macroeconomic impacts of oil price shocks in asian economies abstract this paper analyzes the macroeconomic impact of structural oil shocks in four of the top oil consuming asian economies using a var model we identify three different structural oil shocks via sign restrictions an oil supply shock an oil demand shock driven by global economic activity and an oil specific demand shock the main results suggest that economic activity and prices respond very differently to oil price shocks depending on their types in particular an oil supply shock has a limited impact while a demand shock driven by global economic activity has a significant positive effect in all four asian countries examined our finding also includes that policy tools such as interest rates and exchange rates help mitigating the effects of supply shocks in japan and korea however they can be more actively used in response to demands shocks

international oil shocks and household consumption in china abstract we investigate the impacts that oil price shocks have on residential consumption in china while it is well understood that oil prices affect consumption in a multitude of ways the timing and directness of these effects on specific consumption categories is not clear we demonstrate that the most immediate and direct effect passes through transportation consumption as might be expected but we also show that significant effects pass through consumption in other sectors including food and clothes medical expenditure and other general living expenditure with less immediacy given the results particularly observed asymmetries with respect to rises and falls in international oil prices we discuss some implications for future adjustments to domestic price policies in particular the case for removal of domestic price regulation

assessment of the economic impacts of continuous energy intensity target constraint in china based on an analytical general equilibrium model abstract based on the framework of analytical general equilibrium model this study builds an energy intensity target eit constraint model and simulates the impacts of continuous eit constraint policy on the fossil fuel production ffp sector non fossil fuel production nffp sector household sector and price system in china the main findings of this paper are firstly the eit constraint can change the marginal products and the cross price elasticities of input factors secondly stricter eit constraint can transfer capital and labor inputs from the ffp sector to the nffp sector and lead to a contractionary effect in the ffp sector shown as declining inputs and output the contractionary effect will decline gradually or even fade away if the eit constraint is gradually reduced thirdly if the total capital and labor inputs in the whole economy continue to grow at certain rates along with the weakening of the eit constraint the reduction in energy input and the growth of capital and labor inputs in the nffp sector will slow down however the growth rates of output and intermediate input will increase continuously fourthly the eit constraint has negative impacts on the nffp sector price system and household consumption but these impacts are affordable to the whole economy if the eit constraint is loosened under a certain level it may not curb the growth of fossil fuel consumption anymore therefore other supporting policies for energy conservation must be in place

oil price shocks and their short and long term effects on the chinese economy a considerable body of economic literature shows the adverse economic impacts of oil price shocks for the developed economies however there has been a lack of empirical study of this kind on china and other developing countries this paper attempts to fill this gap by answering how and to what extent oil price shocks impact china s economy emphasizing on the price transmission mechanisms to that end we develop a structural vector auto regressive model our results show that an oil price increase negatively affects output and investment but positively affects inflation rate and interest rate however with the differentiated price control policies for materials and intermediates on the one hand and final products on the other hand in china the impact on real economy represented by real output and real investment lasts much longer than that to price monetary variables our decomposition results also show that the short term impact namely output decrease induced by the cut of capacity utilization rate is greater in the first one to two years but the portion of the long term impact defined as the impact realized through an investment change increases steadily and exceeds that of short term impact at the end of the second year afterwards the long term impact dominates and maintains for quite some time

the effects of petroleum product price regulation on macroeconomic stability in china abstract china has undertaken measures to regulate the prices of petroleum products since 1998 in order to deal with the world oil price shocks on its macro economy however the effects of price regulation are yet unknown especially when the world oil price fluctuates in different regimes the study first analyses the mechanisms of petroleum product price ppp regulation in the case of gasoline and the crude oil gasoline price fluctuation transmission followed by the identification of regimes and their time intervals using regime switching vector autoregressive model and then estimates the effects of gasoline price regulation in reducing macroeconomic volatility it is found that the world crude oil fluctuates in different regimes the mild fluctuation regime and the violent fluctuation regime the ppp regulation can reduce oil price volatility and then macroeconomic volatility but it is more effective in the mild fluctuation regime the findings present a deeper understanding of the stabilization effect of ppp regulation on the macroeconomy provide an evidence for sustaining china s ppp regulation for the purpose of macroeconomic stability and offer policymakers new information for petroleum product pricing reforms

estimates of energy subsidies in china and impact of energy subsidy reform abstract for a transitional economy such as china some energy subsidies are reasonable and sometimes even necessary for achieving social goals however with rising energy prices and environmental concerns we see conflicts emerging between energy subsidies energy demand supply fundamentals and climate change considerations energy subsidies have important implications for sustainable development through their effects on energy use efficiency and the choice of fuel source this paper applies the price gap approach to estimate china s energy subsidies results indicate that china s energy subsidies amounted to cny 356 73 billion in 2007 equivalent to 1 43 of gdp subsidies for oil products consumption are the largest followed by subsidies for the electricity and coal sectors furthermore a cge model is used to analyze the economic impacts of energy subsidy reforms our findings show that removing energy subsidies will result in a significant fall in energy demand and emissions but will have negative impacts on macroeconomic variables we conclude that offsetting policies could be adopted such that certain shares of these subsidies are reallocated to support other sustainable development measures which could lead to reducing energy intensity and favoring the environment

error correction mechanisms the interface between economic theory and applied econometrics is often one of uneasy compromise with the pragmatic justification for many accepted procedures resting on a theoretical base this paper examines the surprisingly strong arguments that exist in terms of economic theory for the use of error correction mechanisms in the specification of short run dynamic adjustment a common heresy exists that while economic theory provides a detailed analysis of comparative static equilibria it can offer no guidance as to the appropriate specification of dynamic adjustment towards an equilibrium perhaps in consequence it is not uncommon to find examples where the necessary dynamic specification is achieved by tacking onto an existing equilibrium specification some relatively ad hoc short run adjustment scheme the intercession of stochastic arguments in this process is confused and critical implications are frequently ignored in practice but perhaps more importantly there will typically be no guarantee that the dynamic specification is consistent with the prescribed equilibrium consistency in this sense requires that the short run dynamic adjustment be directed by the perceived disequilibrium and that eventual convergence to the equilibrium position be ensured that two separate theoretical arguments co exist within the final specification is the root cause of many difficulties both theoretical and empirical this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

the impacts of structural oil shocks on macroeconomic uncertainty evidence from a large panel of 45 countries abstract using local projection methods this paper employs monthly panel data from 1989 to 2017 to examine both linear and nonlinear impulse responses of macroeconomic uncertainty to structural shocks to global oil production aggregate demand oil market specific demand and speculative demand in a large group of 45 economies we find that both oil supply and demand shocks are important drivers of uncertainty there is strong evidence that the impacts of oil price shocks on macroeconomic uncertainty are regime dependent and contingent on the states of investor sentiments and perceived volatility in financial markets the responses of economic uncertainty to oil shocks especially demand side shocks appear to experience a dramatic change in the post global financial crisis period

oil and the macroeconomy since world war ii all but one of the u s recessions since world war ii have been preceded typically with a lag of around three fourths of a year by a dramatic increase in the price of crude petroleum this does not mean that oil shocks caused these recessions evidence is presented however that even over the period 1948 72 this correlation is statistically significant and nonspurious supporting the proposition that oil shocks were a contributing factor in at least some of the u s recessions prior to 1972 by extension energy price increases may account for much of post opec macroeconomic performance

a comparison of the effects of exogenous oil supply shocks on output and inflation in the g7 countries a comparison of the effects of exogenous shocks to global crude oil production on seven major industrialized economies suggests a fair degree of similarity in the real growth responses an exogenous oil supply disruption typically causes a temporary reduction in real gdp growth that is concentrated in the second year after the shock inflation responses are more varied the median cpi inflation response peaks after three to four quarters exogenous oil supply disruptions need not generate sustained inflation or stagflation typical responses include a fall in the real wage higher short term interest rates and a depreciating currency with respect to the dollar despite many qualitative similarities there is strong statistical evidence that the responses to exogenous oil supply disruptions differ across g7 countries for suitable subsets of countries homogeneity cannot be ruled out a counterfactual historical exercise suggests that the evolution of cpi inflation in the g7 countries would have been similar overall to the actual path even in the absence of exogenous shocks to oil production consistent with a monetary explanation of the inflation of the 1970s there is no evidence that the 1973 1974 and 2002 2003 oil supply shocks had a substantial impact on real growth in any g7 country whereas the 1978 1979 1980 and 1990 1991 shocks contributed to lower growth in at least some g7 countries jel e31 e32 q43

the relationship between oil price shocks and china s macro economy an empirical analysis china postdoctoral science foundation 20090460751 ministry of education of the people s republic of china 09yjc790167 09yja820074 national social science funds 09zd050 08ajy031

was the worldwide shift to gold inevitable an analysis of the end of bimetallism abstract this paper analyzes the causes and consequences of the universal switch from bimetallism to the gold standard in the early 1870s it shows that the sole cause for the fall in silver prices after 1871 was the german demonetization of silver and that the subsequent restriction of free silver coinage in belgium and france was unnecessary continued free silver coinage in the latin union would have reduced the share of gold in the union s monetary system only marginally their continued adherence to bimetallism could have avoided much of the deflation in the gold standard world in the 1870s

the demand for m1 in the u s a 1960 1988 estimated u s m1 demand functions appear unstable regularly breaking down over 1960 1988 e g missing money great velocity decline m1 explosion we propose a money demand function whose arguments include inflation real income long term bond yield and risk t bill interest rates and learning curve weighted yields on newly introduced instruments in m1 and non transactions m2 the model is estimated in dynamic error correction form it is constant and with an equation standard error of 0 4 variance dominates most previous models estimating alternative specifications explains earlier breakdowns showing the model s distinctive features to be important in accounting for the data

oil shock and economic growth in japan a nonlinear approach abstract this paper investigates the relationship between oil price shock and economic growth on the basis of the nonlinear approach developed by hamilton hamilton j 2001 a parametric approach to flexible nonlinear inference econometrica 537 573 we use the approach also in hamilton hamilton j 2003 what is an oil shock journal of econometrics 363 398 of capturing this relationship in japan in a nonlinear model the idea is that negative oil price shocks price increase tend to have larger impact on growth than positive shocks do our empirical evidence confirmed the existence of nonlinearity between these two variables and a flexible nonlinear model is estimated additionally several other form of nonlinearity are estimated and tested

analysis of the changes in the scale of natural gas subsidy in china and its decomposition factors abstract this paper applied the price gap approach to estimate natural gas subsidy in china during 2007 2015 and employed the lmdi method to analyze the influencing factors of the changes in the subsidy scale the results showed that the chinese government raised the domestic gas price in contrast to the slump in global gas price in 2009 which accelerated the huge decrease in the natural gas subsidy scale but the stagnation in price adjustment immediately led to a rebound in natural gas subsidy during 2010 2012 however the level of natural gas subsidy has declined substantially in the industrial and commercial sectors since the natural gas pricing mechanism reform began in 2013 but the level of residential natural gas subsidy still remained high because the city gate pricing mechanism was not extended to this sector the pricing mechanism was the most important decomposition factor of changes in the level of natural gas subsidy the contribution rates of competitive gas price pricing mechanism consumption structure and natural gas consumption on decrease in natural gas subsidy scale were 11 08 101 21 3 15 and 9 14 respectively during 2013 2015 a reasonable and well implemented pricing mechanism can prevent a rebound in natural gas subsidy therefore the government should seize the current opportunity of sufficient natural gas supply and relatively low gas price to deepen and advance the natural gas pricing mechanism reform

a model of bimetallism bimetallism has been the subject of considerable debate was it a viable monetary system was it desirable in our model the amounts of each metal are split between coined metal satisfying a cash in advance constraint and uncoined metal yielding utility the ratio of the monies in the cash in advance constraint is endogenous bimetallism is feasible we find a continuum of steady states indexed by the constant exchange rate of the monies bimetallism is not desirable among steady states welfare under monometallism is higher than under any bimetallic equilibrium long run trends in gold and silver production placed limits on the maintenance of bimetallism at any given ratio but its sudden collapse in 1873 remains a puzzle

are the macroeconomic effects of oil price shock symmetric a factor augmented vector autoregressive approach abstract this paper aims to examine the asymmetric effect of oil price shocks on real economic activity in the u s within the context of a nonlinear factor augmented vector autoregressive favar model by employing simulation methods we trace the effects of positive and negative oil price shocks on the macroeconomic variables through the impulse response function irf it is found that the negative impacts of higher oil prices are larger than the positive effects of lower oil prices and the asymmetric effects are more evident when the oil price shocks are larger the results are robust to different lag specification and choice of factors

on the indeterminacy of equilibrium exchange rates in this paper we consider a particular international economic policy regime the laissez faire regime the distinguishing features of which are unrestricted portfolio choice and floating exchange rates and as we show this regime although favored by many economists is not economically feasible it does not have a determinate equilibrium that is an implication of an overlapping generations model more basically it is an implication of the notion that money is wanted only in order to accomplish trades

a model of commodity money abstract commodity money is modeled as one or two of the capital goods in a one consumption good and one or two capital good overlapping generations model among the topics addressed using versions of the model are i the nature of the inefficiency of commodity money ii the validity of quantity theory predictions for commodity money systems iii the circumstances under which one commodity emerges naturally as the commodity money iv the role of inside money money backed by private debt in commodity money systems and v the circumstances under which a government can choose the commodity to serve as the commodity money

inflation risk and the speed of adjustment in short run money demand functions abstract after 1973 money demand functions show a slow speed of adjustment including inflation risk does not help this the ser shows multiple minima as a function of the estimated rho in the error with higher speeds and rhos associated

the crime of 1873 the u s coinage act of 1873 eliminated provision for the free coinage of silver that act cast the die for a gold standard the conventional view is that the act of 1873 was a piece of good fortune this paper indicates that it was the opposite a mistake that had highly adverse consequences this is a judgment about 1873 not 1896 by 1896 when william jennings bryan ran for president on a free silver ticket it was too late to undo the damage bryan was trying to close the barn door after the horse had been stolen

price of oil and world inflation and recession new evidence shows that the commonly held assumption that the 1973 74 oil price increase directly affected us and world inflation and subsequent recession is consistent with the empirical data an extended lucas varro real income equation applied to the us united kingdom canada france germany italy japan and the netherlands gives mixed results partly because of price control and decontrol programs simulation experiments on the price control variable using us data finds strong effects further studies can be made when consistent international data is available for the 1979 80 period 18 references 4 figures 3 tables dck

discovering the link between inflation rates and inflation uncertainty a new time series model is used to reassess the strength of the link between inflation uncertainty and the level of inflation in the united states the model provides several statistical measures that can be used to examine different aspects of uncertainty the main finding is that uncertainty about the long rather than short term prospects for inflation moved strongly with the rate of inflation since the early 1970s copyright 1991 by ohio state university press

energy savings potential in china s industrial sector from the perspectives of factor price distortion and allocative inefficiency abstract china s industrial energy consumption accounted for 70 82 of national and 14 12 of world energy usage in 2011 in the context of energy scarcity and environmental pollution the industrial sector in china faces unsustainable growth problems by adopting the stochastic frontier analysis sfa framework this paper analyzes the factor allocative efficiency of china s industrial sector and estimates the energy savings potential from the perspective of allocative inefficiency this paper focuses on three issues the first is examining the factor allocative inefficiency of china s industrial sector the second is measuring factor price distortion by the shadow price model the third is estimating the energy savings potential in china s industrial sector during 2001 2009 major conclusions are thus drawn first factor prices of capital labor and energy are distorted in china due to government regulations moreover energy price is relatively low compared to capital price while is relatively high compared to labor price second the industry wide energy savings potential resulted from energy allocative inefficiency was about 9 71 during 2001 2009 the downward trend of energy savings potential implies the increasing energy allocative efficiency in china s industrial sector third a transparent and reasonable pricing mechanism is conducive to improving energy allocative efficiency

nominal contracts in a bimetallic standard as its central feature a bimetallic standard grants nominal debtors an option to deliver either of two metals with results from the option pricing literature construction of a formula to evaluate the bimetallic option in debt instruments is straightforward with this formula one can compute the option value in a wide range of nineteenth century u s treasury securities posession of the option values permits an adjustment of the yields on u s securities to make them comparable to yields on nonmetallic european securities evaluating the option allows the estimation of transfers from debtors to creditors copyright 1986 by american economic association

socio economic development and electricity access in developing economies a long run model averaging approach abstract access to electricity continues to be a popular subject in empirical studies however the choice of key factors related to electricity access in the literature to date has been ad hoc due to the lack of a theoretical framework this paper adopts a bayesian model averaging bma approach to selects important factors related to electricity access from 26 socioeconomic indicators using a sample of 48 developing countries and reveal their long term relationship with electricity access the bma approach allows us to identify the optimal empirical model when a theoretical foundation is not available moreover it allows us to address the relative importance of variables using posterior inclusion probabilities and thus has clear policy relevance our results show that access to finance education economic development infrastructure and industrialisation are positively related to electricity access in the long run although the long run relationship does not indicate causality it shows that to maintain this relationship policy adjustments against any deviations from the relationship are needed our study suggests that electrification needs not only economic educational and infrastructural development but also private sector participation governments commitment and political will and integration with poverty reduction and other development schemes

cointegration and unit roots this paper provides an updated survey of a burgeoning literature on testing estimation and model specification in the presence of integrated variables integrated variables are a specific class of non stationary variables which seem to characterise faithfully the properties of many macroeconomic time series the analysis of cointegration develops out of the existence of unit roots and offers a generic route to test the validity of the equilibrium predictions of economic theories special emphasis is put on the empirical researcher s point of view

valuing investment decisions of renewable energy projects considering changing volatility abstract volatility is an important parameter when evaluating investments using the real options method for renewable energy investments the volatility of cash flow continuously changes because as new information and knowledge are gathered there is less foreseen variation this paper proposes an extended recombining trinomial tree model where the changing volatility is used to generate transition probabilities the changing volatility is generated using a consolidation process where multiple random variables including the market price of electricity carbon price and lending rate are integrated into a low dimension stochastic process a two factor learning curve is used to model the changes of investment cost we apply the proposed model to analyze solar photovoltaic pv power generation investment in china the results show volatility with changing feature compared with constant volatility changing volatility may advance investment decisions and change the project value complete grid parity policy in the solar pv industry is infeasible because the opportunity cost brought by the option of delaying cannot be offset the changing volatility may produce a lower and equally effective subsidy level compared with constant volatility a carbon emission trading scheme is helpful in advancing investments in renewable energy which is reflected in improvements in project value advancements in investment decisions and reductions in the required subsidy level

investigating co2 mitigation potentials and the impact of oil price distortion in china s transport sector abstract the transport sector is a major source of oil consumption and co2 emissions in china however due to the regulated pricing mechanism in china the end user oil price cannot reflect real market price and thus oil price distortion exists therefore the main aim of this paper is to study the affecting mechanism of oil price distortion on co2 emission mitigation firstly the level of oil price distortion is evaluated and a dynamic trans log cost function model is built to analyze the substitution relationship among energy products secondly the own price elasticity and cross price elasticity for fuel demand are calculated based on provincial panel data of china s transport sector over 2004 2016 finally co2 mitigation potentials are estimated by removing the impact of oil price distortion results show that 1 there is positive oil price distortion over 2004 2016 2 substitute relationship is observed between oil and coal oil and electricity and the substitution relationship is affected by factor substitution 3 removing oil price distortion will reduce co2 emissions of china s transport sector by 599 million tons in the studying period policies should focus removing the impact of oil price distortion promoting electricity oil substitution and promoting capital energy substitution to mitigate co2 emissions

money demand during hyperinflation and stabilization bulgaria 1991 2000 the demand for money in bulgaria is estimated over a ten year period 1991 2000 of high inflation and inflation uncertainty the paper distinguishes between three well defined sub periods high variable but not systematically accelerating inflation from 1991 until april 1996 the near hyperinflation period from may 1996 to february 1997 and the subsequent stabilization after the adoption of a currency board the empirical analysis utilizes a standard methodology of cointegration and error correction the functional determinants of the demand for money change during the different sub periods during the hyperinflation episode cagan s model is employed

can energy price regulations smooth price fluctuations evidence from china s coal sector abstract due to the dominance of coal in china s energy mix coal prices have always been a challenging part of pricing reform the recent frequent government interventions raise the key research questions what is the actual impact of price policies on coal price fluctuations and how can forward looking pricing policies be made by proposing a novel classification of coal pricing policies and introducing an expectation and forward looking coefficient the paper examines the relationship between coal price fluctuations and pricing policies using the generalized method of moments gmm method it shows that the lagging coal price and coal demand play a positive role in regulating coal prices while coal supply and marketization have significantly negative effects on coal price fluctuations the heterogeneous impacts of price policies are due to differences in market players expectations policy instruments and the methods of policy release in addition china s coal pricing policy portfolio from 2013 to 2016 exerted synergy effects on the restraint of coal price fluctuations as the forward looking coefficient was considerably low the government s intervention behaviors were obviously biased towards ex post facto responses the paper suggests short run and long run policies to advance marketization of coal prices amid the energy transition

energy price regulatory price distortion and economic growth a case study of china energy prices are often distorted by government control which is justified on the grounds that such control will help mitigate the negative impact of price volatility from oil imports and thus positively affect the domestic economy in this paper we show in a two sector growth model that regulatory price distortion can negatively affect the economy and then based on the model we empirically estimate the impact of the price distortion on output growth in china using monthly time series data from 2005m1 to 2012m12 in contrast to the usual argument for regulatory control to mitigate price volatility we find that regulatory price distortion negatively affects output growth in china during both the short and long term because it is robust to different measures of output and price distortion hence the argument that using price regulation to protect economic growth is undermined and subsequently this study lends its support to energy price deregulation a market oriented energy price regime may improve the resilience of the domestic economy to global oil price shocks

money demand during hyperinflation and stabilization bolivia 1980 1988 i introduction the stability of demand for money equations has been at issue in both econometric research and policy analysis the academic debates about the relative merits of the traditional buffer stock and the error correction models of demand for money have centered on parameter stability 1 in policy discussion the scope for remonetization following stabilization depends on the upward shift in the demand for money and the consequent predictability of higher money demand with lower rates of inflation 2 only an increased demand for money would make further credit expansion non inflationary inflation uncertainty has a pervasive effect in the money price nexus high inflation uncertainty makes money a riskier asset depressing the demand for money on a long term and possibly short term basis this impact on the demand for money means that policies influencing inflation will have an additional effect through their impact on inflation uncertainty as well as on expected inflation this paper examines the role of inflation uncertainty in a dramatic case study bolivia during the 1980s this was a decade of extreme macroeconomic instability annual inflation rates reached over 20 000 percent motivating a subsequent stabilization which drove annual inflation rates down to less than 25 percent where they have remained for more than five years perhaps more than any other country in recent history bolivia has undergone a dramatic structural shift in its macroeconomic policy regime to what extent did the demand for money shift during this period in its sensitivity to expected inflation inflation uncertainty and to underlying monetary disequilibria as the inflation stabilization progressed how fast did the money demand parameters react to this new regime change was there scope for remonetization in bolivia following the now famous stabilization plan of august 1985 the new economic plan introduced by president victor paz estenssoro 3 previous literature on the demand for money has explored the role of inflation uncertainty with ambiguous results 4 klein 1977 observed that inflation rate uncertainty reduced the average and marginal productivity of real cash balances in providing monetary services effectively a greater volume of real cash balances is required to obtain the same quality adjusted level of cash balances while the impact on the demand for money is theoretically uncertain because the income and substitution effects work in opposite directions klein provided empirical evidence that inflation uncertainty measured by a moving five year variance around a moving ten year trend with data from 1880 to 1972 actually increased the demand for money in the united states around the same time boonekamp 1978 presented a two period mean variance model of money and bond demand highlighting the potential importance of a hedging role in the demand for money in the face of inflation uncertainty related to aspects of both of these two approaches and working with a capital asset pricing model capm sweeney 1988 drew on university of michigan survey data on inflationary expectations to resolve the theoretical ambiguity of the impact of inflation uncertainty his results based on post war quarterly u s data contrasted with those of klein by showing a negative impact of inflation uncertainty on money demand in his study of the demand for money in the six hyperinflations originally examined by cagan 1956 khan 1977 measured inflation uncertainty by the absolute value of the change in inflation his model assumed that inflation uncertainty would affect the demand for money not directly but by altering the adaptive expectations parameter in the adjustment of inflation expectations his empirical estimates implied a negative impact of inflation uncertainty on the demand for money during accelerating inflation engle 1982 introduced the concept of arch autoregressive conditional heteroskedastic models with a specific application to inflation expectations

credibility and stabilization the paper deals with stabilization as a one shot problem to ask what credibility means in a world where programs will succeed with probability one a model is spelled out where the equilibrium program has some ex ante probability of failure the model draws attention to the factors that raise or lower the probability of success of a stabilization program and thus offers a positive theory of stabilization reputation that emerges as a central element in repeated games has no role in this model