These stools are stunning and minimalist - two things I value a great deal in my counter stools. If you value gorgeous, buy them. If you value comfort over gorgeous, don't buy them. If you think you value gorgeous over comfort, think again. I am 5ft 9in and the rim of the stool cuts me in the thighs getting into it and it cuts me in the thighs getting out of it. The back is low and does not allow you to lean back in it, but then I knew that going into the purchase. These do not lend themselves to lingering at the island bar for good conversation and drinks . 5 stars for the wow factor. 1 star for comfort. These babies are going back.