Rug is very thin. Imagery of the pattern is not clear as if it is out of focus. The colors in the rug’s nap is inconsistent. The pattern is also inconsistent. I would say the rug would definitely fall in the category as a second or factory defective. The rug has been down for days in a very high end carpet pad and had some wrinkles I hope will eventually lay flat. I might as well keep it just to avoid the hassle of returning it.