1 star because it comes with markings (like every piece) like these that according to the manufacturer are “intentional weathering”. Also, if you have a problem with this particular brand of furniture, you must work directly with them to get the problem solved via a Wayfair email.  They must be based overseas because all communication was replied to between the hours of 11pm EST and 5am EST making it nearly impossible to get any sort of continuity of communication.   We ended up keeping the pieces because it would have been more of a hassle to try and figure out how to rebox and return, but these will become playroom decor and not family room decor as soon as we find an acceptable replacement.