an analysis of feed in tariff remuneration models implications for renewable energy investment recent experience from around the world suggests that feed in tariffs fits are the most effective policy to encourage the rapid and sustained deployment of renewable energy there are several different ways to structure a fit policy each with its own strengths and weaknesses this paper presents an overview of seven different ways to structure the remuneration of a fit policy divided into two broad categories those in which remuneration is dependent on the electricity price and those that remain independent from it this paper examines the advantages and disadvantages of these different fit models and concludes with an analysis of these design options with a focus on their implications both for investors and for society

do r d tax credits work evidence from a panel of countries 1979 1997 this paper examines the impact of fiscal incentives on the level of r d investment an econometric model of r d investment is estimated using a new panel of data on tax changes and r d spending in nine oecd countries over a 19 year period 1979 1997 we find evidence that tax incentives are effective in increasing r d intensity this is true even after allowing for permanent country specific characteristics world macro shocks and other policy influences we estimate that a 10 fall in the cost of r d stimulates just over a 1 rise in the level of r d in the short run and just under a 10 rise in r d in the long run

competition and corporate performance are people right to think that competition improves corporate performance my investigations indicate first that there are some theoretical reasons for believing this hypothesis to be correct but they are not overwhelming furthermore the existing empirical evidence on this question is weak however the results reported here based on an analysis of around 670 u k companies do provide some support for this view most important i present evidence that competition as measured by increased numbers of competitors or by lower levels of rents is associated with a significantly higher rate of total factor productivity growth

market share market value and innovation in a panel of british manufacturing firms this paper examines the empirical relationship between technological innovations market share and stock market value new developments in the estimation of dynamic count data models are used to control for unobserved firm specific heterogeneity we find a robust and positive effect of market share on observable headcounts of innovations and patents although increased product market competition in the industry tends to stimulate innovative activity furthermore the impact of innovation on market value is larger for firms with higher market shares we argue that our results are consistent with models where high market share firms have incentives to pre emptively innovate

price competition and market structure the impact of cartel policy on concentration in the uk this paper examines the impact of firms conduct on market structure it studies the evolution of concentration in uk manufacturing following the abolition of cartels using a theoretical framework based on sutton s theory of market structure and a panel data set of four digit industries over 1958 1977 the econometric results suggest that the intensity of price competition has a positive impact on concentration in exogenous sunk cost industries as well as in advertising intensive and r d intensive industries the concentration market size relationship while negative in exogenous sunk cost industries breaks down in industries with high advertising or r d intensity

assessing the determinants of household electricity prices in the eu a system gmm panel data approach abstract a meaningful portion of the consumer basket of european households and companies is embodied by electricity as well as gas or refined petroleum products as energy products are essential inputs of nearly all final goods and services whichever change of energy prices has a direct impact of the general price level in this context the main purpose of this study is to assess the main drivers of household electricity prices in the european union eu throughout a period of deep sector transformation relying on eurostat data not only we analyze the long term progress of household electricity prices across the eu but also we provide empirical evidence on their determinants while confronting the results with the eu energy policy path for this purpose a firsthand approach is herein developed based on a dynamic model with panel data through gmm proposal method by blundell and bond 1998 4 with the windermeijer 2005 41 correction the data analysis provides grounds for a relation between the variable of household electricity prices with variables related to sector liberalization renewable energy sources which support the eu policy to boost liberalization this study offers evidence that the sector liberalization is accompanied by a decreasing trend in prices which is consistent with the european commission s objectives to liberalize

potential sources of productivity growth within chinese industry abstract this paper presents an approach for modeling and estimating potential sources of productivity growth within four major sectors of chinese industry the state and collective sectors and heavy and light industry the findings based upon industrial data from293 chinese counties indicate that substantial productivity gains can be achieved by transferring technology from the state to the collective sector exploiting enterprise and agglomerative scale economies and reallocating investment and labor to take advantage of large disparities between factor returns among the sectors the implications for the results of several idiosyncracies of chinese industrial prices and data are examined

conditional cash transfers and school dropout rates this paper evaluates a united kingdom pilot study designed to test whether a means tested conditional cash transfer paid to 16 to 18 year olds for staying in full time education is an effective way of reducing the proportion of school dropouts the transfer s impact is substantial in the first year full time education participation rates increase by around 4 5 percentage points while the proportion receiving two years of education increases by around 6 7 percentage points those receiving the full payment have the largest initial increase in participation and some evidence is found suggesting that part of the effect can be explained by liquidity constraints

how effective are fiscal incentives for r d a review of the evidence this paper surveys the econometric evidence on the effectiveness of fiscal incentives for r d we describe the effects of tax systems in oecd countries on the user cost of r d the current position changes over time and across different firms in different countries we describe and criticize the methodologies used to evaluate the effect of the tax system on

zombie lending and depressed restructuring in japan this paper explores the role that misdirected bank lending played in prolonging the japanese macroeconomic stagnation that began in the early 1990s the investigation focuses on the wide spread practice of japanese banks of continuing to lend to otherwise insolvent firms we docu ment the prevalence of this forbearance lending and show its distorting effects on healthy firms that were competing with the impaired firms the paper by hoshi 2000 was the first to call attention to this phenomenon and its ramifi

high penetration wind generation impacts on spot prices in the australian national electricity market this paper explores wind power integration issues for the south australian sa region of the australian national electricity market nem by assessing the interaction of regional wind generation electricity demand and spot prices over 2 recent years of market operation sa s wind energy penetration has recently surpassed 20 and it has only a limited interconnection with other regions of the nem as such it represents an interesting example of high wind penetration in a gross wholesale pool market electricity industry our findings suggest that while electricity demand continues to have the greatest influence on spot prices in sa wind generation levels have become a significant secondary influence and there is an inverse relationship between wind generation and price no clear relationship between wind generation and demand has been identified although some periods of extremely high demand may coincide with lower wind generation periods of high wind output are associated with generally lower market prices and also appear to contribute to extreme negative price events the results highlight the importance of electricity market and renewable policy design in facilitating economically efficient high wind penetrations

a historical review of promotion strategies for electricity from renewable energy sources in eu countries abstract the core objective of this paper is to elaborate on historically implemented promotion strategies of renewable energy sources and the associated deployment within the european electricity market hence at a first glance the historic development of renewable energy sources in the electricity res e sector is addressed on member state and on sectoral level as well as consequently discussed according to available res e potentials and costs the specific focus of this paper are promotion strategies for res e options as they are the key driver of an efficient and effective res e deployment therefore the paper depicts the main types of different promotion schemes and their properties additionally several cases studies of different european member states show an in depth analysis of the different res e promotion schemes in this context special emphasises are put on the question of effective and efficient promotion scheme designs of different res e technologies generally conducted research led to the conclusion that technology specific financial support measures of res e performed much more effective and efficient than others did hence it is not all about the common question of feed in tariffs vs quota systems based on tradable green certificates but more about the design criteria of implemented res e support schemes

financial liberalisation and growth in china s economic reform this paper summarises china s financial liberalisation experience and examines the contributions of financial resources on economic growth during the post reform period financial liberalisation has resulted in the reallocation of the four sources of total investment in fixed assets state budget appropriation national bank loans self raised funds and foreign investment we find that the growth of gdp and industrial production are positively related to the growth of self raised funds and foreign investment we conclude that the use of foreign investment and funds raised by the enterprises themselves are more efficient than the government s appropriation and provision of bank loans

renewable generation and electricity prices taking stock and new evidence for germany and austria abstract economic theory predicts that the increase of renewable electricity production should reduce the price of electricity in the short run which is also known as the merit order effect although the merit order effect is only one of several consequences of renewable production on the electricity system it is crucial to determine its size for the economic evaluation of renewable energies in this paper we present a comprehensive overview of relevant past research results on the price effect of renewables additionally we conduct a new empirical analysis of the price effect of renewable production for the austrian german region a market that clearly qualifies for a merit order effect analysis given its characteristics based on the review and our own analysis we show that the merit order effect varies depending on the region and the assessment method chosen we also find that the size of this effect is less dispersed throughout different markets than previously suggested by the literature

can chinese state enterprises perform like market entities productive efficiency in the chinese iron and steel industry as a consequence of economic reforms in china firms have ben affected by three essential changes first instead of surrendering all profits to the government firms now pay tax on their profits according to a contract between them and the government and retain the balance as their own controllable surplus second the central economic plan determines only part of firms production after fulfilling the command plan firms are allowed to adjust their production scale by the availability of inputs and the profitability of production third most consumer and investment goods have two prices a plan price and a market price as most of the plan prices are always lower than the market prices the latter play a basic role in determining firms profits after a decade of economic reforms the important question is can chinese state enterprises perform like market entities the analysis shows that chinese firms in transition domimic the production behaviour of market based efficiency oriented firms

impacts of variable renewable energy on wholesale markets and generating assets in the united states a review of expectations and evidence abstract we synthesize available literature data and analysis on the degree to which growth in variable renewable energy vre has impacted or might in the future impact bulk power system assets pricing and costs in the united states most studies of future scenarios indicate that vre reduces wholesale energy prices and capacity factors of thermal generators traditional baseload generators are more exposed to these changing market conditions than low capital cost and more flexible intermediate and peak load generators from analysis of historical data we find that vre is already influencing the bulk power market through changes in temporal and geographic patterns areas with higher levels of vre the most significant observed impacts have concentrated in areas with significant vre and or nuclear generation along with limited transmission with negative pricing also often occurring during periods with lower system wide load so far however vre has had a relatively modest impact on historical average annual wholesale prices across entire market regions at least in comparison to other drivers the reduction of natural gas prices is the primary contributor to the decline in wholesale prices since 2008 similarly vre impacts on thermal plant retirements have been limited and there is little relationship between the location of recent retirements and vre penetration levels although impacts on wholesale prices have been modest so far impacts of vre on the electricity market will be more significant under higher vre penetrations

the impact of intraday markets on the market value of flexibility decomposing effects on profile and the imbalance costs abstract an increasing share of variable renewable energy sources vres basically affects the electricity price formation in two ways 1 the so called merit order effect tends to lower the base price level and challenges conventional plants to remain profitable 2 due to the variable nature of renewable energy infeed the short term demand for flexibility increases and changes the volatility of electricity prices the more variable prices offer opportunities for controllable electricity producers ceps who provide up and down ramping flexibility to increase their revenues in contrast the vres with high degrees of simultaneity tend to pay for this flexibility in the electricity spot market to reduce their imbalance exposure the intraday market idm for electricity has gained importance for the market value of different technologies lately and continues to expand due to the increasing efforts to balance within day deviation from day ahead schedules this article presents a combination and extension of two existing models to capture the peculiarities of the intraday price formation and to analyze the impact of the idm on the market value of vres and ceps doing so the paper suggests an adjustment of the classical market value factor metric and to go beyond classical day ahead market dam information the article shows that market value factors mvfs can be stabilized if the idm delivers market based price signals for the costs of flexibility that are sufficient to activate flexibilities prior to the usually more expensive imbalance mechanism ibm yet the mvfs from single vre technologies will worsen if their market share is high enough to outweigh forecast errors from other technologies and if they become a permanent price maker in the idm and the ibm

future wind and solar power market values in germany evidence of spatial and technological dependencies abstract achieving ambitious climate targets entails an extensive utilisation of renewable energy sources however due to weather dependent fluctuations generation from variable renewable energy vre sources is characterised by significantly lower market values in comparison to conventional technologies reinforced by a decline in electricity prices this development poses interesting questions as to its drivers and to what extent market values of wind and solar power can be influenced by the design of electricity markets against this background a scenario based analysis is conducted to trace the future development of market values using endogenously derived electricity prices considering different regional and technological vre diversification strategies and investments into vre technologies on a myopic basis the results show a continued decline in market values with increasing regional discrepancies indicating a growing importance of interregional interdependencies for assessing the profitability of vre furthermore from a system point of view a more distributed allocation of onshore wind capacities to contend with declining market values does not always prove to stabilise market values by facilitating a more constant feed in pattern contrary to expectation finally replacing onshore with offshore wind energy appears to be beneficial as it can lead to an overall increase in the market values of offshore onshore as well as pv generation technologies compared to other mitigation strategies this result raise interesting questions about the systemic economic value of offshore wind despite its higher lcoe in the context of market integration of vre

impact of renewables on electricity markets do support schemes matter abstract rising renewable shares influence electricity markets in several ways among others average market prices are reduced and price volatility increases therefore the missing money problem in energy only electricity markets is more likely to occur in systems with high renewable shares nevertheless renewables are supported in many countries due to their expected benefits the kind of support instrument can however influence the degree to which renewables influence the market while fixed feed in tariffs lead to higher market impacts more market oriented support schemes such as market premiums quota systems and capacity based payments decrease the extent to which markets are affected this paper analyzes the market impacts of different support schemes for this purpose a new module is added to an existing bottom up simulation model of the electricity market in addition different degrees of flexibility in the electricity system are considered a case study for germany is used to derive policy recommendations regarding the choice of support scheme

reducing the market impact of large shares of intermittent energy in denmark abstract the increasing prevalence of renewable and intermittent energy sources in the electricity system is creating new challenges for the interaction of the system in denmark high renewable shares have been achieved without great difficulty mainly due to the flexibility of the nearby nordic hydro power dominated system further increases in the share of renewable energy sources require that additional options are considered to facilitate integration with the lowest possible cost with large shares of intermittent energy the impact can be observed on wholesale prices giving both lower prices and higher volatility a lack of wind that causes high prices is rarely seen because long periods without wind are uncommon therefore we focus on the low price effects and the increased value of flexible demand options on the supply side there is an increase in the value of other flexible generation technologies and the attractiveness of additional interconnection capacity this paper also analyses options for increasing the flexibility of heat generation involving large and decentralized chp plants and heat generation based on electricity the incentives that the market provides for shifting demand and using electricity for heat production are discussed based on the variability of prices observed from 2006 to 2008

productivity under the 1997 2010 labour government what was the productivity record under the labour government of 1997 2010 i show that productivity growth and economic performance in general was good when the uk is compared with its main international peers only the us had stronger productivity growth and the uk did better than the us in terms of the jobs market much of this improved performance was a continuation of the pattern since 1979 which broke a century of relative decline some part of the improvement is directly linked to policies especially over human capital innovation and competition we discuss the recent productivity puzzle the disappointing productivity figures since the onset of the great recession in 2008 and argue that our conclusions are unchanged as most other oecd countries have also experienced poor measured productivity

on the economics of renewable energy sources abstract with the global expansion of renewable energy re technologies the provision of optimal re policy packages becomes an important task we review pivotal aspects regarding the economics of renewables that are relevant to the design of an optimal re policy many of which are to date unresolved we do so from three interrelated perspectives that a meaningful public policy framework for inquiry must take into account first we explore different social objectives justifying the deployment of re technologies and review model based estimates of the economic potential of re technologies i e their socially optimal deployment level second we address pivotal market failures that arise in the course of implementing the economic potential of re sources in decentralized markets third we discuss multiple policy instruments curing these market failures our framework reveals the requirements for an assessment of the relevant options for real world decision makers in the field of re policies this review makes it clear that there are remaining white areas on the knowledge map concerning consistent and socially optimal re policies

assessing the impact of wind generation on wholesale prices and generator dispatch in the australian national electricity market abstract growing climate change and energy security concerns are driving major wind energy deployment in electricity industries around the world despite its many advantages growing penetrations of this highly variable and somewhat unpredictable energy source pose new challenges for electricity industry operation one issue receiving growing attention is the so called merit order effect of wind generation in wholesale electricity markets wind has very low operating costs and therefore tends to displace higher cost conventional generation from market dispatch reducing both wholesale prices and conventional plant outputs this paper extends the current literature on this effect through an empirical study employing a range of econometric techniques to quantify the impacts of growing wind penetrations in the australian national electricity market nem the results suggest that wind is having a marked impact on spot market prices and while wind is primarily offsetting higher operating cost gas generation it is now also significantly reducing dispatch of emissions intensive brown coal generation great care needs to be taken in extrapolating these results to longer term implications however the study does propose a methodology for assessing this effect highlights the impacts that wind is already having on nem outcomes and suggests promising directions for future research

portfolio applications in electricity markets review private investor and manager perspective trends abstract the private sector plays a major role in the expansion and operation of power systems in most countries especially those running liberalized electricity markets policymakers have the task of inducing private agents through their regulatory designs to make decisions that point toward social welfare maximization conversely it is a task of private agents to protect themselves against the risks of the sector including regulatory risks international fuel price uncertainty climate change policies natural resource availability electricity demand uncertainty co2 clearance prices etc instead of hiding all of these risks within the total project costs and losing competitiveness private agents can use diversification as a strategy to deal with them this paper presents a review of the main applications voids and challenges of portfolio optimization for two key agents of the private sector investors and managers the problem of the investor is to design a technology portfolio to invest in that maximizes its expected returns and limits risks while the manager has to design a portfolio of financial physical instruments long term contracts futures etc to sell buy electricity and hedge against price risks we have found two fundamental issues in the literature the first and most important is excessive confidence in historical data and statistical analysis for predicting future price behavior for a changing future in detriment of more structural analysis structural analysis can include particularities of modern power systems such as future transmission changes congestion operational constraints ramps new entrants new technologies and new demand grow patterns that cannot be taken into account by simply analyzing price historical values the second is the omission of renewable complementarities which is a proven characteristic of dispersed renewable plants that may have important risk mitigation effects although it has largely been ignored in portfolio analysis due to insufficient data modeling limitations and computational complexity

growth efficiency and convergence in china s state and collective industry in china as in the soviet union and eastern europe economic reform initiatives seek to increase productivity by introducing elements of market oriented policies and institutions into an economy formerly dominated by state planning efforts to evaluate the impact of reform of chinese industry have focused on the measurement of productivity change in state enterprises this study expands the prior framework of analysis in several directions our investigation of productivity trends is not limited to state enterprises but includes quantitative comparisons with china s fast growing collective industries which contributed 36 of overall industrial output in 1988 1 unlike previous studies our analysis works with gross rather than net output this permits us to investigate changes in the productivity of intermediate inputs which occupy a large portion of total costs in chinese industry as well as labor and capital to do this we develop a quasi frontier estimation procedure which seems appropriate for comparisons of total factor productivity based on chinese industrial data finally we offer a quantitative perspective on the extent to which reform efforts have moved industrial resource allocation toward patterns expected of a market system the analysis confirms our previous finding based on a restricted framework employing only labor fixed capital and net output that multifactor productivity in state industry has risen substantially during

the progressive inefficiency of replacing renewable obligation certificates with contracts for differences in the uk electricity market abstract this paper looks at the emerging risk return profile for new renewable assets as a conventional wholesale electricity market progressively decarbonises using a detailed fundamental model of price formation risks under increasing replacement of fossil fuel facilities with onshore and offshore wind we show that the risk return profile becomes less attractive over time and may therefore need sustained and possibly increasing policy support furthermore we show that green certificate trading may become progressively more attractive as a supplementary support to wholesale prices compared to fixed feed in tariffs this is because the increasingly negative correlation between renewable output and wholesale prices reduces its revenue risk compared to fixed feed in tariffs if other factors remain constant and thereby improves conventional financial performance risk metrics in particular this suggests that the recent energy policy change in britain to move away from green certificates and into contracts for differences may have been ill founded

the renewable energy policy paradox abstract one major avenue for policymakers to meet climate targets is by decarbonizing the power sector one component of which is raising the share of renewable energy sources renewables in electricity generation however promoting renewables in liberalized power markets creates a paradox in that successful penetration of renewables could fall victim to its own success with the current market architecture future deployment of renewable energy will necessarily be more costly and less scalable moreover transition towards a full 100 renewable electricity sector is unattainable paradoxically in order for renewable technologies to continue growing their market share they need to co exist with fossil fuel technologies ignoring these findings can slow adoption and increase the costs of deploying new renewable technologies this paper spots the incompatibility between electricity liberalization and renewable policy regardless of the country location or renewable technologies the paradox holds as long as market clear prices with short term marginal costs and renewable technology s marginal cost is close to zero and not dispatchable

distributional costs of wind energy production in portugal under the liberalized iberian market regime abstract wind generation in portugal and spain has grown due to a decrease in technology cost and the availability of renewables electricity generation incentives there is a strong interconnection between spain s and portugal s transmission systems resulting in common prices in both countries however portuguese and spanish producers receive the incentives for producing wind based electricity that are specified in their own national policies resulting in different costs to rate payers in this paper we estimate the costs to portuguese rate payers associated with the current market design and policy incentives to do so we regress hourly spot electricity market prices as a function of hourly wind generation and estimate the resulting feed in tariff costs distributional effects over the various rate payer categories total costs for rate payer are at the minimum level if joint wind generation in portugal and spain increases by 5 5 from what it is today if wind generation increases much further then the costs increase due to the fit overcost increase if wind generation decreases from current levels then costs also increase due to the merit order effect furthermore we find that rate payer categories will endure different portions of the costs with an increase in wind generation penalizing predominantly 20 7 kva rate payers

pros and cons of exposing renewables to electricity market risks a comparison of the market integration approaches in germany spain and the uk abstract the article examines how renewable electricity res e producers are integrated into the electricity market under the support legislations and regulatory frameworks of germany spain and the uk focus is on wind power which faces the highest market integration challenge of all res e the analysis shows that the three countries follow contrasting approaches of exposing res e producers to the market risks of forward electricity markets balancing markets and system planning requirements risk exposure is highest in the uk and lowest in germany from a policy maker s perspective there is a trade off between a high risk and a low risk approach when res e face high market risks a higher level of financial support is required to stimulate res e development than in a low risk environment but the exposure to market risks may also give an incentive to make efficient use of the respective market thus limiting the indirect costs to society the special characteristics of wind energy however put natural limits to the response of wind power plants to market prices and locational price signals and will increasingly influence electricity markets and grid infrastructure these interdependencies should be recognised in the design of res e policies and market regulations

the market value of variable renewables the effect of solar wind power variability on their relative price this paper provides a comprehensive discussion of the market value of variable renewable energy vre the inherent variability of wind speeds and solar radiation affects the price that vre generators receive on the market market value during windy and sunny times the additional electricity supply reduces the prices because the drop is larger with more installed capacity the market value of vre falls with higher penetration rate this study aims to develop a better understanding on how the market value with penetration and how policies and prices affect the market value quantitative evidence is derived from a review of published studies regression analysis of market data and the calibrated model of the european electricity market emma we find the value of wind power to fall from 110 of the average power price to 50 80 as wind penetration increases from zero to 30 of total electricity consumption for solar power similarly low value levels are reached already at 15 penetration hence competitive large scale renewable deployment will be more difficult to accomplish than as many anticipate

the economic record of the 1997 2010 labour government an assessment we consider the economic record of the 1997 2010 labour government in the uk following a brief review of the government s inheritance from its predecessor we review the assessments made in the other papers in this issue of the oxford review of economic policy the change in the macroeconomic policy framework which apparently worked well for a decade but was then struck by the global financial crisis labour market social security and education policies and inequality public investment and public service delivery especially health and corporate taxation we discuss the constraints under which the government operated how much it broke with the past and the new frameworks it introduced we identify strengths and weaknesses and draw lessons from the government s record about the need to remain receptive to other and critical ideas on the one hand and the need for labour to spell out the kind of economy and society it wants to see develop on the other copyright 2013 oxford university press

the merit order effect of wind and solar power volatility and determinants abstract the investment in renewable energy sources power generation is coming into a stall in face of the removal of incentives in most of the european countries the technological maturity of wind and solar power generation is the justification basis and market integration of extensive amounts of renewable energy is seen with concern by electricity systems stakeholders given the low marginal cost of renewable power generation the available load in the spot electricity market for conventional and dispatchable power plants is diminishing the so called merit order effect in this study we estimate the value of the merit order effect due to wind and solar power generation in the iberian electricity market with historical bid supply and demand offers from 2008 to 2017 the estimated values are then used to value determinants and volatility through garch econometric modelling results demonstrate that the merit order effect in iberia is influenced negatively by the residual load and positively by demand wind power and solar power additionally the high merit order effect volatility found mirrors the behavior of spot electricity market

labour s record on financial regulation in 1997 the new labour government launched major initiatives in the area of financial regulation setting up the financial services authority as a comprehensive regulatory body supported by the legislative framework of the financial services and markets act 2000 we evaluate the labour government s record on financial regulation in terms of its achievements and failures especially in dealing with the global financial crisis that started in 2007 while we identify some clear flaws in regulatory design and enforcement our evaluation highlights some inherent difficulties of financial regulation

wind power integration and power system flexibility an empirical analysis of extreme events in germany under the new negative price regime abstract in this article the flexibility of the german power market with respect to the integration of an increasing share of electricity from renewable energy sources was analysed flexibility limiting system components which cause negative prices are explained and illustrated for the german market the decision of the european energy exchange in leipzig to allow negative price bids is then explained the empirical data illustrate the flexibility of conventional generating capacities in germany from october 2008 to december 2009 of the 86 h of negative spot prices 19 h were significantly negative with prices of at least 100 mwh these extreme hours were analysed in greater detail by the examination of different system components thereby load wind power infeed and conventional generation by fuel type were observed as well as the market for negative tertiary reserve as indicators for market tightness although the market situations were found to be severe under the current conditions it could have been much worse in order to enable the market to clear at all times policy recommendations are provided and long run implications of an increasing res e share on the conventional generation capacity are discussed the article concludes with an outlook on additional power system flexibility options

the merit order effect of czech photovoltaic plants abstract we assess the impact of photovoltaic power plants on the electricity supply curve in the czech republic the merit order effect is estimated as the elasticity of electricity spot price with respect to change in supply of electricity from renewable sources data for the czech electricity spot market from 2010 to 2015 are analyzed as this is the period with the steepest increase in a renewable generation capacity the effect is estimated separately for solar and other renewable sources we find a significant difference between these two groups our results show that based on hourly daily and weekly data energy produced by czech solar power plants does not decrease electricity spot price creating double cost to the end consumer however the merit order effect based on averaged daily and weekly data is shown to exist for other renewable sources excluding solar mainly water and wind this contributes to the conclusion that the czech renewables policy that prefers solar to other renewable sources may be considered as suboptimal

the returns to education macroeconomics we offer an extensive summary and a critical discussion of the empirical literature on the impact of human capital on macro economic performance with a particular focus on uk policy we also highlight methodological issues and make recommendations for future research priorities taking the studies as a whole the evidence that human capital increases productivity is compelling though still largely divided on whether the stock of education affects the long run level or growth rate of gdp a one year increase in average education is found to raise the level of output per capita by between three and six percent according to augmented neo classical specifications while leading to an over one percentage point faster growth according to estimates from the new growth theories still over the short run planning horizon four years the empirical estimates of the change in gdp are of similar orders of magnitude in the two approaches the impact of increases at different levels of education appear to depend on the level of a country s development with tertiary education being the most important for growth in oecd countries education is found to yield additional indirect benefits to growth more preliminary evidence seems to indicate that type quality and efficiency of education matter for growth too

evaluating the employment impact of a mandatory job search program this paper exploits area based piloting and age related eligibility rules to identify treatment effects of a labor market program the new deal for young people in the u k a central focus is on substitution displacement effects and on equilibrium wage effects the program includes extensive job assistance and wage subsidies to employers we find that the impact of the program significantly raised transitions to employment by about 5 percentage points the impact is robust to a wide variety of nonexperimental estimators however we present some evidence that this effect may not be as large in the longer run jel j18 j23 j38

promoting the market and system integration of renewable energies through premium schemes a case study of the german market premium abstract with the share of renewable energies within the electricity sector rising improving their market and system integration is of increasing importance by offering plant operators a premium on top of the electricity market price premium schemes represent an option to increase the alignment of renewable electricity production with market signals and have been implemented by several eu member states this paper examines the case study of the german market premium scheme adopted in 2012 building on an evaluation of early experiences we discuss whether the market premium contributes to the aims of market and or system integration effectiveness and what potential efficiency gains and additional costs of administering integration are associated with it efficiency while exposing renewables to price risks is not the scheme s purpose it has successfully increased participation in direct marketing however risks of overcompensating producers for marketing and balancing costs are high and the benefits of gradually leading plant operators towards the market are questionable incentives for demand oriented production are established but they seem insufficient particularly in the case of intermittent renewable energy sources to conclude we provide an outlook on alternative designs of premium schemes and discuss whether they seem better suited for addressing the challenges ahead

risk based assessment of the cost efficiency and the effectivity of renewable energy support schemes certificate markets versus feed in tariffs the introduction of renewable energy sources in the electricity generation mix has the potential to reduce power sector s emissions and countries dependence on imported oil climate change concerns and highly volatile oil prices have attracted governments interest and support to sustain investments in renewable energy capacity and different support policies have been implemented in many countries around the world this paper analyzes the effects of investors risk aversion on the performance of support schemes the analysis compares two policy options a feed in tariff mechanism with a certificate market system results show that while a tariff mechanism could obtain better results than a certificate market its performance is strictly dependent on regulator choices a certificate market instead permits to obtain the desired level of renewable energy market share with good cost efficiency as long as investors risk aversion is moderate moreover discounting future cash flows with higher social discount rates further benefits a certificate system making it preferable to feed in tariffs

banking sector and restructuring in eastern europe abstract the paper seeks to achieve a number of objectives first to analyze the underlying causes of east european commercial banks illiquidity problems second to examine the case for public versus private informal approaches to bankruptcy and bank restructurings as general approaches to these problems third to evaluate the different models of restructuring banks in particular eight alternative models are identified fourth to briefly describe the models that have been chosen by a number of east european countries finally to layout the criteria for policymakers choice of a particular restructuring model

reply to a comment on industry s response to market liberalization in china evidence from jiangsu province jiangsu has experienced impressive industrial development since 1949 often achieving higher growth rates than china s national average nonetheless rates of growth have fluctuated with distinct policy periods in industry s response to market liberalization in china evidence from jiangsu province i analyzed the structure of industrial production and productivity in jiangsu province to explore changes in specialization and efficiency this research covered the years 1952 88 and focused on comparing the period before 1978 when maoist regional self reliance was being promoted with the post 1978 reform when many of the selfreliant policies were reversed to analyze jiangsu s production structure i used location quotients for 29 products the results showed that jiangsu s production patterns became less specialized from 1957 to 1978 consistent with self reliance in fact none of the products in the sample showed an increase in specialization during this period after 1978 however 14 of the products analyzed moved toward specialization showing a clear change in the production structure to analyze productivity i applied a simple growth accounting framework using estimates of the output elasticities with respect to capital and labor based on jiangsu data with these assumptions productivity declined an average of 2 1 per year from 1953 to 1978 while it increased an average of 4 4 per year from 1978 to 1988 these results did not change substantially with alternative parameter assumptions both the specialization and productivity results suggest that reforms had a substantial positive impact on jiangsu s economy the comment by menghao zhao and paul m sommers addresses the last section of my article which compared state and collective industrial productivity in the reform period series for both gross and net out

the merit order effect of wind and photovoltaic electricity generation in germany 2008 2016 estimation and distributional implications abstract generation from renewable energy sources in germany has experienced a considerable uptake in recent years mainly responsible for this development is the german renewable energy sources act erneuerbare energien gesetz eeg this paper considers redistributive implications of the eeg for different electricity consumers using time series regression analysis we show that electricity generation by wind and pv has reduced spot market prices considerably by 6 mwh in 2010 rising to 10 mwh in 2012 we use these results to build a near term forecasting tool for merit order effects projected to reach 14 16 mwh in 2016 on the other hand the costs of the eeg are passed forward to consumers in the form of a surcharge our findings highlight significant redistributive transfers under the current design of the eeg in particular some energy intensive industries are benefiting from lower wholesale electricity prices whilst being largely exempted from contributing to the costs of the scheme we also highlight implications of our results for other areas for reform of the eeg such as adequate remuneration mechanisms that ensure efficient operation and investment decisions are made under the scheme more generally these findings suggest that policy makers need to integrate distributional assessments into policy design and implementation