I would have given this five stars if it would have stuck well on my shower tile. The only way I could get it to securely stay is to have it on the glass and on the ledge. Not sure if it is this particular tile or it just does better on fiberglass tubsshowers. I had ordered three and didn’t want to worry with returning so I gave the other two to a friend of mine. She likes them also and they are staying in place on her fiberglass shower walls. Otherwise, for me I personally love the look and functionality of it after improvising.