a comparative analysis of the rationality of consensus forecasts of u s economic indicators the purpose of this article is to investigate the rationality of two survey forecasts of selective u s macroeconomic performance measures that were widely followed in the financial markets during the 1990 2000 period the research compares the rationality of survey forecast data from money market services inc and thomson financial this article extends prior research that has evaluated the rationality of money market services data for earlier time periods while also evaluating similar consensus forecast data from thomson financial that were widely reported in both barron s and the wall street journal during the 1990s

the illusory effects of saving incentives on saving the authors evaluate research on how tax based saving incentives iras and 401 k s affect saving previous research overstates the impact of the incentives on saving by failing to account for several issues households with saving incentives have stronger tastes for saving than others saving incentives have interacted with debt nonfinancial assets financial markets and pensions and saving incentives represent pretax balances whereas taxable accounts represent posttax balances accounting for these issues essentially eliminates the impact of saving incentives on saving the authors conclude that little if any of the contributions to existing saving incentives have raised saving

how retirement saving programs increase saving this paper summarizes the authors work on the effect of ira and 401 k contributions on net personal saving they consider many different nonparametric approaches to controlling for heterogeneity in individual saving behavior and conclude that the weight of the available evidence suggests that contributions to both iras and 401 k s largely represent new saving the authors devote particular attention to reconciling their results with the findings in other studies that reach different conclusions sometimes using the same databases that the authors analyze methodological limitations that undermine the reliability of results in other studies explain many of these disparities

estimating labour supply responses using tax reforms the 1980 s tax reforms and the changing dispersion of wages offer one of the best opportunities yet to estimate labor supply effects nevertheless changing sample composition aggregate shocks the changing composition of the tax paying population and discontinuities in the tax system create serious identification and estimation problems we develop grouping estimators that address these issues our results reveal positive and moderately sized wage elasticities we also find negative income effects for women with children

rational bias in macroeconomic forecasts do professional forecasters provide their true unbiased estimates or do they behave strategically in our model forecasters have common information confer actively and thus know the true pdf of future outcomes intensive users of economic forecasts monitor forecasters performance closely occasional users are drawn to the forecaster who fared best in the previous period in the resulting nash equilibrium even though economists have identical expectations they make a range of projections that mimics the true probability distribution of the forecast variable those whose wages depend most on publicity produce forecasts that differ most from the consensus empirical evidence supports the model

savings and pensions some uk evidence the sort of problem we shall be interested in is the following how much does a small change in a mature pay as you go pension scheme change aggregate current consumption in the context of a community of workers and pensioners with a variable retirement date and a pension scheme where the government taxes workers to pay pensions two sorts of effects have been posited first changes in pensions re distribute current disposable income this may lead to changes in aggregate consumption the redistribution effect secondly future pension rights constitute a form of wealth and unanticipated changes in the size or composition of wealth holdings may affect current consumption plans wealth effects see gultekin and logue i979 for a survey and references looking at the redistribution effect we observe that if pensioners have a higher short run marginal propensity to consurme than workers and the same long run marginal propensity to consume then an increase in pensions will ceteris paribus raise aggregate consumption initially but cause it to fall in the medium run the long run elasticity will be zero turning to wealth effects we distinguish two principal elements firstly an unanticipated increase in pensions in a pay as you go scheme increases the lifetime income of pensioners and workers close to retirement for workers who intend retiring at pensionable age this will lead to an increase in current consumption so long as it is a normal good this income effect will be less marked for workers at the beginning of their working life since the net income effect may even be negative for many workers as time goes by the aggregate net income effect consequent on a rise in pensions is diminished so that we would expect to see an initial rise in consumption followed by a very slow decline in incremental consumption the long run elasticity of mean consumption with respect to a rise in pensions would be zero note that imperfections in the capital market are unlikely to modify these conclusions since those who wish to increase their consumption are likely to have savings that can be reduced whilst those for whom borrowing constraints are binding i e younger workers are unlikely to wish to increase current consumption by much anyway there are two important caveats to the above the first is that workers who intend to work after the pensionable age may decrease current consumption if the increase in pensions induces a large enough fall in planned post pensionable age labour supply see crawford and lilien i98i for a theoretical discussion

the missing piece in policy analysis social security reform this lecture discusses the economic losses that result from an unfunded social security retirement system and the potential gain from shifting to a funded system the social security payroll tax distorts labor supply and the form in which compensation is paid although each individual s benefits are linked to that individual s previous payroll tax payments the low equilibrium rate of return inherent in an unfunded system implies a net payroll tax that causes distortions the resulting deadweight loss is 1 of each year s gdp in perpetuity an amount equal to 20 of payroll tax revenue and a 50 increase in deadweight loss of the personal income tax also there is the loss of investment income resulting from forcing employees to accept the low implicit return of an unfunded program rather than the much higher return paid on private saving or in a funded social security program the present value of the annual losses from using an unfunded system exceeds the benefit to those who received windfall transfers when the program began and when it expanded shifting to a funded program cannot reverse the crowding out of capital that has already occurred recognizing the existing unfunded obligation only makes that piece of the national debt explicit but shifting to a funded program limits crowding out of capital formation to the amount that already occurred future increases in annual saving that result from economic growth are able to earn the higher rate of return on real capital the present value of these gains is equivalent to a perpetuity of more than 2 of gdp a year the combi nation of improved labor market incentives and higher real return on saving has a net present value gain of more than 15 trillion an amount equivalent to three percent of each future year s gdp forever this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

an analysis of a panel of spanish gdp forecasts this article undertakes an analysis of the forecasts included in the panel of spanish forecasts in order to highlight the fact that the predictions made and the errors committed by the entities participating on this panel contain information that is particularly useful in analysing the evolution of the spanish economy here a study is undertaken of the gdp growth forecasts for the spanish economy for the period 2000 to 2002 made in distinct forecast time horizons specifically it analyses whether the forecasts are optimistic or pessimistic and whether new information concerning the variable being predicted is used efficiently in revising earlier forecasts

why are professional forecasters biased agency versus behavioral explanations professional forecasters may not simply aim to minimize expected squared forecast errors in models with repeated forecasts the pattern of forecasts reveals valuable information about the forecasters even before the outcome is realized rational forecasters will compromise between minimizing errors and mimicking prediction patterns typical of able forecasters simple models based on this argument imply that forecasts are biased in the direction of forecasts typical of able forecasters our models of strategic bias are rejected empirically as forecasts are biased in directions typical of forecasters with large mean squared forecast errors this observation is consistent with behavioral explanations of forecast bias

international risk sharing in overlapping generations models abstract we propose a way to address the backus smith puzzle that instead of relying on extreme parameter values or complex modeling assumptions simply switches the framework from infinitely lived agents to overlapping generations young agents face nondiversifiable wage risk that leads to a low degree of risk sharing within each country subsequently international price movements are not sufficient to achieve the high consumption real exchange rate correlation produced in standard infinitely lived agent dsge models

forecasting gdp all over the world using leading indicators based on comprehensive survey data comprehensive and international comparable leading indicators across countries and continents are rare in this paper we use a free and instantaneous available source of leading indicators the if

testing the rationality of price forecasts new evidence from panel data this paper tests the rationality of individual price forecasts in a panel of professional forecasters here unlike in most previous studies rationality is not rejected the results here differ because 1 using individual forecasts avoids aggregation bias 2 comparison of forecasts to initial data avoids bias due to data revision 3 the professional forecasters have economic incentives to state their expectations accurately and 4 a new covariance matrix estimator consistent when forecast errors are correlated across individuals is used copyright 1990 by american economic association

should social security benefits be means tested social security retirement benefits distort the saving decisions of workers who are rational enough to save for their future since the implicit rate of return in an unfunded social security program is less than the marginal product of capital the resulting decline in saving causes a welfare loss the present paper examines the conditions under which the welfare loss could be reduced by replacing the current universal social security program with a means tested program that pays benefits only to those individuals with little or no other retirement income or assets every society must solve the problem of supporting those individuals who become too old to work but have not made adequate provision for their own old age by saving when they were young at the present time the major industrial countries of the world have responded to this problem by creating social security programs that tax the working population and use the proceeds to provide a universal benefit to all retirees regardless of their financial condition this universal provision of social security benefits distorts the saving decisions of those workers who are rational enough to plan for the future since the implicit rate of return that taxpayers get on their this research is part of the nber study of the government budget and the private economy a more complete version of this paper with some numerical calculations is available as nber working paper no 1775 feldstein 1985b i am grateful to gilbert metcalf for assistance with the calculations presented in this paper and for helpful discussions for a discussion of the effect of promised retirement benefits on the savings of employees see feldstein 1974 1982 barro 1974 1978 has discussed an interesting

data revisions and forecasting the relationship between two sets of gnp data the earliest and the first revisions is examined this comparison enables us to determine whether the early numbers are valuable to forecasters the analysis uses two methods the first is based on a technique which has been used to evaluate whether financial and economic forecasts are valuable to the users the second approach uses time series techniques we conclude that revisions to the 15 day estimates that occur when the 45 day numbers are released are successful and that the 15 day numbers are useful to forecasters

the effects of pensions on household wealth a reevaluation of theory and evidence this paper examines the extent to which households offset pension wealth with reductions in other wealth systematic econometric biases imply that the estimated offsets in previous empirical studies are smaller than the true offset and may even have the wrong sign new empirical estimates that do not correct for the biases generate little offset between pensions and other wealth estimates that correct for the biases show substantially more offset a smaller impact of pensions on overall saving than in most previous studies the estimates also indicate that the effects of pensions on wealth vary significantly across households

declining public pensions in an era of demographic ageing will private provision fill the gap abstract demographic crisis and imprudent commitments have induced a crisis in public pension programmes in oecd countries will present and prospective cutbacks lead to greater private saving either in the form of private pension provision or in other forms of saving the paper surveys existing evidence and provides new results on three questions do individuals substitute private for public provision of savings when public pension programmes are cut back voluntarily do individuals respond to incentives to join sponsored or tax subsidised arrangements if encouraged by the government and if individuals are prepared to make such arrangements and where saving is voluntary do they save enough to replace previous prospective public pension flows

evaluating the oecd s forecasts for economic growth the size and nature of the errors in gdp forecasts in the g 7 countries from 1968 to 1995 are examined these gdp estimates are published by the organization for economic cooperation and development in oecd economic outlook two alternative hypotheses are tested concerning why revisions arise the first hypothesis is that preliminary announcement is simply the true variable measured with error in this case the preliminary announcement is an unconditionally unbiased but irrational forecast of the true value that is the revision is correlated with known variables in particular it is correlated with the preliminary announcement itself the second hypothesis is that revisions arise because the early gdp estimates are a rational forecast of the true variable in this case the error is a rational forecast error and is therefore uncorrelated with known information

crises in public pension programmes in oecd what are the reform options the paper examines projections of the fiscal liabilities of public pension programmes in a number of oecd countries it investigates the reasons why many countries have built up such liabilities in the past and critically appraises the future projections of pension costs it examines the strengths and weaknesses of four reform options which are currently being discussed and implemented in various countries

testing the rationality of japanese gdp forecasts the sign of forecast revision matters abstract this paper analyzes the rationality of japanese gdp forecasts of individual economists it finds that japanese forecasters are pessimistic optimistic when their forecast revisions frs are positive negative and that they always over react to new information across forecasters the magnitude of average fr is not correlated with the magnitude of average forecast errors fe these results together are consistent with neither the rational expectations hypothesis nor reputation models with rational and strategic forecasters

pension wealth and individual saving some new evidence attemprs to measure the tmpact of soctal security and private pensions on household saving have occupied much of the literature in empirical public finance over the past decade empirical estimates of those impacts have been quite varied see the discussion in aaron 1982 this paper provides new estimates of the impact of changes in holdings of social security and private pension annuities on the level of non pension wealth the data examined are drawn from surveys conducted for the u s president s commission on pension policy the impact of the social security system on individual saving has been a concern since feldstein s 1974 pioneering paper l the theoretical argument of feldstein and of barro 1974 1978 centers around the funding status of social security i e the degree to which an unfunded social security system reduces private saving empirical tests of the effects of social security on saving in this line of research have been conducted in the perfect certainty version of the life cycle model modigliani and ando 1957 modigliani and brumberg 1954 in that approach social security affects non pension saving through its impact on individual intertemporal budget constraints disposable income during the working period falls by the amount of

why are latin america s savings rates so low an international comparative analysis abstract this paper presents a theoretical and empirical assessment of the determinants of savings rates with special emphasis on latin american savings rates the study is based on international comparisons using data from 36 countries for 1970 1992 a distinction is made between private and public savings the later are endogenously determined by economic and political variables per capita income growth is the most important determinant of private and public savings public savings are lower in countries with higher political instability public savings crowd out private savings but less than proportionately low latin american savings are due to the magnitudes of their determinants rather than structural differences

is there a retirement savings puzzle in this paper we ask whether households are saving enough for their retirement we use data on income expenditure and expenditure components to analyse patterns of behaviour at and around the time of retirement for successive date of birth cohorts we compare periods of unemployment to periods of retirement and separate expenditures into categories reflecting work related expenditures basic necessities and other goods we find that income typically falls by more at unemployment than retirement but the reverse is true for expenditure we observe falls in expenditure at retirement for all expenditure categories using a stochastic life cycle model including mortality rates we assess the anticipated impact of retirement on consumption against that of unemployment the inter relationship between goods and leisure explains a large part of the persistent fall in expenditure at retirement we argue that the only way in which the life cycle hypothesis could be reconciled with the remaining unanticipated dip in consumption would be with the systematic arrival of unexpected adverse information at the time of retirement

do the oecd 24 month horizon growth forecasts for the g7 countries contain information the oecd produces two year ahead growth forecasts for the g7 countries since 1987 these forecasts have never been evaluated a regression is developed that tests for the information content of the forecasts the idea is that this content is the added value forecasters incorporate in their forecasts the information content is defined relative to the forecast for the previous year in the end the added value contained in the current year forecast is calculated relative to the last observation the test consists in checking whether the information content reduces the forecasts error 1 the authors of the present study refer to mincer and zarnowitz 1969 mcnees 1988 stekler 1991 and fildes and stekler 2002 for a discussion of the evaluation techniques of forecasts the study begins with a calculation of the usual accuracy statistics these indicate an extreme low quality for the forecasts the regression tests support this conclusion although the forecasts for japan do possess some information al