I was a little skeptical based on the mixed reviews, but was SUPER pleased with my purchase.  This chair looks very expensive... it came flawlessly packaged, and was easy to put together.  The details are top notch - the distressed wood legs, the stitching on the upholstery, even the liner underneath the chair - all very well done. 

Re: Comfort - so, I don't think anyone will leave our house saying "We have to go back there, so I can sit in that chair!", but it is an upright armchair... I've never had a piece like this, but It's comfortable.  Not like sitting in a recliner - but I could definitely sit here and watch a movie, and love having some alternative seating options in our living room.  I'm ordering a second today to complete our look!