I give these a 4 star rating due to a small defect. I purchased these lamps for my family room. Upon arrival one of them had a small crack in the glass. Wayfair quickly replaced the damaged item (nice job), but one of the lamps has a small defect bubble in the glass. I don't mind the defect because it is in an industrial themed family room and it isn't real easily noticed. Otherwise, the lamps went together quickly and are a nice size flanking my sofa. I felt it was a good deal for the price.