I really like these lamps, but I suppose this is because of personal tastes.  It's pretty cool that there are pine trees around the inside perimeter of the lamp shades that you can't see until the light is illuminated, and then can see them clearly as if they were situated on the outside of the shade. But, I was compelled to purchase these lamps solely based on the look of them. I personally like them. They are sturdy and look nice with my decor.