I was so excited to get this set. I love the pattern - so blue wave oceany - perfect for my new beach house. I got the Libby “blue wave” glasses and they look great together. One salad plate arrived broken but no worries, Wayfair replaced it. BUT the first time I used one of the plates, it got scratched from the utensils. This happened initially to only one plate, so I thought maybe it was defective. Again, Wayfair replaced it (thank you, Wayfair). However, after a couple of more uses, more of the plates showed the scratches. So now most of them are looking like I’ve used  abused them for years, and I’ve only had them a couple of weeks!  Not happy.