I want to love this sconce, however the packaging is flawed. The rounded shade is packaged against a piece of flat cardboard which causes a dent in the shade. This occurred with my first order as well as my replacement order so I will not be reordering because until they fix the packaging it will continue to be dented. I’m also not returning it because I have to pay the return shipping costs plus the hassle of shipping it back so I’m just cutting my losses. Love their other products and service though. I’m giving it 2 stars because it’s not the sconce that is the problem, it’s the packaging.