It's definitely within what I was expecting, although it seems expensive for what it is. The stenciling/paint of the red cross is ever so slightly wobbly, and there are some minor chips and cracks in the enamel. It seems like they're going for an "antique" look, but the craftsmanship is lacking for something in this price range if you ask me. I'll still use it to organize our medicine cabinet as it's still functional and cuter than a plastic shoebox. If I'd bought it at the original price I would be sending it back.