wheat from chaff meta analysis as quantitative literature review abstract this paper presents and develops a quantitative method of literature reviewing and evaluating empirical research meta regression analysis or mra economics is theory driven yet we must learn empirically if economics is to advance mra offers a more objective statistical method to summarize our empirical knowledge and to explain the wide study to study variation in economic research mra is used to assess the evidence for ricardian equivalence and its findings are contrasted to those of conventional narrative review furthermore mra establishes a platform from which to distinguish genuine empirical effect from the exploitable specification error that infests applied econometrics

natural resources and sub national economic performance does sub national democracy matter abstract the differentiation in the impact of resources on economic growth is often explained by the specifics of institutional factors the aim of this paper is to investigate how sub national political differences influence the effect of natural resources on economic growth using a dataset of russian regions this paper demonstrates that sub national democratization influences the growth effects of resources and considers possible mechanisms for this influence the paper finds that in russia natural resources are only capable of promoting growth in the regions with non democratic political systems that at the same time have an efficient and non corrupt bureaucracy

does the resource curse hold for growth in genuine income as well summary existing studies analyzing the so called resource curse hypothesis regress growth in gross domestic product gdp on some measure of resource intensity this is problematic as gdp counts natural and other capital depreciation as income deducting depreciation from gdp to arrive at genuine income we test whether the curse still holds true we find supporting evidence but the growth disadvantage of resource intensive economies is slightly weaker in terms of genuine income than gdp we suggest that this provides additional but somewhat weak and limited evidence in support of those who argue that the curse is partly due to unsustainable overconsumption

the big push natural resource booms and growth a simple application of big push reasoning suggests that natural resource booms can be important catalysts for development in poorer countries in this paper we present evidence from seven latin american countries that natural resource booms are sometimes accompa nied by declining per capita gdp we present a model with natural resources increasing returns in the spirit of big push models and expectations to clarify some of the reasons this may happen q 1999 elsevier science b v all rights reserved

the political economy of resource driven growth abstract in recent decades resource poor countries have out performed resource abundant ones a stylised facts model of competitive industrialisation describes the long run development of a resource poor country with a political state that is developmental only minor change is required to adapt the model to trace the development trajectory of a resource abundant country with a similar political state however most resource abundant countries engender a political state that is factional or predatory and distorts the economy in the pursuit of rents a staple trap model describes the development trajectory under these conditions the model predicts a growth collapse from which recovery is protracted especially for small economies that lack a niche trade link with a large economy

the curse of natural resources in fractionalized countries abstract this paper develops a model that can explain why natural resources are a blessing for some countries but a curse for others in this model natural resources cause fighting activities between rivalling groups fighting reduces productive activities and weakens property rights making productive activities even less attractive the aggregate production decrease exceeds the natural resources direct positive income effect if and only if the number of rivalling groups is sufficiently large the model thus predicts that natural resources lower incomes in fractionalized countries but increase incomes in homogenous countries empirical evidence supporting this prediction is provided

exports inflation and growth abstract this article seeks to identify some of the main determinants of exports and economic growth in cross sectional data from the world bank covering 160 countries for 1985 94 first the linkages between the propensity to export and population per capita income agriculture primary exports and inflation are studied by statistical methods then the relationship between economic growth and some of the above mentioned determinants of exports as well as investment are scrutinized the same way the main conclusion is that in the period under review high inflation and an abundance of natural resources tended to be associated with low exports and slow growth

resource curse or not a question of appropriability this thesis presents three self contained essays focusing on empirical questions in growth and development economics each article addresses specific questions on why countries perform differently in particular i analyse the effect of democracy on economic development the relationship between natural resources and growth and the efficiency of foreign development assistance in the first essay democracy consolidation and growth i analyse the effect of democracy on economic growth in this context i argue that an important aspect to consider is how consolidated political systems are put simply i find that it is not only a question of how democratic countries are but also how long they have been democratic in other words economic performance tends to improve with the duration of uninterrupted democracy the performance of autocracies on the other hand tends to deteriorate over time however for newly established political systems there seems to be a cost of being democratic this implies that democracies only bear their fruit after some time the analysis has important policy implications to overcome initial straits international assistance focused on democratic consolidation may be important and a very good investment in fostering long run development the second essay resource curse or not a question of appropriability together with anne boschini and jesper roine is concerned with the relation between natural resources and economic development for most laymen as well as for most economists it would seem reasonable that countries richly endowed in natural resources also benefit from this wealth however a large literature has found a systematic negative effect of natural resource abundance on economic growth we suggest that this so called resource curse is not determined by resource endowments alone but rather by the interaction between the type of resources a country possesses and the quality of institutions in the country this combination of factors determines what we call the appropriability of a resource the concept of appropriability captures the likelihood of natural resources leading to rentseeking corruption or conflicts which in turn will harm economic development our results suggest that if institutions are good enough the curse may be turned into a blessing this may explain why some countries such as norway and botswana tend to benefit from their resources while others such as angola and sierra leone do not the third and final essay of this thesis foreign sectoral aid fungibility growth and poverty reduction is a contribution to the aid efficiency literature which is concerned with the question of whether aid helps or hinders economic development foreign development assistance is often targeted on specific public expenditure sectors if this aid is not used in the sector for which it was granted e g health education it is said to be fungible and donors may end up financing something completely different from what they intended e g military expenditures the major concern about sectoral fungibility is that the alternative use of aid may be less productive or less socially useful however measuring fungibility is not sufficient to determine whether foreign sectoral aid fungibility is actually harmful what is important is how the funds treated as fungible are used the essay starts by obtaining estimates of fungibility for 57 countries the results suggest that sectoral aid is indeed largely treated as fungible by recipient countries next to assess the economic and health effects of fungibility these estimates are incorporated into an empirical model of aid and growth as well as into a model of aid and infant mortality altogether i find no evidence of more fungible sectoral aid leading to worse performance

the paradox of plenty a meta analysis since sachs and warner s seminal article in 1995 numerous studies have addressed the link between natural resources and economic growth although the resource curse effect was commonly accepted at first many articles have challenged its existence and the results found in the literature are ambiguous in this paper we aim to quantitatively review this literature in order to i identify the sources of heterogeneity and ii assess the impact of natural resources on economic growth a meta analysis is performed on 69 empirical studies on the resource curse totaling 1 419 estimates our findings show that i only developing countries suffer from the resource curse although it is soft ii the way natural resources are taken into account is crucial to understand the heterogeneity found in the literature iii the negative impact of the volatility of the terms of trade on growth should be qualified an additional mra performed on indirect effects size also indicate that when institutions are at their best level the resource curse disappears and may be turned into a blessing

macroeconomic impacts of fdi in transition economies a meta analysis summary in this paper we conduct a meta analysis of the literature that empirically examines the impact of foreign direct investment fdi on economic growth in central and eastern europe and the former soviet union we found that existing studies indicate a growth enhancing effect of fdi in the region as a whole the results of our meta regression analysis suggest that the effect size and statistical significance of the reported estimates strongly depend on study conditions we also found that the relevant studies fail to present genuine evidence of a non zero fdi effect more research is necessary to identify the true effect

the value line enigma extended an examination of the performance of option recommendations the authors extend the research on the value line enigma by examining the performance of call recommendations in value line options d galai s hedge decomposition procedure identifies the components of the calls returns abnormal call returns were most pronounced immediately following the purchase which is consistent with studies of value line s stock rankings the largest and most significant abnormal performance was by calls assigned the highest rank written on stocks judged by value line to be correctly priced abnormal call return performance by joint call and stock ranks was consistent with hypothesis that value line identifies underpriced call options copyright 1993 by university of chicago press

oil growth and health what does the cross country evidence really show we show that previous results from the body of literature on the resource curse have primarily been driven by the collapse in oil prices during the mid 1980s by exploiting cross country variations in the size of initial oil endowments and the timing of oil discoveries we find that there is a stable positive relationship between oil abundance and long run economic growth using dynamic panel data methods we also find that there is no evidence that higher oil rents hinder growth however to focus on material gain means that the welfare gain from oil is understated because oil rich countries benefit more by the reduction in infant mortality and the gain in longevity interestingly such oil led health improvements are more pronounced in non democratic countries where initial heath conditions were poor and oil wealth is concentrated among the ruling elites

education and economic growth a meta regression analysis summary this paper surveys the literature which examines the effect of education on economic growth specifically we apply meta regression analysis to 57 studies with 989 estimates and show that there is substantial publication selection bias toward a positive impact of education on growth once we account for this the genuine growth effect of education is not homogeneous across studies but varies according to several factors specifically it is attributed to differences in education measurement and study characteristics mainly model specification as well as type of data used and the quality of research outlets where studies are published e g academic journals vs working papers

do resource dependent regions grow slower than they should abstract a large literature documents a negative correlation between income growth and resource dependence this correlation has been named the resource curse we present evidence that suggests that the resource curse can be explained by a slow growing resource sector

the voracity effect abstract we analyze an economy that lacks a strong legal political institutional infrastructure and is populated by multiple powerful groups powerful groups dynamically interact via a fiscal process that effectively allows open access to the aggregate capital stock in equilibrium this leads to slow economic growth and a voracity effect by which a shock such as a terms of trade windfall perversely generates a more than proportionate increase in fiscal redistribution and reduces growth we also show that a dilution in the concentration of power leads to faster growth and a less procyclical response to shocks jel f43 o10 o23 o40

institutions and economic growth an historical introduction abstract in this essay the interdependence of political and economic institutions is examined against premises in neoclassical theories of economies which maintain that population and savings are the principal determinants of economic growth that institutions matter in the development of economies is the difference in assumptions i examine i look at the institutional frameworks that preceded adoption of the united states constitution and the northwest ordinance in early america i then trace the precedents of these american institutions to the evolution of common law in england where interests unconcerned with the crown coalesced to form competing political units i then contrast england s institutional development with the comparatively centralized enforcement mechanisms of spain to examine the hypothesis that institutional differences produce economic consequences

rule of law and the resource curse abundance versus intensity we examine the resource curse using new data on historic resource stocks and an improved econometric methodology the paper distinguishes between resource abundance stocks and extractive intensity flows focusing on relationships between resources and rule of law previously unavailable information on past resource stocks is estimated we find that economically large initial natural resource stocks are associated with subsequent lower levels of rule of law and do not directly affect growth while raw resource exports do not have a significant effect on rule of law when stocks are included in the analysis but do affect average growth rates sample size is maximized through the use of an emis expectation maximization with importance sampling algorithm to replace missing data minimizing the bias and inefficiency associated with listwise deletion which commonly eliminates half or more of the available data in this setting

a dynamic duopoly model with asymmetric information this paper investigates the impact of asymmetric information on the set of equilibria of a two period duopoly game with price competition it turns out that all admissible sequential equilibria of this game share a collusive character i e ex ante expected profits for a firm of any type are higher than in the complete information case for small uncertainties the results are asymmetric a small probability of a good type firm does not make much difference on the set of equilibrium payoffs but a small probability of a bad type firm does these results survive the introduction of kohlberg and martens 1986 stability concept copyright 1990 by blackwell publishing ltd

savings growth and the resource curse hypothesis an important connection between recent attempts to understand the determinants of economic growth and the measurement of sustainability is the finding of a negative and significant relationship between natural resource abundance and economic growth this is the so called resource curse hypothesis using cross country regressions we offer evidence that the curse may itself be a manifestation of the inability of governments to manage large resource revenues sustainably in particular these results offer another perspective on the resource curse hypothesis the countries where growth has lagged are those where the combination of natural resource macroeconomic and public expenditure policies have led to a low rate of genuine saving net saving adjusted for resource depletion

natural resources education and economic development economic growth since 1965 has varied inversely with the share of natural capital in national wealth across countries four main channels of transmission from abundant natural resources to stunted economic development are discussed a the dutch disease b rent seeking c overconfidence and d neglect of education public expenditure on education relative to national income expected years of schooling for girls and gross secondary school enrolment are all shown to be inversely related to the share of natural capital in national wealth across countries natural capital appears to crowd out human capital thereby slowing down the pace of economic development

demographic transition in resource rich countries a blessing or a curse summary this study argues that resource wealth is a key factor for understanding income effects of demographic transition we develop a simple model highlighting how the income effect of increased labor supply may depend on resource rents and provide empirical evidence that support the theoretical predictions using panel data covering the period from 1982 to 2006 for more than 120 countries we find a negative interaction effect between resource wealth and demographic transition on national income moreover the negative interaction effect does not depend on institutional quality and is found also across different samples

institutions and the resource curse countries rich in natural resources constitute both growth losers and growth winners we claim that the main reason for these diverging experiences is differences in the quality of institutions more natural resources push aggregate income down when institutions are grabber friendly while more resources raise income when institutions are producer friendly we test this theory building on sachs and warner s influential works on the resource curse our main hypothesis that institutions are decisive for the resource curse is confirmed our results contrast the claims of sachs and warner that institutions do not play a role

booming sector and de industrialisation in a small open economy this paper presents a theoretical analysis of the dutch disease the phenomenon whereby a boom in one traded goods sector squeezes porfitability in other traded goods sectors both by directly bi

natural resources rent seeking and welfare abstract a new and very simple mechanism to explain why natural resource abundance may lower income and welfare is developed in a model with rent seeking a greater amount of natural resources increases the number of entrepreneurs engaged in rent seeking and reduces the number of entrepreneurs running productive firms with a demand externality it is shown that the drop in income as a result of this is higher than the increase in income from the natural resource more natural resources thus lead to lower welfare

the varieties of resource experience natural resource export structures and the political economy of economic growth many oil mineral and plantation crop based economies experienced a substantial deceleration in growth following the commodity boom and bust of the 1970s and early 1980s this article illustrates how countries dependent on point source natural resources those extracted from a narrow geographic or economic base such as oil and minerals and plantation crops are predisposed to heightened economic and social divisions and weakened institutional capacity this in turn impedes their ability to respond effectively to shocks which previous studies have shown to be essential for sustaining rising levels of prosperity analysis of data on classifications of export structure controlling for a wide array of other potential determinants of governance shows that point source and coffee and cocoa exporting countries do relatively poorly across an array of governance indicators these governance effects are not associated simply with being a natural resource exporter countries with natural resource exports that are diffuse relying primarily on livestock and agricultural produce from small family farms do not show the same strong effects and have had more robust growth recoveries

resource abundance and economic growth in the united states abstract it is a common assumption that regions within the same country converge to approximately the same steady state income levels the so called absolute convergence hypothesis focuses on initial income levels to account for the variability in income growth among regions empirical data seem to support the absolute convergence hypothesis for us states but the data also show that natural resource abundance is a significant negative determinant of growth we find that natural resource abundance decreases investment schooling openness and r d expenditure and increases corruption and we show that these effects can fully explain the negative effect of natural resource abundance on growth

natural resources and economic growth the role of investment is it possible that excessive reliance on natural resources affects saving and investment in a way that retards economic growth and thus in the long run the level of output per capita this paper reviews the literature explores the data and compares and contrasts the explanatory power and interplay of natural resources and civil liberties our proxy for institutional variables currently under scrutiny in the literature we propose that natural resource dependence may be viewed as an exogenous factor that impedes economic growth and investment as well as institutions even if we stress that natural resource abundance may be good for growth

a curse or a blessing natural resources in a multiple growth regimes analysis the literature on the impact of an abundance of natural resources on economic performance remains inconclusive in this article we consider the possibility that countries may follow different growth regimes and test the hypothesis that whether natural resources are a curse or a blessing depends on the growth regime to which an economy belongs we follow recent work that has used a mixture of regressions method to identify different growth regimes and find two regimes such that in one regime resources have a positive impact on growth while in the other they have a negative impact or at best have no impact on growth our analysis of the determinants of whether a country belongs or not to the blessed resources regime indicates that the level of democracy plays an important role while education and economic institutions have no effect

natural resources institutional quality and economic growth in china the resource curse has been mainly studied using cross country samples in this paper we analyze a cross province sample from one country china we focus on the interplay between resource abundance institutional quality and economic growth using two different measures of resource abundance a stock resource reserves and a flow resource revenues and employing various econometric approaches including varying coefficient models we find that resource abundance has a positive effect on economic growth at the provincial level in china between 1990 and 2008 an effect that depends nonlinearly on institutional quality 1995 confidence in courts the west china development drive policy initiated in 2000 caused substantial changes which we investigate through a comparative panel data analysis

shining a light on the resource curse an empirical analysis of the relationship between natural resources transparency and economic growth summary one of the most common policy prescriptions for overcoming the so called resource curse particularly for extractive industries has been to call for greater transparency and accountability from governments however despite the conceptual attraction of this policy it has never been empirically proven that resource rich countries are actually less transparent than other countries and whether this lack of transparency has had a significant negative effect on economic growth using a relatively new index of transparency that has extensive coverage both across countries and time the results suggest a strong and robust negative causal association running from point resource export revenues to transparency furthermore there is also some evidence that this lack of transparency is associated with a subsequent decrease in economic growth

kleptocracy and divide and rule a model of personal rule many developing countries have suffered under the personal rule of kleptocrats who implement highly inefe cient economic policies expropriate the wealth of their citizens and use the proceeds for their own glorie cation or consumption we argue that the success of kleptocrats rests in part on their ability to use a divide and rule strategy made possible by the weakness of institutions in these societies members of society need to cooperate in order to depose a kleptocrat yet such cooperation may be defused by imposing punitive rates of taxation on any citizen who proposes such a move and redistributing the benee ts to those who need to agree to it thus the collective action problem can be intensie ed by threats which remain off the equilibrium path in equilibrium all are exploited and no one challenges the kleptocrat kleptocratic policies are more likely when foreign aid and rents from natural resources provide rulers with substantial resources to buy off opponents when opposition groups are shortsighted when the average productivity in the economy is low and when there is greater inequality between producer groups because more productive groups are more dife cult to buy off jel o12 h00

constitutions and the resource curse abstract utilizing the fact that natural resources are randomly distributed among countries we investigate how public income shocks have different long run economic effects dependent on constitutional arrangements we find that i the so called resource curse is present in democratic presidential countries but not in democratic parliamentary countries ii being parliamentary or presidential matters more for the growth effects of natural resources than being democratic or autocratic and iii natural resources are more likely to reduce growth when proportional electoral systems are in place than when the electoral systems are majoritarian the two first effects appear very robust the last effect less so

political foundations of the resource curse in this paper we argue that the political incentives that resource endowments generate are the key to understanding whether or not they are a curse we show 1 politicians tend to over extract natural resources relative to the efficient extraction path because they discount the future too much and 2 resource booms improve the efficiency of the extraction path however 3 resource booms by raising the value of being in power and by providing politicians with more resources which they can use to influence the outcome of elections increase resource misallocation in the rest of the economy 4 the overall impact of resource booms on the economy depends critically on institutions since these determine the extent to which political incentives map into policy outcomes countries with institutions that promote accountability and state competence will tend to benefit from resource booms since these institutions ameliorate the perverse political incentives that such booms create countries without such institutions however may suffer from a resource curse

economic freedom and productivity growth in resource rich economies summary the focus of this paper is to test whether free market institutions that protect property rights and support freedom of choice and voluntary exchange can change the curse of natural resources into a blessing to examine the above question this paper uses the fraser institute s economic freedom index and its five sub indices namely government size property rights access to sound money freedom to trade and setting proper regulations using data from 99 sample countries over the period 1970 2010 the system gmm estimates suggest that the negative growth effects of resource rents may turn positive in countries with greater economic freedom

the resource curse and its potential reversal several recent papers suggest that the negative association between natural resource intensity and economic growth can be reversed if institutional quality is high enough we try to understand this result in more detail by decomposing the resource measure using alternative measures of both resources and institutions and by studying different time periods while an institutional reversal is present in many specifications only ores and metals interacted with the icrg measure of institutional quality consistently have a negative growth effect but a positive interaction that turns the curse around when institutions are good enough

cursing the blessings natural resource abundance institutions and economic growth summary since sachs and warner s sachs j d warner a m 1995a natural resource abundance and economic growth nber working paper no 5398 contribution there has been a lively debate on the so called natural resource curse this paper re examines the effects of natural resource abundance on economic growth using new measures of resource endowment and considering the role of institutional quality we find a positive direct empirical relationship between natural resource abundance and economic growth in both ols and 2sls regressions the positive resource effects are particularly strong for subsoil wealth our results also show no evidence of negative indirect effects of natural resources through the institutional channel

the elusive curse of oil abstract our goal is to show that contrary to the claims made in several recent papers the effect of a large endowment of oil and other mineral resources on long term economic growth of countries has been on balance positive moreover the claims of a negative effect of oil and mineral wealth on the countries institutions are called into question