I would give the frame 5 stars. It is easy to put together and sturdy. Color is not exactly as bright gold as I expected, but still nice. The shelves are the problem. The top faux marble looks just fine, but the bottom is a mess. It is wrapped and cut unevenly, the black material underneath is smeared with glue and the worse part is that this is all visible because the top few shelves are taller than most people, even standing! I just purchased black contact paper that I am going to add to the bottom of the shelves flush to the edges. It will be a big pain in the neck to do, but it looks terrible already so it will at least look better. The faux marble should have been placed on the bottom also.