making the same mistake again or is this time different the world faces an economic crisis of unprecedented proportions but much of the policy response has certainly not lacked for precedent national governments and international organisations including the international monetary fund imf have looked to crises of the past for solutions to the present and austerity has become a familiar theme the inability to effectively resolve the current crisis however gives rise to the question is this time different this article provides a broad overview to the origins and development of the recent economic crisis and the resort to policies of austerity although there is historical precedent for the resort to austerity such as the uk treasury view during the 1920s and 1930s this time things are different many of the current problems are deeply rooted and reflect the impact of the shift towards free market economics that started in the 1970s 2 the origins of the crisis since the beginning of the 1970s the private sector finance in particular has reorganised on an increasingly global scale it has innovated in terms of both structure and products and it has experienced significant growth as tridico 2012 this issue shows this financialisation was characterised by a ballooning of stock exchanges as many firms decided not only to list their shares but also to become involved in speculative finance in response to pressures on firms to maximise shareholder value together with the progressive erosion of worker and trade union rights and influence labour markets became more flexible and real wages stagnated concurrently profits rebounded leading to burgeoning inequality in this context aggregate demand and consumption were bolstered by easy credit and the wealth effects of speculative bubbles first in stocks and shares and then in housing

the role of the media in fiscal consolidation programmes the case of ireland a number of european countries have implemented austerity programmes since the onset of the current economic crisis this paper focuses on fiscal consolidation a central aspect of such programmes using the case of ireland it investigates the significant role of the mass media in presenting such policies to the public a role which has so far remained unexamined conceiving of the irish experience over the past few decades as a case of neoliberalisation it uses a critical political economic conceptualisation of news organisations to consider 431 editorials and opinion articles discussing fiscal consolidation in three leading irish newspapers between 2008 and 2012 it finds that the majority of articles present viewpoints in favour of fiscal consolidation and display a preference for spending cuts over tax hikes which substantiates the claim that ireland has adopted neoliberal policies to address the crisis only a minority of articles oppose fiscal consolidation these mostly contest specific spending cuts but usually fail to criticise fiscal consolidation itself by calling for economic alternatives such as keynesian stimulus differences between newspapers are also discussed highlighting their ideological cleavages

the ambiguous impact of inequality on local resource management abstract the impact of inequality on the ability of human groups to undertake successful collective action is investigated with special reference to overexploitation of common property resources in voluntary provision problems on the one hand inequality has an ambiguous impact on the feasibility of the efficient outcome even though better endowed agents contribute more to collective action in regulated settings on the other hand inequality tends to reduce the acceptability of available regulatory schemes and therefore to make collective action more difficult

equilibria in unidirectional spatial models abstract this paper a characterizes the unique nash equilibrium of the unidirectional hotelling downs game in which firms maximize their market shares for any distribution of the consumers and b analyzes equilibrium behavior in the variation of the game in which each firm aims to secure a larger market share than its competitor in the first case firms employ identical mixed strategies and each of them serves in expected terms a fraction 1 e of the market and in both cases no firm ever locates in a position to the left of the first quartile of the consumers distribution

conceptualising environmental collective action why gender matters this paper demonstrates how institutions for natural resource management such as community forestry groups which appear to be participative equitable and efficient can be found lacking on all three counts from a gender perspective it also examines possible gender differences in social networks values and motivations although there is little to suggest that women are inherently more conservationist than men the distinctness of women s social networks embodying prior experience of successful cooperation their higher dependence on these networks as also on the commons in general and their potentially greater group homogeneity relative to men could provide an important and largely ignored basis for organising sustainable environmental collective action the paper also outlines the factors that can constrain or facilitate women s participation in formal environmental management groups illustrative examples are drawn from rural south asia

transaction costs collective action and survival of heterogeneous co management institutions case study of forest management organisations in west bengal india abstract cost effective natural resource management is important for equity and efficiency yet transaction costs of cooperation may pose a challenge to heterogeneous co management institutions we conducted a survey in seven forest protection committees of west bengal india to examine this hypothesis empirically we find that 1 among several factors caste heterogeneity distance to forest political heterogeneity land inequality and trust systematically influence transaction costs and collective action and 2 robust institutions bear less costs of cooperation the implication is that transaction costs related to heterogeneity may exert significant influence on successes or failures of co management

collective action for market chain innovation in the andes the papa andina network employs collective action in two novel approaches for fostering market chain innovation the participatory market chain approach pmca and stakeholder platforms engage small potato producers together with market agents and agricultural service providers in group activities to identify common interests share market knowledge and develop new business opportunities these forms of collective action have generated commercial technological and institutional innovations and created new market niches for andean native potatoes grown by poor farmers in remote highland areas these innovations have benefited small farmers as well as other market chain actors this paper describes papa andina s experiences with collective action for market chain innovation it then discusses the implications of these experiences for the understanding of collective action and the policy implications for research and development organizations

sequential location when transportation costs are asymmetric abstract in this paper i study sequential location by three firms when it is more costly for a consumer to move in one direction say to the left than to move to the right i provide a limit result for the ease when the difference between left and right transportation costs approaches zero this result resolves an equilibrium selection problem in the case of symmetric transportation costs i also discuss the entry pattern and the presence of a first mover advantage in the asymmetry case

collective action for small scale producers of agricultural biodiversity products the role of well functioning markets for development is now widely recognized however the challenge remains to make these markets benefit the poor and the environment increasing attention is being given to the potential role markets can play for agrobiodiversity conservation through product diversification and increasing competitiveness in niche and novelty markets several case studies were undertaken that explore the use of market based approaches to on farm agrobiodiversity management and livelihood improvement this paper explores how the theory of collective action can provide a more synthetic understanding of how market chains operate and the changes that could permit a more equitable distribution of benefits the case studies illustrate the need for improved trust mutual understanding of each actor s involvement and an agreed process of collective action with a high level of community participation the cases differ in their degree of collective action the level of market organization and the ways in which handling processing and innovative marketing add value to the agrobiodiversity products comparative analysis identified a range of situations in which market development can support agrobiodiversity conservation and livelihoods

cooperative membership and dairy performance among smallholders in ethiopia this study assesses the impact of cooperative membership among dairy producers in selale ethiopia we selected ten impact indicators proportion of dairy income to total household income total dairy income proportion of crossbreed cows to the total number of cows in the herd indicator of technological innovation amount of feed bought another indicator of technological innovation milk production milk productivity commercialization price per liter of milk price per kg of butter and the share of milk production that is processed at the household level in order to minimize the biases that may arise by simply comparing members and non members we employed a propensity score matching technique the empirical analysis shows that cooperatives are strong in facilitating technological transformations and commercialization but weak in offering better prices these findings suggest structural trade offs between different domains of cooperatives action overall our study concludes that cooperatives can be efficient business institutions to foster rural development and food security

the impact of changes in common property resource management on intrahousehold allocation abstract in developing countries common property resources cprs can be an important source of income for certain individuals within households this paper demonstrates that if changes in the management of cprs impose fixed costs on them or cause a decline in the prices of goods produced from it the intrahousehold allocation of resources may alter in a manner detrimental to those individuals the paper also shows that the assumption of a unitary household model causes the detrimental effects of certain cpr policy interventions to be overlooked although the model is narrowly conceived the results can be generalised to examples where households have members who specialise in different economic activities outside the home

common property institutions and sustainable governance of resources abstract the literature on common property based resource management comprises many important studies that seek to specify the conditions under which groups of users will self organize and sustainably govern resources upon which they depend using three of the more comprehensive such studies and with an extensive review of writings on the commons this paper demonstrates that the enterprise of generating lists of conditions under which commons are governed sustainably is a flawed and impossibly costly research task for a way out the paper examines the relative merits of statistical comparative and case study approaches to studying the commons it ends with a plea for careful research design and sample selection construction of causal mechanisms and a shift toward comparative and statistical rather than single case analyses such steps are necessary for a coherent empirically relevant theory of the commons

biological and economic foundations of renewable resource exploitation abstract a physiologically based population dynamics model of a renewable resource is used as the basis to develop a model of human harvesting the model incorporates developing technology and the effects of market forces on the sustainability of common property resources the bases of the model are analogies between the economics of resource harvesting and allocation by firms and adapted organisms in nature specifically the paper makes the following points 1 it shows how economic and ecological theories may be unified 2 it punctuates the importance of time frame in the two systems evolutionary versus market 3 it shows contrary to prevailing economic wisdom how technological progress may be detrimental to resource preservation 4 it shows how the anticipated effects of high discount rates on resource use can be catastrophic when synergized by progress in harvesting technology 5 it suggests that increases in efficiency of utilization of the harvest encourages higher levels of resource exploitation and 6 it shows the effects of environmental degradation on consumer and resource dynamics the model leads to global implications on the relationship between economic growth and the ability of modern societies to maintain the environment at a sustainable level

the impact of high value markets on smallholder productivity in the ecuadorean sierra a stochastic production frontier approach correcting for selectivity bias abstract this paper uses data from small scale potato farmers in ecuador to examine the impact of the program plataformas de concertacion on productivity growth using propensity score matching combined with a stochastic production frontier model that corrects for sample selection bias we disaggregate the yield growth attributable to the program into technological change tc and technical efficiency te while the results do not exhibit a clear indication of selection bias the analysis does show that on average beneficiaries exhibit higher yields than control farmers given the same input levels but lower te with respect to their own frontiers these results suggest that while the program raised the technology gap in favor of beneficiaries it had a negative effect on te in the short run the latter finding is consistent with the notion that beneficiaries enjoyed a significant change in production techniques but it is very likely that they were still in the learning by doing stages at the time the data was collected in fact the results suggest a fast recovery in te levels on the part of beneficiaries as time with project increased

the euro crisis undetected by conventional economics favoured by nationally focused polity this article interprets the initial success of the launch of the euro and its muddling through since the outbreak of the greek sovereign debt crisis two interrelated processes interacted to deliver a quite complex idiosyncratic systemic crisis first new classical macroeconomics had diffused the belief that market economies are structurally stable money is neutral financial markets are efficient and that the only culprit is public finance the euro crisis was thus inaccurately diagnosed second in the political arena monetary integration has been used by many governments as a justification for liberalisation reforms opposed by various domestic social groups at the european level most governments have been defending national interests whereas the european commission and european parliament had lost most of their expertise and legitimacy in defending a common community in line euro ambitions crisis resolution calls for leadership from a key collective actor to return coherence to the eurozone s institutional setting copyright oxford university press

common property equality and development the appeal of common property ideas may be traced in large measure to the fact that they seem to embody widely held values of equality on the other hand empirical examination of common property institutions reveals that they can coexist with significant inequality in this paper the relationship between common property and equality is examined it is argued that the role of common property can only be understood in the context of the associated private property institutions common property in agriculture is interpreted as part of a system based on small scale peasant proprietorship of arable land common property institutions provide a method of capturing scale economies and thereby increasing the efficiency of small scale proprietorship in competition with large scale production based on wage labor

not your grandfather s imf global crisis productive incoherence and developmental policy space the response by the international monetary fund imf and developing country national governments to the current global financial crisis represents a moment of what i term productive incoherence which has displaced the constraining neoliberal coherence of the past several decades productive incoherence refers to the proliferation of inconsistent and even contradictory strategies and statements by the imf that to date have not congealed into any sort of new organised regime those who see continuity at the imf emphasise the reassertion of the imf s authority the reiteration of pro cyclical policy adjustment and the maintenance of existing governance patterns within the institution in contrast evidence of discontinuity includes a world now populated by increasingly autonomous states in the south the normalisation of capital controls and fund conditionality programmes that are inconsistent in key respects in the face of this evidence it is best to understand the current conjuncture as an interregnum that is pregnant with new development possibilities

an economic theory of church strictness this paper introduces spatial location models into the economics of religion we offer a new explanation for the observed tendency of state monopoly churches to locate toward the low tension end of the strictness continuum obtained through the conjunction of benevolent preferences denominations care about the aggregate utility of members and asymmetric costs of going to a more or less strict church than one prefers we derive implications regarding the relationship between religious strictness and membership religious market interactions and asymmetric costs of membership highlight new explanations for some well established stylised facts opening the way to new empirical comparisons with more traditional explanations

from miracle to cronyism explaining the great asian slump explanations are about the only thing not in short supply in the asian crisis for all their diversity they can be collapsed into two meta interpretations reflecting deeper differences in beliefs about rationality and markets those whose world view emphasizes rationality self adjusting markets and market failure as exceptional except when governments introduce distortions tend to see the crisis as the result of rational calculations in a situation of market distorting government interventions and institutional weaknesses in asian economies those whose world view stresses non rationality or a different kind of rationality than that assumed by neoclassical theory routine failure of well working markets and the need for government interventions to modify market outcomes tend to see it as the result of non rational calculations in under regulated financial markets both national and international

commons regulation and rent seeking behavior the dilemma of pakistan s guzara forests curred over the past 120 years these forests known locally as guzara forests can be characterized as regulated commons the regulation by placing quantitative restrictions on felling aimed at an orderly exploitation of these forests on the surface the failure of regulation seems to be a simple case of enforcement failure however a closer look reveals a fairly complex picture in which factors such as the delineation of property rights and the rent seeking behavior of those subject to regulation as well as of the regulators themselves have contributed to the problems of these forests the evidence presented in this article shows that the way the regulation was devised gave rise to a discordant structure of property rights involving the government and the local inhabitants despite early signals that it could not be effectively enforced no rectifying change was introduced in the structure of rights which has persisted into the postcolonial era indeed there was a reversal of some potentially beneficial institutional changes that had been introduced toward the end of the colonial period while the process of degradation was set in motion by discordances that arose in the process of delineating property rights it is the theory of rentseeking behavior that provides an adequate explanation of its persistence as well as of the subsequent reversals an effective response to the problem of the guzara forests must take account of two additional features in the regulation of these forests first in addition to the common property externality that leads to the tragedy of the commons these forests also display interjurisdictional externality by virtue of their location second a common

the price is right but are the bids an investigation of rational decision theory the television game show the price is right is used as a laboratory to conduct a preference free test of rational decision theory in an environment with substantial economic incentives it is found that contestants strategies are transparently suboptimal in response to this evidence simple rules of thumb are developed that are shown to explain observed bidding patterns better than rational decision theory further learning during the show reduces the frequency of strategic errors this is interpreted as evidence of bounded rationality finally there is no evidence that a concern for fairness significantly alters bidding behavior copyright 1996 by american economic association

price competition when consumer behavior is characterized by conformity or vanity it has long been recognized that the pleasure of consuming a good may be affected by the consumption choice of other consumers in some cases social pressures may lead to conformity in some others individuals may feel the need of exclusiveness under the form of vanity such externalities have proven to be important in several markets however the market implication of these externalities are still unclear to investigate them we propose to combine the consumption externality model and the spatial duopoly model when conformity is present but not too strong both firms remain in business but price competition is fiercer and results in lower prices the market share of the large firm increases with the population size as the population keeps rising the large firm may serve the entire market and set a price that has the nature of a limit price when conformity is strong enough different equilibria may exist in most of these equilibria a single firm captures the whole market at the other extreme when vanity is at work price competition is relaxed

the existence of equilibrium in discontinuous economic games i theory the article presents information about the existence of equilibrium in discontinuous economic games in this paper and its sequel presents study the existence of nash equilibrium in games where agents payoff functions are discontinuous the enquiry is motivated by a number of recent studies that have uncovered serious existence problems in seemingly innocuous economic games in the sequel to this paper authors have explained the utility function in the economic games referred to earlier are neither continuous nor quasi concave however they demonstrate that the payoff functions in mildly modified versions of these constructs exhibit two weaker forms of continuity which together with the requirement of quasi concavity suffice for the existence of an equilibrium from this one may conclude that at least in the modified versions of these models discontinuities in the payoff functions are not the real source of the problem rather it is the failure of the payoff functions to the quasi concave which is responsible for the non existence of equilibrium these observations bear on the existence of nash equilibrium in pure strategies

the structure of a contract and the theory of a non exclusive resource the process of arriving at a useful concept of analysis is not only slow and painful but also may go astray and attain nothing useful someone begins with one example or observation followed by a theory which is intuitively plausible a theoretical term associated with a vague concept is coined examples of a seemingly different type emerge which call for another theory the process goes on as examples and theories continue to accumulate the different categories under the same heading of analysis serve only to confuse and each associated theory becomes ad hoc such has been the fate of the concept of externality a more useful approach i think is via contractual conditions the example chosen for illustration is marine fisheries where the fishing right is taken

collective action for local commons management in rural yunnan china empirical evidence and hypotheses using evolutionary game theory this paper presents hypotheses regarding collective actions for irrigation management with the help of evolutionary game theory data for the analysis were collected by the author from the irrigation system of rural yunnan china an econometric analysis reveals that collective action will be forthcoming in rural communities where few nonfarm job opportunities are provided the degree of income disparity is quite small and resource restrictions are moderately problematic the finding that communities without local government intervention outperform those with intervention supports the proverbial view that external agencies should delegate significant parts of the control rights of common pool resources to immediate stakeholders

property rights regimes and natural resources a conceptual analysis the term common property resource is an example of a term repeatedly used to refer to property owned by a government or by no one it is also used for property owned by a community of resource users such usage leads to confusion in scientific study and policy analysis in this paper we develop a conceptual schema for arraying property rights regimes that distinguishes among diverse bundles of rights ranging from authorized user to claimant to proprietor and to owner we apply this conceptual schema to analyze findings from a variety of empirical settings including the maine lobster industry

common property and collective action in economic development abstract a fundamental issue in many ldcs is the degree to which natural resource mismanagement is caused by common property arrangements this view has led to widespread attempts to privatize forests rangelands and water resources many of these efforts have failed to stop overuse and have contributed to inequality in resource distribution this paper seriously questions this approach and describes a number of reasons why common property may continue to be both efficient and equitable complementing and combining with private rights in a way consistent with the resource endowments of village economies a theoretical approach is outlined showing that the tragedy of the commons is an unsatisfactory model of common property an alternative model is presented together with a call for research into institutional alternatives in resource management

iceland s rise fall stabilisation and beyond iceland is an unusually pure example of the dynamics that blocked regulation and caused financial fragility across the developed world for 20 years this essay describes the statist and corporatist political economy of the country as it soared from near the bottom of the western european income hierarchy at the end of the world war ii to up near the top by the 1980s it illustrates how a group of neoliberal politicians and allied civil servants drove through selective deregulation and privatisation in the 1990s and 2000s in the space created for newly privatised banks icelandic financiers grew the banks and linked private equity firms through mergers and acquisitions abroad to the point where by 2007 tiny iceland supported three banks in the world s biggest 300 banks with assets eight times the gdp second highest in the world after switzerland as profits from these overseas operations were partly redistributed back to iceland the economy boomed in the grip of super minsky processes the government the banks and the media interpreted the boom as testimony to the validity of neoliberal policies and went out of their way to hide increasing financial fragility from view preventing a negative or self correcting policy feedback loop the accident waiting to happen happened in the wake of the lehman collapse in september 2008 the essay charts the zigzags of the government s response and the citizens response and discusses the prospects for a resumption of growth on a more sustainable basis it suggests that iceland illustrates in miniature the ratcheting down of mass living standards underway across the western world now that the cushion of debt has been removed even as financiers and others in the top few percentiles of national income distributions increase their share of national income but economic institutions and politics matter in iceland the large devaluation spread the cut in a relatively apolitical way the government let the banks go bust rather than bail them out at taxpayers expense it imposed capital controls on outflows and it used fiscal transfers to protect the bottom half of the population from disproportionate cuts

linking smallholders to the new agricultural economy the case of the plataformas de concertacion in ecuador abstract this article examines the challenges of linking smallholders to high value food markets by looking at the experience of the plataformas programme in the ecuadorian sierra multiple evaluation methods are employed to ensure identification of program impact the findings suggest that the programme successfully improved the welfare of beneficiary farmers as measured by yields and gross margins these benefits are achieved through improving the efficiency of agricultural production and through selling at higher prices no significant secondary health or environmental effects were found overall the programme provides clear evidence that combining production support with facilitating market access can be successful

why research partnerships really matter innovation theory institutional arrangements and implications for developing new technology for the poor abstract this paper explores the conceptual basis for existing and emergent institutional patterns in the context of partnership approaches to technology development drawing examples from recent studies of private enterprise activity in india smallholder horticulture it suggests that agricultural innovation as a process involves a wider range of organizational types than the conventional policy focus on public sector research organizations would tend to suggest it uses the concept of a national innovation system to argue that a partnership approach is adopted as a core methodology for engaging science and technology development with the livelihood demands of the poor

tenure issues in higher education the system of tenure that dominates american higher education has long been a source of controversy the institution of tenure has been attacked for entrenching a lazy professoriate more interested in attending faraway conferences and producing unreadable research than in teaching or developing practical insights while on the other hand it has long been defended as an absolute necessity for the defense of open intellectual inquiry the tenure controversy has been sharpened in recent years by several events the end of mandatory retirement which was abolished by federal law effective january 1 1994 has heightened concerns about the productivity and commitment of professors who received tenure long ago and who no longer have the same incentives to invest in long term reputation there is also ongoing concern over the steadily rising cost of higher education which raises the question of what students as well as the taxpayers who support public institutions of higher education are getting for their money 1 the idea that tenure is a wasteful institution for universities runs up against the puzzling fact that the commitment to tenure is one that academic institutions impose on themselves although the american association of university professors aaup provides a powerful lobby in favor of tenure generally colleges and universities most notably private ones are under no legal requirement to observe tenure constraints although as administrators we certainly feel the weight of those constraints our view is that a tenure system in fact provides important benefits to society and to colleges and universities we argue here that the role of tenure is

regulation in the market for education and optimal choice of curriculum we analyze educational institutions incentives to set up demanding or lax curricula in duopolistic markets for education with endogenous enrolment of students we assume that there is a positive externality of student achievement on the local economy comparing the case of regulated tuition fees with an unregulated market we identify the following ine ciencies under regulated tuition fees schools will set up ine ciently lax curricula in an attempt to please low quality students even if schools internalize some of the externality on the other hand unregulated schools set up excessively di erentiated curricula in order to relax competition in tuition fees deregulation gets more attractive if a larger fraction of the externality is internalized

ejido reforms in mexico conceptual issues and potential outcomes the evolving privatization of the ejido system in mexico represents a challenge to standard economic models of common property regimes these models tend to emphasize human interrelations while discounting the ecological conditions which form the environment for human interactions a risk spreading safety first model capturing interrelationships between nature and humans is developed to analyze the potential implications of mexico s privatization efforts recognizing that the majority of ejido lands are communal not parcelized located primarily in arid areas the model supports the prediction that privatization will occur and be most successful on irrigated ejido lands with modern social and economic infrastructure

adding environment to the collective action problem individuals civil society and the mangrove fishery commons in ecuador summary research on the commons suggests a more robust understanding of human resource interactions is needed to strengthen theories about collective action and sustainable governance i combine ethnographic and fishery data to explore how resource characteristics and institutions influence people s behavior toward common pool resources in coastal ecuador this comparative study of the commons at two levels mangroves and the cockle fishery highlights how trust communication and social obligation depend on social histories of resource systems and types of collective action problems largely explaining why local institutions encourage individuals to uphold mangrove forest conservation but have little effect on cooperation in fisheries