This is a hard one to rate! I give it five stars for how it looks and feels. It's gorgeous, feels great under my feet, and my pets are in heaven rolling around on it. 

But: it came a little damaged with got a lot of loose threads and unhooked (for lack of a better word) sections of the weaving. Wayfair gave us some of our money back because of the damage, and we are happy to have the rug - but I would just say be prepared for the possibility you won't have a "perfect" looking rug, even on day one, if you do order this one.