I would give these nightstands a solid 4 stars. They're nice enough for the price and function as I needed them to however, they look a little cheaper than i would have liked. I will say the walnut is much darker than pictured and is closer to an espresso. There was also a lot of issues with the shipping and 1 of my 2 nightstands getting lost. Customer service was very responsive and replaced the missing nightstand with in a reasonable amount of time.