5 stars for appearance and functionality. 3 stars for diificulty of assembly. 0 stars for the instructions. The tools that come with it are a joke. Much easier to assemble if you have metric sockets and a real screw driver. There are missing written explanations and/or diagrams needed to complete each step. My favorite is showing a picture of a screw driver in step 4 but never mentioning what its used for. (Hint: The studs that go into the table top are slotted on one end and you use a screw driver to put them in.) In the end I was able to figure it all out and have a beautiful fire pit that we enjoy very much.