Three years pass quietly on the island but a few accidents mar the peace.

Soon after you arrive one of the women falls to her death while gathering eggs from the clifftops, soon after Fletcher Christian's wife gives birth to the first child born on Pitcairn. The year after a second woman dies of an illness. Previously each of the Mutineers had one female partner each while the six Tahitian men had just two women to have sexual relations with. In the summer of 1793 you and the other Mutineers decide to take the two remaining women from the Tahitian men and give them to John Adams and William Brown respectively, the two men whose wives have died.

Trouble erupts when four of the Tahitians take the two women and go to live elsewhere on the island. You and the other Mutineers give one of the remaining Tahitians, a tough character called Menalee a musket and send him off to kill the leader of the rebellious Tahitians, a man called Talaloo. On the first day of August Menalee finds him and shoots him dead. The following day he is sent off again and kills a second man called Oho. The two remaining men return and for a time it looks like all has settled down: Adams and Brown have their wives and the four remaining Tahitian men seem suitably chastised.

One day in September you are in your hut when you hear a few gunshots somewhere nearby. You think nothing of it and a short time later you hear more gunshots. You assume someone is hunting. A short while later you hear loud and excited yells followed by even more gunshots and prolonged shouting. You are now growing concerned and step warily out of your hut. You wonder what to do.

You head away from the village and up into the hills

You wisely flee up into the hills and are startled to meet a panting William McCoy there, he has run all the way from the village after witnessing the Natives shoot and kill his friend John Mills. Soon after you are joined by a breathless Matthew Quintal, who has likewise escaped the village. He has shocking news to tell you, five of your friends: Fletcher Christian, John Mills, William Brown, Isaac Martin and John Williams are dead. Your remaining two companions, John Adams and Edward Young remain in the village, protected by the Native women.

You and your two unarmed companions remain hiding up in the mountains for two weeks, sometimes receiving messages from your wives still in the village. You learn that Menalee has killed another Native man called Timoa after an argument. Scared of his companions Menalee himself joins you two in the mountains saying he would be safer hiding with you. That night when Menalee falls asleep McCoy picks up his musket and shoots him dead.

Three days later Adams and Young succeed in persuading the Native women they should kill the two remaining Tahitian men Nehow and Tetaheite. Young shoots Nehow in the back of the head while a woman called Susan kills Tetaheite with an axe. Your friends quickly send word to you all that it is safe to come back to the village. There are now five of you men left with ten Native women and a few small children.

Peace returns to the island once more.

You alcohol

Four years pass by peacefully on the island, you live with the women, begin raising a child and live a good life. William McCoy and Matthew Quintal are more restless characters than you, John Adams and Edward Young and McCoy, who once worked in a brewery in Scotland, spends a long time trying to brew alcohol out of various things. He finally succeeds in creating an incredibly strong alcohol from the ti-root and he and Quintal quickly become addicted to it, despite the fact it seems to trigger hallucinations. Adams and Young refuse to drink any.

You join in the drinking

You and McCoy soon develop a heavy dependency on the dangerous drink and have many hallucinations. After one particular bout to celebrate the beginning of 1798 you and McCoy decide in your drunken states that you want to swim back to England. You run to the edge of a cliff and plunge down into the sea below. You disappear beneath the waves forever, victims of the terrible alcohol you have created.