wages and productivity growth in a dynamic monopoly abstract this paper studies the intertemporal problem of a monopolistic firm that engages in productivity enhancing innovations to reduce labor costs the optimal innovation policy is not monotone and the rate of productivity growth is the highest when the firm s size is in some intermediate range as long as its initial productivity is not too low the firm eventually reaches a steady state where the rate of productivity growth is identical to the rate of wage growth productivity dependent wage differentials do not affect productivity growth in the steady state they increase however the firm s long run equilibrium cost level

where there is a will there is a way assessing the impact of obstacles to innovation the aim of this article is to assess the impact of obstacles to innovation on firms propensity to innovate we show that distinguishing between firms that do not innovate because they do not intend to and firms that try but fail or give up because of insurmountable obstacles is key for properly measuring the impact of the barriers to innovation estimating an innovation production function on appropriately defined subsamples allows obtaining consistent results i e a significant and negative impact of the obstacles to innovation on firms propensity to innovate these results are robust to the definition of these subsamples to the way obstacles to innovation are defined as well as to the distinction between financial and nonfinancial obstacles

cost reduction competition and industry performance in many markets firms compete over time by expending resources with the purpose of reducing their costs sometimes the cost reducing investments operate directly on costs in many instances they take the form of developing new products that deliver what customers need more cheaply therefore product development can have the same ultimate effect as direct cost reduction in fact if one thinks of the product as the services it delivers to the customer in the way that lancaster pioneered then product development often is just cost reduction

the legacy of steven klepper industry evolution entrepreneurship and geography this introductory essay of the special issue honoring steven klepper provides a synthesis of his work and places the articles of the special issue within the context of his scholarship steven klepper s pioneering work linked life cycle patterns in industry evolution to underlying micro level firm innovation dynamics and employee entrepreneurship and to the macro level implications regarding geographical agglomeration and the growth of economies taken together the lifetime of klepper s research provides an integrated account of the key industrial mechanisms at work and also sets the stage for future research as is elaborated in individual contributions to the special issue

the changing technology of technological change general and abstract knowledge and the division of innovative labour abstract in the past most innovations have resulted from empiricist procedures the outcome of each trial yielding knowledge that could not be readily extended to other contexts while trial and error may remain the primary engine of innovation developments in many scientific disciplines along with progress in computational capabilities and instrumentation are encouraging a new approach to industrial research instead of relying purely on trial and error the attempt is also to understand the principles governing the behaviour of objects and structures the result is that relevant information whatever its source can now be cast in frameworks and categories that are more universal the greater universality makes it possible for the innovation process to be organised in new ways firms can specialise and focus upon producing new knowledge and the locus of innovation may be spread across both users and producers more generally the use of general and abstract knowledge in innovation opens up the possibility for a division of labour in inventive activity the division of innovative labour the implications for public policy especially that on intellectual property rights are discussed

firm size and r d intensity a re examination using data from the federal trade commission s line of business program and survey measures of technological opportunity and appropriability conditions this paper finds that overall firm size has a very small statistically insignificant effect on business unit r d intensity when either fixed industry effects or measured industry characteristics are taken into account business unit size has no effect on the r d intensity of business units that perform r d but it affects the probability of conducting r d business unit and firm size jointly explain less than one per cent of the variance in r d industry effects explain nearly half the variance two sets of well known hypotheses are associated with the later work of joseph schumpeter the first concerns the effects of market concentration on research and development investment and on innovative performance the second bears on the effects of firm size on r d and innovation in a recent paper levin cohen and mowery 1985 we re examined the first set of hypotheses simple regressions at the line of business level replicated the established findings that both r d intensity and innovative performance first increase and then decrease as industrial concentration rises the effect of concentration however was sharply attenuated when we controlled for interindustry differences in technological opportunity and in the appropriability of returns from new technology our results suggested that it is probably unwarranted to conclude that market concentration favors r d investment and innovation in this paper we investigate the schumpeterian hypothesis that large size is conducive to r d investment this relationship has been studied at least as intensively as the link between concentration and r d but our approach is novel in two respects first using data collected by the federal trade

tariffs quotas and piecemeal policy reform abstract this paper extends recent results on the welfare implications of piecemeal tariff adjustments to include cases where the initial trade distortions involve both tariffs and quotas it shows that the standard prescriptions for piecemeal tariff reform are largely unaffected by the presence of unalterable quotas on other goods prescriptions for piecemeal quota reform are also derived although they are constrained by the presence of unalterable tariffs

the size distribution of innovating firms in the uk 1945 1983 a survey of 4 378 significant innovations shows that firms with fewer than 1 000 employees commercialized a much larger share than is indicated by their share of r and d expenditures innovations per employee have been consistently above average in firms with more than 10 000 employees and have become so in firms with fewer than 1 000 intersectoral variation in the size distribution of innovating firms can be explained as a function of r and d based technological opportunities and of technological ease of entry by user firms with principal activities outside the sector copyright 1987 by blackwell publishing ltd

fixed price controls and ad valorem distortions in an open economy abstract this paper compares the welfare effects of ad valorem and fixed price distortions for an open economy in the case of export protection domestic factor growth is much more likely to be immiserizing when fixed price distortions are used in contrast fixed price protection to an import substitute is less likely to induce immiserization via factor growth than ad valorem protection

time intensive r d and unbalanced trade abstract this paper highlights a novel mechanism that generates global imbalances it develops a general equilibrium trade model with one of two countries having a comparative advantage in a sector whose production is characterized by i rapid anticipated demand growth and ii large up front r d costs international funding of the accruing r d costs generates capital inflows in the r d stage which are balanced by subsequent outflows importantly sector level growth does not generate growth differentials between countries typically regarded as rationales of global imbalances additionally it is shown that a trade surplus can coincide with appreciations of the real exchange rate i argue that switzerland s trade surplus which was driven to record heights during 2010 2014 by pharmaceutical exports exemplifies this mechanism calibrating the model to swiss trade flows underpins this argument

strategic r d with spillovers collusion and welfare the author considers a two stage r d then output or price duopoly game in which r d spills over so reducing the marginal cost of both the investing firm and its rival the author compares the noncooperative regime to three collusive regimes joint venture collusion on r d price fixing collusion at the price or output stage and merger collusion at both stages and evaluates under what circumstances a collusive regime improves welfare if spillovers are sufficiently large all three regimes are beneficial although mergers are more likely and price fixing less likely to produce specific benefits than are joint ventures copyright 1994 by blackwell publishing ltd

a structural model for developing countries manufactured exports a dynamic structural econometric model is developed to analyze movements in manufactured exports and to capture lags in the adjustment to equilibrium the model is estimated with pooled cross section time series data for a representative sample of fifteen developing countries grouped according to their export market power the results suggest that prices domestic productive capacity and external economic activity are critical determinants of manufactured exports from developing countries the structural parameter estimates are used to infer the effects of changes in destination country income distinguishing between the short run and long run export volume and export revenue effects the results indicate that domestic economic policies that promote investment and capacity in export oriented activities are likely to play a key role in increasing foreign exchange earnings in developing countries even if growth in external demand is slow

r d appropriability opportunity and market structure new evidence on some schumpeterian hypotheses one of the largest bodies of literature in the field of industrial organization is devoted to the interpretation and testing of several hypotheses advanced by joseph schumpeter 1950 concerning innovation and industrial market structure one set of hypotheses focuses on the role of firm size as a determinant of r d spending and the rate of technological advance another set focuses on the effect of market concentration on r d and technological advance in this paper we reexamine the latter set of hypotheses at the industry level using new data on r d appropriability and technological opportunity collected by levin et al 1984 in a survey of r d executives in 130 industries

patents licensing and market structure in the chemical industry abstract the strategies of rent appropriation and industry structure are inter dependent how firms use patents depends upon industry structure and in turn affects industry structure in the 19th century market leaders in the chemical industry combined patents and secrecy to deter entry within cartels patents were used to stabilize cartels and organize technology licensing the role of patents changed in the less concentrated post world war ii markets in bulk organic chemicals and petrochemicals chemical producers use licensing as an important means of generating revenue from process innovations the increased importance of technology licensing is closely related to the emergence of a class of specialized process design and engineering firms that have played an important role in the development and diffusion of process innovations

persistent heterogeneity of r d intensities within sectors evidence and policy implications abstract do firms in the same sector converge towards the same r d intensities previous research has often assumed this to be true a closer examination using microdata from the eu industrial r d investment scoreboard for the years 2000 2015 shows considerable heterogeneity in r d intensities among firms in the same sector and that this heterogeneity persists over time statistical tests of convergence show that the variation in r d intensities does not decrease over time i e no convergence although firms with an r d intensity below the industry average do seem to catch up with the leaders i e evidence of convergence overall firms in the same industry do not converge to a common r d intensity policy implications are discussed

on the theory of piecemeal tariff reform the case of pure imported intermediate inputs what is the effect of a tariff reduction that applies only to a subset of commodities subject to tariffs this important question was addressed systematically for the first time by james meade 1955 ch 13 in his classic work trade and welfare after a careful analysis meade concluded t here is more likely to be a gain in economic welfare if the rate of duty is high on the primary imports which will come in in increased volume and is low on the secondary imports which will come in in reduced volume p 208 this result was proved formally by trent j bertrand and jaroslav vanek 1971 who demonstrated that in a small open economy if the highest tariff rate is reduced to the next highest one welfare will rise provided the import demand for the good with the highest tariff exhibits gross substitutability with respect to all other goods 2 subsequently following a different strand of the literature as exemplified in john green 1961 tatsuo hatta 1973 1977 and peter lloyd 1974 independently proved similar results in terms of hicksian substitutability 3 in deriving their results bertrand and vanek allowed for the use of final goods as intermediate inputs i e interindustry flows 4 however neither they nor the subsequent writers including hatta and lloyd allowed for the existence of pure imported intermediate inputs that are not produced domestically therefore a natural question is whether the piecemeal policy prescription derived by them remains valid in the presence of pure imported intermediates this question is particularly important for developing countries for two reasons first by far the bulk of the imports of developing countries are intermediate and capital goods according to the world bank during the period 1975 1985 50 percent of developing countries imports were accounted for by intermediate inputs and an additional 30 percent were capital goods a sizable proportion of both capital and intermediate goods are neither produced nor directly consumed in these countries second the meade bertrand vanekhatta lloyd result has been the cornerstone of trade policy reform in many developing countries especially during the last decade in most countries trade reform has been based on the so called concertina approach under which the highest tariffs are reduced to the next highest ones and then to the next highest ones and so on thus lopez professor department of agricultural and resource economics university of maryland college park md 20742 and consultant trade policy division world bank 1818 h street n w washington dc 20433 panagariya senior economist trade policy division world bank 1818 h street n w washington dc 20433 and professor department of economics university of maryland college park md 20742 the findings interpretations and conclusions in this paper are entirely those of the authors they do not necessarily represent the views of the world bank its executive directors or the countries they represent the authors are indebted to two referees and tatsuo hatta for valuable comments on an earlier draft iin this quotation primary imports refers to the goods on which tariffs are reduced while secondary imports refers to other importables subject to tariffs 2robert lipsey and kelvin lancaster 1956 had proved the basic result of bertrand and vanek in a one factor three good model with a cobb douglas utility function 3more recently takashi fukushima 1979 has proved the validity of the hatta lloyd result when the highest tariff is shared by several commodities while rodney falvey 1988 has done the same in the presence of quantitative restrictions on imports 4although hatta 1973 1977 did not allow explicitly for interindustry flows his results can also be shown to be valid in the presence of such flows

modelling imperfectly appropriable r d via spillovers abstract we provide an extensive comparison of the well known r d models of d aspremont jacquemin and kamien muller zang exposing full or partial conflict in key conclusions and policy prescriptions using a mix of formal and or intuitive criteria we argue that the first model is of questionable validity for large spillover values the latter being characterized by jointly increasing returns to scale in the r d process an argument leading to equivalence between the two r d processes but not to agreement on some key conclusions is exposited in conclusion the models emerge as fundamentally different although a unilateral shift in the cost function of the first leads to agreement in all equilibrium outcomes

the anatomy of industry r d intensity distributions using firm data disaggregated by industry we establish a set of regularities in the distribution of firm r d intensities within manufacturing industries we show how a simple probabilistic process in which chance influences a key unobserved determinant of r d and firm size conditions the returns to r d can account for these regularities and other features of the distributions the model provides a unified noncausal explanation of a series of long observed relationships across mean r d intensity market concentration and the coefficient of variation it also offers a novel explanation for the inverse relationship between r d productivity and firm size jel 031

the degree of spillovers and the number of rivals for maximum effective r d abstract the amount of cost reduction or effective r d that results in a symmetric sequential nash equilibrium with quadratic payoffs and differentiated goods is shown to increase with spillovers in oligopolies with a few rivals and to achieve a maximum for spillovers that are not perfect in industries with many firms similar tendencies apply for consumer surplus profits and static welfare more rivals typically lead to reduced investments output and profitability while consumer surplus and welfare increase or at least do not decrease limited entry in markets with a few rivals may enhance innovative investments profitability and consumer surplus if only product differentiation and spillovers are sufficiently high and r d costs sufficiently low too many rivals will then again lead to reductions and a decrease in static welfare

firm heterogeneity imitation and the incentives for cost reducing r d effort i develop and test a model of strategic r d investments where innovating and non innovating firms compete on the basis of their ability to reduce costs and imitate rivals i find that a larger proportion of non innovating rivals stimulates cost reducing investments and attenuates the disincentive effect of imitation by innovators on firm level r d key model properties are verified by estimating the first order condition for the optimal choice of r d using the 1994 carnegie mellon survey of u s industrial r d results also suggest that r d and size are simultaneously determined with r d being proportional to size as predicted by the theoretical model

measuring r d in small firms how much are we missing the oecd surveys on r d are considerably biased towards underestimating r d in small firms this conclusion is derived from the author s comparison between the official dutch r d survey and the findings of his own survey among 3000 firms although being based on dutch observations only the author s considerations have an impact on other oecd countries since the official dutch r d survey is fully compatible with those in other countries the findings call into question the results from a number of empirical studies bearing on subjects such as market structure and r d firm size and r d or r d and growth

the entrepreneurial state evidence from taiwan duvall and freeman 1983 propose an explicit theory to explain the entrepreneurial role of the state in developing societies their argument illuminates linkages between the benefits that an elite group receives from state entrepreneurial activity and the support that this group provides to the state in this article the authors examine theoretically and empirically the ability of their theory to explain the evolution of state entrepreneurship in a rapidly industrializing society taiwan overall the authors show that the formal theory of duvall and freeman holds several features not heretofore explicated but that it is remarkably robust in providing a cogent framework in which to interpret recent taiwanese economic history in short the fit between the model of duvall and freeman and the empirical data for taiwan is quite strong this suggests that state entrepreneurship is used in developing societies in a countercyclical way in order to help manage the political economy the authors also explore the

the persistency and volatility of the firm r d investment revisited from the perspective of technological capability abstract the persistency and volatility of firm rd however previous research has found mixed evidence concerning the persistency and volatility of firm rd positive shocks however technological capability offsets the internal cash flow effect and causes persistency in rd negative shocks these imply that r d investment is not a dichotomous decision between persistency and volatility and is conditional on each firm s technological capability

do tax credits stimulate r d spending the effect of the r d tax credit in its first decade abstract this paper examines the impact of the u s federal r d tax credit between 1981 1991 using confidential irs data from corporate tax returns the empirical analysis makes two key advances on previous work first it implements a new instrumental variables iv strategy based on tax changes that directly addresses the simultaneity of r d spending and marginal credit rates second the analysis makes use of new restricted access irs corporate return data describing r d expenditures estimates imply that a10 reduction in the user cost of r d leads the average firm to increase its research intensity the ratio of r d spending to sales by 19 8 in the short run long run estimates imply that the average firm faces adjustment costs and increases spending over time though small and young firms show evidence of reversing initial increases analysis of the components of qualified research shows that wages and supplies account for the bulk of the increase in research spending elasticities of qualified and total research intensities from a smaller sample suggest firms respond to user cost changes largely by increasing their qualified spending meaning that the type of r d the federal credit deems qualified research is an important margin on which the credit affects firm behavior

dynamics in research joint ventures and r d collaborations abstract we investigate the short and long term effects of different types of r d collaborations on firms consumers and the industry to that end we consider a differentiated product market in which firms compete a la bertrand and invest in process innovation in order to lower the production cost over time investments are stochastic and there can be cartelization or competition strategies among firms at the moment of making the decision on the amount to invest in r d our results show that in equilibrium the long run welfare is larger under a research joint venture than under other environments discounted present value profits increase with the level of the spillover but there are asymmetries that depend on the firms asymmetry on marginal costs

the evolution of new industries and the determinants of market structure several empirical regularities concerning firm growth rates and industry firm size distributions have been developed by studying primarily mature industries the primary purpose of this article is to bring together and extend empirical regularities on the evolution of new industries and to use these regularities to gain further insight into the forces governing industry evolution to explain these regularities a model is constructed which emphasizes how factors governing the early evolution of industries may shape their market structure at maturity it stresses how chance events and exogenous factors that influence the number of potential entrants to the industry the growth rate of incumbents and the ease of imitation of industry leaders will influence the ultimate number and size distribution of firms in the industry

the relationship between firm investments in technological innovation and political action economic theory recognizes the importance of investments in both technological innovation and political activity in firm behavior and extensive research exists which examines independently these expenditures however surprisingly little attention is devoted to analyzing technological innovation and political action expenditures jointly technological innovation and political action are two of the options firms face regarding how to achieve lower costs or market power the characteristics of these choices not only affect the degree to which each is used but also have widely divergent normative and policy implications for society furthermore many forms of technological innovation require regulatory approval so that firms may use the two forms of investment in conjunction with each other in addition to treating them as separate investment alternatives this paper investigates the relationships between firm investments in technological innovation and political activity both forms of investment seek to lower costs and or create market advantage but economists have long recognized the social importance of technological innovation to economic growth while treating most firm political activity as inefficient growing social concerns surrounding declining innovation productivity and growth and increasing firm political activity suggest that these are timely dimensions to explore jointly in the next section i discuss the relationship between firm investments in technological innovation and political action this discussion motivates the subsequent empirical modelling presented in section iii because of the possibility of simultaneity between firm spending in research and development rd these results hold true to various degrees over industries and industry groups section vi offers conclusions and suggestions for further research

temporary import quota and the current account this paper studies the effects of a temporary import quota on the real exchange rate and the current account response is determined by the interaction between two opposing forces the intertemporal relative price effect tends to improve the current account while the wealth the intertemporal relative price effect tends to improve the current account while the wealth effect contributes to a deterioration for a sufficiently low degree of intertemporal consumption substitution the wealth effect is shown to dominate in this event the current account deteriorates in response to a temporary quota and improves only after the quota is lifted

market structure and endogenous productivity growth how do r d subsidies affect market structure abstract conclusions about optimal rd 2 distribution of firm sizes and 3 more complex market structures that vary across industries and over time this paper presents the partial equilibrium for a single industry demonstrating how growth promoting r d subsidies alter the endogenously determined market structure subsidies to r d stretch the distribution of market shares with an increased number of firms in the market but a higher variance in the market shares across firms

the ecological fallacy revisited aggregate versus individual level findings on economics and elections and sociotropic voting several aggregate level studies have found a relationship between macroeconomic conditions and election outcomes operating in intuitively plausible directions more recent survey based studies however have been unable to detect any comparable relationship operating at the individual voter level this persistent discrepancy is puzzling one recently proposed explanation for it is that voters actually behave in an altruistic or sociotropic fashion responding to economic events only as they affect the general welfare rather than in terms of self interested pocketbook considerations it is argued here that the discrepancies between the macro and micro level studies are a statistical artifact arising from the fact that observable changes in individual welfare actually consist of two unobservable components a government induced and politically relevant component and an exogenous component caused by life cycle and other politically irrelevant factors it is shown that because of this individual level cross sectional estimates of the effects of welfare changes on voting are badly biased and are essentially unrelated to the true values of the behavioral parameters of interest they will generally be considerable underestimates and may even be of the wrong sign an aggregate level time series analysis on the other hand will often yield reasonably good if somewhat attenuated estimates of the underlying individual level effects of interest thus in this case individual behavior is best investigated with aggregate rather than individual level data it is also shown that the evidence for sociotropic voting is artifactual in the sense that the various findings and evidence which ostensibly show sociotropic behavior are all perfectly compatible with the null hypothesis of self interested pocketbook voting

the role of knowledge in r d efficiency past research has recognized that both demand and capability influence the allocation of r d resources scholars have had an easier time getting a grip on demand than on capability while it has been recognized that knowledge is an important part of capability to date formalization of knowledge and its role in r d activity has been unsatisfactory this paper models the role of knowledge in r d various sources of such knowledge are considered the model throws a different light on analyses that employ a knowledge capital stock and also illuminates the dual private and public nature of technological knowledge

tariffs quotas and welfare in a monetary economy abstract the effects of tariffs and quotas on welfare in a monetary economy are considered it is shown that while both policies improve the balance of payments they have different lifetime welfare implications even when they are equivalent in the long run the speed of adjustment is shown to be more rapid under a tariff than under a quota therefore adjustment costs associated with changes in money holdings are lower under a tariff while those associated with changes in consumption are higher simulation results are used to examined the implications of various structural parameters for lifetime utility under the two policies

the role of sunk costs in the decision to invest in r d we present a dynamic empirical model of a firm s r d decisions that is consistent with the existence of sunk r d costs taking into account that these costs may differ between small and large firms and among different technological regimes we estimate a multivariate dynamic discrete choice model using firm level data of spanish manufacturing for 1990 2000 conditional on firm heterogeneity and serially correlated unobservable factors we find that r d history matters this true state dependence allows inferring the existence of sunk r d costs associated with performing r d sunk r d costs are found to be higher for large high tech firms

cost reducing and demand creating r d with spillovers this article analyzes r d policies when the returns to cost reducing and demand creating r d are imperfectly appropriable and market structure is endogenous we generalize previous characterizations of appropriability to permit the possibility that own and rival r d are imperfect substitutes we also describe how equilibrium expenditures on process and product r d as well as equilibrium market structure depend on technological opportunities and spillovers in contrast to previous work diminished appropriability does not necessarily reduce r d expenditures for example under some conditions an increase in the extent of process product spillovers will lead to an increase in product process r d we estimate several variants of the model by using manufacturing line of business data and data from a survey of r d executives

public policy towards r d in oligopolistic industries the importance of determining optimal policy towards r d cannot be exaggerated given the worldwide interest in fostering r d and given the significant differences between european and u s policies towards interfirm cooperation on r d moreover the problem is an inherently difficult one because of the complex nature of the r d process since r d is a component of fixed costs industries where it is important tend to be concentrated hence r d policy must go hand in hand with competition policy at the same time r d is like any form of investment in that it precedes the production stage hence issues of time consistency and strategic commitment inevitably arise in considering the choice of r d policy finally r d by one firm typically leads to spillovers wbich benefit other firms so that r d exhibits many of the character department of economics university college dublin belfield dublin 4 ireiatid for helpful discussions and comments we are grateful to two anonymous referees to pedro bartos steve martin massimo motta and damien neven and to participants at seminars in birmingham st andrew s and warwick at a cepr workshop on r d spillovers in lausanne at erwit 94 in caslel gandolfo eea 95 in prague the 1996 conference on industrial economics at universidad carlos iii de madrid and a meeting of the dublin economics workshop this paper was produced as part of the international economic performance programme of the centre for economic performance london school of economics supported by the u k esrc an earlier version was circulated as cepr discussion paper no 1243 see alexis jacquemin 1988 and stephen martin 1996 istics of a public good albeit one that is mostly privately produced tbe degree to which such spillovers occur and can be internalized is another crucial influence on the desirable pattem of intervention