the control of technology alliances an empirical analysis of the biotechnology industry we examine the determinants of control rights in biotechnology alliances through three case studies and a quantitative analysis aghion and tirole 1994 argue that control rights will be assigned so as to maximize the value of the final output as long as the r d firm has sufficient financial resources consistent with this framework the allocation of control rights to the r d firm increases with the firm s financial resources the empirical evidence regarding the relationship between control rights and the stage of the project at the time the alliance is signed is more ambiguous

the structure of licensing contracts industrial organization theory has explored several issues related to licensing but empirical analyses are extremely rare we amass a new and detailed dataset on licensing contracts and use it to present some simple facts concerning licensing behavior our analysis reveals robust cross industries differences in several contractual features such as exclusivity cross licensing ex ante versus ex post technology transfers and licensing to related versus unrelated parties we offer an interpretation of these facts based on cross industry variation in the strength of intellectual property rights

production function regressions returns to scale and externalities a number of recent papers have used simple linear regressions in an attempt to identify market structure the extent of returns to scale and possible external effects in u s manufacturing industries the results obtained from these regressions have important implications for several branches of modern macroeconomics as a result the macro literature frequently cites specific numerical evidence from caballero and lyons 1992 and hall 1990 which suggests that there are quantitatively significant increasing returns to scale or external effects in u s manufacturing in contrast it is the argument of this paper that this evidence is not convincing the most robust evidence suggests that the typical u s manufacturing industry displays constant returns with no external effects on the other hand there is significant heterogeneity across industries

empirical implications of alternative models of firm dynamics abstract this paper considers two models of firm behavior that allow for heterogeneity among firms idiosyncratic or firm specific sources of uncertainty and discrete outcomes exit and or entry both the characteristics of firm level panel data sets and the nature of the questions we characteristically ask of them imply that models with these features are likely to underlie most detailed empirical work on microdata sets the models we consider are a bayesian learning model due to jovanovic 20 and a model of research and exploration due to ericson and pakes 11 the paper provides a simple set of empirical procedures to help determine which if either of these two models might be appropriate for alternative data sets we conclude by checking for the implications of the two models on an eight year panel of wisconsin firms the results indicate that one model is consistent with the data on manufacturing firms while the other is consistent with the data on retail trade journal of economic literature classification numbers c52 l60 l80

total factor productivity and the measurement of technological change tfp is interpreted in the literature in different mutually contradictory ways changes in tfp are shown to measure not technological change only the super normal returns to investing in such change returns that exceed the full opportunity cost of the activity thus in the limit technological change can proceed with unchanged tfp measuring the effects of technological change instead requires counterfactual estimates reasons why changes in tfp are imperfect measures of super normal returns are also studied reasons connected with the timing of output responses the treatment of r d in the national accounts the omission of resource inputs and two types of aggregation la productivite totale des facteurs et la mesure du changement technologique la productivite totale des facteurs ptf est interpretee dans la litterature de manieres differentes et mutuellement contradictoires on montre que les changements dans la ptf ne mesurent pas le changement technologique mais seulement les rendements supra normaux sur les investissements dans de tels changements des rendements qui depassent le plein cout d opportunite de cette activite donc a la limite le changement technologique peut proceder sans que la ptf change mesurer les effets du changement technique reclame des evaluations d hypotheses de rechange les raisons pour lesquelles les changements dans la ptf sont des mesures imparfaites des rendements supra normaux sont aussi etudiees raisons connectees avec la reponse des niveaux de production le traitement de la r d dans les comptes nationaux l omission des intrants de ressources et deux types d agregation

how valuable is patent protection estimates by technology field i present evidence on the private value of patent rights in france for different technology fields and nationalities of ownership using nonparametric techniques and a parametric model of patent renewal i find that the distribution of the value of patent rights is highly skewed that patent protection is a significant but not the major source of private returns to r d and that these characteristics vary across technology fields i compute the r d cash subsidy that is equivalent to the value of patent rights measure the variations in value of time technology fields and nationalities and show that these differences are correlated with patent grant rates

patent protection in the shadow of infringement simulation estimations of patent value empirical estimates of the private value of patent protection are derived for four technology areas computers textiles combustion engines and pharmaceuticals using new patent data for west germany 1953 1988 patentees must pay renewal fees to keep their patents in force as well as legal expenses in order to enforce them a dynamic stochastic discrete choice model of optimal renewal decisions is developed incorporating both learning and depreciation as well as the potential need to prosecute infringement the evolution of the distribution of returns over the life of a group of patents is calculated for each technology using a minimum distance simulation estimator results indicate that the aggregate value of protection generated per year is on the order of 10 of related r d expenditure

agricultural biotechnology s complementary intellectual assets we formulate and test a hypothesis for the dramatic restructur ing that the plant breeding and seed industry has recently undergone the reorganization can be explained in part by the desire to exploit comple mentarities between intellectual assets needed to create genetically mod ified organisms this hypothesis is tested using data on agricultural biotechnology patents notices for field tests of genetically modified organisms and firm characteristics the presence of complementarities is identified with a positive covariance in the unexplained variation of asset holdings results indicate that coordination of complementary assets has increased under the consolidation of the industry ne of the central problems in the economics of inno vation concerns how industries change as they absorb fundamental research breakthroughs rarely has change been more pronounced than in agriculture following the introduction of recombinant dna technology and affiliated techniques of genetic engineering by offering breeders the ability to alter plant traits by directly manipulating se quences of genetic code tools of agricultural biotechnology change the possibilities for crop improvement profoundly the new techniques enhance the speed and precision of agricultural research and development r d while ex panding the space of potential new products seed firms now offer farmers crop varieties embodying new ap proaches for controlling pests managing physical stresses on plants increasing crop yields and growing differenti ated quality enhanced crops concurrent with these technical changes in the r d process the agricultural inputs industry has over the past two decades witnessed a comprehensive restructuring sev eral large chemical firms including monsanto dow and dupont moved aggressively into plant biotechnology mak ing huge investments in the life sciences as newly minted agronomic systems companies these firms acquired all of the large national seed firms in north america including pioneer dekalb asgrow garst and others meanwhile the research intensive agricultural biotechnology sector from its appearance in the 1980s as a large set of small startup firms had by the end of the 1990s already reached a second stage with most of the startups either folded or acquired by the new agronomic systems giants the industry s consoli dation was surprising not only for its rapid pace and com prehensive scope but also for the extremely high valuations at which some firms were acquired in 1997 for example monsanto acquired holdens foundation seeds of wil liamsburg iowa together with two marketing subsidiaries for 1 02 billion 25 times the annual sales of the mature privately held firm whose revenues derived entirely from the breeding and distribution of corn seed the emergent industry structure with a relatively small number of tightly woven alliances each organized around a major life sciences firm each vertically integrated from basic r d through to marketing stands in contrast to the more diffuse structure of twenty years ago this structure is likewise noteworthy when one considers trends in other research intensive fields the pharmaceutical biotechnology industry for example maintains a large number of free standing firms specializing in r d and earning revenues through various licensing agreements majewski 1998 hall and ziedonis 2001 observe that the u s semiconduc

inducement prizes and innovation we examine the effect of prizes on innovation using data on awards for technological development offered by the royal agricultural society of england at annual competitions between 1839 and 1939 we find large effects of the prizes on competitive entry and we also detect an impact on patents especially when prize categories were set by a strict rotation scheme thereby mitigating the potentially confounding effect that they targeted only hot technology sectors prizes encouraged competition and medals were more important than monetary awards the boost to innovation we observe cannot be explained by the re direction of existing inventive activity

characteristics of patent litigation a window on competition we examine the patenting behavior of firms in an industry characterized by rapid technological change and cumulative innovation recent survey evidence suggests that semiconductor firms do not rely heavily on patents to appropriate returns to r d yet the propensity of semiconductor firms to patent has risen dramatically since the mid 1980s we explore this apparent paradox by conducting interviews with industry representatives and analyzing the patenting behavior of 95 u s semiconductor firms during 1979 1995 the results suggest that the 1980s strengthening of u s patent rights spawned patent portfolio races among capital intensive firms but it also facilitated entry by specialized design firms copyright 2001 by the rand corporation

licensing in the theory of innovation this article analyzes licensing in a noncooperative r d game we ask two questions what are the incentives for licensing a production technology and what is the impact of licensing on the pattern of innovation and the consequent evolution of industry costs and market structure the gainsfrom trading information through licensing contracts are achieved through the replacement of inefficient production techniques the ex post incentive and the elimination of inefficient research expenditures the ex ante incentive in a duopoly the availability of licensing encourages research when the firms initial production technologies are close in costs and discourages research when initial costs are asymmetric

growth economies of scale and targeting in japan 1955 1990 this paper explores the usage of various industrial policy tools in japan contrary to the conventional wisdom the authors find that a disproportionate amount of japanese targeting occurred in low growth sectors and sectors with decreasing returns to scale in addition they find no evidence that productivity was enhanced as a result of industrial policy measures copyright 1996 by mit press

non capital investment costs and the adoption of cad and cnc in the u s metalworking industries many studies have shown that firm size is the strongest and most consistent predictor of the adoption of technological innovations but the causes for this relationship are debated i investigate the relationships between various size measures and the adoption of computer aided design cad and computer numerically controlled cnc machine tools plant size is the dominant factor in predicting cad and cnc adoption other measures such as firm size or multiplant operations have independent effects that are not present after controlling for plant size i test four potential explanations for the results noncapital cost spreading equipment replacement risk aversion and learning there is support only for the first explanation

the dynamics of the transfer and renewal of patents this article explores new data on the transfer and renewal of u s patents and interprets this new evidence using a model of patent transfers and renewal we find that the proportion of transferred patents is large and differs across technology fields and especially type of patentees we also find that the probability of a patent being traded depends on a number of factors the age of the patent the number of citations received by a given age the patent generality and whether the patent has been previously traded or not these findings are consistent with the predictions of a model of patent transfers and renewals

returns to scale concept estimation and analysis of japan s turbulent 1964 88 economy there is policy interest in factoring productivity growth into technical progress and returns to scale components our approach uses exact index number methods to reduce the parameters that must be estimated and allows us to exploit the cross sectional dimension of plant level panel data we show that the same equation can also be used to estimate harberger scale economies and technical progress indicators that require fewer assumptions estimates of the elasticity of scale for japanese establishments in three major industries over 1964 88 are presented our study spans the high growth era of the 1960s two oil shocks and other exogenous shocks il y a interet en politique publique a identifier les composantes de la croissance de la productivite attribuables au progres technique et aux rendements a l echelle l approche utilise les methodes des nombres indices exacts pour reduire les parametres qui doivent etres estimes et pouvoir exploiter la dimension transversale des donnees de panel au niveau de l etablissement on montre que la meme equation peut etre utilisee pour estimer les indicateurs d economies d echelle et de progres technique a la harberger lesquels necessitent un plus petit nombre de postulats on presente des evaluations de l elasticite d echelle pour des etablissements japonais dans trois industries importantes entre 1964 et 1988 l etude couvre la periode de forte croissance des annees 1960 celle des deux chocs petroliers et d autres chocs exogenes

patents and cumulative innovation causal evidence from the courts cumulative innovation is central to economic growth do patent rights facilitate or impede such follow on innovation this paper studies the effect of removing patent protection through court invalidation on the subsequent research related to the focal patent as measured by later citations we exploit random allocation of judges at the u s court of appeal for the federal circuit to control for the endogeneity of patent invalidation we find that patent invalidation leads to a 50 percent increase in subsequent citations to the focal patent on average but the impact is highly heterogeneous patent rights appear to block follow on innovation only in the technology fields of computers electronics and medical instruments moreover the effect is entirely driven by invalidation of patents owned by large patentees that triggers entry of small innovators suggesting that patents may impede the democratization of innovation

managers investors and crises mutual fund strategies in emerging markets the authors address the trading strategies of mutual funds in emerging markets the data set they develop permits analyses of these strategies at the level of individual portfolios a methodologically novel feature of their analysis they disentangle the behavior of fund managers from that of investors for both managers and investors they strongly reject the null hypothesis of no momentum trading funds momentum trading is positive they systematically buy winners and sell losers contemporaneous momentum trading buying current winners and selling current losers is stronger during crises and stronger for fund investors than for fund managers lagged momentum trading buying past winners and selling past losers is stronger during noncrises and stronger for fund managers investors also engage in contagion trading selling assets from one country when asset prices fall in another these findings are based on data about mutual funds that represent only 10 percent of the market capitalization in the countries considered were it a larger share of the market finding counterparties for their trades the investors who buy when they sell and sell when they buy would be difficult and the premise that funds respond to contemporaneous returns rather than causing them would become tenuous

wal mart innovation and productivity a viewpoint abstract technology effects business process development and productivity growth are considered in the context of a single company wal mart the starting point is the 2001 mckinsey global institute report which finds that over 1995 2000 a quarter of u s productivity growth is attributable to the retail industry and almost a sixth of that is attributable to wal mart wal mart is interesting as well because of its rapid growth in canada this is now canada s largest private sector employer we also consider other evidence relevant to public policy formation concerning wal mart and conclude with a discussion of options for partially filling important data gaps

estimation of r d depreciation rates a suggested methodology and preliminary application the 2008 version of the sna will recommend capitalization of r d expenditures to implement this recommendation measures for the stock of r d capital must be constructed and this implies a need to determine the depreciation rate of r d capital in this paper we develop a simple model based on a production function method that allows for monopolistic competition to estimate the annual depreciation rate of r d capital we treat r d capital as a technology shifter instead of as an explicit input factor both the r d stock and the time variable are used to capture technological progress modeling r d capital in this manner can better represent the role r d plays in economic growth estimated r d depreciation rates and markup factors are presented for the u s manufacturing sector and four u s knowledge intensive industries namely chemical products sic 28 non electrical machinery sic 35 electrical products sic 36 and transportation equipment sic 37

hybrid innovation in meiji japan japan s hybrid innovation system during the meiji era provides a useful laboratory for examining the effectiveness of complementary incentives to patents patents were introduced in 1885 and by 1911 1 2 million mostly nonpecuniary prizes were awarded at 8 503 competitions prizes provided a strong boost to patents especially in less developed prefectures and they also induced large spillovers of technical knowledge in prefectures adjacent to those with prizes relative to distant control prefectures without prizes linking competition expenditures with the expected market value of patents induced by the prizes permits a cost benefit assessment of the prize competitions to be made

the sale of ideas strategic disclosure property rights and contracting ideas are difficult to sell when buyers cannot assess an idea s value before it is revealed and sellers cannot protect a revealed idea these problems exist in a variety of intellectual property sales ranging from pure ideas to poorly protected inventions and reflect the nonverifiability of key elements of an intellectual property sale an expropriable partial disclosure can be used as a signal allowing the seller to obtain payment based on the value of the remaining undisclosed know how we examine contracting after the disclosure and find that seller wealth is pivotal in supporting a partial disclosure equilibrium and in determining the payoff size

volumes of evidence examining technical change in the last century through a new lens abstract new indicators of technical change based on titles included in the catalogue of the library of congress and on amazon com s website are presented along with evidence that they do capture technological innovation the indicators are used to chart the pattern and nature of technical change over the last century a strong causal relationship is found to exist between these indicators and changes in tfp and output per capita moreover innovations in some subgroups have had a greater impact on output and productivity than in others and the key players change over time information technologies are currently the dominant subgroup jel classificatiion e32 o3 o4 n1

a penny for your quotes patent citations and the value of innovations the use ofpatents in economic research has been seriously hindered by the fact that patents vary enormously in their importance or value and hence simple patent counts cannot be informative about innovative output the purpose of this article is to put forward patent counts weighted by citations as indicators of the value of innovations thereby overcoming the limitations of simple counts the empirical analysis of a particular innovation computed tomography scanners indeed shows a close association between citation based patent indices and independent measures of the social value of innovations in that field moreover the weighting scheme appears to be nonlinear increasing in the number of citations implying that the informational content of citations rises at the margin as in previous studies simple patent counts are found to be highly correlated with contemporaneous rd however here the association is within afield over time rather than cross sectional

estimates of the value of patent rights in european countries during the post 1950 period this paper examines the distribution of the values of patent rights in the united kingdom france and germany during the post 1950 period these values are inferred from the behavior of patentees with respect to payment of renewal fees on their patents a simple economic model of renewal decisions is combined with data on the proportion of patents renewed at alternative ages and the renewal fee schedules to produce estimates of the distribution and the total value of patent rights in these countries moreover the data indicate that there have been changes in the value distribution and we follow these changes over the period the empirical results of particular interest concern the total value of patent rights and the relationship between changes in it and changes in the quantity of patents the skew in the distribution of patent values and the rate of obsolescence on the returns to patents

how to license intangible property we examine the optimal licensing strategy of a research lab selling to firms who are product market competitors we consider an independent lab as well as a research joint venture we show that 1 demands are interdependent and hence the standard price mechanism is not the profit maximizing licensing strategy 2 the seller s incentives to develop the innovation may be excessive 3 the seller s incentives to disseminate the innovation typically are too low 4 larger ventures are less likely to develop the innovation and more likely to restrict its dissemination in those cases where development occurs and 5 a downstream firm that is not a member of the research venture is worse off as a result of the innovation

patents as options some estimates of the value of holding european patent stocks in many countries holders of patents must pay an annual renewal fee in order to keep their patents in force this paper uses data on the proportion of patents renewed and the renewal fees faced by post world war ii cohorts of patents in france the united kingdom and germany in conjunction with a model of patent holders renewal decisions to estimate the returns earned from holding patents in these countries since patents are often applied for at a nearly stage in the innovation process the model allows agents to be uncertain about the sequence of returns that will be earned if the patent is kept inforce formally then the paper presents and solves a discrete choice optimal stochastic control model derives the implications of the model on aggregate behaviour and then estimates the parameters of the model from aggregate data the estimates enable a detailed description of the evolution of the distribution of returns earned from holding patents over their life spans and calculations of both the annual returns earned from holding the patents still in force or the patent stocks in the alternative countries and the distribution of the discounted value of returns earned from holding the patents in a cohort this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

novelty and disclosure in patent law the stringency of the novelty requirement in patent law affects the pace of innovation because it affects the amount of technical information that is disclosed among firms it also affects ex ante profitability of research we compare weak and strong novelty requirements from the standpoint of social efficiency we ask how our answer depends on the rule that determines which firm gets a patent when two firms have patents pending on the same technology the possible rules are first to invent which applies in the u s and first to file which applies everywhere else

licensing to enhance demand for new technologies this article presents a model in which licensing competitors expands demand for a new proprietary product and therefore may be a profit maximizing strategy for the licensor even when licensing increases industry cost in the model buyers care about price and quality sellers can contract on price but not on quality and a single supplier has monopoly power licensing induces quality competition and allows the supplying firms to make a quality commitment that would not be credible for a single firm as a result licensing increases industry demand and may generate an increase in industry revenue sufficient to offset any increase in industry cost some of the characteristics of the model are informed by observations in the semiconductor industry

competition in japan japan registered a remarkable 6 5 percent rate of economic growth from 1955 to 1990 catching up with high income western countries in its level of economic development during the 1950s 1960s 1970s and into the 1980s japan s share of world exports rose dramatically from 2 9 percent in 1960 to 6 1 percent in 1970 8 2 percent in 1980 and a peak of 9 8 percent in 1985 porter takeuchi and sakakibara 2000 japanese firms were increasingly successful internationally in large visible industries such as automobiles semiconductors and consumer electronics the striking economic success of japan was widely attributed to a set of economic institutions and policies that encouraged collaboration and limited competition the japanese case then called into question many of the bedrock assumptions of competition thinking it seemed to show that there was a different path to economic prosperity this article begins by examining competition in japan and the supporting policies and institutions during the twentieth century many factors seem to suggest that competition in japan has been less intense but there is an awkward complication the empirical evidence about the intensity of competition in japanese industry does not support the conclusion the story clearly is more complicated we seek to reconcile the apparent differences between policy and institutional circumstances and the empirical evidence by examining the types of competition that prevail across japanese industries and the underlying causes japan indeed pursued an array of policies that limited competition but these policies were not applied throughout the economy in fact those industries in which competition