trade openness tax reform and tax revenue in developing countries this article investigates empirically whether the effect of tax reform involving the progressive replacement of trade tax revenue with domestic tax revenue in developing countries tax revenue performance measured by tax revenue to gdp ratio depends on the degree of trade openness of these countries the analysis has used an unbalanced panel data set of 95 developing countries over the period 1981 2015 and the two system gmm approach results suggest that tax reform is positively and significantly associated with tax revenue performance in developing countries with the magnitude of this positive effect increasing as countries experience a higher development level additionally and more importantly countries that further open up their economies to international trade enjoy a higher positive effect of tax reform on tax revenue than countries that experience a lower degree of trade openness therefore these findings should help dissipate the concerns of policymakers in developing countries that greater openness to international trade would further erode their tax revenue including by lowering their international trade tax revenue in fact the implementation of an appropriate tax reform in the context of greater trade openness would generate higher tax revenue while concurrently allowing countries to reap the well known benefits of international trade

the world bank global keynesianism and the distribution of the gains from growth sir hans singer whom this volume celebrates was a pupil of john maynard keynes at cambridge and in 1945 attended the bretton woods negotiations at which keynes and others designed the institutions which now seek to regulate and stimulate the international economy the world bank the imf and the gatt sir hans has provided ever since that time frequent creative suggestions concerning the way in which all of those institutions separately and in relation to the un system should set about the task of global economic governance with a particular flurry of activity around 1994 5 when the bretton woods institutions celebrated their half century by this time of course the bretton woods institutions had departed from their original articles of agreement and implicated the world bank progressively more deeply in policy based programme lending alongside its original project lending functions this paper attempts a little belatedly to take up some of the concerns aroused by that flurry of activity with particular reference to the world bank which keynes as we saw above saw as having the principal stimulative and entrepreneurial role the concerns have been expressed by sir hans in the following way the shift to programme lending and policy conditionality tied in with three other developments first the withering away of the development functions of the un created a gap into which it was tempting and easy for the world bank to move together with the imf second the debt crisis of the 1980s made the developing countries pliant in accepting conditionality pressures from the bretton woods institutions third in the process of replacing the un as a focus of development policy guidance and in line with trends in the major industrial countries the world bank developed again together with the imf a new washington consensus emphasising government failures market orientation liberalisation privatisation etc now the purpose of this is i am using the language of the imf and world bank now to cut down today but in doing so lay the foundations for subsequent sustainable growth now the fact is that if you cut down today it is just as likely that if you cut investment today that does not lay the foundations for subsequent growth that does exactly the opposite the imf are quite fond of illustrating their policy with the french proverb reculer pour mieux sauter the trouble is that what we have today is that in all too many cases the developing countries stand on the edge of an abyss and therefore by stepping back they don t gain manoeuvring space for moving forward but they fall into the abyss singer 1995 p 469 and 1994 p 55

aid for the poorest some early lessons of uk experience the paper presents an interim review of recent attempts to reach the poorest people in developing countries through aid policy from the viewpoint of one donor the united kingdom it concludes that the uk has achieved a modest increase in the proportion of aid aimed at the poorest between 1974 and 1979 that poverty focused projects are in general more local cost intensive and have lower rates of return than others and that the principal difficulties in the way of successful implementation of poverty focused projects are excessive size an over rapid rate of disbursement inadequate local cost provisions and failure to specify the target group or the repayment strategy with sufficient precision it is argued that there are political obstacles to removing the second and third of these obstacles in donor countries and to removing the fourth in recipient countries also

could a global marshall plan be successful an investigation using the weep simulation model abstract using the weep simulation model world economic equalization program this research examines the potential impact of a very large scale foreign development assistance program a global marshall plan on the future development of the world economy the benchmark simulations of the model indicate a dramatic reduction in world economic inequality at the cost of a very minor retardation in the economic growth of the rich countries sensitivity analysis demonstrates that with certain key exceptions these optimistic results are reasonably robust against parametric variation

regression discontinuity analysis of gavi s impact on vaccination rates abstract since 2001 an aid consortium known as gavi has accounted for over half of vaccines purchased in the 75 eligible countries with an initial gni below 1 000 per capita regression discontinuity estimates suggest most aid for cheap existing vaccines like hepatitis b and dpt was inframarginal for instance hepatitis b doses sufficient to vaccinate roughly 75 of infants raised vaccination rates by single digit margins these results are driven by middle income countries near the eligibility threshold and do not preclude larger gains for the poorest countries global externalities via vaccine markets or impacts on newer vaccines such as pneumococcal or rotavirus for which income eligibility rules were relaxed

fungibility and the impact of development assistance evidence from vietnam s health sector how can the impact of aid be estimated in the presence of fungibility and how far does fungibility reduce its benefits these questions are analyzed in a context where a donor wants to target its efforts on a specific sector and specific geographic areas a traditional differences in differences method comparing the change in outcomes between the target and nontarget areas before and after the project risks misestimating the project s benefits the paper develops an alternative estimation method in which intersectoral fungibility reduces project benefits insofar as government spending has a smaller impact in the sector to which the funds leak than in the target sector while intrasectoral fungibility reduces benefits insofar as the donor is able to leverage productivity increases in government spending in the target areas the methods are applied to two contemporaneous world bank health projects that set out to target assistance on approximately one half of vietnam s provinces aid is not apparently fungible between vietnam s health sector and other sectors but is fungible across provinces within the health sector differences in differences yield an insignificant impact on infant mortality while the use of the new method yields a statistically significant impact of around 4 per 1000 live births the results however are ambiguous on the costs associated with intrasectoral fungibility

do elites benefit from democracy and foreign aid in developing countries abstract a popular argument for the absence of any beneficial effects of foreign aid is that it is skimmed by political elites in recipient countries however studies also suggest that aid may be more effective in relatively democratic developing countries by exploring data on income quintiles derived from the world income inequality database for 88 developing countries a set of results indicate that foreign aid and democracy in conjunction are associated with a higher share of income held by the upper quintile it thus appears that foreign aid contrary to popular beliefs leads to a more skewed income distribution in democratic developing countries while the effects are negligible in autocratic countries the paper closes with a discussion of potential mechanisms generating this perverse effect

aid and the public sector in pakistan evidence with endogenous aid summary aid has been the principal source of development finance for the majority of developing countries over the past few decades this has spawned a large literature on the effectiveness of aid which remains essentially inconclusive the empirical literature has tended to evaluate the impact of aid by including it as a variable in a regression for the determinants of some economic performance indicator this paper follows a different strand of the literature and examines the impact of aid on public sector fiscal behavior aid is in general given to the public sector thus any effect of aid is mediated by that sector we specifically address this behavioral feature by analyzing how aid revenue affects government fiscal behavior with respect to tax borrowing and expenditure decisions unlike previous contributions aid is endogenous in our model which has a number of important implications we estimate an econometric model that differs from previous studies not only in this respect but also by allowing domestic borrowing in addition to aid and tax revenue to finance both capital and recurrent expenditure structural and reduced form equations are derived and estimated using 1956 95 time series data for pakistan results indicate contrary to much of the literature that only half of aid has gone to government consumption that it has had a slightly positive impact on public investment and negative impact on tax effort

foreign aid and fiscal governance in melanesia summary recent research suggests that foreign aid is effective at spurring economic growth in recipient countries but its effectiveness is likely to depend upon a number of factors arguably the most important factor determining aid effectiveness is how recipient governments mediate foreign aid inflows this paper investigates this issue for the melanesian countries of fiji papua new guinea the solomon islands and vanuatu for the period 1989 2002 results suggest that foreign aid has led to increases in developmental expenditures and to falls in tax revenues and borrowing results also suggest a very different response to aid grants versus loans

foreign aid taxes and public investment abstract using time series data for india we test the foreign aid public investment hypothesis behavioral equations derived from a maximizing framework are estimated after correcting for econometric and data inadequacies of earlier models the results confirm earlier findings regarding the negative relationship between taxes and government investment in the presence of aid however in contrast to the earlier work we find that grants and loans generally go into development projects with no leakages into consumption moreover bilateral aid actually pulls resources out of consumption and puts them into development projects

structural shifts in aid dependency and fiscal policy in developing countries abstractforeign aid is a sizable source of government financing for several developing countries and its allocation matters for the conduct of fiscal policy this article revisits the fiscal effects of shifts in aid dependency in 59 developing countries from 1960 to 2010 it identifies structural shifts in aid dependency and uses treatment effect methods to assess the fiscal effects of aid it finds that shifts in aid dependency are frequent and have significant fiscal effects in developing countries in addition to the traditional evidences of tax and investment displacement and aid illusion we show that upward shifts and downward shifts in aid dependency have asymmetric effects on fiscal accounts in developing countries large aid inflows undermine tax capacity and public investment while large reductions in aid inflows tend to keep recipients fiscal behaviour intact moreover the tax displacement effect tends to be temporary while the impacts on expenditure items tend to last finally we find tha

does foreign aid increase private investment evidence from panel cointegration this article uses panel cointegration and causality techniques to examine the long run relationship between foreign aid and private investment our main result is that aid has a statistically significant negative effect on private investment this result is robust to outliers different measures and forms of aid sample selection and the sample period in addition we find that long run causality runs in both directions suggesting that an increase in aid reduces private investment and that in turn higher private investment leads to lower aid inflows

the economics of development a survey i the subject our definition of the subject will be the use of economic analysis to understand the economies of poor or developing countries this includes in particular how standards of living in the population are determined and how they change over time and further how policy can or should be used in the influence of these processes the definition contains in principle much or most of analytical methods in economics insofar as they can be put to use in the examination of the issues of interest this is as it should be but it poses a problem for a survey in a journal a comprehensive treatment is infeasible so we shall follow a different route the survey will focus on what i take to be the major themes and approaches which characterise the productive aspects of the subject there is therefore no pretence at being exhaustive the purpose is rather to highlight some of the advances many of these have been of real substance there are a number of possible purposes for a survey and it is important to be clear at the outset for whom it is intended what it is and what it is not this survey is addressed to economists and students of economics who know the tools of their trade but not necessarily how they have been applied to and fashioned for the analysis of the economics of developing countries it is a description of the ways in which problems can be productively formulated and approached in terms of examples chosen for their intrinsic importance and interest the vastness of the subject means that we have to be highly selective it does not seek to provide a summary evaluation of the current view of the appropriate response to immediate policy questions it is not a history of thought nor a research manifesto nor an attempt to adjudicate or settle the major debates where they arise naturally from the major purpose some judgements on these subjects will be offered but they do not themselves constitute the primary intent of this survey there are three lines of enquiry or sets of questions which have i suggest been distinctive of the most fruitful work in development economics they will

characterization of the reverse talmud bankruptcy rule by exemption and exclusion properties abstract the reverse talmud rule for bankruptcy problems applies the constrained equal awards rule cea rule for large amounts of the estate while it applies the constrained equal losses rule cel rule for small amounts of the estate the cea rule respectively cel rule can be axiomatized using the exemption and exclusion properties respectively there is no rule that satisfies both these two properties in this paper we axiomatize the reverse talmud rule by using compatible weaker versions of the exemption and exclusion properties

effects of stabex on acps economic growth further evidence the paper deals with the economic growth of the open and small developing countries which signed the lome convention henceforth acps results showing that earnings instability damages their economic performance can be used to support the eu policy of guaranteeing financial aid to those countries suffering reductions in export proceeds the second section of the paper analysing the workings of stabex however highlights certain weaknesses in the effectiveness of stabex transfers when their impact on economic growth is considered the general conclusion is that if the current eu acp negotiations for lome v are to be successful then some aspects of the scheme eligibility criteria and use of funds will have to be radically changed

introduction aid and development the debate on the impact of aid on the economies of developing countries is a rapidly evolving one early studies by e g papanek 1972 reported a positive impact of aid on growth within a multiple regression context this conclusion allowed policy makers to entertain the possibility that poverty across the world could be largely eradicated that countries could be moved out of poverty through the allocation of aid and that the following of successful policies would allow them to generate increased prosperity from their own resources unfortunately after some thirty years the poor are still with us poverty shows relatively little signs of disappearing and until recently enthusiasm for aid amongst donors had declined the papers in this symposium examine the effectiveness of aid in the past and its potential in the future a number of economic studies help explain this apparent failure mosley et al 1987 found it impossible to establish any significant relationship between aid and the growth rate of developing countries they suggested that this might be because of the possibility of leakages into non productive expenditure in the public sector and the transmission of negative price effects to the private sector they also argued for the targeting of aid i e its allocation to countries where it would be used most effectively boone 1996 concluded that aid does not significantly increase growth nor benefit the poor it did however increase the size of the government but again the message was not entirely negative in terms of what aid could achieve and argued for the targeting of aid this time at liberal democratic regimes as they appeared more effective in for example reducing infant mortality hence until recently the dominant view within economics had become pessimistic with respect to the past effectiveness of aid but somewhat optimistically perhaps held out the hope for improvement on the basis of aid targeting more recently however work by burnside and dollar 2000 was to put forward a more optimistic view of the former they concluded that aid had a positive impact on growth for developing countries with good fiscal monetary and trade policies in place but had little impact for those countries who were following poor policies this therefore partially at least provided an explanation of why aid had been found to have little positive impact on growth in previous empirical work it also provided specific criteria for targeting aid this was then built upon by collier and dollar 2001 2002 who calculated a poverty efficient allocation of aid which focused on those countries with a combination of most poverty and best policies they suggested that targeting of aid in this manner would almost double its effectiveness in reducing poverty this work has had an extraordinary impact upon policy and easterly 2003 as well as dalgaard hansen and tarp dht in this symposium document how it

reinventing foreign aid for inclusive and sustainable development kuznets piketty and the great policy reversal this survey essay reviews over 200 papers in arguing that in order to achieve sustainable and inclusive development foreign aid should not orient developing countries towards industrialisation in the perspective of kuznets but in the view of piketty abandoning the former s view that inequality will fall with progress in industrialisation and placing more emphasis on inequality in foreign aid policy will lead to more sustainable development outcomes inter alia mitigate short term poverty address concerns of burgeoning population growth train recipient governments on inclusive development fight corruption and mismanagement and avoid the shortfalls of celebrated kuznets conjectures we discuss how the essay addresses post 2015 development challenges and provide foreign aid policy instruments with which discussed objectives can be achieved in summary the essay provides useful policy measures to avoid past pitfalls output may be growing and yet the mass of the people may be becoming poorer lewis 1955 lewis led all developing countries to water proverbially speaking some african countries have so far chosen not to drink amavilah 2014 piketty 2014 has led all developing countries to the stream again and a challenging policy syndrome of our time is how foreign aid can help them to drink

a panel data analysis of the fungibility of foreign aid the donor community has been increasingly concerned that development assistance intended for crucial social and economic sectors might be used directly or indirectly to fund unproductive military and other expenditures the link between foreign aid and public spending is not straightforward because some aid may be fungible this article empirically examines the impact of foreign aid on the recipient s public expenditures using cross country samples of annual observations for 1971 90 for the base sample of 14 developing countries it finds that aid is not fungible at the aggregate level and there is no associated tax relief increasing the number of countries however makes aid fungible moreover results based on the main sample indicate that aid is fungible in three out of five sectors examined developing country governments receiving earmarked concessionary loans for agriculture education and energy reduce their own resources going to these sectors and use them elsewhere only loans to the transport and communication sector are fully spent on the purposes intended by donors because most aid appears to be fungible the rate of return on a specific donor funded project tells little about the impact of that assistance a better approach may be to tie foreign aid to an overall public expenditure program that provides adequate resources to crucial sectors

the impact of foreign aid on the fiscal behavior of asian ldc governments a comment on khan and hoshino 1992 abstract khan and hoshino 1992 analyze public sector fiscal behavior in the presence of foreign aid using data for five south and southeast asian countries this paper first questions a critical hypothesis test on which khan and hoshino s conclusions depend it then extends khan and hoshino s analysis making explicit both the direct and indirect effects of aid contained within their fiscal response model it argues that a number of khan and hoshino s conclusions do not hold in the context of this representation

foreign aid taxes and public investment a further comment abstract the paper in this journal by gang and khan 1991 employed heller s 1975 fiscal response model to demonstrate that aid to india has all been used to finance government investment this conclusion is shown to be a misinterpretation of the model s results which actually suggest that aid has had no impact on government investment at all however the reported parameters are determined by the estimation procedure adopted by gang and khan and not by the indian government s fiscal behaviour

a model of expertise we study a model in which perfectly informed experts offer advice to a decision maker whose actions affect the welfare of all experts are biased and thus may wish to pull the decision maker in different directions and to different degrees when the decision maker consults only a single expert the expert withholds substantial information from the decision maker we ask whether this situation is improved by having the decision maker sequentially consult two experts we first show that there is no perfect bayesian equilibrium in which full revelation occurs when both experts are biased in the same direction it is never beneficial to consult both in contrast when experts are biased in opposite directions it is always beneficial to consult both indeed in this case full revelation may be induced in an extended debate by introducing the possibility of rebuttal

impact of foreign aid on the fiscal behavior of ldc governments abstract the purpose of this paper is to examine the impact of foreign aid on the behavior of the recipient governments specifically we look at a sample of less developed countries in south and southeast asia and study their response to foreign aid received their response is measured in terms of their public investment and consumption as well as taxation our paper attempts to make two new contributions to the literature first we try to estimate the impact of foreign aid on a sample of five south and southeast asian countries secondly we improve on the earlier method of a combination of single equation and two step least squares by estimating the whole system with a nonlinear three step least squares method the results confirm the hypothesis that aid does affect consumption investment and taxation of these governments but they also show that the relationship is a complex one in particular grants and loans have different effects on investment and taxation

budget referendums and government spending evidence from swiss cantons vortrag im forschungsseminar der wirtschaftswissenschaftlichen fakultat der universitat basel schweiz am 20 november 2000

capital grants and regional public investment in spain fungibility of aid or crowding in effect the aim of capital grants to subcentral governments is to increase their investment however recipients may try to allocate additional resources to cut saving or deficit generating a crowding out effect on self financed investment using data from the spanish autonomous communities during the period 1984 to 1999 the effect of capital transfers on regional public investment saving and deficit are estimated econometric results demonstrate that capital grants have no relevance when explaining the dynamics of saving however in deficit regressions they are shown to be both significant and negative both results lead us to a partial long run crowding out effect of grants on self financed investment

multilateral and bilateral loans versus grants issues and evidence this paper examines a wide range of issues relating to the mix between loans and grants as well as the degree of concessionality of loans a number of empirical tests are carried out based on annual panel data over 1970 to 1999 for 22 donor countries and 72 recipient countries based on the tests we observe that for bilateral donors past grant loan mix and hence reflows from past transfers do not influence the volume of current resource transfers our tests also show that the rate of official borrowing by the recipients and by deduction the extent of their past debt burden is positively influenced by the extent of the concessionality of such loans irrespective of whether it is in the form of subsidised interest rates or longer grace periods the paper concludes with a review of the circumstances in which grants soft loans and non concessional loans might have their respective comparative advantage as well as a discussion of the need so as to overcome the negative incentive problems of soft loans for a typical concessional loan package to be separated into two constituent parts this would enable the recipient to be given the grant component and the option to take from the non concessional loan component as much as desired

does foreign aid promote the expansion of government building on the literature on public finance i seek to advance our understanding of variations in government size by exploring the impact of official development assistance on fiscal policy i hypothesize that foreign aid operates in accordance with the flypaper effect systematically generating incentives and opportunities for the expansion of government spending results from a time series cross sectional regression analysis of growth in government spending over the 1970 99 time period are consistent with the hypothesis for middle and lower income nations aid represents an important determinant of government expansion looking at the tax and revenue side of the equation however reveals a more perverse pattern of response aid promotes not only increased spending but also reduced revenue generation the results have important implications from both a theoretical and policy perspective inter alia they point to the potentially self defeating nature of efforts to promote market oriented programs of state retrenchment via development assistance as well as to the importance of incorporating international transfers into future research on government spending

fiscal composition and aid effectiveness a political economy model summary in the long run tax effort we argue determines the effectiveness of aid and this relationship operates simultaneously with the negative link in the opposite direction observed by brautigam and knack 2004 and others tax effort and the ability of the state to diversify its taxation structure we find are significantly linked to growth and poverty indicators the key message for policy is that a broadening of the tax structure in low income countries is crucial in order to enable those countries to escape from the weak state low tax trap and to make aid effective

rethinking development effectiveness development effectiveness has become a recurring theme in today s international development discourse the expression is largely selfexplanatory it simply refers to the effectiveness of foreign aid in fostering development however as the priority of development has evolved so has the meaning and content of development effectiveness that international development agencies seek to achieve the initial focus of development assistance in the 1940s was the reconstruction of the war torn economies of europe and japan with rapid progress of the postwar reconstruction work the focus of development assistance shifted to what has now come to be known as the developing world at first the goal was to increase the income of these countries however it was soon realized that this was a limited goal owing to the complex conflation of population growth and changing income distributions it was observed that economic growth does not necessarily translate into higher standards of living for the general population by the 1960s and 1970s the focus of the development agenda was on the twin objectives of economic growth and poverty reduction and subsequently shifted gradually toward the basic needs of the population by the 1990s reduction of absolute poverty became a priority in the international development institutions

game theoretic analysis of a bankruptcy problem from the talmud abstract for three different bankruptcy problems the 2000 year old babylonian talmud prescribes solutions that equal precisely the nucleoli of the corresponding coalitional games a rationale for these solutions that is independent of game theory is given in terms of the talmudic principle of equal division of the contested amount this rationale leads to a unique solution for all bankruptcy problems which always coincides with the nucleolus two other rationales for the same rule are suggested in terms of other talmudic principles needless to say the rule in question is not proportional division

does foreign aid distort incentives and hurt growth theory and evidence from 75 aid recipient countries foreign aid transfers can distort individual incentives and hence hurt growth by encouraging rent seeking as opposed to productive activities we construct a model of a growing small open economy that distinguishes two effects from foreign transfers i a direct positive effect as higher transfers allow the financing of infrastructure ii an indirect negative effect as higher transfers induce rent seeking competition by self interested individuals in this framework the growth impact of aid is examined jointly with the determination of rent seeking behavior we test the main predictions of the model for a cross section of 75 aid recipient countries there is evidence that aid has a direct positive effect on growth which is however significantly mitigated by the adverse indirect effects of associated rent seeking activities this is especially the case in recipient countries with relatively large public sectors

funding self sustaining development the role of aid fdi and government in economic success this article challenges a long held development policy assumption that aid and foreign direct investment fdi serve as substitutes or complements in accelerating the development of the world s poorer countries we show both theoretically and empirically that aid and fdi affect development differently aid contributes powerfully to both economic growth and human development and the higher the level of human capital in a country the more aid contributes by contrast fdi at best has no effect on economic growth and actually slows the rate of human development in less developed countries we find no evidence that the degree of democratic responsiveness in government conditions the effectiveness of either aid or fdi although we do find that democracy independently increases human development in all but the most developed countries our results demonstrate that fdi and aid are not and cannot be substitutes in the development of the world s poorer countries nor even can they be thought of as complements certainly not at mid to low levels of development in the end poor countries need democracy and aid not fdi we are extremely grateful to susan rose ackerman gustav ranis frances rosenbluth kenneth scheve and participants at the leitner political economy seminar at yale university in december 2003 for very helpful comments we also received valuable suggestions from two anonymous reviewers stephen kosack would like to thank the national science foundation for the support of a graduate research fellowship

some determinants of foreign aid to india 1960 1985 abstract using a unique data set of aid to india from all sources 1960 1985 we discuss the magnitude and composition of aid and present a principal components analysis of aid giving we then attempt to get at the underlying patterns and causes of aid giving using factor analytic techniques and explain the level of foreign aid by employing a partial adjustment model we find that latent motivations to classify the donor countries into four convenient groups each with different political and economic motivations we also find that the latent variables capturing the motivations of the united states western european countries eastern european countries as well as last year s aid and the balance of trade but not gdp growth are significant determinants of the level of aid

debt relief for poor countries conditionality and effectiveness this paper studies the effectiveness of debt relief to stimulate economic growth in the most heavily indebted poor countries we develop a neoclassical framework with a conflict of interest between the altruistic donor and the recipient government and model conditionality as an imperfectly enforceable dynamic contract in contrast to the recent practice of fully cancelling debt optimal incentive compatible conditionality is accompanied by a concessionality level that implies a combination of subsidized loans and outright grants the optimal concessionality level depends on the recipient s access to international financial markets and on the strength of the conflict of interest incentive compatible transfers with optimal concessionality levels generate substantial welfare gains if the donor does not implement the optimal concessionality level and provides subsidized loans only then the effectiveness of transfers decreases in the long run with severe welfare implications in contrast transfers are less effective in the short run if the donor offers outright grants only

a noncooperative view of consistent bankruptcy rules abstract we introduce a game form that captures a noncooperative dimension of the consistency property of bankruptcy rules any consistent and monotone rule is fully characterized by a bilateral principle and consistency like the consistency axiom our game form together with a bilateral principle yields the corresponding consistent bankruptcy rule as a result of a unique outcome of nash equilibria the result holds for a large class of consistent and monotone rules including the constrained equal award the propositional rule and many other well known rules moreover all of the subgame perefect equilibria are coalition proof in the associated game in strategic form journal of economic literatureclassification numbers c72 and d63

aid policies and growth the authors of this paper use a new database on foreign aid to examine the relationships among foreign aid economic policies and growth of per capita gdp in panel growth regressions for 56 developing countries and 6 four year periods 1970 93 they find that the policies that have a great effect on growth are those related to fiscal surplus inflation and trade openness they construct an index for those three policies and have that index interact with foreign aid they have instruments for both aid and aid interacting with policies they find that aid has a positive impact on growth in developing countries with good fiscal monetary and trade policies in the presence of poor policies aid has no positive effect on growth this result is robust in a variety of specifications which include or exclude middle income countries include or exclude outliers and treat policies as exogenous or endogenous they examine the determinants of policy and find no evidence that aid has systematically affected policies either for good or for ill they estimate an aid allocation equation and show that any tendency for aid to reward good policies has been overwhelmed by donors pursuit of their own strategic interests in a counterfactual they reallocate aid reduce the role of donor interests and increasing the importance of policy such a reallocation would have a large positive effect on developing countries growth rates

the effectiveness of aid on savings and investment in sub saharan africa do volatility and institutional quality matter abstractthe effectiveness of aid is somewhat subject to its volatility this study investigates the impact of aid volatility especially on savings and investment with a particular focus on the role of institutional quality in 45 sub saharan african ssa countries over the period from 1990 to 2013 we used the generalized method of moments gmm technique combined with a measure of volatility namely an averaged data method involving six 4 year sub periods our results suggest that while aid is positively associated with savings and investment its volatility is harmful to savings and investment however when higher quality institutions exist the volatility of aid has a less negative impact on savings and investment the policy implications are diverse first donors and ssa aid dependent countries need to take into account the diversity of shocks to which aid can respond in mitigating its unpredictability secondly ssa countries should be encouraged to establish the conditions for better quality inst

aid the public sector and the market in less developed countries a reply the article in this journal by mosley et al i987 concludes its analysis of aid effectiveness as demonstrating inability of development aid over more than twenty years to provide a net increment to overall growth in the third world p 636 this note purports to show that this conclusion which is ostensibly distressing as the authors claim is not warranted the section of the study which is the basis of the conclusion cited and the subject of this note is a cross section regression analysis full details of which are shown in mosley et al table 3 the note is concerned with the relation between the dependent variable specified as the growth rate of real gdp per cent per annum hereafter gdp and aid specified as a percentage of gdp hereafter aid the aid results with only two significant positive coefficients in one subsample certainly give no basis for claiming aid effectiveness in terms of gdp growth the intention in this note is to interpret the results which are assumed to be valid this is made possible by the fact that the authors have helpfully provided the full input set of mean values derived from the raw data from this it is possible to calculate the gdp aid relationship for each country for the second and third period the procedure for deriving these relationships is as follows for each country the mean values of the time series of gdp and aid are extracted from the data for i 960 70 and for i 970 80 using i 960 70 as the base the signs of the change in the levels of the gdp and aid mean values between periods are recorded this is repeated for i980 4 with i970 80 mean values as the base the relationship between the two signs is an indication of the effect of aid on gdp in the period in which the change in levels is effected thus in the case of an increase in aid being combined with a decrease in gdp the latter must have fallen relatively to the former and aid effectiveness is negative mutatis mutandis for the other three sign combinations thus generating the appropriate gdp aid relationship for each country in each period a frequency distribution of the four sign combinations relating to the full sample is presented in table i since the signs of the changes in the levels of gdp and aid are derived by making explicit the arithmetic relationship implicit in the data they form a valid base from which to draw conclusions without requiring any test of

distributive justice in taxation abstract a classical criterion for apportioning taxes is that all should sacrifice equally in loss of utility suppose that a method of apportioning taxes is continuous and has the following four properties i the way that taxpayers split a given tax total depends only on their own taxable incomes ii an increase in the tax total implies that everyone pays more iii every incremental increase in tax is apportioned according to taxpayers current after tax incomes iv the ordering of taxpayers by pre tax income and after tax income is the same then there exists a utility function relative to which all sacrifice equally

aid poverty reduction and the new conditionality the paper examines the effect of aid on poverty rather than on economic growth we devise a pro poor public expenditure index and present evidence that together with inequality and corruption this is a key determinant of the aid s poverty leverage after presenting empirical evidence which suggests a positive leverage of aid donors on pro poor expenditure we argue for the development of conditionality in a new form which gives greater flexibility to donors in punishing slippage on previous commitments and keys aid disbursements to performance in respect of policy variables which governments can influence in a pro poor direction

aid nontraded goods and the transfer paradox in small countries this paper constructs a model of the transfer paradox for a small open economy with nontraded goods it demonstrates that increased production of nontraded goods can change their domestic price so as to offset the otherwise beneficial effect of aid and under certain conditions to create a transfer paradox even in a small country the model is estimated with time series data for 44 aid dependent countries for the period 1970 90 the results support the model and show that the nontraded goods expansion effect is more likely to cause immiserization than harry g johnson s 1967 tariff distorting export displacement effect

foreign aid and government fiscal behaviour in low income south asian countries the major purpose of this study was to analyse the relationship between foreign aid and government fiscal behaviour using a pooled sample of three low income south asian countries pakistan india and sri lanka a simultaneous equation system was developed and estimated using nonlinear three stage least squares procedure the results confirm the hypothesis that foreign aid affects both the expenditure and the revenue side of the recipient government budgets both grants and loans are used for consumption as well as for investment purposes however grants leak into consumption more than loans thus if the purpose of aid is to generate investment it is more helpful if donors extend loans to the developing countries than by giving grants the results also indicate that both grants and loans increase the taxation effort multilateral aid actually pulls resources out of consumption and places them into investment projects thus the results confirm the assertion that a shift from bilateral to multilateral ai

does economic analysis improve the quality of foreign assistance the world bank undertakes an annual expenditure of around 60 million on country specific economic analysis and advice for its member developing countries what is the impact of this economic and sector work on the quality of world bank lending it will be useful to know whether past analytical work has generated measurable economic benefits that will justify its continued provision in an environment of increasingly scarce resources this article sets out an idealized model of decision making in which a country manager makes a broad allocation of resources between lending services and economic and sector work given that decision the task manager for each project makes project specific decisions with respect to the allocation of resources between preparation and supervision the analysis indicates that economic and sector work has a significant positive impact on the quality of world bank loans the results provide clear evidence of underinvestment in economic and sector work and the analysis shows that resources can be switched from preparation and supervision to economic and sector work to the benefit of both the quality of programs and level of disbursements

foreign aid and the question of fungibility this paper analyzes whether the foreign assistance provided for specific categories of expenditure is shifted among them contrary to the wishes of donors it also considers whether aid reduces the tax effort of recipient governments econometric results are presented for the dominican republic that show that the fungibility of aid has resulted in a thwarting of the intentions of donors an attempt is made to account for the observed differences in behavior of individual countries in altering expenditures copyright 1993 by mit press

the macroeconomic impact of development aid a critical survey the early literature explained aid s macroeconomic impact in the context of the dual gap model showing a clear link between aid and growth many now believe that the empirical evidence shows there to be no such relationship this paper critically reviews the different theoretical perspectives the dual gap model the savings debate recipient fiscal response and aid as dutch disease and the empirical debates on aid savings and growth the basis for denying a relationship between aid and growth is shown to be weak though more recent areas of research offer promising directions for future work

is foreign aid fungible evidence from the education and health sectors this paper adopts a new approach to the issue of foreign aid fungibility in contrast to most existing empirical studies panel data are employed that contain information on the specific purposes for which aid is given this allows linking aid that is provided for education and health purposes to recipient public spending in these sectors in addition aid flows that are recorded on a recipient s budget are distinguished from those that are not recorded on budget and the previous failure to differentiate between on and off budget aid is shown to produce biased estimates of fungibility sector program aid is the measure of on budget aid whereas technical cooperation serves as a proxy for off budget aid the appropriate treatment of off budget aid leads to lower fungibility estimates than those reported in many previous studies specifically in both sectors and across a range of specifications technical cooperation which is the largest component of total education and health aid leads to at most a small displacement of recipient public expenditures

donor preferences and recipient fiscal behavior a simultaneous analysis of foreign aid we theoretically develop and empirically estimate a preference model determining foreign aid donor behavior aid access and levels are separately determined by endogenous budgetary allocations the international economic environment the distribution of income between countries basic human needs the small country effect and regional bias we find fungibility of aid in recipient budgets is due to donor and recipient preferences despite the importance of other economic influences we find a significant pro poor country bias in aid allocations although little aggregate influence of basic human needs or regional bias the small country effect is significant for two of six donors jel f35 o19 h 77

decision processes agency problems and information an economic analysis of capital budgeting procedures corporations use a variety of processes to allocate capital this article studies the benefits and costs of several common budget procedures from the perspective of a model with agency and information problems processes that delegate aspects of the decision to the agent result in too many projects being approved while processes in which the principal retains the right to reject projects cause the agent to strategically distort his information about project quality we show how the choice of a decision process depends on these two costs and specifically on severity of the agency problem quality of information and project risk capital budgeting would be easy in a world without agency and information problems the decision maker would simply calculate a project s irr and compare it to the cost of capital but in the real world those providing the funds for investment must rely on self interested agents to identify projects and provide information on expected returns as a result the quality of capital allocation depends on how effective the decision process is in attenuating agency problems and bringing forth accurate information corporations employ a variety of decision procedures in practice some decisions are fully delegated to division and plant managers typically expansion of an existing plant some decisions require approval of headquarters typically construction of a new plant and other decisions require approval conditional on the nature of the proposal such as when projects requiring more than 1 million go to headquarters while smaller projects can be approved locally 1

delegation versus an approval process and the demand for talent abstract in many organizations a principal uses simple decision rules or decision processes as opposed to complete contingent monetary contracts to regulate a more informed agent s behavior this paper models two such rules delegation and an approval process we determine the principal s preferable rule under different conditions and characterize the optimal demand for talent in addition we describe the agent s expected welfare under these rules and characterize how different talent might sort into the rules if the decision process is not a choice or if the principal chooses approval for private gain the demand for talent can be tied to the magnitude of loss in the worst state rather than the degree of discretion given to the manager however if the principal has discretion over the decision process and proper incentives then more talent is demanded under delegation

fiscal effects of foreign aid in a federal system of governance the case of india abstract this paper models fiscal effects of foreign aid in a federal system of governance our main innovation is to incorporate the inter governmental fiscal link in examining economic fungibility of foreign aid the model is applied to the expenditure decisions of the central government of india the two main findings are i foreign aid merely substitutes for spending that the government would have undertaken anyway funds freed by aid are spent on non development activities and ii in passing earmarked external assistance to states the central government makes a reduction in its transfers to states these findings indicate that the central government s expenditure choices are unaffected by external assistance the implication for donors is that even though their development projects may be associated with very high rates of economic return they could be assisting the central government in financing something very different at the margin for the state governments the finding indicates that they may not be reaping the full benefits of externally procured assistance

effective aid how democracy allows development aid to improve the quality of life abstract research into foreign aid has mostly focused on its ability to affect economic i e gdp per capita growth conclusions have been mixed i consider aid s effectiveness differently by its ability to improve quality of life i find that though aid does not affect quality of life in the aggregate it is effective when combined with democracy and ineffective and possibly harmful in autocracies the results suggest that aid would be more effective if it were combined with efforts to encourage democratization

aid catastrophes and the samaritan s dilemma this paper discusses the impact of foreign aid on the recipient country s preparedness against natural disasters the theoretical model shows that foreign aid can have two opposing eects on a country s level of mitigating activities in order to test the theoretical propositions we analyse the eect of foreign aid dependence on ex ante riskmanagement activity proxied by the death toll from major storms floods and earthquakes occurring worldwide between 1980 and 2002 we find evidence that the crowding out eect of foreign aid outweighs the preventive eect in the case of storms while there is mixed evidence in the case of floods and earthquakes

roads out of poverty assessing the links between aid public investment growth and poverty reduction the authors develop a macroeconomic framework that captures links between aid public investment growth and poverty public investment is disaggregated into education infrastructure and health and affects both aggregate supply and demand dutch disease effects are captured by accounting for changes in the relative price of domestic goods the authors assess the impact of policy shocks on poverty by linking the model to a household survey they calibrate the model for ethiopia and simulate the changes in the allocation of aid and public investment the authors also calculate the amount by which foreign aid should increase to reach the poverty targets of the millennium development goals

the anarchy of numbers aid development and cross country empirics the recent literature contains many stories of how foreign aid affects economic growth aid raises growth in countries with good policies or with difficult economic environments or outside the tropics or on average but with diminishing returns the diversity of the results suggests that many are fragile seven important aid growth papers are tested for robustness using 14 minimally arbitrary tests deriving mainly from differences among the studies themselves this approach investigates the importance of potentially arbitrary specification choices while minimizing the arbitrariness in testing choices all of the results appear fragile especially to sample expansion

aid policies and growth comment in an extraordinarily influential paper craig burnside and david dollar 2000 p 847 find that aid has a positive impact on growth in developing countries with good fiscal monetary and trade policies but has little effect in the presence of poor policies this finding has enormous policy implications the burnside and dollar 2000 henceforth bd result provides a role and strategy for foreign aid if aid stimulates growth only in countries with good policies this suggests that 1 aid can promote economic growth and 2 it is crucial that foreign aid be distributed selectively to countries that have adopted sound policies international aid agencies public policy makers and the press quickly recognized the importance of the bd findings this paper reassesses the links between aid policy and growth using more data the bd data end in 1993 we reconstruct the bd database from original sources and thus 1 add additional countries and observations to the bd data set because new information has become available since they conducted their analyses and 2 extend the data through 1997 thus using the bd methodology we reexamine whether aid influences growth in the presence of good policies given our focus on retesting bd we do not summarize the vast pre bd literature on aid and growth we just note that there was a long and inconclusive literature that was hampered by limited data availability debates about the mechanisms through which aid would affect growth and disagreements over econometric specification see gustav f papanek 1972 robert cassen 1986 paul mosley et al 1987 peter boone 1994 1996 and henrik hansen and finn tarp s 2000 review since bd found that aid boosts growth in good policy environments there have been a number of other papers reacting to their results including paul collier and jan dehn 2001 carljohan dalgaard and hansen 2001 patrick guillaumont and lisa chauvet 2001 hansen and tarp 2001 robert lensink and howard white 2001 and collier and dollar 2002 these papers conduct useful variations and extensions some of which had already figured in the pre bd literature such as introducing additional control variables using nonlinear specifications etc some of these papers confirm the message that aid only works in a good policy environment while others drive out the aid policy interaction term with other variables this literature has the usual limitations of choosing a specification without clear guidance from theory which often means there are more plausible specifications than there are data points in the sample we differentiate our paper from these others by not deviating from the bd specification thus we do not test the robustness of the results to an unlimited number of variations but instead maintain the bd methodology this paper conducts a very simple robustness check by adding new data that were unavailable to bd thus we expand the sample used over their time period and extend the data from 1993 to 1997 easterly department of economics new york university 269 mercer street new york ny 10003 center for global development and national bureau of economic research e mail william easterly nyu edu levine department of finance carlson school of management university of minnesota 321 19th avenue south minneapolis mn 55455 and national bureau of economic research e mail rlevine csom umn edu roodman center for global development 1776 massachusetts avenue nw washington dc 20036 e mail droodman cgdev org we are grateful to craig burnside for supplying data and assisting in the reconstruction of previous results without holding him responsible in any way for the work in this paper thanks also to francis ng and prarthna dayal for generous assistance with updating the sachs warner openness variable and to three anonymous referees craig burnside and henrik hansen for helpful comments 1 see for instance the world bank 1994 2001 2002 the u k department for international development 2000 president george w bush s speech march 16 2002 the announcement by the white house on creating the millennium challenge corporation white house 2002 as well as a washington post editorial february 9 2002 a financial times column by alan beattie march 11 2002 and the economist march 16 2002

aid growth and devolution summary this paper examines whether the degree of fiscal decentralization in aid receiving countries matters in explaining aid effectiveness the decentralization theorem predicts that the devolution of powers should increase aid effectiveness since local decision makers are better informed about local needs thereby decentralization may also have reverse effects e g through coordination problems excessive regulation administrative costs and local capture we use panel data for up to 60 countries and find that aid contributes to economic growth in centralized developing economies whereas it is less effective or even harmful in decentralized countries the cases of indonesia the philippines and uganda support our findings our results imply that donor countries should carefully consider how the two development instruments foreign aid and decentralization interact

growth in africa does the source of investment financing matter this paper examines empirical evidence for 11 sub saharan african countries on the relationship between economic growth and three principal sources of investment funds foreign aid foreign direct investment and domestic saving in light of the shortcomings of traditional cross section analyses the time series approach is used instead modern time series methods are rigorously applied beginning with unit root tests and followed by model specifications that reflect the revealed temporal behaviours of the variables in each of the 11 countries domestic saving seems to play a somewhat more important role in generating economic growth than foreign direct investment or foreign aid however the mixture of results across the 11 countries implies that in general it is not possible to rank one source of investment financing ahead of any other

exogenous shocks foreign aid and civil war the recent civil war literature suggests that negative economic shocks in low income countries increase the risk of civil war foreign aid can be an effective conflict prevention tool in times of severe economic conditions aid cushions government spending from the downward pressures of economic shocks providing recipient governments with resources they can use to make rebellion a less attractive option for aggrieved domestic groups using official development assistance oda data covering 1990 through 2004 we find that foreign aid appears to be a useful tool for preventing civil wars in the wake of negative economic shocks and as such aid should be assessed by donors with these conflict suppressing aspects in mind

a new approach to the allocation of aid among developing countries is the usa different from the rest summary this paper attempts to explain the factors that determine the geographical allocation of foreign aid its novelty is that it develops a rigorous theoretical model and conducts the corresponding empirical investigations based on a large panel dataset we run regressions for different major donors united states canada france italy japan united kingdom and multilateral organizations with the explicit objective of establishing whether the united states in light of its geopolitical hegemony behaves differently from others we find that all the donors respond to recipient need in their allocation of aid but that the united states puts less emphasis on this than the other donors with the exception of japan we also find that the united states puts more emphasis on donor recipient linkages than do the other donors suggesting that the united states attaches greater importance to issues of donor interest for example geopolitical commercial and other links with specific recipients

aid instability as a measure of uncertainty and the positive impact of aid on growth this article contributes to the literature on aid and economic growth we posit that uncertainty measured as the instability of aid receipts will influence the relationship between aid and investment how recipient governments respond to aid and will capture the fact that some countries are especially vulnerable to shocks when we account for uncertainty which is negative and significant we find that aid has a significant positive effect on growth largely due to its effect on the volume of investment the finding that uncertainty of aid receipts reduces the effectiveness of aid is robust when the regression is estimated for the sub sample of african countries these findings hold although the effectiveness of aid appears weaker than for the full sample

politics and the effectiveness of foreign aid abstract critics of foreign aid programs have long argued that poverty reflects government failure in this paper i test predictions for aid effectiveness based on an analytical framework that relates aid effectiveness to political regimes i find that aid does not significantly increase investment nor benefit the poor as measured by improvements in human development indicators but it does increase the size of government the impact of aid does not vary according to whether recipient governments are liberal democratic or highly repressive but liberal political regimes and democracies ceteris paribus have on average 30 lower infant mortality than the least free regimes this may be due to greater empowerment of the poor under liberal regimes even though the political elite continues to receive the benefits of aid programs an implication is that short term aid targeted to support new liberal regimes may be a more successful means of reducing poverty than current programs

are there lasting impacts of aid to poor areas abstract the paper re visits the site of a large world bank financed rural development program in china 10 years after it began and four years after disbursements ended the program emphasized community participation in multi sectoral interventions including farming animal husbandry infrastructure and social services data were collected on 2000 households in project and non project areas spanning 10 years a double difference estimator of the program s impact on top of pre existing governmental programs reveals sizeable short term income gains that were mostly saved only small and statistically insignificant gains to mean consumption emerged in the longer term though in rough accord with the average gain to permanent income the use of community based beneficiary selection greatly reduced the overall impact given that the educated poor were under covered the main results are robust to corrections for various sources of selection bias including village targeting and interference due to spillover effects generated by the response of local governments to the external aid

donor bias towards small countries an overlooked factor in the analysis of foreign aid and economic growth the consensus of the literature is that international cross sectional data do not reveal a stable relationship between foreign aid and economic growth a conclusion which weakens the case for giving aid however previous econometric analysis has not made allowance for the fact that larger countries grow faster but receive less aid in this paper it is demonstrated that when due allowance is made for the effects of country size a positive and significant relationship between aid and growth can be shown to exist

is foreign aid fungible the case of indonesia this paper considers whether foreign aid given for specific categories of expenditure is fungible among them and whether aid reduces tax effort by the recipient government models developed to analyze the fiscal relations among different levels of government in the united states are applied to analysis of the impact of foreign aid econometric analysis of data for indonesia reveals that aid is largely spent as the donors intended that aid does not lead to a reduction in tax effort and that aid is not diverted to nondevelopment current expenditures copyright 1990 by royal economic society

aid and growth regressions this paper examines the relationship between foreign aid and growth in real gdp per capita as it emerges from simple augmentations of popular cross country growth specifications it is shown that aid in all likelihood increases the growth rate and this result is not conditional on good policy there are however decreasing returns to aid and the estimated effectiveness of aid is highly sensitive to the choice of estimator and the set of control variables when investment and human capital are controlled for no positive effect of aid is found yet aid continues to impact on growth via investment we conclude by stressing the need for more theoretical work before this kind of cross country regressions are used for policy purposes

the fungibility of u s military and non military assistance and the impacts on expenditures of major aid recipients abstract this paper examines the impact of u s military and non military assistance on the allocation of public and private sector spending for eight major recipients over the 1972 1987 period the model assumes that an aid recipient s effective post assistance budget constraint is a priori unknown and must be estimated two versions of the model are tested in version a the data is converted into real u s dollars using official exchange rates in version b the data is converted using purchasing power parity exchange rates provided by summers and heston 1991 major findings are the same for both versions u s aid is highly fungible with a significant portion channeled to the private sector where it finances current consumption relatively more than investment