comparing the performance of health care systems an alternative approach the health care system in the united states has been diagnosed as a moribund institution by a large number of media commentators and health policy analysts continually rising health care costs and inadequate health insurance coverage for approximately thirty seven million people are cited as two of the most visible symptoms supporting their diagnosis most of these individuals see little chance for the u s health care system to recover given its present design full recovery they believe requires the successful transplant of a health care system from another country the health care systems in europe and canada where government is assigned a much larger role than in the united states are argued to offer universal health care coverage and simultaneously contain health care costs simple comparative statistics appear to support the view that the performance of the u s health care system could be improved through a new health care system design infant mortality in the united states ranked twentieth among twenty four member countries of the organization for economic cooperation and development oecd in 1988 yet health care expenditures in the united states comprised 11 8 percent of gross domestic product in 1989 while the comparable average for all oecd countries was only 7 4 percent 28 these statistics portray the u s health care system as being deficient and therefore unable to offer quality medical services at a reasonable price given the limited stock of information that exists on this issue however it is ill advised to place full blame for the seemingly dismal performance on the u s health care system the simple international comparisons fail to take into account that differences in performance are not solely due to variations in health care systems while the design of a health care system including the financing scheme reimbursement method and organization of production is indeed important because it influences how various economic technological and demographic characteristics of a country are transformed into health outcomes the performance of the health care system also depends on the magnitude of these national characteristics as well a proper analysis would try to determine how the health care system itself specifically influences the performance of health

a cluster analysis on income elasticity variations and us pharmaceutical expenditures this paper examines the relationship between household income and outpatient prescribed medicines in the usa based on a sample of 2872 privately insured patients from the 1987 nmes data set the analysis is performed on regional typologies of different socioeconomic profiles of patients only a few groups show positive income elasticity

drivers for the use of materials across countries abstract this paper analyses drivers for resource use and material productivity across countries this is not only relevant in light of soaring raw material prices but also because eu policies such as the thematic strategy on the sustainable use of natural resources com 2005 670 the eu raw materials initiative com 2008 699 and various similar policies internationally seek to better manage materials along their life cycle and across economies in order to better understand the system dynamics of material use our paper applies methodologies of material flow analysis and regression analysis to identify the major drivers for resource use and decoupling from gdp drivers are understood as those factors that exert influence on human activities to use resources a panel data set is taken for the european union for the years 1980 2000 eu 15 and 1992 2000 eu 25 the main drivers of resource use were found to be energy efficiency new dwellings and roads construction activities shortcomings of the methodology are also discussed

valuing option existence and bequest demands for wilderness to assess the relative importance of current costs and future benefits of nuclear waste storage we develop a simple model of bequest value the basic model of nonparternalistic altruism is extended to account for the uncertain nature of the externality

the econometrics of the environmental kuznets curve an illustration using australian co2 emissions four econometric issues associated with the estimation and testing of the environmental kuznets curve ekc are considered i model specification with respect to the order of the polynomial ii

carbon dioxide emissions and economic growth panel data evidence from developing countries in this paper we test the environment kuznet s curve ekc hypothesis for 43 developing countries we suggest examining the ekc hypothesis based on the short and long run income elasticities that is if the long run income elasticity is smaller than the short run income elasticity then it is evident that a country has reduced carbon dioxide emissions as its income has increased our empirical analysis based on individual countries suggests that jordan iraq kuwait yemen qatar the uae argentina mexico venezuela algeria kenya nigeria congo ghana and south africa approximately 35 per cent of the sample carbon dioxide emissions have fallen over the long run that is as these economies have grown emissions have fallen since the long run income elasticity is smaller than the short run elasticity we also examine the ekc hypothesis for panels of countries constructed on the basis of regional location using the panel cointegration and the panel long run estimation techniques we find that only for the middle eastern and south asian panels the income elasticity in the long run is smaller than the short run implying that carbon dioxide emission has fallen with a rise in income

material flow accounting in an irish city region 1992 2002 abstract this paper aims to measure raw material inputs and waste flows in an irish city region in order to analyse i whether there was absolute dematerialisation in the particular case study over the period 1992 2002 and ii whether material consumption and waste generation were decoupled from economic growth and increases in disposable income over the same period it was found that the selected material flow indicators showed no evidence of absolute dematerialisation over the given study period although more recent evidence at the national level suggests that a decline in construction activity and extraction of non metallic minerals has resulted in an absolute reduction in material consumption and it is likely that this will be mirrored at the system boundary level it was found that domestic material consumption dmc per capita and direct material input dmi per capita increased at a faster rate than domestic processed output dpo per capita and direct material output dmo per capita between 1992 and 2002 which indicates relative decoupling of consumption from waste generation in addition it was found that there was relative decoupling of consumption and waste generation from disposable income growth over the study period finally it was found that average dmc and dmi figures for the selected case study were lower than the national averages but broadly similar to results for other city regions in the european union eu on a methodological note it was concluded that material flow accounting mfa for city regions in ireland is constrained due to a lack of disaggregated data for material flows with the exception of local waste data and it is recommended that bottom up analysis should be used to complement disaggregated top down data

environmental kuznets curves real progress or passing the buck abstract recent research has examined the hypothesis of an environmental kuznets curve ekc the notion that environmental impact increases in the early stages of development followed by declines in the later stages these studies have focused on the relationship between per capita income and a variety of environmental indicators results imply that ekcs may exist for a number of cases however the measures of environmental impact used generally focus on production processes and reflect environmental impacts that are local in nature and for which abatement is relatively inexpensive in terms of monetary costs and or lifestyle changes significantly more consumption based measures such co2 emissions and municipal waste for which impacts are relatively easy to externalize or costly to control show no tendency to decline with increasing per capita income by considering consumption and trade patterns the author re examines the concept of the ekc and proposes the use of alternative consumption based measures of environmental impact the author speculates that what appear to be improvements in environmental quality may in reality be indicators of increased ability of consumers in wealthy nations to distance themselves from the environmental degradation associated with their consumption

how economic growth affects emissions an investigation of the environmental kuznets curve in portuguese and spanish economic activity sectors abstract it is a disquieting reality that increased economic growth for many years now in the western world is at odds with environmental degradation in this paper the relationship between economic growth and environmental variables is analyzed under two non linear specifications a quadratic and a cubic specification the study is conducted for portugal and spain in the period 1975 2012 using data for 13 sectors gva is used as proxy for income while energy use and carbon dioxide account for environmental degradation there is evidence for an inverted u shaped ekc however there are also other inverted n shaped functions that explain the relationship between economic growth and emissions altogether empirical results do indicate particular differences between portuguese and spanish sectors the results are of interest not only for researchers but also for policy makers political mitigation measures are also analyzed

economic growth and emissions reconsidering the empirical basis of environmental kuznets curves abstract recent empirical research indicates that certain types of emissions follow an inverted u or environmental kuznets curve ekc as income grows this regularity has been interpreted as a possible de linking of economic growth and patterns of certain pollutants for developed economies in this paper the empirical basis of this result is investigated by considering some statistical particularities of the various ekc studies performed it is argued that the inverted u relationship between income and emissions estimated from panel data need not hold for specific individual countries over time based on insights from intensity of use analysis in resource economics an alternative growth model is specified and estimated for three types of emissions co2 nox and so2 in four countries netherlands uk usa and western germany it is found that the time patterns of these emissions correlate positively with economic growth and that emission reductions may have been achieved as a result of structural and technological changes in the economy sustainable growth is defined as the rate of economic growth that does not lead to growth in emissions its rate is calculated for each type of emission and country based on estimated parameter values the resulting indicators reflect a balance between the positive influence of growth and negative influence of structural change and technological progress on emission levels

energy consumption economic growth and carbon emissions challenges faced by an eu candidate member abstract this paper investigates the long run granger causality relationship between economic growth carbon dioxide emissions and energy consumption in turkey controlling for gross fixed capital formation and labor the most interesting result is that carbon emissions seem to granger cause energy consumption but the reverse is not true the lack of a long run causal link between income and emissions may be implying that to reduce carbon emissions turkey does not have to forgo economic growth

price and quantity in international comparisons of health care expenditure an important omission from earlier cross national comparisons of health care expenditure has been the failure to distinguish between price and quantity using recent data on purchasing power parities the purpose of this article is to report some preliminary results regarding health care expenditure and quantity across 22 oecd countries the article concludes that contrary to what has been suggested in some recent articles the relative price of health care is not correlated to the aggregate per capita income the fraction of the national income that is devoted to health care provision increases with the per capita income regardless of whether health care is measured in terms of expenditure or quantity the relative price of health care has a rationing effect on the quantity of health care that is offered with a price alasticity close to minus one the latter finding means that the health care expenditure is not greater in countries with higherprices furthermore the differences in health care expendit

resource compensation and negotiation support in an aboriginal context using community based multi attribute analysis to evaluate non market losses abstract compensation for losses of non market values experienced by aboriginal peoples due to adverse impacts on their land or resource base caused by others is an important issue for law and social justice yet the standard methods of economic valuation as a basis for determining compensation are not always suited to addressing the diverse values of aboriginal people this paper discusses an approach to valuation that employs concepts and methods of decision analysis informed by behavioral decision research in an applied context it uses a multi attribute value assessment as a basis for characterizing the relative significance of resource damages that affect deeply held complex intangible values we draw on the experience of conducting analyses for three metis settlements in alberta canada to illustrate the approach using a case study interpretations of the results as a basis for negotiation regarding compensation are examined

international comparison of resource use and its relation to economic growth the development of total material requirement direct material inputs and hidden flows and the structure of tmr abstract resource flows constitute the materials basis of the economy at the same time they carry and induce an environmental burden associated with resource extraction and the subsequent material flows and stocks which finally end up as waste and emissions a reduction of this material throughput and the related impacts would require a reduction of resource inputs and breaking the link between resource consumption and economic growth would require an increase in resource productivity material flow analysis mfa can be used to quantify resource flows and indicate resource productivity in this article we study the available empirical evidence on the actual de linkage of material resource use and economic growth we compare resource use with respect to total material requirement tmr and direct material input dmi for 11 and 26 countries respectively and the european union eu 15 the dynamics of tmr as well as of the main components are analysed in relation to economic growth in order to show whether there is a decoupling relative or absolute from gdp and a change of the metabolic structure in the course of economic development dmi cap so far only decoupled from gdp cap in relative terms that is in most countries it reached a rather constant level but with the exception of czech republic showed no absolute decline yet tmr cap was reduced in two high income countries and one low income country due to political influence changes in tmr were more influenced by hidden flows hf than by dmi we analyse the dynamics of the structure and composition of tmr in the course of economic development in general the economic development of industrial countries was accompanied by a shift from domestic to foreign resource extraction different relations can be discovered for the share of biomass fossil fuel resources construction resources and metals and industrial minerals

non renewable and renewable energy consumption and co2 emissions in oecd countries a comparative analysis abstract this paper attempts to explore the determinants of co 2 emissions using the stirpat model and data from 1980 to 2011 for oecd countries the empirical results show that non renewable energy consumption increases co 2 emissions whereas renewable energy consumption decreases co 2 emissions further the results support the existence of an environmental kuznets curve between urbanisation and co 2 emissions implying that at higher levels of urbanisation the environmental impact decreases therefore the overall evidence suggests that policy makers should focus on urban planning as well as clean energy development to make substantial contributions to both reducing non renewable energy use and mitigating climate change

why are services cheaper in the poor countries in their important work on international comparisons of national incomes and of comparative price structure kravis heston and summers i982 p 8 have noted that services are much cheaper in the relative price structure of a typical poor country than in that of a rich country this phenonomen has been documented now fairly systematically by the data gathered under their guiding hand of the united nations international comparison icp which covers 34 countries table i reproduced from their work i982 and fig i based on rows 3 and ii 13 indeed show this tendencyfor the relationship between relative service prices and real per capita gdp in this kravis heston summers 34 country 6 group sample the tendency is strongly evident except for the intermediate groups iii and iv

the impact of economic development and social political factors on ecological footprint a panel data analysis for 15 mena countries abstract this paper extends the work of al mulali and ozturk 2015 1 by re investigating the environment kuznets curve ekc hypothesis for 15 mena middle east and north african countries using the ecological footprint ef as a proxy of environmental degradation over the period 1975 2007 unlike the existing studies we augment the basic ekc relationship by considering life expectancy at birth fertility rate and political institutional index variables as new possible determinants of environmental degradation the estimation of this relationship has been conducted for all mena 15 countries for oil exporting and non oil exporting countries sub samples the results show that energy use worsens ecological footprint whereas real gdp per capita exhibits an inverted u shaped relationship with ef in oil exporting countries and in the sample as a whole i e the ekc hypothesis is validated for the non oil exporting countries the relationship between ef and economic growth is u shaped moreover our findings show that socio demographic variables such as urbanization life expectancy at birth and fertility rate improve the environment in the long term we also found that the improvement of political institutions in those countries has not been accompanied by a reduction of environmental stress the granger causality results support evidence of the existence of an error correction mechanism between the ef real gdp energy use and the fertility rate specifically in the short term we found strong evidence for bidirectional causality among the ecological real gdp and energy use variables

aggregate health care expenditures and national income is health care a luxury good it is well known that a strong relationship exists between national expenditures on health care and national income this has been used to suggest that health care is a luxury good and that factors such as the type of health care delivery system in a country are of little importance in determining expenditure levels this paper argues that these implications rely upon the application of microeconomic analysis to macroeconomic data and that this is not appropriate as well as raising questions about the inferences drawn from previous studies new empirical evidence is presented which casts some doubts on previous findings international comparisons are based on purchasing power parity rather than exchange rate conversions underlining the importance of prices as well as quantities in the relationship and leading to the conclusion that the aggregate data show health care to be if anything a necessity rather than a luxury good

natural resource valuation with a tribal perspective a case study of the penobscot nation the unique settings of tribal lands and preferences of tribal members can complicate the effective application of standard natural resource use valuation tools within these tribal settings we pres

giving respondents time to think in contingent valuation studies a developing country application abstract this paper evaluates whether the time given people to think about their responses to cvm valuation questions influences their answers our study was conducted in nigeria as part of an evaluation of rural households willingness to pay for public taps and private connections to improved drinking water systems respondents who were allowed time to evaluate the proposed water system bid significantly less than those who did not have that time moreover this conclusion was upheld regardless of whether the water system was a public tap or a private connection

dynamic linkages between globalization financial development and carbon emissions evidence from asia pacific economic cooperation countries abstract this study determines the dynamic linkages between globalization financial development and carbon emissions in asia pacific economic cooperation apec countries in the presence of energy intensity and economic growth under the framework of environment kuznets curve ekc this study employs the panel data from 1990 to 2016 westerlund cointegration technique to find long run cointegration and continuously updated bias corrected cup bc and continuously updated fully modified cup fm methods to check the long run elasticities between the variables empirical results indicate that globalization and financial development significantly reduce carbon emissions but economic growth and energy intensity increase them these results support the ekc hypothesis for apec countries the dumitrescu and hurlin causality analysis shows that globalization granger causes co2 emissions globalization also causes financial development and energy intensity a feedback effect exists between financial development and co2 emissions furthermore financial development causes economic growth but similar is not true from opposite side in granger sense finally this study presents important policy implications with respect to apec countries

energy consumption carbon emissions and economic growth nexus in bangladesh cointegration and dynamic causality analysis abstract the paper investigates the possible existence of dynamic causality between energy consumption electricity consumption carbon emissions and economic growth in bangladesh first we have tested cointegration relationships using the johansen bi variate cointegration model this is complemented with an analysis of an auto regressive distributed lag model to examine the results robustness then the granger short run the long run and strong causality are tested with a vector error correction modelling framework the results indicate that uni directional causality exists from energy consumption to economic growth both in the short and the long run while a bi directional long run causality exists between electricity consumption and economic growth but no causal relationship exists in short run the strong causality results indicate bi directional causality for both the cases a uni directional causality runs from energy consumption to co 2 emission for the short run but feedback causality exists in the long run co 2 granger causes economic growth both in the short and in the long run an important policy implication is that energy electricity as well can be considered as an important factor for the economic growth in bangladesh moreover as higher energy consumption also means higher pollution in the long run policy makers should stimulate alternative energy sources for meeting up the increasing energy demand

revisiting the environmental kuznets curve hypothesis evidence from the asean 5 countries with structural breaks abstractthis paper tests if the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis exists for asean 5 countries in an annual sample data that covers 1971 2013 by utilizing auto regressive distributed la

a new environmental kuznets curve relationship between direct material input and income per capita evidence from industrialised countries abstract many studies have focused on the quantification of the input of materials into the economy however the insights provided by those studies have generally been limited this paper attempts to bring analytical value to the discussion on dematerialization considering direct material input dmi per capita as the dependent variable in a test of the environmental kuznets curve ekc the explanatory variable is as usual gross domestic product per capita the quadratic and cubic versions of the ekc are tested econometrically using panel data ranging from 1960 to 1998 for 16 industrialised countries the results indicate a strong and robust support for both the quadratic and cubic ekc relationships between material input and income in industrialised economies while the statistical support to both types of evolution may seem contradictory it suggests that as industrialised economies grow the intensity of material consumption first increases but eventually starts exhibiting a decreasing trend after a certain income threshold is reached the inverted u or quadratic relationship is confirmed even though for the ranges of income considered in this study the trend is mostly on the increasing part of the inverted u curve however the statistical support to the cubic specification suggests that these results need to be regarded with caution overall the statistically stronger models are the quadratic and cubic models with country random effects and the cubic model with country and year fixed effects

the co2 emissions income nexus evidence from rich countries the paper attempts to test the environment kuznets curve ekc hypothesis for 36 high income countries for the period 1980 2005 the test is based on the suggestion of narayan and narayan 2010 various panel data unit root and co integration tests are applied carbon dioxide co2 emissions and gdp series are integrated of order one and co integrated especially after controlling for cross sectional dependence additionally the blundell bond system generalised methods of moments gmm is employed to conduct a panel causality test in a vector error correction mechanism vecm setting unidirectional causality running from real per capita gdp to per capita co2 emissions is uncovered in both the short run and the long run the empirical analysis based on individual countries provides evidence of an ekc for greece malta oman portugal and the united kingdom however it can be observed that for the whole panel a 1 increase in gdp generates an increase of 0 68 in co2 emissions in the short run and 0 22 in the long run the lower long run income elasticity does not provide evidence of an ekc but does indicate that over time co2 emissions are stabilising in the rich countries

internalizing co2 emissions via central banks financials evidence from the world researchers and policy makers have suggested tools to mitigate co2 emissions worldwide however there appears to be uncertainty in terms of policy effectiveness the objective of this paper is to develop an innovatively effective co2 internalizing mechanism worldwide which builds on currency in circulation as its core operational tool the study is based on a large sample of countries findings show that urbanization electric power consumption and trade positively impact on co2 emissions no evidence is found in favour of the environmental kuznets curve while the use of renewable energy reduces the level of co2 emissions the paper proposes a central bank carbon dioxide emissions internalizing fund which rests on quantitative and qualitative tools to ensure a truly effective mechanism in co2 emissions abatement quantitatively this implies the use of a direct tax on currency in circulation and a conversion penalty in the fund qualitatively there is the need to establish a global institution which would ensure that funds flow to the most polluting sectors in each country in view of unleashing the strongest decline in co2 emissions

conversion factor instability in international comparisons of health care expenditure parkin mcguire and yule 1987 hereafter pmy report that a regression of per capita health care expenditure on per capita income using different conversion factors exchange rates gdp ppps health ppps gave rise to different results in this note we apply updated data to the same empirical relationship in contrast to pmy we find no noticeable conversion factor instability in that relationship either with respect to the health care income elasticity or with the magnitude of multiple correlation coefficient

an econometric analysis of health care expenditure a cross section study of the oecd countries this paper is an empirical examination of the determinants of aggregate health care expenditure the paper presents a systematic analysis of relationships across 19 oecd countries showing the effects of aggregate income institutional and socio demographic factors on health care expenditure the results indicate that institutional factors of the health systems in addition to per capita gross domestic product gdp contribute significantly to the explanation of the health care expenditure variation between countries for example the way physicians in outpatient care are paid and the mixture of public private funding and inpatient outpatient care

quantifying u s aluminum in use stocks and their relationship with economic output abstract a dynamic material flow analysis model is developed to quantify aluminum in use stocks and old scrap recycling and recovery in the united states for the period of 1900 to 2007 the total in use aluminum stock in 2007 is estimated as 93 million metric tons which represents approximately 34 of the cumulative apparent consumption since 1900 alternately since 1900 nearly 40 of the cumulative discarded aluminum has not been recycled for domestic use in the u s or for export to foreign consumers statistical time series analysis is used to explore the relationship between model results of in use stocks and gross domestic product gdp unlike most previous studies of material consumption and economic activity which ignore the statistical properties of time series data to the detriment of model estimation and inference data stationarity is explicitly evaluated through unit root testing and model specification is adjusted accordingly the annual percentage change in gdp is found to have a large and significant association with the annual percentage change in net additions to in use stocks model sensitivity and uncertainty are quantified through the application of the fourier amplitude sensitivity test and alternate specifications of product lifetime probability density functions

system dynamics modelling and the environmental kuznets curve in ecuador 1980 2025 abstract is it possible for a country in the process of development to comply with the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis in the medium term this is the question that inspired this study this paper is an extension of a previous study focused on economic development and co2 emissions in the coming years in ecuador robalino lopez et al submitted for publication the main goal of this paper is to analyze whether the ekc hypothesis holds within the period 1980 2025 under four different scenarios this paper uses co integration techniques stock and watson 2010 to test the existence of the ekc hypothesis in ecuador in the medium term using jaunky s 2011 specification our proposal goes a step further than previous contributions and intends to see under which conditions a country could approach the fulfilment of this hypothesis in the medium term results do not support the fulfilment of the ekc nevertheless our estimations show that ecuador could be on the way to achieving environmental stabilization in the near future if economic growth is combined with an increase in the use of renewable energies an improvement of the productive sectoral structure and the use of a more efficient fossil fuel technology

income inequality and pollution a reassessment of the environmental kuznets curve abstract improvements in some measures of air and water quality can accompany rising per capita income as illustrated by the so called environmental kuznets curve for pollution variables which show such a relationship we hypothesize that a more equitable distribution of power contributes to these outcomes by enhancing the influence on policy of those who bear the costs of pollution relative to the influence of those who benefit from pollution generating activities an empirical analysis of international variations in seven indicators of air and water quality supports this hypothesis literacy political rights and civil liberties are found to have particularly strong effects on environmental quality in low income countries

energy consumption income and carbon emissions in the united states abstract this paper investigates the effect of energy consumption and output on carbon emissions in the united states earlier research focused on testing the existence and or shape of an environmental kuznets curve without taking energy consumption into account we investigate the granger causality relationship between income energy consumption and carbon emissions including labor and gross fixed capital formation in the model we find that income does not granger cause carbon emissions in the us in the long run but energy use does hence income growth by itself may not become a solution to environmental problems

environmental kuznets curve time series application for turkey why controversial results exist for similar models abstract this paper investigates the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis using 40 year spanned time series for the turkey case co 2 emission series representing environmental pressure and gdp per capita values representing economic development are used for the period 1968 2007 a cointegration has been determined among nonstationary series first phases of an inverted u form ekc relationship have been determined for turkey from the econometric estimations this result is conflicting with that of the similar models for turkey case on the other hand this conflict refers the important arguments in the literature and constitutes the main points of the paper sensitivity critiques for example ahking et al for cointegration tests johansen and engle granger tests have been supported in our study moreover we detected important diversion in results according to drift and trend assumptions both in ci vector and ekc model specifications we conclude that building ekc model according to cointegration ci equation restrictions can be important source for diversion when sensitivity exists in estimations and cointegration tests therefore ekc estimations should be held in non restrictive way the additional structural reasons have been also discussed for developing country ekc cases the most important one is that the narrow income sample of developing countries makes it possible to be defined by similar but different paths therefore policy implications to be drawn from those analyses should not ignore this feature of developing country analyses

low carbon scenarios for transport in india co benefits analysis abstract dependence on oil for transport is a concern for india s policymakers on three counts energy security local environment and climate change rapid urbanisation and accompanying motorisation has created some of the most polluting cities in india and rising demand for oil is leading to higher imports besides causing more co 2 emissions the government of india wants to achieve the climate goals through a sustainability approach that simultaneously addresses other environment and developmental challenges this paper analyses a sustainable low carbon transport slct scenario based on sustainable strategies for passenger and freight mobility vehicle technologies and fuel using global co 2 prices that correspond to 2 c global stabilisation target the scenarios span from years 2010 to 2050 and are analysed using the energy system model answer markal the slct scenario has improved energy security cumulative oil demand lower by 3100 mtoe improved air quality pm 2 5 emissions never exceed the existing levels and the cumulative co 2 emissions are lower by 13 billion t co 2 thereby showing that achieving development objectives with co 2 co benefits is feasible

values of gains and losses reference states and choice of measure the available empirical evidence continues to suggest that people commonly value losses more and often much more than otherwise commensurate gains consequently current practice of using the wtp measure for all changes is often likely to lead to misleading assessments of welfare changes the reference dependence of preferences implies instead that while the wtp measure is appropriate for gains the value of both positive and negative changes in the domain of losses will usually be more accurately assessed with the wta measure