exploiting ergodicity in forecasts of corporate profitability abstract theory suggests that competition tends to equalize profit rates through the process of capital reallocation and numerous studies have confirmed that profit rates are indeed persistent and mean reverting recent empirical evidence further shows that fluctuations in the profitability of surviving corporations are well approximated by a stationary laplace distribution here we show that a parsimonious diffusion process of corporate profitability that accounts for all three features of the data achieves better out of sample forecasting performance across different time horizons than previously suggested time series and cross sectional models as a consequence of replicating the empirical distribution of profit rates the model prescribes a particular strength or speed for the mean reversion of all returns which leads to superior forecasts of individual time series when we exploit information from the cross sectional collection of firms the new model should appeal to managers analysts investors and other groups of corporate stakeholders who are interested in accurate forecasts of profitability to the extent that mean reversion in profitability is the source of predictable variation in earnings our approach can also be used in forecasts of earnings and is thus useful for firm valuation

a statistical equilibrium model of competitive firms abstract we find that the empirical density of firm profit rates measured as returns on assets is markedly non gaussian and reasonably well described by an exponential power or subbotin distribution we start from a statistical equilibrium model that leads to a stationary subbotin density in the presence of complex interactions among competitive heterogeneous firms to investigate the dynamics of firm profitability we construct a diffusion process that has the subbotin distribution as its stationary probability density this leads to a phenomenologically inspired interpretation of variations in the shape parameter of the subbotin distribution which essentially measures the competitive pressure in and across industries our findings have profound implications both for the previous literature on the persistence of profits as well as for understanding competition as a dynamic process our main formal finding is that firms idiosyncratic efforts and the tendency for competition to equalize profit rates are two sides of the same coin and that a ratio of these two effects ultimately determines the dispersion of the equilibrium distribution

corporate growth and industrial structures some evidence from the italian manufacturing industry this work analyses the properties of corporate growth in a large longitudinal sample of italian manufacturing firms in particular it focuses on the statistical properties of growth rates and on the influence of proxies for relative efficiency upon relative growth in line with previous work the emergence of fat tails in growth rate distributions and the idiosyncratic nature of autocorrelation coefficients confirm the existence of a structure in the growth process richer than the one normally assumed by the gibrat law hypothesis and suggest the presence of firm specific drivers of growth at the same time there is a remarkable puzzle concerning the absence of any negative relationship between size and growth variance and only weak influences of relative efficiencies upon growth dynamics

the access pricing problem with deregulation a note this note extends the analysis of m armstrong c doyle and j vickers 1996 to the case of retail price deregulation it is shown that the optimal access price may be above below or in the linear case equal to marginal cost that optimal regulation of the margin between the retail price and the access price entails the efficient component pricing rule and that welfare and entrant profit are higher when the level of the access price rather than the margin is regulated

the persistence of profit differentials in indian industry the competitive process in a market economy is expected to work to eliminate profit differentials between firms industries in the long run in the indian case we note that quite a large number of industries experience above average profits that persist over time our analysis show that such persistence is higher in fast growing industries with high strategic barriers on the other hand government controls seem to be very effective in discouraging such persistence

does classical competition explain the statistical features of firm growth abstract we propose a statistical equilibrium model where the tendency for competition to equalize profit rates results in an exponential power or subbotin distribution the model supports and extends recent evidence on the laplace distribution of firm growth rates

rates of time preference for saving lives an important characteristic of many environmental programs is that their benefits extend far into the future the primary purpose of cleanups at hazardous waste disposal sites for example is often to prevent the contamination of groundwater that could pose risks to future residents at these sites such cleanups typically involve considerable capital and other costs which are incurred at the front end of the project and yield a stream of health benefits often in the form of cancer cases avoided that may not be recognized for many years this would not pose unusual problems for program evaluation if everyone were comfortable with the assignment of dollar values to these reductions in future risk see cropper and portney 1990 however regulatory agencies are sometimes reluctant to make such monetary valuations preferring instead to evaluate programs on a cost per life saved cpls basis office of management and budget 1991 this raises an interesting question should lives saved in the future be discounted for the purpose of calculating cpls or should they be counted the same as those saved tomorrow to shed light on this over the last year we have asked members of the public hypothetical questions that enable us to infer the rate at which they implicitly discount future lives saved john k horowitz and richard t carson 1990 asked similar questions of students in the remainder of this paper we summarize the results of this research details of which can be found elsewhere cropper et al 1991 1992

the diversity of design of tsos it is puzzling today to explain diversity and imperfection of actual transmission monopoly designs in competitive electricity markets we argue that transmission monopoly in competitive electricity markets has to be analysed within a wilson 2002 modular framework applied to the management of electricity flows at least three modules make the core of transmission design 1 the short run management of network externalities 2 the long run management of network investment and 3 the coordination of neighboring transmission system operators for cross border trade in order to tackle this diversity of designs of tsos we show that for each of these modules three different basic ways of managing them are possible among the identified twenty seven options of organisation we define an ideal tso second we demonstrate that 1 monopoly design differs from this ideal tso and cannot handle these three modules irrespective of the institutional definition and allocation of property rights on transmission while 2 definition and allocation of property rights on transmission cannot ignore the existing electrical industry and transmission network structure they have to complement each other to be efficient some conclusions for regulatory issues of transmission systems operators are derived from this analysis of network monopoly organisation

the persistence of profit a new empirical interpretation abstract inferences are drawn about the true coefficients which correspond to sample estimates of a persistence of profit model fitted over a large number of firms this is done by generating simulated sampling distributions for the estimators over various distributional assumptions profits seem to be stationary for all firms with an average short run persistence coefficient of 0 59 higher than most previous estimates long run profit rates differ between firms although by less than is suggested by direct observation of variations in mean profit rates calculated over time short run persistence appears to be inversely related to unsystematic variation in profit

implications of quantal response statistical equilibrium abstract this paper explores the foundations and properties of the quantal response statistical equilibrium qrse model developed by scharfenaker and foley 2017 the qrse model provides a behavioral foundation for the formation of aggregate economic outcomes in social systems characterized by negative feedbacks it can approximate a wide range of commonly encountered theoretical distributions that have been identified as economic statistical equilibrium and displays qualitatively similar behavior to the subbotin and asymmetric subbotin distributions that range from the laplace to the normal distribution in the limit asymmetry in the frequency distributions of economic outcomes can be understood as arising from the unfulfilled expectations of entropy constrained decision makers this paper demonstrates the logic of the qrse model in an application to us stock market data dating back to 1926 the model provides a parsimonious explanation for the distribution of rates of return on private equities as well as a behavioral foundation for asset price fluctuations

the persistence of profits a european comparison this paper is concerned with modeling the movements in profits of firms over time at the heart of the emp irical model is a latent variables problem which arises from the fact that entry and imitation do not actually have to occur to have an ef fect on profits a solution to this problem is explored and then emp irical results are presented comparing a sample of firms from the uni ted kingdom france and west germany copyright 1988 by royal economic society

empirical and public choice evidence for hyperbolic social discount rates and the implications for intergenerational discounting the derivation of the correct discount rate for intergenerational projects in cost benefit analysis is particularly contentious public choice has resulted in lower discretionary exponential discount rates for many intergenerational projects in britain and the usa this is shown to be strong indirect evidence that the true social discount rate may be a hyperbolic rather than an exponential function there is also empirical evidence for this hypothesis the hyperbolic nature of discounting is also a standard finding in the behavioural sciences for intergenerational time frames hyperbolic discount rates should be employed together with exponential discount rates in cost benefit sensitivity analyses

gas market distorting effects of imbalanced gas balancing rules inefficient regulation of pipeline flexibility this paper analyzes the value and cost of line pack flexibility in liberalized gas markets through examination of the techno economic characteristics of gas transport pipelines and the trade offs between different ways to use the infrastructure transport and flexibility line pack flexibility is becoming increasingly important as a tool to balance gas supply and demand over different periods in the european liberalized market context a monopolist unbundled network operator offers regulated transport services and flexibility balancing services according to the network code and balancing rules therefore gas policy makers should understand the role and consequences of line pack regulation the analysis shows that the line pack flexibility service has an important economic value for the shippers and the tso furthermore the analysis identifies distorting effects in the gas market due to inadequate regulation of line pack flexibility by disregarding the sunk costs of flexibility in the balancing rules the overall efficiency of the gas system is decreased finally the analysis demonstrates that the actual costs of line pack flexibility are related to the peak cumulative imbalance throughout the balancing period any price for pipeline flexibility should therefore be based on the related trade off between the right to use the line pack flexibility and the provision of transport services

are output growth rate distributions fat tailed some evidence from oecd countries this work explores some distributional properties of aggregate output growth rate time series we show that in the majority of oecd countries output growth rate distributions are well approximated by symmetric exponential power densities with tails much fatter than those of a gaussian fat tails robustly emerge in output growth rates independently of i the way we measure aggregate output ii the family of densities employed in the estimation iii the length of time lags used to compute growth rates we also show that fat tails still characterize output growth rate distributions even after one washes away outliers autocorrelation and heteroscedasticity

zipf s law and maximum sustainable growth abstract zipf s law states that the number of firms with size greater than s is inversely proportional to s most explanations start with gibrat s rule of proportional growth but require additional constraints we show that gibrat s rule at all firm levels yields zipf s law under a balance condition between the effective growth rate of incumbent firms which includes their possible demise and the growth rate of investments in entrant firms under the additional assumption that firms do not consume more resources than available we show that zipf s law is the signature that firms grow at the maximum reachable long term rate

explaining the distribution of firm growth rates empirical analyses on aggregated datasets have revealed a common exponential behavior in the shape of the probability density of corporate growth rates we present clear cut evidence on this topic using disaggregated data we explain the observed regularities proposing a model in which firms ability to take up new business opportunities increases with the number of opportunities already exploited a theoretical result is presented for the limiting case in which the number of firms and opportunities go to infinity moreover using simulations we show that even in a small industry the agreement with asymptotic results is almost complete

do firms share the same functional form of their growth rate distribution a statistical test abstract we propose a hypothesis testing procedure to investigate whether the same growth rate distribution is shared by all the firms in a balanced panel or more generally whether they share the same functional form for this distribution without necessarily sharing the same parameters we apply the test to panels of us and european union publicly quoted manufacturing firms both at the sectoral and at the subsectoral naics level we consider the following null hypotheses about the growth rate distribution of the individual firms i an unknown shape common to all firms with all the firms sharing also the same parameters or with the firm variance related to its firm size through a scaling relationship and ii several functional shapes described by the subbotin family of distributions our empirical results indicate that firms do not have a common shape of the growth rate distribution at the sectorial naics level whereas firms may typically be described by the same shape of the distribution at the subsectorial level even if the specific shape may not be the same for different subsectors

persistence of profitability and competition in emerging markets abstract this paper reports on time series analyses of the persistence of profitability of firms in emerging markets its central result is that there is less persistence in developing than in advanced economies the implications for the intensity of competition in emerging markets are examined

political institutions of electricity regulation the case of turkey abstract turkey has been going through a liberalization process in its electricity market over the last decade so far the regulatory content of the market reforms has been in the center of attention in the literature to the negligence of regulatory governance however recent studies which applied the theoretical insights of new institutional economics to utilities regulation have demonstrated that political endowments of the country draw the boundaries to which extent such regulatory content can be effectively implemented in line with these studies this paper adopts an institutional approach and attempts to identify the political endowments of turkey in order to further analyze whether the market reforms succeeded in bringing about sufficient checks to cure the institutional problems in other words the paper takes a picture of the overall regulatory arena the results show that the current regulatory structure especially government regulator relations yet fails to meet good regulatory governance criteria the paper also provides some policy suggestions

corporate profitability and the dynamics of competition in emerging markets a time series analysis the paper presents time series analyses of corporate profitability in seven leading developing countries dcs using the common methodology of the persistence of profitability pp studies and systematically compares the results with those for advanced countries acs surprisingly both short and long term persistence of profitability for dcs are found to be lower than those for acs the paper concentrates on economic explanations for these findings it also reports the results on the persistence of the two components of profitability output capital ratios and profit margins these too raise important general issues of economic interpretation for pp studies which are outlined

marginal pricing of transmission services an analysis of cost recovery this paper presents an in depth analysis of network revenues computed with marginal pricing and in particular it investigates the reasons why marginal prices fail to recover the total incurred network costs in actual power systems the basic theoretical results are presented and the major causes of the mismatch between network costs and marginal revenues are identified and illustrated with numerical examples some tutorial and others of realistic size the regulatory implications of marginal network pricing in the context of competitive electricity markets are analyzed and suggestions are provided for the meaningful allocation of the costs of the network among its users

firm growth and laplace distribution the importance of large jumps abstract recent empirical studies have shown that firm growth rate distribution is not gaussian but closely follows a laplace distribution this robust feature of the growth rate distribution challenges existing models based on gibrat s model because it predicts a gaussian distribution first we analyze more than 100 000 japanese firms and empirically show that the laplace shape can be observed for the japanese firms then by using the theory of stochastic processes we theoretically show that the absence of jumps causes the discrepancy between gibrat s model and the laplace shape in particular based on the laplace shape and the law of proportionate effect we show that the firm growth process is a jump process in other words firm growth cannot be explained by the consequence of many small shocks but is determined by a few large jumps the widely observed laplace distribution reflects this jump property of firm growth dynamics

cross disciplinary evidence for hyperbolic social discount rates researchers in different disciplines have independently found evidence to suggest that the social discount rate may be hyperbolic rather than exponential in nature both behaviorist research and some empirical economics studies support the hyperbolic discounting hypothesis u s and u k government discounting dispensations for some long run public development projects are explicable in terms of an underlying hyperbolic social discount rate a statistical aggregation argument demonstrates that even if the behaviorist economics and public choice evidence for hyperbolic discounting is not conclusive the social discount rate of a set of people who individually express time preferences best modeled by exponential discounting functions is nonetheless hyperbolic further empirical economics studies of discounting preferences are required comparisons of different national discounting practices would also be useful to see how widespread is the use of unusually low exponential rates of discount for long run projects the application of hyperbolic discounting would have most impact in long run benefit cost analyses however government agencies would require overwhelming evidence before switching from exponential to hyperbolic discounting

information theoretic approaches in economics economics has seen a recent rise in interest in information theory as an alternative framework to the conventional notion of equilibrium as a fixed state such as walrasian market clearing general equilibrium the information theoretic approach is predicated on the notion of statistical equilibrium se that takes a distribution over all possible states as an equilibrium and therefore predicts the endogenous fluctuations of the system along with its central tendency simultaneously for this reason se approaches can explain the observed data without relying on arbitrary assumptions about random noise and provide useful insights for many interesting economic problems that conventional methods have not been able to satisfactorily deal with in this paper we review the key elements of information theory focusing on the notions and applications of entropy and se in economics particularly paying attention to how entropy concepts open up a new frontline of economic research

does the persistence of profits persist a study of company profits in japan 1964 97 abstract earlier in a time series study of the profit rates of japanese manufacturing firms odagiri and yamawaki concluded that profits persist with the addition of 15 more years of data up to 1997 this conclusion is shown to stand the test of time in particular those firms estimated to earn higher than average long run profit rates in the early study were again estimated to earn higher than average long run profit rates the force of convergence was also found to be at work for instance the firms most profitable in period 1 1964 82 were most likely to face a decline in estimated long run profit rates from period 1 to period 2 1983 97 with the use of two sets of data the firm s profit performance was found to be positively related to measures of market share first among a smaller sample of firms for which reliable market share data could be matched market share was estimated to have a significant positive effect on long run profit rate in either period secondly among the entire sample of 357 firms the long run profit rate in either period was estimated to be positively associated with firm sales relative to industry sales which presumably is a crude measure of market share

asymmetric competition risk and return distribution abstract we propose a parsimonious statistical model of firm competition where structural differences in the strength of competitive pressure and the magnitude of return fluctuations above and below the system wide benchmark translate into a skewed subbotin or asymmetric exponential power aep distribution of returns to capital empirical evidence from us data illustrates that the aep distribution compares favorably to popular alternative models such as the symmetric or asymmetric laplace density in terms of goodness of fit when entry and exit dynamics of markets are taken into account

gibrat s law redux think profitability instead of growth we argue that firm profitability can be conveniently characterized by one and the same diffusion process for all firms akin to gibrat s seminal idea of a common stochastic description for the dynamics of firm growth here we show that the diffusion of profit rates applies across all surviving corporations irrespective of their size or industry which is not true for growth rates the diffusion process is empirically consistent with both the cross sectional distribution of profit rates and the individual time series of corporate profit rates leading to the notion of a statistical equilibrium this has stark and unexpected implications for our understanding of individual destinies since the model and data suggest that idiosyncratic efforts have no impact on the aggregate distributional outcome instead idiosyncratic efforts merely affect the individual persistence of abnormal profits from the system wide norm put differently corporations have to participate in the same game and can merely choose the speed at which they play it but they cannot bend the rules

discount rates inferred from decisions an experimental study two hundred and four students of economics and finance participated in an intertemporal choice experiment which manipulated three dimensions in a 4 4 4 factorial design scenario postponing a receipt postponing a payment expediting a receipt expediting a payment time delay 0 5 1 2 and 4 years and size of cashflow 40 200 1000 and 5000 individual discount rates were inferred from the responses and then used to test competitively four hypotheses regarding the behavior of discount rates the classical hypothesis asserting that the discount rate is uniform across scenarios time delays and sums of cashflow was flatly rejected a market segmentation approach was found lacking the results support an implicit risk hypothesis according to which delayed consequences are associated with an implicit risk value and an added compensation hypothesis which asserts that individuals require compensation for a change in their financial position

a simple nonparametric approach to derivative security valuation canonical valuation uses historical time series to predict the probability distribution of the discounted value of primary assets discounted prices plus accumulated dividends at any future date then the axiomatically rationalized maximum entropy principle is used to estimate risk neutral equivalent martingale probabilities that correctly price the primary assets as well as any predesignated subset of derivative securities whose payoffs occur at this date valuation of other derivative securities proceeds by calculation of its discounted risk neutral expected value both simulation and empirical evidence suggest that canonical valuation has merit since the advent of the justly celebrated black scholes option pricing formula intense interest has focused on testing its implications there is consensus

profit persistence in the very long run evidence from survivors and exiters one of the main shortcomings of the profit persistence literature is the fact that it looks only at surviving companies this paper uses a unique dataset to analyse profit persistence in two different samples of stationary series 85 surviving us companies from 1950 1999 and 72 exiters while the exiters perform more competitively than the survivors there is still significant evidence for profit persistence in both samples concentration and growth of the industry as well as size and volatility of profits seem to play an important role in explaining persistence

environmental policy under a non market discount rate abstract this paper looks at pollution emissions when a non market discount rate is used to evaluate environmental policy and policy is subject to continuous review through time it is shown that a non market rate leads to time inconsistent policy future regulators will want not to follow the current regulator s optimal plans even when the current regulator has perfect foresight and there is no uncertainty therefore the discount rate has different effects depending on whether government can commit to future environmental regulation we then show in a simple linear model that when the environmental discount rate is below the market rate pollution is higher under no commitment than under commitment even under no commitment however a lower discount rate leads to lower emissions we argue that the debate might be better framed over prices i e the value of the environment in the future rather than the discount rate this treatment removes the inconsistency problem yet ensures that future generations interests are represented in policy decisions

turnover activity in wealth portfolios we examine several subsets of the wealthiest individuals in the us and the uk that are compiled by forbes magazine and the sunday times since these are named subsets we can calculate the returns to wealth portfolios and calibrate a statistical equilibrium model of wealth distribution that accounts for the power law of wealth and the asymmetric laplace distribution of portfolio returns the model provides a relative measure of turnover activity that indicates how often changes in the composition of the wealthiest portfolios occur finally we investigate trends in equality mobility and turnover activity

the access pricing problem a synthesis the baumol willig efficient component pricing rule states that it is efficient to set the price of access to an essential facility equal to the direct cost of access plus the opportunity cost to the integrated access provider the authors analyze the relevant notion of opportunity cost under various assumptions about demand and supply conditions including product differentiation bypass and substitution possibilities which all reduce opportunity cost compared to the benchmark case they show that the ramsey approach to access pricing developed by j j laffont and j tirole 1994 is closely related to the efficient component pricing rule provided opportunity cost is correctly interpreted

quantitative empirical research in marxist political economy a selective review this paper surveys quantitative empirical research in some key areas of marxist political economy following an introductory section on the value controversy the paper surveys quantitative empirical research on the following topics a marxist national accounts b classical marxist theory of relative prices c probabilistic political economy d profitability analysis and e classical marxian theories of growth and technical change i end by highlighting two important puzzles in the extant literature

adaptability of competitive electricity reforms a modular analysis abstract among the competitive electricity reforms that have been implemented in europe and the us for the last 18 years none has survived over several years without major changes their changing nature raises the question of their adaptability two characteristics of reforms play a key role on their adaptation properties firstly they are modular objects in the sense of baldwin c 2008 where do transactions come from modularity transactions and the boundaries of firms industrial and corporate change 17 1 155 195 secondly they are produced in an institutional process which leads to incomplete rules and designs pistor k xu c 2003 incomplete law international law and politics 35 931 1013 we propose a typology of adaptations based on the framework proposed by williamson o e 1991 comparative economic organization the analysis of discrete structural alternatives administrative science quarterly 36 2 269 296 for contracts 1 in case of small disturbances adaptations are realized quasi automatically by autonomous decisions of the institutions governing the implementation of reforms 2 in case of middle range disturbances adaption is made by coasian bargaining 3 finally in case of strong disturbances or when bargaining is not feasible the adaptation of reforms is in the hands of legislative and executive institutions north d c 2005 le processus du developpement economique editions d organisation these institutions can reform the reforms joskow p l 2006 introduction to electricity sector liberalization lessons learned from cross country studies in sioshansi f p ed electricity market reform an international perspective elsevier amsterdam pp 1 32 hogan w w 2002 electricity market restructuring reforms of reforms journal of regulatory economics 21 103 132 the role of these types of adaptations in each electricity reform is a consequence of the allocation of rights to the regulator to stakeholders and to legislative and executive institutions

a multilevel modelling approach to triple bounded dichotomous choice contingent valuation the use of dichotomous choice dc questions in the elicitation of willingness to pay wtp in contingent valuation studies is common practice at the present time recent research has shown that double bounded dc questions provide statistically superior results to single bounded questions given an appropriate sampling design this paper uses a relatively new multilevel modelling technique to analyze a triple bounded dc design which in addition includes an initial non monetary question on whether an individual accepts in principle a wtp some unspecified amount the theoretical basis of the multilevel model used is described and some of the possibilities of this potentially powerful and versatile technique are discussed the practical operation of the multilevel model is demonstrated using data from a contingent valuation study conducted in the norfolk broads england an internationally important wetland resource

the dynamics of company profits an international comparison 1 profits and the process of competition dennis c mueller 2 modelling persistent profitability paul a geroski 3 the persistence of profits in the united states dennis c mueller 4 the persistence of profits in us manufacturing industries ioannis kessides 5 the persistence of profitability in canada r shyam khemani and d m shapiro 6 persistence of corporate profits in the federal republic of germany joachim schwalbach and talat mahmood 7 the persistence of profits in france frederic jenny and andre paul weber 8 the persistence of profits in japan hiroyuki odagiri and hideki yamawaki 9 the persistence of profits in the uk john cubbin and paul a geroski 10 the persistence of profits international comparison hiroyuki odagiri and hideki yamawaki 11 the persistence of profits in perspective paul a geroski and dennis c mueller

invariances and diversities in the evolution of manufacturing industries this work explores and compares some basic properties of corporate growth process at both aggregate manufacturing level and disaggregated sectoral levels using an extensive dataset on italian manufacturing firms we investigate which properties of firm growth dynamics are robust under disaggregation we compare the results obtained with three different definitions of firm size namely total sales number of employees and value added our analysis suggests that while different sectors are characterized by significant differences in firm size distributions in the degrees of concentration and in the autoregressive structure of the growth processes there are also regularities which hold across all of them such as the approximate unit root nature of the growth process and the power exponential shape of the growth rates density together these stylized facts suggest challenging puzzles on the drivers of corporate growth and the resulting industrial structures