Would have rated it a 4, but I did a 5 because I do like the chairs, they are comfortable . Plus, the chairs matched my dining room table like I wanted.  The only downfall was that I got a chair with a stain on the fabric already when I opened the box. At first, I thought it was water and dirt like maybe part of the order fell on the ground or something....but as I fixed it, the smell got stronger, and its freakn soy sauce.    How disappointed.  Either I got a used one, and someone spilled soy sauce or some worker spilled soy sauce on part of the chair as theu package it...   but its 1 out of the 4 chairs...so I guess wet carpet cleaner it is for me to do.