Fresh out of the box, both chairs are extremely dirty (it was all wrapped in plastic so it was before it was wrapped) and one has silver paint splashed on the backrest. 
The first chair went together perfectly. The second one is bent and cannot assemble correctly because of it (pics included). The only reason I give 2 stars is because I genuinely love the design of the chairs.  I can clean the dirt off, but not the silver paint. Quality control needs to do better.