It's taken my dog a week, but he's finally picked the Casper bed over his old memory foam bed. He LOVES digging in the bed which I let him do because Casper says the bed can withstand it. He really seems to like it and looks happy in it. The thing that the bed is missing is a bolster (the photos make it look like it has some type of bolster around the bed, but it is really pretty flat). If my dog had to choose, I think he'd definitely prefer a bolster. I, however, prefer the clean look of this bed and as long as he's picking this one over his old one, will stick with it.