I give it 4 out of 5 stars. 

PROS 
The crib is very beautiful,
Is light enough to easily move around especially on carpet,
Instructions that came in a booklet were very easy to follow (only took me 2 hours to put together all by myself, plus 40 mins just to unpack everything out of the box),
Came with extra screws  2 extra boards if you later decide to make it a bed (but you will still need to buy other parts),
Did not arrive damaged. 

CONS Not all of it is solid heavy wood (shelves, the changing pad platform, the wall that separates the crib  changing station,  the wall that covers the drawers are made of thin plywood), 
The drawers were not made very evenly nor close off small gaps (see in pics).
The paint does chip very easily so have some matching paint around,
The hazardwarning stickers that come on the furniture pieces do not come off  if you try to peel it off, you will scratchdamage the paint (see sticker in 3rd pic at the bottom).