I'm giving this a 4.5 because the item arrived scuffed and scratched, but otherwise it was exactly what I was hoping for. It arrived packed very well, but the box was too big to fit in my door, so I had to take it out on the porch and bring it in that way. That being said, I was impressed with the way it was packed, and no extra packing. I feel like scuffing and paint chip must of happened before it was wrapped for packing because it was packed so well. 

The scuff mark, I think I can rub out, but the chip is the finish off. It is on the back of the chair, so I don't think it will be an aesthetic problem, but I worry about rust or something later on down the road.

As for looks, it's fabulous. Modern, beautiful charcoal color cushions, and easy to move around, but still sturdy. The cushions were a bit stiff yet, but I'm sure they will soften with use. I can see getting a lot of use out of this set.