It is as nice, or even better than I was hoping for! And I was truly skeptical!
The color and fabric are very nice and it is extremely comfortable to sit on! I have not slept on it but it feels like it will be very nice for a spare bed. It fits very nicely and stays in place well.
It gives our futon a new, fabulous look and is the perfect addition to our family room!
And for the record, I did not notice any smell other than that of a new cushion. It was gone within a day or two of having it unwrapped. I would highly recommend!!