I ordered them for my bedroom and all in all I'm happy with them. I didn't bother to look at the dimensions of the shades and they're bigger than I expected them to be (my fault). Also, the silver stems are definitely mottled but it works. I took a star off because the lamp shade finials match the base rather than the silver stems and they cheapen the look of the lamps a little bit (i.e. the finials are black faux-wood), but they're easy enough to change out.