money deficit and public debt in the united states this study estimates the underlying parameters in a dynamic game between the fiscal and monetary authorities over the determination of public debt these estimates reveal the policymakers attitude towards the goal of stabilizing the time path of public debt the central finding is that in the united states during the 1955 85 period this goal has been pursued by the fiscal authority but not by the central bank monetary policy has not monetized the stock of public debt outstanding whereas cyclically adjusted net of interest fiscal deficits have been reduced to offset increases in the stock of debt in circulation copyright 1989 by mit press

wheat from chaff meta analysis as quantitative literature review abstract this paper presents and develops a quantitative method of literature reviewing and evaluating empirical research meta regression analysis or mra economics is theory driven yet we must learn empirically if economics is to advance mra offers a more objective statistical method to summarize our empirical knowledge and to explain the wide study to study variation in economic research mra is used to assess the evidence for ricardian equivalence and its findings are contrasted to those of conventional narrative review furthermore mra establishes a platform from which to distinguish genuine empirical effect from the exploitable specification error that infests applied econometrics

a dynamic analysis of the impact of fiscal policy on the money supply note although a positive accommodative fiscal policy money supply relationship is frequently suggested 3 5 often because of an hypothesized overriding concern by the federal reserve with stabilizing interest rates the availablae empirical evidence is mixed l with the exception of 4 the empirical studies have provided estimates of the impact multipliers for various fiscal variables on alternative monetary variables but they have not addressed the question of the impact of a sustained change in a fiscal variable upon the money supply over time in a world in which fiscal variables affect financial and product sector variables with a lag the examination of only the impact multipliers may give an incomplete and or misleading picture thus the aim of this paper is to extend the analysis to a dynamic setting in which the impact of the fiscal variables upon the time path of m1 is examined within the context of a small macroeconomic model in particular dynamic multipliers for the money supply are derived and analyzed

benefit transfer a comparison of wtp for air quality between france and germany a contingent valuation study was carried out under similar conditions on two sites simultaneously strasbourg france and kehl germany in order to test the reliability of the benefit transfer method on average the air quality is approximately the same in the two cities using a transfer of the benefit function we compared the direct estimated benefits from improved air quality with the transferred benefits in the same city the originality of this test is that the valued good is the same in both cities which means that the transfer is an intra site transfer however our findings show that the method of benefit transfer was not generally valid indeed inhabitants of kehl declared a higher price for their state of health and air quality than inhabitants in strasbourg this result could be explained by a stronger sensitivity to environmental problems in germany

political economic chaos abstract this paper investigates the political business cycle when interest group pressure on fiscal policy is incorporated two cases are investigated one in which only autonomous investment is included and one in which a kaldor type induced investment function is incorporated in both cases chaotic fluctuations can emerge even when the politically motivated fiscal forcing term is fairly small

federal reserve independence abstract the federal reserve is always called an independent agency the term independent is rarely defined the only attempt in the literature and internal records is based on chairman martin s statement that the federal reserve is independent with the government not independent of the government martin explained several times that independence within government meant that the federal reserve helped to finance government budget because they were approved by congress and signed by the president financing budget deficits is the very opposite of the principle adopted when congress approved the federal reserve act in 1913 in fact the federal reserve has supported treasury operations many times i conclude that it is far more important to have an enforceable policy rule such as the taylor rule but any rule must have a provision that permits the rule to be set aside

political business cycles 40 years after nordhaus the aim of this article is to survey the huge literature that has emerged in the last four decades following nordhaus s rev econ stud 42 2 169 190 1975 publication on political business cycles pbcs i first propose some developments in history of thought to examine the context in which this ground breaking contribution saw the light of the day i also present a simplified version of nordhaus s model to highlight his key results i detail some early critiques of this model and the fields of investigations to which they gave birth i then focus on the institutional context and examine its influence on pbcs the actual research agenda finally i derive some paths for future research

general economic conditions and national elections the fact that economic conditions influence voters is a leading commonplace of conversation in election years the question is is this fact in fact a fact despite the overwhelming popularity of the fact it has received neither an explicit theoretical analysis presumably because it is so obvious that economic adversity should create political adversaries nor until recently a satisfactory statistical analysis gerald h kramer has presented a multivariate analysis of congressional elections which would strongly suggest that fluctuations in the rate of unemployment have no appreciable effect upon elections but that fluctuations in per capita real income are influential in the following pages i propose to 1 reaffirm his finding on the electoral unimportance of ordinary fluctuations in unemployment 2 argue that contrary to kramer fluctuations in real income also do not have important electoral effects and 3 present an argument based upon rational voter behavior for the unimportance of general economic conditions in national elections

deficits money and inflation abstract this paper examines the interrelationships between monetary and fiscal policy specifically it seeks to determine whether government budget deficits influence monetary growth using a money supply model originally developed by barro we find that deficits have had a significant impact on the growth of the u s money supply throughout most of the period since 1961 such a relationship need not always hold it depends on whether government deficits place upward pressure on interest rates and whether the central bank monetizes the debt in an effort to stabilize interest rates

characterizing the effects of valuation methodology in function based benefits transfer abstract meta analyses have demonstrated that willingness to pay wtp estimates vary systematically according to methodological factors the benefits transfer literature provides little guidance with regard to the treatment of such effects transfers are typically conducted by ignoring such effects using ad hoc adjustments or otherwise suppressing information regarding the sensitivity of wtp to methodological attributes this paper illustrates a means to characterize methodological effects within benefits transfer based on an application of the common bootstrap drawing from meta analysis the approach characterizes the sampling distribution of wtp with respect to patterns of methodological variation present in underlying studies results provide a means to characterize the extent of variation associated with predefined groups of methodological attributes providing transparent information on the sensitivity of wtp not typically available in benefits transfer

do contingent valuation estimates pass a scope test a meta analysis abstract this paper considers the scope test proposed to judge the internal consistency of contingent valuation estimates the test is shown to be quite sensitive to the maintained hypotheses required to derive fairly precise expectations for the properties of wtp functions and therefore a different approach may be needed in gauging the reliability of cv this paper describes an approach that relies on a weight of the evidence criterion and uses meta analysis to develop a systematic appraisal of what the economic values of changes in amenity resources are the approach is illustrated for the case of estimating people s willingness to pay for improving or maintaining visibility at the national parks

the applicability of the traditional theory of economic policy abstract the traditional theory of economic policy requires targets instruments an empirical economic model and a social welfare or criterion function to be specified in order to derive the optimal economic policy empirical studies of reaction functions suggest that economic policy is carried out in some systematic manner subject to interference from political factors this survey addresses the problems of specifying estimating and applying an economic model when economic policy is following a path specified by a reaction function attention is paid to rational expectations the lucas critique and the policy neutrality proposition lack of knowledge of the policy maker s objective function poses the most serious difficulty when applying the theory of economic policy various methods of determining this function are reviewed and the possibility that policy makers might be satisficing is discussed the role played by political factors is considered in the light of the public choice literature

how reliable are meta analyses for international benefit transfers meta analysis has increasingly been used to synthesise the environmental valuation literature but only a few test the use of these analyses for benefit transfer these are typically based on national studies only however meta analyses of valuation studies across countries are a potentially powerful tool for benefit transfer especially for environmental goods where the domestic literature is scarce we test the reliability of such international meta analytic transfers and find that even under conditions of homogeneity in valuation methods cultural and institutional conditions across countries and a meta analysis with large explanatory power the transfer errors could still be large further international meta analytic transfers do not on average perform better than simple value transfers averaging over domestic studies thus we question whether the use of meta analysis for practical benefit transfer achieves reliability gains justifying the increased effort however more meta analytic benefit transfer tests should be performed for other environmental goods and other countries before discarding international meta analysis as a tool for benefit transfer

the keynesian and political determinants of unbalanced budgets u s fiscal policy from eisenhower to reagan the political business cycle proposition that politicians manipulate fiscal policy for political advantage is largely untested more often than not such manipulation is only assumed to occur on the basis of observed movements in inflation and unemployment and the few direct tests of the manipulation hypothesis are characterized by limited consideration of the full possibilities for political influence inadequate control for nonpolitical stabilization policy and inconsistent results this paper constructs several models of political fiscal policy incorporates them into a simple model of keynesian stabilization policy and tests the combined models using u s budget surplus deficit data from fy54 to fy83 the results provide little support for either the electoral motivation or partisan differences interpretations of the political business cycle the implications of these findings for the political business cycle literature long term economic management and deficit directed proposals for institutional reform are discussed

meta analytic benefit transfer of outdoor recreation economic values testing out of sample convergent validity a benefit transfer approach to recreationeconomic valuation using meta analysis isexamined since the meta regression modeltakes into account some of the study specificeffects on willingness to pay wtp estimates benefit transfer using meta analysis couldyield a valid wtp estimate of unstudiedrecreation resources the convergent validityof the meta analytic benefit transfer is testedusing out of sample original studies from theu s the analyses are performed usingpercentage difference paired t test regression and correlation tests the testsreveal mixed results on convergence betweenestimated wtp using meta analytic benefittransfer function btf and out of sampleoriginal wtp values there is a fairly highpercentage difference between the estimated andoriginal wtp values 80 88 and the meandifferences are statistically significant asshown by paired t tests however correlationand regression results consistently showsignificant positive relationships betweennational btf estimated and original wtp valuesindicating some level of convergence theresults show that the national btf outperformthe regional btf indicating a potential of thenational btf for recreation benefit transferwhen a first best primary valuation study isnot affordable

what experimental protocol influence disparities between actual and hypothetical stated values preferences elicited in hypothetical settings have recently come underscrutiny causing estimates from the contingent valuation method to bechallenged due to perceived hypothetical bias given that the receivedliterature derives value estimates using heterogeneous experimentaltechniques understanding the effects of important design parameters onthe magnitude of hypothetical bias is invaluable in this paper we addressthis issue statistically by using a meta analysis to examine data from 29experimental studies our empirical findings suggest that on averagesubjects overstate their preferences by a factor of about 3 in hypotheticalsettings and that the degree of over revelation is influenced by thedistinction between willingness to pay and willingness to accept publicversus private goods and several elicitation methods

electoral politics and monetary policy does the bank of canada contribute to a political business cycle in this paper i apply the work of abrams and iossifov public choice 129 249 262 2006 to monetary policy in canada to see if same political party affiliation is needed to produce evidence of political opportunism after modifying their analysis to maintain the time series consistency of their variables for canada i find that both an error correction model and a taylor rule reformulation of their test generate evidence consistent with same party political opportunism but only weakly so on the other hand i also find the presence of more traditional indicators of political influence in particular the data suggest that the election of a liberal party government a decrease in the degree of political competition and to a lesser extent the election of a minority government all positively influence the expansiveness of canadian monetary policy

presidential politics budget deficits and monetary policy in the united states 1960 1976 this paper has focused on the extent to which the traditional tools of macroeconomic management in the united states monetary and fiscal policy have contributed to a political business cycle regardless of whether politicians can successfully influence real economic variables to their own ends the evidence presented here suggests that they tried and that they enjoyed some at least indirect aid from their independent monetary authorities in doing so several major conclusions emerge

the relationship between budget deficits and money demand evidence from a small economy a considerable number of empirical studies exploring the links between budget deficits and the demand for money have led to mixed results by using annual data of the greek economy and previous empirical studies this paper empirically evaluates the sensitivity and validity of the keynesian proposition and the ricardian equivalence hypothesis the paper employs cointegration ecm methodology and several diagnostic and specification tests the empirical findings show a significant and positive relationship between budget deficits and the demand for money supporting the keynesian model

the political timing of errors in inflation forecasts errors in inflation forecasts do not display a regular electoral rhythm over the entire post war period these results are consistent with the work of mccallum 1978 who explored a sample of similar length and failed to find an electoral pattern in unemployment rates however if unanticipated inflation is regarded as a lagging indicator of policy effectiveness then the data do suggest that three of the four most recent administrations have enjoyed a certain success in manufacturing a pre election upturn

political instability and economic fluctuations in the republic of korea this paper investigates the interaction between political instability and economic fluctuations during the late president chung hee park s regime the timings and outcomes of the elections are juxtaposed with the phases of business cycles and analyzed since no korean data that are comparable to gallup poll popularity indices for the u s presidents exist indices to measure popular discontent with park s regime and to measure international tensions are devised these indices are statistically analyzed with economic indicators for the business cycles and with economic policy measures

unanticipated money and the political business cycle six different series of one period forecasts for money growth are generated for each year 1960 through 1984 the prediction errors are analyzed to see whet herthe authorities attempted to expand the economy in election years by unexpectedly raising money growth while there is no evidence of attempts to fool the public throughout the entire 1960 84 period such fooling may have been tried through 1974 it is speculated that the public discussion of expectations formation and of politicians motivations since then may have signaled officials that further attempts to mislead the public would be prohibitively costly copyright 1986 by ohio state university press

fiscal constraints and electoral manipulation in american social welfare a merican social welfare policy involves a politically significant fiscal interaction between short run pay as you go constraints and long run equilibrium constraints motivated by the contributory principle and the concept of actuarial soundness the fiscal constraints induce conflict between benefit recipients and payroll tax payers to support small election year reductions in payroll taxes means tested program benefits are slightly reduced in election years compared to non election year levels under similar economic conditions the existence of the constraints and of the election year changes is tested using a multivariate time series regression model of monthly transfer payments and contributions for social insurance during years 1948 87 short run dynamics arefound to be weakly incrementalist but otherwise the results support the argument extraordinary manipulations are identified during 1972 special technical features of the econometric analysis are a nonlinear dynamic specification robust generalized method of moments estimation and near cointegration

international transmission of us macroeconomic policy and the inflation record of western europe abstract the interaction between monetary policy government budget deficits and inflation is examined for the four largest western european economies comprising france italy the united kingdom and west germany in order to assess the possible impact of us macroeconomic policy past us monetary base growth deficits and inflation rates are included in the set of explanatory variables for each of the european countries empirical results for the 1962 2 1985 4 sample period reveal interplay between domestic monetary and fiscal policy to be augmented by a significant impact of the us variables across all four countries in the sample

environmental value transfer state of the art and future prospects abstract the main objectives of the paper are to 1 give an overview of the state of the art of environmental value transfer 2 discuss its prospects and potential role in cba as a decision support tool and 3 provide further guidelines for proper use and application environmental value or benefit transfer is a technique in which the results of studies on monetary environmental valuation are applied to new policy contexts the technique is controversial not least because of academic and political reservations over the usefulness and technical feasibility of economic valuation tools to demonstrate the importance of environmental values in project or programme appraisals testing of environmental value transfer so far has been unable to validate the practice taking into account the conditions set out in the literature for valid and reliable value transfer most transfers appear to result in substantial transfer errors this paper discusses why and addresses the question of which factors may have been overlooked it is argued that the problem is much more fundamental than previously acknowledged strict guidelines in terms of quantitative adjustment mechanisms to valid value transfer are meaningless if the more fundamental issue of differences in the very nature of the values elicited is not addressed at the same time

monetary policy signaling from the administration to the federal reserve this chapter employs the index of monetary policy signaling from the administration to the federal reserve safer that was developed in chapter two the safer index is a simple weekly sum of articles that appeared in the wall street journal in which administration officials expressed a desire for easier 1 or tighter 1 monetary policy a key assumption is that systematically over time the financial media capture the essence of communication that is going on between the executive branch and federal reserve officials 1 the signaling index is employed in ordinary least squares regressions for the period from january 1964 to november 1991 cumulative values of the safer index over a three week period as an explanatory variable are found to have a statistically significant effect on the average federal funds rate during the third week as the dependent variable further evidence suggests that the safer index is granger causal with respect to the federal funds rate after classifying the signals by sources within the administration oval office council of economic advisers treasury and other and unidentified sources it is shown that for the overall 1964 1991 period signals from the treasury department and from other and unidentified sources have a statistically significant effect on the federal funds rate while signals from the oval office and the council do not when the data are segmented according to who was the chairman of the federal reserve board at the time ordinary least squares results indicate that the federal reserve did not systematically respond to executive branch signaling in a statistically significant way when william mcchesney martin g william miller and alan greenspan were chairmen but did respond statistically significantly to administration signaling during portions of the periods during which arthur burns and paul volcker were chairmen

congress and the federal reserve we examine legislative activity targeting the federal reserve to determine when congress takes an interest in the fed and whether this interest has an effect on monetary policy using a keyword search of the thomas catalogue for the period from january 1973 through december 2010 we identify 1575 bills in the house and 728 bills in the senate pertaining to the federal reserve we classify these bills into several categories including those that expand fed powers and those that threaten or usurp fed powers using the romer and romer 2004 series of monetary policy shocks we find that prior to the early 1980s the fed responded to bills credibly threatening fed powers by lowering the federal funds target below that prescribed by current and forecast economic conditions however this accommodation ceased following the end of the non borrowed reserves targeting period in october 1982 analyzing the determinants of bill sponsorship we find that high unemployment high inflation and high long term real borrowing costs failures of the fed along the three dimensions of its mandate all lead to a greater number of bills seeking to alter the fed s powers importantly we also find that the relative importance of these three dimensions has changed over time under chairmen burns and miller congress took greater interest when unemployment was high under chairman greenspan congress took greater interest when inflation was high we believe that these findings are consistent with the view that the lessons of the great inflation changed the public perception of the fed s macroeconomic responsibilities which in turn better aligned congressional views on policy with those of the fed and allowed the fed to better resist remaining congressional pressure to its independence

are money growth and inflation related to government deficits evidence from ten industrialized economies abstract we present empirical evidence on the relation between the government debt growth money growth and inflation for ten industrialized countries over the post world war ii period non parametric and parametric tests reveal little evidence that government debt growth is either related to money growth or permanently related to inflation over periods of a decade or less but the level of debt is significantly associated with subsequent inflation from 1974 to 1983 these results are consistent with the hypothesis that central banks in developed economies can conduct independent monetary policy over long periods notwithstanding government deficits

is there a dead spot new evidence on fomc decisions before elections using new data that chronicle the fed s internal forecast of the output gap from 1973 to 1998 this paper tests for an electoral cycle in the decisions of the federal open market committee fomc the paper provides evidence of a dead spot in the committee s decisions before presidential elections for given values of these internal forecasts the fomc is less likely to decide to tighten monetary policy in the year preceding a presidential election than at other times

the impact of urbanization on co2 emissions evidence from developing countries abstract this paper analyzes the impact of urbanization on co2 emissions in developing countries from 1975 to 2003 it contributes to the existing literature by examining the effect of urbanization taking into account dynamics and the presence of heterogeneity in the sample of countries the results show an inverted u shaped relationship between urbanization and co2 emissions indeed the elasticity emission urbanization is positive for low urbanization levels which is in accordance with the higher environmental impact observed in less developed regions among our contributions is the estimation of a semi parametric mixture model that allows for unknown distributional shapes and endogenously classifies countries into homogeneous groups three groups of countries are identified for which urbanization s impact differs considerably for two of the groups a threshold level is identified beyond which the emission urbanization elasticity is negative and further increases in the urbanization rate do not contribute to higher emissions however for the third group only population and affluence but not urbanization contribute to explain emissions the differential impact of urbanization on co2 emissions should therefore be taken into account in future discussions of climate change policies

sequencing and the adding up property in contingent valuation of endangered species are contingent non use values economic values this paper presents tests of the theoretical validity of the contingent valuation cv method the validity of cv is especially a concern when involving environmental goods with a predominant non use value one test of theoretical validity is the adding up property that implies that a specific good should be equally valued irrespectively of it is being valued directly or built up sequentially in this cv study four independent sub samples stated willingness to pay for the same composite good or package using different sequences one sub sample valued the composite good directly while two sub samples faced built up sequences valuing first subsets of this composite good a fourth sub sample valued the composite good from a dividing out approach facing first the valuation of a larger multi package theoretically expected sequencing effects were observed the subset goods obtained higher values earlier in a sequence and the dividing out approach decreased the stated value for the composite good most importantly these cv data did pass the tests of the adding up property

political models of the business cycle should be revived political models of the business cycle have typically been ignored because they appear inconsistent with rational behavior and because empirical evidence is inconclusive this paper addresses the second issue demonstrating for u s real gnp unemployment and inflation that electoral cycles persistent patterns across electoral terms are significant but apparently only for republican incumbents and that partisan cycles persistent differences between parties are also significant these findings are consistent with the conjecture that a minority party is more constrained by electoral concerns whereas a majority party is freer to pursue partisan objectives

the congress and fiscal policy although the common belief is that the congress has paid little attention to fiscal policy the same kinds of political economic models which have been used to explain presidential budgetary policy may be used equally well to explain congressional budgetary behavior the congress fiscal policy appears to be systematically sensitive to both economic and political factors changes in the unemployment rate have a major impact on congressional budgetary policy as for political factors the president s lead is followed most closely on revenue proposals and not at all on the expenditure side the electoral cycle in particular the off year congressional election year is also important inducing larger deficits and smaller increases in revenues

monetary policy and presidential elections a nonpartisan political cycle this paper develops a federal reserve reaction function which relates policy intentions to forecasts of policy objectives pre and postpresidential election estimates of this reaction function for the post accord period of 1953 1984 suggest two conclusions

presidential elections and federal reserve policy an empirical test traditional macro economic models of federal reserve fed behavior typically assume that the fed enjoys a well defined objective function based on social welfare and generally predict counter cyclical monetary policy the increasing observation of procyclical monetary policy has led many researchers to investigate new models of fed behavior several recent papers imply that procyclical fed behavior is due to a lack of political accountability friedman 7 toma 23 and shughart and tollison 21 all attribute considerable bureaucratic discretion to the fed and seek to explain monetary policy by examining typical bureaucratic objectives other papers such as pierce 19 20 weintraub 26 and kane 10 11 argue that the fed operates in an arena filled with political constraints that cause sub optimal monetary policy but these constraints are not modeled explicitly one possible political constraint on fed behavior is the incumbent president s desire for re election in the political business cycle pbc literature presidential re election opportunities are enhanced by the production of a precise set of inflation and unemployment outcomes leading up to the election thus to the extent that presidents desire cyclical macro economic outcomes there will be executive pressure on the fed to create or accommodate such outcomes the effect this pressure will have on fed policy is ultimately an empirical question but most models deal with it by assumption traditional macro modeling assumes a zero effect while the pbc models implicitly assume that a favorable election cycle is a primary goal of all economic policymakers this paper examines presidential influence on the federal reserve by testing for an election cycle in money growth the major result is the identification of a regular 16 quarter cycle in money growth corresponding with presidential elections this cyclical effect is found to be stable over time and significant under a wide range of model specifications further when the cyclical component of money growth is used to simulate a simple macro model it produces a classic political business cycle in inflation and real output growth

elections and the fed is there a political monetary cycle to understand the political causes of macroeconomic policy it is necessary to examine the institutions that actually make such policy and the incentives those institutions face an explanation of the political causes of united states monetary policy must treat the various institutions that are influential in the monetary policy process which are at a minimum the federal reserve fed and the executive including the president the treasury department and other advisors in the executive office of the president the reelection motive has proven useful in modeling presidential incentives in this article i investigate whether electoral incentives associated with the theory of the political business cycle pbc can help to explain the behavior of the fed over the last quarter century the political business cycle has had a curious hold on modern political economy while the empirical evidence in favor of the cycle is far from overwhelming its theoretical importance leads to continuing empirical

deficits politics and money growth the authors examine the linkage between federal deficits and money growth by allowing the fed s resp onse to any given deficit to vary systematically according to how the deficit is generated and the party affiliation of the current presid ent in equations for m1 and monetary base growth the structural def icit is consistently significant and invariant across political chang es while the cyclical component of the deficit or a direct measure of the business cycle is significant only during the tenure of democ ratic presidents copyright 1987 by oxford university press

money and politics in a small open economy a time series analysis indicates monetary growth and the gallup poll in canada are systematically related at electoral cycle periodicities 5 to 20 quarters under flexible exchange rates and demonstrates the absence of an electoral component in canadian monetary growth under fixed rates these results confirm empirically a widely accepted extension of the mundell fleming argument that monetary policy is effective only under flexible rates which to my knowledge has not before been directly investigated international constraints on the small open economy under fixed rates lead to the abandonment of monetary policy as an active instrument in electoral politics

interaction between central bank behaviour and fiscal policy the us case federal reserve behaviour is analysed using a model which incorporates an effect an effect of iscal pressure on monetary policy formulation incentive structures are hypothesized to be such that the central bank plans over a longer horizan than that relevant to the administration with the cyclically adjusted deficit proxying for fiscal pressure from the administration the response to the deficit then plays an interactive role in affecting the trade off weights applied to the competing goals of monetary policy the model performs well for the usa and provides a pattern of policy that is stable over the full 1961ndash 83 period

the federal reserve s response to aggregate demand and aggregate supply shocks evidence of a partisan political cycle the orthodox approach to modeling the fed s response to economic conditions is to employ a monetary policy reaction function most reaction functions are estimated by regressing a policy indicator possibly the federal funds rate or a monetary aggregate on variables that describe the state of the economy such as unemployment inflation and growth in output under certain conditions which we discuss below estimated coefficients from a reaction function provide information about the fed s monetary policy priorities moreover extending the model to include election and partisan dummy variables may provide information about the fed s response to political pressures there are two problems with interpreting the coefficients in a standard reaction function as the weights that the fed attaches to its policy objectives first the monetary policy decision may not be represented accurately by an aggregate reaction function one that models the fed as a whole because there are twelve voting members on the fomc chappell havrilesky and mcgregor 10 have recently addressed this issue by employing a disaggregated set of reaction functions the second problem with interpreting reaction function coefficients as the weights the fed places on its policy objectives is that this interpretation implicitly assumes structural stability of the underlying macroeconomy abrams froyen and waud 1 31 acknowledge this shortcoming when they state coefficients from estimated reaction functions do not provide direct information on policymaker utility functions rather than being the solution to an unconstrained optimization dependent only on policymaker preferences reaction functions are the output of a constrained maximization where the constraints are the reduced form equations that characterize