tax collection with agency costs private contracting or government bureaucrats historically governments contracted with private agents known as tax farmers to collect taxes this paper develops a theoretical framework for determining when a welfare maximizing government should choose tax farmers over bureaucratic tax collectors while bureaucratic collectors have an incentive to shirk and raise collection costs above least costs profit maximizing private collectors tend to reduce tax evasion below the optimal level generally the choice of collection methods depends on a comparison of the welfare loss associated with monitoring in the bureaucratic setting and the welfare loss associated with overdetection of evasion in the private setting copyright 1992 by the london school of economics and political science

sharing the burden for climate change mitigation in the canadian federation dividing the burden for greenhouse gas abatement amongst the provinces has proven challenging in canada and is a major factor contributing to canada s poor historic performance on greenhouse gas abatement as the country aims to achieve substantial cuts to emissions over the next decade and by mid century such burden sharing considerations are likely to be elevated in importance this paper uses a calibrated multi region multi sector computable general equilibrium model to compare a number of archetypal rules for sharing the burden of a joint commitment amongst members for the case of greenhouse gas reductions in canada because of the substantial heterogeneity amongst canadian provinces these different burden sharing rules imply signifcantly different relative abatement effort amongst provinces and also signifcantly different welfare implications when emission permits are allocated on an equal per capita basis welfare is increased in ontario british columbia quebec and manitoba and signifcantly reduced in alberta and saskatchewan in contrast when emission permits are allocated based on historic emissions alberta and saskatchewan are made better off and ontario british columbia quebec and manitoba are made worse off we compare these archetypal burden sharing rules to existing provincial emission reduction commitments and find that none of the standard burden sharing rules comes close to existing commitments we argue that the debate on burden sharing of greenhouse gas abatement in canada could be objectified if informed by coherent quantitative analysis such as the one presented here

opec and the international oil market can a cartel fuel the engine of economic development abstract the opec cartel was formed to promote two economic goals one microeconomic low oil market volatility the other macroeconomic promotes economic development of its members these goals create a tension since the cartel s single tool is output quotas using this dual micro macro perspective we analyze oil exporting countries behavior we find that the effects of the cartel s choices will be reflected in oil market stability long term macroeconomic development and international oil market structure if an oil producing country cares about both oil industry profits and macroeconomic stability the goal of output stability may be inconsistent with cartel membership

decision making in quasi markets a pedagogic analysis abstract the objective of the 1991 nhs reforms was to reduce excessive vertical integration by constructing a quasi market in which incentive structures and increased availability of information would enable decision makers make better use of resources there is however no overall framework in which to consider the welfare gains which result from the introduction of a quasi market or the welfare losses which arise from distortions in a quasi market this paper offers an analysis which can be applied to illustrate the difficulty of estimating the welfare loss from cream skimming and also to consider the impact of local monopoly

limit pricing and the in effectiveness of the carbon tax we present a theory of limit pricing monopoly in non renewable resource production facing a very inelastic demand an oil monopoly seeks to induce the highest price that does not destroy its demand unlike the conventional hotellian analysis the monopoly tolerates some ordinary substitutes to its oil but deters high potential ones with limit pricing policy induced extraction changes do not obey the usual logic for example oil taxes have no effect on current oil production extraction increases when high potential substitutes are promoted but can be effectively reduced by supporting ordinary substitutes the carbon tax not only applies to oil it also penalizes its ordinary carbon substitutes whose market shares are taken over by the monopoly thus the carbon tax ambiguously affects current and long term oil production and carbon emissions

the outlook for us oil dependence abstract oil dependence is defined as a dynamic problem of short and long run market power the potential monopoly power of an oil cartel depends on its market share and the elasticities of oil supply and demand while the economic vulnerability of oil consuming states depends most directly on the quantity of oil imported and the oil cost share of gross domestic product gdp of these factors only the market share of the organization of petroleum exporting countries opec cartel and the rate of growth of world oil demand are clearly different than they were 25 years ago opec still holds the majority of world oil and in the future will regain market share a hypothetical 2 year supply reduction in 2005 2006 similar in size to those of 1973 1974 or 1979 1980 illustrates the potential benefits to opec and harm to the us economy of a future oil price shock opec s revenues are estimated to increase by roughly 0 7 trillion while the us economy loses about 0 5 trillion strategic petroleum reserves seem ineffective against a determined multi year supply curtailment increasing the market s price responsiveness by improving the technologies of oil supply and oil demand can greatly reduce the costs of oil dependence each element of this interpretation of the oil dependence problem is well supported by previous studies this paper s contribution is to unite these elements into a coherent explanation and to point out the enormously important implications for energy policy

iranian oil free zone and international oil prices abstract one of the main elements of economic sanctions against iran due to its nuclear and military programs is crude oil exportation restrictions in addition to investment in iranian energy related projects senders of such sanction are interested in understanding the impacts of such embargos on international oil prices we apply unrestricted vector autoregressive var model using impulse response functions irf and variance decomposition analysis vda tools with annual data from 1965 to 2012 to analyze the dynamic response of international oil prices to iranian oil export sanction controlling for the supply of non iranian oil the world gdp per capita and post islamic revolution exogenous dummy variables we show that international oil prices respond negatively and statistically significant to increasing shock in absolute negative changes of the iranian oil exports our proxy of iran oil sanctions following the first 2 years after shock the main reason is the positive response of the non iranian oil supply to negative shocks in iranian oil exports filling the missing supply of iranian oil in international markets

modeling opec behavior economic and political alternatives the predominant approach to modeling opec behavior depends upon the assumption that economic self interest provides the best predictor of the cartel s price and production strategy with rational monopoly behavior the exogenous characteristics of the oil market determine an optimal price path for the group but opec members have diverse economic as well as political goals and uncertainty about oil market responses provides substantial leeway to argue about what is optimal an examination of the five key opec price decisions since 1973 shows that an operational code of advancing political priorities on arab israeli issues while deflecting security challenges better explains saudi arabia s decision making than the economic optimizing approach moreover no economic formula alone is consistent with saudi behavior the balance of internal and external forces of a political or security character on saudi leadership suggests more of a tilt toward price hawkishness than pure considerations of economic self interest would indicate this tilt is reinforced by a systematic weakness on the part of the u s government to exercise a sustained countervailing influence on the kingdom on behalf of moderation

needs based health care funding implications for resource distribution in ontario capitation models have been suggested as an alternative to funding methods based on historical utilization patterns capitation funding distributes esources to regions or programs according to their population adjusted for the age and gender composition and relative need the most commonly used relative needs measure is the standardized mortality ratio smr this paper compares the distribution of resources in ontario implied by a variety of capitation formula another aspect of this research is to design a mechanism that translates the smr into a funding allocation index we specify a non linear model to capture the relationship between current expenditures and the smr while controlling for historical utilization factors in contrast to previous work in which a linear relationship between expenditures and need was assumed our estimates suggest that the relationship may actually be highly non linear this non linearity ncreases transfers to regions of relative need relative to a linear capitation program jel classification i0 h51 on a suggere des modeles de financement per capita des soins de sante pour remplacer les methodes de financement fondees sur les patterns historiques d utilisation cette solution de rechange distribuerait les ressources aux regions et programmes selon la population avec des ajustements pour tenir compte de la structure ges de sexes et de besoins relatifs la mesure la plus commune des besoins relatifs est le taux de mortalite standardise tms ce memoire compare la repartition des ressources en ontario qui decoulerait de l emploi d une variete de formules on tente aussi de construire un mecanisme qui traduise le tms en un indice d allocation des fonds les auteurs construisent un odele non lineaire qui saisit la relation entre tms et epenses courantes tout en normalisant pour tenir compte des facteurs historiques d utilisation contrairement aux resultats des travaux anterieurs qui postulaient une relation lineaire entre epenses et besoins les resultats de cette etude uggerent que cette relation peut etre fortement non lineaire et que cette non linearite tend a ccroitre les transferts aux regions qui ont les besoins les plus grands

the empirical role of the exchange rate on the crude oil price formation this paper adopts a novel empirical approach to the crude oil price formation for the purpose of understanding the price reactions of opec member countries to changes in the exchange rate of the us dollar against other major currencies and prices of other members the results are broadly consistent with the view of the absence of a unified opec determined price in the international crude market literature in addition the results also highlight a cross regional dimension of the crude oil market

is competition the answer abstract proposals for more price competition in medical services delivery have arisen on both sides of the atlantic perhaps the most visible pro competition spokesman in the united states is alain enthoven 1978 1980 but other names are also prominently associated with the concept mcclure 1978 havighurst 1980 president s commission 1980 greenberg 1981 recently legislation to promote competition has been introduced in the united states congress periodically individuals in other parts of the world also unfurl the banner of competition lees 1961 stahl in press the remarks that follow are limited to the american context for brevity some of them would have to be altered in other institutional contexts

does opec still exist as a cartel an empirical investigation the aim of this paper is to determine if opec acts as a cartel by testing whether the production decisions of the different countries are coordinated and if they have an influence on oil prices relying on cointegration and causality tests in both time series and panel settings our findings show that the opec influence has evolved through time following the changes in the oil pricing system while the influence of opec is found to be important just after the counter oil shock our results show that opec is a price taker on the majority of the considered sub periods finally by dividing opec between savers and spenders we show that it acts as a cartel mainly with a subgroup of its members

the future of the income tax the federal income tax has been under attack by the economics profession for more than a decade the attack comes from two directions supply siders who believe that progressive income taxation impairs economic incentives and more traditional economists who would substitute a progressive expenditure tax for the income tax 2 at one time support for the expenditure tax was confined to a few members of our profession including such distinguished names as john stuart mill irving fisher nicholas kaldor and james meade today it is fair to say that many if not most economists favor the expenditure tax or a flat rate income tax this group has joined the opponents of progressive taxation in the attack on the income tax despite an incessant barrage from both groups no country in the world is planning to abandon the income tax or is even considering a personal expenditure tax a wave of tax reform beginning with the u s reform in 1986 has been sweeping the world aimed at improving the income tax not at eliminating it tax preferences formerly regarded as sacrosanct are being removed and there is a distinct movement toward comprehensive income taxation 3 however individual income tax rates are being cut tax progressivity has been declining almost everywhere and reliance on the income tax has been diminishing it will come as no surprise to this audience that i approve of the base broadening feature of the current tax reform movement but i believe that the reduction in the redistributive effect of the income tax has gone too far in this paper i shall show that the progressivity of the u s tax system never very pronounced except during and immediately after the two world wars has been declining for more than two decades and that the tax reform act of 1986 reversed this decline but only slightly consequently we have a long way to go to improve the equity of the tax system i believe this can be done without punitive tax rates that will hurt economic incentives i begin with a brief review of recent changes in the u s distribution of income and follow this with an analysis of the effect of taxes on the income distribution i next examine arguments for and against the income tax with particular emphasis on its effects on economic incentives and its merits when compared with the expenditure tax i then evaluate the income tax as it emerged from the 1986 tax reform and conclude with tjoseph pechman passed away on august 19 1989 his presidential address was delivered at the onehundred second meeting of the american economic association december 29 1989 atlanta georgia joseph a pechman economic studies program the brookings institution 1775 massachusetts avenue nw washington dc 20036 i have benefited from the comments and suggestions on an earlier draft of this paper by henry j aaron richard goode jane g gravelle robert w hartman donald w kiefer herbert e klarman robert d reischauer clifford m winston and h peyton young but they should not be held responsible for the views expressed in this paper i am indebted to richard kasten for various simulations i am also grateful to stephen j kastenberg for research assistance and to diane a shugart valerie m owens and sara c hufham for secretarial assistance some of the more extreme supply siders argued that large tax cuts pay for themselves see for example laffer 1981 but i believe it is fair to say that this view has been totally discredited for a more reasonable supply side view see the economic report of the president 1982 2see for example michael j boskin 1978 david e bradford 1980 charles l ballard don fullerton john shoven and john whalley 1985 paul courant and edward gramlich 1982 martin feldstein 1978 robert hall and alvin rabushka 1985 john kay and mervyn king 1983 charles mclure 1987 mieszkowski 1980 and lawrence summers 1981 it is interesting that the recent popularity of the expenditure tax among economists was stimulated by a tax lawyer william d andrews 1974 3see pechman 1988

reimbursing health plans and health providers efficiency in production versus selection the tradeoff between an insurer s or medical provider s incentives to select good risks and to produce efficiently is governed by the supply price analog to the demand price tradeoff between moral hazard and risk aversion under a variety of models the optimum supply price is a mixture of capitation and fee for service payments empirical literature shows that pure capitation payment leaves strong incentives for selection that are acted upon the presence of contracting costs in a rothschild stiglitz model means a limited pooling equilibrium can exist and that poor risks will not be at their preferred outcome

health insurance and the demand for medical care evidence from a randomized experiment we estimate how cost sharing the portion of the bill the patient pays affects the demand for medical services the data come from a randomized experiment a catastrophic insurance plan reduces expenditures 31 percent relative to zero out of pocket price the price elasticity is approximately 0 2 we reject the hypothesis that less favorable coverage of outpatient services increases total expenditure for example by deterring preventive care or inducing hospitalization

sample audit tax assessment for businesses what s fair how should a revenue agency assess a business taxpayer s income on the basis of a sample audit of transactions the agency would like to maximize revenue while minimizing the risk that the taxpayer will be assessed more than he really owes the taxpayer reasons that overassessment is worse than underassessment as far as he is concerned and therefore the taxpayer might reasonably argue that the lower bound of a one sided confidence interval should be used by the assessor the revenue agency might understandably take a different point of view the revenue agency might argue that overassessment is really no worse than underassessment from its point of view so the midpoint of such a confidence interval should be used in fact it is this latter position that is currently in use most commonly by state agencies but such practice is being challenged the courts will have to make a decision

in pursuit of monopoly power recent quantitative work in industrial economics this paper reviews empirical work in industrial organization devoted to the question of inferring the existence of monopoly power from data on observed market outcomes like profits and prices the discussion covers inter industry work long conventional in the area newer developments in intra industry analysis and case studies and concludes with some remarks on a small but growing body of work assessing market dynamics the wide range of studies reviewed all generally reveal that market power exists in many industries

opec and cheating revisiting the kinked demand curve abstract given a formal or tacit group agreement by an oligopoly such as opec it is still necessary to understand what pricing and output decisions individual members actually make the well known kinked demand curve model of oligopoly behaviour is useful in this regarg the model is usually applied to a price and market share fixing oligopoly in a deterministic world with appropriate modifications it can be applied to opec as a price fixing cartel with varying degrees of cohesion from 1973 1986 and as a quantity fixing cartel since 1986 operating in an uncertain world

opec and the u s oil import tariff open loop nash extraction plans of exhaustible resource producers in which producers take the plans of others as given are time consistent but proposed open loop oil import tariffs are almost always time inconsistent the paper derives a time consistent open loop nash tariff that can be readily computed for both competitive and a nash cournot specification of the oil market the authors illustrate the time sequence of the optimal import tariff for a simple model of the united states facing a duopolistic version of opec and a comparative fringe of oil producers and compare the outcome with the competitive equilibrium copyright 1991 by royal economic society

opec behavior a test of alternative hypotheses since interpretations of past and future oil price patterns depends on the model chosen the author tests and compares alternative theories of opec as a first step in validating the choice on any one model the results show that among opec countries the partial market sharing cartel model is the only model not rejected by at least some of the 11 members and gives the best explanation of production in comparison with 11 non opec countries the competitive model could not be rejected for 10 of the 11 non opec producers this raises the question of why if opec is a cartel friedman s predictions have not come true and introduces new questions for future research 19 references 3 tables

perestrojka in the dutch health care system a demonstration project for other european countries abstract the dutch government and parliament have recently decided to radically reform the dutch health care system direct government control over prices and productive capacities will have to make way for regulated competition among insurers and among providers there appear to be some similarities between economic problems associated with the perestrojka in eastern europe and the perestrojka that is taking place in the dutch health care system in both cases serious problems may arise as the result of the absence of consumer information the absence of cost related prices the absence of antitrust policy and the absence of market oriented management each of these issues will be discussed it will be concluded that other western or eastern european countries can learn interesting lessons from the demonstration project that is taking place in the netherlands

clustering in crude oil prices and the target pricing zone hypothesis abstract this paper studies the target pricing zone tpz hypothesis for crude oil by examining price clustering in the dollar digit it is hypothesized that price clustering occurs within an established tpz if opec is able to defend the upper and lower bounds through output changes the results show that prices strongly cluster around the dollar digit value of 9 within the tpz sub periods but not outside the sub periods furthermore the degree of clustering declines when production capacity utilization is high and when production significantly exceeds quotas consistent with opec s inability to defend the zone nine centered clustering also results in lower contemporaneous and next day volatility these results support the target pricing zone hypothesis of crude oil

on the economic determinants of oil production theoretical analysis and empirical evidence for small exporting countries abstract in this paper decisions regarding production in oil exporting countries are studied by means of theoretical analysis and empirical investigation in particular we aim at describing the relationship between oil production levels and changes in the world oil demand and prices intertemporal production decisions by a representative oil producer are modeled by means of a partial equilibrium model in this theoretical model oil producers are subject to exogenous shocks in world oil consumption and prices oil companies can change output levels only by incurring a fixed cost results from the simulation of this model show a strong relationship between oil production and changes in world oil consumption on the contrary the effects of changes in real oil prices on oil production decisions seem to be much lower results from the simulation of the theoretical model are then empirically investigated using time series econometric techniques the empirical evidence supports the hypothesis that oil producing countries are characterized by different responses to changes in world oil demand and in real oil prices for many countries production rapidly adjusts to changes in consumption whereas responses of oil production to innovations in real oil prices are found to be not statistically significant in addition when non linearities in the relationship between world oil demand prices and output levels are allowed for evidence of asymmetric effects of shocks to exogenous variables on output levels is found for some countries

risk sharing as a supplement to imperfect capitation a tradeoff between selection and efficiency this paper describes forms of risk sharing between insurers and the regulator in a competitive individual health insurance market with imperfectly risk adjusted capitation payments risk sharing implies a reduction of an insurer s incentives for selection as well as for efficiency in a theoretical analysis we show how the optimal extent of risk sharing may depend on the weights the regulator assigns to these effects some countries employ outlier or proportional risk sharing as a supplement to demographic capitation payments our empirical results strongly suggest that other forms of risk sharing yield better tradeoffs between selection and efficiency

aggregate production planning for process industries under oligopolistic competition abstract we consider a competitive version of the traditional aggregate production planning model with capacity constraints in the general case multiple products are produced by a few competing producers oligopoly with limited capacities production quantities prices and consequently profits depend on production and allocation decisions of each producer in addition there is competition for the raw material whose supplies are limited and where prices reflect these limitations such situations have recently occurred in several process industry settings including petro refining petrochemicals basic chemicals cement fertilizers pharmaceuticals rubber paper food processing and metals we use a successive bertrand cournot framework to address this problem and to determine optimal production quantities prices and profits at the producers and at the raw material supplier our analysis allows a new way to understand and evaluate the marginal value of additional capacity when there is competition for the market and raw materials

are biofuels the culprit opec food and fuel the food commodity price boom of 2003 2008 was the most notable in the past several decades having a substantial impact on global economic activity it affected developing nations by impacting real output the balance of payments government budgetary positions and most important the well being of the very poor high commodity prices also affected developed countries by transmitting business cycle disturbances and creating inflationary pressures several recent studies tried to identify and quantify the factors that caused the food commodity price boom of 2003 2008 see for instance isabel vansteenkiste 2009 these studies suggest that one key factor is growth in demand which since the 1980s has outpaced growth in supply other studies argued that biofuel is the culprit since it increases demand for staple crops see for instance donald mitchell 2008 all these studies however assumed competitive markets and did not consider the impact of biofuel on energy costs to farmers moreover they ignored the organization of petroleum exporting countries opec these studies leave us perplexed regarding the true impact of biofuel on food commodity prices was it or was it not an important contributor to the recent food commodity boom we believe that to answer this question the interactions between energy and food must be modeled and opec introduced and the impact of biofuels compared with other factors that are argued by the literature to be important this paper aims to analyze the multiple contributions of energy and biofuels to the increase are biofuels the culprit opec food and fuel

investment and operating choice oil and natural gas futures prices and drilling activity abstract we present evidence that changes in oil and natural gas field investment measured by drilling rig use respond positively to changes in the futures prices of oil and natural gas consistent with predictions based upon value maximizing behavior these results hold for world regions dominated by private independent oil companies but not national oil companies in those cases where futures price changes are identified as drivers the role of spot prices is either absent or weak the results are robust to several alternative specifications including controls for changes in rig productivity

determinants of opec production implications for opec behavior we estimate models that identify the economic and organizational determinants of crude oil production by individual opec nations to clarify the interpretation of econometric results we model production with specifications that resolve the statistical ordering of variables and estimate models with techniques that can cope with stochastic trends in the time series we also analyze the short run dynamics for asymmetries that may carry important insights about opec behavior results indicate that quotas are an important determinant of production and their effects generally are symmetric which implies that opec is an organization that influences production and ultimately prices real prices generally have a positive effect on production and the size of this effect may depend on spare capacity which implies that opec behaviors also embody competitive elements finally all nations other than saudi arabia show some form of production sharing behavior which may imply that opec shares mismatches between the call for opec production and opec quotas

the threat of cream skimming in the post reform nhs the allocation of budgets to general practitioners to enable them to purchase selected hospital services has been one of the most imaginative elements of the recent national health service reforms in britain however reliance on historic costs budgeting has weakened the efficiency incentives of fund holding while perpetuating the large variations in resource use endemic in general practice on the other hand policy changes aimed to introduce elements of capitation funding although welcome raise the spectre of cream skimming the paper explores the potential for protection against cream skimming offered by incorporating chronic health factors into the formula

estimation of user s cost for a depletable resource such as oil abstract this paper presents an attempt to derive an empirically tractable definition of the user s cost for a depletable resource such as oil it is shown that in an intertemporal optimization framework the user s cost can be measured by the marginal replacement cost mrc of the resource defined as the cost of adding one unit to the stock of the resource this definition is applied to data for the middle east based on an econometric analysis of the proven reserves production process the user s cost is estimated for that area for the period 1960 76 the empirical results show that the user s cost is but a small fraction of the market price of crude oil for the period under consideration

a comparison of alternative models for the demand for medical care we have tested alternative models of the demand for medical care using experimental data the estimated response of demand to insurance plan is sensitive to the model used we therefore use a split sample analysis and find that a model that more closely approximates distributional assumptions and uses a nonparametric retransformation factor performs better in terms of mean squared forecast error simpler models are inferior either because they are not robust to outliers e g anova anocova or because they are inconsistent when strong distributional assumptions are violated e g a two parameter box cox transformation

the equilibrium price range of oil economics politics and uncertainty in the formation of oil prices abstract this paper attempts to clarify the articulation between economic and political factors in the formation of petroleum prices it begins with defining the political factors then it gives a definition of the dynamic equilibrium price of a mineral commodity market the essential point is that when actors control significant low cost reserves and will not or cannot adopt behaviour of a substantial economic rationality then the economic analysis does not allow a unique dynamic equilibrium price to be determined however it does permit definition of an equilibrium price range within which political preferences may be expressed finally the paper draws some conclusions on what could be discussed within the scope of a new oil producer consumer dialogue

will disruptions in opec oil supply have permanent impact on the global oil market abstract opec has long been a major stakeholder and strong player in the global energy market especially in the petroleum sub sector in recent time however there have been questions over the influence of opec in the sub sector due to changing petroleum production landscape specifically as a result of the discovery of unconventional energy resources in north america and emergence of non opec petroleum producing and exporting countries this development could have significant effect on the global energy market and the macro economy of opec member countries the stationarity or otherwise of opec oil production supply has important implications for determining whether fluctuations in opec market supply has temporary or permanent effect using the zivot andrews structural break stationarity test and production data of opec member countries from 1980 to 2011 this paper investigates whether fluctuations in opec market supply has temporary or permanent effect the empirical analysis shows that for only 5 opec members nigeria saudi arabia ecuador kuwait and uae is the hypothesis of unit root rejected this implies that for the five 5 opec members the effects of shocks to oil production are not permanent and future pattern of oil production can be predicted following past trend the practical implication of this finding is that opec production quota strategy may not have long term impact on the global oil market thus the cartel needs to improve oil production policy coordination among members and ensure strict adherence to production quota while also stressing the need for diversification in member countries

delegation as commitment the case of income tax audits in this article we study the value of delegating authority over income tax audit policy arising from the incompleteness of contracts consider a utilitarian government whose ability to commit is limited to aggregate dimensions of its audit policy as publicly verifiable information about detailed allocations of audit budgets is not available we show that the welfare level associated with the full commitment solution can be attained by delegating authority over audit policy to a manager the latter is offered a simple incentive scheme based only on the aggregate variables which are publicly observable in contrast if the government retains authority direct commitment to these same variables does not allow the full commitment welfare level to be achieved thus despite sharing a common informational basis delegation may perform better than centralized arrangements in the presence of incomplete contracts