what are the top five journals in economics a new meta ranking abstractwe construct a meta ranking of 277 economics journals based on 22 different rankings the ranking incorporates bibliometric indicators from four different databases web of science scopus google scholar and repec we account for the different scaling of the bibliometric indicators by standardizing each ranking score we run a principal component analysis to assign weights to each ranking in our meta ranking the top five journals are given by quarterly journal of economics journal of financial economics journal of economic literature jel journal of finance and econometrica additionally leaving out the jel as a survey journal and the finance journals in our top 10 list we confirm the perceived top five journals in the economics profession

on the indifference relation in bewley preferences abstract bewley s 2002 influential model of preferences over uncertain prospects features an incomplete preference relation and a set of priors over the states of the world such that one act is preferred to another if and only if its expected utility is higher under every prior in that set this note shows that under general conditions on preferences the decision maker in the bewley model cannot be indifferent between distinct monetary acts whenever the set of priors is fully dimensional in the special case of two states in particular such objectively rational preferences are incomplete if and only if the indifference relation is trivial in the above sense

uncertainty and risk in financial markets this paper considers a general equilibrium model in which the distinction between uncertainty and risk is formalized by assuming agents have incomplete preferences over statecontingent consumption bundles as in bewley 1986 without completeness individual decision making depends on a set of probability distributions over the state space a bundle is preferred to another if and only if it has larger expected utility for all probabilities in this set when preferences are complete this set is a singleton and the model reduces to standard expected utility in this setting we characterize pareto optima and equilibria and show that the presence of uncertainty generates robust indeterminacies in equilibrium prices and allocations for any specification of initial endowments we derive comparative statics results linking the degree of uncertainty with changes in equilibria despite the presence of robust indeterminacies we show that equilibrium prices and allocations vary continuously with underlying fundamentals equilibria in a standard risk economy are thus robust to adding small degrees of uncertainty finally we give conditions under which some assets are not traded due to uncertainty aversion

aggregation effects on price and expenditure elasticities in a quadratic almost ideal demand system while it is well known that demand elasticities calculated at the macro level will in general differ from those calculated at the micro level because of aggregation effects there remain the questions of how large the effects are and how they vary with the degree of nonuniformity in the income distribution we explore those questions with models based on a quadratic version of the almost ideal demand system we investigate the elasticity differences theoretically and then calibrate the models and generate numerical results using income data for seven countries with widely different distributions the aggregation effects are found generally to be rather small even with highly nonuniform income distributions

knightian uncertainty and moral hazard abstract this paper presents a principal agent model in which the agent has imprecise beliefs we model this situation formally by assuming the agent s preferences are incomplete as in bewley 1986 2 in this setting incentives must be robust to knightian uncertainty we study the implications of robustness for the form of the resulting optimal contracts we give conditions under which there is a unique optimal contract and show that it must have a simple flat payment plus bonus structure that is output levels are divided into two sets and the optimal contract pays the same wage for all output levels in each set we derive this result for the case in which the agent s utility function is linear and then show it also holds if this utility function has some limited curvature

grading journals in economics the abcs of the abdc many institutions and governments grade academic journals for the evaluation of research in this paper we implement a multi bibliometric methodology for the evaluation of such a list of journal grades we examine the grades assigned by the australian business deans council abdc for over 750 journals in the fields of economics and statistics firstly we generate up to 48 bibliometric based grades for each journal based on the grade distribution implied by the abdc secondly we categorize the bibliometrics employing a cluster analysis of an interrater agreement statistic thirdly we present a visualization of the consistency of the grading by journal finally we list those journals where the majority of the matched bibliometrics indicate a higher or lower grade than their abdc grade

intertemporal equilibria with knightian uncertainty we study a dynamic and infinite dimensional model with incomplete multiple prior preferences in interior efficient allocations agents share a common risk adjusted prior and subjective interest rate interior efficient allocations and equilibria coincide with those of economies with subjective expected utility and priors from the agents multiple prior sets a specific model with neither risk nor uncertainty at the aggregate level is considered risk is always fully insured for small levels of ambiguity there exists an equilibrium with inertia where agents also insure fully against knightian uncertainty when the level of ambiguity exceeds a critical threshold full insurance no longer prevails and there exist equilibria with inertia where agents do not insure against uncertainty at all we also show that equilibria with inertia are indeterminate

pareto optima and equilibria when preferences are incompletely known an exchange economy in which agents have convex incomplete preferences defined by families of concave utility functions is considered sufficient conditions for the set of efficient allocations and equilibria to coincide with the set of efficient allocations and equilibria that result when each agent has a utility in her family are provided welfare theorems in an incomplete preferences framework therefore hold under these conditions and efficient allocations and equilibria are characterized by first order conditions

journals preferences and publishing in agricultural and environmental economics research quality is an increasingly important metric for determining funding allocations promotion and tenure and professional prestige a key metric often used as a proxy for research quality is the ranking of the journal in which a manuscript appears while citation based measures of journal quality are commonly used less is known about other dimensions of journal quality and prestige we report results from an international study using best worst scaling to investigate researchers journal preferences respondents used two criteria to assess journals the impact a paper in the journal would have on career progression and the impact beyond academia of papers in the journal among the sample of journals studied the american journal of agricultural economics is ranked at the top for career progression for the aggregate sample while science was rated at the top for broader impact we find no significant correlation between the journal scores based on the two criteria nor between them and the journals impact factors these results suggest that impact beyond academia is poorly aligned with career incentives and that citation measures reflect poorly if at all peers esteem of journals heteroscedastic scale adjusted latent class models reveal marked heterogeneity in journal preferences related to researchers institutional affiliation and geographic region we find significant differences in error variance over people and choices people were less consistent when choosing their least as opposed to their most preferred journal this finding has broader implications given the burgeoning use of best worst surveys

errors of aggregation and errors of specification in a consumer demand model a theoretical note consumer demand models based on the concept of a representative or average consumer suffer from aggregation error misspecification of the underlying micro utility maximizing model which is virtually inevitable also results in error this note provides a theoretical investigation of the relationship between the two types of error misspecified expenditure support functions for demand systems at the micro level induce the same misspecified structure in the corresponding expenditure functions at the macro level and the errors at the two levels are shown to be of similar order jel classification d11 erreurs d agregation et erreurs de specification dans un modele de demande du consomma teur une note theorique les mod eles de demande du consommateur fondsur le con sommateur moyen ou repr esentatif souffrent d une erreur d agr

sustainability and wellbeing a scientometric and bibliometric review of the literature interdisciplinary research on measuring the progress towards sustainability and well being saw from different perspectives and in various contexts has developed dramatically over recent decades this growth in the literature has not only added an enormous number of dimensions to the saw debate but the sheer scale of the expansion has challenged researchers to be able to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the available saw indicators in this work we have proposed a hybrid method comprised of sophisticated scientometric analysis to summarise scientific developments in the massive text corpus of the saw literature in conjunction with a more traditional literature review to categorise the fuzzy details that remain scientometric analysis highlights that the developed oecd countries play a vital role in the development and applications of saw indicators and we describe key developments in this regard via a range of graphical approaches using an extensive collection of existing saw indicators the analysis is then summarised in a matrix of ranked indicators which serve as a powerful tool to compare contrast filter and select indicators for saw assessment with minimum redundancies between indicators the approach undertaken in this study is intended to be flexible and can be extended and applied to other fields of research

overlapping risk adjusted sets of priors and the existence of efficient allocations and equilibria with short selling the theory of existence of equilibrium with short selling is reconsidered under risk and ambiguity modelled by risk averse variational preferences no arbitrage conditions are given in terms of risk adjusted priors a sufficient condition for existence of efficient allocations is the overlapping of the interiors of the risk adjusted sets of priors or the inexistence of mutually compatible trades with non negative expectation with respect to any risk adjusted prior these conditions are necessary when agents are not risk neutral at extreme levels of wealths it is shown that the more uncertainty averse or risk averse the agents the more likely are efficient allocations and equilibria to exist

an examination of the reliability of prestigious scholarly journals evidence and implications for decision makers in universities all over the world hiring and promotion committees regularly hear the argument this is important work because it is about to appear in prestigious journal x moreover those who allocate levels of research funding such as in the multi billion pound research assessment exercise in uk universities often come under pressure to assess research quality in a mechanical way by using journal prestige ratings this paper s results suggest that such tendencies are dangerous it uses total citations over a quarter of a century as the criterion the paper finds that it is far better to publish the best article in an issue of a medium quality journal like the oxford bulletin of economics and statistics than to publish the worst article or often the worst 4 articles in an issue of a top journal like the american economic review implications are discussed

a theory of anticipated utility abstract a new theory of cardinal utility with an associated set of axioms is presented it is a generalization of the von neumann morgenstern expected utility theory which permits the analysis of phenomena associated with the distortion of subjective probability

what makes a great journal great in economics the singer not the song abstract this paper analyses what makes a great journal great in economics alternative research assessment measures ram are discussed with an emphasis on the thomson reuters institute for scientific information isi web of science database isi ram that are calculated annually or updated daily are defined including the classic 2 year impact factor 2yif 5 year impact factor 5yif immediacy zero year impact factor 0yif eigenfactor score article influence citation performance per paper online h index zinfluence pi beta papers ignored by even the authors and two new ram measures self citation threshold approval rating and impact factor inflation the data are analysed for the most highly cited journals in economics management business and business finance on the basis of 2yif in addition to evaluating research in the most highly cited journals in economics management business and business finance the paper evaluates alternative ram highlights similarities and differences in ram criteria finds that several ram capture similar performance characteristics and finds that immediacy and pi beta are not highly correlated with other ram harmonic mean rankings of the 12 ram criteria are also presented emphasizing 2yif to the exclusion of other useful ram criteria can lead to a distorted evaluation of journal performance and influence

asset demands without the independence axiom an important application of the theory of choice under uncertainty is to asset markets and an important property in these markets is a preference for portfolio diversification if an investor is an expected utility maximizer then s he is risk averse if and only if s he exhibits a preference for diversification this paper examines the relationship between risk aversion and portfolio diversification when preferences over probability distributions of wealth do not have an expected utility representation

a more robust definition of subjective probability the goal of choice theoretic derivations of subjective probability is to separate a decisionmaker s underlying beliefs subjective probabilities of events from their preferences attitudes toward risk classical derivations have all relied upon some form of the marschak samuelson independence axiom or the savage sure thing principle which imply that preferences over lotteries conform to the expected utility hypothesis this paper presents a choice theoretic derivation of subjective probability in a savage type setting of purely subjective uncertainty which neither assumes nor implies that the decisionmaker s preferences over lotteries necessarily conform to the expected utility hypothesis copyright 1992 by the econometric society

which journal rankings best explain academic salaries evidence from the university of california the ranking of an academic journal is important to authors universities journal publishers and research funders rankings are gaining prominence as countries adopt regular research assessment exercises that especially reward publication in high impact journals yet even within a rankings oriented discipline like economics there is no agreement on how aggressively lower ranked journals are down weighted and in how wide is the universe of journals considered moreover since it is typically less costly for authors to cite superfluous references whether of their own volition or prompted by editors than it is to ignore relevant ones rankings based on citations may be easily manipulated in contrast when the merits of publication in one journal or another are debated during hiring promotion and salary decisions the evaluators are choosing over actions with costly consequences we therefore look to the academic labor market using data on economists in the university of california system to relate their lifetime publications in 700 different academic journals to salary we test amongst various sets of journal rankings and publication discount rates to see which are most congruent with the returns implied by the academic labor market jel a14 i23 j44

testing restrictions in a flexible dynamic demand system an application to consumers expenditure in canada traditionally restrictions on systems of demand equations have been tested using static models whilst being estimated with time series data this paper develops a vector time series model of expenditure shares in the context of a singular dynamic demand system the model allows for non symmetric and non homogeneous short run behaviour the homogeneity and symmetry restrictions are only examined in the long run structure results based on canadian time series data are presented and reject the current practise of static modelling while restrictions suggested by economic theory are not rejected when imposed on the long run structure

liquidity and valuation in an uncertain world abstract during the 2007 2009 financial crisis there was little or no trading in a variety of financial assets even though bid and ask prices existed for many of these assets we develop a model in which this illiquidity arises from uncertainty and we argue that this new form of illiquidity makes bid and ask prices unsuitable as metrics for establishing fair value for these assets we show how the extreme uncertainty that traders face can be characterized by incomplete preferences over portfolios and we use bewley s 2002 model of decision making under uncertainty to derive equilibrium quotes and the nonexistence of trading at these quotes we then suggest alternatives for valuing assets in illiquid markets

age trend and cohort effects in a macro model of canadian expenditure patterns a quadratic almost ideal demand system allowing for age cohort and trend effects is developed at the macro level the model is estimated by maximum likelihood using a three tier iterative search method applied to pooled 1961 1992 time series for five regions of canada and six categories of expenditure hypothesis tests indicate support for the model specification elasticities are compared with those reported in other studies with special attention to food effects of demographic and trend variables on elasticities and expenditure shares are investigated an overall conclusion is that such effects can be very important in a macro demand system

risk sharing in the small and in the large abstract this paper analyzes risk sharing in economies with no aggregate uncertainty when agents have non convex preferences in particular agents need not be globally risk averse or uncertainty averse in the sense of schmeidler 1989 we identify a behavioral condition under which betting is inefficient i e every pareto efficient allocation provides full insurance and conversely if and only if agents supporting probabilities defined as in rigotti et al 2008 have a non empty intersection our condition is consistent with empirical and experimental evidence documenting violations of convexity in either outcomes or utilities our results show that the connection between speculative betting and inconsistent beliefs does not depend upon global notions of risk or ambiguity aversion

decision theory under ambiguity we review recent advances in the field of decision making under uncertainty or ambiguity we start with a presentation of the general approach to a decision problem under uncertainty as well as the standard bayesian treatment and issues with this treatment we present more general approaches choquet expected utility maximin expected utility smooth ambiguity and so forth that have been developed in the literature under the name of models of ambiguity sensitive preferences we draw a distinction between fully subjective models and models incorporating explicitly some information we review definitions and characterizations of ambiguity aversion in these models we mention the challenges posed by some of the models presented we end with a review of part of the experimental literature and applications of these models to economic settings

subjective beliefs and ex ante trade we study a definition of subjective beliefs applicable to preferences that allow for the perception of ambiguity and provide a characterization of such beliefs in terms of market behavior using this definition we derive necessary and sufficient conditions for the efficiency of ex ante trade and show that these conditions follow from the fundamental welfare theorems when aggregate uncertainty is absent our results show that full insurance is efficient if and only if agents share some common subjective beliefs our results hold for a general class of convex preferences which contains many functional forms used in applications involving ambiguity and ambiguity aversion we show how our results can be articulated in the language of these functional forms confirming results existing in the literature generating new results and providing a useful tool for applications

a definition of uncertainty aversion a definition of uncertainty or ambiguity aversion is proposed it is argued that the definition is well suited to modelling within the savage as opposed to anscombe and aumann domain of acts the defined property of uncertainty aversion has intuitive empirical content behaves well in specific models of preference multiple priors and choquet expected utility and is tractable tractability is established through use of a novel notion of differentiability for utility functions called eventwise differentiability

income distribution and aggregation disaggregation biases in the measurement of consumer demand elasticities abstract we investigate the issue of aggregation and disaggregation biases in demand elasticities drawing on income distribution data for seven countries we calculate the likely range of differences between elasticities evaluated at average income and corresponding aggregate average elasticities

what do we learn about consumer demand patterns from micro data the aim of this paper is to assess the importance of using micro level data in the econometric analysis of consumer demand to do this we utilize a time series of repeated cross sections covering some 4 000 households in each of 15 years employing a number of different aggregation procedures we conclude that aggregate data alone are unlikely to produce reliable estimates of structural price and income coefficients however once certain aggregation factors as well as trend and seasonal components are included an aggregate model is not necessarily outperformed across all demand equations in terms of forecasting ability jel d12 c52 c31 the purpose of this paper is to develop a complete consumer demand system based on a time series of individual household data and to use it to measure the biases introduced into the study of consumer de mand behavior when aggregate data are used in place of the appropriate microeco nomic data we assess the suitability of ag gregate data through the impact on income and price elasticities and by evaluating the ability of both micro and aggregate based models to forecast aggregate consumer de mand the biases introduced by the use of aggregate data depend upon the way that household characteristics interact with in come and price effects and on departures of demand systems from linearity we explore the structure of microeconomic demand sys tems and the role of household characteris tics in the behavior of consumer demand both for the light this may shed on the pattern of future demands and for the im plications this behavior has for issues of aggregation consumer demand patterns typically found in micro data sets vary considerably across households with different household characteristics and with different levels of income we model this variability by making intercept and slope parameters in the budget share equations of our demand sys tem depend on household characteristics and by allowing for nonlinear total log expenditure terms in fact in theory consistent demand systems it is total ex penditure rather than disposable income that is allocated across goods we find that this general framework leads to a well specified data coherent demand system which is a quadratic extension of the popu lar almost ideal model of angus s deaton and john muellbauer 1980 the micro level estimates are shown to be sensitive to the treatment of endogeneity of total expen diture and to the specification of interaction terms with household characteristics in ad dition this specification is also shown to possess many attractive features for the evaluation of aggregate models

estimation of complete demand systems from household budget data the linear and quadratic expenditure systems in this paper we explore two issues in empirical demand analysis the estimation of complete systems of demand equations using household budget data section i and the incorporation of demographic characteristics into such systems section ii although there are numerous studies which use time series data to estimate complete demand systems and many which estimate engel curves from household budget data there are virtually none which combine budget data from different periods to estimate complete systems since each budget study corresponds to a single price situation one might conjecture that estimation of complete systems would not be possible unless budget studies were available from a large number of periods this is incorrect in section i we argue that interesting complete demand systems can be estimated from a small number of budget studies despite the limited price variability represented in such data to demonstrate this we use budget study data for two periods to estimate a pair of related demand systems the familiar linear expenditure system les and a quadratic expenditure system qes a generalization of les in which the demand equations are quadratic in total expenditure the inclusion of demographic variables in the analysis of household consumption patterns is desirable because there are likely to be systematic differences in the consumption behavior of households with different demographic characteristics but the effects of demographic characteristics have seldom been studied within the framework of complete demand systems in section ii we propose translating as a general method for incorporating demographic variables into complete systems of demand equations this method has not previously been discussed as a general technique for bringing demographic variables into demand systems although it has been employed in several studies to improve the estimates of the les and the qes presented in section i we reestimate these two systems using translating to incorporate family size

quadratic engel curves and consumer demand this paper presents a model of consumer demand that is consistent with the observed expenditure patterns of individual consumers in a long time series of expenditure surveys and is also able to provide a detailed welfare analysis of shifts in relative prices a nonparametric analysis of consumer expenditure patterns suggests that engel curves require quadratic terms in the logarithm of expenditure while popular models of demand such as the translog or the almost ideal demand systems do allow flexible price responses within a theoretically coherent structure they have expenditure share engel curves that are linear in the logarithm of total expenditure we derive the complete class of integrable quadratic logarithmic expenditure share systems a specification from this class is estimated on a large pooled data set of u k households models that fail to account for engel curvature are found ro generate important distortions in the patterns of welfare losses associated with a tax increase

macroeconometric modeling and the theory of the representative agent the lucas critique of econometric policy evaluation 1976 argues that to the extent econometric models do not capture the primitive parameters of tastes and technology their coefficients can be expected to vary with changes in policy regimes several econometricians have undertaken empirical work that separates the parameters of tastes technology and policy estimating models that are in principle immune from this critique exemplary contributors to this effort have been thomas sargent 1978 and sargent and lars hansen 1980 the empirical work inspired by the lucas critique has proceeded using representative agent models and aggregate data the treatment of expectations and dynamic optimization has been careful although at times necessarily limited by the analytical requirements of attaining closed form solutions for dynamic programming problems under uncertainty potential problems due to aggregation have usually been ignored although when preferences and technology are quadratic it appears that they can be disposed of quickly assuming a representative firm is only a convenience as the model admits a tidy theory of aggregation sargent 1978 p 1016 it is ironic that a paradigm that emphasizes the isolation of the primitive parameters of tastes and technology has led to empirical work that has ben conducted almost exclusively with aggregate data there are exceptions t macurdy 1983 j biddle 1984 there are several difficulties with this development first the fact that representative agent models with exact aggregation can be constructed is unrelated to whether or not these models are adequate we can also construct models in which agents behavior is unaffected by the policy regime to exclusively model and test one but not the other appears to be a misplacement of emphasis second some of this work has proceeded using representative agents whose behavior cannot be aggregated exactly see m eichenbaum hansen and kenneth singleton 1984 for an example there is a third and most fundamental objection to empirical work which seeks to avoid the lucas critique yet uses aggregate data whenever econometric policy evaluation is undertaken using models estimated with aggregate data it is implicitly presumed that the aggregator function is structural with respect to the policy intervention in question formally aggregator functions are no more structural than are within regime reducedform relations of endogenous to policy variables as a modeling strategy ignoring the sensitivity of aggregators to policy changes seems no more compelling than ignoring the dependence of expectations on the policy regime this paper describes a very modest econometric model in which the effects of ignoring aggregation and of ignoring expectations each within the context of several representative agent models can be appreciated objective functions are quadratic and prices are disparate across agents in these respects the model s assumptions are in the mainstream of lucas and subsequent empirical work the model is carefully contrived so that exact aggregation is always possible this is not essential to the argument in any way but it drastically reduces the number of circumstances to be examined in constructing numerical examples the example pertains to neoclassical production and in each case there are three distinct representative agents one for production one for factor demand professor of economics duke university durham nc 27706 financial support from nsf grant ses8318778 and a sloan research fellowship are gratefully acknowledged a more detailed version of this paper is available on request from the author