do r d tax credits work evidence from a panel of countries 1979 1997 this paper examines the impact of fiscal incentives on the level of r d investment an econometric model of r d investment is estimated using a new panel of data on tax changes and r d spending in nine oecd countries over a 19 year period 1979 1997 we find evidence that tax incentives are effective in increasing r d intensity this is true even after allowing for permanent country specific characteristics world macro shocks and other policy influences we estimate that a 10 fall in the cost of r d stimulates just over a 1 rise in the level of r d in the short run and just under a 10 rise in r d in the long run

how effective are fiscal incentives for r d a review of the evidence this paper surveys the econometric evidence on the effectiveness of fiscal incentives for r d we describe the effects of tax systems in oecd countries on the user cost of r d the current position changes over time and across different firms in different countries we describe and criticize the methodologies used to evaluate the effect of the tax system on

does government r d policy mainly benefit scientists and engineers conventional wisdom holds that the social rate of return to r d significantly exceeds the private rate of return and therefore r d should be subsidized in the u s the government has directly funded a large fraction of total r d spending this paper shows that there is a serious problem with such government efforts to increase inventive activity the majority of r d spending is actually just salary payments for r d workers their labor supply however is quite inelastic so when the government funds r d a significant fraction of the increased spending goes directly into higher wages using cps data on wages of scientific personnel this paper shows that government r d spending raises wages significantly particularly for scientists related to defense such as physicists and aeronautical engineers because of the higher wages conventional estimates of the effectiveness of r d policy may be 30 to 50 too high the results also imply that by altering the wages of scientists and engineers even for firms not receiving federal support government funding directly crowds out private inventive activity this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

how responsive is business capital formation to its user cost an exploration with micro data abstract the response of business capital formation to its user cost is critical to evaluating tax reform deficit reduction and monetary policy evidence for a substantial user cost elasticity however is sparse most evidence has been based on aggregate data although several recent studies with firm level data report substantial effects with a particularly rich micro dataset containing over 26 000 observations this paper explores what can be learned about the user cost elasticity while the results depend to some extent on the specification and econometric technique various diagnostics lead us to prefer a precisely estimated but small elasticity of approximately 0 25 this paper is dedicated to the memory of robert eisner who labored early and ably on uncovering the determinants of investment spending and highlighting the importance of the question found in the title of this paper

market failures and the additionality effects of public support to private r d theory and empirical implications we extend the theoretical basis of the empirical literature on the effects of r d subsidies by providing an estimable model of strategic interaction among subsidy applicants and public and private sector r d financiers our model incorporates fixed r d cost and a cost of external finance we derive the optimal support rule at the intensive extensive margin the costs of external funding reduce increase the optimal subsidy rate we also establish necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of additionality it turns out that additionality at the intensive margin is less likely with higher spillovers our results suggest that the relationship between additionality and welfare may not be straightforward

what drives the dynamics of business growth differences in the dynamisms of economies are persistent notwithstanding the growing body of evidence documenting these large cross country differences our understanding of what drives them is still rather limited this paper seeks to help close this gap using unique data for ten countries the analysis sheds light on the factors that shape the distribution of firm growth and on what role policies play in driving cross country differences the paper provides new evidence on the link of labour market regulation bankruptcy legislation financial market development and r d support policies with growth dynamics the study goes beyond looking at differences in average growth rates as it analyses changes in the whole distribution of firms

influencing factors on hydrogen energy r d projects an ex post performance evaluation abstract to enhance its energy security korea made a significant r d investment in developing hydrogen energy technology over a period of 10 years the hydrogen energy r d center was established in 2003 with a 100 billion korean won krw government investment that would fund the initiative through 2012 this paper is a meaningful attempt to evaluate the ex post performance of completed hydrogen energy r d projects using data envelopment analysis dea through empirical analysis we focus mainly on measuring ex post performance and uncovering the influencing factors on that performance the results of our empirical analysis reveal several interesting findings first overall the ex post performance of completed projects is relatively low however there are major performance gaps among projects second r d type technology type and private sector investment are factors influencing project performance more specifically projects identified as basic research storage technology or without private sector investment had the highest performance with an acceptable level of statistical significance third dea can provide unique information such as results of returns to scale and slack analysis which cannot be gleaned from parametric methods as time went on the decreasing returns to scale drs ratio increased and the increasing returns to scale irs ratio decreased this means that the r d budget was used less and less effectively as time passed moreover among the three year project period the second year s r d budget was used most efficiently in each r d project this study can provide meaningful information to policy makers to enhance the performance of future r d projects and to promote hydrogen r d projects as well as advance the hydrogen economy

participation inertia in r d tax incentive and subsidy programs we examine how persistent firms participation is in rd the use of tax credits in contrast is unrelated to a firm s productivity our results suggest that r d tax incentives and r d subsidies are not substitutes and that any unintended misallocation of support is likely to persist

what drives business research and development r d intensity across organisation for economic co operation and development oecd countries this paper empirically investigates the potential determinants of business sector r d intensity using a panel of oecd countries for the period of 1975 2002 with data measured as five year averages estimates using a system gmm estimator controlling for endogeneity show a high degree of persistence in business sector r d expenditures tax incentives for r d have a significant and positive impact on business r d spending regardless of the specification and estimation techniques furthermore we find that expenditures for r d performed by universities are significantly positively related to business enterprise sector expenditures on r d indicating that public sector r d and private r d are complements direct r d subsidies and the high tech export share are significantly positively related to business sector r d intensity but these effects are only significant using the first differenced gmm estimator the static fixed effects results show that countries characterised by strong patent rights appear to hav

you can lead a firm to r d but can you make it innovate uk evidence from smes the uk government introduced tax credits for smes to promote and support r d in 2000 since then the policy has become more generous in this respect particularly since 2008 in this paper we use the national systems of entrepreneurship as a conceptual framework in which to question whether smes take up of tax credits has actually led to an increase in product service or process innovations our evidence suggests that a sme engagement with the policy is fairly randomly distributed across the sector and b there is little additional product service innovation to justify the expenditure in foregone taxes given the current distribution of credits but c there is evidence of enhanced radical process innovations particularly when combined with strong capability and planning at the firm level

how effective are level based r d tax credits evidence from the netherlands this paper examines the impact of the r d fiscal incentive program on r d by dutch firms taking a factor demand approach we measure the elasticity of firm r d capital accumulation to its user cost econometric models are estimated using a rich unbalanced panel of firm data covering the period 1996 2004 with firm specific r d user costs varying with tax incentives using the estimated user cost elasticity we perform a cost benefit analysis of the r d incentive program we find some evidence of additionality suggesting that the level based program of r d incentives in the netherlands is effective in stimulating firms investment in r d however the hypothesis of crowding out can be rejected only for small firms the analysis also indicates that the level based nature of the fiscal incentive scheme leads to a substantial social dead weight loss

gender time use and public policy over the life cycle patricia apps and ray rees compare gender differences in the allocation of time to market work domestic work child care and leisure over the life cycle using survey data for three countries australia the uk and germany they discuss the extent to which gender differences and life cycle variation in time use can be explained by public policy focusing on the tax treatment of the female partner and on access to high quality affordable child care

the effectiveness of tax incentives for r d i in developing countries the case of argentina abstract there is increasing interest in developing countries in granting tax incentives in order to encourage private investment in research development and innovation r d i however evidence on the effectiveness of such schemes in achieving policy goals in weak innovation systems contexts is still very scarce this paper aims at narrowing this knowledge gap by focusing on the effects of a tax credit scheme for promoting firm level innovation investment in argentina the analysis applies dynamic panel data techniques to a novel dataset merging several waves of the national innovation survey collected by the national institute of statistics and censuses the results suggest that the elasticity of r d i investment to its user cost of capital is a greater than 1 in absolute terms which implies that the intervention has been effective in increasing firms innovation efforts however effects vary depending on the type of innovation investment being subsidized industrial sector and size of the firm moreover when innovation investment is divided into innovation related capital goods expenditures and only r d the results suggest that the absolute value of the elasticity for the r d component of the innovation investment is less than 1 these heterogeneous effects should be exploited for further policy design

evaluating the innovation box tax policy instrument in the netherlands 2007 13 patent boxes are tax incentive schemes aimed at stimulating research and development r d in firms by providing favourable tax rates to profits that can be linked to a specific immaterial asset such as a patent because these profits are often hard to separate from other firm profits patent boxes have been argued to be prone to tax shifting of firms and tax competition between nations as they might shift the location of the profits without affecting the location of r d activities whether or not this occurs may also depend on conditions set in the patent box we evaluate the innovation box policy instrument in the netherlands which is essentially a patent box but without the formal requirement of a patent we ask whether the innovation box has an effect on local r d investment of the firm additionality thereby putting the hypothesis of tax shifting to the test we find that the innovation box indeed has a positive effect on r d investment but the average firm that uses the policy tends to use only a part of the tax advantage for extra r d investment

labor demand and the structure of adjustment costs this study examines the costs firms face in adjusting labor demand to exogenous shocks evidence on monthly plant level data shows that adjustment proceeds in jumps employment is unchanged in response to small shocks but moves instantaneously to a new equilibrium if the shocks are large results in the large literature that assumes smooth adjustment are due to aggregation of this nonlinear relation the finding has implications for cyclical changes in productivity for severance pay layoff and plant closing restrictions and for all other policies that affect the cost of adjusting employment copyright 1989 by american economic association

do r d tax incentives lead to higher wages for r d workers evidence from the netherlands this paper examines the impact of the dutch r d tax incentive scheme on the wages of r d workers we construct firm specific r d tax credit rates that vary over time following variations in the dutch r d tax incentive program using instrumental variables we estimate a wage sharing model with an unbalanced firm level panel data covering the period 1997 2004 the elasticity of the r d wage with respect to the fraction of the wage supported by the fiscal incentives scheme is estimated at 0 2 in the short run and 0 24 in the long run

public r d policies and cost behavior of the us manufacturing industries abstract this paper estimates and evaluates the contribution of r d tax incentives and publicly financed r d investment policies in promoting the growth of output and privately funded r d investment in us manufacturing industries publicly financed r d induced cost savings but crowds out privately financed r d investment while the incremental r d tax credit and immediate deductibility provision of r d expenditures have a significant impact on privately financed r d investment the optimal mix of both instruments is an important element for sustaining a balanced growth in output and productivity in the manufacturing sector

public support for innovation and the openness of firms innovation activities this study explores empirically the relationship between publicly funded schemes to support innovation and the openness of firms innovation practices using survey data from more than 5000 firms in 29 european countries we find that support policies for innovation both monetary and non monetary are related to an increase in the degree of openness of individual firms both in terms of the number of external partners with whom they collaborate and the number of open innovation activities they perform however the relationship between support and openness seems to be negatively moderated by the existence of previous innovative activity within the firm public support has more impact on less innovative firms and less influence when the firm is already innovative which could potentially indicate the existence of crowding out effects additionally our results suggest that non financial support is more strongly linked to openness than financial support for policy makers facing salient budgetary constraints this implies that institutions and government policies could potentially play a more important role than money in fostering open innovation this article contributes to the open innovation literature by tapping into the underexplored question of the role of public policies and has crucial implications for academics and policy makers

r d tax incentives in eu countries does the impact vary with firm size this paper studies the effect of r d tax incentives on the research activity of manufacturing firms based in france italy spain and the uk over the period 2007 2009 using a matching procedure we show that in all the examined countries but spain r d tax incentives induced a statistically significant increase in the intensity of r d expenses over sales however this effect is driven only by the behaviour of small firms by assessing the benefit cost ratio of r d tax policies we find evidence of substantial additional effects in italy and the uk

innovation procurement as capability building evaluating innovation policies in eight central and eastern european countries abstract after decades of impressive growth the new member states of the european union are once again in transition but this time from imitation to innovation driven competitiveness this paper evaluates the relationship between both public funding and public procurement for innovation ppi and firm level innovation output and outcome additionality in eight central and eastern european countries matching estimates on a sample of 41 623 firms suggest that ppi has a large effect on innovation and output and the highest additionality is sometimes achieved when firms receive both financial support and innovation oriented public procurement we argue that policy makers aiming to strengthen indigenous innovation capabilities should place stronger emphasis on ppi

sectors and the additionality effects of r d tax credits a cross country microeconometric analysis abstract do the additionality effects of r d tax credits vary across sectors the paper presents a micro econometric analysis of this question for three countries norway italy and france we use a panel of firm level data from three waves of the innovation surveys carried out in these countries for 2004 2006 and 2008 the study estimates input and output additionality effects of r d tax credits in each of these economies and it investigates how these effects differ across sectors characterized by different r d orientation and competition conditions the results point out that firms in industries with high r d orientation have on average higher propensity to apply to r d fiscal incentives schemes and stronger input and output additionality effects output additionality is found to differ among the three examined countries