on the robustness of robustness checks of the environmental kuznets curve hypothesis since its first inception in the debate on the relationship between environment and growth in 1992 the environmental kuznets curve hypothesis ekc hereafter has been subject of continuous and intense scrutiny the most recent line of investigation criticizes the ekc hypothesis on more fundamental grounds in that it stresses the lack of sufficient statistical testing of the empirical relationship and questions the very existence of the notion of ekc attention is in particular drawn on the stationarity properties of the series involved per capita emissions or concentrations and per capita gdp and in case of presence of unit roots on the cointegration property that must be present for the ekc to be a well defined concept only at that point can the researcher ask whether the long run relationship exhibits an inverted u pattern on the basis of panel integration and cointegration tests for sulfur stern 2004 and perman and stern 1999 2003 have presented evidence and forcefully stated that the ekc hypothesis does not exist in this paper we ask whether similar strong conclusions can be arrived at when carrying out tests of system fractional integration and cointegration as an example we use the controversial case of carbon dioxide emissions the results show that more ekcs come back into life relative to traditional integration cointegration tests however we confirm that the ekc hypothesis remains a fragile concept

which industry is greener an empirical study of nine industries in oecd countries abstract this study analyzed the relationship between the co2 emissions of different industries and economic growth in oecd countries from 1970 to 2005 we tested an environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis and found that total co2 emissions from nine industries show an n shaped trend instead of an inverted u or monotonic increasing trend with increasing income the ekc hypothesis for sector level co2 emissions was supported in the 1 paper pulp and printing industry 2 wood and wood products industry and 3 construction industry we also found that emissions from coal and oil increase with economic growth in the steel and construction industries in addition the non metallic minerals machinery and transport equipment industries tend to have increased emissions from oil and electricity with economic growth finally the ekc turning point and the relationship between gdp per capita and sectoral co2 emissions differ among industries according to the fuel type used therefore environmental policies for co2 reduction must consider these differences in industrial characteristics

industrial pollution in economic development the environmental kuznets curve revisited abstract using new international data this paper tests the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis for industrial water pollution we measure the effect of income growth on three determinants of pollution the share of industry in national output the share of polluting sectors in industrial output and end of pipe eop pollution intensities per unit of output in the polluting sectors we find that the industry share of national output follows a kuznets type trajectory but the other two determinants do not when combined our results imply rejection of the ekc hypothesis for industrial water pollution it rises rapidly through middle income status and remains roughly constant thereafter

the econometrics of the environmental kuznets curve an illustration using australian co2 emissions four econometric issues associated with the estimation and testing of the environmental kuznets curve ekc are considered i model specification with respect to the order of the polynomial ii

the interrelationships between births and deaths this paper provides a preliminary study of the way in which the births and deaths of firms interactover time it uses the retailing sector as a case study although the results also have relevance for other sectors section i of the paper introduces the background to the paper section ii provides a non mathematical theoretical framework for analysing the births deaths interrelationship it identifies three separate types of effect operative in these interrelationships the competition multiplier and marshall life cycle effects the data used in this study value added tax registrations and deregistrations and their limitations are considered in section iii section iv presents the preliminary empirical results this section utilises panel data vector autoregression techniques to identify the salient birth death relationships the final section concludes the paper and draws out possible policy conclusions it also suggests avenues for further work

the toxic intensity of industrial production global patterns trends and trade policy this paper exploits a newly developed data set to investigate recent changes in the international distribution of industrial pollution in particular the authors examine three issues 1 the relationship between the toxic intensity of industrial production and the level of economic development 2 the impact of oecd environmental regulation on global changes in toxic intensity and 3 the relationship between trade policy and the toxic intensity of industrial production in ldc s 10 refs

environmental kuznets curves real progress or passing the buck abstract recent research has examined the hypothesis of an environmental kuznets curve ekc the notion that environmental impact increases in the early stages of development followed by declines in the later stages these studies have focused on the relationship between per capita income and a variety of environmental indicators results imply that ekcs may exist for a number of cases however the measures of environmental impact used generally focus on production processes and reflect environmental impacts that are local in nature and for which abatement is relatively inexpensive in terms of monetary costs and or lifestyle changes significantly more consumption based measures such co2 emissions and municipal waste for which impacts are relatively easy to externalize or costly to control show no tendency to decline with increasing per capita income by considering consumption and trade patterns the author re examines the concept of the ekc and proposes the use of alternative consumption based measures of environmental impact the author speculates that what appear to be improvements in environmental quality may in reality be indicators of increased ability of consumers in wealthy nations to distance themselves from the environmental degradation associated with their consumption

confronting the environmental kuznets curve t he environmental kuznets curve posits an inverted u relationship between pollution and economic development kuznets s name was apparently attached to the curve by grossman and krueger 1993 who noted its resemblance to kuznets s inverted u relationship between income inequality and development in the first stage of industrialization pollution in the environmental kuznets curve world grows rapidly because people are more interested in jobs and income than clean air and water communities are too poor to pay for abatement and environmental regulation is correspondingly weak the balance shifts as income rises leading industrial sectors become cleaner people value the environment more highly and regulatory institutions become more effective along the curve pollution levels off in the middle income range and then falls toward pre industrial levels in wealthy societies the environmental kuznets curve model has elicited conflicting reactions from researchers and policymakers applied econometricians have generally accepted the basic tenets of the model and focused on measuring its parameters their regressions typically fitted to cross sectional observations across countries or regions suggest that air and water pollution increase with development until per capita income reaches a range of 5000 to 8000 when income rises beyond that level pollution starts to decline as shown in the conventional ekc line in figure 1 in developing countries some policymakers have interpreted such results as conveying a message about priorities grow first then clean up numerous critics have challenged the conventional environmental kuznets curve both as a representation of what actually happens in the development process and as a policy prescription some pessimistic critics argue that crosssectional evidence for the environmental kuznets curve is nothing more than a

economic growth and emissions reconsidering the empirical basis of environmental kuznets curves abstract recent empirical research indicates that certain types of emissions follow an inverted u or environmental kuznets curve ekc as income grows this regularity has been interpreted as a possible de linking of economic growth and patterns of certain pollutants for developed economies in this paper the empirical basis of this result is investigated by considering some statistical particularities of the various ekc studies performed it is argued that the inverted u relationship between income and emissions estimated from panel data need not hold for specific individual countries over time based on insights from intensity of use analysis in resource economics an alternative growth model is specified and estimated for three types of emissions co2 nox and so2 in four countries netherlands uk usa and western germany it is found that the time patterns of these emissions correlate positively with economic growth and that emission reductions may have been achieved as a result of structural and technological changes in the economy sustainable growth is defined as the rate of economic growth that does not lead to growth in emissions its rate is calculated for each type of emission and country based on estimated parameter values the resulting indicators reflect a balance between the positive influence of growth and negative influence of structural change and technological progress on emission levels

an alternative analysis of apparent ekc type transitions abstract the hypothesis of the environmental kuznets curve ekc depends upon the assumption that countries pass through a similar environmental impact trajectory as they experience income growth implying that income levels determine pollution levels the authors present evidence that this is not representative of the way many individual country s pollution emission trajectories evolve and question the emphasis on income determinism by the ekc the study proposes that nonlinear dynamic systems analysis provides a more complete description of individual country pollution trajectories in the case of co 2 emissions the nonlinear time trajectories show abrupt transitions that occur contemporaneously with historical events and over a broad range of incomes

reexamining the empirical evidence for an environmental kuznets curve this paper uses an updated and revised panel data set on ambient air pollution in cities worldwide to examine the robustness of the evidence for the existence of an inverted u shaped relationship between national income and pollution we test the sensitivity of the pollution income relationship to functional forms to additional covariates and to changes in the nations cities and years sampled we find that the results are highly sensitive to these changes and conclude that there is little empirical support for an inverted u shaped relationship between several important air pollutants and national income in these data

limited knowledge of demand and oligopoly equilibria abstract in a standard model of oligopoly with differentiated products the existence of an equilibrium at which the first order conditions for profit maximisation are simultaneously satisfied for all firms is proved and this is done without imposing any restrictions on the demand functions this is an equilibrium in the following sense although some firms may not necessarily be maximising their profits nevertheless if each firm s knowledge of demand is limited to the linear approximation of its own demand curve then it will believe that it is indeed maximising its profits

the nexus of electricity consumption economic growth and co2 emissions in the brics countries abstract this study reexamines the causal link between electricity consumption economic growth and co 2 emissions in the brics countries i e brazil russia india china and south africa for the period 1990 2010 using panel causality analysis accounting for dependency and heterogeneity across countries regarding the electricity gdp nexus the empirical results support evidence on the feedback hypothesis for russia and the conservation hypothesis for south africa however a neutrality hypothesis holds for brazil india and china indicating neither electricity consumption nor economic growth is sensitive to each other in these three countries regarding the gdp co 2 emissions nexus a feedback hypothesis for russia a one way granger causality running from gdp to co 2 emissions in south africa and reverse relationship from co 2 emissions to gdp in brazil is found there is no evidence of granger causality between gdp and co 2 emissions in india and china furthermore electricity consumption is found to granger cause co 2 emissions in india while there is no granger causality between electricity consumption and co 2 emissions in brazil russia china and south africa therefore the differing results for the brics countries imply that policies cannot be uniformly implemented as they will have different effects in each of the brics countries under study

economic growth and environmental degradation the environmental kuznets curve and sustainable development abstract in this paper we critically examine the concept of the environmental kuznets curve ekc it proposes that there is an inverted u shape relation between environmental degradation and income per capita so that eventually growth reduces the environmental impact of economic activity the concept is dependent on a model of the economy in which there is no feedback from the quality of the environment to production possibilities and in which trade has a neutral effect on environmental degradation the actual violation of these assumptions gives rise to fundamental problems in estimating the parameters of an ekc the paper identifies other econometric problems with estimates of the ekc and reviews a number of empirical studies the inference from some such ekc estimates that further development will reduce environmental degradation is dependent on the assumption that world per capita income is normally distributed when in fact median income is far below mean income we carry out simulations combining ekc estimates from the literature with world bank forecasts for economic growth for individual countries aggregating over countries to derive the global impact within the horizon of the bank s forecast 2025 global emissions of so 2 continue to increase forest loss stabilizes before the end of the period but tropical deforestation continues at a constant rate throughout the period

the determinants of atmospheric so2 concentrations reconsidering the environmental kuznets curve this analysis explores the effects of income and the spatial intensity of economic activity on the atmospheric concentration of sulfur dioxide the results indicate that there is a u shaped relation between income and atmospheric concentration of so2 and an inverted u shaped relation between the spatial intensity of economic activity and so2 concentrations these results suggest that the spatial intensity of economic activity rather than income provides the impetus for policies and technologies that reduce so2 emissions based on this result the atmospheric concentration of so2 in developing nations may decline faster than indicated by previous analyses the potential for this decline depends on the rate at which income grows relative to population the trade off between the effects of income gains and the spatial intensity of economic activity on the atmospheric concentration of so2 is consistent with the notion that some environmental problems can be ameliorated by slowing population growth and increasing income levels

environmental kuznets curve for co2 in canada abstract according to the environmental kuznets curve hypothesis the relationship between per capita gdp and per capita pollutant emissions has an inverted u shape this implies that past a certain point economic growth may actually be profitable for environmental quality most studies on this subject are based on estimating fully parametric quadratic or cubic regression models while this is not technically wrong such an approach somewhat lacks flexibility since it may fail to detect the true shape of the relationship if it happens not to be of the specified form we use semiparametric and flexible nonlinear parametric modeling methods in an attempt to provide more robust inferences we find little evidence in favour of the environmental kuznets curve hypothesis our main results could be interpreted as indicating that the oil shock of the 1970s has had an important impact on progress towards less polluting technology and production

internal and international migration in mexico 1995 2000 using micro data from mexico and us 2000 population censuses and following a multi choice variant of roy s 1951 model this article pools into one model the determinants of internal and international migration in mexico while paying explicit attention to the potential problem of self selection the results reveal that ignoring multiple destinations in the migration decision might lead to erroneous inferences about the determinants of migration and the type of selection after controlling for wage differences the results suggest that single adult men with low schooling levels tend to migrate to the us while married women and men with higher levels of schooling tend to migrate within mexico we also found that there are strong differences between domestic and international social networks

the environmental kuznets curve semi parametrically revisited this paper re examines the existence of an environmental kuznets curve ekc across countries using a semi parametric regression estimator which places no restrictions on the functional form our results using cross country panel data on sulfur and carbon dioxide strongly suggest that the relationship between wealth and environmental degradation is not bell shaped as suggested by an ekc rather that there is a positive link for the very poorest countries and no clear relationship for richer countries

the nexus between carbon emissions energy consumption and economic growth in middle east countries a panel data analysis abstract the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis assumes that there is an inverted u shaped relationship between environmental degradation and income per capita in other words as a country grows it is assumed that its environmental quality improves in this study we aim to test the ekc hypothesis for 12 middle east countries during the period 1990 2008 by employing recently developed panel data methods our results provide evidence contrary to the ekc hypothesis we found evidence favorable to the u shaped ekc for 5 middle east countries whereas an inverted u shaped curve was identified for only 3 middle east countries furthermore there appear to be no causal links between income and co 2 emissions for the other 4 countries regarding the direction of causality there appears to be a unidirectional causality from economic growth to energy consumption in the short run in the long run however the unidirectional causality chain runs from energy consumption and economic growth to co 2 emissions we also suggest some crucial policy implications depending on these results

a fractional cointegration analysis of purchasing power parity a generalized notion of cointegration called fractional cointegration is introduced to examine the long run purchasing power parity ppp hypothesis by allowing deviations from equilibrium to follow a fractionally integrated process the fractional cointegration analysis can capture a wider range of mean reversion behavior than standard cointegration analyses this gain is flexibility in modeling subtle mean reverting dynamics is found to be important for a proper evaluation of long run ppp empirical results based on historical data for the 1914 1989 period show that ppp reversion exists and can be characterized by a fractionally integrated process in three out of five countries studied the results support ppp as a long run phenomenon though significant short run deviations from ppp can exist

economic growth trade and energy implications for the environmental kuznets curve abstract the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis asserts that pollution follows an inverted u path with respect to economic growth the ekc has been explained in terms of structural changes in the composition of economic output and increased environmental regulation at higher income levels while some authors have incorporated the impact of trade policy orientation on the ekc the impact of the actual movement between countries of goods that embody pollution has not been considered this paper attempts to econometrically quantify the effect using pooled cross country and time series data the ekc hypothesis is examined with respect to commercial energy consumption the source of many serious environmental problems it was found that while both industrializing and industrialized countries have added to their energy requirements by exporting manufactured goods the growth has been substantially higher in the former at the same time industrialized countries have been able to reduce their energy requirements by importing manufactured goods exports of manufactured goods by industrialized countries has thus been an important factor in generating the upward sloping portion of the ekc and imports by industrialized countries have contributed to the downward slope

estimating country specific environmental kuznets curves from panel data a bayesian shrinkage approach designing an efficient global climate policy turns out to be a difficult yet crucial task since there are noteworthy cross country differences in energy and carbon intensities in this article the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis is tested for carbon dioxide co2 emissions and as a modelling technique the iterative bayesian shrinkage procedure is employed to handle the cross country differences the results suggest that first the ekc hypothesis is rejected for 47 out of the 51 countries considered when the heterogeneity in countries energy efficiencies and cross country differences in the co2 emissions trajectories are accounted for second a classification of the results with respect to the development levels of the countries concerned reveals that the emergence of an overall inverted u shaped curve is due to the fact that in high income countries increase in gross domestic product gdp decreases emissions while in low income countries emissions and gdp are positively correlated

does disaggregated co2 emission matter for growth evidence from thirty countries abstract this paper investigates the causal relationship between economic growth and aggregated carbon dioxide co 2 emission as well as economic growth and disaggregated co 2 emission from burning fossil fuel coal oil and natural gas in addition the analysis extends the potential impact on economic growth if countries substitute co 2 emission from dirty energy coal by emission from relatively cleaner energy oil and natural gas the study carries out a panel analysis of 30 countries during 1960 2010 panel unit root tests cointegration techniques and causality tests are used to investigate these relationships using panel var in first differences framework the result indicates that there are feedback relationships in all cases except a unidirectional causality running from economic growth to coal induced co 2 emission utilizing wald test with linear restriction the result also finds that countries will be environmentally benefited if they substitute emission from coal by that of oil and natural gas that is if they substitute coal consumption by oil and natural gas consumption depending on the findings the paper suggests some essential policies

gdp and environment pressure the role of energy in latin america and the caribbean abstract this paper analyzes the relationship between economic growth and energy consumption for a sample of 21 latin american and caribbean countries during the 1970 2007 period the investigation is made on the bases of the energy environmental kuznets curve eekc hypothesis using a panel data analysis energy consumption at aggregate level is used as an indicator of human environmental pressure and gdp per capita as an indicator of economic activity based in a cointegration approach our results does not support the existence of a stable long run relationship between the series rejecting the validity of such hypothesis for the selected sample over the 1970 2007 period

searching for a kuznets curve in environmental efficiency using kernel estimation abstract the paper constructs environmental efficiency indexes for a sample consisting of high and low income countries using nonparametric production frontier techniques and then establishes an environmental kuznets relationship for environmental efficiency by nadaraya watson kernel estimation methodology

greenhouse gases emissions growth and the energy mix in europe the importance of energy on greenhouse gases ghg emissions is reflected by the fact that 65 of said emissions in the world are currently due to the use and production of energy however most empirical emission models are found within the environmental kuznetz curve ekc framework which focuses on the relationship between emissions and economic development ang s 2007 2008 papers are some of the exceptions that simultaneously study the relationship between emissions growth and energy with respect to ang s research we contribute on two important aspects first while ang uses a particular country as the study and use time series techniques we take advantage of a panel data set of 24 european countries between 1990 and 2006 and use a dynamic panel data dpd framework second the impact of energy consumption on emissions would depend on the primary energy mix and on the final use of this energy and we consider both factors in the model

threshold cointegration and nonlinear adjustment between co2 and income the environmental kuznets curve in spain 1857 2007 abstract article history received 9 march 2011received in revised form 24 february 2012accepted 2 march 2012available online 14 march 2012jel classi cation c2q4keywords environmental kuznets curveco 2 emissionsnonlinear relationshipthreshold cointegration inthispaper wemodelthe long run relationship between per capita co 2 and per capita income for the spanisheconomy over the period 1857 2007 according to the environmental kuznets curve eck the relationshipbetween the two variables has an inverted u shape however previous studies for the spanish economy onlyconsidered the existence of linear relationships such an approach may lack exibility to detect the trueshape of the relationship our empirical methodology accounts for a possible non linear relationship throughthe use of threshold cointegration techniques our results con rm the non linearity of the link between thetwo above mentioned variables pointing to the existence of an environmental kuznets curve for the spanishcase 2012 elsevier b v all rights reserved

cointegration fractional cointegration and exchange rate dynamics multivariate tests due to johansen 1988 1991 as implemented by baillie and bollerslev 1989a and diebold gardeazabal and yilmaz 1994 reveal mixed evidence on whether a group of exchange rates are cointegrated further analysis of the deviations from the cointegrating relationship suggests that it possesses long memory and may possibly be well described as a fractionally integrated process hence the influence of shocks to the equilibrium exchange rates may only vanish at very long horizons in the article by baillie and bollerslev 1989a it is argued that seven different nominal spot and forward exchange rates all contain unit roots in their univariate time series representations at the same time however the spot exchange rates appear to be tied together in the long run through a cointegration type relationship the latter finding of baillie and bollerslev has attracted particular interest and several studies such as those by hakkio and rush 1991 and sephton and larsen 1991 have already addressed this issue using the same data as the baillie and bollerslev article sephton and larsen 1991 describe the evidence for the presence of cointegration as being fragile and note that mixed conclusions are reached by truncating the baillie and bollerslev sample at different points in time diebold gardeazabal and yilmaz 1994 henceforth diebold et al provide interesting evidence that application of the johansen 1988 1991 tests with and without an intercept will result in different inferences on the baillie and bollerslev data set furthermore diebold et al carry out an ex ante forecasting experiment and find that the addition of an error correction term to the martingale model as implied by the standard cointegration paradigm fails to reduce the prediction mean square error when compared to a simple martingale model this therefore leads diebold et al to conclude that there exists substantial uncertainty regarding the existence of cointegration relationships among nominal dollar exchange rates this article provides some additional evidence on the existence of such a long run relationship among the same seven nominal spot exchange rates after further analysis it appears that a form of cointegration does exist between the exchange rates so that they do not drift apart in the long run we argue that this form of cointegration is

reassessing the environmental kuznets curve for co2 emissions a robustness exercise the number of studies seeking to empirically characterize the reduced form relationship between a country economic growth and the quantity of pollutants produced in the process has recently increased significantly in several cases researchers have found evidence pointing to an inverted u benvironmental kuznetsq curve in the case of co2 however the evidence is at best mixed in this paper we reconsider that evidence by assessing how robust it is when the analysis is conducted in a different parametric setup and when using alternative emissions data from the international energy agency relative to the literature our contribution can be viewed as a robustness exercise in these two respects the econometric results lead to two conclusions firstly published evidence on the ekc does not appear to depend upon the source of the data at least as far as carbon dioxide is concerned secondly when an alternative functional form is employed there is evidence of an inverted u pattern for the group of oecd countries with reasonable turning point regardless of the data set employed not so for non oecd countries as the ekc is basically increasing slowly concave according to the iea data and more bellshaped in the case of cdiac data d 2005 elsevier b v all rights reserved

pooled mean group estimation of an environmental kuznets curve for co2 abstract we apply the pooled mean group estimator to test for the existence of an environmental kuznets curve for co2 in 22 oecd countries this approach allows for more flexible assumptions in a panel data framework the period goes from 1975 to 1998

income inequality and pollution a reassessment of the environmental kuznets curve abstract improvements in some measures of air and water quality can accompany rising per capita income as illustrated by the so called environmental kuznets curve for pollution variables which show such a relationship we hypothesize that a more equitable distribution of power contributes to these outcomes by enhancing the influence on policy of those who bear the costs of pollution relative to the influence of those who benefit from pollution generating activities an empirical analysis of international variations in seven indicators of air and water quality supports this hypothesis literacy political rights and civil liberties are found to have particularly strong effects on environmental quality in low income countries

a consumption based approach to environmental kuznets curves using the ecological footprint indicator recent research suggests that consumption based measures offer an insightful perspective on the debate on the relationship between economic growth and the environment in this article we deepen the

structural breaks and fractional integration in the us output and unemployment rate abstract in this article we examine the presence of structural breaks in the us output and unemployment rate by means of using fractionally integrated techniques the results based on robinson s journal of the american statistical association 89 1994 1420 tests indicate that for unemployment the inclusion of breaks does not affect to the degree of integration of the series while for the gnp we observe a reduction in its order of integration of about 0 25 when a break due to the oil price crisis is taken into account

is there a long term relationship between agricultural ghg emissions and productivity growth a dynamic panel data approach the paper adopts a single country regional panel dataset to analyse the long term relationship between agricultural greenhouse gases ghg emissions and productivity growth and consequently to assess emissions sustainability the hypothesis of emission sustainability is assessed by estimating alternative panel model specifications with conventional and gmm estimators applied to the highly heterogeneous italian regional agriculture whose methane and nitrous oxide emissions are properly reconstructed for the periods 1951 2008 and 1980 2008 the modelling approach and the empirical specification include the environmental kuznets curve ekc as one of the possible outcomes results suggest that when a significant relationship between agricultural ghg emissions and productivity growth occurs it is often monotonic and though sustainability is accepted for some ghg no univocal robust evidence of the ekc emerges across the different specifications estimators and periods policy implications of this empirical evidence are finally drawn

environmental kuznets curve time series application for turkey why controversial results exist for similar models abstract this paper investigates the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis using 40 year spanned time series for the turkey case co 2 emission series representing environmental pressure and gdp per capita values representing economic development are used for the period 1968 2007 a cointegration has been determined among nonstationary series first phases of an inverted u form ekc relationship have been determined for turkey from the econometric estimations this result is conflicting with that of the similar models for turkey case on the other hand this conflict refers the important arguments in the literature and constitutes the main points of the paper sensitivity critiques for example ahking et al for cointegration tests johansen and engle granger tests have been supported in our study moreover we detected important diversion in results according to drift and trend assumptions both in ci vector and ekc model specifications we conclude that building ekc model according to cointegration ci equation restrictions can be important source for diversion when sensitivity exists in estimations and cointegration tests therefore ekc estimations should be held in non restrictive way the additional structural reasons have been also discussed for developing country ekc cases the most important one is that the narrow income sample of developing countries makes it possible to be defined by similar but different paths therefore policy implications to be drawn from those analyses should not ignore this feature of developing country analyses