choice modeling at the market stall individual versus collective interest in environmental valuation the market stall or valuation workshop has recently been proposed as a way of addressing some of the limitations of conventional stated preference analysis in this paper we attempt to combine a participatory technique similar to the citizens jury with choice modelling a stated preference technique increasingly being applied in environmental economics our focus is on how changes in the context of decision making between choices made in isolation and those made in a group setting and between choices made on individual well being versus collective criteria produce differences in estimated welfare measures the empirical context used is that of water quality improvements under the water framework directive the most significant reform in water legislation in the european union for many years we find that the choice experiment format can be successfully implemented in a valuation workshop and that moving from individual to collective choice produces in this instance a rather interesting change in both values and preferences which depends on the respondent s interests

what to preserve an application of diversity theory to crane conservation this paper attempts to demonstrate how diversity theory can be applied to the analysis of real world conservation policies the specific example chosen to serve as a paradigm concerns preservation priorities among the fifteen species of cranes living wild throughout the world the example is sufficiently actual to show how diversity theory can be used operationally to frame certain critical conservation questions and to guide us toward answers by providing informative quantitative indicators of what to protect at the same time the cranes example is rich enough that it illustrates nicely some broad general principles about the economics of diversity preservation

the concept of natural capital the natural environment is now commonly viewed as a form of capital asset or natural capital also included are ecosystems that provide important goods and services to the economy managing natural capital has consequences for sustainable development however there are contrasting weak versus strong sustainability views which in turn have implications for green accounting natural resource based sovereign wealth funds have emerged as key financial instruments for compensating resource depreciation with greater economy wide investments recent scientific evidence recommends demarcating safe operating spaces to limit exploitation of critical global biophysical subsystems or processes these challenges suggest that the concept of natural capital is pivotal to sound policy

recent advances in the valuation of ecosystem services and biodiversity recent interest in the economics of biodiversity and wider ecosystem services has been given empirical expression through a focus upon economic valuation this emphasis has been prompted by a growing recognition that the benefits and opportunity costs associated with such services are frequently given cursory consideration in policy analyses or even completely ignored the valuation of biodiversity and ecosystem services is therefore increasingly seen as a crucial element of robust decision making and this has been reflected in a growing body of related research we provide a critical review of some of this research considering the valuation methods applied to date and focussing upon their limitations in respect to certain categories of ecosystem services particularly cultural services and the applicability of the extant literature to new settings substantial questions also remain at the interface of natural science and economics and we consider the potential contribution of the conceptualization of ecosystems as assets as a response to this challenge as part of this review we also highlight the role which large scale ecosystem assessments have played as an impetus to extending the valuation evidence base and the way in which frameworks and assessments of how ecosystems contribute to human wellbeing might be translated into policy thinking and decision analyses

willingness to pay for land preservation across states and jurisdictional scale implications for benefit transfer in stated preference valuation of farmland preservation respondents are often told that preservation will occur within various jurisdictional scales that is community or state but are not told the specific location of parcels the resultant availability of welfare estimates for different scales and regions provides numerous avenues for benefit transfer this paper provides a systematic assessment of transfer error contrasting different methods for the transfer of farmland preservation values across states and jurisdictional scales results drawn from multistate choice experiments suggest that the choice of across scale versus across state transfer method can have significant implications for transfer validity

the effect of ethics on labor market success evidence from mbas abstract this paper empirically investigates the link between ethics earnings and gender using a self reported measure from a longitudinal survey of registrants for the graduate management admission test we find that ethical character is negatively associated with males wages for females however this relationship does not hold in addition using measures of the degree to which ethics is emphasized in business school curricula as an indicator for enhancement of individual ethical standards of graduates we investigate variation in the returns to an mba degree we find that the larger the degree to which males report that business education enhanced their ethical character the lower their wages holding other aspects of their education constant for females however enhanced ethics through business school is positively and significantly associated with returns to the mba degree more objective measures of ethics emphasis in business school curricula provide further support of these findings

testing benefits transfer of forest recreation values over a twenty year time horizon we conduct a functional benefit transfer over 20 years of total willingness to pay based on carborne forest recreation in 52 forests using a mixed logit specification of a random utility model and geographic information systems to allow heterogeneous preferences across the population and for heterogeneity over space results show that preferences for some forest attributes such as species diversity and age as well as transport mode have changed significantly over the period updating the transfer model with present total demand for recreation improves the error margins by an average of 282 average errors of the best transfer model remain 25

the rationality of a safe minimum standard the safe minimum standard sms is a policy shift to safety defaults to forestall irreversible outcomes critics charge an inconsistency what justifies business as usual cannot also justify switching to the sms currently the sms is only a procedural shift where economic optimality procedures are buttressed by extra special focus on uncertainty yet social welfare function may not be complete enough warranting a more fundamental sms shift numerous moral positions support this sms approach this sms also operationalizes the intolerable cost as a trigger point noting societies with lower tolerance for sacrifice must trigger the sms earlier

forest conservation in costa rica when nonuse benefits are uncertain but rising stochastic dynamic programming is used to investigate optimal holding of primary tropical forest in humid costa rica when future nonuse benefits of forest conservation are uncertain and increasing the quasi option value of maintaining primary forests is included as a component of investment in natural capital although the impact of uncertainty on conservation incentives is substantial our results indicate that a rising trend in future benefits and compensation by the international community for beneficial spillovers are more important factors in determining optimal holdings of forest stocks without compensatory payments however further deforestation may be warranted

how reliable are meta analyses for international benefit transfers meta analysis has increasingly been used to synthesise the environmental valuation literature but only a few test the use of these analyses for benefit transfer these are typically based on national studies only however meta analyses of valuation studies across countries are a potentially powerful tool for benefit transfer especially for environmental goods where the domestic literature is scarce we test the reliability of such international meta analytic transfers and find that even under conditions of homogeneity in valuation methods cultural and institutional conditions across countries and a meta analysis with large explanatory power the transfer errors could still be large further international meta analytic transfers do not on average perform better than simple value transfers averaging over domestic studies thus we question whether the use of meta analysis for practical benefit transfer achieves reliability gains justifying the increased effort however more meta analytic benefit transfer tests should be performed for other environmental goods and other countries before discarding international meta analysis as a tool for benefit transfer

incorporating resilience in the assessment of inclusive wealth an example from south east australia this paper explores the consequences of changes in a system s resilience on the sustainability of resource allocation decisions as measured by inclusive wealth iw arrow et al in environ resour econ 26 647 685 2003 we incorporate an estimate of resilience in iw by taking account of known or suspected thresholds that can lead to irreversible or practically irreversible changes in the productivity and value of assets and hence social welfare these thresholds allow us to identify policies or projects that may be leading to an increased risk of decline in capital stocks the wealth of the region such risks are not reflected through usual measures of current system performance e g agricultural production we use the goulburn broken catchment in south eastern australia as a case study to explore the significance and practicality of including resilience in inclusive wealth estimates

credit based payments for ecosystem services evidence from a choice experiment in ecuador the original conceptualization of payments for ecosystem services pes promoted direct payments to motivate the provision of environmental public goods but market imperfections and behavioral considerations can mean that pes that reduce market constraints are preferred the main issue with the latter is how to include conditionality we propose credit based pes cb pes as an incentive that links an environmental condition with the reduction of a key market constraint through a choice experiment in ecuador cb pes was found to be a promising form of pes with multiple desirable qualities of an incentive as cited in the behavioral economics and pes literatures

trade tropical deforestation and policy interventions trade interventions are increasingly advocated as a means for controlling timber related tropical deforestation this paper analyzes the impact on deforestation of such policy instruments in a dynamic framework the forest is modelled as a potentially renewable resource and timber is extracted for purposes of export and domestic consumption optimality conditions for a variety of model specifications are derived and the impacts of changes in the terms of trade and market structure on long run deforestation are analyzed the results of this analysis suggest that trade interventions that seek to affect the terms of trade against the export of tropical timber products are in the long run a second best policy option for influencing the deforestation process

meta analysis and benefit transfer for resource valuation addressing classical challenges with bayesian modeling abstract the use of meta regression models based on existing studies to estimate the value of resources at a new policy site has become a popular alternative to collecting original data in recent years there are two prevalent dilemmas associated with classical meta regression models the difference in the available set of regressors across source studies and the treatment of methodological explanatory variables in the construction of benefit transfer functions in this study we illustrate how these issues can be addressed efficiently within a bayesian meta regression framework we find that the bayesian model in contrast to its classical counterpart can estimate a relatively large set of parameters including indicators of unobserved study heterogeneity with reasonable accuracy even when the underlying meta sample is small the incorporation of information from regressor deficient source data in the specification of bayesian priors leads to a better model fit and tighter welfare estimates for benefit transfer in our application of freshwater angling

economic valuation of the vulnerability of world agriculture confronted with pollinator decline there is mounting evidence of pollinator decline all over the world and consequences in many agricultural areas could be significant we assessed these consequences by measuring 1 the contribution of insect pollination to the world agricultural output economic value and 2 the vulnerability of world agriculture in the face of pollinator decline we used a bioeconomic approach which integrated the production dependence ratio on pollinators for the 100 crops used directly for human food worldwide as listed by fao the total economic value of pollination worldwide amounted to 153 billion which represented 9 5 of the value of the world agricultural production used for human food in 2005 in terms of welfare the consumer surplus loss was estimated between 190 and 310 billion based upon average price elasticities of 1 5 to 0 8 respectively vegetables and fruits were the leading crop categories in value of insect pollination with about 50 billion each followed by edible oil crops stimulants nuts and spices the production value of a ton of the crop categories that do not depend on insect pollination averaged 151 while that of those that are pollinator dependent averaged 761 the vulnerability ratio was calculated for each crop category at the regional and world scales as the ratio between the economic value of pollination and the current total crop value this ratio varied considerably among crop categories and there was a positive correlation between the rate of vulnerability to pollinators decline of a crop category and its value per production unit looking at the capacity to nourish the world population after pollinator loss the production of 3 crop categories namely fruits vegetables and stimulants will clearly be below the current consumption level at the world scale and even more so for certain regions like europe yet although our valuation clearly demonstrates the economic importance of insect pollinators it cannot be considered as a scenario since it does not take into account the strategic responses of the markets

valuing the non market benefits of wild goose conservation a comparison of interview and group based approaches wild geese graze on improved pastures and young cereal crops and hence can cause considerable damage to agriculture particularly in areas close to roosting sites this study uses contingent valuation cv to establish whether government compensation payments currently made to farmers represent value for money by estimating the value placed on goose conservation by the general public benefit estimates from a conventional interview approach are compared with a group based approach called the market stall ms this involves two 1 h meetings held 1 week apart and differs from conventional interviews in that participants are given more time to consider their preferences and to discuss their wtp question with other household members we argue that this type of group based approach to environmental valuation offers important advantages over individual interview approaches especially for unfamiliar and or complex environmental goods

national and international benefit transfer testing with a rigorous test procedure benefit transfer as a mean to transfer values from existing monetary valuation studies to new policy sites has been in use for many years this paper aims to analyze the forecasting quality of benefit transfer by applying a rigoroust test also referred to as accuracy t test that takes into account testing errors which were made in previous surveys beside the analysis of national benefit transfers based on two german contingent valuation studies additional efforts were made to investigate into the validity and accuracy of international benefit transfer by considering two norwegian studies that employed a similar survey design

capturing the complexity of biodiversity a critical review of economic valuation studies of biological diversity biodiversity is a highly complex and abstract ecological concept even though it is not one physical entity it influences human well being in multiple ways mostly indirectly while considerable research effort has been spent on the economic valuation of biodiversity it remains to be a particularly challenging valuation object valuation practitioners therefore have to use proxies for biodiversity many of which are very simple single species habitats this paper presents a comprehensive and critical review of biodiversity valuation studies with special emphasis on biodiversity valuation in order to depict the state of the art in this research field it develops evaluation criteria so as to identify best practice applications and shows that the field of biodiversity valuation studies is rather heterogeneous regarding both valuation objects and valuation methods on the basis of our evaluation criteria and best practice studies we suggest that to account for the complexity and abstractness of biodiversity multi attribute approaches with encompassing information provision should be used that emphasise the roles biodiversity plays for human well being

the welfare economic theory of green national accounts this paper takes a critical look at the literature on green national accounts the problem studied is to find a linear index of economic variables that responds to perturbations in the same direction as social well being the thesis of a large literature that net national product which is a flow is that index in closed economies is shown in some interpretations to be simply false and in others to suffer from deep estimation problems it is argued that capital depreciation using shadow prices should certainly be included in national accounts but that the right welfare index is a comprehensive measure of wealth defined as the shadow value of an economy s stock of all capital assets it is shown that comprehensive wealth is usable as a criterion for policy evaluation as well as for determining sustainable economic development

a review of the stern review on the economics of climate change the stern review calls for immediate decisive action to stabilize greenhouse gases because the benefits of strong early action on climate change outweighs the costs the economic analysis supporting this conclusion consists mostly of two basic strands the first strand is a formal aggregative model that relies for its conclusions primari ly upon imposing a very low discount rate concerning this discount rate aspect i am skeptical of the review s formal analysis but this essay points out that we are actual ly a lot less sure about what interest rate should be used for discounting climate change than is commonly acknowledged the review s second basic strand is a more intuitive argument that it might be very important to avoid possibly large uncertain ties that are difficult to quantify concerning this uncertainty aspect i argue that it might be recast into sound analytical reasoning that might justify some of the review s conclusions the basic issue here is that spending money to slow global warming should perhaps not be conceptualized primarily as being about consump tion smoothing as much as being about how much insurance to buy to offset the small change of a ruinous catastrophe that is difficult to compensate by ordinary savings

choice modelling approaches a superior alternative for environmental valuation in this paper we examine some popular choice modelling approaches to environmental valuation which can be considered as alternatives to more familiar valuation techniques based on stated preferences such as the contingent valuation method a number of choice modelling methods are consistent with consumer theory and its focus on an attribute based theory of value permits a superior representation of many environmental management contexts however choice modelling surveys can place a severe cognitive burden upon respondents and induce satisficing rather than maximising behavioural patterns in this framework we seek to identify the best available choice modelling alternative and investigate its potential to solve some of the major biases associated with standard contingent valuation we then discuss its use in the light of policy appraisal needs within the eu an application to the demand for rock climbing in scotland is provided as an illustration

environmental value transfer state of the art and future prospects abstract the main objectives of the paper are to 1 give an overview of the state of the art of environmental value transfer 2 discuss its prospects and potential role in cba as a decision support tool and 3 provide further guidelines for proper use and application environmental value or benefit transfer is a technique in which the results of studies on monetary environmental valuation are applied to new policy contexts the technique is controversial not least because of academic and political reservations over the usefulness and technical feasibility of economic valuation tools to demonstrate the importance of environmental values in project or programme appraisals testing of environmental value transfer so far has been unable to validate the practice taking into account the conditions set out in the literature for valid and reliable value transfer most transfers appear to result in substantial transfer errors this paper discusses why and addresses the question of which factors may have been overlooked it is argued that the problem is much more fundamental than previously acknowledged strict guidelines in terms of quantitative adjustment mechanisms to valid value transfer are meaningless if the more fundamental issue of differences in the very nature of the values elicited is not addressed at the same time

the economic analysis of biodiversity an assessment biodiversity is complex difficult to define difficult to measure and often involves international and intergenerational considerations biodiversity loss presents significant economic challenges a great deal of economics is required to understand the issues but a simple and important observation is that most species and ecosystems are not traded in markets so prices are often absent and biodiversity is under provided despite the formidable obstacles to high quality economic analysis economics has plenty to offer to biodiversity policy first economic valuation techniques can be employed to roughly estimate the value of the benefits provided by biodiversity and ecosystems second assessing the optimum amount of biodiversity involves recognizing that the conversion of natural capital into manufactured and human capital has so far generated vast amounts of wealth while there may have been too much biodiversity in the past economic analysis suggests that this is a difficult position to hold now third econometric techniques and carefully designed policy studies can assist in determining what policies are most suited to different contexts to cost effectively reduce biodiversity loss fourth political economy is helpful because international coordination is often required ecosystems do not respect national borders and many biodiverse ecosystems are in poorer countries this paper synthesizes the issues and proposes a research agenda which includes improving the measurement and accounting of natural capital improving valuation techniques and theory to provide greater guidance as to the optimum biodiversity and developing our understanding of the merits of different alternatives for government intervention to reduce biodiversity loss

the validity of environmental benefits transfer further empirical testing this paper provides further empirical evidence of the validity of environmental benefits transfer based on cv studies by expanding the analysis to include control factors which have not been accounted for in previous studies these factors refer to differences in respondent attitudes traditional population characteristics were taken into account but these variables do not explain why respondents from the same socio economic group may still hold different beliefs norms or values and hence have different attitudes and consequently state different wtp amounts the test results are mixed the function transfer approach is valid in one case but is rejected in the 3 other cases investigated in this paper we provide further evidence that in the case of statistically valid benefits transfer the function approach results in a more robust benefits transfer than the unit value approach we also show that the equality of coefficient estimates is a necessary but insufficient condition for valid benefit function transfer and discuss the implications for previous and future validity testing

environmental ethics and information asymmetry among organizational stakeholders this paper addresses the conflicting environmental interests of a firm and the community an important stakeholder the short term profit maximization objective of a firm may stand in contrast with what the community wants a safe and clean environment this paper argues that the information regarding the environmental impact of a firm s products processes and waste may be asymmetrically distributed between the firm and the community the resultant information asymmetry may influence the probability of a firm acting opportunistically and ultimately a firm s ethical behavior the paper identifies information asymmetry between a firm and community as well as that within the community the perceived information asymmetry across various community segments may perhaps be a determinant of environmental discrimination the paper further contends that information asymmetry may diminish in the long run finally it examines the implications of information asymmetry for firms and government policy

decoy effects in choice experiments and contingent valuation asymmetric dominance while a dominated choice involves a situation in which one option clearly dominates another on all relevant dimensions an asymmetrically dominated choice typically arises where at least two options do not dominate each other and one but not both of those options does dominate a third option we demonstrate that the introduction of such an asymmetrically dominated option can have a significant impact upon choices between non dominated options within the same choice set for non market goods furthermore we show that this effect can then translate into significant impacts upon subsequent valuations for those non dominated options

learning design contingent valuation ldcv noaa guidelines preference learning and coherent arbitrariness we extend the contingent valuation cv method to test three differing conceptions of individuals preferences as either i a priori well formed or readily divined and revealed through a single dichotomous choice question as per the noaa cv guidelines k arrow r solow p r portney e e leamer r radner h schuman report of the noaa panel on contingent valuation fed reg 58 1993 4601 4614 ii learned or discovered through a process of repetition and experience j a list does market experience eliminate market anomalies q j econ 2003 41 72 c r plott rational individual behaviour in markets and social choice processes the discovered preference hypothesis in k arrow e colombatto m perleman c schmidt eds rational foundations of economic behaviour macmillan london st martin s new york 1996 pp 225 250 iii internally coherent but strongly influenced by some initial arbitrary anchor d ariely g loewenstein d prelec coherent arbitrariness stable demand curves without stable preferences q j econ 118 1 2003 73 105 findings reject both the first and last of these conceptions in favour of a model in which preferences converge towards standard expectations through a process of repetition and learning in doing so we show that such a learning design cv method overturns the stylised facts of bias and anchoring within the double bound dichotomous choice elicitation format

reducing gain loss asymmetry a virtual reality choice experiment valuing land use change abstract in the majority of choice experiments ces the attributes of non market goods are conveyed to respondents as a table of numeric and or categorical data recent research suggests that respondents may have difficulties evaluating data in this format in the context of a ce eliciting preferences for changes in coastal land use this study uses a split sample experiment to compare standard presentations with virtual reality vr visualisations conveying objectively identical information we find that compared to the standard presentation preferences elicited in vr treatments are less variable and exhibit a significant reduction in asymmetry between willingness to pay wtp for gains and willingness to accept wta for corresponding losses we conjecture that the greater evaluability of the vr presentation reduces respondent judgement error and moderates reliance on the loss aversion heuristic

long term substitutability between environmental and man made goods abstract substitutability between environmental and man made goods plays a major role in the sustainability debate the notion of substitutability covers a continuous spectrum with perfect substitutability at one end and poor substitutability at the other in this paper it is shown that if economic growth sustains a sharp distinction emerges between perfect and poor substitutability without any intermediate interpretation of substitutability if poor substitutability prevails environmental resources will eventually constitute the major part of total consumption value we relate our results to baumol s disease and assess the implications of this phenomenon for the compensation of environmental losses

sustainable development and resilience in ecosystems two new important developments in environmental and resource economics is presented non convex dynamics of ecosystems and wealth as an indicator of sustainable development non convex dynamics imply existence of resilience that is the robustness of systems to withstand exogenous perturbations resilience can be regarded as an insurance against flips of the system into different basins of stability sustainable development according to the bruntland report is the provision of productive resources to future generations to make it possible for them to live as well as the present generation thus the value of changes in productive assets is therefore an index of whether an economy is on a sustainable path or not resilience can be regarded as one such productive asset and the paper discusses how one can define the value of this asset