One came with a huge stain on it - even had a red thread there to mark the stain by manufacturer. Not sure how it got shipped anyway? Wayfair was quick to exchange it for me though. 
Overall curtains are pretty good, seem thick and warm and washed well. 
But, the colour is much more “muddy” than I expected. Was hoping to use in my sons bedroom but they were quite dark and heavy looking - not quite the blue background to the plaid I had hoped. I plan to use them in the basement though.