foreign direct investment mode choice entry and establishment modes in transition economies in this study we bridge two streams of foreign direct investment literature specifically studies on establishment mode choice i e the choice between an acquisition and a greenfield establishment and studies on entry mode choice i e the choice between a wholly owned outlet and a subsidiary with shared ownership we arrive at a conceptual synthesis for an examination of the effects of the same predictors on the dual entry establishment mode choice made in the context of a single foreign investment we demonstrate that a parent firm s technological intensity international strategy and experience determine both establishment and entry mode choices moreover we apply williamson s new institutional economics to investigate the influence of institution building on multinational enterprises dual investment choice in the context of transition economies we test empirically the possible moderating effect of a host country s institutional environment we conclude that the degree of the host country s institutional advancement moderates the effect of both technological intensity and international strategy on the establishment and entry mode choice

the pace of mnes sequential entries cumulative entry experience and the dynamic process this study examines the pace with which multinational enterprises undertake sequential entries in a foreign market we focus on learning effects from cumulative entry experience of different modes within a host market moreover we investigate the dynamic process of entry mode switch and how cumulative entry experience reduces the expansion constraint using a dataset of sequential entries by us firms in china during 1979 2002 we find that the impact of cumulative entry experience on the pace of sequential entries varies across different modes further firms with more cumulative entry experience can cope with the constraint of entry mode switch

foreign entry cultural barriers and learning this paper examines the longevity of foreign entries hypotheses are developed on the mode start ups vs acquisitions and ownership structure wholly owned vs joint ventures in relation to cultural distance the hypotheses are tested within a framework of organizational learning using data on 225 entries that 13 dutch firms carried out from 1966 onwards results show that the presence of cultural barriers punctuates an organization s learning cultural distance is a prominent factor in foreign entry whenever this involves another firm requiring the firm to engage in double layered acculturation we also identify locational paths of learning the longevity of acquisitions is positively influenced by prior entries of the firm in the same country similarly the longevity of foreign entries in which the firm has a majority stake improves whenever the expanding firm engaged in prior entries in the same country and in other countries in the same cultural block

cost value and foreign market entry mode the transaction and the firm this paper compares and contrasts the mode of foreign market entry decision from the transaction cost internalization and organizational capability perspectives each of these perspectives operates at a different level of analysis respectively the transaction and the firm and consequently differs in the primary arena of attention namely transaction characteristics and the capabilities of firms in making the comparison a key distinction is made between the cost and the value aspects in the management of know how based on which issues pertaining to the transfer of knowledge within and across firm boundaries and the exploitation and enhancement of competitive advantage are closely examined the main purpose of this paper is to demonstrate the implications of a shift in frame from cost to value in the analysis of decisions related to firm boundaries entry into foreign markets is used primarily as a vehicle for the accomplishment of this purpose the paper shows how the value based framework of the organizational capability perspective radically and fundamentally shifts the approach towards the governance of firm boundaries and argues that even though tc internalization theory raises some valid concerns the organizational capability framework may be more in tune with today s business context some of the assumptions of the tc internalization perspective both direct opportunism exploitation of existing advantage and indirect preservation of the value of know how across locational contexts asymmetry between bounded rationality for transaction and production purposes are critically examined and questioned implications of a shift from a cost to a value based framework are discussed and the need for a shift in research focus is emphasized

schooling choices and demographic cycles this paper examines the effect of demographic cycles on schooling choices and the timing of school completion utilizing data from the u s national longitudinal surveys of labor market experience and from the panel study of income dynamics we find that men and women born during the upswing of a demographic cycle obtain more schooling and take longer to finish a year of schooling than comparable individuals born during the downswing of a demographic cycle the patterns that we document are more complex than would be predicted by any of the theoretical models of educational responses to demographic cycles that have been presented in the literature excerpt

internationalisation conceptualising an entrepreneurial process of behaviour in time this paper presents a three stage process of conceptual development in response to the call for a unifying direction for research in the emergent field of international entrepreneurship drawing on classic approaches to internationalisation and importing insight from entrepreneurship as a separate and distinct field of study the paper develops three potential models of internationalisation as a time based process of entrepreneurial behaviour the models evolve from the simple through general to precise levels of conceptualisation research implications are discussed

prior conditions and early international commitment the mediating role of domestic mindset our study investigates why some firms engage in low international commitments such as exports in the early phases of internationalization whereas others leapfrog the internationalization process and start with high international commitments in the form of foreign direct investment fdi process models of internationalization propose that firms start with low commitment activities and gradually increase their commitments to international markets however recent empirical evidence has shown that many firms make high international commitments from the start our findings suggest that domestic resources and competitive action propensity affect early international commitments indirectly through domestic mindsets a domestic mindset refers to the knowledge structures of the top management team prior to starting international activities based on their managerial experience and learning in domestic markets our results suggest that knowledge and learning gained in domestic markets through diverse resource and competitive activities may be crucial in early international commitments

clearing the air the effects of gasoline content regulation on air quality this paper examines the effects of u s gasoline content regulations on groundlevel ozone pollution these regulations are costly and have been shown to fragment gasoline markets and raise prices paid by consumers we provide the first comprehensive empirical estimates of the regulations air quality benefits we exploit the fact that gasoline regulations vary by time and place of introduction using both difference in difference and regression discontinuity designs we show that federal regulations targeting the emissions of volatile organic compounds vocs one of the two main precursors to ozone do not substantially improve air quality this outcome is driven by the response of refiners to the regulation minimizing the cost of abatement involves removing a type of voc from gasoline that is not an important determinant of ozone pollution in california however we show that precisely targeted regulations requiring the removal of vocs particularly prone to forming ozone caused a significant improvement in air quality

mode of entry mode into a foreign market the case of u s mutual funds in canada abstract u s mutual fund companies offer funds in canada through two channels foreign direct investment or trade in advisement services the total value of u s controlled funds amounts to 18 of the canadian equity fund market this paper investigates how the fund level and firm level characteristics affect the channel used to enter the canadian market empirical results indicate that the funds offered through fdi are not especially successful in the u s market but are associated with dominant companies whereas the funds offered through trade in advisement services are highly successful in the u s market and are from companies with relatively few successful funds

choice of foreign market entry mode impact of ownership location and internalization factors firms interested in servicing foreign markets face a difficult decision with regards to the choice of an entry mode the options available to a firm include exporting licensing joint venture and sole venture several factors that determine the choice of a specific foreign market entry mode have been identified in previous literature these factors can be classified into three categories ownership advantages of a firm location advantages of a market and internalization advantages of integrating transactions this study examines the independent and joint influences of these factors on the choice of an entry mode multinomial logistic regression model is employed to test the hypothesized effects

analyzing foreign market entry strategies extending the internalization approach a new fully integrated analysis of the foreign market entry decision is presented encompassing the choice between exporting licensing joint venturing and wholly owned foreign investment the choice between acquisition and greenfield investment is examined and so too are options based on subcontracting and franchising the model extends the insights of internalization theory and draws on concepts from the economics of industrial organization a special feature of the model is the distinction between investment in production facilities and investment in distribution facilities an important practical distinction that has been overlooked in much of the international business literature the strength of competition from indigenous rivals is emphasized as a determinant of entry strategy into both production and distribution

how mncs choose entry modes and form alliances the china experience this study examine two dimensions of firms foreign market entry strategy mode of entry and formation of alliances based on the existing literature we propose a model that describes how host country home country and industry specific factors affect foreign firms decisions on how they enter the market and whether they will enter with a partner firm or not the model also describes how operation related factors i e the location and the level of local government affect these decisions seven major hypotheses were tested using a longitudinal sample of 2 998 foreign business activities in china between 1979 and 1993 our sample consists of foreign investing firms from the u s europe japan and other asian countries by choosing china as a host country the study offers insights into how firms of different regional groups adapted their strategies to a changing host environment

the impact of order and mode of market entry on profitability and market share market share performance and profitability of overseas business activities has long been an important issue in international business in this study we explore the impact of order and mode of market entry into an overseas market we find that early entrants have significantly higher market shares and profitability than late followers we also find that equity joint ventures have a higher profitability than either wholly owned operations or contractual joint ventures a significant interaction exists between order and mode of market entry as expected firm efficiency and size affect the performance of firms these results are based on the business activities of a sample of 14 466 foreign firms in china in 1995

government policies market imperfections and foreign direct investment the internalization eclectic theory of foreign direct investment includes the important insight that government policies create market imperfections which make foreign direct investment an economically rational strategic alternative for firms this paper reexamines the effects of government policies on market imperfections and foreign direct investment fdi it broadens and refines the analysis of the impact of government policies by developing the following arguments 1 there is a wide range of government policies that affect firms fdi decisions via their effects on market imperfections 2 there are numerous dimensions of variability in government policies that need to be identified in order to understand fully the effects of government policies on market imperfections and hence fdi flows 3 some of the effects of government policies on market imperfections and fdi are the opposite of those previously noted in the fdi literature 4 the effects of government policies vary across the several individual components of fdi flows the paper thus examines the following variables and relationships more extensively and precisely than has the previous literature government policy variables as causal factors affecting fdi market imperfection variables as intervening factors in the causal connections between government policies and fdi and the multiple indicators of the various dimensions of fdi as dependent variables

broadening the foreign market entry mode decision separating ownership and control this paper argues that the ownership and control dimensions of foreign market entry mode choice should be separated and that foreign market entry mode decisions should be expanded to business activities beyond production and distribution empirical results from the global hotel industry indicate that the transferability of the entrant s competitive advantages the local market s absorptive capacity and the availability of trustworthy local partners differentially affect the ownership and control dimensions of the entry mode decision

global strategy and multinationals entry mode choice this paper makes a case directed towards establishing the importance of global strategic considerations in choosing multinationals entry mode specifically it is our contention that beyond the environmental and transaction specific factors well established in the literature to affect the entry mode decision we should also consider the strategic relationship a multinational envisages between its operations across borders in reaching this decision after incorporating various global strategic variables into an eclectic framework of the factors influencing the entry mode choice this paper tests both the validity of the overall framework and the importance of each entry mode determinant in differ entiating among entry modes this is done based on ninety six multinational managers responses to a survey questionnaire concerning their entry mode decision experiences the results suggest that an express incorporation of global strategic variables into an analysis of the entry mode decision is warranted

the eclectic paradigm of international production a restatement and some possible extensions this article reviews some of the criticisms directed towards the eclectic paradigm of international production over the past decade and restates its main tenets the second part of the article considers a number of possible extensions of the paradigm and concludes by asserting that it remains a robust general framework for explaining and analysing not only the economic rationale of economic production but many organisational and impact issues in relation to mne activity as well

the impact of corruption on entry strategy evidence from telecommunication projects in emerging economies with globalization and the growth in emerging economies multinational enterprises mnes now frequently confront challenges associated with corrupt governments already a growing body of research has demonstrated that corruption significantly reduces a countrys aggregate inflows of foreign direct investment through its effects on firm performance we move the analysis of corruption from aggregate financial flows toward managerial theory and practice by examining how firms adjust their strategy for entering foreign markets in corrupt environments and how different types of corruption affect firms choices building on institutional theory we predict that mnes will respond to pervasive and arbitrary corruption in a host country by selecting particular types of equity and nonequity modes of entry using data on 220 telecommunications development projects in 64 emerging economies we find that firms adapt to the pressures of corruption via short term contracting and entry into joint ventures we also find that the arbitrariness surrounding corrupt transactions has a significant impact on firms decisions in addition to the overall level of corruption in contrast to extant research we show that mnes use nonequity entry modes or partnering as an adaptive strategy to participate in markets despite the presence of corruption

equity ownership in international joint ventures the impact of source country factors this study examines the impact of four source country factors on the equity ownership in international joint ventures ijvs these factors are exchange rate cost of borrowing export capability and management orientation based on a sample of 8 078 ijvs in china this study shows that equity ownership tends to be higher for parent firms from a source country with strong currency low cost of borrowing strong export capability and high uncertainty avoidance

strategic investments by us firms in transition economies studies in international business have considered both theoretical and empirical analyses of investment strategies by multinational firms in transition economies however there is scant research on the impact of firm specific factors on the likelihood timing and mode of entry decisions in these economies we provide evidence on three aspects of the strategic decisions by us firms to invest in transition economies first we find that firms entering the region have greater advertising intensity and sales growth than industry peers that did not enter the region suggesting that market seeking considerations motivate expansion second we find that earlier entry is undertaken by firms with fewer industry competitors and higher sales growth suggesting that the desire to secure market share ahead of competitors motivates entry timing finally we investigate the choice of entry mode into the region and find that firms from concentrated industries are more likely to enter the region with high equity commitment consistent with market seeking motives we also find that firms incorporate the degree of progress with market oriented reforms in making decisions concerning entry timing and mode

market knowledge diversification and export expansion the research focuses on the export expansion process of small and middle sized manufacturing firms and some of its correlates diversification and geographical market distribution means of acquiring information and modes of international distribution the study reveals the overwhelming influence on export expansion of information acquired from business transactions as opposed to reliance on private or public information services the impact of market diversification and its nature is confirmed policy implications are suggested

asset specificity and foreign market entry mode choice of small and medium sized enterprises the moderating influence of knowledge safeguards and institutional safeguards according to transaction cost economics tce reasoning firms choose equity as opposed to non equity foreign market entry modes to safeguard specific assets the present paper contextualizes the well researched relationship between asset specificity and foreign market entry mode choice by introducing knowledge safeguards international experience host country networks and imitation and institutional safeguards property rights protection and cultural proximity as alternative mechanisms for securing a firm s specific assets testing our hypotheses on a sample of 206 small and medium sized enterprises we find that knowledge safeguards and institutional safeguards weaken the effect of asset specificity on the choice of equity foreign market entry modes contextualizing the relationship between asset specificity and foreign market entry mode choice helps to enhance our understanding of the scope conditions of tce based entry mode studies and beyond

choosing between direct investment and licensing theoretical considerations and empirical tests this paper focuses on the conditions under which an international firm would expand overseas via the transfer of technology and rights to its own controlled equity affiliates as opposed to resorting to the market by selling its technology to independent foreign licensees the relative propensity of u s firms to use licensing versus equity investment is then examined statistically in regression models using data of the department of commerce a second paper in this series forthcoming in the summer 1985 issue will examine strategic and negotiation issues involved in combining equity investment licensing and intra firm trade into one agreement

the effect of national culture on the choice of entry mode characteristics of national cultures have frequently been claimed to influence the selection of entry modes this article investigates this claim by developing a theoretical argument for why culture should influence the choice of entry two hypotheses are derived which relate culture to entry mode choice one focusing on the cultural distance between countries the other on attitudes towards uncertainty avoidance using a multinomial logit model and controlling for other effects the hypotheses are tested by analysing data on 228 entries into the united states market by acquisition wholly owned greenfield and joint venture empirical support for the effect of national culture on entry choice is found

cooperative strategies between foreign firms in an overseas country in this paper we study the cooperative strategies between two firms in an overseas country in part 1 we examine the circumstances under which foreign firms would cooperate with another foreign firm in a third country market drawing upon existing literature we develop and test a set of hypotheses using a longitudinal data set from china the types of cooperative arrangements include all the major modes of operation in part 2 we further investigate what types of operation and level of control exist among the cooperative arrangements between two foreign firms in china we used a sample of 483 cooperative arrangements between two firms from hong kong the u s japan germany or britain this study offers interesting insight as to why foreign firms form cooperative arrangements in an overseas country and what types of cooperative arrangements these firms prefer

equity joint ventures and the theory of the multinational enterprise this paper extends the internalization approach to the theory of the multinational enterprise mne to include an expanded role for equity joint ventures using the transaction cost paradigm of williamson this paper explains why joint ventures may sometimes be preferred over wholly owned subsidiaries also presented is empirical work on joint venture performance in developing countries which demonstrates that under certain conditions joint ventures can be the optimal mode of foreign direct investment

choosing an appropriate alliance governance mode the role of institutional cultural and geographical distance in international research development r d collaborations we identify a variety of r d alliance modes in a knowledge intensive industry e g pharmaceuticals and classify them into four ordered categories which go beyond the traditional binary equity vs non equity alliance classification this enriches our understanding of alliance governance structures and broadens the application of alliance modes in what is today a more complicated international r d collaboration setting we then explore national industry and firm factors that determine the selection of an appropriate r d alliance governance mode using a sample of 237 international alliance deals the likelihood of using a more integrated alliance governance mode decreases as the difference or distance between nations of the partner firms increases in terms of human capital and cultural distance on the other hand a greater geographic and institutional difference is positively associated with the selection of more integrated alliance governance modes furthermore firms in the research stage are more likely to use a more integrated governance mode as opposed to firms in the development stage these findings advance research on alliance governance structure they reveal the factors affecting the r d alliance governance mode choice

firm ownership preferences and host government restrictions an integrated approach two approaches may explain how multinational enterprises mnes select ownership structures for subsidiaries the first argues that mnes prefer structures that minimize that transaction costs of doing business abroad the second argues that ownership structures are determined by negotiations with host governments whose outcomes depend on the bargaining power of the firm this paper presents a framework integrating these two approaches and uses statistical methods to separate their effects empirically

influences on foreign equity ownership level in joint ventures in china this study examines the determinants of foreign equity ownership in joint ventures in china drawing upon duning s ownership locational and internalization paradigm and the literature on bargaining power eleven variables that impact foreign ownership preferences and concessions are examined these variables are advertising intensity foreign capital input country risk of china ejv investment amount ejv contractual duration cultural distance competitive intensity local partner state ownership local partner alignment foreign partner alignment and ejv location the empirical findings are largely consistent with the hypotheses the empirical findings are largely consistent with the hypotheses further interesting differences were found among u s european and japanese firms with respect to the impact of these determinants

what differences in the cultural backgrounds of partners are detrimental for international joint ventures an international joint venture implies that a firm has to cooperate with a partner with a different cultural background in this study hypotheses about which differences in national culture are most disruptive for international joint ventures were developed and tested using hofstede s five dimensions the study focused on how these dimensions affect the survival of international joint ventures as well as their incidence relative to wholly owned subsidiaries the hypotheses were tested on longitudinal data about 828 foreign entries of twenty five dutch multinational in seventy two countries between 1966 and 1994 the database which spans almost three decades was also used to provide new evidence on a key assumption of hofstede s work that cultural values are stable over time

clean air regulation and heterogeneity in us gasoline prices in order to improve public health in areas with air quality problems the us clean air act imposes a variety of federal regulations on gasoline which have led to a proliferation of fuel blends known as boutique fuels more than 45 fuel blends are sold nationwide we examine the effects of this program on wholesale gasoline prices the methodological innovation in this study is the use of a regulatory distance measure as a proxy for measuring market power that arises from product differentiation we find that clean air regulation increases gasoline prices by increasing the cost of refining but more importantly by creating regulatory islands it segments the market and increases the market power of firms our estimation controls for the potential endogeneity of the regulatory variables we find that ols techniques systematically underestimate the effect of regulation on gasoline prices

financial performance and survival of multinational corporations in china this study investigates the impact of entry timing mode of entry market focus and location advantages on the financial performance and survival of multinational corporations mncs in china three major results were found first mncs that entered china in an earlier year had a higher level of profit than those that entered in a later year second equity joint ventures ejvs had a higher profit level than cooperative operations or wholly foreign owned subsidiaries third mncs that utilized well the location advantages in china had a higher profit we also found that ejvs were more likely to survive compared to cooperative operations while wholly owned subsidiaries did not differ from ejvs the findings are based on a 2 year study of about 1000 mnc operations in china copyright 1999 john wiley sons ltd

comparative business failures of foreign controlled firms in the united states we explore the comparative business failures of foreign owned or controlled firms and domestically owned firms original data are collected regarding foreign controlled firms in the u s that filed for bankruptcy protection were involuntarily liquidated or ceased operations mainly due to poor financial performance during the 1978 1988 period our results show that foreign controlled firms fail less often than domestically owned firms the patterns of foreign controlled business failures and the impacts of entry modes ownership types and national culture on the failures of foreign controlled firms are also examined

choice between non equity entry modes an organizational capability perspective many studies have examined the choice between different types of equity and non equity modes however none has focused on the choice between different types of non equity modes that service firms employ routinely this study develops a theoretical framework based on the organizational capability perspective to explain the choice between two non equity modes franchising and management service contracts while previous studies are based on the premise that foreign market entrants choose a mode equity or non equity that offers them most control given their particular circumstances the premise of this study is that foreign entrants choose a non equity mode that in addition offers effective transfer of the firm s capabilities to the host country venture

cluster sample methods in applied econometrics inference methods that recognize the clustering of individual observations have been available for more than 25 years brent moulton 1990 caught the attention of economists when he demonstrated the serious biases that can result in estimating the effects of aggregate explanatory variables on individual specific response variables the source of the downward bias in the usual ordinary least squares ols standard errors is the presence of an unobserved state level effect in the error term more recently john pepper 2002 showed how accounting for multi level clustering can have dramatic effects on t statistics while adjusting for clustering is much more common than it was 10 years ago inference methods robust to cluster correlation are not used routinely across all relevant settings in this paper i provide an overview of applications of cluster sample methods both to cluster samples and to panel data sets

a tale of three countries italian spanish and swiss manufacturing operations in china in this paper the choice of joint venture versus wholly foreign owned enterprise wfoe made by italian spanish and swiss multinationals in china as shaped by the risk of dissipation of intangible assets is investigated probit estimates based on an entirely new firm level dataset constructed by the author show that wfoe is more likely to emerge when know how easily spills over namely for firms endowed with more intangible assets or belonging to high tech sectors in line with the theoretical expectations

does human resource management matter in a transitional economy china as an example this paper investigates the significance of how firms manage their human resources hrs within the confines of powerful social institutions in a transitional economy the people s republic of china china we propose that two dimensions the role of human resource management rhr and followers perception of the leader top are important contributors to firm performance as are the influences of the regional economy and firm ownership we tested our hypotheses with a survey of 180 firms from nine cities in china we found that both role of hrm rhr and follower s perception of top level management top are important to firm performance the study confirms that while social institutions remain powerful in a transitional economy effective hrm is important to firm performance

modes of foreign entry a transaction cost analysis and propositions a frontier issue in international marketing is the appropriate choice of entry mode in foreign markets the objective of this paper is to offer a transaction cost framework for investigating the entry mode decision this framework provides 1 a theoretical basis for systematically interrelating the literature into propositions 2 propositions about interactions which resolve the apparently contradictory arguments advanced to date specifically the paper illustrates the feasibility of clustering 17 entry modes into the degree of control the mode provides the entrant proposes that the most appropriate i e most efficient entry mode is a function of the tradeoff between control and the cost of resource commitment advances testable propositions delimiting the circumstances under which each mode maximizes long term efficiency

balancing private and state ownership in emerging markets telecommunications infrastructure country industry and firm influences bargaining between host states and investors over the terms of investment in sensitive sectors of the economy generates political and economic tensions in this study we investigate the factors that contribute to the outcomes of those negotiations as measured by the private vs state owned share of newly consummated telecommunications infrastructure projects we find that private ownership is positively associated with overall economic development and investment liberalization in the host country and with greenfield vs divestiture and joint venture vs wholly owned projects private ownership is negatively associated with existing telecommunications infrastructure higher levels of state ownership of foreign investing firms and the technological sophistication of the projects our analysis also shows a curvilinear inverted u shaped relationship between investment policy hazards and private ownership this finding supports the insight from transaction cost economics that potential gains from internalization are greatest at intermediate levels of uncertainty

the hierarchical model of market entry modes in this study we propose and test a hierarchical model of market entry modes entry modes can first be viewed as equity based versus non equity based within equity based modes the choice is between wholly owned operations and equity joint ventures while within non equity based modes the choice is between contractual agreements and export empirically we demonstrate that there are factors that exert substantial influences at the equity versus non equity level but rather weak influences at the lower level of choice hierarchy the empirical results are based on a sample of over 10 000 foreign entry activities into china between 1979 to 1998 the findings provide supportive evidence for the hierarchical model of market entry modes

timing of entry in international market an empirical study of u s fortune 500 firms in china this study attempts to explain the timing of entry of firms in international markets based on the existing literature we propose a framework that consists of firm specific factors industry market factors and host country factors empirical results based on the entry information of u s fortune 500 firms in china between 1979 and 1996 show that larger firms with greater level of internalization and scope economies are likely to enter this foreign market earlier in addition non equity modes competitors behavior in the product market and lower levels of country risk are significantly associated with early entry