preference models our results suggest that the model based on perceptions slightly outperforms the models based on objective attribute measures however issues such as the definition of the choice set and the measurement of welfare present significant challenges when using perceptions data

combining revealed and stated data to examine housing decisions using discrete choice analysis abstract this paper uses stated preference and revealed preference data separately and jointly to examine individuals housing choices in particular it combines an established revealed preference approach discrete choice analysis of actual housing purchases and a relatively new stated preference approach choice based conjoint analysis of hypothetical housing purchases to provide us with a better understanding of the factors driving housing decisions these methods are appropriately combined since they reflect the same decision process households select the dwelling that provides the best combination of attributes from the feasible set of alternatives in total this paper analyzes three data sets only actual housing purchases only hypothetical housing purchases and both types of purchases combined analysis finds that actual and hypothetical housing purchases are similar decision processes with respect to some attributes yet are dissimilar with respect to other attributes nevertheless combining the two types of data improves identification of both categories of attributes journal of economic literature classification number r21

the contingent valuation debate why economists should care t he contingent valuation method involves the use of sample surveys questionnaires to elicit the willingness of respondents to pay for generally hypothetical projects or programs the name of the method refers to the fact that the values revealed by respondents are contingent upon the constructed or simulated market presented in the survey a spirited and occasionally mean spirited battle over such methods is currently being waged involving competing factions within the federal government economists and lawyers representing business and environmental groups and interested academics as well at issue is a seemingly quite specific question should environmental regulations currently under development at both the department of the interior and the department of commerce sanction the use of the contingent valuation method in estimating the damage done by spills of oil chemicals or other substances covered by federal law more generally the debate raises broad questions about what economists have to say about the values that individuals place on public or private goods the two papers that follow this one make cases for and against the use of the contingent valuation method my aim here is to provide an overview of the technique and the debate surrounding it i also want to suggest why this debate should matter to economists both professionally and in their roles as citizens and consumers

combining revealed and stated preference data to estimate the nonmarket value of ecological services an assessment of the state of the science this paper reviews the marketing transportation and environmental economics literature on the joint estimation of revealed preference rp and stated preference sp data the rp and sp approaches are first described with a focus on the strengths and weaknesses of each recognizing these strengths and weaknesses the potential gains from combining data are described a classification system for combined data that emphasizes the type of data combination and the econometric models used is proposed a methodological review of the literature is pursued based on this classification system examples from the environmental economics literature are highlighted a discussion of the advantages and disadvantages of each type of jointly estimated model is then presented suggestions for future research in particular opportunities for application of these models to environmental quality valuation are presented

valuing the benefits of coastal water quality improvements using contingent and real behaviour recent moves in the european union have beenmade towards a toughening of legislation onbathing water quality this has focussedpolicy makers thoughts on the welfare benefitsresulting from such improvements especiallygiven their cost our paper uses a combinedstated and revealed preference approach tovalue coastal water quality improvements focussing on an area of scotland which hasconsistently failed to meet standards under thebathing waters directive we combine data onreal behaviour with data on contingentbehaviour using a random effects negativebinomial panel model this allows us to predictboth the change in participation trips shouldwater quality be improved and the welfareincrease per trip our model includes allowancefor the existence of substitute sites and forchanges in recreational behaviour during abeach visit

augmenting travel cost models with contingent behavior data this paper proposes contingent behavior survey questions as a valuable supplement to observed data in travel cost models of non market demand for recreational resources a set of observed and contingent behavior results for each survey respondent allows the researcher to control for individual heterogeneity by taking advantage of panel data methods when exploring the nature of respondent demands the contingent scenarios also provide opportunities to a test for differences between observed and contingent preferences and or b assess likely demands under conditionsbeyond the domain of observed variation in costs or resource attributes most importantly contingent scenarios allow the researcher to imposeexogenously varying travel costs exogenous imposition of travel costs together with panel methods reduces the omitted variables bias that plagues observed data travel cost models of recreational demand using a convenience sample of data for illustrative purposes we show how to estimate the demand for recreational angling by combining observed and contingent behavior data we begin with simple naive pooled poisson models and progress to more theoretically appropriate fixed effects panel poisson specifications

time is money improved valuation of time and transportation costs the proper valuation of time isimportant for estimating the demand for severaleconomic goods this paper explores the propervaluation of time when estimating recreationaldemand where time costs represent asubstantial portion of the purchase price toestimate demand this paper uses a travel costframework to analyze actual behavior revealedpreference data and hypothetical behavior stated preference data which is induced byhypothetical increases in access fees traveltime and travel distance by comparing theresponses to these three contingencies theanalysis adjusts and improves the valuation oftime costs as evidence of this improvement this analysis demonstrates a great increase inthe consistency between the revealed and stateddata similarly this paper improves thevaluation of transportation related costs

imputing a continuous income variable from grouped and missing income observations abstract most cross sectional data sets collect income in a discrete number of categories that is in grouped form to simplify the respondent s task and to encourage a response in spite of such grouped data collection many respondents refuse to provide information on income this paper develops a method to impute a continuous and reliable value for income from grouped and missing income data

prices information and nudges for residential electricity conservation a meta analysis incentivising households to lower their electricity consumption is increasingly used as a tool to create a more flexible electricity demand previous reviews estimate that electricity savings of 6 4 7 4 can be achieved through monetary informational and behavioural incentives this papers argues that a more realistic estimate is of a 1 9 3 9 reduction in consumption based on the most recent experimental data from both peer reviewed and grey literature sources using data from 52 studies published during the smart grid era 2005 onwards the effects of incentives from 128 observations amounting to 713 002 households are analysed the results show that individual and real time feedback as well as personalised advice on how to save electricity are more effective than feedback on electricity costs and general electricity savings tips which lead to relative increases in consumption despite improvements in the quality of more recent studies the analysis highlights the importance of methodological rigour in carrying out and reporting effects of incentives an absence of a control group of socio demographic data and the self selection of participants into treatment leads to overestimation of effects

contingent valuation controversies and evidence contingent valuation cv has become one of the most widely used non market valuation techniques cv s prominence is due to its flexibility and ability to estimate total value including passive use value its use and the inclusion of passive use value in benefit cost analyses and environ mental litigation are the subject of a contentious debate this paper discusses key areas of the debate over cv and the validity of passive use value we conclude that many of the alleged problems with cv can be resolved by careful study design and implementation we further conclude that claims that empirical cv findings are theoretically inconsistent are not generally supported by the literature the debate over cv however has clarified several key issues related to nonmarket valuation and can provide useful guidance both to cv practitioners and the users of cv results

environmental quality preference and benefit estimation in multinomial probit models a simulation approach simulated maximum likelihood is used to estimate a random parameter multinomial probit model of destination choice for recreational fishing trips formulated to accommodate varying tastes and varying perceptions of environmental quality across individuals the restricted likelihood ratio test strongly rejects the independent probit model which is similar to the independent logit model in both the parameter and benefit estimates furthermore both the krinsky robb and bootstrapping procedures suggest that the benefit standard deviation of an environmental policy is found to be markedly lower higher when heterogeneous preferences are taken into account

an independent sample test of yea saying and starting point bias in dichotomous choice contingent valuation abstract we developed several diagnostic tools to test the convergent validity of two common contingent valuation elicitation procedures data were collected from independent samples receiving dichotomous choice and payment card questions we compared actual with counter factual responses using deterministic and monte carlo methods and we found that wtp distributions and mean values varied by the value elicitation method we also developed a paired comparison test for procedure variance which indicated that yea saying and starting point bias influenced dichotomous choice responses

siting noxious facilities a siting lottery with victim compensation abstract this paper proposes a scheme to facilitate the siting of noxious facilities a regional government announces that it will a use a lottery to choose a site for a noxious facility and b transfer income from tenants to host city landowners to at least partly offset the effects of the noxious facility on local property values the government will hold the lottery only if all citizens agree in advance to abide by the resulting siting decision the lottery approach is superior to the conventional approach to siting advance notification in the sense that the lottery approach achieves unanimous support for the siting decision with less compensation the compensation scheme can be financed with a regionwide tenant tax or a tax on residents in the nonhost city for small compensation programs the nonhost tax is superior to the regional tax

structural benefit transfer an example using vsl estimates abstract this paper describes and illustrates a method for benefits transfer referred to as preference calibration or structural benefits transfer this approach requires selection of a preference model capable of describing individual choices over a set of market and associated non market goods to maximize utility when facing budget constraints once the structure is selected the next step involves defining the analytical expressions for the tradeoffs being represented by the set of available benefit measures these algebraic relationships are used with the benefit estimates from the literature to calibrate the parameters of the model the calibrated model then offers the basis for defining the new tradeoffs required for the policy analysis i e for transferring benefits a new application is used to illustrate the structural benefits transfer logic it involves the benefits for mortality risk reductions measured with labor market compensation a worker would accept to be willing to work with added risk the measure is usually labeled the value of a statistical life vsl our application indicates that we should not have expected differences in these measures for the economic value of risk reductions with age the calibrated estimates were not greatly different for combinations of risk levels labor supply choices wages and non wage income for older adults thus simple adjustments relying on value per discounted life year remaining seem questionable

consistency in mixed demand systems contingent valuation and travel cost data in contrast to previous literature we propose a consistency test that does not impose any particular common functional form for the preference structure underlying the travel cost tc and contingent valuation cv models we derive testable consistency conditions between tc and cv data in the context of mixed demand systems when valuing changes in environmental quality these conditions are a subset of the rationality conditions the proposed consistency tests are implemented combining tc and cv data the empirical results show that it is possible to combine stated tc and cv but not revealed tc and cv data

does environmental performance affect financial performance a meta analysis abstract what do we know about the impact of environmental regulations performance on firm performance after more than three decades of theoretical as well as empirical research the results seem to remain inconclusive some papers suggest that regulations harm firms while others claim that regulations may contribute positively and give an impetus to innovations therefore i examine the heterogeneity in financial environmental performance nexus empirically carrying out a meta regression analysis of 64 outcomes from 37 empirical studies to uncover the underlying factors which can influence the observed variation in the empirical results the results suggest both that the empirical method used matters for the nexus and that the likelihood of finding a negative link between environmental and financial performance significantly increases when using simple correlation coefficients instead of more advanced econometric analysis the results also indicate that the portfolio studies tend to report a negative link between environmental and financial performance this likely reflects the omitted factors in portfolio studies the positive link is found more frequently in common law countries than in civil law countries the results also point to the importance of appropriate time coverage to establish a positive link between environmental and financial performance

using angler characteristics and attitudinal data to identify environmental preference classes a latent class model a latent class model of environmental preference groups is developed and estimated with only the answers to a set of attitudinal questions economists do not typically use this type of data in estimation group membership is latent unobserved the intent is to identify and characterize heterogeneity in the preferences for environmental amenities in terms of a small number of preference groups the application is to preferences over the fishing characteristics of green bay anglers answered a number of attitudinal questions including the importance of boat fees species catch rates and fish consumption advisories on site choice the results suggest that green bay anglers separate into a small number of distinct classes with varying preferences and willingness to pay for a pcb free green bay the probability that an angler belongs to each class is estimated as function of observable characteristics of the individual estimation is with the expectation maximization e m algorithm a technique new to environmental economics that can be used to do maximum likelihood estimation with incomplete information as explained a latent class model estimated with attitudinal data can be melded with a latent class choice model

identifying demand parameters in the presence of unobservables a combined revealed and stated preference approach we develop a combined revealed and stated preference approach to identify discrete choice demand parameters in the presence of unobserved determinants of choice our approach overcomes difficulties associated with small choice sets multicollinearity and endogeneity that arise with revealed preference approaches to illustrate our framework we revisit two canadian moose hunting datasets our empirical results suggest the potential gains from fusing revealed and stated preference data but they also suggest its limitations when the data generating processes for the data sources differ

assessing community preferences for development projects are willingness to pay studies robust to mode effects abstract the demand driven approaches to development planning currently promoted by development agencies assume that it is possible to obtain accurate information about community preferences for project outputs whereas dozens of techniques are used to assess community preferences limited research has been conducted on the potential effects of data collection mode on findings in this research four different modes a household intercept and telephone survey and a series of focus group discussions were all employed to assess residents willingness to pay for improved water supply services in odessa ukraine findings from these exercises suggest that data elicitation mode effects such as social desirability and time pressures can bias the results obtained in demand assessment research and lead to substantively different conclusions and policy recommendations

willingness to pay for quality improvements should revealed and stated preference data be combined abstract in this article we propose theoretically consistent welfare measurement of use and nonuse values for an improvement in environmental quality with revealed and stated preference data an analytical model based on the comparative static analysis of the variation function that describes the relationship between recreation demand and dichotomous choice contingent valuation models is estimated our results show that revealed and stated data should not be combined under the same assumed preference structure unless the two decisions imply the same change in behavior induced by the quality change in addition our results indicate scope effects in willingness to pay measures estimated with stated preference data

the effect of common sources of regression error on benefit estimates discussions of the sources of error in recreation demand analysis are common in the existing literature the most traditional line of thought e g gum and martin considers the error component in predicting the individual s recreation behavior to arise from unmeasured socioeconomic factors others e g hanemann attribute at least some of this error to fundamental randomness in human behavior applied statisticians e g hiett and worrall on the other hand suggest that recall of annual number of recreational trips i e the quantity demanded is subject to substantial error still others e g brown et al have argued that recall of explanatory variables such as travel expenses contains error despite the discussion of potential error sources there is no work which relates the sources of error in the demand relationship with benefit measurement 1 of practical importance in recreational demand estimation is whether error assumptions have an influence on welfare measures since it is for public policy decision purposes that recreational demand estimation is usually undertaken will the estimated consumer surplus derived from demand analysis be independent of the assumed source of the error in the regression the purpose of this paper is to explore how the assumptions about sources of error influence estimates of recreation benefits a discussion of the various sources of error in de

a meta analysis on the price elasticity and income elasticity of residential electricity demand abstract price elasticity and income elasticity can quantitatively measure the impact of price volatility and income diversity on household electricity demand to analyze household electricity demand and better identify the main factors affecting residential electricity demand elasticity in previous literature a meta analysis based on a comprehensive and systematic summary of 103 articles is presented in this study the influencing factors are identified with a weighed least squares wls linear regression model to evaluate their strength the price elasticities and income elasticities are discussed from three dimensions namely short term long term and unmarked the results show that residential electricity demand is almost price inelastic and income inelastic in the short term but in the long term some residential electricity demand is price elastic and income elastic the results also reveal that residential electricity demand elasticity is affected by many factors such as time interval and sample period these conclusions can support the formulation of more effective electricity price and energy policy

the role of the reference technology in measuring productive efficiency after a twenty year lull the measurement of productive efficiency is enjoying a revival in particular the index of efficiency developed by debreu i95i and later utilised by farrell i957 has received considerable attention these measures have been used fairly extensively in empirical work in both the operations research and economic literature these types of indexes have also appeared in the growing literature on testing for regularity conditions in production e g in afriat i972 diewert and parkan i983 and varian 1984 since the farrell type measure is the focus in this paper a brief review is useful in the farrell framework overall efficiency oe can be decomposed into two multiplicative components allocative efficiency ae and technical efficiency te

random coefficient models for stated preference surveys abstract this paper combines the use of random coefficient discrete choice models that allow for correlated errors in the form of unobserved preference heterogeneity with an investigation of the reliability and usefulness of rankings data for the data we examine we find significant unobserved preference heterogeneity in the rankings which violates the underlying assumptions of the rank ordered logit model further directly modeling unobserved preference heterogeneity results in significant improvement in the precision of the parameter estimates and in estimated willingness to pay wtp the reliability and usefulness of rankings data should be re examined with econometric models not subject to the independence of irrelevant alternatives iia

a difficulty with the travel cost method instead of observable prices of recreational visits travel cost method tcm re searchers are obliged to substitute researcher assigned visitation cost estimates i argue that visitation costs are inherently subjective but are ordinally measurable so long as the cost in creases with distance travelled it follows that traditional tcm yields only ordinally measur able welfare estimates the household produc tion function formulation of tcm resolves this problem only by imposing severe and un testable analytical restrictions tcm cannot serve as a stand alone technique for estimating recreation benefits rather it must be calibrated using information generated with fundamentally different methods jel q26

evidence of the effects of water quality on residential land prices we use hedonic techniques to show that water quality has a significant effect on property values along the chesapeake bay we calculate the potential benefits from an illustrative but limited water quality improvement and we calculate an upper bound to the benefits from a more widespread improvement many environmental hedonic studies have almost entirely ignored the potential for omitted variables bias the possibility that pollution sources in addition to emitting undesirable substances are likely to be unpleasant neighbors we discuss the implications of this oversight and we provide an application that addresses this potential problem o 2000 acadcmic prcss

estimating the willingness to pay for water services in developing countries a case study of the use of contingent valuation surveys in southern haiti progress in improving the quality and quantity of water used by people in rural areas of the developing world has been unsatisfactory in two respects 1 supplies that have been built are frequently neither used correctly nor properly maintained and 2 extension of improved service to unserved populations has been slow though this poor record is not the result of a single factor a major impediment to improved performance is inadequate information on the response of consumers to new service options the behavioral assumptions that typically underlie most rural water supply planning efforts are simple it is commonly assumed that so long as financial requirements do not exceed 5 of income rural consumers will choose to abandon their existing water supply in favor of the improved system several reviews by the world bank bilateral donors and water supply agencies in developing countries have shown however that this simple model of behavioral response to improved water supplies has usually proved incorrect 1 in rural areas many of those served by new systems have chosen to continue with their traditional water use practices

respondent uncertainty and ordering effect on willingness to pay for salt marsh conservation in the brest roadstead france abstract this paper explores the potential link between the sensitivity of willingness to pay wtp to the order of presenting bid amounts in contingent valuation questions ordering effect and respondent uncertainty the resource being valued is a public project to protect salt marshes against the spread of an invasive aquatic plant in the brest roadstead france valuation uncertainty is captured through a variant of payment card format where respondents are given the opportunity to report their wtp as either a single value option a or an interval of values option b the ordering effect is tested using both parametric models that ignore and control for the potential sample selection bias related to the choice between option a and option b as well as non parametric models the results suggest that 1 respondents place substantial wtp values on salt marsh conservation and 2 the ordering effect is linked to respondent uncertainty since only uncertain respondents react differently to changes in the order of presenting bid amounts specifically for uncertain respondents putting bid amounts in ascending order yields lower welfare estimates than putting bid amounts in descending order or random order policy recommendations and options to deal with ordering effect are discussed

comparing contingent valuation and averting expenditure estimates of the costs of irregular water supply abstract we compare two methods contingent valuation and averting expenditures to measure the demand for improved water reliability in urban jordan traditionally averting expenditures a revealed preference measure have been considered a lower bound for demand relative to contingent valuation a stated preference measure estimates we develop a theoretical model to show that this relationship critically depends on household perceptions in our setting this insight is important because households appear to have relatively low confidence in both the reliability and quality of existing water supplies even though water quality tests suggest that utility water is safe to drink from a microbial perspective averting expenditures which reach 4 of monthly expenditures on average include substantial purchases of non network water sourced from water shops or tankers as well as costs in terms of water collection time storage and in home treatment in contrast the contingent valuation responses while correlated with coping costs reveal low willingness to pay for increases in water reliability from the utility network we attribute this departure from the traditional relationship between averting expenditures and contingent valuation to the lack of household confidence in the quality of utility provided water our study thus adds to previous evidence in the literature which points to the importance of consumer perceptions in determining demand for environmental improvements

the value of household water service quality in lahore pakistan most existing literature focuses on the benefits of establishing basic drinking water access for unserved populations the extensive water supply margin in contrast this article examines the intensive margin the benefits of improving water service to under served households a growing population in developing country cities we use contingent valuation to estimate willingness to pay wtp for improved piped water quality and reductions in supply interruptions among a sample of 193 households in lahore pakistan the distribution of wtp is described using parametric and non parametric models results indicate that households in lahore are willing to pay about 7 50 to 9 per month for piped water supply that is clean and drinkable directly from the tap comparable to the monthly cost of in home water treatment and about three to four times the average monthly water bill for sample households using piped water estimates of wtp for reducing supply interruptions are both smaller and more difficult to interpret since a significant fraction of the estimated wtp distribution for supply improvements is negative all of our wtp estimates are well below 4 of monthly household income the world bank s benchmark upper bound for affordable water service

bureaucratic choice and nonoptimal provision of public goods theory and evidence local governments allocation decisions are modeled in the context of a slack maximizing bureaucrat who produces public goods according to a production function that includes both provision and the constituents socio economic characteristics to gain a better understanding of the determinants of slack comparative statics and an empirical study of illinois municipalities are conducted the indirect output distance function provides efficiency scores upon which we regress several variables representing socio economic characteristics costs and competition measures we find that slack or inefficient behavior is associated with richer communities lower education levels and a lack of competition for residents among municipalities

validation of stated preferences for public goods a comparison of contingent valuation survey response and voting behaviour this study reports the results from an in person comparison of contingent valuation cv survey response and subsequent voting behaviour on comparable propositions to increase public spending for landscape protection a substantial proportion of cv responses were not consistent with self reported actual voting decisions suggesting an upward bias of stated willingness to pay item non response and protest zero bids were more frequently given by those rejecting than those approving the actual proposition self reported actual decisions yielded a more consistent explanatory pattern than did hypothetical choices the official aggregate voting records show that these results cannot be explained simply by errors in self reported votes we conclude that referenda provide a valuable opportunity to test stated preference methods for public goods particularly public goods with significant passive use values however an important requirement is that the stated choices to be compared with the referendum decisions unlike in previous studies come from independent contingent valuation surveys

an indirect approach to the evaluation of producer performance in this paper we suggest a somewhat new analytical approach to producer performance evaluation the suggested approach is somewhat new in that it synthesizes existing analytical techniques from three areas and uses them to look at performance evaluation in a new way the approach is particularly relevant to public sector or service sector contexts in which the performance of alternative providers of a public service is to be evaluated in these contexts any of the following conditions may hold 1 the standard profit maximizing cost minimizing or revenue maximizing paradigms are inappropriate 2 prices of some services being provided or of some resources being consumed are either nonexistent or unobserved 3 observed prices are not exogenous due to monopoly or monopsony power examples abound it is frequently argued that the provision of medical legal educational transportation employment and many other services by public or private agencies is driven by goals other than the maximization of profit moreover these and many other services such as police and fire protection do not always have market prices with which to value them in addition the lack of competition in the provision of many such services and thus in the employment of specialized resources used in their provision makes it dangerous to use existing but distorted market prices to compare the performance of providers on the basis of revenue or cost much less profit