We just received the August Grove Black Kitchen Cart with the black granite top and are very pleased.  It is well made and the instructions on how to assemble it were very easy to follow.  The only reason we gave it a # 4 rating is we wish they would have done a better job polishing the edges of the granite.  Some areas are shaded and slightly rough. In other respects, the cart is as well made as our custom-made kitchen cabinets.