I ordered these 4 different Staub baking dished in matte black. I love the color and sizes. They look great, however they scratch so easily from any utensil (wood, hard plastic, metal) and the scratches are very visible. The only thing that doesn't scratch them is a soft rubber spatula. I also have a red Staub baking dish and never experienced any scratching, even with metal utensils. I am disappointed they aren't holding up as I expected from this brand.