We'd give it a 9 out of 10. The size is perfect for the small space. The chocolate brown color is rich and, for the price, the leather is good -- soft and sturdy. It was easy to assemble. My husband says he wishes the chair were slightly wider; I wish it were slightly longer as my feet fall off the footrest. In a perfect world, I'd've preferred a carmel color but overall, the two recliners are a great value, comfortable and more than fit the bill!  Thank you Wayfair!