I was impressed by the finish of the wood and nice brass hardware.   I have reservations about the fact that the seat is about two-thirds the thickness of the seats that I replaced.   I was not able to find the old seats in the elongated style after looking in several local stores.  Are they going to hold up, or end up cracking.   This is really a concern.   If they were as thick as my old seats, which did not crack, I would not be concerned.   The ease of ordering and timely shipment, once the seats were in stock, was a plus.

Pros: These seats are very nice-looking, and hopefully the finish will hold up and the hardware will not corrode.
Cons: These seats were expensive, compared to solid oak seats that I have purchased in the past