structural factors in the economic reforms of china eastern europe and the former soviet union reform in china and russia jeffrey sachs and wing thye woo china s experience does not show that gradual reform is superior to the shock therapy undertaken in eastern europe and the former soviet union eefsu differing performance primarily reflects different economic structures prior to reform china was a peasant agricultural society eefsu was urban and overindustrialized in both jobs in state enterprises were so heavily subsidized that workers refused to move to new industries elsewhere even when productivity in the latter was much higher in eefsu the large state sector impeded structural adjustment curtailing subsidies would have produced many losers who used their power to resist this outcome failure to curtail subsidies then cut off the potential supply of labour and other factors to new emerging firms china s state enterprises have not performed as well as the rest of the chinese economy and do not explain its success rapid growth was possible because the large agricultural sector contained vast surplus labour and did not enjoy subsidies and soft budget constraints once constraints on migration across regions and jobs were removed this labour was available to fuel expansion in new industries unlike the distributional conflict in eefsu in china reallocation of labour allowed all groups to gain in both partial liberalization also unleashed macroeconomic pressures manageable in china because of rapid growth and adequate monetary policy but explosive in much of eefsu because of deeper structural problems and gross monetary mismanagement

wage and price control policies in transition economies abstract this paper studies the structural impact of wage and price control policies in transition economies using a two sector three factor small open economy model it illustrates the results quantitatively via simulation exercises at the earlier stage of the transition when labor is immobile a strict control on the price of the nontradables and the wage rate minimizes the fall in employment and output also a more severe control on the price of the nontradables than on the wage rate alleviates the fall in the real wage at negligible costs in lost employment and output at the later stage of the transition when labor becomes mobile the liberalization of the price of the nontradables can proceed faster than that of the wage rate this policy combination increases employment and output and reduces the shortage for the nontradables but lowers the real wage

fertility and savings contractions in china long run global implications following three decades of rapid but unbalanced economic growth china s reform agendas are set to rebalance the economy towards consumption while maintaining strong gdp growth headwinds include a demographic contraction that will bring negative labour force growth and rapid ageing rising aged dependency combined with lower saving rates will rebalance the economy but they will reduce both gdp growth and real per capita income while an effective two child policy could sustain growth and eventually mitigate the aged dependency problem it would set real per capita income on a still lower path these conundrums are examined using a global economic and demographic model which shows how the continuing demographic and saving contractions in china would alter the trajectories of both the chinese and global economies

wage flexibility in the chinese labour market 1989 2009 abstractwage flexibility in the chinese labour market 1989 2009 regional studies china s bureaucratic wage determination system is gradually being replaced by a market based system leading to a novel version of a dual labour market this paper studies wage flexibility in this dual market its principal findings are as follows wages in both sectors have become less responsive to changes in official registered unemployment with an alternative market based measure of unemployment becoming more relevant there is evidence of convergence of flexibility between the two sectors the wages of women exhibit greater flexibility than those of men and there is evidence of differences in wage flexibility between workers who have urban residential rights and rural migrants

too many mothers in law abstract developing countries with low tax capacity may rely on predation to finance government functions government predation in turn is often accused of imposing a choking effect on state owned enterprises soes contributing to the latter s poor performance we formalize this choking effect as a problem of inefficient predation that arises from time inconsistency and show that having multiple government bodies supervising the same soe may mitigate this problem our theory provides an efficiency rationale for the chinese style of decentralization before 1978 and challenges the wisdom of china s recent enterprise reform that attempted to consolidate supervisory power

a tale of two reforms i identify the absence of well functioning product markets in transition economies as a sufficient condition under which big bang reduces output initially while a chinese style reform increases output big bang dismantles central planning or centralized organization of production permitting monopolistic and vertically interdependent enterprises to pursue their own monopoly profits by restricting output and inter firm trade to the detriment of the economy as a whole the chinese reform by maintaining central planning but allowing enterprises to produce for the emerging product markets after they have fulfilled their output quotas under planning gives enterprises incentives to expand output beyond planned targets

reforming fisheries lessons from a self selected cooperative we analyze a policy experiment in an alaskan commercial fishery that assigned a portion of an overall catch quota to a voluntary co op with the remainder exploited competitively by those choosing to fish independently unlike the individual quota system advocated by many economists the policy encouraged coordinated fishing and did not require a detailed assignment of rights we model the decision to join and behavior under cooperative and independent fishing the data confirm our key predictions the co op attracted the least skilled fishermen consolidated and coordinated effort among its most efficient members and provided shared infrastructure we estimate that resulting gains in rent were at least 33 percent some independents were disadvantaged by the co op s formation however which prompted them to oppose it in court we analyze the source of their disadvantage and provide guidance for designing fishery reform that leads to pareto improvements enabling reform without losers

the transition to a market economy pitfalls of partial reform we present a theory of a partial economic reform of a planned economy similar to the one that took place in russia since 1988 and in china earlier in such a reform some markets are liberalized in the sense that producers can sell output to whomever they want including private firms at free prices but at the same time must sell to state firms at state prices we show that such a reform can result in a substantial diversion of subsidized inputs away from state firms and toward private firms even when state firms value these inputs more the result may be a reduction of total output the simple analysis sheds light on many consequences of the soviet reform such as breakdown of coordination of production increased state policing of delivery quotas prohibitions of trading cooperatives and opposition to privatization the model also explains why partial reform failed in russia but worked in china

reform without losers an interpretation of china s dual track approach to transition this paper develops a simple model to analyze the dual track approach to market liberalization as a mechanism for implementing efficient pareto improving economic reform that is reform achieving efficiency without creating losers the approach based on the continued enforcement of the existing plan while simultaneously liberalizing the market can be understood as a method for making implicit lump sum transfers to compensate potential losers of the reform the model highlights the critical roles of enforcement of the plan for achieving pareto improvement and full liberalization of the market track for achieving efficiency we examine how the dual track approach has worked in product and labor market liberalization in china

policy reform and growth in post soviet russia in pursuit of its transition from a command to a market economy russia has witnessed enormous regional differences in economic growth rates moreover the implementation of economic reforms has also differed markedly across regions we analyze whether regional differences in reform policies can account for regional differences in growth rates and conclude that to a considerable degree they can most notably we find that regional differences in price liberalization policies exhibit a positive direct correspondence with growth we also find that regional differences in large scale privatization exhibit a positive correspondence with the regional formation of new legal enterprises which in turn exhibits a strong positive correspondence with growth

plan and market in china s agricultural commerce this article examines interactions between markets and state commercial planning in the context of china s agricultural sector it begins with a discussion of recent trends in agricultural planning and commerce in china and then presents a theoretical model that analyzes the way that a mixed commercial system of the sort observed in china functions the theoretical analysis suggests that a mixed system is sustainable and can have desirable efficiency and distributional effects markets however limit the range of sustainable plans and in the presence of markets state planning may no longer directly influence production and consumption behavior

the political economy of transition the overriding importance of political constraints in the transition process has led to developments of the theory of the political economy of reform what are the main insights from that theory how does it reflect the transition reality what have we learned and what do we still need to learn the present article will attempt to answer those questions

when ideas trump interests preferences world views and policy innovations the contemporary approach to political economy is built around vested interests elites lobbies and rent seeking groups which get their way at the expense of the general public the role of ideas in shaping those interests is typically ignored or downplayed yet each of the three components of the standard optimization problem in political economy preferences constraints and choice variables rely on an implicit set of ideas once the manner in which ideas enter these frameworks is made explicit a much richer and more convincing set of results can be obtained in particular new ideas about policy or policy entrepreneurship can exert an independent effect on equilibrium outcomes even in the absence of changes in the configuration of political power

rural reforms and agricultural growth in china this paper employs province level panel data to assess the contributions of decollectivization price adjustments and other reforms to china s agricultural growth in the reform period decollectivization is found to improve total factor productivity and to account for about half of the output growth during 1978 84 the adjustment in state procurement prices also contributed positively to output growth its impact came mainly from the responses in input use the effect of other market related reforms on productivity and output growth was very small reasons for slowdown in agricultural growth after 1984 are also analyzed copyright 1992 by american economic association

cultural amenities and unemployment in dutch cities disentangling a consumerist and productivist explanation for less educated urbanites varying unemployment levels across urban economies previous studies on the advanced economies have shown that unemployment levels of the less educated are low in cities with high employment shares in the advanced producer services scholars have consistently interpreted this finding according to sassen s polarisation thesis this article confronts this production based interpretation with a competing consumption based explanation which focuses on the role of cultural amenities analysing data on 22 dutch metropolitan agglomerations between 1996 and 2008 it is shown that in line with consumerists notions of richard florida advanced producer services settle in cities that are rich in cultural amenities instead of the other way around as classical labour follows capital explanations imply yet only advanced producer services prove to reduce the unemployment levels of the less educated meaning that the polarisation thesis and not the theory on cultural amenities is a valid explanation for the low level of unemployment in post industrial cities

are new tigers supplanting old mammoths in china s banking system evidence from a sample of city commercial banks abstract new tigers including city commercial banks outperform state owned commercial banks burdened with non performing loans from unprofitable state owned enterprises we study whether this is solely due to superior corporate governance multiple shareholders versus total government ownership or also to the favorable environment the new tigers target affluent china while state owned commercial banks operate nationwide using a field survey on 20 city commercial banks from three provinces at different levels of economic development we find better performance at those in the east and worse performance at those controlled by state owned enterprises geography and policy do matter and reform of state owned commercial banks is necessary to bring better banking to china

pareto improving economic reforms through dual track liberalization abstract pareto improving economic reforms that also simultaneously achieve efficiency can be implemented through a strategy of dual track liberalization its success requires the feasibility of the original plan and its continued enforcement by the state the chinese experience demonstrates that such a strategy works

dual track reforms with and without losers the dual track approach to market liberalization has been widely recognized as the key to the success of the chinese economic reform in this paper we study the effectiveness of this strategy in economic environments where the status quo government control is incomplete we show that in a dynamic context contractual arbitrage will emerge potentially resulting in efficiency losses and or adverse distributional effects by establishing a necessary and sufficient condition for the dual track approach to retain its appeal in a dynamic context our analysis provides a clear guideline to the broader applicability of this reform mechanism

an experimental study of compliance and leverage in auditing and regulatory enforcement evidence suggests that a large majority of firms and individuals comply with regulations and tax laws even though the frequency of inspections and audits is often low moreover fines for noncompliance are also typically low when regulatory violations are discovered these observations are not consistent with static compliance models harrington 1988 modified these static models by specifying a dynamic game in which some agents have an incentive to comply even when the cost of compliance each period is greater than the expected penalty this paper reports a laboratory experiment based on the harrington model framework in which subjects move between two inspection groups that differ in the probability of inspection and severity of fine subjects decide to comply or not in the presence of low medium or high compliance costs enforcement leverage arises in the harrington model from movement between the inspection groups based on previous observed compliance and noncompliance our results indicate that consistent with the model violation rates increase when compliance costs become higher and as the probability of switching groups becomes lower behavior does not change as sharply as the model predicts however since violation rates do not jump from 0 to 1 as parameters vary across critical thresholds a simple model of bounded rationality explains these deviations from optimal behavior

does the razor s edge exist new evidence of the law of one price in china 1997 2012 this paper revisits the market integration in china under the gradual economic reform using a novel data set of monthly prices for 267 goods across 173 cities from 1997 to 2012 with price regulations dramatically removed we provide new evidence to show that the law of one price lop holds in the context of china which is experiencing substantial trade liberalisation first by accounting for heterogeneity and cross sectional dependence our results show that prices converge to the lop for most goods and industrial materials converge faster than non perishable goods second in comparison with the earlier analysis with static evidence our results with the moving window show that convergence is escalating third we find that the price dispersion across products at the city level is increasing with distance but it is decreasing with openness and economic development our findings show china s market integration is going well under its ongoing market oriented reforms and cast doubt on the proposition that incremental reform in china has led to the fragmentation of the domestic market

selection staging and sequencing in the recent chinese privatization selection in privatization is a decision making process of choosing state owned enterprises soes prioritizing and sequencing privatizing events and determining the extent of private ownership in partial privatization we investigate this process in an important but rarely studied case of china based on the soe population over 1998 2008 we track 49 456 wholly soes and identify 9 359 privatization cases over time our econometric analysis concludes i the privatization selection is a complex decision making process in which local governments balance between various economic financial and political objectives ii in the recent chinese privatization firm performance relates to the selection staging and sequencing in privatization in an inverted u fashion the worse and the best performing soes are more likely to remain state owned maintain higher state holding when privatized and are less likely to be privatized later in time these patterns suggest the privatization reform slowdown and the underlying changes in the privatization policy

reform and openness why china s economic reforms have delayed democracy most theories that seek to explain democratization look to changes in the economy as the precursor to significant political liberalization locating the main causal factor in either severe economic crisis or rapid economic growth in the chinese context by contrast the communist party has extricated itself from the socialist social contract with the urban working class without losing its grip on political power moreover china has maintained a rapid pace of economic growth for over twenty five years without significant political liberalization comparative analysis of china s post 1978 reform policies yields insights both across types of socialist transition comparing china with eastern europe and russia and across time comparing china with other high growth east asian economies a key factor in china s ability to reform the economy without sacrificing political control is the timing and sequencing of its foreign direct investment fdi liberalization there are two key variables that are important to this comparative analysis china s pattern of ownership diversification and china s mode of integration into the global economy the article relates these two variables to the success of economic change without political liberalization in particular how fdi liberalization has affected relations between workers and the ruling communist party reform and openness in this context resulted in a strengthened chinese state a weakened civil society especially labor and a delay in political liberalization

how to reform a planned economy lessons from china the countries of eastern europe and the former soviet union have been flooded with advice from the west on how to liberalize their planned econo mies this advice is unfortunately offered in an empirical vacuum no one knows how these econo mies will react to the proposed liberalization meas ures there exists however a neglected source of information china offers a long time series of data over a decade s worth on the effects of reforms on a planned economy china s reforms were gradual but their cumulative effect has been large and they have been remarkably successful china s experiments provide some practical les sons on what kinds of reforms can work elsewhere the dominant school of thought among economists favours the big bang policy of reforming quickly and according to a comprehensive plan partial reforms in this view are useless they will be negated by the remnants of the planning system the proponents of big bang reform have been influential with poland czechoslovakia and rus sia announcing plans for a rapid transition to capi talism