Definitely Roth my money. Big Bang for my buck! My husband put this together. The ottoman is already assembled. My husband had to put the padding in the chair which was comforting in knowing you can machine wash it. The padding is kind of thin if you think about using it for the entire year you would probably have to just replace the padding but other than that everything was great quality.  

Pros: Comfortable, good price
Cons: Chair Padding