We replaced all 6 of our dining room chairs with the Carlton chair in gray.  2 arrived broken, but customer service did their best to get me replacements as soon as they were available again.  We finally have all 6 and they look great in our dining room.  The fabric seems durable and they are pretty sturdy.  Assembly was a little bit of a pain (attaching the base to the seat by lining up screw holes and using an Alan wrench to screw together), but overall there weren't any issues with assembly.  I would definitely recommend this chair.