You remain on Tahiti and in the autumn of 1789 you watch the Bounty sail away for the last time. There is little left to do now but settle down to living among the Tahitians and hope that the first ship to visit the island will be a friendly one. Like many of the Mutineers you get into a long-term relationship with a beautiful Tahitian woman and enjoy long days spent relaxing on the beautiful island and nights of hard-drinking and partying with the locals. Seven months after the Bounty leaves violence erupts, threatening to destroy your peaceful existence.

The problem is Matthew Thompson, a middle-aged and brutal man who alone out of all of you doesn't have a romantic partner as the Native women avoid him. One day there is chaos in the village and you learn that Thompson, drunk on strong spirits, has tried to rape a Tahitian woman but was fought off when her screams brought her brother and other men running to her aid.

You go out of your hut and walk towards Thompson's, as do several of your companions, to find him outside his hut shouting at a small crowd of angry Tahitians to go away. He has a musket in his hands and without warning he raises it and fires it at a man. The bullet passes through a baby the man is holding in his arms and into his chest, killing them both. Reversing the musket Thompson swings it in a wild arc, cracking a woman in the head and knocking her unconscious to the ground. The rest of the crowd flees.

Thompson sensibly flees to the shoreline, steals a canoe and paddles away to a small nearby island called Taiarapu. The rest of you have a meeting with the Tahitians where you emphasize that Thompson's actions had nothing to do with the rest of you and you all condemn his cruelty. The Tahitians accept your explanations, largely because Quartermaster Charles Churchill has been adopted by a local chief and is gaining considerable status among the Natives.

After some talk you decide on what to do: you will send a messenger to Thompson telling him he can safely return to Tahiti and when he comes back one or two of you will steal his muskets and cutlasses from his hut and give him no more to prevent him doing anymore harm. It is a risky thing to do as Thompson is a violent man but Churchill volunteers for the task.

You stay out of the whole business

You all send a Native to Thompson telling him all is forgiven and he can return and a suspicious Thompson dutifully returns to Tahiti. About a week after his return when Thompson is elsewhere Churchill sneaks into his hut, takes his weapons and hides them in his own hut. Thompson is absolutely furious when he discovers the theft and unfortunately a Native man with a grudge against Churchill tells Thompson who stole his weapons. Thompson recovers his musket, walks up behind Churchill one day and shoots him dead.

Thompson again flees into the jungle interior and again you all meet to decide what to do. The Tahitians are furious over the death of their friend and intend to tell Thompson all is forgiven before jumping on him and beating him to death with rocks. It is a cold-blooded plan.

You warn Thompson about it

You hurry out of the village to warn Thompson of the Natives' intentions but you are spotted. Quickly realizing what you are intending to do the Natives give chase and run you down after a few hundred meters. A spear stab in the back knocks you down and then the Natives beat you to death with rocks. They then go on and kill Thompson anyway.