We love these plates, they seem make every meal look great but 2 out of 3 sets were damaged. Given Wayfair's quick and effective response to the damage on the first damaged set and that we were told to dispose of this ourselves we were able to swap out most of the damaged plates in the second.  Fairly happy overall but still haven't got a perfect full second set (white dinner plates were the main issue) which is a shame for the price.