I really like this rug.  I gave 4 stars because I've only had it for a few days.  That being said, it looks just like the picture; feels great on bare feet; doesn't seem to mat down too much (leave footprints).   I placed it under a heavy coffee table, so I don't really need a pad under it.  It didn't really smell bad when I opened it, but I did place it on the front porch for several hours.  No smell.  I would highly recommend this rug.  Great buy for the price!