I'm giving it 4 stars because it is a beautiful, simple, and chic side table. My issues are 3 things. It is definitely NOT GOLD, when I opened the box it looked silver. It does have a hue of brassiness/rose gold but it is definitely NOT A GOLD FRAME. If you are looking for a gold piece then this isn't it. In some angles it looks silver and others it looks goldish- very subtle. My second and third complaints are: scratches and the mirror (bottom shelf) has a little crack. Luckily it is on the edge and it is small enough where no one  wouldn't notice. Still, it is a brand new table with a crack, and I know it's there. It's not bad enough where I would return the whole thing. I do want to say that I am actually keeping it l, however, the color is not what I expected ( disappointing ) but it still fits with my decor.