the effect of unions on productivity u s surface mining of coal the purpose of this paper is to compare the abilities of two competing analytical techniques mathematical programming and statistical regression to shed light on the union nonunion productivity differential in u s surface coal mining the programming approach has the virtues of being nonparametric and thus extremely flexible and of being able to provide a decomposition of productivity differentials into three components differences in technical efficiency differences in scale efficiency and differences in congestion identification of these three components provides an aid to management in its search for the sources of and remedies for productivity gaps the econometric approach on the other hand is neither flexible nor does it provide such a decomposition its chief virtue lies in the fact that being stochastic it allows for the presence of noise and measurement error that plagues most if not all empirical data thus the two approaches have complementary virtues the two techniques are used to investigate productivity in two samples of u s surface coal mines the programming approach finds a large and significant positive union nonunion productivity differential this differential is due primarily to greater congestion occurring in the smaller nonunion mines in one sample and to scale inefficiency in the smaller nonunion mines in the other sample the econometric analysis finds nearly the same union nonunion productivity differential but sheds no light on the composition of and thus the cure for the differential

the tale of two research communities the diffusion of research on productive efficiency abstract the field of theoretical and applied efficiency analysis is pursued both by economists and people from operational research and management science each group tends to cite a different paper as the seminal one recent availability of extensive electronically accessible databases of journal articles makes studies of the diffusion of papers through citations possible research strands inspired by the seminal paper within economics are identified and followed by citation analysis during the 20 year period before the operations research paper was published the first decade of the operations research paper is studied in a similar way and emerging differences in diffusion patterns are pointed out main factors influencing citations apart from the quality of the research contribution are reputation of journal reputation of author number of close followers colleagues cadres of proteges ph d students and extent of network invisible college such factors are revealed by the citing papers in spite of increasing cross contacts between economics and operations research the last decades co citation analysis reveals a relative constant tendency to stick to own camp references

nonparametric production technologies with weakly disposable inputs abstract in models of production theory and efficiency analysis the inputs and outputs are assumed to satisfy some form of disposability in this paper we consider the assumption of weak input disposability it states that any activity remains feasible if its inputs are simultaneously scaled up in the same proportion as suggested in the literature the shephard technology incorporating weak input disposability could be used to evaluate the effect of input congestion we show that the shephard technology is not convex and therefore introduces bias in evaluation of congestion to address this we develop an alternative convex technology whose use in the evaluation of congestion removes the noted bias we undertake a further axiomatic investigation and obtain a range of production technologies all of which exhibit weak input disposability but are based on different progressively relaxed convexity assumptions apart from the evaluation of input congestion such technologies should also be useful in applications in which some inputs are closely related or are overlapping and therefore satisfy only the weak input disposability assumption incorporated in the new models

estimation of returns to scale using data envelopment analysis a comment banker 1984 introduced the idea that the sum of the intensity variables in the dea activity analysis model can be used to identify returns to scale a counterexample in chang and guh 1991 shows that banker s method may fail this prompted banker and thrall 1992 to develop an alternative approach to estimate scale efficiency using dea seemingly unaware of the work by byrnes fare and grosskopf 1984 fare grosskopf and lovell 1985 1994 and fare and grosskopf 1985 etc on the same topic their new approach is very similar to the methodology originated in these references the purpose of this comment is to make our method known and to contrast it to the banker and thrall 1992 approach

barriers to efficiency and the privatization of township village enterprises abstract qian 2000 and others suggest that post 1994 tax and banking reforms in china combined with the development of markets for allocating resources influenced the economic performance of township village enterprises tves and private enterprises pes this paper uses chinese provincial level data to search for evidence of advantages and or disadvantages offered to tves and pes before and after the 1994 reforms we define a sectoral net income based measure of overall efficiency and decompose the measure into components that highlight the existence of credit constraints output target constraints and labour hiring constraints the results offer empirical support for qian and others explanation of why private enterprises eventually emerged as the dominant institution for allocating resources in post 1994 rural china

the structure of technical efficiency it is common practice to decompose measures of efficiency into component measures of technical and allocative efficiency in this paper we show how and why to decompose a general measure of technical efficiency into component measures of purely technical efficiency congestion and scale efficiency and we investigate the properties of each measure we do so for a multiple output technology which satisfies a weak axiom system that does not include either constant returns to scale or strong input disposability

some unsolved problems in data envelopment analysis a survey abstract the present study is a survey of a set of inherent characteristics and unsolved problems in current dea models we will focus on what types of local characteristics the dea estimated technology exhibits in relation to non jointness of a multi output multi input production no indicators are currently available telling the analysts whether or not the structure in data supports the existence of a joint technology if the estimated ccr technology has a sparse facet structure in the sense that few facets are active for output vectors in certain cones of the output space then the multi output multi input ccr technology is possibly locally non joint another important field of research relates to the inclusion of explicit distributional assumptions as part of the dea model specification and to the extension of the dea estimation from an estimation of a deterministic frontier towards an estimation of a stochastic frontier some recent results will be compared finally measures of scale economies from parametric models and dea models will be compared

dynamic data envelopment analysis modeling intertemporal behavior of a firm in the presence of productive inefficiencies abstract this study extends data envelopment analysis dea to a dynamic framework our dynamic dea not only provides a measure of dynamic productive efficiency but can also be used as a nonparametric alternative to the econometric modeling of the intertemporal behavior of a firm

efficiency and environmental regulation this paper proposes an extension of the enhancedefficiency indices of fare grosskopf lovell andpasurka 1989 that considers undesirable outputsasymmetrically by assuming that firms can freelydispose of some undesirable productions but areduction of other bad outputs generates a cost interms of desirable outputs this methodologicalapproach is used to analyse the relative efficiency ofa sample of spanish producers of wooden goods andfurnishings whose production process generates fourdifferent wastes we obtain efficiency indices thatserve to measure the impact on firm performance inseveral scenarios related to environmental regulationsaimed to reduce the production of wastes whenenvironmental regulations are assumed it is foundthat firms would have to sacrifice important amountsof potential desirable output in order to reallocateinputs into waste reduction secondly we find thatfirms associated with a technological institute aswell as firms located at a marshallian type industrialdistrict are likely to be less affected byregulations

agricultural externalities and environmental regulation evaluating good practice in citrus production economic activity takes place in a scenario characterized by an increasing number of environmental regulations aimed at bringing under control the emission of contaminating wastes in this paper we evaluate the impact of transforming a code of good practice in nitrogen fertilization on spanish citrus fruit farms into an environmental regulation of compulsory fulfilment using data envelopment techniques we calculate unrestricted and environmentally regulated short run maximum profits both profit values are then used to compute an index of the cost of regulation our results suggest that the cost of shifting from a merely recommended practice to a binding rule is low on average the loss of profit computed is only about 4 furthermore we find that farms overall efficiency is low and that the current gap between observed and regulated fertilization practices could be overcome by improving overall management efficiency

cyclicality of taxes and external debt abstractin their work vegh and vuletin have shown that statutory tax rates are acyclical in developed economies and procyclical in developing ones this article extends their analysis by checking the interaction of statutory tax rates with countries external public debt in general we found that the value added tax rates are changed procyclically in both developed and developing countries i e taxes are raised in bad times and reduced in good times however when the external debt is high in the developing countries the procyclicality increases while the opposite result holds for developed economies this pattern occurs mainly in times of recession when the need for loans is the highest although we found that there was a reduction in procyclicality after the 2000s these findings pose a challenge to policy makers who should think of ways of dealing with lack of foreign funds in difficult times

technical and scale efficiency of japanese commerical banks a non parametric approach not only are the nature and extent and scale efficiency of japanese commerical banks studied but a relationship between both organizational status and size efficiency is also announced the efficiency measures are computed from a 1990 sample of cross sectional data for the estimation we employ the non parametric approach which has recently been gaining popularity for the studies of banking efficiency outside japan

efficiency and technical change in the philippine rice sector a malmquist total factor productivity analysis regional differences in total factor productivity efficiency and technological change in the philippine rice sector are examined for the post green revolution era malmquist productivity indices were constructed for 1971 90 and were decomposed into efficiency and technological change the average annual malmquist productivity growth was only slightly positive productivity growth was negative during the early 1970s and was followed by a period of positive growth growth was negative again in the late 1980s the period of positive growth coincided with the introduction of new rice varieties while the declines are likely to have been caused by intensification of rice production in lowland farming systems certain regions such as central luzon western visayas and southern and northern mindanao had higher rates of technological change than others this may be due to higher investments in infrastructure and education increased adoption of tractors and a better agroclimatic environment

anticipating the consequences of school reform a new use of dea we use dea type linear programming techniques to simulate a basic component of educational reform eliminating restrictions on the allocation of school personnel our technique allows us to identify potential output gains or equivalently potential cost savings from reform we can also identify which personnel groups are likely to gain and lose under this reform when we apply our model to a sample of texas school districts we find evidence that the educational establishment has substantial economic rents to protect from school reform and that the primary beneficiaries of reform are likely to be affluent school districts with few minority students the technique which relies on the relationship between the direct and indirect distance functions can be easily generalized to measure the potential gains from removing other input restrictions such as union work rules environmental regulations or deed restrictions

static efficiency decompositions and capacity utilisation integrating economic and technical capacity notions starting from existing static decompositions of overall economic efficiency on nonparametric production and cost frontiers this article proposes more comprehensive decompositions including several cost based notions of capacity utilization furthermore in case prices are lacking we develop additional decompositions of overall technical efficiency integrating a technical concept of capacity utilization these new efficiency decompositions provide a link between short and long run economic analysis and in empirical work avoid conflating inefficiency and differences in capacity utilization an empirical analysis using a monthly panel of chilean hydro electric power plants illustrates the potential of these decomposition proposals

data envelopment analysis on a relaxed set of assumptions data envelopment analysis is a procedure for evaluation of the relative efficiency of units in a production system dea involves construction of composite units as convex combinations of other units inputs and outputs under various conditions related to returns to scale the assumption of convexity is inconsistent with increasing returns to scale and not implied by constant or non increasing returns to scale an alternative dea approach which does not invoke the assumption of a convex production possibility set is developed in this paper it is implemented in two stages stage one is concerned with the spanning of isoquants and stage two with an evaluation of the position of an observed input output combination compared to the isoquants both stages involve linear programming techniques solely

the efficiency of conventional fuel power plants in south korea a comparison of parametric and non parametric approaches abstract the efficiencies of the 64 conventional fuel power plants operating in south korea were determined by data envelopment analysis dea approaches as well as by a stochastic frontier method the banker charnes and cooper bcc dea efficiencies were introduced into an econometric estimate of a standard production function model leading to a corrected factors version of the model with significant improvement of the statistical explanation of our data a statistical analysis of the dea efficiencies was carried out and these were compared to efficiencies revealed by a stochastic frontier method

linear programming models for firm and industry performance programming models of technology are enjoying a revival in several strands of literature one such strand is the growing literature devoted to the assessment of firm performance based on the work of farrell 1957 and the later popularized by charnes cooper and rhodes 1978 under the name of data envelopment analysis dea for an early programming model see boles 1966 a second strand of literature seeks to model the industry production function and is associated with johansen 1972 fbrsund and hjalmarsson 1987 and aigner and chu 1968 a third strand of literature uses programming techniques such as nonparametric tests of regularity conditions in production see afriat 1972 hanoch and rothschild 1972 diewert and parkan 1983 and varian 1984 one of the purposes of this paper is to examine the relationship between the first two areas i e analysis of firm and industry programming models of technology and performance in order to compare the industry and firm models we restate them in a general programming form and ignore issues of functional form examination of these models in primal and dual form reveals that the industry approach constructs technology from firm data but allows hypothetical reallocation of aggregate resources across firms to yield an industry function the firm models also construct technology from the data on all firms in the sample industry but do not allow for reallocation of inputs across firms this suggests a natural hybrid an industry model which allows for both firm specific inputs and inputs which can be reallocated across firms the paper unfolds as follows we begin by presenting a stylized version of the aigner and chu and johansen models of industry production we

small island developing states and their economic vulnerabilities abstract many small island developing states sids face special disadvantages associated with small size insularity remoteness and proneness to natural disasters these factors render the economies of these states very vulnerable to forces outside their control a condition which sometimes threatens their very economic viability the gdp or gnp per capita of these states often conceals this reality in this paper the major vulnerabilities faced by sids are discussed and when possible quantified in the form of an index an attempt is also made to construct a composite index of vulnerability

property rights versus public spirit ownership and efficiency of u s electric utilities prior to rate of return regulation for over a century american economists have been engaged in a vigorous theoretical and empirical debate over the economic performance of publicly owned versus privately owned electric utilities the authors review the historical debate and use micro data collected by the u s commissioner of labor in 1897 98 to construct efficiency measures based on a nonparametric frontier production function since this is prior to state rate of return regulation regulatory effects do not confound the analysis the authors find that publicly owned electric utilities were significantly more efficient than their privately owned counterparts copyright 1991 by mit press

measuring efficiency with quasiconcave production frontiers abstract comparing with the frontiers derived from the data envelopment analysis dea and banker charnes cooper bcc methods the frontier derived from the free disposal hull fdh method is the closest to observed decision making units dmus and hence it can give each dmu the highest efficiency score however the frontier from the fdh method may not be a quasiconcave production frontier the production frontiers derived by petersen on the other hand may overstate inefficiency for some quasiconcave production frontiers this paper has used the minimum convex input requirement set and maximum convex output possible set to construct the closest quasiconcave production frontier for dmus by ordering dmus by input output level the dea method can be employed to estimate input based and output based efficiency scores

non parametric efficiency progress and regress measures for panel data methodological aspects this purely methodological paper deals with the role of time in non parametric efficiency analysis using both fdh and dea technologies it first shows how each observation in a panel can be characterized in efficiency terms vis a vis three different kinds of frontiers i contemporaneous ii sequential and iii intertemporal these are then compared with window analysis next frontier shifts outward and inward interpreted as progress or regress are considered for the two kinds of technologies and computational methods are described in detail for evaluating such shifts in either case these are also contrasted with what is measured by the malmquist productivity index finally an alternative way of identifying progress and regress independent of the frontier notion and referring instead to some benchmark notion is extended here to panel data

decomposing productivity indexes into explanatory factors abstract productivity measures are increasingly regarded as key indicators of economic performance identifying sources of productivity growth is of interest to both firms and policy makers this paper revisits the debate on how to decompose productivity growth into explanatory factors with a focus on extracting technical progress technical efficiency change and returns to scale components using bjurek s concept of the malmquist index introduced into production theory in a systematic way by caves christensen and diewert a reference technology is required to define the components of interest unlike other approaches ours do not make any convexity assumptions on the reference technology but instead follows the example of tulkens and his coauthors in assuming that the reference technology satisfies free disposability assumptions a new decomposition of a productivity index is provided with the existence and properties of the underlying distance functions of the decomposition proven under relatively unrestrictive assumptions the paper also provides for the first time a theoretical justification for the geometric average form of the bjurek productivity index these rigorous theoretical contributions provide significant avenues for enhanced understanding of empirical productivity performance

the measurement of productive efficiency a reconsideration the purpose of this paper is to generalize the farrell indexes of productive efficiency to nonhomothetic production technologies and at the same time maintain the cost interpretation of the farrell measures since the generalized indexes rely heavily on recent developments in the estimation of frontier cost and production functions several frontier models are reviewed in addition to generalized indexes of technical allocative and overall productive efficiency a variety of single factor efficiency measures are discussed the applicability of the proposed efficiency measures is illustrated with a numerical example of electric power generation

the role of the reference technology in measuring productive efficiency after a twenty year lull the measurement of productive efficiency is enjoying a revival in particular the index of efficiency developed by debreu i95i and later utilised by farrell i957 has received considerable attention these measures have been used fairly extensively in empirical work in both the operations research and economic literature these types of indexes have also appeared in the growing literature on testing for regularity conditions in production e g in afriat i972 diewert and parkan i983 and varian 1984 since the farrell type measure is the focus in this paper a brief review is useful in the farrell framework overall efficiency oe can be decomposed into two multiplicative components allocative efficiency ae and technical efficiency te

a note on banking efficiency in portugal new vs old banks following entry into the european community in 1986 portugal transformed rapidly its repressed banking system with deregulation the opening of borders the granting of new banking licenses and privatization in a more competitive banking system one would expect a priori an increase in operational efficiency this paper attempts to quantify the magnitude of efficiency gains over the years 1990 1995 moreover the paper documents the relative efficiency performance of new domestic banks not hampered by a legacy of inefficiency from the past they could operate nearer the efficiency frontier the case of portugal provides unique information on the joint effect of deregulation and the granting of new banking licenses on the change in operational efficiency of a previously repressed banking system

an indirect approach to the evaluation of producer performance in this paper we suggest a somewhat new analytical approach to producer performance evaluation the suggested approach is somewhat new in that it synthesizes existing analytical techniques from three areas and uses them to look at performance evaluation in a new way the approach is particularly relevant to public sector or service sector contexts in which the performance of alternative providers of a public service is to be evaluated in these contexts any of the following conditions may hold 1 the standard profit maximizing cost minimizing or revenue maximizing paradigms are inappropriate 2 prices of some services being provided or of some resources being consumed are either nonexistent or unobserved 3 observed prices are not exogenous due to monopoly or monopsony power examples abound it is frequently argued that the provision of medical legal educational transportation employment and many other services by public or private agencies is driven by goals other than the maximization of profit moreover these and many other services such as police and fire protection do not always have market prices with which to value them in addition the lack of competition in the provision of many such services and thus in the employment of specialized resources used in their provision makes it dangerous to use existing but distorted market prices to compare the performance of providers on the basis of revenue or cost much less profit