privatizing the commons an improvement recent years have seen political economists turning to an institutional paradigm wherein the extent to which property rights are defined and enforced is an important determinant of human action furubotn 1972 the institutional or property rights approach has become an important component of explanations of both economic growth and economic inefficiency the institutional environment now holds a prominent place in explanations of differential growth rates among political units and over time 1 the property rights approach has also become commonplace in the analysis of the environmental crisis where the lack of well defined property rights is seen as the cause of environmental problems and movement toward a more complete specification of those rights as the solution even bureaucratic inefficiencies have been analyzed in the context of property rights mckean 1965

institutional dynamics and technology legitimacy a framework and a case study on biogas technology legitimacy is central for both novel and established technologies to mobilize the resources necessary for growth and survival a loss of legitimacy in turn can have detrimental effects for an industry in this paper we study the rise and fall of technology legitimacy of agricultural biogas in germany over a period of more than 20 years 1990 2012 the field witnessed impressive growth and professionalization for many years and has become one of the key technologies in germany s energy transition in recent years however it has been confronted with major criticism which finally resulted in a substantial cut back of public and political support the aim of our study is twofold in empirical terms we will explain the technology s loss of legitimacy despite its compliance with original policy objectives growth and maturation in theoretical terms we work toward a more general framework to understand technology legitimacy and to explain the institutional dynamics of technological innovation systems

the governance of sustainable socio technical transitions a quasi evolutionary model of socio technical transitions is described in which regimes face selection pressures continuously differentiated transition contexts determine the form and direction of regime change in response to these pressures the articulation of pressures and the degree to which responses are coordinated and based on resources available within the regime define the transition context four alternative contexts are described endogenous renewal re orientation of trajectories emergent transformation and purposive transitions agency and power in the governance of regime transformation are analysed power to affect change depends on regime membership the distribution of resources for change and expectations

understanding carbon lock in abstract this paper narrative argues that industrial economies have been locked into fossil fuel based energy systems through a process of technological and institutional co evolution driven by path dependent increasing returns to scale it is asserted that this condition termed carbon lock in creates persistent market and policy failures that can inhibit the diffusion of carbon saving technologies despite their apparent environmental and economic advantages the notion of a techno institutional complex is introduced to capture the idea that lock in occurs through combined interactions among technological systems and governing institutions while carbon lock in provides a conceptual basis for understanding macro level barriers to the diffusion of carbon saving technologies it also generates questions for standard economic modeling approaches that abstract away technological and institutional evolution in their elaboration the question of escaping carbon lock in is left for a future paper

directly unproductive profit seeking dup activities this paper propses directly unproductive profit seeking dup activities as a general concept that embraces a wide range of recently analyzed economic activities including the subset of rent seeking activities considered by krueger it then proceeds to provide a synthesis and generalization of the welfare theoretic analysis of such activities by developing a fourfold categorization of cases depending on the levels of distortions before and after the dup activity thus a unification and overview of the subject are achieved

rent seeking from a property rights perspective james buchanan 15 15 has suggested that rent seeking analysis can readily be incorporated within the property rights approach and as with public choice the theory of rent seeking can be interpreted as an appropriate extension yet no one has really explored rent seeking or revenue premium tariff or directly unproductive profit seeking from a property rights perspective buchanan 14 15 16 17 clearly indicated that property rights assignments actually underlie the rent seeking process and others have also recognized this 4 20 23 28 but there are further insights into the workings of the political economy which can be derived for instance lobbying activities with nonpecuniary goals clearly fit into the rent seeking framework when viewed through the property rights paradigm this contrasts strikingly with the perception of rent seeking held by some writers 9 10 11 12 13 furthermore a property rights approach to rent seeking provides predictions of a spiraling process of government growth since successful rent seeking by one interest group generally requires expansion of bureaucratic powers while at the same time creating incentives for the formation of additional rent seeking interest groups legislative responses to these new groups requires further expansion of the bureaucracy and creates incentives for more rent seeking so the growth process continues in this paper a brief summary of the conclusions of the rent seeking literature will be presented followed by an explanation of how the same conclusions have been deduced using the property rights paradigm various extensions of the rent seeking concept such as those alluded to above are then obtained by emphasizing a property rights approach following this the terms used to describe rent seeking e g directly unproductive profit seeking etc will be discussed to determine which if any is the most appropriate characterization of the phenomenon

rent seeking noncompensated transfers and laws of succession my purpose in this paper is to analyze inefficiencies that may emerge from the noncompensated transfer of valued rights among persons this source of inefficiency has not to my knowledge been fully incorporated either in the economic theory of property rights or in orthodox tax analysis my discussion is based on the elementary fact that all noncompensated transfers are rents to the recipients implications for the emergence of rent seeking behavior follow straightforwardly the now familiar propositions to the effect that rent seeking may dissipate economic value can be applied to a variety of transfer settings only a few of which are explored in this paper 1 to the extent that the efficiency criterion is the relevant norm direct implications may be drawn for policy with respect to the laws or rules for succession

creative destruction or mere niche support innovation policy mixes for sustainability transitions recently there has been an increasing interest in policy mixes in innovation studies while it has long been acknowledged that the stimulation of innovation and technological change involves different types of policy instruments how such instruments form policy mixes has only recently become of interest we argue that an area in which policy mixes are particularly important is the field of sustainability transitions transitions imply not only the development of disruptive innovations but also of policies aiming for wider change in socio technical systems we propose that ideally policy mixes for transitions include elements of creative destruction involving both policies aiming for the creation of new and for destabilising the old we develop a novel analytical framework including the two policy mix dimensions creation and destruction by broadening the technological innovation system functions approach and specifically by expanding the concept of motors of innovation to motors of creative destruction we test this framework by analysing low energy policy mixes in finland and the uk we find that both countries have diverse policy mixes to support energy efficiency and reduce energy demand with instruments to cover all functions on the creation side despite the demonstrated need for such policies unsurprisingly destabilising functions are addressed by fewer policies but there are empirical examples of such policies in both countries the concept of motors of creative destruction is introduced to expand innovation and technology policy debates to go beyond policy mixes consisting of technology push and demand pull instruments and to consider a wider range of policy instruments combined in a suitable mix which may contribute to sustainability transitions

the demand for environmental quality in driving transitions to low polluting energy sources the purpose of this paper is to understand the long run demand for energy related environmental quality its influence on legislation and on transitions to low polluting energy sources it starts by presenting a simple framework of the relationship between the demand for and supply of environmental quality environmental legislation and energy this forms the structure for presenting a series of episodes in british history where a demand for improvements in energy related environmental quality existed this analysis proposes that markets can drive transitions to low polluting energy sources in specific economic conditions however most probably governments will need to push them and this cannot be expected without strong and sustained demand for environmental improvements yet while demand is a prerequisite it is not enough it must also be spearheaded by strong creative and sustained pressure groups i e powerful lobbying and the weakening of the counter lobby to introduce legislation to enforce it and to avoid it being over turned by future governments

the journey towards decarbonization exploring socio technical transitions in the electricity sector in the province of ontario 1885 2013 and potential low carbon pathways this article employs the multi level perspective on socio technical transitions to explore the historical evolution of the electricity regime in the province of ontario from 1885 2013 and to interpret the potential for future movement towards decarbonization with an emphasis on the political and social dimensions of transitions this analysis traces the key features influencing change within ontario s electricity system over the past century this paper uses multiple criteria the phase of electrification role of the electricity system in economic development structures of ownership market and regulation dominant technologies and the relative stability of arrangements to characterize distinct regime configurations and periods of instability which separate relatively stable system orientations lessons are drawn from the historical case with implications for future decarbonization in the province including the importance of 1 residual momentum 2 embedded guiding principles and 3 politico economic coalitions

evolving theories of sustainability and firms history future directions and implications for renewable energy research abstract sustainability has become a critical perspective in managing firms via a holistic approach by considering economic environmental and social dimensions of firms with the rising significance of sustainable development the theories of sustainability in firms have evolved during the past six decades this article offers a critical review of the evolving theories linking sustainability to firms and discusses their implications for future renewable energy research the relationships among different theories are critically analysed and the directions for future research are discussed the paper shows that the main theories linking sustainability to firms in a chronological order are 1 corporate social responsibility 2 stakeholder theory 3 corporate sustainability and 4 green economics currently various innovative approaches and new theories emerged such as co evolution theory and multi level perspective reflecting three directions of theory development namely 1 shifting from what to how 2 growing use of interdisciplinary approach and 3 towards broader systems renewable energy studies associated with firms and future research opportunities in this area are also critically analysed the comprehensive review offered in this paper provides a useful reference for policy makers corporate managers and researchers interested in corporate sustainability and renewable energy related studies

structuring a theory of moral sentiments institutional and organizational coevolution in the early thrift industry the authors investigate the coevolution of organizations and institu tions they study how institutional definitions rules and expectations unfold in tandem with the organizational structures and processes that embody those institutions the research site is the early thrift industry changes in thrifts technical environment the rise of a transient and heterogeneous population and institutional environment the rise of progressivism propelled this coevolutionary process the coevolution of thrift organizations and institutions proceeded primarily through selection adaptation was constrained by both institutional factors it was difficult to adopt a novel institutional logic and technical factors early thrifts were generally small so entry and exit were easy

reply to commentary on the special issue scaling up biofuels a critical look at expectations performance and governance abstract the special issue scaling up bioenergy identifies major policy expectations attached to biofuels production worldwide and it provides systematic reviews of actual biofuel performance and governance in these areas papers address the extent to which policy expectations related to climate change mitigation energy security rural livelihoods and risk mitigation have been achieved and the effectiveness of public and private governance in advancing sector sustainability building on these findings the synthesis paper asks what next for countries wishing to advance national biofuel programmes as one option for the necessary divestment from fossil fuels among other sine qua nons the special issue highlights the urgent need to downscale global energy demand and to stop treating biofuels as an isolated sector goldemberg et al 2018 query several aspects of our approach from research design data collection to our recommendation to apply the precautionary principle in research as well as policy making unfortunately goldemberg et al 2018 incorrectly portray our main argument moreover they claim bias in our approach and mistakes in our empirical evidence however without bringing forward an evenhanded critique of research philosophy methodology or referencing different empirical literature we fully stand behind our research philosophy and findings presented

the destabilisation of existing regimes confronting a multi dimensional framework with a case study of the british coal industry 1913 1967 because innovation studies are oriented towards novelty scholars in this field have paid less attention to the destabilisation of existing regimes this paper discusses four views on industry destabilisation and presents an encompassing conceptual framework which addresses interactions between the build up of external pressures industry response strategies and the gradual weakening of commitment to existing regime elements we confront the framework with an in depth longitudinal case study of the british coal industry 1913 1967 specific conclusions are developed about different degrees of regime inertia the ebb and flow of external pressures the relative importance of economic and socio political pressures and interactions between them

determinants of renewable energy development in the eu countries a 20 year perspective abstract the objective of the paper is to identify factors which determine energy policy in the eu countries in the middle of 1990s this objective is achieved in three stages first the changes in the distribution of res in 26 eu countries in the period between 1995 and 2014 are investigated the analysis demonstrates that over the last 20 years the eu countries diversify the res they use which results in substantial changes in their distribution second the distribution of energy sources in 1995 is described as it is assumed that the distribution might be a crucial factor influencing energy policy in each country third several other factors related to energy security environmental concerns economy and politics are considered as potential determinants of renewable energy development two statistical methods of variable selection namely the best subset regression and the lars method reveal that the present in 2014 share of res in the energy mix significantly depends on the condition of the eu countries in the middle of 1990s the distribution of energy sources in 1995 is the crucial determinant of renewable energy development countries without their own fossil fuel sources are the ones which develop renewable energy to the greatest extent other important factors boosting re development include gdp per capita concentration of energy supply swi and the costs of consumption of energy obtained from fossil fuels in relation to gdp

on the measurement of unemployment abstract this paper suggests a new measure of unemployment which takes into account both the intensity and distribution aspects of unemployment the proposed index is also generalised to a parametric family of measures where the parameter is interpreted as an indicator of aversion to unemployment it also possesses the property of additive decompasibility which enables us to quantify the contribution for a specific group towards total unemployment the measure is most suitable for the less developed economies where major work activities especially in the rural area are often irregular and sporadic leading to frequent entry and involuntary withdrawls from the labour force on the part of workers an empirical exercise based on indian national sample survey data illustrates the usefulness of the proposed index

government affiliated intermediary organisations as actors in system level transitions the article draws from two theoretical fields innovation intermediation and sustainability transitions to examine the role of government affiliated intermediary organisations in system level transitions the role of intermediaries working between actors producers and users entrepreneurs and adopters idea generators and funders has seldom been specifically addressed in the transitions literature thus the role of intermediary organisations in enacting change in socio technical regimes particularly of intermediaries falling between traditional public sector and private sector actors is of interest in this article empirical analyses of two finnish organisations sitra and motiva show that government affiliated intermediaries are likely to engage in strategic niche management processes in diverse ways each organisation having its own distinct characteristics the analysis also points out that to get from niches to transition sustained systemic intermediaries are crucial in articulating new visions and expectations government affiliated intermediaries may make an important contribution to sustainability transitions by initiating and managing new policy or market processes and by acting as an impartial contact point or voice for new networks of actors while independence from public administration is likely to facilitate networking too neutral a stance or limited temporal engagement may reduce the transition facilitating effects

regime destabilisation as the flipside of energy transitions lessons from the history of the british coal industry 1913 1997 this paper investigates a neglected aspect of the transitions literature the destabilisation of existing regimes and industries it presents an analytical perspective that integrates four existing views on destabilisation and conceptualizes the process as a multi dimensional and enacted phenomenon involving technical economic political and cultural processes this perspective is illustrated with two historical cases of the british coal industry 1913 1967 1967 1997 these cases are also used to articulate five lessons regarding the overall destabilisation process and five lessons regarding the economic and socio political environments of industries the conclusion section translates the historical lessons into insights with relevance for the contemporary challenge of climate change and transitions to low carbon energy systems

spite and development in a wide variety of settings spiteful preferences would constitute an obstacle to cooperation trade and thus economic development this paper shows that spiteful preferences the desire to reduce another s material payoff for the mere purpose of increasing one s relative payoff are surprisingly widespread in experiments conducted in one of the least developed regions in india uttar pradesh in a one shot trust game the authors find that a large majority of subjects punish cooperative behavior although such punishment clearly increases inequality and decreases the payoffs of both subjects in experiments to study coordination and to measure social preferences the findings reveal empirical patterns suggesting that the willingness to reduce another s material payoff either for the sake of achieving more equality or for the sake of being ahead is stronger among individuals belonging to high castes than among those belonging to low castes because extreme social hierarchies are typically accompanied by a culture that stresses status seeking it is plausible that the observed social preference patterns are at least partly shaped by this culture thus an exciting question for future research is the extent to which different institutions and cultures produce preferences that are conducive or detrimental to economic development

geography urbanization and lock in considerations for sustainable transitions to decentralized energy systems the importance of moving towards sustainable energy systems is critical to achieving societal sustainability transitions theory is a useful approach to look at the potential and limitations of systemic transitions and has been applied in a number of alternative contexts in the current study we examine transitions theory and its implications for the progress of decentralized energy systems in japan in the period after the fukushima accident of 2011 empirical data from a targeted nation wide survey is used to examine the progress and change in consumer preference and behavior since the disaster as possible evidence for the potential transition paths likely to be occurring importantly this study utilizes data that examines a spectrum of urban rural and disaster non disaster areas in order to explore whether any differences in response patterns were present results indicate that although the desire of stakeholders has been to change the energy system there are barriers to transformation variation between rural and urban sites and between disaster affected and unaffected areas was examined indicating that at least under the chosen classification there was surprisingly little difference the results have implications for understanding transitions at a much broader level and imply that if the empirical data is a useful indicator japan is within a locked in or reorganization transition in order to move to a more radical conversion type change a new approach is likely to be required to nurture niche innovations effectively

socio technical inertia understanding the barriers to electric vehicles it is widely accepted that electrification of the transport sector is one of several technological trajectories that could redress some of the environmental issues associated with the growth in travel demand including climate change and oil demand at a global scale and air quality and noise pollution at the urban scale electric vehicles have been considered a promising technology at repeated intervals over the last century but this promise has not been realised this paper is a contribution to understanding the key tools and strategies that might enable the successful introduction of new technologies and innovations by exploring the key barriers to electric vehicles encountered in two countries uk and germany where the automobile industry has been historically significant the study evaluates stakeholders opinions on relevant regulation infrastructure investment r d incentives and consumer incentives the key findings of the research are that the introduction and penetration of evs is confronted by several barriers that inhibit a larger market penetration under current conditions which in turn casts doubt on the assumptions of strategic niche management and transitions theory

poverty and unemployment in india an analysis of recent evidence a careful analysis of the data for two states of india shows that the incidence of unemployment was markedly higher among those whose usual activity was casual labour the self employed and family helpers reported a much less than average level of unemployment or underemployment the casual labourers were over represented among the bottom deciles in terms of their per capita expenditure they reported a lower than average level of literacy and education and were generally younger than other workers those in rural areas were predominantly agricultural labourers with no land or very small land holdings two distinct groups among urban casual labourers were agricultural labourers and miscellaneous workers in the not elsewhere classified category the incidence of unemployment in 17 major states of india shows a statistically significant positive association with the percentage of casual labourers in the rural labour force and in the urban male labour force the importance of casual labourers if the labour force seems to explain a good part of the interstate variance in unemployment rates

distortion triggered lobbying and welfare a contribution to the theory of directly unproductive profit seeking activities abstract the paper considers the normative implications of lobbying for non exclusive income generated by an exogenously specified policy intervention such lobbying activities are a subset of what bhagwati has termed directly unproductive profit seeking dup activities it is demonstrated that the welfare effects of lobbying triggered by a policy distortion depend critically on whether the direct impact of the policy constraint is on price or an quantity it is also shown that several standard comparative static welfare analyses of alternative policy distorted states are significantly affected once the policy intervention is assumed to be continuously accompanied by lobbying for the associated non exclusive income