I got the 37 x 37 x .75 thick. It’s really thin. I should’ve gotten the thicker one given the size I chose because when it’s leaning above the fireplace, it seems a bit flimsy. I love it though and it’s really versatile. I feel like you could style it so many different ways. Perhaps in a living room anchored by some black wall sconces on both sides, throw some striped pillows on your sofa and it would be great. I actually got this for our nursery but I’ve repurposed it in our living room for spring and love it. Highly recommend.