I just got these yesterday. Here are my thoughts. First, the color is more saturated/less pale than I expected. They are decidedly aqua in color. They seem good quality, heavy but not overly so. 

The plates are more flat than any plates I've ever seen. As other reviewers mentioned, the center of the plate is actually the highest point. The sides do tilt up just a little, so I didn't feel like the food would fall off. The brown faux-aging pattern is different on every piece, so that's kinda cool. The bowls and mugs are a good size, not dinky like in other sets I've seen/had. Overall, they're good, attractive dishes that I'll be using for a while.

I ordered two sets. The last things of the last set I was unpacking were the bowls, and one was broken. I contacted Wayfair about it, wondering if I could get a replacement bowl... and the next morning they said they shipped *a whole new set*. Do I need a whole new set? Not at all. But that's an amazing response.