retail payments new contributions empirical results and unanswered questions abstract we offer a selected survey of retail payments and suggest areas where additional research would prove useful after summarizing eight papers presented at a recent norges bank central bank of norway payment conference and published in this volume we show how they and many of the other papers presented there have contributed to the payments literature we also illustrate how institutional and other differences across countries led to different payment arrangements historically which now due to technological innovation affecting bank costs have made payment arrangements across countries more homogeneous

payment card rewards programs and consumer payment choice abstract by using a unique data set that contains detailed information about consumer payment choice and consumers attitudes toward each payment method we estimate the effects of payment card rewards on consumer choice of payment methods our approach allows us to control for consumer heterogeneity we find the effects of rewards to be statistically significant across five retail types our policy experiments suggest that for the sub population who hold both credit and debit cards removing rewards would increase their share of paper based payment methods i e cash and checks measured in terms of in store transactions by no more than 4 percentage points

the dual structure of incomplete demand systems integrability of incomplete demand systems is discussed the concepts of weak integrability quasi expenditure function quasi indirect utility function and quasi utility function are defined their relationships to the expenditure function indirect utility function and utility function are developed the dual structure of the quasi functions permits exact welfare analysis and reveals the conditional preference structure for the commodities of interest new results relating the uniqueness and exactness of consumer s surplus to the structure of the expenditure and indirect utility functions are obtained

optimal policies for a capacitated two echelon inventory system this paper demonstrates optimal policies for capacitated serial multiechelon production inventory systems extending the clark and scarf 1960 model to include installations with production capacity limits we demonstrate that a modified echelon base stock policy is optimal in a two stage system when there is a smaller capacity at the downstream facility this is shown by decomposing the dynamic programming value function into value functions dependent upon individual echelon stock variables we show that the optimal structure holds for both stationary and nonstationary stochastic customer demand finite horizon and infinite horizon results are included under discounted cost and average cost criteria

money is privacy an extensive literature in monetary theory has emphasized the role of money as a record keeping device money assumes this role in situations where using credit would be too costly and some might argue that this role will diminish as the cost of information and thus the cost of credit based transactions continues to fall in this paper we investigate another use for money the provision of privacy that is a money purchase does not identify the purchaser while a credit purchase does in a simple trading economy with moral hazard the efficiency of money is compared with that of credit and we find that money may be useful even when information is free

a time series framework for supply chain inventory management we consider a supply chain in which the underlying demand process can be described in a linear state space form inventory is managed at various points of the chain members based on local information that each member observes and continuously updates the key feature of our model is that it takes into account the ability of the members to observe subsets of the underlying state vector and adopt their forecasting and replenishment policies accordingly this enables us to model situations in which the members are privy to certain explanatory variables of the demand with the latter possibly evolving according to a vector autoregressive time series for each member we identify an associated demand evolution model for which we propose an adaptive inventory replenishment policy that utilizes the kalman filter technique we then provide a simple methodology for assessing the benefits of various types of information sharing agreements between members of the supply chain we also discuss inventory positioning and cost performance assessment in the supply chain our performance metrics and inventory target levels are usually presented in matrix forms allowing them to accommodate a relatively large spectrum of linear demand models and making them simple to implement several illustrations for possible applications of our models are provided

realizing the gains from electronic payments costs pricing and payment choice the growth of electronic payments can substantially reduce the social cost of a country s payment system we provide an estimate of the potential savings in social cost and determine the responsiveness of payment users when relative prices are used to speed up the substitution of electronic for paper based payments while some countries norway japan have encouraged their banking systems to establish explicit prices to promote electronic payments others the united states have not for the first time ever survey data are available to permit estimation of a model of payment choice from which own price cross price and payment substitution elasticities are derived the data which are semiannual panel data concern the use of three methods for making retail payments in norway cash withdrawals at atms writing a check or using a debit card at the point of sale our finding that payment users are quite sensitive to relative prices that reflect the relatively lower cost of electronic payments is generalizable both production techniques and consumer needs for payment instruments are very similar across developed countries even though instrument usage differs

consumers use of debit cards patterns preferences and price response debit card use at the point of sale has grown dramatically in recent years in the united states and now exceeds the number of credit card transactions however many questions remain regarding patterns of debit card use consumer preferences when using debit and how consumers might respond to explicit pricing of card transactions using a new nationally representative consumer survey this paper describes the current use of debit cards by u s consumers including how demographics affect use in addition consumers stated reasons for using debit cards are used to analyze how consumers substitute between debit and other payment instruments we also examine the relationship between household financial conditions and payment choice finally we use a key variable on bank imposed transaction fees to analyze price sensitivity of card use and find a 12 decline in overall use in reaction to a mean 1 8 fee charged on certain debit card transactions we believe this represents the first microeconomic evidence in the united states on price sensitivity for a card payment at the point of sale

optimal policy for a two stage assembly system under random demand this paper considers an inventory system in which an end product is assembled from two components each of which is ordered from an external supplier only the end product has final demand which is assumed to be random using the functional equation approach of dynamic programming we characterize the forms of both the optimal order policy for the components and the optimal assembly policy of the end product for a multiperiod problem of arbitrary but finite length we believe that this work represents the only exact analysis of an mrp type assembly system when demand is stochastic

who benefits from transshipment exogenous vs endogenous wholesale prices this paper studies how transshipments affect manufacturers and retailers considering both exogenous and endogenous wholesale prices for a distribution system where a single manufacturer sells to multiple identical cost retailers we consider both the manufacturer being a price taker and the manufacturer being a price setter in a single period setup under multivariate normal demand distribution in the case of the manufacturer being a price taker we provide several analytical results regarding the effects of key parameters on order quantities and profits in the case of the manufacturer being a price setter we characterize the stackelberg game that arises and provide several insights into how the game dynamics are affected by transshipments specifically we find that risk pooling makes retailers order quantities less sensitive to the wholesale price set by the manufacturer hence in general the manufacturer benefits from retailers transshipments by charging a higher wholesale price while retailers are often worse off the paper captures the effect of demand correlation and the effect of the number of retailers throughout and it illustrates the findings by a numerical example we also provide an interactive web page for numerical experiments

a capacitated production inventory model with periodic demand for a single product single stage capacitated production inventory model with stochastic periodic cyclic demand we find the optimal policy and characterize some of its properties we study the finite horizon the discounted infinite horizon and the infinite horizon average cases a simulation based optimization method is provided to compute the optimal parameters based on a numerical study several insights into the model are also provided

the structure of constant elasticity demand models the demand model with constant price and income elasticities has been used extensively in applied agricultural economics this paper analyzes the structure of incomplete systems of constant elasticity demand functions it is demonstrated that there is a duality theory for incomplete demand systems that is analogous to the duality theory for complete systems this theory permits the recovery of that portion of the direct and indirect preferences pertaining to the goods of interest and we can calculate exact welfare measures for changes in income and in the prices of these goods for an incomplete system of constant elasticity demands the slutsky symmetry restrictions for integrability are presented and the implied structure of the direct and indirect preferences with respect to the prices and goods of interest is derived

value of information in capacitated supply chains we incorporate information flow between a supplier and a retailer in a two echelon model that captures the capacitated setting of a typical supply chain we consider three situations 1 a traditional model where there is no information to the supplier prior to a demand to him except for past data 2 the supplier knows the s s policy used by the retailer as well as the end item demand distribution and 3 the supplier has full information about the state of the retailer order up to policies continue to be optimal for models with information flow for the finite horizon the infinite horizon discounted and the infinite horizon average cost cases study of these three models enables us to understand the relationships between capacity inventory and information at the supplier level as well as how they are affected by the retailer s s s values and end item demand distribution we estimate the savings at the supplier due to information flow and study when information is most beneficial

information distortion in a supply chain the bullwhip effect this article originally appeared in management science april 1997 volume 43 number 4 pp 546 558 published by the institute of management sciences consider a series of companies in a supply chain each of whom orders from its immediate upstream member in this setting inbound orders from a downstream member serve as a valuable informational input to upstream production and inventory decisions this paper claims that the information transferred in the form of orders tends to be distorted and can misguide upstream members in their inventory and production decisions in particular the variance of orders may be larger than that of sales and distortion tends to increase as one moves upstream a phenomenon termed bullwhip effect this paper analyzes four sources of the bullwhip effect demand signal processing rationing game order batching and price variations actions that can be taken to mitigate the detrimental impact of this distortion are also discussed

product differentiation and the treatment of foreign trade in computable general equilibrium models of small economies this paper examines the treatment of exports and imports and external closure rules adopted in recent single country computable general equilibrium models of small economies the paper presents a simple one sector analytic model which captures the major features of the multi sector counterpart used in applied models the paper derives graphical and algebraic solutions to the model and shows that unlike some earlier external closures this one gives rise to a well behaved price taking economy the model is also useful to illustrate the role of elasticities in popular trade theoretic models that include traded and non traded goods

how people pay evidence from grocery store data abstract empirical evidence based on grocery store transaction data shows that consumer payment behavior at the point of sale is important for understanding models of money demand there are statistically significant effects of transaction costs opportunity costs and product characteristics on the choice of payment instrument which then in turn affect money demand these results emphasize the overlap between the work of empirical researchers in payment choice and theoretical modelers of monetary economics and should inform both literatures

challenges in quantitative economic analysis in support of multilateral trade negotiations abstract a wide range of economic analysis of agricultural trade liberalization was performed prior to and during the uruguay round of trade negotiations views differ as to the effectiveness of this research although most would agree that it became less relevant as the negotiations progressed this paper reviews the contributions of economists to the trade liberalization debate with an emphasis on the quantitative assessment of multilateral agricultural trade liberalization with a new round of agricultural trade negotiations scheduled to begin in 1999 it is crucial that the quantitative work required to support these negotiations begin in the near future the authors conclude that the uruguay round outcome provides numerous challenges and opportunities in analyzing the traditional agenda of agricultural trade liberalization in addition new issues will be added to the agenda of the next round of negotiations these include trade and the environment competition policy and intellectual property rights it is important that economists begin to develop a research agenda that can address these issues and become activists in addressing these topics in public forums

98 effective integer ratio lot sizing for one warehouse multi retailer systems a warehouse supplies n retailers constant external demand occurs at each retailer and shortages are not allowed there are linear holding costs and fixed costs for ordering at the warehouse and at each retailer the goal is to minimize the long run average cost over an infinite time horizon we define a new class of policies for this problem whose simple structure facilitates both computation and implementation the cost of a policy that is optimal within this class is shown to be within 2 of the cost of an optimal policy for the original problem in the worst case such a policy can be computed in on log n time

approximations of dynamic multilocation production and inventory problems consider a central depot or plant which supplies several locations experiencing random demands orders are placed or production is initiated periodically by the depot the order arrives after a fixed lead time and is then allocated among the several locations the depot itself does not hold inventory the allocations are finally received at the demand points after another lag unfilled demand at each location is backordered linear costs are incurred at each location for holding inventory and for backorders also costs are assessed for orders placed by the depot the object is to minimize the expected total cost of the system over a finite number of time periods this system gives rise to a dynamic program with a state space of very large dimension we show that this model can be systematically approximated by a single location inventory problem all the qualitative and quantitative results for such problems can then be applied

why is the doha development agenda failing and what can be done a computable general equilibrium game theoretical approach we use a world computable general equilibrium model to simulate 143 potential trade reforms and seek solutions to the issues hampering progress in the doha development agenda dda inside the domain defined by all these possible outcomes we apply the axiomatic theory of bargaining and select the nash solution of cooperative games the solutions vary according to the objective functions adopted by the trade negotiators when real income is the objective and services are excluded or when optimising terms of trade is the objective the nash solution is the status quo trade liberalisation is feasible only when the negotiators focus on national exports or gross domestic product gdp our assessment of some possible solutions reveals that excluding members having a gdp below a certain threshold improves the bargaining process regardless of the governments objective formation of coalition such as the g20 constitutes an option for its members to block outcomes imposed by rich members we also find that side payments may be a solution but represent a very high share of the global income gain

using scheduled ordering to improve the performance of distribution supply chains we study a supply chain with one supplier and many retailers that face exogenous end customer demands the supplier and the retailers all try to minimize their own inventory related costs in contrast to the retailers newsvendor type ordering behavior under which retailers may place orders freely in every period we propose two scheduled ordering policies the scheduled balanced ordering policy sbop and the scheduled synchronized ordering policy ssop under both the sbop and ssop retailers are allowed to order freely only in one period of an ordering cycle and receive fixed shipments in other periods retailers take turns to order freely under the sbop while under the ssop all retailers order freely in the same period with the average supply chain cost per period as the performance measure we identify mathematical conditions under which scheduled ordering policies outperform the newsvendor type ordering through a large scale numerical study we find that scheduled ordering policies are most effective when i the supplier s holding and expediting costs are high and the retailer s backorder cost is small ii the end customer demand variance and correlation are high and iii the supplier s capacity is high in addition we observe that the behavior of the ssop often complements that of the sbop whereas the sbop is better than ssop when the supplier s capacity is low and when the end customer demand correlation level is high the ssop is better when the opposite conditions prevail

transshipment and its impact on supply chain members performance this note extends some of the key results of dong and rudi 2004 to general demand distributions this generalization is achieved in two steps first we build on the analysis of dong and rudi to demonstrate that an inventory problem with transshipment is equivalent to a newsvendor problem with an adjusted demand then we study the impact of transshipment by comparing the adjusted demand with the original demand in addition to extending the results in the existing literature this note presents a novel approach for analyzing the impact of risk pooling

an experiment on retail payments systems we study the behavioral underpinnings of adopting cash versus electronic payments in retail transactions a novel theoretical and experimental framework is developed to primarily assess the impact of sellers service fees and buyers rewards from using electronic payments buyers and sellers face a coordination problem independently choosing a payment method before trading in the experiment sellers readily adopt electronic payments but buyers do not eliminating service fees or introducing rewards significantly boosts the adoption of electronic payments hence buyers incentives play a pivotal role in the diffusion of electronic payments but monetary incentives cannot fully explain their adoption choices findings from this experiment complement empirical findings based on surveys and field data

managing supply chain demand variability with scheduled ordering policies this paper studies supply chain demand variability in a model with one supplier and n retailers that face stochastic demand retailers implement scheduled ordering policies orders occur at fixed intervals and are equal to some multiple of a fixed batch size a method is presented that exactly evaluates costs previous research demonstrates that the supplier s demand variance declines as the retailers order intervals are balanced i e the same number of retailers order each period this research shows that the supplier s demand variance will generally decline as the retailers order interval is lengthened or as their batch size is increased lower supplier demand variance can certainly lead to lower inventory at the supplier this paper finds that reducing supplier demand variance with scheduled ordering policies can also lower total supply chain costs

assessing global computable general equilibrium model validity using agricultural price volatility computable general equilibrium cge models are commonly used for global agricultural market analysis concerns are sometimes raised however about the quality of their output since key parameters may not be econometrically estimated and little emphasis is generally given to model assessment this article addresses the latter issue by developing an approach to validating cge models based on the ability to reproduce observed price volatility in agricultural markets we show how patterns in the deviations between model predictions and validation criteria can be used to identify the weak points of a model and guide development of improved specifications with firmer empirical foundations

comparing supply side specifications in models of global agriculture and the food system this article compares the theoretical and functional specification of production in partial equilibrium pe and computable general equilibrium cge models of the global agricultural and food system included in the agmip model comparison study the two model families differ in their scope partial versus economy wide and in how they represent technology and the behavior of supply and demand in markets the cge models are deep structural models in that they explicitly solve the maximization problem of consumers and producers assuming utility maximization and profit maximization with production cost functions that include all factor inputs the pe models divide into two groups on the supply side 1 shallow structural models which essentially specify area yield supply functions with no explicit maximization behavior and 2 deep structural models that provide a detailed activity analysis specification of technology and explicit optimizing behavior by producers while the models vary in their specifications of technology both within and between the pe and cge families we consider two stylized theoretical models to compare the behavior of crop yields and supply functions in cge models with their behavior in shallow structural pe models we find that the theoretical responsiveness of supply to changes in prices can be similar depending on parameter choices that define the behavior of implicit supply functions over the domain of applicability defined by the common scenarios used in the agmip comparisons in practice however the applied models are more complex and differ in their empirical sensitivity to variations in specification comparability of results given parameter choices is an empirical question to illustrate the issues sensitivity analysis is done with one global cge model magnet to indicate how the results vary with different specification of technical change and how they compare with the results from pe models

a multiechelon inventory model with fixed replenishment intervals this paper develops a new model for studying multiechelon inventory systems with stochastic demand for the model we assume that each site in the system orders at preset times according to an order up to policy that delivery times are deterministic and that the demand processes are stochastic with independent increments we introduce a new scheme for allocating stock in short supply which we call virtual allocation and which permits significant tractability we exercise the model on a set of test problems for two echelon systems to get insight into the structure of good policies the primary findings are that both the central warehouse upper echelon and the retail sites lower echelon should hold safety stock but that most of the safety stock should be at the retail sites consequently the central warehouse will stock out with high probability furthermore we show that the virtual allocation rule is near optimal for the set of test problems

experimental evidence of bank runs as pure coordination failures abstract we investigate how coordination requirement measured by the coordination parameter affects the occurrence of miscoordination based bank runs in controlled laboratory environments we identify an indeterminacy region of the coordination parameter such that games with the parameter within the region have varying coordination outcomes and exhibit persistent path dependence experimental economies with the parameter above below the region stay close or converge to the run non run equilibrium switches between the two equilibria occur even with fixed economic fundamentals the experimental results are well accounted for by a version of the evolutionary algorithm that uses experimentation rates estimated from the experimental data

the payments system liquidity and rediscounting in an economy where fiat money serves both as a medium of exchange and the means by which debts are cleared it is shown that nonoptimal equilibria of constrained liquidity may arise optimality may be restored by temporary expansions of the monetary base e g an active central bank discount window copyright 1996 by american economic association

a north american free trade agreement analytical issues and a computational assessment abstractthe following sections are included introductionissues in analyzing the economic impact of the naftathe computational modelcomputational resultsconclusionsstudy questionsreferencessuggested further reading this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

global models of trade in agriculture and related environmental modelling a review and assessment the continuing process of global integration bears implications for farmers and related supplying and processing industries in all parts of the world but also for the rest of the world economy an assessment of agricultural and trade policy impacts is bound to be complex and is often supported by quantitative modeling analysis this article provides an assessment of the present state of applied modelling in the area of trade and agricultural policies we provide in this paper a comparative assessment of alternative modelling approaches considering a total of 16 partial equilibrium and general equilibrium models the assessment includes theoretical modelling foundations datasets employed and institutional aspects such as model maintenance and dissemination of results a typology of models is provided by structuring the assessment along a clear set of evaluation criteria

incentives at the counter an empirical analysis of surcharging card payments and payment behaviour in the netherlands in card payment systems no surcharge rules prohibit merchants from charging consumers extra for card payments however such rules are prohibited in the netherlands dutch retailers are allowed to surcharge consumers for debit card use this setting permits an empirical analysis of the impact of surcharging card payments on merchant acceptance and consumer payment choice based on consumer and retailer survey data our analysis shows that surcharging steers consumers away from using debit cards towards cash half of the observed difference in debit card payment shares across retailers can be explained by this surcharge effect removing debit card surcharges may induce cost savings of more than eur 50 million in the long run

the quantity flexibility contract and supplier customer incentives consider a supply chain consisting of two independent agents a supplier e g a manufacturer and its customer e g a retailer the latter in turn serving an uncertain market demand to reconcile manufacturing procurement time lags with a need for timely response to the market such supply chains often must commit resources to production quantities based on forecasted rather than realized demand the customer typically provides a planning forecast of its intended purchase which does not entail commitment benefiting from overproduction while not bearing the immediate costs the customer has incentive to initially overforecast before eventually purchasing a lesser quantity the supplier must in turn anticipate such behavior in its production quantity decision this individually rational behavior results in an inefficient supply chain this paper models the incentives of the two parties identifying causes of inefficiency and suggesting remedies particular attention is given to the quantity flexibility qf contract which couples the customer s commitment to purchase no less than a certain percentage below the forecast with the supplier s guarantee to deliver up to a certain percentage above under certain conditions this method can allocate the costs of market demand uncertainty so as to lead the individually motivated supplier and customer to the systemwide optimal outcome we characterize the implications of qf contracts for the behavior and performance of both parties and the supply chain as a whole

exact and approximate evaluation of batch ordering policies for two level inventory systems we consider a two level inventory system with one warehouse and n identical retailers lead times transportation times are constant and the retailers face independent poisson demand in a previous paper we derived a recursive procedure for determining the policy costs for an average item in case of one for one replenishment policies in this paper we show how these results can be used for the exact or approximate evaluation of more general policies where both the retailers and the warehouse order in batches we compare our methods to the method recently suggested by a svoronos and p zipkin