I purchased the thicker shelves. Very heavy. Have not installed yet. A little disappointed. One shelf is amazing! The edge is beautiful and very attractive. The other not so much. The second one is nice, but doesn't look at all as good as the first. I understand they aren't going to look the same. The edge is lacking, it just looks basic.  I purchased them for a guest room, so they will do. If it was in a room I had to see the in every day, then I would request an exchange on the one shelf.