The quality is what I was expecting. The 1 star is because 1) the width is slightly smaller than what I ordered. If I had known that I would have ordered an inch wider. There are gaps on the side that let in the light, so there's no blackout at all. 2) A corner of the fabric on the top is turned up, I'm going to try to use a hair straightener to fix it. 3) It's missing a piece! The plastic end cap on the bottom rail is missing on one side, so the sticks inside kept sliding out while I was trying to install it. It doesn't look good. Wayfair can you please send a replacement piece?