estimates of output gaps in four southeast asian countries abstract the output gaps derived for four countries using a generalized hamilton model are compared with conventional output gap estimates further research is needed to explain why the output gap identifies crisis episodes as slowdowns instead of recessions in some countries

social security liquidity constraints and pre retirement consumption one of the primary goals of the social security retirement program is the maintenance of consumption in old age in the past decade since the pioneering paper by feldstein 13 studies have examined the impact of the system on consumption over the entire life cycle and not just in old age empirical work has tested the impact on consumption of the individual wealth transfers accompanying the introduction of a pay as you go social security system extending this discussion of the impact of social security on pre retirement consumption hubbard 21 has shown in the context of lifetime uncertainty that even an actuarially fair fully funded social security system can raise lifetime consumption hence previous partial equilibrium estimates of the impact of social security on consumption drawn solely from consideration of the intergenerational wealth transfer at the introduction of the system are underestimates of the potential effect 2 an important assumption in the approaches cited above is that of perfect capital markets i e that individuals can borrow against prospective gains from participating in the social security system such an assumption is at variance with actual limitations on borrowing e g upward sloping interest rate schedules collateral requirements and quantity restrictions hayashi 18 found that approximately twenty percent of all consumption in the u s is accounted for by liquidity constrained consumers 3 flavin 16 found that the estimate of the marginal propensity to consume is affected dramatically by the inclusion of proxies for liquidity constraints suggesting that liquidity constraints are an important part of the observed excess sensitivity of consumption to current income since its inception in 1935 old age and survivors insurance oasi provided

social security and aggregate capital accumulation revisited dynamic simultaneous estimates in a wealth generation model this paper re examines feldstein s 1974 1982 results of the effect of social security on private capital accumulation in the context of a simultaneous equation model of capital accumulation the model incorporates dynamic feedback effects in capital accumulation and is estimated by fiml to incorporate theoretical restrictions that are tested against the data it is then simulated as a full dynamic model to analyze the long run effect of ssw on private capital accumulation the simulated effects are in the same direction as found by feldstein but are considerably weaker

interdependency of personal savings and labour force participation of the elderly and social security wealth a time series analysis using japanese annual time series data covering the period 1950 1982 our study shows that social security wealth during this period depressed personal savings as a result there was a reduction of approximately 79000 yen of wealth per capitain real terms from 1960 to 1980 however the declining labour force participation of elderly males brought about for example by earlier retirement stimulated personal savings by an estimated 13000 yen over the same period the results indicate that the benefit effect tends to outweigh the retirement effect furthermore this study has identified a negative interdependency between the level of personal savings and the retirement behaviour of elderly males a typical male worker saves more before retirement if that individual expects to stay a shorter time in the labour market retirement behaviour is less responsive to a change in personal savings behaviour than vice versa

capital accumulation and the characteristics of private intergenerational transfers many recent studies of the process of family accumulation in general and household response to social security in particular have revealed growing dissatisfaction with the life cycle theory of saving see for example barro 1978 kotlikoff 1979 darby 1979 kotlikoff and summers 1981 kurz 1981 blinder gordon and wise 1981 david and menchik 1982 leimer and lesnoy 1982 an alternative to the life cycle hypothesis is expressed by defining the preference of each family over its own consumption as well as the welfare of the generations that follow thus each family consists of an infinite chain of generations who have interdependent preferences and for this reason we shall call it the inter generational hypothesis it was recently used by barro 1974 1978 to attack the conclusions of the life cycle hypothesis our purpose in this paper is to start the long road of studying the structure of the private inter generational transfer system with the aim of providing additional tests of the two competing hypotheses

transversality conditions budget constraints and the determinacy of a perfect foresight equilibrium in a monetary growth model the purpose of this paper is to analyze the number of perfect foresight equilibria in a monetary model where the consumer s behavior and the firm s behavior are explicitly derived from an intertemporal optimization we show that the relevant transversality conditions reduce to the satisfaction of the intertemporal budget constraint of the consumer or alternatively of the government the assumption of a separable utility function enables us to characterize completely the perfect foresight equilibria their number is shown to depend both on the specification of the government s policy instruments and on the utility function

pay as you go social security and the distribution of altruistic transfers this paper studies the impact of an unfunded social security system on the distribution of altruistic transfers in a framework where savings are due to both life cycle and random altruistic motivations we show that the effect of social security on the distribution of these transfers depends crucially on the strength of the bequest motive in explaining savings behaviour we measure this strength by the expected weight that individuals attach to the utility of future generations on the one hand if the bequest motive is strong then an increase in the social security tax raises the bequests left by altruistic parents on the other hand when the importance of altruism in motivating savings is sufficiently low the increase in the social security tax could result in a reduction of the bequests left by altruistic parents under some conditions on the attitude of individuals toward risk and on the relative returns associated with private saving and social security some implications concerning the transitional effects of introducing an unfunded social security scheme are also discussed

new evidence on the ricardian equivalence theorem a multicointegration approach this paper derives major theoretical constructs which underlie richardian equivalence and using multicointegration methodology empirically tests whether they bear out results indicate that government spending and revenues are cointegrated however the cointegrating scalar is less than one therefore in order for government to obey its intertemporal budget constraint debt and government revenue must be multicointegrated they are not additional evidence indicates that saving and debt may be weakly cointegrated the findings suggest that failure of richardian equivalence may be due to public rather than private sector failure

a head to head comparison of augmented wealth in germany and the united states we examine the composition of augmented household wealth i e the sum of net worth and pension wealth in the united states and germany pension wealth makes up a considerable portion of household wealth of about 48 percent in the united states and 61 percent in germany when pension wealth is included in household wealth the gini coefficient falls from 0 889 to 0 700 in the united states and from 0 755 to 0 508 in germany if the wealth shares in germany were the same as in the united states this would lead to a 12 6 percent increase in the gini coefficient in the augmented wealth distribution in germany

aggregate consumption function and public social security the first time series study for a developing country turkey this article is the first attempt in the literature to investigate the effects of public social security on aggregate consumption in a time series setting for a developing country turkey that has one of the most generous social security systems in the organization for economic cooperation and development oecd region in order to quantify the social security variable this article uses the social security wealth ssw series calculated for turkey in a separate study this study indicates that ssw is the largest part of the household wealth in turkey and therefore should not be ignored in the aggregate consumption studies the results show that its effect on consumption is positive and robust

the meaning of failed replications a review and proposal the welcome rise of replication tests in economics has not been accompanied by a consensus standard for determining what constitutes a replication a discrepant replication in current usage of the term can signal anything from an unremarkable disagreement over methods to scientific incompetence or misconduct this paper proposes a standard for classifying one study as a replication of some other study it is a standard that places the burden of proof on a study to demonstrate that it should have obtained identical results to the original a conservative standard that is already used implicitly by many researchers it contrasts this standard with decades of unsuccessful attempts to harmonize terminology and argues that many prominent results described as replication tests should not be described as such adopting a conservative standard like this one can improve incentives for researchers encouraging more and better replication tests

social security and private saving new time series evidence in an important article in the journal of political economy martin feldstein 1974 estimated that the introduction of the social security system had reduced personal saving by 50 percent with serious consequences for capital formation and output his conclusion was based on a consumer expenditure function estimated with u s time series data and incorporating a social security wealth variable of his construction this paper presents new evidence that casts considerable doubt on feldstein s conclusion first the social security wealth variable used by feldstein was seriously flawed as a result of a computer programming error simply correcting this error substantially changes the estimated effect of social security on saving second the statistical evidence depends upon assumptions which are embedded in the construction of the social security wealth variable assumptions that are not demonstrably preferable and are in some cases inferior to alternative assumptions these assumptions relate first to how individuals form their expectations about the social security benefits they expect to receive and the social security taxes they expect to pay and second to estimates of the number of workers dependent wives and surviving

viewpoint replication in economics this examination of the role and potential for replication in economics points out the paucity of both pure replication checking on others published papers using their data and scientific replication using data representing different populations in one s own work or in a comment several controversies in empirical economics are used to illustrate how and how not to behave when replicating others work the incentives for replication are examined and proposals aimed at journal editors and authors are advanced that might stimulate an activity that most economists applaud but few perform

social security and private saving a reconsideration of the assumptions whether social security discourages private saving has been the focus of an ongoing debate since feldstein s 1974 paper on that paper he assumes that people expect after retirement social security benefits to increase at an annual real rate of 2 in this paper using a wide sample of cross section data we estimate people expected real rate of growth of after retirement social security benefits the estimates range between 0 63 and 0 76 depending on the specification used the obtained estimates are far different from the 2 imposed ad hoc by feldstein these estimates will presumably imply lower values of the social security wealth variable this casts a serious doubt on the strong depressing effect of social security on private saving

tax incidence in a model with perfect foresight of agents and rationing in markets abstract this paper examines the incidence of several taxes in a macroeconomic model producers and consumers optimize with perfect foresight price inertia leads to rationing in the market for goods and for labour in the long run the system tends towards walrasian equilibrium meanwhile there may be keynesian unemployment classical unemployment or repressed inflation with possible switches of regimes balanced budget policies are analysed by working through numerical examples

estimating potential output as a latent variable this article proposes a new method for estimating potential output in which potential real gross domestic product gdp is modeled as an unobserved stochastic trend and deviations of gdp from potential affect inflation through an aggregate supply relationship the output and inflation equations together form a bivariate unobserved components model which is estimated via maximum likelihood through the use of the kalman filter algorithm the procedure yields a measure of potential output and its standard error and an estimate of the quantitative response of inflation to real growth and the output gap

new keynesian economics and the phillips curve models with sticky prices are an important part of new keynesian economics the author shows that several of the new keynesian models imply a formulation that is similar to the expectations augmented phillips curve of milton friedman and edmund phelps he then presents new estimates of the new keynesian phillips curve the author uses two proxies for price expectations survey based measures and an econometric based measure originally developed by bennett mccallum 1976 overall the results are consistent with the model but the survey based results are more precise suggesting that the surveys may be better measures of actual expectations copyright 1995 by ohio state university press

government debt government spending and private sector behavior a current period tax reduction financed by issuing government debt shifts the timing of tax collection from the current period to the future if the future taxes implied by government debt are not fully perceived and discounted by the private sector there will be a net wealth effect that increases private sector consumption thus reducing capital accumulation and growth if on the other hand the implied future taxes are perceived and discounted by the private sector the current period tax reduction will be used to increase private saving to pay for the future taxes and government debt will be absorbed without any real effects on the economy the effects of government spending financed by current period taxation also depend upon private sector perceptions 2 if the benefits of government spending are ignored private sector consumption will decrease in accordance with the reduction in permanent disposable income to the extent that government spending is on consumption type goods that are perceived as substitutes for privately provided consumption goods there will be a relatively greater reduction in private sector consumption to the extent that government spending is on investment type goods yielding future goods and services that are perceived as substitutes for future privately provided consumption goods there will be a relatively smaller reduction in private sector consumption the standard approach to modeling private sector consumption saving behavior involves a rather asymmetric set of assumptions as to how the private sector perceives the various elements of government fiscal policy 3 current period taxes are assumed to be fully perceived but current period government spending is implicitly assumed to be completely ignored by the private sector in considering permanent personal disposable income the private sector is assumed to be forward looking in its assessment of income and taxation the stock of government debt is nevertheless included as part of the stock of private wealth the implicit assumption associate professor of economics graduate school of business university of chicago 1101 east 58th street chicago il 60637 i thank eugene fama levis kochin michael mussa paul evans and an anonymous referee for helpful comments i am particularly grateful to daniel benjamin for contributing many hours of discussion and laura lahaye who was a research assistant and valuable adviser on earlier drafts the theoretical debate on the burden of the debt has been long standing gerald o driscoll 1977 documents ricardo s nineteenth century position robert barro 1974 reopened the debate by introducing the fundamental issue of intergenerational transfers also discussed in merton miller and charles upton 1974 the empirical side of the debate was initiated by levis kochin s 1974 attempt to test for the effects of deficits on consumption and by martin feldstein s 1974 attempt to test for the effects of social security wealth on consumption other empirical contributions include jess yawitz and laurence meyer 1976 myself 1978 and j earnest tanner 1978 1979 with respect to the effects of government deficits and debt and barro 1978 michael darby 1979 and dean leimer and selig lesnoy 1982 with respect to social security wealth see also interesting recent papers by john seater 1982 who generates detailed tests of the effects of deficits and debt on consumption charles plosser 1982 who explores the effects of government spending and debt shocks on interest rates and feldstein 1982 who attempts tests similar to some in this paper see fn 29 2martin bailey s 1962 1971 development of the effects of government spending on private consumption and aggregate economic activity is the seminal contribution paul david and john scadding 1974 extend bailey s ideas and provide some supporting empirical evidence more recently willem buiter 1977 and myself 1978 developed models based on bailey s earlier work barro 1981 has an interesting paper on related issues see also david aschauer 1982 3the standard approach incorporates fiscal policy through the concept of personal disposable income and by including the stock of government debt as part of personal wealth see for example the empirical specification of albert ando and franco modigliani 1963 which has been the basis of most empirical consumption studies since and feldstein 1974 for one of the more influential papers based on the ando modigliani specification

the labor force participation of older workers this study examines the decision to participate in the labor force made by persons over 54 years of age through the use of a set of pooled time series cross section observations from the current population survey over the years 1974 80 the analysis emphasizes the effect of two factors on this decision cohort crowding and supplemental security income ssi the empirical results reveal that pressures arising from the relative growth in the youth population led to increased labor market activity by older women that retirement incentives in the form of ssi and social security had a negative effect on female as well as male labor force behavior though the effects were considerably stronger for men and that the differential between men s and women s participation rates was largely a result of the female response to marital status and retirement incentives

the effects of social security in a life cycle family labor supply simulation model abstract we simulate a number of social security provisions in an overlapping generations model of family labor supply the program causes both men and women to shift labor toward the beginning of the life cycle increases the family s ratio of retirement consumption to consumption when young and lowers both wage rates but does not substantially alter the male female wage ratio the wealth effects of the program appear to dominate the incentive effects our exhaustive sensitivity analysis reveals that our results are robust to changes in several key labor supply parameters the intertemporal male and female own wage elasticities and the cross wage elasticity

testing among models of intrahousehold resource allocation households are the locus for much economic decision making households function as producers investors in human and physical capital managers of risk and as consumers many resources are allocated within households and the effects of many policies depend on the dynamics of household decision making for example household decisions about allocating food among individual household members may determine who benefits from programs to improve health nutrition or welfare in many microeconomic studies the household is treated as an individual for analytical purposes in other words it is assumed that a household acts as a single entity with a single set of preferences recently however a number of economists have recognized that households are sites of conflict as well as cooperation and have begun to use new classes of models to explain how resources are allocated among household members this literature has especially improved our understanding of households in which income is not completely pooled in such a setting standard household models may offer misleading conclusions about the effects of policies on individual household members i this paper goes beyond recent surveys of intrahousehold issue by explicitly examining the assumptions predictions and empirical implications of different intrahousehold models in particular it analyzes empirical tests that distinguish among competing models by clarifying the similarities and differences among alternative models this paper also clarifies what has actually been demonstrated and what has not been demonstrated by previous empirical studies in so doing the paper points to specific topics in need of further research this paper is organized as follows section 2 analyzes the assumptions and predictions of each of the five main classes of intrahousehold resource allocation models section 3 describes empirical tests of these assumptions along with an analysis of empirical work that has been generated sections 4 and 5 discuss the questions that remain unanswered and directions for future research

should social security benefits be means tested social security retirement benefits distort the saving decisions of workers who are rational enough to save for their future since the implicit rate of return in an unfunded social security program is less than the marginal product of capital the resulting decline in saving causes a welfare loss the present paper examines the conditions under which the welfare loss could be reduced by replacing the current universal social security program with a means tested program that pays benefits only to those individuals with little or no other retirement income or assets every society must solve the problem of supporting those individuals who become too old to work but have not made adequate provision for their own old age by saving when they were young at the present time the major industrial countries of the world have responded to this problem by creating social security programs that tax the working population and use the proceeds to provide a universal benefit to all retirees regardless of their financial condition this universal provision of social security benefits distorts the saving decisions of those workers who are rational enough to plan for the future since the implicit rate of return that taxpayers get on their this research is part of the nber study of the government budget and the private economy a more complete version of this paper with some numerical calculations is available as nber working paper no 1775 feldstein 1985b i am grateful to gilbert metcalf for assistance with the calculations presented in this paper and for helpful discussions for a discussion of the effect of promised retirement benefits on the savings of employees see feldstein 1974 1982 barro 1974 1978 has discussed an interesting

the hamilton model with a general autoregressive component estimation and comparison with other models of economic time series abstract this paper generalizes the hamilton model to the important case in which the autoregressive component need not contain a unit root using u s quarterly real gnp data the model is estimated and the results are compared to those of hamilton some monte carlo evidence for the model is presented and its in sample forecasting performance is discussed and compared to the original hamilton model the arima model and the deterministic time trend model

social security trust fund flows and the welfare costs of rent seeking the current study provides estimates from a parks regression using panel data that suggest that the welfare costs due to rent seeking efforts by interest groups to obtain social security trust fund flows ranged from approximately 132 million per twoyear federal election cycle from 1985 1994 to a theoretical expectation of 66 billion all in real terms these welfare costs are in addition to any other social costs that may be present including the reduced levels of national saving that social security may induce

social security uncertainty adjustments and the consumption decision this paper analyzes the consumption decision focusing on the degree of substitutability between fungible assets and prospective wealth and on the different risk adjustments associated with different types of prospective wealth the results reveal substantial differences among these risk adjustments and imply that a dollar of social security wealth substitutes for about three fifths of a dollar of fungible assets although implying that social security wealth reductions would have a positive and sizeable effect on private saving the results also suggest that such reductions could entail a substantial loss in consumer welfare copyright 1992 by the london school of economics and political science

social security preretirement labor supply and saving a confirmation and a critique in an earlier article in thejournal of political economy burkhauser and turner 1978 we used time series data to test the net empirical importance of the substitution and wealth effects of social security on the market work of prime age men we found that hours worked per week would have fallen by 2 3 hours without the present social security system a recent paper by leimer and lesnoy this issue has shown that the feldstein 1974 social security wealth variable which we used in our regressions was calculated incorrectly in the light of this finding we have reestimated our original regressions using the leimer lesnoy corrected social security wealth variables our primary regression in table 1 col 1 which uses the entire sample period confirms our original results again we find that the work week is 2 3 hours higher than it would have been in the absence of social security a result empirically significant by conventional standards leimer and lesnoy have made an important contribution to research on social security by correcting a calculation error our empirical results however raise a fundamental question not discussed in our original paper which requires a reexamination of the empirical methodology found in feldstein 1974 leimer and lesnoy this issue and other papers the facile assumption that the effect of social security on saving can be directly determined from a consumer expenditure function we show leads to an overstatement of social security s negative effect on saving

inflation dynamics marginal cost and the output gap evidence from three countries recent studies have argued that the new keynesian phillips curve calvo pricing model is empirically valid provided that real marginal cost rather than detrended output is used as the variable driving inflation one interpretation of this result is that real marginal cost is not closely related to the output gap and so models for monetary policy need to include labormarket rigidities an alternative interpretation is that marginal cost and the output gap are closely related but that the latter needs to be measured in a manner consistent with dynamic general equilibrium models to date there has been little econometric investigation of this alternative interpretation this paper provides estimates of the new keynesian phillips curve for the u s the u k and australia using theory consistent estimates of the output gap using this theory to measure the output gap leads to a considerable improvement in the empirical performance of output gapbased phillips curves

bequest motives social security and economic growth junxi zhang this article conducts a systematic analysis of four bequest motives in a simple model of endogenous growth it analyzes how bequest motives affect fertility savings growth and the effects of pay as you go social security it is found that altruistic and exchange motives give equivalent outcomes if the discount factors are set the same the outcome under the joy of giving motive may involve a higher bequest ratio higher saving and better growth rates than that under altruism if bequests are accidental the equilibrium values will depend on the probability of survival moreover the results provide testable implications on bequest motives jel d1 d9 h55 j1 i introduction although the importance of bequests in aggregate savings has been established by kotlikoff and summers 1981 who reported that 80 of u s household wealth is inherited wealth what bequest motives lead to inheritance remains an unsolved problem yet it is well known that bequest motives have important implications for the behavior of financial markets the macroeconomic impacts of fiscal policies and the intergenerational transmission of inequality in the distribution of wealth at least four hypotheses for the existence of bequests have been discussed in the literature 1 bequests may arise from intergenerational altruism that is parents obtain utility from their heirs utility as well as from their own consumption barro 1974 2 the prospect of bequests is used by parents to induce children to behave as desired by parents bernheim et al 1985 3 bequests may arise from the joy of giving that is parents leave bequests simply because they obtain utility directly from the bequest yaari 1964 1 and 4 bequests may be the unintentional by product of precautionary savings and a stochastic date of death in the absence of an annuity market abel 1985 following barro 1974 and becker 1974 the altruistic bequest motive has been used most frequently however the enormous empirical work using micro data has not led to conclusive evidence on the one hand bernheim et al 1985 cox 1987 and cox and rank 1992 show that bequests are more consistent with exchange than altruism altonji et al 1992 1997 also show that altruism is decisively rejected moreover wilhelm 1996 finds little support for an altruistic theory of bequests on the other hand a recent reexamination of the exchange motive by perozek 1998 shows that the finding of bernheim et al is not robust laitner and juster 1996 find some evidence of altruistic bequests therefore a definite conclusion on bequest motives seems far from over indeed though altruism has not been supported by most of those empirical studies it remains a plausible hypothesis and continues to be used frequently see e g coate 1995 and davies and zhang 1995 abel 1985 argues theoretically that although the simple life cycle model without bequest motives is an inadequate description of the savi ng behavior in the united states as found in kotlikoff and summers 1981 accidental bequests by selfish consumers can account for a sizable fraction of aggregate wealth however little formal empirical work has been done to test whether bequests are accidental or arise from joy of giving given the lack of consensus on bequest motives it is interesting to conduct a systematic theoretical analysis of different bequest motives in a particular context becker et al 1990 and caballe 1995 assume altruism in their models of economic growth wiedmer s 1996 analysis of social security and growth does not consider bequests except ihori 1994 there seems to be no analysis of other bequest motives in the context of economic growth the purpose of this article is to analyze how different bequest motives affect fertility savings and economic growth the article will also examine how the effects of pay as you go social security depend on bequest motives

replication in empirical economics the journal of money credit and banking project this paper examines the role of replication in empirical economic research it presents the findings of a two year study that collected programs and data from authors and attempted to replicate their published results the research provides new and important information about the extent and causes of failures to replicate published results in economics the findings suggest that inadvertent errors in published empirical articles are a commonplace rather than a rare occurence copyright 1986 by american economic association