impacts of opec s political risk on the international crude oil prices an empirical analysis based on the svar models abstract the impacts of opec s political risk on the fluctuations of international crude oil prices have caused widespread concern and analyzing the impacts is of great significance to the investment decisions and risk aversion strategies in the crude oil markets therefore using the international country risk guide icrg index as a proxy for the countries political risk situation we empirically investigate the impacts of opec s political risk on the brent crude oil prices based on several structural vector autoregression svar models the main empirical results indicate that 1 the political risk of opec countries does have a significant and positive influence on brent crude oil prices in the sample period from january 1998 to september 2014 and the most significant positive influences appear in about one and a half year and last about a year 2 opec s integrated political risk contributes to 17 58 of the oil price fluctuations in the sample period which is only lesser than that of the oil demand shocks 34 64 3 compared with the political risk of opec countries in north africa and south america the political risk of opec countries in the middle east contributes most to the oil price fluctuations 4 among the eight components of the political risk in opec the internal conflicts contribute most to the oil price fluctuations in the sample period

what has driven oil prices since 2000 a structural change perspective abstract this paper characterizes weekly international oil price fundamentals since 2000 by analyzing the transformation of the market mechanism based on structural change perspective using endogenously determined break tests that allow for changes in both level and trend we divide the price fluctuations in the international oil market after 2000 into three stages relatively calm market period january 07 2000 to march 12 2004 the bubble accumulation period march 19 2004 to june 06 2008 and the global economic crisis period june 13 2008 to september 11 2009 the results show the existence of structural breaks refutes the utility of investigation of the full sample period as a whole and in different structural periods the main drivers of oil price changes and their way of influence and degree are significantly distinct then we demonstrate the evolving process of market mechanism since 2000 through establishing comparative models we also quantitatively measure the roles of speculation and episodic events in oil price fluctuations

do global risk perceptions influence world oil prices abstract this paper investigates the information transmission mechanism between world oil gold silver dollar euro exchange rate markets and volatility index vix accommodating for global risk perceptions we find that there is a unique long run equilibrium relationship where gold silver exchange rate and risk perceptions appear as long run forcing variables of world oil prices we uncover that global risk perceptions have a significantly suppressing effect on oil prices in the long run we also discover that global risk perceptions play a less important role in explaining the forecast error variance of oil prices in the short run than prices in the alternative investment markets our results also suggest that a shock in risk perceptions of global investors have a negative but short lived initial impact on oil prices

index investment and financialization of commodities the authors found that concurrent with the rapidly growing index investment in commodity markets since the early 2000s prices of non energy commodity futures in the united states have become incr

volatility spillovers between oil prices and stock sector returns implications for portfolio management abstract in this article we take a recent generalized var garch approach to examine the extent of volatility transmission between oil and stock markets in europe and the united states at the sector level the empirical model is advantageous in that it typically allows simultaneous shock transmission in the conditional returns and volatilities insofar as volatility transmission across oil and stock sector markets is a crucial element for portfolio designs and risk management we also analyze the optimal weights and hedge ratios for oil stock portfolio holdings with respect to the results our findings point to the existence of significant volatility spillover between oil and sector stock returns however the spillover is usually unidirectional from oil markets to stock markets in europe but bidirectional in the united states our back testing procedures finally suggest that taking the cross market volatility spillovers estimated from the var garch models often leads to diversification benefits and hedging effectiveness better than those of commonly used multivariate volatility models such as the ccc garch of bollerslev 1990 the diagonal bekk garch of engle and kroner 1995 and the dcc garch of engle 2002

equity market implied volatility and energy prices a double threshold garch approach abstract this study investigates the role of vix in determining the returns and return volatilities of oil heating oil gasoline and natural gas a double threshold garch 1 1 methodology is utilized where the vix index is used as the threshold regime change indicator daily data from january 4 1999 to december 31 2013 are used a sub period analysis covering only the financial crisis period of january 2 2007 to december 31 2009 is also performed this study provides evidence that the level of equity market volatility i e vix that triggers a regime shift is commodity specific the results also indicate that the threshold vix values are time varying furthermore natural gas prices appear to withstand considerably more volatility in the equity market than do the prices of other energy commodities this relationship is even more pronounced during the financial crisis period approximately 70 and 50 of the estimated coefficients display asymmetric sensitivities due to regime changes during the entire period and the crisis period respectively the findings have practical implications as the underlying volatility of an asset plays a significant role in determining its associated activity in the futures markets

roughing it up including jump components in the measurement modeling and forecasting of return volatility a rapidly growing literature has documented important improvements in financial return volatility measurement and forecasting via use of realized variation measures constructed from high frequency returns coupled with simple modeling procedures building on recent theoretical results in barndorff nielsen and shephard 2004a 2005 for related bi power variation measures the present paper provides a practical and robust framework for non parametrically measuring the jump component in asset return volatility in an application to the dm exchange rate the s p500 market index and the 30 year u s treasury bond yield we find that jumps are both highly prevalent and distinctly less persistent than the continuous sample path variation process moreover many jumps appear directly associated with specific macroeconomic news announcements separating jump from non jump movements in a simple but sophisticated volatility forecasting model we find that almost all of the predictability in daily weekly and monthly return volatilities comes from the non jump component our results thus set the stage for a number of interesting future econometric developments and important financial applications by separately modeling forecasting and pricing the continuous and jump components of the total return variation process

assessment of the relationship between oil prices and us oil stocks abstract this paper qualitatively and quantitatively analyzes the relationship between us monthly ending oil stocks position with that of west texas intermediate wti oil prices from february 1995 to july 2004 the paper concludes if other things are held constant wti is inversely related to the petroleum products ppp combined petroleum products and crude oil cppp crude oil alone crude total oil stocks including petroleum products crude oil and strategic petroleum reserves spr total total gasoline tgo total distillate tdo it could not establish a statistically significant and negative relationship with spr when run alone one percent increase decrease in cppp ppp crude total tgo and tdo leads to decrease increase in wti respectively by 0 70 0 43 0 37 0 97 0 26 and 0 21 percent oil prices are largely influenced by total crude and crude and ppp inventories levels while modestly with variations in gasoline and distillate stocks levels despite a healthy increase of over 22 percent in spr from january 2001 to april 2004 it did not result in easing of oil prices primarily because spr are meant for security of supply concern and are only released under extreme conditions by the president of united states they are neither meant for the purposes of balancing supply demand gap nor for the stability of oil prices the aggressive spr buildup in recent years is related to international terrorism geopolitical situation in the middle east particularly in iraq that encourages us government to enhance its spr to meet any short term eventuality the analyst must keep a close eye on cppp and the total oil stocks variation to forecast wti in the short run whilst gasoline and distillate influence oil prices modestly in the short run spr on the other hand are expected to play a pivotal role in balancing oil prices and in providing a critical resource for the economy in case of any major shortfall in the long run

on the dynamic effects of oil price shocks a study using industry level data abstract this paper analyzes the effects of oil price shocks on demand and supply in various industries the impulse responses of identified var models indicate that for industries that have a large cost share of oil such as petroleum refinery and industrial chemicals oil price shocks mainly reduce supply in contrast for many other industries with the automobile industry being a particularly important example oil price shocks mainly reduce demand the paper suggests that oil price shocks influence economic activities beyond that explained by direct input cost effects possibly by delaying purchasing decisions of durable goods

insurance as a lemons market coverage denials and pooling abstract the standard monopoly insurance model with adverse selection implies that there are always gains to trade that only the best unobservable risks can go uninsured and that a profit maximizing menu cannot pool all types we show that insurance provision costs can explain both coverage denials only to those likely to be the worst risks and complete pooling specifically we prove a general comparative statics theorem formalizing coverage denials only to those deemed to be the worst risks and two theorems showing that the insurer offers a single contract complete pooling with either zero or positive coverage we point out some implications of these results for empirical work on insurance our results expand upon a point made by hendren 2013 that the main effect of adverse selection on insurance might not be misallocation in active markets the traditional emphasis after rothschild and stiglitz 1976 but simply in shutting down markets as in akerlof 1970 classic lemons model

a comparison of the effects of exogenous oil supply shocks on output and inflation in the g7 countries a comparison of the effects of exogenous shocks to global crude oil production on seven major industrialized economies suggests a fair degree of similarity in the real growth responses an exogenous oil supply disruption typically causes a temporary reduction in real gdp growth that is concentrated in the second year after the shock inflation responses are more varied the median cpi inflation response peaks after three to four quarters exogenous oil supply disruptions need not generate sustained inflation or stagflation typical responses include a fall in the real wage higher short term interest rates and a depreciating currency with respect to the dollar despite many qualitative similarities there is strong statistical evidence that the responses to exogenous oil supply disruptions differ across g7 countries for suitable subsets of countries homogeneity cannot be ruled out a counterfactual historical exercise suggests that the evolution of cpi inflation in the g7 countries would have been similar overall to the actual path even in the absence of exogenous shocks to oil production consistent with a monetary explanation of the inflation of the 1970s there is no evidence that the 1973 1974 and 2002 2003 oil supply shocks had a substantial impact on real growth in any g7 country whereas the 1978 1979 1980 and 1990 1991 shocks contributed to lower growth in at least some g7 countries jel e31 e32 q43

gender implications of biofuels expansion in africa the case of mozambique summary we use a gendered dynamic cge model to assess the implications of biofuels expansion in a low income land abundant setting mozambique is chosen as a representative case we compare scenarios with different gender employment intensities in producing jatropha feedstock for biodiesel under all scenarios biofuels investments accelerate gdp growth and reduce poverty however a stronger trade off between biofuels and food availability emerges when female labor is used intensively as women are drawn away from food production a skills shortage among female workers also limits poverty reduction policy simulations indicate that only modest improvements in women s education and food crop yields are needed to address food security concerns and ensure broader based benefits from biofuels investments

a nonparametric garch model of crude oil price return volatility the use of parametric garch models to characterise crude oil price volatility is widely observed in the empirical literature in this paper we consider an alternative approach involving nonparametric method to model and forecast oil price return volatility focusing on two crude oil markets brent and west texas intermediate wti we show that the out of sample volatility forecast of the nonparametric garch model yields superior performance relative to an extensive class of parametric garch models these results are supported by the use of robust loss functions and the hansen s 2005 superior predictive ability test the improvement in forecasting accuracy of oil price return volatility based on the nonparametric garch model suggests that this method offers an attractive and viable alternative to the commonly used parametric garch models

modeling oil price us stock nexus a varma bekk agarch approach abstract this study adds to the existing literature on oil price us stock nexus in three ways first it employs the varma agarch model developed by mcaleer et al 2009 within the context of bekk framework using west texas intermediate wti and brent as proxies for oil market and s p stocks as a proxy for us stock market secondly it modifies the model to include endogenously determined structural break using the general structure for analyzing breaks with unit roots in perron 2006 third it uses the adopted model to compute optimal portfolio weight and hedge ratios between oil price and us stocks using different sample data based on the break date on average our empirical evidence suggests a significant positive return spillover from us stock market to oil market and bi directional shock spillovers between the two markets in addition there is significant own asymmetric shock effect in both markets while volatility spillover from oil market to stock market became pronounced after the break which coincides with the period of global economic slowdown similarly the results of portfolio management differ across the sample data more importantly we find that ignoring structural break when it exists may exaggerate hedging effectiveness

deutsche mark dollar volatility intraday activity patterns macroeconomic announcements and longer run dependencies this paper provides a detailed characterization of the volatility in the deutsche mark dollar foreign exchange market using an annual sample of five minute returns the approach captures the intraday activity patterns the macroeconomic announcements and the volatility persistence arch known from daily returns the different features are separately quantified and shown to account for a substantial fraction of return variability both at the intraday and daily level the implications of the results for the interpretation of the fundamental driving forces behind the volatility process is also discussed the efficient market hypothesis contends that financial asset prices provide rational assessments of fundamental values and future payoffs by implication price changes should reflect the arrival and processing of all relevant new information however the proportion of return variability that can be ascribed to public news announcements is low for example cutler poterba and summers 1989 find that even the largest daily price changes in the stock market generally cannot be associated with any significant economic news 1 moreover proxies for the flow of public information e g the number of news items released by reuter s news service berry and hiowe 1994 or dow jones company mitchell and mulherin 1994 explain little of the overall variation thus if private information is ruled out proponents of rational price formation have to assert the existence of important news items

quantifying the speculative component in the real price of oil the role of global oil inventories abstract one of the central questions of policy interest in recent years has been how many dollars of the inflation adjusted price of oil must be attributed to speculative demand for oil stocks at each point in time we develop statistical tools that allow us to address this question and we use these tools to explore how the use of two alternative proxies for global crude oil inventories affects the empirical evidence for speculation notwithstanding some differences overall these inventory proxies yield similar results while there is evidence of speculative demand raising the price in mid 2008 by between 5 and 14 dollars depending on the inventory specification there is no evidence of speculative demand pressures between early 2003 and early 2008 as a result current policy efforts aimed at tightening the regulation of oil derivatives markets cannot be expected to lower the real price of oil in the physical market we also provide evidence that the libyan crisis in 2011 shifted expectations in oil markets resulting in a price increase of between 3 and 13 dollars depending on the inventory specification with regard to tensions with iran in 2012 the implied price premium ranges from 0 to 9 dollars

oil prices and the impact of the financial crisis of 2007 2009 abstract oil prices increased dramatically during 2004 2006 industry experts initially attributed these price increases to fundamental factors such as the rise in global demand but also because of disruptions in the supply of oil the price increases however were so substantial that additional factors are needed to explain such dramatic changes we propose that the decline in the value of the u s dollar measured both by the appreciation of the euro and of gold prices played an important role as oil suppliers demanded compensation for the declining value of the dollar using a markov switching regime methodology we find evidence that this hypothesis is true prior to the financial crisis but its validity does not hold after the crisis when oil prices crashed and the dollar rallied

oil prices exchange rates and emerging stock markets abstract while two different streams of literature exist investigating 1 the relationship between oil prices and emerging market stock prices and 2 the relationship between oil prices and exchange rates relatively little is known about the dynamic relationship between oil prices exchange rates and emerging market stock prices this paper proposes and estimates a structural vector autoregression model to investigate the dynamic relationship between these variables impulse responses are calculated in two ways standard and the recently developed projection based methods the model supports stylized facts in particular positive shocks to oil prices tend to depress emerging market stock prices and us dollar exchange rates in the short run the model also captures stylized facts regarding movements in oil prices a positive oil production shock lowers oil prices while a positive shock to real economic activity increases oil prices there is also evidence that increases in emerging market stock prices increase oil prices

the economic value of co movement between oil price and exchange rate using copula based garch models article i nfo the us dollar is used as the primary currency of international crude oil trading as such the recent substantial depreciation in the us dollar has resulted in a corresponding increase in crude oil prices in addition oil price and exchange rate returns have been shown to be skewed and leptokurtic and to exhibit an asymmetric or tail dependence structure therefore this study proposes dynamic copula based garch models to explore the dependence structure between the oil price and the us dollar exchange rate more importantly an asset allocation strategy is implemented to evaluate economic value and confirm the efficiency of the copula based garch models in terms of out of sample forecasting performance a dynamic strategy based on the cgarch model with the student t copula exhibits greater economic benefits than static and other dynamic strategies in addition the positive feedback trading activities are statistically significant within the oil market but this information does not enhance the economic benefits from the perspective of an asset allocation decision finally a more risk averse investor generates a higher fee for switching from a static strategy to a dynamic strategy based on copula based garch models

oil price shocks and stock markets in the u s and 13 european countries abstract oil price shocks have a statistically significant impact on real stock returns contemporaneously and or within the following month in the u s and 13 european countries over 1986 1 2005 12 norway as an oil exporter shows a statistically significantly positive response of real stock returns to an oil price increase the median result from variance decomposition analysis is that oil price shocks account for a statistically significant 6 of the volatility in real stock returns for many european countries but not for the u s increased volatility of oil prices significantly depresses real stock returns the contribution of oil price shocks to variability in real stock returns in the u s and most other countries is greater than that of interest rate an increase in real oil price is associated with a significant increase in the short term interest rate in the u s and eight out of 13 european countries within one or two months counter to findings for the u s and for norway there is little evidence of asymmetric effects on real stock returns of positive and negative oil price shocks for oil importing european countries

oil and the macroeconomy since the 1970s economists have long been intrigued by empirical evidence that suggests that oil price shocks may be closely related to macroeconomic performance this interest dates back to the 1970s the 1970s were a period of growing dependence on imported oil unprecedented disruptions in the global oil market and poor macroeconomic performance in the united states thus it was natural to suspect a causal relationship from oil prices to u s macroeconomic aggregates since then a large body of work has accumulated that purports to establish this link on theoretical grounds and to provide empirical evidence in its support we do not attempt a comprehensive survey of this literature but rather provide an idiosyncratic synthesis of what we view as the key issues in this debate and the insights gained over the last 30 years the timing seems right for such an account although the experience of the 1970s continues to play an important role in discussions of the link between oil and the macroeconomy there have been a number of new oil price shocks since the 1970s notably the 1986 collapse of oil prices and the 2000 boom in oil prices as well as the oil price increases associated with the 1990 1991 gulf war and the 2003 iraq war given this richer case history we are arguably in a better position than two decades ago to distinguish the idiosyncratic features of each oil crisis from the systematic effects increases in oil prices have been held responsible for recessions periods of excessive inflation reduced productivity and lower economic growth in this paper we review the arguments supporting such views first we highlight some of the conceptual difficulties in assigning a central role to oil price shocks in explaining

interaction between oil and us dollar exchange rate nonlinear causality time varying influence and structural breaks in volatility abstractthis article examines the nonlinear granger causality and time varying influence between crude oil prices and the us dollar usd exchange rate using the hiemstra and jones hp test the diks and panchenko dp test and the time varying parameter structural vector autoregression model by applying the iterated cumulative sums of squares icss algorithm and the dcc garch model the effects of structural breaks in volatility of the two markets are also investigated the empirical analysis indicates that first crude oil prices are the nonlinear granger cause of the usd exchange rate but not vice versa second the usd exchange rate exerts a stronger and more stable negative influence on crude oil prices in the short term and the influence gradually weakens after 2012 finally ignoring structural breaks can increase the negative volatility correlation between the oil and usd exchange rate markets which is particularly remarkable during the financial crisis

forecasting crude oil market volatility further evidence using garch class models abstract this paper extends the work of kang et al 2009 we use a greater number of linear and nonlinear generalized autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity garch class models to capture the volatility features of two crude oil markets brent and west texas intermediate wti the one five and twenty day out of sample volatility forecasts of the garch class models are evaluated using the superior predictive ability test and with more loss functions unlike kang et al 2009 we find that no model can outperform all of the other models for either the brent or the wti market across different loss functions however in general the nonlinear garch class models which are capable of capturing long memory and or asymmetric volatility exhibit greater forecasting accuracy than the linear ones especially in volatility forecasting over longer time horizons such as five or twenty days

oil price forecastability and economic uncertainty information on economic policy uncertainty does matter in predicting the change in oil prices we compare the forecastability of standard bayesian and time varying var against univariate models the time varying var model outranks all alternative models over the period 2007 1 2014 2

oil prices speculation and fundamentals interpreting causal relations among spot and futures prices abstract a consensus that the world oil market is unified begs the question where do innovations in oil prices enter the market here we investigate where changes in the price of crude oil originate and how they spread by examining causal relationships among prices for crude oils from north america europe africa and the middle east on both spot and futures markets results indicate that innovations first appear in spot prices for dubai fateh and spread to other spot and futures prices while other innovations first appear in the far month contract for west texas intermediate and spread to other exchanges and contracts links between spot and futures markets are relatively weak and this may have allowed the long run relationship between spot and future prices to change after september 2004 together these results suggest that market fundamentals initiated a long term increase in oil prices that was exacerbated by speculators who recognized an increase in the probability that oil prices would rise over time

risk appetite and oil prices abstract we demonstrate that oil prices and their volatility are no longer determined solely by real economic shocks to supply of and demand for oil but are also driven by shocks originating in the economic uncertainty and risk appetite of investors that prevail in the equity market the contribution of the latter factor has become particularly remarkable since the mid 2000s to establish these results we dismantle the squared vix index determined in the s p 500 options market into the conditional variance in stock returns to proxy for economic uncertainty and the equity variance risk premium to proxy for risk appetite using threshold garch structural vector auto regression and causality models we provide evidence about the link between risk appetite oil price returns and volatility furthermore investors appetite for risk drives changes in the ovx which measures perceptions about future oil volatility but not vice versa our results provide a better understanding of the relationship between oil the vix and its two proposed components in particular we show that changes in the risk appetite of investors are an important determinant not only for the price of equities but also for that of the most important energy resource oil

speculation and volatility spillover in the crude oil and agricultural commodity markets a bayesian analysis this paper assesses factors that potentially influence the volatility of crude oil prices and the possible linkage between this volatility and agricultural commodity markets stochastic volatility models are applied to weekly crude oil corn and wheat futures prices from november 1998 to january 2009 model parameters are estimated using bayesian markov chain monte carlo methods speculation scalping and petroleum inventories are found to be important in explaining the volatility of crude oil prices several properties of crude oil price dynamics are established including mean reversion an asymmetry between returns and volatility volatility clustering and infrequent compound jumps we find evidence of volatility spillover among crude oil corn and wheat markets after the fall of 2006 this can be largely explained by tightened interdependence between crude oil and these commodity markets induced by ethanol production

oil price dynamics and speculation a multivariate financial approach abstract this paper assesses empirically whether speculation affects oil price dynamics the growing presence of financial operators in the oil markets has led to the diffusion of trading techniques based on extrapolative expectations strategies of this kind foster feedback trading that may cause considerable departures of prices from their fundamental values we investigate this hypothesis using a modified capm following shiller 1984 and sentana and wadhwani 1992 first a univariate garch 1 1 m is estimated assuming the risk premium to be a function of the conditional oil price volatility the single factor model however is outperformed by the multifactor icapm merton 1973 which takes into account a larger investment opportunity set analysis is then carried out using a trivariate ccc garch m model with complex nonlinear conditional mean equations where oil price dynamics are associated with both stock market and exchange rate behavior we find strong evidence that oil price shifts are negatively related to stock price and exchange rate changes and that a complex web of time varying first and second order conditional moment interactions affects both the capm and feedback trading components of the model despite the difficulties we identify a significant role played by speculation in the oil market which is consistent with the observed large daily upward and downward shifts in prices a clear evidence that it is not a fundamental driven market thus from a policy point of view given the impact of volatile oil prices on global inflation and growth actions that monitor speculative activities on commodity markets more effectively are to be welcomed

hedgers funds and small speculators in the energy futures markets an analysis of the cftc s commitments of traders reports the commodity futures trading commission cftc s commitments of traders cot data are examined for crude oil unleaded gasoline heating oil and natural gas futures contracts the collection procedures for the cot data are first examined followed by granger causality tests to determine if relationships between trader positions and market prices exist a positive correlation between returns and positions held by noncommercial traders and a negative correlation between commercial positions and market returns are found furthermore positive returns result in an increase in noncommercial net positions in the following week whereas the net long positions held by commercial hedgers decline following price increases however traders net positions do not lead market returns in general

organizing the health insurance market this paper presents a new approach to organizing universal health insurance first the government divides the entire population into many large groups then the government creates a federal health insurance system healthfed modeled on the federal reserve system to fill the role now played by the benefits office of a large firm the healthfed would create a short menu of alternatives solicit bids for insuring the entire group and price alternatives there would be redistribution between groups and pricing of alterna tives to reflect optimal social insurance principles there would be no connection between health insurance and employment it may seem odd that this presidential address is my first publication in health economics at the time when i might have been working on an alternative address i was chair of an expert panel for the advisory council on social security looking at issues in both retirement income and medical care 2 in the process of this work i have come up with a new approach to organizing universal health insurance that is the subject of this paper before starting on health insurance i will say a few words about a wider context offering what i will say as an example in that setting 3 a great deal of attention has been focused on the exciting issue of reorganizing economies dropping central planning commonly economists from those countries em brace capitalism or more specifically laissez faire competition with an enthusi asm which exceeds that ofwestern economists although not necessarily western businessmen yet laissez faire capitalism has received little serious support in the west for a very long time we all know the fundamental welfare theorem which shows many ways that capitalism can be imperfect we have also seen a growth in discussion and analysis of the many ways governments can mess up resource allocation the real question is the design of arrangements that try to integrate the things that each type of institution does better this is hard for two reasons one is that it is in the realm of second best with many constraints the more the constraints the harder the analysis the second is that we do not have good positive theories of government behavior good examples yes good theories no thus the analysis is more intuitive less theory driven than in our picture of private markets but also in our private market analyses we have been greatly complicating our picture recognizing all sorts of information imperfec tions that affect the way that private markets work so i will present to you a proposal for universal health insurance meant to combine something that

oil shocks and aggregate macroeconomic behavior the role of monetary policy a recent paper by bernanke gertler and watson 1997 suggests that monetary policy could be used to eliminate any recessionary consequences of an oil price shock this paper challenges this conclusion on two grounds first we question whether the federal reserve actually has the power to implement such a policy for example we consider it unlikely that additional money creation would have succeeded in reducing the fed funds rate by 900 basis points relative to the values seen in 1974 second we point out that the size of the effect that bernanke gertler and watson attribute to oil shocks is substantially smaller than that reported by other researchers primarily due to their choice of a shorter lag length than that used by other researchers we offer evidence in favor of the longer lag length employed by previous research and show that under this specification even the aggressive federal reserve policies proposed would not have succeeded in averting a downturn