commodity price responses to monetary policy surprises commodity prices are important both as a source of shocks and for the propagation of shocks originating elsewhere in the economy many vector autoregression var studies estimate a gradual response of commodity prices to monetary policy shocks exploiting information in high frequency financial market data and using the methods of rigobon and sack 2004 i find that a 10 basis point surprise change in interest rates causes commodity prices to fall immediately by about 0 5 this is about two thirds of the estimated response of the s p500 and about five times larger than the response in a var 12 months after the shock metals prices tend to respond more than agricultural commodities the point estimate for oil prices is similar to other commodities but is estimated imprecisely

the reaction of interest rates to unanticipated federal reserve actions and statements implications for the money announcement controversy this paper examines the reaction of long and short term interest rates to monetary policy surprises that influenced market expectations of the future behavior of the federal funds rate in the period after october 1979 we find that the relative reaction of long and short term rates to policy surprises is similar to the relative reaction of these rates to money announcements consequently we conclude that the large reaction of long term interest rates to money announcements in the period after october 1979 is consistent with the policy anticipations hypothesis which views this reaction as a movement in real interest rates

monetary policy regimes expected inflation and the response of interest rates to money announcements this paper examines the response of the term structure of interest rates to weekly money announcements estimated responses for both the pre and post october 1979 periods are first presented then two competing hypotheses involving the policy anticipations and expected inflation effects are formally specified and compared with the estimated responses both hypotheses are found to be consistent with the responses but they have sharply different implications about the federal reserve s short run monetary policy by exploiting these different implications additional empirical results focusing directly on the money stock process support the policy anticipations hypothesis

strategic eurasian natural gas market model for energy security and policy analysis formulation and application to south stream abstract the mathematical formulation of a strategic eurasian natural gas market model is presented the model represents horizontal oligopolistic relationships among producers bilateral market power between producer russia and transit ukraine countries detailed transport constraints and operation decisions over a 20 year time horizon to demonstrate the model s capabilities a financial and market analysis of the proposed south stream gas pipeline from russia via the black sea to south europe is summarized insights obtained include the following first expectations of high demand growth in europe and or transit risks do not justify the construction of the south stream pipeline because under all demand and ukraine transit interruption scenarios the net benefits to the south stream participants are negative the npv ranges from 1 9 billion bn to 7 4 bn second ukraine s perception of high transit market power vis a vis russia may trigger the construction of the otherwise unprofitable south stream project thus under ukraine s high transit market power scenario the npv of south stream ranges between 2 4 bn and 24 5 bn third we find that the south stream investment increases the efficiency of the european gas market under the following conditions i when gas demand in europe grows 2 per year up to 2030 ii when ukraine poses high transit market power or iii under a combination of severe transit risks through ukraine and low demand scenarios in europe it should be noted that the value of south stream to both its project sponsors and the market as a whole is much higher when ukraine exercises transit market power than under the high demand scenario therefore whether ukraine is likely to wield market power is crucial to the success of the south stream project because that is the only scenario in which the project yields both a positive expected npv to its sponsors and the highest value to the market as a whole

the impact of fomc statements on the volatility of asset prices this article examines the impact of federal open market committee fomc statements on asset prices statements are found to have a much more pronounced impact on the volatility of asset prices than interest rate surprises they influence primarily stock returns intermediate and long term yields whereas short term rates are driven both by statements and by interest rate surprises we also find that the regime shift of may 1999 has improved the effectiveness of monetary policy as reflected in an overall reduction in market volatility during the most recent regime in addition markets are equally well prepared for the upcoming rate decision in both regimes but the process of adjustment depends on whether a statement was issued in the old regime or not when a statement is issued price adjustments are very similar across both periods whereas if no statement is issued then the rate of adjustment towards the new value is more gradual and occurs throughout the entire intermeeting period

international interest rates and us monetary policy announcements evidence from hong kong and singapore this paper investigates the responses of market interest rates to us monetary policy announcements for the us and two emerging economies hong kong and singapore which are similar on many respects but have experienced opposite exchange rate regimes in the last twenty years our results based on market expectations extracted from federal fund futures rates document that fomc announcements significantly affect the term structure of interest rate in the us and both asian countries further international interest rate differentials around fomc meeting dates tend to be negative for short maturities with the impact gradually dissipating as bond maturity increases finally for the case of singapore we find that domestic interest rates react to both external and domestic monetary policy announcements with a magnitude that is larger over the full bond maturity spectrum for domestic announcements these results are robust to time varying futures risk premia and alternative measures of interest rates expectations

asymmetric quantile analysis of the swedish mortgage price discovery process based on swedish banking data we discover robust and significantly positive asymmetric price transmission apt effects over all analysed regression quantiles of our mortgage interest rates with even larger positive apt for the higher percentiles the analysis was enabled through unique access to a swedish bank s seb own records of their true borrowing costs our central contribution is that there is a higher propensity for the bank to rapidly increase its mortgage interest rates for customers following an increase in its borrowing costs compared with the propensity for the bank to decrease its customers mortgage rates subsequent to a corresponding borrowing cost decrease

does the federal reserve affect asset prices abstract the federal reserve is probably one of the institutions most closely monitored by investors this indicates that investors believe the actions of the fed have implications for asset prices to this date the trading activities of the fed in the financial markets have not been examined to see how the fed influences asset prices using daily data on open market operations omos and asset prices this study fills this void one finding of the paper is that omos granger cause both short and long term interest rates furthermore the sign of the relationship confirms the existence of the liquidity effect given that its trades represent a small portion of the market volume how the fed influences bond prices is a puzzle the only reasonable explanation is that the fed s trades have high information content judging by the impulse response paths the reaction of interest rates to open market operations is fast additionally it appears that monetary policy has a lasting impact on interest rates

the fed and short term rates is it open market operations open mouth operations or interest rate smoothing abstract it is widely believed that the fed controls the federal funds rate by altering the degree of pressure in the reserve market through open market operations when it changes its target for the funds rate recently however several analysts have suggested that the fed need not conduct open market operations to change the funds rate rather they argue it is sufficient that the fed indicate its desire for the funds rate this paper notes that there is yet a third alternative the interest rate smoothing hypothesis that suggests that the fed does not move rates per se but rather smooths the transition of rates to the new equilibrium required by economic shocks this paper tests the open market and open mouth alternatives using a methodology first used by cook and hahn journal of monetary economics 1989a 331 finding no evidence that either open market operations or open mouth operations can account for the close relationship between the funds rate and the funds rate target a variety of evidence consistent with the interest rate smoothing hypothesis is considered the results suggest that many changes in the fed s funds rate target are an endogenous response to economic events and suggest that an alternative way to identify exogenous changes in policy is to identify exogenous changes in the fed s funds rate target

interest rate smoothing and price level trend stationarity abstract this paper discusses the definition and mechanics of central bank interest rate smoothing under rational expectations a tension arising between interest rate smoothing and macroeconomic stabilization objectives induces non trend stationary price level and money stock behavior the paper thereby helps explain why such nominal non stationarities are widely observed further implications are drawn for base drift distribution of real returns on long term fixed rate nominal debt and operating characteristics of interest rate pegs and policy instruments

an exploration of a strategic competition model for the european union natural gas market abstract following jansen et al 2012 we examine an unconventional cournot model of the european union natural gas market with three major suppliers russian gazprom norwegian statoil and algerian sonatrach to reflect russia s other strategic consideration besides profit we incorporate a relative market share into gazprom s objective function we prove that when gazprom pursues the control of market share along with profit it will be good news for consumers but bad news for its pure profit maximising rivals we further show that by seeking a proper market share gazprom can achieve the same profit of a stackelberg leader in a simultaneous move model as in the standard sequential move leader follower model compared with jansen et al s our approach makes both the analysis considerably simpler and more transparent and the model more applicable

monetary policy surprises and interest rates choosing between the inflation revelation and excess sensitivity hypotheses author affiliation willem thorbecke george mason university and senior fellow research institute of economy trade and industry 1 3 1 kasumigaseki chiyoda ku tokyo 100 8901 japan tel 81 3 35018286 e mail wthorbec gmu edu corresponding author hanjiang zhang department of finance mccombs school of business university of texas at austin 1 university station b6000 austin tx 78712 usa e mail hanjiang zhang mccombs utexas edu acknowledgment we thank the co editor kent kimbrough two anonymous referees and seminar participants at the research institute of economy trade and industry for many helpful comments we also thank andrew swiston for generously providing us data on unexpected changes in the federal funds rate target 1 introductionwhy do increases in the federal reserve s fed s target for the federal funds rate raise interest rates on long term treasury securities one might expect that contractionary monetary policy would raise short term rates because of a liquidity effect and reduce long term rates by lowering expected inflation yet cook and hahn 1989 reported that increases in the fed s target for the federal funds rate from september 1974 to september 1979 raised interest rates at all horizons similarly kuttner 2001 found that unanticipated increases in the federal funds rate target over the june 1989 to february 2000 period increased interest rates at all maturities one interpretation of the results of cook and hahn 1989 and kuttner 2001 is that contractionary monetary policy raises longer term real interest rates the nominal interest rate equals the real interest rate plus the expected inflation rate if contractionary monetary policy lowers expected inflation or leaves it unchanged then evidence that it increases the nominal interest rate implies that it must also be increasing the real interest rate romer and romer 2000 provided an alternative explanation for these findings they showed that the fed has substantially more information about future inflation than is available from commercial forecasts their results imply that the optimal strategy for individuals with access to both the fed s forecasts and commercial forecasts would be to rely exclusively on the fed s forecasts they also demonstrated that federal reserve policy actions reveal some of the fed s private information about inflation an increase in the federal funds rate target could thus increase interest rates by raising expectations of future inflation gurkaynak sack and swanson 2005a presented evidence indicating that increases in the federal funds rate target have the opposite effect lowering expected inflation from 1990 2002 they found that unexpected increases in the funds rate target lower the one year forward rate 10 years ahead they also found that real long term forward rates derived from inflation indexed treasury securities do not respond to monetary policy surprises while the compensation for inflation responds with a significant negative coefficient to positive innovations in the federal funds rate target they interpreted these findings to mean that surprise increases in the federal funds rate target lower future expected inflation their conclusion is thus exactly the opposite of romer and romer s 2000 information revelation explanation ellingsen and soderstrom 2001 presented a model that encompasses the models of romer and romer 2000 and gurkaynak sack and swanson 2005a in their model unanticipated changes in the central bank rate can occur because the central bank has private information about the economy or because the central bank changes its preferences for inflation stabilization relative to output stabilization romer and romer focused on the first effect and gurkaynak sack and swanson focused on the second campbell 1995 noted that the effect of funds rate increases on inflation expectations should depend on the fed s credibility in fighting inflation

stock market reaction to fed funds rate surprises state dependence and the financial crisis this paper examines the response of us stock returns to federal funds rate ffr surprises between 1989 and 2012 focusing on the impact of the recent financial crisis we find that outside the crisis period stock prices increased as a response to unexpected ffr cuts state dependence is identified with stocks exhibiting larger increases when interest rate easing coincided with recessions bear markets and tightening credit conditions however an important structural shift occurred during the crisis changing the stocks response to ffr shocks and the nature of state dependence throughout the crisis period stocks did not react positively to unexpected ffr cuts which were interpreted as signals of worsening future economic conditions this triggered a rebalancing of investment portfolios away from falling equities and towards safe haven assets our results highlight the severity of the crisis and the ineffectiveness of conventional monetary policy close to the zero lower bound

discount window borrowing and federal reserve operating regimes i introduction the borrowing behavior of banks at the federal reserve s discount window is a component of most models of the monetary sector including the model used by the federal reserve 1 as several researchers have noted 2 however the policy importance of accurate predictions of borrowing behavior depends on the federal reserve s short run operating procedure if the federal reserve uses a federal funds rate target to control money growth as it did in the 1970s inaccurate predictions of borrowing behavior have no effect on money supply growth if the federal reserve uses a nonborrowed reserves target as is usually assumed for the october 1979 to october 1982 period or a borrowed reserves target as was used after october 1982 then poor predictions of bank borrowing are a potentially significant source of errors in controlling money 3 given the importance of accurate borrowing predictions to monetary control under current short run operating procedures admissions by the federal reserve that its borrowing equation poorly explains recent borrowing behavior are cause for concern 4 part of the problem may lie with inadequate allowance for differences in bank borrowing behavior under different operating procedures the choice of operating procedure determines not only the importance of accurate borrowing predictions but also affects borrowing behavior by affecting the stochastic process characterizing the spread between the federal funds rate and the discount rate 5 the standard model for aggregate borrowing typified by goldfeld and kane 1966 assumes a positive relationship between borrowing and the spread the optimizing model of individual bank borrowing decisions of goodfriend 1983 used by cosimano 1988 and dotsey 1989 among others suggests that borrowing also depends negatively on banks expectations about future levels of the spread specifically goodfriend s model of risk neutral banks predicts a larger impact on borrowing of a spread change that banks expect to be temporary than one that banks expect to be more persistent to the extent that banks predict future spreads using an autoregressive model changes in the stochastic process characterizing the spread should change the impact realizations of the spread have on borrowing 6 moreover if banks are risk averse changes in the operating procedures that produce less predictable spreads may affect both banks borrowing and excess reserve behavior 7 because the spread s stochastic behavior depends on the federal reserve s operating procedure borrowing behavior in turn should depend on the federal reserve s operating procedure consequently the federal reserve should not assume that the borrowing equation in its model is invariant to changes in operating procedure as goodfriend notes such an assumption is another example of the lucas critique bryant 1983 and dutkowsky and foote 1988 show that borrowing equations estimated during the period when the federal reserve targeted the federal funds rate produce poor forecasts of borrowing after the regime change of 6 october 1979 these papers do not however provide evidence on how the borrowing equation changed after october 1979 one purpose of this paper is to investigate whether bank borrowing behavior changed with changes in federal reserve operating procedures leading to estimated borrowing equations that differ significantly under different operating procedures in addition to the changes in operating procedures the federal reserve also changed the reserve accounting rules in february 1984 replacing lagged reserve accounting with contemporaneous reserve accounting although the effect of this switch on bank reserve management is difficult to predict the increased uncertainty about reserve needs and the decrease in information about the aggregate demand for reserves make it plausible that banks became more conservative affecting their excess reserve behavior and their discount window borrowing

dynamics of the federal funds target rate a nonstationary discrete choice approach we apply a discrete choice approach to model the empirical behaviour of the federal reserve in changing the federal funds target rate the benchmark of short term market interest rates in the us our methods allow the explanatory variables to be nonstationary as well as stationary this feature is particularly useful in the present application as many economic fundamentals that are monitored by the fed and are believed to affect decisions to adjust interest rate targets display some nonstationarity over time the chosen model successfully predicts the majority of the target rate changes during the time period considered 1994 2001 and helps to explain strings of similar intervention decisions by the fed based on the model implied optimal interest rate our findings suggest that there is a lag in the fed s reaction to economic shocks during this period copyright 2004 john wiley sons ltd

monetary policy and long term interest rates in germany abstract in this paper we provide new empirical evidence on the relationship between short and long run interest rates for germany we find a positive correlation after a supply and demand shock and a negative correlation after a monetary policy shock this finding is consistent with the theory of ellingsen and soderstrom american economic review 2001 91 5 1594 1607

federal reserve interest rate targeting rational expectations and the term structure abstract the amount of information in the yield curve for forecasting future changes in short rates varies with the maturity of the rates involved indeed spreads between certain long and short rates appear unrelated to future changes in the short rate contrary to the rational expectations hypothesis of the term structure this paper estimates a daily model of federal reserve interest rate targeting behavior which accompanied by the maintained hypothesis of rational expectations explains the varying predictive ability of the yield curve and elucidates the link between fed policy and the term structure

the term structure with semi credible targeting the federal reserve sets targets for interest rates which it enforces through direct market intervention these targets are changed periodically in this paper we develop a term structure model in which the short rate is subject to a control which keeps it close to a target which changes from time to time the probability of target changes is not constant in the model but changes as a function of observables the model performs well at explaining the shifts in the yield curve that accompany target changes in u s financial markets the federal reserve bank the fed is a unique player usually we assume that market participants are price takers in financial markets however there is evidence that this is not true of the fed in fact the fed sets targets for short term rates which it attempts to maintain by market intervention injecting or withdrawing funds from the market to keep the rates near their targets targets are changed from time to time and market participants know when such a target change occurs they may in fact have some limited ability to forecast such target changes several recent papers have provided evidence that models which allow the short rate to revert toward a mean which is itself a random process perform

interest rate co movements global factors and the long end of the term spread the decoupling of us short and long interest rates has been a distinctive feature of the 2000s we employ recent advances in panel econometrics to document this disconnect for industrial countries and link it to a global latent factor in long term rates we investigate whether international forces such as global inflation global output or the global savings glut may be behind this global latent factor the savings glut is the most likely contender suggesting that reserve accumulation and a search for yield from emerging markets has lowered long rates internationally driving a wedge between domestic short and long rates

the term structure spread and future changes in long and short rates in the g7 countries abstract according to the expectations hypothesis when the spread between long and short rates widens next quarter s long rate should rise in the united states however long rates decline instead of rising this anomaly is also present in canada the uk germany and japan four of the additional six g7 countries nevertheless in contrast to the us where long rates appear to overreact to expected future developments the anomalous short run movement of long rates in these other g7 countries is caused by an additive white noise error on long rates that does not materially affect the information in their term structure

pre announcement effects news effects and volatility monetary policy and the stock market abstract i examine pre announcement and news effects on the stock market in the context of public disclosure of monetary policy decisions the results suggest that the stock market tends to be relatively quiet conditional volatility is abnormally low on days preceding regularly scheduled policy announcements although this calming effect is routinely reported in anecdotal press accounts it is statistically significant only over the past four to five years a result that i attribute to changes in the federal reserve s disclosure practices in early 1994 the paper also looks at how the actual interest rate decisions of policy makers affect stock market volatility the element of surprise in such decisions tends to boost stock market volatility significantly in the short run and positive surprises higher than expected values of the target federal funds rate tend to have a larger effect on volatility than negative surprises the implications of the results for broader issues in the finance and economics literatures are also discussed

changing interest rate responses to money announcements 1977 1983 abstract this paper investigates when and how the response of interest rates to money announcements changed in recent years the response of both short and long rates rises in october 1979 but drops during 1981 during mid 1982 the response of long rates raises again but without a change in the response of short rates despite a number of ex post explanations for these shifts none of the major hypotheses of why interest rates respond to money announcements provides a complete ex ante explanation of these response shifts

the impact of discount rate changes on market interest rates evidence from three european countries and japan abstract this paper examines the impact of official discount rate odr changes on market interest rates of four countries germany france japan and the uk during the period from 1980 through 1997 the overall results indicate that short term rates are more responsive than long term rates for all countries the magnitude of the changes is country specific market rate responses are lower for germany and japan which have fewer changes in odr these results are consistent with expectations that there is less uncertainty under such regimes consistent with the pace of regulatory reforms the results of odr changes are strongest in uk and weakest in japan when monetary policy is changed or reversed interest rate responses are shown to be larger for countries with frequent changes in discount rates

the effect of changes in the federal funds rate target on market interest rates in the 1970s abstract this paper examines the influence of monetary policy on interest rates by estimating the effect of changes in the federal funds rate target the federal reserve s policy instrument on market interest rates in the 1970s we find that changes in the target caused large movements in short term rates and smaller but significant movements in intermediate and long term rates we hypothesize that the similarity of the reactions of three six and twelve month rates to changes in the target offers a possible explanation for the lack of support for the expectations theory from studies that have tested the theory using these rates

the effect of the fed s large scale asset purchases on inflationary expectations in 2008 u s demand collapsed and triggered deflation the fed employed large scale asset purchases lsap to fight deflation how did news of lsap affect inflationary expectations if investors believed that lsap would raise inflation they would sell assets exposed to inflation and purchase inflation hedges this would lower the prices of assets that are harmed by inflation and raise the prices of assets that benefit from inflation examining the relationship between asset price changes and inflation sensitivities can thus shed light on how financial markets process lsap news results across 60 assets indicate that initially lsap announcements lowered expected inflation only as inflation approached its target did news of lsap raise expected inflation

dynamic limited dependent variable modeling and u s monetary policy i estimate using real time data a forward looking monetary policy reaction function that is dynamic and that also accounts for the fact that there are substantial restrictions in the period to period changes of the fed s policy instrument i nd a substantial contrast between the periods before and after paul volcker s appointment as fed chairman in 1979 both in terms of the fed s response to expected in ation and in terms of its response to the perceived output gap in the pre volcker era the fed s response to in ation was substantially weaker than in the volcker greenspan era conversely the fed seems to have been more responsive to real activity in the pre volcker era than later

inference using qualitative and quantitative information with an application to monetary policy i introduction there has been a revival of interest in the use of qualitative information in macroeconomic analysis recently an impetus for this revival is the apparent inability of modern statistical analyses that use only quantitative information to resolve significant macroeconomic controversies for example the direction of causality between money and output continues to be the subject of considerable debate the use of qualitative information in macroeconomic analysis has a long tradition mitchell 1927 and burns and mitchell 1946 use the descriptions in thorp s 1926 annals and several statistical series to identify the unobserved phase of the business cycle 1 in their chapters on the federal reserve friedman and schwartz 1963 use diaries policy records and monetary aggregates to identify the stance of monetary policy the essence of this traditional method is that it is prudent to use both qualitative and quantitative information in the process of inference because of the potential gain in confidence associated with cross verification both types of information are needed to identify the asymmetries and nonlinearities that are characteristic of business cycles policy initiatives and other economic phenomena questions concerning the interpretation of results using qualitative information however have been raised 2 a source of unease is the difficulty of assessing a researcher s distillation of the information in descriptive materials no obvious metric for evaluating the coding of a qualitative variable exists i present an alternative framework for combining qualitative and quantitative information in order to draw inferences of an unobservable variable quantitative information is an observable time series variable qualitative information is an indicator variable coded by a researcher that reflects the distillation of literary materials motivated by the traditional method i consider the case where both types of observable information are imperfect representations of an unobserved state variable an iterative algorithm that uses quantitative and qualitative information to draw inferences of the unobservable variable is constructed the algorithm produces an inference of the unobservable state variable for each sample period using the two types of information it also produces a probabilistic assessment of whether the qualitative indicator is a reliable indicator of the true unobserved state as discussed in more detail below this algorithm is closely related to those of cosslett and lee 1985 and hamilton 1989 the algorithm is applied to the problem of determining the stance of monetary policy a goal is to confront a problem that economic agents may actually face because of the secrecy surrounding the monetary policy process a description of that problem is how can observable information qualitative and quantitative be combined to infer the stance of monetary policy also can the reliability of the qualitative information or a distillation of it be measured i implement the algorithm using two prominent indicators of monetary policy the paper is organized as follows the alternative framework for using qualitative and quantitative information to draw inferences of an unobservable variable is presented in the next section the application to the problem of inferring the stance of monetary policy is presented in section iii in this section indicators of policy are introduced the model is estimated and the relationship between the dynamic conditional monetary policy inferences and an important forecaster of macroeconomic activity is explored section iv concludes ii an alternative framework for inference stochastic structure my alternative framework is based on a particular conception of the statistical model underlying the traditional method let y sub t denote a quantitative variable and i sub t denote a 0 1 qualitative variable

federal reserve information and the behavior of interest rates this paper tests for the existence of asymmetric information between the federal reserve and the public by examining federal reserve and commercial inflation forecasts it demonstrates that the federal reserve has considerable information about inflation beyond what is known to commercial forecasters it also shows that monetary policy actions provide signals of the federal reserve s information and that commercial forecasters modify their forecasts in response to those signals these findings may explain why long term interest rates typically rise in response to shifts to tighter monetary policy jel e52 e43 d82 asymmetric information between the federal reserve and the public is a phenomenon that is often posited but rarely tested numerous models of central bank behavior for example show that the existence of asymmetric information has important implications for the effectiveness of policy and the consequences of dynamic inconsistency yet there

gas trade in the european community during the 1970s a model analysis abstract the european gas market has the reputation of being ruled by secrecy and particular deals this paper tries to explain its development during the 1970s in terms of market equilibrium more precisely we focus with a partial equilibrium model gtm on three important years for gas industry and show that while equilibrium can easily qualify 1974 short term considerations have to be introduced to explain the market in 1978 the analysis is further pursued until 1980 where we investigate the price increases that took place during that period

the information content of discount rate announcements and their effect on market interest rates this paper presents evidence that throughout the 1973 85 period the federal reserve systematically used certain types of discount rate a nnouncements to signal changes in its policy instrument the federal funds rate market participants understood the signals contained in d iscount rate announcements and used them to revise their expectations of the funds rate these revisions in funds rate expectations caused movements in treasury bill rates copyright 1988 by ohio state university press

do markets care who chairs the central bank this paper assesses the effects of central bank governor appointments on financial market expectations of monetary policy to measure these effects we assemble a new dataset of appointment announcements from 15 countries and conduct an event study analysis on exchange rates bond yields and stock prices our main findings are threefold first exchange rates and bond yields display a statistically significant response to the announcement of a new governor especially when the appointee s identity was not anticipated in advance second the reactions are especially pronounced for central banks lacking either independence or a clear nominal anchor third new governors are not generally perceived to lack credibility there is no tendency for announcements to be associated with jumps in inflation expectations

high frequency identification of monetary non neutrality the information effect we present estimates of monetary non neutrality based on evidence from high frequency responses of real interest rates expected inflation and expected output growth our identifying assumption is that unexpected changes in interest rates in a 30 minute window surrounding scheduled federal reserve announcements arise from news about monetary policy in response to an interest rate hike nominal and real interest rates increase roughly one for one several years out into the term structure while the response of expected inflation is small at the same time forecasts about output growth also increase the opposite of what standard models imply about a monetary tightening to explain these facts we build a model in which fed announcements affect beliefs not only about monetary policy but also about other economic fundamentals our model implies that these information effects play an important role in the overall causal effect of monetary policy shocks on output

competition transmission and bank pricing policies evidence from belgian loan and deposit markets abstract this paper addresses the pass through from market interest rates to retail bank interest rates the paper advocates a heterogeneous approach and applies it to the belgian banking market a substantial proportion of the heterogeneity in bank pricing policies can be explained by the bank lending channel and the relative market power hypothesis the results also suggest that the long term pass through is typically less than one for one rejecting the completeness hypothesis while there is no convincing evidence for asymmetry in retail rates large deviations from equilibrium mark ups are faster reduced than small deviations overall conditions for corporate loans are more competitive compared to consumer loans demand and savings deposits have by far the most rigid prices

market reactions to ecb policy innovations a cross country analysis abstract regulators have been paying increasing attention to governing and steering market fluctuations with their role in shaping the economic cycle being ever more crucial the combined effect of the financial and sovereign debt crises as well as the approach to the zero lower bound has made actions even more pressing forcing the european central bank to resort to unconventional instruments to revive the economies and counter deflationary pressures by using a combined event study and panel regression methodology we investigate whether european monetary union equity markets react heterogeneously to standard and non standard european central bank policy innovations our results show that conventional policies unevenly affect financial indices in the eurozone and hence are bound to generate asymmetries that reflect on real economies while unconventional measures albeit with different intensities exercise a homogeneous pressure on all markets our evidence highlights the beneficial impact of unconventional measures and suggests that they can play a useful role even in non crisis times

the relation between narrative and money market indicators of monetary policy this paper studies the relation between narrative based indicators of monetary policy and widely used money market indicators of monetary policy three principal findings emerge first changes in monetary policy as measured by the narrative based policy indices are associated with persistent changes in the levels of m2 and the monetary base in contrast changes in the narrative policy indicators lead to transitory changes in short term interest rates nonborrowed reserves and the spread between the six month commercial paper rate and the three month treasury bill rate third these findings are generally robust across different narrative based policy indices

optimal interest rate smoothing this paper considers the desirability of the observed tendency of central banks to adjust interest rates only gradually in response to changes in economic conditions it shows in the context of a simple model of optimizing private sector behaviour that assignment of an interest rate smoothing objective to the central bank may be desirable even when reduction of the magnitude of interest rate changes is not a social objective in itself this is because a response of policy to irrelevant lagged variables may be desirable owing to the way it steers private sector expectations of future policy

the validity of the event study approach evidence from the impact of the fed s monetary policy on us and foreign asset prices this paper documents the effects of changes in us monetary policy on asset prices in 51 countries to evaluate the validity of the event study approach we find that the event study estimates contain a significant bias however this bias is fairly small and the ordinary least squares approach tends to outperform in an expected squared error sense the heteroscedasticity based estimator for both small and large sample sizes hence in general the event study methodology should be preferred moreover we show that us monetary policy has been an important determinant of global financial markets

monetary policy surprises and interest rates evidence from the fed funds futures market abstract this paper estimates the impact of monetary policy actions on bill note and bond yields using data from the futures market for federal funds to separate changes in the target funds rate into anticipated and unanticipated components interest rates response to anticipated target rate changes is small while their response to unanticipated changes is large and highly significant these responses are generally consistent with the expectations hypothesis of the term structure surprise target rate changes have little effect on expectations of future actions however which helps to explain the lack of empirical support for the expectations hypothesis at the short end of the yield curve

financial and capital markets responses to changes in the central bank s target interest rate the case of japan we propose new proxy variables for monetary policy shocks in japan for the period from july 1989 to march 2001 and investigate the effects of changes in the policy target variable on stock prices and the term structure of interest rates we find that changes in the surprise component of the target variable significantly affect both intermediate term and long term interest rates a surprise decrease in the target rate of 1 leads on average to a 3 increase in stock prices the magnitudes of estimated reactions of financial variables are similar in japan and the us

household electricity and gas consumption for heating homes energy consumption has been drastically changed because of energy source depletion price fluctuations development and penetration of alternative energy sources and government policies household energy sources are interrelated and energy price and household characteristics such as income level and dwelling size affect the usage to supply energy consistently and achieve a balance between production and consumption stakeholders must understand consumer energy consumption behavior therefore this study identifies household heating energy usage patterns and the substitutive and or complementary relationships between electricity and gas based on a multiple discrete continuous extreme value model household utility structure is identified from data on gas heating usage results show greater utility and the smallest satiation values for gas boilers than for electric heaters and electric heating beds the effects of consumer socioeconomic and environmental characteristics on the choice of heating energy sources were analyzed also for further comparison the respondents were split into high and low categories for income heating degree days dwelling size and gas usage gas was found to be the most economical heating choice for households

the response of term rates to fed announcements in february 4 1994 the federal reserve began the practice of announcing changes in the targeted level for the federal funds rate immediately after such decisions were made this paper investigates to what extent the policy of the announcement affected a key ingredient in the monetary transmission mechanism the term structure of nominally risk free treasury securities we find that term rates react much more in unison during announcement days than at any other time moreover the practice of circumscribing almost all changes in the federal funds rate target to federal open market committee fomc meeting dates regiments the formation of market expectations in the overnight rate and the price discovery process of term rates thus facilitating the fed s goal of controlling long term rates

anticipations of monetary policy in financial markets in recent years financial markets appear better able to anticipate federal open market committee fomc policy changes beginning in the late 1980s and early 1990s longer term interest rates and futures rates have tended to incorporate movements in the federal funds rate several months in advance in contrast to the largely contemporaneous response typically observed before that time after identifying these emerging trends the paper parses the enhanced predictability into a component that can be attributed to the autoregressive behavior of the funds rate and a nonautoregressive component the paper considers institutional developments in fomc policy making that may have contributed to each of these components including gradualism in adjusting the federal funds rate target and transparency regarding the setting of the target and future policy intentions

the information content of discount rate announcements what is behind the announcement effect abstract a considerable volume of research shows that asset prices respond to changes in the federal reserve s discount rate while several competing hypotheses have been advanced to explain the market s response to discount rate announcements comparatively little effort has been made to differentiate among alternative hypotheses the result is an abundance of evidence establishing that asset prices respond to discount rate announcements but little if any agreement about why markets respond this article attempts to fill a void in the literature by pointing out how competing hypotheses differ and by constructing tests explicitly designed to differentiate among competing explanations the evidence suggests that the market s reaction to discount rate changes is purely an announcement effect i e a reaction to new information contained in the announcement that the direct effect of discount rate changes on market rates is nil that the announcement effect is invariant to the federal reserve s operating procedure and that generally speaking changes in the discount rate do not signal a change in monetary policy the announcement effect appears to vary with both the nature and extent of the information that the announcement of a discount rate change is believed to contain

when did the fomc begin targeting the federal funds rate what the verbatim transcripts tell us in october 1982 the fomc deemphasized m1 and moved to what is commonly referred to as a borrowed reserves operating procedure sometime thereafter the fomc switched to a funds rate targeting procedure but never formally announced the change given the close correspondence between a borrowed reserves operating procedure and a funds rate targeting procedure thornton 1988 suggested that the fomc went immediately to a funds rate targeting procedure others date the switch to the funds rate procedure later meulendyke 1998 suggests the switch came in late 1987 while others suggest the change occurred later this paper reviews the verbatim transcripts of the fomc meetings to establish the timing of the switch the verbatim transcripts suggest that the fomc effectively switched to a funds rate targeting procedure in 1982 the documentary evidence is supported by an analysis of the spread between the funds rate and the funds rate target which suggests that the differences in the behavior of the spread before october 1979 and after october 1982 are relatively small and economically unimportant

partisan monetary policies presidential influence through the power of appointment we investigate the channels through which partisan influence from a presidential administration could affect monetary policy making influence could be a result of direct presidential pressure exerted on members of the federal open market committee fomc or it could be a result of partisan considerations in presidential appointments to the board of governors to investigate these two channels of influence we devise and apply a method for estimating parameters of monetary policy reaction functions that can vary across individual members of the fomc our results suggest that the appointments process is the primary mechanism by which partisan differences in monetary policies arise

are the effects of monetary policy asymmetric huntley schaller by building on the hamilton 1989 markov switching model we examine questions like does monetary policy have the same effect in expansions and recessions given that the economy is currently in a recession does a fall in interest rates increase the probability of an expansion does monetary policy have an incremental effect on the growth rate within a given state or does it only affect the economy if it is sufficiently strong to induce a state change e g from recession to expansion as suggested by models with sticky prices or finance constraints interest rate changes have larger effects during recessions jel e52 e32 much of the recent work in macroeconomics has proceeded under the assumption that variables follow linear stochastic processes with constant coefficients as a result some of the richness of the burns mitchell analysis such as its focus on asymmetries between recessions and expansions may well have been lost blanchard and fischer 1989 7 i introduction for decades macroeconomists have debated whether monetary policy has the same effect on real output in expansions and recessions as far back as the 1930s keynes and pigou debated whether monetary policy would have less effect on output during a severe economic downturn in the 1960s there were active debates on a very different proposition namely whether the rightward portion of the aggregate supply curve was vertical so that monetary policy would have less effect on real output during expansions in this article we provide a new type of evidence on whether monetary policy has different effects depending on whether the economy is in an expansion or recession empirical evidence on this issue is particularly relevant in light of new theoretical work in macroeconomics that predicts asymmetric effects of demand shocks conditional on the state of the economy two examples of this work are s s type models of price adjustment and models in which there are agency costs of financial intermediation 1 the intuition for the latter class of models is simple 2 when there is information asymmetry in financial markets agents may behave as if they were constrained for a variety of reasons these finance constraints are more likely to bind during recessions when the net worth of agents is low an increase in interest rates will then have two effects on investment the standard effect of increasing the cost of capital and therefore reducing investment demand and an additional effect of reducing liquidity e g by increasing debt service obligations and thus reducing investment demand for constrained agents as a result monetary policy actions that change interest rates will have greater effects during a recession 3 the s s type price adjustment models of ball and mankiw 1994 caballero and engel 1992 and tsiddon 1993 lead to a convex aggregate supply curve and therefore also imply that monetary policy will have stronger effects during recessions one of the more frequently cited empirical papers on the potentially asymmetric effects of monetary policy is cover 1992 which finds evidence that positive monetary shocks have different effects from negative monetary shocks we are looking at a different type of asymmetry namely between booms and recessions we study asymmetries using an extension of the markov switching model developed by hamilton 1989 estimated over the period 1955 93 in hamilton s econometric specification the growth rate of output depends on a state variable that corresponds to an expansion or recession this approach has several advantages first unlike linear projections it allows for nonlinearities and asymmetries second in estimating the recession coefficients it gives greater relative weight to observations that most clearly correspond to recessions and similarly for the expansion coefficients

liquidity transaction costs and real activity this paper studies the liquidity effect in a pecuniary transaction cost model to model the asymmetric impact of monetary injections we consider two behavioral assumptions sluggish money demand and sluggish firm investment it is found that under reasonable parameterization the model is capable of generating a dominant liquidity effect our result suggests that with alternative monetary specifications and behavioral assumptions general equilibrium models are still useful for studying the liquidity effect at business cycle frequencies

the efficiency of the scandinavian banking sector a wavelet quantile regression analysis in this article the scandinavian housing financing market is analysed in order to determine whether the interest rate price discovery processes of denmark norway and sweden are efficient based o

monetary policy and market interest rates this thesis contains four chapters each of which examines different aspects of the uncertainty facing monetary policymakers monetary policy and market interest rates investigates how interest rates set on financial markets respond to policy actions taken by the monetary authorities the reaction of market rates is shown to depend crucially on market participants interpretation of the factors underlying the policy move these theoretical predictions find support in an empirical analysis of the u s financial markets predicting monetary policy using federal funds futures prices examines how prices of federal funds futures contracts can be used to predict policy moves by the federal reserve although the futures prices exhibit systematic variation across trading days and calendar months they are shown to be fairly successful in predicting the federal funds rate target that will prevailafter the next meeting of the federal open market committee from 1994 to 1998 monetary policy with uncertain parameters examines the effects of parameter uncertainty on the optimal monetary policy strategy under certain parameter configurations increasing uncertainty is shown to lead to more aggressive policy in contrast to the accepted wisdom should central banks be more aggressive examines why a certain class of monetary policy models leads to more aggressive policy prescriptions than what is observed in reality these counterfactual results are shown to be due to model restrictions rather than central banks being too cautious in their policy behavior an unrestricted model taking the dynamics of the economy and multiplicative parameter uncertainty into account leads to optimal policy prescriptions which are very close to observed federal reserve behavior

disinflation and interest bearing money in high inflation countries policymakers often end up paying interest on part of the money supply higher interest rates on money have been used as a disinflationary policy this paper analyzes the effectiveness of such a policy in the context of a closed economy staggered prices model both a permanent and a temporary rise in the interest rate on money provoke an inflation at the expense of a recession when the rise is temporary however the initial inflation slowdown is eventually followed by an upsurge of inflation over the level prevailing before the policy was implemented copyright 1996 by royal economic society

economic forces in the european gas market a 1985 prospective abstract future gas supply and demand patterns of the european community are simulated using a gas trade model gtm this study is intended to provide an economic background for exploring the future policies of the main suppliers of the community the type of price movements that can be expected and the possible role of high cost gas simulations are provided for both short term 1985 1990 and long term 1995 2000 developments a decrease in dutch gas prices algeria s price concession and abandonment of high prices for norwegian gas are the main trends arising from the analysis they all materialized between 1985 and the first half of 1986

monetary policy predictability in the euro area an international comparison we evaluate the ability of market participants to anticipate monetary policy decisions in 14 countries first by looking at both the magnitude and volatility of changes in the money market rates we show that the days of policy meetings are special days for financial markets second we find that the predictability of federal reserve fed bank of england and european central bank ecb is fully comparable finally an econometric analysis of the ability of market participants to incorporate in the current short term interest rates the expected policy changes shows that in the euro area and in other countries policy decisions are anticipated well in advance

allocation of canadian natural gas to domestic and export markets canadian natural gas is allocated to domestic and export markets using a non linear optimization model efficient near term prices are low to stimulate consumption and reduce reserves of shut in natural gas many near optimal depletion paths also exist implying greater importance of non efficiency criteria for selecting a socially optimal depletion path finally for canadian consumption decisions through the early 1990s the value of perfect information about future export prospects is likely small mistakes in allocating gas to domestic markets to that time are unlikely to cause serious losses in any of several performance measures including producer surplus economic rent l allocation du gaz naturel canadien entre le marche domestique et les marches d exportation on alloue le gaz naturel canadien entre les marches domestique et 6trangers a l aide d une modele d optimisation non lineaire les prix efficients a court terme sont bas a la fois pour stimuler la consommation et pour reduire les reserves de gaz naturel des puits fermes on peut identifier plusieurs sentiers d epuisement quasi optimaux qui donnent une importance relativement plus grande aux criteres autres que l efficacite dans la selection d un sentier d epuisement socialement optimal enfin pour ce qui a trait aux decisions de consommation au canada jusque dans les debuts des annees 1990 il appert que la valeur d une information parfaite quant aux possibilites d exportation n est pas susceptible d etre grande de plus des erreurs dans l allocation du gaz aux marches domestiques jusqu a ce moment ia ne sont pas susceptibles de causer des pertes enormes quels que soient les indicateurs de performance y compris le surplus au producteur i e la rente economique

the impact of money on short term interest rates this study reviews empirical evidence from four research methods related to the impact of money on short term nominal rates the studies consistently fail to find evidence supporting the much hypothesized short term negative relationship between money and nominal rates since at least april 1975 reasons for the absence of a negative relationship include the tendency of financial markets to anticipate corrective action by the fed whenever ml deviates from targeted growth ranges and a rapid adjustment of inflationary expectations to changes in money growth

the high frequency impact of news on long term yields and forward rates is it real abstract macroeconomic news announcements move yields and forward rates on nominal and index linked bonds and inflation compensation this paper estimates the reactions using high frequency data on nominal and index linked bond yields allowing the effects of news announcements on real rates and inflation compensation to be parsed far more precisely than is possible using daily data long term nominal yields and forward rates are very sensitive to macroeconomic news announcements inflation compensation is sensitive to announcements about price indices and monetary policy however for news announcements about real economic activity such as nonfarm payrolls the vast majority of the sensitivity is concentrated in real rates accordingly most of the sizeable impact of news about real economic activity on the nominal term structure of interest rates represents changes in expected future real short term interest rates and or real risk premia rather than changes in expected future inflation and or inflation risk premia such sensitivity of real rates to macroeconomics news is hard to rationalize within the framework of existing macroeconomic models

monetary policy announcements and market interest rates response evidence from china abstract this paper examines the daily responses of market interest rates to three monetary policy announcements in china using the event study approach i find that the interest rate responses to announced changes in the regulated retail interest rate and the required reserve ratio are positive and significant at all maturities of interest rates but smaller at the long end of the yield curve by contrast market interest rates barely respond to the qualitative mpc announcements about the monetary policy stance these findings are robust to alternative econometric methods that correct for potential bias arising from violations of the identification assumption these findings suggest that the pbc should formulate its policy communication in a quantitative way

expectations surprises and treasury bill rates 1960 82 changes in six month bill rates over semiannual periods in the 1960s and 1970s are successfully related to expected changes and to surprises the latter include unanticipated changes in expected inflation in the growth of industrial production and base money and in inflation uncertainty estimation of the basic equation through the middle of 1983 does not suggest any change in structure moreover the equation explains 60 percent of the extraordinarily high level of real rates since late 1980 largely owing to an excess of unexpected net increases in anticipated inflation over actual increases our estimates provide some support for the expectations theory there appears to be information content in six month forward rates while this content is swamped by the impact of surprises in equations explaining rate changes in terms of forward rates alone the content is clear when proxies for the surprises are included in the equations the height and volatility of interest rates in the early 1980s spectacularly exceeded that of the past half century various researchers have attributed this to the sharp increase and decline in inflation the special characteristics of recent monetary the monetarist experiment and fiscal the structural deficit policies and mysterious or unidentified forces see clarida and friedman 1982 and makin and tanzi 1983 the present paper estimates the relationship between the six month treasury bill rate and its determinants in the 1960s and 1970s the purpose is to test various hypotheses regarding interest rate determination and to determine whether this relationship was altered markedly in the early 1980s the short term bill rate is chosen for investigation for two reasons first the yield on a short term instrument is independent of longer term expectations regarding inflation output growth and fiscal and monetary policies longerterm yields should depend heavily on such variables while reasonably accurate measures of expectations over say a six month horizon can probably be deduced are in fact available from survey data longer term expectations are both more uncertain and vary more widely across market participants second analysis of a short term bill rate allows an easy test of the expectations theory of interest rates recent studies by shiller campbell and schoenholtz 1983 and by mankiw and summers 1983 suggest that observed interest rate movements are unrelated to expected changes in rates extracted from the term structure of short term rates calling into question the validity of the expectations theory but see fama 1983 for an alternative view the six month bill rate is analyzed because it meshes best with the livingston survey data