nonmonetary effects of the financial crisis in propagation of the great depression this paper examines the effects of the financial crisis of the 1930s onthe path of aggregate output during that period our approach is complementary to that of friedman and schwartz who emphasized the monetary impact of the bank failures we focus on non monetary primarily credit related aspects of the financial sector output link and consider the problems of debtors as well as those of the banking system we argue that the financial disruptions of 1930 33 reduced the efficiency of the credit allocation process and that the resulting higher cost and reduced availability of credit acted to depress aggregate demand evidence suggests that effects of this type can help explain the unusual length and depth of the great depression this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

why does the economy fall to pieces after a financial crisis the worst fi nancial crisis in the history of the united states and many other he worst fi nancial crisis in the history of the united states and many other countries started in 1929 the great depression followed the second worst countries started in 1929 the great depression followed the second worst struck in the fall of 2008 and the great recession followed commentators struck in the fall of 2008 and the great recession followed commentators have dwelt endlessly on the causes of these and other deep fi nancial collapses have dwelt endlessly on the causes of these and other deep fi nancial collapses less conspicuous has been the macroeconomists concern about why output and less conspicuous has been the macroeconomists concern about why output and employment collapse after a fi nancial crisis and remain at low levels for several or employment collapse after a fi nancial crisis and remain at low levels for several or many years after the crisis this article pursues modern answers to that question it many years after the crisis this article pursues modern answers to that question it focuses on events in the united states since 2008 focuses on events in the united states since 2008 existing macroeconomic models account successfully for the immediate effects existing macroeconomic models account successfully for the immediate effects of a fi nancial crisis on output and employment i will lay out a simple macro model of a fi nancial crisis on output and employment i will lay out a simple macro model that captures the most important features of modern models and show that realistic that captures the most important features of modern models and show that realistic increases in fi nancial frictions that occurred in the crisis of late 2008 will generate increases in fi nancial frictions that occurred in the crisis of late 2008 will generate declines in real gdp and employment of the magnitude that occurred but this declines in real gdp and employment of the magnitude that occurred but this model cannot explain why gdp and employment failed to recover once the fi nancial model cannot explain why gdp and employment failed to recover once the fi nancial crisis subsided the model implies a recovery as soon as fi nancial frictions return to crisis subsided the model implies a recovery as soon as fi nancial frictions return to normal at the end of the article i will mention the ideas that are in play to explain normal at the end of the article i will mention the ideas that are in play to explain the persistent adverse effects of temporary crises but these ideas have not made their the persistent adverse effects of temporary crises but these ideas have not made their way into the mainstream model way into the mainstream model this article cites only a few of the many important contributions to the mainthis article cites only a few of the many important contributions to the mainstream model my paper hall 2009 contains many citations and the forthcoming stream model my paper hall 2009 contains many citations and the forthcoming new volume of the new volume of the handbook of monetary economics discusses the literature fully discusses the literature fully

technology is changing lending implications for research abstract costello down and mehta 2020 trace their slider intervention to deviations from the credit line amount recommended by a credit scoring model the deviations are followed by larger delinquency declines and bigger sales orders and costello et al interpret these results using discretion based theories however incremental deviations are concentrated on newer clients rather than those the lender has accumulated soft information about deviations also appear larger for public than private borrowers my discussion evaluates whether these results align with discretion based theories and explores alternative interpretations based on salience and unique aspects of the trade credit setting differences in interpretation aside the evidence is informative about technological advances in commercial lending i conclude with an overview of several recent advances and discuss the implications for lending research

uncertainty shocks and firm creation search and monitoring in the credit market abstract we develop a business cycle model where endogenous firm creation stems from two credit market frictions first entrepreneurs search for a lending relationship with a bank second an optimal debt contract with monitoring is implemented we analyze the interplay between both frictions and embed it into an otherwise standard business cycle model which we estimate with bayesian techniques we find that uncertainty shocks are a prime contributor to business cycle fluctuations in the us not only for macro financial aggregates but also for firm creation moreover we point out that the credit search friction dampens the financial accelerator mechanism because default may imply the end of the lending relationship

bad times good credit banks limited knowledge about borrowers creditworthiness constitutes an important friction in credit markets is this friction deeper in recessions thereby contributing to cyclical swings in credit or is the friction reduced as bad times reveal information about firm quality we test these alternative hypotheses using internal ratings data from a large swedish cross border bank and credit scores from a credit bureau the ability to classify corporate borrowers by credit quality is greater during bad times and worse during good times soft and hard information measures both display countercyclical patterns our results suggest that information frictions in corporate credit markets are intrinsically countercyclical and not due to cyclical variation in monitoring effort the presence of countercyclical information frictions provides a rationale for countercyclical provisions or capital in banks to smooth credit cycles

debt deleveraging and the liquidity trap a fisher minsky koo approach in this paper we present a simple new keynesian style model of debt driven slumps that is situations in which an overhang of debt on the part of some agents who are forced into rapid deleveraging is depressing aggregate demand making some agents debt constrained is a surprisingly powerful assumption fisherian debt deflation the possibility of a liquidity trap the paradox of thrift a keynesiantype multiplier and a rationale for expansionary fiscal policy all emerge naturally from the model we argue that this approach sheds considerable light both on current economic difficulties and on historical episodes including japan s lost decade now in its 18th year and the great depression itself

this time is the same using bank performance in 1998 to explain bank performance during the recent financial crisis are some banks prone to perform poorly during crises if yes why in this paper we show that a bank s stock return performance during the 1998 crisis predicts its stock return performance and probability of failure during the recent financial crisis this effect is economically large our findings are consistent with persistence in a bank s risk culture and or aspects of its business model that make its performance sensitive to crises banks that relied more on short term funding had more leverage and grew more are more likely to be banks that performed poorly in both crises

understanding the macroeconomic impact of illiquidity shocks in the united states in this paper we empirically investigate the role of stock market illiquidity shocks stemming from amihud s illiquidity measure in explaining u s macroeconomic fluctuations from 1973 to 2018 we find that the impact of illiquidity shocks on economic activity is substantial and historical decomposition analysis shows that cumulative illiquidity shocks were an essential contributor to the prolonged economic slump of the great recession moreover our identified illiquidity shocks represent a distinct source of macroeconomic instability this suggests that illiquidity shocks measured by the stock price impacts may contain more information than other types of shocks in recent studies such as financial shocks and uncertainty shocks jel c32 e32

the international transmission of financial shocks the case of japan one of the more dramatic financial events of the late 1980s and early 1990s was the surge in japanese stock prices that was immediately followed by a very sharp decline of more than 50 percent while the unprecedented fluctuations in japanese stock prices were domestic financial shocks the unique institutional characteristics of the japanese economy produce a framework that is particularly suited to the transmission of such shocks to other countries through the behavior of the japanese banking system the large size of japanese bank lending operations in the united states enables us to use u s banking data to investigate the extent to which this domestic japanese financial shock was transmitted to the united states as well as to identify a supply shock to u s bank lending that is independent of u s loan demand we find that binding risk based capital requirements associated with the decline in the japanese stock market resulted in a decline in commercial lending by japanese banks in the united states that was both economically and statistically significant this finding has added importance given the severe real estate loan problems currently faced by japanese banks how japanese bank regulators decide to resolve these problems will have significant implications for credit availability in the united states as well as in other countries with a significant japanese bank presence

household wealth and macroeconomic activity 2008 2013 this paper provides estimates of the effects of the fall in financial and housing wealth in 2008 09 on overall macroeconomic activity when the wealth losses are run through a structural macroeconometric model it is estimated that the fall in wealth contributed about 2 1 percentage points to the rise in the unemployment rate in 2009 and about 3 3 points in 2010 the contribution to the fall in real gdp was 4 5 and 5 4 in the 2 years these estimates account for most but not all of the recessionary increase in unemployment the remaining increase in unemployment may have resulted more directly from financial stresses but little evidence is found for this in this study

international shock transmission after the lehman brothers collapse evidence from syndicated lending after lehman brothers filed for bankruptcy in september 2008 cross border bank lending contracted sharply to explain the severity and variation in this contraction we analyze detailed data on cross border syndicated lending by 75 banks to 59 countries we find that banks that had to write down sub prime assets refinance large amounts of long term debt and experienced sharp declines in their market to book ratio transmitted these shocks across borders by curtailing their lending abroad while shocked banks differentiated between countries in much the same way as less constrained banks they restricted their lending more to small borrowers

small bank comparative advantages in alleviating financial constraints and providing liquidity insurance over time we use novel monthly survey data from 1993 to 2012 on small business managerial perceptions of financial constraints and other conditions matched with information on banks in their local markets the data suggest that small banks have comparative advantages in alleviating these constraints these advantages tend to be greater during adverse economic conditions and do not appear to decrease or increase secularly small banks also appear to have comparative advantages in providing liquidity insurance to small business customers of large banks experiencing liquidity shocks during financial crises our findings suggest a source of social costs from ongoing consolidation of the banking industry received december 28 2015 editorial decision january 13 2017 by editor philip strahan

firing the wrong workers financing constraints and labor misallocation abstract firms consider wages current and expected productivity as well as firing and hiring costs when firing a worker financing constraints distort this intertemporal trade off leading firms to sub optimally fire short tenured workers with high future expected productivity we provide empirical evidence of this distortion using matched employer employee data from the swedish population between 2000 and 2010 we propose a new empirical strategy that uses credit ratings to identify financing constraints and uses exchange rates and trade data to identify demand shocks our empirical results identify an important new misallocation effect of financial frictions that operates within firms across different types of workers

investment banks as corporate monitors in the early twentieth century united states we study the effect of financial relationships on firms investment decisions and access to external finance in the early twentieth century securities underwriters commonly held directorships with american corporations section 10 of the clayton antitrust act prohibited bankers from serving on the boards of railroads for which they underwrote securities we find that following the implementation of section 10 railroads with strong preexisting relationships with underwriters saw declines in their investment rates valuations and leverage and increases in their costs of external funds reassuringly we do not observe similar effects among industrials and utilities which were not subject to section 10 our results are consistent with underwriters on corporate boards acting as delegated monitors and highlight the potential for regulations intended to address conflicts of interest to disrupt valuable information flows

facts and challenges from the great recession for forecasting and macroeconomic modeling this paper provides a survey of business cycle facts updated to take account of recent data emphasis is given to the great recession which was unlike most other postwar recessions in the united states in being driven by deleveraging and financial market factors we document how recessions with financial market origins are different from those driven by supply or monetary policy shocks this helps explain why economic models and predictors that work well at some times do poorly at other times we discuss challenges for forecasters and empirical researchers in light of the updated business cycle facts

financial frictions and employment during the great depression abstract we provide new evidence that a disruption in credit supply played a quantitatively significant role in the unprecedented contraction of employment during the great depression using a novel hand collected dataset of large industrial firms our identification strategy exploits preexisting variation in the need to raise external funds at a time when public bond markets essentially froze local bank failures inhibited firms ability to substitute public debt for private debt which exacerbated financial constraints we estimate a large and negative causal effect of financing frictions on firm employment we find that the lack of access to credit likely accounted for a substantial fraction of the aggregate decline in employment of large firms between 1928 and 1933

got rejected real effects of not getting a loan using a lender cutoff rule that generates plausibly exogenous variation in credit supply i investigate a new channel through which funding shocks are transmitted to the real economy based on a sample of more than 15 000 loan applications from small and medium sized enterprises i find that precautionary savings motives can aggravate real effects low liquidity firms whose loan applications were rejected increase cash holdings and cut noncash assets in excess of the requested loan amount these results point to the amplifying effect of precautionary savings motives in the transmission of credit supply shocks received december 11 2016 editorial decision february 22 2018 by editor philip strahan

cyclicality of credit supply firm level evidence abstract we quantify fluctuations in bank loan supply in the time series by studying firms substitution between loans and bonds using firm level data any firm that raises new debt must have a positive demand for external funds conditional on the issuance of new debt we interpret firms switching from loans to bonds as a contraction in bank credit supply we find strong evidence of this substitution at times that are characterized by tight lending standards depressed aggregate lending poor bank performance and tight monetary policy we show that this substitution behavior has strong predictive power for bank borrowing and investments by small firms

do banking crises improve democracy we study the relationship between banking crises and the level of democracy we use an event study method on a sample of up to 129 countries over the period 1975 2010 featuring 94 systemic banking crises we find that banking crises are followed by an improvement in democracy and report evidence suggesting that the relation may be causal the bulk of the improvement takes place between 3 and 10 years after the banking crisis the impact of a banking crisis is greater in non democratic countries and when the banking crisis is severe we explain this finding by the fact that banking crises create windows of opportunity to contest autocratic regimes

costly monitoring loan contracts and equilibrium credit rationing this paper develops a model with asymmetrically informed agents and costly monitoring of loan contracts where an equilibrium can exhibit credit rationing borrowers are identical ex ante but some receive loans and others do not in contrast to existing credit rationing theories rationing does not occur here due to inflexible prices adverse selection or moral hazard optimizing behaviour produces a standard debt contract in equilibrium the aggregate quantity of loans and equilibrium interest rates respond differently depending on whether there is rationing in equilibrium

option price without expected utility abstract we consider the meaning of the option price commonly acknowledged as the preferred ex ante welfare measure in the rank dependent expected utility rdeu framework the importance of this pertains to performing benefit cost analysis when rdeu maximizers are prevalent in society

uncertainty and the geography of the great recession we document the link between increased levels of economic and policy uncertainty and unemployment at the state level during the 2007 2009 recession the cross sectional variation in uncertainty robustly matches the distribution of employment outcomes during this period when we instrument for this cross sectional variation using preexisting institutions we find evidence for a causal role for uncertainty in increasing unemployment a simple model of hiring and firing under uncertainty rationalizes these results and the within state distribution of effects across industries occupations and individuals is consistent with this model s predictions together these results suggest that increased uncertainty contributed to the severity of the great recession

the employment effects of credit market disruptions firm level evidence from the 2008 9 financial crisis this article investigates the effect of bank lending frictions on employment outcomes i construct a new data set that combines information on banking relationships and employment at 2 000 nonfinancial firms during the 2008 9 crisis the article first verifies empirically the importance of banking relationships which imply a cost to borrowers who switch lenders i then use the dispersion in lender health following the lehman crisis as a source of exogenous variation in the availability of credit to borrowers i find that credit matters firms that had precrisis relationships with less healthy lenders had a lower likelihood of obtaining a loan following the lehman bankruptcy paid a higher interest rate if they did borrow and reduced employment by more compared to precrisis clients of healthier lenders consistent with frictions deriving from asymmetric information the effects vary by firm type lender health has an economically and statistically significant effect on employment at small and medium firms but the data cannot reject the hypothesis of no effect at the largest or most transparent firms abstracting from general equilibrium effects i find that the withdrawal of credit accounts for between one third and one half of the employment decline at small and medium firms in the sample in the year

are banks really special new evidence from the fdic induced failure of healthy banks the fdic used cross guarantees in order to close 38 subsidiaries of first republicbank corporation in 1988 and 18 subsidiaries of first city bankcorporation in 1992 when lead banks from each of these texas based bank holding companies were declared insolvent i use this plausibly exogenous failure of otherwise healthy subsidiary banks as a natural experiment in order to study the impact of bank failure on local area real economic activity the resolution of these institutions was associated with a significant decline in failed bank lending that led to a permanent reduction in real county income of about 3 percent jel codes e5 g18 g33 keywords bank failures cross guarantee uniqueness of banks

does basel ii affect the market valuation of discretionary loan loss provisions we use a sample of banks from 24 european countries to investigate whether the adoption of the basel ii capital accord in 2008 affects the market valuation of discretionary loan loss provisions dllps although basel ii lowers the incentives of internal ratings based irb banks to recognize income increasing dllps in an opportunistic manner it has no such impact on the remaining banks which adopt the standardized methodology we use this setup in a difference in difference did design where standardized banks act as a control group our evidence supports the three hypotheses that for irb relative to standardized banks basel ii is associated with i less income increasing dllps and ii less income smoothing via dllps which enhances the informational content of dllps about future loan losses and leads to iii higher market valuation of dllps our findings are timely and have policy implications for future regulatory developments in the banking industry

unanticipated monetary growth output and the price level u k 1946 1977 abstract this paper develops and estimates using annual data from 1946 1977 a three equation model of the u k economy in which output is affected only by unanticipated monetary growth whereas the price level is influenced by both anticipated and unanticipated changes in money supply expectations of monetary growth are assumed to be muth rational the model was estimated using efficient procedures and tests of the over identifying restrictions were generally favourable to model specification some features of the price equation are unsatisfactory and the results in this section must be considered tentative

banking on the boom tripped by the bust banks and the world war i agricultural price shock bank lending booms and asset price booms are often intertwined although a fundamental shock might trigger an asset boom aggressive lending can push asset prices higher leading to more lending and so on such a dynamic seems to have characterized the agricultural land boom surrounding world war i this paper examines i how banks responded to the asset price boom and how they were affected by the bust ii how various banking regulations and policies influenced those effects and iii how bank lending contributed to rising farm land values in the boom and how bank closures contributed to falling prices in the bust we find that rising crop prices encouraged bank entry and balance sheet expansion in agriculture counties state deposit insurance systems amplified the impact of rising crop prices on the size and risk of bank portfolios while higher minimum capital requirements dampened the effects further increases in county farm land values and mortgage debt were correlated with the number of local banks ex ante and increases in bank loans during the boom when farm land prices collapsed banks that had responded most aggressively to the asset boom had a higher probability of closing while counties with more bank closures experienced larger declines in land prices than can be explained by falling crop prices alone

from financial crisis to great recession the role of globalized banks this paper provides evidence of the role of globalized banks in transmitting financial stresses to the real economy during the global financial crisis a novel dataset is constructed from quarterly balance sheet reports provided by all uk resident banks to the bank of england i find that the shock to bank funding from non resident creditors was transmitted domestically through a significant reduction in bank credit supply resident subsidiaries and branches of foreign owned banks reduced lending by a larger amount than domestically owned banks while the latter calibrated the reduction in domestic lending more closely to the size of the funding shock