After searching high & low for days on end and reading countless reviews of all chairs, these were the ones we ordered.  I can't say enough how much we love them -- they are sturdy, comfortable, and the seat is nice & wide so you don't feel like you're going to fall off.  They look terrific with our farmhouse dining room table & the nail heads add a little bit of pop.  We did Scotchgard them, just to be safe, but I anticipate a long life from them.  Thanks Wayfair!