I really love the look of this fire pit, and it's a great size that was easy to assemble. However, despite the box being in fine condition, the fire pit itself was definitely beat up. It's got some scuffs and dents in it that make it seem like it was lightly used. Since this is going outside, I decided it wasn't a huge problem and didn't want to deal with the hassle of returning it. But it was disappointing to see on an otherwise fine fire pit.