I absolutely love this one. Very sturdy and super heavy. Love the finish. Great looking storage piece. I can’t even fault it because per my hubby it was an absolute night mare to assemble. In my husband words, “ never again “. It took him 3 hours. He said it should taken 2 people. He Finally got it together on his own. He said some of it could have arrived already assembled. Every piece had to be glued together. Regardless, I love it!!!