the role of the trade channel in the propagation of oil supply shocks abstract this paper analyzes when and why idiosyncratic oil supply shocks produce large macroeconomic effects in an analytically tractable two country general equilibrium model we focus on a demand driven mechanism the trade channel which transmits oil shocks across economies through changes in the non oil goods terms of trade when the trade channel is operative we have three main consequences on the transmission of oil shocks first the macroeconomic impact of oil shocks may be large and asymmetric across countries second the magnitude of the effects is nonlinear in the size of the oil shock third terms of trade movements never ensure international risk sharing after an idiosyncratic oil supply shock

international oil shocks and household consumption in china abstract we investigate the impacts that oil price shocks have on residential consumption in china while it is well understood that oil prices affect consumption in a multitude of ways the timing and directness of these effects on specific consumption categories is not clear we demonstrate that the most immediate and direct effect passes through transportation consumption as might be expected but we also show that significant effects pass through consumption in other sectors including food and clothes medical expenditure and other general living expenditure with less immediacy given the results particularly observed asymmetries with respect to rises and falls in international oil prices we discuss some implications for future adjustments to domestic price policies in particular the case for removal of domestic price regulation

household electricity demand revisited respond to price changes this paper develops a model for evaluating the effects of alternative tariff designs on electricity use the model concurrently addresses several interrelated difficulties posed by nonlinear pricing heterogeneity in consumer price sensitivity and consumption aggregation over appliances and time we estimate the model using extensive data for a representative sample of 1300 california households the results imply a strikingly skewed distribution of household electricity price elasticities in the population with a small fraction of households accounting for most aggregate demand response we then estimate the aggregate and distributional consequences of recent tariff structure changes recent efforts to restructure electricity markets have renewed interest in electricity demand and pricing this interest reflects a broad desire to improve the efficiency of electricity markets and policy makers concerns over the impact of price changes on consumers how new pricing mechanisms would affect households consumption and expenditures is a matter of considerable uncertainty however this uncertainty has provoked controversy and debate in the regulatory policy arena hampering market reforms using econometric methods to assess the effects of electricity price changes presents several challenges these include the nonlinear structure of tariff schedules aggregation of metered consumption behaviour over time and appliances and the interdependence of energy use with longer term household decisions over appliance ownership and dwelling characteristics the first two issues introduce complex simultaneity problems between marginal prices and consumption the third issue imposes high data requirements information on household specific appliance holdings and residence features and creates heterogeneity in consumption responses related to the characteristics of these durable goods when the researcher s objective is to develop a model for simulating the effects of prospective tariff changes ignoring these issues will provide an incomplete assessment of demand responses and potentially misleading predictions of a new tariff s consumption and revenue consequences in this paper we estimate a model of household electricity demand that can be used

energy price shocks and external balances this paper studies the impact of a wide set of energy price shocks on external balances using a two country framework comprising multiple sectors and endogenous energy production with convex costs the paper disentangles different demand and supply shocks in the energy market through their distinct impact on external balances it provides a theoretical confirmation of kilian et al 2009 and a theoretical foundation to the determining role of the non energy trade balance in the transmission of energy price shocks the presence of durables also highlights the immediate channel through which energy prices impact the non energy trade balance

energy and physical capital a case of non classical dynamics we study the importance of considering different energy requirements for physical capital and final good production in an overlapping generations olg resource economy in contrast to the standard olg framework but consistently with the empirical evidence we assume that the accumulation of physical capital requires more energy than the production of consumption goods focusing on exhaustible energy resources we find that olg equilibria can exhibit non classical dynamics the economy generates complex dynamics where differing from the response predicted by the standard approach resource prices may not increase monotonically this result illustrates that the technological assumptions behind the energy inputs should be taken with caution in particular on dynamic analyses involving exhaustible energy resources

time variation in the inflation passthrough of energy prices from bayesian estimates of a vector autoregression var which allows for both coefficient drift and stochastic volatility we obtain the following three results first beginning in approximately 1975 the responsiveness of core inflation to changes in energy prices in the united states fell rapidly and remains muted second this decline in the passthrough of energy inflation to core prices has been sustained through a recent period of markedly higher volatility of shocks to energy inflation finally reduced energy inflation passthrough has persisted in the face of monetary policy which quickly became less responsive to energy inflation starting around 1985

oil price shocks and the macroeconomy this paper examines the impact of oil price shocks and attempts to explain why the rise in oil prices up to 2008 had little impact on the world economy it makes three main arguments first that oil prices have never been as important as is popularly thought second that the most important route through which oil prices affect output is monetary policy when oil prices pass through to core inflation monetary authorities raise interest rates slowing growth based on the second argument the third argument is that high oil prices have not reduced growth in recent years because they no longer pass through to core inflation so the monetary tightening previously seen in response to high oil prices is absent it also argues that oil prices had little impact on the global recession of 20089

the short term impact of a domestic cap and trade climate policy on local agriculture a policy simulation with producer behavior this study is intended to develop understanding of possible impact of a domestic cap and trade climate policy on local agriculture we focus the study on the transition period after the policy has raised input prices for production but before establishment of new equilibrium in agricultural commodity markets we construct a policy simulation model based on production economics that explicitly considers producer behavior in the focal period we apply the model to a production region in the us to quantify the impact of different levels of carbon price on production cost production value and farm income our case study shows that 1 producers have ability to alleviate the cost impact 2 producers may benefit by selling carbon credits in the carbon market but the revenue is likely to be limited 3 the economic return of farm production is critical to the impact assessment 4 the impact may vary across producers and 5 regulation on the fertilizer industry is an important policy element that can influence the assessment of the impact this study has important implications for climate policy design

useful exergy is key in obtaining plausible aggregate production functions and recognizing the role of energy in economic growth portugal 1960 2009 abstract the role of energy in economic growth is controversial models based on aggregate production functions apf range from the neoclassical which downplay energy due to a cost share theorem but typically rely on exogenous total factor productivity tfp to the ecological economic which acknowledge energy s importance the validity of the apf concept itself is questioned here we apply cointegration analysis to identify apfs between output capital labor and possibly energy measured as primary energy or useful exergy we test for tfp growth by including a time trend we require that plausible apfs verify cointegration non negative output elasticities and granger causality linking inputs to output our method recognizes cases where a plausible apfs do not exist thereby addressing the apf critique b energy impacts growth directly c energy impacts growth indirectly through capital and labor we apply the method to portugal 1960 2009 considering standard and quality adjusted capital labor measures with a time trend or disregarding energy plausible apfs are never found without a trend plausible apfs are found only when considering capital energy labor combinations within these with quality adjusted capital and labor and useful exergy results are consistent with the cost share theorem but energy plays a central role through a constraint on all factors of production

relative energy price and investment by european firms abstract a dynamic model of investment is estimated with data on non financial firms in 15 european countries across 25 industries over 1991 2006 a rise in real energy price reduces the degree of persistence in the investment adjustment cost function panel results suggest that in manufacturing a 1 rise in real energy price reduces investment by a country s firms by 1 9 relative to that by firms in other countries with a smaller effect for non manufacturing firms the negative effect of a higher relative price of energy on firm level investment is significantly less marked the larger the firm results imply that stabilizing the relative price of energy would steady firm investment with greater gains in stability at smaller and medium sized firms results are robust to consideration of country business cycle effect and firm leverage estimation of investment is based on the euler equation approach with over 21 000 observations individual country regressions imply that a rise in the relative price of energy price has a statistically significant negative effect on firm level investment in 14 out of 15 countries to avoid dynamic panel bias estimation is by generalized method of moments with instrumental variables

allocative disturbances and specific capital in real business cycle theories chanted albeit in varying degree with business cycle theories that either posit unexplained nominal wage and price rigidities or rely on misperceptions about nominal variables as a key driving force one response to this disenchantment has been a concentration of research effort on real business cycle theories aside from dissatisfaction with competitor theories the very visible oil price shock episodes of the 1970 s lent plausibility to the view that exogenous real disturbances cause large fluctuations in aggregate economic activity this essay on real business cycle theory considers the role of allocative disturbances in aggregate economic fluctuations when human and physical capital are specialized by allocative disturbances i mean events that impinge on the economy by inducing a costly time consuming reallocation of specialized resources at least since the publication of ricardo s principles in 1817 economists have recognized some of the potentially important aggregate consequences of allocative disturbances ricardo writes

speculative storage in imperfectly competitive markets markets for many commodities are characterized by imperfectly competitive production as well as substantial storage by speculators who are attracted by significant price volatility we examine how speculative storage affects the behavior of an oligopoly producing a commodity for which demand is subject to random shocks speculators compete with consumers when purchasing the commodity and then subsequently compete with producers when selling their stocks resulting in two opposing incentives on the one hand producers would like to increase production to capture future sales in advance by selling to speculators while on the other hand they would like to withhold production to deter speculation thereby eliminating the additional supply from speculators in future periods we find that the incentive to sell to speculators can be quite strong potentially resulting in prices sufficiently high to drive consumers from the market furthermore these incentives are non monotonic in the number of producers speculative storage occurs more frequently in a relatively concentrated oligopoly than in the extremes of monopoly or perfect competition

the role of energy in real business cycle models abstract this paper modifies hansen s 1985 analysis of a real business cycle mode with indivisible labor by explicitly including energy as a productive input and modelling the relative price of energy as an exogenous random process one goal is to determine the extent to which the introduction of energy price shocks reduces the reliance of the real business cycle model on unobserved technology shocks the other goal following christiano and eichenbaum 1991 is to compare the correlation between real wages and hours predicted by the energy inclusive model to that predicted by hansen s model

oil price shocks and real gdp growth empirical evidence for some oecd countries this study assesses empirically the effects of oil price shocks on the real economic activity of the main industrialized countries multivariate var analysis is carried out using both linear and non linear models the latter category includes three approaches employed in the literature namely the asymmetric scaled and net specifications evidence of a non linear impact of oil prices on real gdp is found in particular oil price increases are found to have an impact on gdp growth of a larger magnitude than that of oil price declines with the latter being statistically insignificant in most cases among oil importing countries oil price increases are found to have a negative impact on economic activity in all cases but japan moreover the effect of oil shocks on gdp growth differs between the two oil exporting countries in the sample with the uk being negatively affected by an oil price increase and norway benefiting from it

stock returns and inflation with supply and demand disturbances we account for the relation between stock returns and inflation with two independent disturbances supply shocks and demand shocks supply shocks reflect real output shocks and cause a negative relation between stock returns and inflation while demand shocks are mainly due to monetary shocks and generate a positive relation between stock returns and inflation we show both theoretically and empirically that the stock return inflation relation varies over time and across countries depending on the relative importance of the two types of shocks our empirical evidence is based on pre and postwar periods in the united states as well as the postwar period in the united kingdom japan germany article published by oxford university press on behalf of the society for financial studies in its journal the review of financial studies

oil shocks and external balances abstract we provide estimates of the effects of demand and supply shocks in the global crude oil market on several measures of oil exporters and oil importers external balances including the oil trade balance the non oil trade balance the current account capital gains and changes in net foreign assets nfa first we show that the effect of oil demand and supply shocks on the merchandise trade balance and the current account which depending on the source of the shock can be large depends critically on the response of the non oil trade balance our results provide evidence of an intermediate degree of international financial integration second we document the presence of large and systematic valuation effects in response to these shocks valuation effects overall tend to cushion the effect of oil demand and supply shocks on the nfa positions of oil exporters and oil importers third we quantify the overall importance of global business cycle demand shocks as well as oil market specific demand and supply shocks for external balances

what happens during recessions crunches and busts we provide a comprehensive empirical characterization of the linkages between key macroeconomic and financial variables around business and financial cycles for 21 oecd countries over the period 1960 2007 in particular we analyse the implications of 122 recessions 113 28 credit contraction crunch episodes 114 28 episodes of house price declines busts 245 61 episodes of equity price declines busts and their various overlaps in these countries over the sample period our results indicate that the interactions between macroeconomic and financial variables can play a major role in determining the severity and duration of a recession specifically we find evidence that recessions associated with credit crunches and house price busts tend to be deeper and longer than other recessions stijn claessens m ayhan kose and marco e terrones

on the dynamic effects of oil price shocks a study using industry level data abstract this paper analyzes the effects of oil price shocks on demand and supply in various industries the impulse responses of identified var models indicate that for industries that have a large cost share of oil such as petroleum refinery and industrial chemicals oil price shocks mainly reduce supply in contrast for many other industries with the automobile industry being a particularly important example oil price shocks mainly reduce demand the paper suggests that oil price shocks influence economic activities beyond that explained by direct input cost effects possibly by delaying purchasing decisions of durable goods

the general equilibrium costs and impacts of oil price shocks in newfoundland and labrador abstract the 2014 2015 dramatic drop in world oil prices had devastating impacts on a global scale we analyse economic costs and impacts of a negative oil price shock following the 2014 2015 decrease in oil prices on the provincial economy of newfoundland and labrador canada we use a dynamic computable general equilibrium model to estimate a drop in oil prices by inputting the estimated effect as a direct impact to royalties which are the land input in the oil and gas sector of the provincial economy we provide sensitivity to account for the duration and magnitude of the shock as well as the timing of recovery our results suggest that a shock in the price of oil will have its most significant impact on gdp in the initial years over the first five years the reduction in gdp due to this shock would be roughly 2 1 of gdp in our most realistic shock scenario but could be much higher in other scenarios considered a sharp drop in gdp over the first five years will be mitigated somewhat in the long run as the growth in oil prices rises however negative long run impacts to gdp persist due to the oil price shock in 2014 2015 and will worsen if there is a prolonged shock

an identification robust test for time varying parameters in the dynamics of energy prices summary we test for the presence of time varying parameters tvp in the long run dynamics of energy prices for oil natural gas and coal within a standard class of mean reverting models we also propose residual based diagnostic tests and examine out of sample forecasts in sample lr tests support the tvp model for coal and gas but not for oil though companion diagnostics suggest that the model is too restrictive to conclusively fit the data out of sample analysis suggests a random walk specification for oil price and tvp models for both real time forecasting in the case of gas and long run forecasting in the case of coal copyright 2010 john wiley sons ltd

oil and the macroeconomy since world war ii all but one of the u s recessions since world war ii have been preceded typically with a lag of around three fourths of a year by a dramatic increase in the price of crude petroleum this does not mean that oil shocks caused these recessions evidence is presented however that even over the period 1948 72 this correlation is statistically significant and nonspurious supporting the proposition that oil shocks were a contributing factor in at least some of the u s recessions prior to 1972 by extension energy price increases may account for much of post opec macroeconomic performance

speculative bubbles in recent oil price dynamics evidence from a bayesian markov switching state space approach abstract motivated by repeated spikes and crashes during previous decades we investigate whether the heavily financialized market for crude oil has been driven by speculative bubbles in our theoretical modeling we draw on the convenience yield approach in order to approximate the fundamental value of the oil price we separate the oil price fundamental from the bubble component by expressing a standard present value oil price model in state space form we then introduce two markov regimes into the state space representation in order to distinguish between two distinct phases in the bubble process namely one in which the oil price bubble is a stable process and one in which the bubble explodes we estimate the entire markov switching state space specification using an econometrically robust bayesian markov chain monte carlo mcmc methodology based on inferential techniques designed for statistically separating both markov regimes in the bubble process from each other we find robust evidence for the existence of speculative bubbles in recent oil price dynamics

world steel production a new monthly indicator of global real economic activity this paper proposes world steel production as an indicator of global real economic activity world steel production data is published with only a one month delay thereby providing timely information for world real gdp forecasters we find that world steel production and lutz kilian s 2009 index of global real economic activity generate large gains in forecasting world real gdp relative to an autoregressive benchmark a forecast combination of world steel production kilian s 2009 index of global real economic activity and an index of the industrial production of oecd countries plus six non oecd emerging economies produces significant gains in forecasting world real gdp relative to an autoregressive benchmark

what do we learn from the price of crude oil futures summary despite their widespread use as predictors of the spot price of oil oil futures prices tend to be less accurate in the mean squared prediction error sense than no change forecasts this result is driven by the variability of the futures price about the spot price as captured by the oil futures spread this variability can be explained by the marginal convenience yield of oil inventories using a two country multi period general equilibrium model of the spot and futures markets for crude oil we show that increased uncertainty about future oil supply shortfalls under plausible assumptions causes the spread to decline increased uncertainty also causes precautionary demand for oil to increase resulting in an immediate increase in the real spot price thus the negative of the oil futures spread may be viewed as an indicator of fluctuations in the price of crude oil driven by precautionary demand an empirical analysis of this indicator provides evidence of how shifts in the uncertainty about future oil supply shortfalls affect the real spot price of crude oil copyright 2010 john wiley sons ltd

models of energy use putty putty versus putty clay energy use is inelastic in time series data but elastic in international cross section data two models of energy use reproduce these elasticities a putty putty model with adjustment costs developed by pindyck and rotemberg 1983 and a putty clay model in the pindyck rotemberg model capital and energy are highly complementary in both the short run and the long run in the putty clay model capital and energy are complementary in the short run but substitutable in the long run we highlight the differences in the cross section implications of the models by considering the effect of an energy tax on output in both models in the putty putty model an energy tax that doubles the price of energy leads to a fall in output in the long run of 33 in contrast the same tax in the putty clay model leads to a fall in output of only 5 3

a comparison of the effects of exogenous oil supply shocks on output and inflation in the g7 countries a comparison of the effects of exogenous shocks to global crude oil production on seven major industrialized economies suggests a fair degree of similarity in the real growth responses an exogenous oil supply disruption typically causes a temporary reduction in real gdp growth that is concentrated in the second year after the shock inflation responses are more varied the median cpi inflation response peaks after three to four quarters exogenous oil supply disruptions need not generate sustained inflation or stagflation typical responses include a fall in the real wage higher short term interest rates and a depreciating currency with respect to the dollar despite many qualitative similarities there is strong statistical evidence that the responses to exogenous oil supply disruptions differ across g7 countries for suitable subsets of countries homogeneity cannot be ruled out a counterfactual historical exercise suggests that the evolution of cpi inflation in the g7 countries would have been similar overall to the actual path even in the absence of exogenous shocks to oil production consistent with a monetary explanation of the inflation of the 1970s there is no evidence that the 1973 1974 and 2002 2003 oil supply shocks had a substantial impact on real growth in any g7 country whereas the 1978 1979 1980 and 1990 1991 shocks contributed to lower growth in at least some g7 countries jel e31 e32 q43

imperfect competition and the effects of energy price increases on economic activity the authors show that modifying the standard neoclassical growth model by assuming that competition is imperfect makes it easier to explain the size of the declines in output and real wages that follow increases in the price of oil plausibly parameterized models of this type are able to mimic the response of output and real wages in the united states the responses are particularly consistent with a model of implicit collusion where markups depend positively on the ratio of the expected present value of future profits to the current level of output copyright 1996 by ohio state university press

atheoretical macroeconometrics a critique abstract the spurious nature of the restrictions used to identify many macroeconometric models has led some researchers to advocate a style of econometric inquiry that is less dependent on prior theoretical restrictions of the sort that were central to the approach of the cowles commission this development which we call atheoretical macroeconometrics is summarized and evaluated in the current paper it is contrasted with an updated version of the cowles commission approach we conclude that while some of the exercises of atheoretical macroeconometrics are valid those that have attracted the most attention and appear the most innovative exogeneity testing impulse response analysis and policy analysis using estimated vector autoregressions are based on incorrect analysis

oil prices and the terms of trade abstract the combination of substantial terms of trade variability and unstable correlation patterns of trade prices with output and trade volumes has led some to suggest a break in the link between trade volumes and prices we find that oil accounts for much of the variation in the terms of trade over the last twenty five years and its quantitative role varies significantly over time and since our dynamic general equilibrium model predicts that the economy responds differently to oil supply shocks than to other shocks changes in their relative importance helps to account for the unstable correlations in the data

permanent household income and consumption in urban south america milton friedman s permanent income hypothesis pih is considerably more complex and difficult to test than it appears at first sight which is why certain of its postulates still cannot be accepted or rejected with certainty one of the chief difficulties is that of separating the effects on consumption of permanent income which is unobservable and of various observable household characteristics which may be highly correlated with permanent income but may also be presumed to affect consumption directly this difficulty can be overcome provided a variable can be found which is associated with permanent income but has no independent direct effect on the propensity to consume if households are grouped by classes of that variable the permanent consumption propensity or elasticity can be estimated from mean income and consumption in the groups this technique requires the assumption of zero mean transitory income in each group but does not depend on the postulate that transitory income is uncorrelated with consumption for these reasons it cannot be applied to individual households this paper presents and estimates a model which separates the direct and indirect effects on consumption of a series of observable characteristics using regression techniques on individual household observations this makes it possible to estimate all the parameters of the model both the consumption propensity or elasticity and the contribution to permanent income of each observable explanatory variable the technique still requires that at least one of the explanatory variables affect consumption only through permanent income but for all other variables both direct and indirect influences can be estimated and the propensity to consume a given income can vary among households with different characteristics another principal problem with the pih is the assumption that transitory income and consumption are uncorrelated efforts to test this postulate can lead to very different results ranging from agreement with the hypothesis to findings of high propensities to consume transitory income see robert ferber pp 1306 09 this inconsistency and continued controversy over the hypothesis is due to the fact that permanent income cannot be estimated exactly but can be known only with an error which is conceptually distinct from transitory income empirical work on the pih has uniformly overlooked this fact treating estimates of permanent income as exact and regarding the whole of the unexplained residual as transitory income the present model explicitly distinguishes the estimation error from the error of transitory income or consumption the two transitory components can then be assumed to be uncorrelated while the part of permanent income which is not explained is consumed exactly like the explained part whether residual income and consumption appear to be correlated or not then depends on the relative sizes of these two components the unexplained permanent part and the true transitory part this technique has the further advantage that estimating the variance of the error of estimation makes it possible to tell how well a set of observable variables explain permanentincome this explanation may be better than the brookings institution robert solow richard eckaus and robert hall supervised the dissertation 1974 on which this article is based i am particularly grateful to ross williams and robert hall for help in specifying and estimating the model and to denisard alves for a crucial suggestion william cline irwin friend ricardo ffrench davis and robert ferber provided helpful comments on earlier versions subsequent discussions with surjit bhalla and robert lawrence have been most useful i am also much indebted to the managing editor and to a referee for improvements in the final version

income and health spending evidence from oil price shocks health expenditures as a share of gdp in the united states have more than tripled over the past half century a common conjecture is that this is a consequence of rising income we investigate this hypothesis by instrumenting for local area income with time series variation in oil prices interacted with local oil reserves this strategy enables us to capture both partial equilibrium and local general equilibrium effects of income on health expenditures our central income elasticity estimate is 0 7 with 1 1 as the upper end of the 95 confidence interval which suggests that rising income is unlikely to be a major driver of the rising health expenditure share of gdp 2013 the president and fellows of harvard college and the massachusetts institute of technology

expectations learning and the changing relationship between oil prices and the macroeconomy this paper estimates a structural general equilibrium model to investigate the changing relationship between the oil price and macroeconomic variables the oil price through the role of oil in production and consumption affects aggregate demand and supply in the model the assumption of rational expectations is relaxed in favor of learning oil prices therefore affect the economy through an additional channel i e through their effect on the formation of agents beliefs the estimated learning dynamics indicates that economic agents perceptions about the effects of oil prices on the economy have changed over time oil prices were perceived to have large effects on output and inflation in the 1970s but only milder effects after the mid 1980s since expectations play a large role in the determination of output and inflation the effects of oil price increases on expectations can magnify the response of macroeconomic variables to oil price shocks in the estimated model in fact the implied responses of output and inflation to oil price shocks were much more pronounced in the 1970s than in 2008 therefore through the time variation in the impact of oil prices on beliefs the paper can successfully explain the observed weakening of the effects of oil price shocks on real activity and inflation

does the source of oil price shocks matter for south african stock returns a structural var approach abstract in this paper we investigate the dynamic relationship between different oil price shocks and the south african stock market using a sign restriction structural var approach for the period 1973 01 to 2011 07 the results show that for an oil importing country like south africa stock returns only increase with oil prices when global economic activity improves in response to oil supply shocks and speculative demand shocks stock returns and the real price of oil move in opposite directions the analysis of the variance decomposition shows that the oil supply shock contributes more to the variability in real stock prices the main conclusion is that different oil price shocks affect stock returns differently and policy makers and investors should always consider the source of the shock before implementing a policy and making investment decisions

energy consumption and economic growth in the united states abstractwe study the relationship between energy consumption and real gdp in the usa using a multivariate time varying model 1973q1 2014q1 we show that the combination of disaggregation into specific fuels and time variation gives more nuanced results than the alternatives for the usa specifically we find that the granger causal relationship between total energy and real us gdp is bi directional through much of the 1990s but unidirectional running from real us gdp to energy consumption in the 2000s as for each fuel similar patterns of change were observed in the causal relationship between coal consumption and real us gdp oil consumption largely shows a bi directional relationship between consumption and us gdp especially after 2009 and natural gas consumption shows a brief period in the early to mid 2000s where us gdp predicts energy consumption but primarily shows that natural gas consumption and economic growth are independent

are oil shocks inflationary asymmetric and nonlinear specifications versus changes in regime this paper identifies a structural break in core u s inflation phillips curves such that oil prices contributed substantially before 1981 but since that time pass through has been negligible this characterization is robust to a variety of re specifications and fits the data better than asymmetric and nonlinear oil price alternatives evidence does not support the hypotheses that declining energy intensity or deregulation of energy producing and consuming industries played an important role monetary policy did not itself become less accommodative of oil shocks but may have helped create a regime where inflation is less sensitive to price shocks more generally

oil prices and financial stress a volatility spillover analysis this paper examines whether there is a volatility transmission between oil prices and financial stress by means of the volatility spillover test we employ wti crude oil prices and cleveland financial stress index for the period 1991 2014 and divide the sample into pre crisis in crisis and post crisis periods due to the downward trend in oil price in 2008 the volatility model estimations indicate that oil prices and financial stress index are dominated by long run volatility the volatility spillover causality test supports evidence on risk transfer from oil prices to financial stress before the crisis and from financial stress to oil prices after the crisis the impulse response analysis shows that the volatility transmission pattern has similar dynamics before and after the crisis and is characterized by higher and long lived effects during the crisis our results have implications for both policy makers and investors and for future work

do gasoline prices respond asymmetrically to crude oil price changes the authors test and confirm that retail gasoline prices respond more quickly to increases than to decreases in crude oil prices among the possible sources of this asymmetry are production inventory adjustment lags and market power of some sellers by analyzing price transmission at different points in the distribution chain the authors attempt to shed light on these theories spot prices for generic gasoline show asymmetry in responding to crude oil price changes which may reflect inventory adjustment effects asymmetry also appears in the response of retail prices to wholesale price changes possibly indicating short run market power among retailers

the effects of oil price shocks on output and inflation in china crude oil price shocks derive from many sources each of which may bring about different effects on macro economy variables and require completely different designs in macro economic policy thus distinguishing the sources of oil price fluctuations is crucial when evaluating these effects this paper establishes an open economy dynamic stochastic general equilibrium dsge model with two economies china and the rest of the world to assess the effects of oil price shocks the ces production function is extended by adding oil as an input based on the model the effects of four types of oil price fluctuations are evaluated the four types of oil price shocks are supply shocks driven by political events in opec countries other oil supply shocks aggregate shocks to the demand for industrial commodities and demand shocks that are specific to the crude oil market simulation results indicate the following oil supply shocks driven by political events mainly produce short term effects on china s output and inflation while the other three shocks produce relatively long term effects in addition demand shocks that are specific to the crude oil market contribute the most to the fluctuations in china s output and inflation

this is what happened to the oil price macroeconomy relationship reply abstract james hamilton argues that oil price changes are still important for the macroeconomy and that using a filter which screens out drops and measures increases relative to a reference level wellrepresents the effects of price changes when they are choppy while this measure outperforms the oil price transformations considered in my paper much of its predictive power is coming from the pre 1986 and pre 1973 part of the sample with less than 10 years of choppy data finding the best oil price transformation will likely require analysis with cross sectional components ruling out effects from oil price decreases is also probably counterproductive to uncovering structure

gasoline prices transport costs and the u s business cycles abstract the effects of gasoline prices on the u s business cycles are investigated in order to distinguish between gasoline supply and gasoline demand shocks the price of gasoline is endogenously determined through a transportation sector that uses gasoline as an input of production the model is estimated for the u s economy using five macroeconomic time series including data on transport costs and gasoline prices the results show that although standard shocks in the literature e g technology shocks monetary policy shocks have significant effects on the u s business cycles in the long run gasoline supply and demand shocks play an important role in the short run

historical energy price shocks and their changing effects on the economy abstract the purpose of this paper is to identify the changes in the impact of energy shocks on economic activity with an interest in assessing if an economy s vulnerability and resilience to shocks improved with economic development using data on the united kingdom over the last three hundred years the paper identifies supply aggregate demand and residual shocks to energy prices and estimates their changing influence on energy prices and gdp the results suggest that the impacts of supply shocks rose with its increasing dependence on coal and declined with its partial transition to oil however the transition from exporting coal to importing oil increased the negative impacts of demand shocks more generally the results indicate that improvements in vulnerability and resilience to shocks did not progress systematically as the economy developed instead the changes in impacts depended greatly on the circumstances related to the demand for and supply of energy sources if these experiences are transferable to future markets a transition to a diversified mix of renewable energy is likely to reduce vulnerability and increase resilience to energy price shocks

the history of the phillips curve consensus and bifurcation while the early history of the phillips curve up to 1975 is well known less well understood is the post 1975 fork in the road the left fork developed a theory of policy responses to supply shocks in the context of price stickiness in the non shocked sector its econometric implementation interacts shocks with backward looking inertia the right fork approach emphasizes forward looking expectations that can jump in response to anticipated policy changes the left fork approach is better suited to explaining the postwar us inflation process while the right fork approach is essential for understanding behaviour in economies with unstable macroeconomic environments the history of the phillips curve pc has evolved in two phases before and after 1975 with a widespread consensus about the pre 1975 evolution which is well understood bifurcation begins in 1975 when the pc literature split down two forks of the road with little communication or interaction between the two forks the major contribution of this paper and hence the source of bifurcation in its subtitle is to examine contrast and test the contributions of the two post 1975 forks the pre 1975 history is straightforward and is covered in section i the initial discovery of the negative inflation unemployment relation by phillips popularized by samuelson and solow was followed by a brief period in which policy makers assumed that they could exploit the trade off to reduce unemployment at a small cost of additional inflation then the natural rate revolution of friedman phelps and lucas overturned the policy exploitable trade off in favour of long run monetary neutrality those who had implemented the econometric version of the trade off pc in the 1960s reeled in disbelief when sargent demonstrated the logical failure of their test of neutrality and finally were condemned to the wreckage of keynesian economics by lucas and sargent following the twist of the inflation unemployment correlation from negative in the 1960s to positive in the 1970s the architects of neutrality and the opponents of the keynesian trade off emerged triumphant with two major caveats that their own models based on information barriers were unconvincing and that their core result that business cycles were driven by monetary or price surprises floundered without supporting evidence after 1975 the evolution of the pc literature split in two directions each of which has largely failed to recognize the other s contributions section ii reviews the left fork of the road the revival of the pc trade off in a coherent and integrated dynamic aggregate supply and demand framework that emerged in the late 1970s in econometric tests in theoretical contributions and in intermediate macro textbooks this approach which i have called mainstream is resolutely keynesian because the inflation rate is dominated by persistence and inertia in the form of long lags on past inflation an important difference between the mainstream approach and other post 1975 developments is that the role of past inflation is not limited to the formation of expectations but also includes a pure persistence effect due to fixed duration wage and price contracts and lags between

a neoclassical model of unemployment and the business cycle this paper investigates a general equilibrium model of unemployment and the business cycle in which specialization of labor plays a key role a rational expectations equilibrium with fully flexible wages and prices can exhibit unemployment in which the marginal product of employed workers exceeds the reservation wage of those who are without jobs workers are unemployed either because they are in the process of relocating for a better job or because they are waiting for conditions in the depressed sector to improve moreover seemingly small disruptions in the supplies of primary commodities such as energy could be the source of fluctuations in aggregate employment and can exert surprisingly large effects on real output

what happened to the oil price macroeconomy relationship abstract strong evidence is found that oil prices no longer granger cause many u s macroeconomic indicator variables in data after 1973 a number of potential explanations are explored that sample stability issues are responsible that oil prices are now endogenous and that linear and symmetric specifications misrepresent the form of the oil price interaction none of these hypotheses are supported by the data the opec price increases do appear to have had significant impacts while the effects of the price declines of the 1980s are smaller and harder to characterize these results have potentially important implications for the large body of research which utilizes oil prices as an instrumental or explanatory variable

oil prices monetary policy and counterfactual experiments recessions are associated with both rising oil prices and increases in the federal funds rate are recessions caused by the spikes in oil prices or by the sharp tightening of monetary policy this paper discusses the difficulties in disentangling these two effects

the effects of the corporate average fuel efficiency standards in the us this paper examines the effects of the corporate average fuel economy standards cafe on automobile sales prices and fuel consumption first a discrete choice model of automobile demand and a continuous model of vehicle utilization are estimated using micro data from the consumer expenditure survey for 1984 1990 next the demand side model is combined with a model of oligopoly and product differentiation on the supply side with these elements in place the effects of the cafe regulation are assessed through simulations and compared to the effects of alternative policy instruments such as an increase in gasoline tax

oil and the macroeconomy since the 1970s economists have long been intrigued by empirical evidence that suggests that oil price shocks may be closely related to macroeconomic performance this interest dates back to the 1970s the 1970s were a period of growing dependence on imported oil unprecedented disruptions in the global oil market and poor macroeconomic performance in the united states thus it was natural to suspect a causal relationship from oil prices to u s macroeconomic aggregates since then a large body of work has accumulated that purports to establish this link on theoretical grounds and to provide empirical evidence in its support we do not attempt a comprehensive survey of this literature but rather provide an idiosyncratic synthesis of what we view as the key issues in this debate and the insights gained over the last 30 years the timing seems right for such an account although the experience of the 1970s continues to play an important role in discussions of the link between oil and the macroeconomy there have been a number of new oil price shocks since the 1970s notably the 1986 collapse of oil prices and the 2000 boom in oil prices as well as the oil price increases associated with the 1990 1991 gulf war and the 2003 iraq war given this richer case history we are arguably in a better position than two decades ago to distinguish the idiosyncratic features of each oil crisis from the systematic effects increases in oil prices have been held responsible for recessions periods of excessive inflation reduced productivity and lower economic growth in this paper we review the arguments supporting such views first we highlight some of the conceptual difficulties in assigning a central role to oil price shocks in explaining

this is what happened to the oil price macroeconomy relationship abstract many of the quarterly oil price increases observed since 1985 are corrections to even bigger oil price decreases the previous quarter when one looks at the net increase in oil prices over the year recent data are consistent with the historical correlation between oil shocks and recessions

analysing gasoline demand elasticities a survey this paper is a survey of studies on gasoline demand although there are very many dxerent studies in this eld which sometimes appear to arrive at contradictory results we find that with proper stratification of studies by model and data type much of the contict turns to consensus in this survey we classtfy studies by data type and by ten d erent categories of model and with the exception of estimates on seasonal data which tend to be unstable and of certain inappropriate model formulations we find a fair degree of agreement concerning average short run and even long run income and price elasticities

how sensitive are consumer expenditures to retail energy prices abstract there is growing evidence that the primary effect of energy price shocks on the u s economy involves a reduction in consumer spending we quantify the direct effect on real consumption of unanticipated changes in discretionary income shifts in precautionary savings and changes in the operating cost of energy using durables the possibility of asymmetries in the response of real consumption to energy price shocks is also considered we demonstrate that linear models are consistent with the symmetric behavior of real consumption in 1979 when energy prices increased sharply and in 1986 when they fell sharply it is shown that historically energy price shocks have been an important factor in explaining u s real consumption growth but by no means the dominant factor

exogenous oil supply shocks how big are they and how much do they matter for the u s economy abstract the paper proposes a new measure of exogenous oil supply shocks the timing the magnitude and the sign of this measure may differ greatly from current state of the art estimates it is shown that only a small fraction of the observed oil price increases during oil crisis periods can be attributed to exogenous oil production disruptions exogenous oil supply shocks cause a sharp drop of u s real gdp growth after five quarters rather than an immediate and sustained reduction in economic growth and a spike in cpi inflation after three quarters overall exogenous oil supply shocks made remarkably little difference for the evolution of the u s economy since the 1970s although they did matter for some historical episodes

saving money vs investing money do energy ratings influence consumer demand for energy efficient goods abstract the article analyses economic barriers leading to the energy efficiency gap in the market for energy using products by observing several million transactions in the uk over two years the empirical exercise estimates aids models for refrigerators washing machines tvs and light bulbs results indicate that market barriers are crucial in the demand for energy efficient options and consumer response to changes in appliance prices total expenditures and energy prices depends on the possibility of behavioural adjustments in consumption in contrast with the induced innovation hypothesis current electricity prices can fail to induce innovation because of their short term impact on disposable income while consumers invest in energy efficiency when expecting electricity prices to rise in the future

relative price variability real shocks and the stock market in this paper we investigate the effects of relative price variability on output and the stock market and gauge the extent to which inflation proxies for relative price variability in stock return inflation regressions the evidence shows that the negative stock returninflation relations proxy for the adverse effects of relative price variability on economic activity particularly during the seventies when the u s experienced oil supply shocks hence it appears that inflation spuriously affects the stock market in two ways the aggregate output link of fama 1981 and the supply shocks reflected in relative price variability a number of papers have attempted to explain the anomalous negative relations between stock returns and inflation witnessed in the post war period one hypothesis that has held up well in light of empirical evidence suggests that the negative relation between stock returns and unexpected inflation simply reflects the more fundamental positive relation between stock returns and future real variables see e g fama 1981 geske and roll 1983 and kaul 1987 1989 in this paper we investigate the effects of relative price variability on output and the stock market and gauge the extent to which inflation proxies for relative price variability in stock return inflation regressions first relative price variability can have detrimental effects on output and employment see e g friedman 1977 and barro 1976 second absolute relative price confusion models of the lucas 1973 type suggest that monetary shocks can induce a positive relation between inflation and relative price variability see e g cukierman 1983 hence the negative stock return inflation relations could simply be a reflection of the negative effects of relative price variability on the stock market we use data for the 1947 1985 period to test the various links of our hypothesis the results indicate that relative price variability is positively related to both expected and unexpected inflation measures relative price variability also has a significant negative effect on output and the stock market more importantly

the economic effects of energy price shocks large fluctuations in energy prices have been a distinguishing characteristic of the u s economy since the 1970s turmoil in the middle east rising energy prices in the u s and evidence of global warming recently have reignited interest in the link between energy prices and economic performance this paper addresses a number of the key issues in this debate what are energy price shocks and where do they come from how responsive is energy demand to changes in energy prices how do consumers expenditure patterns evolve in response to energy price shocks how do energy price shocks affect u s real output inflation and stock prices why do energy price increases seem to cause recessions but energy price decreases do not seem to cause expansions why has there been a surge in the price of oil in recent years why has this new energy price shock not caused a recession so far have the effects of energy price shocks waned since the 1980s and if so why as the paper demonstrates it is critical to account for the endogeneity of energy prices and to differentiate between the effects of demand and supply shocks in energy markets when answering these questions

the role of model uncertainty and learning in the u s postwar policy response to oil prices abstract this paper studies optimal monetary policy in a framework that explicitly accounts for policymakers uncertainty about the channels of transmission of oil prices into the economy more specifically using postwar us data i examine the evolution of the policy recommendations originating from an optimal linear regulator problem that encompasses model uncertainty and learning as proposed by cogley and sargent 2005b in this environment i find that one of the underlying models dominates the robust interest rate response to oil prices and i show that this result is due to the instability of this specification in the sample period under analysis

energy price shocks and the macroeconomy the role of consumer durables so far the literature on dynamic stochastic general equilibrium models with energy price shocks uses energy on the production side only in these models energy shocks are responsible for only a negligible share of output fluctuations we study the robustness of this finding by explicitly modeling private consumption of energy at the household level in addition to energy use at the firm level to account for total energy use in the economy additionally we distinguish between investment in consumer durables and investment in capital goods the model economy is calibrated to match total energy use and durable goods consumption as observed in the u s data simulation results indicate that despite higher total energy use this economy has an even smaller proportion of output fluctuations attributable to energy price shocks productivity shocks continue to be the primary force behind business cycle fluctuations the driving force behind our results is that the household now has the flexibility to rebalance its investment portfolio specifically the energy price hike is absorbed by reducing durable goods investment more than investment in capital goods thereby cushioning the hit to future production at the expense of current consumption hence our model better matches the consumption volatility observed in the data jel classification e32 q43

oil shocks and aggregate macroeconomic behavior the role of monetary policy hamilton and herrera hh have provided an interesting comment on our 1997 paper bernanke gertler and watson 1997 bgw we take the opportunity offered to us by the editors to respond briefly the goal of bgw was to show that the magnitude and shape of the economy s response to a particular exogenous shock will typically depend critically on how monetary policy makers choose to react to the shock as a consequence we argued that assessments of the importance of monetary policy for real activity should take into account the systematic portion of policy i e the policy rule as well as the unsystematic component i e monetary policy shocks the specific type of exogenous shock that we considered in bgw was a sharp increase in the price of oil of the magnitude observed during several episodes in the 1970s using a modified var framework we considered counterfactual scenarios in which monetary policy represented by the level of the federal funds rate does not respond to an oil price shock we found that the adverse effects of an oil price shock on output are reduced considerably when the endogenous response of the funds rate is shut off indeed our point estimates suggested that the endogenous response of monetary policy accounted for virtually all the negative impact of the oil shock on this research was funded in part by nsf grants to each of the authors we thank michele cavallo for research assistance

common cycles and common trends in the stock and oil markets evidence from more than 150 years of data abstract this paper investigates the role of permanent and transitory shocks within the framework of common cycles and common trends in explaining stock and oil prices we perform a multivariate variance decomposition analysis of monthly data on the west texas intermediate wti oil price and the s p 500 the dataset used in the study spans a long period of 150 years and therefore contains a rich history to examine both the short and long run comovement properties of oil and stock prices given that the oil and stock markets might comove both in the short and long run it is of interest to see the relative impacts of transitory and permanent shocks on both variables we find that log oil price and log s p 500 share a common stochastic trend for our full sample of september 1859 to july 2015 but a common cycle only exists during the post ww ii period full and post ww ii samples have quite different common feature estimates in terms of the impact of permanent and transitory shocks as measured by the impulse responses and forecast error variance decompositions we also find that in the short run oil is driven mostly by cycles transitory shocks and stock market is mostly driven by permanent shocks but permanent shocks dominate in the long run

speculation and volatility spillover in the crude oil and agricultural commodity markets a bayesian analysis this paper assesses factors that potentially influence the volatility of crude oil prices and the possible linkage between this volatility and agricultural commodity markets stochastic volatility models are applied to weekly crude oil corn and wheat futures prices from november 1998 to january 2009 model parameters are estimated using bayesian markov chain monte carlo methods speculation scalping and petroleum inventories are found to be important in explaining the volatility of crude oil prices several properties of crude oil price dynamics are established including mean reversion an asymmetry between returns and volatility volatility clustering and infrequent compound jumps we find evidence of volatility spillover among crude oil corn and wheat markets after the fall of 2006 this can be largely explained by tightened interdependence between crude oil and these commodity markets induced by ethanol production

oil and the economy a systematic review of the literature for ecological economists abstract this article offers a systematic review of the mainstream literature in oil economics macroeconomics international and financial economics and political economy complementing and complicating the way ecological economics understands the links between oil and the economy we look at the supply and demand factors that affect oil prices the ways oil prices affect the economy the effect of interest rates capital flows and exchange rates on oil prices and extraction and the role of geo politics in governing oil and money flows we develop an illustrative system model of the causal pathways that link oil and the economy and compare alternative explanations of the oil price shocks of the 1970s and 2000s the emphasis of ecological economics on peak oil and resource limits to growth may be relevant over the long run but is less capable of explaining precisely how oil contributes to concrete economic short run crises now

segment shifts and capacity utilization in the u s automobile industry an important school of thought argues that sectoral shifts may account for a substantial portion of aggregate fluctuations e g david lilien 1982 fischer black 1987 steven davis 1987 events such as the oil shocks of the 1970 s exchange rate fluctuations and shifts in government spending have their direct effect on the composition of economic activity the sectoral shift literature argues that they may affect the level and the dynamics of output and employment as well the typical story is of a slowly functioning labor market after a sectoral shock search behavior matching problems and a time cost of switching sectors slow the reallocation of workers across sectors this focus however misses important elements of the reallocation problem as black 1987 has argued not only sector specific human capital but also complementary physical and managerial engineering organization etc capital must be reallocated or recreated in response to sectoral shocks if jobs are linked to capital then the slow adjustment of labor may be attributable in part to the sluggishness in the adjustment of capital this paper presents an empirical study of the impact of oil shock sectoral shifts within the u s automobile industry from an analytical perspective a sectoral shift is any event that raises desired output and employment in some sectors and lowers them in others for our purposes a sector is a size class of automobiles within the automobile industry we will be able to study two distinct questions first did the oil priceinduced shocks to the composition of demand interact with short run rigidities in supply to limit industry wide capacity utilization we will quantify the extent to which the changing composition of demand was reflected in a lower aggregate output level with obvious consequences for the employment of capital and of labor and for the return to firms knowledge capital our second question concerns the pace of the intermediate run adjustment to sectoral shocks how rapidly could capital and labor be reallocated to new demand conditions such considerations determine the impact of sectoral shocks on employment and capacity utilization dynamics

forecasting the real prices of crude oil using forecast combinations over time varying parameter models abstract in this paper we forecast real prices of crude oil using real time forecast combinations over time varying parameter tvp models with single predictor we reveal the significant predictability at all horizons up to 24 months the mean squared predictive error reduction over the benchmark of no change forecast is as high as 17 and the directional accuracy as high as 0 645 a combination with tvp models is found to generate more accurate forecasts than the same combination with constant coefficient models because the forecast errors of individual tvp models are correlated at a lower degree we also evaluate the forecasting performance in the framework of density forecasting our results indicate that the benchmark model can be significantly outperformed by forecast combination at the horizons longer than 3 months

why are prices sticky the dynamics of wholesale gasoline prices the menu cost interpretation of sticky prices implies that the probability of a price change should depend on the past history of prices and fundamentals only through the gap between the current price and the frictionless price we find that this prediction is broadly consistent with the behavior of nine philadelphia gasoline wholesalers nevertheless we reject the menu cost model as a literal description of these firms behavior arguing instead that price stickiness arises from strategic considerations of how customers and competitors will react to price changes

do oil price increases cause higher food prices us retail food price increases in recent years may seem large in nominal terms but after adjusting for inflation have been quite modest even after the change in us biofuel policies in 2006 in contrast increases in the real prices of corn soybeans wheat and rice received by us farmers have been more substantial and can be linked in part to increases in the real price of oil that link however appears largely driven by common macroeconomic determinants of the prices of oil and of agricultural commodities rather than the pass through from higher oil prices we show that there is no evidence that corn ethanol mandates have created a tight link between oil and agricultural markets moreover increases in agricultural commodity prices have contributed little to us retail food price increases because of the small cost share of agricultural products in food prices in short there is no evidence that oil price shocks have been associated with more than a negligible increase in us retail food prices in recent years nor is there evidence for the prevailing wisdom that oil price driven increases in the cost of food processing packaging transportation and distribution have been responsible for higher retail food prices similar results hold for other industrialized countries there is reason however to expect food commodity prices to be more tightly linked to retail food prices in developing countries christiane baumeister and lutz kilian

storable good monopoly the role of commitment we study dynamic monopoly pricing of storable goods in an environment where demand changes over time the literature on durables has focused on incentives to delay purchases our analysis focuses on a different intertemporal demand incentive for consumers the key force on the consumer side is advance purchases or stockpiling this stockpiling motive can be present in the case of standard durables as well in environments unmodeled in the prior literature we show that if the monopolist cannot commit then prices are higher in all periods and social welfare is lower than in the case in which the monopolist can commit this is in contrast with the durable goods analysis in the literature on the coase conjecture

oil and the macroeconomy when prices go up and down an extension of hamilton s results in an important paper hamilton 1983 demonstrated a strong correlation between oil price changes and gross national product growth in u s data however his study pertained to a period in which all the large oil price movements were upward and thus it left unanswered the question whether the correlation persists in periods of price decline moreover the price variable he used was somewhat distorted by price controls in the 1970s this note investigates whether hamilton s results continue to hold when the sample is extended to include the recent oil market collapse and the oil price variable is corrected for the effects of price controls particular attention is given to the possibility of asymmetric responses to oil price increases and decreases as suggested in the structural employment literature loungani 1986 davis 1987 hamilton 1988 like hamilton i based my investigation on the gnp equation in sims s 1 980b six variable quarterly vector autoregressive model

oil shocks and aggregate macroeconomic behavior the role of monetary policy a recent paper by bernanke gertler and watson 1997 suggests that monetary policy could be used to eliminate any recessionary consequences of an oil price shock this paper challenges this conclusion on two grounds first we question whether the federal reserve actually has the power to implement such a policy for example we consider it unlikely that additional money creation would have succeeded in reducing the fed funds rate by 900 basis points relative to the values seen in 1974 second we point out that the size of the effect that bernanke gertler and watson attribute to oil shocks is substantially smaller than that reported by other researchers primarily due to their choice of a shorter lag length than that used by other researchers we offer evidence in favor of the longer lag length employed by previous research and show that under this specification even the aggressive federal reserve policies proposed would not have succeeded in averting a downturn