I like the shade overall.  The construction quality is good, and the cost value is very fair.  The installation was easy enough (both side and top mount options).  The concern I had is that this shade doesn't close as the blinds I replaced it with did; there is only up/down.  From the representative picture I can see that some light comes through (does appear much less in the catalog picture), ... just didn't realize that this shade type was limited in this way.  Worth the money, and looks good over all.

Pros: good quality, good value, easy installation, looks good
Cons: can't limit light