sheepskin effects in the returns to education some previous discussions have dismissed screening theories of education partly on the ground that diploma years of education do not confer especially large earnings gains similarly most empirical research on earnings functions has assumed an absence of sheepskin effects we report evidence however of substantial and statistically significant sheepskin effects although this suggests that the previous dismissals of the screening hypothesis were premature our evidence of sheepskin effects is amenable to nonscreening interpretations also according to screening theories of education individuals with more schooling tend to earn more not because or at least not solely because schooling makes them more productive but rather because it credentiates them as more productive a frequently cited article by layard and psacharopoulos 1974 however dismissed the importance of the screening hypothesis on the grounds that several of its refutable predictions were not supported by available evidence one of these was the sheepskin prediction that wages will rise faster with extra years of education when the extra year also conveys a certificate after surveying a number of studies layard and psacharopoulous henceforth lp concluded that rates of return to dropouts are as high as to those who complete a course which refutes the sheepskin version of the screening hypothesis since publication of the lp paper an undergraduate labor economics textbook has cited lp s analysis of sheepskin effects as telling criticism of the screening hypothesis a prominent proponent of the screening hypothesis riley 1979 has accepted lp s summary of the empirical evidence but responded that some versions of the screening hypothesis do not imply sheepskin effects in the meantime the ongoing flood of empirical research on earnings functions typically has continued to treat the natural logarithm of the wage rate as a linear or occasionally quadratic function of years of education with no allowance for discontinuities in diploma years 2 the estimated rates of return used by lp were based on data that did not disaggregate dropouts earnings by how many years of school they had completed lp acknowledged we would have preferred to show the earnings gain associated with each year of the course including the year when it was successfully completed this note presents a reanalysis of sheepskin effects based on the type of data lp wished they had the results contain very strong evidence of sheepskin effects after all the next section describes our analysis and the following section summarizes and discusses our

the incidence of personal income taxation evidence from the tax reform act of 1986 abstract this paper studies the short run incidence of personal income taxation in the us by examining how the wage structure shifted after the tax reform act of 1986 i calculate the marginal tax rate for the median worker of each occupation during the 1980s to determine the professions whose workers were most affected by the tax change when controlling for trends over time in the wage structure by occupation i find that individuals in occupations that experienced large decreases in their median marginal tax rates received lower pre tax wages after 1986 as the number of workers and the hours worked in those professions increased the results suggest that consideration of the wage effects of tax reforms is important when using these reforms to identify behavioral parameters and evaluating their distributional consequences

monopolistic competition increasing returns to specialization and output persistence abstract devereux et al economics letters 1993 41 57 61 showed that introducing together imperfect competition and increasing returns to specialization into real business cycle rbc type models results in making output more persistent than the underlying technology shocks we carry out a simple generalization of their model which clearly disentangles the two features and show that the added persistence is actually because of the increasing returns to specialization

does consumer sentiment forecast household spending if so why in the three months following the iraqi invasion of kuwait the university of michigan s index of consumer sentiment ics fell an unprecedented 24 3 index points to its lowest level since the 1981 1982 recession this collapse in household confidence became the focus of a great deal of economic commentary and indeed frequently was cited as an important if not the leading cause of the economic slowdown that ensued concern was fueled by the well known contemporaneous correlation between the ics and the growth of household spending figure 1 shows quarterly averages of the index 1978 1993 together with the quarterly growth in real personal consumption expenditures as measured in the national income accounts bureau of economic analysis the correlation is impressive of course it is not surprising that sentiment and the growth of spending are positively correlated this correlation may simply reflect that when economic prospects are poor households curtail their spending and also give gloomy responses to interviewers thus the contemporaneous correlation between sentiment and spending does not refute traditional life cycle or permanentincome models of consumption nor does it necessarily make the job of forecasting changes in consumption any easier from the point of view of an economic forecaster the questions of interest are first whether an index of consumer sentiment has any predictive power on its own for future changes in consumption spending and second whether it contains information about future changes in consumer spending aside from the information contained in other available indicators in section i we present evidence that the answer to the first question is a clear yes we find that lagged values of the ics taken on their own explain about 14 percent of the variation in the growth of total real personal consumption expenditures over the post1954 period further investigation shows that the answer to the second question is probably yes as well though here the margin is narrower and the evidence more murky the ics contributes about 3 percent to the r2 of a simple reduced form equation for total personal consumption expenditures in the longer of the two sample periods we examine but nothing in the shorter sample period though the latter result is heavily influenced by the observation for 1980 2 for the major subcategories of spending the contribution generally ranges between 1 percent and 8 percent overall we read the evidence as pointing toward at least some significant incremental explanatory power therefore we take as given for the remainder of the paper that sentiment forecasts spending and we turn to the issue of how that statistical relationship should be interpreted one possible interpretation is that sentiment is an independent driving factor in the economy and that changes in carroll division of research and statistics stop 80 federal reserve board washington dc 20551 fuhrer research department federal reserve bank of boston boston ma 02106 wilcox division of monetary affairs stop 71 federal reserve board washington dc 20551 we have benefited from the research assistance of stephen helwig and christopher geczy and the comments of an anonymous referee the views expressed in this paper are those of the authors and not of the federal reserve board the federal reserve bank of boston or the other members of the staff of either institution ithe conference board s consumer confidence index also plunged at the same time

the hyperbolic consumption model calibration simulation and empirical evaluation ur preferences for the long run tend to conflict with our short run behavior when planning for the long run we intend to meet our deadlines exercise regularly and eat healthfully but in the short run we have little interest in revising manuscripts jogging on the stairmaster and skipping the chocolate souffleala mode delay of gratification is a nice long term goal but instant gratification is disconcertingly tempting this gap between long run intentions and short run actions is apparent across a wide range of behaviors including saving choices a 1997 survey found that 76 percent of respondents believe they should be saving more for retirement looking only at respondents who believed they were at an age where you should be seriously saving already the survey found that 55 percent reported being behind in their savings and only 6 percent reported being ahead farkas and johnson 1997 the report on the survey concluded t he gaps between people s atti tudes intentions and behavior are troubling and threaten increased insecurity and dissatisfaction for people when they retire americans are simply not doing what logic and their own reasoning suggests they should be doing a 1993 luntz webber merrill lynch survey found similar answers when baby boomers were asked what percentage of your annual household income do you think you should save for retirement and what percentage of your annual

using subjective income expectations to test for excess sensitivity of consumption to predicted income growth abstract we test for precautionary saving and excess sensitivity of consumption to predicted income growth using a 1989 1993 panel survey of italian households that has measures of subjective income and inflation expectations these expectations provide a powerful instrument for predicting income growth the empirical specification controls for predictable changes in labor supply and allows a fairly general specification for the stochastic structure of the forecast error we find that consumption growth is positively correlated with the expected variance of income and uncorrelated with predicted income growth overall the results support the precautionary saving model

consumer confidence and rational expectations are agents beliefs consistent with the theory consumer confidence is found to have predictive content for a wide range of macroeconomic variables including consumption growth contrary to standard repih we find that on uk data the repih is rejected due to the predictive content of consumer confidence and not labour income we explain this finding in terms of precautionary behaviour extending the hansen and singleton consumption capm model to allow a conditional variance we find a high level of confidence is associated with both greater optimism about the level of consumption and greater uncertainty about the forecaster variance once allowance is made for time aggregation the over identifying restrictions implied by this model are accepted we estimate a small but statistically significant intertemporal elasticity of substitution

confidence and the real economy the japanese case this paper empirically analyses whether consumer confidence has an effect on the real economy in japan this paper uses vector autoregressions including variables which represent consumer confidence it is shown that in the cases of quarterly and monthly data consumer confidence has a significant effect on gdp fluctuations whereas in the case of semiannual data it has no effect in other words consumer confidence has an effect on only short term economic fluctuations

the social contingency of wants abstract economic models typically assume that individual wants are determined by forces exogenous to the economic system social psychology and consumer research in contrast support the view that the perceived benefits of goods and services are strongly affected by endogenously determined social norms we present a selective overview of the literature on the relationship between consumption and well being exploring the ways in which informal arguments from social science might be linked to formal models of economic behavior we find that the fixed preferences hypothesis leads to the systematic undervaluation of environmental services and the underprovisioning of environmental goods

choosing the joneses endogenous goals and reference standards a growing economic literature stresses the importance of relative comparisons e g for savings and consumption or happiness in this literature it is usually assumed that reference standards against which people compare themselves are exogenously given in contrast findings from social psychology suggest that people play an active role in determining their reference standards we introduce a social comparison model where people choose their reference standards to serve motives of self improvement and self enhancement the model predicts that reference standards increase in individuals abilities and that people thus tend to compare themselves to similar others the results of a questionnaire study confirm the prediction of the model

optimal linear income taxation in models with occupational choice the purpose of this paper is to investigate the implication of occupational choice for linear income taxation occupational choice is restricted to entrepreneurship versus wage earning different settings are considered concerning the introduction of uncertainty and that of individuals heterogeneity in ability or risk aversion for each setting an optimal tax formula is derived and shown to be made up of various components pertaining to insurance redistribution and efficiency

willingness to consume and ability to consume abstract george katona 1960 introduced the distinction between ability to buy and willingness to buy ability to buy refers to the objective factors determining actual purchases whereas willingness to buy captures subjective factors such as attitudes or moods i show that katona s theory can be reconciled easily with standard models of intertemporal utility maximization if one allows for a time varying preference parameter that is exogenous to the consumer and determined by the social environment such a willingness to consume model is tested against standard alternatives using data from seven european countries the empirical evidence rejects the permanent income hypothesis and supports the willingness to consume model

optimal linear income taxation with general equilibrium effects on wages abstract the paper argues that the endogeneity of wages may make a considerable difference to optimal linear tax rates in this case there is not only the usual direct redistribution via the fiscal system but also the general equilibrium redistribution due to the change in wages depending on the elasticity of substitution of the production function and the labour supply elasticities these may be reinforcing or opposing it is shown that the general equilibrium effect may plausibly outweigh the direct effect so that net redistribution to the lower paid involves a wage subsidy financed by a lump sum tax

long memory and persistence in aggregate output abstract we examine persistence in u s aggregate output by estimating fractionally integrated arima models these models provide better low frequency approximations to the wold representation than previous stochastic specifications and earlier results on the importance of a permanent component emerge as special cases we find evidence of long memory which induces persistence though this long memory need not be associated with a unit root our point estimates indicate that macroeconomic shocks while persistent are distinctly less persistent than many earlier studies suggest however confidence intervals associated with the long run response are quite wide

a theory of the consumption function with and without liquidity constraints fifteen years ago milton friedman s 1957 treatise a theory of the consumption function seemed badly dated dynamic optimization theory had not been employed much in economics when friedman wrote and utility theory was still comparatively primitive so his statement of the permanent income hypothesis never actually specified a formal mathematical model of behavior derived explicitly from utility maximization instead friedman relied at crucial points on intuition and verbal descriptions of behavior although these descriptions sounded plausible when other economists subsequently found multiperiod maximizing models that could be solved explicitly the implications of those models differed sharply from friedman s intuitive description of his model furthermore empirical tests in the 1970s and 1980s often rejected these rigorous versions of the permanent income hypothesis in favor of an alternative hypothesis that many households simply spent all of their current income today with the benefit of a further round of mathematical and computational advances friedman s 1957 original analysis looks more prescient than primitive it turns out that when there is meaningful uncertainty in future labor income the optimal behavior of moderately impatient consumers is much better described by friedman s original statement of the permanent income hypothesis than by the later explicit maximizing versions furthermore in a remarkable irony much of the empirical evidence that rejected the permanent income hypothesis as specified in tests of the 1970s and 1980s is actually consistent both with friedman s original description of the model and with the new version with serious uncertainty there are four key differences between the explicit maximizing models

choice of occupation tax incidence and piecemeal tax revision a model is presented where workers move between two different occupations in response to economic incentives which are distorted by an income tax wages assume equilibrium values which are affected by the tax parameters incidence and welfare effects of small tax revisions are analyzed with particular attention to the role of tax induced wage changes it is demonstrated that within the economic setting of the model such wage effects may be neglected in assessments of piecemeal tax revisions

let s get real a factor analytical approach to disaggregated business cycle dynamics this paper develops a method for analysing the dynamics of large cross sections based on a factor analytic model we use law of large numbers arguments to show that the number of common factors can be determined by a principal components method the economy wide shocks can be identified by means of simple structural var techniques and that the parameters of the unobserved factor model can be estimated consistently by applying ols equation by equation we distinguish between a technological and a non technological shock identification is obtained by minimizing the negative realizations of the technology shock empirical results on 4 digit industrial output and productivity for the u s economy from 1958 to 1986 show that 1 at least two economy wide shocks both having a long run effect on sectoral output are needed to explain the common dynamics 2 although the technological shock accounts for at least 50 of the aggregate dynamics of output it cannot by itself explain dynamics at business cycle frequencies 3 sector specific shocks explain the main bulk of total variance but generate mainly high frequency dynamics 4 both the technological and the non technological component of output show a peak for positive sectoral comovements of output at business cycle frequencies 5 technological shocks are strongly correlated with the growth rates of the investment in machinery and equipment sectors and their inputs many interesting questions about cyclical fluctuations and economic growth can be answered only by studying the dynamic behaviour of sectoral variables when data contain information on time for a large cross section of sectors traditional econometric techniques used in the macroeconomic literature such as vector autoregressive var and vector autoregressive moving average varma models are not appropriate since they require the estimation of too many parameters this is why new methods which allow for the reduction of the parameter space need to be developed the objective of this paper is both methodological and descriptive at the methodological level we develop a simple framework for the dynamic analysis of large cross sections the basic model is a dynamic factor analytic model as in sargent and sims 1977 the sectoral variables are decomposed into two unobservable components a common component driven by macroeconomic shocks and a purely sectoral component when

long memory and aggregation in macroeconomic time series this paper explores the interaction between long memory and aggregation results are derived which link the possibly fractional orders of integration of the aggregate series with those of the underlying series when the aggregation is either cross sectional or temporal in discrete or continuous time these results provide empirically testable hypotheses that are examined using six u k macroeconomic series a semiparametric method is found to be broadly consistent with the implications of the theory but fully parametric arfima models show considerable variation each series appears to be integrated of an order of between one and one and a half

aggregation persistence and volatility in a macro model we introduce firm heterogeneity into the standard monopolistically competitive real business cycle rbc model the fundamental equilibrium path is derived and the time series properties of aggregate gdp are studied analytically although firms productivities are subject to temporary shocks the aggregate process displays a surprising novel form of nonlinearity and long memory which had not been built into the model at the outset this aggregate gdp turns out to have very different properties from log linear time series models such as auto regressive ar models and their extensions it displays very strong persistence which ends abruptly with a sudden change of tendency giving its autocorrelation function acf an s shape although persistent it is mean reverting unlike the everlasting memory of unit root processes its volatility is of a greater order of magnitude than that of any of its components so small micro shocks can generate large macro fluctuations it is also characterized by long asymmetric cycles of random lengths increased monopoly power tends to reduce the amplitude and increase the

aggregation and simple dynamics the koyck geometric lag or ar 1 specification is a commonly proposed behavioral model sometimes after differencing the distribution of koyck lag or ar 1 coefficients across agents in an economy is shown to be completely identified just from the dynamic behavior of aggregate macroeconomic data aggregate testable implications of an economy composed of agents having koyck lags or ar 1 models are provided extensions to higher order and time varying lags are discussed aggregate u s consumption data are shown to support the hypothesis that some consumers have random walk consumption while the rest have arima 1 1 0 consumption with widely varying ar coefficients copyright 1994 by american economic association

the social and political consequences of overeducation this study employs national survey data to estimate the extent of overeducation in the u s labor force and its impact on a variety of worker attitudes estimates are made of the extent of overeducation and its distribution among different categories of workers according to sex race age and class background the effects of overeducation are examined in four areas of worker attitudes job satisfaction political leftism political alienation and stratification ideology evidence is found of significant effects of overeducation on job satisfaction and several aspects of stratification ideology the magnitude of these effects is small however and they are concentrated almost exclusively among very highly overeducated workers no evidence is found of generalized political effects of overeducation either in the form of increased political leftism or in the form of increased political alienation these findings fail to support the common prediction of major political repercussions of overeducation and suggest the likelihood of alternative forms of adaptation among overeducated workers

consumer confidence and economic fluctuations if consumers become pessimistic about the state of the economy can there be a slowdown in output even if their pessimism is not based on economic fundamentals recent macroeconomic models show the answer is yes if there are strategic complementarities and multiple equilibria we investigate the link between consumer confidence and economic fluctuations using vector autoregressions in all models after controlling for economic fundamentals the hypothesis that consumer sentiment does not cause gnp in the granger sense can be rejected variance decompositions suggest that consumer sentiment accounts for between 13 and 26 percent of the innovation variance of gnp

distributed lags aggregation and compounding some econometric implications this paper considers the aggregation of discrete distributed lags in the spirit of houthakker and johansen well known distributed lag models in econometrics are shown to arise from aggregation across heterogeneous microeconomic units the technique of analysis is based on the statistical theory of compound distributions the paper goes on to consider how consistently estimated macro distributed lags may be decomposed into two components which represent respectively the microeconomic response and the heterogeneity in that response related problems of identification and estimation and the interpretive value of the approach are also discussed and illustrations provided

the predictive power of the business and bank sentiment of firms a high dimensional granger causality approach we study the predictive power of industry specific economic sentiment indicators for future macro economic developments in addition to the sentiment of firms towards their own business situation we study their sentiment with respect to the banking sector their main credit providers the use of industry specific sentiment indicators results in a high dimensional forecasting problem to identify the most predictive industries we present a bootstrap granger causality test based on the adaptive lasso this test is more powerful than the standard wald test in such high dimensional settings forecast accuracy is improved by using only the most predictive industries rather than all industries

monopolistic competition technology shocks and aggregate fluctuations abstract we analyze a real business cycle rbc model in which aggregate production exhibits increasing returns to specialization in conjunction with imperfect competition and free entry and exit of firms over the business cycle we show that the requirements of both high variance and high persistence in technology shocks that have been noted by critics of rbc theory may arise from the assumptions of perfect competition and constant returns to scale rather than from the general proposition that real productivity shocks can significantly account for the business cycle

effort taxation and unemployment abstract the importance of the design of the income tax system for the incentive to supply effort is considered in a situation where firms set wages a tax reform raising marginal taxes at all income levels and increasing decreasing average taxes at high low income levels may lead to higher wages lower employment and higher unemployment

the optimal linear taxation of employment and self employment incomes abstract this paper models optimal linear taxation when occupational choice and labour supply are endogenous workers choose between paid employment self employment and unemployment self employment incomes are risky and employees may be involuntarily laid off calibrating the model to the uk economy the optimal tax solution involves relatively high taxation with substantial redistribution and a higher nominal but not effective marginal tax rate imposed on the self employed than on employees the implications of making unemployment benefits as well as tax rates endogenous are also analysed and robustness checks are performed

education and training an american perspective america is a country worried about its excess of life s necessities while many other countries are concerned about satisfying minimum daily nutritional needs we worry about overeating or improper diet so too while others fight illiteracy we discuss overeducation or misdirected schooling this is not a paper about cholesterol but about a system or lack of one which makes the school leaving decision almost entirely that of the student and which places so great an emphasis on college education as a means of achievement college and university will be used interchangeably hereafter that among the 1985 high school graduating class 58 per cent went on to further education cohany 1986