These stools are exactly as anticipated.  They look great in my renovated kitchen.  They are a bit smaller than expected, but they are sturdy enough for most adults.  They match well with the Reagan bar stools (they have backs).  I don' think these bar stools will last more than a few years with lots of use... they are not quite as sturdy as other barstools out there (why I gave them 4 stars).  But for now, they fit the bill (and budget).  Loved that no assembly was required, though we did tighten some of the screws on the seats.