deg udlis n a A.C.GIGNOUX (sb:16)  Amyeḍres n Julia kristeva yemxalaf ɣef win n M.Bakhtine deg waṭas n tneqqiḍin : axeddim n usentel n win yettmeslayen ad yawi iḍrisen n tedyezt deg umyeḍresihi bakhtine iwekked tilin n umaru deg uxeddim. Ma yella d kristeva d yiwet seg ugraw n yeẓriyen tsened ɣef tudert d tnefsit n umaru dɣa tekkat ad tebṭṭel tikti n usentel n ususru5.