Ordered these to fit into the OXO/Rev a Shelf container pull out. They no longer make the original version this pull out was designed for and I've been struggling to find replacements that fit. I bought the shelf 6 months ago and already outdated. These are smaller than the originals so they do fit in the carve out loosely. The newer more affordable white versions cannot fit into the slots. I'm not loving the heavy metal lid vs the white of the remaining ones, but I have no other options. These were VERY EXPENSIVE vs the normal ones. Generally, not happy with the cost, look or size, but at least they fit in the slots. I'm regretting having invested in an OXO pull out drawer permanently in my kitchen island now that I see what a hassle these canisters are to replace and how often their lids break. The pop mechanism is short lived with regular use.