the hausman macurdy controversy why do the results differ across studies the two perhaps most influential empirical labor supply studies carried out in the united states in recent years hausman 1981 and macurdy green and paarsch 1990 report sharply contradicting labor supply estimates in this paper we show that the seemingly irreconcilable views on the size of work disincentive effects and welfare losses can be attributed to the use of differing nonlabor income and wage measures in the two studies monte carlo experiments suggest that the wage measure adopted by macurdy green and paarsch 1990 might cause a severely downward biased wage effect such that data falsely refute the basic notion of utility maximization

organizational commitment in a mixed oligopoly agricultural cooperatives and investor owned firms a number of agricultural cooperativeorganizations prominent examples includetri valley growers and the saskatchewanwheat pool currently face considerable nancialand organizationalchallenges externally these challenges include a grow ing concentration in a number of sectors e g beef and pork packing and a greater preva lence of vertical integration and contracts internally cooperatives co ops encountergreater heterogeneity among members greater property rights problems cook anda decline in member commitment fulton1999 this latter factor has been cited asone reason for the declining market shareand poor nancialperformance of a numberof co ops fulton and gibbings the purpose of this article is to examinethe issue of member commitment in the con text of a mixed oligopoly where co ops andinvestor owned rms iofs compete witheach other in supplying a consumer good

an ecology of ideology theory and evidence from four populations this paper analyzes the founding rates of two types of jewish agricultural cooperatives the moshav and the kibbutz to show how political ideology intersects with resource requirements to produce competition and mutualism between organizations these two populations which share ideology and a resource base competed with each other they both enjoyed mutualism with the population of credit cooperatives which represented a kindred ideology but relied on different resources they both suffered competition from the population of corporations which represented a rival ideology capitalism copyright 2004 oxford university press

assessing policies to equalize opportunity using an equilibrium model of educational and occupational choices abstract the inter generational correlation of education in the u s is tremendous for instance in psid data from 1990 young males with college educated parents had a 70 chance of attending college but those with high school drop out parents had only a 15 chance in this paper we analyze the impact of college attendance bonus schemes designed to increase college attendance rates and pv of lifetime income of youth from disadvantaged backgrounds of course policies that increase the supply of skilled labor may reduce the college wage premium see heckman et al heckman james lochner lance and taber christopher explaining rising wage inequality explorations with a dynamic equilibrium model of labor earnings with heterogeneous agents review of economic dynamics 1 1998a 1 58 heckman james lochner lance and taber christopher general equilibrium treatment effects a study of tuition policy american economic review 88 2 1998b 381 386 this may have the unintended consequence of wiping out most of the gains to the targeted groups the strength of such equilibrium effects on wages depends on the substitutability between different types of labor thus it is important to evaluate education subsidies within an equilibrium framework that allows for flexible patterns of substitution across factor inputs this is exactly what we do here using an overlapping generations equilibrium model of the u s labor market fit to psid data from 1968 to 1996 the model allows for imperfect substitution among types of labor differentiated by education gender age and ten 1 digit level occupations a much finer differentiation than has been considered in prior work we find that very large college attendance bonuses are necessary to equate college attendance rates between youth whose parents had only high school degrees or were high school dropouts and youth whose parents attended at least some college the size of these bonuses far exceeds any reasonable measure of college costs suggesting the costs the bonuses overcome are primarily psychic or effort costs for example youth from disadvantaged backgrounds may be poorly prepared for college this suggests that bonuses targeted at college age youth are probably a very inefficient way to reduce inequality earlier intervention is likely called for

exchange rate rules and macroeconomic stability this paper discusses exchange rate rules in their role as macroeconomic instruments we abstract throughout from the trend part of exchange rate behaviour a crawling peg necessitated by differences in trend inflation and emphasise instead the implications of exchange rate rules in providing flexibility of real wages or in affecting the stability of output or prices

new evidence on labor supply employment versus hours elasticities by sex and marital status using the tri annual micro panel data of the survey of income and program participation we estimate fixed effects labor supply models separating the extensive and intensive margins the employment elasticity is 0 6 for single men versus 1 1 for married men the employment elasticity is 2 4 for single women versus 1 8 for married women the compensated hours worked elasticity is 0 4 for employed single and married men and 0 7 for employed single and married women the implied aggregate employment elasticity of 1 5 and hours per employee elasticity of 0 5 indicate employment fluctuations account for three fourths of wage induced variation in labor hours

exploring the effect of crisis on cooperatives a bayesian performance analysis of french craftsmen cooperatives the aim of this paper is to understand the economic performance of craftsmen cooperatives during the crisis period these cooperatives have the distinctive feature of being supply cooperatives we

the effect of income taxation on the labor supply of married men in sweden abstract this paper presents labor supply functions estimated on a sample of prime age swedish males the model used takes account of the nonlinear character of individuals budget sets caused by the progressive income tax it also allows preferences to vary between individuals calculations with the estimated functions using a partial equilibrium framework indicate a sizeable effect of the income tax on hours of work the average expected deadweight loss of the income tax is found to be approximately 20 percent of tax revenue

indexing and inflation abstract much of the opposition to indexation as a means of adapting to ongoing inflation arises from the view that indexation is itself inflationary this paper examines the basic for that view in a simple macroeconomic model in which budget deficits are in part financed through the printing of money it is shown that all aspects of indexing wage indexation bond indexation and tax indexation tend to increase the impact on the price level of any inflationary shock however this association between indexation and inflation is in large part a consequence of the monetary and fiscal policies being followed by the government evidence from a cross section of forty countries on the effects of indexation on the inflationary impact of the oil price shock of 1973 1974 suggests that indexation did not in general increase the inflationary impact of the oil shock the evidence is further consistent with the view that the absence of an excess inflationary effect of indexation is a result of the countries with substantial indexation not having accommodated the oil price shock as much as other countries

the effect of taxes on male and female labor supply in sweden this paper estimates labor supply functions for married men and women in sweden using data from 1980 taking account of the complete form of individuals budget constraints both linear and quadratic supply functions are estimated with and without random preferences a novel feature is that for women the wage rate and labor supply functions are estimated simultaneously using a full information maximum likelihood method this method yields substantially larger wage and income elasticities than does the previously used two step methods another result is that the quadratic supply function wage elasticities for men and women are virtually the same if the elasticities are evaluated at the same net wage rate and hours of work for men and women the estimated functions are used to calculate the effect of tax reforms

a life cycle consistent empirical model of family labour supply using cross section data this paper estimates a utility maximising model of the joint determination of male and female labour supplies using a sample of married couples from the u k family expenditure survey the emphasis is on the estimation of within period preferences that are consistent with intertemporal two stage budgeting under uncertainty however the approach we adopt provides an alternative method of estimating certain aspects of life cycle behaviour to the fixed effects constant approach of heckman and macurdy 1980 macurdy 1981 and browning deaton and irish 1985 moreover it relaxes some of the underlying restrictions that are implicit in these constant models under uncertainty

a structural model of multiple welfare program participation and labor supply work on estimating the labor supply effects of high marginal tax rates in welfare programs has been hindered by the difficulty of estimating the effects of participation in multiple welfare programs simultaneously the authors solve this problem by applying methods of simulation estimation to a model of labor supply and multiple program participation the results show asymmetric wage and tax rate effects with fairly large wage elasticities of labor supply but very inelastic responses to moderate changes in cumulative marginal tax rates implying that high welfare tax rates do not necessarily induce major reductions in work effort copyright 1998 by economics department of the university of pennsylvania and the osaka university institute of social and economic research association

the search for a stable money demand function a survey of the post 1973 literature phe question of whether the demnand function for money is stable is one of the most important recurring issues in the theory and application of macroeconomic policy what is being sought in a stable demand function is a set of necessary conditions for money to exert a predictable influence on the economy so that the central bank s control of the money supply can be a useful instrument of economic policy as such the notion of a stable demand function appears to involve three key elements e g john t boorman 1976 p 317 and david e w laidler 1977 pp 34 35 first the demand for money relation should be highly predictable in a statistical sense as measured by the usual goodness of fit statistics precision of estimated coefficients and presumably its ability to forecast accurately out of sample second a stable demand function for money has relatively few arguments a relationship that requires knowledge about a large number of variables in order to pin it down is in effect not predictable finally the variables that appear as arguments in the function should represent significant links to spending and economic activity in the real sector in sum a stable demand function for money means that the quantity of money is predictably related to a small set of key variables linking money to the real sector of the economy the importance of a stable money demand function for monetary policy can be illustrated with the standard is lm model in which interest rates and gnp are the endogenous variables in this context a stable demand function for money translates into a well defined relationship between money interest rates and gnp

the short run relation between growth and inflation in latin america reply sebastian edwards uses a new unexpected money variable based on the addition of the contemporaneous fiscal deficit to my autoregressive money growth equations to argue that 1 in brazil and chile there is no significant relationship between unexpected money growth and output growth 2 unexpected money growth has different estimated effects on output in colombia peru and mexico and these effects substantially exceed those estimated in brazil and chile and 3 thus my 10 percent rule for the effect of unexpected money growth on output growth does not hold in addition edwards incorporates the terms of trade in his output equations and finds they are important in the case of chile and mexico finally edwards takes issue with my use of lagged inflation to explain output edwards and i use somewhat different data not only in terms of sources but also edwards often uses m2 rather than ml in reporting his best results however edwards and my basic results are broadly similar compare his table 1 and my original tables 1 and 4 this is encouraging and in general makes it seem not worth quibbling over the differences in data however there is one difference which affects the results that i will discuss later the inclusion of the fiscal deficit in the money growth equation is a key difference in our work as i pointed out in my earlier article fiscal and monetary policy often are closely related in latin america thus it is not surprising that edwards finds the deficit divided by lagged money is a significant factor in explaining money growth however the point is not to explain money growth but to estimate a relationship which the public could have been using to predict how much money and thus nominal aggregate demand has grown since the last observation on the money stock 2 it strains credulity to assume that in latin america the budget deficit could be used by the public to estimate money growth contemporaneously data on the cash deficit usually are available publicly only with a long lag moreover many alternative versions of a deficit involving creative accounting methods are reported for example for many years in colombia the reported deficit which is available with about a one quarter lag treated both the unspent portion of the budget and the accounting profits from the revaluation of the local currency value of exchange reserves as income procedures which caused great confusion inside as well as outside the government despite such problems the cash deficit still might be useful as a monetary growth predictor for example it may be correlated with some other easily available contemporaneous indicator of money growth however its usefulness can best be judged from a comparison of the results when the deficit is used only as the money growth predictor to determine unexpected money a constrained equation with those obtained when it is used as an additional independent variable an unconstrained equation a test robert barro has suggested in another context world bank the views and interpretations expressed in this article are my own and should not be attributed to the world bank its affiliated organizations or to any individual acting in their behalf edwards also uses the seemingly unrelated regression technique to take into account possible interrelationships in the error terms across countries judging from the reported t statistics this procedure did not improve the fits greatly 2surprisingly the deficit is not significant in explaining domestic credit in mexico this result and the estimated negative relationship between edwards domestic credit series and output suggest a problem in the domestic credit variable

productivity capital and labor in labor managed and conventional firms an investigation on french data using two new data sets from france the authors present the first study of the comparative productivity of labor managed and conventional firms involving large representative samples of firms in a

process innovation activity in a mixed oligopoly the role of cooperatives this article develops a sequential game theoretic model of heterogeneous producers to examine the market and welfare effects of cooperative involvement in process innovation activity in the agricultural sector the analysis examines an open membership input supplying cooperative co op that maximizes member welfare and finances its innovation activity through retained earnings analytical results show that the presence of the co op can increase the arrival rate of innovations while reducing the price of agricultural inputs cooperative involvement in innovation activity can thus be welfare enhancing and socially desirable with its effectiveness being determined by the degree of producer heterogeneity and the size of innovation costs

a time to grow and a time to die growth and mortality of credit unions in new york city 1914 1990 one vision of organizational evolution suggests that old and large organizations become increasingly dominant over their environment a second suggests that as organizations age they become less able to respond to new challenges in this article the authors investigate which of these visions best characterizes the evolution of state chartered credit unions in new york city from 1914 through 1990 by analyzing the effects of organizational age size and population density on rates of organizational failure and growth the authors find evidence that old and small institutions are more likely to fail while young and small organizations have the highest growth rates

labor supply and taxes a survey i survey the male and female labor supply literatures focusing on implications for effects of wages and taxes for males i describe and contrast results from three basic types of model static models especially those that account for nonlinear taxes life cycle models with savings and life cycle models with both savings and human capital for women more important distinctions are whether models include fixed costs of work and whether they treat demographics like fertility and marriage and human capital as exogenous or endogenous the literature is characterized by considerable controversy over the responsiveness of labor supply to changes in wages and taxes at least for males it is fair to say that most economists believe labor supply elasticities are small but a sizeable minority of studies that i examine obtain large values hence there is no clear consensus on this point in fact a simple average of hicks elasticities across all the studies i examine is 0 30 several simulation studies have shown that such a value is large enough to generate large welfare costs of income taxation for males i conclude that two factors drive many of the differences in results across studies one factor is use of direct vs ratio wage measures with studies that use the former tending to find larger elasticties another factor is the failure of most studies to account for human capital returns to work experience i argue that this may lead to downward bias in elasticity estimates in a model that includes human capital i show how even modest elasticities as conventionally measured can be consistent with large welfare costs of taxation

estimating intertemporal labour supply elasticities using structural model in this paper the author proposes empirical models where both the intertemporal substitution elasticity and the elasticities measuring the impact of different wage profiles are estimated taking into account the restrictions derived from utility maximization she considers models assuming a stone geary utility function and also a constant elasticity of substitution across periods function the data used are a sample of men from the michigan panel of income dynamics her estimates support the low intertemporal substitution elasticity found in previous studies the estimates for the uncompensated elasticities are also small copyright 1989 by royal economic society

a superior measure of consumption from the panel study of income dynamics abstract this paper provides a simple technique for assigning a measure of total consumption to households in the panel study of income dynamics psid using regressions from the consumer expenditure surveys of 1972 1973 and 1983 linear predictions of total consumption are estimated which are stable over time and explain up to 78 percent of the total variance in consumption

economies of diversification in the us credit union sector summary significant scale economies have been recently cited to rationalize a dramatic growth in the us retail credit union sector over the past few decades in this paper we explore another plausible supply side explanation for the growth of the industry namely economies of diversification we focus on the fact that credit unions differ among themselves in the range of financial services they offer to their members since larger credit unions tend to offer a more diversified financial service menu than credit unions of a smaller size the incentive to grow in size may be fueled not only by present scale economies but also by economies of diversification this paper provides the first robust estimates of such economies of diversification for the credit union sector we estimate a flexible semiparametric smooth coefficient quantile panel data model with correlated effects that is capable of accommodating a four way heterogeneity among credit unions our results indicate the presence of non negligible economies of diversification in the industry we find that as many as 27 91 depending on the type and the cost quantile of diversified credit unions enjoy substantial economies of diversification the cost of most remaining credit unions is invariant to the scope of services we also find overwhelming evidence of increasing returns to scale in the industry

dynamic labour force participation of married women and endogenous work experience this paper presents and estimates a dynamic model of married women s labour force participation and fertility in which the effect of work experience on wages is explicitly taken into account because current participation alters future potential earnings the investment return to work will be an important factor in the current work decision in any forward looking behavioural model the model is estimated using the national longitudinal surveys mature women s cohort we use the estimates of our model to predict changes in the lifecycle patterns of employment due to changes in schooling fertility husband s income and the magnitude of the experience effect on wages we find that although work experience increases the disutility of further work the effect is overwhelmed by the positive effect of experience on wages leading to persistence in the employment patterns of these women in addition we find that an increase in young children and in husband s income substantially reduces participation while increased schooling has a powerful positive impact on participation this paper presents an estimable structural dynamic model of married women s labour force participation and fertility in which wages are stochastic and work experience or cumulative participation is endogeneous the model is structural in the sense that the parameters which are estimated are contained in the fundamental relationships governing behaviour namely the utility function and the constraints the model is contained in the class of models which describe the life cycle capital accumulation process with endogeneous labour supply such as weiss 1972 and heckman 1976 it is closest in spirit to that of weiss and gronau 1981 1 the basic feature of their model and ours is that labour market participation affects future wages which then affects future participation the investment return to current work will necessarily be taken into account in any forward looking optimizing model as weiss and gronau note estimates of labour supply models have ignored the inherent behavioural dynamics associated with a positive wageexperience profile there is no adequate empirical treatment of the human capital investment dimension of the labour force participation decision in the literature heckman and willis 1977 have studied a sequential discrete choice model of the labour force participation of married women in a reduced form framework their work

monetary targets real exchange rates and macroeconomic stability abstract in this paper i develop a model to determine the optimal degree of flexibility in attaining monetary targets in an economy that is affected by shocks in the labor and financial markets i then simulate the model to assess the optimal degree of monetary policy flexibility in spain a country that has adopted monetary targets rigidly since 1978 i show that the model supports the policy choice of that country i also show that the monetary authorities should attribute more importance to real exchange rate movements in choosing their policies if the spanish economy becomes more open to international trade or if the labor market becomes more flexible

the specification and estimation of dynamic stochastic discrete choice models a survey our main goal is to quantify the returns to a career in the united states congress we specify a dynamic model of career decisions of a member of congress and estimate this model using a newly collected dataset given estimates of the structural model we

the effects of health wealth and wages on labour supply and retirement behaviour this paper estimates a life cycle model of labour supply retirement and savings behaviour in which future health status and wages are uncertain individuals face a fixed cost of work and cannot borrow against future labour pension or social security income the method of simulated moments is used to match the life cycle profiles of labour force participation hours worked and assets that are estimated from the data to those that are generated by the model the model establishes that the tax structure of the social security system and pensions are key determinants of the high observed job exit rates at ages 62 and 65 removing the tax wedge embedded in the social security earnings test for individuals aged 65 and older would delay job exit by almost one year by contrast social security benefit levels health and borrowing constraints are less important determinants of job exit at older ages for example reducing social security benefits by 20 would cause workers to delay exit from the labour force by only three months

household choices in equilibrium this paper is an empirical investigation of equilibrium restrictions on household consumption and male labor supply it exploits a simple factor structure rationalized by two assumptions that household allocations are pareto optimal and that the labor market is competitive the paper estimates household preferences and tests how well this parsimonious factor structure represents panel data on married couples and time series data on asset returns most of the estimates are roughly comparable to those found in previous work no evidence against the simple factor representation is found and the intertemporal capital asset pricing model is not rejected copyright 1990 by the econometric society

on the effects of sterilized intervention an analysis of weekly data abstract as the recent empirical studies surveyed here illustrate it is very difficult to demonstrate that the exchange rate risk premium depends through a portfolio balance channel on the currency composition of outside assets the existence of a portfolio balance effect is a necessary condition for sterilized intervention to be a genuinely independent tool of monetary policy this paper studies u s canadian data and attempts to improve on earlier studies by using higher frequency weekly data and by implementing an appropriate instrumental variables technique 2s2sls however we still fail to detect evidence of a portfolio balance effect

intersectoral labor mobility and the growth of the service sector one of the most striking changes in the u s economy over the past 50 years has been the growth in the service sector between 1950 and 2000 service sector employment grew from 57 to 75 percent of total employment however over this time the real hourly wage in the service sector grew only slightly faster than in the goods sector in this paper we assess whether or not the essential constancy of the relative wage implies that individuals face small costs of switching sectors and we quantify the relative importance of labor supply and demand factors in the growth of the service sector we specify and estimate a two sector labor market equilibrium model that allows us to address these empirical issues in a unified framework our estimates imply that there are large mobility costs output in both sectors would have been double their current levels if these mobility costs had been zero in addition we find that demand side factors that is technological change and movements in product and capital prices were responsible for the growth of the service sector

individual heterogeneity and interindustry wage differentials estimates of interindustry wage differentials are obtained using a fixed effects estimator on a long panel the national longitudinal survey of young men nls after controlling for observable worker characteristics 84 percent of the residual variance of log wages across industries is explained by individual fixedeffects only 16 percent of the residual variance is explained by industry dummies since no controls for specific job characteristics are used job characteristics that vary across industries could potentially explain this rather small residual across industry log wage variance that is not attributable to individual effects clearly then these data do not force us to resort to noncompetitive explanations of interindustry wage differentials such as efficiency wage theory furthermore efficiency wage theories predict that wages in efficiency wage paying or primary industries should be relatively rigid therefore industry wage differentials should widen in recessions however no such tendency is found in the data

profiles of fertility labour supply and wages of married women a complete life cycle model of all the major economic and demographic events in the postwar united states period the trends in fertility and female labour supply stand out as among the most dramatic fertility rates after their depression lows rose unexpectedly after world war ii far more than was anticipated as an adjustment to the war and continued to rise until the late 1950 s and early 1960 s when they again took an unexpected turn downward all the way to today s historical lows female labour force participation rates continuing their historical climb grew throughout the postwar period at an increasing pace by 4 percentage points during the 1950 s by 5 percentage points during the 1960 s and by 8 percentage points during the 1970 s these two trends are of course closely related for most married women have traditionally spent at least some minimal time out of the labour force while caring for their own children thus for example the slower growth rate of labour force participation rates in the 1950 s is probably connected with the higher fertility rates in that period in this paper a complete model of female labour supply and fertility choice is constructed and estimated the model is more complete than previous models in several respects first labour supply and fertility decisions are modelled as completely joint in the same sense as the consumption of two goods is joint second both are modelled as life cycle decisions that is as decisions regarding sequences of labour supply and fertility events rather than levels of the same hence the timing of both is important third the life cycle path of wage rates is made endogenous to the model given a wage function showing the effect of work experience on future wages the path of wages is determined automatically by the chosen path of labour supply which in turn is related to fertility decisions that require some period of non work econometrically the three profiles for labour supply fertility and wages are estimated with a full information maximum likelihood technique that solves several econometric problems such as the problem of heterogeneity of tastes the selectivity problem of missing wage rates for non workers and the problem of simultaneous equations bias the value of constructing a complete model is best seen by briefly reviewing past work in this area the modern literature in the area is based upon the work of becker

monetary versus real exchange rate targets when capital mobility is limited abstract a country that follows a ppp exchange rate rule with limited capital mobility will face a trade off between output and price stability providing money demand is not extremely sensitive to expectations this conclusion is thus the same as in the closed economy model of taylor 1979

staggered wage setting and exchange rate policy in an economy with capital assets abstract this paper investigates the effects of exchange market intervention on price output stability tradeoffs in the context of a moderately sized open economy in this model which incorporates interest bearing capital assets monetary accommodation is the mechanism whereby exchange rate indexation is achieved it is seen that increased exchange market intervention reduces output variability but only at the expense of enhanced price and nominal exchange rate variability this is true of stochastic disturbances on the supply side for disturbances originating in the money market increased intervention unambiguously reduces both price and output variability

optimal wage indexation foreign exchange intervention and monetary policy this paper deals with the design of optimal monetary policy and with the interaction between the optimal degrees of wage indexation and foreign exchange intervention the model is governed by the characteristics of the stochastic shocks which affect the economy and by the information set that individuals possess because of cost of negotiations nominal wages are assumed to be precontracted and wage adjustments follow a simple indexation rule that links wage changes to observed changes in price the use of the price level as the only indicator for wage adjustments may not permit an efficient use of available information and may result in welfare loss the analysis specifies the optimal set of feedback rules that should govern policy aiming at the minimization of the welfare loss these feedback rules determine the optimal response of monetary policy to changes in exchange rates interest rates and foreign prices the adoption of the optimal set of feedback rules results in the complete elimination of the welfare cost arising from the simple indexation rule and from the existence of nominal contracts since optimal policies succeed in the elimination of the distortions issues concerning the nature of contracts and the implications of specific assumptions about disequilibrium positions become inconsequential the analysis then proceeds to examine the interdependence between the optimal feedback rules and the optimal degree of wage indexation it is shown that a rise in the degree of exchange rate flexibility raises the optimal degree of wage indexation one of the key conclusions is the proposition that the number of independent feedback rules that govern a policy must equal the number of independent sources of information that influence the determination of the undistorted equilibrium thus it is shown that with a sufficient number of feedback rules for monetary policy there may be no need to introduce wage indexation it is also shown that an economy that is not this abstract was borrowed from another version of this item

corrigendum on a life cycle model of female labour supply in the empirical work in our article on the intertemporal substitution of leisure time for married women heckman and macurdy 1980 we inadvertently constrained the estimated intertemporal substitution elasticity to be too high since this parameter plays a prominent role in discussions of equilibrium models of the business cycle and since our empirical work has been cited in discussions on this topic e g hall 1980 we would like to present a corrected set of empirical results for our model the period t utility function adopted in this note is in the notation of our original paper equation 15

qualitative and mixed methods research in economics surprising growth promising future qualitative research in economics has traditionally been unimportant compared to quantitative work yet there has been a small explosion in use of quantitative approaches in the past 10 15 years including mixed methods projects which use qualitative and quantitative methods in combination this paper surveys the growing use of qualitative methods in economics and closely related fields aiming to provide economists with a useful roadmap through major sets of qualitative methods and how and why they are used we review the growing body of economic research using qualitative approaches emphasizing the gains from using qualitative or mixed methods over traditional closed ended approaches it is argued that although qualitative methods are often portrayed as less reliable less accurate less powerful and or less credible than quantitative methods in fact the two sets of methods have their own strengths and how much can be learned from one type of method or the other depends on specific issues that arise in studying the topic of interest the central message of the paper is that well done qualitative work can provide scientifically valuable and intellectually helpful ways of adding to the stock of economic knowledge especially when applied to research questions for which they are well suited