I was very happy with this 24" Bar Stool. The on line catalog photo was accurate except for the colors of the wood finishes available. They both looked very dark so I ordered the lighter of the two which was called "warm medium walnut". When the box arrived the color "chestnut" was stamped on the side. As it turned out that color actually matched my other furniture perfectly. A very pleasant surprise. I was also pleased with the weight of the stools. They are very substantial and I assume they will be sturdy once we assemble them.  The fact that we had to assemble them was a surprise but no big deal. Overall I would give them 5 stars.  Pros: Delivered on time and as promised.Cons: Not all the on line catalog descriptions are accurate.  Colors were difficult to see.