optimal incentive schemes with many agents the grossman hart principal agent model of moral hazard is extended to the multiple agent case to explore the use of relative performance in optimal incentive contracting under the assumption that the principal chooses incentive schemes to implement agent actions as nash equilibria necessary and sufficient conditions are derived for the optimality of independent contracts of rank order tournaments and for attainability of the first best in this context the relation of the principal s welfare to the correlation between the underlying randomness in outputs of different agents is also investigated finally some problems with the nash equilibrium implementation assumption are discussed in this paper we extend the grossman hart analysis of the principal agent problem to a multiple agent setting in this version of the problem a risk neutral principal is assumed to observe the output or a performance index for each risk averse agent the output of any agent depends on a privately observable action chosen by the agent and an exogenous random variable the realization of which is not observed either by the principal or by the agent before choosing its action we especially focus attention on the role of relative performance evaluation in optimal incentive contracts and the way this depends on properties of the underlying production technology and the joint distribution of the random variables affecting the outputs of different agents in section 2 of the paper we consider the principal s problem of finding an optimal incentive scheme and an action tuple for agents subject to the constraint that the latter be implemented as a nash equilibrium between agents by the chosen incentive scheme where agents must attain at least their reservation utilities a characterization of optimal incentive schemes is derived analogous to the grossman hart characterization for the single agent problem this characterization is then utilized to find sufficient and generically necessary conditions for a optimal contracts for any agent to be independent of the performance of other agents and b optimality of rank order tournaments where payments depend solely on ordinal comparisons of output across agents we then describe a necessary and sufficient condition for the principal to extract maximum advantage from relative performance clauses i e achieve the first best level of expected utility in the multiagent situation an implication of this result is that under fairly weak conditions perfect correlation in the underlying production uncertainties for different agents enables the principal to attain the first best if and only if sufficiently heavy penalties can be inflicted on agents we then enquire what happens in intermediate cases of non perfect correlation it turns out that while in general the principal s welfare is a continuous function of the correlation coefficient it is not always nondecreasing in the latter because the correlation coefficient is not a general measure of association between two random variables but rather a measure of linear association between them

symposium on globalization in perspective an introduction the principle of comparative advantage is one of the crown jewels of the economics profession the idea that all nations gain from trade even when one of them may have an absolute cost advantage in producing everything is subtle in its logic yet powerful in its implications ever since 1817 when david ricardo worked out his example of trade between england and portugal in wine and cloth the principle has shaped the way that economists view the world and it serves as the basis for our profession s overwhelming support for free trade the success that economists have had in swaying minds over the desirability of open economic borders has waxed and waned over the centuries i don t know much about the tariff but i know this much abraham lincoln is supposed to have said when we buy manufactured goods abroad we get the goods and the foreigner gets the money when we buy the manufactured goods at home we get both the goods and the money to economists consternation political discourse about trade policy has not improved much since lincoln s time ask yourself how many members of congress today or for that matter how many of your faculty colleagues in other departments would recognize the fallacy in lincoln s statement and disagree with it

the measurement and trend of inequality comment in a recent article in this review morton paglin proposes a measure of concentration which he claims will correct the gini ratio for overstatement in populations where each individual may be expected to vary his income or wealth over his life cycle the paglin measure suggests that the gini ratio overstates income concentration in the united states by a third and does not reveal a 23 percent decline in concentration which has occurred between 1947 and 1972 these results are based on an improper decomposition of the gini ratio in this note i decompose the gini ratio to derive the paglin measure it is shown to correct for neither demographic nor life cycle income effects and to understate intracohort income or wealth inequality if properly normalized the paglin measure shows that the gini overstates u s income concentration by 7 percent or less and indicates a decline in u s interfamily income concentration of less than 12 percent four percentage points of this decline are the result of demographic change while less than 7 points comparable to the 5 percent decline of the gini are the result of decreased income concentration within cohorts of family heads decomposition further reveals major changes in the division of income among cohorts and in concentration of income within cohorts these changes compensate each other in the paglin measure the use of which as a measure of income or wealth concentration is not recommended the gini concentration ratio

production subsidy and countervailing duties in vertically related markets the hog pork case between canada and the united states this paper analyzes u s countervailing import duties aimed at offsetting the effects of a canadian hog production subsidy approximate countervailing duty formulae for two alternative objectives are derived the permissible range of these duties is illustrated and empirical evidence is provided to restore equilibrium at the presubsidy level in the u s hog market a countervailing duty on hog imports suffices this duty should be less than the unit hog production subsidy to restore equilibrium in both the u s hog and pork markets countervailing duties on both hog and pork imports are required such duties should be less than the unit subsidy and the duty on pork should be less than the duty on hogs

labour supply effects of unemployment insurance benefits data from the 1976 wave of the panel study of income dynamics are employed to study the effect of unemployment insurance ui benefits on weeks worked ols regressions to model labour supply behaviour are estimated for both recipients and nonrecipients of ui benefits we find some inteesting differences between the labour supply behaviour of ui recipients and nonrecipients

dynamic programming model estimates of social security disability insurance application timing this paper develops a dynamic programming model of the social security disability insurance ssdi application timing decision we estimate the time to application from the point at which a health condition first begins to affect the kind or amount of work that a currently employed person can do we use health and retirement study hrs and restricted access social security earnings data for estimation our results show that the type of work limiting health condition presence of employer accommodation and the relative value of income in the application state to income in the work state significantly affect the timing of ssdi application copyright 2004 john wiley sons ltd

choice under uncertainty a model of applications for the social security disability insurance program abstract not all people with health problems are disabled some individuals with severe physical or mental impairments such as blindness or limb amputation continue to hold jobs and generally function satisfactorily they constitute however a group of potentially disabled individuals who might apply and qualify for disability insurance or other disability related benifits if they were to lose their jobs or to decide that employment offered an inadequate financial or non pecuniary reward thus disability or a health related inability to work is more than a medical problem but involves motivational and attitudinal factors we specify a model of the application process which we model as choice under uncertainty about approval of an application for disability insurance we specify the possible outcomes to the choice process of an individual in which the probability of acceptance for disability insurance is a key consideration we then estimate a joint model of labor supply and application to the disability insurance program based on the 1972 survey we then compare our results to the observed time series applications process since 1976 lastly we estimate the sensitivity of the application process to the probability of acceptance and the level of benifits

us federal redistributive income policies the purpose of this paper is to present a statiscial model of inequality that allows us to analyse simultaneously the impact of several major redistributive expenditure policies as well as analysing the impact of income taxation on inequality the paper includes multivariate exogeeity tests to determine whether the policies have caused the observed income distribution or if there is feedback i e inequality in the distribution has lead to enhanced or diminished redistributive policies the direction of causality for these policies has not to ourr knowledge been previously examined this paper examines the usual redistributive vehicles of transfer payments social security medicare and medicaid as well as analysing the impact of the personal income tax system on inequality using time series analysis we can allow for lagged effects of these policies as well as current period effects this lagged effects specification may be sugggestive of behavioural responses to policy changes

means testing versus universal provision in poverty alleviation programs this paper contrasts the use of means tested and universal schemes in the alleviation of poverty using a class of poverty measures the authors illustrate the trade off from the fact that means testing is costly to both the government and the claimant while universal provision entails a leakage to the nonpoor the paper provides numerical as well as analytical results copyright 1990 by the london school of economics and political science

male labour force participation following illness or injury this paper develops a model of the disabled individual s labour force participation decision following illness or injury and confronts it with data on the financial consequences of ill health a utility function is specified which allows for the effect of changes in health on work leisure preferences and is evaluated in relation to a household budget constraint estimation is through maximization of the appropriate likelihood function correcting for self selection bias within a switching regression model results are presented showing significant effects of financial variables on participation and these are seen to vary with age disability and income

welfare recipient work choice and in kind benefits in washington state we analyze the work choice of welfare recipients potential welfare recipients compare their on and off welfare utility from after tax income and in kind benefits via employment or welfare and choose whether to work our null hypothesis which we reject is that benefits affect only the decision to work or not not the hours worked which will depend on wages using temporary assistance for needy families tanf administrative data from washington state we find that employer provided health insurance and child care subsidies significantly raise exit rates of tanf recipients and induce greater work effort other work inducing factors include wages and the earned income tax credit while increased levels of medicaid food stamps and the income guarantee increase welfare dependency

employment and welfare participation among women laurie j bassi the model makes a distinction between voluntary and involuntary welfare receipt the findings suggest that among female heads of households the increase in welfare receipt that occurred between 1967 and 1979 was almost completely attributable to an increase in involuntary unemployment and an increase in the proportion of the population that was eligible for welfare due to changes in program parameters the passage of time used as a proxy for changes in the stigma associated with receiving welfare appears to be of secondary importance the labor supply response to welfare programs is small and possibly diminishing over time i introduction during the last thirty years the aid to families with dependent children afdc and food stamp programs experienced phenomenal increases in outlays between 1965 and 1975 the afdc population grew 162 percent and real government spending on benefits more than tripled by 1980 the probability that a family was receiving afdc was four times the probability in 1950 value the food stamp program after its introduction in the late 1960s experienced equally dramatic increases in recipiency rates and outlays these striking increases in welfare costs and participation brought an emerging consensus that the afdc and food stamp programs had failed as charles murray writes in losing ground 1984 146 the popular wisdom is characterized by hostility toward welfare it makes people lazy historian james patterson 1981 179 provides an alternative though not inconsistent explanation of the skyrocketing caseloads despite the hostility of the middle classes to increases in welfare poor americans refused at last to be cowed from applying for aid compared to the past when poor people harassed and stigmatized by public authorities were slow to claim their rights this was a fundamental change both of these explanations of the increase in welfare participation assert changes in people s response to the programs murray claims that program changes in the 1960s induced negative labor supply responses increasing numbers of individuals voluntarily reduced their earned income in order to become eligible for welfare patterson claims that a reduction in the stigma associated with welfare led a greater percentage of those eligible to apply for welfare a theoretical model for evaluating the validity of these two views as descriptions of reality is presented here the model is tested using data on women who headed households at some time between 1967 to 1979 the analysis attempts to identify changes in behavior among female heads of households but does not model the decision to head a family a decision which embodies both marital status and fertility choices the implications of this limitation are discussed at the end of the paper the focus is on developing a tractable theoretical structure that allows for a distinction between voluntary and involuntary welfare participation the model also provides a simple test for whether reported unemployment is a constraint on choice or rather a result of it i e whether unemployment too is involuntary or voluntary the empirical results enable us to dis aggregate the changes in welfare participation into their component parts the findings suggest that the increase in welfare participation rates among female heads of households during the late 1960s and 1970s is attributable to both an increase in involuntary unemployment and to an increase in those eligible for welfare as a result of changes in program parameters the passage of time used as a proxy for a lessening of stigma appears to be of minor importance the labor supply response to welfare programs appears to be small and possibly diminishing over time in section ii a model for determining the effect of redistribution schemes on labor supply and welfare participation decisions is developed

precautionary savings a panel study theoretical literature shows that income uncertainty boosts saving yet empirical work is incomplete i test for the precautionary motive for saving using panel data knowing this motive s size is important for gauging the responsiveness of saving to government programs that reduce uncertainty and for comparison to other motives such as bequests most empirical studies of precautionary saving use either aggregate time series or cross sectional data which cannot capture the effects of individual income uncertainty i derive measures of total permanent and transitory income uncertainty from panel data the national longitudinal survey and find a strong precautionary motive a doubling of uncertainty increases the ratio of wealth to permanent income by 29

currencies and the allocation of risk the welfare effects of a monetary union in a general equilibrium model with incomplete asset markets nominal securities and mean variance preferences a monetary union is desirable when the gain from eliminating excess volatility of nominal variables exceeds the cost of reducing the number of currencies with which to hedge risks copyright 1998 by american economic association

the decline in male labor force participation comment in an article in thisjournal parsons 1980a analyzes the doubling in the rate of nonparticipation in the labor force of older men since 1946 using cross sectional data from the national longitudinal survey parnes et al 1970 in an index function model of the labor force participation decision he tests the assertion that the withdrawal of older males is attributable to the rapid expansion of alternatives to work provided by the social security disability insurance ssdi program he reports an elasticity of nonparticipation with respect to the replacement rate of ssdi benefits of 631 and concludes that the recent decline in labor force participation can be largely explained by the increased generosity of social welfare transfers particularly social security disability payments p 130 the magnitude of parsons s estimate and its impact on the public debate over disability transfer policy require careful scrutiny of its basis in section i we describe parsons s econometric model and construction of variables in section ii we provide a critique in section iii we test the robustness of parsons s elasticity estimate by presenting alternative estimates based on corrections and extensions of his basic model section iv concludes

a measure of horizontal inequity politicians academicians and the general public alike have perceived that the status quo tax and transfer legislation creates inequities among living units tax laws create numerous situations in which living units with seemingly equal abilities to pay are taxed quite different amounts state by state differences in welfare eligibility rules benefit schedules and administrative procedures the general unavailability of cash welfare to childless nonaged healthy couples and single individuals and other features of transfer programs similarly provide vastly different levels of income support to units with equal needs advocates of major tax and welfare reform have marshalled such evidence into a central argument in favor of their proposals while there is wide agreement that the process of redistributing incomes abounds with inequities there have been few attempts to quantify their extent 2 this paper develops a measure of horizontal inequity and illustrates its use section ii discusses the concept of horizontal equity then builds upon familiar lorenz curve gini coefficient analysis to derive the inequity index the third part considers some problems of implementing the measure and illustrates it section iv provides a short conclusion

measuring the influence of unemployment insurance on unemployment experiences this article investigates the comprehensive effects of unemployment insurance ui policies on the amount of time and unemployment that individuals report between jobs the econometric model jointly determines the effects of ui on the lengths of nonemployment spells the classification of these spells as unemployment and the likelihood of collecting program benefits the model carefully attempts to isolate variation in ui benefits attributable to differences in generosity across programs to avoid biases in estimating policy effects induced by other contaminating sources of benefit variation using data on men from the national longitudinal survey of youth the empirical results find a ui recipients typically experience longer spells between jobs at least up to the exhaustion of ui benefits and report substantially larger fractions of these spells as unemployment b weekly benefit amounts exert no significant influence on the likelihood of ui recipiency on the length of spells between jobs or on t

the tradeoff between equality and efficiency short run politics and long run realities in concluding this paper the best way to emphasize what has been argued is to make as clear as possible what has not been argued nothing in the above argumentation or evidence can or is intended to deny that some social welfare programs genuinely serve the long run interests of the poor undoubtedly such programs exist and can be identified as successful other programs exist however that are undeniably making the poor worse off from the perspective of reducing income inequality it is obvious that the successful programs should be maintained and even expanded in ways that further assist the poor while the harmful programs should be terminated unfortunately it is simply not possible politically to select out those programs that do promote broad social goals such as reducing poverty while eliminating those programs that do not this is a point that the present paper is intended to emphasize once you open up the political transfer process to one group no matter how deserving that group may be economic rents are generated that will motivate competition among politically organized interest groups the inevitable result of this competition is a package of programs that serve a variety of interests but which on balance do little if anything to benefit those groups which it was our intention to assist

why have uk disability benefit rolls grown so much abstract over the last 30 years many countries including the uk have seen a dramatic rise in the share of the working age population receiving sickness and disability benefits hereafter disability benefits this is despite health levels that are generally thought to be slowly improving this paper describes the time path of uk disability benefit rolls and explores the existing uk literature together with literature from the usa in search of potential explanations for it since the early 1990s despite a number of detailed descriptive studies surprisingly little attention has been paid to quantifying the importance of the different factors believed to be driving the uk benefit roll growth this is all the more surprising given the continued growth and the level of policy attention recently and currently devoted to disability benefits in the uk

do means tested transfers reduce labor supply abstract it is frequently argued that recipients of means tested government transfers work less than they would in the absence of the transfer this note shows that this conclusion may not be accurate for many participants in a major housing program

how income transfer programs affect work savings and the income distribution a critical review for helpful comments on earlier drafts we thank without implicating moses abramovitz yves balcer john bishop alan blinder richard burkhauser michael darby irwin garfinkel alan gustman daniel hamermesh martin holmer george jakubson robert lampman paul menchik robert moffitt michael murray joseph quinn timothy smeeding eugene smolensky barbara wolfe and two anonymous referees

disability transfers and the work decision of older men the potential causal relationship between the availability and generosity of disability transfers and the nonparticipation rates of older men is often asserted and much studied parsons 1980 haveman and wolfe 1984 leonard 1986 however estimates of the magnitude of this linkage vary widely the growth in transfer availability and generosity has been credited with from 30 to 100 percent of the significant post 1960 fall in older male participation rates the disparity in these research results stems primarily from 1 alternative sources of data that differentially constrain estimation of relevant expected wage and transfer incomes 2 specifications that are unable to distinguish income transfer from labor market effects and 3 reliance on measures of health status that are endogenous to the work leisure decision this study seeks to narrow the range of estimates by addressing each of these issues our utility maximization model of work status choice assumes that workers who differ in health status choose between the mutually exclusive options of working at the wage offered for their characteristics and accepting public or private disability transfers because the income flows in the two options are censored they are estimated using switching regression techniques as expectations conditional on exogenous individual characteristics hence accounting for the potentially endogenous process that separates wage earners from transfer recipients the marginal utilities of income from the two sources are allowed to differ because of stigma effects in the estimation we adjust the choice based nature of our sample employ longitudinal earnings data to measure expected changes in as distinct from the expected level of income in the two options and use a separately estimated latent health status measure largely purged of its endogeneity with the participation decision

cash welfare as a consumption smoothing mechanism for divorced mothers abstract while there has been considerable research on the disincentive effects of cash welfare under the aid to families with dependent children afdc program there is little evidence on the benefits of the program for single mothers and their children one potential benefit of this program is that it provides short run consumption insurance for women at the point that they become single mothers this is only true however to the extent that the program is not crowding out other sources of support such as own savings labor supply or transfers from others i assess the importance of this insurance mechanism by measuring the extent to which afdc smooths the consumption of women who transition to single motherhood through marital dissolution i use longitudinal data on family structure and consumption expenditures on food and housing from the panel study of income dynamics psid matched to information on the welfare benefits available in each state and year over the 1968 1985 period i find that raising potential benefits by one dollar raises the food and housing consumption of women who get divorced and their families by 28 cents this estimate implies that for each dollar of afdc received by this population their consumption of these categories of goods rises by up to 51 cents this is roughly the share of food and housing in the consumption bundle of divorced mothers and their families suggesting little crowdout of other sources of support

the economic consequences of debilitating illness the case of multiple sclerosis the economic consequences of debilitating illness are defined and then estimated for one such illness multiple sclerosis economic losses are defined as the consumption losses to the affected household because of illness these losses are measured as the change in earnings of all family members plus the increase in gross not out of pocket medical costs earnings models are specified and estimated and gross medical costs calculated for multiple sclerosis the average annual loss to the multiple sclerosis household is 5 336 per year in 1976 dollars the estimated aggregate decline in consumption for the year 1976 was 0 656 billion lifetime costs discounting by 0 06 total 207 200 per multiple sclerosis household and 25 50 billion for society as a whole for the current 1976 pool of multiple sclerosis patients and 30 45 billion for all future multiple sclerosis patients copyright 1987 by mit press

labor supply response to welfare programs a dynamic analysis previous static analyses of the work disincentive effects of welfare programs are extended to a dynamic context using a sample of continuous longitudinal labor market histories estimates are derived for welfare nonwelfare differences in labor market flows among the states of employment unemployment and nonparticipation the estimates are used to identify the main sources of the lower employment and labor force participation rates and higher unemployment rate of welfare recipients the findings indicate that welfare programs have substantial effects on virtually every labor market transition examined but that the primary source of the static work disincentive effect is slower entry into employment

does unemployment compensation affect unemployment duration abstract we use a flexible hazard rate model with unrestricted spell duration and calendar timeeffects to analyse a dataset including all norwegian unemployment spells during the1990 s the dataset provides a unique access to conditionally independent variation inunemployment compensation we find that a marginal increase in compensation re duces the escape rate from unemployment significantly irrespective of business cycleconditions and spell duration the escape rate rises sharply in the months just prior tobenefit exhaustion while men are more responsive than women with respect to mar ginal changes in compensation women are most responsive with respect to benefitexhaustion keywords unemployment spells business cycles unemployment compensation non parametric duration analysis jel classification c41 j64 the ragnar frisch centre for economic research oslo we wish to thank the re search council of norway for financial support and christian brinck harald goldstein costas meghir espen moen steinar strom rolf aaberge and three anonomyous referees for helpful comments cor respondence to knut roed the ragnar frisch centre for economic research gaustadalleen 21 0349oslo norway e mail knut roed frisch uio no

four case studies of agri food cvds and a proposal for reforming national administered protection agencies abstract this paper reviews the role of national administered protection agencies whose primary responsibility is the enforcement of national trade remedy laws after reviewing four recent cases of trade disputes between canada and the united states it is argued that the role of national administered protection agencies should be changed the growth of regional trading blocks the increasing use of anti dumping and countervailing duty actions against fairly traded imports and the additional responsibilities assumed by the wto in administering the agreement on agriculture strongly suggest that all trade disputes should be taken to the wto for settlement the role of national administered protection agencies should be changed to make them agents for trade liberalization this would involve these agencies taking on three primary functions i as transparency agents ii as investigatory agents and iii as advocacy agents

accounting for recent declines in employment rates among working aged men and women with disabilities during the 1990s while overall employment rates for working aged men and women either remained roughly constant men or rose women employment rates for people with disabilities fell during the same period the fraction of the working aged population receiving social security disability insurance di benefits increased quite dramatically we present simple time series and cross state evidence suggesting that the growth in the di program can account for much of the decline in the relative employment position of men and women with disabilities

disability capacity for work and the business cycle an international perspective important policy issues arise from the high and growing number of people claiming disability benefits for reasons of incapacity for work in oecd countries economic conditions play an important part in explaining both the stock of disability benefit claimants and inflows to and outflows from that stock employing a variety of cross country and country specific household panel data sets as well as administrative data we find strong evidence that local variations in unemployment have an important explanatory role for disability benefit receipt with higher total enrolments lower outflows from rolls and often higher inflows into disability rolls in regions and periods of above average unemployment in understanding the nature of the cyclical fluctuations and trends in disability it is important to distinguish between work disability and health disability the former is likely to be influenced by economic conditions and welfare programmes while the latter evolves in a slower fashion with medical technology and demographic changes there is little evidence of health disability being related to the business cycle so cyclical variations are driven by work disability the rise in unemployment due to the current global economic crisis is expected to increase the number of disability insurance claimants

welfare the earned income tax credit and the labor supply of single mothers during 1984 1996 welfare and tax policy were changed to encourage work by single mothers the earned income tax credit was expanded welfare benets were cut welfare time limits were added and welfare cases were terminated medicaid for the working poor was expanded as were training programs and child care during this same time period there were unprecedented increases in the employment and hours of single mothers we show that a large share of the increase in work by single mothers can be attributed to the eitc and other tax changes with smaller shares for welfare benet cuts welfare waivers training programs and child care programs

poverty comparisons with dependent samples standard inference procedures for poverty comparisons require samples to be independent for many commonly used income samples however this requirement is not ful lled since samples are rotated this note introduces an easy to use method of correction for sample dependency we also apply the method to test changes in u s poverty in the 1990s and evaluate the marginal effects of public assistance on poverty before and after the recent welfare reform

pension wealth and household savings tests of robustness abstract a substantial literature exists on the impact of pension schemes both public and private on the level of household saving yet there is no clear consensus on the impact of pensions on private saving in this paper we show how beliefs about this displacement effect are modified by prior beliefs both about variables which might be relevant in an equation for private savings and about the magnitude of the displacement effect using data for 8279 canadian households and estimates of pension wealth both private and social security which we construct for each household in the sample the estimated displacement effects are found to be relatively robust with respect to both types of prior belief

welfare and macroeconomic interdependence we develop a baseline model of monetary and fiscal transmission in interdependent economies the welfare effects of expansionary policies are related to monopolistic supply in production and monopoly power of a country in trade an unanticipated exchange rate depreciation can be beggar thyself rather than beggar thy neighbor as gains in domestic output are offset by deteriorating terms of trade smaller and more open economies are more prone to suffer from inflationary shocks larger economies benefit from moderate demand led expansions but may be worse off if policy makers attempt to close the output gap fiscal shocks are generally beggar thy neighbor in the long run in the short run they raise domestic demand at given terms of trade thus reducing the welfare benefits from monetary expansions analytical tractability makes our model uniquely suitable as a starting point to approach the recent new open economy macroeconomic literature

the health and earnings of rejected disability insurance applicants applicants for social security disability benefits who fail to pass the medical screening form a natural control group for beneficiaries data drawn from the 1972 and 1978 surveys of the disabled done for the social security administration show that fewer than 50 percent of rejected male applicants work typical earnings of those that do are less than 59 percent of median earnings for other men their age these data cast doubt on recent econometric work that suggests that the disincentive effects of the social security disability program have been substantial copyright 1989 by american economic association

female labor supply with a discontinuous nonconvex budget constraint incorporation of a part time full time wage differential this paper incorporates the well documented part time full time wage differential into an empirical labor supply model with both a heterogeneity and a random error term and estimates that model fo

disability earnings income and consumption using longitudinal data for the period 1968 2005 for a sample of male household heads we determine the prevalence of disability during the working years and examine how the extent of disability affects a range of outcomes including earnings income and consumption we have seven main findings first disability rates are high we divide the disabled along two dimensions based on the persistence and severity of their work limiting condition we estimate that a person reaching age 56 has a 53 percent chance of having been disabled at least once during his working years and a 19 percent chance that he has begun a chronic and severe disability second the economic consequences of disability are frequently profound ten years after disability onset a person with a chronic and severe disability on average experiences a 68 percent decline in earnings a 32 percent decline in after tax income a 22 percent decline in food and housing consumption and a 21 percent decline in food consumption third the various economic consequences differ sharply across disability groups the outcome declines for those with a chronic and severe disability are often more than twice as large as those for the average disabled fourth our findings show the partial and incomplete roles that individual savings family support and social insurance play in reducing the consumption drop that follows disability only about half of this most disabled group reports receiving social security disability insurance or supplemental security income fifth we find a noticeable fall in earnings and income prior to the onset of a reported disability consumption also falls somewhat suggesting that future disability is partially but incompletely predictable in the short run sixth time use and detailed consumption data further indicate that disability is associated with a decline in well being seventh the quantities we have estimated combined with elasticities from the literature allow us to examine the optimality of current compensation for the disabled we find that the current compensation for our most disabled group appears to be lower than is optimal

incumbent performance and electoral control in the pure theory of electoral competition citizens compare the platforms of the candidates and vote for the one whose platform is preferred candidate strategies are identified with promises about future performance in office models of this sort have been developed in both static mckelvey 1975 and dynamic kramer 1977 i settings and all appear to have the property that if the set of alternatives is large enough in some sense equilibrium platforms rarely exist but these models have another feature that is quite as disturbing as their instability in the static setting discussed by mckelvey little attention is paid to the possibility that once in office the politician s preferences may diverge from those of his constituents and that he may therefore choose policies at variance from his platform instead it is simply assumed that promises will be kept whether or not such behavior is congruent with the interest of the officeholder it is sometimes argued that an enforcement mechanism may exist to discipline politicians for failing to keep promises but without a specification of the mechanism it is not obvious that it would be in the interests of the

welfare as a cause of poverty a time series analysis since the inception of welfare programs critics have argued that giving aid to the poor dampens their incentive to provide for themselves and their dependents 1 charles murray s losing ground 1984 presents a modern reincarnation of this work disincentive hypothesis he notes that both nominal welfare benefits and caseloads increased during the seventies suggesting that higher benefits cause more people to join the welfare rolls others contend that welfare receipt may be a necessity rather than a matter of personal choice even if the nonworking poor actively sought employment many would not be able to find jobs furthermore many would find only low paying jobs which would not enable them to work their way out of poverty e g abraham 1983 in this view unemployment labor market segmentation and low wages cause poverty which view is correct studies of the effects of welfare typically specify a single model and use regression analysis to test whether the data support its implications in contrast this paper uses the granger 1969 causality test in a system of welfare and employment equations this strategy offers two advantages first regression presumes causality whereas the granger approach tests whether or not causality defined in a technical sense exists second we can use a very general empirical model to test the work disincentive hypothesis as well as the implications of two competing models section 2 presents three models of the welfare caseload and their implied patterns of causality section 3 explains granger s concept of and test for causality in section 4 the test is performed indicating the direction of causality between real afdc benefits the afdc caseload and unemployment we then repeat the exercise using labor force participation rates rather than unemployment rates the paper concludes with a summary of the results and their qualifications

labour force participation by disabled males in canada the disabled are not necessarily unemployed although about a quarter of them report they are completely prevented from working a disabled person s decision to work or not depends on a variety of psychological social and economic as well as health factors this paper asks if canadian disability related insurance schemes discourage work it models and measures the impact of disability benefits on the work choice of disabled prime age males it finds that they amount to a significant work disincentive but better yet they likely save many disabled persons from unsuitable and or undesirable jobs

a theory of yardstick competition in the typical regulatory scheme a franchised monopoly has little incentive to reduce costs this article proposes a mechanism in which the price the regulatedfirm receives depends on the costs of identical firms in equilibrium each firm chooses a socially efficient level of cost reduction the mechanism generalizes to cover heterogeneous firms with observable differences medicare s prospective reimbursement of hospitals by using diagnostically related groups is a scheme very similar to the one outlined here

in kind transfers cash grants and the supply of labour abstract this paper corrects the notion that somehow benefits given in kind interfere less with the work leisure choice than cash grants of equivalent monetary value in a simple model the analysis proves that the true effect depends on the extent of the in kind transfer and the substitutability of the good in question with leisure

risk aversion and the propensities for self insurance and self protection for a risk averse individual the methods for reducing the expected financial impact of a loss include reducing the severity of any loss that occurs self insurance and reducing the probability of the occurrence of a loss self protection the literature on this topic has pointed to several anomalies whereby the use of self protection and self insurance yield quite unsimilar results for example ehrlich and becker 5 show that self insurance is always a substitute for market insurance an insurance company s indemnifying a loss whereas self protection and market insurance might be complements dionne and eeckhoudt 4 show that a more risk averse consumer would always invest more in self insurance activities but not necessarily more in self protection activities they argue 4 42 that this result is counterintuitive and provides an exception to the widely accepted result that increased risk aversion reduces risky activities ehrlich and becker 5 639 argue that the incentive to self protect is not so dependent on attitude towards risk both of the above papers seem to take for granted that self protection activities reduce the riskiness of the final wealth distribution however as we argue below this is not the case if riskiness is defined as in rothschild and stiglitz 14 even if we use the variance as our risk measure we do not always reduce risk via self protection dionne and eeckhoudt suggest that these results might not be robust enough to extend to models that incorporate random initial wealth risk and state dependent preferences we show that the model seems to be very robust we also explain why self protection is not at all an exception to the long standing result of arrow 1 whereby more risk averse individuals undertake a lower

why do disability benefit rolls vary between regions a review of the evidence from the usa and the uk mcvicar d 2006 why do disability benefit rolls vary between regions a review of the evidence from the usa and the uk regional studies 40 519 533 over the last 30 years many organization for economic co operation and development oecd countries have seen a dramatic rise in the share of the working age population receiving earnings replacement sickness and disability benefits the reasons behind this growth particularly for the usa but also to a lesser extent elsewhere have been extensively researched in the economics literature what have been less well researched are the large spatial differences in the size of disability benefit rolls that have emerged in some countries over this period the uk displays a distinct regional pattern where working age men and women in the north are considerably more likely to be claiming disability benefits than those in the south the usa has its own version of the north south divide with many southern states displaying disproportionately large disabilit

long term supply side implications of the great depression we compare the experiences of the us and uk during and after the great depression with particular attention to overall productivity growth industrial organization the growth of human capital and protectionism we discover many implications of the great depression experience and policies for post war economic activities we conclude that one should never waste a good crisis in the implementation of one so wn economic policies labour market policies should encourage the formation of human capital and it is dangerous to assume that other countries will not change in an economic crisis

optimal retention in agency problems this paper studies the interaction between a single long lived principal and a series of short lived agents in the presence of both moral hazard and adverse selection we assume that the principal can influence the agents behavior only through her choice of a retention rule this rule is further required to be sequentially rational i e no precommitment is allowed we provide general conditions under which equilibria exist where a the principal adopts a cut off rule under which agents are retained only when the reward they generate exceeds a critical bound and b agents separate according to type with better agents taking superior actions we show that in equilibrium a retained agent s productivity is necessarily declining over time but that retained agents are also more productive on average than untried agents due to selection effects finally we show that for each given type agents of that type are more productive in the presence of adverse selection than when there is pure moral hazard i e when that type is the sole type of agent in the model nonetheless adding uncertainty about agent types cannot benefit the principal except in uninteresting cases

trade remedy actions in nafta agriculture and agri food industries the economic rationale for trade remedy law while always weak is undermined by the formation of free trade areas however due to political pressure first cusfta and then nafta have continued the use of domestic antidumping and countervailing duty laws with the lowering of border protection it was feared that there would be an explosion of trade remedy law as nafta was implemented this article examines data on the use of anti dumping and countervailing duty investigations in agriculture and analyses the incidence between nafta partners before and after the implementation of free trade and compared to the incidence with other countries given the cost of current ad and cvd suits options are explored for alternative methods to resolve ad and cvd suits evaluation of options hinges on goals held for dispute resolution within nafta given continued political opposition to eliminating ad and cvd processes increasing the options for resolving these suits may reduce their overall costs

multilateral trade cooperation what next this paper first briefly describes the role of the wto and its history it then lays out a simple bargaining model of international negotiations which can be used for understanding the doha round of talks this simple framework is used to distil and discuss a number of potential explanations for the difficulties that have arisen in concluding these talks as well as a number of systemic questions that confront wto members a key question is whether the wto should concentrate primarily on market access or on further expanding its coverage to deal with regulatory issues or with other domestic policies that may have an impact on trade given the difficulties that arise in agreeing on behind the border disciplines we argue that a continued focus on market access and enforcement of market access commitments is likely to prove most fruitful

public transfers family socioeconomic traits and the job search behavior of the unemployed evidence from puerto rico abstract this paper explores the theoretical and empirical associations between the job search efforts of the unemployed and the socioeconomic characteristics of the family it takes as a point of reference that certain supply side phenomena may contribute to puerto rico s high open unemployment rate the statistical analyses carried out indicate that there does exist what can be labeled luxury unemployment in other words government provided transfer payments generate disincentive effects with respect to the job market behavior of the unemployed moreover the dependency status of the individual within the family group also leads to lower job search effort

income distribution in the united states political action has affected postwar income distribution in the united states mainly through policy induced variations in macroeconomic activity and government transfer benefits in proportion to total income we present a small dynamic model of the connections among the partisan balance of power macroeconomic fluctuations transfer spending trends and income distribution outcomes the model is based on the premise that the parties have different distributional goals and it is designed to identify how shifts in party control of the presidency and the strength of the parties in congress have affected the distribution of after tax after transfer income by influencing cyclical economic performance and the flow of resources to transfer programs we therefore extend the partisan theory of macroeconomic policy to the domain of income distribution outcomes

does disability insurance receipt discourage work using examiner assignment to estimate causal effects of ssdi receipt abstract we present the first causal estimates of the effect of social security disability insurance benefit receipt on labor supply using all program applicants we use administrative data to matc

disability benefits replacement ratios and the labour market a time series approach in this paper a study of factors affecting the number of disability beneficiaries in norway is presented equations determining entry rates into the disability benefit system are estimated using aggregated time series data grouped by sex and age unemployment is found to influence disability entry the results regarding effects of the replacement ratio are ambiguous a model determining the number of beneficiaries including the estimated entry equations is presented the model is used to simulate the effect of counterfactual changes in exogenous variables on the number of disability beneficiaries

social spending and automatic stabilizers in the oecd the macroeconomic literature on automatic stabilization tends to focus on taxes and dismiss the relevance of government expenditure except for unemployment compensation our results go sharply contrary to this view we engage in an empirical analysis of 21 oecd countries from 1982 to 2003 and find that age and health related social expenditure as well as incapacity and sick benefits all react to the cycle in a stabilizing manner while possibly new in the macro literature this conforms to many results in studies in labour economics the policy implications are broad since much previous analysis of discretionary fiscal policy rests on official figures for automatic stabilization there are also major implications for efforts to incorporate automatic fiscal policy in simulation models julia darby and jacques melitz

replacement income duration of unemployment and the migration of unemployed prime age males the relationship between the interstate migration of unemployed males of prime working age i e 25 44 years of age the level of unemployment replacement income and the duration of unemployment spells is addressed through the use of a relatively untapped data source the us census s survey of income and program participation sipp the rich set of details that are provided in this database allows a more precise empirical analysis of the above relationships than has been possible with psid cps and other previously used databases by restricting the sample to a relatively homogeneous segment of the work force its is possible to isolate better the effects of unemployment replacement income and job search duration on the migration decision of unemployed workers without the confounding effects of the variety of demographic factors that previous studies have shown to influence labour force migration the results suggest that for unemployed prime working age males the probability of migration is negativel

disability transfers self reported health and the labor force attachment of older men evidence from the historical record we use trends in self reported disability to gauge the impact of the growth of disability transfer programs on the labor force attachment of older working aged men our tabulations suggest that between 1949 and 1987 about half of the 4 9 percentage point drop in the labor force participation of men aged 45 54 and between one quarter and one third of the 19 9 point drop among men aged 55 64 represented a movement of men out of the labor force and onto the rolls of transfer programs targeted at the disabled since the expansion of transfer programs represents only one of the forces behind this movement these figures represent upper bounds on the impact of such programs on work force attachment

the economic implications of disability insurance in canada the article empirically estimates the effects of disability pensions provided under the canada quebec pension plans on the labor force participation rates of males aged 45 64 years two data sets are used one consists of pooled cross section annual time series data by province for the years 1975 83 the other consists of observations as of 1985 on 651 males in the specified age group naive estimation results from both sets of data suggest a large negative effect of pension income in the case of the micro data this effect becomes small and statistically nonsignificant when more sophisticated estimation methods are used

a comparison of the effect of welfare programme features on welfare participation one and two parent families the effect of welfare programme characteristics on the decision to enter the welfare system is modelled as a binary discrete choice latent variable model dependent upon an underlying index function the two chief classes of welfare beneficiaries in the us welfare system are analysed two parent families and single female headed families the data set is a large recent non experimental multiyear cross sectional pooled data set derived from the us census bureaus current population survey behavioural impacts from a range of economic variables are consistent in sign with predictions made by economic theory newly estimated comprehensive descriptive statistics of the entire welfare system for both single female household heads and married couples with children are employed to characterize the welfare system statistically significant estimates of substantial magnitude are obtained for the impacts on welfare participation for the welfare guarantee level the effective tax rate on earned income and the effec

should social security benefits be means tested social security retirement benefits distort the saving decisions of workers who are rational enough to save for their future since the implicit rate of return in an unfunded social security program is less than the marginal product of capital the resulting decline in saving causes a welfare loss the present paper examines the conditions under which the welfare loss could be reduced by replacing the current universal social security program with a means tested program that pays benefits only to those individuals with little or no other retirement income or assets every society must solve the problem of supporting those individuals who become too old to work but have not made adequate provision for their own old age by saving when they were young at the present time the major industrial countries of the world have responded to this problem by creating social security programs that tax the working population and use the proceeds to provide a universal benefit to all retirees regardless of their financial condition this universal provision of social security benefits distorts the saving decisions of those workers who are rational enough to plan for the future since the implicit rate of return that taxpayers get on their this research is part of the nber study of the government budget and the private economy a more complete version of this paper with some numerical calculations is available as nber working paper no 1775 feldstein 1985b i am grateful to gilbert metcalf for assistance with the calculations presented in this paper and for helpful discussions for a discussion of the effect of promised retirement benefits on the savings of employees see feldstein 1974 1982 barro 1974 1978 has discussed an interesting

american federalism welfare policy and residential choices the relationship between welfare benefit levels and the residential choices of the poor raises two issues for federalism in the united states do state benefit levels affect the residential choices of the poor do residential choices of the poor affect the level at which a state sets its benefit levels empirical studies have seldom studied the interconnection between these two issues this research estimates simultaneously the mutual effects of welfare benefits and poverty rates while controlling for other economic and political variables when benefit levels become high the size of the poverty population increases conversely when poverty rates become high benefit levels are cut the findings are consistent with the claim that state determined benefit levels distort policy and residential choices

incumbent behavior vote seeking tax setting and yardstick competition this paper develops a model of the political economy of tax setting in a multijurisdictional world where voters choices and incumbent behavior are determined simultaneously voters are assumed to make comparisons between jurisdictions to overcome political agency problems this forces incumbents into a yardstick competition in which they care about what other incumbents are doing we provide a theoretical framework and empirical evidence using u s state data from 1960 to 1988 the results are encouraging to the view that vote seeking and tax setting are tied together through the nexus of yardstick competition

accountability and decentralisation in government an incomplete contracts model this paper approaches the question of the appropriate level of decentralisation of power in government as a problem in the allocation of control rights under incomplete contracts the model of the paper compares allocations of power to local central and regional government as alternative means of motivating governments to act in the interests of citizens centralisation allows benefits from policy coordination but has costs in terms of diminished accountability which can be precisely defined as the reduced probability that the welfare of a given region can determine the re election of the government the model is extended to allow for conflicts of interest within regions and externalities between central and local governments in a federation it is also applied to determining levels of fiscal transfer between localities and to circumstances where governments may act as leviathans appropriating resources for their own use

labour supply impacts of effective welfare programme parameters a reanalysis we quantify the impact of effective welfare programme parameters on the labour supply of single female household heads the primary group of welfare recipients in the usa our panel of data is derived from the us census bureau s current population survey for the years 1979 to 1990 inclusive behavioural impacts from a range of economic variables are consistent in sign with predictions made by economic theory we find that effective welfare gurantee levels and the effective tax rate on earned income both significantly decrease labour supply the marginal effects of these welfare programme parameters are economically small a us 1000 increase in the expected welfare guarantee level reduces annual labour supply by about 36 hours a 10 percentage point increase in the effective tax rate on earned income reduces annual labour supply by about 7 5 hours

disability benefit take up and local labor market conditions exploiting county level variation in oil producing areas from shocks to world oil and gas prices we study how local labor market conditions affect disability take up we extend well known previous work using a similar research design by analyzing a different price shock a larger more representative set of labor markets and a more recent period marked by skyrocketing disability payments our estimated elasticity for ssdi payments with respect to earnings of 0 29 is surprisingly similar to earlier findings our preferred ssi elasticity estimate of 0 16 is smaller than previous findings but we show that ssi programmatic changes explain most of the difference jel codes j0 h0

regional trading arrangements natural or supernatural members of the customs union the potential unfavorable effects arise from the introduction of distortions in the relative price between the goods of members and nonmembers in terms of classic customs union theory the trade off is between trade creation and trade diversion the entire exercise assumes that the firstbest solution of worldwide free trade is not attainable for political reasons thus the choice between a status quo of nondiscriminatory most favored nation mfn tariffs and a move to preferential trading arrangements pta s is an exercise in the theory of the second best this paper summarizes recent research by the authors we make an evaluation of the

pensions and retirement evidence from union army veterans i investigate the factors that fostered rising retirement rates prior to social security and most private sector pensions by estimating the income effect of the first major pension program in the united sates that covering union army veterans the elasticity of nonparticipation with respect to union army pension income was 0 73 the findings suggest that secularly rising income explains a substantial part of increased retirement rates comparisons with elasticities of nonparticipation with respect to social security income suggest that the elasticity of labor force nonparticipation may have decreased with time perhaps because of the increasing attractiveness of leisure

a political agency model of coattail voting abstract this paper provides a theoretical model for the coattail effect where a popular candidate for one branch of government attracts votes to candidates from the same political party for other branches of government i assume a political agency framework with moral hazard in order to analyze the coattail effect in simultaneous presidential and congressional elections i show that coattail voting is the outcome of the optimal reelection scheme adopted by a representative voter to motivate politicians efforts in a retrospective voting environment i assume that an office motivated politician executive or member of congress prefers her counterpart to be affiliated with the same political party this correlation of incentives leads the voter to adopt a joint performance evaluation rule which is conditioned on the politicians belonging to the same party or to different parties two sided coattail effects then arise on the one hand an executive s success props up while failure drags down her partisan ally in the congressional election which implies a presidential coattail effect on the other hand the executive s reelection itself is affected by a congress member s performance which results in a reverse coattail effect

economic integration and political accountability abstract this paper studies to what extent economic integration or globalization influences the accountability of politicians assuming that politicians are controlled by the voters through reelection rules we analyze to what extent economic integration affects the form of those rules and the efforts made by politicians we define economic integration by the existence of policies and shocks interdependences between countries then from a political point of view this integration is shown to be a two sided phenomenon shock interdependence allows yardstick comparison increases political accountability and therefore efforts while policy interdependence induces a lack of responsibility and harms the extent to which politicians can be controlled

unemployment insurance in the united states layoff incentives and cross subsidies we survey unemployment insurance ui in the united states and provide new evidence on the ui payroll tax most ui receipt is due to firms that pay part of the ui costs of their layoffs but weak experience rating leads most firms to pay considerably less than the full costs industries consistently receiving subsidies from the ui system are construction manufacturing and mining finally a large fraction of layoffs resulting in payment of ui are made by firms that are not charged for the costs of the claim because they have employed the individual for less than 2 quarters

the impact of economic conditions on participation in disability programs evidence from the coal boom and bust abstract we examine the impact of the coal boom of the 1970 s and the coal bust of the 1980 s on disability program participation these shocks provide clear evidence that as the value of labor market participation increases disability program participation falls for the disability insurance program the elasticity of payments with respect to local earnings is between 0 3 and 0 4 and for supplemental security income the elasticity is between 0 4 and 0 7 consistent with a model where qualifying for disability programs is costly the relationship between economic conditions and program participation is much stronger for permanent than for transitory economic shocks

regional free trade areas sorting out the tangled spaghetti as a result of the difficulties in negotiating the liberalization of trade globally countries seek liberalization among smaller groups we describe open regionalism as one such attempt to do this and show why after a decade of success it ran into the ground as a strategy the formation of discriminatory regional free trade areas ftas is sometimes seen as another response to this problem this paper point outs what is wrong with this response that it distorts trade patterns and thereby sets up an unpleasant prisoner s dilemma and suggests some ways forward we propose the formation of open trading arrangements otas and the establishment of a trade transparency commission in each country that is participating in an ota we also suggest global regulation of trade diversions caused by all ftas whether otas or not ultimately the return to health of the global trading system will require expanded understanding of the basic insight of economics that liberalization enhances the welfare of citizens of the liberalizing country

uncertain lifetime consumption and dissaving in retirement this paper asks whether the continued accumulation or mild dissaving observed among the retired can be explained by uncertain lifetime in the absence of annuities after an initial period influenced by borrowing constraints under constant relative risk aversion uncertain lifetime depresses consumption by a proportion increasing with age if the elasticity of intertemporal substitution in consumption is small illustrative computations based on actual income and survival data show that plausible elasticities are sufficiently small to give this effect the reduction in consumption is large enough to explain much of the lack of decumulation by the elderly

a multiple time series analysis of labor supply and earnings in economic development abstract using multivariate time series techniques the dynamics of male and female labor supply and earnings in puerto rico are examined during a period of rapid economic developemnt 1953 1978 the temporal analysis suggests that aggregate male and female labor force participation rates are exogenous to male and female earnings in addition continous declines in male participation have been partly responsible for increases in both male and female earnings and a narrowing of relative earnings differentials the study also finds that the advent of the food stamp program in 1975 has resulted in a small reduction in male labor force participation moreover the inclusion of food stamps as an intervention component is quite useful in forecasting the male participation rate the forecasting accuracy of univariate and multivariate models is assessed with the result that in every instance the multivariate transfer functions prove superior overall the results support the incorporation of multiple time series in econometric studies of developing countries and provide evidence of its usefullness for development planning and policy

labor market behavior of older men abstract a three way qualitative choice model is employed to evaluate the response of men aged 62 64 to changes in expected income flows in alternative work and public transfer program options in the united states workers in this age group have three available options working accepting public early retirement benefits and private pensions or seeking and accepting public disability benefits we estimate the change in response to two income flows expected nontransfer largely labor market income and expected transfer income using the estimated responses we simulate the pattern of altered choices from two changes in the public transfer system a 20 percent decrease in benefits for early retirement and an earnings related income supplement while the reduction in early retirement benefits results in a small percentage decrease in the number of retirees the earnings supplement has a substantial positive effect on the number of older men choosing to continue working and results in both a rise in government expenditures and in family income

do welfare asset limits affect household saving evidence from welfare reform we use data from the panel study of income dynamics to estimate the effect of new saving incentives implemented as part of the 1996 welfare reform on household saving economic theory predicts that loosening asset limits will increase total savings for households with a large ex ante probability of welfare receipt such as female headed households with children we follow a sample of female heads with children and find that in both absolute terms and relative to comparison groups of male heads and female heads without children there has been no effect of welfare policy changes on the saving of at risk households

unemployment benefit duration and incentives in britain how robust is the evidence abstract recent years have seen considerable advances in the econometric treatment of micro data in models of unemployment duration this paper examines the evidence from such models concerning the effects of unemployment benefits on incentives to work in britain widely accepted results of a small but significant benefit effect are reproduced using a sample of 1 231 unemployed men however these results are only found when benefit receipt is assumed to follow a hypothetical pattern which is shown to be unrealistic and over generous when more realistic calculations of benefits are used no benefit effect is found the paper also argues that search theory is of little help in determining the choice between competing functional forms and explanatory variables results concerning benefits are shown to be sensitive to the latter