empirical strategies for incorporating weak complementarity into consumer demand models abstract this article appraises existing empirical strategies for incorporating weak complementarity into consumer demand models the repackaging integrating back and discontinuity approaches are evaluated in terms of their behavioral implications and potential usefulness for applied research the appraisal suggests that the repackaging approach offers the most flexibility and tractability in the multi good demand system framework but the integrating back approach holds considerable promise in the single good context a multi good empirical comparison suggests that qualitatively similar policy inference arises from different repackaging approaches

the dual structure of incomplete demand systems integrability of incomplete demand systems is discussed the concepts of weak integrability quasi expenditure function quasi indirect utility function and quasi utility function are defined their relationships to the expenditure function indirect utility function and utility function are developed the dual structure of the quasi functions permits exact welfare analysis and reveals the conditional preference structure for the commodities of interest new results relating the uniqueness and exactness of consumer s surplus to the structure of the expenditure and indirect utility functions are obtained

separability partial demand systems and consumer s surplus measures abstract in practice complete demand systems are not estimated rather either an incomplete demand system is estimated or separability is invoked and a partial demand system is estimated this paper considers the relationship between the conventional compensating variation equivalent variation and the corresponding welfare measure that can be derived from a partial demand system and the current budget allocation to the separable group even assuming the separability assumption invoked is appropriate these partial measures provide in general only a limited amount of information about the compensating variation and no information about the equivalent variation great care is therefore needed when using partial welfare measures to evaluate policy

electoral competition with uncertainty averse parties abstract the non existence of equilibria in models of electoral competition involving multiple issues is one of the more puzzling results in political economics in this paper we relax the standard assumption that parties act as expected utility maximizers we show that equilibria often exist when parties with limited knowledge about the electorate are modeled as uncertainty averse what is more these equilibria can be characterized as a straightforward generalization of the classical median voter result

consumer s surplus versus compensating variation revisited consumer s surplus and a second order approximation to compensating variation are compared to the exact compensating variation for a subsystem of several commodities an empirical application to the relative retail price distortions created by the u s dairy program is presented in the application a new specification for weakly integrable incomplete demand models is developed and estimated the integrable demand model has sufficient flexibility that it is not rejected by the data both welfare approximations are found to introduce large errors in the measurement of deadweight losses

welfare losses due to livestock grazing on public lands a count data systemwide treatment backcountry hikers willingness to pay for removing grazing from trails in the hoover wilderness is analyzed using a multinomial dirichlet negative binomial distribution this multivariate discrete distribution allows the direct calculation of seasonal welfare measures that are derived from an incomplete demand specification the welfare maximizing choice of activities is examined on a trail by trail basis using the results of the analysis our findings suggest that a mix of hiking and grazing activities provide the greatest social welfare

improving environmental valuation estimates through consistent use of revealed and stated preference information abstract environmental valuation data from stated and revealed preference methods are integrated into a unified model of preferences for environmental quality improvement that identifies the use and nonuse components of the total value estimate this articulates clearly what parts of the total value estimate come from each type of data and permits tests of whether estimated preferences satisfy weak complementarity between the environmental good of interest and related private goods the statistical advantages of using more information for the valuation problem are exploited while retaining flexibility to identify value estimates from any individual method of analysis

duality theory for variable costs in joint production duality methods for incomplete systems of consumer demand equations are adapted to the dual structure of variable cost functions in joint production this allows identification of necessary and sufficient restrictions on technology and cost so that con ditional factor demands can be written as functions of input prices fixed inputs and cost these are observable when variable inputs are chosen and committed to production hence the identified restrictions allow ex ante conditional demands to be studied using observable data this class of production technologies is consistent with all von neu mann morgenstern utility functions when ex post production and or output prices are un certain

the calibration of incomplete demand systems in quantitative analysis an easily implemented and flexible calibration technique for partial demand systems is introduced combining recent developments in incomplete demand systems and a set of restrictions conditioned on the available elasticity estimates the technique accommodates various degrees of knowledge on cross price elasticities satisfies curvature restrictions and allows the recovery of an exact welfare measure for policy analysis the technique is illustrated with a partial demand system for food consumption in korea for different states of knowledge on cross price effects the consumer welfare impact of food and agricultural trade liberalization is measured

the producer welfare effects of trade liberalization when goods are perishable and habit forming the case of asparagus asparagus is a perishable highly seasonal crop we find that out of season imports of asparagus caused habit formation that increased demand in the u s growing seasons we find that habit effects offset about 64 of the welfare losses to u s asparagus producers from increased mexican imports under nafta and all of the u s producer welfare losses from increased peruvian imports under the andean trade preference act we estimate that the u s producer welfare losses from nafta are less than the annualized value of market loss assistance provided them in the 2008 farm bill jel classifications d12 f130 q17 q18

what s the use welfare estimates from revealed preference models when weak complementarity does not hold abstract in this paper we consider the theoretical and empirical ramifications of welfare measurement in revealed preference models when weak complementarity does not hold in the context of a kuhn tucker model of recreation demand we show that while it is possible to estimate preferences that do not appear to exhibit weak complementarity the calculation of welfare measurements from these models requires a cardinal interpretation of preferences that cannot be tested furthermore we reiterate the under appreciated fact that even traditional use value estimates require a cardinal restriction on preferences that while often intuitive also cannot be tested we demonstrate empirically that the choice of restrictions can have significant ramifications as use value estimates can vary based on the assumed preference structure

recreation demand choices and revealed values of leisure time i introduction at least since the work of becker 1965 it has been recognized widely that time may play an important role in consumer demand one of the areas where this may be most significant empirically is in the valuation of natural resource amenities through their associated recreation demands a principal reason is that recreation is a time intensive commodity so that the value of the time spent in recreation would be expected to play a large role in its overall value the potential bias to consumer s surplus estimates of the net economic value of recreation from excluding time prices from the demand model has been recognized from the outset for example by knetsch 1963 and clawson 1959 to incorporate time into recreation demand models researchers have generally adopted the practice suggested by mcconnell 1975 of defining the full price of recreation as the money cost of a trip plus its monetized time cost though the use of full budgets also called for by the becker approach is less widespread bockstael et al 1987 pointed out quite clearly that both full budgets and full prices are required in the demand function if the recreationist is jointly choosing labor supply with recreation at an exogenous marginal wage but that the structure of demand was unclear if the individual was not making such marginal labor supply choices i e if he or she was working fixed hours subsequently larson and shaikh 2001 showed that the full prices full budgets specification is sufficient to satisfy the constraints on demand parameters that arise because choice is made subject to two binding constraints regardless of the individual s position in the labor market they also pointed out that models that use full prices but only money income in effect ignoring the role of time as a resource constraint cannot be consistent with the requirements of choice subject to two constraints although the outlines of how time should enter the structure of demand are becoming clear a major unresolved issue is how to determine its value in practice several studies have followed the basic logic of becker s early work assuming that the opportunity cost of recreation time i e the value of other time forgone in favor of recreation is an exogenous parameter such as the average wage rate or more commonly some fraction thereof this fraction is either chosen arbitrarily or estimated as part of the recreation demand model as in cesario 1976 mcconnell and strand 1981 and smith et al 1983 such assumptions may be erroneous for a variety of reasons assuming the average wage is the appropriate opportunity cost of time presumes that the individual faces no constraints on hours worked derives no utility or disutility from work and has a linear wage function as has been noted by chiswick 1967 bockstael et al 1987 and smith et al 1983 this is unlikely to be true for many people assuming some constant fraction of the wage is the opportunity cost of time especially an arbitrarily chosen fraction also seems likely to be incorrect for most people for all of these reasons an individual s average wage does not necessarily reveal anything about the shadow value of discretionary leisure time either as an upper or lower bound in a recent advance feather and shaw 2000 adapted the heckman 1974 labor supply model to include information supplied by recreationists about their labor supply status in particular whether they felt under or over employed relative to their desired number of hours this information is used to identify subgroups in the data for which the shadow value of leisure time is less than the wage or more than the wage which helps in the estimation of both a wage function and a shadow value of leisure time function this approach produces individual specific estimates of the opportunity cost of leisure time based on their demographics and labor market decisions which are used in a subsequent recreation demand analysis

measuring the consumer welfare effects of carbon penalties theory and applications to household energy demand abstract this study implements a money metric approximation to the hicksian equivalent variation hev based on observable demand functions this approach is a less restrictive approximation to the hev than the marshallian consumer surplus mcs in situations where mcs is misleading this study also implements a generalized logit demand system that conforms better to the theory of consumer behaviour than standard flexible functional forms eg translog the almost ideal demand system aids generalized leontief and minflex laurent models the generalized logit model was estimated using new york state level and company level data on residential consumption of electricity natural gas and fuel oil the demand model and money metric were combined to measure the consumer welfare effects of carbon penalties on electricity and fuels while the application is specific the generalized logit model of demand and the money metric measure of welfare change can encompass a wider range of applications than conventional methods of analysis

on measuring the value of a nonmarket good using market data we use line integral theory to lay out in a more general theoretical framework the conditions under which it is possible to measure with market data the welfare effects of a change in a nonmarket good we present in detail a numerical method of measuring the value of nonmarket goods using market data under either weak neutrality or weak complementarity our numerical method is more flexible than the existing analytical method because it can be used with any well behaved marshallian demand function and can be used even when the willig condition does not hold

economic assessment of nutritional recommendations abstract the effect of consumers compliance with nutritional recommendations is uncertain because of potentially complex substitutions to lift this uncertainty we adapt a model of consumer behaviour under rationing to the case of linear nutritional constraints dietary adjustments are derived from information on consumer preferences consumption levels and nutritional contents of foods a calibration exercise simulates for different income groups how the french diet would respond to various nutrition recommendations and those behavioural adjustments are translated into health outcomes through the dietron epidemiological model this allows for the ex ante comparison of the efficiency equity and health effects of ten nutritional recommendations although most recommendations impose significant taste costs on consumers they are highly cost effective with the recommendations targeting salt saturated fat and fruits and vegetables f v ranking highest in terms of efficiency most recommendations are also economically progressive with the exception of that targeting f v

measuring the welfare effects of nutrition information cost benefit analysis justifies regulations altering the amount of health related information presented to consumers the current method of benefit analysis the cost of avoided illness is limited it assumes the benefits of health related information are adequately represented by changes in illnesses the manuscript develops a benefit estimation method to measure the welfare impacts of providing nutrient information nutrient labeling significantly affects purchase behaviour but may not lead to increased consumption of health foods nutrient labeling may increase welfare without any change in health risk thus the cost of avoided illness approach can underestimate the social benefits of providing nutrient information copyright 2001 oxford university press

recovering weakly complementary preferences abstract this paper demonstrates a method for recovering weakly complementary expenditure and indirect utility functions while integrating back from marshallian demand specifications that do not intrinsically embody weak complementarity weak complementarity of a good with quality provides information about how the constant of integration over price must behave with respect to quality and this information can be incorporated into the process of recovering preferences the weakly complementary expenditure and indirect utility functions are recovered for the linear demand specification and for the stone geary utility function with any value of the subsistence parameter

alternative models of recreational off highway vehicle site demand a controversial recreation activity is off highway vehicle use off highway vehicle use is controversial because it is incompatible with most other activities and is extremely hard on natural eco systems this study estimates utility theoretic incomplete demand systems for four off highway vehicle sites since two sets of restrictions are equally consistent with utility theory both are imposed and the best fitting restrictions are identified using voung s non nested testing scheme the demand system is modeled using both poisson and negative binomial ii distributions data are provided by a survey conducted at four recreational off highway vehicle ohv sites in western north carolina

by ounce or by calorie the differential effects of alternative sugar sweetened beverage tax strategies the obesity epidemic and excessive consumption of sugar sweetened beverages have led to proposals of economics based interventions to promote healthy eating in the united states targeted food and beverage taxes and subsidies are prominent examples of such potential intervention strategies this paper examines the differential effects of taxing sugar sweetened beverages by calories and by ounces on beverage demand to properly measure the extent of substitution and complementarity between beverage products we developed a fully modified distance metric model of differentiated product demand that endogenizes the cross price effects we illustrated the proposed methodology in a linear approximate almost ideal demand system although other flexible demand systems can also be used in the empirical application using supermarket scanner data the product level demand model consists of 178 beverage products with combined market share of over 90 the novel demand model outperformed the conventional distance metric model in non nested model comparison tests and in terms of the economic significance of model predictions in the fully modified model a calorie based beverage tax was estimated to cost 1 40 less in compensating variation than an ounce based tax per 3 500 beverage calories reduced this difference in welfare cost estimates between two tax strategies is more than three times as much as the difference estimated by the conventional distance metric model if applied to products purchased from all sources a 0 04 cent per kcal tax on sugar sweetened beverages is predicted to reduce annual per capita beverage intake by 5 800 kcal

a new market for an old food the u s demand for olive oil while u s consumption of olive oil has tripled over the past two decades nearly all olive oil continues to be imported estimation of a demand system using monthly import data reveals that the income elasticity for virgin oils sourced from eu is above one but demand for nonvirgin oils is income inelastic the demand for olive oil as a single product is price inelastic differentiated by product characteristic and origin olive oils are highly substitutable with each other but not with other vegetable oils news about the health and culinary benefits of olive oil and the spread of mediterranean diet contribute significantly to the rising demand

further results on willingness to pay for nonmarket goods abstract some implications of substitution relationships between private and public goods for measuring the value of changes in nonmarket goods such as environmental quality are explored if a market good is hicks neutral to quality for some price vector the total value of discrete changes in quality consisting of both use and nonuse value can be measured from empirical demand coefficients a plausible motivation for neutrality is developed in the contexts of specifying incomplete demand systems for weak complements to quality and measuring nonuse value when the consumption of weak complements is held at zero previous results on bounding marginal willingness to pay for nonmarket goods are also strengthened

benefit transfer via preference calibration prudential algebra for policy this paper proposes a new approach to benefit transfer the method assumes a specific form for preferences and uses available benefit information to identify and calibrate the preference parameters to match the existing benefit estimates this approach assures economic consistency of the transfers benefit measures can never be inconsistent with household income the logic also offers a series of potentially observable predictions that can be used to gauge the plausibility of benefit transfers when multiple benefit estimates from different methods are available such as hedonic property value travel cost demand and contingent valuation the framework uses the definition of the benefit concept from each method in a single preference function to reconcile differences it provides a specific way to take account of baseline conditions and scope effects i e the size of the proposed change consistently in the transfer the method is illustrated using estimates for benefit measure changes in water quality from three studies travel cost demand hedonic property value and contingent valuation analysis q26

targeting nominal income a closer look abstract i derive conditions under which the monetary authority should target nominal spending the relevant spending target is a weighted average of income and consumption despite sticky nominal wages under optimal policy the economy behaves as if all markets clear

linear demand functions in theory and practice abstract integrability conditions for an incomplete system of linear demand functions are considered the parameter restrictions consistent with integrability are identified and the structure of the conditional preference map is obtained it is found that the conditional preferences for a set of linear demand functions are either quadratic or leontief from a translated origin welfare analysis with linear demand models is also considered

brand choice and purchase frequency revisited an application to recreation behavior the role that total purchases play in determining the choice among brands has been considered in microeconomic theory for quite some time but for traditional goods only consumption of outdoor recreation is an unusual good most often measured using an individual s recreational trip adding the trips made on a number of choice occasions seems the obvious way to aggregate this good but doing so leads to several problems in defining a meaningful price index the hicks leontief conditions for aggregation suggest that trips to destinations may be thought of as brand choices on consumption occasions andthe continuous analogue to total purchases may in fact be the individual s total travel an empirical example of the model is used to estimate welfare impacts for a group of anglers