national co2 policy and externalities some general equilibrium results for switzerland abstract switzerland following the kyoto agreement plans to reduce co 2 emissions by 10 over the next decade with a tax on the use of fossil fuels this policy while having a marginal effect on global co 2 emission levels will have a positive effect on local environmental quality however since different sources of energy produce different local external effects a uniform co 2 tax is ill targeted this paper shows that a policy setting tax rates equal to the lower bounds of the estimated local marginal external effects would reduce the national co 2 level by 30 using a computable general equilibrium model of the swiss economy it also finds substantial efficiency gains of pigovian taxes as compared to a uniform co 2 tax

implicit co2 prices of fossil fuel use in switzerland abstract this study aims to assess the efficiency of the fossil fuel taxation scheme currently in effect in switzerland to this end the concept of implicit co2 prices is introduced based on which prices for different fossil fuel uses are derived implicit co2 prices are defined as the difference between actual prices paid by consumers and efficient domestic fuel prices efficient domestic fuel prices in turn consist of private production costs a uniform value added tax and only local external costs not including external costs due to co2 emissions and global climate change the resulting prices differ substantially which suggests that there is considerable cost saving potential in reducing co2 emissions in switzerland for passenger cars and air traffic the implicit prices are negative for these uses higher fuel charges would therefore be beneficial from a purely domestic perspective i e without considering the negative repercussions of global warming

price determination in the eu ets market theory and econometric analysis with market fundamentals abstract we investigate the price determination of the european union emission allowance eua of the european union emissions trading scheme eu ets we postulate an uncertain permit price and risk averse firms which have the possibility to hedge in the forward market the firms produce final goods abate their emissions and trade permits in the permit market the dependence of the equilibrium permit price on exogenous variables is studied in a permit market model we test our theoretical findings with empirical data from 2005 to 2010 in the eu ets market we use daily forward prices of eua as our dependent variable we use several econometric models with multiple stationary time series to discover that there is a strong relationship between the fundamentals such as german electricity prices and gas and coal prices with the price of eua we find that the eua forward price depends on fundamentals especially on the price of electricity as well as on the gas coal difference in a statistically significant way

speculative and hedging activities in the european carbon market abstract we explore the dynamics of the speculative and hedging activities in european futures carbon markets by using volume and open interest data a comparison of the three phases in the european union emission trading scheme eu ets reveals that i phase ii of the eu ets seems to be the most speculative phase to date and ii the highest degree of speculative activity for every single phase occurs at the moment of listing the contracts for the first time a seasonality analysis identifies a higher level of speculation in the first quarter of each year related to the schedule of deadlines of the eu ets in addition a time series analysis confirms that most of the speculative activity each year occurs in the front contract whereas the hedging demand concentrates in the second to deliver futures contract

measuring the efficiency of china s carbon market a comparison between efficient and fractal market hypotheses abstract in this study variance ratio test and detrended fluctuation analysis are adopted to measure the efficiencies of beijing guangdong hubei shanghai shenzhen tianjin and chongqing seven carbon markets in china the empirical results indicate that on the basis of efficient market hypothesis adopts variance ratio test hubei and guangdong markets are weak efficient beijing shenzhen and shanghai markets are inefficient and the efficiencies of tianjin and chongqing are uncertain under daily returns all seven carbon markets are weak efficient under weekly returns on the basis of fractal market hypothesis hurst exponents are obtained by detrended fluctuation analysis shanghai guangdong and hubei markets are weak efficient the other four markets are inefficient under daily returns beijing and hubei markets are weak efficient and the other five markets are inefficient under weekly returns on the whole the efficiencies of china s carbon markets are generally low combining the empirical results with the reality of china s carbon markets it s proved that the results of fractal market hypothesis are more convincing in comparison to efficient market hypothesis fractal market hypothesis can more effectively measure the efficiency of carbon market

role of carbon swap trading and energy prices in price correlations and volatilities between carbon markets the present paper theoretically and empirically examines the role of carbon swap trading and energy prices in volatilities and price correlations between the eu and kyoto protocol emissions trading schemes a supply and demand based correlation model between eua and scer price returns is proposed in detail using inverse box cox type marginal abatement cost mac curves and simple emission reduction volume processes the model includes financial players eua scer swap transaction in boom periods of carbon prices using the logit model for eua and eua scer swap volume correlations and stronger energy price impacts on eua prices than scer prices using a mean reverting lognormal process for energy prices the empirical studies using eua and scer prices estimate the model parameters resulting in a positive eua volume impact on eua scer swap transactions and a positive energy price impact on eua prices it is shown that high eua scer price correlations during high eua price periods stemmed from eua scer swap transactions whereas high eua scer price correlations during the period of financial turmoil with low eua prices came from the drop in energy prices we also show that the leverage effects often observed in security markets exist in both the eua and scer markets according to the price volatility relation

dynamic behavior of co2 spot prices co2 emission allowances are traded nowadays over the counter otc and on exchanges across the european union eu it thus becomes increasingly important for traders of these emission certificates to have a valid co2 spot price model to value potential derivatives in addition co2 emitting companies require an adequate co2 spot price model in order to better assess their production costs and support emissions related investment decisions however sufficient price history is still lacking for the european union emission trading scheme eu ets we therefore present a tractable stochastic equilibrium model reflecting stylized features of the eu ets and analyze the resulting co2 spot price dynamics our main findings are that co2 prices do not have to follow any seasonal patterns discounted prices should possess the martingale property and an adequate co2 price process should exhibit a time and price dependent volatility structure a brief empirical examination regarding market efficiency complements our analysis

a multimarket decision making framework for genco considering emission trading scheme in a multimarket environment a genco produces electricity subject to a number of factors including physical and environmental constraints together with trading strategies in the electricity market em fuel market fm and carbon market cm to assist a genco to maximize its profits from em fm and cm this paper proposes a dynamic decision making model with two consecutive stages fuzzy differential evolution algorithm is used to solve this decision making problem taking transactions in the three interactive markets into account the proposed model has been tested for a genco consisting of seven thermal units and a wind farm a rational tradeoff between the profit making and emission reduction has been demonstrated by the genco using the proposed model indicating a well alignment with the intended goal of the introducing emission trading scheme ets

nonparametric modeling of carbon prices this paper constitutes the first exercise of nonparametric modeling applied to carbon markets the framework of analysis is carefully detailed and the empirical application unfolds in the case of bluenext spot and ecx futures prices the data is gathered in daily frequency from april 2005 to april 2010 first we document the presence of strong nonlinearities in the conditional mean functions second the conditional volatility functions reveal an asymmetric and heteroskedastic behavior which is dramatically different between carbon spot and futures logreturns the results for spot prices are also robust to subsamples decomposition third we show in an out of sample forecasting exercise that nonparametric modeling allows reducing the prediction error by almost 15 compared to linear ar models this latter result is confirmed by the diebold mariano pairwise test statistic

predicting carbon market risk using information from macroeconomic fundamentals abstract economic theories suggest that carbon price movements are closely related to economic fundamentals this paper develops an economic state dependent sd approach to evaluate carbon market value at risk var that incorporates information from macroeconomic fundamentals into carbon return var modeling and forecasting this method implements an economic sd sampling scheme that utilizes historical carbon return observations from the relevant economic states to predict future carbon market var applying this sd method to the european union eu carbon market we confirm that the eu fundamental economy has two distinct states that correspond to expansion and recession periods and that the carbon returns have different distributions in the two states we find that the sd method outperforms the traditional non sd methods in out of sample var forecasts and this is particularly evident when the carbon market experiences large scale economy driven structural breaks

an econometric analysis of emission allowance prices knowledge of the statistical distribution of the prices of emission allowances and their forecastability are crucial in constructing among other things purchasing and risk management strategies in the emissions constrained markets this paper analyzes the two emission permits markets co2 in europe and so2 in the us and investigates a model for dealing with the unique stylized facts of this type of data its effectiveness in terms of model fit and out of sample value at risk forecasting as compared to models commonly used in risk forecasting contexts is demonstrated

effects of carbon taxes in an economy with prior tax distortions an intertemporal general equilibrium analysis abstract this paper analyzes the costs of carbon taxes in a model that recognizes interactions between this tax and pre existing taxes first we examine the extent to which costs of a u s carbon tax are reduced when its revenues finance cuts in income taxes such use of revenues significantly reduces but does not eliminate the overall policy costs the positive overall costs reflect the carbon tax s focus on intermediate inputs and its relatively narrow base in comparison with income taxes we also examine the sensitivity of the carbon tax s costs to the level of pre existing taxes for any given use of revenues welfare costs rise significantly with pre existing tax rates indicating that models disregarding pre existing taxes may substantially understate the costs of new environmental tax initiatives

carbon trading thickness and market efficiency abstract this note tests for the efficient market hypothesis emh in the market for co 2 emission allowances in phase i and phase ii of the european union emissions trading scheme eu ets as usually is the case in emerging and non competitive markets such as the eu ets trading often not occurs on a frequent basis this has adverse implications for both the gains from permit trade as well as biases the emh tests variance ratio tests are employed to adjust for the thin trading effect the results indicate that phase i the trial and learning period was inefficient whereas the first period under phase ii shows signs of restoring market efficiency

on the efficiency of the european carbon market new evidence from phase ii i examine in the period 2008 2011 the efficiency of four carbon dioxide co2 emission allowance futures traded in the intercontinental exchange ice to this end i assess the profitability of trading strategies based on simple technical analysis rules and naive forecasts the results from 2010 onwards are consistent with weak market efficiency in turn this finding suggests that the european carbon market is gradually attaining a state of maturity

an empirical analysis of energy cost pass through to co2 emission prices abstract we use the nonlinear autoregressive distributed lag nardl model to analyze the asymmetric and nonlinear pass through effects of changes in crude oil prices natural gas prices coal prices and electricity prices on the co 2 emission allowance prices we find that i the crude oil prices have a long run negative and asymmetric effect on the co 2 allowance prices ii the decreases in the coal prices have a stronger impact on the carbon prices in the short run than the increases iii the natural gas prices and electricity prices have a symmetric effect on the carbon prices but this effect is negative for the former and positive for the latter these findings are robust when using both monthly and daily data and when considering bivariate and multivariate models

price discovery and volatility spillovers in the european union emissions trading scheme a high frequency analysis abstract this paper models the relationship of european union allowance spot and futures prices within the second commitment period of the european union emissions trading scheme based on high frequency data we analyze the transmission of information in first and second conditional moments to reveal long run price discovery we compute common factor weights of schwarz and szakmary 1994 and information shares of hasbrouck 1995 based on estimated coefficients of a vecm to analyze the short run dynamics we perform granger causality tests we identify the futures market to be the leader of the long run price discovery process whereas the informational role of the futures market increases over time in addition we employ a version of the ueccc garch model as introduced by conrad and karanasos 2010 to analyze the volatility transmission structure the volatility analysis indicates a close relationship between the volatility dynamics of both markets whereas in particular we observe spillovers from the futures to the spot market as a whole the investigation reveals that the futures market incorporates information first and then transfers the information to the spot market

environmental prices uncertainty and learning there is an increasing demand for putting a shadow price on the environment to guide public policy and incentivize private behaviour in practice setting that price can be extremely difficult as uncertainties abound there is often uncertainty not just about individual parameters but about the structure of the problem and how to model it a further complication is the second best nature of real environmental policy making in this paper we propose some practical steps for setting prices in the face of these difficulties drawing on the example of climate change we consider how to determine the overall target for environmental protection how to set shadow prices to deliver that target and how we can learn from the performance of policies to revise targets and prices perhaps most significantly we suggest that estimates of the marginal cost of environmental protection rather than the marginal benefit will often provide the more consistent and robust prices for achieving targets

air pollutant taxation an empirical survey abstract this paper provides an empirical analysis of the current taxation of the air pollutants sulphur dioxide nitrogen oxide and carbon dioxide in the scandinavian countries the netherlands france and japan political motivation and technical factors such as tax base rate structure and revenue use are compared conclusions are drawn characterizing the general concepts of the current policies

a model for energy pricing with stochastic emission costs we use a supply demand approach to value energy products exposed to emission cost uncertainty we find closed form solutions for a number of popularly traded energy derivatives such as forwards european call options written on spot prices and european call options written on forward contracts our modeling approach is to first construct noisy supply and demand processes and then equate them to find an equilibrium price this approach is very general while still allowing for sensitivity analysis within a valuation setting our assumption is that in the presence of emission costs traditional supply growth will slow down causing output prices of energy products to become more costly over time however emission costs do not immediately cause output price appreciation but instead expose individual projects particularly those with high emission outputs to much more extreme risks through the cost side of their profit stream our results have implications for hedging and pricing for producers operating in areas facing a stochastic emission cost environment

modeling and explaining the dynamics of european union allowance prices at high frequency in this paper we model the adjustment process of european union allowance eua prices to the releases of announcements at high frequency controlling for intraday periodicity volatility clustering and volatility persistence we find that the high frequency eua price dynamics are very well captured by a fractionally integrated asymmetric power garch process the decisions of the european commission on second national allocation plans have a strong and immediate impact on eua prices on the other hand our results suggest that eua prices are only weakly connected to indicators about the future economic development as well as the current economic activity

smart srec a stochastic model of the new jersey solar renewable energy certificate market markets for solar renewable energy certificates srecs are gaining in promi nence in many states stimulating growth of the u s solar industry however srec market prices have been extremely volatile causing high risk to participants and potentially less investment in solar power generation such concerns necessitate the development of realis tic flexible and tractable models of srec prices that capture the behavior of participants given the rules that govern the market we propose an original stochastic model called smart srec to fill this role building on established ideas from the carbon pricing liter ature and including a feedback mechanism for generation response to prices we calibrate the model to the new jersey market and backtest it analyzing parameter sensitivity and demonstrating its ability to reproduce historical dynamics finally we run simulations to investigate the role and impact of regulatory parameters thus providing insight into the crucial role played by market design

modeling eu allowances and oil market interdependence implications for portfolio management abstract this paper examines the dependence structure between european union allowances euas and crude oil markets during the second commitment period of the european union emissions trading scheme and the implications for portfolio management using different copula models our findings suggest positive average dependence and extreme symmetric independence that is consistent with interdependence and no contagion effects between the eua and crude oil markets the implication of this result for eua oil portfolios points to the existence of diversification benefits hedging effectiveness and value at risk reductions the eua market is therefore an attractive market for investors in terms of diversifying market risk and reducing downside risk in crude oil markets

norwegian climate policy reforms in the presence of an international quota market abstract this study shows that the second best optimal difference between tax rates on goods that generate greenhouse gas emissions and non polluting goods is equal to the quota price plus a ramsey tax on the quota price when emission quotas are traded between governments and the price elasticity of these goods is identical this tax difference exceeds the second best optimal difference between tax rates on goods that generate a negative externality equivalent to the quota price and non polluting goods model simulations show that a unilateral increase in emission tax to above the international quota price generates a welfare gain for norway model simulations also show that an international tax quota price increase generates a welfare gain loss for norway if norwegian imports of oil become substantial marginal in the long run

the efficiency of the crude oil markets evidence from variance ratio tests this study examines the random walk hypothesis for the crude oil markets using daily data over the period 1982 2008 the weak form efficient market hypothesis for two crude oil markets uk brent and us west texas intermediate is tested with non parametric variance ratio tests developed by wright j h 2000 alternative variance ratio tests using ranks and signs journal of business and economic statistics 18 1 9 and belaire franch j and contreras d 2004 ranks and signs based multiple variance ratio tests working paper department of economic analysis university of valencia as well as the wild bootstrap variance ratio tests suggested by kim j h 2006 wild bootstrapping variance ratio tests economics letters 92 38 43 we find that the brent crude oil market is weak form efficiency while the wti crude oil market seems to be inefficiency on the 1994 2008 sub period suggesting that the deregulation have not improved the efficiency on the wti crude oil market in the sense of making returns less predictable

efficient timing of communication in multiperiod agencies this paper examines communication in a two period principal agent model in which the agent receives a private signal about the second outcome before the first outcome is realized no communication is compared with communication at three possible dates before the first outcome early at the first outcome consumption date normal and between the initial consumption date and the second outcome delayed delayed communication is shown to have no value if the agent s information is perfect but can have value if it is imperfect early and normal communication can be used to smooth compensation across periods and hence generally have incremental value over delayed communicationif the agent cannot borrow or save however the smoothing benefits disappear if he can borrow and save early and normal communication are equivalent if the agent has domain additive exponential preferences and the private signal is uninformative about the first outcome if the private signal is informative about the first outcome the incremental value of early compared with normal communication attains its maximum for medium informativeness a unifying example is used throughout

co2 taxes equity and the double dividend macroeconomic model simulations for austria abstract this paper investigates the impacts of co2 tax schemes on co2 emissions equity and macroeconomic indicators in austria with the macroeconomic model dynk aut our scenarios focus on non ets co2 emissions and comprise different tax rates and revenue recycling options lower labor taxes lower vat and lump sum payments the short term comparative scenario analysis indicates that co2 taxes without recycling lead to significant co2 emission reductions at moderate economic costs equity impacts on households depend on the indicator used but can be regressive without recycling most recycling schemes can achieve a double dividend i e emission reductions and increases in gdp lump sum payments are less efficient than reducing the vat or labor taxes equity impacts are progressive with lump sum payments rather proportional with lower vat and regressive with lower labor taxes a combination of recycling schemes and or a restriction of lump sum payments to lower income households can minimize the trade off between equity and efficiency our simulations suggest that well designed co2 tax schemes could be a crucial and socially acceptable element within a comprehensive policy package to achieve ghg emission targets for non ets sectors in austria

on the stochastic properties of carbon futures prices pricing carbon is a central concern in environmental economics due to the worldwide importance of emissions trading schemes to regulate pollution this paper documents the presence of small and large jumps in the stochastic process of the co 2 futures price the large jumps have a discrete origin i e they can arise from various demand factors or institutional decisions on the tradable permits market contrary to the existing literature we show that the stochastic process of carbon futures prices does not contain a continuous component brownian motion the results are derived by using high frequency data in the activity signature function framework todorov and tauchen in j econom 154 125 138 2010 todorov and tauchen in j bus econ stat 29 356 371 2011 the implication is that the carbon futures price should be modeled as an appropriately sampled centered levy or poisson process the pure jump behavior of the carbon price might be explained by the lower volume of trades on this allowance market compared to other highly liquid financial markets

modeling co2 emission allowance prices and derivatives evidence from the european trading scheme this paper studies the three main markets for emission allowances within the european union emissions trading scheme eu ets powernext nord pool and european climate exchange ecx the analysis suggests that the prohibition of banking of emission allowances between distinct phases of the eu ets has significant implications in terms of futures pricing motivated by these findings we develop an empirically and theoretically valid framework for the pricing and hedging of intra phase and inter phase futures and options on futures respectively

research on the efficiency of carbon trading market in china abstract in 2014 china proposed medium and long term low carbon development goals in china u s joint statement on climate change that the emission of carbon dioxide would reach its peak and the proportion of non fossil energy accounted for the primary energy consumption would increase to 20 in 2030 in order to achieve these goals the unified carbon emission trading system should be put into effect by 2017 the implementation of the unified carbon emission trading system depends on the effectiveness of the current carbon trading market in china on the basis of the effective market theory and fair game model the unit root test and the run test are developed to analyze the carbon emission market of four representative cities in china the results show that 1 the carbon trading market in china has only achieved weak efficiency while the semi strong efficiency and the strong efficiency have not been reached 2 with the expansion of the market scale the increase of trading volume the carbon trading market would converge from the state of inefficiency to weak form efficiency gradually and the carbon trading market in china shows signs of restoring market efficiency

forecasting carbon futures volatility using garch models with energy volatilities abstract this article examines the volatility forecasting abilities of three approaches garch type model that uses carbon futures prices an implied volatility from carbon options prices and the k nearest neighbor model based on the results we document that garch type models perform better than an implied volatility and the k nearest neighbor model this result suggests that carbon options have little information about carbon futures due to their low trading volume we also investigate whether the volatilities of energy markets i e brent oil coal natural gas and electricity forecast following day s carbon futures volatility according to the results we suggest that brent oil coal and electricity may be used to forecast the volatility of carbon futures

multiple bubbles in the european union emission trading scheme abstract the european union emission trading scheme eu ets is the first large scale co 2 emission trading system in the world carbon allowances are financial assets potentially vulnerable to the behavior of traders and investors in fact the carbon price has been quite volatile since the inception of the market and it has recently hit very low values however to date no work exists to evaluate whether volatility and price spikes are due to episodes of speculation and price bubbles our paper fills this gap we use the recent approaches developed by phillips and yu 2010 phillips et al 2011 and phillips et al 2015a 2015b who propose a recursive right sided unit root approaches to detect and date stamp mildly explosive behaviors and carbon market exuberance we complement this methodology by using the wild bootstrap procedure by goncalves and kilian 2004 to control for the heteroschedasticity of carbon price data analyzing the eu ets front month contract price from 2005 to 2014 we find different episodes of price bubbles these episodes are not explained by similar behavior of the fundamentals but seem related to energy and environmental policy announcements our results can provide insightful policy implications in the context of the actual carbon market reform as well as the implementation of stricter financial regulations rules to co 2 trading

are electricity risk premia affected by emission allowance prices evidence from the eex nord pool and powernext the links between emission and energy markets are of great interest to practitioners academics and policy makers in this paper it is conjectured that a positive relationship exists between emission allowance spot returns and electricity risk premia within the european union emissions trading scheme eu ets we discuss how this can be justified on the basis of the substantial uncertainties in the carbon markets we also argue that this link could be due to trading strategies followed by electricity producers who attempt to exploit their initial allocation of free allowances analysis of data from three major markets the eex nord pool and powernext offers empirical support to our conjecture these findings have significant policy implications since they imply that efforts should be made in order to reduce the uncertainty in the carbon markets by clearly defining the eu ets regulative framework and design over the next years moreover our results suggest that the allocation of free allowances and their unrestricted trading enable electricity producers to accomplish windfall profits in the derivatives market at the expense of other market participants

the impacts of liquidity dynamics on emissions allowances price different evidence from china s emissions trading pilots abstract the liquidities of china s emissions trading markets have significant impacts on emissions allowances price movement and pricing efficiency liquidity measures on illiquidity ratio and trade values indicate hubei emissions allowances hbea product has the highest liquidity shenzhen allowances sza and guangdong emissions allowances gdea products have the higher liquidity than beijing emissions allowances bea and shanghai emissions allowances shea products while tianjin emissions allowances tjea product has the lowest market liquidity in considered china s emissions trading pilots the dynamics of the illiquidity ratios for all selected emissions allowances products are negatively related with emissions allowances returns and trade volumes for bea tjea sza and hbea products are also negatively related with emissions allowances returns the dynamics of daily illiquidity ratios and trade based liquidity in beijing tianjin guangdong shenzhen hubei emissions pilots have significant volatility clustering impacts on the variances of regional emissions allowances returns previous market shocks of overnight and intraday price variations have the more persistent influences on the gdea returns than hbea returns reflecting greater inter day price ranges clustering effect

market efficiency in the european carbon markets in this paper we study the relationship between futures and spot prices in the european carbon markets from the cost of carry hypothesis the aim is to investigate the extent of efficiency market the three main european markets bluenext eex and ecx are analyzed during phase ii covering the period from march 13 2009 to january 17 2012 futures contracts are found to be cointegrated with spot prices and interest rates for several maturities in the three co2 markets results are similar when structural breaks are taken into account according to individual and joint tests the cost of carry model is rejected for all maturities and co2 markets implying that neither contract is priced according to the cost of carry model the absence of the cost of carry relationship can be interpreted as an indicator of market inefficiency and may bring arbitrage opportunities in the co2 market

short term contracts and long term agency relationships abstract long term contracts are valuable only if optimal contracting requires commitment to a plan today that would not otherwise be adopted tomorrow we show that commitments are unnecessary and hence short term contracts are sufficient if 1 all public information can be used in contracting 2 the agent can acess a bank on equal terms with the principal 3 recontracting takes place with common knowledge about technology and preferences and 4 the frontier of expected utility payoffs generated by the set of incentive compatible contracts is downward sloping at all times

modeling the price dynamics of co2 emission allowances abstract in this paper we analyze the short term spot price behavior of carbon dioxide co 2 emission allowances of the new eu wide co 2 emissions trading system eu ets after reviewing the stylized facts of this new class of assets we investigate several approaches for modeling the returns of emission allowances due to different phases of price and volatility behavior in the returns we suggest the use of markov switching and ar garch models for stochastic modeling we examine the approaches by conducting an in sample and out of sample forecasting analysis and by comparing the results to alternative approaches our findings strongly support the adequacy of the models capturing characteristics like skewness excess kurtosis and in particular different phases of volatility behavior in the returns

thin versus thick co2 market abstract the idea that trading is more costly the thinner the market is is common in most studies of market exchange with frictions surprisingly this element is lacking from previous attempts to allow for frictions in pollution permit markets this paper considers a co 2 cap and trade model where trading costs develop endogenously as a function of the market size the pre trade allocation of permits determines whether the market size can be strongly influenced by expectations that have a role because of adjustment costs the pre trade allocation also sets preconditions for endogenously vanishing trading costs and thus has nonstandard effects on long run trading levels and market allocations

causes of the eu ets price drop recession cdm renewable policies or a bit of everything new evidence the price of eu allowances euas in the eu emissions trading scheme eu ets fell from almost 30 tco2 in mid 2008 to less than 5 tco2 in mid 2013 the sharp and persistent price decline has sparked intense debates both in academia and among policy makers about the decisive allowance price drivers in this paper we examine whether and to what extent the eua price drop can be justified by three commonly identified explanatory factors the economic recession renewable policies and the use of international credits capitalizing on marginal abatement cost theory and a broadly extended data set we find that only variations in economic activity and the growth of wind and solar electricity production are robustly explaining eua price dynamics contrary to simulation based analyses our results point to moderate interaction effects between the overlapping eu ets and renewable policies the bottom line however is that 90 of the variations of eua price changes remains unexplained by the abatement related fundamentals together our findings do not support the widely held view that negative demand shocks are the main cause of the weak carbon price signal in view of the new evidence we evaluate the eu ets reform options which are currently discussed

carbon price drivers phase i versus phase ii equilibrium abstract the aim of this paper is to investigate the determinants of the carbon price during the two phases of the european union emission trading scheme eu ets more specifically relying on daily eu allowance futures contracts we test whether the carbon price drivers identified for phase i still hold for phase ii and evolve toward a long run relationship using cointegration techniques and accounting for the 2006 structural break in the carbon market we show that while a cointegrating relationship exists for both phases of the eu ets the nature of this equilibrium relationship is different across the two subperiods with an increasing role of fundamentals in phase ii deriving equilibrium values we show that the carbon price tends to be undervalued since the end of 2009

a model of carbon price interactions with macroeconomic and energy dynamics abstract this paper develops a model of carbon pricing by considering two fundamental drivers of european union allowances economic activity and energy prices on the one hand economic activity is proxied by aggregated industrial production in the eu 27 as it provides the best performance in a preliminary forecasting exercise vs other indicators on the other hand brent natural gas and coal prices are selected as being the main carbon price drivers as highlighted by previous literature the interactions between the macroeconomic and energy spheres are captured in a markov switching var model with two states that is able to reproduce the boom bust business cycle hamilton 1989 first industrial production is found to impact positively negatively the carbon market during periods of economic expansion recession thereby confirming the existence of a link between the macroeconomy and the price of carbon second the brent price is confirmed to be the leader in price formation among energy markets bachmeier and griffin 2006 as it impacts other variables through the structure of the markov switching model taken together these results uncover new interactions between the recently created eu emissions market and the pre existing macroeconomic energy environment

trader types and volatility of emission allowance prices evidence from eu ets phase i abstract this paper studies the relation between the trading activity of market participants and the volatility of the european emission allowance price during phase i of the european union emission trading system eu ets we focus on the contrasting roles of different trader types we find evidence of a positive and significant trading activity volatility relation which appears to be stronger when accounting for trader type the positive relation can be mainly attributed to energy providers in contrast industrial companies seem to have traded more frequently when volatility levels were lower finally the non liable players represented by financial intermediaries appear to have acted as a flexible counterparty trading more with the energy sector when volatility was higher and more with the industrial firms when volatility was lower we discuss possible explanations for these contrasted positions understanding the trading activity volatility link is relevant for evaluating the efficiency of the eu ets although the relation is generally positive many players remained often inactive and traded mostly when volatility levels were lower policies targeting the engagement of less active players could lead to a smoother incorporation of information into prices and to an increase in market efficiency

optimal environmental taxation in the presence of other taxes general equilibrium analyses this paper examines the optimal setting of environmental taxes in economies where other distortionary taxes are present we employ analytical and numerical models to explore the degree to which in a second best economy optimal environmental tax rates differ from the rates implied by the pigovian principle according to which the optimal tax rate equals the marginal environmental damages both models indicate contrary to what several analysts have suggested that the optimal tax rate on emissions of a given pollutant is generally less than the rate supported by the pigovian principle moreover the optimal rate is lower the larger are the distortions posed by ordinary taxes numerical results indicate that previous studies may have seriously overstated the size of the optimal carbon tax by disregarding pre existing taxes this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

fat tails and volatility clustering in experimental asset markets abstract this paper presents results from experimental asset markets with asymmetric fundamental information we observe leptokurtic returns and a slowly decaying autocorrelation function of absolute returns in contrast to results from heterogeneous agent models hams we find that noise has no significant influence on the emergence of fat tails instead we observe a significantly positive relationship between the degree of heterogeneity of fundamental information and absolute returns which suggests that heterogeneous fundamental information is the source of fat tails with respect to volatility clustering we discover an intra periodical pattern where absolute returns decrease after the arrival of new asymmetric fundamental information

modeling persistence of carbon emission allowance prices this study reexamines the issue of persistence in carbon emission allowance spot prices using daily data and covering the period from 28 2 2007 to 14 05 2014 for this purpose we use techniques based on the concept of long memory accounting for structural breaks and non linearities in the data with both of these aspects potentially affecting the degree of persistence our results indicate that while there is no evidence of non linearity when allowing for structural breaks persistence of shocks to the carbon emission allowance is markedly reduced with the same being transitory in nature for recent sub samples

modeling and forecasting the volatility of carbon dioxide emission allowance prices a review and comparison of modern volatility models abstract the launch of the markets for carbon dioxide emission allowances was guided by the aim to use the supposedly efficient price formation mechanism of an organized exchange to optimally allocate a certain quantity of emissions among potential polluters while this introduction of a centralized trading arrangement should have helped to achieve required emission reductions with a minimum of economic losses from the viewpoint of market participants it has raised concerns about appropriate risk management provisions to cope with the fluctuations of time varying allowance prices the present review provides an overview over state of the art models for price volatility expanding the scope from relatively simple garch type models to models with long term dependence and regime switches including the relatively recent class of so called multifractal models we provide a comparative application of these models to carbon dioxide emission allowance prices from the european union emission trading scheme and evaluate their performance with up to date model comparison tests based on out of sample forecasts of future volatility and value at risk

the forecasting accuracy of implied volatility from ecx carbon options abstract this study analyzes the forecasting accuracy of the implied volatility of options on futures contracts for the delivery of co 2 emission allowances carbon options traded on the european climate exchange we demonstrate that option implied volatility is highly informative about the variance of returns realized over the remaining life of the options it is also directionally accurate in predicting future volatility changes however we also find that implied volatility of carbon options is biased especially for periods of time which do not coincide with the remaining life of the option this suggests that the market has yet to fully mature

communication and income smoothing through accounting method choice this paper shows how accounting income smoothing could arise as rational equilibrium behavior i develop a two period agency model in which an agent obtains after the first period s production operation private information regarding future productivity of the operation direct communication of the agent s private signal yields a strict pareto improvement over no communication in this two period world since it allows the agent to achieve signal contingent interperiod consumption smoothing delegation of accounting method choice to the agent is shown to be an alternative pareto equivalent mechanism to direct communication in this paper thus accounting method choice is one way to achieve interperiod signal contingent consumption smoothing by smoothing accounting income one such accounting choice which arises from the structure of the problem is the choice of depreciation method

mean reversion of standard poor s 500 index basis changes arbitrage induced or statistical illusion mean reversion in stock index basis changes has been presumed to be driven by the trading activity of stock index arbitragers we propose here instead that the observed negative autocorrelation in basis changes is mainly a statistical illusion arising because many stocks in the index portfolio trade infrequently even without formal arbitrage reported basis changes would appear negatively autocorrelated as lagging stocks eventually trade and get updated the implications of this study go beyond index arbitrage however our analysis suggests that spurious elements may creep in whenever the price change or return series of two securities or portfolios of securities are differenced mean reversion in stock index basis changes has been amply documented mackinlay and ramaswamy 1988 find significant negative first order autocorrelation in normalized intraday basis changes of the s p 500 index futures traded on the chicago mercantile exchange cme yadav and pope 1990 find similar behavior using financial times stock exchange ftse 100 index futures data from the london international financial futures exchange liffe as does lim 1990 using nikkei 225 index futures from the singapore international monetary exchange simex the trading activity of stock index arbitragers has been presumed to be driving this elastic realignment of stock index and index futures prices when the basis widens beyond its theoretical level arbitragers simultaneously sell index futures and buy the index portfolio pulling the difference between the futures and index

the role of regulatory uncertainty in certificate markets a case study of the swedish norwegian market abstract price volatility in green certificate markets reflects uncertainty over future prices representing a major source of risk for renewable energy generators price risk is considered the principal deficiency of this market based policy since it causes investors to require higher returns moreover investors are exposed to regulatory risk namely the risk that a change in the regulation will materially impact the certificate price regulatory uncertainty is reflected in market volatility exacerbating certificate price risk using an econometric approach we investigate the role of regulatory changes on price volatility in the swedish certificate market the results of our analysis indicate that regulatory changes strongly affect certificate markets resulting in periods of higher volatility moreover we analyze whether certificate price volatility has changed after creating a joint swedish norwegian market results indicate that the ambivalence surrounding the creation of this bigger market led to a period of increased price volatility between 2010 and 2011 overall this article brings a better understanding of the role of regulatory uncertainty on certificate markets and gives evidence for its negative impact in terms of increased price volatility

how to improve the market efficiency of carbon trading a perspective of china abstract emissions trading scheme ets is one of the effective measures to realize energy conservation and emission reduction in order to set up a nationwide carbon emissions trading mechanism seven ets pilots have been launched in china firstly based on empirical investigation and research of seven pilots this paper analyzed the market efficiency of ets pilots from four aspects carbon price trading volume market liquidity and information transparency the result showed that the market efficiency of ets pilots is not satisfactory in spite of the fact that system designs of ets have achieved preliminary result then the reason for low market efficiency of ets pilots was discussed from some factors such as institutional arrangements market participants the supply and demand etc finally this paper puts forward some policy suggestions to improve the market efficiency of china s carbon trading market

an ahp decision making model for optimal allocation of energy subsidy among socio economic subsectors in iran abstract this paper presents an analytical hierarchy process ahp decision model for sectoral allocation of energy subsidy based on several criteria with determination of priorities for these criteria through questionnaire and ahp method the overall rank of these criteria that have the most influence on distribution of energy subsidy among socio economic sub sectors are as the following inflation economic growth labor intensity distribution of energy subsidy among socio economic levels energy intensity and social cost of air pollution according to the model the first priority for allocation of energy subsidy is commercial sector and the last priority is related to transportation sector investigating the impact of changing priority of the criteria on overall results indicates that the socio economic sub sectors ranking in receiving subsidy have little sensitivity for changing priority of the subsidy criteria

understanding volatility dynamics in the eu ets market abstract we study the short term price behavior of phase 2 eu emission allowances we model returns and volatility dynamics and we demonstrate that a standard armax garch framework is inadequate for this modeling and that the gaussianity assumption is rejected due to a number of outliers to improve the fitness of the model we combine the underlying price process with an additive stochastic jump process we improve the model s performance by introducing a time varying jump probability that is explained by two variables the daily relative change in the volume of transactions and the european commission s announcements regarding the supply of permits we show that i sharp increases in volume have led to increased volatility during the april 2005 december 2007 period but not for the period beginning in january 2008 and ii announcements induce jumps in the process that tend to increase volatility across both periods thus authorities face a trade off between disseminating information effectively and promoting market stability

the efficacy of the european union emissions trading scheme depicting the co movement of carbon assets and energy commodities through wavelet decomposition abstract environmental system thresholds have been crossed for a number of dimensions of global environmental pollution such as greenhouse gas emissions under this scenario institutions and corporations are required to implement sustainable policies as a condition for humanity staying within planetary boundaries accordingly the european union created the largest emissions trading scheme in the world with the aim of properly managing corporations carbon dioxide reductions this paper aims to contribute to the literature focused on testing the effectiveness of institutional environmental management policies specifically this research evaluates whether the objectives of the european union emissions trading scheme are partially achieved by analyzing the dynamics of carbon assets and the main energy commodities worldwide this paper provides relevant information both for policy makers and company managers so that contributions towards the common goal of developing a clean energy future and curbing climate change are ameliorated based on wavelet coherence analysis this paper proposes a model free way of estimating the time varying correlations between carbon assets and energy commodities at both high and low frequencies our central results reveal that carbon assets and energy commodities present a changing lead lag behavior at different frequencies the energy commodities lead the european union allowances returns at medium frequencies but the contrary was true for the highest investment horizons this finding should be in line with the goal of significantly reducing emissions because during long cycles if the majority of companies have not switched to cleaner industrial processes they must buy more carbon assets increasing their prices in that case energy commodities would be more expensive because of the energy commodities market behavior during long term horizons with european union allowances lead the certified emissions reductions lead in a negative way most of the energy commodities at medium frequencies thus indicating that investors handling energy commodities oriented portfolios could incorporate the mentioned carbon assets for diversification purposes these specific findings suggest that polluting activities would be more expensive which would provide an incentive to companies to implement environmentally friendly industrial processes the european union emissions trading scheme can result in significant emission reductions and compliance of the european union with the objectives of the kyoto protocol

energy taxation as a policy instrument to reduce co2 emissions a net benefit analysis abstract this study evaluates the costs and benefits of energy taxation as a policy instrument to conserve energy and reduce co2 emissions the study combines economic cost estimates generated with a cge model and monetary estimates of environmental damages in a comprehensive cost benefit framework we find that optimal co2 emissions reductions range from 5 to 38 depending on different assumptions about energy substitution elasticities and environmental damages co2 emissions reductions of between 8 and 64 can be attained at no additional welfare cost relative to a policy of not undertaking any action to control co2 emissions

pricing emission permits in the absence of abatement abstract if emissions are stochastic and firms are unable to control them through abatement the cap in a permit market may be exceeded or not be reached i derive a binary options pricing formula that expresses the permit price as a function of the penalty for noncompliance and the probability of an exceeded cap under the assumption of no abatement i apply my model to the eu ets where the rapid introduction of the market made it difficult for firms to adjust their production technology in time for the first phase the model fits the data well implying that the permit price may have been driven by firms hedging against stochastic emissions

the multiperiod principal agent problem in repeated principal agent models long term contracts can improve on short term contracts only if they commit either principal or agent to a payoff in some future circumstance lower than could be obtained from a short term contract negotiated if that circumstance occurs we show that efficient contracting under moral hazard alone does not require long term commitment from the principal provided a short term contract can punish the agent sufficiently in a sense made precise it requires no commitment from the agent either then linking payoffs in one period to outcomes in previous periods does not improve the tradeoff between incentives and risk sharing

information asymmetry participation and long term contracts this paper examines the economic value of participative processes in the setting of long term incentives when informational asymmetries arise between employers supervisors and employees subordinates about future states questions arise as to whether and when resolving these informational asymmetries produces economic gains to address these questions i use a two period principal agent contracting framework in which the agent employee receives imperfect private information about the second period state in the first period and make a welfare comparison between two alternative communication regimes in the delayed communication regime a report from the agent is considered only for second period contract in the early communication regime the report is considered for first period contracting as well this regime can therefore be viewed as encouraging participation in long term contracts i identify conditions under which the early communication regime is strictly preferable to the delayed communication regime further given some additional structure on the agent s preferences this result obtains even if the agent can access capital markets to smooth inter temporal consumption finally i examine the setting in which the principal at the time of contracting has the option of whether or not to install an information system that provides the agent with private information about the future period state i identify conditions under which installing the information system and resolving the consequent information asymmetry through participation is strictly preferable to not installing the information system

energy prices and co2 emission allowance prices a quantile regression approach we use a quantile regression framework to investigate the impact of changes in crude oil prices natural gas prices coal prices and electricity prices on the distribution of the co2 emission allowance prices in the united states we find that i an increase in the crude oil price generates a substantial drop in the carbon prices when the latter is very high ii changes in the natural gas prices have a negative effect on the carbon prices when they are very low but have a positive effect when they are quite high iii the impact of the changes in the electricity prices on the carbon prices can be positive in the right tail of the distribution and iv the coal prices exert a negative effect on the carbon prices

the marginal efficiency effects of taxes and subsidies in the presence of externalities a computational general equilibrium approach abstract using 1983 data we develop a 19 sector computational general equilibrium model incorporating producer producer externalities and producer consumer externalities simulation results indicate that when additional government expenditure is financed by pigouvian taxes the marginal cost of public funds is substantially below one labor sales and output taxes also affect the output of the polluting industries and thus have indirect pigouvian effects which tend to reduce the associated marginal costs of public funds pigouvian taxes are usually more efficient than pigouvian subsidies since the tax revenue can be used to reduce other taxes