Would probably give this a 4.5 star if that was an option. Decent construction. Having experience with much heavier tents with the same type of framing, this certainly did the job, and at a fraction of the price for other models at other retailers. Contrary to other posts (I read them before "pulling the trigger" on a purchase), this held up to some heavy rain and about 12 mph winds over last weekend in Maryland (if you want to check weather conditions for central MD in that time frame). Stayed up overnight, with the tie-downs in place. No problem. I would note two quick items - first, make sure you mark the poles with a permanent marker, because the labels come off easily; second, I did not have any need to attach the walls, so this review is without walls only. I cannot comment on how well the tent would work in the wind with the walls in place.