more mortgages lower growth in newly collected data on 46 economies over 1990 2011 we show that financial development since 1990 was mostly due to growth in credit to real estate and other asset markets which has a negative growth coefficient we also distinguish between growth effects of stocks and flows of credit we find positive growth effects for credit flows to nonfinancial business but not for mortgage and other asset market credit flows by accounting for the composition of credit stocks and for the effect of credit flows we explain the insignificant or negative growth effects of financial development in recent times what was true in the 1960s 1970s and 1980s when the field of empirical credit growth studies blossomed is no longer true in the 1990s and 2000s new bank lending is not primarily to nonfinancial business and financial development may no longer be good for growth these trends predate the 2008 crisis they prompt a rethink of the role of banks in the process of economic growth jel e44 o16 o40 c33

finance and the sources of growth at various stages of economic development this article studies the effects of financial development on the sources of growth in different groups of countries recent theoretical work shows that financial development may affect productivity and capital accumulation in different ways in industrial versus developing countries this hypothesis is tested with panel data from 74 countries using gmm dynamic panel techniques results are consistent with the hypothesis finance has a strong positive influence on productivity growth primarily in more developed economies in less developed economies the effect of finance on output growth occurs primarily through capital accumulation jel o4 g1

borrowing constraints human capital accumulation and growth abstract borrowing constraints increase aggregate savings and therefore may increase growth this paper argues however that by reducing human capital accumulation borrowing constraints also have negative effects on growth these effects are discussed in an overlapping generations model with endogenous growth empirical evidence for oecd and developing countries lend support to the main predictions of the model

financial intermediation and endogenous growth an endogenous growth model with multiple assets is developed agents who face random future liquidity needs accumulate capital and a liquid but unproductive asset the effects of introducing financial intermediation into this environment are considered conditions are provided under which the introduction of intermediaries shifts the composition of savings toward capital causing intermediation to be growth promoting in addition intermediaries generally reduce socially unnecessary capital liquidation again tending to promote growth

the financial development and growth nexus a meta analysis this is the accepted manuscript the final version is available from wiley at http onlinelibrary wiley com doi 10 1111 joes 12086 abstract

financial development and economic growth a meta analysis we analyze 1334 estimates from 67 studies that examine the effect of financial development on economic growth taken together the studies imply a positive and statistically significant effect but the individual estimates vary widely we find that both research design and heterogeneity in the underlying effect play a role in explaining the differences in results studies that do not address endogeneity tend to overstate the effect of finance on growth while the effect seems to be weaker in less developed countries the effect decreases worldwide after the 1980s our results also suggest that stock markets support faster economic growth than other financial intermediaries

policies to move from stabilization to growth although some discussions of stabilization see growth as more or less an assured product of appropriate stabilization this paper argues that there is no guarantee that stabilization will lead to growth it may result in stagnation the paper discusses the essentials of stabilization including inflation targets fiscal policy monetary policy exchange rates and incomes policy and suggests that two areas of structural reform deregulation including trade reform and reform of the financial sector can play a central role in the long run success of a stabilization effort the paper concludes that countries that have experienced protracted high inflation financial instability and payments crises probably will have a difficult and protracted transition to growth and that external resources will be necessary as a continuing feature of the transition sustained external support in the form of long term loans heavily conditioned on the tangibility and credibility of domestic progress in adjustment will help provide a bridge by which flight capital may return and foreign direct investment may be encouraged to take advantage of fresh opportunities

same financial development yet different economic growth why we re study the relationship between financial development and real gdp per capita growth in 48 countries what we find is an interesting evidence that only stock market development has positive effects on growth and that banking development has an unfavorable if not negative effect on growth we examine whether or not these impacts are a product of various financial and economic conditional variables our conditional variables consist of financial liberalization two sets of country development dummies crises in banking and currency dummies the creditor protection index as well as the anti director and corruption indices our results clearly show that the conditional variables of financial liberalization high income level and good shareholder protection mitigate the negative impacts of banking development on growth in contrast the conditional variables of middle income level regional latin american sub saharan african and east asian dummies banking and currency crises good creditor protection and higher corruption strengthen the negative impacts of banking development on growth next the conditional variables of middle income level latin american sub saharan african and east asian dummies strengthen the positive impacts of stock market development on growth whereas the conditional variables of financial liberalization mitigate the positive impacts of stock market development on growth last we find that the relationship between growth and bank development is better described as a weak inverse ushape this inverse u shape becomes stronger when additional stock market variables are squared thus financial development and growth may in fact be in a nonlinear form

liberalizing foreign investments by pension funds positive and normative aspects abstract the paper evaluates the economics of foreign investment regulation for pension funds with a focus on developing countries where fully funded pension systems are being started de novo the analysis proceeds in three steps first it is argued that the benefits of global portfolio diversification apply particularly to developing country pension assets because the volatility of asset returns is high while the risk tolerance of pensioners is low second restrictions of foreign investmetn by domestic pension funds can hardly be justified on ground of financial development arguments the paper presents crosscountry evidence which shows little support for the claim that the accumulation of pension assets would provide strong externalities for financial development moreover the home bias generally observed in pension fund investment should translate into sufficient potential demand for domestic financial assets as to deepen markets and develop the institutional infrastructure third a case for initial localization requirements however can be derived from the fiscal costs of moving from unfunded to fully funded pension systems if fiscal illustion and domestic tax collection costs are important

is the relationship between financial development and economic growth monotonic evidence from a sample of middle income countries summary we revisit the relationship between financial development and economic growth in a panel of 52 middle income countries over the 1980 2008 period using pooled mean group estimations in a dynamic heterogeneous panel setting we show that there is an inverted u shaped relationship between finance and growth in the long run in the short run the relationship is insignificant this suggests that too much finance can exert a negative influence on growth in middle income countries the finding of a non monotonic effect of financial development on growth is confirmed by estimating a threshold model

are financial development and trade openness complements or substitutes this article studies the long and short run relationships between financial development and trade openness using the pooled mean group estimator of pesaran shin and smith 1999 for unbalanced panel data for 87 countries over the 1960 2005 period our empirical results indicate that long run complementarity between financial development and trade openness coexists with short run substitutionarity between the two policy variables but when splitting the data into oecd and non oecd country groups this finding can be observed only in non oecd countries for oecd countries financial development has negligible effects on trade in addition we find nonlinearity in the relationship in that long run responses of trade decrease with financial development the article further finds coexistence of negative trade effects of financial fragility and positive trade impacts of financial depth

real interest rates and growth improving on some deflating experiences tests of the mckinnon shaw hypothesis typically investigate the relationship between real interest rates and growth recent work has concluded that this relationship may be non monotonic this article investigates the role of real interest rate mismeasurement in explaining these non monotonicities when such mismeasurement is systematically related to growth it will produced biased empirical results after addressing these biases the article demonstrates that financial liberalisation may offer substantial economic gains in an average country raising real interest rates from 25 per cent to five per cent will increase real annual per capita gdp growth from zero to a relatively robust rate of two per cent

financial development and growth in sub saharan africa do legal origin and cfa membership matter this article examines whether relations between legal origin financial development and economic growth that hold worldwide hold in british and french legal origin sub saharan africa ssa as well we also test for the differential impacts on financial development and on growth of communaute financiere africaine cfa currency union membership within french legal origin ssa our panel regressions and descriptive measures agree with the findings of british legal origin advantage with respect to financial development in addition financial development contributes positively to economic growth in british legal origin ssa as it does worldwide within french legal origin ssa we find that currency union constraints tend to hinder financial development in cfa countries beyond the negative impacts of french legal origin moreover contributions to the growth of various indicators of financial development in french legal origin ssa are negative or insignificant irrespective of cfa membership

structural change and financing constraints abstract in a multi industry growth model firms need external funds for productivity enhancing r d and face financing constraints the cost of research differs across industries so financing constraints hinder industry productivity growth unevenly equilibrium industry dynamics map into a differences in differences regression specification where industry growth depends on the interaction between country financial development and industry r d intensity the paper provides a framework for interpreting several empirical results that rely on industry growth data in terms of r d induced technology transfer and identifies a new channel for finance to encourage aggregate growth the reallocation of resources towards sectors with rapidly expanding technological frontiers

ir theory built on the founders principles with empirical application to australia the authors identify 10 core principles of industrial relations ir theory and policy based on the writings of british ir founders beatrice webb and sidney webb and u s ir founder john commons these principles are then represented diagrammatically in an expanded ir version of the marshallian demand supply ds model the ds and ir models representing on one side the merits of abstraction and parsimony and on the other realism and complexity are applied to a case study an analysis and explanation of the reasons behind the formation of the australian ir system in the 1890s and its evolution to 2010 although the ds model captures important forces behind the shift from a centralized and unionized employment system in the early period to a significantly decentralized and deunionized system in the latter period the evidence indicates the extra structural and behavioral elements in the ir model are important for a full and accurate explanation

financial development and energy consumption in central and eastern european frontier economies this study examines the impact of financial development on energy consumption in a sample of 9 central and eastern european frontier economies several different measures of financial development are examined including bank related variables and stock market variables the empirical results obtained from dynamic panel demand models show a positive and statistically significant relationship between financial development and energy consumption when financial development is measured using banking variables like deposit money bank assets to gdp financial system deposits to gdp or liquid liabilities to gdp of the three stock market variables investigated only one stock market turnover has a positive and statistically significant impact on energy consumption both short run and long run elasticities are presented the implications of these results for energy policy are discussed

the effect of financial development on economic growth a meta analysis in this article we contribute to the current debate on the sign and size of the finance growth relation to this purpose we use a meta analysis with 551 estimates from 68 empirical studies that t

good bye financial repression hello financial crash some unintended consequences of financial liberalization in latin america are analyzed in this paper intrinsic imperfectious in financial markets and the policy dilemmas they pose are reviewed first the stylized facts of southern cone experiments in financial liberization are then presented alternative ways of organlzing domestic capital markets under latin american conditions are discussed and an eclectic reform mongering program is proposed

financial development and economic growth abstract this paper examines the empirical relationship between long run growth and financial development proxied by the ratio between bank credit to the private sector and gdp we find that this proxy is positively correlated with growth in a large cross country sample but its impact changes across countries and is negative in a panel data for latin america we argue that the latter findings is the result of financial liberalization in a poor regulatory environment our findings also show that the main channel of transmission from financial development to growth is the efficiency rather than the volume of investment

stagflationary effects of stabilization programs in reforming socialist countries enterprise side and household side factors dismantling subsidies could give rise to serious macroeconomic difficulties in the short run this article explores a view based on the enterprise sector as a central source and main channel of the stagflation phenomenon using as an example the stagflation that followed the 1990 stabilization program in poland the stagflation phenomenon is linked to features of the financial market that are somewhat peculiar to reforming socialist economies the weak credit links between households and enterprises and the existence of large interenterprise debt the policy implications of the enterprise side view include more explicit consideration of initial conditions in the credit market implementation of privatization schemes and the development of a domestic banking

financial crisis in southeast asia dispelling illusion the minskyan way this paper extends minsky s financial instability hypothesis to the case of the open liberalised economy making it possible to put forward a specifically minskyan account of the road to the financial crisis in southeast asia 1997 1998 the analysis suggests that the threats to growth and employment emanating from the financial sector which minsky identified in the closed economy setting are much intensified in open liberalised developing economies financial liberalisation is an important key factor in this process rival explanations of the crisis are examined and rejected in favour of the extended minskyan explanation the policy implications are derived and discussed copyright 2002 oxford university press

manufacturing growth and financial development evidence from oecd countries recent theoretical models conjecture that the development of the financial sector is essential for economic growth we investigate this hypothesis from a time series perspective and find that financial sector gdp is cointegrated for many oecd countries not so much with manufacturing gdp but mostly with manufacturing total factor productivity moreover this relation is in some instances characterized by long run causality in the sense of granger and lin however even within this homogeneous group of countries the variety of results suggests a more complex picture than is apparent from cross sectional evidence

causal relationship between energy consumption and gdp growth revisited a dynamic panel data approach abstract this paper uses the panel data of energy consumption and gdp for 82 countries from 1972 to 2002 based on the income levels defined by the world bank the data are divided into four categories low income group lower middle income group upper middle income group and high income group we employ the gmm sys approach for the estimation of the panel var model in each of the four groups afterwards the causal relationship between energy consumption and economic growth is tested and ascertained we discover a in the low income group there exists no causal relationship between energy consumption and economic growth b in the middle income groups lower and upper middle income groups economic growth leads energy consumption positively c in the high income group countries economic growth leads energy consumption negatively after further in depth analysis of energy related data the results indicate that in the high income group there is a great environmental improvement as a result of more efficient energy use and reduction in the release of co2 however in the upper middle income group countries after the energy crisis the energy efficiency declines and the release of co2 rises since there is no evidence indicating that energy consumption leads economic growth in any of the four income groups a stronger energy conservation policy should be pursued in all countries

financial development growth and the distribution of income a paradigm is presented in which both the extent of financial intermediation and the rate of economic growth are endogenously determined financial intermediation promotes growth because it allows a higher rate of return to be earned on capital and growth in turn provides the means to implement costly financial structures thus financial intermediation and economic growth are inextricably linked in accord with the goldsmith mckinnon shaw view on economic development the model also generates a development cycle reminiscent of the kuznet hypothesis in particular in the transition from a primitive slow growing economy to a developed fast growing one a nation passes through a stage in which the distribution of wealth across the rich and poor widens

heterogeneous borrowers liquidity and the search for credit abstract we develop a general equilibrium model of credit formation where borrowers and lenders must search for matches and where the composition of borrowers adjusts to satisfy equilibrium entry conditions when market liquidity dries up as a result of fundamental shocks to the system fewer borrowers will participate in the credit market with low quality borrowers suffering disproportionately because of a flight to quality however less liquid credit markets need not be associated with lower social output because the effect of higher average quality may outweigh that of reduced market participation depending crucially on the source of the liquidity shock

non linear growth effects of financial development does financial integration matter using both macro and industry level data this paper analyses the non linear effects of financial development and international financial integration on economic growth in europe special attention is devoted to modeling threshold effects with respect to the depth of financial markets as a measure of economies absorption capacity results reveal evidence of significant non linear effects with less developed european countries gaining more from financial development in contrast benefits of international financial integration become significant at higher levels of financial development the data show that monetary integration in europe significantly contributed to a higher degree of financial integration entry of new eu members to the european monetary union may thus be the mechanism ensuring a virtuous development circle as the adoption of the euro may allow the development of domestic financial markets and financial integration to go hand in hand

waves of international banking integration a tale of regional differences abstract we propose an original measure of international banking integration based on gravity equations and a spline function on a panel of 14 countries and their 186 partners between 1999 and 2012 contrary to the conventional wisdom we uncover that 1 the international banking integration outside the euro area has been tenaciously increasing since 1999 and has even strengthened after the crisis 2 in contrast the international banking integration of the euro area has been cyclical since 1999 with a peak in 2006 and a complete reversal since then 3 this decline is not a correction of previous overshooting but a marked disintegration 4 outside the euro area the level of income does not affect the shape of banking integration

causality between financial development and economic growth an application of vector error correction and variance decomposition methods to saudi arabia this article makes an attempt to test the possible directions of causality between financial development and economic growth which were labelled by patrick 1966 as the supply leading and demand following hypothesis saudi arabia is taken as a case study the methods applied are the error correction and variance decompositions techniques including the most recently developed long run structural modelling lrsm pesaran and shin 2002 which by imposing exactly identifying and overidentifying restrictions on the cointegrating vector has taken care of a major limitation of the conventional cointegrating estimates in that they were atheoretical in nature to the best of our knowledge there has not been any study on this issue with the application of the techniques that incorporate lrsm the stability of the functions has also been tested by cumulative sum cusum cumulative sum of squares cusumsq and chow test chow tests our findings based on the above mentioned rigorous techniques tend to s

who gains from non collusive corruption non collusive corruption i e corruption that imposes an additional burden on business activity is particularly widespread in low income countries we build a macroeconomic model with credit market imperfections and heterogeneous agents to explore the roots and consequences of this type of corruption we find that credit market imperfections by generating rents for the incumbent entrepreneurs create strong incentives for corrupt behavior by state officials however non collusive corruption not only redistributes income from non officials towards officials but also within the group of potential entrepreneurs if borrowing is limited bribes prevent poorer but talented individuals from starting a business but this is likely to benefit those who may enter anyway the cost of capital is lower and there is less competition on the goods markets

critical mass effect and restructuring in the transition towards a market economy abstract restructuring firms in a transition economy produces a sort of network externality in that the profitability of restructuring depends on the number of firms that already adopted this strategy we investigate under what conditions a critical mass exists i e a situation in which such externality is positive and restructuring spurs imitation possibly leading to the eventual transformation of the whole economy we find a critical mass effect when the main effect of restructuring is an increase in value added i e aggregate demand rather than an increase in the firm s ability to compete against rival home firms the critical mass case becomes the typical one when competition spurs firms efficiency

financial markets in development and the development of financial markets what is the relationship between markets and development it is argued that markets promote growth and that growth in turn encourages the formation of markets two models with endogenous market formation are presented to analyze this issue the first examines the role that financial markets banks and stock markets play in allocating funds to the highest valued use in the economic system it is shown that intermediation will arise under weak conditions the second focuses on the role that markets play in supporting specialization in economic activity the consequences of perfect competition in market formation are highlighted

credit policy inflation and growth in a financially repressed economy this report analyzes credit policy in an open economy macro model incorporating stylized facts about the financial sector of ldc s absence of security markets existence of a curbmarket these facts are incorporated in the financial sector part of a keynes wicksell growth model it focuses on a transmission channel of monetary policy into the supply side of the economy via the cost of working capital it shows that ignoring this effect when analysing restrictive credit policy leads to underestimates of inflation and overestimation of output and current account improvements it is shown that a credit crunch can be stagflationary in the short run a cut in the real stock of credit is shown to lead to a lower steady state capital stock

law and finance at the origin what are the key determinants of financial development and growth a large literature debates the relative importance of countries legal and political environment in this paper i present evidence from ancient rome where an early form of shareholder company the societas publicanorum developed i show that the societas publicano rum flourished in a legally underdeveloped but politically supportive environment roman republic and disappeared when roman law reached its height of legal sophistication but the political environment grew less supportive roman empire in the roman case legal development appears to have mattered little as long as the law as practiced was flexible and adapted to economic needs the law as practiced in turn reflected prevalent political interests after discussing parallels in more recent history i provide a brief overview of the literature on law and finance and on politics and finance the historical evidence suggests that legal systems may be less of a technological constraint for growth than previously thought at least at the origin