institutions and progress an insistent theme in richard nelson s work is that of capitalism as an engine of progress in this paper i explore this idea through a sequence of his writing distinguishing progress as outcome from progress as instituted process this leads to a deeper issue within this nelsonian theme namely the incompatibility between progress and equilibrium i argue that evolving systems are ordered and coordinated but they are never in equilibrium capitalism is restless it always generates change from within and the proximate source of this progressive tendency is the uneven accumulation of knowledge capitalism is restless because knowledge is restless copyright 2001 by oxford university press

technology structural change and bop constrained growth a structuralist toolbox the latin american structuralism las is a significant part of the heterodox tradition in the theory of long run growth with a focus on the problems of developing economies which started their industrialization process when other regions had already accumulated substantial technological capabilities the emergence of a centre periphery system posed specific problems to growth and distribution in laggard economies which las discusses in a systematic way in this paper we presented a simple model which firstly captures key insights of the las school such as the persistency of technological asymmetries and structural heterogeneity secondly it can be used to analyze the impacts of shocks and policies based on how they affect supply side and demand side parameters of the model thirdly it links more closely post keynesian macroeconomics based on the bop constraint with the evolutionary microeconomics concerned with the dynamics of learning lastly it can be used as a toolbox and a teachable model in the analysis of the interactions between structural change technological catching up and long run growth

is education important in assessing the impact of institutions on economic growth in emerging economies in this article we empirically revise the hypothesis that institutions cause economic growth for emerging countries starting from a theoretical model our sample consists of 21 countries covering

persistence in international inflation rates we test for fractional dynamics in inflation rates based on the consumer price index cpi for 27 countries and inflation rates based on the wholesale price index wpi for 22 countries the fractional differencing parameter is estimated using semiparametric and approximate maximum likelihood methods significant evidence of fractional dynamics with long memory features is found in both cpi and wpi based inflation rates for industrial as well as developing countries implications of the findings are considered and sources of long memory are hypothesized

global growth and international cooperation a structuralist perspective this paper revisits the structuralist ideas on trade and growth and suggests based on the prebisch s principle of implicit reciprocity that policies for promoting structural change in the periphery may lead to higher global growth and a better income distribution across countries the paper discusses the inter relations and complementarities that exist between autonomous expenditure and industrial and technology policies in the long run with this objective we develop a structuralist growth model in which the technology gap and the growth rate of the domestic autonomous expenditure are endogenously determined in a two country centre and periphery international economy copyright the author 2010 published by oxford university press on behalf of the cambridge political economy society all rights reserved oxford university press

both institutions and policies matter but differently for different income groups of countries determinants of long run economic growth revisited summary this paper revisits the recent debate on the determinants of long run economic growth with the simple idea that different factors matter at different country groups classified by income levels this paper improves on the methodology by conducting not only cross section estimations but also fixed effects panel and system gmm estimations the results suggest that new policy variables such as technology and tertiary education as well as institutions matter as the determinants of long run economic growth in addition this paper finds that while secondary education and institution turn out to be important for lower income countries an emphasis on technology and higher education appears to be effective in generating growth for the upper middle and high income countries but not for the lower middle and low income countries

structural change and the bop constraint why did latin america fail to converge this paper discusses why latin america failed to achieve sustainable convergence with the developed world since 1960 and analyses different phases of convergence and divergence using a structuralist keynesian approach first it is argued that there are critical differences between latin america the developed economies and the asian economies as regards the evolution of the income elasticity of the demand for imports the rate of growth of exports and the balance of payments constrained rate of growth the income elasticity of the demand for imports in latin america showed an upward trend particularly after the mid 1970s which was not matched by a similar increase in exports a pattern in sharp contrast with that of the east asian countries the evolution of and exports are used to set forth a typology of latin american economic growth since 1960 in addition the paper relates elasticities and the less favourable latin american performance to the intensity and direction of structural change using a broad sample of developed and developing economies it is shown that the developing countries that succeed in reducing the income gap are those that transformed their economic structures in favour of sectors with higher schumpeterian and keynesian efficiency copyright the author 2009 published by oxford university press on behalf of the cambridge political economy society all rights reserved oxford university press

private agri food standards implications for food policy and the agri food system abstract this paper provides a brief introduction to the evolution and nature of private food safety and quality standards highlighting the resultant impacts on the structure and modus operandi of supply chains for agricultural and food products and the challenges posed for processes of agricultural development it serves as an introduction to a series of papers that provide a comprehensive overview of the current state of knowledge regarding private food safety and quality standards in both an industrialised and developing country context in so doing it aims to provide a catalyst for further research on this rapidly evolving field of inquiry

decomposing learning by doing in new plants the paper examines learning by doing in the context of a production function in which the other arguments are labor human capital physical capital and vintage as a proxy for embodied technical c

empty sources of growth accounting and empirical replacements a la kaldor with some beef standard sources of growth accounts are empty of content because they rely on neoclassical production theory rather analysis can be based on productivity growth quations derived either from nipa accounting conventions or algebraic identities these complementary schemes impose valid restrictions on growth rates of the wage rate profit rate capital labor and their respective average productivities a solow type growth model based on proper accounting can be shown to converge detailed results differ markedly from those of the standard model alternative essentially kaldorian supply and demandbased alternatives to sources of growth based on a familiar output growth vs productivity growth diagram with constant employment growth contours added in look like a useful alternative to the mainstream models

foreign know how firm control and the income of developing countries nber working paper seriesforeign know how firm control and the income of developingcountriesariel bursteinalexander monge naranjoworking paper 13073http www nber org papers w13073national bureau of economic research1050 massachusetts avenuecambridge ma 02138may 2007we thank manuel amador pol antras andy atkeson wilbur john coleman pete klenow eva nagypal giorgio primiceri andres rodriguez clare esteban rossi hansberg martin schneider aleh tsyvinski and seminar participants in various places for useful comments and suggestions gilberto arce providedsuperb research assistance the views expressed herein are those of the author s and do not necessarilyreflect the views of the national bureau of economic research 2007 by ariel burstein and alexander monge naranjo all rights reserved short sections of text not to exceed two paragraphs may be quoted without explicit permission provided that full credit including notice is given to the source

sources procedures and microeconomic effects of innovation fabio arcangeli paul david frank engelman christopher freeman massimo moggi richard nelson luigi orsenigo nathan rosenberg michele salvati g n von tunzelman two anonymous referees and the participants at the meeting of the committee on distribution growth and technical progress of the italian national research council cnr rome november 16 1985 have helped with various redraftings a particularly grateful acknowledgment is for the insightful and patient help of moses abramovitz this work has been undertaken at the science policy research unit spru university of sussex as part of the research program of the designated research centre sponsored by the economic and social research council esrc earlier support to the research that led to this paper by the italian national research council cnr is also gratefully acknowledged the statistical research has been undertaken with the assistance of stephano brioschi ilaria fornari and giovannu prennushi

stagnation or transformation of a dual economy through endogenous productivity growth a growth model is developed for an open dual economy the economy expands owing to a higher growth rate of labour productivity in the modern sector through the kaldor verdoorn channel and higher effective demand through a keynesian channel the model incorporates a retardation mechanism affecting the slopes of productivity and output growth schedules as labour surplus and economies of scale diminish a wage led or profit led regime and initial conditions may give rise to de industrialization in terms of both output and employment a growth trap sustaining a situation of structural heterogeneity or sustainable employment and adequate output and productivity growth

premature de industrialisation theory evidence and policy recommendations in the mexican case the main consequences of premature de industrialisation are a slowdown in the rate of economic growth and the deferral of economic development despite having adopted a successful export led growth strategy since the early 1980s these two phenomena have characterised the mexican economy during the past three decades in this article i investigate whether premature de industrialisation has been a major contributor to mexico s economic stagnation and attempt to identify which factors have been driving it the results confirm the hypothesis of premature de industrialisation and suggest that the evolution of income capital accumulation labour manufacturing productivity trade openness and the exchange rate provide an explanation for this process i also suggest a set of alternative policy measures aimed at returning the mexican economy to the path of growth and development

technological regimes catching up and leapfrogging findings from the korean industries abstract this paper examines the experiences of selected industries in korea to identify the stylized facts in the process of technological capability building and thereby to sort out the conditions for the catching up to occur to explain the process we have built a model of technological and market catching up a special attention has been given to the question of whether there has been a case of leapfrogging in any industry in korea and if so what are the conditions for its incidence in our framework we first measure the degree of catching up in terms of market shares in the world then we focus on catching up in technological capabilities in explaining the different record and prospects of korean industries in market catching up in the model technological capability is determined as a function of both technological effort and the existing knowledge base as determinants of technological effort we look at the technological regimes of the industries such as cumulativeness of technical advances fluidity predictability of technological trajectory and the properties of knowledge base using this model we explain the different technological evolution of the selected industries in korea including the d ram automobile mobile phone consumer electronics personal computer and machine tool industries we find three different patterns of catching ups path creating catching up cdma mobile phone path skipping catching up d ram and automobile and path following catching up consumer electronics personal computers and machine tools we interpret the first two case of catching up as leapfrogging unlike the argument by perez and soete perez c soete l 1988 catching up in technology entry barriers and windows of opportunity in dosi et al eds technical change and economic theory pinter publishers london we find that important r d projects except automobiles where only private r d was involved involved both private and public capacities and that entry was not driven by endogenous generation of knowledge and skills but by collaboration with foreign companies

the middle class in macroeconomics and growth theory a three class neo kaleckian goodwin model this paper presents a three class growth model with labor market conflict the classes are workers a middle management middle class and a top management capitalist class the model introduces personal income distribution that supplements conventional concerns with functional income distribution within such a model endogenously generated changes in personal income distribution can generate endogenous shifts from profit led to wage led regimes and vice versa a model of an economy with three classes enables us to consider richer patterns of class conflict because the middle class has shared interests and conflicts with both capitalists and workers changes that benefit the middle class do not necessarily increase growth or employment or benefit workers

adoption of agricultural innovations in developing countries a survey this paper reviews various studies which have provided a description and possible explanation to patterns of innovation adoption in the agricultural sector the survey points out that the tendency of many studies to consider innovation adoption in dichotomous terms adoption nonadoption may not be appropriate in many cases where the actual decisions are defined over a more continuous range more attention needs to be given to the socio cultural and institutional environment in area studies so that their interrelation with economic factors affecting adoption can be inferred the presence of several interrelated innovations is another aspect that needs to be considered more carefully in future research since a number of simultaneous decisions may be involved furthermore the possibility of regular sequential patterns in adopting components of a new technological package should be specifically addressed in future studies finally the impact of differential adoption rates on land holding distribution merits attention in future research

optimal migration a world perspective we ask what level of migration would maximize world welfare welfare is assumed to be a weighted average of the utilities of the world s various citizens but the weights are also country specific using a calibrated one sector model we find that unless the weights are heavily biased toward the natives of rich countries the extent of migration that would be optimal far exceeds the levels observed today the claim remains true in a two sector extension of the model all versions of the model assume that migration is the only redistributive tool

global value chains and market formation process in emerging export activity evidence from ethiopian flower industry abstract this article provides a case study of the ethiopian flower export industry which successfully emerged at time when the eu market main destination was already characterised by increasingly stringent standards and delivery requirements entering this market required a multitude of capabilities at firm sector and national levels several of these capabilities were absent or weak in the domestic market when the new activity kicked off the article analyses how the capabilities of individual firms and the industry at large co evolved and the role of various actors in the market formation process

heterodox theories of economic growth and income distribution a partial survey heterodox theories of economic growth and income distribution are surveyed focusing on major theories and recent contributions first a general framework for examining growth and distribution is discussed in terms of which classical marxian and post keynesian kaleckian and other theories are presented since this framework examines how variables are determined in equilibrium second dynamics behind equilibria are examined focusing on goods market and labor market changes third the framework is extended in a variety of ways to examine additional models addressing productivity growth and technical change money and inflation finance and debt additional distributional considerations multisector issues open economy questions and the environment it is concluded that the literature on heterodox theories of growth and distribution is vibrant large and growing and addresses many issues that are ignored or neglected in orthodox theories including power unemployment and aggregate demand

a time series approach to test a change in inflation persistence the mexican experience when a central bank commits credibly to a nonaccommodative monetary policy observed inflation should be a stationary process in countries where for a variety of reasons the determinants of inflation could lead it to follow a nonstationary process the adoption of a credible disinflationary programme should therefore induce a fundamental change in the stochastic process governing inflation and in particular should diminish its persistence this article studies the time series properties of both inflation and core inflation during the 1995 2006 period for the mexican economy using recently developed techniques to detect a change in the persistence of economic time series consistently with the adoption of an inflation targeting framework the results suggest that inflation in mexico seems to have indeed switched from a nonstationary to a stationary process around the end of year 2000 or the beginning of 2001

debt and development in historical perspective the external constraints of late industrialisation revisited through south korea and brazil current debates about the role of external finance in development mostly overlook the insights from early development economics that late industrialisation generates a structural tendency to run trade deficits thereby exacerbating rather than relieving external foreign exchange constraints the developmental role of external finance is therefore based on its strategic marginal contribution to relieve such constraints external debt in particular also allows countries to pursue industrial strategies without reliance on foreign direct investment these insights are revisited in this paper as a critical input to both mainstream and heterodox contemporary scholarship on debt and development while the mainstream generally avoids discussion of state led industrial policy the heterodox has converged on a view that developing countries should avoid external finance the contrasting external account histories of south korea and brazil are examined to demonstrate the validity of the classic insights and the contemporary fallacies while the south korean case speaks much to its geopolitical context this does not necessarily refute the principle that post war late development engenders an intensive demand for external finance which must be met if industrialisation strategies are not to be stymied as in the case of brazil no matter how effectively domestic strategies are conceived and implemented

comparing features of convenient estimators for binary choice models with endogenous regressors abstract we discuss the relative advantages and disadvantages of four types of convenient estimators of binary choice models when regressors may be endogenous or mismeasured or when errors are likely to be heteroscedastic for example such models arise when treatment is not randomly assigned and outcomes are binary the estimators we compare are the two stage least squares linear probability model maximum likelihood estimation control function estimators and special regressor methods we specifically focus on models and associated estimators that are easy to implement also for calculating choice probabilities and regressor marginal effects we propose the average index function aif which unlike the average structural function asf is always easy to estimate

on the persistence of prices in mexico a fractional integration approach abstracta relevant yet often overlooked characteristic of the inflation rate is its mean reverting property if a series has this feature shocks eventually dissipate whereas if it does not they have a permanent effect on the series the usual i 1 versus i 0 dichotomy in time series econometrics goes only so far towards disentangling this issue by employing a methodology that estimates the persistence of inflation by allowing i fractional integration and ii persistence and level shifts in the series we aim to define whether it is stationary and or mean reverting and if so during which periods the results of our analysis for the period 1987 2015 are threefold firstly inflation in the eighties and nineties should be seen as a highly persistent yet mean reverting process not a random walk secondly inflation remained mean reverting though became a short memory less persistent process around the date of the implementation of the inflation targeting framework of 2001 thirdly during the l

education and economic growth a meta regression analysis summary this paper surveys the literature which examines the effect of education on economic growth specifically we apply meta regression analysis to 57 studies with 989 estimates and show that there is substantial publication selection bias toward a positive impact of education on growth once we account for this the genuine growth effect of education is not homogeneous across studies but varies according to several factors specifically it is attributed to differences in education measurement and study characteristics mainly model specification as well as type of data used and the quality of research outlets where studies are published e g academic journals vs working papers

mean reversion in the real exchange rates abstract robinson s j am stat assoc 89 1994 1420 fractionally based tests for unit roots and other hypotheses are applied to real exchange rate data between u s and five industrialized countries the results indicate that the series are fractionally integrated with mean reversion if the disturbances are autocorrelated

long memory in inflation rates international evidence we examine monthly inflation rates of five industrial countries the application of tests against stationarity as well as tests against a unit root yield contradictory results thus fractional integration allowing for long memory is a plausible model we discuss and apply the periodogram regression to estimate the difference parameters for all countries we find estimates significantly different from 1 as well as from 0 this is evidence in favor of long memory specification tests and maximum likelihood estimates support the fitted models finally we relate our empirical results to the construction of the data

structural differences in economic growth an endogenous clustering approach this article addresses heterogeneity in determinants of economic growth in a data driven way instead of defining groups of countries with different growth characteristics a priori based on for example geographical location we use a finite mixture panel model and endogenous clustering to examine cross country differences and similarities in the effects of growth determinants applying this approach to an annual unbalanced panel of 59 countries in asia latin and middle america and africa for the period 1971 2000 we can identify two groups of countries in terms of distinct growth structures the structural differences between the country groups mainly stem from different effects of investment openness measures and government share in the economy furthermore the detected segmentation of countries does not match with conventional classifications in the literature

knowledge diffusion market segmentation and technological catch up the case of the telecommunication industry in china abstract this paper examines the growth of technological capability in the telecommunication industry in china we apply a modified version of lee and lim s lee k lim c 2001 the technological regimes catch up and leapfrogging findings from the korean industries research policy vol 30 model of technological learning and catching up using the three cases of the shanghai bell the cit led r d consortium and indigenous companies such as huawei we analyze how the catching up in the telecommunication industry occurred we find that the important factors in the catch up are the strategy of trading market for technology the knowledge diffusion from shanghai bell both to the r d consortium and to huawei and industrial promotion by the government as a condition for successful catch up the paper points out that the technological regime of the telephone switches is featured by a more predictable technological trajectory and a lower cumulativeness these conditions and strategies helped the chinese firms to achieve a stage skipping catch up namely by skipping the stage of analogue electronic switches to jump to digital electronic switches

a neo kaleckian goodwin model of capitalist economic growth monopoly power managerial pay and labour market conflict this paper presents a neo kaleckian goodwin model of growth and distribution the key innovation is the introduction of managerial pay kaleckian monopoly power determines the functional distribution of income and goodwin labour bargaining power determines the wage bill division the model helps explain slower us growth over the past 30 years for much of that period the functional distribution of income was relatively constant but growth slowed because income inequality increased owing to a wage bill shift from workers to managers the wage bill division effect explains why economies can display wage led and profit led characteristics economies can be profit led regarding functional income distribution and wage led regarding wage bill distribution

institutional voids or organizational resilience business groups innovation and market development in latin america summary the paper compares the innovativeness of group affiliated firms gafs and standalone firms safs and it investigates how country specific institutional factors affect the group innovation relationship the paper analyzes the contrasting predictions of two competing views the institutional voids and the organizational resilience theses the empirical analysis focuses on a large sample of firms in latin america in line with the organizational resilience thesis the results point out that the superior innovation performance of gafs is stronger for national economies with more efficient financial legal and labor market institutions

long memory or structural changes an empirical examination on inflation rates abstract the modified local whittle method is proposed for testing long memory when the data have structural changes we apply it to analyze monthly g7 inflation rates empirical results show that for germany and japan the long memory phenomenon may just be a consequence of structural changes and that for other countries the inflation rates may have both long memory and structural changes

economic growth and balance of payments constraint in brazil an analysis of the 1995 2013 period abstract the purpose of this work is to analyze the balance of payments constrained growth in brazil considering thirwall s law 1979 to this end we estimate export and import demand functions using two econometric models vector error correction and structural state space model for the period of 1995 2013 our results suggest that the balance of payments is a constraint to the brazilian economic growth given i the ratio between exports and imports income elasticities ii the low sensitivity of exports to changes in the real exchange rate and iii the evidence that exports are more sensitive to alterations in commodities prices than to changes in the real exchange rate

governance and trade in fresh vegetables the impact of uk supermarkets on the african horticulture industry production of fresh vegetables for export has grown rapidly in a number of countries in sub saharan africa over the last decade this trade brings producers and exporters based in africa together with importers and retailers in europe large retailers in europe play a decisive role in structuring the production and processing of fresh vegetables exported from africa the requirements they specify for cost quality delivery product variety innovation food safety and quality systems help top determine what types of producers and processors are able to gain access to the fresh vegetables chain and the activities they must carry out the control over the fresh vegetables trade exercised by uk supermarkets has clear consequences for inclusion and exclusion of producers and exporters of differing types and for the long term prospects for the fresh vegetables industry in the two major exporting countries studied kenya and zimbabwe

inflation dynamics in the u s global but not local mean reversion a stylized fact of u s inflation dynamics is one of extreme persistence and possible unit root behavior if so the implications for macroeconomics and monetary policy are somewhat unpalatable our econometric analysis proposes a parsimonious univariate representation of the inflation process for the last 60 years the nonlinear exponential smooth autoregressive the empirical results confirm a number of the key features such as global stationarity local unit root behavior and lower persistence in the post 1983 period than in the pre 1983 period we compare the forecasting ability of our model with that of competing univariate models and find that the nonlinear model outperforms the linear autoregressive model in the pre 1983 period and the random walk in the post 1983 period at short horizons

firms adoption of international standards evidence from the ethiopian floriculture sector global trade in agriculture and food products is increasingly governed by an array of standards a survey conducted in 2010 covering all operational firms in the nascent floriculture industry in ethiopia revealed that only 36 per cent have managed to acquire certification for international private standards this study uses a census based panel dataset from ethiopian floriculture to empirically examine the determinants of firms adoption of international private standards it also analyses overall industry level efforts and public private partnership to launch and implement a national scheme for good agricultural practice and build firms capacity to comply with the standards key words standards certification floriculture exports estate farms ethiopia africa

nonlinearity and stationarity of inflation rates evidence from the euro zone countries earlier studies hardly reject the hypothesis of a unit root in inflation few studies have examined the possibility of nonlinearity in inflation and tested nonlinear stationarity of the inflation rates this study thus intends to fill the gap this study utilizes the tests for nonlinearity along with the unit root tests that allow for nonlinearity in the variables to examine the stationarity of inflation rates of 12 european countries that formed the euro zone ez later in the sample period the results suggest that the majority of these countries inflation rates can be characterized by mean reversion during the floating exchange rate period many of them appear to be nonlinear stationary this finding is essential in conducting applied economic studies for these countries when constructing models whose validity relies on whether or not inflation is stationary the results of this study also imply that shocks to inflation have a transitory effect on inflation in the euro area therefore it would be le

understanding economic policy reform one of the eventual consequences of the global debt crisis was a wave of market oriented economic reforms this paper discusses the state of our knowledge on the political economy of this process why were inefficient and often unsustainable policies maintained for so long why are so many governments reforming now after decades of adherence to policies of an opposite kind have the reformers internalized the correct lessons from the east asian experience finally are there any helpful rules for reformers to follow in guiding their policies through complicated political terrain

global value chains labor organization and private social standards lessons from east african cut flower industries summary this article examines the opportunities and challenges that private social standards pose for labor organizations it explores different labor responses to private social standards in east african cut flower industries the analysis incorporates the concept of labor agency in global value chain analysis and reveals how retailer driven chains offer more room for labor organizations to exercise their agency than the traditional cut flower value chains labor organizations have been able to influence social standard setting and implementation and to use standards to further labor representation at production sites however labor organizations ability to seriously challenge the prevailing governance structure of the cut flower value chain appears extremely limited

measuring the importance of transaction costs in cattle marketing transaction cost economics recognizes that transactions do not occur in a frictionless economic environment information negotiation and monitoring costs arise in any transaction and can influence the vertical coordination outcome this paper demonstrates a method for measuring the influence of transaction costs on slaughter cattle marketing the paper focuses on the factors affecting the choice between liveweight live ring auction and deadweight direct to packer sales using tobit limited dependent variable analysis data from a survey of uk farmers are used to estimate the relative importance of various transaction costs and farm characteristic variables for the choice of marketing channel

the world distribution of income falling poverty and convergence period we estimate the world distribution of income by integrating individual income distributions for 138 countries between 1970 and 2000 country distributions are constructed by combining national accounts gdp per capita to anchor the mean with survey data to pin down the dispersion poverty rates and head counts are reported for four specific poverty lines rates in 2000 were between one third and one half of what they were in 1970 for all four lines there were between 250 and 500 million fewer poor in 2000 than in 1970 we estimate eight indexes of income inequality implied by our world distribution of income all of them show reductions in global inequality during the 1980s and 1990s

local and personal networks in employment and the development of labor markets evidence from the cut flower industry in ethiopia summary we examine the roles of local and personal networks in the employment process and the emergence and development of the labor market in ethiopia s growing cut flower industry using primary survey data of 320 workers randomly sampled from all 64 farms we find that workers who were recruited informally using the social ties were paid less than the formally recruited workers at hiring however these workers quickly increased their productivity and the effect of social ties on wages disappeared over time further we find that the development of labor market for this newly emerged industry took place particularly within the industrial cluster

long memory and level shifts in the volatility of stock market return indices there has been interest in the possibility of confusing long memory and structural changes in level and studies showed that when a short memory process is contaminated by level shifts the estimate of the fractional differencing parameter is biased upward and the autocovariances decay slowly we analyze the properties of the autocorrelation function the periodogram and the log periodogram estimate of the memory parameter when the level shift component is a mixture model our results explain many findings reported and uncover new features we confront our theoretical predictions using log squared returns as a proxy for the volatility of some assets returns including daily s p 500 returns over the period 1928 2002 the estimates follow patterns that would obtain if the process was short memory with level shifts instead of fractionally integrated a simple test is also proposed which reinforces this conclusion

uneven growth between interdependent economies an evolutionary view on technology gaps trade and growth preface part one theory and empirics of international growth rate differentials and technology gaps chapter 1 technology growth and welfare a historical perspective 1 1 the search for welfare and the role of technology 1 2 aim of the book 1 3 organisation of the rest of the book notes chapter 2 the literature on economic growth and technological change 2 1 a brief overview 2 2 the traditional literature on economic growth 2 3 new neoclassical growth models endogenous innovation 2 4 the role of technological change 2 5 explaining growth rate differentials notes chapter 3 an evolutionary theory of economic growth and technological change the basics 3 1 economic growth as an evolutionary process a macroeconomic interpretation 3 2 economic growth as an evolutionary process a microeconomic interpretation 3 3 towards an evolutionary theory notes chapter 4 technology and growth in an international perspective 1960 1990 an impressionistic approach 4 1 economic growth and structural change 4 2 technology 4 3 technology and growth catching up or falling behind a global issue 4 4 summary and conclusions appendix iv 1 postwar economic welfare and the selection of country samples appendix iv 2 the 3 digit isic sector classification revision 2 appendix iv 3 on measuring and graphing structural differences between countries appendix iv 4 some tests for the influence of multicollinearity on the regressions in section 4 2 notes part two technology spillovers between interdependent economies catching up or falling behind chapter 5 a model of catching up or falling behind 5 1 description of the model 5 2 solving the model 5 3 the outcomes of the model under varying parameter restrictions 5 4 conclusions of the model notes chapter 6 an empirical test of the model 6 1 testing procedure and data sources 6 2 result 6 3 interpreting the results 6 4 summary and some policy conclusions appendix vi l a description of the data appendix vi 2 the calculation of the n statistic notes part three technological change international trade and economic growth chapter 7 an evolutionary model of technological change specialisation and economic growth 7 1 a descriptive interpretation 7 2 the model 7 3 simulation results 7 4 summary and conclusions appendix vii 1 initial values of the simulation runs for the 3 country 2 sector case appendix vii 2 some mathematical details of the selection equation in discrete time notes chapter 8 an empirical view on the evolution of trade and technology 8 1 patents as indicators of innovation 8 2 summarising some known correlations 8 3 trade and technology a dynamic evolutionary framework 8 4 estimation of the replicator equation 8 5 some further tests on the robustness of the replicator estimates 8 6 explaining the results for the patent variables 8 7 summary and conclusions

differences in income elasticities and trends in real exchange rates abstract one might expect that differences in income elasticities in trade and or differences in growth rates among countries would give rise to strong secular trends in real exchange rates for example fast growing countries might need steady depreciation to get the world to accept their growing exports in fact however income elasticities are systematically related to growth rates by the 45 degree rule under which fast growing countries appear to face high income elasticities of demand for their exports while having low income elasticities of import demand the net effect of this relationship between elasticities and growth rates is that secular trends in real exchange rates are much smaller than one might otherwise have expected relative ppp holds fairly well this paper documents the existence of a 45 degree rule and suggests an explanation in terms of increasing returns and product differentiation

economic performance through time prize lecture to the memory of alfred nobel december 9 1993 this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

a technology gap interpretation of growth paths in asia and latin america abstract this paper presents a north south technology gap model which combines the schumpeterian approach to technical and structural change with the keynesian perspective on effective demand and the balance of payments bop constraint as drivers of growth three are the contributions of the paper first it develops a model in which the technology gap relative productivity and relative wages co evolve and may generate different paths of convergence or divergence between south and north depending on the parameters of the model second the parameters of the model are associated with different types of policies which allows for discussing how these policies may change the growth path finally the model is used to discuss the contrasting experiences of asia and latin america since 1970 convergence in asia and divergence in latin america have been extensively debated topics in the literature on comparative economic development which highlights the crucial role of industrial policy it is argued that the results of the technology gap model are consistent with the findings of this literature and helps understand the forces behind convergence and divergence

public policies and the art of catching up matching the historical evidence with a multicountry agent based model in this paper we study the effects of industrial policies on international convergence using a multi country agent based model which builds upon dosi et al 2019b the model features a group of microfounded economies with evolving industries populated by heterogeneous firms that compete in international markets in each country technological change is driven by firms activities of search and innovation while aggregate demand formation and distribution follows keynesian dynamics interactions among countries take place via trade flows and international technological imitation we employ the model to assess the different strategies that laggard countries can adopt to catch up with leaders market friendly policies industrial policies targeting the development of firms capabilities and rd protectionist policies focusing on tariffs only we find that markets cannot do the magic in absence of government interventions laggards will continue to fall behind on the contrary industrial policies can successfully drive international convergence among leaders and laggards while protectionism alone is not necessary to support catching up and countries get stuck in a sort of middle income trap finally in a global trade war where developed economies impose retaliatory tariffs both laggards and leaders are worse off and world productivity growth slows down

trade standards and poverty evidence from senegal summary in the debate on trade and poverty it is argued that standards act as trade barriers and cause marginalization of the poor this paper quantifies income and poverty effects of high standards trade and integrates labor market effects by using company and household survey data from the vegetable export chain in senegal we find that exports grew sharply despite increasing standards contributing importantly to rural incomes and poverty reduction tightening standards induced a shift from smallholder contract farming to integrated estate production altering the mechanism through which poor households benefit through labor markets instead of product markets

the importance of manufacturing in economic development has this changed summary manufacturing has traditionally played a key role in the economic development of developing countries in recent years it has been argued that the importance of manufacturing has diminished over the last 20 25 years resulting in premature deindustrialization or non industrialization in developing countries this study explores whether the low levels of industrialization in developing countries are attributable to long term changes in opportunities available to the sector around the globe the study s findings show that the manufacturing sector s value added and employment contribution to world gdp and employment respectively have not changed significantly since 1970 the declining manufacturing value added and manufacturing employment share in many developing countries has not been caused by changes in the sector s development potential but has instead resulted from a shift of manufacturing activities to a relatively small number of populous countries thus resulting in a concentration of manufacturing activities in specific developing countries as was the case in the last millennium industrialization has continued to play a key role in the growth of developing countries which have sustained rapid and long term growth for the last 25 years achieving economic development by following the path of industrialization will likely remain important for low income countries because they are able to take advantage of their backwardness relative to those countries which have already experienced rapid industrialization with a disproportionately large share of manufacturing activities and could soon enter a mature stage of industrialization

sectoral regularities of productivity growth in developing countries a kaldorian interpretation this paper provides a kaldorian interpretation for empirical regularities of product ivity growth at the sectoral level of the economy the statistical evidence is based on a dataset drawn from internationally compatible time series for employment and value added in 30 developing countries based on novel non linear statistical techniques the findings show i a regular pattern of positive sectoral employment elasticities with respect to output growth ii robust differences across sectors in the magnitude of the employment elasticities and iii employment elasticities for all sectors that are signifi cantly less than unity suggesting strong evidence for increasing returns at the sector level of the economy

intra union flexibility of non ets emission reduction obligations in the european union the eu proposal on greenhouse gas emission reduction has 28 targets for 2020 an eu wide one for co2 emissions covered by the european trading system ets and one target for non ets emissions per member state implementation is more expensive than needed i consider three alternative proposals to reduce costs in the irish proposal member states can purchase ets permits to offset excess non ets emissions in the polish proposal member states can sell excess non ets emissions in the ets in the swedish proposal member states can trade their non ets allocations i compare these alternatives to the default policy no flexibility outside the ets and the cost effective solution full flexibility i calibrate a simple model to the results of the eu impact assessment which did not disclose all details and made odd assumptions the non ets allocation exceeds the projected emissions for three member states the alternative flexibility mechanisms would be used to only a limited extent but would cut the costs of meeting the target the swedish and polish proposals come closest to the cost effective solution because of the hot air the irish proposal performs best if there are negative surprises in either abatement costs or emissions the swedish proposal will become policy

eu climate change policy 2013 2020 using the clean development mechanism more effectively in the non eu ets sector abstract under european union proposals for co 2 emission reduction between 2013 and 2020 a member state can transfer to another member state the right to use its unused clean development mechanism cdm credits the paper addresses three issues in relation to these cdm warrants cdm w first how should the member state treat the cdm w in making decisions concerning emission reduction the price of the property right is an important signal for a member state in deciding the level of domestic abatement compared to trading in cdm w s in other words a shadow price for cdm w s should be used in formulating the emission strategy in order to determine whether or not a member state is a buyer or seller of cdm w s second what mechanism should be used to facilitate the exchange of cdm w s the preferred mechanism depends on the market size over which there appears to be some ambiguity market intermediaries such as over the counter trades and exchanges are preferred if market size is small auctions if the market size is large third who should realise the value of cdm w s the state existing polluters etc the value of cdm w s should accrue to the state

occupational choice and development abstract the rise in world trade since 1970 has been accompanied by a rise in the geographic span of control of management and hence also a rise in the effective international mobility of labor services we study the effect of such a globalization of the world s labor markets the world s welfare gains depend positively on the skill heterogeneity of the world s labor force we find that when people can choose between wage work and managerial work the worldwide labor market raises output by more in the rich and the poor countries and by less in the middle income countries this is because the middle income countries experience the smallest change in the factor price ratio and where the option to choose between wage work and managerial work has the least value in the integrated economy our theory also establishes that after economic integration the high skill countries see a disproportionate increase in managerial occupations using aggregate data on gdp openness and occupations from 115 countries we find evidence for these patterns of occupational choice

appropriate intellectual property protection and economic growth in countries at different levels of development this paper examines how the role of patents and utility models in innovation and economic growth varies by level of economic development using a panel dataset of over 70 countries we find that patent protection is an important determinant of innovation and that patentable innovations contribute to economic growth in developed countries but not in developing instead in developing economies a minor form of intellectual property rights iprs namely utility models is conducive to innovation and growth controlling for other factors using korean firm level data as a case study we find that utility model innovations contribute to firm performance when firms are technologically lagging and that those minor innovations can be a learning device and thus a stepping stone for developing more patentable inventions later on upon reaching higher levels of technological capabilities firms become more reliant upon patents and less on utility models thus the lesson here is that patent protection enhances innovation and economic growth in countries where the capacity to conduct innovative research exists where this capacity is weaker a system that provides incentives to conduct minor incremental inventions is more conducive to growth the significance of this paper is to emphasize the importance not just of the strength of iprs but of the appropriate type of iprs for economic development

accumulation innovation and catching up an extended cumulative growth model this paper presents an extended model of cumulative growth in which the effects of innovation and catching up are considered innovation adds another source of cumulative growth to that of traditional models and allows a consideration of the importance of non price determinants of international competitiveness catching up is the major force leading to convergence in productivity owing to the effect of the diffusion of technology the model allows one to analyse whether cumulative forces may lead to stable growth and whether this solution generates convergence in productivity levels the structural model is tested for a set of oecd countries over the period 1965 94

the national system of innovation in historical perspective contrary to some recent work on so called globalisation this paper argues that national and regional systems of innovation remain an essential domain of economic analysis their importance derives from the networks of relationships which are necessary for any firm to innovate whilst external international connections are certainly of growing importance the influence of the national education system industrial relations technical and scientific institutions government policies cul tural traditions and many other national institutions is fundamental the historical examples of germany japan and the former ussr illustrate this point as well as the more recent contrast between east asian and latin american countries introduction the national system of friedrich list according to this author s recollections the first person to use the expression national system of innovation was bengt ake lundvall and he is also the editor of a highly original and thought provoking book 1992 on this subject however as he and his colleagues would be the first to agree and as lundvall himself points out the idea actually goes back at least to friedrich list s conception of the national system of political economy 1841 which might just as well have been called the national system of innovation the main concern of list was with the problem of germany overtaking england and for underdeveloped countries as germany then was in relation to england he advocated not only protection of infant industries but a broad range of policies designed to accelerate or to make possible industrialisation and economic growth most of these policies were concerned with learning about new technology and applying it the racialist and colonialist overtones of the book were in strong contrast to the inter nationalist cosmopolitan approach of the classical free trade economists and list s belief that holland and denmark should join the german bund and acquire german nationality because of their descent and whole character reads somewhat strangely in the european community of today nevertheless despite these unattractive features of his outlook he clearly anticipated many contemporary theories after reviewing the changing ideas of economists about development in the years since the second world war the world bank 1991 concludes that it is intangible investment in knowledge accumulation which is decisive rather than physical capital investment as was at one time believed pages 33 35 the report cites the new growth theory

trade and capital flows a financial frictions perspective the classical heckscher ohlin mundell paradigm states that trade and capital mobility are substitutes in the sense that trade integration reduces the incentives for capital to ow to capital scarce countries in this paper we show that in a world with heterogeneous nancial development the classic conclusion does not hold in particular in less nancially developed economies south trade and capital mobility are complements within a dynamic framework the complementarity carries over to nancial capital ows this interaction implies that deepening trade integration in south raises net capital in ows or reduces net capital out ows it also implies that at the global level protectionism may back re if the goal is to rebalance capital ows when these are already heading from south to north our perspective also has

sustainability in a post keynesian growth model for an open economy the paper expands the bop constraint growth model and kaldorian regimes productivity and demand regimes in order to include some of the concerns raised by ecological economics in post keynesian models for open economies the demand regime is modified by taking into account porter s hypothesis which suggests that environmental innovations spurred by environmental policies can foster competitiveness as a result the equilibrium bop constrained rate of growth increases leading to a different version of thirlwall s law which opens room for analyzing the impact of environmental innovations on convergence between developing and developed economies the productivity regime in turn considers the growth and employment implications of innovations in labor productivity standard innovations and environmental efficiency environmental innovations it is argued that the fiscal policy and composition of public expenditure matter for long run growth employment and sustainability

unravelling projected energy savings in 2020 of eu member states using decomposition analyses abstract the objective of this paper is to provide deeper insights into the energy savings efforts of eu member states by exploring the impact of new policies the recent economic recession and other effects using decomposition analyses the results of the study show that the difference between the two official eu baseline projections primes 2007 pre recession pre climate and energy package and primes 2013 post recession including the new policies of the package can be explained by the combined impact of the new policies the economic recession and other effects such as differences in energy prices however the impact of the other effects remains largely unexplained in the official primes 2013 report and is clouding the right interpretation of the policy effect by providing these insights this study could help policy makers in better understanding scenario outcomes and the impact of their policies if eu member states would be able to achieve their 2020 energy savings targets then an important step has been taken to bridge the energy savings gap since the economic recession plays a major role in bridging this gap and economic recovery is aimed for further intensification of energy efficiency policies is crucial to contribute to the ghg reduction target for 2030 and beyond

wage inequality segregation by skill and the price of capital in an assignment model abstract some pieces of empirical evidence suggest that in the u s from the 1970s to the 1990s i wage inequality between plants rose much more than wage inequality within plants and ii there was an increase in the segregation of workers by skill into separate plants this paper presents a frictionless assignment model in which these two features can be explained simultaneously as the result of the decline in the relative price of capital additional implications of the model regarding the skill premium and the dispersion in labor productivity across plants are also consistent with the empirical evidence the model permits to consider changes in the skill distribution too combining these changes with falling capital prices provides a more comprehensive view of the overall trend of wage inequality and of workers segregation by skill in the data and it helps explaining some episodes of decreasing wage inequality

estimation in a class of simultaneous equation limited dependent variable models estimation in a class of simultaneous equation limited dependent variable models is considered the minimum chi squared method is used to compare the asymptotic relative efficiency of marginal and new conditional maximum likelihood estimators for this class of models efficient minimum chi squared estimation procedures are described a two step algorithm based on a conditional maximum likelihood estimator provides a natural framework for both computing a linearized and locating the joint maximum likelihood estimator the unimodality of the simultaneous equation tobit likelihood function is proved and this model is used to illustrate the empirical application of some of the estimators considered in the paper the relative efficiency of these estimators in the simultaneous equation tobit model is examined in a set of monte carlo experiments many applications of microeconomic theory to individual data face the joint problems of censoring and simultaneity in particular the dependent variable under investigation may not be continuously observed and some of the conditioning variables representing the outcome of other decisions by the individual may be simultaneously determined smith and blundell 1986 developed an asymptotically efficient test for exogeneity or simultaneity in the simultaneous equation tobit model as a byproduct a conditional maximum likelihood estimator was obtained which is consistent under the alternative hypothesis of simultaneity nelson and olsen 1978 amemiya 1978 1979 and heckman 1978 consider a number of consistent marginal maximum likelihood estimators based on marginal maximum likelihood estimators of the reduced form parameters for the probit and tobit models in contrast the estimator derived from smith and blundell 1986 is based on the corresponding conditional maximum likelihood estimators this paper is concerned with estimation in a class of simultaneous limited dependent variable regression models which includes the simultaneous probit and tobit models as special cases analogous marginal and conditional maximum likelihood estimators to those of nelson and olsen 1978 amemiya 1978 1979 heckman 1978 and smith and blundell 1986 are derived and other new estimators are suggested the minimum chi squared approach discussed by ferguson 1958 malinvaud 1970 and rothenberg 1973 is used to compare the asymptotic relative efficiency of various estimators considered a simple two step algorithm based on the conditional maximum likelihood

endogeneity in semiparametric binary response models this paper develops and implements semiparametric methods for estimating binary response binary choice models with continuous endogenous regressors it extends existing results on semiparametric estimation in single index binary response models to the case of endogenous regressors it develops a control function approach to account for endogeneity in triangular and fully simulataneous binary response models the proposed estimation method is applied to estimate the income effect in a labor market participation problem using a large micro data set from the british fes the semiparametric estimator is found to perform well detecting a significant attenuation bias the proposed estimator is contrasted to the corresponding probit and linear probability specifications jel c14 c25 c35 j22

history versus equilibrium and the theory of economic growth a model of cumulative causation is developed and the limits of this model as a characterization of historical rather than equilibrium long run growth outcomes are discussed an extension of the model which postulates that cumulative causation occurs in the context of technological and institutional regimes is proposed outcomes in the extended model are shown to be more influenced by history than those in the original model the extended model also addresses a number of recent criticisms of cumulative causation copyright 1997 by oxford university press

the patterns of technological capabilities of countries a dual approach using composite indicators and data envelopment analysis this study explores the patterns of technological capabilities for a sample of 42 countries over the period 1995 2007 introducing a novel methodological approach we exploit duality between data envelopment analysis and composite indicators to address the inconsistency between the two methodologies the empirical findings point to the end of the hegemony of north america western europe and japan showing that a process of convergence in technological capabilities has occurred limited to the 42 countries included in this study based on our methodology a classification is provided highlighting differences in the patterns of technological capabilities of countries

a structural economic dynamics approach to balance of payments constrained growth this paper derives a balance of payments equilibrium growth rate analogous to thirlwall s law from a pasinettian multi sector macrodynamic framework the resulting formula which we call the multi sectoral thirlwall s law asserts that a country s growth rate of per capita income is directly proportional to the growth rate of its exports with such a proportionality being inversely directly related to sectoral income elasticities of demand for imports exports these income elasticities are weighted by coefficients that measure the share of each sector in total imports and exports respectively it is shown that several theoretical empirical and policy implications can be drawn from such a structural economic dynamics approach to balance of payments constrained growth

unemployment and the real wage the economic basis for contesting political ideologies using the keynesian theory of effective demand this paper demonstrates how particular models such as that of cooperative capitalism enunciated by the left keynesian social democrats the marxian model of profit squeeze emphasizing distributive conflict and even the conservative model relying on supply side stimulus fit in as particular variants of a more general theoretical scheme through a reconstruction of the familiar is schedule the argument is weaved around the theme of the relations between unemployment and real wage in the context of both a closed and an open economy to explain the common macroeconomic basis of contesting ideologies copyright 1990 by oxford university press

imbalance in europe s effort sharing decision scope for strengthening incentives for energy savings in the non ets sectors abstract europe s 2020 greenhouse gas ghg reduction target consists of two sub targets one for the emissions trading scheme ets sectors and one for the non ets sectors the non ets target covers co 2 emissions in buildings transport and non ets industry and non co 2 ghg emissions the non ets target is known as europe s effort sharing decision this article discusses the gdp per capita method the european commission has applied in setting member state specific targets for the non ets the effort sharing and shows that it results in an imbalanced reduction effort among the member states it turns out that the principal mechanism of the gdp per capita method low gdp countries get room to catch up with high gdp countries by allowing them to increase emissions is obscured by the non co 2 ghgs the baseline projections of which are highly policy induced and not correlated with the growth of gdp per capita we propose an alternative method that 1 corrects for the policy induced decrease of non co 2 ghg emissions and 2 is based on energy savings potentials this approach could be used in future target setting for non ets sectors including in the case that the overarching eu wide target would be strengthened and would provide a direct support to europe s energy savings ambitions and policies

are international trade and factor mobility substitutes abstract this paper analyzes whether factor flows and commodity trade are substitutes or complements i e whether increasing the level of one impacts adversely or favorably on the volume of the other it derives with the aid of a new general equilibrium framework of the world which allows possible differences in factor endowments tastes and technologies across the two trading countries the necessary and sufficient condition for substitutability and complementarity the results are then further examined in two special cases a survey of different concepts of substitutability and complementarity which have appeared in the literature is also given

real exchange rate and elasticity of labour supply in a balance of payments constrained macrodynamics a macrodynamic model is proposed in which the real exchange rate and the elasticity of labour supply interact defining different trajectories of growth and income distribution in a developing economy growth depends on imports of capital goods which are paid with exports there are no capital flows and hence is constrained by equilibrium in current account the role of the elasticity of labour supply is to prevent the real exchange rate from appreciating as the economy grows thereby sustaining international competitiveness the model allows for endogenous technological change and considers the impact of migration from the subsistence to the modern sector on the cumulative kaldor verdoorn process of learning copyright the author 2009 published by oxford university press on behalf of the cambridge political economy society all rights reserved oxford university press

technology demand and distribution a cumulative growth model with an application to the dutch productivity growth slowdown this paper argues that the case for real wage growth restraint and the consequent restoration of profitability which the mainstream consensus regards as a necessary condition for sustained output and productivity growth is based on weak foundations because it neglects the negative impact of wage moderation on productivity growth using a general keynesian growth model which integrates a wage led or profit led demand regime and a productivity regime incorporating the productivity growth enhancing effects of higher demand and higher real wages the conditions are identified under which real wage restraint fails to raise output and productivity growth the model is applied empirically to the netherlands 1960 2000 copyright 2006 oxford university press

inequality among world citizens 1820 1992 this paper investigates the distribution of well being among world citizens during the last two centuries the estimates show that inequality of world distribution of income worsened from the beginning of the 19th century to world war ii and after that seems to have stabilized or to have grown more slowly in the early 19th century most inequality was due to differences within countries later it was due to differences between countries inequality in longevity also increased during the 19th century but then was reversed in the second half of the 20th century perhaps mitigating the failure of income inequality to improve in the last decades jel d31 f0 n0 o0

structural modernization and development traps an empirical approach in this paper we analyse economic development through the lenses of a newly developed index the structural modernization index this index combines two dimensions that have been widely invoked as prime drivers of economic development namely structural change and technological catch up for each country the index calculates the productivity gap with respect to the world frontier in activities that typically represent the modern part of the economy and weighs this relative productivity by the employment share of those activities in the total labour force in doing so it combines a technological dimension relative productivity and a structural dimension the size of the modern sector thus providing a concise measure of the degree of modernity of an economy the index is calculated for a large sample of countries over a long time span significant efforts have been made to put together a dataset with international comparable data on value added and employment disaggregated by sectors for 100 countries covering the period 1950 2009 the estimates are used to explore the relationship between structural modernization and the so called poverty and middle income traps in analysing this relationship the interactive nature of structural change and technological catch up is stressed important insights are obtained regarding the nature of low and middle income development traps finally the usefulness of this new index is illustrated when studying the diverse structural trajectories of a set of countries that can be taken as examples of success and failure in the process of economic development

the origins and dynamics of taiwan s r d consortia a series of collaborative r d ventures have emerged in taiwan within a quite distinctive institutional framework unlike the case of many of the collaborative arrangements between established firms in the us europe or japan where mutual risk reduction is frequently the driving influence in the case of taiwan it is technological learning upgrading and catch up industry creation that is the object of the collaborative exercises the taiwan r d alliances were formed hesitantly in the 1980s but have flourished in the 1990s as institutional forms have been found which encourage firms to cooperate in raising their technological levels several alliances could be counted in taiwan in the late 1990s bringing together firms and public sector research institutes with the added organizational input of trade associations and catalytic financial assistance from government the article discusses the evolving organizational architecture of these r d alliances utilizing several case studies and seeks to draw comparisons between these institutional innovations in taiwan and established collaborative arrangements in the usa japan and europe