energy consumption and economic growth relationship evidence from panel data for low and middle income countries abstract this paper uses the panel data of energy consumption ec and economic growth gdp for 51 countries from 1971 to 2005 these countries are divided into three groups low income group lower middle income group and upper middle income group countries firstly a relationship between energy consumption and economic growth is investigated by employing pedroni 1999 panel cointegration method secondly panel causality test is applied to investigate the way of causality between the energy consumption and economic growth finally we test whether there is a strong or weak relationship between these variables by using pedroni 2001 method the empirical results of this study are as follows i energy consumption and gdp are cointegrated for all three income group countries ii the panel causality test results reveal that there is long run granger causality running from gdp to ec for low income countries and there is bidirectional causality between ec and gdp for middle income countries iii the estimated cointegration factor is not close to 1 in other words no strong relation is found between energy consumption and economic growth for all income groups considered in this study the findings of this study have important policy implications and it shows that this issue still deserves further attention in future research

the impacts of tourism energy consumption and political instability on economic growth in the mena countries using panel data of 24 countries in the middle east and north african mena region from 2001 to 2009 the purpose of this study is to examine the impacts of tourism energy consumption and political instability on economic growth within the neoclassical growth framework to address the objective of this study we utilise both the static panel data approach as well as the dynamic generalised method of moments gmm estimator to examine the impact of candidate variables our results show that energy consumption and tourism significantly contribute to the economic growth of countries in the mena region hence our study lends some support to the existence of the tourism led growth and energy led growth hypotheses in the region in line with our expectation our estimation results also reveal that political instability impedes the process of economic growth and development in the mena region therefore macroeconomic policies to promote expansion in tourism and energy consumption will directly stimulate economic growth additionally efforts to help the region overcome its history of political instability would attract more international tourist arrivals and further invigorate economic growth

causal relationship between trade openness economic growth and energy consumption a panel data analysis of asian countries abstract this paper explores the causal relationship between economic growth trade openness and energy consumption using data of 15 asian countries the study covers the period of 1980 2011 we have applied panel cointegration and causality approaches to examine the long run and causal relationship between variables empirical results confirm the presence of cointegration between variables the impact of economic growth and trade openness on energy consumption is found to be positive the panel granger causality analysis reveals the bidirectional causality between economic growth and energy consumption trade openness and energy consumption

energy and physical capital a case of non classical dynamics we study the importance of considering different energy requirements for physical capital and final good production in an overlapping generations olg resource economy in contrast to the standard olg framework but consistently with the empirical evidence we assume that the accumulation of physical capital requires more energy than the production of consumption goods focusing on exhaustible energy resources we find that olg equilibria can exhibit non classical dynamics the economy generates complex dynamics where differing from the response predicted by the standard approach resource prices may not increase monotonically this result illustrates that the technological assumptions behind the energy inputs should be taken with caution in particular on dynamic analyses involving exhaustible energy resources

the nexus between financial development and energy consumption in the eu a dynamic panel data analysis abstract the relationship between financial development and energy consumption has newly started to be discussed in energy economics literature this paper investigates this issue in the eu over the period 1990 2011 by using system gmm model no significant relationship is found in the eu27 the empirical results however provide strong evidence of the impact of the financial development on energy consumption in the old members greater financial development leads to an increase in energy consumption regardless of whether financial development stems from banking sector or stock market by contrast we find for the new members that the impact of financial development on energy consumption depends on how financial development is measured using bankindex the impact of financial development displays an inverted u shaped pattern while no significant relationship is detected once it is measured using stockindex

energy consumption and gdp in developing countries a cointegrated panel analysis in this paper we re investigate the co movement and the causality relationship between energy consumption and gdp in 18 developing countries using data for the period 1975 to 2001 recently developed tests for the panel unit root heterogeneous panel cointegration and panel based error correction models are employed the empirical results provide clear support of a long run cointegration relationship after allowing for the heterogeneous country effect the long run relationship is estimated using a full modified ols the evidence shows that long run and short run causalities run from energy consumption to gdp but not vice versa this result indicates that energy conservation may harm economic growth in developing countries regardless of being transitory or permanent

pollution private investment in healthcare and environmental policy in this paper we demonstrate that in a two period overlapping generations model the relationship between environmental taxation and economic activity output level and growth has an inverted u shape when we take into account the detrimental impact of pollution on health and the individual decision of each working age agent to improve her health we also demonstrate that the link between environmental tax and lifetime welfare also has an inverted u shape and that a tighter environmental policy might enhance economic activity while reducing steady state lifetime welfare finally we investigate the social optimum and the determinants of the optimal environmental tax

energy consumption and gdp causality relationship in g 7 countries and emerging markets abstract the causality relationship between energy consumption and income is a well studied topic in energy economics this paper studies the time series properties of energy consumption and gdp and reexamines the causality relationship between the two series in the top 10 emerging markets excluding china due to lack of data and g 7 countries we discover bi directional causality in argentina causality running from gdp to energy consumption in italy and korea and from energy consumption to gdp in turkey france germany and japan hence energy conservation may harm economic growth in the last four countries

how to avoid borrowed plumes in academia abstract publications in top journals today have a powerful influence on academic careers although there is much criticism of using journal rankings to evaluate individual articles we ask why this practice of performance evaluation is still so influential we suggest this is the case because a majority of authors benefit from the present system due to the extreme skewness of citation distributions performance paradox effects aggravate the problem three extant suggestions for reforming performance management are critically discussed we advance a new proposal based on the insight that fundamental uncertainty is symptomatic for scholarly work it suggests focal randomization using a rationally founded and well orchestrated procedure

a robust analysis of the relationship between renewable energy consumption and its main drivers we provide a comprehensive and robust analysis of the drivers of renewable energy consumption for a panel of 64 countries using both the static pooled ols panel fixed and random effects and dynamic difference and system gmm panel data estimation approaches we show that the dynamic panel data model provides more efficient estimators than the static ones and that increases in per capita co2 emissions and per capita trade with foreign partners mainly drive the changes in per capita renewable energy consumption we also find limited evidence of oil price effects on renewable energy consumption which reflects the fact that renewable energy is just a complement and not a perfect substitute of crude oil at least in the short run

renewable resource use and nonseparable amenity benefits we incorporate amenity benefits into an overlapping generations model with a renewable resource as a factor of production source of amenity benefits and store of value unlike the conventional renewable resource problems studied under the assumption of additive consumption and amenity benefits we let amenity benefits affect the utility of consumers in a nonseparable fashion we examine the role that weights given to consumption and amenities have for harvesting and the resource stock we characterize dynamics and stability of steady state equilibria with a logistic resource growth function we demonstrate in parametric and numerical models that the weights given to consumption and amenities in the utility function matter substantially for the steady state equilibrium stock and its stability and dynamics both conventional saddle point equilibria and indeterminacy with infinite number of equilibria and saddle node bifurcation is possible depending on the weights given to consumption and amenities in addition we show that for each inefficient equilibrium stock there is a unique subsidy rate that can move the economy from an inefficient equilibrium to an efficient one the presence of indeterminacy provides a challenge to resource policies because the system becomes unpredictable therefore expectations and market psychology may play an important role in resource utilization and provision of amenities

the growth of income and energy consumption in six developing countries this paper reexamines the inter temporal link between energy consumption and income in six developing countries with diverse economic backgrounds and energy statistics in a production function framework we employ the generalized variance decompositions and generalized impulse response techniques to see if the growth of income and energy consumption contains considerable information to predict each other in all countries energy appears as an essential factor of production results indicate that energy may be a relatively more important input than labor and or capital in some countries hence neutrality of energy does not seem to hold

the political economy of environmental policy with overlapping generations a two sector overlapping generations model illuminates the intergenerational effects of a tax that protects an environmental stock a traded asset capitalizes the economic returns to future tax induced environmental improvements benefiting the current asset owners the old generation absent a transfer the tax harms the young generation by decreasing their real wage future generations benefit from the tax induced improvement in environmental stock the principal intergenerational conflict arising from the tax is between generations alive at the time society imposes the policy not between generations alive at different times a pareto improving tax can be implemented under various political economy settings

renewable and non renewable energy consumption growth nexus evidence from a panel error correction model abstract unlike previous renewable energy consumption growth studies this study examines the relationship between renewable and non renewable energy consumption and economic growth for 80 countries within a multivariate panel framework over the period 1990 2007 the pedroni 1999 2004 heterogeneous panel cointegration test show a long run equilibrium relationship between real gdp renewable energy consumption non renewable energy consumption real gross fixed capital formation and the labor force with the respective coefficient estimates positive and statistically significant there is little difference in the elasticity estimates with respect to renewable and non renewable energy consumption the results from the panel error correction model reveal bidirectional causality between renewable and non renewable energy consumption and economic growth in both the short and long run also there is bidirectional short run causality between renewable and non renewable energy consumption indicative of substitutability between the two energy sources

energy consumption and economic growth evidence from the commonwealth of independent states abstract this study examines the relationship between energy consumption and economic growth for eleven countries of the commonwealth of independent states over the period 1991 2005 within a multivariate panel data framework based on pedroni 1999 pedroni 2004 heterogeneous panel cointegration test and corresponding error correction model cointegration is present between real gdp energy consumption real gross fixed capital formation and labor force with the respective coefficients positive and statistically significant the results of the error correction model reveal the presence of unidirectional causality from energy consumption to economic growth in the short run while bidirectional causality between energy consumption and economic growth in the long run thus the results lend support for the feedback hypothesis associated with the relationship between energy consumption and economic growth

is aging harmful to the environment how does aging affect the environment we analyze this question using anoverlapping generations model featuring uncertain lifetimes andenvironmental externalities we show that whether aging is harmful to theenvironment depends on the curvature of utility function which ismeasured by the degree of relative risk aversion we also explore theimplication of the results for environmental policy in an aging society

the causal relationship between energy resources and economic growth in brazil abstract this study investigates the causal relationship between clean and non clean energy consumption and economic growth in brazil over the period of 1980 2009 clean energy consumption at aggregated level of total renewable energy consumption and disaggregated levels of hydroelectric new renewables and nuclear energy consumption are tested within a production function framework a cointegration test reveals a long term equilibrium relationship between real output capital labor and renewable and non renewable energy consumption at aggregated level and a long term equilibrium relationship between real output capital labor and hydroelectric new renewables nuclear and fossil fuel energy consumption at disaggregated level the capital labor and new renewables elasticities of real output are positive and statistically significant other energy consumption item s elasticities are insignificant the results from error correction model reveal the interdependencies between new renewables nuclear fossil fuel and total non renewable energy consumption and economic growth the unidirectional causality from hydroelectric total renewable consumption to economic growth the substitutability between new renewables and fossil fuel consumption and the substitutability between new renewables and nuclear energy consumption additionally nuclear and new renewables energy consumption responds to bring the system back to equilibrium overall aggregated analysis may obscure the relationship between different types of clean energy consumption and economic growth

on energy consumption and gdp studies a meta analysis of the last two decades abstract the relationship between energy consumption and gdp growth has been intensely examined in multiple frameworks set by various methods and countries this paper is a meta analysis of 51 studies published in the last two decades with worldwide data since 1949 on the relationship between energy consumption and gdp growth the aim is to systemize some of the factors that cause the variation of results in these studies our results yield evidence that the long run elasticity of gdp growth with respect to energy consumption is not independent of the method employed for cointegration the data type and the inclusion of variables such as the price level or capital in the cointegration equation also 1 increase in capital increases the elasticity of gdp with respect to energy consumption by 0 85

energy consumption and economic growth the case of oil exporting countries this paper examines the causal relationship between the per capita energy consumption and the per capita gdp in a panel of 11 selected oil exporting countries by using panel unit root tests and panel cointegration analysis the results show a unidirectional strong causality from economic growth to energy consumption for the oil exporting countries the findings have practical policy implications for decision makers in the area of macroeconomic planning in most major oil exporting countries government policies keep domestic prices bellow free market level resulting in high levels of domestic energy consumption the results imply that the energy conservation through reforming energy price policies has no damaging repercussions on economic growth for this group of countries

causal relationship between energy consumption and gdp growth revisited a dynamic panel data approach abstract this paper uses the panel data of energy consumption and gdp for 82 countries from 1972 to 2002 based on the income levels defined by the world bank the data are divided into four categories low income group lower middle income group upper middle income group and high income group we employ the gmm sys approach for the estimation of the panel var model in each of the four groups afterwards the causal relationship between energy consumption and economic growth is tested and ascertained we discover a in the low income group there exists no causal relationship between energy consumption and economic growth b in the middle income groups lower and upper middle income groups economic growth leads energy consumption positively c in the high income group countries economic growth leads energy consumption negatively after further in depth analysis of energy related data the results indicate that in the high income group there is a great environmental improvement as a result of more efficient energy use and reduction in the release of co2 however in the upper middle income group countries after the energy crisis the energy efficiency declines and the release of co2 rises since there is no evidence indicating that energy consumption leads economic growth in any of the four income groups a stronger energy conservation policy should be pursued in all countries

competitive equilibria and sustainable growth in a life cycle model with natural resources the purpose of this note is to consider interactions between capital accumulation and natural resource exploitation in diamond s 1965 overlapping generations olg model the presumption in the literature on economic growth under resource constraints e g solow 1974 or stiglitz 1974 is that constant standards of living are possible in the presence of nonreproducible natural resources even in the absence of technical progress provided only that capital and resources are good substitutes in production and society makes sufficient investments in reproducible capital to offset the optimally declining stock of natural resources this literature ignores generation overlap and treats society in each period as a single generation which cares about and also discounts the welfare of its immediate descendants and which has complete control over the rate of resource use and the saving rate whether a sequence of selfish finite lived and interdependent generations interacting via competitive markets will implement these paths is an open question this note introduces a stationary population log linear version of diamond s model in which natural resources are selfreproducible and essential in production and capital depreciates completely after one period in this environment it is technically feasible to achieve growth paths in which the input and the stock of natural resources are constant and in which capital accumulation leads to growth in living standards these paths of resource use can be interpreted as emanating from the normative concept of sustainable development now advocated

renewable resources in an overlapping generations economy without capital abstract we incorporate a renewable resource into an overlapping generations model without capital and with quasi linear preferences besides being an input for production the resource serves as a store of value we characterize the dynamics efficiency and stability of the steady state equilibria the stability properties are sensitive to the type of resource growth for constant growth there is only one steady state equilibrium which is stable and efficient in the general case of the concave growth function there are usually at least two steady state equilibria one of which is stable and the other one unstable the unstable steady state is efficient but the stable one may or may not be we study the robustness of our results by assuming a logarithmic utility function we show that for the cobb douglas production function the steady state is unique and stable regardless of whether the equilibrium is efficient or inefficient our analytical results are illustrated by numerical calculations

electricity consumption and economic growth bounds and causality analyses of opec members this paper investigates the relationship between electricity consumption and economic growth for opec members the bounds test yields evidence of a long run relationship between electricity consumption and economic growth for all opec members causality results suggest that economic growth is dependent on electricity consumption in five countries less dependent in three countries and independent in three countries because these countries do not necessarily share similar political and economic traits no single universal policy implication can be inferred from the results the disparities across these causality results therefore stress the importance of formulating causality explanations while taking into account the particularities of individual countries rather than blindly applying the conventional interpretations

does renewable and or non renewable energy consumption matter for total factor productivity tfp growth evidence from the brics abstract studies proved that output growth is mainly associated with the total factor productivity tfp growth and variables that affect the tfp have an important explanatory power on output in this regards the aim of this study is to examine the causal relationship between different types of energy consumption and tfp growth in the brics from 1992 to 2012 a panel bootstrap granger causality test by konya 2006 68 was employed to investigate the direction of possible connection between energy consumption and tfp growth results show that no remarkable causal link exists between renewable energy consumption and tfp growth in the brics however in the case of non renewables energy consumption creates a positive externality that contributes economic development in brazil and south africa by the growth of tfp as well as energy use itself in this respect policies that promote coal and non renewable electricity consumption in south africa and natural gas consumption in brazil may be beneficial for their economic development

energy consumption economic growth and prices a reassessment using panel vecm for developed and developing countries this paper reinvestigates the energy consumption gdp growth nexus in a panel error correction model using data on 20 net energy importers and exporters from 1971 to 2002 among the energy exporters there was bidirectional causality between economic growth and energy consumption in the developed countries in both the short and long run while in the developing countries energy consumption stimulates growth only in the short run the former result is also found for energy importers and the latter result exists only for the developed countries within this category in addition compared to the developing countries the developed countries elasticity response in terms of economic growth from an increase in energy consumption is larger although its income elasticity is lower and less than unitary lastly the implications for energy policy calling for a more holistic approach are discussed c 2006 elsevier ltd all rights reserved

energy consumption and economic growth in the light of meeting the targets of energy policy in the eu the bootstrap panel granger causality approach abstract the aim of the paper is to assess linkages between energy consumption and economic growth in the light of compliance with the eu energy policy targets stated in the climate and energy package for 2020 in the european union member states in the period 1993 2011 the study is divided into two main stages during the first one using cluster analysis methods four groups of countries which met three energy policy targets stated in the package at similar levels were identified during the second stage the bootstrap granger panel causality approach proposed by konya 2006 was used to verify the hypothesis of causality between energy consumption and economic growth in the countries from four groups created in the previous step the global financial crisis was also taken into account the results obtained reveal that the level of compliance with energy policy targets influences linkages between energy consumption and economic growth the results indicate causal relations in the group of countries with the greatest reduction of greenhouse gas emissions the highest reduction of energy intensity and the highest share of renewable energy consumption in total energy consumption in the remaining groups the results mostly confirm the neutrality hypothesis

rational randomization by journal editors a mathematical derivation a response to osterloh and frey s discussion paper on borrowed plumes abstract should journal editors and grant giving bodies ever make use of random draw mechanisms to make their final decisions this short note argues that the answer is yes it describes a mathematical rationale for such randomization put intuitively random draw should be used when the gains from the acceptance of unorthodox path breaking papers outweigh the costs of publishing the unorthodox poor papers the mathematical case for this rests on an averaging argument and requires convexity of scientific influence in a sense explained in the note the long observed skewness of citations distributions is consistent with such convexity hence this note attempts to offer a conceptual and practical addendum to the potentially important randomization proposal of margit osterloh and bruno frey 2020

energy consumption and growth in south america evidence from a panel error correction model abstract this study examines the relationship between energy consumption and economic growth for a panel of nine south american countries over the period 1980 2005 within a multivariate framework given the relatively short span of the time series data a panel cointegration and error correction model is employed to infer the causal relationship pedroni s heterogeneous panel cointegration test reveals a long run equilibrium relationship between real gdp energy consumption the labor force and real gross fixed capital formation with the respective coefficients positive and statistically significant the granger causality results indicate both short run and long run causality from energy consumption to economic growth which supports the growth hypothesis

the importance of energy quality in energy intensive manufacturing evidence from panel cointegration and panel fmols this paper expands on the panel gdp energy cointegration modeling literature it does so by using data disaggregated along sectoral lines and adjusting energy consumption for the quality of the energy source e g electricity is of higher quality than oil which is of higher quality than coal in order to examine the role of energy quality in the five most energy intensive manufacturing sectors iron and steel non ferrous metals non metallic minerals chemicals and pulp and paper the database was constructed by combing energy consumption and energy price data to construct the energy quality index from the iea with economic data value added labor employed and physical capital from the oecd s structural analysis database in addition to finding the variables analyzed are panel i 1 and cointegrated for each sector based panel the long run elasticity estimates from panel fmols indicate the importance of energy quality primarily the shift toward the use of high quality electricity in these energy intensive manufacturing sectors in each case the elasticity for energy quality is greater than that for conventionally measured energy consumption sometimes orders of magnitude greater indeed the elasticity of conventionally measured energy consumption is insignificant to very small for three of the five sectors also when using the energy quality measure the importance of energy consumption relative to the other production factors stands out such results are useful for both energy gdp cointegration causality modelers and cge modelers who may need to estimate elasticities

energy income causality in oecd countries revisited the key role of capital stock abstract this paper applies a recent advance in panel analysis to estimate the panel cointegration and panel vector error correction models for a set of 22 oecd countries using annual data covering the period 1960 2001 we investigate the relationship between energy consumption and income using an aggregate production function and controlling for the capital stock as well as by exploring the dynamic directions of the causality among these three variables we firstly obtain solid and convincing evidence of a fairly strong long run equilibrium relationship among them secondly it is found that the capital stock is much more productive than energy consumption third it is observed that neglecting the impact of the capital stock on income tends to overestimate the effect of energy consumption finally the panel causality test shows bi directional causal linkages exist among energy consumption the capital stock and economic growth overall the findings reveal that the capital stock plays a critical role in realizing the dynamic relationship between energy and income

co integration and causality testing of the energy gdp relationship a cross country study in this paper the energy gdp relationship in per capita terms is analysed for a sample of 16 countries over the time period 1950 51 to 1984 85 co integration theory is first used to test whether a long run equilibrium relation exists between the two variables after co integration has been established causality measures are constructed to quantify various types of feedback between energy and gdp for each country it is then examined whether the causality measures are longitudinally related to certain basic economic indicators of the countries in the sample

conservationist government policies and intergenerational equity in an overlapping generations model with renewable resources abstract this paper shows that in overlapping generations models incorporating renewable natural resources competition may lead to perpetually declining living standards in environments in which it is technically feasible to achieve intergenerationally equitable distributions of consumption first and second best conservationist government policies are examined these include forced nationalization of the entire stock of natural capital government open market purchases and sales of natural capital taxation of industrial use of resources and subsidies to private investments in natural capital

an overlapping generations model of growth and the environment this article analyzes the potential conflict between economic growth and the maintenance of environmental quality in an overlapping generations model short lived individuals make decisions which have long lasting effects on both factor productivity and the environment the model provides a theoretical explanation of observed correlations between environmental quality and income whereby economic growth is associated first with declines then improvements in environmental quality it suggests circumstances in which multiple pareto ranked steady state equilibria may arise and in which sustained growth of both capital and environmental quality may occur overmaintenance of the environment analogous to dynamically inefficient overaccumulation of capital may emerge copyright 1994 by royal economic society

sustainability constraints versus optimality versus intertemporal concern and axioms versus data sustainable sustained or survivable development are defined here as distinct sustainability constraints on intertemporal distribution in a context which ignores uncertainty environmental and intratemporal concerns such constraints are neither self contradictory nor redundant for they can conflict with maximizing the present value of utility optimality nor inferior since the axioms underlying optimality are ethically arbitrary and refuted by empirical psychological data axiomatic arguments may clarify but cannot resolve debates about intertemporal concerns data suggest that sustainability constraints are not respected and that intertemporal welfare functions containing a preference for sustained improvement may better reflect what bodies politic mean by sustainability

a literature survey on energy growth nexus abstract this paper provides a survey of the recent progress in the literature of energy consumption economic growth and electricity consumption economic growth causality nexus the survey highlights that most empirical studies focus on either testing the role of energy electricity in stimulating economic growth or examining the direction of causality between these two variables although the positive role of energy on growth has become a stylized fact there are some methodological reservations about the results from these empirical studies a general observation from these studies is that the literature produced conflicting results and there is no consensus neither on the existence nor on the direction of causality between energy consumption electricity consumption and economic growth as a policy implication to avoid from conflicting and unreliable results the authors may use the autoregressive distributed lags bounds test two regime threshold co integration models panel data approach and multivariate models including new variables such as real gross fixed capital formation labor force carbon dioxide emissions population exchange rates interest rates etc thus the authors should focus more on the new approaches and perspectives rather than by employing usual methods based on a set of common variables for different countries and different intervals of time

energy consumption and economic growth in central america evidence from a panel cointegration and error correction model abstract this study examines the relationship between energy consumption and economic growth for six central american countries over the period 1980 2004 within a multivariate framework given the relatively short span of the time series data a panel cointegration and error correction model is employed to infer the causal relationship based on the heterogeneous panel cointegration test by pedroni pedroni p 1999 critical values for cointegration tests in heterogeneous panels with multiple regressors oxford bulletin of economics and statistics 61 653 670 pedroni p 2004 panel cointegration asymptotic and finite sample properties of pooled time series tests with an application to the ppp hypothesis new results econometric theory 20 597 627 cointegration is present between real gdp energy consumption the labor force and real gross fixed capital formation with the respective coefficients positive and statistically significant the granger causality results indicate the presence of both short run and long run causality from energy consumption to economic growth which supports the growth hypothesis

sustainable forestry timber bequests future generations and optimal tax policy this paper analyzes harvesting and timber bequest behavior in a two period overlapping generations model where the government uses site productivity yield and inheritance taxation the ceteris paribus effects of forest and inheritance taxes are derived first then the paper discusses the optimal design of forest and inheritance taxes by assuming that intergenerational externalities are either absent or operative in the absence of intergenerational externalities it is optimal to use only the site productivity tax and not to introduce yield and inheritance taxes at all in the presence of intergenerational externalities the situation changes the paper demonstrates that the externality can be internalized by introducing either a yield tax or an inheritance subsidy or both if the government is able to use both at the same time it is desirable to use the yield tax to punish excessive harvesting and an inheritance subsidy to bribe to give bequests