strategic behavior in contests reply in my 1987 paper i modeled contests where the probability of each player winning a prize depends on all players efforts and examined the first order benefits to one player of making a commitment to a strategy slightly different from his nash equilibrium strategy in the special case of a two player symmetric contest i found that this first order effect was zero michael r baye and onsong shin 1999 have taken the useful further step of finding the second order conditions which ensure that the local stationary point is a local maximum they also find an example where such a commitment has a third order benefit whether this is of any substantive economic interest remains to be seen i used the phrase no local effect to mean zero first order effect which was clearly a sloppy use of language but some such restriction on the use of local is essential if the phrase x has no local effect on f x at x 5 a were to mean that all derivatives f a are zero then a taylor series expansion would show that f x 5 f a for all x and no local effect would be the same as no global effect most importantly symmetric contests were only a very special case of my model the focus was on the much more interesting and more general situation of asymmetry among the players where one player s commitment to a strategy different from his nash equilibrium strategy does bring him a first order benefit the favorite benefits by committing to excessive effort and the underdog from committing to too little others for example kyung h baik and jason f shogren 1992 have extended the analysis to endogenize the order of moves and found that it can be in the interests of both contestants to let the underdog make the commitment in my view these are the more interesting economic issues to do with contests than are third order effects in the symmetric case

an equilibrium conflict model of land tenure in hunter gatherer societies i apply features of the economics of conflict and spatial competition in developing a model of the emergence of land ownership in hunter gatherer societies tenure regimes are the result of interactions between those seeking to defend claims to land and those seeking to infringe on those claims the model highlights the dependence of land ownership on ecological parameters such as resource density and predictability and allows for situational ownership in which the nature of ownership changes as realized ecological conditions change the paper concludes with a comparative assessment of tenure across a representative sample of hunter gatherer peoples

the creation of effective property rights traditionally general equilibrium models have taken effective property rights to be given and have been concerned only with analyzing the allocation of resources among productive uses and the distribution of the resulting product but this formulation of the economic problem is incomplete because it neglects that the appropriative activities by which people create the effective property rights that inform allocation and distribution are themselves an alternative use of scare resources this paper develops two canonical general equilibrium models of resource allocation and income distribution that allow for the allocation of time and effort to the creation of effective property rights to valuable resources in one model the valuable resources are initially in common pool in the other models the analysis reveals how the amount of time and effort that agents allocate to the creation of effective property rights on the technology of production and on the scale of the economy the paper also analyses the security of initial claims to valuable resources and speculates about why initial claims are perfectly secure

inequality democracy and the protection of property rights motivated by the observed relevance of institutional quality such as strong property rights for economic performance this research considers the emergence of property rights protection as a political outcome it argues that the support for such protection is greater the more equal income distribution and the smaller political bias when these conditions initially hold the politically influential rich elite may prefer to relinquish its power through democratisation in order to commit future policy makers to the enforcement of property rights thus ensuring larger investment and faster growth along the transition path in a very unequal economy however such democratisation will not take place

on the origins of property rights conflict and production in the state of nature i analyse the emergence of property rights in a model of conflict and production in the absence of institutions of enforcement the population of agents evolves dynamically through conflicts for possession of factor goods among pairs of randomly matched agents conflicts are incomplete information wars of attrition with an agent s type consisting of his or her independently drawn valuation of the prize and cost of competing for it i prove equilibrium existence and show that in the steady state of the game the population sorts into two stable groups resource haves and have nots in accordance with a known function of their primitive types

a dynamic model of conflict and appropriation abstract this paper presents an extension of a static model of economic conflict analyzed by hirshleifer 1991 1995 and skaperdas 1992 to an infinite horizon differential game our aim is to highlight the strategic role of appropriation among a smaller group of agents in an intertemporal context the model yields the conclusion that there exists a unique linear nonlinear markov perfect equilibrium strategy even when strategies are defined over the entire state space we demonstrate that partial cooperation can be seen as a long run response to conflict moreover a decrease in the effectiveness of appropriation the depreciation rate of a common pool stock the rate of time preferences or an increase in the degree of noise improves the degree of partial cooperation and thus welfare in an anarchic society

discretionary monetary and fiscal policy with endogenous sovereign risk abstract how does the presence of sovereign risk affect the conduct of public policy to answer this question this paper studies optimal monetary and fiscal policy without commitment for a model economy with nominal public debt and strategic sovereign default compared to an economy without the possibility of default economies with sovereign risk experience more volatile interest rates which impedes the government s ability to smooth tax rates across states risk of default also limits public debt accumulation reducing the government s incentive to use surprise inflation on average when calibrated to the united states the model predicts that a counterfactual increase in the average annual default probability from 0 to 1 lowers average inflation by 33 raises the standard deviation of inflation by 18 and increases the standard deviation of the labor income tax by 73 the transmission of exogenous shocks to real aggregate quantities is however almost unaffected by the possibility of default for example the presence of sovereign risk would increase the standard deviation of log real gdp by less than 1 in the experiment above similarly the welfare consequences of sovereign risk are found to be of negligible size as well

debt dilution and sovereign default risk we measure the effects of debt dilution on sovereign default risk and study debt covenants that could mitigate these effects we calibrate a baseline model with endogenous debt duration and default risk in which debt can be diluted using data from spain we find that debt dilution accounts for 78 percent of the default risk in the baseline economy and that eliminating dilution increases the optimal duration of sovereign debt by almost 2 years eliminating dilution also increases consumption volatility but still produces welfare gains the debt covenants we study could help enforcing fiscal rules

the invisible hand and the grabbing hand evidence from a survey of 105 shop owners in moscow and warsaw shows that the reliance on private protection as well as the burden of regulation and corruption are much greater in moscow the evidence suggests that the invisible hand model of government better fits the warsaw local government and the grabbing hand model is more appropriate for moscow the evidence implies that the singular focus on the speed of economic reforms to understand the success of transition is misplaced and that the quality of government may be as essential this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

establishing property rights establishing secure property rights in transition economies amounts to solving two problems inefficiency structures of control rights over assets and poor contract enforcement politicians and bureaucrats still wield excessive control over assets which results in inefficient underinvestment by entrepreneurs corruption is one way of getting around political control but the drawbacks are considerable particularly the limited enforceability of corruption contracts more workable strategies for establishing property rights in transition economies are giving equity to the bureaucrats and other parties that have control reforming the civil service and removing bureaucratic control rights through privatization russia s experience shows how privatization combined with equity incentives for enterprise insiders transfers control rights from the bureaucrats and stimulates political and economic pressures to protect private property rights

a theory of exit in duopoly we develop a duopoly model in which exit occurs because of the existence of fixed costs or opportunity costs each firm enters the market knowing its own cost but not that of its opponent as times goes on each firm becomes increasingly pessimistic about the cost of its remaining rival the time of exit is the only strategic variable so that our model is a war of attrition in contrast to the classic war of attrition however we assume that with positive probability each firm s costs may be low enough that staying in forever is a dominant strategy thus our model unlike the classic one has a unique equilibrium

anarchy and its breakdown anarchy defined as a system in which participants can seize and defend resources without regulation from above is not chaos but rather a spontaneous order however anarchy is fragile and may dissolve either into formless amorphy or into a more organized system such as hierarchy under anarchy each contestant balances between productive exploitation of the current resource base and fighting to acquire or defend resources anarchy is sustainable only when there are strongly diminishing returns to fighting effort the decisiveness parameter is sufficiently low and incomes exceed the viability minimum these considerations explain many features of animal and human conflict

trade wars and trade talks when governments meet in the international arena their actions reflect the political situations at home previous studies of trade relations have focused on governments that are immune from political pressures and that act as benevolent servants of the public interest here we introduce domestic politics into the analysis of international economic relations we study the interactions between national leaders who are concerned both with providing a high standard of living to the general electorate and collecting campaign contributions from special interest groups our analysis sheds light on the determinants of the structure of protection in non cooperative and cooperative policy equilibria

the rationale behind interfirm tender offers information or synergy this paper investigates the rationale behind interlirm tender offers by examining the returns realized by the stockholders of lirms that were the targets of unsuccessful tender offers and lirms that have made unsuccessful offers our results suggest that the permanent positive revaluation of the unsuccessful target shares documented by dodd and ruback 1977 and bradley 1980 is due primarily to the emergence of and or the anticipation of another bid that would ultimately result in the transfer of control of the target resources we also find that the rejection of a tender offer has differential effects on the share prices of the unsuccessful bidding firms depending upon whether the tender offer process results in a change in the control of target resources on the basis of these results we conclude that acquisitions via tender offers are attempts by bidding firms to exploit potential synergies not simply superior information regarding the true value of the target resources

workers warriors and criminals social conflict in general equilibrium we incorporate appropriation activities social conflict into canonical models of trade and study how economic shocks and policies affect the intensity of conflict we show that not all shocks that could make society richer reduce conflict positive shocks to labor intensive industries diminish conflict while positive shocks to capital intensive industries increase it the key requirement is that conflict activities be more labor intensive than the economy as this determines how shocks affect the returns and costs of conflict our theory is consistent with several observed patterns of conflict and implies that empirical work should take into account the relative factor intensities of the productive and conflict sectors in each country incorporating appropriation into a canonic general equilibrium model affects what policies may be deemed desirable in order to reduce conflict and generate pareto improvements policy must be distortionary while reforms that appear efficiency enhancing under the unrealistic assumption of perfect property rights may backfire this offers one explanation for why reforms based on traditional models without appropriation may be delayed and become unpopular when implemented and why societies may sympathize with seemingly inefficient redistribution

slavery and other property rights the institution of slavery is found mostly at intermediate stages of agricultural development and less often among hunter gatherers and advanced agrarian societies we explain this pattern in a growth model with land and labor as inputs in production and an endogenously determined property rights institution the economy endogenously transits from an egalitarian state with equal property rights to a despotic slave society where the elite own both people and land thereafter it endogenously transits into a free labor society where the elite own the land but people are free

entitled to work urban property rights and labor supply in peru this brief summarizes the results of a gender impact evaluation study entitled entitled to work urban property rights and labor supply in peru new legal rights were issued in 1996 project teams providing titling service through 2003 in peru the study observed that between 1996 and 2003 the peruvian government issued property titles to over 1 2 million urban households the largest titling program targeted at urban squatters in the developing world this paper examines the labor market effects of increases in tenure security resulting from the program pre program squatters in program neighborhoods were significantly more likely to report improved tenure security by 60 percent similarly program participants were 18 8 percentage points less likely to report a high likelihood of eviction or invasion and 18 8 percentage points more likely to report that their dwelling was currently very secure from eviction or invasion the likelihood of working inside the home significantly falls by 11 6 percentage points for the average squatter family with two program periods

the social efficiency of private decisions to enforce property rights costs must be incurred if an owner is to enforce private property rights effectively we show that in a perfectly competitive economy private decisions to enforce rights may result in either more or less enforcement than is socially efficient cases of multiple stable equilibria occur and an equilibrium may be locally but not globally efficient resources may not be employed in their socially most valuable uses and enforcement may be accompanied by inefficient investment in resource productivity

a note on unsuccessful tender offers and stockholder returns recent research shows that unsuccessful tender offers may affect target share returns for two years past the offer s announcement this note examines target returns in the interim between the announcement and one year after the offer s withdrawal analyzing a recent sample of targets that did not get another bid in the year following a failed tender offer this study reaches two conclusions first all of an offer s premium disappears by the time failure becomes public second excess returns are zero in the post failure year an explanation that is based on the causes of the tender offers failures is presented previous research has shown that shareholders of firms acquired by tender offers realize significantly positive excess returns see bradley 3 bradley desai and kim 4 and dodd and ruback 6 early studies such as bradley 3 and dodd and ruback 6 indicated that failed offers raise share values permanently recently bradley desai and kim 4 challenged this view with a study of returns to firms that did not receive offers for a long time following a cancelled bid they discovered that though a withdrawn offer may favorably affect a target s share value for months after the offer the initial price increase disappears within two years of the announcement similar developments such as those of asquith 1 dodd 5 langetieg 8 and mandelker 9 marked the research on mergers this note extends the work of bradley desai and kim hereafter bdk by analyzing returns to target shares in the time between the date of offer and one year after the offer s failure and public withdrawal the tests focus on two key but not fully explored phases of a failed offer the time from announcement to withdrawal and the first year after that event the sample of failed offers is quite special because it contains only those whose targets received no other bid in the year after the offer s withdrawal as bdk emphasize and as asquith 1 shows in his study of mergers only such rare cases provide the opportunity for a precise evaluation of returns to targets of failing acquisition efforts

luther and suleyman this paper emphasizes that the evolution of religious institutions in europe was influenced by the expansionary threat posed by the ottoman empire between the mid 15th century and the early 17th century various historical accounts have suggested that the ottomans rise helped the protestant reform movement as well as its various offshoots such as zwinglianism anabaptism and calvinism survive their infancy and mature utilizing a comprehensive dataset on violent conflicts for the period between 1451 and 1650 i find strong empirical support for the idea that ottoman military engagements in continental europe lowered the number and extent of violent conflicts among and within the european states ottomans influence in europe extended to the feud between the protestant reformers and the catholic establishment during the time between the birth of lutheranism and the end of the thirty years war the likelihood and timing of military engagements between the protestant reformers and the counter reformation forces depended negatively and statistically significantly on ottomans military activities in europe

on the joint determination of fiscal and monetary policy abstract the conduct of fiscal and monetary policy absent commitment depends on the interaction between the objective of smoothing distortions intertemporally and a time consistency problem when net nominal government obligations are positive both fiscal and monetary policies are distortionary and the choice of debt depends on how the anticipated response in future monetary policy affects the current demand for money and bonds there exists a unique steady state with positive net nominal government obligations which is stable and time consistent for any initial level of debt the welfare loss due to lack of commitment is small

management buyout proposals and inside information this paper explores stock price behavior surrounding withdrawn buyout proposals to determine whether managers proposal announcements reveal any information which is unrelated to the efficiency gains associated with completed buyouts on average firms whose managers withdraw buyout proposals do not sustain significantly positive stock price effects unless they receive subsequent acquisition bids in addition managers of firms with completed buyouts are no more likely to have access to inside information than managers who withdrew proposals i interpret this evidence as inconsistent with the notion that inside information commonly motivates management buyout proposals management buyouts occur when a group of investors including some incumbent managers buy all of a firm s outstanding common stock with the intent of taking it private critics of management buyouts argue that managers access to inside information allows them to time their proposals to expropriate the wealth of outside shareholders these opponents generally cite anecdotal evidence that favorable inside information motivates management buyout proposals 1 managers themselves suggest that their proposals are motivated at least in part by their information advantage 2 however assistant professor of finance texas a m university this paper is based on my univer

dictators and oligarchs a dynamic theory of contested property rights in an economy with weak economic and political institutions the major institutional choices are made strategically by oligarchs and dictators the conventional wisdom presumes that as rent seeking is harmful for oligarchs themselves institutions such as enforcement of the property rights will emerge eventually we explicitly model a dynamic game between oligarchs and a dictator who can contain rent seeking the oligarchs choose either a weak dictator who can be overthrown by an individual oligarch or a strong dictator who can only be replaced via a consensus of oligarchs in equilibrium no dictator can commit to both i protecting the oligarchs property rights from the other oligarchs and ii not expropriating oligarchs himself we show that a weak dictator does not limit rent seeking a strong dictator does reduce rent seeking but also expropriates individual oligarchs we show that even though eliminating rent seeking is pareto optimal weak dictators do get appointed in equilibrium and rent seeking continues this outcome is especially likely when economic environment is highly volatile

conflicts over property rights and natural resource exploitation at the frontier abstract competition for land at the frontier is analyzed by considering a game between a first settler and a contestant although the first settler is the legitimate owner of a plot of land his remoteness from the government s administrative center makes it difficult to prove it this creates incentives for a contestant to dispute his claims both contenders will expend resources in order to secure ownership due to transport costs the more remote a plot of land is the lower its output value this tends to discourage appropriative activities land degradation is sometimes used as a substitute to appropriative activities a lower discount rate may encourage land degradation

can the shadow of the future harm cooperation abstract it is generally thought that in long term relationships high valuations of the future are conducive to cooperation in an intertemporal model of conflict however we demonstrate the possibility of the opposite effect a longer shadow of the future may harm cooperation in particular we show that the degree of inefficiency is positively related to i the agents valuation of the future ii potential growth rates in resources iii the size of initial resource endowments and iv the effectiveness of conflict

swords or plowshares a theory of the security of claims to property this paper develops a general equilibrium model of the allocation of resources among appropriative and productive activities the model emphasizes the distinction between offensive weapons which are the instruments of predation and fortifications which provide defense against predation the analysis of this model shows how the equilibrium security of claims to property is determined the analysis focuses on the possibility of a nonaggressive equilibrium in which no resources are allocated to offensive weapons and claims to property are fully secure we also analyze the complex relation between economic welfare and the security of claims to property we find for example that a relatively poor agent could be better off in an equilibrium with less secure claims to property

an analysis of the war of attrition and the all pay auction we study the war of attrition and the all pay auction when players signals are affiliated and symmetrically distributed we a find sufficient conditions for the existence of symmetric monotonic equilibrium bidding strategies and b examine the performance of these auction forms in terms of the expected revenue accruing to the seller under our conditions the war of attrition raises greater expected revenue than all other known sealed bid auction forms journal of economic literature classification numbers d44 d82 1997 academic press

endogenous timing in general rent seeking and conflict models we examine simultaneous versus sequential choice of effort in a two player contest the timing of moves determined in a preplay stage prior to the contest subgame as well as the value of the prize is allowed to be endogenous contrary to endogenous timing models with an exogenously fixed prize the present paper finds the following 1 players may decide to choose their effort simultaneously in the subgame perfect equilibrium spe of the extended game 2 the spe does not need to be unique in particular there is no unique spe with sequential moves if the direct costs of effort are zero 3 symmetry among players does not rule out incentives for precommitment to effort locally away from the cournot nash level 4 finally there may be no correlation between win probability and strategic incentives in our framework a finding most central in the analysis of fixed prize contests