natural resources curse or blessing are natural resources a curse or a blessing the empirical evidence suggests that either outcome is possible this paper surveys a variety of hypotheses and supporting evidence for why some countries benefit and others lose from the presence of natural resources these include that a resource bonanza induces appreciation of the real exchange rate deindustrialization and bad growth prospects and that these adverse effects are more severe in volatile countries with bad institutions and lack of rule of law corruption presidential democracies and underdeveloped financial systems another hypothesis is that a resource boom reinforces rent grabbing and civil conflict especially if institutions are bad induces corruption especially in nondemocratic countries and keeps in place bad policies finally resource rich developing economies seem unable to successfully convert their depleting exhaustible resources into other productive assets the survey also offers some welfare based fiscal rules for harnessing resource windfalls in developed and developing economies

the long term consequences of resource based specialisation using geological variation in oil abundance in the southern us i examine the long term effects of resource based specialisation through economic channels in 1890 oil abundant counties were similar to other nearby counties but after oil was discovered they began to specialise in its production from 1940 90 oil abundance increased local employment per square kilometre especially in mining but also in manufacturing oil abundant counties had higher population growth higher per capita income and better infrastructure 2010 the author s the economic journal 2010 royal economic society

the big push natural resource booms and growth a simple application of big push reasoning suggests that natural resource booms can be important catalysts for development in poorer countries in this paper we present evidence from seven latin american countries that natural resource booms are sometimes accompa nied by declining per capita gdp we present a model with natural resources increasing returns in the spirit of big push models and expectations to clarify some of the reasons this may happen q 1999 elsevier science b v all rights reserved

health and democracy in spite of the inexorable march of democracy around the globe just how democratic institutions a ect human well being is open to debate the evidence that democracy promotes prosperity is neither strong nor robust moreover which aspects of policy making and human well being are promoted by democracies is still a subject of debate 1 even if correlations between democracy and outcome measures can be found there is an overriding di culty of interpreting them as causal e ects whether democracy matters per se or simply serves as a proxy for societal and political development presents a di cult problem for research in this area thinkers such as lipset 1959 have argued that democracy can thrive only when conditions are right if this is correct then becoming democratic may only serve as a proxy for these hard to measure cultural and societal preconditions this paper explores these issues further by reconsidering the link between democracy and health using panel data from a cross section of countries the

eliciting preferences for collectively financed health programmes the willingness to assign approach improving public involvement in health system decision making stands as a primary health policy goal however still limited guidance is available on how best to elicit preferences for health care programmes this study examines a contingent choice technique to elicit preferences among health programmes and named willingness to assign wtas wtas reveals relative monetary based values of a set of competing public programmes under a hypothetical healthcare budget assessment experimental evidence is reported from a deliberative empirical study valuing ten health programmes in the context of the catalan health service evidence from this experimental study reveals that within the context of multiple programmes preferences are internally more consistent and slightly less affected by preference reversals as compared to values revealed from an adapted technique eliciting the willingness to pay wtp extra taxes another finding suggests that although programmes promoting health received the higher rel

the quantity and quality of life and the evolution of world inequality gdp per capita is usually used to proxy for the quality of life of individuals living in different countries welfare is also affected by quantity of life however as represented by longevity this paper incorporates longevity into an overall assessment of the evolution of cross country inequality and shows that it is quantitatively important the absence of reduction in cross country inequality up to the 1990s documented in previous work is in stark contrast to the reduction in inequality after incorporating gains in longevity throughout the post world war ii period health contributed to reduce significantly welfare inequality across countries this paper derives valuation formulas for infra marginal changes in longevity and computes a full growth rate that incorporates the gains in health experienced by 96 countries for the period between 1960 and 2000 incorporating longevity gains changes traditional results countries starting with lower income tended to grow faster than countries starting with higher income we estimate an average yearly growth in full income of 4 1 percent for the poorest 50 percent of countries in 1960 of which 1 7 percentage points are due to health as opposed to a growth of 2 6 percent for the richest 50 percent of countries of which only 0 4 percentage points are due to health additionally we decompose changes in life expectancy into changes attributable to 13 broad groups of causes of death and three age groups we show that mortality from infectious respiratory and digestive diseases congenital perinatal and ill defined conditions mostly concentrated before age 20 and between ages 20 and 50 is responsible for most of the reduction in life expectancy inequality at the same time the recent effect of aids together with reductions in mortality after age 50 due to nervous system senses organs heart and circulatory diseases contributed to increase health inequality across countries

is environmental policy a secondary trade barrier an empirical analysis should international trade agreements be extended to include negotiations over environmental policy the answer depends on whether countries distort levels of environmental regulations as a secondary means of providing protection to domestic industries our results suggest that they do previous studies of this relationship have treated the level of environmental regulation as exogenous and found a negligible correlation between environmental regulation and trade flows in contrast we find that when the level of environmental regulation is modelled as an endogenous variable its estimated effect on trade flows is significantly higher than previously reported jel classification fl f14 f18 est ce que la politique environnementale est une barriere commerciale secondaire une analyse empirique est ce que les accords commerciaux internationaux doivent etre etendus pour couvrir la politique environnementale la reponse depend du degre de distorsion que les pays introduisent dans leur politique environnementale pour proteger leurs industries nationales nos resultats suggerent que cet impact est important des etudes anterieures de cette relation ont traite la politique environnementale comme exogene et ont montre qu il existe une co relation negligeable entre politique envir onnementale et flux commerciaux au contraire nous revelons que quand la politique environnementale est consideree comme variable endoge ne son effet sur les flux com merciaux est plus eleve de maniere significative que ce qu on a note anterieurement

do giant oilfield discoveries fuel internal armed conflicts we use new data to examine the effects of giant oilfield discoveries around the world since 1946 on average these discoveries increase per capita oil production and oil exports by up to 50 percent but these giant oilfield discoveries also have a dark side they increase the incidence of internal armed conflict by about 5 8 percentage points this increased incidence of conflict due to giant oilfield discoveries is especially high for countries that had already experienced armed conflicts or coups in the decade prior to discovery

on environmental federalism and direct emission control abstract a theoretical exception to the race to the bottom contends that if decentralized environmental policy is comprised of direct controls on each firm emissions standards are set too high when compared to a centralized optimum herein we examine potential distortions in decentralized decision making by reconciling two recent views of direct environmental controls we show that differences in direct control policy can arise from differences in the number of symmetric jurisdictions in an economy our results suggest the race is on once the number of jurisdictions competing for a fixed number of firms increase we see the race is off when few jurisdictions can exploit their form of environmental market power

resource curse or not a question of appropriability this thesis presents three self contained essays focusing on empirical questions in growth and development economics each article addresses specific questions on why countries perform differently in particular i analyse the effect of democracy on economic development the relationship between natural resources and growth and the efficiency of foreign development assistance in the first essay democracy consolidation and growth i analyse the effect of democracy on economic growth in this context i argue that an important aspect to consider is how consolidated political systems are put simply i find that it is not only a question of how democratic countries are but also how long they have been democratic in other words economic performance tends to improve with the duration of uninterrupted democracy the performance of autocracies on the other hand tends to deteriorate over time however for newly established political systems there seems to be a cost of being democratic this implies that democracies only bear their fruit after some time the analysis has important policy implications to overcome initial straits international assistance focused on democratic consolidation may be important and a very good investment in fostering long run development the second essay resource curse or not a question of appropriability together with anne boschini and jesper roine is concerned with the relation between natural resources and economic development for most laymen as well as for most economists it would seem reasonable that countries richly endowed in natural resources also benefit from this wealth however a large literature has found a systematic negative effect of natural resource abundance on economic growth we suggest that this so called resource curse is not determined by resource endowments alone but rather by the interaction between the type of resources a country possesses and the quality of institutions in the country this combination of factors determines what we call the appropriability of a resource the concept of appropriability captures the likelihood of natural resources leading to rentseeking corruption or conflicts which in turn will harm economic development our results suggest that if institutions are good enough the curse may be turned into a blessing this may explain why some countries such as norway and botswana tend to benefit from their resources while others such as angola and sierra leone do not the third and final essay of this thesis foreign sectoral aid fungibility growth and poverty reduction is a contribution to the aid efficiency literature which is concerned with the question of whether aid helps or hinders economic development foreign development assistance is often targeted on specific public expenditure sectors if this aid is not used in the sector for which it was granted e g health education it is said to be fungible and donors may end up financing something completely different from what they intended e g military expenditures the major concern about sectoral fungibility is that the alternative use of aid may be less productive or less socially useful however measuring fungibility is not sufficient to determine whether foreign sectoral aid fungibility is actually harmful what is important is how the funds treated as fungible are used the essay starts by obtaining estimates of fungibility for 57 countries the results suggest that sectoral aid is indeed largely treated as fungible by recipient countries next to assess the economic and health effects of fungibility these estimates are incorporated into an empirical model of aid and growth as well as into a model of aid and infant mortality altogether i find no evidence of more fungible sectoral aid leading to worse performance

willingness to pay for publicly financed health care how should we use the numbers this paper addresses the question of how willingness to pay wtp values in health care evaluation can be used by policy makers the way in which wtp values are used depends on from whom values are elicited and whether the good concerned is privately financed or publicly financed through taxation thus four possible uses of wtp values are identified the focus is on the two uses which arise in the publiclyfinanced situation conventional use of wtp values where the decision as to whether or not to provide a service depends upon whether or not wtp values are greater than total cost applies only in the privately financed and not publiclyfinanced situations the situations with publicly financed goods are more complex the use of wtp values for publicly financed goods is justified and illustrated

news shocks in open economies evidence from giant oil discoveries this article explores the effect of news shocks in open economies using worldwide giant oil and gas discoveries as a directly observable measure of news shocks about future output the delay between a discovery and production is on average four to six years we first analyze the effects of a discovery in a two sector small open economy model with a resource sector we then estimate the effects of giant oil and gas discoveries on a large panel of countries our empirical estimates are consistent with the predictions of the model after an oil or gas discovery the current account and saving rate decline for the first five years and then rise sharply during the ensuing years investment rises robustly soon after the news arrives whereas gdp does not increase until after five years employment rates fall slightly and remain low for a sustained period

the paradox of plenty a meta analysis since sachs and warner s seminal article in 1995 numerous studies have addressed the link between natural resources and economic growth although the resource curse effect was commonly accepted at first many articles have challenged its existence and the results found in the literature are ambiguous in this paper we aim to quantitatively review this literature in order to i identify the sources of heterogeneity and ii assess the impact of natural resources on economic growth a meta analysis is performed on 69 empirical studies on the resource curse totaling 1 419 estimates our findings show that i only developing countries suffer from the resource curse although it is soft ii the way natural resources are taken into account is crucial to understand the heterogeneity found in the literature iii the negative impact of the volatility of the terms of trade on growth should be qualified an additional mra performed on indirect effects size also indicate that when institutions are at their best level the resource curse disappears and may be turned into a blessing

oil growth and health what does the cross country evidence really show we show that previous results from the body of literature on the resource curse have primarily been driven by the collapse in oil prices during the mid 1980s by exploiting cross country variations in the size of initial oil endowments and the timing of oil discoveries we find that there is a stable positive relationship between oil abundance and long run economic growth using dynamic panel data methods we also find that there is no evidence that higher oil rents hinder growth however to focus on material gain means that the welfare gain from oil is understated because oil rich countries benefit more by the reduction in infant mortality and the gain in longevity interestingly such oil led health improvements are more pronounced in non democratic countries where initial heath conditions were poor and oil wealth is concentrated among the ruling elites

oil governance and the mis allocation of talent in developing countries this paper sheds light on the relationship between oil rent and the allocation of talent toward rent seeking versus more productive activities conditional on the quality of institutions using a sample of 69 developing countries we demonstrate that oil resources orient university students toward specializations that provide better future access to rents when institutions are weak the results are robust to various specifications datasets on governance quality and estimation methods oil affects the demand for each profession through a technological effect indicating complementarity between oil and engineering manufacturing and construction however it also increases the size of the cake therefore when institutions are weak oil increases the incentive to opt for professions with better access to rents law business and the social sciences rather than careers in engineering creating a deviation from the optimal allocation between the two types of specialization

footloose and pollution free in numerous studies economists have found little empirical evidence that environmental regulations affect trade flows in this paper we propose and test several common explanations for why the effect of environmental regulations on trade may be difficult to detect we demonstrate that whereas most trade occurs among industrialized economies environmental regulations have stronger effects on trade between industrialized and developing economies we find that for most industries pollution abatement costs are a small component of total costs and are unrelated to trade flows in addition we show that those industries with the largest pollution abatement costs also happen to be the least geographically mobile or footloose after accounting for these distinctions we measure a significant effect of pollution abatement costs on imports from developing countries and in pollution intensive footloose industries

natural resources and economic growth a meta analysis summary an important question in development studies is how natural resources richness affects long term economic growth no consensus answer however has yet emerged with approximately 40 of empirical papers finding a negative effect 40 finding no effect and 20 finding a positive effect does the literature taken together imply the existence of the so called natural resource curse in a quantitative survey of 605 estimates reported in 43 studies we find that overall support for the resource curse hypothesis is weak when potential publication bias and method heterogeneity are taken into account our results also suggest that four aspects of study design are especially effective in explaining the differences in results across studies 1 controlling for institutional quality 2 controlling for the level of investment activity 3 distinguishing between different types of natural resources and 4 differentiating between resource dependence and abundance

debt relief for poor countries conditionality and effectiveness this paper studies the effectiveness of debt relief to stimulate economic growth in the most heavily indebted poor countries we develop a neoclassical framework with a conflict of interest between the altruistic donor and the recipient government and model conditionality as an imperfectly enforceable dynamic contract in contrast to the recent practice of fully cancelling debt optimal incentive compatible conditionality is accompanied by a concessionality level that implies a combination of subsidized loans and outright grants the optimal concessionality level depends on the recipient s access to international financial markets and on the strength of the conflict of interest incentive compatible transfers with optimal concessionality levels generate substantial welfare gains if the donor does not implement the optimal concessionality level and provides subsidized loans only then the effectiveness of transfers decreases in the long run with severe welfare implications in contrast transfers are less effective in the short run if the donor offers outright grants only

fdi income and environmental pollution in latin america replication and extension using panel quantiles regression analysis abstract this paper replicates estimates according to sapkota and bastola 2017 and provides additional insights for the relationship between foreign direct investment fdi income and environmental pollution in latin america to this end we address the heterogeneity in terms of economic development and environmental pollution heterogeneity that characterize the retained group of countries our panel quantiles regression analysis conducted for 14 latin america countries over the period 1980 to 2010 shows that fdi has no clear impact on pollution while the ekc hypothesis is called into question for the low income group of countries while our results partially validate the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis they contrast with those reported by sapkota and bastola 2017 for the pollution haven hypothesis phh

using contingent valuation to elicit public preferences for water fluoridation the methods and results of a contingent valuation survey to elicit public preferences for water fluoridation are reported the study demonstrates that not only is it important to acknowledge that there will be losers from the introduction of such a programme but that losers must be allowed to express a value for the magnitude of their perceived loss two methods of valuing this loss are explored conventional willingness to accept compensation questions are compared with questions in which losers are asked to state their willingness to pay to prevent their water being fluoridated the results provide tentative support for asking willingness to pay to prevent questions instead of willingness to accept questions when evaluating certain types of public good the issue of protest responses in contingent valuation surveys is also highlighted and discussed

determinants of pollution abatement in developing countries evidence from south and southeast asia abstract developing countries pa ticularly those in asia are fast adopting industrial pollution control standards similar to those in developed countries formal regulation has been greatly hampered however by the absence of clear and legally binding regulations limited institutional capacity lack of appropriate equipment and trained personnel and inadequate information on emissions one would predict highly pollution intensive production under such conditions our research however has uncovered strongly contradictory evidence despite weak or nonexistent formal regulation there are many clean plants in the developing countries of south and southeast asia of course there are also many plants which are among the world s most serious polluters what explains such extreme interplant variation this paper reviews evidence drawn from three empirical studies of plant level abatement practices conducted 1992 1994 the analyses test the importance of plant characteristics economic considerations and external pressure in determining environmental performance the results consistently show that pollution intensity is negatively associated with scale productive efficiency and the use of new process technology it is strongly and positively associated with public ownership but foreign ownership has no significant effect once other plant characteristics are taken into account among external sources of pressure community action or informal regulation emerges as a clear source of interplant differences in all three studies the results suggest that local income and education are powerful predictors of the effectiveness of informal regulation they also show that existing formal regulation has measurably beneficial effects even when it is quite weakly developed

applications of cost benefit analysis to health care departures from welfare economic theory in applying the principles of cost benefit analysis to real world problems of resource allocation particular care must be taken to ensure that the welfare economic theory which underlies the cost benefit technique is adhered to major problems arise where costs and benefits are used interchangeably to represent the good and bad attributes of a programme furthermore in the presence of mutually exclusive projects focussing attention upon the net benefits or cost benefit ratios of individual projects as opposed to the net benefits of the use of budgeted resources can lead to biased estimates of the shadow price of projects and consequently errors in analysts conclusions as a result economic appraisals of individual projects are not directly relevant for choosing between mutually exclusive projects of different sizes both types of problem are illustrated by reference to both simple examples and published economic appraisals of health care techniques integer programming is proposed and demonstrated as a method of selecting between mutually exclusive projects

natural resources rent seeking and welfare abstract a new and very simple mechanism to explain why natural resource abundance may lower income and welfare is developed in a model with rent seeking a greater amount of natural resources increases the number of entrepreneurs engaged in rent seeking and reduces the number of entrepreneurs running productive firms with a demand externality it is shown that the drop in income as a result of this is higher than the increase in income from the natural resource more natural resources thus lead to lower welfare

increasing returns and the genesis of american resource abundance the usa became the world s leading mineral producing nation between 1870 and 1910 a development paralleled by the rising resource intensity of american manufacturing this paper challenges the premise that resource abundance simply reflected the country s geological endowment of mineral deposits instead in the century following 1850 the usa exploited its natural resource potentials to a far greater extent than other countries and did so across virtually the entire range of industrial minerals the paper argues that natural resource abundance was an endogenous socially constructed condition that was not geologically preordained it examines the complex legal institutional technological and organizational adaptations that shaped the us supply responses to the expanding domestic and international industrial demands for minerals and mineral products it suggests that strong positive feedbacks even in the exploitation of depletable resources were responsible for the explosive growth of the american minerals economy

resource abundance and economic growth in the united states abstract it is a common assumption that regions within the same country converge to approximately the same steady state income levels the so called absolute convergence hypothesis focuses on initial income levels to account for the variability in income growth among regions empirical data seem to support the absolute convergence hypothesis for us states but the data also show that natural resource abundance is a significant negative determinant of growth we find that natural resource abundance decreases investment schooling openness and r d expenditure and increases corruption and we show that these effects can fully explain the negative effect of natural resource abundance on growth

the resource curse exorcised evidence from a panel of countries abstract this paper evaluates the impact of major natural resource discoveries since 1950 on gdp per capita using panel fixed effects estimation and resource discoveries in countries that were not previously resource rich as a plausibly exogenous source of variation i find a positive effect on gdp per capita levels following resource exploitation that persists in the long term results vary significantly between oecd and non oecd treatment countries with effects concentrated within the non oecd group i further test gdp effects with synthetic control analysis on each individual treated country yielding results consistent with the average effects found with the fixed effects model

ownership risk investment and the use of natural resources the effect of insecure ownership on ordinary investment and natural resource use is examined insecure ownership is postulated to depend on the type of government regime in power and the prevalence of political violence or instability the political determinants of economy wide investment are estimated from cross country data and the results are used to form an index of ownership security when introduced into empirical models of natural resource use this index has a significant and quantitatively important effect on the use of forests and petroleum contrary to conventional wisdom ownership risk slows resource use in some circumstances

oil and women a re examination abstract in a seminal article ross 2008 reports a negative correlation between oil production and women s representation in the labour force and politics across countries this article re examines these relationships exploiting variations in oil endowments to address endogeneity concerns we confirm that oil production causes decline in women s representation additionally we show that consistent with dutch disease effects oil production decreases women s employment in the traded sector however it also leads to an increase in women s employment in the nontraded sector we explore some social consequences of oil production and show that it results in women marrying earlier and having more children

pollution control and foreign direct investment in mexico an industry level analysis foreign direct investment fdi flows into developing countries have been increasing dramatically over the past decade at the same time there has been widespread concern that lax environmental standards are in part responsible for this surge this paper revisits the question of the existence of a pollution haven effect by examining the extent to which the pollution intensity of production helps explain fdi in mexico we focus on pollution intensities which are directly related to emission regulations rather than unobservable pollution taxes and allow for substitution between capital and pollution examining several different pollutants we find a positive correlation between fdi and pollution that is statistically and economically significant in the case of the highly regulated sulfur dioxide emissions industries for which the estimated relationship between fdi and pollution is positive receive up to 30 of total fdi and 30 of manufacturing output although we confirm the importance of mexico s comparative advantage in labor intensive production processes consistent with the previous literature our results suggest that environmental considerations may matter as well for firms investment decisions

more oil less democracy evidence from worldwide crude oil discoveries this article exploits variations in the timing and size of oil discoveries to identify the impact of oil wealth on democracy i find that discovering 100 billion barrels of oil approximately the initial endowment of iraq pushes a country s democracy level almost 20 percentage points below trend after three decades the estimated effect is larger for oilfields with higher quality oil and lower exploration and extraction costs however the estimates become less precise when oil abundance is measured by oil discovery per capita suggesting politicians may care about the level instead of the per capita value of oil wealth

political foundations of the resource curse in this paper we argue that the political incentives that resource endowments generate are the key to understanding whether or not they are a curse we show 1 politicians tend to over extract natural resources relative to the efficient extraction path because they discount the future too much and 2 resource booms improve the efficiency of the extraction path however 3 resource booms by raising the value of being in power and by providing politicians with more resources which they can use to influence the outcome of elections increase resource misallocation in the rest of the economy 4 the overall impact of resource booms on the economy depends critically on institutions since these determine the extent to which political incentives map into policy outcomes countries with institutions that promote accountability and state competence will tend to benefit from resource booms since these institutions ameliorate the perverse political incentives that such booms create countries without such institutions however may suffer from a resource curse

international investment location decisions abstract in international location tournaments governments compete for foreign investment with tax and other short run incentives such tournaments can be won if agglomeration economies are sufficiently powerful to overcome investors desire to spread investments as a hedge against risk we focus on manufacturing investments by u s multinationals in the 1980s our econometric results suggest that agglomeration economies are indeed the dominant influence on investor calculations paradoxically short run incentives have limited apparent impact on location choice we conclude that high cost tournament play is unnecessary for countries with good infrastructure development specialized input suppliers and an expanding domestic market

mining away the preston curve summary i estimate the long term national health and education impacts of having a larger mining share in the economy by instrumenting the relative size of the mining sector with the natural geological variation in countries fossil fuel endowments i provide evidence suggestive of a causal relationship the findings suggest that countries with larger mining shares tend to have poorer health and education outcomes than countries with similar per capita incomes geographic characteristics and institutional quality doubling the mining share of an economy corresponds to on average the infant death rate being 20 higher life expectancy being 5 lower total years of education being 20 lower and 70 more people having no formal education divergences from the preston curve the concave relationship between cross country income and life expectancy that has long been of interest to economists demographers and epidemiologists are thus partly explained by the size of the mining sector within country evidence from indonesia paints a similar picture my results provide support for a growing body of evidence linking mining to poorer average living standards particularly vis a vis other types of income i also estimate the effects of national mining dependence on non mining income health and education investment and institutions

the elusive curse of oil abstract our goal is to show that contrary to the claims made in several recent papers the effect of a large endowment of oil and other mineral resources on long term economic growth of countries has been on balance positive moreover the claims of a negative effect of oil and mineral wealth on the countries institutions are called into question