trade policy coordination and food price volatility many countries adjust their trade policies counter cyclically with food prices to the extent that the use of restrictions by food exporting countries has occasionally threatened the food security of food importing countries these trade policies are inconsistent with the terms of trade motivation often retained to characterize the payoff frontier of self enforcing trade agreements as they can worsen the terms of trade of the countries that apply them this article analyzes trade policy coordination when trade policies are driven by terms of trade effects and a desire to reduce domestic food price volatility this framework implies that importing and exporting countries have incentives to deviate from cooperation at different periods the latter when prices are high and the former when prices are low since staple food prices tend to have asymmetric distributions with more prices below than above the mean but with occasional spikes a self enforcing agreement generates asymmetric outcomes without cooperation an importing country uses its trade policy more frequently because of the concentration of prices below the mean but an exporting country has a greater incentive to deviate from a cooperative trade policy because positive deviations from the mean price are larger than negative ones thus the asymmetry of the distribution of commodity prices can make it more difficult to discipline export taxes than tariffs in trade agreements

risk aversion and the recommended hedging ratio in a recent article in this journal kahl reviewed the existing literature on the determination of optimal futures and cash market positions the optimal hedging ratios were found to depend on whether the cash position was treated as endogenous or predetermined and some general implications were set forth the surprising conclusion was that the optimal hedging ratio is independent of the individual s risk aversion even though the optimal positions in the cash and futures markets are themselves not independent of the risk parameter kahl demonstrates that this conclusion

the role of market expectations in commodity price dynamics evidence from oil data abstract this paper examines the contribution of market expectations to commodity price dynamics it proposes a dynamic competitive storage framework with an explicit expectations shock along with concurrent shocks to study the commodity price movements this allows for a refined analysis of the expectations effect on price and inventory and the estimation of the expectations applied to the world crude oil market it finds that the contribution of market expectations to the crude oil spot price movements is limited from 1987 to 2014

agricultural price instability a survey of competing explanations and remedies there are two explanations for agricultural price dynamics one follows cobweb logic and models fluctuations driven by expectation errors but emphasises that these expectations create complex dynamics and possibly chaos the other stems from the rational expectations tradition of dynamics driven by real shocks the empirical evidence tends to support the latter but is not conclusive the rational expectations model generates an optimal dynamic path from which no improvement can be expected from public intervention however if we take account of all the potential market failures in agricultural markets and especially in developing countries this conclusion might require some qualifications although an appropriate policy design for stability has still to be achieved this paper surveys the positive and normative literature on agricultural prices highlighting empirical evidence and identifying remaining unresolved issues

taxing fossil fuels under speculative storage long term environmental consequences of taxing fossil fuel usage have been extensively studied in the literature however these taxes may also impose several short run macroeconomic policy challenges the nature of which remains underexplored this paper investigates the mechanisms through which environmental taxes on fossil fuel usage can affect the main macroeconomic variables in the short run we concentrate on a particular mechanism speculative storage formulating and using a dynamic stochastic general equilibrium dsge model calibrated for the united states with an explicit storage facility and nominal rigidities we show that in designing environmental tax policies it is crucial to account for the fact that fossil fuel prices are subject to speculation the existence of forward looking speculators in the model improves the effectiveness of tax policies in reducing fossil fuel usage improved policy effectiveness however is costly it drives inflation and interest rates up while impeding output based on this tradeoff we seek an answer to the question how monetary policy should interact with environmental tax policies in our dsge model of fossil fuel storage we show that in an environment with no speculative storers monetary policy should respond to output along with cpi inflation in order to minimize the welfare losses brought by taxes however when the storage facility is activated responding to output in the monetary policy rule becomes less desirable

wheat storage and trade in an efficient global market domestic and international linkages in speculative stockholdings and trade of wheat are analyzed using a dynamic rational expectations model of the world wheat market dominated by the u s and the eu the results demonstrate the importance of endogenizing both storage and trade in studying commodity markets and suggest that past government stockholdings have not followed efficient market outcomes results indicate that elimination of the export enhancement program by the u s and of export restitution payments by the eu are unlikely to have a major impact on wheat exports from the two regions but will save millions of tax dollars in both regions

estimation of dynamic nonlinear rational expectations models of primary commodity markets with stochastic dynamic programming and disequilibrium maximum likelihood methods are combined to estimate a dynamic nonlinear rational expectations model of a market for a storable primary commodity the estimation model captures the inherently nonlinear structure of private stockholding dynamics the disequilibrium effects of government buffer stock intervention and the impact of price expectations and risk on private supply and stockholding decisions copyright 1993 by mit press

primary commodity prices and inflation primary commodities are products which have been only minimally processed agricultural foods which may either be directly consumed or form an input into the food processing industries industrial raw materials which may either be agricultural e g natural rubber or mineral mainly metals and most of important of all petroleum and petroleum products primary commodity prices are variable section ii and in part this variability is the result of macroeconomic fluctuations in the industrial ized countries rises in commodity prices will to a greater or lesser extent feed through into inflation

evaluating the economic cost of natural gas strategic storage restrictions the european commission wants to implement a single market for gas one of the components of this market is a regulated provision for security of supply which consists of rules for the implementation and use of a given reserve stock of gas we investigate the impact of this policy on the profitability of a storage operator using data from denmark and italy keeping storage capacity constant the costs of the strategic stock are around 20 of the value of the storage market for denmark and 16 for italy this cost is due to the inability to extract arbitrage profits from the captive stock furthermore the strategic storage restriction induces behavior that would virtually never be replicated by a private storage operator in an unconstrained market in particular in the first 6 months of the year when unconstrained firms empty their reservoirs much faster suggesting the strategic restriction is unnecessarily distorting the market c 2010 published by elsevier b v less

dynamic programming models and algorithms for the mutual fund cash balance problem fund managers have to decide the amount of a fund s assets that should be kept in cash considering the trade off between being able to meet shareholder redemptions and minimizing the opportunity cost from lost investment opportunities in addition they have to consider redemptions by individuals as well as institutional investors the current performance of the stock market and interest rates and the pattern of investments and redemptions that are correlated with market performance we formulate the problem as a dynamic program but this encounters the classic curse of dimensionality to overcome this problem we propose a provably convergent approximate dynamic programming algorithm we also adapt the algorithm to an online environment requiring no knowledge of the probability distributions for rates of return and interest rates we use actual data for market performance and interest rates and demonstrate the quality of the solution compared to the optimal for the top 10 mutual funds in each of nine fund categories we show that our results closely match the optimal solution in considerably less time and outperform two static newsvendor models the result is a simple policy that describes when money should be moved into and out of cash based on market performance

speculative intensity and spot and futures price variability this paper develops a simultaneous stochastic rational expectations model of futures and spot price determination using the model we find that increases in what we term speculative intensity increase spot price variability arising from storage cost shocks but decrease spot price variability arising from demand shocks in contrast increases in speculative intensity unambiguously decrease futures price variability regardless of the underlying source of disturbances we are able to develop these comparative static results because the model has a unique equilibrium

the effects of commodity price stabilization programs in this paper the authors analyze the effects of commodity programs in which the government attempts to support and stabilize price through open market purchases and sales specifically they as sess the effects of such programs on the u s soybean market using a rational expectations model that allows for private storage expected price responsive production and arbitrary support and release price s a salient feature of the model is that private storage and product ion behavior adjusts to changes in government policy stochastic simu lations of the market model demonstrate that price stabilization prog rams can reduce long run market price and destabilize producer revenu e copyright 1988 by american economic association

agro industrial processing and agricultural pricing under uncertainty processing domestically available materials for export has intuitive appeal e g if transport costs are reduced uncertainty in the supply of the raw material can be a crucial factor the theoretical model of this paper shows how to choose the optimal processing capacity and relatedly the optimal price to pay producers of the input issues include decision makers preferences sources and nature of uncertainty availability of inputs to produce the raw material and technology and costs of processing econometric estimates of the climate yield relation are used to simulate these decisions for the case of senegalese groundnut processing there is an intuitive appeal to industrial strategies based on processing domestically available raw materials for export for instance relative to export of the raw material for processing abroad domestic processing often achieves cost savings based on certain locational advantages such as the opportunity to decrease the product s weight prior to transport in this paper i analyse the costs and benefits of investing in processing capacity under particular conditions and the related question of the appropriate domestic pricing of the raw material the second part of the paper presents an application of the theory to senegalese groundnut culture and processing especially for agricultural inputs the domestic supply of the raw material is likely to be uncertain this uncertainty interacts with locational advantages in important ways affecting both the optimal choice of agro industrial processing capacity and the optimal choice of the price to be offered agricultural producers of the input from the viewpoint of the processing mills the locational advantage means that stochastically low availability of the raw material cannot be fully compensated by imports thus the problem of idle processing capacity arises similarly harvests of the input above the level that can be processed imply some loss of the locational advantages assuming that the input cannot be stored costlessly to illustrate these basic notions consider the simplest case of a single input with a given world price pj transformed at a constant unit cost r into an output with a given world price p let the size of the crop also be certain say of magnitude m so long as p pi r optimal processing capacity is m now consider a situation of uncertainty with two equiprobable states of nature faced

price stabilization using buffer stocks abstract the price stabilization problem is stated and solved for a nonlinear cobweb model with government stocks it is shown that if the storage capacity for the commodity is sufficiently large then there exists a simple stabilization policy called the keep supply at equilibrium kse policy such that the equilibrium price is a global attractor for the corresponding closed loop system in addition it is shown that if the government approximates the equilibrium supply with the average supply stabilization is guaranteed we refer to this policy as keep supply at average ksa

commodity price stabilization in imperfect or cartelized markets most studies of commodity price stabilization assume that all agents behave competitively however many commodities suitable for stockpiling are produced by countries with a significant share of the world market and commodity agreements themselves often result in cartelization of the market the paper explores the consequences of market power for the choice of storage rule and the degree of price stabilization it finds that with linear demand dominant producers choose more stable prices than under perfect competition and price stability increases with their market share with constant elastic demand the competitive degree of price stabilization is achieved

the empirical merit of structural explanations of commodity price volatility review and perspectives this paper presents both the history of and state of the art in empirical modeling approaches to the world commodity price volatility the analysis builds on the storage model and key milestones in its development specifically it is intended to offer a reader unfamiliar with the relevant literature an insight into the modeling issues at stake from both a historical and speculative viewpoint the review considers primarily the empirical techniques designed to assess the merits of the storage theory it does not address purely statistical approaches that do not rely on storage theory and that have been studied in depth in other streams of the commodity price literature the paper concludes with some suggestions for future research to try to resolve some of the existing empirical flaws and hopefully to increase the explanatory power of the storage model

food security and storage in the middle east and north africa in times of highly volatile commodity markets governments often try to protect their populations from rapidly rising food prices which can be particularly harsh for the poor a potential solution for food deficit countries is to hold strategic reserves which can be called on when international prices spike but how large should strategic stockpiles be this paper develops a dynamic storage model for wheat in the middle east and north africa mena region where imported wheat dominates the average diet the paper uses the model to analyze a strategy that sets aside wheat stockpiles which can be used when needed to keep domestic prices below a targeted price this paper shows that if the target is set high and reserves are adequate the strategy can be effective and robust contrary to most interventions strategic storage policies are counter cyclical and when the importing region is sufficiently large a regional policy can smooth global prices this paper shows that this is the case for the mena region nevertheless the policy is more costly than the pro cyclical policy of a targeted intervention that directly offsets high prices with a subsidy similar to food stamps

demand uncertainty and price stabilization price stabilization is an important policy goal of government intervention in competitive markets these policies are primarily directed at raising producer income and stabilizing market prices at levels acceptable to consumers and producers fox 1956 turnovsky 1978 newbery and stiglitz 1979 many of the stabilization policy results have been developed from the study of agricultural commodity markets in these markets prices tend to be highly variable due to uncertain and inelastic supply and demand schultz 1945 gardner 1981

optimal food price stabilization in a small open developing country in poor countries most governments implement policies aiming to stabilize the prices of staple foods which often include storage and trade measures insulating their domestic market from the world market it is of crucial importance to understand the precise motivations and efficiency of those interventions because they can have consequences worldwide this paper addresses those issues by analyzing the case of a small open developing country confronted by shocks to both the crop yield and foreign price in this model government interventions may be justified by the lack of an insurance market for food prices considering this market imperfection the authors design optimal public interventions through trade and storage policies they show that an optimal trade policy largely consists of subsidizing imports and taxing exports which benefits consumers at the expense of producers import subsidies alleviate the non negativity of food storage in other words when stocks are exhausted subsidizing imports prevents domestic price spikes one striking result an optimal storage policy on its own is detrimental to consumers since its stabilizing benefits leak into the world market and it raises the average domestic price by contrast an optimal combination of storage and trade policies results in a powerful stabilizing effect for domestic food prices

learning and the monetary policy strategy of the european central bank abstract this paper examines the welfare implications of alternative inflation targeting proposals for the monetary policy of the european central bank we assume that policy makers have to learn the laws of motion of inflation in an economy characterized by stickiness in domestic price setting behavior and subjected to recurring shocks to productivity exports and foreign price we find that a switch from an asymmetric inflation targeting strategy to an symmetric makes little difference in welfare payoffs but it comes at a cost of much higher interest rate variability we also find that there are practically no welfare gains from switching from an inflation targeting strategy based on the harmonized index of consumer prices hicp to a strategy based on the domestic price component of the hicp

food security policy in a stochastic world abstract food security may be increased by variance reducing strategies by food aid or by development strategies this paper uses a korea cge model subjected to random fluctuation in world prices and domestic food productivity to evaluate these policies we find that poverty reducing development strategies are the most food security strategies

the price stabilization effects of the eu entry price scheme for fruit and vegetables the paper assesses the stabilization effects of the eu import regime for fresh fruit and vegetables based on the entry price system the analysis is carried out on the eu prices of tomatoes and lemons and those of imports from some of the main competing countries on the eu domestic markets morocco argentina and turkey it is based on the estimation of a threshold vector autoregressive econometric model that is shown capable of taking the workings of the import regime into account the model shows that prices behave differently when import prices are above below the trigger entry price this paper allowed to highlight the cases for which the isolation effect of eps seems reached and the resulting stabilization effects

global biofuels key to the puzzle of grain market behavior these jumps in the prices of these three major grains have also revealed the these jumps in the prices of these three major grains have also revealed the chaotic state of economic analysis of agricultural commodity markets economists chaotic state of economic analysis of agricultural commodity markets economists and scientists have engaged in a blame game apportioning percentages of responand scientists have engaged in a blame game apportioning percentages of responsibility for price spikes to bewildering lists of factors which include a surge in meat sibility for price spikes to bewildering lists of factors which include a surge in meat consumption caused by unprecedented increases of income of the vast populations consumption caused by unprecedented increases of income of the vast populations of china and india idiosyncratic regional droughts and fi res speculative bubbles a of china and india idiosyncratic regional droughts and fi res speculative bubbles a new fi nancialization of grain markets the slowdown of global agricultural research new fi nancialization of grain markets the slowdown of global agricultural research spending jumps in costs of energy and fertilizers shifts in interest rates the decline spending jumps in costs of energy and fertilizers shifts in interest rates the decline of the dollar the surge in biofuels demands bans on genetically modifi ed plants of the dollar the surge in biofuels demands bans on genetically modifi ed plants and climate change several observers have claimed to identify a perfect storm in and climate change several observers have claimed to identify a perfect storm in the grain markets in 2007 2008 a confl uence of some of the factors listed above the grain markets in 2007 2008 a confl uence of some of the factors listed above the continuing confused state of the economics of grain price volatility may the continuing confused state of the economics of grain price volatility may seem odd after all grain markets have many of the features of textbook competiseem odd after all grain markets have many of the features of textbook competitive models the products are relatively uniform their primary producers and tive models the products are relatively uniform their primary producers and ultimate consumers are atomistic price takers prices and outputs in the united ultimate consumers are atomistic price takers prices and outputs in the united states and other developed countries are unusually well measured by the standards states and other developed countries are unusually well measured by the standards of most goods and services in the world economy with data freely available from of most goods and services in the world economy with data freely available from

pricing and storage of field crops a quarterly model applied to soybeans this paper considers the role of competitive storage in markets for annually harvested field crops a quarterly model is presented that considers the allocative role of storage both within and between crop years rational price expectations are endogenous variables calculated by a recursive method forward stochastic simulations using the model generate data that can be used to characterize the distributions of the variables in the base case the model is assigned parameter values from a quarterly econometric model of the u s soybean market the results shed light on the distributions of the quarterly variables including the rational price expectations and show how these distributions are affected by changes in the carrying charge

business cycles and emission trading with banking abstract we propose an emission cap adjustment policy for an emission trading system ets that allows banking of allowances for later use and faces business cycle uncertainty the forward looking banking decisions cause a commitment problem with respect to regulator s next period allowance supply decision we tackle the commitment problem by focusing on the markov equilibrium of the policy the equilibrium policy has a surprisingly simple structure combining features from both price and quantity instruments the regulator s ability to choose a new cap for each period does not render banking obsolete but on the contrary makes banking an integral part of the equilibrium policy using data from the eu ets to calibrate the model we solve the markov equilibrium policy for the case of carbon emissions regulation and compare markov policies with and without the possibility to bank allowances a counterfactual analysis of the eu ets during the period of 2009 2013 shows that the optimal markov policy would have led to a steadier allowance price level and a stricter emission regulation than what was actually observed in the eu ets

a quantile autoregression analysis of price volatility in agricultural markets this paper investigates the dynamics of agricultural price volatility based on a quantile autoregression qar model the qar model provides a flexible representation of the distribution of price and its dynamics the approach is applied to u s wheat and corn markets over the period of 1980 2017 this period is of significant interest as it covers important changes in agricultural policy and increased reliance on markets the price analysis is conducted conditional on stocks held in the previous period we show how increasing previous stocks shift the price distribution to the left and decreases the odds of facing price spikes by shifting down the upper tail of the price distribution our analysis also examines the effects of changing public stocks on prices for both wheat and corn this reflects changing agricultural policy contrasting the 1980s when public stocks were relatively high with the post 2005 period when public stocks became zero we document how higher public stock ratio during the previous period did not lower the odds of facing price spikes applied to the wheat and corn markets we also uncover evidence of local dynamic instability in the upper tail of the price distribution suggesting that price instability becomes more pronounced when previous stocks are low

the economic role of commodity storage one of the earliest and most successful exainples of economic policy is the oftquoted biblical account of joseph s interpretation of the pharoah s dream joseph foretold that seven years of abundant harvests would precede seven years of drought and recommended that the pharoah accumulate grain during the good years since that time the central role of storage in stabilising the economy in the face of exogenous disturbances has been obvious but our understanding of the nature of that role has not greatly advanced without divine assistance in forecasting stochastic production the storage decision is considerably more complex than the one joseph faced and the role of storage quite different in fact several commonly held impressions about the role of storage of commodities such as grains are incorrect rather than stabilising production storage actually accentuates its variability rather than causing a mean price preserving decrease or a mean output preserving decrease in the dispersion of price storage generally causes a more complex modification of the distribution of price rather than being most effective at eliminating short falls in consumption storage actually is more effective at eliminating the incidence of exceedingly high consumption in this paper we explore the role of storage in a model where production is stochastic and both production and storage are performed by competitive profitmaximisers who form rational expectations about the returns to their activities we derive the subtle but very important interactions among production price expectations and storage which simpler models cannot capture finally we make a comparative statics assessment of the distributional implications of storage these results while confirming the importance of the specification of the demand function and the supply elasticity identified in recent analytical studies e g wright i979 and newbery and stiglitz i979 are surprisingly favourable to consumers considering the asymmetric nature of the effects of storage on consumption and price storage is simply a productive activity one that transfers a commodity from one period to the next like other forms of production it is costly the total cost of storing an amount st from period t to period t i is as of period t i

inflation targeting learning and q volatility in small open economies this paper examines the welfare implications of managing asset price with consumer price inflation targeting by monetary authorities who have to learn the laws of motion for both inflation rates the central bank can reduce the volatility of consumption as well as improve welfare more effectively if it adopts state contingent taylor rules aimed at inflation and q growth targets in this learning environment however under perfect model certainty pure inflation targeting dominates combined consumer and asset price inflation targeting

the performance of rice markets in bangladesh during the 1974 famine recent discussions have further emphasised the role of speculation in foodgrains as a cause of famine hartmann and boyce i 979 sobhan i 980 rashid i 980 sen i98i greenough i982 by this reasoning famine is attributed to the expectation on the part of foodgrain stockholders of a substantial future price increase or future rationing there is a weakness in this explanation as arrow remarks in his review of sen i98i

anti hoarding laws a stock condemnation reconsidered economists have regarded anti hoarding laws as irrational reactions to nonexistent monopoly in the storage of grain this paper shows that anti hoarding laws cannot be rationally directed against a monopolistic storer for he will always store less not more than would be stored under competition but seemingly perverse competitive storage in the form of excessive stockholding can arise when a price ceiling distorts the market additional public storage exacerbates this perverse private behavior and may even induce behavior that appears to be active market manipulation under such circumstances anti hoarding laws can be desirable second best measures

policy options for stabilizing earnings in a speculative market a structural analysis abstract this paper examines the impact of price stabilization or price supports and different forms of supply controls on the earnings distribution in a speculative commodity market both strategies lead to a conflict in which greater earnings stability has to be brought with lower average earnings neither on its own can help reduce the probability of periods with loss earnings or large disturbances but it is shown how combinations of these two strategies may be used to gain stability while reducing those probabilities and maintaining the earnings level

the behavior of commodity prices in ethiopia in an attempt to identify price stabilization strategies and rationalize public intervention in buffering markets this article investigates the intertemporal dynamics of commodity prices in ethiopia a classical rational expectation model is modified to account for seasonal correlation of shocks model predictions are reduced to computable periodic threshold autoregression several nonlinearity tests are applied to detect threshold effects a regime switching normalized maximum likelihood method is formulated to estimate thresholds and threshold autoregression parameters using monthly data from ethiopia for the period 1996 2006 the result indicates the presence of periodic price thresholds that could be formed as a result of speculative storage comparison of price movements below and above thresholds indicates that prices are more correlated below the thresholds than above them however the effect on error variance is not very strong temporal arbitrage which is the gross return from speculative storage appears to be modest the long and short term implications of the findings are discussed within the context of ongoing policy debates

trade liberalization and national food security rice trade between bangladesh and india abstract following a poor harvest in late 1997 and a massive flood in 1998 private sector traders in bangladesh imported several million metric tons of rice from india this paper presents evidence that this trade made possible by separate trade liberalizations in india and bangladesh in the early 1990s augmented domestic supplies and stabilized prices in bangladesh at import parity levels letters of credit data indicating the participation of hundreds of importers and a close correlation of price movements across the two countries suggest that the trade was competitive a risk of co incident crop shortfalls in the two countries remains though these have occurred rarely in the past two decades bangladesh imports from alternative sources would also enhance food availability if another production shortfall occurs but these imports face higher transport costs and would involve far fewer importing firms given the economies of scale of shipments by sea the positive contribution of trade liberalization to short run food security in bangladesh in recent years does not minimize the importance of increased agricultural productivity and rural economic growth to provide rural poor households with sufficient incomes to acquire food nonetheless the bangladesh experience shows that trade liberalization offers potential benefits for national food security by enabling a rapid increase of food supplies following domestic production shortfalls

a two season agricultural household model of output and price uncertainty abstract this paper presents a two season model of a household s production consumption labor supply and storage decisions in an environment of output and price risk the analytical results in this study are markedly different from those of models prevalent in the mainstream of the agricultural household literature the empirical analysis that uses panel data from a village in india provides support for the theoretical results and underscores the seasonal dimension of the farmers choice problems the results also show that ignoring risk or risk averse preferences may introduce substantial downward bias in optimal response estimates

the prebisch singer hypothesis a reappraisal independent of stationarity hypotheses time series behaviour of the relative price of primary commodities raul prebisch i950 and hans singer i950 believed that the long term trend of primary commodity prices was negative the latter in an interesting discussion of the above quandary pp 482 3 viewed rises in primary commodity prices as purely temporary sources of surplus that offered short lived opportunities to increase industrial investment these opportunities were missed by private investors who instead increased primary sector investment in such circumstances because all private activity tends to be governed by the price