I had been looking for wingbacks for my office and decided on these because of looks, price, and positive reviews. They arrived quickly and I am quite pleased with them. They seem well made and have firm seat and lower back support.  I like that, but I could see how someone wanting a softer chair would want to look elsewhere.  I was considering similar wingbacks from P-Barn, but feel that these are about as nice for significantly less money. I am almost willing to give 5 stars, but they aren't as comfortable as the wingbacks in my family room.