institutions and the environmental kuznets curve for deforestation a crosscountry analysis for latin america africa and asia abstract the relationship between deforestation and income across 66 countries of latin america africa and asia is examined institutional characteristics as well as macroeconomic policies of each country are hypothesized to impact deforestation results show strong evidence of an environmental kuznets curve ekc relationship between income and deforestation for all three continents institutional structure and macroeconomic policy significantly affect the tropical deforestation process improvements in political institutions and governance significantly reduce deforestation the factors leading to deforestation differ across regions however and there is no one size fits all global policy recommendation for restraining the tropical deforestation process

identifying the efficiency status in network dea abstract data envelopment analysis dea is commonly employed to evaluate the efficiency performance of a decision making unit dmu that transforms exogenous inputs into final outputs in such a black box dea approach details of an internal production process of the dmu are typically ignored and hence the locations of inefficiency are not adequately provided in view of this dea researchers have recently developed various network approaches by looking into the black box where the inputs that enter the box and the outputs that come out of it are only considered however most of these network approaches evaluate divisional efficiency by using an optimal solution of their respective optimization problem if such an optimal solution is used in the case when there are multiple optima then managerial guidance based on this solution alone may be inappropriate because more appropriate targets from the viewpoint of management may be ignored taking this fact into account therefore we propose a network approach for identifying the efficiency status of each dmu and its divisions this approach provides a practical computational procedure

measuring positive externalities from unobservable victim precaution an empirical analysis of lojack lojack is a hidden radio transmitter device used for retrieving stolen vehicles because there is no external indication that lojack has been installed it does not directly affect the likelihood that a protected car will be stolen there may however be positive externalities due to general deterrence we find that the availability of lojack is associated with a sharp fall in auto theft rates of other crime do not change appreciably at least historically the marginal social benefit of an additional unit of lojack has been fifteen times greater than the marginal social cost in high crime areas those who install lojack however obtain less than 10 percent of the total social benefits leading to underprovision by the market

strategic responses to resource management pressures in agriculture institutional gender and location effects sustainable management of natural resources by farmers is under increasing public scrutiny in australia the case of water unsustainably used and stored by agricultural businesses has gained attention with communities in catchments potentially deprived of water and placed at downstream risk yet sustainable water management institutional policy mechanisms remain disjointed around the country the study reported here applies a strategic response typology to a survey of 404 farmers in four different institutional environments in australia to explore their responses to institutional pressures findings demonstrate a convergence in typologies that relate to farmers organising each other and communities influencing and networking for the benefit of agricultural resource management thereby questioning the traditional continuum of resistance furthermore the mid range typology avoidance emerges as a highly problematic typology for sustainable water management policymakers especially those in weaker institutional environments where there is a need to develop policy instruments that retain farmer water management decision making power and encourage networks the paper also extends the strategic response typology to enable understanding of how gender and location affect strategic responses to institutional pressures findings provide insight for policy design in times of increasing catastrophic flood and drought conditions exacerbated by poor water management practice

crime rates and local labor market opportunities in the united states 1979 1997 the labor market prospects of young unskilled men fell dramatically in the 1980s and improved in the 1990s crime rates show a reverse pattern increasing during the 1980s and falling in the 1990s because young unskilled men commit most crime this paper seeks to establish a causal relationship between the two trends previous work on the relationship between labor markets and crime focused mainly on the relationship between the unemployment rate and crime and found inconclusive results in contrast this paper examines the impact of both wages and unemployment on crime and uses instrumental variables to establish causality we conclude that both wages and unemployment are significantly related to crime but that wages played a larger role in the crime trends over the last few decades these results are robust to the inclusion of deterrence variables controls for simultaneity and controlling for individual and family characteristics

some models for estimating technical and scale inefficiencies in data envelopment analysis in management contexts mathematical programming is usually used to evaluate a collection of possible alternative courses of action en route to selecting one which is best in this capacity mathematical programming serves as a planning aid to management data envelopment analysis reverses this role and employs mathematical programming to obtain ex post facto evaluations of the relative efficiency of management accomplishments however they may have been planned or executed mathematical programming is thereby extended for use as a tool for control and evaluation of past accomplishments as well as a tool to aid in planning future activities the ccr ratio form introduced by charnes cooper and rhodes as part of their data envelopment analysis approach comprehends both technical and scale inefficiencies via the optimal value of the ratio form as obtained directly from the data without requiring a priori specification of weights and or explicit delineation of assumed functional forms of relations between inputs and outputs a separation into technical and scale efficiencies is accomplished by the methods developed in this paper without altering the latter conditions for use of dea directly on observational data technical inefficiencies are identified with failures to achieve best possible output levels and or usage of excessive amounts of inputs methods for identifying and correcting the magnitudes of these inefficiencies as supplied in prior work are illustrated in the present paper a new separate variable is introduced which makes it possible to determine whether operations were conducted in regions of increasing constant or decreasing returns to scale in multiple input and multiple output situations the results are discussed and related not only to classical single output economics but also to more modern versions of economics which are identified with contestable market theories

evaluating the environmental efficiency of a two stage system with undesired outputs by a dea approach an interest preference perspective abstract in this study we propose a new dea model to evaluate the environmental efficiency of a two stage system with undesired outputs the two stage system consists of two parts a production subsystem and a pollution treatment subsystem different choices for allocating resources to each subsystem represent different interest preferences of decision makers with the production subsystem corresponding to short term interests and the pollution treatment subsystem corresponding to long term interests based on a proposed new dea model three theorems are established to show the relationships between the interest preference parameter and the change of efficiency scores an empirical analysis was conducted using the data of 30 provinces and municipalities eight regions of china the empirical results show the effectiveness of the proposed model and the usefulness of the theorems for the real world data optimal efficiency rankings of the eight regions are provided and the efficiency rankings truly reflect the current environmental situations of these eight regions to examine the economic impacts and facilitate sustainable development we also analyze the shadow prices for undesired outputs corresponding implications of the empirical analysis are also discussed

does energy efficiency have a spatial spill over effect in china evidence from provincial level data abstract the analysis of spill over effect and mechanism is of great significance for eliminating the unbalanced development of regional energy efficiency our research considers the impact of external environmental factors on energy efficiency and the spatial durbin model is used to discover the spatial spill over effect and mechanism the main conclusions are as follows 1 eastern china is the most efficient region central china ranks second and west china ranks third with a gradually descending trend in the temporal dimension compared to the traditional dea model the results removed the environmental factors to be more in line with economic intuition 2 the spatial distribution of china s energy efficiency has a significant positive correlation from the global perspective implying that provinces with high energy efficiency are surrounded by neighbouring provinces with high energy efficiency and provinces with low energy efficiency are surrounded by neighbouring provinces with low energy efficiency provinces in each quadrant change slightly from a local perspective indicating that energy efficiency has stable spatial correlation characteristics 3 neighbourhood mimicry generates a complementary effect which promotes the spatial spill over of energy efficiency it is important to encourage yardstick competition and restrain lower tier competition 4 industrial structure market factors opening up energy price energy structure and environmental regulation exert certain influences on energy efficiency

measuring ecological efficiency with data envelopment analysis dea abstract the measurement of ecological efficiency provides some important information for the companies environmental management ecological efficiency is usually measured by comparing environmental performance indicators data envelopment analysis dea shows a high potential to support such comparisons as no explicit weights are needed to aggregate the indicators in general dea assumes that inputs and outputs are goods but from an ecological perspective also bads have to be considered in the literature bads are treated in different and sometimes arbitrarily chosen ways this article aims at the systematic derivation of ecologically extended dea models starting from the assumptions of dea in production theory and activity analysis a generalisation of basic dea models is derived by incorporating a multi dimensional value function f extended preference structures can be considered by different specifications of f e g specifications for ecologically motivated applications of dea

industrial eco efficiency in china a provincial quantification using three stage data envelopment analysis abstract the coordinated development of industrialization and the ecological environment is vital to achieve ecological civilization in china integratively considering the economy energy and resources and environment this study aims to measure the industrial eco efficiency of 30 provinces autonomous regions and municipalities in china between 2005 and 2013 a three stage data envelopment analysis dea modeling approach is adopted to eliminate interference of the external environment and statistical noise with industrial eco efficiency measurement the results show that regional industrial eco efficiency in china is affected by the factors of the environmental regulation technological innovation level of economic development and industrial structure after eliminating the impacts of external environment and statistical noise china s national average industrial eco efficiency declines by 30 between 2005 and 2013 the industrial eco efficiency of the 30 provinces increases but at different rates of growth the variation of overall regional industrial eco efficiency is primarily caused by scale efficiency furthermore all the 30 provinces are classified into four groups to interpret the causes of variation and differences of regional industrial eco efficiency in general the management and technology level and the economy of scale of industries should be improved simultaneously even though specific opportunities for industrial eco efficiency improvement vary across provinces in china

why do increased arrest rates appear to reduce crime deterrence incapacitation or measurement error this paper attempts to discriminate between deterrence incapacitation and measurement error as explanations for the negative empirical relationship between arrest rates and crime measurement error cannot explain the observed patterns in the data incapacitation suggests that an increase in the arrest rate for one crime will reduces all crime rates deterrence predicts that an increase in the arrest rate for one crime will lead to a rise in other crimes as criminals substitute away from the first crime empirically deterrence appears to be the more important factor particularly for property crimes jel k42

using electoral cycles in police hiring to estimate the effect of police on crime comment previous empirical studies have uncovered little evidence that police reduce crime possibly due to simultaneity problems this paper uses the timing of mayoral and gubernatorial elections as an instrumental variable to identify a causal effect of police on crime increases in the size of police forces are shown to be disproportionately concentrated in mayoral and gubernatorial election years increases in police are shown to substantially reduce violent crime but have a smaller impact on property crime the null hypothesis that the marginal social benefit of reduced crime equals the costs of hiring additional police cannot be rejected

the eco efficiency of pulp and paper industry in china an assessment based on slacks based measure and malmquist luenberger index abstract china has become the world largest paper and paperboard producer however pulp and paper industry has involved high resource consumption and severe pollution especially for water this research has assessed the eco efficiency of china s pulp and paper industry at the national level and provincial level an overview regarding the cleaner production of china s pulp and paper industry was presented to reveal the measures for reducing environmental impact in the last two decades slacks based measure was used to analyze the efficiency levels of 16 provinces pulp and paper industries to uncover the underlying causes of eco efficiency performance malmquist luenberger index was calculated to discover the drivers of productivity growth of pulp and paper industries our results showed that the pollution treatment of china s pulp and paper industry has made progress in terms of water consumption and water pollution although the absolute amount of pollution discharge is still large chemical oxygen demand emissions are still the first critical influencing factor of pulp and paper industry s inefficiency furthermore efficiency progress was the dominating contribution of the industry s productivity growth between 2010 and 2013 the policies for adjusting the industrial structure of pulp and paper industry have resulted in the scale effects through eliminating backward production capacity and accelerating merger and acquisitions moreover the productivity of pulp and paper industry was underestimated when the undesirable outputs were ignored it indicates that the stricter environmental regulations have positive effects on paper companies to internalize environmental pressures in the production activities through environmental management in the future pulp and paper companies should further internalize the cost of pollution treatment through scale effects and technology improvement

enforcement of pollution levies in china abstract this paper investigates how industrial plants react to inspections conducted by environmental authorities under the pollution levy taxation regulation in china contrary to studies in the united states and canada magat and viscusi 1990 laplante and rilstone 1996 and previous studies in china dasgupta et al 2001 we find that inspections increase plants self reported pollution by 3 45 we provide a model to analyze plants strategic reactions to the pollution levy regulation in china the model concludes that under the specific regulation plants actual pollution might increase with inspections our study provides a key policy implication that inspections by environmental authorities in china are effective for verifying plants self reported pollution but not for reducing their pollution

from the marketplace to the dinner plate the economy theology and factory farming factory farming is big business since the products of factoryfarming are living breathing sentient creatures particular ethical issues are raised in a market system based on efficiency productivity costs of production and profit this paper focuses on the question of weather food animals in the american market system are subjected to unnecessary pain and suffering before they make it to our dinner plates the single most important consideration then is an exploration of the extent to which economic considerations render factory farming not only lucrative but also necessary under present market conditions the concern for unnecessary suffering moves the paper into an exploration of the extent to which the practices and effects of factory farming raise spiritual concerns which believers ought to address

decomposition weights and overall efficiency in two stage additive network dea abstract data envelopment analysis dea is a technique for performance evaluation of peer decision making units dmus the network dea models study the internal structures of dmus using two stage network structures as an example the current paper examines additive efficiency decomposition where the overall efficiency is defined as a weighted average of stage efficiencies and the weights are used to reflect relative importance of individual stages we show that weights may not affect the calculation of stage efficiency scores and that variation in the overall efficiency resulting from using different weights can be associated with constant stage efficiencies we demonstrate the need to isolate the impact of weights on the overall efficiency we propose to use a new overall efficiency index to address some pitfalls in weighted additive efficiency decomposition our findings are illustrated using two empirical data sets representing two types of two stage network structures

efficiency analysis of major cruise lines three major cruise lines account for 82 of the total market share their financial statements show different results between the operating incomes and net incomes over time to examine the major causes of the differences this study measured the efficiency of the top three cruise lines to develop a network dea model to analyze the cruise operations at two stages namely operating and non operating stages in addition the determinants of the efficiencies were examined using a bootstrapped truncated regression model overall cruise lines were efficient at the operating stage but varied widely in the efficiency of the non operating stage cruise lines attempting high capacity expansion were relatively inefficient because of the heavy interest payments arising from the high debt to capital ratio moreover the neglected hedging policy regarding the financial risks also contributed to the inefficiency

the collaborative enterprise instead of the currently prevailing competitive model a more collaborative strategy is needed to address the concerns related to the unsustainability of today s business this article aims to explore collaborative approaches where enterprises seek to build long term mutually beneficial relationships with all stakeholders and want to produce sustainable values for their whole business ecosystem cases here analyzed demonstrate that alternative ways of doing business are possible these enterprises share more democratic ownership structures more balanced and broader governance systems and a more comprehensive view of organizational goals and performance which goes beyond the narrow concept of financial bottom line and into a stronger and systematic care of the needs and requirements of the different stakeholder groups thanks to this evidence and different theoretical and empirical contributions we suggest that the strength and sustainability of enterprises come from their ability to fit into the environmental social and cultural context in which they operate by creating values for all stakeholders enterprises can involve them and gain deep support based on their commitment this may lead to superior performance from a multiple bottom line perspective

the sopranos redux the empirical economics of waste crime almer c and goeschl t the sopranos redux the empirical economics of waste crime regional studies evidence for the argument that enforcement makes environmental policies effective is limited with respect to geography scope enforcement tools and regulatory context non us evidence on criminal enforcement of illegal waste disposal is examined using a panel dataset of 44 counties from the german state of baden wurttemberg for the period 1995 2005 the results support the pro enforcement argument cumulatively there is clear evidence for a general deterrence effect of enforcement intensity on the amount of waste crime however regional economic and political economy factors matter significantly for environmental outcomes violations appear to be treated differently depending on their local political economy context

productivity and customer satisfaction in swedish pharmacies a dea network model this paper presents a data envelopment analysis dea network model that allows inclusion of customer satisfaction in efficiency and productivity measures the network consists of a production node and a consumption node and offers flexibility in modelling the production and consumption process where a firm specific allocation of input resources to production and customer oriented activities is allowed the proposed model is applied on a sample of swedish pharmacies with organizational objectives that necessitates a monitoring of efficiency and productivity as well as customer satisfaction estimation results from the network model and a direct productivity model without customer satisfaction are compared and indicate that the technical efficiency is lower under the network model the productivity results indicate productivity progress under both models albeit with a slower rate of change under the network model

dea like models for efficiency evaluations of specialized and interdependent units abstract the problem of evaluating the efficiency of a set of specialized and interdependent decision making subunits dmsus that make up a larger decision making unit dmu is considered the dmsus are interdependent in the sense that part of the output produced by each of them may be used as an input by the other ones they are also specialized hence non homogeneous as they may have not the same inputs and outputs for this problem some efficiency indexes are introduced and they are shown to satisfy some basic properties

industrial eco efficiency regional disparity and spatial convergence of china s regions abstract in this study the industrial eco efficiency measures of 30 chinese provinces municipalities and autonomous regions from 2001 to 2015 were estimated based on a proposed data envelopment analysis dea model and the non convex metafrontier undesirable outputs super efficiency slacks based measure ncmeta us sbm which simultaneously incorporates non convex metafrontier technology undesirable outputs and super efficiency into slacks based measure subsequently dynamic spatial econometric models were employed to test the spatial convergence of industrial eco efficiency the empirical results show that 1 the average value of industrial eco efficiency was the highest in the eastern region 0 67 followed by the western region 0 30 and central region 0 27 indicating the existence of a significant regional disparity 2 strong evidence for global and club spatial convergence of industrial eco efficiency was found with regard to regional heterogeneity provinces in the eastern region converged faster than those in the central and western regions while the convergence speed of industrial eco efficiency increased after 2008 with respect to temporal heterogeneity 3 the ownership structure appeared to have a higher impact on industrial eco efficiency than other controls in the presence of spatial conditional convergence these findings are robust with regard to both spatial econometric model and spatial weighting matrix specifications based on the empirical analysis the following policies promote industrial eco efficiency in china have been recommended first relevant authorities must take effective measures to encourage the central western regions to adopt clean energy technologies the energy subsidy policies should strive to break through the technological lock in and turn to regional green development second full advantage of the spatial effects must be taken and technological exchanges and cooperation among neighboring areas must be strengthened to ensure that the industrial eco efficiency of the central and western regions converge with those of the eastern coastal areas policy implications of multidimensional heterogeneity and adjustment of industrial structure should be highlighted while promoting industrial eco efficiency finally it is crucial to emphasize factors such as foreign direct investment fdi ownership and industrial structures to attract fdi and optimize the current industrial structure

dynamics of china s provincial level specialization in strategic emerging industries this paper examines the dynamics of technological specialization in strategic emerging industries seis within each of mainland china s 31 provinces and the likely effectiveness based on the experiences of taiwan and south korea of the provinces strategies for developing these industries grounded in economic decentralization theories the empirical method employed includes analyzing the scores on an sei specialization promotion index per each province alongside several analytics of invention patent data from each province in the seven seis newly designated by the central level government as of 2010 the data is quantitatively analyzed according to four groups of indicators based on the following specialization relevant concepts comparative advantages and technological capabilities economy size and income technological uncertainty and lifecycles and latecomer entry into complex technologies where knowledge is most cumulative the analysis finds that china s system of economic decentralization has partially worked to ensure provincial industrial policymaking is effective whereby a notable number of provinces are seemingly pursuing sei development strategies in terms of sei selection and promotion that may enable catch up however paradoxically at the same time the system appears to sometimes facilitate provincial sei development strategies that are quite risky or even likely ineffective

best performing us mutual fund families from 1993 to 2008 evidence from a novel two stage dea model for efficiency decomposition when analyzing relative performance especially at the institutional level the traditional data envelopment analysis dea models do not recognize vastly different and important activities as separate functions and therefore cannot identify which function may be the main source of inefficiency we propose a novel two stage dea model that decomposes the overall efficiency of a decision making unit into two components and demonstrate its applicability by assessing the relative performance of 66 large mutual fund families in the us over the period 1993 2008 by decomposing the overall efficiency into operational management efficiency and portfolio management efficiency components we reveal the best performers the families that deteriorated in performance and those that improved in their performance over the sample period we also make frontier projections for poorly performing mutual fund families and highlight how the portfolio managers have managed their funds relative to the others during financial crisis periods

reexamining criminal behavior the importance of omitted variable bias to what extent do changes in the expected penalty alter the willingness of individuals to engage in illegal activity becker 1968 developed a theoretical model of criminal behavior that asserted offenders respond to incentives in much the same way as those who engage in legal activities respond ehrlich 1973 pioneered empirical tests of the model and concluded that there was a strong positive correlation between income inequality and property crimes that the crime rate was positively related to relative gains and negatively related to the costs associated with criminal activity and that law enforcement activity had a deterrent effect for all crimes recently many papers have used arrest rates to mea

toward a new conception of the environment competitiveness relationship accepting a fixed trade off between environmental regulation and competitiveness unnecessarily raises costs and slows down environmental progress studies finding high environmental compliance costs have traditionally focused on static cost impacts ignoring any offsetting productivity benefits from innovation they typically overestimated compliance costs neglected innovation offsets and disregarded the affected industry s initial competitiveness rather than simply adding to cost properly crafted environmental standards can trigger innovation offsets allowing companies to improve their resource productivity shifting the debate from pollution control to pollution prevention was a step forward it is now necessary to make the next step and focus on resource productivity

individual transferable quota markets and investment decisions in the fixed gear sablefish industry this paper presents an ex ante analysis of an individual transferable quota itq program imposed on one species in a multispecies fishery utilizing mathematical programming pseudo data and tobit regression market demand for quota and prospective gains in economic rent and efficiency gains from quota trade are assessed for the pot and longline sablefish fleet off the pacific coast of the united states incentives for disinvestment and industry exit after quota exchange implications for structure of the industry and itq market and policy implications are examined

environment and development theory and international evidence the environmental effects of economic development have significant implications for a wide array of policy questions facing both low and high income countries today internationally agricultural research centers are considering how to incorporate sustainability issues into their research agendas while international lending institutions are taking a close look at the environmental consequences of industrial projects domestically the north american free trade agreement has brought the relationship between economic development and environmental quality to the forefront of u s public policy debate it is surprising that despite the postwar growth of development economics the genesis of environmental economics and the fusion of ideas from both fields into the theme of sustainable development economists have not made much progress in describing the impacts of long term economic growth on environmental quality yet a vigorous public debate has arisen between individuals who maintain that environmental degradation is a necessary outcome of economic growth and those who believe that economic growth and environmental quality go hand in hand this debate was highlighted at the 1992 united nations conference on environment and development in rio de janeiro in part this debate hinges on the properties of the aggregate demand for and supply of environmental quality if the income elasticity of demand for environmental quality or amenities is high then the increased prosperity engendered by economic growth could lead to significantly higher demand for environmental quality proponents of economic growth believe this demand will translate into a higher realized level of quality as both public and private institutions and organi

juvenile crime and punishment evidence from japan over the last decade juvenile crime has become a serious social problem in japan the juvenile law was revised in 2001 to impose harsher punishment on juvenile offenders this revision makes it possible to impose criminal punishment on 14 and 15 year old criminal offenders while those offenders aged 16 19 have always faced criminal punishment both before and after the revision using this revision as a natural experiment this study conducts a difference in differences estimation to examine the effect of punishment on juvenile crime the analysis provides evidence that punishment can deter juvenile crime in addition this research examines the criminal behaviour of 13 year olds who face no change in punishment but who soon will in the near future the results suggest that the revision also had a negative impact on the criminal behaviour of these younger offenders

the effect of prison population size on crime rates evidence from prison overcrowding litigation simultaneity between prisoner populations and crime rates makes it difficult to isolate the causal effect of changes in prison populations on crime to break that simultaneity this paper uses prison overcrowding litigation in a state as an instrument for changes in the prison population the resulting elasticities are two to three times greater than those of previous studies a one prisoner reduction is associated with an increase of fifteen index i crimes per year while calculations of the costs of crime are inherently uncertain it appears that the social benefits associated with crime reduction equal or exceed the social costs of incarceration for the marginal prisoner

journey for green development transformation of china s metal industry a spatial econometric analysis abstract the metal industry mi in china is energy and emissions intensive this paper tries to provide guidance for the green development transformation of china s mi by investigating the green total factor productivity gtfp and its influencing factors using a global data envelopment analysis and a spatial tobit regression model the estimation results show that 1 from 2000 to 2015 gtfp of china s mi enjoyed a considerable improvement however the current value of gtfp of china s mi is still less than 0 5 indicating that gtfp of china s mi is far from efficient 2 the spatial correlation test shows that gtfps of china s provincial mis have positive spatial correlations most of the provinces scattered in high high and low low agglomerations 3 gtfp of china s mi is significantly positive related to the degree of marketization fiscal decentralization environmental regulation industrial scale is significantly negative related to resources endowment and product structure and has u shaped relationship with the level of economic development the above results suggest that china already has made remarkable achievements in promoting green development of its mi however there is much room for further improvement policy options for the green development transformation of china s mi include but are not limited to promoting market oriented and financial system reforms strengthening environmental supervision and optimizing industrial scale and product structure finally recommendations for the effective implementation of these policies are provided at the end of the study

influencing factors on hydrogen energy r d projects an ex post performance evaluation abstract to enhance its energy security korea made a significant r d investment in developing hydrogen energy technology over a period of 10 years the hydrogen energy r d center was established in 2003 with a 100 billion korean won krw government investment that would fund the initiative through 2012 this paper is a meaningful attempt to evaluate the ex post performance of completed hydrogen energy r d projects using data envelopment analysis dea through empirical analysis we focus mainly on measuring ex post performance and uncovering the influencing factors on that performance the results of our empirical analysis reveal several interesting findings first overall the ex post performance of completed projects is relatively low however there are major performance gaps among projects second r d type technology type and private sector investment are factors influencing project performance more specifically projects identified as basic research storage technology or without private sector investment had the highest performance with an acceptable level of statistical significance third dea can provide unique information such as results of returns to scale and slack analysis which cannot be gleaned from parametric methods as time went on the decreasing returns to scale drs ratio increased and the increasing returns to scale irs ratio decreased this means that the r d budget was used less and less effectively as time passed moreover among the three year project period the second year s r d budget was used most efficiently in each r d project this study can provide meaningful information to policy makers to enhance the performance of future r d projects and to promote hydrogen r d projects as well as advance the hydrogen economy

productivity and intermediate products a frontier approach abstract in recent years it has become popular to measure productivity using non parametric approaches however this has been done while ignoring intermediate products here we develop a non parametric productivity measure that explicitly incorporates such products

how do environmental regulation and environmental decentralization affect green total factor energy efficiency evidence from china abstract green development is critical for china s economic transformation enhancing green total factor energy efficiency hereafter gtfee is vital to emission reduction and to win win industrial development this study uses the panel data of 30 chinese provinces for the period 2005 2016 to investigate the relationship between environmental regulation and china s gtfee the spatial durbin model is employed to control for the possible spatial spillover effect a dynamic threshold panel model that can effectively address the endogeneity problem and regional heterogeneity is utilized to examine the potential non linear relationship between environmental regulation and gtfee under different conditions of environmental decentralization the estimation results indicate that there is a significant u shaped relationship between environmental regulation and china s gtfee with the further expansion of environmental decentralization the local government s autonomous choice of pollution control is improved the improvement of environmental decentralization can lead to negative moderating effect of environmental regulation on gtfee additionally the regression results of dynamic threshold model show that environmental decentralization can increase the negative influences of environmental regulation on gtfee interestingly the non linear impact of environmental regulation on gtfee is dependent on the specific type of environmental decentralization higher degree of environmental decentralization can lead to an increase in the restraining effect of environmental regulation on gtfee however an improvement in the decentralization of environmental supervision and environmental monitoring can increase the negative influences of environmental regulation on gtfee

assessing the relationship between government policy and deforestation abstract the effects of public policies on deforestation are assessed in a general equilibrium framework a forest can be left in its natural state to provide a consumption benefit such as biodiversity or carbon absorption in its natural state it is subject to free access however alternatively it can be converted to a market input needed to produce a valuable final product the utility of consumers depends on the amount of the forest left standing on consumption of the forest using commodity and on consumption of a numeraire that is produced from non forest inputs only final commodities are traded with the outside world at constant prices the model is used to evaluate claims in the literature regarding the effects of government policies on deforestation in developing countries the polices examined include transportation improvements taxes and royalties on timber harvests controls on log exports a variety of agricultural policies tax incentives to promote domestic processing industries and employment opportunity enhancement

the impact of industrial structure efficiency on provincial industrial energy efficiency in china abstract regional disparity in terms of industrial energy efficiency is noticeable in china due to the unbalanced economic progress in past decades analyzing the provincial industrial energy efficiency and its influencing factors is of great significance to formulate differentiated policies to date the influence of many social economic factors on the industrial energy efficiency have been examined but the impact of the inter industry structure has almost been ignored in this paper the slacks based measure model incorporating undesirable output is applied to evaluate the industrial energy efficiency both at the provincial level and the sectoral level in china for the period 2010 to 2016 then industrial structure efficiency is introduced which reflects the inter industry structure and takes the sectoral level energy efficiency into consideration and the impact of the industrial structure efficiency on provincial industrial energy efficiency is tested by tobit regression model the results show that huge discrepancies of provincial industrial energy efficiency exist and the industrial structure efficiency is confirmed to be a determinative factor to the provincial industrial energy efficiency with the coefficient of 0 525 policy recommendations are provided for adjusting the provincial inter industry structure and improving the industrial energy efficiency

deriving the dea frontier for two stage processes data envelopment analysis dea is a method for measuring the efficiency of peer decision making units dmus recently dea has been extended to examine the efficiency of two stage processes where all the outputs from the first stage are intermediate measures that make up the inputs to the second stage the resulting two stage dea model provides not only an overall efficiency score for the entire process but as well yields an efficiency score for each of the individual stages due to the existence of intermediate measures the usual procedure of adjusting the inputs or outputs by the efficiency scores as in the standard dea approach does not necessarily yield a frontier projection the current paper develops an approach for determining the frontier points for inefficient dmus within the framework of two stage dea

moral development of the economic actor abstract in this article we argue that the changes in moral content in economics can be explained as an evolution in accordance with the maturing process presented in kohlberg s stages of moral development firstly we describe and discuss the three levels of moral progress pre conventional conventional and post conventional as presented in kohlberg s theory secondly we draw a distinction between classical economics neoclassical economics and ecological economics and discuss to what extent the differences in ethics within the three theories can be explained by referring to the ethical development characterizing kohlberg s moral stages thirdly we discuss some of the hallmarks characterizing economics based upon what kohlberg termed universal principles at the highest stage in the development of moral reasoning to exemplify the evolution of moral reasoning in different economic theories we describe the changes that take place in the image of man over the last 2 300 years the human being in economics has been discussed in this journal with reference to three different relations to himself community and nature we have used the metaphors economic man social man and ecological man to characterize the ethical content of the three first stages at the first stage economic man interpreted as an egocentric individual seeking personal gain characterizes classical economics at the second stage social man seeks the best for a group of people within the perspective of neoclassical economics at the third stage ecological man is aware of the interrelatedness between economy and nature within ecological economics the agent is termed ecological man to indicate the interconnectedness between economy and the ecosystems while being aware of the weakness in predictive power inherent in these kinds of stage theories we find it stimulating to conclude with a description of economics based upon the ideas characterizing the highest level stage 7 in kohlberg s theory we put forward a hypothesis concerning a fourth stage in the development of economics termed neo ecological economics we describe the economic actor as cosmic man cosmic man has an extended self and incorporates all the other images of man

malmquist index measurement for sustainability enhancement in chinese municipalities and provinces abstract this study discusses a use of dea environmental assessment in a time horizon we use a radial approach to examine a dynamic change of index measures related to china s regional development and industrial pollution prevention in applying the proposed assessment to a time series data we need to examine components that produce a shift of an efficiency frontier in a time horizon a unique feature of the proposed assessment is that it incorporates a framework of malmquist index to examine the frontier shift among multiple periods here the frontier shift indicates a progress potential on technology development and or managerial improvement among observed periods thus it is not an efficiency measure rather the measurement eliminates inefficiency by shifting an organization to an efficiency frontier in this study the index is conceptually separated into 6 subcomponents which are further disaggregated into 12 different elements 6 subcomponents 2 disposability concepts under natural and managerial disposability concepts the proposed index measurement needs to consider a possible occurrence of a frontier crossover among different periods because technology diffusion on production activities usually has a time lag until it becomes really effective methodologically this study conveys the message that dea is an approximation method so being not perfect therefore it is necessary for us to use several different approaches e g potential improvement by measuring a frontier shift and efficiency analysis to obtain reliable empirical evidence as an application this study examines the level of sustainability related to 30 municipalities and provinces in china from 2003 to 2014 the following six policy implications are obtained in this study first all municipalities and provinces have made a considerable progress on their economies and pollution prevention efforts second the effect of the frontier crossover is limited in china because they attain a high level of their potentials on economic development and pollution prevention of course this effort is within the chinese boundary not international because this study does not compare them with other industrial nations third china needs to allocate its resources to western provinces at a level that it has used for coastal developments fourth the government should reinforce efforts on environmental protection in central and southern regions fifth the government has focused on the sustainability development in urban municipalities and provinces and then has gradually shifted the policy influence toward rural areas finally different empirical results are confirmed by the potential analysis which consists of the malmquist index measurement and the efficiency analysis both approaches need to be examined for future planning on chinese regional development

trade offs in the allocation of prosecution resources an opportunity cost of overcriminalization one in every five citizens has a criminal record in korea scarce prosecution resources have been severely skewed toward prosecuting more legislated crime than conventional crime we estimate the opportunity cost of this prosecutory pattern in terms of spillovers to conventional crimes the cost was found to be substantial for example in 2003 the total spillovers accounted for approximately 25 of the increase in conventional crimes for 3 years from 2000 because of the disproportionate prosecutory focus on legislated crimes compared with that of the 1990s this article has relevance to those countries with an overcriminalizing trend for legislated crimes

a coevolutionary model for promoting agricultural sustainability abstract this article presents a coevolutionary model of agricultural development that is based on observations from the environmental history of agriculture and the need for addressing development processes toward sustainability it asserts that the challenge of agricultural sustainability can be fruitfully addressed within an analytical framework that consciously and explicitly considers agricultural development as consisting of processes of coevolution involving agriculture and the surrounding ecological and socioeconomic systems widening the processes to include strong interconnectedness with national and global systems with respect to off farm resources and farm outputs has led to various agro ecological problems strengthening local interaction and interconnectedness in a rural urban context is found to be essential for developing a system of sustainable agriculture such development requires influencing many subsystems and implementing changes in production methods and land use as short term responses to the problem and technological development resource allocation and changes in values as long term responses it also requires some sustainability principles and indicators in order to direct actions and to facilitate communications which can be derived from the model applying the model on swedish agricultural sustainability during the twentieth century reveals some probably important findings for building sustainable agriculture and lends support to the usefulness of the model

shared wealth or nobody s land the worth of natural capital and ecosystem services the prerequisite for a sustainable and equitable use of common resources the so called commons must be the proper evaluation of their role within the complex network of relationships that ensure ecosystems functioning resilience and evolutionary dynamics it is crucial to ascertain to what extent the common wealth is used for the common benefit money based schemes for valuing the commons such as the so called willingness to pay provide a user side evaluation perspective based on the idea that value only stems from utilization by humans as a complement to such a point of view we present and discuss in this paper a donor side evaluation method emergy synthesis based on the idea that a proper measure of value can be achieved by also accounting for the work done by the biosphere in generating services and resources it should not be disregarded that such resources and services also provide support to other species in the web of life emergy a scientific measure of such environmental support is suggested as a tool capable to assess quantity and quality of shared resources thus providing a basis for their environmentally sound management

evaluating the efficiency of industrial environmental regulation in china a three stage data envelopment analysis approach abstract environmental regulation is of great concern to international academics and policy makers previous studies often regarded environmental regulation as an influencing factor when calculating eco efficiency or energy efficiency more attention should be given to the efficiency of environmental regulation especially in industrial field according to exiting studies industrial environmental regulation efficiency iere may be influenced by external environmental factors to explore the influence and obtain an actual efficiency this paper calculated iere in china by using the panel data of 30 regions from 2011 to 2015 the 12th five year plan period through the three stage data envelopment analysis approach firstly the undesirable slacks based model method was used to calculate the original iere secondly the economic base industrial structure urbanization level and education level were taken as external environmental variables and the effect of external environmental factors and stochastic disturbance were excluded thirdly the actual iere can be calculated after adjusting input values the results showed that china s iere was underestimated due to the impact from external environmental factors moreover the iere was more influenced by pure technical efficiency than scale efficiency the iere of each region varied thus targeted policies should be formulated according to local conditions this research provided a new analytical method for calculating environmental regulation efficiency the method can be applied either in other countries or in other sectors

will airline efficiency be affected by carbon neutral growth from 2020 strategy evidences from 29 international airlines abstract in this paper the impact of the carbon neutral growth from 2020 cng2020 strategy on airline efficiency is analyzed based on the predicted data of 29 international airlines during 2021 2023 the data is predicted through neural network following the principle of cng2020 strategy we calculate the emission limit for each airline two models network range adjusted measure with natural disposability and network range adjusted measure with managerial disposability are proposed to discuss the efficiency change when the cng2020 strategy is considered the following findings are gotten 1 under natural disposability the indices related with undesirable output have a larger role in deciding benchmarking airline 2 for most of the 29 airlines cng2020 strategy has little influence on their efficiency

assessment of china transit and economic efficiencies in a modified value chains dea model abstract this study incorporates the concepts of undesirable intermediate intermediate input uncontrollable input and undesirable output to the value chains model chen and zhu 2004 thereby creating a modified value chains model to compute transit and economic efficiencies in 30 regions of china the modified value chains model forms a more general formulation to the value added chains in the utilization of the above concepts it also provides an optimal intermediate measure which differs from the independent two stage measure empirical evaluations indicate that large scale transit development in china s coastal area does not necessarily represent higher transit efficiency because in the coastal area there is a lack of significant positive relationships between transit and economic efficiency high economic efficiency does not contribute to greater transit efficiency the finding also suggests that by simultaneously decreasing the quantity in passenger and freight transport transit and economic efficiencies have greatly improved in most regions of china

cost and learning efficiency drivers in australian schools a two stage network dea approach this article explore performance issues in australian public schools using a two stage dea network model which accounts simultaneously for both cost and learning efficiency levels in the cost efficiency stage different types of expenses and investments are employed to support a given number of students teachers and administrative staff in the learning efficiency stage these groups of individuals help to produce important outputs related to performance in student tests and school rankings results indicate that australian public schools are heterogeneous policy implications are also discussed

measuring the efficiency of china s regional innovation systems application of network data envelopment analysis dea chen k and guan j measuring the efficiency of china s regional innovation systems application of network data envelopment analysis dea regional studies this study applies a relational network data analysis envelopment to the systematic evaluation of the innovation efficiency of china s regional innovation systems by decomposing the innovation process into the two connecting sub processes technological development and subsequent technological commercialization the results show that only one fifth of china s regional innovation systems are operating on the empirical best practice frontier during the whole process from technological development to commercialization furthermore it is found that substantial inconsistencies exist between technological development capacity and commercialization capacity in most regional innovation systems and that downstream commercialization capacity plays a more important role in the innovation performance of regional innovation systems chen k et guan j evaluer

the effect of police response time on crime clearance rates police agencies devote vast resources to minimizing the time that it takes them to attend the scene of a crime despite this the long standing consensus is that police response time has no meaningful effect on the likelihood of catching offenders we revisit this question using a uniquely rich dataset from the greater manchester police to identify causal effects we use a novel strategy that exploits discontinuities in distance to the response station across locations next to each other but on different sides of division boundaries contrary to previous evidence we find large and strongly significant effects in our preferred estimate a 10 increase in response time leads to a 4 7 percentage points decrease in the likelihood of clearing the crime we find stronger effects for thefts than for violent offences although the effects are large for every type of crime we find suggestive evidence in support of two mechanisms the likelihood of an immediate arrest and the likelihood that a suspect will be named by a victim or witness both increase as response time becomes faster we argue that under conservative assumptions hiring an additional response officer would generate a benefit in terms of future crime prevented equivalent to 170 of her payroll cost

crime apprehension and clearance rates panel data evidence from canadian provinces the becker 1968 model of crime establishes the importance of the probability of apprehension as a key factor in a rational individual s decision to commit a crime in this respect most empirical studies based on us data have relied on variation in the number of police officers to estimate the impact of the probability of apprehension or capture we measure the probability of apprehension by clearance rates and study their effects on crime rates employing a panel of canadian provinces from 1986 to 2005 ols gmm gls and iv estimates yield statistically significant elasticities of clearance rates ranging from 0 2 to 0 4 for violent crimes and from 0 5 to 0 6 for property crimes these findings reflect the importance of police force crime solving productivity

estudos econ omicos das causas da criminalidade no brasil evid encias e controv ersias this study aims to gather and to discuss the literature on the economics of the criminality in brazil the main diculties evidences and controversies found in empirical research are presented besides some of the main criminal data bases available in brazil unavailability of data crime underreporting and the inverse causality between the deterrence variables and the criminality are some of the main inherent diculties of the economic investigation of crime the main controversy among the studies is the eect of law enforcement on crime rates the main results are that income inequality and returns on crime lead to increases in criminality also there are spatial eects aecting

green productivity growth in china s industrial economy abstract this paper uses a directional distance function ddf and the malmquist luenberger productivity index to estimate the changing patterns of green total factor productivity gtfp growth of 38 chinese industrial sectors during the period 1980 2010 unlike the measures of traditional total factor productivity tfp growth the ddf incorporates carbon dioxide emissions as an undesirable output directly into the production technology which credit sectors for simultaneously reducing their emissions and increasing their output our estimates of aggregate and sector level gtfp growth reveal that chinese industry is not yet on the path towards sustainable low carbon growth a dynamic panel data analysis of the determinants of gtfp across sectors is used to identify factors that might rectify this situation including state owned enterprise soe reform the growth of small private enterprises continued openness to foreign investment and higher spending on r d particularly in emission intensive sectors

productivity growth and environmental regulations accounting for undesirable outputs analysis of china s thirty provincial regions using the malmquist luenberger index this paper employs the malmquist luenberger ml productivity index to evaluate china s growth in total factor productivity tfp incorporating undesirable outputs during the period from 1989 to 2008 the ml productivity index and its components technical and efficiency changes are derived from the directional distance function which gives credit for an increase in good outputs and for reductions in undesirable outputs the average annual ml productivity growth accounting for undesirable outputs is 2 46 whereas the value of the traditional malmquist productivity index is 4 84 showing that the true tfp growth in china is overestimated if undesirable outputs are ignored we explore the strictness in enforcing environmental regulations and its impact on improvements in ml productivity the results show that the enforcement of environmental regulations in china is in general far below the levels achieved in the best performing regions and that the more stringent enforcement of environmental regulations would help to improve ml productivity growth in china

collaborative enterprise and sustainability the case of slow food the current and prevailing paradigm of intensive agricultural production is a straightforward example of the mainstream way of doing business mainstream enterprises are based on a negativistic view of human nature that leads to counter productive and unsustainable behaviours producing negative impact for society and the natural environment if we want to change the course then different players are needed which can flourish thanks to their capacity to serve others and creating values for all the participants in the network in which they are embedded in the article through the analysis of the slow food movement and the use of recent theoretical and empirical contributions in behavioural sciences and psychology we support the collaborative enterprise model as an alternative to the still prevailing mainstream business models evidence shows that caring and responsible efforts of economic agents are acknowledged and reciprocated even in highly competitive markets

interprovincial two stage water resource utilization efficiency under environmental constraint and spatial spillover effects in china although existing studies have paid much attention to the measurement model of water resource utilization efficiency they have failed to consider the spatial spillover effect of some influencing factors of water resource utilization efficiency causing biased results this study measures the water resource utilization efficiency of 31 provincial administrative regions in china from 2001 to 2014 and the efficiency of each stage by adopting a slack based efficiency evaluation model based on the relaxation of two stages to consider undesirable output then this study employs a spatial durbin econometric model by considering spatial effect to analyze the influencing factors of the overall efficiency of water resource utilization by per capita water resources industrial water living water consumption per capita gross domestic product degree of opening to the outside world industrial structure technological progress and other aspects by comparison existing studies do not consider the spatial spillover effect this study estimates the direct and indirect effects of the influencing factors of water resource utilization efficiency to distinguish local and neighbors impacts of influencing factors of water resource utilization efficiency the results are as follows 1 first stage overall efficiency is significantly higher than second stage water resource utilization efficiency overall efficiency is close to second stage efficiency and second stage efficiency determines the overall effectiveness of water resource utilization 2 the spatial autocorrelation intensity of water resource utilization overall efficiency is significantly greater than zero and water resource utilization overall efficiency presents concentration distribution in the space for which the eastern coastal regions are high high type and the central and western regions are low low type 3 the overall efficiency of water resource utilization has spatial spillover effects and the region s overall efficiency is influenced by both region and neighborhood region 4 the direct and indirect effects of domestic water consumption degree of opening up and industrial structure are the primary significant influencing factors of overall efficiency of water resources in china the spatial spillover effects of domestic water consumption and industrial structure have a significant impact to improve water resource utilization efficiency the government and citizens should focus on such solutions as pollution reduction domestic water savings and transforming the industrial structure moreover china should consider the spatial effects of these influencing factors when government policies are designed

income inequality and pollution a reassessment of the environmental kuznets curve abstract improvements in some measures of air and water quality can accompany rising per capita income as illustrated by the so called environmental kuznets curve for pollution variables which show such a relationship we hypothesize that a more equitable distribution of power contributes to these outcomes by enhancing the influence on policy of those who bear the costs of pollution relative to the influence of those who benefit from pollution generating activities an empirical analysis of international variations in seven indicators of air and water quality supports this hypothesis literacy political rights and civil liberties are found to have particularly strong effects on environmental quality in low income countries

development and application of the hicks moorsteen productivity index for the total factor productivity assessment of wastewater treatment plants abstract the assessment of the productivity change in wastewater treatment plants is essential to improve performance and reduce operational costs several indices are available to compute unit productivity however some assessments are more reliable than others in the absence of price data the malmquist productivity index is the most commonly applied but it does not maintain total factor productivity properties under variable returns to scale technology hence malmquist productivity index is not a suitable index to compute total factor productivity change in wastewater treatment plants the present study served to overcome such limitations by calculating for the first time total factor productivity changes in a sample of 204 spanish wastewater treatment plants using the hicks moorsteen productivity index it is a multiplicatively complete index which can be decomposed as several sub indices representing technical and efficiency changes therefore this study also investigated the drivers of total factor productivity change in wastewater treatment plants results showed a 5 4 total factor productivity decline per year from 2003 to 2008 in the plants analysed the primary driver in the reduction was efficiency change alternatively technical change improved during the five years of study the results of this study provide support for policymakers and managers in decision making processes and contribute to the improvement of technical and economic wastewater treatment plants performance in addition it is evidenced that wastewater treatment plants current dependence on external energy sources should be reduced to improve productivity and reduce costs to citizens who pay for wastewater treatment services

estimating the economic model of crime with panel data previous attempts at estimating the economic model of crime with aggregate data relied heavily on cross section econometric techniques and therefore do not control for unobserved heterogeneity this is even true of studies that estimated simultaneous equations models using a new panel data set of north carolina counties the authors exploit both single and simultaneous equations panel data estimators to address two sources of endogeneity unobserved heterogeneity and conventional simultaneity their results suggest that both labor market and criminal justice strategies are important in deterring crime but that the effectiveness of law enforcement incentives has been greatly overstated copyright 1994 by mit press

carrots sticks and broken windows abstract this paper investigates the effect of economic conditions carrots and sanctions sticks on murder assault robbery burglary motor vehicle theft grand larceny and rape in new york city using monthly time series data spanning 1974 99 carrots are measured by the unemployment rate and the real minimum wage sticks are measured by the number of felony arrests size of the police force and number of new york city residents in prison in addition the paper tests the validity of the broken windows hypothesis consistent with its implementation by the new york police department we use misdemeanor arrests as a measure of broken windows policing the broken windows hypothesis has validity in the case of robbery motor vehicle theft and grand larceny while both economic and deterrence variables are important in explaining the decline in crime the contribution of deterrence measures is larger than those of economic variables

casinos crime and community costs we examine the relationship between casinos and crime using county level data for the united states between 1977 and 1996 casinos were nonexistent outside nevada before 1978 and expanded to many other states during our sample period most factors that reduce crime occur before or shortly after a casino opens whereas those that increase crime including problem and pathological gambling occur over time the results suggest that the effect on crime is low shortly after a casino opens and grows over time roughly 8 of crime in casino counties in 1996 was attributable to casinos costing the average adult 75 per year

the economics of tropical deforestation this paper provides a survey of first wave economic studies of tropical deforestation and land use these studies of tropical forest land conversion are generally at the cross country level we also conduct a synthesis cross country analysis of tropical agricultural land expansion the results show that agricultural development is the main factor determining land expansion but institutional factors have an important influence income effects tend to vary from region to region and do not always display an environmental kuznets curve relationship copyright 2001 by blackwell publishers ltd

do we punish high income criminals too heavily many critics believe that since high income criminals can afford to purchase better legal services they are less severely punished than poor criminals who commit equivalent crimes others are concerned that the penalties imposed on criminals are too small this paper shows that ignoring the effect conviction has on later earnings dramatically underestimates the total monetary penalty paid by those convicted and that the penalty structure is extremely progressive where evidence on the probability of conviction is available it shows that the highest income criminals face the highest expected penalties

the economic epidemiology of crime economic analysis of infectious diseases emphasizes the self correcting character of epidemics as rising risk of infection causes potential victims to take self protective measures we apply the analysis to crime showing how rational potential victims of crime will take increased self protective measures in response to rising crime rates causing those rates to moderate victim responses to crime can offset public expenditures on crime control this implies that there may be a natural rate of crime that is difficult for the public sector to affect we show that victim responses to crime can impart a cyclical pattern to crime rates and discuss the implications of our analysis for gun control and present empirical evidence concerning the responsiveness of self protective measures to crime rates and the cyclical pattern of those rates

eco efficiency analysis of power plants an extension of data envelopment analysis abstract in public discussion on environmental policy the notion of eco efficiency is often used the joint production of goods and undesirable outputs such as pollutants which may not be freely disposable without costs causes difficulties to measure the overall performance of the firm because of the absence of market prices for the undesirable outputs we are not able to estimate the environmental costs some of the measurement and evaluation difficulties can be overcome by employing data envelopment analysis dea as the efficiency measurement vehicle we propose the use of two different approaches in the first approach we start by decomposing the problem into two parts 1 the problem of measuring technical efficiency as the relation of the desirable outputs to the inputs and 2 the problem of measuring so called ecological efficiency as the relation of the desirable outputs to the undesirable outputs separately those two efficiency indicators are then combined in the second approach we treat pollutants as the inputs in the sense that we wish to increase desirable outputs and decrease pollutants and inputs the approaches are applied to the problem of measuring the efficiency of 24 power plants in a european country