I’m kind of torn between giving 3 stars or 4.  I ordered 4 sets for an event, but only 1 set arrived. No kidding! The box had 3 staples to hold it closed. No, shipping receipt, return papers or anything! Idk if they fell out or wasn’t ever included.  At any rate, they are nice....kind of a strange color though not pewter, not copper, not shiny silver but kind of a mix of the three.  2 of the holders are bent and I haven’t tried to bend them to see if they can be straighter. Not sure how they will hold any candle though since 2 are leaning. After writing the review, I think I will give them a 3.