I really like the the finish of the kitchen island; the size is perfect for the space I wanted to use; and the stainless steel top is great to have near my cooktop.  The only reason that I rated a 4 is that the draw does not work right.  My husband found that the glides attached to the cabinet were too far apart, so he added a shim to both sides.  That helped a little, but it still does not operate smoothly like a similar island I have had in the past.  The draw wheels seem to catch on something and I need to pull sharply and with a downward force to get it to open, and then it will close.  If I had a draw that worked correctly this would be five stars!