I liked the look of the lantern, as it matches the two on either side of the garage doors.  I found it to be well made with good attention to finish details. I gave it only 4 stars because of the fastening system with tiny nuts and washers for the cap. Kind of difficult to hold the lantern, get the cap holes fitted through the studs, then put the washer and nut on with just two hands!  Other than that, I like the look and price of the fixture and look forward to seeing it vs. the old, ugly brass one it replaced!